BlockBefore

Selma Las Palmas Courtyard Apartments, 6700-6718 West Selma Avenue and 1535-1555 North Las Palmas Avenue, Los Angeles

Selma Las Palmas Courtyard Apartments, 6700-6718 West Selma Avenue and 1535-1555 North Las Palmas Avenue, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CA-2968, with a 3,888-word written history.

From the record

“The property is significant as a prime example of courtyard housing designed in the American Colonial Revival style.”

Written record, HABS CA-2968 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CA-2968 · the record runs 3888 words · one of 386 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

88 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2968. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

West Selma Avenue and North Las Palmas Avenue, Los Angeles, Los Angeles County, California. The approximate center of the property is located at latitude: and longitude: For specific location coordinates, see the HABS report for each of the three buildings. The points were obtained on September 1, using Google Earth There is no restriction on their release to the public. Present Owner/ Occupant: The present owner is Cross Roads Properties I, The three apartment buildings are occupied by numerous residential tenants, although many of the units are vacant.

Significance

51 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2968. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The property is significant as a prime example of courtyard housing designed in the American Colonial Revival style. The three two-story courtyard apartment buildings and five one-story garages were designed by engineer Joseph J. Rees. The buildings were constructed in by the Aetna Construction Company, which was owned by Irving Siegel.

Written history

3439 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2968. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

This report was prepared for the Los Angeles Department of City Planning in compliance with a condition of approval and a mitigation measure for a mixed- use development project known as Crossroads Hollywood (ENV-2015-2026- EIR). The project involves the demolition of all of the buildings on the property. In addition to the architectural historian Teresa Grimes, the project team included the photographer Dennis Hill. The project sponsor was Harridge Development Group, SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of erection: The apartment buildings and garages were constructed in 2. Engineer: The buildings were designed by the engineer Joseph J.

Rees Rees was born in Grodno, Russia2 on March 19, His last name was originally Rzepniewsky. He was educated as a civil engineer while he and his wife, Eugenia, were living in Liverpool, England. They immigrated to the United States in and became citizens a decade later.3 Like most Russian Jewish immigrants to Los Angeles, they settled in Boyle Heights.4 By Rees and his family had moved west to East Hollywood, and he served as the president of the Rees Engineering Company with offices at 253 S. Broadway in Downtown Los Angeles.5 He died on November 11, at the age of Rees designed at least one other building for the Aetna Construction Company, a two-story apartment house at S. Hobart Boulevard in 3.

Original and subsequent owners, uses, and occupants: Original Owner The original owner of the property was the Aetna Construction Company. When the buildings were constructed, Irving Siegel was the president of the company. Siegel was born in Brooklyn, New York on February 7, to Jewish parents, Louis and Yetta, who had immigrated from Poland. Louis Siegel was a contractor and the family slowly moved to Los Angeles with stops in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania8 and Berrien County, Michigan.9 By the early the family was living in Los Angeles and Louis and Irving were working together in the construction industry under the banner L. Siegel & Son.

Together they constructed a number of apartment buildings, mostly in the area now called Wilshire Center-Koreatown.10 When Louis died in Irving founded the Surety Building & Finance Co. and continued to construct apartment buildings.11 By the name of the company had changed to Aetna Construction.12 In Siegel 1 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permits No. LA18813, LA18814, LA18815, May 8, 2 Grodno changed countries several times. It was part of Poland after World War I, U.S.S.R after World War II and is now within Belarus. 3 U.S. Federal Naturalization Records, October 24, 4 U.S. Census 5 California Voter Registration, U.S. World War II Draft Registration Card, 6 U.S. Find a Grave Index. 7 Construction of Eight Apartment Houses Due, Los Angeles Times, August 16, 8 U.S.

Census 9 U.S. Census 10 Zoning Change Yields Activity, Six Apartments Rise After Pellissier Ruling, Los Angeles Times, October 28, 11 New Apartment Building s Cost to Be Los Angeles Times, June 28, Construction of Eight Apartment Houses Due, Los Angeles Times, August 16, 12 Ten Buildings Rise, Others Planned in Same Program, Los Angeles Times, April 24, SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 3) was part of a group of investors that purchased the Sunset Fields Golf Club, renamed it the Brentwood Country Club, and admitted Jews as members. Siegel died in at the age of 47.

His estate, valued at was almost entirely left to his wife and their adopted son.13 Subsequent Owners The property was sold to a partnership headed by Kee Whan and Kyung Hee Ha, along with In Kyo and Ok Ja Han, Ok Suk and Busun Kim as well as with Sung Ho and Que Hee Lee on September 24, On April 26, the four couples placed it under Las Palmas Apartment c/o Olympic Property Management Company. A year later, on April 4, it was deeded to Louis and Carmen Harvey Warscham. A few months later, on June 13, the property was sold to the Cross Roads Trust, with Morton La Kretz as the Trustee. Finally, on June 20, the property was placed under Cross Roads Properties I, the present ownership of record.

Original and Subsequent Uses The three apartment buildings have been used as multi-family residences since they were constructed. Original and Subsequent Occupants The tenants have changed frequently since the three apartment buildings were constructed. 4. Contractor and suppliers: The Aetna Construction Company was the contractor.14 No information was found regarding the suppliers of building materials. 5. Original plans and construction: No original plans or historic photographs of the property were found. The field inspection and building permit record indicate the property has not been significantly altered from its original construction. It is comprised of two O-shaped apartment buildings at and N. Las Palmas Avenue and a third U-shaped apartment Building at N.

Las Palmas Avenue and W. Selma Avenue. There are also five garages along the rear (west) property line that are accessed by driveways between the apartment buildings on Las Palmas Avenue and from Selma Avenue. All of the buildings have wood-framed structures sheathed in stucco. The two- story apartment buildings have American Colonial Revival style features on the street- facing facades and within the courtyards, while the five one-story garages are utilitarian in design. The three apartment buildings share many features creating an overall cohesive aesthetic, but each has a unique design. 13 Kin Inherit Million from Irving Siegel, Los Angeles Times, January 18, 14 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permits No.

LA18813, LA18814, LA18815, May 8, SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 4) 6. Alterations: Alterations to the individual buildings are described in separate HABS reports (HABS No. CA-2968-A, HABS No. CA-2968-B, and HABS No. CA-2968-C) for the three apartment buildings as their related garages. B. Historical Context The Selma Las Palmas Courtyard Apartments are significant in the context of architecture as an excellent example of a courtyard apartment complex designed in the American Colonial Revival style. Courtyard Apartments15 The courtyard apartment was the natural successor to the earlier development of the bungalow court in Southern California.

Courtyard apartments were first built in the when multi- family residential construction in Los Angeles began in earnest, with the type continuing to evolve in form and style through the However, proliferation of the courtyard apartment in Los Angeles reached its zenith in the The growing popularity of this type of multi-family housing during this period coincided with the greatest population growth in the city s history. While the bungalow court reflected the earliest attempt at a compromise between privacy and density, the pressing demand for more housing made it necessary to develop a higher-density residential alternative.

The courtyard apartment of the and early built on the early twentieth century trends but the form of buildings and the integral landscaped spaces depended to a much greater extent on precedents found throughout the Mediterranean region and Mexico. According to Stephanos Polyzoides, Roger Sherwood, and James Tice, authors of Courtyard Housing in Los Angeles, European and Middle Eastern sources for the courtyard apartment include what they label as the urban patio house and the urban callejon. 16 The former was a basic element of urban structure in western antiquity. On the Iberian Peninsula, it can be traced through six centuries of Roman domination. The callejon is a dead-end urban street that is typical of Arab cities in southern Spain.

Though it is composed of different buildings, the scale of the street, framed by the openings of the attached buildings creates a dynamic, unified space. Another ingredient in the development of and early courtyard apartment houses was the contemporary interest in vernacular adobes of California, many of which were arranged around a central courtyard or patio. These buildings were the subject of numerous publications, including Donald R.

Hannaford and Revel Edwards Spanish Colonial or Adobe Architecture of California, 15 Adapted from Historic Resources Group, Context: Residential Development and Suburbanization, Theme: Multi- Family Residential Development, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, (December 16 Stephanos Polyzoides, Roger Sherwood, James Tice, and Julius Shulman, Courtyard Housing in Los Angeles: A Typological Analysis (Berkeley: University of California Press, 28. 17 Donald R. Hannaford and Revel Edwards, Spanish Colonial or Adobe Architecture of California, (New York: Architectural Book Publishing Company, Inc., SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No.

CA-2968 (Page 5) By the late Southern California courtyard apartments were labeled by New York architect and housing expert Henry Wright as a California Type essentially a complex constructed around an open patio.18 These projects were seen as regional variants of the garden apartment, a concept that Wright and others endorsed as a desirable solution to the cause of humane urban living. Courtyard apartments were distinguished from their predecessors by their multi-story massing, which could more than double the number of units that could be accommodated on the same lot.

Because of the unobtrusive manner in which courts merged with smaller and less socially active buildings, they were utilized extensively in spot development that did not disrupt the physical and social context of given neighborhoods.19 Also, courtyard apartments contained their residential units in a single building, or perhaps a mirrored pair of buildings, allowing for greater density than could be achieved with earlier bungalow courts, where units were freestanding. Furthermore, unlike the relatively modest bungalow court, whose construction originally dominated the early development of multi-family housing in Southern California, the courtyard apartment of the was primarily designed for and marketed to somewhat more affluent residents.

The initial form of the courtyard apartment complex evolved from that of the bungalow court: one or two buildings, typically two stories in height, oriented around a central common area. Examples of courtyard apartments constructed during the height of their development in the frequently featured a U-shaped plan, which is believed to account for some eighty percent of the known courtyard apartments in Los Angeles.20 Alternate arrangements included the similar double-L shaped plan or the completely enclosed O-shaped plan. Buildings could contain as few as four or as many as twenty units, sharing common walls.

Few windows faced the street; instead, they were concentrated on the courtyard facades to provide more attractive views.21 In the central open area of each building were one or more courtyards with fountains, and, often, luxuriant tropical plants in small private garden spaces.22 As the location, density, and quality of courtyard housing shifted to accommodate a growing upper-middle-class clientele, architects became increasingly involved in their design. Several architects were instrumental in the development of the courtyard apartment as a building type during the The best-known examples were designed by brothers F. Pierpont Davis and Walter S. Davis, and by the husband-and-wife team of Arthur and Nina Zwebell.

The character of courtyard apartment complexes was defined through the work of these architects and others throughout the As Polyzoides explains, The ideal image of the suburban landscape (coupled with early building regulations safeguarding against earthquakes) 18 Henry Wright, The Apartment House, A Review and Forecast, Architectural Record Vol. 69 (March 19 Polysoides et al., Courtyard Housing in Los Angeles, 12. 20 Polysoides et al., Courtyard Housing in Los Angeles, 38. 21 Robert Winter and Alexander Vertikoff, The Architecture of Entertainment: L.A. in the Twenties (Salt Lake City, UT: Gibbs Smith, 90. 22 Ibid. SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 6) kept the courts to a two-story limit.

Within these limits, courts had no need to advance or radically depart from common building technologies of the period from to 23 As a result, significant departures from the original building type were not seen until later decades, when increased density requirements forced the intensification of building within the court envelope.24 Today, examples of courtyard apartments can be found throughout the city, particularly in those neighborhoods that originally developed or saw rapid growth during this period. The majority of extant examples were designed in the Spanish Colonial Revival style, with others popular styles of the period represented in smaller numbers, including Mediterranean Revival, French Norman Revival, Tudor Revival, and Streamline Moderne.

Known architects of these properties, in addition to those mentioned above, include Arganbright, Charles Gault, Arthur W. Larsen, Allen Ruoff, Milton R. Sutton, Frank M. Tyler, and Paul R. Williams. The next evolution of the courtyard apartment occurred in the Government regulations for construction-controlled price, size, financing, permits, and materials, which curbed the expression of earlier architectural forms and channeled building toward small houses and apartment houses.25 At the same time, the postwar population boom necessitated a sudden and substantial need for housing. Developers of courtyard apartments during this period responded by moving away from the O- shaped plan and adopting the E-shape plan, which allowed for the construction of a greater number of units.

Complexes also continued to exhibit the traditional U-shaped plan, but complexes now featured a central building entrance with common stairwells and interior corridors, rather than the former plan of individual entrances. Garages were no longer incorporated into the plan for the apartment complex itself but were detached from the building and frequently situated at the rear of the property. Styles, too, evolved during this period, away from the widely utilized Spanish Colonial Revival and other Exotic Revival styles popular during the Postwar courtyard complexes frequently exhibited the more modern American Colonial Revival or Minimal Traditional styles.

The iteration of the courtyard apartment was popular in the southeastern parts of the San Fernando Valley, which was developing during this period. Today, examples of the type can be found in Toluca Lake, North Hollywood, Valley Village, and Sherman Oaks. The residences tend not to employ architects, but instead are builder-designed. 23 Polysoides et al., Courtyard Housing in Los Angeles, 24 Ibid., 44. 25 Merry Ovnick, Los Angeles: The End of the Rainbow (Los Angeles: Balcony Press, SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No.

CA-2968 (Page 7) American Colonial Revival26 The American Colonial Revival style became popular after the Centennial Exposition in Philadelphia in and even more so after the Columbian Exposition in Chicago in Americans looked back to the colonial past idealistically as a time when life was simpler and purer. They exhibited enthusiasm for all things colonial, including everything from clothing to furniture. The period room in museums, installed as a replica of an interior from a particular period, also became popular during the late nineteenth century. The American Colonial Revival and its related styles were not as widely used in Los Angeles as other historicist styles such as the Spanish Colonial Revival.

It was most frequently applied to residential buildings, though there are examples of its application to other building types. The Early and Late American Colonial Revival styles were by the far the most widely used iterations of the style. Large-scale residences, found in neighborhoods such as Bel Air, tended to be more direct reproductions of the style and were often the work of well- known architects such as Paul Williams or Roland Coate. Early examples of the style date to the though the Dutch Colonial Revival style usually pre-dates this period.

Homes constructed in the style were often described in local newspapers and building trade journals as imposing, solid, and reminiscent of the architecture of the colonial South, where the rural setting allowed the upper classes to build homes that reproduced the sprawling footprints of English gentry houses. One residence, the Los Angeles Times wrote, was said to be reminiscent of the early South Carolina colonial type, with suggestions of the English Georgian. 27 More modestly sized bungalows and residences, on the other hand, simply borrowed design elements such as columns or entryway detailing.

Residential examples of the style tend to be scattered geographically, so there are few examples of neighborhood concentrations occurring in the city, though some exist in the San Fernando Valley. The style was somewhat popular for commercial and institutional buildings, which applied Classical and American colonial architectural forms to a larger scale. The style was used for schools, churches, banks, libraries, and post offices in this manner. It was less commonly used for small-scale commercial buildings, and such examples tended to be constructed after World War II. These small-scale commercial buildings are found in neighborhoods such as Toluca Lake and Studio City that developed during the postwar period.

Early American Colonial Revival was often a looser interpretation of colonial architecture than the contemporaneous Georgian Revival. The earliest examples of the style took design elements or influences, such as columns and pediments, and applied them to otherwise Victorian era buildings. By the late and early the style began to be utilized in a manner that was more faithful to eighteenth century architecture, though it was still not as duplicative as the Georgian Revival style. Most examples of the style constructed in Los Angeles were single- family residences, though multi-family residential and commercial examples can also be found. The style was even applied to bungalow courts, a fitting idiom for a democratic housing type.

26 Adapted from GPA Consulting, Context: Architecture and Engineering, Theme: American Colonial Revival, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, (December 5, 27 Reminiscent of South, Los Angeles Times, July 2, SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 8) Architects who worked in the style included Dennis and Farwell, Walker and Eisen, Paul Williams, Roland Coate, John Byers, and Edla Muir. Buildings constructed in the Early American Colonial Revival style are typically one or two stories in height, symmetrical in design with the entryway as the primary focus, and have hipped or gabled roofs, most often with boxed eaves. They feature simple classical detailing, sometimes with exaggerated proportions.

They usually have clapboard or brick exterior cladding; multi- pane double-hung sash windows, frequently with fixed shutters; and paneled front doors, sometimes with sidelights and transoms. Other design details may include pediments, columns or pilasters, and multiple roof dormers. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: The following discusses the overall character of the Selma Las Palmas Courtyard Apartments, as individual buildings are described in separate HABS reports. The property contains one U-shaped and two O-shaped courtyard apartment buildings that are oriented toward Selma Avenue and Las Palmas Avenue respectively. The apartment buildings are set back from the street with relatively narrow landscaped front yards.

The northern, U-shaped courtyard is visible from the Selma Avenue, while the central and southern O-shaped courtyards are barely visible through the main entrances from Las Palmas Avenue. In both cases, the units are oriented around the common outdoor area. The two-story apartment buildings are American Colonial Revival in style; however, the character-defining features are concentrated on the street-facing facades and within the courtyards.

The character-defining features included hipped roofs with boxed eaves and dentil moldings, symmetrically organized facades with project bays that give dimension, centrally located main entrances, second story balconies with diamond patterned steel railings, and stucco exteriors with classical details like stringcourses between stories and fluted pilasters and quoins at corners. Steel casement windows sometimes have decorative wood lintels or stucco frames. Unit entrances consist of paneled wood doors flanked by pilasters. Some have triangular pediments, some have broken pediments, and others are straight lintels. The side and rear facades are plain by comparison.

Roofs are flat with low parapets, steel casement windows are organized randomly, and walls are generally unarticulated and lacking in detail. The one-story garages are also simple in design. They all have flat roofs with the exception of the one facing Selma Avenue, which has a hipped roof. Roll up metal garage doors are paneled on Selma Avenue but ribbed elsewhere. SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 9) 2. Condition of fabric: Building conditions vary and are described in more detail in separate HABS reports for individual buildings. B. Description of Exterior For a description of each apartment building exterior, see HABS No. CA-2968-A, HABS No. CA-2968-B, and HABS No. CA-2968-C. C.

Description of Interior For a description of each apartment building interior, see HABS No. CA-2968-A, HABS No. CA-2968-B, and HABS No. CA-2968-C. D. Site 1. Historic landscape design: For description of each apartment building landscape design, see HABS No. CA-2968-A, HABS No. CA-2968-B, and HABS No. CA-2968-C. 2. Outbuildings: For description of the garages behind each apartment building, see HABS No. CA-2968-A, HABS No. CA-2968-B, and HABS No. CA-2968-C. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Architectural Drawings: None found. B. Early Views: Sanborn Map Company. Los Angeles Volume 10. Sheet Accessed on September 1, www.lapl.org. UCSB Library Geospatial Collection. Aerial Photographs. Various dates. Accessed on September 1, C. Interviews: None conducted. D. Selected

Sources

206 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2968. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Ancestry.com. California Voter Registration Records, U.S. Federal Census, U.S. World War II Draft Registration Cards, U.S. Federal Naturalization Records, U.S. Find a Grave Index. Various dates. City of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety. Building Permits. Various dates. Hannaford Donald R., and Revel Edwards. Spanish Colonial or Adobe Architecture of California, New York: Architectural Book Publishing Company, Inc., SELMA LAS PALMAS COURTYARD APARTMENTS HABS No. CA-2968 (Page 10) Historic Resources Group. Context: Residential Development and Suburbanization, Theme: Multi-Family Residential Development, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement. Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, December GPA Consulting.

Context: Architecture and Engineering, Theme: American Colonial Revival, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement. Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, December Los Angeles City Directory. Various dates. Los Angeles Times. Various dates. Ovnick, Merry. Los Angeles: The End of the Rainbow. Los Angeles: Balcony Press, Polyzoides, Stephanos, Roger Sherwood, James Tice, and Julius Shulman. Courtyard Housing in Los Angeles: A Typological Analysis. Berkeley: University of California Press, Winter, Robert and Alexander Vertikoff. The Architecture of Entertainment: L.A. in the Twenties. Salt Lake City: Gibbs Smith, Wright, Henry. The Apartment House, A Review and Forecast, Architectural Record, Vol. 69, March E. Likely Sources Not Yet Investigated: None. F. Supplemental Material: None.

In context

Los Angeles, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Los Angeles County, California 1,078 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Los Angeles

24 of 142 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Los Angeles building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Los Angeles River BridgesHAER CA-27121,165 words
Los Angeles Music CenterHABS CA-278018,683 words
Lytton Savings and Loan AssociationHABS CA-293616,955 words
Eames HouseHABS CA-290316,265 words
Times Mirror Building and Parking StructureHABS CA-293514,277 words
Los Angeles City HallHABS CAL,19-LOSAN,51-9,036 words
Crossroads of the WorldHABS CA-29658,968 words
Vickrey-Brunswig BuildingHABS CA-27988,766 words
Plaza HouseHABS CA-27998,766 words
Golden Gate TheaterHABS CA-28798,348 words
Holiday BowlHABS CA-27758,280 words
Westlake School for GirlsHABS CA-27918,007 words
Morris Landau HouseHABS CA-27897,644 words
The Hollywood Reporter BuildingHABS CA-29597,302 words
Olive Switching StationHABS CAL,19-LOSAN,80-7,190 words
El AlisalHABS CAL,19-LOSAN,15-6,775 words
Parker CenterHABS CA-29236,594 words
First Street Viaduct over Glendale BoulevardHAER CA-23436,577 words
Brunswig AnnexHABS CA-27936,453 words
University of California Los AngelesHABS CA-2678-A5,023 words
California Teachers Association Building No. 1HABS CA-29604,425 words
Hollyhock HouseHABS CAL,19-LOSAN,28-4,248 words
Rancho La Brea AdobeHABS CAL,19-LOSAN,26-4,227 words
Bullinger BuildingHABS CA-29644,042 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CA-2968. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.