This report was prepared for the Los Angeles Department of City Planning in compliance with a condition of approval and a mitigation measure for a mixed- use development project known as Crossroads Hollywood (ENV-2015-2026- EIR). The project involves the removal of the building on the property. In addition to the architectural historian Teresa Grimes, the project team included the photographer Dennis Hill. The project sponsor was Harridge Development Group, TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of erection: 2. Architect: The building was designed by the architect Howard W.
Wood Wood was born in Washington, Indiana on September 7, By he was living in Bakersfield, California and working as a carpenter.1 Precisely when he moved to Los Angeles is unknown. By he was living in Hollywood with his wife, Jennie E. McCadden.2 Wood was business partners with McCadden s father, William G. McCadden, who was a real estate investor in Hollywood. In Howard and Jennie were living at N.
McCadden Place and his business was listed as McCadden & Wood.3 Wood designed and constructed a number of buildings during the including the Hollywood First Methodist Church a Craftsman style house on Poinsettia Place, Los Angeles a Craftsman style house at Selma Avenue, Hollywood 6 and a Mission Revival style house on Elvado Avenue, Beverly Hills During World War I, Wood was apparently no longer working for himself, as his occupation was listed on his draft registration card as a ship builder and his employer as the South Western Ship Building Company in San Pedro.8 From to at least Wood was working as a self-employed architect again; however, research did not reveal any other examples of his work.9 3.
Original and subsequent owners, occupants, and uses: Original Subsequent Owners The building was constructed in for Elsie S. Talbot however, there is no evidence she ever occupied either unit.10 Talbot was born in Indiana in No other information was found regarding the early part of her life. By she was living at 548 W. Hollywood Boulevard and working as a dressmaker.11 It appears that Talbot and Wood were partners in life, but never married. In Wood and his wife separated but never divorced.12 From to Talbot and Wood cohabitated in the house he constructed at Selma Avenue, which was around the corner from the subject 1 U.S.
Census, 2 Marriage Licenses, Los Angeles Times, December 25, 3 Los Angeles City Directory, 4 Southwest Builder & Contractor, August 10, 5 Hollywood Citizen, October 18, 6 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No.12093, August 6, 7 Hollywood Citizen, February 25, 8 U.S. World War I Draft Registration Cards, 9 U.S. Census, and U.S. World War I Draft Registration Cards, 10 A record of her death was not found; however, she was not listed in the Los Angeles City Directory after 11 Los Angeles City Directory, 12 Husband Wins, Los Angeles Times, July 23, TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 3) property. They moved to another building Wood constructed at Los Feliz Boulevard and remained there until they died, she sometime in the mid-1950s and he in Subsequent owners included E.E.
Chiapella from approximately1948 to William I. Zidell from to Eileen Ulrich from to and George and Sharri Ullman from to Cross Roads Properties LLC has been the owner since Original and Subsequent Uses The use of the building changed from residential to commercial in At that time the first floor was an office, and the second floor was a beauty salon.13 The building is currently vacant. Original and Subsequent Occupants The residential and commercial tenants have changed frequently since the building was constructed. 4. Contractors and suppliers: The architect, Howard W. Wood, also served as the contractor. No information was found regarding the suppliers of building materials. 5. Original plans and construction: No original plans or historic photographs of the property were found.
The property consists of a two-story duplex constructed in The Sanborn map documents that there were three other buildings to the rear of the duplex; however, none remain. The field inspection and building permit record indicate the building has sustained some alterations from its original construction. Rectangular in plan, the building has a wood-framed structure sheathed in wood shingles and a concrete foundation. The low-pitched composition shingle roof is side gabled with overhanging eaves and exposed rafter tails. There are vents in the apex of the gables on the north and south facades. The primary (west) facade is symmetrically organized and three bays wide. The center bay is occupied by a balcony that projects from the second story and is accessed by a set of French doors.
The north and south bays are occupied by front porches on the first story with doors and picture windows and two sets of casement windows on the second story. Fenestration on the other facades consists of casement and double-hung sash windows in a variety of sizes. The south fa ade features a stucco chimney and a canted bay on the second story. 6. Alterations: The building permit record documents some but not all of the alterations. The building appears to have remained un-altered until the when a permit was issued to repair interior finishes, replace some plumbing fixtures, install central heating and air conditioning, and construct a new stairway.14 The new stairway is presumably the 13 Certificate of Occupancy for Permit No.
June 30, 14 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. February 18, TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 4) exterior stairway on the east fa ade. When the stucco was removed from the southern front porch is unknown. Several original wood windows on the south fa ade were replaced with vinyl windows at an unknown date. B. Historical Context15 The Talbot Wood Duplex is significant in the context of multi-family residential development in Los Angeles. One of the earliest and most modest types of apartment housing in Los Angeles was the duplex. There were several reasons that development of the duplex prevailed during the early days of multi-family development in the city.
Chief among them was the fact that duplexes presented even the average homeowner with the opportunity to capitalize on the concurrent population and real estate booms. Composed of two separate dwelling units, the arrangement of the typical duplex allowed the homeowner to live in one unit while renting out the other, thus enabling the construction of both a residence and income property on a single lot. Duplexes were also appealing because their size and scale resembled that of the single-family homes with which they sometimes shared the block. Todd Gish explains the various iterations of the most common duplex plans: The double bungalow was a single-story structure divided down the middle, forming two units side-by-side.
These buildings were often perfectly symmetrical in plan and front elevation. The double house was a two-story version of this, essentially a pair of adjoining row houses, with living rooms and kitchens below and bedrooms above. The two-flat was a two-story building with a unit on each floor a double-decker, in other words. An architecturally elaborate form of the two-flat became popular in the and characterized by stylized accents such as wrought iron grilles, Spanish tile roofs, and ceramic tile panels.
Most noticeable in this version was a prominent exterior stair ascending to the second-floor unit s entrance from a small patio outside the lower unit s entry 16 The similarity in scale and massing allowed duplexes to be designed in many of the same styles as were popular for single-family residences at the time, including the Craftsman style and various Period Revival styles.
Gish notes that double bungalows appear to have been the most popular, likely due to their affordable single-story construction, and that the double-house or row-house pair like the Talbot Wood Duplex was comparatively rare.17 Duplexes of all kinds, however, were built in large numbers for decades, and were classified as a distinct dwelling type by the Building Department well in to the Part of what distinguished the development of the duplex was that it could be constructed anywhere, and individual examples were indeed built throughout the city.
15 Adapted from Historic Resources Group, Context: Residential Development and Suburbanization, Theme: Multi- Family Residential Development, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, December 16 Todd Douglas Gish, Building Los Angeles: Urban Housing in the Suburban Metropolis, PhD Diss., University of Southern California, 89. 17 Ibid., 89, 91. 18 Ibid., 89. TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 5) Independent Hollywood liked to present itself as a community of single-family homes. Generally, this was true, particularly for the tract north of Hollywood Boulevard and west of Cahuenga Boulevard. But the Sanborn map shows that, here and there, multi-family dwellings were beginning to appear.
Situated on the east side of Vine Street, one-half block north of Hollywood Boulevard, was the Marjorie Apartments. South of Hollywood Boulevard, between Highland Avenue and Cahuenga Boulevard, were a handful of individual buildings simply identified as flats. One was on the west side of McCadden Place just south of Hollywood Boulevard, another on the northwest corner of Selma and Cherokee Avenues, and two more on Highland Avenue between Selma Avenue and Sunset Boulevard.19 The Sanborn map shows that this trend toward more dense development in the area continued. In addition to the construction of more duplexes and fourplexes, the owners of single-family homes constructed cottages and bungalows in their backyards. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1.
Architectural character: The Talbot Wood Duplex is an excellent example of the Craftsman style. Craftsman architecture reflected the Arts and Crafts movement s conscious search for the supposed simplicity of a pre-industrial time when objects revealed the skill and craftsmanship of the laborer and, further, a rejection of the highly ornamented Victorian aesthetic. The style applied to more than the building envelope; architects designed everything in harmony, from the furniture and fixtures to the landscape. The ultimate bungalows of the style were usually two stories in height and custom designed by architects working closely with local artisans.
Later, the aesthetics of the style would be adapted to single-story, mass-produced bungalows grouped in neighborhoods for the middle class.20 In Southern California, the Craftsman style is most closely associated with the work of brothers Charles and Henry Greene of Pasadena. Both followed developments within the British Arts and Crafts movement, as well as American publications featuring Craftsman style work. The Gamble House in Pasadena is one of the most venerated examples of Craftsman architecture, incorporating influences from all cultures and historical periods celebrated by the Arts and Crafts movement. The work of Greene and Greene and contemporary architects in the region demonstrates how the style came to fruition in Southern California.
Many accomplished local architects, such as Sumner Hunt, Frank and Arthur S. Heineman, contributed to the development of the style in Los Angeles. The Craftsman style is characterized by a degree of eclecticism because of the numerous influences on the architects of the Arts and Crafts movement including Swiss, Japanese, and English architecture.21 19 Daniel Prosser, Context: Pre-Consolidation Communities in Los Angeles, Theme: Hollywood, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, July 20 Teresa Grimes, Context: Architecture and Engineering, Theme: Arts and Crafts Movement, Los Angeles Citywide Historic Context Statement (Los Angeles Office of Historic Resources, June 21 Ibid.
TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 6) By World War I, the Craftsman style declined in popularity and was outpaced by Period Revival styles. Part of this may be attributed to a change in tastes; heavy, dark wood interiors, and paneling so commonly associated with the Craftsman aesthetic was deemed gloomy and dismal. The Craftsman bungalow continued to be built through the but was often painted lighter colors and stripped of its dark wood interior in favor of plaster walls. Multi-family residences were sometimes constructed in the Craftsman style, the most common of which was the fourplex. Less common were duplexes such as the subject property.
The character-defining features of the Talbot Wood Duplex include the two- story height, rectangular plan, low pitched gabled roof with broad overhanging eaves and exposed rafter tails, wood shingle siding, symmetrically arranged primary fa ade, and wood casement windows. 2. Condition of fabric: The building is generally in good condition. B. Description of Exterior 1. Overall dimensions: The building is approximately 30' wide, 30' deep, and 30' tall. 2. Foundations: The foundation is concrete. The thickness varies to accommodate changes in grade. 3. Walls: The exterior walls are sheathed with square butt wood shingles in alternating rows of short and medium lengths. 4. Structural system, framing: The building has a wood frame and floors. Interior bearing walls are 2" by 4" wood studs. 5.
Porches, stoops, balconies, porticos, bulkheads: There are two front porches at each end of the west fa ade. Each porch is approached by a short flight of concrete steps that begins in the center of the fa ade, sits perpendicular to the fa ade, and leads to a small landing. The steps are enclosed by low walls with concrete caps. The stucco cladding remains on the northern porch but has been removed from the southern porch to reveal the underlying masonry. A second story balcony projects from the center of the west fa ade. The battered walls are clad in the same wood shingles used on the rest of the building. A pair of wood beams appear to be supporting the balcony. 6. Chimneys: There is a chimney toward the west end of the south fa ade that pierces the roofline.
It is constructed of masonry and sheathed in stucco. 7. Openings TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 7) a. Doorways and doors: The two front doors are identical in design and consist of painted wood slabs. They appear to be Douglas fir with an oak veneer on the outer side. There are beveled glass lights in the upper portion above an extended ledge with three brackets. The original hardware has been replaced. The two rear doors are stacked vertically at the north end of the east fa ade. They are non-original and covered with non-original metal security doors. There is one set of French doors that open on to the balcony. They are painted wood. b. Windows and shutters: Wood windows are distributed regularly on the west fa ade and irregularly across the other facades.
Window openings are rectangular in shape, different in size, and surrounded by plain wood frames with lug sills. There are two fixed picture windows with stained glass transoms on the first story of the west fa ade. There is one picture window with diamond-patterned muntin on the second story of the north fa ade. Otherwise, most windows are multi-paned casements in groups of twos and fours. A few double hung sash windows are found on the south and east fa ades. Non-original security bars are attached to some window frames on the north, south, and east facades. A few wood windows on the south fa ade have been replaced with vinyl windows within the original openings. 8. Roof: a.
Shape, covering: The building is covered by a low pitched, side gabled roof with non-original composition shingles. There is a gable with the same shape and roofing material that projects over a canted bay at the west end of the south fa ade. b. Cornice, eaves: The roof has overhanging eaves with exposed rafter tails on the east and west facades and paired beams on the north and south facades. The attic vents in the apex of the gables are filled with wood lattice panels. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: There is a gabled dormer centered on the west side of the main roof. C. Description of Interior 1.
Floor plans: The building consists of two apartments, one above the other, that are each approximately 925 square feet and include a living room, dining room, kitchen, utility room, one bedroom, and one bathroom. 2. Stairways: There are two stairways, one interior and one exterior, both on the north side of the building. The interior stairway is accessed from the northern front porch, enclosed with plaster walls, and comprised of wood treads and risers. The exterior stairway is non- original and consists of a metal frame, risers, and handrail with concrete treads. TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 8) 3. Flooring: There is a variety of flooring in the building. In the ground-floor unit, the original flooring has been removed and/or covered with a faux wood vinyl.
In the second- floor unit the flooring is oak parquet in the living room and dining room, non-original faux wood vinyl in the bedroom, non-original ceramic tile in the bathroom, and non- original linoleum in the kitchen and utility room. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: In the ground-floor unit, walls are plaster covered with non- original wallpaper and ceilings are plaster that has been painted. In the second-floor unit, walls are painted plaster and ceilings are non-original painted gypsum board. 5. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: Virtually all of the doors have been removed with the exception of those associated with the bathrooms, which are painted wood with glazing in the upper portion and three panels in the lower portion.
Otherwise, there is only one original five panel painted wood door remaining in the second- floor unit. b. Windows: Windows are visible throughout the interior. Those in the living rooms and dining rooms have painted wood frames and crown moldings. The windows in the bedrooms, kitchens, and bathrooms have plain painted wood frames. 6. Decorative features and trim: The living and dining rooms have painted wood features and trim including a sideboard, a wainscot with a picture rail, crown moldings, and baseboards. The tiled fireplaces have simple wood mantels. In the second-floor unit, there are pony walls with built-in bookcases between the living and dining rooms. This feature in the ground-floor unit was removed at an unknown date. The wood used throughout the interior is Douglas fir.
In the second-floor unit, the paint has been partially removed from the decorative features and trim. 7. Hardware: There is no historic hardware of note on the building interior. 8. Mechanical equipment a. Heating, air conditioning, ventilation: The original system is unknown but likely a furnace that vented heat through floor registers. The present forced air heat and air conditioning system uses non-original wall and ceiling registers, the equipment is located under the exterior stairway on the east facade. The date of installation was b. Lighting: No original light fixtures remain in the building. 22 Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety Permit No. LA57805, February 18, TALBOT-WOOD DUPLEX HABS CA-2971 (Page 9) c.
Plumbing: Plumbing fixtures are purely utilitarian and have no unique design. Both units have built-in bathtubs that appear to be original. The ground-floor unit has a non-original toilet but no sink in the bathroom, and the plumbing fixtures in the kitchen and utility room have been removed. In the second-floor unit, the bathroom, kitchen, and utility room has been remodeled including the plumbing. 9. Original furnishings None. D. Site 1. Historic landscape design: The property does not include any historic landscape design features. The present landscape includes an asphalt covered surface parking lot. 2.
Outbuildings: As early as the property included three other buildings east of and to the rear of the existing duplex: a one-story garage, a one-story building with one dwelling unit, and a one-story building with two dwelling units side-by-side.23 These buildings survived until at least By they had been removed.25 PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Architectural Drawings: None found. B. Early Views: Sanborn Map Company. Los Angeles Volume 10. Sheet and Accessed on November 1, www.lapl.org. UCSB Library Geospatial Collection. Aerial Photographs. Various dates. Accessed on November 1, C. Interviews: None conducted. D. Selected