This recording project was completed in compliance with Mitigation Measure HIST-1 as described in the report entitled Draft Environmental Impact Report for a 22-Unit Condominium Housing Project La Puente, California.1 This documentation was undertaken in April and May by Justin Castells, M.A. of PaleoWest, LLC and Dennis Hill of Dennis Hill Content Creation and was submitted to the City of La Puente. 1 Chambers Group, Inc. Draft Environmental Impact Report for A 22-Unit Condominium Housing Project, La Puente, California. Prepared by Chambers Group, Inc. for the City of La Puente, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 2) Part I. Historical Information A. Physical History: 1. Date of Erection: 2. Architect: S. Charles Lee 3.
Original and Subsequent Owners: Steven and Emma Chorak Robert Stein Leo Borunda Arturo Gutierrez and Efrain Tobalina (1976-early Star of La Puente, LLC (Present owner). 4. Builder, Contractor, Supplier: Summerbell B. Historical Context2: City of La Puente History Europeans first came to the La Puente region in when the Portola Expedition led by Gaspar de Portola entered the San Gabriel Valley. When the Mission San Gabriel was established in the La Puente region was incorporated into the mission lands and used primarily as agricultural land. By the region was being referred to as Rancho de La Puente.3 After Mexico declared independence from Spain in the Mexican government secularized mission lands and distributed much of the property as land grants.
Rancho La Puente was one of the largest Mexican land grants in California. In it was granted to John Rowland by Governor Juan Alvarado as a 17,740-acre rancho for The rancho was enlarged to acres in when Governor P o Pico named both John Rowland and William Workman as co-owners. With the annexation of California by the United States in the validity of the grant was reviewed by the U. S. Land Commission; and it was not until that title was confirmed by President Andrew Johnson.4 The western half of the rancho was granted to Workman; while the eastern half, including the future site of the City of La Puente, was granted to Rowland.5 In the Southern Pacific Railroad came through the La Puente Valley and a depot was built to accommodate the railroad.
By only two additional buildings had been constructed, a saloon/store/post office and a warehouse. The town of La Puente was 2 The historical context was largely excerpted from Castells, Justin. Historic Assessment Report of the Star Theater, 145 North 1st Street, La Puente, California. Prepared by Chambers Group, Inc., San Diego, California, 3 Van Horn, David M. and Laurie S. White. A Historic Resource Report on the City of La Puente Downtown Business District Specific Plan Area, Los Angeles County, California. Prepared by Archaeological Associates, Sun City, California, 4 Workman and Temple Family Homestead Museum. Rancho La Puente.: Accessed at: Accessed 5 Van Horn, David M. and Laurie S.
White; PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 3) officially established in when a townsite of 37 parcels of land was offered for sale. The townsite grew slowly as businesses serving the railroad and surrounding ranches began to be built. Growth in the area was slow in large part due to the lack of readily available water in the La Puente Valley.6 In to address the lack of water, rancher Will McClintock drilled a line of wells across his property. Other ranchers followed suit, and soon the region s agricultural economy began to thrive. By the area s major agricultural products were oranges, beans, and walnuts.
Between and the population of La Puente more than doubled, and the agricultural industry continued to grow.7 In the the city was home to the world s largest walnut packing plant.8 As with most of the country, La Puente was hit hard by the Great Depression, which also coincided with significant loss of citrus and walnut crops due to disease. The post-World War II years saw a dramatic reversal of fortune for the region as agricultural lands were developed into housing tracts. In the City of La Puente was incorporated. The community continued to grow throughout the twentieth century as a bedroom community for the City of Los Angeles.9 Today, the suburban community of over people is predominately residential with commercial land use located primarily along major highways and streets.
Industrial land use is less than five percent of the City's 3.5-square- mile land area.10 S. Charles Lee Star Theater Architect Simeon Charles Levi (later Lee) was born in Chicago in Growing up in Chicago, he was influenced by the works of Daniel Burnham, Louis Sullivan, and Frank Lloyd Wright. Lee s favorite building was reportedly the Carson Pirie Scott Department Store designed by Louis Sullivan. Lee s career in architecture began in working after school in the office of architect Henry Newhouse, who specialized in designing small motion picture houses and nickelodeons, and remodeling storefronts into theaters.
Lee attended the Chicago Technical College and graduated in He served in the Navy during World War I, after which he attended the Armor Institute of Technology and earned a degree in architecture in At the Armor Institute of Technology, Lee s coursework primarily followed the principles of the Ecole des Beaux Arts, but he was also interested in modernism.11 Lee moved to Los Angeles in and joined an architecture syndicate. By Lee 6 Ibid. 7 Ibid. 8 City of La Puente. A Little History of La Puente. Accessed at Accessed 9 Van Horn, David M. and Laurie S. White; 10 City of La Puente, 11 Scheid, Ann. S. Charles Lee, Architect. UCLA Library, Special Collections.
Accessed at Accessed PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 4) was unhappy with the arrangement of the syndicate and sold his interest to form his own architecture firm.
It was during this time that he changed his last name from Levi to Lee to avoid potential anti-Semitism from clients.12 Soon after the establishment of his firm, Lee received his first theater commission, The Tower Theater.13 Completed in the theater was designed in the Renaissance Revival style and was the first movie theater to be wired for talking pictures.14 With the success of the Tower Theater, Lee s career skyrocketed as he received commissions for a succession of grand movie palaces, including the Saban Theater (formerly the Fox Wilshire) in the Los Angeles Theater in and the Bruin Theater in Lee s designs of the often Art Deco or Streamline Modern, reflected the opulence of Hollywood during that period.
They often included extensive use of neon lighting, etched aluminum, bas relief murals, and sculptures. Lee also recognized early the impact of the automobile and incorporated driveways and rear parking into his theater designs, most notably with the Florence Theater and the Academy Theater With the onset of World War II, the construction of new theaters in the United States slowed as building materials such as steel were diverted to support the war effort. Material scarcity continued into the years after the War and, as a result, influenced the look of movie theaters, including those designed by S. Charles Lee. He began to experiment using alternative materials such as porcelain, glass, and plastics. His designs of the also often used plaster, terra cotta, and concrete.
Lee s theater designs of the differed from his earlier designs in many respects. Much of the flamboyant curves and excessive ornamentation that typified his work during the was gone. His designs were squarer, sparer, and less streamlined in appearance. The scale and proportions, however, were much larger to attract the attention of passing motorists. The space above the marquee often featured a huge decorative motif, and the name of the theater was often spelled in large letters directly on the building itself.17 One of Lee s most notable departures from his previous work was his experiments with the Quonset hut design.
The Quonset hut, which is composed of a prefabricated structure of corrugated metal that is shaped like a half cylinder, was developed during World War II as an economical building that was quick and easy to construct. The design appealed to Lee in the post-War years because it was inexpensive to build and easy to cool while also having good acoustics.18 12 Valentine, Maggie. The Show Starts at the Sidewalk: An Architectural History of the Movie Theater, Starring S. Charles Lee. Princeton: Yale University Press, 13 Los Angeles Conservancy. S. Charles Lee Accessed at Accessed 14 Los Angeles Conservancy. Tower Theater. Accessed at Accessed 15 Los Angeles Conservancy. S. Charles Lee 16 DeWolfe, Evelyn. UCLA to Be Custodian for S. Charles Lee s Renderings. Los Angeles Times, February, 19, pg.
O1. 17 Valentine, Maggie, 18 Ibid. PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 5) Lee also experimented with lamella roof structures, which are trussless roofs made of short, wooded sections arranged in a diamond pattern that formed a continuous arch. The design originated in Europe in but did not become commonly used in the United States until the and Among the most prominent uses of lamella structures was for the Houston Astrodome and the New Orleans Superdome The design was particularly attractive during this period because wood was a cheap, unrestricted material; and the design allowed for wide spans with no supporting columns. Lee designed five theaters using the lamella design between and including the Star Theater.19 Of the five lamella roof theaters designed by S.
Charles Lee, at least two have been demolished.20 The Helix Theater in La Mesa, California, and the Garmar Theater in Montebello, California, were both demolished in the The Visalia Theater (now the Main Street Theater) in Visalia, California, still remains. Research has yielded no information on the location and status of the fifth theater. During his career, Lee designed more than 400 movie theaters around the world. While he is most widely recognized as a designer of movie theaters, he also designed thousands of residential, industrial, and commercial buildings over the course of his prolific career. One of his most notable commercial buildings was the Max Factor Building in Hollywood.
Lee died in at the age of History of the Star Theater According to Los Angeles County Assessor Office data, the Property was constructed in The building was the Puente Theater, which was later renamed the Star Theater. Prior to it appears that the lot that the Star Theater occupies was undeveloped. Sanborn Map coverage from and show no development on the parcel.24 USGS maps from and also do not depict any buildings on the parcel.25 The Puente Theater was designed by S. Charles Lee and constructed during the post- World War II period when demand for movie theaters was growing in suburban areas, but restrictions were still in place for certain building materials including steel. The 19 Ibid. 20 Los Angeles Conservancy.
Correspondence between Adrian Scott Fine of the Los Angeles Conservancy and John DiMario of the City of La Puente, Dated June 20, 21 Cinema Treasures. Helix Theater, La Mesa Boulevard, La Mesa, CA. Accessed at: Accessed LA Eastside. Memories of a Lost Boulevard: The Garmar Theater. Accessed at: page-2. Accessed 22 Los Angeles Times. S. Charles Lee; Architect of Art Deco Theaters. Jan 30, pg. A22. 23 Los Angeles County Assessor. Property Assessment Information System. Retrieved October from Accessed 24 Sanborn Map Company. La Puente, CA. Volume 1, Sheet 4, New York: Sanborn Map Company, Sanborn Map Company. La Puente, CA. Volume 1, Sheet 4, New York: Sanborn Map Company, Sanborn Map Company. La Puente, CA. Volume 1, Sheet 4, New York: Sanborn Map Company, 25 U.S. Geological Survey (USGS).
USGS Historical Topographic Maps, various dates. Accessed at Accessed PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 6) Puente Theater was one of five theaters designed by Lee between and that utilized lamella roof design. Of Lee s five lamella roof theaters, the Puente Theater is the only theater designed with the half-cylinder shape exposed.26 The other four theaters were designed with rectangular facades more consistent with Lee s other theaters from the The Puente Theater was initially owned by Steven and Emma Chorak.27 In the Choraks sought damages against film distributors under the treble-damage provision of the antitrust law, asserting that the nearby El Monte Theater was given preferential booking to their own Puente Theater.
In a lawsuit that the Los Angeles Times referred to as the first of its kind, the courts found in favor of the film distributors.28 Research has yielded little additional information regarding Steven and Emma Chorak. Between and the name of the theater was changed from the Puente Theater to the Star Theater; and Robert Stein became the owner of the theater.29 Between and Leo Borunda purchased the property.30 Research has yielded little information regarding Stein or Borunda. Borunda sold the property to Arturo Gutierrez and Efrain Tobalina in Shortly after Gutierrez and Tobalina purchased the property, they changed the format to adult X-rated films.
In addition to the Star, Tobalina and his wife operated two other X-rated theaters, the Mayan in downtown Los Angeles and the X Theater in Hollywood.31 Research has yielded little additional information regarding Gutierrez or Tobalina. It appears that by Gutierrez and Tobalina sold the theater to Jose Cortez.32 The theater continued to show adult films until when the theater lost its adult entertainment permit.33 Between and the theater was renovated and began showing first-run family films with Spanish subtitles before closing in In subsequent years the theater has been abandoned and has fallen into disrepair. Part II. Architectural Information A. General Statement: 1.
Architectural Character: The Star Theater is a two-story Modern-style theater building constructed in The building is of lamella roof construction 26 Los Angeles Conservancy. Correspondence between Adrian Scott Fine of the Los Angeles Conservancy and John DiMario of the City of La Puente. 27 County of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety. Application for Building Permit, Permit Dated November 28 Los Angeles Times. Film-Booking Battle Won by Distributors. October 21, pg. A1. 29 City of La Puente Planning Department. Correspondence, Re: Advertising Sign Star Theater. March 31, 30 City of La Puente Planning Department. Planning Department Correspondence, Re: 145 North First Street. March 10, 31 Morris, Jonathon S.
Groups Fight Theater Showing X-Rated Films: Protesters Press la Puente City Council to Close Movie House for Zoning and Moral Reasons. Los Angeles Times, October 30, pg. SG1 32 City of La Puente Planning Department. Planning Department Correspondence, Re: 145 North First Street, 33 Baer, Stephanie K. La Puente s Star Theater could be headed for demolition. Here s why activists are trying to save it. San Gabriel Valley Times. May 8, updated August 30, 34 Los Angeles Conservancy. Star Theater. Accessed at Accessed PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 7) resulting in a half-cylinder Quonset hut-style appearance. The walls are clad in rough-textured stucco on the east and west elevations.
The north and south elevations feature rough-textured stucco to approximately three-quarters of the way up the building, with the top of the cylinder being clad in exposed aluminum sheeting. Heating, ventilating, and air conditioning units and piping are located on the roof of the building. The building has been abandoned since and is largely in disrepair and much of the building is in poor condition. The east elevation features a half-circle fa ade. The first and second floors are separated by a cantilever overhang that extends out from the building into a point. The exterior edge of the overhang is enclosed in horizontal wood siding. The primary entrance to the theater is recessed beneath the overhang on the east elevations.
The recessed entryway is flanked on either side by wood-frame movie poster display cases. Two sets of commercial metal doors flank a wood-frame movie poster display case that is centered on the fa ade. The south set of commercial doors has been boarded with plywood, and the glass on the north set of commercial doors has been broken. The south wall of the entryway features a built-in ticket window with security glass. The second floor of the east elevation is recessed beneath an arched eave that extends to the top of the cantilevered overhang. A row of aluminum-framed, double-hung windows is centered on the second floor of the east elevation, the majority of which have been covered with plywood. Above the windows are two rows of vents, one of which has been filled with an A/C unit.
One aluminum-frame, double-hung window is located on each of the angled walls of either side of the second floor of the east elevation. The windows have been boarded with plywood. A marquee sign extends east from the center of the second floor of the east elevation. The sign is attached to the building by metal brackets and supported from below by a metal pole. The plastic insert of the marquee sign features the word Star with a decorative star motif on the north and south elevations of the sign. The west elevation of the building features two sets of double security doors. Above each security door is a triangular vent. A square vent is centered on the elevation near the roofline. The elevation features metal piping and a light over the south security door.
The south elevation is clad in rough-textured stucco and features no doors of fenestration. A metal pipe, likely a portion of a light pole, is mounted to the building on the west portion of the south elevation. The east portion of the north elevation features a wood electrical room addition with rough-textured stucco siding, above which is a dormer with a small door with two vents. A metal pipe, likely a portion of a light pole, is mounted to the building on the west portion of the north elevation. The remainder of the elevation is clad in rough-textured stucco and features no doors of fenestration. PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 8) A large-scaled sign is located adjacent to the northeast corner of the building.
The sign is freestanding and composed of 10 alternating metal poles supported by four regularly spaced brackets. A metal flagpole extends upward from the top bracket. The top of the sign features a large star with five successively smaller star shapes made of neon lights on the north and south elevations. The lights are all white except for the third star, which is yellow. 2. Condition of Fabric: The condition of the fabric is generally poor. While the building retains much of its historic material, years of neglect have led to a general disrepair and deterioration of much of the building. B. Description of Exterior: 1. Overall Dimensions: Approximately by 53' 2. Foundations: Concrete 3. Walls: The walls are clad in rough-textured stucco on the east and west elevations.
The north and south elevations feature rough-textured stucco to approximately three-quarters of the way up the building 4. Structural System, Framing: Lamella-roof/ wood framed Quonset hut 5. Openings: a. Doorways and Doors: The primary entrance to the theater is recessed beneath the overhang on the east elevations. The recessed entryway is flanked on either side by wood-frame movie poster display cases. Two sets of commercial metal doors flank a wood-frame movie poster display case that is centered on the fa ade. The south set of commercial doors has been boarded with plywood, and the glass on the north set of commercial doors has been broken. The west elevation of the building features two sets of double security doors. b.
Windows: A row of aluminum-framed, double-hung windows is centered on the second floor of the east elevation, the majority of which have been covered with plywood. One aluminum-frame, double-hung window is located on each of the angled walls of either side of the second floor of the east elevation. The windows have been boarded with plywood. 6. Roof: a. Shape, covering: The building is of lamella roof construction resulting in a half-cylinder Quonset hut-style appearance. The north and south elevations feature rough-textured stucco to approximately three-quarters PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 9) of the way up the building, with the top of the cylinder being clad in exposed aluminum sheeting. C. Description of Interior: 1. Floor Plan: a.
First Floor: Lobby on east elevation with snack counter, bathrooms and theater entrance doors on north and south portions of the lobby. A stairway is in the south portion of the lobby. Beyond the lobby is the main auditorium which had an east-west rectangular plan. A small stage and screen are located on the east portion of the auditorium. b. Second Floor: The second floor features an office, projector room, bathroom, and storage spaces. 2. Stairways: A stairway with a single landing is in the south portion of the lobby and provides access to the second floor. 3. Flooring: Concrete flooring, intermittent carpeting. 4. Wall and Ceiling Finish: Smooth stucco walls, drop ceiling concealing exposed lamella roof structure. D. Site: 1.
Historic Landscape Design: The Star Theater was constructed on a previously undeveloped lot and was surrounded with hardscape. An approximately square foot parking lot was located to the south of the building. Part III. Sources of Information A. Bibliography Baer, Stephanie K. La Puente s Star Theater could be headed for demolition. Here s why activists are trying to save it. San Gabriel Valley Times. May 8, updated August 30, Castells, Justin. Historic Assessment Report of the Star Theater, 145 North 1st Street, La Puente, California. Prepared by Chambers Group, Inc., San Diego, California, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 10) Chambers Group, Inc. Draft Environmental Impact Report for A 22-Unit Condominium Housing Project, La Puente, California. Prepared by Chambers group, Inc.
for the City of La Puente, Cinema Treasures. Helix Theater, La Mesa Boulevard, La Mesa, CA. Accessed at: Accessed City of La Puente Planning Department. Correspondence, Re: Advertising Sign Star Theater. March 31, City of La Puente Planning Department. Planning Department Correspondence, Re: 145 North First Street. March 10, City of La Puente. A Little History of La Puente. Accessed at Accessed County of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety. Application for Building Permit, Permit Dated November County of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety. Application for Occupancy Inspection. Dated October 23, DeWolfe, Evelyn. UCLA to Be Custodian for S. Charles Lee s Renderings. Los Angeles Times, February, 19, pg. O1. LA Eastside. Memories of a Lost Boulevard: The Garmar Theater.
Accessed at: page-2. Accessed Los Angeles Conservancy. S. Charles Lee Accessed at Accessed Los Angeles Conservancy. Tower Theater. Accessed at Accessed Los Angeles Conservancy. Correspondence between Adrian Scott Fine of the Los Angeles Conservancy and John DiMario of the City of La Puente, Dated June 20, Los Angeles Conservancy. Star Theater. Accessed at Accessed Los Angeles County Assessor. Property Assessment Information System. Retrieved October from Accessed Los Angeles Times. Film-Booking Battle Won by Distributors. October 21, pg. A1. PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 11) Los Angeles Times. S. Charles Lee; Architect of Art Deco Theaters. Jan 30, pg. A22. Morris, Jonathon S.
Groups Fight Theater Showing X-Rated Films: Protesters Press La Puente City Council to Close Movie House for Zoning and Moral Reasons. Los Angeles Times, October 30, pg. S. Charles Lee Papers, University of California, Los Angeles Special Collections. Charles E. Young Research Library. Sanborn Map Company. La Puente, CA. Volume 1, Sheet 4, New York: Sanborn Map Company, Sanborn Map Company. La Puente, CA. Volume 1, Sheet 4, New York: Sanborn Map Company, Sanborn Map Company. La Puente, CA. Volume 1, Sheet 4, New York: Sanborn Map Company, Scheid, Ann. S. Charles Lee, Architect. UCLA Library, Special Collections. Accessed at Accessed U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). USGS Historical Topographic Maps, various dates. Accessed at Accessed Valentine, Maggie.
The Show Starts at the Sidewalk: An Architectural History of the Movie Theater, Starring S. Charles Lee. Princeton: Yale University Press, Van Horn, David M. and Laurie S. White. A Historic Resource Report on the City of La Puente Downtown Business District Specific Plan Area, Los Angeles County, California. Prepared by Archaeological Associates, Sun City, California, Workman and Temple Family Homestead Museum. Rancho La Puente. Accessed at: Accessed B. Supplemental Material Historic Photographs (see field notes). PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 12) Part IV. Appendix: Color Images Fig. 1. East elevation showing front entrance and sign, looking west. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 13) Fig. 2.
Detail view of eastern end of front entrance showing star sign, marquee and entrance, looking south. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 14) Fig. 3. View of east and north elevations showing entrance and sign looking southwest. Dennis Hill, April 26, Fig. 4. View of eastern end of north elevation and sign looking southeast. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 15) Fig. 5. View of north and west elevations looking south-southeast. Dennis Hill, April 26, Fig. 6. View of west and south elevations looking northeast. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 16) Fig. 7. Contextual view of south and east elevation looking northwest. Dennis Hill, April 26, Fig. 8. Detail view of front entrance and ticket booth looking south-southwest.
Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 17) Fig. 9. Interior view of candy counter and entrance to auditorium looking west. Dennis Hill, April 26, Fig. 10. Interior view of windows on second floor of east elevation looking east. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 18) Fig. 11. Interior view showing projector windows second floor, looking west- northwest. Dennis Hill, April 26, Fig. 12. Interior view of auditorium showing auditorium entrance and projection windows looking east. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 19) Fig. 13. Interior view of auditorium showing auditorium screen looking west. Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 20) Fig. 14. Interior detail in auditorium showing wall structure looking south.
Dennis Hill, April 26, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 21) Fig. 15. Interior detail ceiling view looking up to the east. Dennis Hill, May 7, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 22) Fig. 16. Interior view from auditorium showing auditorium entrance, ceiling and acoustic tiles looking east. Dennis Hill, May 7, PUENTE THEATER HABS CA-2934 (Page 23) Fig. 17. Interior detail view of ceiling and plaster wall looking south. Dennis Hill, May 7,