The summer field team was under the direction of Eric N. DeLony, (Chief of HAER). The recording team included Andrew Johnston, Field Supervisor, (University of California, Berkeley); and Erin Ammer (Tulane University), Jason Currie (U.S.ICOMOS, Ottawa, Canada), Grant Day (University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana), David Greenwood (University of Southern California) and Heather Larson (University of California, Berkeley), architects; Portia Lee, Project Historian, (California Archives, Los Angeles) and Elizabeth Watson (City University of New York Graduate Center), historian; and Brian Grogan, photographer, (El Portal, California). An additional drawing was done by German B. Calas, (Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering).
Project assistance was provided by Clark Robins, Deputy City Engineer, Bureau of Engineering, City of Los Angeles; Shashi Bhakta, Wenn John Koo, Raffi Massabki, Ejike Mbaruguru, Peter See, Alex Vidaurrazaga and Jim Hao-Jen Wu (Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, City of Los Angeles); Amid Habbal (Vanir Construction Management); and Todd Croteau, (HAER Roads and Bridges Program). FOURTH STREET VIADUCT HAER No. CA-280 (Page 3) Bridge Description and Eligibility The Fourth Street Viaduct was constructed as part of a Los Angeles city bond issue to improve automobile and trolley crossings over the Los Angeles River and adjacent railroad tracks.
Apart from providing "permanent" crossings, the reinforced concrete structures were built with the aim of creating architecturally attractive structures. Fourth Street Viaduct was embellished with four monumental pylons, decorative railings, and ornamented light standards, some of which also functioned as trolley poles. Fourth Street was also notable for its length and graceful open-spandrel arch design. The viaduct continues to provide a link between Boyle Heights and the downtown Los Angeles, clearing Atchison Topeka & Santa Fe Railroad yard, Union Pacific tracks, the Los Angeles River, and two adjoining streets. Fourth Street Viaduct was seismically retrofitted in by the City of Los Angeles.
Bridge History Prior to there-were two crossingsalong Fourth Street between downtown Los Angeles and the residential suburb of Boyle Heights. Both crossings were steel and wood truss and trestle bridges. One carried the Los Angeles Railway Company's trolley cars and the other, maintained by the City of Los Angeles, carried vehicular traffic. At the time, neither bridge was considered attractive or appropriate for a modem city. 1 While viaducts at First Street crossed over the railways, many of the other bridges crossing the Los Angeles River did not. The necessity of stopping for the frequent trains resulted in major traffic delays. In a collision between a railroad train and a trolley .kiiled five people, resulting in ari effort fo resolve the railroad crossing problems.
2 After lengthy legal negotiations, the California Railroad Commission issued an order mandating that the major transportation line owners, including the City of Los Angeles, jointly construct grade separati()ns. 3 _ Thif>_ga\l"e rise to the)_~~~ Vi~duct Program. On June 5, the city voters passed the Bond to improve nine Los Angeles River crossings linking East Los Angeles with the downtown. 4 City Engineer John A. Griffin saw the Bond program as an opportunity to beautify Los Angeles. Not only would the new constructions "relieve traffic congestion'', but they would also be approJ>J.i.a.t~ Street Viaduct was the fifth bridge pursued under the Bond.
In accord with tlie Railroad 1 See page 5 in the correspondenc(!_ t<>_!l~111er_ Harnl_i~_fr~m P~~eri!J.clude<i_fn the Homer-Hainlin, Annual Report of the Civil Engineer ofLos Angeles,-ealifornia ending November 30, Typewritten, City Archives. City of Los Angeles Bureau of Engineering, Annual Report, 55. 2 Stephen D. Mikesell, "The Los Angeles River Bridges: A Study in the Bridge as a Civic Monument", Southern California Quarterly, 3 Larry Meyer, "A More Perfect Uni_c;m,"Nov~mber 71. 4 Stephen D. Mikesell, ''The Los Angeles River Bridges: A Study in the Bridge as a Civic Monument'', Southern California Quarterly, 5 Mikesell, ''The Los Angeles River Bridges: A Study in the Bridge as a Civic Monument'', Southern California Quarterly, FOURTH STREET VIADUCT HAER No.
CA-280 (Page 4) Commission mandate, the City paid 25% and the remaining portion was divided as follows: Los Angeles County, Los Angeles Railway, and Union Pacific Railway, 6 Bridge Design Merrill Butler, Engineer of Bridges and Structures for the City of Los Angeles Bureau of Engineering, oversaw the design of the Fourth Street Viaduct. The viaduct was the longest bridge in the City at the time it was constructed. The structural elements consisted of girder and arch spans, including an open-spandrel arch over the Los Angeles River. The open-spandrel arch spanned 254 feet with a rise of only 33 feet. Butler considered the Fourth Street Viaduct "one of the best examples" of architecture and engineering elements being designed together to create a harmonious structure.
A "Gothic" architectural treatment-was-selected-to emphasize the progression of the structure through vertical elements. 7 The design team consisted-of bridge engineers and architects headed-by Butler. They were attentive to the visual cohesion of the viaduct. Though consisting of at least three distinct support systems: the open spandrel arch, barrel arch, and girders; the horizontal spans share a similar curvature. Aside from the visual continuity, the arches helped reduce the perception of the deck deflections over the long girder spans, which averaged 63 feet from pier to pier. The open spandrel arch crossed the River with four symmetrical ribs containing four open spandrels on each side. The spandrels consisted of columns topped with low-rise arches.
The barrel, forming rigid-frame bedstead arches, crossed over Mission Road and Santa Fe A venue. The girder spans acted in tandem with elastic piers providing the necessary clearances for the railroad trains. With reinforcement laid diagonally at the ends and bent horizontally in the center of each girder, the girder appears to be an arch although it structurally acts as a beam. According to Butler, "The soffits of these girders near the river were cambered to give the appearance of very flat arches to harmonize with the arched sections of the viaduct. " 8 The alignment of the viaduct was curved to provide a straight connection to Fourth Street on both sides of the Los Angeles River.
The design included an onramp for vehicular traffic from Mateo Street giving the west approach a forked plan. In addition to the numerous underpasses for the Santa Fe Railroad yard, the viaduct also provided underpasses for Santa Fe Avenue and Mission Road. The architectural details were meant to evoke "Gothic omament."9 The ornament was applied to combination trolley poles and light standards, two sets of pylons located at the abutments of the river span, and the railing along the bridge deck. The trolley posts 6 Merrill Butler, "Architecture and Engineering are Harmonized in Fourth St. Viaduct", Southwest Builder and Contractor, August 7, 50. 7 Butler, "Architecture and Engineering," 49. 8 Ibid. 9 Butler, "Architecture and Engineering," 50. FOURTH STREET VIADUCT HAER No.
CA-280 (Page5) also served as lighting standards. The posts, about 26 feet high, supported the two lamps with a Corinthian capital form. Opalescent glass panels capped by a vegetal band in tum surmounted by finials enclosed the aluminum lighting elements. The monolithic pylons served functionally holding two lighting elements and a trolley suspension hook. The pylons were designed with a central pointed archway below the suspension post. The archway also provided a small balcony for pedestrians. The handrails have heavy beveled lancet arches below a plain cap. The running design is interrupted at intervals by stone benches. Along the roadway sides of the viaduct approaches, the support piers are rounded just below the handrail, then decorated with a superimposed concrete block.
These posts were set at 60-degree angles forming a trefoil in the middle of the equilateral triangle. 10 Bridge Construction Contractors Fisher, Ross, MacDonald & Kahn's bid of$1,246,635 to construct the Fourth Street Viaduct was selected in May of 11 Apart from supplying the design, the City-specified the concrete mix. Aratio-of 1:2:3-was used for the structure. The concrete used was class D and F. Three aggregate sizes were specified, ranging from sand to 1.5 inches. 12 An average slump of inches was recorded, while average for the 28-day strength was3658 pounds per square inch. 13 The concrete was mixed near the site on Mission road then transported by truck for pouring. 14 The abutments and piers were set upon Raymond cast-in-place reinforced concrete piles.
The Raymond Concrete Oil Company installed the piles with a steam hammer. The river abutment footings were installed 20 feet below the riverbed, extending downward 12 to 15 feet. The approaches were built as fills between Falsework was used to_construct the girder approaches and the spandrel arch. The span over the River was the longest span builtin Los Angeles to that date. In order to avoid large "secondary stresses" during the construction process, the arch ribs were poured as two pieces connected to each other and at the abutments by compressive hinges. The secondary stresses were described as those stresses induced during curing due to the shrinkage of the concrete, temperature changes, abutment settlement, and deflections of the arch que to the dead load.
Poured as a single, continuous rib from -alrutmenHo--abutment,thes --Stresses-would be contained by the-rib.-~-With each rib poured as two pieces, the hinges accommodated the shrinkage and deflections. 16 JQ_ Engineering Department of the City of Los Angeles; Plans and-Specifications for Fourth Street -Viaduct. Los Angeles: Board of Public Works, 11 "Bridges," Western Construction News, February 25, 12 Ibid. 13 "New Method of Arch Rib Construction Feature Fourth St. Viaduct", Southwest Builder and Contractor, April24, 48. - -- ~-- 14 Ibid. 15 Ibid. 16 Butler, "Architecture and Engineering," 50. FOURTH STREET VIADUCT HAER No.
CA-280 (Page 6) The hinges consisted of"heavily reinforced, spirally wrapped concrete columns, which presented little resistance to bending." 17 The reinforcement of the hinge was over nineteen feet long. 18 The intention of the design was to dissolve the hinges after the centering had been removed and the entire dead load of the completed superstructure had been placed. However, during the pouring of the bridge deck, the engineers decided to seal the center hinge at the arch crown. By uniting the two pieces at that time, the negative moment at the crown was retained. The hinges at the abutment were left open. After the bridge deck was completed, the space around the hinges were reinforced and sealed with concrete, converting the ribs into continuous forms.
19 The construction method was estimated to have saved by the reduction of the amount of concrete and steel that was required for the arches. 20 While Butler stated that "thenewmethod, which originated in Europe but had not prevfously been used in the United States;'' temporary hinge-eenstructien-had been-used before in Los Angeles by the Bureau of Engineering in the Main Street Bridge. 21 However, the hinges in the Main Street Bridge were converted into joints in their final form.
The construction costs for Fourth Street Bridge totaled approximately $-2;800,000~The viaduct was opened for train and vehicular traffic in July of 22 Seismic Retrofit The bridge was modified in and 23 The modification addressed the potential for earthquake damage, attempting to provide protection without executing a detailed analysis of the structure. Because the bridge deck consisted of slabs supported on the piers with: roller consisted of unifying the bridge deck by installingTesttaine1s ac10ss the ioints. More-retrofit construction would follow with the earthquake. 24 --------EollowingJhe 1989_.Whittier Narrows Earthquake, Proposition "G" was assembled to provide money for the seismic retrofit of bridges in Los Angeles. The voters passed the proposition in providing for the task.
Subsequently, the Federal government would pay of this amount. As part of this federal funding, historic structures underwent a review process to record and reduce ---lhWeW-:Methoct,-.,.41:'= -- - - - --- - - 18 See Plans and Specifications. 19 ''New Method," 48. 20 Butler, "Architecture and Engineering," 50. 21 Ibid. Also see "A Three-Hinged Ribbed Arch Concrete Bridge," Southwest Builder and Contractor, May 7, 22 Department of Engineering, Plans and Specifications, 1. 23 Caltrans, "Bridge Report: Fourth Street Viaduct," October 7, 24 John Koo and Shashi Bhakta in conversation with the author, June 13, FOURTH STREET VIADUCT HAER No. CA-280 (Page 7) modifications to the structure. 25 Fourth Street Viaduct was one of the 118 bridges that underwent a retrofit under the program.
In order to evaluate the modifications needed to improve the structure's response to an earthquake, the bridge was analyzed under a horizontal force. Subsequently, the Northridge Earthquake drove CalTrans, the California Department of Transportation, to amend the code to require bridge structures be analyzed at Re-analyzing the Fourth Street structure at resulted in variations of 10 per cent or less from the first analysis. 26 The Bureau of Engineering retrofit team selected a seismic design approach that would create a more rigid system. The modifications were approached as two phases: 1) to link the bridge elements together with redundancy and 2) to retrofit the substructure.
While the earlier modifications in 197 5 had united the bridge deck, the risk that the deck slabs might shift off the supports still existed if the restrainers became elongated. To minimize this risk, the seat widths were expanded and shear keys were installed. 27 The modifications tothe substructure included modifications to the piers and spandrel arch. The bents were aligned along the railroad tracks making them skew to the viaduct alignment. Some of these skewed bents were converted to shear walls by creating an infill wall between the piers. The spandrel arch was found to be more massive than the bridge deck, meaning the response of the arches would be greater than that of the bridge deck during the course of an earthquake.
In order to provide the arch with more lateral support, additional struts were added between the arch ribs. The deck, now acting as a diaphragm, was connected to the arches to provide to support the arch during laterally loading. The arch also needed this support due to the weak moment resistance provided at the former hinge locations.28 - -- -- - - - - The retrofit was executed under the City Engineer Vitaly Troyan and Clark Robins Deputy City Engineer of the Structural and Geotechnical Engineering Division. John Koo served as the project engineer. The retrofit-was c0mpleted in 25 Karin Tan to Tom LaBonge, Memo, 7 May 1. Provided by Structural Engineering Division, Bureau of Engineering. 26 John Koo and Shashi Bhakta in conversation with author, June 13, 27 Ibid. 28 Ibid.
FOURTH STREET VIADUCT HAER No. CA-280 (Page 8) SOURCES CONSULTED Published "Bridge Construction", Western Construction News, February 25, "Bridge Construction", Western Construction News, August 25, Butler, Merrill. "Architecture and Engineering are Harmonized in Fourth St. Viaduct", Southwest Builder and Contractor, August 7, Calhoun, Chad F. "Fourth Street Viaduct, Los Angeles", Western Construction News, August 10, Engineering Department of the City of Los Angeles. Plans and Specifications for Fourth Street Viaduct. Los Angeles: Board of Public Works, "Five Million Dollar Bridge Building Program Still Ahead of Los Angeles", Southwest Builder and Contractor, October 21, 37- 38. Mikesell, Stephen D. Historic Highway Bridges of California.
Sacramento: Caltrans, "New Method of Arch Rib Construction Feature Fourth St. Viaduct", Southwest Builder and Contractor, April 24, Unpublished Sources Conversation with John Koo and Shashi Bhakta. July 13, Lee, Portia. "Finding of Adverse Effect: Seismic Retrofit of Fourth Street Viaduct." On file, Structural Division, Bureau of Engineering, Department of Public Works, City of Los Angeles.