This report was prepared for the Los Angeles Department of City Planning in compliance with a condition of approval and a mitigation measure for a mixed- use development project known as Crossroads Hollywood (ENV-2015-2026- EIR). The project involves the removal of all of the buildings on the property. In addition to the architectural historian Teresa Grimes, the project team included the photographer Dennis Hill. The project sponsor was Harridge Development Group, MAJOR HARRY E. KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of erection: 2. Architect: Unknown1 3. Original and subsequent owners, occupants, and uses: Original Owner and Occupant The house was constructed in for Maj.
Kunkel and was used as his dwelling until Kunkel was born in Missouri in By he had moved to Los Angeles and worked in the restaurant his brother William had founded at 463 S. Spring Street. When Harry joined William, their restaurant became known as Kunkel & Kunkel.3 By Harry was engaged as an engineer at Kass, Derr, and Dameral Heating Co.4 Kunkel married Norma Sternberg of Minnesota in and the couple purchased the subject property.5 By the couple had moved to S. Alvarado Street.6 7 During World War I, Kunkel was a pilot with the Infantry in France.8 He rose to the rank of Major and proudly used the title the remainder of his life.
During the he was the Air Pollution Controller, first for the City and then the County of Los Angeles.9 He died in at the age of Subsequent Owners and Occupants The property has been owned and occupied by a number of people. From to it was owned and occupied by the Zabach family including Frank A. and Lena L., both immigrants from Germany, and their children Ernest, Frances, Frank, George, and Rose.11 1 The house was constructed before Hollywood consolidated with Los Angeles, and Hollywood did not keep building permits. 2 U.S. Census, Harry was still living in Missouri at this time. 3 Los Angeles City Directory, 4 Los Angeles City Directory, 5 Marriage Licenses, Los Angeles Herald, January 27, 6 Los Angeles City Directory, 7 Sometime during the the couple divorced. In the U.S.
Census Harry was single and Norma was remarried to John B. Young. 8 U.S. Army Transport Service Arriving and Departing Passenger Lists, August 9, and For Los Angeles Own, Los Angeles Times, March 19, 9 New Official Appointed by County to Speed Up Drive Against Smog, Los Angeles Times, October 23, 10 Maj. Kunkel, First Smog Fighter for City, Dies, Los Angeles Times, February 18, 11 U.S. Voter Registrations, Los Angeles City Directory, and MAJOR HARRY E. KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 3) From to approximately the various members of the Uhlik family lived at the property.
The family include Charlotte May Uhlik and her five sons, Clark, Edgar, Mark, Robert, and Jere As early as until as late as Frank and Anna Pappalardo, Italian immigrants, owned and occupied the property with their children Frank John, and Grace. Everyone in the family was a working musician and Frank and Anna operated a musical instruments store at Hollywood Boulevard.13 Other residents included Gloria Gordon14 during the and and Mamie and Eugene Bean during the and Original and Subsequent Uses The house was used for its original purpose until approximately when the property changed owners. The house is currently used as an office. 4. Contractors and suppliers: No information was found regarding the contractors or suppliers of building materials. 5.
Original plans and construction: No original plans or historic photographs of the property were found. The property consists of a one-story house constructed in at the southwest corner of lot and a one-story garage constructed in at the northeast corner of the lot. The field inspection and building permit record indicate the property has sustained some alterations from its original construction. Rectangular in plan, the house has a wood-framed structure sheathed in wood clapboard and a concrete foundation. The low-pitched composition shingle roof is side gabled with overhanging eaves and exposed rafter tails. There are vents in the apex of the gables on the north and south facades. The primary (west) facade is asymmetrically organized and two bays wide.
A recessed porch occupies the south bay and contains a door in the corner and a group of five casement windows. The porch is defined by two wood posts atop square piers and a wood plank balustrade. The north bay contains a group of four casement windows. A shed dormer with exposed rafter tails and three windows is centered on the west slope of the roof. Fenestration on the other facades consists of casement windows in a variety of sizes. 6. Alterations: The building permit record documents some but not all of the alterations. The house appears to have remained substantially intact until the 12 U.S. Census, Los Angeles City Directory, 13 U.S. Census, Los Angeles City Directory, 14 Los Angeles City Directory, 15 Los Angeles City Directory, MAJOR HARRY E.
KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 4) In a permit was issued to replace the roof material on the house.16 In a permit was issued to bolt the house to the foundation.17 In two permits were issued to remove the chimney and repair the related roof material.18 Most of the unpermitted alterations to the house appear to have occurred just after when the ownership of the property changed. These include the application of stone to the porch pillars, the addition of knee braces to support the overhanging eaves, the addition of wood crosspieces around the porch posts, the installation of a security door over the back door and bars on all of the windows, the addition of a small deck at the northeast corner, and the application of texture coating to the clapboard siding.
The property is surrounded by a pipe metal and wire fence that appears to be original; however, the other site features were added at a later date. The driveway long the north property line was presumably added when the garage was constructed in but the asphalt appears to be non-original. The wood and stone arbor at the front entrance to the property was likely added after as the construction resembles the alterations to the front porch. A door and window sheltered by a shed roof porch were add to the south fa ade of the garage at an unknown date but likely after B. Historical Context19 The Maj. Kunkel House significant in the context of early residential development in Hollywood, prior to its consolidation with Los Angeles.
Hollywood is one of ten incorporated cities that consolidated with the City of Los Angeles for one reason or another. The other one- time independent cities include Wilmington, San Pedro, Sawtelle, Eagle Rock, Hyde Park, Venice, Watts, Barnes City, and Tujunga. Of all the pre-consolidation cities, Hollywood seems the most improbable. It had no apparent reason for a separate existence. It was not geographically isolated like Tujunga or Eagle Rock. It had no unique natural feature like the harbors of San Pedro or Wilmington. It had no anchoring institution like the amusement district of Venice, the Soldiers Home of Sawtelle, or even the circus of Barnes City. Instead, from its beginning, independent Hollywood functioned like a somewhat distant neighborhood of Los Angeles.
It portrayed itself as another Pasadena, but it lacked that suburb s 16 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. LA07450, September 2, 17 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. LA25327, October 3, 18 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. July 21, and No. July 7, 19 Adapted from Daniel Prosser, Context: Pre-Consolidation Communities in Los Angeles, Theme: Hollywood, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, (July MAJOR HARRY E. KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 5) strong economic base. In reality, Hollywood resembled an affluent section of Los Angeles like the West Adams area.
Only its lack of a common boundary with Los Angeles, and its resort-like Hollywood Hotel, differentiated it from other well-off neighborhoods within the Los Angele City limits. Ambivalence toward independence was evident at the incorporation of Hollywood as a city in A sizable minority opposed incorporation, and a segment of the local leadership instead supported annexation to Los Angeles. Only the lack of a common border prevented this from occurring. In October of a common border was finally achieved and just four months later, in January of Hollywood voted 409 to 18 in favor of consolidation. It seems as if Hollywood could not wait to give up its independence. There is little left of institutional and commercial pre-consolidation Hollywood.
The few business blocks remaining have been altered beyond recognition. There are, however, examples of residential building types that have retained their integrity. They can best be categorized by scale. The first group consists of the estates and mansions of the very well off. The second are the generous homes of the upper-middle class. The third are the more modest cottages and bungalows of the working and lower-middle class. The Maj. Kunkel House is an example of the third category. Together the categories illustrate the range of social groups that made up Hollywood during its brief period as an independent suburb. Estates for the very well off are represented by two landmarks. The first is the Wattles Mansion at N. Curson Avenue (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No.
The mansion is a two-story Italianate structure designed by Myron Hunt and Elmer Grey, the Pasadena-based architects of the addition to the nearby Hollywood Hotel. It was built in by a wealthy Omaha banker, Gordon Wattles, as his winter home.20 The second is known today as the Magic Castle at Franklin Avenue (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. It was originally built in as a home for Rollin Lane, a banker, real estate developer, and philanthropist. Like so many other buildings in pre-consolidation Hollywood, it was designed by the architecture firm Dennis and Farwell. It is Chateauesque in style and patterned after the Kimberly Crest House in Redlands.21 The homes of Hollywood s upper-middle class were typical of those found in the fashionable suburban neighborhoods of the day.
They were generally two stories in height and in the sprawling relaxed forms of either the Craftsman or a loosely interpreted Colonial Revival style. Extant examples tend to be concentrated in the northern and eastern section of pre-consolidation Hollywood, north of Franklin Avenue or east of Wilton Place. There are three landmarks that typify the upper-middle residence. Both the Dunning House at Carlton Way (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. from and the Tornborg House at N. Tamarind Avenue (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. from are in the Craftsman style. The Toberman House at N. Harvard Drive (Los 20 Jeffrey Hart, editor, Landmark L.A.: Historic-Cultural Monuments of Los Angeles (Los Angeles: City of Los Angeles Cultural Affairs Department, 21 Ibid., MAJOR HARRY E.
KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 6) Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. from is in a somewhat free version of the Colonial Revival style by ever-active architects Dennis and Farwell. It is notable as well for its owner. James R. Toberman served as mayor of Los Angeles from to and again from to More modest homes for the working and lower-middle classes are typically single-story cottages and bungalows. In Southern California with its vast supply of land, even those of modest means could strive to live in a detached dwelling with a carefully tended garden. Cottages and bungalows were constructed on relatively small lots and tend to be located in the southern and southwestern sections of pre-consolidation Hollywood.
Both types were easy to construct and modify and were based upon designs from plan books and mail-order catalogs rather than architects. Independent Hollywood liked to present itself as a community of single-family homes. Generally, this was true, particularly for the tract north of Hollywood Boulevard and west of Cahuenga Boulevard. But the Sanborn map shows that, here and there, multi-family dwellings were beginning to appear. Situated on the east side of Vine Street, one-half block north of Hollywood Boulevard, was the Marjorie Apartments. South of Hollywood Boulevard, between Highland Avenue and Cahuenga Boulevard, were a handful of individual structures simply identified as flats.
One was on the west side of McCadden Place just south of Hollywood Boulevard, another on the northwest corner of Selma and Cherokee Avenues, and two more on Highland Avenue between Selma Avenue and Sunset Boulevard. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: The Maj. Kunkel House is a typical example of a Craftsman bungalow. Although the term bungalow has been closely associated with the Arts and Crafts movement and the Craftsman style of architecture, it refers to a type of house rather than a style of architecture. As Craftsman style architecture reached the masses in the form of small homes described in catalogs as bungalows, the term became inextricably linked with the style.
The bungalow idea was a European, probably an English invention of the seventeenth century. Its etymological root was bangala, a Bengali word referring to the typical native dwelling of that region of India as well as to the region itself. By the eighteenth century the English had adapted it to their way of life in the colony. But whatever the improvisations on the original type, it remained a one- story residence with a front porch. The bungalow appeared in Southern California during the first decade of the twentieth century. It was a house type ready made for the mild climate and profound demand brought about by the rapidly expanding population. While some bungalows were custom- designed by architects, most were selected from plan books or catalogues and were 22 Ibid., MAJOR HARRY E.
KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 7) constructed by contractors or assembled from prefabricated pieces. Popular bungalow styles included Spanish Colonial Revival, English Revival, American Colonial Revival, and Craftsman. The character-defining features of the Maj. Kunkel House include the one-story height, rectangular plan, low pitched gabled roof and shed dormer with shallow overhanging eaves and exposed rafter tails, wood clapboard siding, recessed front porch, and wood casement windows. 2. Condition of fabric: The house is generally in good condition. B. Description of Exterior 1. Overall dimensions: The house is approximately 31' wide, 52' deep, and 15' tall. 2. Foundations: The foundation is concrete. The thickness varies to accommodate changes in grade. 3.
Walls: The exterior walls are sheathed with wood clapboard that has been texture coated. 4. Structural system, framing: The house has a wood frame and floors. Interior bearing walls are 2" by 4" wood studs. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, porticos, bulkheads: The front porch at the south end of the west fa ade is recessed. It is approached by a short flight of non-original brick and stone steps. The floor is stained wood plank, and the ceiling is wood beadboard. The square porch pillars are in their original locations but have been clad in non-original stone with brick caps. The square wood posts are original. The wood balustrade is comprised of top and bottom cross beams with vertical wood boards. The rear deck at the north end of the east facade does not appear to be original.
It has a stone foundation, wood plank floor, and wood balustrade that resembles the design of the front porch. 6. Chimneys: There are no chimneys. 7. Openings a. Doorways and doors: The front door consist of a wood slab with a square light in the upper portion. The rear door is also wood. There are three panels in the lower portion and a square light in the upper portion. A non-original metal security door is attached to the door frame. b. Windows and shutters: Windows are distributed irregularly across all facades. Window openings are rectangular in shape, different in size, surrounded by plain MAJOR HARRY E. KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 8) wood frames with lug sills, and filled with wood casements and sashes.
Casement windows have vertical and horizontal wood muntins at the top and are found along the west, north, and south facades. Double hung sash windows are found on the east fa ade. Non-original security bars are attached to the window frames. 8. Roof: a. Shape, covering: The low pitched, side gabled roof is covered with non-original composition shingles. b. Cornice, eaves: The roof has overhanging eaves with exposed rafter tails and non-original knee braces. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: There is a shed dormer centered on the west side of the roof. It has three windows and details like the main roof. C. Description of Interior 1. Floor plans: The first and only floor is approximately square feet and includes a living room, dining room, kitchen, utility room, two bedrooms, and one bathroom.
2. Stairways: None. 3. Flooring: There are oak floors in the living room and dining room and fir floors in the bedrooms, kitchen, and utility room. The boards have an east-west orientation and stained a honey color. In the bathroom, the floor is a large green hexagonal ceramic tile with black ceramic tile trim. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: Walls and ceilings are mostly painted plaster. 5. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: Doorways are filled with single leaf wood paneled doors. Some doors have one panel, but most have five. Some doors are painted but most are stained. b. Windows: Windows are visible throughout the interior. Those in the living room and dining room have stained wood frames and crown moldings.
The windows in the bedrooms, kitchen, and bathroom have the same wood frames and moldings, but the wood is painted. The window frames in the utility room are plain painted wood. 6. Decorative features and trim: The living and dining rooms have stained wood features and trim including a sideboard with diamond paned cabinet doors, a wainscot with a MAJOR HARRY E. KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 9) picture rail, crown moldings, baseboards, and faux ceiling beams. The brick fireplace has a stained wood mantel. The wood used throughout the interior is Douglas fir. 7. Hardware: There is no historic hardware of note on the house interior. Original hardware is brass but not unique. Non-original hardware is period appropriate. 8. Mechanical equipment a.
Heating, air conditioning, ventilation: The original system is unknown but likely a furnace that vented heat through floor registers. The present forced air heat and air conditioning system uses the original floor registers, the equipment is located in the backyard. The date of installation is unknown but likely after b. Lighting: No original light fixtures appear to remain. Ceiling mounted fixtures in the living and dining rooms are non-original but period appropriate. c. Plumbing: Plumbing fixtures are purely utilitarian and have no unique design. The clawfoot bathtub appears to be original, while the toilet and sink do not In any case, the fixtures are white porcelain. 9. Original furnishings None. D. Site 1.
Historic landscape design: The pipe metal and wire fence may be a remnant of the original design of the landscape. The present landscape includes a variety of succulents in the front yard, a mature eucalyptus tree in the back yard, an asphalt driveway along the north property line, and a non-original arbor at the entrance to the property. 2. Outbuildings: The property includes a detached one-car garage constructed in It has a rectangular plan, a wood-framed structure, a concrete foundation, and a front gabled roof with overhanging eaves. The exterior is sheathed with wood clapboard and there are a pair of wood plank doors on the west facade. On the south fa ade, there is a non- original door and window that are covered by a shed roof porch. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A.
Architectural Drawings: None found. B. Early Views: Sanborn Map Company. Los Angeles Volume 10. Sheet and Accessed on October 1, www.lapl.org. MAJOR HARRY E. KUNKEL HOUSE HABS CA-2969 (Page 10) UCSB Library Geospatial Collection. Aerial Photographs. Various dates. Accessed on October 1, C. Interviews: None conducted. D. Selected