The summer field team was under the direction of Eric N. DeLony, (Chief of HAER). The recording team included Andrew Johnston, Field Supervisor (University of California, Berkeley), and Erin Ammer (Tulane University), Jason Currie (U.S.ICOMOS, Ottawa, Canada), Grant Day (University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana), David Greenwood (University of Southern California) and Heather Larson (University of California, Berkeley), architects; Portia Lee, NORTH MAIN STREET BRIDGE HAER No. CA-276 (Page 2) Project Historian, (California Archives, Los Angeles) and Elizabeth Watson, (City University of New York) historian; and Brian Grogan, photographer (El Portal, California). An additional drawing was done by German B. Calas, (Structip:al Division, . Bureau of Engineering).
Project assistance was provided by Claik Robins, Deputy City Engineer (Bureau of Engineering, City of Los Angeles) and Shashi Bhakta, Wenn John Koo, Raffi Massabki, Ejike Mbaruguru, Peter See, Alex Vidaurrazaga and Jim Hao-Jen Wu, (Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, City of Los Angeles); Amid Habbal (Vanir Construction Management); and Todd Croteau, Manager, (HAER Roads and Bridges Program, Washington, NORTH MAIN STREET BRIDGE HAER No. CA-276 (Page 3) Bridge Description Main Street Bridge over the Los Angeles River is feet wide and 280 feet long, with 3 spans, each 87 .5 feet with a rise of 11 feet. The bridge was symmetrical with 4 lanes and a flush walkway. The mainspan is a reinforced concrete, open spandrel, 3- hinged, elliptical, 6-ribbed arch measuring feet.
The structure crosses the river in a west to east direction. The context of the surrounding land use is light industrial with manufacturing units and warehouse buildings. 1 Bridge History In an article written during construction, City Engineer Homer Hamlin reported that the authorization for Main Street Bridge had come from City Councilman of the District, Bernard Healy.
The previous bridge near the site, old East Main Bridge, could no longer safely carry both street railway and highway traffic, The City of Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Railway Company were constructing a joint bridge at the crossing to cost approximately To secure sufficient waterway, the City Engineer reported, flat arches had been constructed abutting against massive steel hinges that were hidden from view and lights would be placed on concrete shafts over the piers. 2 In fact, Councilman Healy had been calling for East Main's replacement for several years. An article in the Los Angeles Daily Journal had an attention-grabbing headline: New Main Street Bridge. Councilman Healy is Firm in Demand-Rotten Stringers.
The story reported that Healy had objected to the City Engineer and Board of Public Works' plan to spend on the old wooden bridge. To demonstrate the seriousness of the "rotten stringers, beams, flooring and other wooden portions, as well as the rusting iron bolts, plates and rods which had caused the timbers to rot away, leaving the bridge in a very dangerous condition. "3 Since Hamlin was himself mounting an ambitious plan to construct high water, permanent concrete arch bridge over the river, it is likely that he was delighted at the Councilman's action. Construction on a new Main Street Bridge began soon thereafter.
In the Daily Journal headline read, "Order More Improvements." The story was subtitled, "City Will Put Fancy Railing and Lights on Main Street Bridge." This time Hamlin had gone to Council, asking them to advertise for bids for the new bridge, which was "almost ready to receive such additional construction. "4 1 Arch Bridge Rating Sheet Bridge No. Main Street Bridge. On file, California Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento. 2 Homer Hamlin, "Bridge Construction in the City ofLos Angeles," in Charles Mulford Robinson, The City Beautiful (Los Angeles: John A. Porter, 3 "New Main Street Bridge," Los Angeles Daily Journal, 2 September 1 4 "Order More Improvements," Los Angeles Daily Journal, 19 November 1 NORTH MAIN STREET BRIDGE HAER No.
CA-276 (Page 4) Bridge Design Main Street Bridge was widely published and discussed in professional journals during the building process. The last of three concrete open-spandrel arch bridges constructed in the period between and it's construction method- the three- hinged-arch - had never before been built in the western United States. Hugo Eckhardt, a German engineer and contractor Carl Leonardt's engineer, developed the technique. Main Street Bridge's three spans, each 87 .5 feet, were supported by piers 226 feet below the river channel. The piers rested on piles driven 12 feet deeper into the riverbed. Nine feet thick on top, the piers were constructed hollow with walls 2 feet 3 inches thick at the spring line of the arch, then widening to 3 feet 5 Yi inches at the footing.
The abutments were also built hollow, extending 21 feet below the depth of the channel. The depth of the piers compensated for the lowering of the channel due to the extensive mining of sand and gravel from the riverbed. Eight ribs were contained in the width of the arch, one supporting each railway track, two supporting the railway on either side, and one supporting each sidewalk. One hinge is placed in the crown, the other in the end of the arch. Each hinge is a 3/16-inch steel shaft, which presses against cast iron, shoes, which in turn bear against a network of steel beams. After this construction is encased in concrete, joints around the shaft are filled with melted lead and a compressible joint is constructed across the entire rib.
The compressible joint, composed of one 3 3/8-inch batten with 'l4 inch of deadening felt, is pasted to each side. The story reported that Contractor Leonardt used a higher- priced cement, one manufactured in his own factory, because it resisted the action of oil, which was supposed to be prevalent in the river water at the crossing. 5 Bridge Architecture In line with the policy of Hamlin to build bridges that were "sightly" as well as practical, care was taken to ornament Main Street Bridge with elements in the City Beautiful, Beaux Arts style. The structure was detailed with applied decorative elements in cast concrete: a keystone in each arch; a <lentil below the railing on each of the piers and, when built, pierced starburst handrails.
6 Special attention was given to the arch rings: thirty days after the concrete was poured, the arch rings were picked out with a pointed tool, as were the spandrel walls. The concrete light posts were faced with "marbelite," a mixture of crushed marble and crushed lava to resemble granite. As a final 5 Southwest Contractor and Manufacturer," A Three-Hinged Ribbed Arch Concrete Bridge," 7 May 16. 6 State of California, Department of Parks and Recreation "Historic Resources Inventory, Main Street Bridge," on file, State Office of Historic preservation, South Central Coastal Information Center, Fullerton, California. See illustration in Southwest Contractor and Manufacturer, "A Three hinged Ribbed Arch," 16. NORTH MAIN STREET BRIDGE HAER No.
CA-276 (Page 5) touch, the arch ribs were darkened by adding one pound of lampblack per sack of cement and using dark stone from Hollywood. 7 Alterations The bridge has lost some integrity due to insensitive alterations. The decorative handrails are gone, having been replaced by tube rails. The period lamp posts have been altered by the addition of modem globes. Alteration to the river channel piers is the result of flood control and water diversion modifications.
Seismic Retrofit Despite the technical advance the bridge represented and its economical construction, by the Bureau of Engineering already viewed the bridge as being a construction of a prior era and not to a "modem standard." Main and Aliso Street Bridges were the only two river crossin~s in the downtown area that did not provide a grade separation for the railroad tracks. Today, the bridge is both dangerous and inconvenient. Main Street Bridge is viewed as antithetical to good seismic design. The three hinged construction that made its single span across the river possible become three weak links in the event of an earthquake. While the hinges were filled and could tolerate shear forces, they still offer the least resistance to moment forces within the bridge.
Contemporary conceptions of earthquake force believe that the hinges offer the benefit of flexibility to movement. However, the plane of movement offered by the hinges was designed for vertical direction to accommodate settlement and shrinkage along the arch, not to counteract lateral or transverse forces. 9 No decision has been made on a plan to retrofit the bridge. Its inherent structural deficiency makes it doubtful that it can be retrofitted for less than building a new bridge. Since the consensus is that the bridge should be widened, it is probable that no decision will be made about a seismic upgrade without further study. 7 Southwest Contractor and Manufacturer, "A Three Hinged Ribbed Arch," 17.
8 Annual Report of the Bureau of Engineering, Los Angeles, 51.On file, Los Angeles City Archives. 9 City Engineers John Koo and Raffi Massabki, personal communication with the author, June NORTH MAIN STREET BRIDGE HAER No. CA-276 (Page 6)
Annual Report of the Bureau of Engineering, Los Angeles. Los Angeles City Archives. California Department of Transportation Library, Sacramento, California. Historic Resources Inventory. Sate Office of Historic Preservation, South Central Coastal Information Center. Fullerton, California. Hamlin, Homer. "Bridge Construction in the City of Los Angeles." Charles Mulford Robinson, ed. The City Beautiful. Los Angeles: John A. Porter, Koo, John. Interview with Elizabeth Watson, June Los Angeles Daily Journal. 2 September 19 November Massabki, Raffi. Interview with Elizabeth Watson, June Southwest Contractor and Manufacturer. 7May1910.