San Diego, California - City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California (part 2 of 13)
From City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. 15,966 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
5 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,966 wordsMachine-read from scans of City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Naturally enough as the cattle and hide industry grew in importance, those at and near San Diego began to look for more land on which cattle could be raised and fed. By 1820 valuable grants were made to private individuals, beginning with veteran and invalid soldiers, and by 1834 the practice of granting lands included in the mission holdings had started. This continued with great liberality up to the time California was taken by the United States in 1846.
Spain's power in Mexico had gone by 1822 and on April 20 of the year the Spanish flag was hauled down. It ai)pears that the ceremony in which it was supplanted by the Mexican colors in San Diego was a simple one. The little establishment was far away from the scene of turbulence. The people here were not greatly concerned over ihe change and they accepted the beginning of Mexican rule without any signs of great excitement.
Chapter Iv Under The Mexican Flag
The story of San Diego under Mexican control is not one of vast importance. The hide and tallow industry kept increasing in importance, but growth in population was slow, and as Smythe has aptly said, the Mexican authorities spent much of their time and energy in political squabbles which kept conditions sadly unsettled. Yet in these disputes there were a number of interesting characters, and in the government of California San, Diego played a large part.
Among the San Diegans who became prominent in that period was Juan Bandini, one of the most striking characters in all California at that time. Another was Pio Pico, who was the last Mexican governor of California. Still another was Henry D. Fitch, a New Bedford sailor, who became a iSlexican citizen here, who was first town attorney of San Diego when the pueblo form of government was organized and who kept the largest store at Old Town for many years prior to American occupation. Then there were the Arguellos, the Carrillos, the Estudillos, the Zamoranos and many other families whose names are a very part of Old Town. They joined in buikling up at the little settlement such an atmosphere of old-time courtesy and hospitality that its romantic fragrance has lasted through all the years.
Although never so officially designated, San Diego was to all intents and purposes the capital of California for about five years, while (ien. Jose Maria Echeandia was governor. His territory, it must be remembered, included both Upper and Lower California, and San Diego was not very far, geographically, from the center of that large section, but his choice of San Diego met with some opposition from various other places and when he attempted in 1827 to hold an assembly at San Diego the delegates declared that this city was too hard to reach. Echeandia seems to have been a fairly sensible and efficient officer, but his career as governor was not without troubles of various kinds. His presence and residence at San Diego made the i)lace of course the political center of affairs in California, and i)olitical schemes in abundance were concocted here. The volatile schemers doubtless were a source of some anxiety to Echeandia.
At that time, too, Americans were beginning to come not only by sea biU ]jy land to California, the hardy pioneers of the nation being ever eager to push on to the west. Some of these came to San Diego in what is known as the Pattie party in 1828. In referring to this episode Smythe directs attention to the fact that the Californians (or Mexicans) were not hostile to the Americans, probably being more inclined toward them than to the Spaniards who viewed the advent of Mexican or Mexican rule with no great satisfaction. But the Californians somewhat naturally looked upon all foreigners with sus- picion. Under that suspicion the Pattie party fell. This party was headed by Sylvester Pattie, a Kentuckian who had achieved fame as an Indian fighter. His son, James O. Pattie, later wrote a "Narrative" of the affair and left considerable room for argument. At any rate, Pattie in 1827 organized a company at Santa Fe, New Mexico, to trap and hunt on the Colorado River, about which, of course, little was known at that time. Eight of the company, all Americans, including the two Patties, floated down to the mouth of the Colorado and after considerable hardships started west, at last reaching the mission at Santa Catalina in Lower California, early in 1829. All eight men were brought to San Diego. Echeandia had them locked up and they remained prisoners here for several months. The elder Pattie died and was buried on Presidio Hill. The younger Pattie appears either to have been an obstreperous prisoner or to have been badly treated. His six companions were released under guard to go for some furs they had buried near the Colorado River, but he was kept in prison until, as Pattie's story has it, a smallpox epidemic broke out and he, having some vaccine with him, was let out to vaccinate everybody around. He later seems to have gone to San Francisco and to have played the doctor there.
The old governor had some trouble with the Indians, and kept his troops busy much of the time in keeping them scared away from the port. The California soldiers brought in the ears of their victims to show what the day's work had been. On one occasion a lieutenant is said to have brought in twenty pairs of ears from Indians slain in this section.
An interesting account of San Diego in the days of Governor Echeandia rule is given by Alfred Robinson in his "Life in California." Robinson came here in 1829 as clerk on the trading ship, Brookline, and in 1836 married, at Santa Barbara, Ana Maria, the daughter of Capt. Jose de la Guerra y Noriega, one of the wealthiest Spaniards of California. After the Brookline hove to, a boat was sent ashore and "satisfactory arrangements" were made with Governor Echeandia, after which the Brookline ran in and anchored close under the guns of old Fort Guijarros. The Brookline was there for a long stay, so the long boat was hoisted out, ready to be put down, the royal yards and masts and the top-gallant yards of the good ship were lowered, "and these and all other surplus rubbish on the decks sent on shore and deposited." Those were not modern days of telegraphic haste in trading, but the good old leisurely times, in which the Spanish courtesies had to be thoroughly observed before any mere barter was to be considered. Then lumber was sent ashore and the ship's carpenter began to build "a large house" for the storage of hides. This, wrote Robinson, served "as a place of accommodation" for the lighter part of the Brookline's cargo while it was being examined and cared for by the Spanish custom officers. Don Manuel Dominguez, a brother-in-law of one of Robinson's companions, soon sent horses to the visitors and they galloped away to the town. Then followed Robinson's interesting description of the San Diego of those days : deep and broad ravine, where formerly some river had flowed, but its bed was now filled with bushes and shrubs. Previous to this we passed a small shanty in an unfinished state, which had been erected some time before as a Custom-House, but owiuir to its incapacity and situation, had been abandoned. We saw also the commencement of a new Presidio, that, on account of the difficulty of procuring water, had also never been completed. These two monuments of the imprudence and want of foresight of the Governor, served as very good evidence to me of the want of sagacity and energy of the Government.
"A short ride further brought us to the house of our friend Don Manuel. We rode into the 'patio', or courtyard, where a servant took the horses. At the threshold of his door we were met by Don Manuel, who embraced us cordially, and presented us to the family, his mother, wife and sister. This was to be our home during the ship's detention, and though its coarse mud walls and damp ground floor did not altogether coincide with the idea I had previously formed of it, yet if their walls were cold, and their floors damp, their hearts were warm, and the abundance of their luxurious entertainment more than compensated for any disappointment.
"After dinner we called on the Gen. Don Jose Alaria de Echeandia, a tall, gaunt personage, who received us with true Spanish dignity and politeness. His house was located in the centre of a large square of buildings occupied by his officers, and so elevated as to overlook them all, and command a view of the sea. On the right hand was a small Gothic chapel, with its cemetery, and immediately in front, close to its principal entrance, was the guard-room, where the soldiers were amusing themselves ; some seated on the ground playing cards and smoking, while others were dancing to the music of the guitar; the whole was surrounded by a high wall, originally intended as a defence against the Indians. At the gate strode a sentinel, with slouched hat and blanket thrown over one shoulder, his old Spanish musket resting on the other : his pantaloons were buttoned and ornamented at the knees, below which, his legs were protected by leggins of dressed deer-skin, secured with spangled garters.
"On the lawn beneath the hill on which the Presidio is built stood about thirty houses of rude appearance, mostly occupied by retired veterans, not so well constructed in respect either to beauty or stability as the houses at Monterey, which with the exception of that belonging to our 'Administrador,' Don Juan Bandini, whose mansion, then in an unfinished state, bade fair, when completed, to surpass any other in the country.
"The climate of St. Diego is milder than that of any other part on the coast, and not so much subject to dense fogs as ^Io^te^ey and St. Francisco. The soil presents a barren and uncultivated appearance, and although several spots dignified by the name of gardens are found upon the bank of a river which flows from the mountains during the rainy season, in which they cultivate a few vegetables, yet nothing can be seen of any agricultural importance except in places at some distance from the town. The hills and glens abound with many kinds of cactus, among which the rabbit and quail find shelter pursued by the s[)ortsman. These are both very numerous, the latter freciuently rising in flocks of two or three hundred. Hares are abundant and here also, as at all other places on the coast during the rainy season, the plains and ponds are crowded with ducks and geese, while thousands of brant cover the extensive bay.
"0*ur accounts with the Custom-House were soon adjusted, and we were prepared to commence our trade. Visitors were numerous, both male and female, who came on board to purchase. Amongst others, the Rev. Padre Antonio Peyri, of the Mission of St. Luis Rey, had expressed a wish to visit his many friends on shipboard for - besides our own, there were two other vessels in port, the English brig Vulture, under charter by H. D. Fitch, of Massachusetts (whose matrimonial adventures I shall presently relate) and the Mexican brig Maria Ester, from Acapulco. The good old priest was accordingly invited, and the last day of his visit was to be passed with us ; other friends camie also, and dinner was prepared for the occasion.
''As the old gentleman was held in universal respect upon the coast, not only as a founder of the Mission over which he presided, but also as a man of great mental energy and capacity ; high in favor with the government because of these qualities, and being dearly loved by the people for the extreme benevolence of his disposition, we were prepared to receive him with 'all the honors." Accordingly as the Reverend Padre descended the gangway, we thundered forth a salute and proceeded to show him the different parts of the vessel. Particularly did we call his attention to our trade-room, which had been fitted up with shelves and counters, resembling in appearance a country variety store. The amount of his purchase testified how vastly he had been pleased.
"On the following morning he departed, and when the boat had reached a short distance from the ship, the men laid upon their oars whilst our guns sounded a parting salute. As the smoke cleared off I beheld the old man standing in the boat, and gazing toward us with apparent delight, and I thought I could perceive from the glistening of his eye that future patronage would be the result of this reception."
Another interesting account of San Diego at this period is given in William Heath Davis' "Sixty Years in California." Davis came here in 1831, two years after the time of which Robinson wrote. Governor Echeandia's term of ofifice had ended, but conditions at San Diego were not changed to any great extent, of coarse. Davis' account makes it plain that the military headquarters was still maintained at the presidio, which, wrote Davis, was placed so as to protect the citizens of the "miniature city" from "the ferocious and savage Indians." He estimates that the citizens and soldiers at that time numbered from 400 to 500. "Quite a large place," remarked the writer. Davis also observed that at San Diego in those days there was much gaiety and refinement, the people being, according to his account, "the elite of this portion of the department of California." Old Town had been laid out, but the people had not yet become satisfied that they would be entirely safe in leaving the protection of the presidio for houses on the level land below Presidio Hill. Monterey by that time had been designated as the port of entry for
California and also the seat of Government, and vessels which came from the Atlantic coast were obliged to go to Monterey and enter that port before they could come to San Diego for trading; but, after paying the necessary duties at Monterey, they could enter any other California port.
Echeandia's term ended in December, 1830. when Col. Manuel A'ictoria, the new governor, arrived in San Diego. His headquarters was established at Alonterey. Pio Pico, Juan Bandini and several others started a little revolution at San Diego and organized a force which went to Los Angeles and seized it. Victoria was badly wounded in a battle which followed and left the country. The months that followed were full of plots and threatened revolutions. Echeandia went to Mexico in 1833 to remain. Pico became governor in 1832.
The pueblo of San Diego was formed on December 21, 1834. Juan Maria Osuna was the first alcalde, or mayor. In 1838 the population had fallen off to such an extent that San Diego was not entitled to a town council or ayuntamiente, as the Californians called it. and from that time until the United States stepped in, San Diego was under Los Angeles jurisdiction.
The last years of California rule were filled with petty i)olitical disputes among the various leaders, '*re\olutions" with "armies" of 100 men and "battles" which were sometimes wholly bloodless. In the political affairs of the time the following were some who were prominent: Juan Kandini, Pio Pico, who became governor; Andres Pico, who had command of the Californians at the battle of San Pasqual in 1846; Santiago E. Arguello and Francisco Maria Alvarado. Of these by far the most noted in San Diego annals was Bandini. a slightly built yet impressively, dignified, tyjiically graceful Si)anish gentleman. ( )n one side of the i)laza in Old Town he erected a mansion, then very fine, at least in comparison with many of those around it, and its walls still stand, although they bear the additional burden of another story, in less romantic times, to serve as part of a hotel. In this mansion, as in the Estudillo home across the way, there wa.>i many a gay dance or ball. When Commodore Robert F. Stockton arrived at .San Diego and took the ])ort it was Inandini himself who, siding with the Americans, as did many of his kind, oft'ered the residence to Stockton for the American headquarters. Exquisitely polite, well educated, known far and wide as one of the most graciou-^ and hosjMtable of all residents of California, a fluent writer, a good speaker, with a biting sarcasm, the father of several beautiful daughters. Bandini indeed was a notable figure of the j)criod and easily the foremost citizen of San Diego at the time. Just before the United .States went to war against Mexico, Bandini was secretary' to Governor Pico, but he soon espoused the American cause without hesitation and became one of its most loyal and valuable supporters in this part of California. He cHed at Los Angeles in 1850 leaving a familv, several branches of which are still prominent in California.
Pio Pico, in the last few months of his rule, made a name for himself by giving away land to his friends and followers. He did it lavishly and almost U]) to the last minute before the Americans took control of California. .And he thereby built up a puzzle which it took the .American courts manv a long dav to sol\e. lohn Steven
"It appears from the records, not to speak of the memory of men still living, that no governor of California even remotely approached in openhanded generosity Don Pio Pico."
The truth of the matter is, as McGroarty says, that Governor Pico and his close associates saw that California was certain to fall into the hands of the United States and that it would be a fine thing to apportion as much of this land as possible to his friends and supporters. So he kept at the task of conveying property up to the very last and made a legal tangle which went up to the Supreme
Pico In 1820
Court of the United States. This court, after many years of effort in American courts to decide between valid and fraudulent titles to the vast expanse of land claimed by virtue of Pico's grants, said:
"No class of cases that come before this court are attended with so many and such perplexing difiiculties as these are. The number -of them which we are called upon to decide bears a very heavy disproportion to the other business of the court, and this is unfortunately increasing instead of diminishing. Some idea of the difficulties that surround these cases may be obtained by recurring to the loose and indefinite manner in which the Mexican Government made the grants which we are now required judicially to locate. That Government attached no value to the land, and granted it in what to us appears magnificent quantities. Leagues instead of acres were their units of measurement, and when an application was made to the Government for a grant which was always a gratuity, the only question was whether the locality asked for was vacant or public property. When the grant was made, no surveyor sighted a compass or stretched a chain. Indeed, these instruments were probably not to be had in that region. A sketch, called a diseno, which was rather a map than a plat of the land, was prepared by the applicant. It gave, in a rude and imperfect manner, the shape and general outline of the land desired, with some of the more prominent natural objects noted on it, and a reference to the adjoining tracts owned by individuals, if there were any, or to such other objects as were supposed to constitute the boundaries. Their ideas of the relation of the points of the compass to the objects on the map were very inaccurate ; and as these sketches were made by uneducated herdsmen of cattle, it is easy to imagine how imperfect they were. Yet they are now often the most satisfactory and sometimes the only evidence by which to locate these claims.''
Literally hundreds of these cases were review'ed by the United States Supreme Court. ]\Iany celebrated attorneys took part in the preparation and argument of these cases. Among them were Jeremiah Sullivan Black, at one time Attorney-general of the United States ; Caleb Gushing, Edwin '\l. Stanton, Reverdy Johnson, William M. Everts, John J. Crittenden, Judah P. Benjamin, Charles O'Conor, Titian J. CofTey, and Hall McAllister.
The United States Land Conmiission, to which was intrusted the task of investigating these grants, reported that a greater variety of subjects or a wider field of inquiry had rarely if ever been put before anv tribunal. In connection with this the work of Col. J. D. Stevenson of the U. S. Army is of interest. In the spring of 1847 he was put in command of the southern military district of this state and instructed to investigate the ^Mexican land grants.
"Colonel .Stevenson," writes McGroart\', "said that sf)on after he got his district in order he began to make inquiries as to who were the civil officers under Pico, and learned from Abel Stearns and others that he (Stearns) \vas either the prefect or subprefect, and an intimate and confidential friend of Pico, and from him and others he learned that grants were made after it was known that the Americans had taken possession of California, which were antedated, and especially those made in this section of the county from San Jose this way. and that a very large portion of them were signed by Pico on the day and night preceding his start for Mexico, which was about the 8tli or 9th of August, 1846; Stearns told him that he was present on the day and night referred to, especially the night those grants were executed, and that Pico left him ( Stearns) in charge as next otifioer in command. These grants were frequently the subject of con\ersation ; and on one occasion a partv to whom a valuable grant was made, confessed to him that the grant was executed that night, and he knew nothing of it until he was sent for to accept the grant. Fie availed himself of every opportunity to obtain information about these grants, both bv conversation and otherwise.
"And that was the way things went in those days - the good old days now long since gone, when a few thousand acres of land between friends was a small matter ; and not as it is now, when they measure it otf by the inch to you, and every foot of it in Los Angeles is worth a king's ransom."
Chapter
Mewed in the light of modern warfare, with its powerful guns, torpedoes, its gas, its tremendous naval and military equipments and its great sea and land forces, San Diego's part in the Mexican war now seems to have been a puny afTair. It doubtless was serious enough for those who had part in it in this section. Yet even they lived in an atmosphere strikingly different from that of the present day San Diegan. The romanticism and chivalrous nature of the Spanish families of California gave to the picture a tone all itsown. For San Diego was never wholly Mexican, even when Mexico ruled, and this distinction became more apparent when the course of the United States seemed bound to triumph in the fight against the new and politically unsettled republic below the Rio Grande. Then, too, Americans had begun to settle in this section and to marry into the families they found here. Some of these had become Mexican citizens, and their Spanish wives were loyal to their husbands. Some of the best known Spanish families indeed sided with the Americans as soon as the war started. Such were the Banch'nis and Arguellos. When the war actually came to San Diego it came in a softened fashion, bringing days more filled with apprehension than carnage, episodes more dramatic than important from a military viewpoint.
So it was when Captain .^amuel F. Dupont sailed into San Diego harbor on July 29, 1846, in the sloop Cyane, bringing John C. Fremont and his band of eighty, about as many marines and a party of scouts headed by the redoubtable Kit Carson of "the terrible eye." All formed the '"California Battalion." Fremont wasted no time in hoisting the .\merican flag at Old Town and in leaving a marine guard there to see that it stayed at the top of the staff, floating over the southernmost settlement in California. .Apparently Fremont feared little trouble here : certainly he did not experience much. The Cyane remained here until .August ^, and having left the troops ashore, beat out to sea again. Fremont's plan was to use San Diego as a base for a movement upon Los Angeles, then an important point, so as soon as he could prei)are for the march north, he left, departing the day before the Cyane sailed out. Only a small garrison was left at San Diego. Near Los .\ngeles Fremont joined forces with Commodore Robert F. StocktcMi, and they seized that city. The Californians in that section, however, soon organized a force formidable in numbers, took Los Angeles back again and determined on an attempt to wrest San Diego from the .Americans. The garrison at San Diego had been cut down to a very small numl>er of men, and the defenders, hearing that the Californians were coming in force, decided on a retreat. So aboard the whaler Stonington, then in the harbor, they went, taking with them their sympathizers and their famihes. The next morning the Mexicans had raised their flag at Old Town. American reinforcements were called from Los Angeles by boat, and a member of the American party, who was sent ashore, got to the old cannon on Presidio Hill and spiked them. Then the Americans landed, taking two cannon, and marched on the town. It was then time for the Mexicans to absent themselves, and after making a nice picture of battle array, they departed. The Mexican flag was then hauled down and replaced with the Stars and Stripes. The honor of raising the American colors was given, so tradition has it, to Albert B. Smith, to whose able hands had been entrusted the task of spiking the Mexican guns. A girl, Maria Antonia Machado, kept the Mexican flag from falling to the dust and carried it off loyally and lovingly.
Thereafter San Diego was American territory, although it was besieged with a fair degree of success by the Mexicans, whose course of action compelled Stockton to come here and start a vigorous cleaning up of the territory around San Diego. In this task the Spanish fighters w^ho had joined the Americans did valiant service, Captain Santiago Arguello and Captain Miguel de Pedrorena taking their men in a brave assault on the Mexican trenches wherein was a cannon with which they were peppering the Americans. The assault was a dashing exploit and was successful, the gun being captured and the Mexicans being driven away. Stockton then built a strong fort which has borne his name ever since and whose earthworks have lasted through many years. Also he brought together a force of considerable size and drilled his men with great care for a new movement upon Los Angeles. San Diego thus acquired real military importance. With it came a social importance, for the American officers were glad of a chance to participate in social activitv, and their feelings were well matched by those of the Spanish residents. Commodore .Stockton at this time made his headquarters in the Bandini residence at the request of its illustrious owner, and there were many gay dances and parties in the little town. For the Spanish loved this kind of life and welcomed men who fitted into it. Meanwhile the Mexicans, now imder Gen. Andres Pico, were in the vicinity of San Bernardo and about eighty strong. Such was the situation when Commodore Stockton heard of the unexpected approach of Gen. Stephen Watts Kearney and his little army, marching from the East. That brings the story to the battle of San Pasqual.
Chapter Vi Battle Of San Pasqual
The battle of San Pasqual was not an important engagement in a military way and certainly was not of importance because of numbers involved, but it deserves a place in American history because it signalizes in a manner the seizure of Alta California from the Californians, or Mexicans. Examination of the available records and accounts, too, does not provide any great reason to heap laurels upon the American commander on this occasion ; to the contrary the verdict would seem to be that, although he won a technical victory because the leader of the Californians fled with his troops at the end. it was a costly victory, decidedly not one to try to repeat. To San Diego, however, the battle, so-called, has a special significance because it was the only real battle ever fought in this county. As this volume is being prepared steps have been taken to mark the battle field with a memorial, for which the state of California will contribute a fund.
The battle was fought in the little San Pasqual valley, in the Northern ])art of San Diego County, not very far from Escondido. To this valley, in 1920. came Owen C. Coy, Ph. D., director of the California Historical Survey Commission, to whom had been delegated the task of preparing a narrative of the events connected with the engagment. with special reference to its location and to determine a wav in which the state could suitably mark the site. He came in connection with a gift received by the state from William G. Henshaw and Ed. Fletcher of an acre of ground supposed to be the site of the battle and accepted by California in 1919, in an act which contained a recommendation that the site be marked in a fit manner. Dr. Coy collected a wealth of material concerning the fight, and from his able report, printed in 1921. the writer has drawn extensively.
The American commander at the battle of San Pasqual was Gen. Stephen Watts Kearny, for whom Camp Kearny, training ground near San Diego of thousands of young Americans in 1917 and 1918 for service in the Great war, was named. When the Mexican war began. General Kearny, then a colonel in rank, was made brigadiergeneral and placed in command of an expedition comj-josed of volunteers from various Southwestern States and called the "army of the west." although, as a matter of fact, it is said that it never contained more than about 400 men. The leader on the Mexican -^ide was Cajv tain Andres Pico, under orders of General Flores. conunandante of the Californians.
supremacy of the United States troops on California soil was generally recognized, except by rather small and rather scattered bands of native talifornians. Pico led one of those bands, which was hovering at the time not far from San Diego, and to the north of the city. In its preparations for the war with Mexico the Government had arranged a plan whereby General Kearny should push overland with his force, take possession of New Mexico, and then to go ahead with sufficient force to California, there to co-operate with the United States naval forces in occupation of the coast. Large discretion in all matters was left to General Kearny, the letter of instructions from William L. Marcy, Secretary of War, laying emphasis on this point, one made doubtless with full realization that General Kearny and his men would have to traverse a country about which, of course, comparatively little was then known at Washington. In it wild sections and desert areas abounded and in it at any time the American soldiers might be confronted by hostile forces. Through such a country, however, these American troops were trained to go for fighting business, and it appears also that they were as brave a band as ever started out on a mission of the kind.
In obedience to his orders Kearny left Leavenworth late m June, occupied Santa Fe and. it is recorded, finished his occupation of New Mexico in August. Then, having received his commission as brigadier-general, he prepared for his journey overland to the Pacific coast and left Santa Fe with his little "army" on September 25. Of this journey, as Doctor Coy has written, interesting accounts are given in the diaries of two aides, Lieut. -Col. W. H. Emory and Capt. Abraham R. Johnston. The essential facts of the march to what is now San Diego County are given in General Kearny's official letter of December 12, from "headquarters. Army of the West, San Diego, Upper California," to Brig.-Gen. R. Jones, adjutantgeneral. Although dated the 13th, the letter, it will be noticed, contains no mention of the battle which then had occurred. It says:
"As I have previously reported to you I left Santa Fe for this country on the 25th of September, with 300 of the First Dragoons under Major Sumner. We crossed to the bank of the Del Norte at Al- Ijuouerque (65 miles below Santa Fe) continuing down on that bank till the 6th of October when we met Mr. Kit Carson, with a party of 16 men, on his way to Washington City with a mail and papers, an -express from Commodore Stockton and Lieutenent-Colonel Fremont, reporting that the Calif ornians were already in possession of the Americans under their command ; that the American flag was flying from every important position in the territory, and that the country was forever free from IMexican control : the war ended, and peace and harmony established among the people. In consequence of this information. I directed that 200 dragoons under Major Sumner should remain in New Mexico and that the other 100, under Captain Moore, should accompany me to the south, on the right bank of the Del Norte, to the distance of about 230 miles below Santa Fe, when, leaving that river on the 15th October, in about the 33d degree of latitude, we marched westward for the Copper mines, which we reached on the 18th, and on the 20th reached the river Gila, proceeding down the
Gila, crossing and re-crossing it as often as obstrnctions in our front rendered it necessary ; on the 1 1th November reached the Pimos village, about 80 miles from the settlements in Sonora. We crossed the Colorado about 10 miles below the mouth of the Gila, and marching near it about 30 miles farther, turned off and crossed the desert - a distance of about sixty miles - without water or grass. On the 2d December we reached Warner's rancho ( Agua Caliente), the frontier settlement in California, on the route leading to Sonora. On the 4th we marched to Mr. Stokes' rancho (San Isabella) ; and on the 5th were met by a small party of volunteers, under Captain Gillespie, sent out from San Diego by Commodore Stockton, to give us what information thev i)ossessed of the enemy, 600 or 700 of whom are now said to be in arms, and in the field throughout the territory, determined upon opposing the Americans, and resisting their authority in the country. Encamlped that night near another rancho (San Maria) of Mr. Stokes, about forty miles from San Diego."
(Editor's note: Modern and accepted spelling of places mentioned in this report makes "San Isabella" Santa Ysabel and "San Maria" Santa Maria.)
"We arrived at the rancheria after dark, where we heard that enemy was in force nine miles distant, and, not finding any grass about the rancheria. we pushed on and encamped in a Canyon, two miles below.
"A party under Lieutenant Hammond was sent out to reconnoitre the enemv reported to be near at hand. By some accident, the party was discovered, and the enemy placed on the 'qui vive'. We were now on the main road to San Diego : all the 'by-ways' being in our rear, and it was therefore deemed necessary to attack the enemy and force a passaii^e. About 2 o'clock a. m. the call to horse was sounded."
Captain Johnston's journal, under December 4, tells of hearing about the enemy's nearness, which makes the absence of anv such mention in General Kearny's report the more noticeable.
"If ^'ou can send a jiarty to open communication with us. on the route to this place, and to inform us of the state of affairs in California. I wish you would do so, and as quickly as possible.
"Your express bv Mr. Carson was mot oti the Del Norte, and your mail must have reached Washington at least ten days since. You might use the bearer, Mr. Stokes, to conduct your party to tliis place."
under Pico, and he seems to have concluded, on the receipt of Kearny's letter, that it would be well to join with Kearny in order to increase the chances of overwhelming the enemy. At any rate, he acted promptly, as shown by the reply he sent to Kearny: half past six o'clock p. m. "Sir: I have this moment received your note of yesterday, by Mr. Stokes, and have ordered Captain Gillespie, with a detachment of mounted riflemen and a field piece, to your camp without delay.
Captain Gillespie is well informed in relation to the present state of things in California, and will give you all needful information. I need not, therefore, detain him by saying anything on the subject. I will merely state that I have this evening received information, by two deserters from the rebel camp, of the arrival of an additional force in this neighborhood of one hundred men, which in addition to the force previously here, makes their number about one hundred and fifty.
"I send with Captain Gillespie, as a guide, one of the deserters, that you make inquiries of him, and, if you see fit, endeavor to surprise them.
As the letter has said, the expedition under Captain Gillespie left that evening. The captain had with him Captain Samuel Gibson, with a company of twenty-five volunteers, and ten carbineers from Stockton's flagship, the Congress, under Edward Fitzgerald Beale, acting lieutenant, of whom more will be told later, and Midshipman James M. Duncan. It is recorded that this party took all of the horses in San Diego and a brass piece of the four-pounder variety. Lariats were attached to drag it over the rough, hard way. It was not until the second day, indeed, that the Gillespie party met Kearny's force, the juncture being made at Ballena, between the Santa Ysabel and Santa Maria ranches. That fact had considerable eft'ect on the Americans. Winter rains in the mountain sections of San Diego County are by no means conducive to comfort, even in the days of enclosed automobiles, and it is easy to picture the effect of the weather on Kearny's command, with men and mounts sore and tired from their long trip from New Mexico.
Smythe records the fact that when a council of war was held, after the forces joined. Lieutenant Beale spoke against an immediate engagement, suggesting instead, an attempt to surprise the Californians and capture their horses. Kearny, however, was for action on the line of "surprise" suggested in Commodore Stockton's letter, by Gillespie, to General Kearny. So, while the main force went into camp for a miserable night, Kearny sent out a small party to reconnoitre.
That party at length reached the little Indian village at San Pasqual. There was the camp of Captain Pico, commander of the Californians. Dr. Coy says that this party had come south from Los Angeles originally to try to cut off a force which was supposed to have left San Diego for Santa Ysabel, but, not finding- that force, "had remained near San Diego, making headquarters at San Luis Rey and Santa Margarita. On the night of December 5, he had gone into camp at San Pasqual. Doctor Coy beheves that by this time he Iiad learned of the departure of the Gillespie party from San Diego and had directed his own course to try to cut that party off. At any rate, it appears that Kearny's reconnoitering party was detected by the Californians and hastily withdrew, returning as fast as possible to General Kearny's camp. Kearny, on hearing of the presence of the Californians at San Pasqual, decided to break camp and march upon the enemy. This description of the order of march is given "by Smythe in his chapter on the battle :
"First rode an advance guard of twelve men, on the best horses, imder Capt. Abraham R. Johnston. After them came General Kearny with Lieutenants William H. Emory and William H. Warner, of the engineers, and four or five of their men. Then Capt. Benjamin D. Moore and Lieutenant Hammond, with about fifty mounted dragoons. Next Captains Gillespie and Gibson, with twenty volunteers. Then Lieut. John W. Davidson, in charge of the artillery, with a few dragoons. The balance of the force, some fifty or sixty men, brought up the rear under Major Swords."
The Americans first saw the Californians from the top of a small "hill or rise above the little village of San Pasqual, when the enemy's camp-fires were still burning. Pico's men were ready for action and wdien the order to charge was given and Captain Johnston's men rushed down the slope, the Californians were drawn up in order. So well mounted were Johnston and his men, in comparison wnth the rest of Kearny's force, or at least with those immediately behind, that they soon were far in advance. The Californians apparently saw this, realized their advantage and stood fast. As the Americans came near, the Californians fired a volley and then waited with their lances set.
Captain Johnston fell dead at the first volley, a bullet having struck his head, and several others were wounded. That, however, was only the beginning, for Pico's men were expert with their lances and they began to use them with deadly eft'ect. the fighting soon resolving itself into a furious hand-to-hand conflict in which the American advance had serious trouble. Soon, however, the rest of Kearny's force reached the scene of conflict, and the Californians fled down the -valley, pursued by the Americans. Antonio M. Osio, a California writer, says, in his "Historia de California," that Pico was merely feigning flight to draw the Americans out. At any rate, the evidence available indicates that he was not lacking in generalship : for, when "he and his men had gone, about half a mile, they wheeled and waited to receive the oncoming Americans, again spread apart by reason of the differences in their mounts - some horses, some mules, and, doubtless, all worn out. The second engagement, like the first, was "brief and hard fought, and the Americans again got the \yorst of the encounter. Captain Moore was killed while fighting Pico himself, two of Pico's men rushing with their lances when Moore, having broken his sword, tried to use his pistol. Captain Gillespie was wounded and, it is recorded, was saved from Moore's fate only by shamming death as he lay on the ground, having been thrown from his horse. Gen. Kearny himself was wounded twice at this time. It is said that the Calif ornian who inflicted the wounds spared his life and that while at San Diego in later and peaceful days Gen. Kearny had his former adversary brought before him to receive appreciation for his brave and soldierly conduct. Such, it seems, was the chivalrous spirit of the times - something closely resembling that ascribed to the knights of long ago. Another such instance is that of Pico's conduct ; he is said to have watched his men carefully to see that none attacked a foe when unhorsed and helpless.
The Californians retreated again as soon as Kearny's full force arrived, but in their retreat took one of the howitzers which the Americans had brought with them. The mules which drew the gun became unmanageable and raced with the howitzer to the enemy, who seized both opportunity and cannon.
Kearny's force then went back to camp and "took stock." The report compiled was not cheering. He had lost about 20 killed and 15 .wounded; his official report, made later, set the number of American dead at 19, as follows :
Killed : Captains Johnston and ^Nloore ; Lieutenant Hammond ; Sergeants Moore and Whitness ; Corporals West and Ramsdale ; privates Ashmead, Campbell, Dunlop, Dalton, Lucky, Repsoll, Gholston, Fiel, and Gregory, of the dragoons, and Booker of the volunteers ; farrier Johnson ; and Menard of the engineers.
None of Pico's men seems to have been killed. Two of his force were taken prisoner. Several, at least, were wounded, but probably not more than ten or fifteen. Two days after the fight Gen. Kearny ofifered in a chivalrous way to send to Pico's camp Dr. John S. Griffin, surgeon of the American force, to care for Pico's wounded ; but this offer, says Smythe in an account of the affair, was declined, the Californian's leader declaring, in a spirit of bravado, that he had no wounded. Incidentally, Dr. Griffin remained for some time in San Diego when Kearny's men at last reached safety, land cared not only for the wounded of the American forces but for people of the town who needed medical assistance.
"Our provisions were exhausted, our horses dead, our mules on their last legs and our men, now reduced to one-third of their number, were ragged, worn out by fatigue and emaciated."
Kearny at first gave orders that the dead should be packed on mules and carried to San Diego, but it was soon found that there were not enough mules of service to carry both dead and wounded, so the dead - 18 at that time - were buried, while "a myriad of coyotes'' howled about the little band.
Then the Americans tried to get sadly needed rest, but the night was cold, the ground damp, hard and rocky. "Sleep was impossible," Emor}' wrote.
^Teanwhile Capt. H. S. Turner, who IkkI assumed command because of Gen. Kearny's condition, had sent Lieutenant (jodey and two or three men to Commodore Stockton with this letter :
Sir : I have the honor to report to you that at early dawn this morning General Kearny, with a detachment of the United States Dragoons and Captain Gillespie's Company of mounted riflemen, had an engagement with a very considerable Mexican force near this camp.
We have about eighteen killed and fourteen or fifteen wounded, several so severely that it may be impracticable to move them for several days. I have to suggest to you the propriety of disj)atching, without delay, a considerable force to meet us on the road to San Diego via the Soledad and San Bernardo, or some other means of transporting our wounded to San Diego. We are without provisions, and in our present situation find it impracticable to obtain cattle from the ranches in the vicinity.
General Kearny is among the wounded, but it is hoj)ed not dangerouslv ; Captains Moore and Johnston. First Dragoons, killed: Lieutenant Hammond. First Dragoons, dangerously wounded.
Early on the morning of December 7. Kearny, who was not badly wounded, resumed command and started his battered forces toward .San Diego, the Calif ornians harassing them at every o[)portunity. They reached the San F')ernardo ranch, however, and there got a few chickens, which were cooked for the wounded. lUit no grass was found for the horses and mules, so the Americans, seizing some cattle which they found there, went on toward the San Bernardo river bed. The Californians then swept in and captured the cattle which the Americans had just taken. The Californians also threatened Kearny '.s men to such a degree that Emory says the Americans were "convinced that if we attempted ativ further progress with the aiubulances we must lose our sick and- our packs." So camp was made in as good a position as possible, the decision being to await reinforcements from Stockton. It appeared to the .Americans that the number of Californians was increasing rapidly. Not knowing, of course, what Godey's fate had been. Kearny decided to try to send another appeal to Stockton. For this hazardous task three volunteers were selected. One was Lieutenant Beale. the navy ofticer, who, it will be remembered, had been wounded. .Another was the redoubtable Kit Carson, made famous later in volumes of facts and fiction. The third was an Indian. Panto, no less brave than the others, even though one name must suffice for him, in this narrative. It was what Senator Benton later described as "a forlorn hope." Yet these .Americans - one a navy officer, living to the highest degree, up to the traditions of his branch of the service, the second a noted scout, and the third a humble Indian, doubtless trained in the arts of warfare of that time - all went at the job like heroes. It was not a great battle, as has been said before, and it was not vastly important in a military way, but this incident of the whole affair raised it above the common-place and left in the swiftly moving scenes of American history a picture of real inspiration. They started with almost no food, though keenly hungry. They had to get through a cordon of well trained, acute foes who seemed to know every dimple of the landscape. Their journey was to be no short one and through cruelly rough and rock territory of which only the Indian knew much. Yet they went, and gladly, and won their way to the end. They were men - Americans all.
Off the three went in the darkness, creeping to the hostile line of sentinels, squirming so close that they could smell the smoke of the cigarettes smoked by the hardy and no less brave Calif ornians. The navy officer, Beale, it is related, at one time thought that secrecy iio longer could win and that they must run and try to dash through. So he pressed Kit Carson with his hand and whispered his advice. The noted scout, however, whispered back to be patient, proclaimed his confidence in Providence, which, he said, had served him in tighter places, and convinced his companion that they would get through. And the three separated and went to San Diego by different paths. Pick three dift'erent paths "across lots" to San Diego from that spot today, with the advantage of good roads and with friendly lights shining for miles from a hospitable city. Imagine three men beating their way in even with all these advantages and place alongside your mental picture that of these three men. Then you will begin to realize what they did. For the seventy-five years that have gone by have not smoothed out greatly that vast roughness ; the great earth gashes are just as deep as those canyons of 1846; the scrubby undergrowth is just as likely to scratch and tear; while roads have been made and bridges built and sign posts put up every few miles or so, the way "across lots" is still hard. And the coyotes still yelp dismally.
Godey, it seems, gave verbal report, on December 7, having buried his letter from Kearny when capture seemed imminent. Beale was nearly dead when he arrived on December 9, and after telling his story went into a delirium. The Indian Panto had got to San Diego only a short time before Beale. Carson was the last of the three to arrive. From them all, doubtless, the story was gleaned and patched together. And Commodore Stockton did all he could. Let us eliminate details and controversies regarding delay and tempting social affairs which some say caused delav in relief for Kearny. Stockton sent 215 sailors and marines who had been drilling on Presidio Hill. They took one field piece. Lieutenant Andrew F. A". Gray of the Congress was in command. Lieut. Jacob Zeilin was in command of the marines. It will be noticed that in those days as now, the marines were "on the job."
They were besieged, yet by a gallant foe who proposed and eft'ected exchange of prisoners. They captured a fat mule from Pico, shot him, cooked him and ate him. Sergeant Cox, wounded, died and was buried. He had married a pretty girl at Leavenworth, as all the command knew, and they felt the loss not only for themselves but for the girl left l^ehind. There was little to cheer them all. Yet the wounded, on whom Doctor Griffin, the surgeon, worked long and hard, improved rapidly. And General Kearny, doubtless studying the situation every minute, decided on the night of December 10 that he could move his force the next day. Doctor Griffin, in fact, reported that the woimded could stand the attempt. So they lay down for another night. Let Lieutenant Emory's diary tell the next incident :
"We were all reposing quietly, but not sleeping, waiting for the break of day, when we were to go down and give the enemy another defeat. One of the men. in the part of the camp assigned to my defense, reported that he heard a man speaking in English. In a few minutes we heard the tramp of a column, followed by the hail of the sentinel. It was a detachment of 100 tars and eighty marines under Lieutenant Gray, sent to meet us by Commodore Stockton, from whom we learned that Lieutenant IJeale, Carson and the Indian had arrived safely in San Diego. The detachment left San Diego on the night of the 9th, cached themselves during the day of the 10th and joined us on the night of that day. These gallant fellows busied themselves till day distributing their i^rovisions and clothes to our naked and hungry people."
The arrival of the relief force, ably directed, ended the "battle". The Californians retreated to the north. Kearny's command and the sailors and marines marched unmolested into San Diego. They arrived on December 12. Picture the welcome for yourself.
This practically ended the Mexican war as far as San Diego was concerned. The official end came about a month later, to be exact, Jan. 13, 1847, when the treaty of peace was signed by John C. Fremont and Andres Pico, four davs after the battle of San Gabriel.
There have been many arguments concerning Kearny's judgment. Some historians have been caustic on adverse criticism. Some have been lenient. A fair verdict seems to be this : he did his best, perhaps being obliged to depend on advice which did not turn out to be right.
The brightest spot of it all, at anv rate, was the accomplishment of the navv men - especiallv Lieutenant Beale - of Kit Carson and the Indinn Panto.
Doctor Coy's report says that Lieutenant l^mory's '"exceedingly valuable" map, made later, was remarkably good, although lacking a scale of miles, and that it contained "only one serious defect." failure to place accurately the San Bernardo River. Still, the toiX)grapiiy is. as Doctor Coy says, "somewhat deceiving to one v/ho has not had ODnortunitv to examine it carefully," as Doctor Coy did. Doctor Cov concludes thus : there can be but little doubt that the sites of the three engagements can be located with all the accuracy required in cavalry battles such as these were, and that the land accepted by the State of California as a gift from William G. Henshaw and Col. Ed. Fletcher under the provisions of the statutes of 1919, chapter 172, is the true site of the battle of Dec. 6, 1846."
"Many methods have been suggested as suitable means of marking this battle site. Probably the best is that prepared by Col. Ed. Fletcher, one of the donors of the site, who recommends the construction of a community house built of adobe and tile, with a suitable boulder marked and placed in a good location in front of the building, with a tablet calling attention to the event commemorated. An inscription either upon the boulder or on the walls of the home itself should give the names of those killed and wounded. Action of this character on the part of the state would not only mark the spot but also encourage the local people to care for the surrounding landmarks. Assurance has been given that, should the state see fit to make a small appropriation toward a suitable memorial, the remainder would be raised within the county."
According to records at Fort Rosecrans, sixteen non-commissioned officers and privates who were killed in the battle of San Pasqual were buried in a trench at the military cemetery on Point Loma. The San Diego Union of July 18, 1906, tells of the discovery of the old records and continues :
"It appears that the bodies were temporarily buried on the battlefield and they were afterwards taken up and buried at Old Town, in a plot of ground donated for that purpose by J. A. Sutherland. From there the bodies were taken to Fort Rosecrans military cemetery to the final resting place."
General Kearny was born in Newark, N. J., August 30, 1794. At the outbreak of the War of 1812 he was in Columbia University and left to go into the service. He was promoted for bravery and remained in the army after the war ended. For his services in the Mexican War he received the brevet of major-general December 6, 1846, and was made Governor of California, holding that place until the next June. Then he was sent to Mexico and was made military and civil governor of Vera Cruz. He died at St. Louis, October 31, 1848, of an illness which had begun in Mexico. He published a "Manual of the Exercise and Maneuvers of the U. S. Dragoons" in 1837, and "Laws for the Government of the Territory of New Mexico," in 1846.
Stockton, like Kearny, was from New Jersey. Also, like Kearny, he was a student when the War of 1812 began. Stockton was at Princeton, his birthplace, and entered the service as a midshipman in 1811, while still enrolled at Princeton. The next year he went to the famous old frigate President and made several cruises in that ship. Later he commanded 300 sailors in the defense of Baltimore against the British army, was commended for his work and was promoted to lieutenant in 1814. The next year he sailed with Decatur and took part in the war on Algerian pirates. It is recorded that he fought several duels on the Mediterranean station with British officers and distinguished himself on one occasion by a bold escape after he had wounded his adversary. Stockton was commander of the gunboat Princeton when one of its large guns burst and killed the Secretary of State, Secretary of the Navy and several others, including President Tyler's father-in-law, in 1844, but a naval court of in([uiry jiromptly exonerated him ; and soon after that disaster he sailed in command of the Princeton to bear annexation resolutions to the government of Texas. In October, 1846, he was sent to the Pacific to command the Pacific squadron and relieved Commander Sloat at Monterey. In July, 1846, he assumed command of all American forces on the Pacific coast and, after organizing his forces, sent Fremont in the Cyane to San Diego. Meanwhile he marched with a navy brigade upon Los Angeles, occupying that place, August 13. Trouble with the Indians in the north compelled him to leave, with the result that the Mexicans in the south took Los Angeles and San Diego back. Stockton came south, his forces took San Diego back, and later, having brought all his forces in the south together, Stockton defeated the Mexicans and took all of California. Kearny and Stockton had a disi)ute as to authority, but Stockton's course was upheld. In 1847 he returned home overland, receiving many honors. For him the town of Stockton in the state was named. Fort Stockton Boulevard in San Diego was also named to mark his stay here. Stockton died at Princeton, N. J., October 7, 1866.
There has been considerable argument over the respective merits of Stockton and Kearny. In this Stockton seems to have decidedly the better of it. An interesting contemporary comment on the question was made by William Heath Davis, who wrote that he regarded Stockton as "the real conqueror of California" and attached high value to Stockton's ability, foresight and judgment. He contrasted these attributes with the qualities shown by Kearny in his fight at San Pasqual and expressed with considerable force his opinion that the "striking contrast,'' as he put it, was all in favor of Stockton.
Chapter Vii Picturesque Old Town
From the present-day aspect of "Old Town," the birthplace of San Diego, it is hard to realize that ever, in this drowsy suburb of the modern city, the gayety and animation, the zest of living- and the romance of vSpanish California days held sway. Yet the records of many travelers show that San Diego was once among the liveliest of the California towns, a center of amusement and hospitality for all the territor)^ between Los Angeles and Real del Castillo, Baja California.
The history of those early days shows that San Diego occupied a position of considerable political and social importance in California life, and there is ample evidence that Old Town had its share of all that was gay and picturesque in the Spanish regime which forms the most colorful chapter in California's history.
Indeed, there are some San Diegans yet living who recall incidents and customs as picturesque as any chronicled by the California historians of other parts.
It is interesting, therefore, to attempt to reconstruct the Old Town - the San Diego - of the later days of California regime and the early period of American colonization.
San Diego was larger, more important and more lively after the Mexican war than it had been under the Mexican or Californian rule which just preceded. At that time - in the '50s and '60s - the social relations between the enterprising Americans and the best California families were pleasant, while in the homes of many of the Americans the customs of life were much the same as in the homes of the better class of Californian families. The intermingling of the nationalities apparently added much to the gayety of San Diego life - certainly it did not in any way impair its brilliance.
It is of this time - while the old customs of the Spanish regime still held sway, and while the pioneer American families of San Diego were beginning to make themselves felt in the city's life - that this chapter treats.
The Old Town of those days, however unimpressive it may be in comparison with the cities of our time, was a much more attractive place than a casual visitor to the region today might believe it.
The plaza was, of course, a center of the little city's life. In the time of which we write, it was nearly surrounded by stores and residences, only a few of which remain today. It was gradually built tip, until in the '60s the mercantile houses nearly covered one block, the block east of the plaza, and made up a good proportion of the building west of the square.
South of the ])laza, the Estudillo house stood, occupying the entire frontage of that block, as it does today. The Bandini house stood in its present location, just east of the Estudillo home - known today as "Ramona's Marriage Place." In an enclosure betwen these two houses a flour mill was started by a man named Hoffman, and there was often a line of wagons and carts from the ranches standing in this end of the plaza, during harvest time, with grain for milling.
Dona Tomasa Pico Alvarado, a sister of Pio and Andres Pic(3, had a large adobe house on the corner just north of the liandini house, and Juan Machado, an influential citizen, lived next to the Alvarado home. There were several store buildings on the same street, fronting on the plaza, while on the eastern half of the block, around the store that Mannasse and Schiller owned, were several more. South of the Estudillo establishment, two wealthy Spanish traders, Jose Antonio Aguirre and Miguel Pedrorena, had their stores. "Ramona's }klarriage Place," in its present state, is, according to old residents of the town, no more pretentious than were several of the other pri\ate residences in the days of Old Town's prosperity.
These homes have disappeared with the march of the years, or are in ruins today. When an adobe house was abandoned, stripped of the tiles which covered its roof and of the lumber used in its construction, its disintegration was a rapid process, and this fact accounts for the lack of tangible evidence of Old Town's palmy days. Some of the "big houses" of the '50s are now nothing but irregular, grass-grown mounds of earth.
The town itself, then, during this middle period, was by no means insignificant. It had a goodly number of the more pretentious residences of the Spanish type, and the Americans, often in partnership with their Californian friends, built several frame buildings of a type which w^as regarded by San Diegans of that time as more modern and elaborate. A small example of this type of building is the old "Congress Hall,'' now standing near the northeast corner of the plaza, adjoining the Murtha estate.
The San Diego of those days was bordered on the west by the bed of the San Diego River, which then ran directly into the harbor, and the river willows and sycamores which grew in the "wash" formed a boundary for ihe little farms which were cultivated along the (»utskirts of the town.
It must be remembered, too, that the social and business life of old San Diego was not dependent solely upon the people who lived' within the settlement itself. Tributary to it also were at least a score of great ranchos and many small ones, scattered about within a radius of seventy or a hundred miles - from San Juan Capistrano to Cuyamaca, Tecate and San Rosario. Most of the owners of the great ranchos lived in San Diego, and probably all of them had relatives in the town and transacted all their business there. Any big event in San Diego brought these pr()j)rietors, their families and many of their employes riding into the town, although in some cases the trip from rancho to the town required several days of traveling.
With this in mind, it is easy to believe the accounts of the great fiestas in old San Diego, some of which have assumed almost the status of legends among the old inhabitants of the present-day town.
The architecture of the typical California ''big house" has been too often described to need detailed treatment here. The restored Estudillo house is doubtless a good reproduction of the old mansion house, except that it is considerably idealized. The patio or courtyard of the house in the days of its usage was not a bovver of flowers. In the court were the outdoor ovens, used by the Indian cook some 360 days of the year. At the rear of the court were stable buildings, perhaps, and corrals, and it is not reasonable to suppose that the Spanish residents of those days were any more exacting, aesthetically, than are their descendants of today. There was always, of course, a garden spot in the residences of the higher class, where the women might sit in the sun with their friends and enjoy the air.
There were many homes humbler than that represented by the Estudillo place which, nevertheless, were entirely respectable and maintained social recognition for their residents. Several examples of these smaller houses remain today.
A fairly complete floor plan of such a dwelling may be traced in the ruins of the adobe house that once was the residence of Dona Juanita Machado de Wrightington. The ruins stand just across the boulevard from the northwest corner of the plaza, only the walls of the two front rooms remaining.
To the left of the entrance is a small living room, where the chimney of the crude fireplace may still be seen. The street door gives entrance directly to a larger room, which was used as a dining room and which also had a fireplace. Directly opposite the front door of the little house was a door into the court at the back, which was formed by the angle of the front part of the house with a wing which extended back from the north side of the house. In this wing were two bedrooms and a kitchen. The kitchen opened directly into the court, where outdoor ovens were probably used ; and to pass from the kitchen to the dining room it was necessary to cross an angle of the open court.
This house is supposed to have been built by Domasio Alipas in about 1830-35. Dona Wrightington, who lived there during the most populous period of the town, was the daughter of Juan Machado, arid as he seems to have been a man of considerable prominence, the fact of her residence there shows that the house was at least an average middle-class dwelling.
During the '50s and '60s there were several hotel buildings situated near the plaza. The Bandini house, in its present state, gives a general idea of the architecture of these buildings, as it was remodeled into a hotel by A. L. Seeley who owned the stage line from the north. The broad porch along two sides of the building was a typical feature.
The Gila house was one of the most famous of these hotels, and was for several years a center of the social gayeties that marked the American-Californian period. It was built by Juan Bandini, and, unlike the Bandini house, was entirely a frame structure. Old-timers remember it as a large frame building, oblong in shape, and about 200 feet long by fifty feet wide. The verandas extended the entire length of the building on two sides, and across the front. It was a twostory building, and each floor had a veranda entirely around three sides of it.
The kitchens were in an adobe house a Httle to the left of the main building, and during meal hours the waiters jogged leisurely back and forth between the two buildings. Lumber for the house was brought " 'round the Horn," in about 1850. After the fire which swept the plaza buildings in 1872, the Gila house was wrecked for the lumber in it, which is said to have been of a very high class.
It was in this curiously composite town - a town built up partly of adobe residences of the old style, and partly of brick and frame buildings of the fashion that was then new - that the scene of one of San Diego's most interesting periods was laid.
The town, in spite of the flag Which flew above its plaza, was still Spanish. The old Spanish families of importance - the Bandinis, Estudillos, Picos, Arguellos and many more - still made up the most respected and influential, and the wealthiest, portion of the population. On the other hand, mingling with them on equal tenns, intermarrying with them, and at least equally important with them in the business life of San Diego, were the American pioneers who were laying the foundation for the A.merican city of today.
The social life and customs of San Diego in this interesting period were thoroughly Spanish. The Americans entered into this life and lived according to these Spanish customs. It was in the business sphere that the Americans first began to make Old Town American. Even politics was still dominated by the old Spanish forms, and, it may be said, by the old Spanish spirit of *'manana."
In the homes of the Spanish inhabitants, particularly those of the better class, the day was planned, meals served, and recreation and work carried on just as it had been fifty years before. The elders of the family ruled - ruled through strict laws of courtesy, it is true, but ruled the family nevertheless strictly.
Social intercourse began with the hour of rising, early in the morning, (iuests were as common at breakfast as at the other meals of the day, except in those families where the business duties of the head of the house called for his early departure. In such cases, visitors made their social calls at the family place of business, dropping in for a cup of coffee and a chat with the proprietor - if they so desired - in the early morning.
The first meal of the day varied, in the different households. In some, the first meal was in the nature of the French "i)ctit dejeuner" - a cup of coffee and a tortilla, or a spiced cake. In other homes, a regular meal was served, with a dish, or several of them, of highly seasoned meat, as the principal course.
A favorite dish was the "gisado de carne seca" - a meat gravy made by braising dried meat into shreds and cooking it in a rich gravy with tomatoes, onions and green chili. This gravy was known to the Americans as "chili gravy," from its principal seasoning, and formed a staple breakfast dish and a "base," so to speak, for many other preparations.
Tamales were also a staple form, and for breakfast they were often made of green corn, thoroughly macerated and cooked without meat. These were "sweet tamales." Children usually had boiled com meal or fresh corn, mashed and boiled and served with sugar and milk.
"Enchilladas" for breakfast use were made by piling up a stack of tortillas, each covered with a layer of grated cheese and finely sliced onion tops, and covering the entire pile with hot chili gravy. Each tortilla was served separately, with generous "helping" of the gravy.
Coffee was the usual beverage, but chocolate or milk was sometimes used. There was no bread used at breakfast in the Spanish families, even in the "middle period" of which this chapter treats The tortilla, a thin, unraised griddle cake, cooked usually to a crisp, took the place of bread.
At noon, another heavy meal was served. Again tamales might be put upon the table, this time made of meal with chili pepper, meat - either beef or chicken - chopped onions, and perhaps two or three water-cured olives added. The form of the tamale is familiar to most San Diegans and visitors in Southern California. The filling or body of the tamale consists of the corn meal or meat, and is wrapped about with corn husks tied at the ends, and the whole thing is cooked together by boiling.
Beans, fried in chili gravy with ham or pork, formed a favorite dish, and they also figured prominently in many other meat preparations. Game was abundant around San Diego at that time, and rabbits and quail were often served at noon or at night. Baked or roast fish was also used. Several kinds of meat were usually served at each meal.
Salads were sometimes served, but were usually made with a good deal of meat, rather than simply of vegetables. A sort of salad was made by pouring cold chili gravy over water-cured ripe olives, and adding a sauce of which the principal ingredients were chopped onions and vinegar.
Meat pies were common, the filling being always highly seasoned with pepper, chili, onions, garlic and sometimes with chopped olives. As American cooking become known, pumpkin, apple and raisin pies were sometimes served in the California households. Meat balls - "albondigas" - made of finely chopped meat with corn meal and chili, were also popular. The albondigas were boiled in soup, the meal thickening the soup, and the soup serving to add flavor to the meat.
The evening meal did not differ greatly from the dinner at noon. Desserts - corn meal puddings, tortillas fried crisp and covered with syrup or a sweet sauce, and various fruits or melons - were served at these meals. Several kinds of cakes and pastries were also used as desserts.
Fish sauces were sometimes made with wine, and brandy was used in making certain sauces for puddings. Sometimes rare wines were served with seafood dishes, particularly with roast mussels.
At ceremonial dinners, the menu was varied by the introduction of delicacies of various kinds, preserves, jellies, candies - many of them imported - and venison, roast pig or barbecued meat was often served - always, of course, with the rather heavy seasoning which characterized the Spanish cuisine. A favorite barbecue consisted of the heads of young beeves, cooked over night in closed pits lined wnth hot stones. When the beeves' heads were taken from the pits, they were so w-ell done that the meat fell from the bone, and this meat was served with chili gravy and garnishes.
While breakfast was being prepared in the morning, the life of the little town began. Serving women and cooks passed from one courtyard to another. In the courtyards of the big houses, horses were groomed for the day's journeyings. Vendors of water - two men carrying a twenty-gallon can of water on a pole between them - visited the homes where no private well w'as available, asking a price of twenty-five cents for their load.
Even among the wealthy families, it was not uncommon to exchange "breakfast visits." A family setting out on a trip to one of the outlying ranchos would sometimes drive only a short distance up the street to the home of another family, get out, pay their respects to their friends, and incidentally accept a wholesale invitation to partake of breakfast before leaving on their journey.
This animation continued until after the noon meal, when the Californians, even in the davs of American ascendancy, enjoyed the "siesta" typical of Spanish life. The hours before the evening meal were the family hours, when the women plied their needles, gave the children the instruction which constituted an education in those days, or otherwise occupied themselves about the house. The dinner at night was the occasion of more social visits between neighbors. Some families, after a luncheon in the afternoon, did not serve dinner until eight o'clock or so, in the evening, making that meal the social event of the day.
When a dance was planned, preparations for the feast to ])recede it began early in the day - perhaps, in the case of big gatherings, several days ahead of the date set - and the house and grounds where the event was to be held was a gathering place for the poorer people of the town and for the children. W'hen such an event was to be held, according to ore old resident of the town, the Spanish families did not feel visits from friends an intrusion, and neighbors of the host of the evening would come in great state to inspect nreparatinns for the "baile."
The ranchos about San Diego, as has alread)- been stated, added a great deal to the animation of the little town. Picturesque cavalcades of rancheros enlivened the streets when the ranchmen came to the town to buv supplies or to amuse themselves. When the owner of a rancho came to Old .*^an Diego, attended. ])erhaps. by two or three of his horsemen, he rode up to the home n\ one of his friends, he and his companions dismounted and gave their horses to an attendant, and the ranchero was formalh- met at the doorwav bv the head of the family to which he wished to pay his respects. Perhaps the visitor would remain only for a few words of formal greeting and the exchange of interesting news. Perhaps he might accept the invariable invitation to remain for a meal wnth the family, before passing on to visit the next family of his acquaintance.
A visit to the rancho by the family of a ranch owner living in San Diego was an event of considerable importance. As late as 1855, the ox-cart - ''carreta" - was the common mode of conveyance for women and children making a journey, and the progress through the town of two or three of these carretas. lined with soft blankets and covered with bright cloths to shield its occupants from the sun, brought crowds of spectators, large and small, from every home.
Angelo Smith, son of the A. B. Smith whose flag-raising exploit for Commodore Stockton and whose services as a guide for the American troops in the Mexican War period have already been mentioned, is one of the old residents of Old Town at the present time whose recollections of these early times are remarkably clear and enlightening. Mr. Smith, now seventy years old, was born in old San Diego.
"They would stop sometimes twenty times before they got out of the town," said Mr. .Smith, describing the progress of one of these miniature caravans, "and at each place where they stopped the people would invite them in. Sometimes the travelers did not go in, of course, and then the neighbors would visit with them for a time, wish them all manner of good wishes, salute them very courteously and wave farewells to them.
"Sometimes it was several days' journey, by the carretas, to an outlying ranch, but the travelers always went slowly and easily, stopping wdien they chose. One man walked ahead of each team of oxen, and one man walked behind the team, to prod them on with long goads. The party would often stop over night or for meals or the siesta, with the family of some ranchero on the road. Sometimes the travelers had an extra carreta filled with bedding, cooking materials and other camping necessities, and then they would camp wherever they pleased, on their w^ay to the rancho."
In the early days of the industry in tallow and hides, when the American commercial firms, notably that of Mannasse & Schiller, marketed the products of the ranchos for the less business-like Californian rancheros, the semi-annual collection days of the store keepers added another picturesque feature to San Diego life.
Mannasse & Schiller practiced a liberal policy of credit toward the rancheros, selling large bills of goods and allowing payment to be made in cattle, t\\ice a year.
The collectors of those days w-ere different in type from the tactful talkers who collect bills today. They were vaqueros, riding about in charge of a foreman from the San Diego store to each of the ranchos which had been charged with bills of goods. At each rancho the foreman would present the store's bill, bargain with the ranchero on the number of cattle to be sent in, and the vaqueros would "cut out" the required number of cattle and drive them away. When a
Sometimes the semi-annual collection for Mannasse & Schiller alone would require two or three weeks, and the droves of cattle would be herded each day into the corrals especially built by the merchants just east of their store. The advent of the wild cattle from the ranchos, with the horsemanship and striking garb of the vaqueros, made these events and other similar ones interesting to all the people of the little town.
Although at the time - the middle period of San Diego's history - the colorful costume of the Spanish period was being somewhat sobered by contact with the less picturesque American garb, the Tanchmen. their vaqueros and the prominent Spanish people of San Diego still dressed in the Spanish fashion, and this fashion was the ceremonial dress of the Californians at any considerable social event, and was worn, with modifications, by some of the Americans.
William Heath Davis, in his invaluable work, "Sixty Years in California," describes in detail the dress of one of the Californian Tancheros :
"When the rancheros ihus rode about, during the leisure season, which was between the marking time and the matanza or killing time, and from the end of the matanza to the spring time again, the more wealthy of them were generally dressed in a good deal of style, with short breeches extending to the knee, ornamented with gold or silver lace at the bottom, with botas (leggings) below, made of fine soft deer skin, well tanned and finished, richly colored, and stamped with "beautiful devices (these articles having been imported from Mexico, where they were manufactured), and tied at the knee with a silk cord, two or three times wound around the leg, with heavy gold or silver tassels hanging below the knee. They wore long vests, with filagree buttons of gold or silver, while those of more ordinary means had them of brass. They wore no long coats, but a kind of jacket of good length, most generally of dark blue cloth, also adorned with filagree buttons. Over that was the long scrape or poncho, made in Mexico and imported from there, costing from $20 to $100, according to the quality of the cloth and the richness of the ornamentation. The serape and the poncho were made in the same way as to size and cut of the garments, but the former was of coarser texture than the latter, and of a variety of colors and patterns, while the poncho was of dark blue or black cloth, of finer ([uality. generally broadcloth. The seraf)e was always plain, while the ponclio was heavily trimmed with gold or silver fringe around the edges, and a little the collars around the shoulders. They wore hats imported from Mexico and Peru, generally stitT, the finer quality of softer material - becuna. a kind of heavy beaver skin obtained in those -countries. Their saddles were silver-mounted, embroidered with silver or gold, the bridle heavily mounted with silver, and the reins made of the most select hair of the horse's mane, and at a distance of every foot or so there was a link of silver connecting the different parts together. The tree of the saddle was similar to that now in use by the Spaniards, and covered with the mochila. which was of leather. It extended beyond the saddle to the shoulders of the horse in front and back to the flank, and downwards on either side, half w^ay between the rider's knee and foot. This was plainly made, sometimes stamped with ornamental figures on the side and sometimes without stamping. Over this was the coraza, a leather covering of finer texture, a little larger and extending beyond the mochila all around, so as to completely cover it. It was elaborately stamped with handsome ornamental devices. Behind the saddle, and attached thereto, was the anquera, of leather, of half-moon shape, covering the top of the hindquarters of the horse, but not reaching to the tail; which was also elaborately stamped with figures and lined with sheep skin, the wool side next to the horse. This was an ornament, and also a convenience in case the rider chose to take a person behind him on the horse. Frequently some gallant young man would take a lady on the horse with him, putting her in the saddle in front and himself riding on the anquera behind. The stirrups were cut out of a solid block of wood, about two and a half inches in thickness. They were very large and heavy. The straps were passed through two holes near the top to attach it to the stirrup ; so that when the foot was placed in the stirrup the tapadera was in front, concealed it, and protected the foot of the rider from the brush and brambles in going through the woods.
"This was the saddle for everyday use of the rancheros and vaqueros, that of the former being somewhat nicer and better finished. The reins for everyday use were made of deer or calfskin or other soft leather, cut in thin strips and nicely braided and twisted together, and at the end of the reins was attached an extra piece of the same with a ring, which was used as a whip. Their spurs were inlaid with gold or silver, and the straps of the spurs worked with silver and gold thread.
"When thus mounted and fully equipped, these men presented a magnificent appearance, especially on the feast days of the saints, which were celebrated at the Missions. Then they w'ere arrayed in their finest and most costly habiliments and their horses in their gayest and most expensive trappings. They were usually large, well developed men, and presented an imposing aspect. The outfit of a ranchero and his horse, thus equipped, I have known to cost several thousand dollars."
This was the costume which, although less common than formerly on the streets of Old San Diego, added brilliance to the fiesta days and color to the spectacles of bull fight and baile. .\.ngelo Smith, to whom reference has already been made, described this typical Californian costume recentl}^ in detail, adding that it was a common type of clothing in his boyhood days.
The dress of the women were often extremelv handsome, the brilliant colors in which they delighted being tempered by the richness of the materials available to the wealthy families.
In the early days of the American occupation, the houses of lose Antonio Aguirre and Miguel Pedrorena still imported rich silks and other fabrics from the Philippines Avhich were very popular with women of the richer class. It is related that the two merchants
Much has been written about the beauty and attractiveness of the women of old California - qualities which seem to have been striking to most of the pioneer Americans who have left records of their impressions of the people of that time. A few paragraphs of Mr. Davis' account may be of interest:
"During my long and intimate acquaintance with Califoniians, I have found the women as a class much brighter, ([uicker in their perception, and generally smarter than the men. Their husbands often times looked to them for advice and directions in their general business affairs. The people had but limited opportunities for education. As a rule they were not much educated ; but they had abundant instinct and native talent, and the women were full of natural dignity and self-possession; they talked well and intelligently, and appeared to much better advantage than might have been supposed from their meagre educational facilities. The families of the wealtliier classes had more or less education ; their contact with the foreiljn population was an advantage to them in this respect.
women were exceedingly clean and neat in their houses and persons and in all their domestic arrangements. One of their peculiarities was the excellence and neatness of their beds and bedtling, which were often elegant in appearance, highly and tastefullv ornamented, the coverlids and pillow cases being sometimes of satin and trimmed v/ith beautiful and costly lace. The women were plainly and becomingly attired, were not such devotees of fashion as at the i)resent day, and did not indulge in jewelry to excess.
"The Mexican as well as the California ladies were noted for their siuall feet and hands, which is a characteristic of the Spanish race. The Mexican ladies when smoking w^ere in the habit of holding the cigarito between the thumb and finger ; the rich using a gt)ld or siKer holder, to prevent staining the fingers with the tobacco, and the poorer classes a holder made of gamuza, or fine deer skin - with two little pockets, into which they slipped the thimib and finger. Holding up the cigarito, as they ])laced it in the mouth or removed it, they displayed their little hands to advantage, the fingers extended with an air of coquetry, all very graceful and bect)ming, and (|uite captivating to the observer.
"I was astonished at the endurance of the California women in holding out. night after night, in dancing, of which they never seemed to weary, but kept on with an appearance of freshness and elasticity that was as charming as surprising. Their actions, movements and bearing were as full of life and animation after several nights of dancing as at the beginning, while the men. on the other hand, became wearied, showing that their powers of endurance were not e(|ual to those of the ladies. I have frequently heard the latter ridiculing the gentlemen for not holding out unfatigued to the end of a festi\al of this kind.
"Notions of propriety and morality were so strict among the people that voung people engaged to be married were permitted little association hv themselves. Thev were scarcelv allowed to see each other or to converse together, except in the presence of their parents. This was mv own experience in an engagement of over two years. The courtship was usually arranged by the mother of the young lady, or sometimes a favorite aunt was sought and first consulted by the young gentleman who desired the daughter or niece in marriage. If the suitor was considered a worthy person by the father, the young lady was communicated with, after which a request in writing came from the young man to the father. If the application was deemed satisfactory he sent a written reply. Time, however, was taken for consideration, and no haste displayed. It would be an excellent thing if, in this respect, the old Spanish custom, having .so much of simplicity and purity, prevailed today. Although the young ladies were not so highly educated as at the present time, yet on going into a family one could see at a glance that artlessness, afifection and modesty were the characteristics of the feminine portion thereof, and these merits in my estimation transcend all others.''
Of amusements there were many. As a frontier post and the center of a large area of "new" territory, old San Diego provided entertainment for hundreds who did not live within the borders of the town. Old San Diego brought guests and performers to it on the occasion of each of the numerous feast days or fiesta seasons, while for the more private festivities provided by one of the prominent families, it was not uncommon for guests to come a hundred miles to take part.
The ordinary amusement resorts of a frontier town were, of course, not lacking in early San Diego. Although the Californians are described by Davis, Alfred Robinson and others of the early settlers among them as a very temperate people, there were several saloons, in the '50s and '60s which did a good business. Congress Hall was one of them. The building still stands, just north of the northeast corner of the plaza, and is now used as a residence.
The "Jolly House," which was later used as a chapel and is now used as a kindergarten, was one of the most famous. It is still standing near the new schoolhouse. It is an adobe building, but is somewhat changed in form from its early plan and has been entirely enclosed in a wooden sheath. It is now pointed out as a former church, and at its west end is the frame on which the last of the famous mission bells once hung.
Provenance
Text from City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.