This report was prepared for the Los Angeles Department of City Planning in compliance with a condition of approval and a mitigation measure for a mixed- use development project known as Crossroads Hollywood (ENV-2015-2026- EIR). The project involves the removal of all of the buildings on the property. In addition to the architectural historian Teresa Grimes, the project team included the photographer Dennis Hill. The project sponsor was Harridge Development Group, GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of erection: 2. Architect: Unknown1 3.
Original and subsequent owners, occupants, and uses: Original Owner and Occupant The house was constructed in by Godfrey Fritz and was used as the dwelling of his daughter and son-in-law Nettie and Raymond Vondenbosch until at least Fritz was born in Alsace-Lorraine, France, on April 20, In he immigrated to the United States and settled in St. Louis, Missouri.3 By Fritz had moved to Los Angeles with his wife and their children and worked as a builder.4 His obituary in the Los Angeles Times stated, He erected many of the old buildings on Main and Spring Streets and also supervised the construction of the Oxnard sugar factory at Oxnard.
5 Fritz was a member of the Union League and Builders Exchange.6 The Union League was an organization affiliated with the Republican Party and members were primarily professionals and businessmen. In Fritz served on the Appeals Committee of the Builder s Exchange and became treasurer in He joined the board of directors in Nettie Louise Fritz and Raymond Herman Vondenbosch married on August 12, and promptly rented the house from Nettie s father.
Nettie was born in Los Angeles on July 12, and Raymond was born in Missouri on September 30, When he first moved to Los Angeles he worked as a cornice maker.9 During the period he lived in the house he managed the Central Hardware Company at Hollywood Boulevard.10 By the name Vondenbosch was changed to Vanderbush.11 The couple was still 1 The house was constructed before Hollywood consolidated with Los Angeles, and Hollywood did not keep building permits. Given the fact that Fritz was a builder, it is assumed that he constructed the house. 2 U.S. Find a Grave Index. 3 U.S. Census, Fritz was living in St. Louis at this time with his wife Maria Vogel and their children. 4 Los Angeles City Directory, 5 Pioneer s Funeral Arranged, Los Angeles Times, January 10, 6 Ibid. 7 U.S.
County Birth, Marriage, and Death Records. 8 Geneanet Community Trees Index. 9 Los Angeles City Directory, 10 Los Angeles City Directory, and 11 U.S. World War 1 Draft Registration Cards, September 11, GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 3) living in the house in and by this time they had a daughter and son.12 Sometime in the it appears that the couple divorced and moved.13 Subsequent Owners and Occupants Little information could be found on subsequent owners and occupants. It appears that Godfrey Fritz continued to own the property and rented it to various individuals. The address does not appear in the Los Angeles City Directory until when it was occupied by R.
Dillard and when it was occupied by Robin Preston.14 Original and Subsequent Uses The house was used for its original purpose until approximately when the property was converted into a school. The school closed in The house is currently used as an office. 4. Contractors and suppliers: As Godfrey Fritz was a builder, it is presumed but not documented that he constructed the house. No information was found regarding the suppliers of building materials. 5. Original plans and construction: No original plans or historic photographs of the property were found. The property consists of a one-story house constructed in at the northeast corner of lot. The and Sanborn maps indicate that there was a one-car garage in the southwest corner of the lot.
Its date of construction and demolition are unknown. The field inspection and building permit record indicate the property has sustained numerous alterations from its original construction. Rectangular in plan, the house has a wood-framed structure sheathed in wood clapboard and a concrete foundation. The moderately pitched composition shingle roof is predominately hipped with a projecting gabled bay on the east fa ade and hipped bay on the west fa ade. The roof has overhanging eaves and exposed rafter tails. The primary (east) facade is asymmetrically organized and two bays wide. A front porch occupies the north bay, which is covered by a project gable with carved knee braces. The gable face is clad with wood shingles and there is a rectangular vent in the center.
Three square wood posts rest on a low wall that encloses the porch. The design and materials of the original front steps, porch floor, and front door are unknown. There is a canted bay beneath a gabled dormer in the approximate center of the south fa ade with a tripartite window. The fenestration pattern is irregular on each facade with wood frames and lug sills. The design and material of the original windows are unknown but were likely fixed and double-hung wood sash. 6. Alterations: The building permit record documents some but not all of the alterations. 12 U.S. Census, Vondenbosch or Vanderbush was misspelled Nauderbrusk.
13 Various sources indicate that Raymond remarried Mamie Haben in 14 Los Angeles City Directory, and GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 4) In a permit was issued to repair the foundation of the house.15 In an 800 square-foot building was constructed at the rear of the property. According to the permit, the house was used as an office at this time.16 In a permit was issued to replace the roof on the house.17 The house was substantially altered in when its use was change from a residence to a school. The description of the work on the permit was fully sprinkler, upgrade toilet rooms, and structural strengthening of floor framing by adding joists, girders, and concrete piers.
18 The sketch map attached to the permit indicate an existing rear addition and accessibility ramp, meaning they were already present at this time. Although not described on the permit, it is likely that many other alterations occurred at this time. These include the covering of clapboard with stucco on the north fa ade, the replacement of the front steps and handrails, the installation of tile on the front porch, the conversion of a wood window on the east fa ade with a sliding vinyl door, the replacement of the front door, and the replacement of most of the wood windows with vinyl windows.
Another alteration to the house related to the school use occurred in when the kitchen was remodeled.19 None of the site features appear to be original with the possible exception of two mature palm trees in the front yard. These include the concrete driveway long the south property line, metal fence with brick piers along the front entrance to the property, and accessibility ramp. B. Historical Context20 The Godfrey Fritz House is significant in the context of early residential development in Hollywood, prior to its consolidation with Los Angeles. Hollywood is one of ten incorporated cities that consolidated with the City of Los Angeles for one reason or another.
The other one- time independent cities include Wilmington, San Pedro, Sawtelle, Eagle Rock, Hyde Park, Venice, Watts, Barnes City, and Tujunga. Of all the pre-consolidation cities, Hollywood seems the most improbable. It had no apparent reason for a separate existence. It was not geographically isolated like Tujunga or Eagle Rock. It had no unique natural feature like the harbors of San Pedro or Wilmington. It had no anchoring institution like the amusement district of Venice, the Soldiers Home of Sawtelle, or even the circus of Barnes City. 15 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. LA31695, February 23, 16 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. March 9, 17 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No.
October15, 18 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. September 20, 19 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. October 25, 20 Adapted from Daniel Prosser, Context: Pre-Consolidation Communities in Los Angeles, Theme: Hollywood, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, (July GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 5) Instead, from its beginning, independent Hollywood functioned like a somewhat distant neighborhood of Los Angeles. It portrayed itself as another Pasadena, but it lacked that suburb s strong economic base. In reality, Hollywood resembled an affluent section of Los Angeles like the West Adams area.
Only its lack of a common boundary with Los Angeles, and its resort-like Hollywood Hotel, differentiated it from other well-off neighborhoods within the Los Angele City limits. Ambivalence toward independence was evident at the incorporation of Hollywood as a city in A sizable minority opposed incorporation, and a segment of the local leadership instead supported annexation to Los Angeles. Only the lack of a common border prevented this from occurring. In October of a common border was finally achieved and just four months later, in January of Hollywood voted 409 to 18 in favor of consolidation. It seems as if Hollywood could not wait to give up its independence. There is little left of institutional and commercial pre-consolidation Hollywood.
The few business blocks remaining have been altered beyond recognition. There are, however, examples of residential building types that have retained their integrity. They can best be categorized by scale. The first group consists of the estates and mansions of the very well off. The second are the generous homes of the upper-middle class. The third are the more modest cottages and bungalows of the working and lower-middle class. The Godfrey Fritz House is an example of the third category. Together the categories illustrate the range of social groups that made up Hollywood during its brief period as an independent suburb. Estates for the very well off are represented by two landmarks. The first is the Wattles Mansion at N. Curson Avenue (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No.
The mansion is a two-story Italianate structure designed by Myron Hunt and Elmer Grey, the Pasadena-based architects of the addition to the nearby Hollywood Hotel. It was built in by a wealthy Omaha banker, Gordon Wattles, as his winter home.21 The second is known today as the Magic Castle at Franklin Avenue (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. It was originally built in as a home for Rollin Lane, a banker, real estate developer, and philanthropist. Like so many other buildings in pre-consolidation Hollywood, it was designed by the architecture firm Dennis and Farwell. It is Chateauesque in style and patterned after the Kimberly Crest House in Redlands.22 The homes of Hollywood s upper-middle class were typical of those found in the fashionable suburban neighborhoods of the day.
They were generally two stories in height and in the sprawling relaxed forms of either the Craftsman or a loosely interpreted Colonial Revival style. Extant examples tend to be concentrated in the northern and eastern section of pre-consolidation Hollywood, north of Franklin Avenue or east of Wilton Place. 21 Jeffrey Hart, editor, Landmark L.A.: Historic-Cultural Monuments of Los Angeles (Los Angeles: City of Los Angeles Cultural Affairs Department, 22 Ibid., GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 6) There are three landmarks that typify the upper-middle residence. Both the Dunning House at Carlton Way (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. from and the Tornborg House at N. Tamarind Avenue (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. from are in the Craftsman style.
The Toberman House at N. Harvard Drive (Los Angeles Historic-Cultural Monument No. from is in a somewhat free version of the Colonial Revival style by ever-active architects Dennis and Farwell. It is notable as well for its owner. James R. Toberman served as mayor of Los Angeles from to and again from to More modest homes for the working and lower-middle classes are typically single-story cottages and bungalows. In Southern California with its vast supply of land, even those of modest means could strive to live in a detached dwelling with a carefully tended garden. Cottages and bungalows were constructed on relatively small lots and tend to be located in the southern and southwestern sections of pre-consolidation Hollywood.
Both types were easy to construct and modify and were based upon designs from plan books and mail-order catalogs rather than architects. Independent Hollywood liked to present itself as a community of single-family homes. Generally, this was true, particularly for the tract north of Hollywood Boulevard and west of Cahuenga Boulevard. But the Sanborn map shows that, here and there, multi-family dwellings were beginning to appear. Situated on the east side of Vine Street, one-half block north of Hollywood Boulevard, was the Marjorie Apartments. South of Hollywood Boulevard, between Highland Avenue and Cahuenga Boulevard, were a handful of individual structures simply identified as flats.
One was on the west side of McCadden Place just south of Hollywood Boulevard, another on the northwest corner of Selma and Cherokee Avenues, and two more on Highland Avenue between Selma Avenue and Sunset Boulevard. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: The Godfrey Fritz House is a typical example of a vernacular hipped cottage. This house type was constructed throughout the United States from to The vernacular hipped cottage is primarily distinguished by its square plan capped by a pyramidal (or hipped) roof shape, and secondarily by the tendency to cut the front porch space out of the basic square of the house.
In Los Angeles, the vernacular hipped cottage developed slightly later than the vernacular gabled cottage and was even more common at the turn of the twentieth century because it was so easy to construct and modify. The box-like shape, meaning the lack of projections or wings, made it especially affordable to build. It was also advertised as efficient because of the belief that the square lines permitted a maximum utilization of interior floor space. Plan book companies responded to the vernacular hipped cottage because 23 Ibid., GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 7) they required little ornamentation. However, if a customer so chose the possibilities to add ornamentation were endless.
Detailing and proportions of the openings and bays could link the house either to the Queen Anne, Neoclassical, or American Colonial Revival styles. Later examples show the influence the Shingle style and Arts and Crafts elements such as exposed rafter tails. The character-defining features of the Godfrey Fritz House include the one-story height, rectangular plan, hipped roof with shallow overhanging eaves, wood clapboard siding, off-set gabled bay containing a recessed front porch, and tripartite bay window. 2. Condition of fabric: The house is generally in good condition. B. Description of Exterior 1. Overall dimensions: The house is approximately 31' wide, 56' deep, and 15' tall. 2. Foundations: The foundation is concrete. The thickness varies to accommodate changes in grade. 3.
Walls: The exterior walls are sheathed with wood clapboard. 4. Structural system, framing: The house has a wood frame and floors. Interior bearing walls are 2" by 4" wood studs. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, porticos, bulkheads: The front porch at the north end of the east fa ade is recessed and enclosed by a low wall. It is approached by a short flight of non-original concrete steps covered with stone tile. The same non-original stone tile covers the floor. Three square wood posts support a cross beam that features a dentil molding. The porch roof is gabled with overhanging eaves supported by three carved knee braces. The face of the gable is clad with wood shingles and there is a rectangular vent in the center with a wood frame, sill, and lintel.
The enclosed shed roof bay at the south end of the west fa ade may have been a back porch at one time. Currently, there is a non-original concrete accessibility ramp with a metal railing that leads to landing in front of the back door. 6. Chimneys: There is one interior brick chimney. It is square in shape and pierces the crest of the hipped roof toward the rear of the house. 7. Openings a. Doorways and doors: The main entrance is centered on the east fa ade within the front porch. It consists of a non-original wood door that is set within the original wood frame and lintel. The back door is also non-original and located at the top of the accessibility ramp. GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 8) b. Windows and shutters: Windows are distributed irregularly across all facades.
Window openings are rectangular in shape, different in size, surrounded by plain wood frames with lug sills, and filled with non-original vinyl sashes. 8. Roof: a. Shape, covering: The moderately pitched hipped roof is covered with non- original composition shingles. b. Cornice, eaves: The roof has overhanging eaves with exposed rafter tails. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: There is a gabled dormer with a rectangular vent in the approximate center of the south side of the roof. C. Description of Interior 1. Floor plans: The first and only floor is approximately square feet and originally included a living room, dining room, kitchen, utility room, two bedrooms, and two bathrooms.
The floor plan was reconfigured when the house was converted into a school in The kitchen and bathrooms remain in their original locations, but other walls have been moved. 2. Stairways: There is an enclosed stairway in the approximate center of the house that leads to the attic. It has wood steps and treads but does not have a handrail or any ornamental features. 3. Flooring: The floor material is non-original and varies from room to room. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: Walls and ceilings are mostly painted dry wall. The few original walls remaining are lath and plaster. 5. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: Doorways are mostly filled with non-original single leaf wood paneled doors that are painted. The trim around the doorways does not appear to be original.
A few original five-panel painted wood doors remain. b. Windows: Windows are visible throughout the interior. The openings appear to be original, but the trim does not. 6. Decorative features and trim: There are no historic decorative features or trim remaining in the house interior. 7. Hardware: There is no historic hardware of note on the house interior. GODFREY FRITZ HOUSE HABS CA-2970 (Page 9) 8. Mechanical equipment a. Heating, air conditioning, ventilation: The original system is unknown but likely a furnace that vented heat through floor registers. The present forced air heat and air conditioning system is ducted through the ceiling, the equipment is located in the attic. The date of installation is unknown but likely after b. Lighting: No original light fixtures appear to remain.
c. Plumbing: Plumbing fixtures are non-original. 9. Original furnishings None. D. Site 1. Historic landscape design: The original design of the landscape is unknown. The present landscape includes two mature palm trees in the front yard. There is a non- original metal fence with brick piers at the front entrance to the property. A concrete walkway leads to the front porch. On either side of the walkway the front yard is paved with bricks. A non-original concrete driveway along the south property line leads to the back yard, which is paved with concrete. 2. Outbuildings: At the rear of the property there is a two-story building that was constructed in It has a rectangular plan, a wood-framed structure, a concrete foundation, and a shed roof with overhanging eaves.
The original garage door at the north end of the east fa ade has been infilled and contains a door and window. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Architectural Drawings: None found. B. Early Views: Sanborn Map Company. Los Angeles Volume 10. Sheet and Accessed on October 1, www.lapl.org. UCSB Library Geospatial Collection. Aerial Photographs. Various dates. Accessed on October 1, C. Interviews: None conducted. D. Selected