BlockBefore

McKinley Park, Bounded by Alhambra Boulevard, McKinley Boulevard, 35th Street, Park Way, 33rd Street, and H Street, Sacramento

McKinley Park, Bounded by Alhambra Boulevard, McKinley Boulevard, 35th Street, Park Way, 33rd Street, and H Street, Sacramento, Sacramento County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-133, with a 6,971-word written history.

From the record

“McKinley Park is a significant cultural landscape as Sacramento s first park related to the American urban parks movement of the nineteenth century and to the phenomenon of pleasure grounds created by streetcar companies.”

Written record, HALS CA-133 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-133 · the record runs 6971 words · one of 165 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

6531 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-133. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

McKinley Park is a significant cultural landscape as Sacramento s first park related to the American urban parks movement of the nineteenth century and to the phenomenon of pleasure grounds created by streetcar companies. Developed in McKinley Park is also one of the earliest parks developed in the West only San Francisco s Golden Gate Park being older Its naturalistic design of meadows, informal tree plantings, and curving pathways is typical of urban parks during that period. The park is also significant for its collection of recreation features added during the reform park movement of the twentieth century prior to McKinley Park is significant at local and state levels.

Description: McKinley Park was originally known as East Park and was created as a destination park by Sacramento s street car company to promote use of the streetcars, primarily on weekends. Similar to other late nineteenth century pleasure grounds, the park s primary uses were picnicking, musical performances, dancing, ball games, and enjoying the naturalistic landscape. The park s naturalistic design was typical of urban parks of the era as pioneered by Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux at New York s Central Park. With roots in English estate landscapes, naturalistic park design borrowed from Pastoral and Picturesque landscape theories and promoted the benefits for urban dwellers to experience rural landscapes.

Trees and other vegetation were planted in random patterns calculated to emulate nature. Water features such as lakes were often part of the landscape. In the park became a city park with the encouragement of civic groups and it was named for President William McKinley who was assassinated a year earlier. The growth of suburban development in Sacramento resulted in the park being situated in a residential neighborhood, rather than an agricultural area on the outskirts of the city. As the park evolved, new facilities were added, but the overall naturalistic design was maintained. The rise of Progressivism in the in the early twentieth century led to government reforms and the search for solutions to social problems.

Government became actively involved in public health issues, housing, and clean water. Parks, and particularly services for children, became part of the Progressive-era goals. McKinley Park became 1 Land for San Diego s Balboa Park and Portland s Washington Park was set aside earlier, but neither park was developed until years later. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 2 a focus of city improvements including the Clunie Memorial building, library, and pool. A playground for children, basketball court, tennis courts, and other recreation facilities were also added to the park during this period.

The growth of the residential neighborhood around the park, and the development of other parks in Sacramento (particularly Land Park) meant a transition for McKinley Park from destination park to neighborhood park. Although no longer drawing as many people from other parts of Sacramento, McKinley Park has grown in importance for its contribution to the quality of life for east Sacramento neighborhoods. In recent years, with the city fiscally challenged to maintain park facilities, neighborhood groups such as the Friends of East Sacramento have rallied support to preserve and maintain the Clunie Memorial community center and rehabilitate the rose garden.

Landscape Characteristics Spatial Organization The design of McKinley Park appears to have grown organically over time and was not necessarily based on a master design plan. The one existing natural feature was the remnant of Burns Slough that became the park s Lake Kiesel. As the city s street grid was extended around the park, the rectangular pattern formed the shape of the park and became a major organizing element. As major park features (such as the Clunie Memorial, the Rose Garden, the tennis courts, and the Garden and Arts Center) evolved or were added over time, they were oriented with the street grid. The other major organizing element is the relationship of trees and open space meadows.

The trees are planted in naturalistic form with two large open spaces the sports field in the northwest corner, and the baseball diamond on the east side. The trees, meadows, and curving circulation paths follow the style of a naturalistic urban park established in the late nineteenth century. The concept was for these parks to provide a healthful natural experience as a foil to urban life. Despite the lack of a formal design, McKinley Park s landscape of mature trees, turf, and open meadows (sports fields) is a naturalistic and pastoral landscape of beauty with ample shade in warm weather. One formal element of the McKinley Park landscape that no longer exists is the palm drive entry to the park at the corner of Alhambra and H St.

This diagonal entry feature followed the original line of the streetcar track into the park. Sometime between and the tracks were removed and replaced by a road lined with an all e of palm trees. The roadway was removed in the (possibly related to the construction of the Clunie Memorial) and replaced with turf. Other trees were planted which have matured and most of the palm trees are no longer present, resulting in the loss of this design feature. A few of the palms remain. One other formal element is the rose garden which was established in The formal arrangement of beds and turf paths consists of concentric ovals with radiating paths on the ends. The oval form is said to derive from an oval running track that previously existed on the site. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO.

CA-133 PAGE 3 There is no complete record of how the park s design evolved and changed over time. The best available evidence is found by analysis of the collection of historic photographs. It appears that there have been minimal changes to the park s overall spatial organization since the end of the period of significance and therefore the park s spatial organization and overall design is a contributing feature to the historic significance of the park. Circulation Park circulation consists primarily of rational and functional pedestrian paths. A perimeter sidewalk and path encircles the park. This was supplemented in with a granular running path around the park perimeter.

Other pathways, primarily curvilinear in form, provide access to the park s interior, and a pathway encircles the lake. Vehicular circulation and parking is primarily on the streets around the park with two exceptions. One is the G Street extension that was built around to reduce congestion and provide parking. The other exception is the small parking lot at the Garden and Arts Center. There is no complete record of the circulation system during the historic period or how it changed over time other than what we see in historic photographs. It is assumed that much of the existing circulation system was in place at the end of the period of significance and is therefore a contributing feature.

Topography The topography of McKinley Park is mostly flat, as is much of this part of Sacramento being the former flood plain of the American River. The main topographic feature is the remnant of Burns Slough, and the lake that sits in the park s low point. The average elevation is approximately 20 above sea level, with most elevations in the park being between 18 and 22 , with the exception being Lake Kiesel which has a water level elevation of approximately 16 . Vegetation The vegetation of McKinley Park consists primarily of large mature trees and a turf ground plane. Shrubs and ground covers are used as accents in key places and in foundation planting around the buildings, but most of the landscape consists of open views in the meadows and below the trees.

A recent tree survey found over 500 trees of approximately 70 different species are present in the park2 that would qualify the park as an arboretum. Significant tree species in the park include London plane (Platanus acerfolia), English elms (Ulmus procera), several species of oaks (Quercus Canary Island date palms (phoenix canariensis), and Coast redwood (sequoia sempervirens). Most of the trees in the park appear to be in good condition judging by their full canopies, but a few trees are clearly in decline. As with any landscape of mature and senescent trees, a number of large trees have been removed in recent years. The East Sacramento neighborhood is known for its tree-lined streets.

The park has contributed to that with its row of historic sycamore trees along McKinley and a 2 The Magnificent Trees of McKinley Park. Sacramento Tree Foundation. Pamphlet, no date; and McKinley Park tree survey provided by the Sacramento Parks & Recreation Department. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 4 row of more-recently planted ginkgo trees along H Street. Although not part of the park, also notable is the row of Canary Island palm trees on the south side of H Street. The park s vegetation likely evolved and changed over time, however many of the existing trees were present during the period of significance. Overall the park s vegetation is considered as a contributing feature to its historic significance.

Horticultural Features The rose garden is the park s primary horticultural feature. The garden was established in by Frederick Noble Evans, a landscape architect and the city s first parks superintendent. The garden contains over ornamental roses and has perimeter companion beds with perennials, ornamental grasses and shrubs. Pathways between the beds are turf, and concrete bands edge the beds. Several steel arbors support climbing roses. Two large Canary Island date palms (Phoenix canariensis) are located at the center of the two semi-circular ends. Mature trees around the perimeter of the rose garden contribute to the gardens setting.

The rose garden underwent an extensive rehabilitation in Dating from the rose garden retains integrity and contributes to the historic significance of the park. Another notable garden in the park is the Japanese-style garden in the courtyard of the Garden and Arts Center. The garden, which included a water feature, is in need of rehabilitation. Water Feature The park s Lake Kiesel was one of the earliest features of the park, created from a remnant of Burns Slough that formerly carried flood water from the American River through the site. Construction of the North Levee in cut off Burns Slough from the direct flow of flood waters, but it remained a low area and was used for the creation of the lake in A wooden bridge and deck on the lake are no longer present.

The island was added in for wildlife habitat. Otherwise, the lake remains largely unchanged from the historic period. Buildings and Structures The two major buildings in McKinley Park are the Clunie Memorial Clubhouse and the Iva Gard Shepard Garden & Arts Center. The Clunie Memorial was designed by architects Harry Devine and Starks & Flanders. Opened in the brick building with terra cotta and concrete detailing is a modernist interpretation of Spanish Colonial Revival style. The building includes an auditorium, meeting room, branch public library, and pool house. The Clunie Memorial Clubhouse and pool are largely unchanged from the period of significance and are considered as contributory features to the park s historic significance.

The Iva Gard Shepard Garden & Arts Center opened in It was designed by architects Franceschi & Mullen, in the California Modernist style. The facility contains an auditorium, meeting rooms and an outdoor courtyard and garden. The Garden & Arts Center and the center s courtyard patio garden retain integrity from the period of significance and are both contributory features to historic significance of McKinley Park. Other park buildings include the rose garden building (used primarily for storage), rustic brick restroom near the baseball diamond, a picnic shelter and restroom near the MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 5 playground, and a small kiosk at the tennis courts.

Small Scale Features Small scale features include benches, picnic tables, signs, lights, monuments, plaques, arbors, drinking fountains, and other similar features. A few of these may date from the period of significance, but they are beyond the scope of this study to inventory individually. Physical Condition The park is maintained by Sacramento Parks and Recreation Department and is generally kept in good condition. Major features including the lake, children s playground, and rose garden have been rehabilitated in recent years. Individual Park Features Perimeter Sidewalk. The concrete sidewalk around the perimeter of the park was reportedly constructed in early with federal funding from the Works Progress Administration.

Much of this original concrete remains although sections have been removed and replaced with contemporary accessible curb ramps. One date stamp is found in the concrete reading A. Teichert & Son Contractors Contributing feature. Tennis Courts. The early tennis courts in this location were lawn tennis and were constructed around The date of construction of the existing courts is not known. Likely contributing as a continuing use. Tennis Courts Kiosk. The date of the small kiosk structure at the tennis courts is unknown (probably recent construction) and it is likely non-contributing. Garden & Arts Center. The garden and arts center is an excellent example of California Modernist architecture. Designed by architects Franceschi & Mullen. Contributing feature.

Garden & Arts Center Courtyard Patio Garden. The courtyard patio garden adjacent to the Garden & Arts Center is integrally designed with building and illustrates the close relationship between indoor and outdoor spaces in the California Modernist style. The patio and an original garden were likely part of the original building construction. The Japanese-style garden present today was installed circa (after the period of significance) but is a compatible feature. The garden includes traditional Japanese garden stones and plants. A water feature with a small pond and bamboo water pipe is no longer extant. Contributing feature. Picnic Areas. The main picnic area is south of the tennis courts and a smaller picnic area is west of the rose garden.

There is also a picnic area and shelter adjacent to the playground. Picnicking is a historic use in the park, but the current picnic facilities likely post-date the period of significance and there is no documentation of where picnic areas were located during the historic period. Non-contributing feature. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 6 Baseball Diamond. Baseball has been played in the park since its early days in the nineteenth century. The original diamond was in the northwest corner of the park. The current location of the baseball diamond was likely established after the zoo was relocated to Land Park in Contributing feature. Brick Restroom Building. The brick restroom near the baseball diamond was likely built during the Contributing feature. Horseshoe Pits.

The date of installation of the horseshoe pits is unknown. Perimeter Running Track. The granular running track around the park was installed in Non-contributing feature. Rose Garden. The rose garden was first created in by Frederick Noble Evans, the city s first parks superintendent. The oval shape reflects a running track that previously existing on the site. The garden was rehabilitated in Contributing feature. Rose Garden Building. The building adjacent to the rose garden was built around the same time as the rose garden. Contributing feature. G Street Extension and Parking Area. The extension of G Street into the park was reported created around to address traffic congestion and to provide additional parking. Contributing feature. Lake Kiesel.

The park s lake was created around as one of the early park features. It was created from the remnant of Burns Slough that previously connected to the American River. The lake was named in by the parents of Frederick Birdsall Kiesel after the death of their infant son. Contributing feature. Children s Playground. A playground in this location may have dated as early as the and is seen in photographs from the The current playground was constructed in Because none of the original equipment remains and there is no historic integrity, the playground is a non-contributing feature. Picnic Shelter. The existing picnic shelter near the playground was part of the playground reconstruction and is a non-contributing feature. Restroom Near Playground.

The existing restroom building was also constructed in and is a non-contributing feature. Basketball Court. A basketball court at this location dates from the but has been reconstructed and is a non-contributing feature. Clunie Memorial Clubhouse and Pool. The park clubhouse and pool was built in and houses an auditorium, meeting rooms, library, and pool house. The brick building is a modernist interpretation of Spanish Colonial Revival style. Contributing feature. Northwest Sports Field. The northwest turf area of the park has been used for sporting MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 7 events since at least the first decade of the twentieth century. Contributing feature. Park Light Standards.

The traditional-style pole and acorn luminaire are likely a recent addition to the park and are considered non-contributing. Irrigation System. The park s irrigation system may include components from different eras, but most of the system is likely of modern construction and system is considered non-contributing. Park Features No Longer Extant Original Park Clubhouse. The original park clubhouse was built in as a two- story, wood-framed building with a large wood deck that served as a basketball court and dance floor. The building was removed in Zoo. No physical description or photographs of the East Park zoo has been found, but a variety of animals were kept including a pond full of alligators. The zoo was closed in when a larger zoo was created at William Land Park.

Streetcar Line into the Park. A diagonal streetcar line entered the park and brought visitors directly to the original clubhouse. The tracks were removed sometime between and Palm Drive. After the streetcar tracks were removed, a park road was built and lined on either side by palm trees (some of which still exist). The drive was removed and replaced with turf, possibly related to the construction of the Clunie Memorial clubhouse and pool. Rustic Deck and Bridge. A rustic deck and bridge at the lake are seen in early photographs and postcards. It is not known when these features were removed. Auto Camp. An auto camp operated in the panhandle area of the park between and It served travelers on the transcontinental Lincoln Highway. Running Track.

A running track was built sometime prior to It was removed around and replaced with the rose garden which took on its oval shape. History: In the Sacramento Street Railway Company purchased 30 acres to develop as a destination park to promote its street car service. By East Park, as it was originally known, was being constructed. A two-story park building was built complete with balconies and piazzas with views to both the Sierras and the Coast Range.3 The streetcar line from H Street was extended directly into the park, bringing visitors right to the park building where events, music performances, and dances were held.4 3 Sacramento Daily Union. June 8, 4 Until approximately when overhead electric lines were installed, streetcars were pulled by mules. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO.

CA-133 PAGE 8 A newspaper report at the time noted that the grounds are being tastefully laid out with drives, avenues and approaches, and ornamented with trees, shrubs and flowers. 5 A lake was planned in the park s low point and constructed from a remnant of Burns Slough. The slough was once a source of flood waters into Sacramento from the American River. Levees were built to prevent the flooding and most of the slough was filled in and eventually developed. A zoo was part of the early East Park with deer, raccoons and other animals. The inspiration for the zoo was apparently the Woodward s Gardens, a combination amusement park, museum and zoo that opened in in San Francisco s Mission District.6 The early plantings in East Park were subject to trial and error.

An newspaper article noted that severe frosts killed or damaged a number of trees and shrubs including pepper trees, acacias, oleanders, and Australian gum trees. A nursery was set up on two acres in the southwest corner of the park to grow replacement plants.7 While East Park was purposefully designed, there is little record of who designed the park. It may have been C. Jacob Zeinwaldt (or Zumwaldt) who is credited as the park s first superintendent, with early park work being done under his direction.8 Zeinwaldt was listed as the East Park gardener in city directories from to and had previously worked as a farmer.9 In the streetcar company purchased an additional acres at the northeast corner of the park for a picnic grounds.

The park was deemed a success and the streetcar company added extra service on Sundays to accommodate the crowds. As early as the baseball games were a popular activity on weekends. Maintaining the park was costly and eventually the streetcar company lost interest and the park s condition deteriorated. In the Tuesday Club, a group of civic-minded Sacramento women, urged the city to purchase East Park. The Tuesday Club hoped that city stewardship would lead to park improvements, particularly the addition of a large children s playground. The assassination of President William McKinley in led to the Tuesday Club proposing to make the park a memorial to the slain president.

Their idea was not to build a memorial monument, but rather to make the park itself the memorial.10 At the time, Sacramento had no other large parks there was only Capitol Park and ten small public squares deeded to the city by John Sutter.11 In Albert Gallatin, president of the streetcar company had been planning to sell the East Park land to be subdivided for residential development. The Tuesday Club persuaded Gallatin to reduce the price for the land from to and allow the city to purchase the property. After much discussion, and the Tuesday Club promising to maintain and improve the park, the city finally agreed to purchase the park. 5 Sacramento Daily Union. June 8, 6 Reference to Woodward Gardens is made in the June 8, Sacramento Daily Union article. 7 Sacramento Daily Union.

February 1, 8 Sacramento Daily Union. November 23, 9 Anderson, Christy and Mahan, William E. Sacramento History Journal, Volume III No. 1, Winter & Spring P. 14. 10 Anderson and Mahan. P. 19. 11 Official Map of Sacramento. California State Library. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 9 Now under city ownership, East Park became McKinley Park. Through the efforts of Carrie Miller, the Tuesday Club managed to raise private funds for maintaining the park between and A city map shows McKinley Park in some detail for the first time. The map shows a developed system of paths or drives, a running track, deer park, flower garden, baseball field, lawn tennis, basketball, zoological gardens and a picnic grounds. In the city annexed East Sacramento and allocated funds for the maintenance of the park.

A Board of Park Directors was created in to oversee management of the park. In Sacramento engaged John Nolen, a landscape architect and urban planner from Cambridge, Massachusetts to prepare a general plan for a park system. The plan included a series of roadways and parks in Sacramento s surrounding suburban areas. East Sacramento was among the first suburban areas to be transformed with street and utility improvements, and residential development. The Lincoln Highway, the nation s first transcontinental highway, passed through Sacramento and in the city created an auto camp for travelers in the park s panhandle section.

The camp hosted over touring autos in It operated until neighborhood complaints resulted in its closure in In George Sim was hired as the city s first Superintendent of Playgrounds. He noted the poor condition of McKinley Park and began planning improvements. The park report of the Board of Park Directors noted several accomplishments including new plant nurseries, greenhouses, a children s playground, improved driveways, six tennis courts, an outdoor dance platform, and a running track.12 Also during this time, landscape architect Frederick Noble Evans was hired as the city s first Superintendent of Parks. A zoo had been part of the park since the early days of East Park. A variety of exotic animals were added over the years including two brown bear cubs, monkeys, and a lion.

A pond in the zoo area was full of alligators. With the creation of a new zoo in Land Park in the McKinley Park zoo was closed. The deer park area of the zoo became the baseball field (current site of the George Butter Cole Field) and additional tennis courts were built on the site of the zoological gardens. In Superintendent of Parks Frederick Noble Evans began planning a rose garden for McKinley Park on the site of a running track. The rose garden maintained the oval form created by the running track. The original park clubhouse was torn down in and plans were made for a new park facility. Florence Turton Clunie, Sacramento businesswoman and wife of Congressman Thomas J. Clunie, donated for the building of a community center and pool in McKinley Park.

Clunie died in and the park clubhouse and pool, that bears her name, were completed in Designed by architects Harry J. Devine and Starks & Flanders, the community center included an auditorium, meeting room, and public library branch in addition to the pool and bathhouse. 12 Anderson and Mahan. P. 29. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 10 As previously mentioned, the H Street streetcar line extended diagonally into the park from the southwest corner. The streetcar tracks were removed sometime between and and replaced with a park drive lined with an all e of palm trees. This striking design feature dominated views of the park for many years. The roadway was later removed and replaced with turf, likely around the time of the construction of the Clunie Memorial.

With the growth of other trees and loss of many of the palms, the all e effect has been lost, but a few of the palms remain, providing some evidence of this lost park design feature. In the early the Works Progress Administration (WPA), one of President Franklin Roosevelt s New Deal programs, built new sidewalks around the perimeter of the park.13 Around G Street was extended across the park s southwest corner to provide parking and reduce traffic congestion.14 In a garden and arts center was built on the panhandle section of the park. The building was designed by Raymond R. Franceschi (Franceschi & Mullen Architects).

In the garden and arts center was named for Iva Gard Shepard, leader of the Sacramento Garden Club and garden columnist for the Sacramento Bee.15 The children s playground was improved with new playground equipment in The facility was improved again in with a community-built playground, only to be destroyed by a fire in A community fundraising effort resulted in the current playground that opened in A popular 1.1-mile crushed granite running track around the perimeter of the park was added in In the City planned to close the Clunie Memorial due to budgetary constraints. Closure would have also resulted in the loss of the branch library housed in the building. The Friends of East Sacramento assumed management of the community center in and preserved access to this valuable community asset.

Also in the Friends of East Sacramento assumed management of the Rose Garden and provide volunteers who work to maintain the garden. McKinley Park Chronology The North Levee along the American River was raised to 30 cutting off the river from flooding the city, and cutting off Burns Slough from its water source. The transcontinental railroad is completed with Sacramento as its western terminus, significantly boosting the city s economy. Sacramento Street Railway Company purchases 30 acres of undeveloped and unincorporated land for use as East Park. Streetcars begin running along H Street to East Park. Early planting of the park included 600 evergreen trees (pines, cypresses, and acacias). 13 Anderson & Mahan. P. 34. 14 Anderson & Mahan. P. 36. 15 Anderson & Mahan. P. 36.

MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 11 The streetcar company builds a two-story park building with balconies and piazzas. The streetcar line is extended into the park to bring visitors directly to the park building. Social dances and musical performances begin in the park. Lake constructed from the remnant of Burns Slough. Railway company purchases an additional 14.5-acre parcel at the northeast corner of the park for a picnic grounds. Other improvements include ball grounds, shooting alleys, and a zoo. Baseball games were a regular activity in East Park. Railway company sells the site to a group of investors called the East Park Association (headed by Albert Gallatin), and the park falls into disrepair and suffers from competition from Joyland in the Oak Park neighborhood.

A formal carriage entrance at and F streets and a graded dirt path along the edges of the park are seen on an map. The Tuesday Club, a women s cultural improvement association, lobbies for the City to purchase East Park as a children s playground named in honor of recently-assassinated President William McKinley. The East Park Association has been considering subdividing the park for development. City Trustees voted to purchase the property from the East Park Association, and Albert Gallatin agrees to lower the price from to In convincing the city to purchase the park, the Tuesday Club claimed that they would maintain the park themselves (a fact later in dispute). To offset the cost of maintaining the park, the City fences off the 14.5-acre panhandle section and leases it as a cow pasture.

J. Henry Miller, manager of the park from to suggested the creation of flower beds in the park. City consults with city planner Charles Mulford Robinson on the city s park system. He notes that McKinley Park is very incompletely and poorly developed. ca. Streetcar tracks removed from within the park and replaced with a palm- lined drive. The City annexes East Sacramento into its boundaries, and allocates funding for the park s upkeep. City creates a Board of Park Directors to manage park-related issues, including McKinley Park s mosquito infestation. E Street is extended, creating McKinley Boulevard. An auto camp was established in McKinley Park s panhandle area to serve travelers on the transcontinental Lincoln Highway. George Sim hired as Sacramento s first Superintendent of Playgrounds.

Landscape architect Frederick Noble Evans hired as Sacramento s first Superintendent of Parks. Tennis courts built (approximate date). Residential development in the neighborhood around McKinley Park accelerates. Report of the Board of Park Directors extolled new plant nurseries, greenhouses, a playground for children, improved driveways, six tennis courts, an outdoor dance platform, and a running track. City approved the purchase and development of William Land Park, MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 12 creating another destination park for Sacramento. Due to objections from neighbors, the auto camp was closed. McKinley Park zoo is closed and animals transferred to a new zoo at Land Park. Frederick Noble Evans begins planning the McKinley Park Rose Garden.

The oval form reflects a running track that previously occupied the site. Original wood frame clubhouse torn down. Florence Turton Clunie Memorial Clubhouse and pool constructed. The federal Works Progress Administration (WPA, a New Deal relief agency) encircled the park with sidewalks. The rose garden was named after Frederick Noble Evans. ca.1955 The G Street extension cuts the southwest corner of the park to relieve congestion and provide more parking. Construction of the Garden & Arts Center (last major addition to McKinley Park). The Garden & Arts Center is named for Iva Gard Shepard. New playground equipment installed in the children s area.

Baseball diamond named in honor of George Butter Cole, who promoted amateur baseball in Sacramento from the A proposal to install a parking lot on the park s northwest corner resulted in a neighborhood rebellion and the plan was defeated. ca. The courtyard garden at the Garden & Arts Center was redesigned as a Japanese-style garden with garden stones and a small pond. A proposal to expand the Garden and Arts Building and add more parking was defeated by organized neighbors to preserve lawn areas and limit traffic. A 1.1 mile crushed granite running track was constructed around the perimeter of the park to address muddy conditions and protect tree roots. An island in Lake Kiesel was built to provide habitat and nesting ground for the ducks and geese.

A new community-built playground is installed. Improvements to the edge of Lake Kiesel were made including installation of a stone edge to address erosion (constructed from former Sacramento street paving stones) and a new pathway around the lake. Accessibility improvements made at Clunie Memorial City planned to close the Clunie Memorial. Friends of East Sacramento leases and assumes operation of the Clunie Memorial, and establishes the Clunie Community Center. City completes a rehabilitation of the rose garden with new irrigation system and accessibility improvements. Friends of East Sacramento sign a long-term lease for management of the rose garden. Playground destroyed by fire. Playground rebuilt after fire. Restroom and picnic shelter are also added as part of the project.

MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 13 Historic and Design Context With its strategic location at the confluence of the American and Sacramento rivers, Sacramento became a boom town after the discovery of gold at Sutter s Mill, the subsequent California Gold Rush, and California statehood in The settlement was selected as California s capital in By the with a population over Sacramento was growing into an American city and beginning to expand beyond its downtown core. The local streetcar company, looking for ways to expand ridership, purchased land and real estate interests were looking at lands to the east of downtown for expanding residential development.

Urban Parks Movement As the country was evolving from an agrarian economy to a more urban and industrialized economy during the nineteenth century, people s lives changed. Working and living conditions disconnected them from nature and outdoor activities. Oppressive urban conditions in New York led to the development of Central Park and it was recognized for its civilizing and humanizing influence. 16 Growing cities around the country recognized the need for urban parks and their development became a national movement. Even in the brand new cities of the West, parks were seen for both their social contributions but also for a way for them to show they were the equals of the cities of the East.

San Francisco established Golden Gate Park in Within a year, the Sacramento Street Railway Company purchased land to create a pleasure ground as they were called at the time. Although this park development by a streetcar company may have been more entrepreneurial (to gain riders and spur real estate development), the effect was the same and it provided residents a place for Sunday outings, music, dancing, and outdoor recreation. A pleasure ground park being created at the end of a streetcar line was not unique to Sacramento. In fact trolley parks were a phenomenon of the era and there may have been up to similar parks around the United States17. Many of these parks started similarly to East Park as pleasure grounds for picnicking, music, and other outdoor recreation.

A good number of them also developed into amusement parks with rides, carousels, swimming pools and other attractions (some of which survive today). McKinley Park may be unusual in that it became a city park. Naturalistic Park Design The earliest urban parks and squares in the United States were often small and of formal or geometric designs. At New York s Central Park, Frederick Law Olmsted created a naturalistic design that purposely contrasted from the urban environment of cities. Building on the naturalistic garden style espoused by American landscape designer Andrew Jackson Downing, Olmsted created a new design form and vocabulary for American urban parks.

These nineteenth century parks were characterized by open meadows defined by forested areas, and accented with natural features such as rock outcroppings, lakes, streams, and waterfalls. Curvilinear pathways and drives were designed to move park goers through the landscape with ever-changing vistas. East 16 David Schuyler. The New Urban Landscape: the Redefinition of City Form in Nineteenth-Century America. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 17 Street Railway Journal. Street Railway Parks and Pleasure Resorts. June 1, Vol. XVII, No. 22. MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 14 Park (later McKinley Park) was designed in this naturalistic tradition with meadows, informal tree plantings, its small natural-form lake, and curving pathways.

As in Central Park, East Park was created in the context of an urban grid of streets. Both parks rectangular shapes further contrasting with the organic, naturalistic designs within. Reform Parks Movement and Progressivism In the early decades of the twentieth century, social reformers worked to address urban issues through the reform and growth of local government and services. As municipal lands, urban parks were often seen as places well suited to provide social services.

The reform park movement resulted in new park facilities being added to parks including playgrounds, recreation and sports facilities, pools and public buildings.18 In McKinley Park, this reform movement is evidenced in the addition of tennis courts children s playground and the Clunie Memorial clubhouse and pool The Great Depression of the resulted in President Franklin Roosevelt s New Deal programs, several of which benefitted parks around the nation. The Works Progress Administration (WPA) and the Civilian Conservation Corps provided funding and labor for park projects. In McKinley Park, a new perimeter sidewalk and (possibly) the brick restroom building were benefits of these programs.

McKinley Park in the Context of Sacramento Parks When Sacramento s street grid was created in ten blocks distributed around the grid were reserved for public squares. Eight of these squares survive today as small parks in the downtown core. The 40-acre Capitol Park, created in the was the only other park in the downtown core. Land for East Park (later McKinley Park) was purchased by the streetcar company in and the park was opened in as Sacramento s first park other than the public squares. Land for Southside Park was purchased by the city in and William Land Park was created in the East Park was not the only Sacramento park created by a streetcar company. Oak Park (now McClatchy Park) was created in the at the terminus of a streetcar line whose goal was developing the suburb of Oak Park.

In a roller coaster, swimming pool and other amusements were added by the streetcar company, creating the Joyland amusement park. A fire in destroyed the amusement park and in the McClatchy family purchased the property and donated it to the city for a public park. Additional Note: At the time of this writing, July the City of Sacramento is in the initial stages of planning a 1 million cubic foot combined sewer system storage vault within McKinley Park. The vault is planned to be 270 by 300 by 40 deep and located under the existing athletic fields . The impacts to the park are currently unknown, but there is concern for the future of the historic landscape. 18 Galen Cranz. The Politics of Park Design- a History of Urban Parks in America. MIT Press, MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 15

Bibliography

219 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-133. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Anderson, Christy and Mahan, William E. History of McKinley Park. Sacramento History Journal. Volume III, No. 1, Winter & Spring Board of Park Directors. Park Report, Sacramento Room, Sacramento Public Library. California Southland. November Article on auto camp. California State Library. Cranz, Galen. The Politics of Park Design- A History of Urban Parks in America. MIT Press, Historic Environment Consultants. McKinley Park Rose Garden Evaluation of Significance. LD Research & Writing. McKinley Park Historic District Project, Phase I: Research, Writing & Recommendations. June Draft. Unpublished research report. Mead & Hunt. Cultural Landscape Survey and Evaluation of William Land Park. Norton, Merren Gillis. Achievements A History of the Tuesday Club of Sacramento, California.

California State Library. Phillips, Kerry C. Sacramento Park Neighborhoods. StoneBridge Properties, Sacramento Daily Union and Sacramento Bee. Various dates. Sacramento Tree Foundation. The Magnificent Trees of McKinley Park. Brochure, no date. Schuyler, David. The New Urban Landscape- The Redefinition of City Form in Nineteenth-Century America. Johns Hopkins University Press, United States Geologic Survey. TopoView website. Source for historic topographic maps. Historic Photographs and Maps: Historic photographs and maps used for research were from the following sources: - Center for Sacramento History - Sacramento Public Library - California State Library - Bancroft Library of the University of California - Sacramento Parks and Recreation Department - U.S. Geologic Survey

Written history

133 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-133. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Douglas Nelson, ASLA RHAA Landscape Architects Mill Valley, California July Second Place Winner HALS Challenge: Documenting City or Town Parks MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 16 Mature trees and grassy meadows characterize the landscape of McKinley Park. (Douglas Nelson, April Lake Keisel is a remnant of a former river slough. (Douglas Nelson, April MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 17 Rose garden. (Douglas Nelson, April Arbor, formal beds, and turf pathways at the rose garden. (Douglas Nelson, April MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 18 The Clunie Memorial clubhouse and pool. (Douglas Nelson, April The Iva Gard Shepard Garden & Arts Center. (Douglas Nelson, November MCKINLEY PARK HALS NO. CA-133 PAGE 19 Japanese-style garden at the Garden and Art Center.

(Douglas Nelson, November Perimeter running track around the park. (Douglas Nelson, April

In context

Sacramento, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Sacramento County, California 221 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Sacramento

24 of 101 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Sacramento building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Southern PacificHAER CA-30359,252 words
Reclamation District 1000HAER CAL,33-SAC.V,1-17,861 words
Central Pacific Transcontinental RailroadHAER CAL,34-SAC,63-14,932 words
Southern Pacific Railroad DepotHABS CA-234013,351 words
Strub BuildingHABS CAL,34-SAC,60-11,356 words
Sacramento Junior CollegeHABS CAL,34-SAC,68A-9,730 words
Hudson-Cippa-Wolf RanchHABS CAL,34-SAC,61-8,813 words
Southern Pacific Railroad DepotHABS CAL,34-SAC,69A-8,744 words
California State Printing OfficeHABS CAL,34-SAC,59-7,759 words
Leland Stanford HouseHABS CAL,34-SAC,9-7,047 words
Sacramento Army DepotHAER CAL,34-SAC,49-6,269 words
Esquire TheaterHABS CAL,34-SAC,67-5,837 words
Sacramento River Water Treatment Plant Intake Pier & Access BridgeHAER CA-3245,366 words
Coolot BuildingHABS CAL,34-SAC,66-5,269 words
Crocker Art GalleryHABS CAL,34-SAC,20-5,036 words
Sutter's Fort State Historic ParkHALS CA-1304,608 words
Studio TheaterHABS CAL,34-SAC,70-4,362 words
Sacramento River BridgeHAER CAL,34-SAC,58-4,200 words
Lincoln SchoolHABS CAL,34-SAC,55-3,869 words
California State Library & Courts BuildingHABS CAL,34-SAC,64-3,336 words
Sacramento City HallHABS CA-418-A3,285 words
California State Office Building No. 1HABS CAL,34-SAC,65-3,154 words
Sacramento City HallHABS CAL,34-SAC,48-3,130 words
San Francisco BoulevardHALS CA-1462,189 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-133. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.