The summer field team was under the direction of Eric N. DeLony, (Chief of HAER). The recording team included Andrew Johnston, field supervisor (University of California, Berkeley), and Erin Ammer (Tulane University), Jason Currie (U.S./ICOMOS, Ottowa, Canada), Grant Day (University of Illinois, Champaign- Urbana), David Greenwood (University of Southern California), and Heather Larson (University of California, Berkeley), architects; Portia Lee, project historian FLETCHER DRIVE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-273 (Page 2) (California Archives, Los Angeles) and Elizabeth Watson, (City University of New York, The Graduate Center), historian; and Brian Grogan, photographer (El Portal, California). An additional drawing was done by German B. Calas (Bureau of Engineering).
Project assistance was provided by Alex Vidaurrazaga, Peter See, John Koo, Jim Wu, Raffi Massabki, Shashi Bhakta, Ejike Mbaruguru, and Wenn (City of Los Angeles, Bureau of Engineering); Amid Habbal (Vanir Construction Management); and Todd Croteau and Richard O'Connor (Historic American Engineering Record). FLETCHER DRIVE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-273 (Page 3) Description and Historic Designation Fletcher Drive Bridge spans the Los Angeles River between Larga Avenue and Crystal Street within the City of Los Angeles. 1 Construction was completed on the bridge in and the total cost was 2 The Los Angeles Cultural Heritage Commission declared Fletcher Drive Bridge City of Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No.
322 on July 21, The bridge, a reinforced concrete, T-beam structure with concrete abutments and reinforced concrete piers on timber piles, is 469 feet long, 71 feet wide, and has seven, 67-foot spans. The roadway has four lanes of asphalt concrete flanked with sidewalks on both sides. Architectural details consist of pairs of pylons designed to resemble articulated masonry at each entry to the bridge, a denticulate entablature at the bridge girder, a pierced railing, simple marbelite columns supporting single globes, and decorative brass lanterns at each pylon.
Events Leading to the Construction of the Bridge Authorized by the Bridge Bond Issue, Fletcher Drive bridge, crossing over the Los Angeles River, was one part of"the Great Fletcher Drive Improvement," a project championed by Ash, councilman from the Fourteenth District. In and early he campaigned to secure county funds to construct the bridge. A decision by the County Board of Supervisors in February of awarded half of the construction cost of the bridge, or The City of Los Angeles paid the other half of the cost. The Fletcher Drive Bridge, as part of the Great Fletcher Drive Improvement, was heavily influenced by City Beautiful ideals.
Proponents of the City Beautiful believed that monumental public works could uplift the citizens of a city, and boosters of Los Angeles believed that monumental works could raise the status of the City as an ent~rprising and properly developed metropolis. Visitors arriving by train were meant to experience the grandeur of the bridges, which were designed to harmonize and complement each other. The construction of Fletcher Drive Bridge was supported by politicians such as Councilman Ash, who as a booster of northeast Los Angeles wanted the best for his district, and by the designers, who were guided in their work by City Beautiful designs prominent at the time. The site of the bridge was a political issue that was fought out between the City of Glendale and the City of Los Angeles.
Citizens and politicians of the City of Glendale wished to have the bridge located further north along the river at a point more advantageous to the growth and development of their city. In the end Councilman Ash won this battle,. and the bridge was built at a location advantageous to the northeast section of the City of Los Angeles. 3 1 Fletcher Drive Bridge is Caltrans bridge 2 Mid-Week News Herald Los Angeles{l 6 February 3 Mid-Week News Herald Los Angeles(l6 February FLETCHER DRIVE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-273 (Page 4) The Design and Engineering of the Bridge City Engineers prepared plans for the bridge and its construction was done under their supervision. John C. Shaw was the City Engineer at the time the bridge was constructed; Merrill Butler was the Bridge Engineer.
The Lance-Cannon Engineering Company constructed the bridge. The Department of Engineering, in its Annual Report, stated that the bridge had elicited much favorable comment both for its design and construction, and was considered an outstanding achievement in reinforced concrete construction. The Seismic Retrofit of the Fletcher Drive Bridge The Fletcher Drive Bridge was one of the 459 city bridges identified as needing seismic retrofit in the Municipal Facilities Report presented to the City Council in December of In the bridge screening process conducted by the Bureau of Engineering in late the bridge was identified along with the historic river bridges as being significantly at risk in a seismic event.
The Fletcher Drive Bridge was the first of the fifteen historic bridges studied in the Los Angeles River Bridges Recording Project to undergo seismic retrofit. In the words of Clark Robins of the Bureau of Engineering, "a standard Caltrans approach was used" in the retrofit, indicating that the retrofit was designed for safety and economy paying little attention to a solution that would retain the structure's historical and engineering features. Following the Loma Prieta earthquake the California Department of Transportation established new design standards for the seismic performance of bridges in the State. The engineers of the Bureau of Engineering began their retrofit program using the Caltrans codes.
On the Fletcher Drive Bridge only City money was used-the federal funding, and the federal requirements for the preservation of historic features came later. For these reasons the Fletcher Drive Bridge seismic retrofit is viewed by the engineers as a necessary step in the transition to the innovative combination of seismic technology and historic restoration that characterizes the retrofit of most of the river bridges. Two main problems with the seismic performance of the bridge were corrected in the retrofit. First, the expansion joints were tied together. This involved tying the girders to the diaphragms with % inch metal cable restrainers. This retrofit allows the bridge to work as one member in relation to longitudinal forces, though it does not produce any moment at the connection.
Fletcher Drive Bridge is skewed at 49 degrees off perpendicular in relation to the orientation of the riverbed. 4 This skew is at least partially responsible for the complex system of girders that support the bridge deck, and it is this girder system that is tied together with the cable restrainers. . These cable restrainers, designed with Caltrans codes, are highly visible and detract from the historic appearance of the bridge. 4 The skew is due to the alignment of Fletcher Drive. FLETCHER DRIVE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-273 (Page 5) The second retrofit involved replacing the rocker bearings with catcher blocks topped with elastomeric bearing material. The rocker bearings of the original design were found to be unstable under earthquake forces.
The rocker bearing could tip and allow the bridge deck to crash. The catcher blocks were inserted near the rocker bearings to catch the bridge deck if it should fall. The elastomeric bearing material is inserted as a shim to limit the amount that the bridge deck can fall. Later bridge retrofits use the new elastomeric bearing pads, which allow for movement at the point where the deck meets the piers but does not allow the deck to slip off the pier. FLETCHER DRIVE BRIDGE HAER No. CA-273 (Page 6) SOURCES CONSULTED City ofLosAngeles,-Bureau of Engineering, Environmental Section. An Evaluation of the Fletcher Drive Bridge over the Los Angeles River. January, City of Los Angeles, Department of Parks and Recreation. Historic Resources Inventory Fletcher Drive Bridge over the Los Angeles River.
February City of Los Angeles. Historic Property Survey, Fletcher Drive Bridge over the Los Angeles River-Improvements. Office of the City Engineer, May City of Los Angeles, Cultural Heritage Commission Fletcher Drive Bridge-Outstanding Achievement in Reinforced Concrete Construction. Historic-Cultural Monument No. Declared 21 July City of Los Angeles, Minutes of the Los Angeles City Council, 23 September "County Accepts City Plans for Fletcher Bridge-To Pay Half," Mid-Week News Herald (16 February 1. Las-Angeles-Times-(July1987)~