BlockBefore

Chaffey-Isle House, 5490 Etiwanda Avenue, Rancho Cucamonga

Chaffey-Isle House, 5490 Etiwanda Avenue, Rancho Cucamonga, San Bernardino County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1-, with a 6,772-word written history.

From the record

“One of the oldest surviving buildings from the ongms of the Etiwanda Colony, the Chaffey/Isle House is significant historically and architecturally.”

Written record, HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1- · the record runs 6772 words · one of 145 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

5520 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Etiwanda A venue Rancho Cucamonga (Etiwanda) San Bernardino County, California USGS Cucamonga Peak Quadrangle Map, Universal Transmercator Coordinates: Block E: Lot 6, Etiwanda Colony Lands Deed Annie A. Chaffey and George Chaffey to 0. S. Winstanley. Assessors Lot Book. F. Winstanley Deeds Estate of 0. S. Winstanley to J. H. and John Scott. Assessors Lot Book. J. H. and John Scott. Second Block D, Lot 16 Etiwanda Colony Lands Assessors Lot Book. Charles Chaffey. Assessors Lot Book. H. S. Rose. Assessors Lot Book. James C. Isle. Assessors Lot Book. William R. Myers. Assessors Lot Book. James C. Isle. Assessors Lot Book. Martha E. Isle. Assessors Lot Book. Margaret Elizabeth Scott Barnes. Assessors Lot Book. Martha E. Isle. Assessors Lot Book. Alfred W. McGuire. 4.

Builder, Contractor, Suppliers: While George Chaffey is known to have been responsible for the house's construction as a home for his mother and CHAFFEY /ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 3) sister, it is not presently known who actually constructed the house, and no details of suppliers are available. 5. Original Plans and Construction: As originally built, the structure was a small, wood-framed house one and a half stories high, with a steep, bellcast Mansard roof. Rows of patterned shingles of varying designs encircled the roof slope. Fenestration includes paired dormers on the facade and two sides. The floor plan was roughly square. A recessed transomed entry accessible by three steps was centered on the facade, and it was flanked by two large 2/2 double-hung windows.

A porch spanned the front, with the roof supported by four posts; there was no porch rail.2 6. Alterations and additions: After being moved approximately one half mile to its present location around the building remained essentially the same, though minor changes were introduced. A small, square cobblestone addition was constructed at the northwest comer. The front porch was extended to wrap around the south side of the building, and it was redesigned to echo the Mansard shape of the main roof. Squared porch supports were replaced by turned posts, and a "Chinese Chippendale" railing was added. The central entrance steps were removed, and the main entrance steps were placed diagonally at the southeast comer connecting to a walkway. Later, a doorway was added on the south side.

The roof was damaged in a windstorm, and its replacement is roughly consistent with the original pyramid shape of the original, though the roofing is asphalt shingles, and a 1" x6" fascia board was added at the upper level.3 B. Historical Context The Isle House origins date back to the founding of the Etiwanda Colony in the early by George and William Chaffey, natives of Brockville in Ontario, Canada. In their father, George Chaffey Sr. retired from his Canadian ship building business and moved to Riverside, California with his wife Annie and two of his sons William and Charles. There the Chaffeys planted citrus orchards.4 In their third son, George Jr. joined the family in Riverside. George had been educated as an engineer and his brother William had a background in agriculture.

They formed a partnership for the purpose of developing an irrigated agricultural colony. On Thanksgiving Day the brothers purchased acres with existing water rights to four nearby mountain streams in Day, Middle, East and Young Canyons from Captain J. S. Garcia, a retired Portuguese seaman who had established a sheep ranch in the area. In Garcia had planted the first orange trees in the region.s By January they had expanded their holdings to acres and by May had organized the Etiwanda Water Company.6 The Chaffeys divided their holdings into ten acre lots and named the new colony Etiwanda after a Lake Michigan Indian chief. Sales began in the spring of and a preliminary subdivision map was filed on December 22, The brothers CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No.

CA-2677 (Page 4) promoted their project in Canada and soon a community of Canadian farmers formed at Etiwanda.s By March 46 individuals had purchased acres. Crops included oranges, apricots, Muscat grapes, and lemons.9 By the end of around acres had been sold and 20 families resided in the settlement. Raisins were the dominant crop and three train car loads had been packed. The community had a school house and hotel.to A report for stated that Etiwanda farmers cultivated acres. Seventy-five car loads of raisins had been shipped in Two years later in boxes of raisins were packed at Etiwanda.12 By Etiwanda had grown steadily and had a population of about Local historian L. A. Ingersoll noted "About acres in the district are now in vineyard and a winery in operation.

A good many lemon orchards have been planted and Etiwanda has a citrus association and a packing house, and a number of business establishments." 13 The Colony was the location of many firsts in Southern California history including: the site of the first development of hydro-electric current, the first house and community to be lighted with electricity, the first successful mutual water company, the first irrigation project to use under ground concrete pipe, and the first long distance telephone. All were the results of the efforts of George Chaffey.14 On November 30, electrical lights were turned on for the first time in Southern California at Etiwanda. George Chaffey had rigged a small electric dynamo with a paddle wheel that could be run on an irrigation ditch.

Wires from the dynamo led to an arc lamp installed on the roof of Captain Garcia's former house where George now resided. The light could be seen as far away as Riverside and it was said that ordinary print could be read at night a quarter mile away.is In August Chaffey was installing electric lights in his home.16 The key to the Colony's success was the water system. From a distribution reservoir concrete pipes conveyed water to the highest point on each ten acre parcel. Since the entire Etiwanda tract ran downhill in a southerly direction from the base of the mountains this could be accomplished by gravity flow without pumps.17 The Etiwanda Water Company owned all water rights.

Each purchaser of land received one share in the water company for every acre acquired resulting in the transfer of ten shares of water company ownership to each purchaser of a ten acre lot. The water company assumed responsibility for distribution of water to each tract irrespective of distance from the reservoir and no one was entitled to more than their respective shares of water company stock. This system resolved problems inherent in distribution systems used in California up to that time in which each land owner claiming water from a single source put in a channel to convey it to his holdings with no obligation to others downstream.

This resulted in those near the source having plenty of water while those further downstream often went without.is Under Chaffey's system all members of the Etiwanda Water Company were guaranteed the proportion of water their company shares entitled them to, regardless of the distance of their fields from the reservoir. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 5) As previously noted, origins of the present-day Isle House can be traced back to George Chaffey and the founding of Etiwanda. George Chaffey set up residence in Captain Garcia's former home where he conducted his famous electrical experiments. The building, known today as the Chaffey Garcia House, was located on the west half of Lot 6, Block E of the Etiwanda Colony Lands.

Following the death of his father in George built the structure presently known as the Isle House near his own dwelling on the east half of Lot 6, as a home for his mother, Annie Chaffey, and sister.19 According to local legend this house was also wired for electricity.20 This seems probable, given Chaffey's enthusiasm for electricity and the fact that the house was near his own and for his mother. Shortly thereafter, the Chaffeys moved to Australia.21 The property, including both houses, was sold to Orlando S. Winstanley for on December 3, Winstanley and his family resided in the Chaffey Garcia house and the small dwelling built for Chaffey's mother served as a rental.

In the early it was occupied by a widow, Sahara Spencer, and her daughter Susie.23 Followin.g Winstanley's death his property was sold to Etiwanda pioneer J. H. Scott on December 19, for Following purchase of the property by Scott, the house originally built in for George Chaffey's mother and sister became the home of the Isle family. James Christopher Isle was born in England in and had come to the United States in He became a U.S.

Citizen in Delmont County, California in With his first wife, a Native American woman, he ran a dairy near the Klamath River.27 He married his second wife, Martha, in Regua California, on January 30, Martha Isle had also been born in England and had immigrated to this country in On February 20, James Isle purchased Lot 16, Block D of Etiwanda Colony Lands from Homer and Fannie L. Rose for dollars. He then purchased the former Annie Chaffey home from the Scott family for dollars. He moved it on log rollers approximately one half mile to its present location on Lot 16, Block D, at the corner of Etiwanda and Highland Avenues.29 It would be several more years, however, before James Isle permanently settled on the property. On October 19, he conveyed Lot 16 to William R.

Myers.30 Almost five years later he bought the property back. On January 4, William and Bertha Myers transferred title of Lots 3 and 6, Block I; Lots 15 and 16 Lot Block D and fifty shares of Etiwanda Water Company stock to James C. lsle.31 Isle and his descendants would live in the former Chaffey house until the early James Isle became one of the largest citrus producers in Etiwanda and came to control 125 acres in Etiwanda located in Blocks D, E, and In at age 56, he lived in the house with his 32-year-old wife Martha, 74-year-old mother-in-law, Hanna Watson; and two daughters from his previous marriage: 20-year-old Agnes, and 18-year-old Tina.33 In Isle was assessed for orchards on Lots 15 and 16 Block D and Lots 3 and 6, Block In James C.

Isle was one of the founding members of the Etiwanda Foothill Citrus Association.35 His tenure did not last long, however. He transferred all his shares in the association to C. Newton Ross two years later.36 By the makeup of the household had changed from its composition ten years earlier. Living with James and Martha were James' brother-in- CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 6) law, Thomas Fox, age 50; his son-in-law, George P. McGuire, age 27; his 28-year-old daughter (and George's wife Agnes); their 19-month-old son Olin; and George Nelson, a hired man.37 It was during this period that James Isle and his son-in-law, George McGuire owned 125 acres of Etiwanda citrus lands.38 Meanwhile the community of Etiwanda had continued to progress.

In there were 202 households in the colony (Property Tax Rolls The Directory lists 107 households in the community, a decline which may reflect the agricultural depression of the In spite of hard times for many farmers in the U.S., Etiwanda growers in packed boxes of naval oranges, boxes of Valencias, boxes of lemons, boxes of grapefruit, and an additional boxes of miscellaneous fruits.39 Production apparently rose in spite of the economic depression of the For the season, Etiwanda production totaled boxes of navel oranges, boxes of Valencias, boxes of lemons, boxes of grapefruit, and boxes of miscellaneous fruit. In addition the colony produced tons of juice grapes and 700 tons of table grapes.

Raisins, the original money crop of the colony, were no longer grown.4o Aerial photographs from the period reflect the productivity of Etiwanda, showing the area around the Isle House as well as all of Etiwanda covered in orchards and vineyards.41 James Christopher Isle died at the age of 77 on December 11, Martha Isle continued to reside in the house and oversee the orchards until her death in the early By James Isle's grandson, Alfred McGuire, and his wife Antoinette lived in the house, continuing in the citrus business. Over the next forty years agricultural production at Etiwanda would gradually decline.

The community had reached it peak agricultural production by the start of World War II in Establishment of Kaiser Steel and other industrial plants in the area following the war brought population growth and subdivision.44 In the mid elimination of citrus groves began to accelerate followed by housing tract construction in the By Alfred McGuire was no longer dependent solely on farming for his income and was working as the local constable.46 Aerial photographs from show small housing tracts already beginning to replace orchards in Etiwanda. Some fields around the Isle House appear fallow.4 7 Alfred and Antoinette McGuire moved out of the house in the early to a new home on Etiwanda Avenue. Since that time the building has served as a rental property.48 PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A.

General Statement: 1. Architectural Character: The property is architecturally significant for its embodiment of the distinctive characteristic of the Second Empire architectural style, a style that was popular during the Victorian Period from - "The style is characterized by a Mansard roof with dormer windows on the steep lower slope; molded cornices normally bound the CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 7) lower roof slope both above and below; decorative brackets usually present beneath the eaves."49 The structure was originally built in and relocated to this site in 2. Condition of fabric: The condition of the structure varies from good to poor. The structure is generally in a weathertight condition.

Some of the exterior elements that are more prone to exposure from the elements, such as shingles on the south side, are showing the most wear. B. Description of Exterior: 1. Overall dimensions: Rectangular plan 25' x 40' with a 6 1 porch on east and south with the 8 1 x 10' root cellar attached to one side creating a very short squat "L" shaped structure. The second story 25' x 24' aligns over the front of the residence. 2. Foundation: Pier and Post. 3. Walls: The walls are constructed with horizontal flush siding with a 6" tongue-and-groove shiplap joint and comer boards from the frieze board to the water table. Below the water table the crawl space area is covered with vertical tongue-and-groove siding with a baseboard.

On the north elevation the area below the water table is skirted in painted pressed tin 12" x 12" panels. The root cellar is constructed of cobblestones set in uncut irregular courses. 4. Structural systems, framing: The structure was built as wood frame construction. There are no openings in the walls to view the construction technique or sizes and frequency of the structural members. The floor is wood framing. The roof framing is wood construction but there are no openings in the ceiling to view the construction technique or sizes and frequency of the structural members. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, bulkheads: a. Front Porch: A porch wraps the entire east elevation and a majority of the south elevation.

The porch has turned wood columns bearing on the porch floor and supporting the porch roof. The columns support a plain frieze board with the mansard roof of the porch above. The columns show evidence of the bases being built up and repaired over time. The posts while similar in design are of different diameters 4 %" to 5"and have their detailing occurring at different heights from 36" to 38 above finished floor. The tops of several of the posts show patching at the top of the post just below the frieze board. This would have been a likely location for some kind of open fret work or turned spindle spandrel panels. The roof is wood shingle in a similar pattern to the main roof. The wood shingles vary in CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No.

CA-2677 (Page 8) width with a hexagonal and diamond pattern. The porch flooring is 36 above grade finished with narrow tongue-and-groove boards. The ceiling of the porch is finished with tongue-and-groove boards with a center bead detail. The concrete steps leading up to the porch are set at a 45 degree angle at the southeast comer of the residence. The steps have flanking bulkheads of rusticated cast stone in regular courses. The east side stairs are of similar construction. b. Rear entrance stoop: Concrete stairs with no railing or bulkheads. 6. Chimneys: The only chimney is a prefabricated metal chimney projecting from the upper hip roof of the Mansard roof. 7. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: The structure currently has three exterior doorways.

The east elevation doorway was the original primary entrance into the main parlor. The doorway extends to the ceiling line with a two light upper transom and a raised four panel door below. A window screen has temporarily been nailed over the opening making the entrance impassable. The south elevation doorway appears to be of a slightly newer vintage. The door is a three panel door with the top panel a single light and almost half of the door. The casing is not as elaborate and the siding over the doorway shows evidence of being patched, suggesting that either a full height door with transom similar to the primary entrance was once at this location or a window was once here. b.

Windows and shutters: The original windows are all two over two double hung wood windows with wood sash and casings with no shutters. The casings are fairly ornate with distinctive side casings that extend below the window stool and apron and crossing the head casing. One fixed panel window has been added to the original structure at the bottom of the stairs. The casing is simple 1x stock material. The downstairs bedroom addition has two pairs of six light casement windows with simple 1x stock casing, one on the south elevation and one on the west elevation. On the west elevation the bathroom has a four light casement window and the laundry porch has three fixed single light windows. 8. Roof: a.

Shape, covering: The residence has a straight with a flair mansard roof with wood shingles which vary in width with a hexagonal, plain and diamond pattern in variegated rows. With a plain curb at the top and a modeled cornice at the bottom. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 9) b. Cornice, eaves: Decorative brackets align the frieze board below the eaves. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: Gabled wall dormers align over windows below creating symmetrical wall patterns. C. Description of Interior: 1. Floor plans: a. First floor: The first floor plan has a front porch that wraps the structure on the east and south elevations. From the front porch the front door enters the northeast room, the main parlor.

From the main parlor three door ways lead to the other rooms on this level and the staircase leads to the second floor. One door accesses the southeast room, the Side Parlor. The middle south room the dining room and the west room the kitchen. From the kitchen one door on the north side leads to the root cellar; the door on the west side leads to the enclosed laundry porch; and the door on the south leads to a small hallway. The hallway has four doorways. The door on the north comes from the kitchen the door on the east leads to the dining room; the door on the south leads to a bedroom; and the door on the east leads to the bathroom. The bathroom is a tow room configuration with a separate room for the bathtub and another for the lavatory and toilet. b.

Second floor: The stairs are "L" shaped. The first flight leads to a square landing and turns 90 degrees for the second flight. The second floor consists of three rooms and a hallway. One bedroom extends the entire south side of the second floor. The other two bedrooms are situated in the north east and northwest comers of the second floor. 2. Stairways: The stairs are situated between the main parlor and the kitchen. The stairs are "L" shaped the first flight of 8-7 risers leads to a square landing and turns 90 degrees for the second flight of 8-7 risers. The stairs are wide and completely enclosed on all sides with no handrail. 3. Flooring: First Floor: a. Main Parlor: Wood parquet tile flooring and pile carpeting.

Under the wood burning stove and between the door to the side parlor and the dining room door is a 4" raised brick hearth. The hearth is set in a basket weave pattern and the bricks appear to be a dark gray, almost black color. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 10) b. Side Parlor: Wall-to-wall carpeting. c. Dining Room: Wood parquet tile flooring and pile carpeting. d. Laundry Porch: Low loop blue indoor outdoor carpeting and plywood. e. Kitchen: 12" x 12" vinyl tile. f. Root Cellar: Concrete slab. g. Bathroom: Wall-to-wall carpeting. h. First Floor Bedroom: Wall-to-wall carpeting. i. Hallway: Wall-to-wall carpeting. j. Stairs: Wall-to-wall carpeting. Second Floor: k. South bedroom: Wall-to-wall carpeting. l. Northeast bedroom: Wall-to-wall carpeting. m.

Northwest bedroom: Plywood. n. Hallway: Wall-to-wall carpeting. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: First Floor: The interior walls are all 4 W' wide. a. Main Parlor: The walls are constructed of lath and plaster with a heavy texture on all of the walls except the south wall. The south wall has had white brick veneer installed behind the wood burning stove. The ceiling has had a 2' x 4' suspended acoustical ceiling grid with fluorescent fixtures installed completely covering the original ceiling. The grid is a bright chrome with white panels. b. Side Parlor: The walls are constructed of lath and plaster. And the ceiling of plaster. c. Dining Room: The walls and ceiling are lath and plaster with 40" high wainscot.

The wainscoting is constructed of vertical tongue and groove wood paneling stained a dark mahogany color. The ceiling shows evidence of the original location of the center chandelier. CHAFFEY /ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 11) d. Kitchen: The ceiling is constructed of gypsum board that at one time had a covering glued to it. The covering has been removed, however portion of the glue and the material it held up remain on the ceiling. The walls are an amalgam of materials: a wainscot of horizontal pine siding with painted or wallpapered walls above. Over the kitchen counter behind the sink a tile backsplash extends the length of the countertop. e.

Root Cellar: The ceiling is constructed of lath and plaster from which all of the plaster has been removed leaving the lath behind. The walls are lath and plaster over stone. f. Laundry Porch: The ceiling is constructed of painted fiber board. The walls are constructed of gypsum board. g. Bathroom: The walls and ceiling are gypsum board construction painted. One wall in the tub enclosure has a wainscot of tile with repetitive floral motifs assembled from 6 decorative tiles. The ceiling vaults following the underside of the roof. There are numerous soffits encircling the ceiling. h. First Floor Bedroom: The walls and ceiling are gypsum board construction painted. The central portion of the ceiling is raised 10" to the underside of the roof line.

The roof rafters and top plates are exposed their edges eased and siding covers the ceiling between the exposed rafters. i. Hallway: The walls and ceiling are gypsum board construction. The ceiling has a skylight with pine wood trim. Second Floor: All of the second story rooms have 3' high knee walls and the exterior walls from that point then slope in until they reach the ceiling. The ceiling is level. j. South bedroom: The walls are constructed of lath and plaster. The ceiling has had spray on acoustical finish. k. Northeast bedroom: The walls are constructed of lath and plaster. The west wall has been covered with contemporary wood sheet paneling that has been painted. The ceiling has applied 12" x 12" acoustical tile. I.

Northwest bedroom: The walls and ceiling are constructed of lath and plaster. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE {McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 12) 5. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: Many of the original doorways and doors are intact. The original doors were all raised four panel doors 11 on the first floor and 11 on the second floor. The casings on the first floor are 6 The casings on the second floor are 4 %". The cased openings in the kitchen, hallway, bathroom and bedroom are all contemporary in design. The doors are hollow core flat slab doors and the casings with no detailing. b. Windows: The window casings are 6 in the main parlor, side parlor, and dining room. 6.

Decorative features and trim: The main parlor's baseboard is topped with a quirked bead and is 7 Baseboards in the addition areas are 2". The second-story bedrooms all have 8 base boards with no detailing. At the bottom of the stairs in the main parlor there is a beam that spans from the stair wall to the north wall of the room and at the 2/ 3rd point it is supported by a wooden column. The column is identical to the columns on the front porch and appears to have been scavenged from the south side porch. 7. Hardware: Some original door hardware remains. The door to the closet under the stairs is a good example of a mortised skeleton key lock with a rectangular back plate and a knob handle. 8. Mechanical equipment: a.

Heating, air conditioning, ventilation: Heating is provided by the wood burning stove in the main parlor. The flue extends through the second floor in the closet of the northeast bedroom. b. Lighting: There are porcelain base light receptacles centered in the ceilings of the root cellar. Fluorescent ceiling fixtures in the living room. The dining room has no fixture except for a trouble light hanging from the northeast comer of the room. The bathroom has a wall sconce and a vanity light. Ceiling mounted incandescent electrical fixtures are typical in all other rooms. c. Plumbing: Plumbing fixtures were not original to the residence. The kitchen was remodeled in the or 60s and shows no scars of earlier kitchen fixtures.

The bathroom has also been remodeled on more than one occasion and little information can be gleaned from the extant fixtures. 9. Original Furn~shings: No original furnishings remain. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 13) D. Site: 1. General setting and orientation: The site is situated at the northwest comer of Etiwanda A venue and Highland A venue. The property is an open agricultural pasture with an adjacent woods to the north. The front of the house faces east to Etiwanda Avenue. 2. Historic landscape design: From the age of the plantings closest to the house there appears to have been some purposeful landscape design. At the northeast comer of the root cellar a fruit tree was planted.

Along Etiwanda A venue starting at the comer of Highland Avenue and moving north are four large (approx. Canary Island Date Palms (Phoenix Canariensis) with a few seedlings sprouting at their base. The palms extend the length of the front facade. Continuing north is a long windrow of eucalyptus trees. Another windrow runs perpendicular to this one on the north side of the horse corrals. A lone Canary Island Date Palm is located along Highland A venue off of the southwest comer of the residence. 3. Outbuildings: On the north side of the residence are a number of outbuildings that service the horse corrals or were for farm implements. None of the structures appear to date from the period of significance of the residence.

The outbuildings consist of two horse sheds, a four-bay shed that could shelter a small tractor and a smaller shed. The one additional improvement to the property is a stone cistern located directly west of the residence in the middle of the pasture area. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 14)

Notes

Robert Elingwood, telephone interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 16, San Bernardino Sun Telegram 4 June Robert L. Hickcox, A History ofEtiwanda, Second Edition (Etiwanda: Etiwanda Historical Society, Aaron A. Gallup, California Department of Transportation Architectural Inventory/Evaluation Form: McGuire House/James C. Isle House. Sacramento: Caltrans. Ibid: To. Betty Richards, "The Chaffeys: Saga of a Southern California Family." Pomona Valley Historian, 7 (January ): Ibid: 34. L.A. Ingersoll, Ingersoll's Century Annals ofSan Bernardino County to (Los Angeles, L. A Ingersoll, Articles of Incorporation No. 351 Etiwanda Water Company, on file San Bernardino County Archives.

Ontario Fruit Grower, 18 December Preliminary Map of the Etiwanda Colony Lands filed December 22, on file San Bernardino County Archives. The Chaffey Letter Press Books at the Model Colony Room of the Ontario City Library contain numerous correspondence from the Chaffey Brothers and their agents to Canadians. Chaffey Letters, Books I and Il ( ), Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. Ontario Fruit Grower, 13 March 10 Ontario Record, 16 December, II Lewis Publishing Company, An Illustrated History of Southern California, (Chicago, Lewis Publishing Company, 72. 12 Ingersoll, Annals of San Bernardino County, 13 Ibid. 14 Clippings from the Daily Report, 7 October in the Etiwanda Vertical File, Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. 15 Ontario Fruit Grower, 11 December 3. Donald L.

Clucas, Light Over the Mountain: A History of the Rancho Cucamonga Area, (Upland CA, California Family House Publishers, 16 Clucas, Light Over the Mountain, 17 Wallace W. Elliott, History of San Bernardino and San Diego Counties (San Francisco, Wallace W. Elliott and Company, 18 J. A. Alexander, The Life of George Chaffey (New York, MacMillan Company, 19 Elingwood, telephone interview. San Bernardino Sun Telegram 4 June 20 George McGuire, interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 12, Etiwanda, CA. 21 Alexander, Life ofGeorge Chaffey, Elingwood, Interview. 22 Deeds, Book 43 San Bernardino County Recorder's Office. Original Deed Books are on file at the San Bernardino County Archives. 23 Phyllis Jean Clark, telephone interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 13, Robert L.

Hickcox, telephone interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 13, CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 15) 24 Deeds, Book 324 San Bernardino County Recorder's Office. 25 U.S. Census Bureau, Fourteenth Census, Population Manuscript Returns. 26 Great Register, San Bernardino County ( l on file San Bernardino County Archives. 27 McGuire, Interview. Hickcox, History ofEtiwanda, 28 Marriage license of James C. Isle and Martha Isle, Regua, California in possession of George McGuire, Etiwanda, CA 29 Hickcox, History ofEtiwanda, 30 Assessor Lot Books ( San Bernardino County Archives.

The Index to Deeds at the San Bernardino County Archives records the entry for the transaction between Isle and Myers and indicates the transfer is recorded in Deed Book page However a copy of the deed is not recorded on the page indicated and it could not be found. A mistake must have occurred when the transaction was recorded in the Index to Deeds. 31 Deeds, Book 408 San Bernardino County Recorder's Office. 32 Hickcox, History ofEtiwanda, Assessors Books, San Bernardino County Archives. 33 U.S. Census Bureau, Thirteenth Census, Population Manuscript Returns. 34 Property Tax Assessment Rolls Vol. 2: San Bernardino County Archives. 35 Articles of Incorporation No. Etiwanda Foothill Citrus Association ( ), San Bernardino County Archives.

36 Miscellaneous Records, Book 2 San Bernardino County Recorder's Office. 37 U.S. Census Bureau, Fourteenth Census, Population Manuscript Returns. 38 Hickcox, History ofEtiwanda, 39 County of San Bernardino, Office of Horticultural Commissioner, Report on Crop Production, Acreage and Valuation, On file San Bernardino County Archives. 40 County of San Bernardino, Office of Agricultural Commissioner, Report on Crop Production, Acreage and Valuation, On file San Bernardino County Archives. 41 Transportation / Flood Control Aerial Photograph AXL June 3, San Bernardino County Archives. 42 Daily Report, l l December 43 County Directory George McGuire, Interview. 44 Hickcox, History ofEtiwanda, 3. 45 McGuire, Interview. 46 County Directory McGuire, Interview.

47 Transportation Flood Control Aerial Photograph No. 55, Dec. 2, San Bernardino County Archives. 48 McGuire, Interview. 49 Virginia and Lee McAlester, A Field Guide to American Houses, Alfred A Knopf, CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 {Page 16) PART Ill. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings: None located. B. Early Views: A circa photograph of the house at its original location before the or present porch was added is reproduced in Etiwanda The First 100 Years, Etiwanda Historical Society, C. Interviews: Clark, Phyllis Jean (Great-grand daughter of Sahara Spencer) Telephone Interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 13, Elingwood, Robert (Biographer of George Chaffey Telephone interview with Stephen R.

Van Wormer, June 16, McGuire, George (Great grandson of James C. Isle) " Interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 12, Etiwanda, CA. Hickcox, Robert L. (Etiwanda Historian) Telephone Interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 13, D.

Significance

384 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

One of the oldest surviving buildings from the ongms of the Etiwanda Colony, the Chaffey/Isle House is significant historically and architecturally. The house was built in by George Chaffey one of the founders of the Etiwanda Colony. As a result of Chaffey's engineering and leadership, the Etiwanda Colony was the site of significant firsts in Southern California, including the first development of hydro-electric current, the first house and community to be lighted with electricity, the first successful mutual water company, the first irrigation project to use underground concrete pipe, and the first long distance telephone. Not long after Chaffey departed for Australia, the house was purchased by James C. Isle, who moved it on log rollers to its present location.

Isle achieved local prominence as a large-scale citrus producer and a founder of the Etiwanda Foothill Citrus Association. Architecturally, the house is an excellent example of an Second Empire residence constructed on a small scale. Although somewhat deteriorated, the building still represents its type and period, and it is one of the rare surviving examples of a Mansard-roofed building in Southern California. CHAFFEY /ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1. Date of erection: In the early the Chaffey brothers subdivided and began to develop the Etiwanda Colony. After the death of George Chaffey Sr.

in his son George Chaffey built this one-and-a-half story, Mansard-roofed house on the east half of Lot 6, Block E, Etiwanda Colony Lands for his mother, Annie E. Chaffey, and his sister. They lived in the structure until circa when the family moved to Australia. Around the house was purchased by James C. Isle and moved approximately one half mile to its present location on Lot 16, Block D, Etiwanda Colony Lands at the intersection of Highland and Etiwanda Avenues.1 2. Architect: No architect has been identified in relation to the design of the building. 3. Original and subsequent owners, occupants and uses: For most of its existence the Isle House has been used as a farm house. It has also, at times, been utilized as a rental dwelling.

Details of the various owners and occupants are provided in the narrative history. Following is an outline of past ownership at its original location and after it was moved in Original

Bibliography

797 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

1. Primary Sources Articles of Incorporation No. 351 Etiwanda Water Company, on file San Bernardino County Archives. No. Etiwanda Foothill Citrus Association San Bernardino County Archives. Assessor Lot Books On file San Bernardino County Archives. Chaffey Letters - Chaffey Letter Press Books I and II. Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. County Directories On file, Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 17) County of San Bernardino, Office of Horticultural Commissioner Report on Crop Production, Acreage and Valuation. On file San Bernardino County Archives. County of San Bernardino, Office of Agricultural Commissioner Report on Crop Production, Acreage and Valuation. On file San Bernardino County Archives.

Daily Report Various issues cited in notes. On file Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. Deeds, Books - Various Deed Books cited in notes on file San Bernardino County Recorder's Office. Original Deed Books are on file at the San Bernardino County Archives. Etiwanda Colony Lands Preliminary Map of the Etiwanda Colony Lands filed December 22, on file San Bernardino County Archives. Elliott, Wallace W. History of San Bernardino and San Diego Counties. San Francisco: Wallace W. Elliott and Company. Great Register, San Bernardino County On file San Bernardino County Archives. Marriage License Marriage License of James C. Isle and Martha Isle. In possession of George McGuire, Etiwanda, CA. Miscellaneous Records Books Miscellaneous Records, Book 2, San Bernardino County Recorder's Office.

Ontario Fruit Grower Various issues cited in notes. Clippings on file Etiwanda Vertical File, Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. Ontario Record Issue of December 16, Clippings on file Etiwanda Vertical File, Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 18) Property Tax Assessment Rolls Property Tax Assessment Rolls Vol. 2, San Bernardino County Archives. Transportation / Flood Control Aerial Photograph Photograph AXL June 3, San Bernardino County Archives. Photograph No. 55, Dec. 2, San Bernardino County Archives. U.S. Census Bureau Thirteenth Census, Population Manuscript Returns. Fourteenth Census Population Manuscript Returns. 2. Secondary Sources Alexander, J. A. The Life of George Chaffey. New York: MacMillan Company.

Clucas, Donald L. Light Over the Mountain: A History of the Rancho Cucamonga Area. Upland, CA: California Family House Publishers. Gallup, Aaron A. California Department of Transportation Architectural Inventory /Evaluation Form for McGuire House/ James C. Isle House, Rancho Cucamonga, CA. Caltrans, Sacramento. Hickcox, Robert L. A History of Etiwanda, Second Edition. Etiwanda: Etiwanda Historical Society. Ingersoll, L. A. Ingersolrs Century Annals ofSan Bernardino County to Los Angeles: L. A. Ingersoll. Lewis Publishing Company An Illustrated History ofSouthern California. Chicago: Lewis Publishing Company. McAlester, Virginia and Lee A Field Guide to American Houses. New York: Alfred A Knopf. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No.

CA-2677 (Page 19) Richards, Betty "The Chaffeys: Saga of a Southern California Family." Pomona VaJJey Historian, 7 San Bernardino Sun Telegram Edition of June 4, E. Likely sources not yet investigated: Personal papers of George Chaffey, as well as oral histories with individuals familiar with the Isle family, may contain further related information. PART IV. PROJECT INFORMATION This project was conducted in compliance with a Memorandum of Agreement for the State Route 30 Improvements Project (07-LA-30.2.4/7.8; dated November Parties to the MOA include the Federal Highway Administration, California State Historic Preservation Officer, California Department of Transportation, San Bernardino Associated Governments (SANBAG), and Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.

As a consequence of project implementation, the subject property will be relocated or demolished. Preparation of this HABS document was conducted during May and June by William Manley Consulting under contract with SANBAG Project Coordinator for SANBAG was David Clark. William R. Manley managed the project for Architectural Analysis and documentation was prepared by Ione R. Stiegler, AIA. Historical documentation was prepared by Stephen R. Van Wormer. Photographic documentation was prepared by Philipp Scholz Rittermann. CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 21) !t "' -u - - " II,. ~ fi.,L, ~ I ~.9-.i:I -."I '2/.af'r. litt-'i f .; p Cl l ~ . .j ,! ' . " . I! j ,) ; 0 i I,~ . -I ' ! ui :: :I . t . .__ u 8 i I i. JI i "' r'B f ! i r ;_ - ... ..

- - 6iot ~j 'ti cl e,, ..l.ro;;i~~'f? CHAFFEY/ISLE HOUSE (McGuire House) HABS No. CA-2677 (Page 22) -1 - -~. - .. --- !., __ r .- -- - t - - ~ .. - - ' I -21 ._ .!. ... r- ,.. jiC\ - ' - - t . ! "' . " - ; . - + J_? i--------1-l1L-'~-~--.... -~. ... -. 1l T -- . . . ' ! I , := f - - 1 . -- - I - - ' ~ - . . i. - ..

In context

Rancho Cucamonga, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Bernardino County, California 963 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Rancho Cucamonga

7 records

The federal surveyors worked through Rancho Cucamonga building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Sam & Alfreda Maloof CompoundHABS CAL,36-RANCU,3-15,953 words
Goerlitz HouseHABS CAL,36-RANCU,2-9,198 words
Ernst Mueller HouseHABS CAL,36-RANCU,4-2,853 words
Sam & Alfreda Maloof CompoundHABS CAL,36-RANCU,3A-38 words
Sam & Alfreda Maloof CompoundHABS CAL,36-RANCU,3D-38 words
Sam & Alfreda Maloof CompoundHABS CAL,36-RANCU,3B-36 words
Sam & Alfreda Maloof CompoundHABS CAL,36-RANCU,3C-33 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,36-RANCU,1-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.