San Diego, California - City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California (part 5 of 13)
From City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. 15,879 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
8 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,879 wordsMachine-read from scans of City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
"'Sir. Horton's first house in San Diego was one which William Heath Davis had brought irom the east. One of these houses was used as Dunnells' Hotel. His second was down near where the gas w^orks now are - \vay down there. Mr. Horton then built at Tenth and G streets : that was an English cottage. He had a whole block for his residence. Thos. L. Nesmith had this house later, and after that it was moved to Second and Beech streets. The second residence he built for himself in San Diego was erected in 1873 and was at Sixth and A streets. It cost $5,000. He later built a house of twelve rooms at First and Fir streets and still later another at State and Olive streets in ^^liddletown and it had eleven rooms."
Before The Boom
In 1870 the Federal census gave the County of San Diego a population of 4,951. The population of the new city at that particular time has been variously estimated, the figures ranging from "nearly 3,000" down to about 2,300. Perhaps the total was nearly 2,500. It kept increasing with the hope that the Texas & Pacific Railroad would
The Old Courthouse
THE OLD COURTHOUSE On Broadway between Front and Union streets. Photograph by Parker & Parker in Chamber of Coniincrce booklet issued in 1874. The old building forms the central part of the present courthouse.
be built through by Thomas A. Scott, as told in another chapter of this book; but, with the failure of that plan in 1873 and despite hopes held until about 1878 that the Scott plan would mlaterialize after all, the population dwindled or stood still, and progress was slow. The Federal census of 1880 gave San Diego County 8,618 population and the new city 2,637. The assessed valuation of the county in 1870 was $4,480,456. In 1880, ten vears later, it had grown to onlv $4,995,469.
in that year; the total was $11,707,737. A large part of that growth was due of course to the coming here of the Santa Fe Railroad, through its local connection, the California Southern ; that railroad development is set forth in some detail elsewhere in this book. In 1890 the population of the city was 16,156, despite the loss sustained after the collapse of the "big boom," which ended in 1888. The county's population meanwhile had grown to 34,987.
San Diego had grown to be a city of some consequence. The boom brought it many improvements, but San Diego's progress was not due by any means to that alone. That healthy progress was easily discernible as early as 1885, as shown by this editorial comment in the San Diego Union, early in 1886:
"In point of fact, a great transformation is taking place. The new buildings, both in the business and residence sections of the city, are beginning to outnumber the old ones. The character of these imijrovcmients, too, in style of architecture and cost of construction, is notably superior. We are building for years and not for days. The work now being done bears the stamp of permanence. During 1855 there were erected 219 business and residence buildings, at a total cost, in round numbers, of $769,000. Nearly all of this construction was in the last half of the year, and a very large proportion of the capital thus invested was brought here from abroad. * :;= * jj-ig change in the outward appearance of San Diego is not more remarkable than that in the population of the city. The new comers decidedly outnumber the okl residents. One who had been absent for a year, returning today, might fancy himself in a strange place, he would meet so many new faces on the streets and in the public places. '-'' * '-' A spirit of activity is in the very air in which live men move, and San Diego is full of live men today."
As early as 1870 an attempt was made in San Diego to furnish gas for lighting. The attempt failed, although machinery was installed at some expense, and there was no renewal of the effort until
1881, when the San Diego Gas Company was formed. The incorporators were O. S. Witherby, George A. Cowles, Dr. R. M. Powers, E. W. ^Nlorse, Gordon & Hazzard, Bryant Howard and M. G. Elmore. A plant in which petroleum was used was built at a cost of about $30,000 at Tenth and M streets. Two years later the fuel was changed to coal, and from that time on the venture was a success, the company's list of patrons making steady growtli almost in every year.
Toward the end of 1885 the Jenney Electric Company comi)leted a plant for the maimfacturc and distribution of electricity for lighting. Street lights, the first being on tall towers well remembered in the present day. were turned on March 16. 1886. It was asserted then that much better lighting effects would have been obtained by more frequent, lower lights, and the truth of this assertion became evident in a short time : yet the old tower lights remained in service for many vears after that.
and Douglass Gunn, secretary. Other directors were A. Wentscher, I. A. Fairchild and Simon Levi. The company started out with only thirteen subscribers in June, 1882, but the number had grown to nearly 300 by 1887.
Street improvements in the early davs were few. The streets were very dusty in summer and very muddy whenever it rained in the "winter" season. A few board walks helped out a little bit downtown, but there was felt to be little pressing need for more permanent improvement until some years after the boom. In 1886, however, after a long discussion in which prominent citizens took an active part, the citv decided to hold a bond election for a sewer system, the need for which was evident by that time. At the election, which was held in the spring of 1887, when San Diego was growing with remarkable rapidity, the city voted $400,000 bonds for the sewer systerni. The work, which was carried on under a plan submitted by Col. George E. Waring of Newport. Rhode Island, was completed in the summer of 1888. It included 211,560 feet of pipe. The job w^as a good one, as shown by the constant use of the pipe to this day.
It was not until 1886 that San Diego had a street car line. The first cars, drawn by horses, ran two miles up Fifth street. Other lines were soon built up D street, now Broadway ; on H street, now Market, and on First street. On Jan. 1. 1888. at the height of the boom. San Diego had more than thirty-six miles of street railway either in operation or in construction.
Water development was started early in the history of the new citv of San Diego. Necessity for a domestic supply dictated that movement. At first the development took the form of wells, from which water was peddled about town from wagons at the rate of "two bits" a pail. Some residents, the wealthier, sank wells of their own and used windmills to get a supply for home and garden. San Dies"o outgrew that method in the early seventies, and early in 1873 the San Diego Water Company was organized. Prominent in it were Tacob Gruendike, D. W. Briant, H. M. Covert. D. O. McCarthy, William K. Gardner, B. F. Nudd and Return Roberts. Covert was its first president. The engineers went up to Pound Canyon, at the southeast corner of the city park and drilled two wells and built two small reservoirs, into which the water was pumiped. It was believed rather generally at the time that the supply thus obtained would be sufficient for a much larger population than San Diego then had, but bv 1875 it was demonstrated that another source must be developed. So a reservoir was built on University Heights, and water was pumped from the bed of the San Diego river. A long tunnel helped to convey the water to the city, then on the lower levels and not at all on the "mesa," where later sections were soon built.
It was not until 1889 that the San Diego Flume Company, after many trials and tribulations, succeeded in bringing mountain water into the city. This system, of course, is the backbone of the present Cuvamaca water system, whose source of supply begins at Cuyamaca Lake.
Chapter Xii The Great Boom
Some writers have referred to the "great boom" of 1886-8 as a phenomenon. Some aspects of its development were certainly as weird as the ordinary phenomenon ; yet that word is hardly the one to apply to the period. There was nothing phenomenal about the prosi)erity which the country at large shared at about 1885 : there had been a steady growth in many communities in Southern California, and in all that section people were learning that nowhere else were conditions more fa\orable for comfortable, healthful living. The fame of Southern California's matchless climate and the fertility of its soil and the possibilities of that soil for the earning of a living had begun to spread all over the United States. San Diego apparently was beginning to come into its own ; the Santa Fe Railroad was running trains to the city ; there was here all that could be found at any other place in Southern California and in addition a superb harbor, the only real harbor on the Pacific coast of the United States south of San Francisco. Why should people not come to San Diego?
That people had heard of San Diego and wanted to share in its prosperity was evident in the summer of 1885. Those who lived in San Diego were well aware of the fact that the summers in San Diego were fully as delightful as the winters, but "tourists" had not learned that or were not ready to take advantage of the fact ; they had come in winter and had departed for their homes when spring came. Yet in the summer of 1885 there was an influx of visitors and prospective residents that surprised the residents. These newcomers, or many of them, had money to invest and they seemed to be convinced in a short time that here was the best place on earth to invest it. Ikiying of real estate began to be brisk. When its force was evident, the professional "lx)omer," always near at hand in the western part of the country, began to come in. Soon there was speculation on a large scale. Here was a chance for people to make money by buying and selling real estate, and the people who were here and who came here took that chance - took it with avidity, as people will. Thus there was a "boom."
.\ large part of the "boom" was productive of very good results to San Diego. P.uildings sprang up almost over night - not merely the despised "shacks" of the southwest but large, substantial structures. Many of the business buildings had ornate trimmings of the "gingerbread" variety, to be sure, but their frames were solid, they were meant to stay and help {provide office and store room for many years and the decorations after all were only an architectural failing of the period. There are a number of them still in San Diego, doing the service for which they were intended, and their days are far from over. It was the same way with the new homes ; they spread far from the original confines of San Diego; the population increased in a little more than a year from about 8,000 to 21,000, and homes had to be built to house the new arrivals. The sudden prosperity of San Diego also gave to various civic movements an impetus which long had been lacking, and tangible results followed.
The speculation of the boom period - the buying of a corner lot to sell it the next day or perhaps the next hour for twice the price just paid - that aspect of the boom was weirdly sensational. It is easy to see how ordinarily conservative, careful business men were influenced to join in the speculation. For many months - about eighteen in all - it seemed that nothing was easier than to make monev by buying and selling San Diego property ; the price kept going up day by day, so it seemed to be only common sense to buy today at a dollar so as to sell tomorrow at a dollar and a half or two dollars. The professional real estate nijcn - or many of them - doubtless were engulfed in the same craze as all the rest of the city. There were some fraudulent schemes of the boom period - the selling of "corner lots" under water or far out in the hills, miles from where the city might be expected to grow in twenty years, but it appears that most of these were hatched not in San Diego but in other places. San Diego's Chamber of Commerce exerted itself in a very commendable manner and to an equally commendable degree to expose those frauds.
The brass bands, the free excursions, the barbecues of the time were not frauds ; they were simply the outcropping of the moneymaking excitement which gripped the whole city and into whose grasp fell practically all new-comers almost at the moment they stepped from train or steamer to San Diego streets. The new population was not all that could be desired ; with the many upright citizens came some who were not so upright and who put speculation of the gambling variety far above substantial progress, and their arrival and stav in San Diego did much to disturb the even tenor of the town's old ways, but with the collapse of the boom most of the fly-by-night crowd left, and many who were of the kind that make good citizens remained and are here yet.
At the very height of the boom toward the end of 1887, Theodore S. Van Dyke, the noted and picturesquely brilliant writer, whose residence here had given him an excellent view of what had happened to San Diego, wrote as follows :
"The growth of San Diego now began in earnest, and by the end of 1885 its future was plainly assured. A very few who predicted a population of fifty thousand in five years were looked upon as wild, even by those who believed miost firmly in its future. Even those who best knew the amount of land behind it and the great water resources of its high mountains in the interior, believed that twentyfive thousand in five years would be doing well enough. Its growth since that time has exceeded fondest hopes. It is in truth a surprise to all and no one can truthfully pride himself upon superior sagacity, however well founded his expectations for the future may be. At the close of 1885 it had prohably about 5,000 people. At the close of 1887, the time ot writinj^: this sketch, it has fully 30,000, with a more rapid rate of increase than ever. New stores, hotels and dwellings are arising on every hand from the centre to the farthest outskirts in more l)ewildering- numibers than before, and people are pouring in at double the rate they did but six months ago. It is now impossible to keep track of its progress. No one seems any longer to know or care who is ])utting up the big buildings, and it is becoming difficult to find a familiar face in the crowd or at the hotels."
The advertising of the period is not without interest, even at this late day. The cream of this work was done liy Thomas L. Fitch, well remembered bv San Diegans of that time as "the silver-tongued orator." A sample of the kind of work which he did day after day to stimulate trade in San Diego property appears in the following advertisement of Howard & Lyons, taken from the Golden Era, a magazine then i)ublished in San Diego:
"No back country at San Diego!" sneers Los Angeles, squatting among her sloughs, and fearful that the scepter of empire may be speedily snatched from her fever-flushed hands.
"No back country at San Diego!" shouts San Francisco, gathering tolls upon highways she never built, watching with anxious eyes her dwindling commerce, and justly apprehensive that the Hawaiian and Australian, and possibly the China steamers, may seek nearer and cheaper and safer wharfage in the silver-gated bay of San Diego.
"No back country at San Diego!" squeak the little towns that fancy there will be no feast for them, except in the crumbs which fall from Los Angeles' table-cloths.
And the belated Eastern speculator, who might have bought land in our valleys a few years since at $5 an acre, and citv lots at SIO per front foot ; and who lacked the cash or the courage to invest then, now looks about him, and finds that, while he slept, the wand of progress has multi])lie(l values by tens; and so. in the ho]:»e of discouraging the faint-hearted and keeping down prices until he can load up with cheap land, he likewise toots his little toot that "There is no back country to San Diego!"
"Liars and slaves!" as Mr. Macbeth remarked to the Western L^nion District Messenger who brought him a message to the effect that I)irnam W'ood was mo\ing toward Dunsinane ; "Liars and slaves." listen to the truth.
Los .\ngeles is a part of our back country. IHea-infested in summer, mired in winter, roasted at noonday, chilled at night, unsewered, typhoid afflicted, pneumoniated Los Angeles. Smile not, oh five-dollar excursionists, but listen to the truth :
Tu.st as soon as either of the two railroads now Ituilding. and both of which will be C()mi)lcted by fall - just as soon as either of these roads shall be completed, Los .Angeles will be within three or four hours of San Diego. Railroad men will tell you - if they tell vou the truth, as they do occasionally - that there can be no safer or better business than to carrv freight to Los Angeles at a dollar and a half per ton, or less tbati the cost of lighterage from the steamer to the wharf at Wihiiington, and as for the new goosenecked harbor at Ballona, why, if that winter resort for young ducks shall ever become an actuality as a harbor, it will never be for vessels drawing over ten feet of water.
Los Angeles city and county is part of the back country of San Diego ; so is Ventura county, and so is the county of San Bernardino, and when we come nearer home there is the fat and fertile valley of the Tia Juana, there is broad and rich El Cajon, there are Escondido and Poway, San Bernardo and Santa Margarita and a dozen other valleys whose only outlet is by San Diego ; valleys whose combined area of arable acres is greater than that of the State of Connecticut, vallevs whose agricultural products will, when settled, be counted annually by millions. And further back on the hills beyond Lake Cuyamaca, hills covered with forests of oak and madrone and sugar pine, and draped v/ith tangled vines and blossoming chapparal - hills from the summit of which you see on a clear night the Colorado glinting like a silver thread in the East, and the electric lights of San Diego sparkling like stars in the west - back on these hills there may be found in an area of a hundred miles in length and thirty miles and more in width, hundreds of ledges of gold-bearing quartz. San Diego county shipped over a million dollars in gold bars last year, the product of two or three mines, and this part of our "back country" is to quintuple its yield next year.
Some of those who extolled "bay and climate" in real estate advertisements at that time fell into verse, as witness the following, which appeared as a "border" to a page advertisement of La Jolla Park, which the Pacific Coast Land Bureau, R. J. Pennell, manager and auctioneer, put on the market toward the close of the boom:
"The tongues of men were talking fast. As forth from San Diego passed A man whose banner did entice Admiring crowds - with grand device - -La Jolla Park!'"*
Advertising poets, however, must meet competition from other sections where real estate is being sold, so the poet, after a stanza or two, breaks forth with :
" 'Oh, stay !' sweet Coronado cried ; 'And rest the buyers by my tide.' A kindly smile lit Pennell's eye. 'Best thanks - hut first we haste to buy La Jolla Park.' "
One of the most striking characters of San Diego's boom days was William H. Carlson, who came to the city from the northern part of the state and who later l^ecame assemblyman from this district and served two terms as mayor of San Diego. The extravagant optimism of the times was typified in this young man. He had started work as a page in the State Legislature in l!^0 and soon became everybody's friend because of his sunny disposition and his eagerness to serve, and this cheerful manner was always with him in business and politics. He was gi\en to immaculate dress, yet never hesitated to soil both garb and hands if work demanded it. It is related, for instance, that one day when he was clad in a cool outing suit of cream color he saw a little dog run over by a wagon and that, without hesitating a second, he ran out to the middle of the street, picked up the badly injured animal and carried it, bleeding profusely, to a doctor's office that the poor brute might be relieved. This story was related to the writer not long since to illustrate the big-heartedness of this striking character of San Diego's boom days. On another occasion, when somewhat more dignifiedly garbed, wearing among other things a silk hat and an expensive white shirt, on a real estate excursion arranged by his firm of boosters, he was caught in a railway tieup on the waterfront and to try to mend the railroad and end an increasingly embarrassing delay, seized a heavy tie in a valiant effort to pry some errant rails back into place. In his political campaigns, particularly his first for the mayorship, he exhibited the same joyous spirit, shaking haml after hand, saying a kind word to each prospective supporter, winning friends by the score. And who cared much if an extravagant promise or two went along with the smile? All knew that "Billy" Carlson was one of the most cheerful sons of sunny San Diego. What is nwre, he got the necessary- votes and won, not only once but twice, and completely flabbergasted the astute politicians of the period who had not reckoned on him as a strong candidate. But that is told in detail in another part of this story.
Carlson soon after coming to San Diego formed a real estate partnership with Albert E. Higgins, son of a pioneer of the city, and their firm, Carlson and Higgins, promoted many enterprises typical of the Southern California boom days. Principal of these was the exploitation of Ocean Beach, which in later years has come up to the expectations of the boom times and seems destined to become one of the great beach resorts of Southern California if the population of San Diego maintains its ])resent rate of increase. In those davs it was nothing but an expanse of sand running to the rocks near Sunset Cliff and bordered on the west by scrub growth of various kinds. Carlson's idea was to start another town there. So the firm built a considerable hotel on the bluff, took advantage of signs of oil, even then a speculative lure in this section, and started an oil well ; also then began to build a railroad from San Diego to this new bonanza beach. Two parts of the line were actually built : one section was constructed and operated more or less successfully from the foot of Broadway, then D Street, to Hawthorne Street, and the other ran across the backbone of Point Loma through the canvons. Those were the brass band days par excellence, and when construction work was to be launched, it was the occasion for a parade in which wagons of lumber, gaily decorated with flags and alluring signs, were sent forth, the band blaring out its part of the advertisement.
By May of 1888, at the height of the boom, Carlson and Higgins were ready for the barbecue, then the proper thing in real estate promotion. To get the crowd out a free meal was always a good bait. After the crowd had arrived and had been fed it was expected that lots would be sold, and there were always plenty of lots to sell. Some of the old-time stakes still stand like ghostly marks of the high tide of hope, some reaching far back from shore property in some San Diego sections to the foothills, where not even yet is there settlement. The crowd got out to Carlson's Ocean Beach properties without serious difficulty, and all had a fine time. But when the throng started home there was another story. Those were not the days of fast electric cars and of speeding automobiles or of smooth concrete roads, and when the railway system's western end gave way under the heavy pressure not even Billy Carlson's smile could mend matters ; and many in the throng spent a good part of the night in getting back to San Diego.
The excursion had not been a success, and Ocean Beach did not receive the necessary impetus : in fact, it had to wait many years for real growth. The big hotel stood deserted for many years and at last was burned.
When he came back to San Diego in 1920, after having got into very serious trouble through his enthusiasm and having paid a penalty for it, he came full of hope and confidence and on that occasion told a stoT}' which is well worth recording not only as a view of the past as compared with the present but as a human document. And here it is in part :
"I looked ofif at the mass of lights on the ships in the harbor, beyond them to the lights on North Island, and, honestly, it made a lump in my throat. That bay at night was nothing but a black waste, in my early days here. Some of us dreamed ahead and saw the reflection of those lights, but we were laughed at. And now it has all come true! I've seen it!
"With all respect to the rest of this great, wonderful state of ours, I say that San Diego is its brightest spot. Here is the true opportunitv of the future. I have come back because I believe that, and I believe that because I have seen the past.
"In 1896, when I was elected one of the five trustees to govern the city, I cast the deciding vote for the first sewer system. We voted $400,000 in bonds, to run twenty years. And we laid the system clear to 25th street on the east and Upas on the north, - clear out into the wilderness. People said we were crazy and that the city would collapse under the burden. Yet we paid up those bonds without noticing it. and the system installed then - it was built by the same man that sewered Chattanooga, Tennessee. - is the nucleus and basis of the system used today.
"I went to Imperial Valley. It was called New River Valley, then, - that was in 1893. I organized an expedition to the valley, at a cost to me of $500, and took some pictures of that great region. Then in San Diego I hired the old Isis Theatre, at a rate of ^75, got a band, which cost me $50, and gathered an audience of San Diego people, i told them to go out there and locate, when they could get land free from the government, instead of waiting until it was worth $300 an acre. D. C. Reed sjjoke there, too, and Governor Murphy, of Arizona, who was in town at the time.
"From the past one can see a little ahead into the future, and because of what I have seen, I know what is to come. - and I tell you San Diego will be no cit\-, - it will be a metroi)olis !"
There are many living in 1921, of course, w^ho were in San Diego at the time of the "great boom," which began in 1886 and lasted until the winter of 1887-8. It is to be doubted, however, that many can tell a more interesting story of that strange period than Judge Thomas J. Hayes, who came here before the boom started and has remained a resident of San Diego ever since. Judge Hayes was a man of about 35 years at the time. He had been practicing law in the little town of Hiawatha, Kansas, and was county attorney there. His health began to fail, and the family doctor advised him to seek an outdoor life.' preferably in Southern California, whose climatic advantages had attained son^e fame throughout the rest of the nation at that time. So Hayes, half-sick and badly worried about his condition, set forth for Southern California. He went first to Los .Angeles, but soon became "homesick" there, as he relates it. and after a short stay decided to come on to San Diego. The famous steamer ( Orizaba brought him to the Harbor of the Sun. As the Orizalxi pushed her way past Point Loma on the morning of Sept. 28, and the beauties of the port and surrounding country were spread before the passengers' eyes, the young Kansas attorney decided at once that "this was the finest location for a city" that he had ever seen. His decision to remain here was half-made at that time. It did not take long to complete the resolution.
At the wharf was a "hack." driven by W. \V. Rowers, who ran the old IHorence Hotel, now enlarged and remodeled into the Ca.sa Loma, at Fir Street, between Third and JMiurth streets.
"The Florence Hotel in those days." said Judge Hayes in a recent talk with the writer, "was then, way out of town, or so it seemed. I rememiber that when we got up to the Snvder corner. Fifth and D .streets, as it was called then. I said to P.owers. 'Where are we going?' He indicated the location of the Florence Hotel, and I told him that I wanted to stop in town. He told me to come al(Mig with him. saying that it would be all right, adding that it was like the road to the New Jerusalem - somewhat hard to traverse but very nice when you got there. We went on and reached the hotel, and after breakfast I went out and took a look around. I was indeed out in the country. As I stood at the side of the hotel and looked about, I could see little but wild country. There was a big flock of sheep near the hotel, but ofT where the fine city park now is there was little but sagebrush and cactus. It did not look much then as if the city would build up that far for a long time, but in a comparatively few months it had spread far beyond that - largely on paper, it is true, but it actually spread pretty fast.
"On the way down on the boat from Los Angeles I had as a fellow-passenger W. T. Wheatley, a young man who came from the same county in Kansas where I had lived ; I had met him coming to California when I reached Alojave. He is now living in Los Angeles.
The Marston Company Store
Well, he had been here only about two weeks before he decided to go into the lumber business. He had no money to speak of, but decided to go 'on his nerve,' and he did it in good shape, too, making a success.
"The first man I had an introduction to was Simon Levi, the well known merchant, and the next was George W. Marston, who then had a small store at Fifth and F streets.
"Well, to get back to myself : I hired a horse and buggy the next day after my arrival in San Diego and started out to ride around the county. I went all over it for a couple of months in search of my old health, and it came back in great shape. When I came out here the doctor thought that I would not live long, yet I have kept going all these years. Why, in a short time I had added twenty pounds to my weight and felt like a boy. I never had slept so well in my life. The roads were rough and very dusty, but I did not care much for that, because there was such a lot that was pleasant. I shall never forget my first Christmas day in San Diego County. I was riding all by myself in the buggy that I had rented and was up on the road between San Diego and Fallbrook. The birds were singing merrily ; everything was nice and green and fresh as the result of recent rains, and it just seemed like Heaven to me. At Fallbrook I stopped at a boarding house which was kept there by a Mr. Ritchie - I believe that was his name - and there I met Theodore S. Van Dyke, the well known writer. I had a long talk with him, and it was very interesting, as he was a remarkable man. For our Christmas dinner that day we had such delicacies as ripe strawberries and ripe tomatoes, and I tell vou I shall never forget that meal. It seems to me now that it was about the funniest Christmas I ever had ; it was so different from the cold weather and such things that I had been accustomed to back in my home.
"I remember that when I first got to San Diego I saw A. C. Stephens, an old friend, and told him of my conviction that some day this would be a big city. He cast a good deal of doubt on it, and said the lack of water would hold it back. It must be remembered that there was no domestic supply then except what was pumped out of the riverbed, and that was not so very good, either. It had to be kept in ollas on the north side of the house, to keep it cool and purify it. Well, I said to my friend:
" 'There must be good water in abundance in the mountains, and some way will be found to store that up and bring it to the city. Anyway, the climate alone is going to make this a big city ; the rest will come.'
"And my prediction has come true. San Diego was far from being a big city then, however. For instance, there were no sidewalks worthy of the name downtown, where practically the whole town w'as. There were a few board sidewalks downtown on Fifth street, to be sure, but they were crude affairs, and everywhere there was sand, and the dust was thick in summer. And the sand was full of fleas.
"When I returned from my trip through the county, I stoi)ped at the Commercial Hotel. William H. Carlson, who was a great boomer then, and who later became mayor of San Diego, was stO])ping there at the time. He had a real estate office on Fifth street between F and G. Mr. Metcalf and Mr. Hale also were stop])ing there at the time, and they were taking a great interest in the prospective growth of the city. Also, they were talking about building a street car system. The entire jiopulation seemed to have great faith in the town.
"I spent that winter in the city and in the spring went back to Kansas, much improved in health, but the California 'fever' had taken possession of me, and I stayed in the Fast only a few months. When 1 returned to San Diego I took the train at Colton and came on to this city through the Temecula canyon and Oceanside. That was in June, 1886. By that time the town was beginning to be very active. People who wanted to come here from the East changed cars at Colton and came straight to San Diego without going through Los Angeles.
"In a short time after that there commenced the wildest boom I ever heard of in this or in any other country. Everbody seemed to be possessed with the idea that this was to be the biggest city on the Pacific coast. Almost everybody soon went into the real estate business ; it was almost imipossible to stay out of some phase of it, because people soon got to talking and thinking of little else. The town grew from about 3,000 population in 1885 to 35,000 in 1888; people came from everywhere, and everybody seemed to have plenty of money. And everybody seemed to be crazy to buy San Diego real estate. The bigger reputations they had for being conservative business men, the harder they seemed to get into the spirit of the thing. I remember well one wealthy and experienced business man from Chicago who came here and went into the real estate buying game with a vengeance. He was convinced that in a short time the whole country between here and Los Angeles on the coast would be built up solid. And he bought in accordance with that belief.
"There were barl)ecues every week or so, it seems to me now. Many speeches were made. Dinners were given, and there was lots of money for them too, and the excitement grew from day to day. You could not help catching the contagion of the times. Dishwashers, barbers, bakers, everybody, - all were buying and selling real estate. It was easv to sell ; people would buy a hole in the ground just as quickly as they would buy a nice level lot. It did not seem to make much ditTerence how far away the lots were : many a section of lots out as far as San Miguel Mountain were sold, and bought and sold again. And it seemed to be the safest thing on earth to buy San Diego property ; you could buy it, walk around the corner and sell it again at an advance.
"I knew few people here, and one day I went to South San Diego, as it was called then, or Imperial Beach, as it is now known. There I met Captain John H. Folks, who later became sheriff of San Diego Countv. He was from Kansas, too, having been an editor in Sunmier County. He had built a fine house, and on the subject of San Diego real estate and San Diego's future he was about as wild a man as I ever saw. He asked me what I had bought, and I told him I had not made any purchase. He replied: 'Well, get in and buy. Buy something. It doesn't make much difference what it is, but buy.' I asked him what there was for sale of which he had knowledge, and he pointed over to some property which a friend of his named Volney had down there at South San Diego ; that was for sale, he said, and he thought it was a good buy. There were forty acres of it. I said, 'Let me take a look at it,' and went over and looked. It was nice, level land, and that was about all I could tell himi when I got back. But by that time Volnev had come up and had set a price - $5,000. 'You'd better take it,' said Cantain Folks to me. Volney at last said he would take half cash and let me pay the rest in sixty days. I made up my mind to buy. We came to San Diego and went to one of the banks. I had a letter to the bank president from Governor Morrill of Kansas, and I had been assured that my name was good for any sum up to $10,000. Well, to make a long story short, the papers were put in escrow, and I had the South San Diego property. Then I went home to think about it. It had taken all my ready money, and here I was obligated to pay $2,500 more in sixty days. I didn't like the looks of it, quite, and worried a little bit. I got to thinking that I had made a fool of myself. So I opened up a real estate ofhce. thinking to make some money in that way. I had lots of business almost from the start. My place was on F street between Sixth and Seventh, opposite where the Maryland Hotel now is. One day not long after that a man and a woman came in and wanted to know what I had to sell, and I told them about this property. They asked me what I wanted for it. I said the price was $12,000. Honestly, I expected them to otter me about 86,000; to tell the truth, I should have been glad at that time to get my money out of the deal. They went down with me and looked at it, and when they came back to mv office we had a little talk. We had bargained that if they bought, I should pay for the horse and team which we had used for the trip down there, and if they did not buy they were to pay for the costs of the tri]). I didn't say a word to the couple when ,ve got back to the office. At last the woman came to me and asked me about our bargain. She said, 'As I undersand it, we are to pay for the horse and wagon if we do not buy.' 'That's right,' I said. 'Well.' she said, 'we will buy the land.' The bargain was closed and I had mv money exactly thirty days after I had bought the land. Then I began to feel a little guilty. I said to myself, 'You probably have taken more for this land than it is worth, and you ought to look into it.' lUit while 1 was still thinking about the matter and how to clear it up, in came the man and his wife and told me they had just sold the land for $16,000. or $4,000 more than they had' paid. "That's an example of how things went. X'^othing like it was ever known. People were crazy wild to buy. Tom Fitch, 'the silvertongued orator,' was making speeches every day, telling about the charms and beauties of San Diego and its climate and other advantages. Lots way out on the hills were sold with ease. They put up fine pictures of the 'new addition' in some window, and the people flocked to buy. A line was formed in front of one of these offices one day. and it kept on forming up to midnight, I guess. At anv rate, I had a friend from Illinois who had just got into town. He saw the line and didn't even stop to check his baggage or wash up. He got into line to buy. The sign said that the price would go up the next day, and that was enough for him. He bought seven lots out there, and came into my office the next day to tell me about it. 1 told him that he had lost what he had paid, and, sure enough, he did. In a few days he couldn't give them away. But that was the exception. City property sold as fast as it could be put up for sale. There were additions clear out to El Cajon and clear up to Del Mar.
"You may wonder how people lived. Of course there was a lot of building but thou.sands lived in tents which they rented by the night for a dollar a tent. Manv others lived in barns and sheds and wherever they could find a place to sleep. I was offered $75 a month for my little barn, and it was not a very good one, either. Rents went 'way up. It was hard to rent a house or room anywhere.
"Then all of a sudden it ended. I remember that one day we had a big rain, and after it was over I went downtown. The streets that had been jammed with people as is the case in the streets of Chicago or some other big city, seemed to lack something. The bottom had dropped out of the big boom. From whence the boom came I do not know, and I have never been able to learn to my complete satisfaction. It stopped more suddenly by far than it came. It reversed motion and went down like a chunk of sawed-off wood. I have heard it said many a time that misfortunes never come singly. And this was true of San Diego. When the boom ended and it was hard to give property away which was really worth something, although nothing like the prices which had been recorded, a storm came and swept out the railroad in Temecula canyon. This was not rebuilt ; instead, a railroad was built by the Santa Fe, hugging the shore most of the way down from Los Angeles. From that time people who intended to come to San Diego had to go through Los Angeles, and many of them were satisfied to remain in Los Angeles. Then the Santa Fe moved its machine shops up to San Bernardino, the street car lines which had been laid w'ere ripped up, nobody wanted to buy real estate, people began to leave town, and in less than two vears the population had been reduced from 35,000 to about 17,000. The boom had hit San Diego hard."
Chapter Xiii In The Wake Of The Boom
The collapse of the boom hit San Diego as hard as it did any other section of Southern California; the tlattening-out process left manv residents in dire straints ; many who had been potentially rich found themselves poor almost overnight ; some left town for other places, in many cases selling out for enough to pay railroad fare to other parts of the country, or, being unable to sell, borrowed or scraped up the money in some way. Yet, hard as the blow was. it was not a staggering one, and San Diego, hard hit, rose from the ground and kejjt on fighting for her destiny.
In this struggle there were many who did valiant work, but much of the encouragement and much of the financial power which were necessary to keej) San Diego on her feet came from John D. Spreckels and his associates. He had established a coal business here, and had sold much coal to the Santa Fe. which, when it went into the hands of a receiver, owed him hundreds of thousands of dollars for the fuel which he had furnished the line. By 1888 Spreckels had become vitally interested in the progress of San Diego, for which he has always held a deep afifection, and when the crash came, he and his brother, Adolph, to use the words of William Clayton, managing director of the Spreckels companies in San Diego, "'stood up to their necks in the ebb tide, set their teeth together and determined to fight it out." They fought well, too. Spreckels advanced the money for carrying on the plans of the Coronado Beach Conipany in which he had become interested and which included operation of the great Hotel del Coronado, which had been opened on February 1, 1888, just as the boom was about to break. Soon after that he became interested in the street car company, and electricity was made its motive power in 1891. There was at the time a cal)le line in San Diego, but it later went into the hands of a receiver, and Sjireckels bought it in 1897. In later years, as will be related in more detail. he took over the Southern California Mountain Water Company, b}' which for the first time the city of San Diego received an ade- (|uate and dependable su]:){ilv of good mountain water for its domestic needs : he extended the street car svstem all over the city and linked it up in various ways with suburbrvn sections : he built several of the largest office and hotel buildings in the city, he did much to start the Exposition and keep it going, and, finally, by his preserverance in the face of tremendous discouragenuents, he was instrumental in the conipletion of the San Diego and Arizona Railway, by which San Diego in 1919 realized at last the dream she had cherished for vears of a direct rail outlet to the East. This is only a mere sketch of what John D. Spreckels has done for San Diego ; in a hundred other ways he has assisted in keeping the city of his adoption a going concern, and in a large measure the prosperity of the San Diego of today is due to him. Some in past years have sneered at San Diego as a "one-man town," but if there ever was a town lucky for having a man as its largest one force, San Diego is that town ; in recent years, it may be added, the few who have sneered have been adequately silenced in the chorus of admiration which has been raised in praise of this one man, the foremost citizen of San Diego, who has labored so long and unselfishly for the progress of the city.
The story of the manner in which John D. Spreckels made his first visit to San Diego and the way in which he was greeted is of mOre than passing interest ; it affords, too, a sidelight on the character of the man and of the kind of town there was at San Diego then. Mr. Spreckels first arrived in San Diego harbor one day in 1887. He was on his yacht, the Lurline, and had been making a somewhat leisurely trip down the coast from San Francisco, then his home. The yacht put in at several ports and at last drifted into the Harbor of the Sun. As the Lurline came inside, a small boat put out from shore, bearing a middle-aged gentleman who was on his way to offer free pilotage into the harbor. San Diego evidently had heard of Mr. Spreckels' trip down the coast and wanted to overlook no chance to show him true San Diego hospitality.
As it happened, the yacht's owner, wearing old clothes and a regulation sou'wester, was at the wheel of the yacht, where he had a perfect right to be, being expert in seamanship. He did not look like a yacht owner, however, in his sea-going garb; and the San Diego welcome party of one did not pay any attention to him as he stepped aboard and began to cjuestion the man on deck. Thus the distinguished visitor was able to overhear a very interesting conversation in which the San Diegan asked a number of pertinent questions about John D. Spreckels, just who he was and what kind of man he was. The formal introduction soon followed, however and both Mr. Spreckels and his new friend had a hearty laugh over the little joke.
Soon after Mr. Spreckels' arrival at San Diego, a wharf franchise was offered to him. The committee which made the offer frankly explained that San Diego believed it would be a good thing to interest him in the city. He accepted the offer, for his interest in San Diego had become keen almost at a glance, and by virtue of that franchise built a wharf on which were installed modern coal bunkers. He soon began shipping coal direct into San Diego to supply the Santa Fe, whose Pacific terminal, of course, was then at San Diego, and that was his first investment in the city. Mr. Spreckels has said since that he became attracted to San Diego at first sight and that the evident possibilities of the city in a commercial way and as a place of residence were impressed upon him with force by that view.
The boom period and the next two or three years saw many note worth V improvements in San Diego. Reference already has been made to the completion of the Hotel del Coronado, whose fame has spread far and wide. The Spreckels coal bunkers, out of which the Santa Fe engines got fuel by which service in this section was kept going, were also finished. The courthouse was rebuilt ; the flume system was completed ; the San Diego, Cuyamaca and Eastern, which later was extended to Foster, on the way through the hills to the East, was finished as far as El Cajon, opening up that great valley to the port.
There was a setback of some consecjuence in 1891 when the California National Bank, which had been started at the height of the boom, in 1888, went under with a crash. In 1892 several of the other San Diego banks were hard hit, but the city had gone too far to be stopped, and its citizens had the confidence which brings success out of failure, and San Diego kept on growing - slowly it is true, but just as surely. A notable building was added in that year to the ever-growing list ; this was the Fisher Opera House, later Isis Theatre, built by John C. Fisher. In September of the same year San Diego had a big celebration to mark the 350th anniversary of Cabrillo's discovery of the port. San Diegans who were here then will not soon forget the three days devoted to the program, in which a number of native Indians, dressed in historically correct manner, joined with San Diegans garbed as Spaniards in presenting a notable pageant, staged to tell the story of Cabrillo's landing.
To this period there belongs also the relation of an incident which gave San Diego an international importance for quite a while. This was "the Itata incident,", taking its name from the steamer Itata, by which sympathizers of a revolution in Chile hoped to obtain arms and ammunition for their cause. The schooner Robert and Minnie got the arms and munitions at San h^rancisco and started south to meet the Itata. which was guarded by the revolutionists' man-of-war Esmeralda. The Itata had to put into San Diego for fuel, and meanwhile the I'. S. authorities learned of the plan, which was to transshij) the arn>s and ammuntion from the Robert and Minnie to the Itata off San Clemente Island. U. S. Marshal Card of Los Angeles formally seized the itata and i)ut a man aboard her as a guard. On May 13 the Itata's skii)]:)er. having waited until he became inijiatient, got u]) steam and left the harbor. Outside the Itata met the Robert and Minnie and took aboard the arms and ammunition from that craft. The American cruiser Charleston later seized the Itata at Iquique and brought her back to San Diego, the seizure resulting in court action in which the U. S. Government was found to have df^ne wrong. The Chilean rexolutionists meanwhile were winning against the old Government of their country, and when the revolution was all over. .American ])opidarity in Chile had suff'ered materially. That feeling against .Americans became strikingly apparent at \'al])araiso on Oct. 16, 1891. when more than 100 officers and men of the U. S. S. Baltimore went to the city on shore leave. A quarrel ."Started between some Chilean sailors and the Americans, and there soon began a formidable riot in which two of the Baltimore's men were killed. News of the fight was flashed all o\er the world, and after some contro\ersy the I nited States, in the following year, demanded and got indemnity from Ciiile. So it is no wonder that mention of the Itata incident is enough to set the tongues of the old waterfront residents of San Diego to'wagginsr reminiscentlv.
The "panic" of 1893 had its effect in San Diego, compelling one bank to close forever and making trouble for others, but the financial atmosphere in San Diego was soon cleared up in good shape. The next few years were not marked by any remarkable progress.
"San Diego, Our Italy," was the title of an interesting booklet issued by the Chamber of Commerce in 1895 and containing a wealth of solid information. This information gives rather good idea of the general condition of the city's business and industrial life at that time.
To the fruit growing industry of the back country is given great emphasis, and a published report of the number of trees, both tearing and non-bearing, placed the total at 6,475, of which about 4,800 were citrus trees. Some space in the booklet is devoted to mining. The Julian gold mines are credited with having produced more than $3,000,000 in the period between 1870 and 1893^. Seven of the Julian mines are mentioned by name and several of them were said to have had 10- and 20-stamp mills in operation
The assertion was made that San Diego had for several years past been one of the leading counties in the United States in the production of honey. The annual output was given at between 1,000,000 and 2,000,000 pounds.
Four firms were named as being engaged in the fishing industry here, and the value of the total product of the industrv is placed at $106,010.
Considerable space is given to transportation lines. The La Jolla line, the Coronado road, the Cuyamaca line and the National City & Otay are mentioned with the Santa Fe as the county's transportation routes. Under the heading, "A Railroad Men's Railroad," a brief account is given of the San Diego, Pacific & Eastern project, which had been indorsed at mass meetings by the Chamber of Commerce, the Board of Trade and the City Council. This road was to have run northeast to Utah.
"The city is connected with San Francisco by rail and steamship lines. Among other things of which any city miay be justly proud, San Diego has a $150,000 county courthouse; as fine a public library containing over 12,000 volumes ; 20 churches, and 30 church organizations ; 8 graded public schools ; 5 kindergartens ; 45 miles of graded streets : 4^ miles of paved streets ; 44 miles of sewers, costing about $425,000: 14 miles of gas mains: 65 miles of water mains: 44 miles railways, including a magnificent electric car system; 15 electric light masts, each 125 feet high: pure, cold mountain water: a $100,000 opera house ; 5 incorporated banks : 4 daily newspapers ; the largest hotel in the world, at Coronado ; the Old Mission building and many other points of historical interest ; a fire-alarm system costing $7,500, and a well-equipped fire department. There are also many magnificent brick blocks that would do credit to a city of 100,000 inhabitants."
City Of Sax Diego And San Diego Col'Xtv 145
A special chapter devoted to San Diego harbor is convincing in the array of figures pubhshed. The number of vessels arriving during the years 1893-4 is given as 322. with a total net tonnage of 241,035. The value of dutiable imports is named at $307,918.04, and of free imports, $52,929.33 - a total of $360,847.37. Lumber receipts are named as 17,724,000 feet; coal, value, $235,264.60; cement value, $45,172.73. Revenues collected by the customs office at the port amounted to $95,127.24. for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1894.
The cha])ter also states that San Diego was chosen as the coaling station for the British North Pacific naval sfiuadron. having been given the preference over San Francisco.
"Some idea of the wharf accomodations may be had from a partial description of the Spreckels Bros', wharf, which is 3,500 feet long, and was built at a cost of over $90,000. The coal bunkers on the wharf have a capacity of over 15,000 gross tons. The machinery is of the most modern and best improved type, and in point of efficiency second to none in America. The wharf has a track connectingit with the Southern California Railway. Ships are unloaded directly into the bunkers, from which a train may be loaded in fifteen minutes.
"In addition to the Spreckels Bros." wharf there are the Santa Fe's the Pacific Coast Steamship Company's, the Dock Company's and the Russ Lumber & Mill Companv's costing from $25,000 to $80,000 each, and from 2.000 to 3.200 feet in length."
The city directory of 1895 listed 30 churches, two morning newspapers, and one evening newspaper, seven architects. 82 attorneys or firms of attorneys, and six banks, the Bank of Commerce, Blochman Banking Com])any, First National. Merchants National, San Diego Savings and Savings Bank of San Diego County ; there were three building and loan associations; seven civil engineers, 17 dentists, and nine drygoods houses, the list including George \V. Marston, then at the northeast corner of Fifth and F streets. John Black, S. \V. Bone. Mrs. M. V. Carroll, the City of Paris. J. W. Cregan. M. A. Lesem. L. Siieyer and the White House. Two engraving firms tiien found work here. There was nearly sixty retail groceries, a good indication of the w'ay in which the town had spread by that time. There were sixty-five physicians and surgeons practising here then, and it is of interest to note who some of them were. Dr. P. C. Remondino. dean of the physicians now practising in San Diego, was. as today, at Fifth and Beech streets. Dr. C. M. Fenn, another well known phvsician, was at 651 Seventh street. Dr. D. Gochenauer had his offices in the I^xpress Block. Dr. Francis H. Mead was in the Keating Block. Fifth and F streets. Drs. Fred and Charlotte Baker were in their old offices at Fifth and C streets. Dr. T. G. McConkey, who was promintent also in the rowing club, was in the Bon Ton Block. Sixth and D streets. Dr. R. J. Ciregg. now retired but still living, was at 850 Fourth street. Dr. F. R. lUirnham. who lived then at 1708 C street, had offices in the Kuhn Block. Fourth and D streets. Dr. I. C. Mearne was at Fourth and Ash streets.
The public library in those days was at Seventh and F streets, in the St. James building, over the postoffice, and had only about 12,000 books. There were about 75 real estate dealers listed. There were 14 printers in the 1905 directory, one of the firms being Garrett & Smith at 721 Fifth street. The Western Union Telegraph office was on F street. The only theatres were the Louis Opera House and the Fisher Opera House. The only undertaking firms were Johnson & Co. (P. M. Johnson and J. E. Connell) at Sixth and E streets, and W. W. Whitson & Co., at Fourth and E streets. The list of retail liquor dealers contained Zl names.
The fire department, of which A. B. Cairnes was chief, was only partly paid at that time. It had 41 men, two steam engines, three hose carts and one truck and ladder outfit. There were only 25 alarm boxes in the city, th^ central office being 930 Third street.
The Chamber of Commerce then had its rooms on F street between Third and Fourth. The city hall was at Third and D streets, and the redoubtable William H. Carlson was mayor.
From the foot of H street east to National avenue and Thirtysecond street ; from the foot of Fifth street north to University avenue, where it connected with a horse-car line running to the Cable Pavilion. The D street line ran from the foot of H street to D, then on D to Fifteenth street; an extension to Twenty-fifth street was being made at the time. There was a so-called belt line running around the business section to and from the Coronado ferry. On First street there was a horse-car line running from D street to H"awthorne.
The Coronado Belt Line Railroad, from San Diego to Coronado, ran trains around the bay then. The National City & Otay road, now part of the San Diego & Arizona system, was running trains to National City, Chula Vista, Otay and Tia Juana. The San Diego & Arizona system, was running to Foster, from which point a daily stage ran to Julian. The San Diego, Pacific Beach & La Jolla ran steam trains to La Jolla.
In those days Edward W. Scripps, the newwspaper publisher, had established his residence at Aliramar. Joseph Jessop, the jeweler, also had his residence there.
Such were conditions in the city at the end of 1895 - about seven years after the boom had collapsed. The city was not growing vigorously, but it had gained encouragement from the manner in which some of its citizens, notably, John D. Spreckels, had shown their faith in the place. Hopes were still entertained of a railroad running directly East from the port, the failure of the Santa Fe to provide such an outlet having become apparent. New blood was being added to the population - vigorous, hopeful pioneers of the later days - and the old pride in San Diego was as strong as ever. To that was added, bit by bit, more hope for the future, to which the people of San Diego looked with confidence.
in San Diego harbor on July 21, 1905. The vessel, a ship of the third class, was lying in the stream, about to depart for the north, when the forward and main port boilers exploded at about 10:30 a. m. The ship was soon enveloped in steam, and aboard the craft was a scene of horror which will live long in the memory of those who saw it m part. The explosions and the scalding steam killed fifty-one men outright. Of the injured who were taken alive from the fated gunboat, nine died later, making the total death list sixty. There were forty-six others who were injured, many severely. About ninety of the crew escai)ed without injury.
The injured men were rushed to the Agnew Sanitarium and St. Josei)h"s Hospital or to im])rovised hospitals, many kinds of vehicles being pressed into service. \'olunteers came from all parts of the city to aid in relieving the victims, many of whom suffered agonies with a fortitude that called for glowing praise.
The funeral of the victims was held July 23, the people of the city joining in the tribute to the sailors who had given up their lives. Most of the victims were buried in the Military Cemetery on Point Loma, where, in January, 1908, the Bennington monument, a beautiful shaft, was unveiled.
Chapter Xiv San Diego'S Railroad History
From the early '50s to 1919 San Diego hoped for but still was without a direct rail outlet from her magnificit harbor to the Eastern States of the Union. From 1883 on, to be sure, the Santa Fe ran trains here, but early in San Diego's dealings with that railroad it became apparent that the San Diego line, instead of being a direct road, was doomed to be a branch line, and such it is at this day, although its importance has increased with the years and in recent times the railroad company has apparently done ever>'thing reasonable to advance San Diego's interests. The fine station built before the Exposition at the foot of Broadway is an example of that friendly interest in San Diego's advancement and appreciation of the city's legitimate demands.
It remained, however, for John D. Spreckels, eminent and loyal San Diegan, to bring to realization the dreams which his city has cherished for the many years of a direct road to the East.
The early ideas and hopes for such a rail outlet as was provided when the San Diego & Arizona was completed in 1919 were, naturally, more or less hazy. The Federal Government, however, granted appropriations for preliminary surveys in the early '50s. One of these was completed and reported in 1853 ; that report was published by Col. J. Bankhead ^Nlagruder, president of the Atlantic and Pacific Railroad Company, which had a name of such resonance and significance as to deserve perpetuation as one of the great transcontinental lines of the United States. The other survey was made only a few months later, although the report was not made public until 1856: this survey was made by Col. i\ndrew B. Gray for a route for the Southern Pacific, on the 32d parallel, for the Texas Western Railroad Company.
Early in the stay of Lieut. George H. Derby at San Diego, in the '50s when he was building up his fame as the author of "Phoenixiana," he acquired railroad enthusiasm to some extent - certainly to sufficient degree to mention it in his writings. For instance, although San Diego at the time was just a little part settlement, principally at Old Town and La Playa, and was growing very gradually, he foresaw that it some day would be a railroad terminus. "Should," he wrote, "the great Pacific railroad terminate at San Diego, an event within the range of probability, the Playa must be the depot, and as such will become a point of great importance." His prophecy, so far as it relates to La Playa, has not been fulfilled, but the rest of it has become realization. And those who have watched closely the progress of events along the Pacific coast, especially in Southern California, have become convinced that, with the completion of this
A period of remarkable i)rosperity for San Diego as a result of her new railroad connection will be a pleasant chapter to follow the chapter of many disai)pointments. And what a chapter! First, when everything seemed lo be favorable, the outbreak of the Civil War, paralyzing commerce for years and halting the progress of the Southern States, on which San Diego relied in early days for railroad help. Then "Ulack bViday" in 1873, stopijing Thomas A. Scott of the I'ennsyhania road in his nearly successful attempt to bring a railroad through to San Diego. Then in the 'SOs the disappointment i\ue to the failure of the Santa Vc to do what the j)eople of San
Union Station, San Dikgo
Diegc had hoped would l)e done. Later, with the case of the San Diego <^- Arizona, trouble in Mexico, financial stringencv and the World War - none of which, however, daunted or dismayed its builder, Mr. .*^preckels, and his closest associates.
Late in 1854 there was organized in San Diego a company which used the comprehensixe name San Diego & Gila, Southern Pacitic & Atlantic Railroad Company. It was duly chartered at Sacramento and elected these officers, nearly all of whom became prominent in the citv : President. James W. Robinson: Vice President, O. S. Witherby; Treasurer. Louis Rose; Secretary, George P. Tebbetts : Directors. J. W. Robinson. Gen. H. S. P.urton. I^. W. ]\lorse, Joseph Reiner, b^lm Hays. M. M. Sexton, Louis Rose. L. Strauss, j. R. (nibchell, George Lvons. ( ). S. Witherby. and William C. Ferrell. As was the case later with the San Diego X: .Arizona, the purpose of this comipany was to build as far as Yuma, Ariz., there to connect with whatever Hue might be built to that point from the East. To start such a work it was necessary to make a survey from San Diego over the mountain to what is now the Imperial Valley, no previous survey having taken in that section. The surveyors followed the general line of the San Diego River up as far as Santa Ysabel, at which the mountain to the East now forks, one lateral going to Warner's ranch and the other climbing the hills to Julian. The surveying party brought back a very encouraging report which to some extent was verified in later years when the San Diego, Cuyamaca & Eastern Railroad was built as far as Foster, with intentions to keep climbing over the mountains to the East. In 1855 the city voted to give the companv nearly 9,000 acres of land with the proviso that the road be built. It never got beyond the surveying stage. While hope was still strong for it in San Diego, the Civil War began to loom, and that soon became reality. After the war there were several other railroad projects from which San Diego got small hope, but it was not until 1871, when the Texas & Pacific was organized, by Thomas A. Scott and a group of associates, that this hope came anywhere near realization. The following year, Scott, who was head of the great Pennsylvania road of the East, got authority from Congress to build from the Mississippi River to the Pacific Coast. San Diegans then selected a committee of forty citizens to work toward the end that San Diego might be made the western terminus of the Scott road. Thomas L. Nesmith was made chairman, and A. E. Horton, who by that time had put into the new town an enthusiasm which could not be restrained, went to Washington to confer with Congressman S. O. Houghton of California and Gen. Thomas S. Sedgwick, who several years before had made a survey to San Diego. Scott seemed very favorable to San Diego's presentation and he made arrangements to come here on a visit. As soon as he reached the coast. August 20, 1872, he announced that he had come to the West purely on business "in fact, to visit San Diego, the Western terminus of the Texas & Pacific Railway." He also said: ''Work will be commenced at San Diego immediately, as the charter of the company requires the line to be commenced at that place before the end of the year." The Scott party was described at the time as "the largest party of distinguished persons ever visiting the Pacific coast." Certain it is that its coming across the continent aroused much interest, and when it started down the coast from San Francisco, to which it had gone by rail, and in considerable style, the San Francisco newspapers sent along reporters to "cover" the doings at San Diego. They did it, too. at considerable length. The trip down the coast was made on the steamer California, a stop being made at Santa Barbara. The arrival here was on August 26. It is well here to stop a momlent and consider the makeup of this party, indeed distinguished.
These were Directors : Col. Thomas A. Scott, president of the road; Gen. G. M. Dodge, chief engineer; W. T. Walters of Baltimore, Col. John W. Fornay of Philadelphia, Former Senator John S. Harris of Louisana, John McManus of Reading, Pa., and Gov. J. W. Throckmorton of Texas. Others in the party were : Col. George Williamson of Shreveport, La., Senator John Sherman of Ohio, N. P. Dodge of
Council Bluffs. Iowa. W. H. Rinehart of Rome, Italy, John P. Greene, secretary to President Scott, W. H. Brady, D. B. Jackson, accent of the Pennsylvania Central Station at San Francisco, ]\Iis5 Walters and Airs. John P. Greene. Accompanying- the party from the North by invitation were Gov. R. C. McCormick of Arizona and Senator Cornelius Cole. There was a large crowd at the wharf to welcome the visitors headed by the "Railroad King," as the Union of that time described Scott. Carriages took all to the Horton House, then the finest hotel in all Southern California, and greeting them all there was Horton, "the happiest looking man we have ever seen." A meeting had been arranged for outdoors that evening that all San Diego mio'ht see and hear Scott, but while the party, or most of it was out taking carriage rides that afternoon, a light rain, not to be expected at all at that time of the year, came up, and it was decided to have the meeting in the rink under Horton's Hall. This was soon crowded. Chairman Nesmith of the Citizens' Committee i)resided and presented Col. Scott, who spoke at some length. He declared he did not see wh\- the railroad shold not be l)uilt to San Diego within five years. He referred to the fact that other communities - "your neighbors" - would be working for trade w^ith the East, and mentioned San Francisco in particular. But he added: "Your location is so many miles nearer to the Atlantic that you must certainly secure the most liberal share of the commerce 1 have referred to."
Several other members of the Scott party spoke. So did Prof. Louis Agassiz, who had come here a few days before on the steamer Hassler, which had brought a party of scientists from the East for exploration and acquisition of various specimens of animal life. Prof. Agassiz said "This day is the one from which you can date vour real prosperity." The good professor of course was not able to look into the future and see the "Black Friday" that was on the calendar of the Fates.
The next afternoon Col. Scott met with the Citizens' Railroad Committee and the Board of City Trustees in the parlor of the bank, the San Diegans being assembled to hear his proposal, expressed simply, as it came from the great railroad man to the humble, expectant community :
"Third - That you give us the lot of land (as designated on the map) 1,500 feet in length by 600 feet in width, adjoining the waterfront, with streets and alleys vacated.
"Fourth - That you give us 1(X) acres of tidelands (as designated on the map) to be acceptable to the company as to shape: or the same amount of tidelands within the boundaries of Horton's addition, adjoining the shore.
A committee was appointed to confer with a special committee of the San Diego & Gila company with reference to terms on which the lands granted to that company could be obtained for the new railroad venture, and a second meeting was held in the parlor of the Horton House that afternoon. The San Diego & Gila committee, headed by Col. W. Jeff Gatewood of the World, proposed to sell the required lands for not less than $100,000. This proposal was accepted, and it was voted to notify Colonel Scott that his terms were agreeable. Scott immediately said that he was eager to go ahead with actual construction work.
"San Diego is jubilant," said the Ubion next day in describing the feelings with which the city took the news. "Scott has passed his word, and he never goes back on a pledge."
The feeling of jubilation was evident throughout a farewell banquet which was served at the Horton House. After the viands had been eaten and the wine had been used in toasts, a salute was fired and the party was escorted by happy San Diegans to the steamer California, which took the visitors on the first leg of the journey back East.
Formal transfer of the property and franchise of the old San Die"-o & Gila to the Texas & Pacific was made in the following December. The San Francisco papers at the time valued the properties at $3,000,000, and it is said that Colonel Scott himself valued them at $5,000,000.
Grading work on the San Diego end of the proposed road was started on April 21 of the next year. The ceremony was hastily arranged, but was nevertheless impressive. Work was started on the railroad lands about 100 yards from the Mannasse & Schiller addition. Among those taking part was J. S. Harris, a director of the Texas & Pacific ; Thomas L. Nesmith, head of the citizens' committee, presided, and said :
"The day has at last arrived. The Texas & Pacific, as you are well aware, has been endowed by Congress with extensive land grants, and it has been further liberally aided by the State of Texas sufficiently so as to guarantee its completion.
He also expressed the hope that the road could be finished in time for all San Diegans to travd over it to the Centennial celebration in 1876, a remark which was heartily cheered. Horton who turned the first sod, paused after he had taken off his coat and hat to start the task and said :
At this time there were some murmurings of discontent in San Dieeo that progress on the new railroad was not faster, but Scott, it seems, w-as doing all he could. In the fall he went to Europe to complete arrangements with French financiers for taking bonds. While the papers were being drawn up he went away for a visit. The papers were completed and the financiers were ready to sign, but
Scott delayed his return. Then came the news of the "Black Friday," sig'nai of a financial crash, and when Scott came around for the necessary signatures the financiers had changed their minds about making the proposed loan. Scott sent word to San Diego that he could not carry out the plan.
Scott, as a matter of fact, had not given up the fight, but his ho])e now rested on the possibihty of getting a subsidy from Congress, and that hope was shared by the people of San Diego, who devoted much time, money and effort in their work to bring about if possible the necessary legislation by Congress. Collis P. Huntington, however, was making his influence felt against Scott, and the fight for a subsidy was a losing one from the start. As a matter of fact, there was much feeling at the time against the award of large grants to encourage railroad building, and Congress Vv-as acutel\- aware of this sentiment.
\\ hen the Texas & Pacific was chartered in 1872 three surveying parties had been sent out. The three routes which they took were the southern by Campo, a middle way, via Warners, and the northern, through the San Gorgonio Pass. Disposition of national legislators to arrive at a compromise in the railroad fight was based on the possible use of the San (iorgonio Pass. San Diego saw that use of this route and the establishment of San Francisco as the western terminus, as proposed in the compromise, would not be to San Diego's advantage.
That the San Gorgonio route would be to the distinct advantage of Eos Angeles became apparent soon to the people of that city, who later gave Scott's opponents $400,000 to use it and no other.
While their motives were being argued San Diego sent several special representatives to W'ashington, and a number of long telegrams were exchanged. In December, 1876, the Board of City Trustees and the Citizens Railroad Committee sent to Colonel Scott a telegram in which he was told that San Diego was relying on his pledges, and that it was his duty to demand the "direct route" into San Diego, and that San Diego would unanimously oppose any compromise ^vhich did not include the direct line. Colonel Scott sent this reply :
"Have used my utmost eff'orts to secure to San Diego a railroad line on such route as can best effect the object; and if you can effect it in any better shape than I can, I should be very glad to have you take it up and adjust it with any party, or on any terms that vou may think best. But in taking these stei)s, I shall expect you to relieve me of any possible obligation."
About a month later, in January. 1877. (Jen. Thomas S. Sedgwick, who had been engaged by the San Diegans to work in their behalf at Washington, sent a telegram to the Board of City Trustees in which he declared that in his opinion it was best for San Diego to support the proposed compromise to the subsidy bill then pending in Congress and tliat .^an Diego should make conce^'^ifuis to get a railroad even though it came by the San Gorgonio route. "We are losing friends in committee l)y our persistence." he said, "and canuot count our present strength hereafter for any other move. By yielding we may get guaranteed bonds subsidy for whole line ; and if Huntington does not build San Gorgonio line you will have the direct route, under the bill, by the time the through line is completed. The committee concede that the direct line must follow soon under any conditions." Sedgwick's telegram concluded thus:
"At this time shortness of route is not so important as results in developing Arizona and getting connections that will increase your commercial importance and population and trade many-fold in few years, which growth will enable you to build the direct route long before you will need it to cheapen freight. Why not help yourselves now, to strengthen yourselves hereafter? Unless the subsidy bill passes, there will be no road for you to meet."
"It is the deliberate and unchangeable conviction of San Diego, that the ]:)ro]iosed connection north of here, in the hands of the Southern Pacific Company, would be an injury instead of a benefit to us, because :
"2. Trade and population would be taken away from, instead of brought here, while the road is building. It is now moving from the northern part of the county to Colton.
"6. Experience has taught us that the strongest promises in a bill do not protect us against subsequent amendments at the desire of the corporation. Legislation that fails to require immediate beginning at the end, and construction of so much road before next session of Congress as to remove the temptation to amend bill, is worse than w^orthless.
"7. Whatever supposed guarantees may be put in bill making the road a 'highway', it is well known by all engineers that the company building the road holds in fact control of it ; and no other company can have equal use, or will build parallel road.
"8. Southern Pacific Company one year ago agreed to build on direct line, provided San Diego would consent that it should have the western end.
''So far from a San Diego standpoint : But we hold no petty local view; we supplicate no favors. The interest of San Diego is here bound up with national interest. We submit to impartial statesmen the conceded truth that the proposed compromise diverts the nation's bounty from the original purpose of the Southern transcontinental legislation ; deprives all the millions east of San Diego to direct access to their nearest Pacific harbor ; and destroys competition for all time. San Diego's natural advantages are such, that in asking the nation's aid for the construction of a railroad to her port, she asks it upon a line, and upon terms that will contribute to the Xation's support and wealth for all time to come ; while the compromise plan will be an intolerable and interminable national burden. For these reasons San Diego prefers Xo bill, rather than the San (iorgonio branch. Read again both our dispatches to Lamar."
Hope for the San Diego plan died hard, but went out at last in 1878. By that time, however, San Diego's population had dwindled away to a disappoinring extent, many residents having seen the handwriting on the wall that ordered San Diego to wait for her direct road. This exodus had. in fact, begun as soon as the Scott's failure abroad and of the "Black Friday" collapse had been received in San Diego. A good many persons in poor or moderate circumstances had started to buy land of Horton, and they api)ealed to him for aid. which he promptly gave, repaying dollar for dollar and taking back their contracts. San Diego's population had grown to more than 4.000. but this fell off to about 2.500. There were hard times not only in San Diego but elsewhere, so the city settled back and waited for new railroad plans. While it waited, its people went to work developing their home resources, so to this extent the loss of the direct railroad at that time was of some good even to disaj)pointed San Diego.
There was some hope for a time, indeed, that Huntington might build the Southern Pacific to San Diego, but nothing came of that hope, and Huntington, it seems, gave little ground for it. In fact, he told friends that it was not to the interest of himself and asso- -ciates to build to San Diego at the time. He made a visit here with some of those associates and they were well entertained by the people of San Diego - Horton put them up at the Horton House and "did not charge them a cent," as he said with some quaintness in later years. Horton says that Huntington oft'ered to build the road from San Diego to Yuma if San Diego would give only half the property which it had agreed to lei Scott have if his Texas & Pacific went through. And this half would have been a princely gift. But Huntington apparently was making the offer only as a "feeler." at any rate, nothing came of it*. E. W. Morse, a San Diegan who was a careful observer of events in the city and who made accurate reports of those events, has expressed the opinion that Huntington did not intend to build here and that his visit to San Diego was for "political effect." He says that Huntington never actually made any proposal. Telling of Huntington's meeting with the San Diego committee. Mr. Morse later said that Huntington declared that he was not ready.
"I told them^" said Mr. Morse, "about General Rosecrans' trip to Jacumba Pass and what he said about the route. Mr. Huntington objected that it would take them down in Mexico, which he thought would make undesirable complications."
^Ir. Morse suggested that he could make some such arrangement with Mexico as had been made by the Grand Trunk in skirting the Canadian border. On this Huntington took a non-committal attitude, although General Rosecrans continued to praise the proposed route. partly through Mexican territory. It is interesting to note that the
San Diego & Arizona Railway, completed many years after by Mr. Spreckles, with the help of the Southern Pacific as a partner, took a route which ran through Mexican territory, dipping into the Southern Republic at Tijuana and emerging near Jacumba, in the mountains.
Mr. Huntington and his party left San Diego without submitting any proposal, and none was forthcoming later. This was followed by charges that Huntington was showing a spirit of vindictiveness. This feeling was not shared by Morse, who was in close touch with the situation and who was concerned with all the correspondence and negotiations connected with it. He attributed the attitude of the Huntington interests to the fact that they wanted the long haul into San P^rancisco and that if they had built to San Diego they would have been obliged to share the profits with a steamship line.
By 1879 the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe, stretching its rails across the continent in an ambitious plan not only to span the United States but to connect at the Pacific coast with a steamship service by which it might obtain a large share of the trade with the Orient, had been built as far as Santa Fe, New Mexico. To the heads of this creat system the people of San Diego, still hopeful and confident that they miight escape isolation in the development of transcontinental railway systems, went at last for relief. Ultimately they obtained it, only through no fault of their own to have disappointment embitter the cup of joy. They got the railroad connection but it soon developed that it was nothing more than a connection, instead of making San Diego a great western terminal.
In the negotiations which led up to this end Frank A. Kimball of National City was the acknowledged leader ; and to him is largely due the credit not only for what San Diego actually got but for the far greater portion to which she was rightfully entitled by reason of her natural advantages and generosity. Frank A. Kimball and his brother. Warren C. Kimball, owned large stretches of land in and about National City, where they had resided for some time. The family had a "show place" at the time when Col. Thomas A. Scott and his distinguished party had visited San Diego in 1872. Some of the Scott party took luncheon there. Mr. Kimball even before that had been actively interested in the plans to obtain a railroad for San Diego.
In 1878 he corresponded with Commodore Vanderbilt and with Jay Gould, then at the height of their power, but got little satisfaction from either. Smythe's history tells in an interesting manner of the careful way in which the next step was taken.
"After six months of futile correspondence with the railroad kings," he writes, "Mr. Kimball called a secret meeting at the residence of E. W. Morse on Tenth street in the spring of 1879. He and Elizur Steele represented National City, while Mr. Morse and T. S. Gordon represented San Diego. John G. Capron joined the secret committee at an early stage of the movement. It was decided that a vigorous efifort should be made to induce one of the railroads then building across the continent to come to San Diego Bay. Mr. Kimball was selected, was elected to represent the conimittee in the East and started on his mission about the first of June, 1879. The sum of $450 had been raised in San Diego and National City toward the expense of his trip, and he raised the balance by putting a mortgage on his house. He took with him the endorsement of the city authorities and of the Chamber of Commerce.
"Mr. Kimball went first to Philadelphia, where he soon concluded that there was no hope of doing anything with the Texas & Pacific. In New York he learned what he could of the intentions of Stanford and Huntington and came to the conclusion that the best hope of success lay with the Santa Fe. which was determined to strike the Pacific ocean somewhere and which, as he soon learned, was most favorably disposed to Guaymas, in Mexico."
Provenance
Text from City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.