The summer field team was under the direction of Eric N. DeLony, (Chief of HAER). The recording team included Andrew Johnston, Field Supervisor (University of California, Berkeley), and Erin Ammer (Tulane University), Jason Currie (U.S.ICOMOS, Ottawa, Canada), Grant Day (University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana), David Greenwood (University of Southern California) and Heather Larson (University of California, Berkeley), architects; Portia Lee, Project Historian, (California Archives, Los Angeles) and Elizabeth Watson, (City University ofNew York) historian; and Brian Grogan, photographer (El Portal, California). An additional drawing was done by German B. Calas, (Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering).
Project assistance was provided by Clark Robins, Deputy CityEngineer (Bureau of Engineering, City of Los Angeles) and Shashi Bhakta, Wenn John Koo, Raffi Massabki, Ejike Mbaruguru, Peter See, Alex Vidaurrazaga and Jim Hao-Jen Wu, (Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, City of Los Angeles); Amid Habbal (Vanir Construction Management); and Todd Croteau, Manager, HAER Roads and Bridges Program. Washington, NORTH BROADWAY BRIDGE HAER No. CA-274 (Page 3) Historic Bridge Description and Eligibility As built in the North Broadway Bridge over the Los Angeles River was an earth filled, 7-arch span of reinforced concrete, spanning the Los Angeles River and the tracks of the Southern Pacific Railroad. Weighing nearly forty thousand tons, the structure measured 70 feet wide and 968 feet long.
Its eight piers rose forty feet above the riverbed and descended thirty-six feet below it, resting on piles driven in bedrock. The mainspan, an open spandrel, fixed, elliptical, 6-ribbed arch, measured 119 feet in diameter. The North Broadway Bridge is significant as one of the twelve historic bridges over the Los Angeles River eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. The longest and widest concrete bridge in California and one of the first long-span, open spandrel arch viaducts in California, its design became standard for reinforced concrete bridges. North Broadway Bridge was also the first bridge in California to use Beaux-Arts architectural details, the style prevailing in Europe and America at the turn of the century for monumental City Beautiful civic structures.
1 History On June 2, General Chaffee of the Department of Public Works introduced a resolution requesting the Los Angeles City Council to authorize his Board to advertise for bids and award a contract for a reinforced concrete arch viaduct across railroad property and the Los Angeles River, connecting the segments of Buena Vista Street east and west of the river. Chaffee's resolution stated that "public necessity and convenience" required the construction whose cost was to be shared between the city's bridge fund and the Los Angeles Railway Company. 2 When the bridge opened on September 24, it connected Buena Vista Street to Downey Avenue on the west. Subsequently both street names were changed to North Broadway.
The new structure stood between two early bridges, the Downey A venue viaduct and the Pasadena Avenue Bridge. The northbound cars of the North Main Street and Griffin Avenue lines constituted the first traffic over the new bridge, outbound on one of the two new parallel tracks and inbound over the wood-trestle Pasadena Avenue Bridge. Soon after, it was tom down and both lines routed via the new North Broadway crossing. The iron and wood Downey Avenue structure, described as "still sturdy," 1Finding of Adverse Effect: Seismic Retrofit ofNorth Broadway Bridge." On file, Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, Department of Public Works City of Los Angeles. See also Arch Bridge Rating Sheet, on file, California State Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento, California.
2 Minutes of the Board of Public Works, June 2, in the collection of the Los Angeles City Archives. NORTHBROADWAYBRIDGE HAER No. CA-274 (Page 4) was also tom down. At the west end of the North Broadway bridge, a newly constructed Y led traffic to Pasadena Avenue on the north and to A venue 20 and Downey Avenue (North Broadway) on the south, a plan adopted by the city engineers to dispose of both old bridges as part of the construction of the new one. 3 Beginning in the Eastside Improvement Association and their Councilman, Dromgold, actively promoted the bridge construction in order to bring about more convenient streetcar transportation and freight traffic movement across the river between east Los Angeles and downtown.
Development in the foothills to the north, present day Montecito Heights and the Monterey Hills, also was beginning and could be expected to increase. Dromgold conferred with officials of the Los Angeles Railway who agreed to fund about one-third of the construction cost and all of the paving and improvement of their right-of-way. In addition Los Angeles Railway gave the city for a portion of hillside in Elysian Park near the west end of the Pasadena Avenue Bridge to increase its track facilities. In August of all the business arrangements were complete and construction began. City employees did all of the design, with the exception of massive ornamental pylons by architect Alfred F. Rosenheim, the city's most prominent Beaux-Arts architect.
Although he was in private practice, Rosenheim was civic-minded, serving as a member of the Municipal Arts Commission from and the Building Ordinance Commission from to The Times called North Broadway Bridge,"not only one of the greatest improvement the city has made, but one of the triumphs of bridge designing and construction...an ornament where any other structure might fail in the purpose." 5 Historical Architectural Description Designers intended the North Broadway Bridge to be seen by passengers on the railroads that entered the city at the level of the riverbed. Two massive pressed stone pylons standing on high square pedestals towered 3 7 feet above the bridge deck.
Erected opposite one another at either end of the bridge, they were placed at angles to achieve the most dramatic visual effect from the rail cars. Their fluted columns, 21 feet high, were surmounted by a modified Doric entablature and capped with a balustrade completed with finials. On the bridge deck, handrails cast as running balusters were set on a two- step base. At intervals along the deck, twelve round balconies, supported from below by classical columns, served as view bays for strollers along the bridge. These supporting 3 "Great Viaduct About Ready," Los Angeles Times, 24 September Pt. II, p. 1. 4 See Paul Gleye, The Architecture of Los Angeles, Rosebud Books, Los Angeles, 1981,passim. 5 "People's Need makes Demand.
Crosstown Line Is Urgent For Their Accommodation," Los Angeles Times, 24 September pt. II, pp. NORTH BROADWAY BRIDGE HAER No. CA-274 (Page 5) columns also provided a visual impact from the river level, particularly on the north elevation where the central view bay was supported by a semi-circular colonnade. Seventeen ornamental lampposts with four round-globe electroliers lighted the balconies. 6 Engineering The eight piers of the North Broadway Bridge, 36 feet below the level of the riverbed and 40 feet above it, rested on piles of solid concrete driven to bedrock. To build the monolithic structure, 968 feet long and 50 feet high, 18, 200 cubic yards of concrete were used.
Engineers estimated weight to be pounds, or 36, 855 tons, calculated by estimating a cubic foot of concrete to weigh 150 pounds. High towers, feet apart, supported a cable tram that transported the material for the piers. The riverbed itself furnished the sand and gravel for the piers. 7 Since the weight of the bridge rested on 465 wood piles set in concrete, as well as the massive piers, the bridge was allowed to settle before the entire surface finishes were added. The roadway and sidewalks were filled with earth, graveled, then allowed to settle for two winters before being paved with asphalt. The fills on the Y approaches received similar treatment. While only a portion of the sidewalks was cemented, engineers allowed the completion of the ornamental balconies, balustrade and pylons.
8 The bridge's seven spans vary from 105 feet to 119 feet in length; moving from west to east: 3@ 1 @ 2@ 1 @ The four river spans' design features arch ribs with hollow spandrel walls. As originally engineered, the railroad spans at either end of the structure were solid and earth-filled. Total width was 70 feet with a roadway width of 56 feet. Abutments were constructed counterfort on spread foundations. The design method was working stress with a live load of The tangent alignment has a 5 skew at the river. 9 Alterations Most of the omaniental feaii.iies on North Broadway Bridge were lost over time. The pylons were in place until thensubsequently disappeared, most probably in the 6 "Majestic Great Viaduct," 1, 6. 7 "People's Need Makes Demand, 2 8 "Majestic Great Viaduct," 6.
9 See Bridge Report, Bridge "Los Angeles River (North Broadway)" December 26, 27, and revised original report, "North Broadway Viad. Over L.A. River," August 9, State of California Department of Transportation, Sacramento, California. NORTH BROADWAY BRIDGE HAER No. CA-274 (Page 6) Long Beach Earthquake of 10 The handrails deteriorated and were replaced by modem tube rails and cobra lights replaced the electroliers. The streetcar line was discontinued and the rails removed. The context of river and mountains also changed as housing rose on the hills. The river bottom and sides were converted to a concrete spillway. Seismic Retrofit To reduce seismic loads, the entire original earth fill in the North Broadway Bridge was removed.
Massive caissons extending 50 feet below the level of the river, together with heavy slabs, were constructed at the east and west abutments. In order to shift seismic forces to the strengthened abutments, existing expansion joints were filled in and a box girder created at the deck level to support the columns. At Piers 2 and 3, a portion of the pier wall located above the arch and below the deck was removed and reconstructed. Pier 4 was reinforced by thickening the pier walls. Adding concrete to both vertical sides over a portion of the rib's length strengthened the structure's arch ribs. In order to minimize the visual impact to these character-defining elements, the increase, which varied along the length of the rib, did not exceed 3".
Vertical loads did not change, since the arch ribs were originally designed for vertical loads. Arch spans 4 through 7 had their spandrel columns removed, reinforced, and reconstructed to original dimensions. Bolsters were doweled in to confine the lateral displacement of the arches. 11 As mitigation for the seismic retrofit, the four massive pylons, supporting colonnades and baluster handrails were reconstructed accordiny to original drawings and historic illustrations in glass fiber reinforced concrete 2 In accordance with the original drawings, the ornamental light globes were replaced and the three-armed In F. McCanriwrofe fo theLos-Aiigeies City- Council noting that North Broadway was one of the City's main gateways to visitors from other parts of the country.
She suggested that the columns at both __ endsJ1e Books of the City Council, _ __l_une_3~19_32, in the collection of the Los A~ City Arc_hjves _ 11 See "Supplemental Environmental Impact Report, Seismic Retrofit of North Broadway and Olympic Bridge," on file, Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, Department of Public Works, City of Los Angeles. 12 technology is a process of pouring material into sectional molds sculpted out of rubber. In the case of the Scamozzi capitals of the pylons, a replica was sculpted in plaster of Paris using correct historic details. That cast then served as a model for the mold.
See drawings and correspondence between Willis Construction Company, San Juan Bautista, California and the Structural Engineering Department, Bureau of Engineering, on file in the Bureau of Engineering, Department of Public Works, City of Los Angeles. NORTH BROADWAY BRIDGE HAER No. CA-274 (Page 7) ornamental lightposts recast and replicated by the City of Los Angeles Bureau of Street Lighting using modem metals~ 13 13 See Douglas Shuit, "Historic Bridge to Downtown Reopens," Los Angeles Times, 31 March, B3. NORTH BROADWAY BRIDGE HAER No. CA-274 (Page 8) SOURCES CONSULTED Published Gleye, Paul. The Architecture ofLos Angeles. Los Angeles: Rosebud Books, "Majestic Great Viaduct About Ready.
Cars Run Over the Buena Vista Structure." Los Angeles Times, (24 September "People's Need Makes Demand. Crosstown Line Is Urgent for Their Accommodation." Los Angeles Times, (24 September Shuit, Douglas, "Historic Bridge to Downtown Reopens." Los Angeles Times, (31 March, Unpublished Arch Bridge Rating Sheet, North Broadway Bridge on file, California State Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento, California Bridge Reports, Bridge "Los Angeles_River (North Broadway)." December 26, 27, and revised original report, "North Broadway Viad. Over L.A. River," August 9, State of California Department of Transportation, Sacramento, California Finding of Adverse Effect: Seismic Retrofit of the North Broadway Bridge.
On file, Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, Department of Public Works, City of Los Angeles. Minutes of the Board of Public Works. In the collection of the Los Angeles City Archives. Minute Books of the City Council. In the collection of the Los Angeles City Archives. City of Los A.rlgelesc:-bepaiiiiienfof Pii.bTfo WcfrI<:s:- Bureaii~ofEiigirieeiiiig. -~ --Environmental _ ~--8eismic Retrofit nf.North_B.ro.adway.and Olympic Bridge. Report prepared for Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering. On file, Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, Department of Public Works, City of Los Angeles.