Memphis, Tennessee - Standard History of Memphis, Tennessee, from a Study of the Original S (part 4 of 13)
From Standard History of Memphis, Tennessee, from a Study of the Original Sources, published 1912. 15,996 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,996 wordsMachine-read from scans of Standard History of Memphis, Tennessee, from a Study of the Original Sources, published 1912. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Wednesday night the mob was out again. Seeing Mr. M. C. Gallaway, editor of the Avalanche, a paper Southern in its sympathies, some of the men tried to lift him to their shoulders and persuade him to lead the mob to the office of the Post, a republican paper, and demolish that office. He refused and appealed to the men not to attempt such a thing, trying to make them comprehend how harmful such a proceeding would be. Mr. Gallaway afterward testified that he did not know a man in the mob. After the crowd left him they shot at two negroes. The colored population was very scarce that night, the mass of them being secreted by white people in their homes. A striking fact connected with this riot was that of the two thousand or more ex-Confederate veterans resident in the city, not one raised his hand against the negroes but, in hundreds of instances, sheltered them in their homes.
This riot, like other occurrences in Southern cities during that strained period of "reconstruction" was the outcome of extreme prejudice on both sides. It was disgraceful in itself, as all passionate revolutions are, but did not brand all Memphis people, as was claimed by some papers and political parties. At the time of its outbreak there was extreme antagonism between the negroes and a large element of white people, especially the Irish laboring class, who have never been known
*This description is taken from the testimony of Major D. Upman, a United States officer and strong Union man; Dr. S. J. Quimby, a five months' resident of Memphis, from Center Harbor, Mich., who served in the Union army from 1862 to the close, part of the time commanding colored troops; and others.
to affiliate with people of an inferior race. From one-half to two-thirdst of the' better class of white men were disfranchised, so that the men in political power were largely from the inferior class of society, such officers frequently being unequal to their duties and not men who would have been selected by the two thousand or more disfranchised Confederate officers and soldiers living in Memphis at the time.
The Memphis police force in 1866 comprised 180 men, of these 167 being Irish, 8 American and 5 of unknown nationality. The firemen in April and May, 1866, numbered 46, of whom 42 were foreign born, 3 Americans and one unknown. As this was the official material the sheriff and mayor had for their posses, the futility of their efforts can be understood. It was much like taking a troop of lions to guard a herd of unruly cattle.
Mr. G. S. Shanklin, member of the Select Committee, afterward selected by Congress to investigate the Memphis riots, said: "It is most conclusively shown by all the testimony in this investigation that this mob was exclusively composed of the police, firemen, rowdy and rabble population of the city of Memphis, the greater part of whom are voters in the city of Memphis, under the franchise law of the State of Tennessee, enacted by what is known and called the 'radical Brownlow party,' and intended to disfranchise all persons in that State, who had in any manner aided, encouraged or abetted the late rebellion, and thereby place the political and civil power of the State in the hands of and under the control of those they call true loyal men."
The mayor and sheriff have been harshly criticised for not quelling the riots, and even accused of abetting it, but both these officers tried to get the cooperation of the military in restoring order on the first day. At the breaking out of the riots Tuesday afternoon. May 1, Sheriff Winters appealed to Major-General Stoneman for troops but that officer refused aid, saying that he wished to see if the city could govern herself and stop disturbances, as Southern people had boasted she could, if the United States troops were removed. The
' ' General : There is an uneasiness in the public mind, growing out of the occurrences of today, which would be materially calmed if there was an assurance of military cooperation with the civil police in suppressing all disturbances of the public peace. I should be happy to have it iu my power to give this assurance at once. It would intimidate the lawless, and serve to allay the apprehensions of the orderly. I therefore request that you will order a force of, say, two hundred men, commanded by discreet officers, to be held ready to cooperate with the constabulary force of the citj'' in case of any further continued lawlessness.
"Dear Sir: - I am in receipt of yours of this instant. In reply I have the honor to inform you that the small force of regular infantry stationed at this post, in all not more than one hundred and fifty strong, will be directed to hold itself in readiness to cooperate with the civil authorities of Memphis in 'case of further continued lawlessness.' This force is in camp at the fort, where you can communicate with the commanding officer in case you shall find that you need his assistance and support. I should prefer that the troops be called upon only in case of an extreme necessity, of which you must be the judge.
Two days later. May 3, some Memphis citizens had a meeting at the courthouse, after which this letter and resolutions were sent to Major-General Stoneman: the following resolutions which passed unanimously, and to request from you your cooperation in any measures that may be taken in pursuance thereof,
R. C. Brinkley." ^^Resolutio7is. ''Resolved, That the mayor of the city and the sheriff of the county together with the chairman of this meeting, (W. B. Greenlaw,) be authorized to summon a force of citizens of sufficient number to act in connection with the military, which shall constitute a patrol for the protection of the city, to serve such time as the mayor, sheriff, and chairman of the meeting shall direct.
"Resolved, That the chairman, (W. B. Greenlaw,) J. H. McMahan, S. P. Walker and R. C. Brinkley, be requested to wait upon General Stoneman and inform him of the proceedings of this meeting.
In his testimony afterward taken by the Select Committee, appointed by Congress to investigate the riots. General Stoneman said, "When this resolution was transmitted to me, I told them I had determined to take the thing into my own hands, and that I should have to set all civil government aside."
"Gentlemen: Circumstances compel the undersigned to interfere with civil affairs in the city of Memphis. It is forbidden for any person, without the authority from these headquarters, to assemble together any posse, armed or unarmed, white or colored. This does not include the police force of
General Stoneman seemed to be somewhat vindictive in his conduct. In his testimony he said that Union officers were not welcome in Memphis society and that Southern people were less loyal than they had been six months previous to that time. He also complained that they were ever ready to cheer "Dixie" and to hiss "Yankee Doodle," and that the only flags to be seen in the city were the one at his headquarters, one at the Freedmen's Bureau and one in front of the Republican paper, the Post. He sent word to the manager of the theatre that he would interfere if national airs were again hissed. He showed little understanding of human nature in condemning a feeling that had been part of the nature of Southern people for over four years and he seemed not to comprehend that it had taken just such treatment to make Southern people "less loyal than they had been six months before."
"No city in the Mississippi Valley can claim a more intelligent cultivated and refined society, or more active and efficient business men can be found, than in the city of Memphis. The growth of the city is rapid, the masses of the population are industrious, orderly and moral, and with these classes the sentiment of condemnation of the riot is universal; then why should they suffer reproach or condemnation? They were deprived by the law, in the enactment of which most of them had no voice, civil or legal power; they had but recently emerged from military control and government. The military was then present for the purpose of aiding in the enforcement of the law and preventing disorder; and whilst they in a large body offered their services to General Stoneman, and to be under his control, and such officers as he might appoint over them, to aid in suppressing the mob, these proffered services having been declined by General Stoneman, it is fair to pre-
The outlook for Memphis was not promising. Leaders of the government misunderstood conditions in the South, were unable to grasp them or felt only rancor toward ex-Confederates. The best material of Southern citizenship, - the men who were capable of the best feeling, best reasoning and judgment, and who, since they knew the cause they had fought and suffered for to be lost, were the sort to look the inevitable in the face and go to work on new lines to readjust affairs to suit the changed conditions, were, according to the law, placed lower than the ignorant, the childish and rabble material of the community. James Ford Rhodes, writing of this period, says: "It may be affirmed with confidence that there was nothing in the condition of the South which required the stringent military rule provided for in the Reconstruction acts."
All Northern men were not in sympathy with these "stringent" measures, and Mr. Rhodes quotes Governor Andrews of Massachusetts as saying: "The true question is now, not of past disloyalty, but of present loyal purpose," to which he himself adds : ' ' On the practical question of loyalty the Southern men were sound."
Abraham Lincoln must have realized the state of disruption that would be brought about by the mismanagement of reconstruction when he said in his last public speech, April 1, 1865, "We shall sooner have the fowl by hatching the egg than by smashing it." This just man also said: "We can't undertake state governments in all these Southern states. Their people must do that, though I reckon that at first they may do it badly."
Insults to Confederate soldiers continued at intervals but, as inharmony is not the true and God-given state of man, it cannot always last, and adjustment was slowly asserting itself. In June of this chaotic year of the riots and other race and political disturbances, it was decided that all criminal cases in which negroes were parties were to be turned over to the civil authorities of Memphis, and these officers were also
But the Bureau was only dying, not dead. On the thirteenth of this month Brigadier-General Runkle, who was in charge of Bureau affairs at Memphis, issued an order that "all contracts with negroes must be registered and approved by the Freedmen's Bureau, otherwise they would have no binding force."*
This order retarded adjustment between the races and was the indirect cause of more bad feeling. The police of the city were organized into a force that amounted to militia and they and the citizens became very antagonistic. Later, officers and police became implicated in crimes that brought them into even more disrepute. The unscrupulous among these men used, so far as possible, the power given them by the "Brownlow radical administration." The commissionert was charged with "forgery, bribery and robbery, and with two of his detectives,$ was placed under bonds, and the grand jury found two bills against them,"ยง but this case, with others against the "radicals" could not be sustained, especially after November, when the Legislature passed an act "disqualifying and prohibiting all Confederate soldiers and sympathizers serving as jurors. "I [
The "radicals," "carpet-baggers," or "scalawags," as they were variously called, usually narrow and fanatical, could not grasp the true status, and so Southern respectability was forced into the background while those in charge officially had full sway. They succeeded in getting the entire country into a muddle, deeper into debt and filling their own pockets. Again quoting Mr. Rhodes: "Military government at the South may be described as possessing all powers and no responsibilities."
John Park was continuously elected mayor of Memphis until after the war and when the conflict came to an end he remained in office a year longer than his expired term, owing to the fact that no election was held that year. On October 15, 1866, W. 0. Lofland was elected to the office for two years, that time being determined the following year, 1867, by the Legislature for the term of mayor's office.
"From mouth of Wolf River to Brinkley Street, thence east to Mosely Avenue, thence south to old Raleigh road, thence east to Brinkley Avenue, thence south to its termination, thence to Dunlap Street, thence to west boundary of Elmwood Cemetery, thence to Walker Avenue, thence west to Bayou Gayoso, thence to Gaines Street, thence by this street to Mississippi River, thence by the river to the beginning. The added territory to compose the Ninth and Tenth wards, Madison Street dividing them."*
The city debt was all this while increasing enormously. The papers tried to make the people realize the seriousness and detriment to the city of this debt, but affairs were in too much turmoil generally and too much distrust was abroad for matters to be set straight or even attempted by the people then. However, this very state of affairs was waking citizens to more determination to get the city government into their own hands, and some of the state senators and representatives were beginning to work to the end of placing the people in power over the State.
President Johnson, with all of his erratic behavior and unpopularity was at this time doing what he could to lift the white man's burden in the South. In Memphis he became as popular as he had been unpopular, and a mass meeting was held in Court Square, where his new policy of restoration was publicly sanctioned and delegates elected to a convention that was to be held in Philadelphia for the purpose of uniting in a "National Union Party," all in favor of the President's policy. Forty-one Democratic members of Congress signed an address to the people of the United States, approving the call of this convention, the aim of which was to bring harmony to the distracted country. These signers endorsed all of its principles, Southerners accepting much that was distasteful and even humiliating, for the sake of bringing about a more livable condition of government in their land.
This National convention, held in June, helped to break down the barrier between the sections and gave a blow to the rabid radicalism which was threatening even the Constitution.
Soon after this Memphis gave her first public greeting to a Union soldier, - General Frank P. Blair. He was cordially received by the mayor and aldermen and was warmly greeted as he arose to address the people.
Confederate soldiers, who had so long remained silent, began to show interest in aifairs and when General Blair again visited the city they gave him a hearty welcome and General Forrest this time introduced him to an audience.
Colonel Keating says of these pacifying events, "The ice was at last broken. Brownlow and his Legislature were no longer to have things their own way."
But this change for the better was only beginning. Continued night stealing, burning and other depredations by negroes was rarely punished, which gave them more and more a sense of license and insolence, and had become such a nuisance and even terror that strategy was resorted to by men who understood their superstitious natures. A secret order for frightening them into their homes at night was formed and became known as the Ku Klux Klan.
The object of the organizers of this order was to bring tranquility and safety to the community, nor was their method new, though their particular klan was. Numerous such orders have come down to us through history, notably the Nihilists of Russia, Alumbrados of Spain and other orders organized for religious freedom.
The Ku Klux Klan was secretly and mysteriously conducted and its members could not be caught. These men would ride about the country at night in fantastic garb, pretending to be the spirits of departed Confederate soldiers, come back to avenge outrages on their people. Some of them had a method of seeming to elongate themselves and others had concealed bags into which they would empty one or more buckets of water, seeming to the astonished onlookers to be drinking it. Soon the colored population could not be induced to leave their houses at night and some white people were quite as much afraid.
'* Whatever may be the judgment of history, those who know the facts will ever remain firm in the conviction that the Ku Klux Klan was of immense service at this period of Southern history. Without it, in many sections of the South, life to decent people would not have been tolerable. It served a good purpose. Wherever the Ku Klux appeared the effect was salutary. For a while the robberies ceased. The lawless class assumed the habits of good behavior."
After the Klan has achieved its purpose it went out of existence in 1869, and its members ceased their self-imposed discipline. The Ku Klux Klan has often been maligned and men were arrested, after the order had disbanded, for misconduct done under the guise of the former Klan. Lester and Wilson say of this: "No single instance occurred of the arrest of a masked man who proved to be - when stripped of his disguises - a Ku Klux."
At a Ku Klux convention held in Nashville in 1867, where numerous and prominent Memphis men were in attendance, their principles were thus stated :
(1) To protect the weak, the innocent and the defenseless, from the indignities, wrongs and outrages of the lawless, the violent and the brutal ; to relieve the injured and the oppressed ; to succor the suffering, and especially the widows and orphans of Confederate soldiers.
(2) To protect and defend the Constitution of the United States, and all laws passed in conformity thereto, and to protect the States and people thereof from all invasion from any source whatever.
(3) To aid and assist in the execution of all constitutional laws, and to protect the people from unlawful seizure, and from trial except by their peers in conformity to the laws of the land.
Instead of having treasonable designs, as had been preferred against them, their creed is additional proof of fidelity to the United States.
We, the order of the * * * ^ reverentially acknowledge the majesty and supremacy of the Divine Being, and recognize the goodness and providence of the same. And we recognize our relation to the United States Government, the supremacy of the Constitution, the Constitutional laws thereof, and the Union of States thereunder.
But behind it all was a determined purpose to rid the "reconstructed" Southern States of carpet-bag government and misrule, and this was ultimately accomplished.
The last of this decade of the sixties, with its war effects, was as disastrous for Memphis as the war itself. Municipal and financial affairs were in deplorable condition, an epidemic of yellow fever in 1867 claimed 550 victims and several big fires added to the stress of losses already experienced.
Each year seemed to strengthen affairs a little and better feeling between Northerners and Southerners was making its way. Carpet-bag rule was weakened and the South was beginning to stand up again. By 1870 all her states had been readmitted to the Union and she was avowedly and really ready to take her part in the welfare of the common country.
The year 1870 started with John W. Leftwich as mayor, he having succeeded W. 0. Lofland. In that year the Memphis board of rulers was changed from that of "Mayor and Aldermen" to "Mayor, Board of Aldermen and Board of Common Councilmen, " all these together denominated the General Council. Each ward was entitled to one alderman, elected for two years, and two councilmen, elected for one year. The city boundaries were also reduced at this time thus :
Beginning at a point on the west line of the State of Tennessee, where the center of Kerr Street, produced, would strike the Mississippi River; thence eastward on a line with the center of Kerr Street, if extended, would strike the town reserve ; thence southward, along the said east line of the town reserve, to the middle of the old Raleigh road, or Johnson's Avenue ; thence eastward along the middle of the old Raleigh road to a point where the center line of Dunlap Street, produced, northward, would intersect the same ; thence southward along the said produced line, and the middle line of Dunlap Street to the middle of Union Avenue ; thence westward along the middle of Union Avenue to the middle of Walnut Street ; thence southward along the middle of Walnut Street to the middle of the old Fort Pickering Railroad; thence westward along the middle of the old Fort Pickering Railroad, or Broadway, to the middle of Bayou Gayoso ; thence southward, up said bayou, and along the middle of the same, to Jackson Street ; thence along the middle of Jackson Street and the prolongation of said street, to the west line of the State of Tennessee; thence northward with the west line of the State of Tennessee to the beginning.
In January of 1870 John Johnson was elected mayor of the city and served two terms, or four years. The Federal census of this year gave Memphis a population of 40,226. Of this number 24,755 were white ; 15,471, colored ; 6,780, foreign ; 3,371, Irish; 2,144, German.f
This showed an increase of nearly 18,000, although the Ninth and Tenth wards had been taken from the corporation. This official census encouraged the people as it proved that the town was at least active and they trusted to its becoming sane and harmonious soon.
"Reconstruction," so called, was ended in Tennessee and although carpet-bag rule had depleted Memphis, the people felt relieved, took heart and hoped to do their little part in the working out of the Nation's welfare.
The Charter Amendment provided that day and night police, exclusive of the chief, should consist of one policeman to every 1,000 inhabitants under the Federal census. The Board of Commissioners were to elect the chief of the Fire Department, and to adopt rules of discipline, which they required the chief to enforce. There were to be enough firemen to manage all the equipment and to extinguish fires, but no more, and they were also to be employed by the Commissioners.
Municipal enterprise was going forward. "Work was being done on the streets and the Popular Street turnpike was nearing completion. Two railroads that had been discussed and agitated in former years were begun, - one to Selma, Alabama, and the other to Paducah, Kentucky.
The new mayor was much handicapped by the condition in which he found affairs. In his first report he stated that the city was "without a dollar of cash in her treasury and her credit so impaired that she was really paying at least two prices for all services rendered, or supplies purchased; her bonds, authorized to be issued to fund due outstanding indebtedness, having been and being disposed of by her own officefs at less than fifty cents on the dollar to pay current expenses; and though ostensibly the pay of the city employees and supplies obtained were at cash rates, yet, by allowances thereon in various ways, and for heavy interest on loans, and fabulous discount on bonds sold, the cost to the city was eventually more than double the amount nominally paid. Her floating debt.
then over $600,000 in excess of all assets applicable for its liquidation, was being increased in the ratio of 100 to 65, by being exchanged for her own six per cent bonds, so that, in taking up $65 of debt in one shape, she issued to the fortunate holders thereof, $100 in a much better form. The floating debt at that date being, in round numbers about $1,200,000, with assets applicable to its reduction to only half that amount, and that inequality between debt and means continuously and rapidly increasing, it must be obvious to any one who will impartially examine this matter, that this pretense of merely taking up floating indebtedness by issuance of six per cent bonds when in the exchange there was really so great an increase, would, by a continuance of the system (the city's credit rapidly depreciating as her necessities increased) soon have led to financial ruin and actual bankruptcy."
Mr. Johnson considered this state of affairs appalling, as well he might, and proposed that the city be run on a cash basis until finances were in better condition, but the people did not join with him and he was "hampered and hindered by ward politicians, "t
$500,000 more of bonds were issued for funding purposes. Taxes were high but debt increased and poor management was fast hurrying Memphis to bankruptcy and humiliation. Distrust was felt on all sides and the mayor himself was charged with fraud in regard to "the payment of some Memphis coupons in the hands of the state, "$ but he was exonerated by Mr. William M. Farrington, president of the Union & Planters Bank, in a manner so satisfactory to the public that he was reelected mayor at the next municipal election.
Crimes were so numerous during this time that many arrests were made and it became necessary to hold so many criminals that in August of 1871 Judge Flippin lectured on the state of affairs and warned those in charge of the jail to be vigorous "in preventing criminals from escaping and mur-
The levy of taxes became so heavy that citizens protested strongly, even appealed to the Supreme Court and Legislature for redress, but the Supreme Court sustained the city government and declared their legislation constitutional. But even the excessive taxes could not meet expenses and suits were brought against the city for debts. One contractor brought suit for $448,000, for Nicholson pavement, and obtained judgment.*
In the midst of her own troubles news came to Memphis of the terrible Chicago fire and she raised over $50,000 for the benefit of the thousands made homeless by that catastrophe. Little did she think then that the sufferers from that great conflagration would, in a few years, be called upon to help her own stricken people.
"While this burden of excessive taxes was being borne by the people, who were striving to build up their unfortunate city, the fact was published by the grand jury that the County Court had not been spending as much for public improvements as the city and county had been charged for. The tax-collector was declared to be a defaulter to the amount of $100,0{)0 and the amount was afterwards found to be three times that sum.
When their officials could not be trusted the people knew their troubles were not decreasing. While they were taxed beyond the rates of larger cities, still municipal affairs were woefully neglected. The streets were in poor condition, filth was allowed to accumulate in yards, alleys and even streets, and sewerage was scarcely regarded at all. As effect is sure to follow cause, Memphis paid the penalty for this neglect.
The beginning of 1873 seemed to point to an unraveling of municipal tangles and to city prosperity, but plans of men are as naught when Nature punishes. It is then that we realize that merely human existence is very uncertain, and that to be well in this span of life we must regard the laws of decency and right as pointed out to us by Mother Nature herself. The unsanitary conditions of Memphis, the foul air that had been
As the last decade had been one of war and poorly managed reconstruction, this one seemed to be destined for one of pestilence. Before the winter of early 1'873 was over small-pox laid seize to the city; in June and July it was followed by a "malignant type of Asiatic cholera,"* and in August came yellow fever.
When yellow fever was pronounced epidemic, September 14,t the people were terror-stricken and in a very short while the population was reduced to 25,000, and many of these left later. Business of course was almost entirely suspended, the law of self-preservation usurping all other interests. Of those left 4,204 were stricken with the disease, of which number 1,244 died.l
Memphis was in poor condition to care for an epidemic, but a Citizens' Executive Committee was organized and they set valiantly to work to care for the stricken, soliciting aid from abroad. All the states responded to this call and several European countries sent large subscriptions. The Howard Association, which had been formed for the especial purpose of aiding yellow fever epidemics, called its forces together the day after the announcement of the epidemic. Only eight of its original members responded to the roll-call, but more joined the association and they were soon engaged in their noble work. The eight members on hand when the meeting was called were : J. G. Lonsdale, Sr., Dr. P. P. Frame, A. D. Langstaff, W. J. B. Lonsdale, J. P. Robertson, E. J. Mansford, A. G. Raymond and Fred Gutherz. The new members were: W. J. Smith, J. J. Murphy, B. P. Anderson, J. G. Simpson, W. P. Wilson, G. W. Gordon, J. H. Smith, E. B. Foster, A. E. Frankland, W. S. Rogers, W. A. Holt, F. F. Bowen, J. F. Porter, R. T. Halstead, T. R. Waring, S. W. Rhode, W. J. Lemon, W. G. Barth, L.
JDowell gives these figures as the nearest estimate, not including those that died before September 14, and after November 9, although there were deaths both before and after those dates, but no official record was kept of them.
Seibeck, J. E. Lanphier, J. H. Edmondson, John Johnston (attorney), J. W. Cooper, F. A. Tyler, Jr., C. A. Laffingwell, H. D. Connell, P. W. Semmes, D. E. Brettenum and D. B. Graham.* They only had $130 in the treasury but their call for aid was quickly responded to by contributions of money, clothing and provisions of all sorts from all over the country.
Several physicians who had had experience with the disease came to the city and many other helpers came at the call of distress. Besides the workers of the Howard Association and the Citizens' Committee, the Odd Fellows, Masons, priests and sisters of the Catholic church, and others volunteered service, and contributions from Protestant, Catholic and Jewish churches, from the secret organizations, trade organizations, police, firemen, city, county. State and all states, came pouring in. Ministers of all denominations could be seen among the patients, some having come from afar to take part in allaying the suffering. All feelings between the North and the South were forgotten and "carpet-baggers," "scalawags," foreigners, - all classes and nationalities thought only of the suffering and became brothers.
"Women of station in society joined in the work and often beside them and the religious workers, would toil a former "outcast," tending the needs of patients, closing the eyes that were blind to earthly scenes, or otherwise assisting in their self-sacrificing and volunteer work for others. Many of these unselfish ones laid their lives on the altar of sacrifice, perhaps after bringing to convalescence many others.
When, in November, the epidemic was declared to be a horrer of the past, the General Council passed resolutions of thanks to all the states and countries that had sent succor during the disheartening seige.
When the year ended confidence had been regained and 1874 showed noteworthy increase in business improvements, but the city government was still a cause of complaint. A writer in "Old Folks Record" in 1874, said: "We need legislative reform. Our city government should be simplified. As it is, too many members of our city legislature have axes to grind, and they are ground at the expense of their fellow citizens." This writer advocated one tax-collector instead of four or five, and continued: "We could dispense with some of our courts and incidental expenses. We could reform our jury system, and in this particular save thousands of dollars.
The city's monthly outlay at that time was said to exceed $35,000, much more than the depleted and debt-encumbered corporation could afford. Taxes continued to be a great burden and for 1873 amounted to $4.00 on the $100, on a tax valuation of $28,217,000, and in addition to this extortionate levy, the mayor was demanding the collection of $977,000 of back taxes. For this purpose the General Council issued distress warrants, after the United States court had issued a writ of mandamus against the city for $514,900, for the Nicholson pavement contractor before mentioned.
Crime still stalked through the town, but the officers had grown very determined and were doing what they could to lessen its evils by enforcing strict laws against carrying concealed weapons and bringing all criminals to justice. Judge Flippin again lectured to the city and appealed to the sense of civic pride and right in the citizens to do all in their power to eradicate crime and build up poor Memphis, who had had many terrible experiences to hold her back on the road to progress.
Confidence between the white people and negroes was gaining ground and the latter had learned to a great extent that their former owners were not enemies, though many of them had never thought so. Occasional riots were threatened and a serious one in 1874 occurred in Gibson County in which several negroes were killed.
Memphis people held a mass meeting to denounce this affair and try to establish harmony, especially now that the state had returned to Democratic government and conditions generally had improved or, at least were improving, in the South. At this meeting were many former Confederate soldiers and some of the speakers were ex-President Jefferson Davis, Isham G. Harris and General Forrest.
John Loagiie, Mayor. Financial Difficulties. Census of 1875. New Charter. The Flippin Administration. Schemes to Retire City Debt. Sale of Navy Yard. Surrender of Charter Considered. Great Epidemic of Yellow Fever Begins. Panic and Stampede of Citizens. Terrible Scenes of Suffering and Death. Howard Association and Relief Committees. Heroism of the Workers. The Tragedy of Death and Burial. The Daily Press Faithful. Generosity of Non-Residents. Loyal Negro Militia. Death Roll of the Howards. End of the Epidemic. Thanksgiving for Relief.
^d OHN LOAGUE, who had succeeded John Johnson as ^1 mayor, was a good financier and his most earnest work ^^ in his new office was to reduce Memphis' debt and the overwhelming burden of her taxes. In his first message to the General Council he set forth in plain figures the enormity of the debt which was crushing the town. In a second message he questioned the legality of some of the bonds and thought the courts could not force Memphis to pay more than she had received from them, which would be about forty-two per cent. A few months later this determined mayor issued another message in which he "urged the appointment of a commission of eminent citizens to unite with the creditors of the city in a convention to consider the debt and agree and determine upon a plan by which it might be refunded at a rate, below its face value, that would bring it within the reach of the city to pay."* This plan was agreed upon and Mayor Loague recommended G. A. Hanson, I. M. Hill, E. M. Apperson, P. C. Bethel, J. M. Keating and A. J. Keller for such commissioners. They were appointed by the General Council and given power to act.
The total debt of the city amounted to $5,651,165.* These commissioners went to New York to consult some of the creditors, but failed to get them to agree to anything less than the face value of the bonds. This failure was discouraging but the mayor set to work to use strenuous means to lessen the city's burdens. After much controversy by and between the General Council, even sometimes almost to the point of combat, it is recorded, Mr. Loague was authorized "to issue scrip for the certificates held by the tax-payers who had paid the Nicholson pavement tax. "f
Financial difficulties of the Nation coming on at this time, the Memphis officials found their task of straightening out home affairs all the more perplexing. Of the Country 's trials during this decade James Ford Rhodes says: "These five years [1873- 1878] are a long dismal tale of declining markets, exhaustion of capital, a lowering in value of all kinds of property, including real estate, constant bankruptcies, close economy in business and grinding frugality in living, idle mills, furnaces and factories, former profit-earning iron mills reduced to the value of a scrap-heap, laborers out of employment, reductions of wages, strikes and lockouts, the great railroad riots of 1877, suffering of the unemployed, depression and despair. "$
Financial complications occupied the General Council at the expense of other city needs, but some attention was paid to sanitation. The neighborhood where yellow fever had started in 1873 was cleaned up and the Board of Health exerted itself in various directions.
The County Court, despite the County's financial misfortunes, purchased the old Overton Hotel for a courthouse and voted $20,000 for the building of a new insane asylum, to be conducted upon more thoughtful and humane methods than formerly.
of only four in five years, the smallest gain Memphis had ever made in any other five or even one year since her beginning. Had it not been for the disastrous epidemic of 1873 the city would no doubt have grown as she had heretofore, and as her physical situation indicated that she should. But sickness, war, misgovernment, abnormal taxes, debt, had discouraged the people and they were not as alert and energetic as they should have been. After the experience of 1873 the place should have been put in thorough sanitary condition, but as one summer passed after another and the fever did not return, premises, alleys, vacant lots and other localities became unclean and general neglect grew from bad to worse with only an occasional spurt of activity on the part of the Board of Health.
Memphis seemed to be rushing pell-mell into ruin from many causes. Property-holders were growing or had grown indignant at the looseness of municipal management and were beginning to assert themselves through the public press and otherwise. Most of the office-holders were not tax-payers and the majority of the voters owned no property. These, it was claimed, thought more of personal gain than of the city's good. The rent derived from property in many cases did not pay taxes, repairs and insurance. In consequence, persons not already property-holders, preferred renting to investing their money in Memphis real-estate. Manufacturers were drive q away and no inducements were held out to others to come. Few buildings were erected and mechanics were idle or left the city. Capital and labor both suffered as one necessarily affects the other.
Citizens came to the conclusion that if the city was in such a deplorable condition under existing circumstances, surely a change was needed. A people's Protective Union was formed, and the members recommended reforms for the city government, affecting such items as taxes and their collection, salaries and fees of city officials, juries and jury-service, vagrancy, the establishment of a reformatory prison and other needs.
The new charter contained some reforms. For instance, a Board of Fire and Police Commissioners were to govern and control the police and fire departments and the members were prevented from taking any part, as formerly, in politics, more than casting votes at elections. It limited the city tax to $1.60 and prevented city officials from having any interest in city bonds.
This revised charter was approved by Mayor Loague but opposed by the Council, and brought up lively controversies. City Attorney G. A. Hanson and Comptroller Newsom did not agree in their figures as to the city's indebtedness. Hanson reported the debt to be $6,500,000 in round numbers, with an interest of $390,000, while Newsom reported it to be $5,522,362.22, against which he said were assets amounting to $1,675,208.39. The Council was opposed to Attorney Hanson and a committee, appointed by it, endorsed NeAvsom's statement and disputed Hanson's, whereupon the latter resigned.
The People's Protective Union sent a request, through a committee, to the Council to employ a city attorney of high grade to handle efficiently the suits and mandamus proceedings that hovered as dark shadows over the city. Besides this request for the appointment of an able lawyer, the committee set forth the grievances of the people thus :
"The financial condition of the city of Memphis has reached a crisis, threatening wholesale confiscation, and the expulsion of the people from their homes, alarming to every citizen having the interest of the city at heart. The remorseless Shylocks who speculate in city bonds at twenty-one cents demand their payment dollar for dollar and expect by the writ of mandamus to override the law limiting the rate of taxation and compel the collection of a tax sufficient for its immediate payment. If this is the law, and it is to be enforced, it amounts to virtual confiscation, and the people, especially the poor, will be turned into the streets, and their humble homes, the fruit of years of hard toil and frugality, will pass for a mere song into the hands of greedy speculators in city bonds. It is well known that a large amount of the debt of the city is illegal, and was imposed upon a people having no voice in its creation through military rule and through the instrumentality of elections held in violation of law, and conducted in fraud and violence, while a large majority of tax-payers were disfranchised and denied the right of voting upon the very proposition to issue the bonds. In the election for the million dollar issue in 1868, some man who paid thousands of dollars of taxes annually, was driven from the polls with insult when he offered to vote against the issue of bonds. A large amount of the debt of the city has been created not only without authority, but in positive violation of law. Every dollar of the scrip issued by the military government, and subsequently funded, is illegal. * * * * Those who speculate in the life-blood of the city, and some who esteemed it no dishonor to neglect the payment of their private debts, prate about the honor and credit of the city, and insist upon the 'pound of flesh,' though the operation reduced the people to penury and serfdom to the bondholder. Such people talk of the innocent holder, as if none but bondholders were innocent, and the people a set of knaves, seeking to evade the payment of just debts. We proclaim and insist that the victimized and plundered people are the innocent parties, and the bondholders were bound to know of the fraud and outrage perpetrated upon a helpless people."
Mayor Loague appointed Judge Sam P. Walker to the position of city attorney, that able lawyer resigning the chancellorship to accept it. He took matters seriously in hand and won several suits that saved the city thousands of dollars. Mayor Loague, in his last report tendered to the city, showed how the expense of city government had lessened, and the mayor succeeding him, Judge John R. Flippin, and his new council, started in with determination for even stricter economy and reforms for bringing the city out of her difficulties. These new officials found affairs worse than Comptroller Newsom's report had led them to believe, and nearer the condition that ex-City Attorney Hanson had declared. Mayor Flippin in his first report gave the city a debt at $5,600,000, of which $600,000 was matured coupons bearing interest at the rate of- seven per cent. The annual interest of the city amounted to $350,000, while annual expenses were $300,000. In order to meet all the indebtedness for the year and payexpenses it would require $1,400,000, and the city was not equal to it.*
Mayor Flippin proposed "to retire all the debt over $5,000,000 by delinquent taxes; then from the gross sum deduct one third, leaving $3,333,333, fund this in $100 bonds due in 30 years, interest on them payable when drawn, as per schedule given. From these draw annually paying four per cent on numbers drawn, using not less than $140,000 for the last ten years."*
The mayor's plan was much discussed but was thought not feasible and was not adopted. Judge Flippin then went to New York for the purpose of making a settlement with the bond-holders. They agreed to scale at sixty cents on the dollar.
After this compromise the General Council authorized the mayor to prepare a bill for the next Legislature for the purpose of carrying it out.
The Navy Yard was sold during this administration, in 1876, to Amos Woodruff and J. J. McCombs for $117,000, they being allowed to give notes from date of purchase, bearing six per cent interest. This sale terminated long discussions and litigation which had cost Memphis $540,000. t
The Board, though running on economical lines, allowed a few civic improvements. The levee was repaired and added to. Main and Madison Streets were partly paved and numerous bridges were built throughout the city. But the population did not increase, those remaining grew poorer, taxes were extortionate without much to show for expenditures, property continually decreased in value, the funding of the big debt was discouragingly slow, the United States court mandamus writs had become urgent and city conditions were as bad as could be.
Mayor Flippin worked zealously trying to get rid of the city debt and carried on much correspondence with the bondholders and talked to them personally when possible, making trips to Charleston, Baltimore and New York for that purpose. By the close of 1877 he had succeeded in funding more than
Several meetings were held by the Chamber of Commerce and the Cotton Exchange to weigh affairs and try to bring about a solution and remedy. These meetings brought forth suggestions of dissolving the corporation of Memphis, and by consulting with able attorneys, Judges J. W. Clapp and H. T. Ellett, it was learned that "Public corporations are but part of the machinery employed by the sovereign power of the State for the purposes of government, and as they are created and exist only by law, they may be changed and destroyed by law." Also, "The city of Memphis, then, is but the creature of the Legislature, and though our State Constitution is peculiar in its provisions as to the creation and destruction of corporations, which may or may not include public corporations, yet its corporate franchises may, by proper legislation, be suspended or taken away; its corporate limits extended or curtailed ; its name changed, and its legal existence annihilated at the pleasure of the Legislature, and with or without the consent of its inhabitants."
To the questions of citizens as to the consequences ensuing from such dissolution, the attorneys responded that the city's "personal estate vests in this country in the people, and in England in the crown, and the debts due to and from the corporation are totally extinguished."
In such case franchises, they said, are taken from the corporation dissolved, still, "This rule has been repudiated as to private corporations in this state, and almost universally, and whilst the franchises of a corporation that has forfeited its charter are taken away, the existence of the corporation is prolonged by the statute until its debts are paid or its effects disposed of for the benefit of its creditors."
These lawyers gave much study to the questions in controversy and handed in quite an elaborate document, over their signatures, of the digested law. In continuation of the matter already quoted, they replied in part : existence, it can enact no law that impairs the obligation of any contract which the municipality has, by authority of law, entered into. * * * * Whilst the Legislature may abolish the charter of the city of Memphis, it cannot disannul its contracts, nor cancel its debts, nor can it deprive its creditors of the remedies to which they are entitled under their contracts. It may change the form of the remedy, and may, perhaps, substitute one less stringent and efficient, but unless a substantial remedy be left, it is apprehended the act would be held void by the courts. * * * * When a creditor deals with a municipal corporation, he knows that it is the creature of the legislative will and may therefore be presumed to take the risk of the repeal of the charter and the loss of his remedy as a part of the law of his contract. * * * * The municipal officers, who were such at the time of the passage of the act annulling the charter, might be judicially determined to be still in office and subject to the mandates of the courts as to the levy and collection of taxes for the purpose of paying the debts of the city. * * * * Were the city charter abolished, the Legislature, in the exercise of its unrestrained power of taxation, except as limited by the State Constitution, could, we presume, by special legislation for the territory now within the city limits adopt a plan of local taxation sufficient to meet the expenses incident to such public regulations as might be necessary for the protection of the persons and property of the inhabitants, and might, perhaps, if it chose to do so, levy a special tax upon such inhabitants, or upon their property and pursuits, for the purpose of providing a fund to pay off the indebtedness of the city at the time of the repeal of its charter."
After this answer was received and considered a committee consisting of W. P. Proudfit, F. S. Davis, J. W. Clapp, H. T. Ellett, B. Bayliss and D. P. Iladden, was appointed to formulate a plan of action in conformity therewith. The city attorney, S. P. Walker, was requested to draft a bill, which he did and presented at a meeting of the Chamber of Commerce, Cotton Exchange, citizens and officials. The caption of this bill gives its purport and is as follows:
"AN ACT to repeal the charter of certain municipal corporations, to remand the territory embraced within the corporate limits of such municipalities to the government of the county courts, to enlarge the powers of such county courts and to levy and dispose of special local taxes upon the persons and property located within the territorial limits of such municipalities. ' '
This bill was approved by three of the committee and many others, but the mayor and many with him, repudiated such a step on the part of the city. Men spoke for and against such action and on a vote being taken the bill was defeated by nearly two to one. This vote was reconsidered, however, and the committee instructed to have five hundred copies, together with the legal opinion of Judges Clapp and Ellett, printed and sent to the senators and representatives for their consideration. The bill was opposed in the Legislature and those members attempted to pass another bill appointing a receiver for Mempihs, but this failed, as the Governor did not sign it.
The General Council, most of whom were against dissolving the city government, passed resolutions opposing the bill. They were of the opinion that Mayor Flippin was handling the enormous debt problem efficiently and that with time, judicious perseverance would lift the incubus from Memphis.*
This by no means ended considerations of dissolving the charter and the subject continued to be agitated, especially after the United States court issued a peremptory order for the Nicholson pavement debt of $200,000 to be paid immediately, the money to be obtained by levying a special tax. This order aroused the people to frenzy. Indignation meetings were held and Major Minor Meriwether, representing the People's Protective Association, addressed the General Council, explaining how impossible it was for the people to meet this and other enormous demands. He urged a repeal of the charter as a necessity for getting city affairs settled and perhaps keeping the people from rebellion.
during which time it was decided to cut down the salaries of city employes from ten to twenty per cent, reduce salaries of school-teachers and take salaries entirely away from the Sinking Fund Commissioners.
Collection of back taxes was again agitated and the people wrangled and planned and blundered until the stealthy yellow enemy that had remained away five years, giving the city time to rid herself of dirt, came back in the midst of the financial confusion, political wrangles, dirty streets, filthy alleys, open vaults of putrefaction, stench, and said, "Stop your human chatter! After your sinful neclect of God's first law and a city's highest need, order and cleanliness, I claim this town as mine!"
Dr. R. W. Mitchell, president of the Board of Health, who had been urging and pleading for quarantine and appropriations for sanitary precautions, discouraged by failure to obtain any assistance from the General Council, resigned his position. When the first suspicious case of fever appeared in the city, the officials became alarmed, refused the resignation of Dr. Mitchell and agreed to meet his demands. The whole city went to work with feverish energy to clean up. Polities, debt, disagreements, amusements, business, - everything else gave way before fear and efforts to prevent an epidemic. It was too late !
Reports came daily from New Orleans and other places, showing a constant increase in the spread of the disease and mortality. Memphis people became excited. Quarantine restrictions were enforced and the Board of Health, that had so lately begged in vain for assistance and cooperation, now had their hands upheld by the General Council and the citizens. Merchants, who a short while before, had thought they could spare no money for anything, subscribed liberally to supply the means that the city lacked.
A steamboatman at the city hospital had a suspicious case of illness and on August 2, it was pronounced yellow fever. Other cases occurred but were kept suppressed until August 14, when an Italian snack-house keeper, Mrs. Bionda, was reported as having a well-defined case of the dread disease.
This caused general alarm and many sought safety in flight. The day after Mrs. Bionda's case twenty-two others were announced and panic ensued. On the following day, the sixteenth, thirty-three new cases were reported, and the people rushed from the city like mad. Fear, more contagious than the disease, possessed men and women, and the predominant impulse was to flee. Houses were not only left in haste, but many of them were left open, with silver-plate in dining-rooms, elegant rugs, curtains, pictures and other valuable furnishings forgotten and barely enough clothing taken to supply immediate needs, while the owners rushed for trains that could not supply all the demands. Seats, aisles, platforms and roofs of all cars were crowded and men who could not obtain entrance by doors climbed through car-windows, despite all protests from people in the packed seats. Courtesy was forgotten and often, even the common feelings of humanity. Self preservation reigned as law.
Policemen were stationed at trains to enforce order, but when men found their entrance to cars interfered with they eared not for law and order; they considered that life hung in the balance, and many obtained admittance for themselves and families by the use of fire-arms. The officers saw the futility of trying to keep people back and they, themselves in sympathy with the crowd, simply tried to keep order until the trains would push out. And push out they did, more packed than they had ever been before, as fast as managers could get them ready, though all too inadequate was the service.
Those who could not get away on trains left in carriages, buggies, wagons, vans, - even drays were pressed into passenger service, while others walked, not even knowing where they were going, their only object being to get away from the pestilence. Many w^ho would have gone could not because themselves or families were overtaken by the now striding plague. Some, however, were not even held by family ties and one of the saddest pictures, of the whole horrible time that we contemplate at this distant day is that of persons leaving relatives and friends to suffer and die unattended save by the noble strangers who stayed or came to help while others fled. It is recorded that even men left their wives and fathers their families and a few, away at the time of the stampede refused to come to afflicted wife or children or both. It is pitiful when narrow human nature supplants the nobler nature of man made in God's image, but when we do behold that Image, the contemplation exalts even human nature in our minds. Though there were a few deserters, we are told that no wife deserted her husband and, at a later time Governor Marks, in his address made at the laying of the corner-stone of the Memphis Custom House, said: ''In the history of the pestilence I read that parents deserted their children, children their parents, husbands wives, but that no wife deserted her husband. * * * * When you erect your monument to commenorate the heroes of the pestilence of 1878, in justice to the noble women of Memphis, let it be written upon that monument that 'Thermopylae had her deserter, but the wives of Memphis had none.' "
As the disease spread here other towns and cities became alarmed for their own safety and quarantine laws caused many Memphis refugees to be turned away, in some places even shot-guns being used to show the determination of the inhabitants. Many of these rejected and helpless safety-seekers camped in the woods, without necessary equipment for the crudest comforts, or later joined one of the camps provided for refugees.
By August 26, the rush from the city was over, though some still sought safety in unquarantined places. The panic being over, those left settled down to the inevitable. Business and traffic of course, were paralyzed, streets deserted, houses desolate, many standing open and none properly protected against dust or thieves. Politics, the $5,000,000 debt, inadequate or extortionate taxes, cries of people for improvements or justice, - these and all other things were forgotten, and only the alleviation of human suffering or the saving of human life was considered.
In one week the population had been reduced to 19,600, 14,000 of these being negroes. Of the less than 6,000 white people 4,204 died, and of the negroes 946 died. Up to the epidemic of this year colored people had been thought to be immune, and even then the purely African type usually escaped and when they had it the disease did not prove fatal. The hybrid part of the population was not so fortunate and many of them succumbed. About two hundred and fifty white people escaped the disease, most of these having had it in previous epidemics.
On the 17th of August the Citizens Relief Committee organized and itsi members were soon doing what they could to relieve the stricken, keep order and take systematic charge of all money and provisions sent to them. The Howard Association was called together and thes)e good men were soon hand in hand with the Relief Committee in their brave work.
Many people of this generation do not even know what the Howard Association was and it is but fair to devote a little space to them in passing. This organization originated in New Orleans in 1853, among the clerks of N. B. Kneass. The mother of two of these young men had been a resident of San Domingo where yellow fever was a common malady and she had learned to treat it successfully. When the epidemic afflicted New Orleans in 1853, these young men went about distributing the medicines prepared by this good woman, giving much relief, though that year claimed 7,970 victims in the Crescent City. Other young men joined these, some from wealthy families, and they organized under the name of the Howard Association, choosing the name of the greatest philanthropist, John Howard. As the Association grew, physicians, nurses and medicine were furnished by it and agencies were formed in all towns where there with liklihood of the yellow pest. The sole purpose of the association was to aid in this one disease and whenever it made its appearance Howard members assembled for work. In 1867 a call was made in Memphis for this association and members met to form a working order in the Bluff City. These first Memphis members were : R. "W. Ainslie, William Everett, H. Lonergan, John Heart, C. T. Geoghegan, J. K. Pritchard, A. D. Langstaff, J. B. Wasson, J. P. Gallagher, Jack Home, E. J. Mansford, John Park, Rev. R. A. Simpson, Dr. P. P. Fraime, J. P. Robertson, T. C.
As soon as these men were organized they notified the public that they were ready to furnish necessities, which they did as long as the fever lasted. When that year's pestilance was over the members adjourned, subject to call whenever yellow fever sufferers claimed their services again. A charter was not granted to the Memphis association until 1869.
As has been related, these self-sacrificing men were next called together for work in 1873, when the few members remaining responded, new members joined and they went to work.
The next call came in 1878, when, on the fourteenth day of August, the members again answered roll-call, added new names to the roll and, under the first vice-president, A. D. Langstaff, launched upon their duties, to face the worst epidemic the heroic men of any of the Howard associations had yet encountered. According to the Howard custom, the city was divided into districts and members assigned to each. Cases from each district were reported at headquarters, each investigated at once and the necessary supplies were furnished.
The first week after the fever started in Memphis in 1878, 1,500 were reported sick, ten dying every day. The second week registered 3,000 cases, with fifty deaths a day. The following week showed a still greater mortality, which continued to increase until the middle of September, when the average deaths per day were two hundred, with between 8,000 and 10,000 sick. September fourteenth was the day of greatest mortality, when considerable over two hundred deaths were reported.
The plague had a fearful hold and threatened to depopulate the town. As such stupendous increase came fear seized physicians and nurses, which caused them to succumb more easily to the disease than at first, and so their ranks were rapidly thinned. There were much uncertainty about methods. Some patients died under treatment that seemed to cure others. Doctors consulted, but there were many disagreements and much of the treatment was guess work or experiment, but they worked conscientiously and did the best they could.
Dr. Robert W. Mitchell, an experienced and scientific physician, had a corps of efficient workers under him and they had great success in treating the disease. Dr. G. B. Thornton, in charge of the City Hospital, was much overworked, as well as those who aided him. How those faithful hospital doctors and nurses did work, stopping only when the disease they were fighting claimed them for its own. Doctors, nurses, the organization workers, ministers, priests, church sisters and other volunteers worked, forgetting exhaustion and their own needs in trying to make up for the inadequacy of their forces.
By the last of August the workers were falling rapidly, some of them going until they fell prostrate. By the middle of September nineteen Howards were dead or sick. The noble President of the Association, Butler P. Anderson, who had frone to Grenada to help the sufferers there, had returned to Memphis, taken the fever and died. Mr. Langstaff was stricken and his place was filled by ex-Mayor John Johnson. Early in October only three officers of the Howard Association were on duty and many members of the other working orders were down or gone to rest after giving their lives for others.
The Citizens Relief Committee was conspicuous for its broadcast work, as were the Masons, Odd Fellows, Knights of Pythias, Knights of Honor, the Father Matthew Society, the Hebrew Hospital Association, the Typographical Union, Telegraphers, Southern Express Company, the railroad companies and many private volunteer workers, - physicians, nurses and ministers of all denominations.*
Poor and rich alike accepted the services of these laborers and indeed were at their mercy. The patients were no longer patrons, they were all the children of the relief societies and these organizations were supplied by the world.
*Out of ten members of the Odd Fellow<? Relief Committee by the sixth week of the epidemic only one was left, John A. Linkhauer, and he carried on the relief work alone.
Memphis seemed a doomed city. Her streets were deserted except for the nurses, doctors and occasional other pedestrians, and it has been said that even dogs, cats, rats and other animals became so oppressed by the general gloom that they left by hundreds. Many of course starved, as the few people left were so intent in their ministrations to human charges that they usually forgot the animals.
At midday the streets showeli life when negroes and some white people went to the relief headquarters for daily rations. When they were gone the death-like silence fell again and one man said his own footsteps on the pavement would sometimes startle him.
Doctors met at night for consultation and this put a bit of social refreshment into their overworked lives. Their days were ghastly enough with the moaning, dying and dead on every hand, the deserted, hot, dusty streets, the oppressive atmosphere, even worse than that of a battle-field after the battle, the sorrowful, hopeless faces of convalescents, bereft of whole families, perhaps, little children left orphans and penniless, who so lately had been blest with homes, with all that that word implies, - gloom, devastation, pall, - it was more terrible than any of the other discouraging experiences these heroic men and women had been through during the past two decades. Human life seemed so pitiful, so useless at times, and yet they worked, these men and women, hoping for the end and for brighter days after all the horrible gloom. Can Memphis ever be grateful enough to those devoted souls who dropped at their posts, succumbed or rose from their beds, still weak from the ravages of the pest, and went to work again. Occasionally they met in the silent streets, spoke, shook hands, compared notes, laughed, maybe shed tears, saw the wagon-loads of piled-up coffins go by to await their turns at the cemeteries for interment, paid little heed to the irreverence with which these were treated, passed on and worked!
Sometimes it was many hours before bodies could be buried, owing to the difficulty of getting men to dig the graves. These grave-diggers were a courageous few and their work during the dark days of 1878 deserves to be remembered by
Memphis people. All day bodies were deposited in the graveyards, sometimes buried with funeral rites and sometimes without. Catholic priests were vigilant in this respect and many bodies Catholic and Protestant, received a last religious service from watchful priests, that would otherwise have gone into their last earthly beds unattended.
Colonel Keating says that the Elmwood Cemetery bell "was for a long time tolled by a lovely girl, who for weeks was her father's only help. She kept the registry of the dead, and knew what the havoc of the fever was ; yet she remained at her self -selected post, her father's courageous clerk, until the fell disease overcame her physical energies. But she recovered, and after a few days resumed her place, keeping tally of the dead until the plague itself was numbered with the things that were. No bell save that of death was tolled. The churches were closed."
While these awful tales told of the past harrow us to a degree, there was a time when they were in the present, - now ! and the now of a horrible time is much more terrible than future generations, told of the happenings, can realize.
Many other places were visited by the plague that same year, notably New Orleans and Grenada, Mississippi, but Memphis paid the greatest penalty of all. Colonel Keating calls this 187.8 epidemic "the horror of the century, the most soul-harrowing episode in the history of the English-speaking people in America," and he had reason to know of it as he stayed through the whole terrible siege, being one of the few who escaped having the disease.
This splendid man, who has preserved a history of the plague for future generations, is one of the heroes of Memphis. If he had done nothing else for this city than what he did during the epidemics she has endured, he would deserve a monument.
In this particular year, as the populace fled for safety and the disease progressed. Colonel Keating felt that it was essential to keep the world informed of each day's occurrences, so he kept his paper alive in addition to his offices as member of the Citizens Relief Committee. Men stayed with him on the press work, brave men, deliberately facing danger that the outside world might be served. Colonel Keating says of this class of workers: "The printers and telegraphers suffered more than any other classes. * * * * The nature of their employment exposed them more than any other classes, save the doctors and nurses, to the fever poison. They fell very fast. Only one of all those employed by the telegraph company escaped, and of the editors, compositors and pressmen of the daily press, only one escaped of the Ledger, four of the Avalanche and two of the Appeal. Their numbers thus so rapidly decreased, these heroic men continued not only to fulfil the duties expected of them by a public, impatient for every fact and incident of the epidemic, but nursed their sick and buried their dead. Though often wearied to exhaustion, ready to fall for want of strength, they continued to send messages, and print papers and to succor those who had claims upon them."
This is a tribute to his co-workers, truly earned, but he fails to tell of his individual work. He also was often "wearied to exhaustion," but he did not falter. His history does not record the day that he went to the Appeal office and found that of the force he was the only one left. Other duties as well as press work were demanding him but he said, "The paper must be printed, and I am the only one who can do it. ' ' His message was one that the world was expecting and he felt the urgency of giving it. Memphis refugees looked for it as they did for nothing else. Each day the readers learned what was being done in the unfortunate city and the lists of dead and convalescent were eagerly scanned in Canada and all the states. People wept or rejoiced as they read names of relatives or friends in one list or the other and waited impatiently for the next day's intelligence. Colonel Keating did not allow them to be disappointed. He wrote his editorial, the reports and all matter needed, set the type, worked the press, printed the sheets, folded them and gave his small but valuable sheet to the waiting world that day and other days.
from 1868 to 1874," and poor Memphis, who had suffered them all, in 1878 could say, ''and even worse than carpet-bag rule is this awful pestilence!"
But the heavier the gloom the more beautiful are the rays of good that filter through its depressing weight. The rays in those dark days that made themselves manifest were unselfishness and brotherly sympathy. Selfish humanity goes on in its daily business, considering only its own welfare, but when a great human crisis comes the merely human, selfish nature is replaced by the god-nature that asserts itself. At such times people become brothers in the true sense.
In 1878, when our country and the world learned of the terrible strait Memphis and the South was in, all animosity, all sectional feeling and every other sentiment save that of sympathy, were forgotten and help such as the outside world could give, poured in to strengthen the efforts of those brave souls who had sacrificed themselves to the cause of suffering humanity. Money was sent from near and far. The Howard Association alone used $500,000 during that one epidemic. They employed 2,900 nurses and furnished doctors, nurses and supplies to 15,000 people. The Citizens Relief Committee spent $93,914.11 and issued 745,735 rations. Altogether during that siege Memphis received nearly a million dollars in money, clothing Medicine and other supplies. The world contributed to the entire South that year $4,548,700, for the relief of yellow-fever patients.
One train came to Memphis loaded almost entirely with coffins, a grewsome but very acceptable gift at that time. All sorts of people and all sorts of institutions were interested in the various contributions. Many were collections of mayors of cities and towns, others of churches of all denominations, of secret societies, men's and women's clubs and church societies. Lecturers gave lectures and artists gave concerts or other entertainments for the sufferers. Contributions came accompanied by letters from "young ladies;" "young men," "the children;" "little girls;" "colored contributions;" "employees;" "ministers;" "soldiers;" "Jews;" "Quakers;"
Nashville came to the aid of the children who had been orphaned and these little ones were put into her asylums or into private homes, where some have grown up as the adopted and loved children of the people who took them.
Some misguided human beings commit depredations even in the midst of distress, but fortunately these are a minority. Some of these weeds of humanity appeared in Memphis during those direful days, and planned for much mischief to gain their selfish ends. The negroes, the ignorant mass of whom had been given such false ideas of their importance, were now instigated by a few white men to take possession of the commissary department and to overpower the white people. They were told and made to believe that the fact of their not having the fever as white people did, proved that God meant for them to have the land and that they could take it now that the white people were so weakened and helpless. It is easy to imagine the added horrors if these fiends and foragers could have got the upper hand. But they reckoned more foolishly than they knew and were defeated by the vigilance of the Citizens Relief Committee and the Howard Association, both of which organizations were most looked to for succor and protection.
The police and fire forces were so reduced that the associations had to provide for guarding the city. Some thieves stole Howard nurse badges and so were enabled to enter homes and looted them, but steps were quickly taken by the Relief Committee to drive them from town. The police were instructed to arrest all persons on the streets after nine o'clock at night, unless the pedestrians could give satisfactory reasons for being abroad. At Court Square were stationed two negro military companies composed of trustworthy members of the race. At Camp Joe Williams the Bluff City Grays were placed with instructions to be ready to take the train kept for them immediately, if they were needed. The highly trained Chickasaw guards were ordered to Grand Junction, where they were to be in readiness if called. A Raleigh company of over a hundred volunteered their services when needed, and another company south of Memphis volunteered and kept in readiness for the call. In the city were not more than one hundred white men that could have been mustered but they were to be relied upon. If the necessity arose for their services the signal was to be three taps of the fire-bell, when they were to hasten to the express office on North Court Street.
One day, when men and women were lined up for their daily apportionment, a bullying black, instigated by a white ruffian, and several of his own color near, attacked the colored sentry at the commissary entrance. It was probably the beginning of a general rush to overpower the small force at headquarters, but the sentry was not to be intimidated, and immediately shot his assailant. Then arose a wail of women and howl of men that portended trouble, but the negro soldiers rushed to the scene. The mob soon comprehended that these soldiers were for order, and in nowise inclined to join in any irregularity, so they were checked in the very beginning of their uprising. The disturbance brought out the members of the Relief Committee who were in the building, and General Luke E. Wright, one of the most earnest of the self-sacrificing band of workers, raising his voice above the Bedlam of tongues, thanked the sentry for his prompt action and then, turning to the soldiers, commended them for their soldierly behavior. He then told the crowd that any depredations from thieves or any other attempted mob violence would be met as summarily as in this case, and that in a very short while military enough could be called to destroy their whole force. It is recorded that the white man who urged the negro to make his attack, disappeared, and was never heard from again.
This occurrence, with the assurance that court, or no court, lawlessness was not to be tolerated, brought about a beneficent result and the would-be looters knew that although the respectable element was small they were determined and able to defend themselves.
It was unfortunate that those who were working so unselfishly to save their fellows and the life of the city, and who were so sorely needed for their daily tedious rounds, should have the additional responsibility of keeping order. One can not but wonder that at such a time there could be human beings so low as to add crime to universal sorrow and helplessness, but weeds flourish in all sorts of soil. There seems to be no doubt that if it had not been for the vigilance of the Relief Committee a riot would have added to the horrors of the city, perhaps ending in its total destruction, for when useless, non-producing ignorance gets the upper hand, temporary liberty is only license and during the period of such license it knows no cessation nor feeling of compassion or order.
Memphis can scarcely realize the debt of gratitude she owes to such men as General Wright, Colonel Keating, Mr. Langstaff, Dr. Mitchell, Dr. Thornton, and the scores of noble souls who stayed and actually saved the city for future usefulness. Fortunately Colonel Keating has preserved for us the names of the men and women who worked and died and worked and lived for Memphis in those strange dark days.
The commissary department was so well managed and the outside world so generous that all the patients and others in the city were supplied with necessities and even luxuries such as ice, fruit, wine and other sick-room supplies were not wanting. The efficient men who had distribution in charge so directed that, as Colonel Keating says, "every pound and ounce of food or bushel or cord of fuel or suit or part of a suit of clothes was accounted for." By this system the bounty of the states and Europe was not wasted and nourishment and supplies went where it was intended that they should. The commissary clerks died rapidly but, as in the ranks of battle, their places would be filled, though the recruits would often have to serve day and night to supply the demands. The men who gave their time and sometimes their lives to this work had no recompense save that of the consciousness of doing what they could to help others.
By October 7, new cases of the fever had fallen to fiftyseven and deaths on that day to twenty-four, so the Howards having, what with other organizations, more supplies than were needed for the Memphis demands, President Langstaff organized relief trains to be run on the Memphis & Charleston,
Mississippi & Tennessee, and Louisville, Nashville & Great Southern, to supply calls from surrounding towns. These trains carried physicians, nurses, medical supplies and provisions. The Association had done some work for outsiders before, but not until the plague had abated in the larger city had they been able to take many supplies for other places.
As October advanced the fearful heat abated, cases continued to diminish and the faithful few who had been keeping the world informed were able to say that the siege was almost over. On the twenty-ninth of this month the Board of Health declared the epidemic at an end. The nurses were paid and discharged; the physicians also dismissed; the medical department and its agencies closed. Some cases occurred later but they were scattered, - just remnants of the awful visitation. However, so long as there was a need for help it was supplied, although organized work of the associations was closed.
The Howards who reported for duty and then faithfully fulfilled that duty were, as given by Colonel Keating: A. D. Langstaff, W. J. Smith, J. H. Edmundson, J. H. Smith, John Johnson, A. M. Stoddard, J. W. Cooper, B. P. Anderson,* W. D. McCallum,* Louis Frierson, D. G. Reahardt, W. S. Rogers, F. F. Bowen, J. G. Lonsdale,* E. B. Mansford,* N. D. Menkin,* J. T. Moss, S. M. Jobe,* R. P. Waring, J. Kohlberg, Charles Howard, J. W. Page, T. R. Waring, P. W. Semmes, W. A. Holt, E. B. Foster,* J. W. Heath,* Fred Cole,* A. F. C. Cook,* W. S. Anderson, C. L. Staffer, W. Finnic. The honorary members who reported for duty were : Dr. Luke P. Blackburn of Kentucky, Major W. T. Walthall, Captain P. R. Athy, and the Reverends W. E. Boggs, S. Landrum* and E. C. Slater.*
The surviving members of the Relief Committee were: Luke E. Wright, D. T. Porter, J. M. Keating, James S. Prestidge, Ed. Whitmore, W. W. Thatcher, Casey Young, C. F. Conn, D. F. Goodyear and Captain J. C. Maccabe. The members of this committee who gave their lives were : Charles G.
The ordeal was over but there was another ordeal to come ! People began coming home. Nearly all of them wore black and the crowded cars were as sombre in appearance as in feeling. The city was more desolate than ever before and the inhabitants hardly knew how to take up the threads of life again. So many homes were wrecked, all had borne losses. Thanks to the vigilance of the good people who had stayed, few houses had been molested and many that had been left open had been found closed and so saved from thieves, dust and weather.
The order of the time was sadness, but human nature is plastic and easily shapes itself to circumstances. Interests came back, threads that had been entirely lost were taken up again and Memphis became an active community once more, though much reduced in the number of her inhabitants. Once more the business wheels began to revolve and city officials turned from the work of getting their homes started again to municipal affairs. If these had been staggering before they seemed dead now.
On Thanksgiving Day, November 28, a mass-meeting was held, when public acknowledgment was made and thanks tendered to the world for the help so lately extended to stricken Memphis, and especially to those noble men and women who had given their lives and labors.
*The account of this epidemic is gathered chiefly from Colonel Keating's history of that year's dreadful experience, a remarkable record valuable to Memphis for all time, and from conversations with people who remained here during the siege or were among the refugees. It would take a volume like Colonel Keating's own to do justice to the terrible catastrophe.
Debt and Disaster Follow the Fever. Surrender of the City Charter. The Taxing District Act. Struggle with Creditors. How Memphis had been Robbed. The Taxing District Officials. How Memphis was Redeemed. Another Epidemic Breaks Out. Efficient Sanitary Measures Discussed. The Meeting of Refugees in St. Louis, Colonel Waring Plans Sewer System. Work on the Sewers Begun. Character of the System. The People Take Heart. Progress of Reconstructing the City Government. D. P. Hadden, President. The Old Debt Refunded. New Water System Established. Artesian Wells Sunk.
AFTER domestic and business affairs were again fairly launched, more attention was paid to sanitation than had been before, and there was certainly much to be done in this line. The city had little money to use, as her repeated calamities had left her bankrupt and, under the burden of an enormous debt, - the only thing that had not decreased during the plague, - that hung over her like a great pall.
It was evident that under the then existing government there was no way of escaping the Tennessee and United States writs of mandamus, which were demanding all the taxes collected and would leave nothing for carrying on the city, nor allow her anything with which to take precautions against future scourges of disease. Creditors became clamorous for their money, despite the general mourning and financial embarrassment of the people, and men saw that nothing short of complete change in government would or could work out a solution and get the disabled town in condition to escape annihilation.
meeting was called when people listened to a bill that had been prepared by Colonel George Gantt, and a discussion in which the true state of affairs was set forth and a dissolution of the charter earnestly recommended.
The bill drafted before the epidemic by S. P. Walker was reexamined and revised by able legal men, prominently among them Judge C. W. Heiskell and Colonel Gantt. The new bill as revised, was adopted and ordered presented to the members-elect of the Legislature, for their consideration. These members had been elected with a view to their approval of the bill and now they were urged to push it through immediately.
On January 29, 1879, the bill was passed, but not approved by Governor Marks until January 31. During this delay of two days Memphis officials resigned and the city government became thoroughly disorganized.
Humiliations seemed to pile up for poor Memphis. Now she was not even a city, - had been reduced to a Taxing District. Her charter of incorporation passed in 1826, and approved and extended at later intervals, had been dissolved, her population "resolved back into the body of the state," her offices all abolished and her municipal affairs were to be managed b ythe state. But it has been shown how unsettled conditions during and after the war, fraud, misgovernment and pestilence had made such ravages on the town that she had been left stranded and the Taxing District Act* seemed the only lever to assist in setting her again afloat.
This new ])ill provided that taxes for the support of the government of the Taxing District "shall be imposed directly by the General Assembly of the State of Tennessee and not otherwise." But an amendment of tliis Actf gave the Taxing District more power to handle her own affairs.
Instead of a Board of Mayor and Aldermen or the General Council, as heretofore, the Taxing District was to be regulated and administered by the "Legislative Council of the Taxing District," to consist of "the commissioners of the fire and
Provision was made for "A board of health, to consist of the chief of police, a health officer and one physician, * * * * who shall be ex officio president of the board."
Section 3, of this bill defined the powers of the government of the Taxing District, which were much the same as those of the former city, giving "power over all afi'airs in the taxing district in which the peace, safety and general welfare of the inhabitants is interested."
The President of the Board of Fire and Police Commissioners was also judge of the police court and tried all offences against the District ordinances. He was also a justice of the I)eace, having criminal jurisdiction within the limits of the District. When the same act was an offense against the State and District, he had the right to try both offenses ; when against the state only he could fine, if the party submitted, otherwise the accused was held to the criminal court.
Section 4, defined the powers and restrictions of the Legislative Council, this being "restricted to the business alone of making ordinances or local laws for the Taxing District, except as hereinafter provided."
Section 5, fixed the salary of the president at $2,000 per annum, demanding that he "shall devote his entire time and attention to the duties of his office." This $2,000 was to be his only compensation, any fees that he might make as justice of the peace, to be credited on his salary "and if such fees amount to $2,000 or more per annum, he shall receive no other compensation."* The salaries of the commissioners are also provided for and fixed at $500 per annum.
Section 5, also provided the number of fire and police commissioners, their ages, duties and mode of appointment. They were authorized to elect a president from their number after each biennial election, such president to be the executive officer of the Taxing District. The said commissioners were also authorized to appoint a secretary at a yearly salary of $1,800, and they were given "power to appoint all officers and subordinates in the police and fire service, including the Chief of Police, and to suspend and discharge the same at will." Also to make rules for the discipline of policemen and firemen.
In Section 6, the Commissioners are given supervision over streets, drains, sewers and all sanitary measures, lighting, bridges, wharves, etc., and are authorized to "employ a competent civil engineer at a salary not exceeding $2,000 per annum.
The remaining sections, with the amendments, elaborate on the duties of the Commissioners and all officials, their oaths, elections, levy of taxes for streets, hospital purposes, wharfage, contracts and other Taxing District necessities.
This government is simply an agent of the state government, without the power of credit or taxation, and the evils consequent thereto. It owns no property, except for governmental purposes alone. It can issue no bonds and has no power to pay them if they are issued. It contracts no debt, except as against particular taxes levied by the state itself, to pay them year by year. It therefore pays as it goes - the only true policy for individuals and states. What improvements it makes it pays for, and if it has no money to pay, it waits till it has. Launched under such auspices, it is hoped that it will prove a lasting blessing, and that economy, honesty and enterprise, cleanliness and sanitation, good streets, and an efficient fire and police protection, wall close its gates on the pestilence forever, and open wide the doors of health and lasting prosperity.
affairs and attempted to test this new law creating taxing districts in every court until the Supreme Court of the United States declared it entirely constitutional. Colonel Gantt worked hard to gain this opinion and many declared that his argument before the United States Supreme Court on the
This new settlement brought great relief to Memphis people and assured them of more time and money for civic improvements and defense against future attacks of pestilence.
Doctor Porter said of the new form of government: "The object in creating the Taxing District was not to repudiate the debt of the old city of Memphis, but to have a cheap and efficient system of government, so as to put the municipality in a good sanitary condition, pave the streets, and enable us to pay that debt upon terms that may be agreed on by the commissioners that may be appointed, and the creditors."
When the bondholders could no longer mandamus the citizens of Memphis to provide for their improvident debts, they petitioned the General Assembly of the state to give them power to collect their money, in which petition they stated that their debts were lawfully created and that "there is no substantial ground on which it can be claimed that such debts, or any part or portion of any of them are not justly owing."
In the cross-petition of the citizens to that of the bondholders, and in response to the above charge, they answered: "There is much of the debt that is not justly owing, but very largely fraudulent. As a sample, we submit the following statements :
"First Statement - On the 10th of June, 1868, Joseph A. Mabry, holding $275,000 of city script, and others holding large amounts, submitted a written proposition to the acting mayor to accept city bonds for their debts, giving $65 of script for each $100 of bonds, a loss to the city of 35 cents on the dollar, when the amount paid for the indebtedness was not exceeding 30 cents for a dollar, thus making a $1000 bond cost $216. This proposition was accepted, and it is stated that the arrangement was consummated, without any authority from the Board of Mayor and Aldermen. This fact appears from the report of a committee raised by the Board of Mayor and Aldermen in 1872, four years after the transaction. That report is in these words : appear from the records that any meeting from the Board of Aldermen was held on the 10th day of June, 1868, as stated in the indorsement,' (the Mayor's endorsement accepting the proposition.)
"By this arrangement, $568,000 six per cent bonds were issued to take up $369,000 of open accounts. In other words to settle $369,000 of debt, the bonds and interest would cost us $1,590,400.
''Second Statement - In June, 1867, $897,000 of paving bonds were authorized to be issued. Under this authority sixtytwo bonds, ($62,000) were actually sold at the following prices:
"And so, petitioners, through your honorable body and the highest judicature of the country, having obtained some surcease from their intolerable burdens, hope your honorable body will not again enslave them, but allow them to maintain their vantage ground, and make such a settlement of the debts of the dead city of Memphis as will be just and fair to the creditor, and not compel petitioners to desert their homes, or give them over to the merciless exaction of those who in time past have shown no mercy."
Provenance
Text from Standard History of Memphis, Tennessee, from a Study of the Original Sources, published 1912, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.