Powerhouse No. 1 is a contributing feature to the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System. The San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System was found to be eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C in The system was found eligible under Criterion A, for its representation of hydroelectric development in southern California and the system was also found to be eligible under Criterion C, for its use of tanks rather than forebays, which represented a departure from typical western hydroelectric systems, using a technique more common to the eastern United States. Furthermore, the San Gorgonio System utilized automatic controls which were a new innovation in the and later became an industry standard.
Additionally, the two powerhouses were found to be good examples of utilitarian structures influenced by Classical Revival style architecture. Report Prepared by: Ben Taniguchi, Historian II and Nicole Collum, Architectural Historian II Galvin Preservation Associates S. Pacific Coast Highway, Redondo Beach, CA Date: September Project Information SCE is planning to decommission the project's two power plants and part of their appurtenant water conveyance system. Some of the project components are scheduled to be decommissioned and removed, decommissioned and abandoned in place, or transferred to new ownership. The hydroelectric generators and other pieces of hardware and equipment will be removed from the powerhouse buildings, but the buildings will remain.
Components slated for removal will be demolished using SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 2) bulldozers and other components will be removed using hand crews where there is no present vehicle access. The San Gorgonio Pass Water Agency plans to acquire those project facilities that are not decommissioned. The transferred facilities would no longer be used for the generation of power. As a result of this project the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System was documented with Historic American Engineering Records. The entire system was documented in an overview report, San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System HAER No.
CA-2278 and each contributing element of the system was documented with separate supporting reports as follows: San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, East Fork Dam and Intake, HAER No. CA-2278-A; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, South Fork Dam and Intake, HAER No. CA-2278-B; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, Powerhouse No. 1, HAER No. CA-2278-C; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, Tank No. 1 and Penstock No. 1, HAER No. CA-2278-D; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, Operator's Bungalow, HAER No. CA- 2278-E; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, Operator's Garage, HAER No. CA-2278-F; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, Powerhouse No. 2, HAER No. CA-2278-G; San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, Flowline No. 2, Tank No. 2, & Penstock No. 2, HAER No. CA-2278-H.
SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 3) Part I: Historical Information Physical History Powerhouse No. 1 was constructed between and The original proposed drawing of Powerhouse No. 1 drawn by (likely an in-house architect or draftsman) is dated August 3, The original general specifications for the water wheel, governors and hydraulic equipment contained within Powerhouses No. 1 and 2 is dated July 14, and signed by Chief Engineer Charles O. Poole. An original six-page type written document showing general specifications for the generators, transformers, switchboards and control equipment contained within Powerhouses No.
1 and 2 is dated July 13, and is unsigned; the document was supplied to potential equipment suppliers prior to the construction of Powerhouse No. 1. There is also an original plan for the outgoing flowline for Powerhouse No. 1 dated October and drawn by The contractor for the building was CD. Sotiras. Physical alterations and additions to the building include: re-sheathing the roof with corrugated metal, stucco sheathing of the concrete, and the addition of security grills. Although, the precise dates of the above alterations are not known the corrugated metal roof, stucco sheathing of the concrete and the addition of security grills appears to date from the when Southern California Edison acquired the property.
The original paling fence around the transformers and the building likely occurred prior to SCE acquiring the property as a safety precaution; however the exact date of these alterations is not known. Historical Context Although, the Los Angeles based, Consolidated Reservoir and Power Company had initially planned to construct a hydroelectric power plant along the Whitewater River in concrete construction plans for a hydroelectric plant were not established until when reorganized as the San Gorgonio Power Company The company's objective was to utilize the already existing concrete irrigation conduit as a flowline for a series of power plants along the Whitewater River.
Once the project was completed the company would then sell the power produced to the Southern Sierras Power Company, who at the time provided electricity to the city of Banning. hired Charles O. Pool as the chief project engineer and CD. Sotiras as the contractor._ chose to construct both powerhouses for the system in the Classical Revival Style, which had been influencing the construction of powerhouse design since By September of construction began on both Powerhouse No. 1 and Powerhouse No. 2 which were designed to work in tandem, as a comprehensive system._ 1 Weber, Carmen A. and Richard Starzak. A Historical Assessment of the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System. Irvine, CA: Chambers Group, Inc., p. 3. 2 S. D. Mikesell. National Register of Historic Places Nomination, Kern River No.
3 Relicensing Project. Prepared by ENTRIX, Inc. for Southern California Edison Company, p 4. 3 "Power Plants Going In," The Banning Record, September 28, p. 1. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 4) Powerhouse No. 1, also known as "Big Oaks", was constructed in Big Oaks Canyon, situated at approximately feet above sea level. The mechanical equipment for Powerhouse No.l was purchased from the Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Company in Pittsburg Pennsylvania and shipped to the project site. The mechanical equipment inside the powerhouse consisted of a water wheel, generator, exciter, switchboard, and control equipment. The water wheel was a 2,330-horsepower Pelton impulse water wheel, controlled by a Pelton type 0.3 stream deflecting governor.
The generator, was a Westinghouse 1,875-kilowatt 2,400-volt, 60-cycle, three-phase, generator, which was mounted on the shaft next to the wheel. The shaft terminated at a Westinghouse 125-volt exciter, a switchboard with mounted operating controls monitored the system and a Venturi meter read the water flow through the plant. The transformer equipment located outside the powerhouse consisted of three Westinghouse single-phase 667 kV-a, Oil Insulated Self Cooled, 60-cycle, volt transformers with two frill-capacity taps on high-and low tension windings. Powerhouse No. 1 was placed into service on December 5, and Powerhouse No.
2 was placed into service 12 days later on December 17, By August of the system had a generating capacity of volts and fed into the Southern Sierras trunk line._ However, the output of the powerhouses was not sufficient enough to meet the power demands of the residents of Banning, especially during peak usage. Thus they were later downgraded to back-up status. Due to their back-up status, Banning continued to receive its primary power from the In reorganized as the San Gorgonio Electric Company, following financial difficulties as a result of the economic depression. In massive flooding affected areas of both Riverside and San Bernardino counties, when the Santa Ana River, which is linked with the Whitewater River, jumped its banks.
The flooding washed out sections of the flowlines near both the east and south fork intakes, significantly damaging the water intake system for Powerhouse No.l. The damaged sections were immediately repaired with spiral weld steel pipes that were reinforced to withstand any future flooding or landslides. On January 9, the San Gorgonio Electric Company sold the plant to the California Electric Power Company and on December 31, the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric system became part of the Southern California Edison Company by license transfer (this occurred when California Electric Power merged with the Southern California Edison Company).
SCE continued to use both the former power generating facilities until they were finally shutdown 4 SCE Manuscript, Operating Instructions and Description of the San Gorgonio Power Company System, Prepared by A.F.A., Engineering Department, August p. 2. 5 Mount and H. L. Fryer. "Southern/Hoover Hydro Generation Division History," Southern California Edison Manuscript, May 21, Southern Sierras Service Bulletin, Vol. 2, Number 11 August Weber, p. "Plane Trip Shows Scene of Desolation," Los Angeles Times, March 4, p. 1. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 5) in after Tank No. 1 collapsed; the property remains under ownership of SCE.
The irrigation system remains in operation (as of and the water rights are still owned by the Banning Heights Water Company; the system is owned and maintained by SCE. Please see the Historic Context section in the general Historic American Engineering Record for the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System (HAER No. CA-2278) for additional information. Part II. Structure/Design Information General Description San Gorgonio Powerhouse No. 1 (also known as Big Oaks Powerhouse) is utilitarian in style but has elements of the Classical Revival style. The tall one-story building has a rectangular floor plan that at the exterior measures x It has a reinforced concrete structural system with a two-by-three-bay plan (two bays on the ends and three on the side elevations).
The exterior is skimmed with textured stucco. A gabled roof sheathed with corrugated metal covers the powerhouse. One of the few decorative elements on the building consists of gable ends with shallow eaves with a cornice that frames a triangular louvered vent. Fenestration consists of large metal sash industrial awning windows with 30 panes each; the windows are located on all sides of the building and are covered by metal mesh security screens. The width of the window openings measures There are pedestrian entrances in recessed bays on both ends of the powerhouse that consist of single flush wood doors.
There is also a large service entrance on the southwest elevation that consists of an eight foot wide sliding wood door with diagonal grooved wood slat construction; the wood doors are covered with mesh screen security doors. The perimeter of the building is paved with a concrete walkway. The powerhouse, including a switch rack is surrounded by an eight foot tall chain link fence that is topped by barbed wire. Condition The overall condition of Powerhouse No. 1 is good. It appears to be structurally sound and there appears to be no deterioration of the exterior or interior. Exterior A steel bi-level switch rack that makes up the switch yard is located near the northern end of the powerhouse.
The switch rack rests on a concrete pad that measures approximately 18' x There is also an eight foot tall chain link fence between the rack and the powerhouse. 9 Timothy Smith, "Water Restoration Plan Passes 1st Vote," Record Gazette , November 29, website accessed November SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 6) The electrical equipment used in the switch yard consists of the following: A total of three circa Westinghouse single-phase transformers and a circa generator circuit breaker at the base of the switch rack. A total of three ground banks mounted on the upper portions of the rack. There are also several rows of ceramic insulators on the upper and middle levels of the switch rack.
Interior The entire floor of the powerhouse is paved with concrete that is scored in a geometric pattern. Powerhouse No. 1 contains equipment used for power generation. There are steel rafters that brace the roof and the trusses rest on the upper concrete ledge of the walls; the rafter system runs the length of the building and a single steel I-beam is attached to the trusses and is used as a track for an equipment crane. The power generating equipment is located on the southeast side of the powerhouse and a control panel and a resistor is located on the northwest side. A wood booth at the east corner of the room contains a toilet and a sink is attached to the outside of the booth.
The interior of the powerhouse is illuminated with light fixtures consisting of circa rafter mounted industrial double tube fluorescent lights with hoods. A circa emergency light with a porcelain shade is mounted on the rafters and a circa light fixture with a missing globe is mounted on the southwest wall, near the turbine generator. The power generating equipment consists of the following: Pelton impulse horsepower water wheel from the early that is powered by water fed through a penstock and the flow controlled by a TSO valve; the flow of the water is measured by a circa Venturi meter, which is attached to the base of the water wheel. The water wheel itself is covered by a rounded riveted steel cover (housing) with metal block letters that spells out P-E- L-T-O-N.
Westinghouse alternating current generator from the early kilowatt, volt, 60 cycle, three phase, 720 rotations per minute) that is powered by the Pelton water wheel via a shaft. The generator is mounted on a cast iron base and is installed over a tub that is used to make room for the lower half of the generator. The center of the turbine is covered by a steel cover with vented openings and the ends have steel covers that are in sections for ease of access. Control panel from circa containing switches and gauges used to control and monitor the generator and water wheel Westinghouse resistor from the early that controls the amount of direct current power that was transmitted to the generator field (inside of the generator). SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO.
1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 7) Yale Spur Geared Block crane from circa early that is controlled by a metal chain and pulley with an attached metal hook. The crane was used to carry sections of the power generator, which have metal loop hooks. Mechanical Operation The operating mode for Powerhouses No.l and No. 2 of the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System are unique in conception. Since the system gathers its water source from multiple streams, water could not be stored in a standard forebay, instead the system utilized tanks and relied on a special automatic system to maximize the flow of water. The operator for Powerhouse No. 1 would regulate the operation of Powerhouse No. 2 by remote control. This remote control system included: a push-button control for starting and stopping Powerhouse No.
2; a push button control of the load carried at Powerhouse No. 2, depending on the water level available in Tank No. 2 and an automatic control to shut down Powerhouse No. 2 when the available water level dropped below the minimum allowable. The system also used the following remote indicating devices with the electrical equipment: a water level indicator at both Powerhouse No. 1 and No. 2 for Tank No. 2, a load indicator at Powerhouse No. 1 for the load carried at Powerhouse No. 2 and audible indicator at Powerhouse No. 1 for when Powerhouse No. 2 goes off line automatically. They system was operated 16 hours a day, with powerhouse operators working in two 8- hour shifts. To begin the 16-hour cycle, the operator at Powerhouse No. 1 would manually start Powerhouse No. 1.
Shortly after, the operator at Powerhouse No. 1 would start Powerhouse No. 2 from remote control. This system worked based on the assumption that Tank No. 2 would be frill because at the end of the previous day the water from the Powerhouse No. 1 flowline would have been collected at Tank No. 2, filling the tank, when the system was shut down. Powerhouse No. 2 would carry a frill load until Tank No. 2 reached the half empty mark. Once this mark was hit, the load would be automatically reduced to a compatible level of Powerhouse No. 1 since, by that time, water from Powerhouse No. 1 would have reached Tank No. 2. Just before the end of the 16-hour cycle, Powerhouse No. 2 was increased to a frill load so that the water in Tank No. 2 would fall to the lowest operating level.
Once this occurred, Powerhouse No. 2 would be automatically shut down. The operator at Powerhouse No. 1 would shut down Powerhouse No. 2 once he received notification that Powerhouse No. 2 had been shut down. The water would then flow from Powerhouse No. 1 to Tank No.2, to fill the tank for operating the 16-cycle for the following day. When the water levels were low, the system could only be operated when Tank No. 1 was sufficiently frill. When this occurred the system could be operated at 50 percent or more capacity. One of the primary advantages to the design of the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric 10 Garrett, Automatic Hydro-Electric Plant of the San Gorgonio Power Company. The Electric Journal, Vol. XXII, No. 6. n Ibidp.286-287. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO.
1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 8) System was that it only required two operators to be on-site. A single operator at Powerhouse No. 1 to oversee the operation of Powerhouse No. 1 and Powerhouse No. 2 and a single operator at Powerhouse No. 2 which could leave the powerhouse to conduct routine maintenance throughout the system, including overseeing the flowlines and other 1 -i mechanical equipment. The system became fully automated by Once the system became fully automated each powerhouse was connected by a cable to its respective tank. Once the tank was full, a control signal was initiated to start the plant. This signal initiated the opening of the turbine needles to provide adequate water to operate the turbines at high efficiency.
When the water level in the tanks was at a predetermined low water level, the turbines were signaled to shut down and the cycle repeats. The units were synchronized to the system as synchronous motors, aided by speed switches and the generators' amortizer windings. The system was finally shutdown in following the collapse of Tank No. 1. Site Information Powerhouse No. 1 is located roughly three miles southwest of the East and South Fork Dams and Intakes located Whitewater River and one mile southwest of the site of Tank No. 1. It is feet above sea level. Powerhouse No. 1 is one of two powerhouses in the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System that contained equipment used to generate electrical power. The source of water for Powerhouse No. 1, Whitewater River originates at San Gorgonio Mountain.
Part HI: Sources of Information "Big Contract Let," Los Angeles Times, May 5, p. Brown, John. History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties. Madison, Wisconsin: The Western Historical Association, "Company is Formed to Harness Whitewater," Los Angeles Times, September 21, p. "Deal in Water Rights," Los Angeles Times, April 10, p. "File on Water of Whitewater," Los Angeles Times, October 20, p. Garrett, Automatic Hydro-Electric Plant of the San Gorgonio Power Company. The Electric Journal, Vol. XXII, No. 6. "Giant Engineering Feat is Accomplished," Los Angeles Times, April 31, p. 12 Garrett, Automatic Hydro-Electric Plant of the San Gorgonio Power Company. The Electric Journal, Vol. XXII, No. 6. 13 Ibid p. 50. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO.
1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 9) "Gives New Turn to Enterprise: Contract for Conduit Let by Power Company," Los Angles Times, May 3, p. Ill 1. "Great Project Nears Finish," Los Angeles Times, May 27, p. "Growing Fine Almonds, Apricots and Peaches around Banning," Los Angeles Times, March 1, p. Historic American Engineering Record (HAER), National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior, "Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System," HAER No. CA-145. "Important Water Claims Filed," Los Angeles Times, June 8, p. 7. Mount, and H. L. Fryer. "Southern/Hoover Hydro Generation Division History," Southern California Edison Manuscript, May 21, Myers, William A.
Iron Men and Copper Wires: A Centennial History of the Southern California Edison Company, Glendale, CA: Trans-Anglo Books, "New Power Project," Los Angeles Times, July 1, p. "Palm Springs (advertisement)," Los Angeles Times, October 8, p. 7. "Plane Trip Shows Scene of Desolation," Los Angeles Times, March 4, p. 1. "Power Houses Now Ready in Local Canyon," The Banning Record, November 29, p. 1. "Power Plants Going In," The Banning Record, September 28, p. 1. "Reservoir and Power Company Secures Privileges in White Water River," Los Angeles Times, April 10, p. "Riverside Utility to Buy L.A. Unit," Los Angeles Times, July 16, p. 10. Robinson, John W. "Cyrus Baldwin Southern California Hydroelectric Pioneer," The Branding Iron The Westerners Los Angeles Corral (Spring Robinson, John W.
The San Bernardinos: The Mountain Country from Cajon Pass to Oak Glen: Two Centuries of Changing Use, Arcadia, CA: Big Santa Anita Historical Society, Schuiling, Walter C. San Bernardino County: Land of Contrasts, Woodland Hills, CA: Windsor Publications, Inc., SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 10) "Settlers Worry About River," Los Angeles Times, April 27, p. Smith, Timothy. "Water Restoration Plan Passes 1st Vote," Record Gazette , November 29, website accessed November Southern Sierras Service Bulletin, Vol. 2, Number 11 August "Three After Water," Los Angeles Times, April 25, p. "To Harness Snow Creek," Los Angles Times, May 28, p. "Unduly Alarmed," Los Angeles Times, May 17, p. Ill 1. "Water Claims," Los Angeles Times, January 4, p. 13.
Weber, Carmen A. and Richard Starzak. "A Historical Assessment of the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System". Prepared by Chambers Group, Inc. and prepared for Southern California Edison, Rosemead CA. November "Where Water Pumps Water for Banning Orchards," Los Angeles Times, September 4, p. "Whitewater River Makes Greater Banning." The Banning Record, September 4, P. i. "Whitewater River Utilized," Los Angeles Times, July 19, p. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 11) Reduced size overview map of the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System. Map courtesy of Southern California Edison Company. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 12) M. Reduced size plan of Flowline No.
1 and No.2 with Powerhouse No.l identified to the northeast. Original drawing courtesy of Southern California Edison. Full size image available in the Field Records Section of the HAER for the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, HAER No. CA-2278. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 13) r_ Ui M^ Detail of Powerhouse No.l site taken from previous reduced size plan. Original drawing courtesy of Southern California Edison. SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 14) Reduced size drawing of Powerhouse No. 1. Original drawing courtesy of Southern California Edison Company. Full size image available in the Field Records Section of the HAER for the San Gorgonio Hydroelectric System, HAER No. CA-2278.
SAN GORGONIO HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, POWERHOUSE NO. 1 HAERNo.CA-2278-C (Page 15) Sketch plan for Powerhouse No.l site. Sketch plan created by Galvin Preservation Associates