BlockBefore

Memphis, Tennessee - History (part 2 of 17)

From History of the City of Memphis and Shelby County Tennessee, published 1888. 15,921 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

11 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,921 words

Machine-read from scans of History of the City of Memphis and Shelby County Tennessee, published 1888. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Civil List

21st Corporate Year - March, 1847,!to March, 1848. - Mayor: Enoch Banks. Aldermen: Jos. D. Allen, J. W. A. Pettit, J. Fowlkes, Daniel Hughes, Wm. Connell, V. D. Barry, S. A. Norton, Joseph I. Andrews, Samuel Mosby, and W. B. Miller.

24th Corporate Year - July, 1850, to July, 1851. - Mayor: E. Hickman. Aldermen: Thomas Conway, John Kehoe, E. McDavitt, E. H. Porter, S. W. Jefferson, A. D. Henkle, S. P. Walker, D. Looney, A. B. Shaw, J. Waldran, G. W. Smith and A. B. Taylor.

25th Corporate Year - July, 1851, to July, 1852. - Mayor: E. Hickman. Aldermen: F. Titus, T. Conway, E. H. Porter, E. McDavitt (resigned), S. W. Jefferson, A. D. Henkle, David Looney (resigned), S. P. Walker, J. M. Patrick (resigned), A. B. Shaw, Wm. Ruffin, G. W. Smith, W. S. Cockrell (resigned), A. Woodruff and J. D. Danbury.

26th Corporate Year - July, 1852, to July, 1853. - Mayor: A. B. Taylor. Aldermen: J. Kehoe, B. Wright, A. Woodruff, R. W. Thompson, A. D. Henkle, M. Eagan, S. P. Walker (resigned), J. D. Danbury, A. B. Shaw (resigned), T. W. Hunt, A. N. Edmunds, M. Jones, A. P. Merrill, F. Lane (resigned), J. M. Patrick and A. G. Underwood.

28th Corporate Year - July, 1854 to July, 1855. - Mayor: A. B. Taylor. Aldermen: John L. Saffarans, Dan'! Hughes, S. B. Curtis, John Neal, A. Street (resigned), A. M. Hopkins, A. A. Smithwick (resigned), J. L. Morgan (resigned), J. M. Patrick, Jas. Jenkins, W. E. Milton, A. H. Douglass, A. Woodruff, W. Houston and J. D. Danbury.

29th Corporate Year - July, 1855, to July 1856. - Mayor: A. H. Douglass. Aldermen: Jno. L. Saffarans, Dan'l Hughes, S. B. Curtis, Jno. Neal, A. Woodruff, Jas. Elder, W. R. Chandler, J. D. Danbury, James Jenkins, Jno. L. Morgan (resigned), W. E. Milton, F. M. Copeland and A. B. Shaw.

31st Corporate Year - July, 1857, to July 1858. - Mayor: R. D. Baugh. Aldermen: Dan'l Hughes, J. S. Irwin, A. Street, W. O. Lofland, A. Woodruff, R. S. Jones, Thos. J. Finnie, I. M. Hill, F. M. E. Falkner, T. A. Hamilton, John Martin and F. M. Copeland. |

32d Corporate Year - July, 1858, to July, 1859. - Mayor: R. D. Baugh. Aldermen: J. O. Drew, Daniel Hughes, A. Street, R. H. Norris (resigned), 'Chas. Kortrecht, N. B. Forrest, Jas. Elder, T. J. Finnie, T. A. Hamilton, A. H. Douglass, G. P. Foute, D. H. Townsend, Jno. B. Robinson, F. M. Copeland, Jno. Neal, S. W. Jefferson and S. T. Morgan.

33d Corporate Year - July, 1859, to July, 1860. - Mayor: R. D. Baugh.. Aldermen: Jno. O. Drew, Sam'! Tighe, A Street (resigned), N. B. Forrest, James Elder, C. Potter, T. A. Hamilton, A. H. Douglass, W. E. Milton (resigned), Marcus Jones, J. N. Barnett, Wm. Farris, J. C. Griffing, W. M. Perkins, D. H. Townsend, S. T. Morgan, W. O. Lofland and C. Kortrecht.

38th Corporate Year - July, 1864, to July, 1865. - Mayors: Lieut. Colonel Thomas H. Harris and Captain C. Richards - the former from July to November, the latter the remainder of the term. Aldermen: J. P. Foster (appointed chief of police), A. Renkert, G. D. Johnson, S. T. Morgan, Bak: C. Brooks, A. J. Miller (died), I. M. Hill, J. G. Owen, W. S. Bruce (resigned), W. W. Jones, J. E. Merriman, C. C. Smith, G. P. Ware, Jos. Tagg, Patrick Sherry, H. T. Hulbert, J. B. Wetherill, H. G. Smith (resigned), W. R. Moore and W. M. Farrington.

Police Department

From the early days of the territorial administration, when the functions of a town marshal were assumed by officers of the government from any portion of the territory of Tennessee, up to the time after this section had been admitted into the Union as a State, there was always need here of a larger number of efficient officers of the law than the resources of the bluff city could supply.

1 The board of 1879 served but one month of this year (January), when the city charter was repealed, and all the above offices were vacated.

For many years after the town of Memphis was settled it was inhabited by a badly mixed population, and it was with great difficulty that order could be preserved. The preservation of the peace devolved upon a single constable and a wharfmaster, who were unable to suppress the prevalent violence and outlawry. Fights and feuds were of common occurrence, and many crimes were committed for which the perpetrators were never called to an account. It was only by the co-operation of the better class of citizens with the town constable that even a feeble enforcement of the law was secured against its violators. The worst classes with which the early civilisation of Memphis had to deal were the gamblers and flat boatmen, all of whom were, with rare exception, a constant terror to the peaceable and law abiding people of the town. The incorporation of the city in 1826, whereby a mayor and board of aldermen were provided for the purpose of administering justice, had little effect so far as preserving the peace and suppressing violence was concerned, and during the ten years that followed the inauguration of the city government there were more violations of the law, more bloodshed and outrages committed against the peace and dignity of the community than during any other period of the same length afterwards.

Prior to 1845 city marshals or constables were the officials by whom the maintenance of order was entrusted, but they had other business to attend to and did not give their entire time to the service of the municipal government. In 1845 two regular patrolmen were employed to keep watch and ward on the streets at all hours, and to render a service such as policemen perform at the present time. The two patrolmen divided their time between day and night, and a year after the establishment of this form of police protection it was found necessary to have two officers for night service instead of one. The force was gradually increased, and in 1850 there were twelve to sixteen patrolmen regularly employed. These officers were under the control of the city marshal - who was chosen by the mayor - and whose duties were similiar to those devolving upon the present chief of police. Josiah Horn was elected city marshal in 1852, and in 1855, before his term of office had expired, the force had grown to twenty-five to thirty men. In 1855 Thomas Minott was chosen city marshal and chief of police; J. O. Rienhart in 1856, and William Underwood in 1857. B. J. Garrett was chosen city marshal in 1858 and continued in such capacity until June, 1862, when the city was captured by the Federal forces, at which time Patrick M. Winters was appointed chief of police. When martial rule was inaugurated in 1864 J. P. Foster, an alderman under the military administration, was appointed chief of police. In 1865, by an act of the Legislature, Colonel S. B. Beaumont was made chief of police, and served until the end of the year 1866. During the war the city required a very large police force, and one hundred and twenty men were regularly employed. This large force was continued until the election of John Johnson as mayor in 1870, among whose first acts was to reduce the number of policemen to eighty. In 1873 Phil R. Athy became chief of police, who served through the yellow fevers of 1873, 1878 and 1879, and through the term of Dr. D. T. Porter as president of the taxing district, and during these trying periods the city had no more brave, hard working and efficient public official. The service rendered by the entire force during the disastrous epidemic of 1878 has been referred to elsewhere in words of deserved praise. In their devotion to duty several brave officers lost their lives, and none failed to courageously face every danger, and to do his uttermost in the maintenance of order and to alleviate the suffering of the distressed.

The members of the force in the year 1878, and during the epidemic, were as follows: Chief, Phil R. Athy; sergeant, George T. O'Haver ; captain, C. Davis; captain, William H. Homan; sergeant, R. C. Maunels; sergeant, Charles Kunholz; patrolmen, John McPartland, T. C. Couch, John Doherty, Henry Wilson, P. Logan, John Jenny, John Longinotti, M. Mulowney, Con. Daly, T. Carmichael, J. H. Campbell, August Pante, T. N. Baker, T. G. Forrest, Charles Stanley, W. H. Sweeney, James McConnell, M. H. Allison, J. J. Huber, Mike Cannon, William Unerzagt, Fred Reslemyer, Tim Hope and Patrick Ryder. Among those who were on the police force during the fever of 1878, and who lost their lives, were Captain William Homan, Sergeant R. C. Maunels, and Patrolmen Mike Cannon, J. J. Huber, M. H. Allison, James Mc- Connell, W. A. Sweeney, Charles Staley, Patrick Ryder, Tim Hope, Fred Reslemyer and William Unerzagt. In 1879 those who died of yellow fever while in the service, were Patrolmen Thomas McGuire and Thomas Kief.

In 1881 Captain W. C. Davis was appointed chief of police by the board of fire and police commissioners, and has been continned in office up to the present time. The police captains from 1870 to 1872, were Barney Gray and Phil R. Athy; 1872 to 1874, George K. Weatherford and Charles T. Smith; 1875 to 1878, R. F. Arata, C. H. Brown, and William Homan; 1878 to 1879, W. C. Davis and G. T. O'Haver. Since 1880 the night and day captains have been G. T. O'Haver and P. Hackett.

Fire Department

The first volunteer fire company in Memphis was organised in the latter part of the year 1829. Six months later Alderman George Alfred was sent to Cincinnati to purchase a fire engine. He returned after securing the " Little Vigor," a small hand engine. The service performed by this machine did not amount to much, and it is authentically stated that at this period "a house never caught fire but it burned down." But this was not always the fault of the engine, or the lack of faithful exertions by the members of the fire company. The difficulties surrounding these early fighters of flames were numerous. There was no supply of water to speak of, and when a fire alarm was sounded the men in charge of the " Little Vigor," would haul her to the scene by ropes, break into somebody's back yard near by, and proceed to exhaust the family cistern. This tended tomake the volunteer organisations of the period some what unpopular, and it was frequently the case that they had to force an entrance into a citizen's yard at the muzzle of a shot gun.

For nearly eight years the " Little Vigor" was the only fire engine in the city. In 1837 another volunteer company was formed, and after a few months the " Deluge" was purchased. This is said to have been a more serviceable engine than the " Little Vigor," and its arrival in the city was a subject for general rejoicing. John F. Schabell was the first captain of the new company. Rivalry between the two organisations was strong, and greatly tended to the efficiency of both. The property of the entire city was taken care of by these two companies until March 6, 1841, when another brigade was organised, and named the Memphis Fire Company No. 1. The officers were F. Titus, captain; David Park, first lieutenant; J. H. Lawrence, second lieutenant; J. H. Saffarans, first engineer; James Graham, second engineer; J. B. Mosely, secretary, and C. Blas, treasurer.

In addition to having a new hand engine, which was called the ** Vigilant No. 1," the Memphis Fire Company No. 1 formed a hook and ladder brigade of seventeen members, in connection with the regular organisation. The company had no trucks upon which to carry their utensils of war when they went to fight the flames, but carried them along upon their shoulders, each man being provided with a ladder, hook and ax. Company No. 1 had the largest membership of any fire company that had been formed, and soon obtained the ascendency over the others in point of usefulness and popularity. It was composed mainly of the best young men at that time in Memphis, and gradually members of the old organisations began to withdraw from them and join the new company. But a sufficient number of good firemen remained in the old com- panies, however, to keep them in existence, and for several years the city was blessed with three of the best organisations of their kind in the State.

On the 14th of January, 1846, an independent fire company was formed with Henry Painter as its first captain. This company purchased a hand engine named "Lady Washington." In 1848 Company No. 2 was formed with Captain Richard in command, and in 1849, still another was added to the list by the formation of Company No. 3, under the command of Captain Kinkle. The old companies of 1830 and 1838 had by this time gone out of existence and the members of the old associations attached themselves to the new companies, so that in 1850 Memphis had four fire companies, each having a good hand engine, while the independent still retained its hook and ladder and ax department.

In 1851 Company No. 5 was organised, with William Kehoe as captain. In 1855 Company No. 6 was formed with Captain Banton in command, and in 1857 the organisation of Company No. 7 was perfected, with William Miller as captain. Company No. 7 was the last volunteer fire organisation ever formed in Memphis.

The organisation of a paid fire department in Memphis was mainly due to the efforts of J. B. Danbury, who in 1859, in the face of great opposition and numerous difficulties, succeeded in inducing the board of mayor and aldermen . to try the experiment of maintaining a paid fire service. The first chief of the department was Captain A. B. Jewell, his assistants being Henry Painter and William Kehoe. In 1860 the first steam fire engine was purchased by the city, and named the " J. B. Danbury," in honor of one of the most enthusiastic and valuable firemen of that day.

Captain A. B. Jewell served as chief until August, 1860, when Samuel Whitsitt was elected to fill his place. The latter served one year. The third chief was Edward O'Neill, who was succeeded by Walter Owen, who had been fireman in Memphis for many years. He also served only one term, and on August I, 1863, John E. Randle, at present a member of the legislative council, and proprietor of the Chickasaw Iron Works, was made chief of the fire department. Mr. Randle made a capable and efficient officer for two years, but was forced to resign in 1865, because of business interests which demanded his entire time and attention.

During the war little progress was made, and great difficulty was experienced in keeping the department up to the standard on account of the frequent changes made by members leaving to join the Southern Army. In 1863 two new engines were bought. These were Nos. 2 and 3, and were first used in February, 1863. In 1866, during the administration of William Kehoe as chief, the citizens, in conjunction with the city council, purchased the fourth steam engine for the paid department. The companies with the hand engines remained as volunteers until they were gradually crowded out by the better and

William Kehoe, who had been one of the old volunteer firemen of 1834, served as chief for six years, or from 1865 to 1871. From the latter date, to 1874, Edward Anderson served as chief of the department. Attheend of his term of office the place was filled by Michael McFadden, who died in January, 1882. Atthe time of McFadden's death, Memphis, after having passed through the yellow fever of 1879, had commenced again, slowly but surely, to increase in wealth, population and prosperity, when new and better fire engines were demanded.

The new taxing district officers took hold of this important matter in earnest, and early in 1882, at the beginning of present Chief James E. Cleary's term of service, they began to improve and perfect the department in every way. Chief Cleary entered the Memphis fire service in 1860, as a volunteer, and soon after became a member of the first paid company. He was gradually promoted until, in 1882, he was made captain, in which capacity he was rendering valuable service, when he was elected to the position of chief. In 1882 the president of the taxing district, in his report to the governor, in speaking of Chief Cleary said: "A thorough mechanic, a strict disciplinarian, ever ready and progressive, his entire department, though small, stands unsurpassed by any similar organisation in the country."

The first move made by the new city government of Memphis, in the way of securing better equipment for the department, was the purchase of steam engine No. 1, which is now in service at the engine house, on the corner of Adam and Second streets. Soon after engine No. 2 was purchased and stationed at the corner of Butler and Main streets. Engine No. 3, the heaviest and finest now in the city, was purchased in 1874, and christened the "De Soto" in honor of the street upon which it is located. The present Nos. 4, 5 and 6 were bought in 1884. They were named respectively, " James Speed," "Invincible" and * C. L. Pullen." All of the old engines of 1860, 1862 and 1866 were exchanged in part payment for new ones, or disposed of in various ways. Ofthe present engines Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 4 are the only ones now in service, Nos. 5 and 6 being kept in reserve, in case of emergency.

Necessity For Sanitary Improvements

To-day Memphis has one of the most efficient fire departments in the country, in proportion to the number of men employed. There are four steam engines in active use, and two in the reserve. There is also a finely equipped hook and ladder company and a chemical Babcock engine, making eight apparatus which can be brought into use at any moment they may be required. The present efficiency of the service is largely due to the well directed labors of Chief Cleary, who is a thorough disciplinarian and perfectly familiar with all

In no one direction during the last few years have the efforts of the people of Memphis attracted more wide attention than in dealing with the problem of local sanitation. At one period of its history perhaps no city existed with greater necessity for reform in this regard, and it is certain that in none have more beneficent results been accomplished in the same length of time under more adverse circumstances. The last three epidemics of yellow fever in 1873, 1878 and 1879 made it apparent that the growth of the city and the extension of its commercial interest would not only cease, but a rapid decline in all elements of wealth would follow as a consequence, if the visitation of infectious disease was not stopped by expeditious means. As some of the most lasting lessons are taught by saddest experience, so it seems great and permanent good to Memphis has been the direct result of its reverses. Necessity was the spur which has resulted in the accomplishment of the present unexcelled sanitary condition of Memphis. The progress of its people' in; dealing with this question was closely watched, and was the means of arousing an interest in city sanitation heretofore unknown all over the country, and there can be no question that the experience of Memphis has had a potent effect in increasing and developing a better understanding of all matters pertaining to public hygiene.

56 HISTORY OF MEMPHIS. AAA CAE E lu ro uem N ee wenn for many years a board of health in Memphis, and the unsanitary reputation of the city, prior to 1879, was not the result of total disregard of all sanitary work, nor because sanitation had been entirely lost sight of. But the efforts in this direction, as in too many other cities, had been of a too spasmodic character, and not on a scale commensurate with the necessity of the situation. Those in authority, like a majority of the population, not appreciating the value of sanitary work, permitted a large portion of the city to be built without regard to the simplest rules of sanitary science, and by 1873 Memphis had become a large commercial centre, in a climate where no prevention from contagious diseases can reasonably be expected without thorough observance of at least the ordinary sanitary and quarantine safeguards.

In its rapid growth the city has become filled with a decidedly mixed population, a large proportion of which had very crude ideas of individual hygiene, and a total disregard of public hygiene, only so far as it was enforced by law. That the city so long escaped violent epidemic disease is perhaps attributable more to good fortune than to any well directed effort toward prevention. Many of the unsanitary features which existed in Memphis, prior to the last few years, were, and are still, common to other cities, though circumstances . have not arisen to bring them so prominently to light.

After the epidemic of 1873 more attention was paid to sanitary affairs. The board of health was reorganised, a voluminous health ordinance adopted, which seemed sufficiently explicit and comprehensive to meet the requirements; but partly through due appreciation of its necessity, and from want of proper support by the law-making and executive power, as well as the restricted financial condition of the people, rendered a limited accomplishment of any good. But this should not be charged upon the former city government or its health authorities as designedly a dereliction of duty. The widespread and destructive epidemic of 1878 not only aroused the people of Memphis to its deplorable sanitary condition, but awakened an interest in sanitation, previously unknown all over the country, and was the direct influence which created the National Board of Health.

On the subsidence of the epidemic in 1878 the city seemed literally paralysed, and the winter passed without an effort being made worthy of mention toward general sanitary work. Under the act creating the taxing district of Shelby county the board of health was organised in February, 1879, with Dr. G. B. Thornton, president; Dr. F. A. Williamson, secretary ; D. F. Jackson, health officer; W. C. Davis, chief police, and D. T. Porter, president of the taxing district, ex-officio members. At this time it was asserted by those who professed to be competent witnesses, and whose position entitled them to respectful consideration, that the city presented some of the most unsanitary features to be found to exist in any city of its size in the country. As soon as practicable the work of sanitation was commenced by the new board under the amended ordinances of the old corporation, but the task of perfecting a system to an extent at all commensurate with the necessities of the situation was a work of Herculean proportions, and the health officers, with the limited facilities at their command, were compelled to move slowly. Dr. Thornton, in his first annual report, February, 1880, speaking of the operation of the board immediately after organisation, said: "Owing to circumstances unprecedented in the history of Memphis, the work was slow of practical results. The new government itself being novel and untried, had not only the embarrassment of the general want of confidence arising from this fact, but was subjected to a rigid judicial investigation before its legality was conceded beyond question. Much valuable time was thus consumed at a season of the year when some sanitary work could only with safety be done, and should have been most vigorously prosecuted. The violent epidemic of 1878, which commenced in August and lasted until November, and the political revolution in the city government which followed in January, 1879, caused more or less delay and neglect of all public work for more than six months. This neglect of public work was not alone confined to the health department, though it was more noticeable there than elsewhere, owing to the fact that the city had just been scourged by epidemic disease, which for malignancy and wide-spread devastation finds no parallel in history. The first practical step after organisation, was to remove the accumulation of six months of every conceivable character of garbage from the public thoroughfares, the streets and alleys, through many of the latter of which it was impossible to pass a wagon because of the obstruction caused by actual accumulations. From the want of organisation in every department of the new government, this work of street and alley cleaning, and in many instances of street repairing, devolved upon the board of health, under whose supervision it was done, being let to contract. A temporary garbage service was improvised and operated by contract under the immediate supervision of the health officer. This arrangement lasted until March. Its operations were not confined exclusively to the removal of daily accumulation, but embraced street and gutter clearing, and in many instances street repairing, work ordinarily belonging to the engineer's department. In addition to this public work citizens were required to remove similar accumulations from their private premises, where they were found to exist, and to cleanse all privy vaults, cess pools and unsanitary places as far as it was practicable and prudent, before the weather was too warm for such work to be done without endangering the public health."

The early operations of the health department were supplemented by an organisation known as the Memphis Auxiliary Sanitary Association, composed of many of the most public-spirited and prominent citizens of the city. A history of the organisation, and work accomplished by this association very properly belongs to a history of sanitary work in Memphis. It was the out-

A DATO IAN en RT Mo iL linis growth of an editorial which appeared in the Memphis Appeal May 10, 1879 calling attention to the necessity for improving the sanitary conditien of the city, in which the efficient aid which an auxiliary association in the city of New Orleans had rendered to the board of health of that city was cited, and the people were asked to consider the propriety of a similar move here.

On the 20th of the same month the matter was discussed at a joint meeting of the Cotton Exchange and Chamber of Commerce. The filthy condition of the city was referred to, and attention was called to the fact that pending litigation in a measure tied the hands of the city authorities and prevented the accomplishment by the city government of the needful sanitary reforms. A committee consisting of Dr. R. W. Mitchell, A. D. Langstaff, Rev. W. E. Boggs, Rev. S. Landrum and Major J. S. Prestige was appointed to elaborate a plan of operation and report to a meeting to be held on the 22d. On that day a public meeting was held in the Memphis Theatre, which was crowded with the leading citizens of Memphis, thoroughly aroused to the importance of the subject, and anxious to promote any measures which would prevent the visitation of infectious disease, such as had already left its withering blight upon the city. The subject of sanitation was thoroughly and ably discussed, especially so by Mr. Keating, of the Appeal, who had, he said, for years felt it to be his duty as a journalist, to inform himself upon this subject. He showed that the sanitary condition of Memphis was such in fact as to invite pestilence. Thousands of privy vaults had, for years, been the receptacles of human excreta, and these accumulations of filth and poison had contaminated the entire soil, from wbich noxious exhalations arose, especially when the surface was upturned. The water used for drinking and culinary purposes was largely drawn from wooded cisterns set in this soil, and was more or less contaminated by the poisons conveyed to it from the soil by percolation; or in the case of wells a still worse condition existed. Garbage from kitchens, etc., added its contributions to the vitiated soil, or sent forth its gaseous exhalations to be wafted hither and thither in the atmosphere. The Nicholson pavement, which had come to a decaying condition, was shown to be another source of unhealthful emanations.

In view of all these sources of pestilence, and with the memory of the horrors of the previous year still fresh, the people were not slow to sanction efficient measures for sanitary reform. The committee that had been appointed for that purpose, reported a plan of organisation for an auxiliary sanitary association, and it was unanimously adopted. This plan provided for the election of officers and the appointment of committeesifor the work of the association, and prescribed their functions. The officers chosen were Colonel James S. Prestige, president; General Colton Green, J. W. Dillard, N. Fontaine and H. Furstenheim, vice-presidents; W. W. Thatcher, treasurer; A. D. Langstaff, secretary; John T. Williams, assistant secretary; Elias LOWE David Eiseman and J. S. Wilkins, sr., executive committee; Drs. R. W. Mitchell, G. W. Overall and W. B. Winn, medical staff.

Vigorous Sanitary Work

The society at once entered on its work. It took an office on Madison street, where it held almost daily meetings and directed the work of its agents and committees. Its work was done under the advice and with the concurrence of Dr. Mitchell, of the National Board of Health, and of Dr. Thornton, of the local board. It did not usurp the functions of the city authorities, but, as its name indicates, was auxiliary to them, and an amount of work was accomplished which could not have been done by the city alone, embarrassed as it was. Funds to the amount of $10,000 to $15,000 were raised by subscription, mules and carts were purchased and scavengers were employed; privy vaults were emptied and disinfected ; garbage was carted away; the bayou, which had been the receptacle of all kinds of filth, such as the contents of privies, and dead animals, which covered its stagnant pools with a putrid scum that sent forth a deadly miasm, was cleared out; cellars in which had been permitted to generate gases, which emerged by night to poison the air, were cleaned and fumigated, and everything of an offensive character was, as far as practicable, removed. When the legal cases, that were pending in the courts, and which involved the legal existence of the government of the taxing district were decided in favor of that government, the authorities took up and carried out the sanitary work which the association had so efficiently commenced.

The outbreak of yellow fever, in July, 1879, arrested the operations of the board of health in some of its work of sanitary reform, but that it failed to prove as disastrous as its predecessor, it is believed was due to the repressive measures and quarantine restrictions which had been adopted and carried out by the health department and the valuable aid rendered by the citizens' auxiliary association. This reappearance of yellow fever in 1879 increased the interest in local sanitation, quarantines and all subjects pertaining to public hygiene, and as soon as the weather permitted the board of health took up the work of eradicating every local condition which was believed made the city susceptible to epidemic disease, and it was determined that no effort should be left untried that promised relief.

The National Board of Health, by invitation of the authorities of Memphis, visited the city in December, 1879, and with competent engineers and sanitarians made a careful sanitary survey of the city and advised what work was. necessary to put the city in proper sanitary condition. During the progress of this inspection, which lasted two months and a half, detailed schedules of nuisances and unsanitary features were made to the local board of health, which greatly facilitated the efficiency of the work of reform.

The leading features of the work aimed at by the board of health, as inaugurated in 1879, and since, in the main, carried out, until Memphis, from a sanitary standpoint, has become one of the healthiest cities in the country, have consisted in cleansing the city of all objectionable accumulations and the prevention of re-accumulations, by the operation of a public garbage service, which disposes of all such garbage; the abolition of all privy vaults, cesspools and improperly constructed underground and surface drains, and the substitution of a complete system of sewers and sub-soil drainage pipes; the destruction or renovation of unsanitary houses; the removal of saturated and decayed pavements; the improvement of the water supply and a rigid enforcement of the health ordinances, both in regard to public and private property, including the improvement of the Bayou Gayoso, which affords the natural drainage for twothirds of the western, the central and all of the eastern portion of the city.

The elevated position of Memphis and natural water-sheds afford superior natural advantages for drainage, as shown by the following approximate elevations of the different points in the city above high and low water mark:

Calhoun and Shelby streets, seventy feet above high-water, and a hundred and three above low-water mark ; along bed of bayou, two to thirty feet above high-water, and thirty-five to sixty-five above low-water mark.

Average rise of river from low to high-water mark, thirty-three feet; extreme rise, thirty-six feet; fall of ground from Front street to Bayou Gayoso, on Madison street, forty feet; fall of ground from Front to Concord streets, twenty feet; fall of ground from Dunlap street, the eastern rep ee to bayou on Madison street, forty-eight feet.

But, while nature has done a great deal in the topography of the site on which the city is built, by affording unsurpassed surface drainage, it required the intervention of art well directed, to remove many existing defects. This has been secured in the completion of a system of sewerage which has been pronounced by the leading health authorities as the best in the United States.

Prior to January, 1880, there existed but four and a half miles of sewers in the entire city, which were constructed and owned by individuals or private corporations. The pressing need of sewers was one of the most important features in the general plan of sanitation which confronted the new government. After much study and investigation by the authorities, the Waring system of sewerage was adopted, at that time an untried scheme on an extended scale, and an innovation on all recognised systems, both in this country and Europe. But its successful operation has demonstrated its utility, and the wisdom of those entrusted to provide the city with as perfect a system of sewerage as could be devised. The character of the soil and the general topography of the ground facilitated the construction of sewers, and although pipe-laying was not commenced until January 20, 1880, on July Ist, of the same year, about twenty miles had been laid. Extensions have been made during the various years since, until at the present time, there are in the city limits nearly forty miles of new sewer lines, and over thirty-five miles of sub-soil drains. The few miles of sewers which existed before the building of the new, were purchased by

Colonel Waring'S Sewerage System

COLONEL WARING'S SEWERAGE SYSTEM. 61 - « a the city, but do not enter into the general plan of sewerage, with which they have no connection, although the same ordinances apply to them as to the new. They discharge by separate outlets into the Mississippi River opposite the city.

"The unit of the system is a sewer of vitrified pipe six inches in diameter, with tight joints laid in the street (or in the alley between two streets where said alley exists), having at its upper end a * Rogers's field flush-tank," with a discharging capacity of one hundred and twelve gallons. All the houses on both sides of the sewer are connected with it by four-inch pipes of the same material. The house connection drains enter the sewer at an acute angle, and by a funnel-shaped branch-piece, which delivers the house-waste at the bottom of the sewer, and which ventilates it to its top. The house-connection drain has no top, and itis continued by an untrapped soil-pipe, four inches in diameter, which continues above the roof of the house. Therefore every house-connection furnishes free ventilation to the sewer. The water-closets, sinks, and other vessels in the house are separated from the soil-pipe and drain, each by its own trap.

"The flush-tank is fed by a constant small stream from the water-works, only sufficient to fill it about once in twenty-four hours. When full the continuance of the same small stream causes its automatic siphon to come into action, and the entire contents of the tank are discharged directly into the head of the sewer in from thirty-five to forty seconds. This rapid discharge of such a volume flushes the sewer completely.

* At the lower end of the sewer - near its junction with the river - there is a fresh-air inlet, to supply the upward draft through the soil-pipes of the houses.

" The six-inch sewer, after receiving not to exceed three hundred housedrains, discharges into a main, or sub- main sewer of eight inches diameter (or more), and the sub-mains discharge into the larger mains. The sizes of the sub-mains and mains are of eight-inch, ten-inch, twelve-inch, fifteen-inch, and twenty-inch diameter. The greatest flow of the twenty-inch main sewer is about nine inches deep.

* Porous sub-soil tile drains are laid in the same trench with the sewer, to underdrain the ground ; and these discharge directly into Bayou Gayoso."

The practical working of the sewers for several years has proved most satisfactory, and has fully answered all the ends claimed for it by its projectors. The success of the system has attracted wide attention, and secured its adoption in several cities where it has given equal satisfaction, while the leading sanitarians who have investigated the subject, pronounce it a well-nigh perfect solution of the sewer question. Certain it is that the greatly improved general healthfulness and freedom from epidemic diseases of Memphis which has followed its completion here, can be largely attributed to this source. 9

There are many circumstances calculated to subject Memphis to more severe tests of health preservation than ordinarily fall to the lot of most cities of like population elsewhere. It is located about the centre of the Mississippi Valley, on the direct line of water transportation from the north to the south - a railroad centre for many lines of roads, a commercial centre for an extensive radius of country - affording a combination of interests to induce a floating population, the migratory carriers of any infectious diseases which might exist in the country. From force of circumstances, it also has a large migratory negro population out of proportion to that which ordinarily obtains in similar cities, while its permanent colored population is larger in proportion to its total population, than exists in any other city in the United States; but it is a well conceded fact, that although the mortality among the negro population is high in Memphis, it is less than the average for all Southern cities.

But the death rate among colored people of Memphis is no criterion by which to judge of its healthfulness or sanitary provisions. Asa class it is useless to expect the colored race to attain a higher standard of mortality until their social and moral status is improved. Their present mode of living taken as a whole, shows a disregard for the plainest rules of individual hygiene both as to diet, habits of life, and general domiciliary arrangements. These facts should be stated that a fair idea may be gained of the causes which give Memphis a higher death rate than certain other cities of the same population, but not surrounded with like conditions. The following table gives the death rate per thousand population, on the basis of the local census. Where the population is stated as 40,000, the rate is obtained on the basis that one-third represents the colored population ; where 46,064 is given, it is divided into 28,273 whites, and 17,741 colored, and the population of 1883 as follows: 40,207 whites, and 22,128 colored:

Death Rate Per Thousand Population

* Epidemic years. In the year 1885 the deaths of non-residents and from violence were 196 white, and 151 colored ; in 1886, 209 whites, and 167 colored ; and in 1887,

Comparative Death Rates

224 white, and 225 colored. To show the correct mortality among the residents proper of Memphis for these years, the number of such deaths should be eliminated from the above table. With this done the following result is attained :

Ratio Per 1,000 Population

When it is considered that in calculating the death rate for these years an estimated population of 62,335 is used, when the last city directory gives 21,- 924 names of persons residing inside the city limits, which by the usual methods of computing population from business directory would make a population of nearly 80,000, it will be seen that the above table of figures makes a highly creditable showing in regard to mortality in Memphis. Even with the death rate among the negro population, which has always been largely in excess of the whites, the average mortality in Memphis shows what is undoubtedly the fact, that Memphis is one of the healthiest cities in the United States.

Since the yellow fever epidemics of 1878 and 1879 the health authorities of Memphis have brought about a system of sanitary measures such as would seem adequate to render the fullest protection to the health and lives of its citizens. There are now no known available precautions not in operation in Memphis, which engineering skill, quarantine restrictions and cleanliness, and a perfect knowledge of public hygiene can devise, to ward off and prevent the spread of disease. In all this work, so admirably done, Dr. G. B. Thornton, the president of the board of health since its organization, has been the head and front. In a recent issue of the Appeal, upon the occasion of publishing President Thornton's report, appeared the following editorial comment upon the valuable services he had rendered:

"For much of this we are indebted to the zeal, discretion and energy of Dr. Thornton, who has, with his rare fidelity, surrendered himself to his duties as health officer, often to the exclusion of a professional practice worthy one of our most skillful physicians and surgeons. He has accomplished a great deal at but comparatively small cost, and he is constantly devising and enforcing whatever will tend to make the sanitary officers under him more efficient, and secure a model service."

Dr. Thornton has made a most thorough study of the science of public hygiene and his numerous sketches on this important subject have attracted wide attention and elicited the most favorable expressions of approval We have largely drawn upon Dr. Thornton's annual reports, as president of the board of

Chapter

HE idea of law may be, as some writers assert, intuitive to every people, but a fortunately for American civilisation, it had neither to rely upon this intuition nor did it have to wait for its slow development. The progress of American civilisation was, to a great extent, the simple march to new territory and conquest over material forces.

The history of America has no chapter on the origin ofits laws. The pioneers who settled up the new territories and prepared them for states, were familiar with at least the elementary principles of the science of the common law. They carried this knowledge with them, and so soon as sufficient numbers had congregated, its machinery was easily put in motion. Montesquieu justly observes, however, that all laws of necessity adapt, and to a great extent, mould themselves to the habits and characteristics of the people adopting them, and this was true to the extent of adaptation in America.

The common law adapted itself to the character and was shaped by the genius of the American people themselves. We see these observations verified by the early history of Shelby county. We might say the law was before there was law. So soon as a sufficient number had congregated on the Chickasaw Bluffs to need the protecting arm of the law and the establishment of tribunals of justice, and before there was any county or State, we find Isaac Rawlings presiding as justice, getting his commission from common consent and not the State. His was the first judicial tribunal of which we have any account upon the Bluffs. His office was elective in the highest sense, but from the meagre accounts we have of its administration, this had no weight with him. He seems to have been a man with strong native intellect, of unflinching courage, stern integrity and sincerely desirous of adjudging rightly. True he had the prejudices usual to narrow views and circumscribed personal association, but these seldom interfered, if ever, with the scale's balance. His jurisdiction was coextensive with the settlement, and embraced both the rights of persons and property. The cases of the first were usually petty thefts and assaults and battery.

The Bench And Bar

The punishment was the whipping-post and banishment, and were meted out without delay, or the privilege of appeal or habeas corpus. The second was mostly possessory, and ample restitution was the decree of the court. The machinery was so simple there was scarcely need of the engineer, the lawyer, and we have no authentic account of any lawyer settling here until after the organisation of the county of Shelby.

The constitution of 1796 did not establish any court, but simply vested the judicial power in such supreme courts of law and equity as the Legislature should from time to time establish. On the 24th of November, 1819, the Legislature of Tennessee, then sitting at Murfreesboro, established a new county on the Mississippi River, called Shelby county, and authorised a court of " Pleas and Quarter Sessions," which was organised on the first day of May, 1820, with William Irvine as chairman, with four others commissioned as justices. There were four terms a year of this court. Its jurisdiction was general, embracing the administration of county affairs and civil and criminal cases. Appeals were from this court to the Circuit Court of Humphreys county. Its sessions were held wherever a room could be found in Memphis, and sometimes, doubtless, a/ fresco.

The adjournment of the January term, 1827, was to its April term and to Raleigh, the attorneys agreeing in open court, of which a minute was made, that no exception should be taken by reason of this adjournment from Memphis to Raleigh. The addition of the words, " Pleas and Quarter Sessions," seems to have been dropped from the minutes of the April term, 1836, and from this time it has been styled simply * County Court." This court has, with some changes, continued to this day, its central idea of representation being as firmly fixed in the affections of the people as in the statutes of the State. Serious doubts, however, have arisen whether this representative and legislative form of government is best for counties of large population and great wealth, and composed largely of incorporated cities with additional machinery of government and retinue of officers. It is suggested with great force that the large number of justices makes the machinery too cumbrous and, with municipal officers in addition, too expensive for such counties as Shelby and Davidson.

On the 22d of July, 1836, a general act was passed creating the office of county judge, elected by the people. On the 4th of November, 1857, this act was repealed, but on July 18, 1858, the office was re-established for Shelby and several other counties. Several changes have been made since as to the function and jurisdiction of this court, finally ending in the present Probate Court, having especial charge of all matters of probate.

The Circuit Court was the next highest court in dignity and jurisdiction established, having both civil and criminal jurisdiction. That for Shelby county was established by act of the Legislature, 1827, Shelby being in the 8th circuit and presided over by Judge Joshua Haskell.

In 1846, however, a special court for Shelby county was established called the " Commercial and Criminal Court," with Hon. E. W. M. King as judge, who presided from 1846 to 1850, when J. C. Humphreys became judge and continued until 1862. This Circuit Court has also undergone various changes, its criminal jurisdiction being at one time relegated to the Circuit Court and then to a special Criminal Court for Shelby county, and its civil casesto the Common Law and Chancery Court.

The next and most important court of civil jurisdiction is the Chancery Court. The first Legislature, which convened on the 28th of March, 1796, passed an act establishing a Supreme Court of Law and Equity. Then by act, 1822, ch. 13, it was provided that one of the judges of the Supreme Court of Errors and Appeals should open and hold a Court of Equity at the places appointed by law. Then by act of 1827, ch. 79, this act, directing the supreme judges to hold Chancery Courts was repealed, the State was divided into two chancery divisions, the Eastern and Western, and two chancellors appointed by joint ballot of the General Assembly.

By the act of 1835, ch. 41, the districts and chancellors were increased to three, Fayette and Shelby constituting the seventh district of the Western Division, court to be held at Somerville. On the 15th of December, 1840, Shelby and Tipton were made a district, court to be held at Memphis and the first minutes of the court show Hon. Alexander McCampbell, chancellor of the Western Division, presiding. The first case upon the rule docket of this court, filed May 26, 1846, was James O. Hutchins vs. R. K. Eskridge, and was to enjoin collection of note given for hire of slave. Delafield, Massey and P. G. Gaines were solicitors for complainant, and Sylvester Barley for defendent. Bill dismissed on hearing. An examination of these old records shows we have made considerable improvement even in the mechanical department of the law. There were then neither legal cap nor metal fasteners. The paper was simply foolscap with the left edges sewed together with silk, carefully and neatly done. A comparison of the pleadings, however, of that day with those of this, show no improvement here. There were then neither prolixity nor redundancy, but the cases were stated, simply, briefly and clearly, two pages of foolscap being sufficient for most bills. There were one hundred and five cases filed in the court in 1846.

Shelby county has been singularly fortunate in the judges of its courts. They have of course been of different capacity, some fitted for the very highest judicial offices, and others scarcely equal to the duties of this particular office. But for uprightness and purity of character they challenge comparison with

The earlier circuit judges were Joshua Haskell, V. D. Barry, Perry W. Humphreys, William B. Turley, L. M. Bramlett, W. C. Dunlap and William R. Harris. Of some of these, little was known to the writer, nor could he learn much of their earlier life, their habits or character.

Hon. Valentine D. Barry was the first circuit judge who resided in Shelby county. He was a native of Ireland, and had many of the characteristics, though few of the failings of that gifted and sometimes erratic race.

He was medium size, about five feet nine inches in height, with gray eyes, a fine, well developed head, brown hair, which he retained to his latest years. He was a man of most excellent attainments. Not only well grounded in the law, but also cultivated in literature. In his profession he was laborious and accurate, and devoted his time assiduously to his clients and his profession. There was in his office huge tomes of his own manuscript, revisals of our statute laws and digests of decisions. He was a model of neatness and order in his office and was impatient of all slip-shod, careless practice. He would sometimes say pleasantly to a brother lawyer he found careless with his papers, quoting Currin to Grattan: * You would be the greatest man of your age, if you would buy a few yards of red tape and tie up your papers." In conversation he was fluent, entertaining and instructive. As a public speaker upon general subjects he was graceful and powerful, sometimes eloquent. He was fond of instructing the young lawyers, and always had a number in his office for instruction. Among others who read under him was the Hon. J. L. T. Sneed, now ex-judge of our Supreme Court, and still a member of the Memphis bar. No better tribute to the elegance of manner, the general culture and solid attainments of Judge Barry could be proposed than to say that Judge Sneed has fully transmitted them. It is from Judge Sneed's copious memory and facile pen the best recollections and characteristics of the older lawyers is preserved.

William B. Turley was born in Virginia. His father removed with his family to Kentucky, and thence to Clarksville, Tenn., where W. B. Turley was admitted to practice. He subsequently removed to Shelby county, Tenn., and was judge of the Circuit Court for a number of years. He was then judge of the Supreme Court of Tennessee for fourteen years, until 1850. He declined continuance on this bench on account of its great labor, and accepted instead the judgeship of the Common Law and Chancery Court at Memphis, which position he filled until his death. This was as unexpected as singular and tragic. He was walking along on the sidewalk, slipped, and in falling, his cane was broken, and wounded him so badly that he died from it.

Judge Turley was an admirable circuit judge, quick in perception, keen in discrimination, and utterly impartial. He was kind in manner, but at the same time prompt and firm in the dispatch of business. His charges to juries were clear, concise, and giving no uncertain note. His opinions as supreme judge found from 9th Yerger to 10th Humphreys inclusive, are models of clear and comprehensive exposition. This was a great triumvirate - Green, Reese and Turley. An admirable obituary of him will be found in preface to 11 Humphreys's Reports.

W. C. Dunlap was circuit judge from 1840 to 1850, when he retired from the bench. He could have remained in office to his death had he so desired, as he was very popular with all classes of people. He was born at Knoxville, February 25, 1798, of one of its best families. He was one of twenty-three children by his mother, and twin brother to Hugh W. Dunlap. He was over medium size, and of fine presence, with a benevolent face, and was a genial and interesting companion. In early life he was prominent in State and national politics, and was a representative in the State Legislature fourteen years. Also represented his district in Congress several terms, where his ability and faithfulness were conspicuous. He was judge of the Circuit Court ten years. As judge he was impartial and able. He was never known to display the slighest irritation on the bench, and never forgot that he was a gentleman as well as a judge. It seemed pleasant to him to make the law amiable in the sight of the people, and thus insure a more ready and careful obedience to its mandates. The older lawyers say it was a positive pleasure to practice before him. He was gentle to all, even fatherly to the young lawyers. He put them forward whenever it was possible to do so, and seemed to rejoice in their success. One of them related that he was appointed by Judge Dunlap to defend a prisoner indicted for murder. He did so successfully, when Judge Dunlap called him to his side on the bench, congratulated him on his success, and whispered, "Now go and tell the people you have had experience in great State cases, and never lost a case in your life."

After retiring from the bench Judge Dunlap lived in this county, respected and beloved by all until his death, which occurred at Buntyn, in this county, November 17, 1872; married in Knoxville to Miss Susanna Gillian, by whom he had a large family of children, among others, Rachel G., J. T. Dunlap, of Nashville, and John H. Dunlap, father-in-law to Governor Porter.

Wiliam R. Harris was born in Montgomery county, North Carolina, in 1802. His parents removed with him to Bedford county, Tenn., when he was an infant They subsequently removed to Franklin county, Tenn., where William would work in the fields during the crop season, and then attend the oldfield school in winter. He finally studied law at Lawrenceburg, and having obtained his license, located at Paris, in Henry county. He was subsequently, and for a number of years circuit judge of this district. He afterwards removed to Memphis, and in 1851, upon the sad death of W. B. Turley, he was appointed to the judgeship of the then Commercial and Criminal Court of

Memphis, which he filled until r854. He was subsequently appointed to the supreme bench of the State, and then elected to the same position. While filling this position his life was suddenly brought to an untimely end by the explosion of the ill-fated steamer, Pennsylvania. He died on the 20th of June, 1858, after lingering for a week in great pain, making the second judge of this court who died by accident.

In social life Judge Harris was a Christian gentleman, and was greatly respected and loved. As a lawyer he was faithful to the interests of his clients, and as a judge he was laborious, painstaking and able. A beautiful tribute to his memory will be found in 5 Sneed's Reports.

E. W. M. King. When the Commercial and Criminal Court was established in 1846 E. W. M. King was appointed judge, and held the office until 1350.

In person Judge King was quite tall, with blue eyes and long straight black hair, which stood out upon his head like General Jackson's, or like the "fretful porcupine's quil." He was of a quick and fiery temper, and prone to rashness. While kind and gentle to those he loved, he was a dangerous adversary, and carried to the fullest the advice of Polonius to Laertes. It was told of him that while on the bench he once charged a jury " that the d d lie was equivalent to a blow," and the jury acquitted the defendant on the ground of self-defence.

In his practice he had made the criminal law his specialty and was vigorous and able in both prosecution and defence. He was attorney-general for the district for some time, prosecuting violaters of the law with almost ferocious vigor. Then on the criminal bench he enforced the law with a strong hand. He lived in Shelby county up to his death.

B. F. McKiernan succeeded Judge King on the bench. He was a native of Alabama; came to Memphis in early life, before 1846. He had a fine head, blue eyes, light hair, and was about five feet eight inches in height. He wasa pleasant gentleman, a good lawyer, and made an admirable judge. He died early - too early for the State.

Hon. John C. Humphreys was a native of Kentucky. He first moved to Dover, Tenn., and thence to Somerville. He was the son of a lawyer, and no pains or expense was spared in his preparation for the bar, and with good fruit too, for he was well equipped in habit and learning to adorn both bar and bench. He was one of the handsomest men of his day, black eyes and hair, and a most intellectual face, but of frail physique. It was said of him as of Lord Ellsmere, that the people frequently came into court simply to see the handsome judge. Nor could it be said of him as of Napoleon, "His frown terrified the glance his magnificence attracted." His personal and judicial character were absolutely pure, and he died in Somerville in 1868, respected and lamented by all.

Of the Criminal Court established in 18 - five of its judgas have passed away - John D. Adams, Thos. H. Logwood, P. T. Scruggs, J. E. R. Ray and L. B. Horrigan. Three of these, Judges Adams, Ray and Scruggs died of yellow fever. They were all painstaking and conscientious judges.

Of these, Judge Phineas T. Scruggs had perhaps the most varied and eventfullife. He was in later years large and portly, with blue eyes, gray hair and beard, a round, benevolent face, and dignified presence. He was born in Lauderdale county, Ala.; was first a Methodist preacher, and made much reputation for zeal and ability. He afterwards practiced law, became a judge in Mississippi, and then went to Jackson, Tenn., and thence to Memphis in 1867, where he practiced law until 1872. He then joined the ministry again, and returned to the bar in 1877. In 1878 he was elected judge of the criminal court but died soon after. Had he begun and continued at the law his natural ability would have commanded its most successful practice and bright honors.

J. P. Caruthers succeeded Judge Harris in 1862. He was born in Lincoln county, Tenn., and a relative of the distinguished Abram Caruthers. In early years he was the attorney-general of this district and was afterwards chancellor, making a most excellent chancellor. He removed to Chicago some years ago, where he died in 1876. His was a familiar figure in Memphis after the war. He was tall, slim, light hair and eyes, benevolent though firm face, and a very quiet manner. He was looked upon then as one who had served his time, fought the fight, and now enjoying a serene, dignified and honorable old age. During the war the courts were closed, or virtually so, veryifying the maxim "inter arma leges sileunt." Then for several years after the war during reconstruction days, when bayonets prevailed and "carpet baggery " held sway, though the courts were open, the administration of justice was nearly a mockery, so true was the saying of Chatham that "where tyranny begins the law ends."

Of the courts and judges of this period, with some honorable exception, little had best be said. Their most charitable mention is silence. The judges were in most cases petty tyrants - beggars raised to horseback and commandants of military posts clothed with the ermine. Among these honorable exceptions were W. M. Smith, still living and then a respected chancellor, and Thomas G. Smith, of the Law Court created in 1866. i;

Thomas G. Smith was born in Mecklenburg county, Va., January 10, 1820. In May, 1831, he moved with his father to Haywood county, Tenn.; was educated in the schools of that county and began teaching there himself in 1839. He afterwards went to the University of Tennessee, at Nashville, where he graduated in 1842. He studied law there under R. J. Meigs and began practice in Brownsville in 1843, and soon thereafter came toa good country practice. He was a stern, uncompromising Unionist and took no part in secession, but remained out of the State during the war. After the war he came to Memphis

THE BENCH AND BAR. 71 CR ri Um Ee TN ERE A TIE innen lan) with Colonel M. R. Hill, and the firm of Smith & Hill soon asserted its strength. On the creation of the Law Court of Memphis, in 1866, he was appointed its judge and filled this bench until his death on October 18, 1867.

Though the appointee of a then unpopular administration, he was more than acceptable to the bar and people of Shelby county, who regarded themselves quite fortunate in his selection. He was one of the foremost lawyers in the State, and soon proved himself a model judge. He combined the "suavitor in modo" with the " fortiter in re" most admirably. Though sound in judgment and correct in conclusion, he was quick as a flash, and went to the very heart of the case without delay. He was fond of indulging in sparkling, though pleasing and dignified, repartee for the bench and made the most tedious case interesting and entertaining. His death was a genuine loss to the bar, the bench and the public.

Charles Kertrecht was elected chancellor in 1878. This was a well won honor, gained after years of toil and crowning a life of earnest devotion to the profession. He was born in New York. His school education was very limited He labored asa journeyman carpenter during the day and studied books at night. During the forties he came to Somerville, Tenn., arriving there on foot from the Mississippi River, where he landed from a boat. He taught school there and at the same time studied law under Judge Humphreys. When licensed as a lawyer he came to Raleigh about 1845, and thence afterwards to Memphis. From his entrance to the bar at Raleigh, up to his death, in September, 1878, he was identified with its history and its fortunes as intimately as any that ever belonged to it. He was emphatically a working lawyer. Slow, methodical, painstaking, persistent, he won his way by tedious toil to the front rank in profitable and honorable practice. He was not brilliant or showy, attained no point of vantage by intellectual alertness, but when once attained, he fortified and held with genuine Jackson sturdiness and courage. He was a Whig in politics, devoted to the Union, and when secession came, acknowledged no fealty greater than that which he owed to the Union. He was non-partisan and non-combatant during the war, and when it ended naturally joined the Republican party, by which he was elected chancellor in 1878, but died soon after. There was no doubt of his fitness for the position, and had he lived, all classes would have joined in respectful consideration of his opinions, and the bar especially recognised the fitness of his occupancy of the bench.

The pioneer lawyers of Shelby county were not all great men, but from the meagre traditions we have of them handed down from father to son, there were many of that day who would challenge comparison in all that adorns and dignifies a profession, with any of this day. Many of them came here from the older settlements, bringing with them the thoughts, habits and culture of a more advanced society, and some from the schools. To this culture was added the courage and self-reliance of the pioneer. They had but few books, but these few they knew well. They read less and thought more. They grounded their cases upon elementary and eternal principles and not precedents alone, and thus preserved these principles in greater purity and simplicity. The courts were held at Raleigh for a number of years and many of the lawers practiced in other counties, especially at Somerville. They went from Memphis to Raleigh and Somerville in the hack, on horseback (when their horses did not do as did Lord Eldon's when he rode the circuit, " demur when he should have gone to the country" ), and in some instances walked. We know of one instance of a then young lawyer, now an ex-supreme judge, who was under engagement to try a ten dollar replevin case, and who could not pay his stage fare, walking to Somerville to try the case. On these circuits they went together, they lived together and thus became more sociable and companionable with each other, and in social amenities wore off each night the frictions and asperities of each day's conflicts. Many are the stories of amusing adventure, practical joking and fun and frolic told of those circuit days. Some of them, if not nearly all, indulged at times in a small game of "draw poker," though the " Pastor's Aid Society " was the name of latter days.

Henry G. Smith, Ed. Yerger, W. T. Avery, D. M. Leatherman, James Wickersham, Granville Seary, Valentine Barry, John Farrington, W. A. Blythe and John L. T. Sneed and others were, if tradition be true, a jolly and companionable set in those days.

In the trial of cases, and the arguments of counsel, more attention was paid then than now, for now, alas, "the days of oratory are over," to the graces and force of elocution. It was not then, though as now, that the lawyer spoke to a beggarly array of empty benches, but to crowded court-houses. Everybody in the county came court days and listened to the lawyers " plead." There was not that hurry and rush in the dispatch of business as of to-day. The lawyer took his time, and spoke to the people, as well as to the court and jury. He was therefore better known, and more carefully weighed and estimated by the people. Accustomed thus to speak to the public, the lawyer of that day naturally became the stump speaker, the legislator, and the statesman; and from the ranks of the law, the Legislature and the Senate were filled.

Of the lawyers, Robert McAlpin seems to have been the first who settled in Memphis. He was a native of Alabama, came to Memphis from Mobile, and subsequently returned there. He was of medium size, good looking, and said to be a good lawyer. He was in Memphis earlier than 1822.

John Montgomery, David W. Massey, John Brown, William Stoddard and Robert Hughes were admitted to practice at the same time. Of these, nothing could be learned by the writer of this, in the short space allowed for the preparation of this article. Nothing remains of them but a name upon the docket.

They have passed away and out of the memory and lives of the men of this age, as utterly as if they had lived in the days of Rameses, leaving only a name upon some ruin. Notonly these, but many more who were at the bar since the war, have left no record of their birth, their lives or death, save in the memory of scattered loved ones. * How soon we is forgot, when we is gone."

Of the early lawyers of special mention, in addition to those already noticed in the list of judges, P. T. Gaines was perhaps the first to reside in Memphis. He was very tall, with gray eyes, short, curly, light hair, and dark complexion. He was an inveterate politician, familiar with all. the party machinery of Democracy, and was the strategist of his party, and his office was the headquarters of all opposition to Whigism. All this was naturally to the neglect of his law business, and he had a large practice. The result was he was never ready for trial. He was called "Old Continuendo" by the younger lawyers. He was a pleasant, genial gentleman, and lived and died a bachelor.

Wm. T. Brown was probably the oldest lawyer, and best cultivated member of the bar of his day. He was about five feet eleven inches high, dark complexion, black eyes, thin black hair, medium size. He was a native of North Carolina, brother to Hon. Bedford Brown, congressman and senator from that State for a number of years. He was for awhile circuit judge in Middle Tennessee, and came from there to Memphis, forming a partnership with F. P. Stanton, and the firm was soon doing the largest business in the county. He practiced law with great vigor, was quick and nervous in movement and temperament. His utterances were so rapid when speaking, that he made some ludicrous mistakes, especially in his Latin or French quotations. He was defending a client at Raleigh in an action of trespass, vi el armis. His client had been knocked down in the fray, and Mr. Brown in referring to his prostrate form, cried out, "look at him gentlemen of the jury. There he lay de hors the combat, and out of the fight." In addition to being one of the foremost lawyers of the day, and an able, earnest politician and Democrat, he was a genial, cultivated, companionable gentleman. He built and resided in the elegant residence just east of St. Agnes Academy on Vance street, and there dispensed an open and hearty hospitality.

Granville D. Searcy was another strong lawyer. He had a frank, open countenance, large blue eyes, and pleasing expression. He came from Somerville to Memphis, where he practiced for a number of years, doing a large share of the most lucrative business of the circuit. Asan advocate and lawyer he had great power, and this, coupled with a vast fund of anecdote, and a ready and nimble wit, made him one of the most popular men of his day. He died December, 1853.

James Wickersham was another notable figure at the bar in the ante bellum days. He was very tall and erect in figure, with blue eyesand light hair. He came from the North and settled here about 1844. At the first he did but lit-

74 HisTORY OF MEMPHIS. e ITe RR ERR tle practice, but by patient industry and attention to business, he accumulated a fine practice and estate. He was an excellent lawyer, and a kind and generous man.

He was for a time like Sam Gammon of later years, much indebted to his landlord, but did not as Sam did, threaten to leave his landlord if the boardbill was mentioned. He finally got what is called an "admiralty case," an attachment on a flat-boat, made a good fee, and bought up his landlord's paper, with which he paid off his board. He died a bachelor, leaving a good estate, which dissolved in chancery.

Hon. Spenser Jarnagan came to Memphis from East Tennessee, in 1847. He was a philosopher and a fisherman. If the fish were biting well, the court had to wait. It is related of him that once during a term of court he went fishing. That day a case of his was called, and the opposite attorney pressed for a trial. Finally the judge called to the sheriff to adjourn the court until to-morrow, saying: "He bed d if Spenser's case shall suffer while he is fishing for the court."

Mr. Jarnagan was a man of splendid ability, and at one time a distinguished member of the United States Senate. He was about five feet ten inches in height, with light hairland gray eyes. He was a genial gentleman, and an able lawyer. He died in Memphis, June 25, 1851.

Colonel James B. Thornton was born in Carolina county, Va., August 28, 1806. He was educated at William and Mary College, then studied law and practiced in Virginia, until 1846. He was in the Virginia Senate in 1838-39. He married Miss Mariamia T. Horner, of Warrenton, by whom he had four sons and a daughter, all now dead except James B. Thornton, now living in Fayette county, and Dr. G. B. Thornton of Memphis.

In 1847 he moved to Memphis and began the practice of the law there and continued an honored member of this bar for many years. His first wife died in 1852, and he subsequently married Miss Susan Stuart Thornton, by whom he had Lee Thornton, a promising young lawyer of Memphis. Colonel Thornton was a man of fine education and literary attainments. He was also well read in the law. He was a man of letters, He wrote " Thornton on Cenveyancing," which at once took its place on the table of every well-equipped lawyer, was made a text book in the Law School of Cambridge, Mass., and ran through two editions. He also wrote a work on Assignments, but in 1860 the manuscript was burned with his office, and the labor of years was destroyed just as it was ready for the press.

In the campaign of 1860, he was an ardent Breckenridge and Lane Democrat, and upon the breaking out of the war he joined the Confederate army and remained with it during the war. He died at his residence near Memphis.

THE BENCH AND BAR. 75 - - - - M RA ODO sq reared in Maury county, Tenn., graduated at Pennsylvania University and commenced practice at Bolivar, Tenn. He was of medium size, dark complexion, and fine appearance. He was a warm friend but a bold and aggressive enemy. Was active in politics, a lawyer of fine attainments. Was killed in a personal difficulty, 1850.

Walter Coleman was a conspicuous figure at the bar from 1846 until some years after the war. He was of large, portly figure, dark hair, light gray or blue eyes, quite large. He was a splendid lawyer, and one of the most fluent and eloquent speakers ever at the Memphis bar. Domestic misfortunes impaired his usefulness, and prevented his attaining those honors his commanding abilities deserved.

Thomas J. Turley, was a noted lawyer of that day. He was a brother of the distinguished W. B. Turley, of the Supreme Court. He was a man of sound learning, and a charming character, and beloved and honored by the people for the gentleness of his manner, and his sterling integrity and fidelity to every trust. He was a laborious and ardent practitioner. He and Judge Wright became partners, and did a large and lucrative practice to the death of Turley, which occurred in 18 - . It is pleasing to note that their sons are now partners at the same bar, filling the places of their fathers in all the worthy offices of life.

Wm. K. Poston linked the past and the present. Among the earliest at the Memphis bar, he grew up with it and the city, and contributed much that was best to both.

He was born in Montgomery county, Tenn., in 18 - . Married quite young, studied and began the practice of law in Memphis. He was a man of medium height, stoutly built, though not portly, with round smooth face, fine eyes and mouth, and a general appearance in which dignity and gentleness were so blended, that neither asserted prominence or lost themselves. Asa lawyer, he was remarkable for the wisdom and soundness of his judgment, the carefulness of his practice, and the smoothness of manner. As a citizen, he was upright and active in his duty to the public, going when necessary and where duty called, though like Luther, "a devil growled at him from every tile." He was a stern Whig, opposed secession with earnestness and power, but when the State seceded he gave his only sons who were able to bear arms, David and King, to the Southern cause, which he himself upheld with a dignity and fidelity that commanded the respect and secured the protection of the Federal commanders themselves.

He died at the early age of forty-four, in 1866, in the vigor of life, and very fullness of usefulness, leaving a large family, some twelve worthy sons and accomplished daughters, and a widow, who like Cordelia of old, has reared these to lives of duty and usefulness.

ENDE QR SELBER mei CS eco dm nen u. boro, in 1819, and graduated at the Nashville University in his seventeenth year. Read law under Return J. Meigs. Wasa candidate for the Legislature at twenty-one years of age, and though defeated for this office, made such a reputation as a popular speaker, that he was made elector on the Polk ticket, in the canvass of 1843-44. He served several terms in the State Legislature from Memphis, and made one or two races for Congress. He was twice elected to the Confederate Congress, and died near Richmond, Va., March 25, 1864.

Mr. Currin was a lawyer of ability, but his taste and genius were in the broader field of politics. He was devoted to literature, and spoke with a readiines and elegance that was simply charming. He was a ready wit and caustic satirist. He was earnest, indefatigable, faithful and fearless. Some of his speeches while in Congress, notably an eulogium on a member of the Confederate Congress from Missouri, were models of literay taste and finish.

Henry G. Smith. One of the lawyers that came earliest to Memphis, was Henry Grattan Smith. Born in Connecticut in 1807, he received a liberal and classical education, and removed in early manhood to North Carolina, and was there appointed to a professorship in Chapel Hill University. After a few years he removed to Greenville, Tenn., and thence to Memphis about 1845. He was appointed to the supreme bench of Tennessee in 1868, and occupied his seat there until 1870, when he resumed the practice in Memphis. He served one term in the State Senate. On the night of the 31st of December, 1878, he attended a public meeting of citizens in Memphis, where he made an earnest speech of counsel and advice. On reaching home after the meeting, he fell to the floor and died with scarcely a struggle.

Such is the brief outline of his life. Such the cold chronicler would write and then end. But in this life of seventy-one years there was more of ardent, passionate. youth, warm and vigorous manhood, dignified but graceful old age, more of ambition, labor, struggle, victory, honor, much more to be remembered and emulated than usually attend those years.

His life and character was full, round and complete. A fine and graceful figure, good head, keen eyes, and a manner dignified, yet pleasing, always commanding respect but never repelling. A temper sometimes cold in the intensity of thought and the earnestness of struggle, alternating, however, quickly and often with the best of humor, the liveliest of wit, and the utmost abandon of cheerfulness and good nature. See him in the arena of the forum or in the public debate, and his blade flashed as keenly as that of Saladin, while his arm struck with the vigor of a Richard. See him, after the contest was over, in the circle of lawyers that loved to gather around him, and his fund of anecdote and reminiscence, his store of good humor made you forget the formidable foeman in the cheerful raconteur, while in the home circle and the salons of society he was at once polished and refined, graceful and gentle.

odical worker. Here was the arena of his labors, his struggles, his honor and happily for that profession, here will the deep impress of his character longest endure. He took an earnest interest in everything that touched the dignity and honor of the profession. He was the father of the Memphis Law Library, for to him more than to any one else, do we owe the establishment of this invaluablelibrary. Devoting his time earnestly to his profession, he yet found time to serve the State, not as a politician, looking to his own advancement, but as a citizen devoting his time, his energy and his thoughts to the service of the people. He gave his time and his talents as he paid his taxes - as a duty he owed to the commonwealth to share the common burden. Of the firmest convictions of policy and right and duty, he was deaf to ridicule, and regardless of public opinion when he felt that opinion was wrong. He moved in straight lines, with noble purpose, to exalted positions of thought and duty, having always "the sense of virtue, looking not to what is called a good name, for reward, but to itself, the highest sense of virtue."

His last public appearance was at a meeting of citizens called to take action upon a matter of vital importance to the city. He then earnestly warned against impending danger to the interests of his city and in a few moments thereafter was dead. This speech was his Morituri Salutamus.

Edwin M. Yerger. Of him, Judge J. L. T. Sneed furnishes the following sketch: *'It is no disparagement to any of his associates at the bar of that day to say that Edwin M. Yerger was the most remarkable man of his day. Indeed, he was confessedly so among them all. Francis Jeffrey once said of Macaulay, 'Tom. Macaulay ought to be embalmed and kept.' The same might have been said of Judge Yerger; and what Macaulay said of Lord Bacon might also be said of him, that *he had one of the most exquisitely constructed intellects that was ever bestowed upon any of the children of men.' He was not a philosopher like Lord Bacon, nor, like him, had he made his mind 'the mirror of the universal world' by profound researches in the occult sciences and all things else. He was not a perfect man. Who is? 'No human quality is so well wove in warp and woof, but there's some flaw in it.' But his social virtues and intellectual beauties held all his frailties in such black eclipse, that no friend, however near, was prepared to admit that any very grave fault could be laid to his charge. Indeed, there was a halo of bonhomie always about him and a fascination in his converse that charmed men into oblivion of all else but his brilliant wit, his genial nature and electric brain power. One thing may be said and will be said by all who knew him well, that he had in his character that sort of chastity of personal honor which shrunk from a blot of his good name, as

He was born at Lebanon, Tenn., and was of- German extraction. The old homestead is still to be seen in Lebanon, the birth-place of a family of great lawyers. In boyhood he went with his brother-in-law, the present Judge Finley, of Florida, to the Seminole war. Returning, he became a law student in the office of his distinguished brother, George S. Verger, once attorney-general of Tennessee. He came to Memphis early in the forties and was one of the strong firm of Herron, Finley Yerger. Both of his partners were strong men. Herron has passed away. Finley, one of the first men of his time in all that ennobles man, removed to Florida, where for many years he has been a central figure; a member of Congress, a. brigadier-general of the Confederacy, a judge, and now recently a United States Senator by executive appointment. He was, in 1844, also mayor of Memphis. When Yerger came to Memphis he was very poor, but caring little for money, he freely divided his little income among the young men in a worse condition than himself. And it was "long division" at that, for the younger toilers of that day had a hard time. He had the most generous heart I ever knew. Sometimes after dividing out I have known him to walk to his courts at Raleigh for the want of money to get there otherwise. I accompanied him several times on these expeditions. After a while he made the walking to Raleigh a fashionable recreation, and we were accompanied once by Wickersham, the *admiralty lawyer," and by Stanton, the eminent politician and lawyer of that day. I shall never forget my first pedestrian trip with Yerger to Raleigh. We had stopped at Wolf River bridge and were calmly looking at the clear water before entering town. I said: "Ed, let's 'hurry on; I may have to return home to-night." "What for," he asked in surprise. "Well, I have no money, and I don't know that the landlord will be willing to trust me, as I must tell him the situation as soon as I get there." "Let me fix that," said he, *I'll talk to Zenas Alexander about it. He is one of the cleverest men you ever saw and I'll bet he says yes." When we reached the hotel he called out Mr. Alexander, and introducing me, said: "Here's a young who has come here to live or starve at the law. He wants to stay here and has no money. Will you credit him for his board on his prospects ?" " Certainly I will," said the landlord, and I know not which was the happier of the two, Edwin or myself. I made more than a hundred dollars in cash that term and at the end of it we all rode home in the hack.

The faculty which distinguished Judge Yerger above all his contemporaries was the process of ratiocination, by which he could reason out the law of every case without absolute knowledge of it, and without looking into books. In nineteen out of twenty cases the books would show that his process of induction had brought him to the right conclusion. And indeed if the books did not agree with him, some of us had come to believe that the books must be wrong. His reasoning powers in this respect were wonderful, and tended much to confirm the saying of Lord Coke, that the common law was at least only the perfection of reason. When Judge Yerger accepted the chancellorship of Shelby county he made a great mistake. He was too great at the bar to dwarf himself into a tread-mill position like that. And yet he was an able chancellor, and was seldom reversed, and when so reversed, as the old man said of the sectional war, "God only knows who was right." It was as an advocate, a pleader and a counselor that he shone conspicuous over all. His arguments were generally brief, without any surplus words. He believed with Southey, that words are like sunbeams, the more they are condensed the more they burn. He seemed to need no mere say so himself to know what the law was, but his propositions before the court were always braced by what Jerry Black would call, * a torrent of authority." His wit and repartee was generally of that benevolent order that left no sting, but he wasa fearless man when provoked by a saucy adversary, he could let fly the /ethalis arundo of forensic satire with terrific effect. Such was Edwin M. Yerger, a man without guile and a man without a peer. His jealous solicitude for the independence of the bar, if nothing else, deserves a monument from the lawyers and the people. Who that knew him well, has not heard him quote those celebrated words of Edmund Burke: *I will forever, and at all hazards, assert the dignity, independence and integrity of the English bar, without which impartial justice, the most sacred guarantee of British liberty, can have no existence."

John F. Sale. The name of Ed. Yerger conjures up the name and form of that other inseparable companion, and true genius, John F. Sale. John F. Sale was born in Union county, Ky., December 29, 1822. He was given a school education, studied law and was admitted to the bar at Morganfield, Ky. In his twenty-third year he married Miss Anna B. Johnson, and in 1846 he moved to Memphis. In 1855 he was elected attorney-general for this district and served four years. In 1859 he was defeated for the same office by the shrewdest and most popular man at the bar by only about a dozen votes. From that time forth, until his death, on the 16th of November, 1872, he devoted himself almost exclusively to the criminal practice, and was known throughout this and adjoining States as one of the most adroit and powerful criminal lawyers at the bar. There was scarcely an important case from 1850 till his death, in which he was not engaged. Of the most noted of these were the Bolton case before the war, and the Dickens and Graves and Poston cases since. He was the last of that brightest coterie of legal minds, Brown, King, Yerger and Sale, which' for twenty years and more made the Memphis bar famous in criminal polemics. He was more than six feet in height, well proportioned, dark hair and eyes, fine head indicating more power than of refinement. His face was the broad mirror of his character. A notice of him at his death, written by Colonel M. C. Galloway, portrayed him so well, it is here partly given: 'John F. Sale was great in his frivolities, great in his burlesque,

A A PME N oom o orator, the great blackguard, the great companion, the great friend, the great worshiper of ladies, the great spendthrift. In nothing was he little. He excelled in everything. While speaking in almost alternate sentences he could make the transit from 'grave to gay, from lively to severe.' He could make a speech abounding in the loftiest statesmanship, philosophy or metaphysics, and then suddenly deal in abuse, either chaste, classic or vulgar as the emergency required. His wit was bright and sparkling as a diamond; his sarcasm keen, sharp and pungent; his irony was caustic and biting; his ridicule was chafing, withering, overwhelming, and when the exigency required it, he could, by his abuse, granulate his victim into mincemeat. His intelléctual display, whether . speaking, writing, or in private conversation, was that of a Titan tumbling down massive fragments of originality. He always produced a splash and a foam as he launched into the stream of other men's thoughts, his bright, fresh and unique ideas" He was the most original in thought and simile of any member of the bar. "Why, gentlemen of the jury," he once said, "the opposing counsel has the most fertile brain and imagination of the universe; give him a leather shoestring and he will make a whole tanyard out of it."

He and Ed. Yerger were for a number of years inseparable. It was.an unusual sight to see one upon the street without the other. They walked together, talked together, drank together, and had almost one purse in common. They were often employed together in defence of same defendant, and it was a sturdy jury indeed that could withstand the strategy and the force of one, and the learning and eloquence of the other.

"T see him now, as oft we saw him stand, Majestic in his form, his soul more grand, What eloquence and wit alternate blazed, "Till jurors wept, and judges sat amazed, While guilt and meanness sifted through and through, Quailed to the lash his fiery vengence threw,

When the war came on, the bar of Shelby county were the first to the front. Kit Williams went in the full bud of ripening greatness, and fell in the first battle, Shiloh, with all his blushing honors thick upon him. Thomas W. Preston went and fell at the same time. Turley gave one son, Wright gave two, following them to the field himself, and one came not back. McKisick, Morgan, Bankhead, Beard, Hammond, Scott, Hume, Finly, Stovall, Frayser, Beecher,. Logwood and many others of the Memphis bar made gallant soldiers, and rose to high rank.

Provenance

Text from History of the City of Memphis and Shelby County Tennessee, published 1888, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.