San Diego, California - City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California (part 6 of 13)
From City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. 15,978 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
5 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,978 wordsMachine-read from scans of City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Then he went to see Thomas Nickerson, president of the Santa Fe System, at Boston, and spent several months there, pleading San Diego's cause with Nickerson and with other officers and directors of the line. That he jdid a hard task well is evident from all the records of that time. Ultimately he got the Santa Fe financiers, who were then powerful but not in a perfectly commanding position in the railway world, as was later evident, to promise to build a road forty miles east from San Diego within eight months. The Santa Fe. of course, was to build west and to connect. On his side he had agreed to raise $10,000 cash to pay for a right of way, to give 10,000 acres of the great National Rancho and to get much additional subsidy. The Santa Fe sent out three representatives, including an engineer, the next month, to investigate and they reported favorably. Then came the first of a series of disappointments resulting from San Diego's dealings with the .Santa Fe. The news came that the directors, instead of running their line through by the southern and direct route, had decided to go in with the Atlantic &: Pacific as the result of overtures which had been made by that line, to take an interest in the Atlantic & Pacific across the northern part of Arizona, to share in the advantages which that would give the Santa Fe of connection with San I'rancisco, always ])redominant in the California railway field, and, finally to share in the rich land subsidy which the Atlantic & Pacific had obtained. The new railroad deal was carried out, and the first agreement which Kimball had negotiated was off. So, after several conferences of the San Diego committee, he was sent back to Poston. There he succeeded in getting another agreement from the Santa Fe. San Diego raised a magnificent subsidv whose value amounted later to more than $3,000,000. A syndicate was formed to handle the lands put in by Kimball and otiiers. The Santa Fe agreed to run a line by way of Colton and to connect with the .Atlantic & Pacific. .\n arrangement which was not made public at the time and which subjected Kimball to some very severe criticism later provided that the real terminal should be at National City ; to this, however. National City and the Kimballs, by reason of their donations, were apparently entitled, as Smythe views the matter. At anv rate the terminal was put there, and National City as a result had a boom which threatened to put it out in front of San Diego.
."^an Diego's subsidy to the Santa Fe was indeed a princely one. Practically all who could well do so contributed to it and the final list shows a total of S25,000. more than 17,000 acres of land and 485 city lots. The Kimball brothers led the list with 10,000 acres, but there were many others who gave generously. The Bank of San Diego, for instance, gave $1,000; John G. Capron, who was active in the railroad negotiations of the time, gave $750; D. Choate, well known San Diegan, donated $400; Gordon & Hazzard's gift was $500 ; George Hyde's was $600 and twenty acres ; George W. Alarston, ever eager to aid San Diego, was down on the list for $300; E. W. Morse, with whom the San Diego committee had kept in touch with Kimball while the latter was in the east, gave $750; Charles S. Hamilton gave $500 ; Col. A. G. Gassen contributed 300 acres ; David Felsenheld gave twelve city lots ; A. Overbaugh's name went down for $500 and twelve city lots; A. H. Wilcox subscribed $1,000; A. E. Horton was down for $250; the city of San Diego put in 4,500 acres and 124 city lots. And so it went until there was more than 250 individuals and firms on the long list - a truly remarkable evidence of civic pride, faith in San Diego and generous, patriotic desire to helD in the city's advancements.
The contrast presented by what the Santa Fe did, finally removmg its "terminal" at National City and abandoning all effort to make San Diego a great railroad point - "utter bad faith," Smythe calls it - is not a picture pleasant to San Diegans. It must be remembered, however, that those of the Santa Fe who would have gladly helped San Diego were not always in a position to do so. Those were days of two-fisted fighting in stock control of railroads ; there was many struggles for such control of which there are few public records ; the Santa Fe passed from the hands of Nickerson and his associates into other hands ; policies were changed by force of necessity. Yet at this day the soreness of the Santa Fe hurts to San Diego have barely disappeared, although its relations with the newer Santa Fe are of the pleasantest kind. The erection of the beautiful Santa Fe station at the foot of Broadway in time for San Diego's Exposition of 1915 and 1916 is a notable example of the cordial relations now existing between the city and the great railroad system.
But to get back to the story. To complete the bargain with the Santa Fe, San Diego wanted to hand over to the railroad the lands which had been given to Colonel Scott's Texas & Pacific road, never built. There was a long delay in settling this - a delay extending over several years - and the upshot of it all was that the Texas & Pacific retained half of the lands. This seemed to be the best way out of it, and that was the way finally taken in 1880 when the case was finished before Judge JMcNealy in superior court.
In Octol>er of that year the San Diego end of the new road was chartered as the California Southern Railroad, to build from National City to San Bernardino. The officers were: Benjamin Kimball, who was soon succeeded by Thomas Nickerson of Boston, president, and M. A. Luce of San Diego, vice president. Other directors were George B. Wilbur and Lucius G. Pratt, who had come with engineer W. R. Morley from Boston early in the Santa Fe and Kimball negotiations ; John A. Fairchild and Frank A. Kimball. Judge Luce was attorney. The preliminaries were arranged as quickly as possible, and actual construction was rushed. By June. 1881, the first rail had been laid at National City. A year and a half later and the road was through to Colton, which was reached by way of Oceanside and the Temecula Canyon, and in September, 1883, the line had been built to San Bernardino. While the road was being built there San Diego grew rapidly. Then came disastrous times in the winter of 1883-84, the winter tioods rushing down Temecula Canyon and ripping out thirty miles of track.
The disaster - for it was nothing less - led many to believe that the line would never be rebuilt, and "thousands," to quote Judge M. A. Luce, left the city. The sum of $250,000 was set as necessary for the rebuilding work, and this at last was raised by putting a second mortgage on the property, and the line through Temecula Canyon was improved. It was, however, abandoned and a new line was run up the coast to San Juan Capistrano and Santa Ana, -making a connection with the Santa Fe from Los Angeles and thereby creating a branch of the San Diego line. As Smythe says, "from that time forward the Santa Fe railroad ceased to serve the pur])ose which the people of San Diego had in mind when they contributed their subsidy - the purpose of developing a seaport as the direct outlet of a true transcontinental railway - but this was not fully appreciated at the time."
By that time, too, the Southern Pacific, rival of the Santa Fe, had apparently got stock control of the Atlantic & Pacific and had threatened to build a line from Mojave to Needles, making it appear that the California Southern would be left "up in the air" with one end dangling at the north without any transcontinental connection and necessitating the construction of 300 miles more of road even to connect with the Southern Pacific. The Santa Fe financiers, however, got back control of the Atlantic & Pacific.
Through trains from the East began to arrive (ner the California Southern late in 1885, and on November 19 of that year the city held a celebration which will be long remembered by old residents of San Diego. A newspaper account of the affair refers to it as "our day of jubilee," and such it was, with the whole city and many invited guests joining in the festivities. The day was started with a parade led by the City (iuard r>and, then newly organized, with sixteen pieces. C. A. Burgess being leader and J. D. F*almer drum-major. Then came the San Diegt) City (hiard. the 7th Infantry Battalion of the National Chiard of the state. Lieut. George M. Dannals commanding. Then, in order, were Heintzleman Post No. 33, G. A. R., H. H. Conklin post commander; Chevalier Division. Uniform Rank, Knights of Pythias, E. T. Blackmer commanding: children of the public schools, members of the city board of trustees. "leather" A. E. Horton. who was president of the day. with the s])eakers ; officers of the Chamber of Commerce, officers of the .Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe, Atlantic & Pacific and California Southern; foreign consuls; veterans of the Mexican War and merchants of San Diego. The grand marshal was Gen. T. T. Crittenden, and his aides were J. C. Sprigg, Jr., and W. J. Hunsaker, with these assistants: W. W. IJowers, M. D. Hamilton, H. H. Conklin and T. J. Arnold. S]>eakers at the Opera House included Horton, Bowers. S. O. Houghton, Thomas S. Sedgwick, land agent of the .Atlantic ^- Pacific; Joseph Winchester, British consul; S. C. Evans and L. M. Holt of Riverside and Dr. L. C. Gunn.
The echoes of the big celebration had hardly died down before the Santa Fe shops at National City were moved. That let down the curtain on San Diego's brightest hopes from the Santa Fe. The great wharves and warehouses which had been planned in the days when Nickerson was at the helm would have been started, Judge Luce has said, if Nickerson and his associates had been young and strong enough to meet the financial crisis which then was beginning to loom; but they passed out of control of the great Santa Fe system and left it to the hands of others, hoping, as Judge Luce adds, "to save the company from the receivership which, in the end, they were finally compelled to accept."
Yet as Judge Luce also says, it was San Diego alone of all the cities of California which brought the Santa Fe to the Pacific coast ; and that much satisfaction San Diego may cherish for what it is worth. It is true also that the coming of the Santa Fe to San Diego gave the city a great deal of beneficial advertising and brought many to the city; and even though the end of the boom of 1887-88 saw a great deal of the population fade away ; San Diego had received a net gain of no small importance. That is plain to an unprejudiced observer. To many who had worked hard and hopefully against this combination of circumstances which resulted in so much disappointment to San Diego, the outcome at the time served to be a cruel blow. Some years later indeed Judge Luce in a public address referred to it in such words as these :
"Thus in 1890 San Diego was again stripped of all its commercial hopes, and had nothing remaining to it as a resource for building a city except its attractive climate."
Of those living in San Diego today there is probably no man who was more closely in touch with the dealings of San Diegans and the Santa Fe Railroad than is Judge M. A. Luce, well known citizen and attorney, to whom reference has been made. He was one of the organizers of the California Southern, by which San Diego obtained a connection with the Atlantic & Pacific line, and served for several years as vice-president and general counsel of that company. Moreover, before the California Southern was formed, he had lived in San Diego for about seven years and had not only seen the failure of the Tom Scott project but had been in close touch with the preliminary negotiations with the Santa Fe officials.
In a recent conversation w^ith the writer Judge Luce gave the following interesting account of the California" Southern and Santa Fe matters :
"The California Southern was organized in the fall of 1880 to build directly north to meet the Atlantic & Pacific. It was completed to Barstow in December, 1885. All of the subsidies which the people of San Diego gave for the new railroad were given to the California Southern - a matter of some interest in itself. These lands later were transferred to the Land and Town Company. For a long time the Santa Fe ran trains to and from San Diego by lease of the California Southern, as the Santa Fe at that time did not own the line. The road, as is well known, was built first up through the Temecula Canyon, going through Murrietta, Ferris and Colton to San Bernardino, leaving Riverside about two and a half miles from the road. At the request of Riverside, which naturally wanted to be on the line of the new road, another survey was made to carry out Riverside's purpose of getting on the line. In connection with this plan the people of Riverside gave a banquet to which president Nickerson was invited as guest of honor, and I also was there. I recall that they displayed in a striking manner samples of the fruits which are grown in that section - oranges, lemons and so on - and their speakers declared that Riverside was the only big producing region in Southern California. Mr. Nickerson made a nice little speech in reply, talking in a kindly way, but declared that he would not swerve the line of the road by so much as a mile for all the products of Southern California. I mention this matter to make it plain that his purpose in having this road built was to furnish a connection by which he could carry out plans he had made for extensive international trade. He intended to have here wharves and depots from which three steamship lines would go on three routes, namely, to South America, the Hawaiian Islands, and to Yokohama and Hong Kong. Some have thought it peculiar that he made such elaborate plans for internaticmal commerce, but it must be remembered that Nickerson was a shipper and had made much money in that way. Then, too, it must be remembered that at that time coal was being mined very cheaply in Australia ; it was delivered at the wharves in Sydney at about a dollar and a half a ton. One of his plans, for instance, was to bring that coal to San Diego and to carry goods from San Diego to Australia. That is just an example of how he had worked out his plans. Another matter which must be considered is the cheapness of coal in the United States at that time. F'or that reason Nickerson did not care much for heavy grades on the Santa Fe line ; heavy grades and consequent consumption of extra fuel did not mean so much in those days as it would mean now. That is a point which I have found is not commonly understood by those who refer to that period.
"In accordance with these elaborate plans, plans were laid out for great warehouses and terminals and wharves. The failure came from the great financial break of 1892 and 1893. The whole San Diego plan was abandoned and the road was turned back into a combination with the Southern Pacific.
"The Santa I'e j)lan, as it atTected San Diego, really failed as the Tom Scott plan had failed, because of financial storms. Why, when T came here in 1873 thev were grading ten miles of road for the Texas & F*acific connection, and it looked very much for a time as if the Scott plan would succeed, but that was stopped bv the financial (11)
"The new men in the Santa Fe as directors did not carry out the plans which Nickerson had made, and in the course of time they moved the shops from National City to San Bernardino and really made Los Angeles the terminal, at least for Southern California."
Before John D. Spreckels announced that he would build the San Diego & Arizona Railway San Diego made another effort, extending over several years, to provide a direct rail outlet to the East. That took form in the organization of the San Diego-Eastern Railway Company. This movement was started in the Chamber of Commerce, which appointed a railway committee, headed by George W. Marston, who for many years has been in the very forefront of every organized attempt to advance the interests of the city. That committee, styled the San-Diego Eastern Railway Committee, issued a statement of its purposes and an appeal to the public on July 20, 1901. This statement was summarized as follows :
"The San Diego-Eastern Railway Committee in response to the demand of the Chamber of Commerce and citizens generally, having given full consideration to the subject in hand, submits the following plan :
"Fourth, to secure the services of a competent chief engineer whose duties shall be to indicate the kind of route required to meet the highest demand of a first-class modern system and prepare detailed estimates concerning the cost of construction, equipment and operation of such line.
''Fifth, to secure all possible data and exact information for a prospectus which shall duly set forth the reasons why such a road should be undertaken without delay and shall make to capital an appeal in behalf of the project, absolutely convincing.
( "ine of the principal movers in the plan was Major S. W. Fereusson, who had taken a large part in the colonization of Imperial \^allev. This great inland empire, watered by the "Nile of America", the Colorado River, was then in its infancy, but the vast possibilities of the section as an agricultural treasure ground were about to unfold, and Fergusson and other far-sighted men of the time had become convinced of its coming greatness. He was made general manager of the Chamber's committee. Other members of the comm.ittee were L. L. Boone, well known attorney, who was secretary ; U. S. Grant, Tr., who later built the U. S. Grant Hotel in San Diego ; John E.
Boal, superintendent of the San Diego Land and Town Company ; F. S. [ennings, head of an investment company bearing his name, and W. F. Holt of Imperial X'alley.
The general plan, as outlined in the beginning, was to build a railway from San Dieco to bdrt \'uma. Arizona, following, roughly speaking, the lines laid down in \ari(nis projects and surveys that had been made in the year> iirecedin^-. Surveys were made by H. T. Richards, chief engineer, with H. Hawgood as consulting engineer, and when three years bad elapsed it was announced that a line had been "'carefully and com])letely surveyed" to Yuma. The company then made this statement:
"About thirty miles of this line has been permanently located and is now practically ready for grading. A careful preliminary line has been run from Fort Yuma through Southern Arizona to the town of Fairbanks near the present western terminus of the El Paso and Southwestern Railroad and also to Benson on the same line.
"These surveys have brought realization to our most hopeful expectations, as they have demonstrated beyond question not only the feasibility and practicability, but also the superiority of this transcontinental line over all the others now constructed, from the standpoint of its shortness, low altitude at which it crosses the mountain ranges and consequent low gradient, favorable curvature and cheapness of construction and maintenance, as very fully aj^pears from oilr engineer's reports.
"A striking illustration of this suj^criority may be had when one compares the cost of this line with that of the Union Pacific, which is capitalized for over $100,000 per mile.
"The amount of the capitalization of forty miles of that road would build and e(|uip our line, in an e(|ually substantial manner, from the bay of San Diego to the Colorado River, while the amount of the capitalization of 140 miles of that line would build and equip our line to the town of Fairbanks. Arizona, to a connection with the El Paso and Southwestern, a distance of nearly .^00 miles.
''W^e have secured by purchase, or contract, the right of way over almost the entire line to the Colorado River, and have purchased, paid for, and now own thirty acres of land and many town lots near the bay. and along our right of way, within the city of San Diego, most eligilile and suitable for shops, yards, ternn'nal groimds, warehouses, etc., and have options to purchase 100 acres more.
"We have a franchise through the entire city of San Diego, and extending for over three miles along the most desirable bay frontage, giving us the most ample and favorable facilities for wharfage and shipping.
The booklet in which this statement is made contains such a good picture of San Diego of twenty years ago that it is well worth reproducing :
"San Diego, with a population of 25,000, ranks as the second city of Southern California. Located at a distance of 126 miles from Los Angeles, and, like the latter, a favorite spot with Eastern tourists, it enjoys many of the improvements and facilities not usually to be found in a city of its size. It has an extensive system of street railways, connecting' the residence sections with the business centre, with the ferry to Coronado, and with the depots of the Santa Fe svstem, and the various suburban railways. Additional franchises have been granted, and several new lines are under construction. The hotel facilities are most extensive and very superior, especially when it is considered that the famous Coronado is within thirty minutes' ride of the business centre. There are over sixty-five miles of graded, nearly four miles of asphalt paved and a considerable length of macadamized streets. There is a good system of sewerage, with about forty miles of pipe. The extensive water plant is now owned by the city. School accommodations are ample and of the best. The high school occupies a commanding site overlooking the town.
"There is a well equipped library housed in a large and beautiful building, erected at a cost of $60,000, occupying beautiful grounds. As the seat of one of the largest counties in California, the city has public buildings of superior character. One of the finest normal schools in the state' is also located here in a building of unusual architectural beauty. The comfort and attractiveness of its many homes, due in part to the presence of wealthy people, drawn here by the charming climate, has given to San Diego the name of 'Homeland' a distinction to which it is well entitled."
Naturally, there was no thought on the part of those working for the new railroad project that the line could be built by San Diegans alone. Their plan was to make preliminary surveys, obtain certain rights of way and then appeal to the great railway financiers of the nation in the hope of getting some man or group of men to take the plan up and finish the work. To carry on the preliminary work a sum of about $40,000 - no inconsiderable sum for San Diego to contribute in those days - was raised. Many citizens gave comparatively large sums, but a lot of small contributions, pleasing evidence of the unshaken faith of the people in the plan, were made. In all there were some 800 contributors. The directors of the railway gave loyally and unsparingly of time, money and efifort to interest financiers and railway builders in the project. Mr. Marston and ^Ir. Boone made several trips to New York and other cities of the East and carried eloquent appeals to the great railroad men of that time, among them Phelps, Dodge & Co., George J. Gould and E. H. Harriman of the Southern Pacific. They were all interested, but none of them could take up the enterprise then. The time was not ripe, some said. It was evident that others who might have helped were so bound by certain agreements that they could not aid. Mr. Marston recently related to the writer an amusing incident which grew out of a conference which he and Secretary Boone had with Cleveland Dodge of I'helps, Dodge & Co. The little San Diego road had t)een somewhat impressively capitalized for $10,000,000, but only $217,000 had actually been subscribed. The great railway magnate, having talked with his San Diego visitors for a few minutes, and expressing great interest in the plan, suggested that some knowledge which he had of the steel market would aid the San Diegans in their railway building. Steel, he said, w?as going to rise in price, and now was a good time to buy steel rails for that new road. Mr. Marston and Mr. Boone, knowing they had not the money available to equip even ten miles of the line with rails, nevertheless held straight faces and expressed keen interest in the "tip". But after they returned to their hotel rooms they had a laugh wliich sent them rolling on their beds for relief.
The San Diego project was enlarged on paper, in the course of time, to include a line clear through from San Diego to El Paso, and a statement of what could be expected of a railway running betw-een the two cities was drawn up and presented to at least one railway magnate. Although it bore no immediate fruits, it contains such a clear and interesting summary of the railroad situation as affecting San Diego that space may well be given to it. The statement was furnished to the writer recently by Mr. Marston, who throughout the life of the San Diego-Eastern Company was naturally in close touch at all times with what that company tried to do. It is as follows :
1. El Paso is the terminus of five important railroads, viz., the Santa Fe, Rock Island, Texas & Pacific, Southern Pacific and Mexican Central. The St. Louis & San Francisco Railroad is also being built toward El Paso. From El Paso there is only one railroad, the Southern Pacific, running directly w^estward to the Pacific coast. This road is doing an enormous business, and present traffic alone justifies another line.
2. San Diego is the nearest Pacific port to El Paso, the distance being about 750 miles, a less distance than El Paso is from Galveston in its own state. By the proposed San Diego-Eastern Railroad the mileage frouT El Paso to San Diego will be 100 miles less than to San Pedro, the port used by Los Angeles. It is even a less distance to San Francisco by way of San Diego h.irbor, using steamer connection at San Diego, than it is by rail from El Paso to San Francisco over the Southern Pacific. It can be easily demonstrated that freight transportation between San Francisco and El Paso will cost less per ton via San Diego than by any other route. It naturally follows that the short line advantages of the San Diego railroad apply particularly to the whole southwest country that is covered by the railroads terminating at El Paso, and also in a large measure to general transcontinental traffic from the Atlantic to the Pacific.
3. San Diego has a safe, capacious harbor that is adequate for the largest commerce. Its natural advantages are now being improved by the United States Government with an expenditure of $267,000. Before the end of the year the depth of water over the bar will admit vessels of 30,foot draught at mean low tide (this work had been accomplished in November, 1903), and the new jetty is expected to maintain this ample depth. The port is only 116 miles from the great circle route that ships would take from Brito or Panama to Yokohama, and on the completion of the isthmian canal this will be of great commercial importance. In general, the harbor of San Diego is recognized as the natural shipping point for an immense commerce. Even under adverse conditions the imports and exports for the year 1900 amounted to four million dollars valuation.
4. A thorough railroad survey from San Diego to Yuma, and a careful reconnaissance from Yuma to Tucson and Benson, Arizona, have demonstrated very clearly that the proposed short line from San Diego directly eastward is not only practicable, but that it is a better one physically than any of the existing lines that enter California. For more detailed information, reference may be made to a "Summary of the Survey of the San Diego-Eastern Railway", which the San Diego committee has prepared.
5. The opportunity herewith presented for profitable freight business is very unusual. The possibilities of transcontinental trafific in connection with steamship lines to the Orient can hardly be estimated, but any conservative consideration will satisfy one of the immense business that can be secured. Undoubtedly a large share of Central California business will come to the new railroad, owing to cheap v\-ater transportation along the coast, as compared to the costly railroad haul between San Francisco and Yuma, a distance of 730 miles. Mexican and South American business will certainly be done through the port of San Diego, as both water and land distances are shorter for traffic interchange between points south of San Diego on the Pacific and the large cities of the West and Southwest. Thousands ot' tons of ores for Colorado smelters, and great quantities of cofifee for the Middle West are now carried past this port to San Francisco, owing to the lack of railroad and steamship co-operation. For Southeastern Arizona business, San Diego is the natural western connection. The largest item of freight would be lumber, which can be handled more cheaply through this port than anywhere else. The Southern Pacific is carrying annually about 6,000 carloads of Puget Sound lumber to Arizona, all of which goes via San Pedro now. Phoenix, Tucson, Bisbee, Yuma and other Arizona cities would welcome a short railroad line to San Diego and have business to ofl:er.
Colorado Delta traffic is all tributary to San Diego, and the most fertile part of it lies in San Diego County (that was before Imperial County was formed) and in Lower California south of San IDiego County. This county is now 298 miles by rail from San Diego City, and the new road would bring it 150 miles nearer. The amazing development of the Imperial Valley will alone justify the building of the California part of the proposed road. Within three years 4,000 people have settled in the valley; production of grain and livestock has risen from nothing in 1901 to 10,000 tons in 1903; and the estimate for 1904 in 40,000 tons. The water supply from the Colorado is ample for millions of acres, and the Imperial companies alone have 300,000 acres of irrigable land. As only a tenth of this is yet under cultivation, the increase of production will be enormous.
6. San Diego is a city of 25,000 people and is growing rapidly. Its local railroad business makes the California Southern railroad line from Los Angeles to this point one of the most profitable lines on the Santa Fe system. The county produces more lemons and honey than any other in California ; general agricultural conditions are good this year: 50,000 tons of grain (including Imperial Valley) have been produced ; industries are improving, and all kinds of mercantile business growing. The United States Government is expending about a million dollars in fortifications, barracks, quarantine station, roads and harbor improvements. Every year adds to the material resources and traffic business of San Diego city and county.
7. The passenger business of the San Diego-h^astern Railroad would be vastly larger than on ordinary lines in the western interior. San Diego is an unrivalled tourist and health resort in both summer and winter. With all its present adverse conditions in respect to railroads, it attracts thousands of travelers here each season. Three thousand people were at Tent City, Coronado Beach, at one time during the present summer, and direct railroad connection with Arizona would add immensely to summer travel. Transcontinental passenger business would of course be very large, tourists naturally preferring to begin their Southern California travel at the most southern point.
8. Looking at the proposition in a large, general way, it is very evident that a modern railway from El Paso to San Diego, being 100 miles shorter than the Southern Pacific to its ocean terminals and built under a bond issue perhaps one-half that of its competitor, would easily take the lead in economy of operation and profita!)le results.
Among those to whom an appeal was made was John D. Spreckels, whose interest in San Diego had been aroused. F. S. Tennings was selected to confer confidentially with him, but Mr. Spreckels was not ready then to announce his plans, which later gave the San Diego <S: .\rizona to San Diego. Nor was Mr. Harriman of the Southern Pacific ready to aid. But in December, 1*^X)6, the San Diego & .\rizona announcement was made, and it later develo[)ed, through announcement by Mr. Sj)reckels, that the great head of the Southern Pacific was his partner in the enterprise.
When the plans for the new lines had been made, the San Diego & .Arizona took over the entire holdings of the San Diego-Eastern and Mr. Spreckels sent to Mr. Marston a check covering the amount of the fund which had been subscril)ed by San Diego ]ieople.
At one time the San Diego-Eastern plan had been worked thr(^ugh to such an extent that a third interest had been taken, or was about to be taken, by each of two well known men heavily interested in railroad buiUling and the San Diego-Eastern directors tried to get Mr. .'Spreckels to take the remaining third. Mr. S])reckels held off. however, and Mr. Harriman although he came here to .see the city and its possibilities, also declined to give a definite answer. When he arrived in San Diego, Chief iMigineer Richards of the San Diego- Eastern was out of town, engaged in field work tor the road, and bv the time he was brought in to give- engineering information which the directors wished to give Mr. Harriman. the great railroad man had gone to Santa Barbara. Secretary Boone and ICngineer Richards went on after him later, but accompUshed nothing, although the San Diego-Eastern plans were laid before the Southern Pacific's engineer at San Francisco at about that time.
At all times in the history of the San Diego-Eastern, to which in no small degree is due the credit for bringing the San Diego & Arizona to San Diego, the people of the city took keen interest in what was going on, or in what they could learn of the various negotiations, and the various visits which the officers of the road made to interview great railway men were watched closely. At various times this interest was imjDatient, as San Diego wanted the direct road to the East and wanted it (|uickly, and this impatience even took the form of suggestions that actual construction ought to be started at once ; those suggestions, or demands, of course, were based on misinformation as to the money necessary for such work and as to how little the company actually had to spend.
With the driving of a golden spike, the last j)ut into the ties of the San Diego & Arizona Railway, John D. S])reckels, president of the line, on Nov. 15, 191*>, brought to realization a dream which San Diego had cherished for many years. By this spike-driving the noted .San Diegan also closed one of the most interesting chapters in the whole history of American railway building. For the building of this direct rail outlet to the East, making connection with the Southern Pacific lines and thus providing one of the shortest routes to the East, was accomplished only by dint of great perseverance and pluck on the part of its sponsor. It was on Dec. 14, 1906, that John D. Spreckels" morning news])aper. The San Diego Union, thrilled the citv with the announcement that this railroad was to be built. Yet the task extended over nearly thirteen years and was attended by discouragements and setbacks which would have daunted most men. It is to be seriously doubted that the line would have been built - at least for a long time after it was actually finished - but for the persistent courage and never-ceasing faith of its builders, headed by Mr. Spreckels. The financial item alone is one of staggering im])ortance, for to construct the 148 miles of line from .San Diego to El Centro in Imperial \'allev recpiired a sum said to have been approximately $18,000,000. Yet other great factors entered into the problem, making it seem at times almost impossible of solution, e.xcept perhaps after long and disheartening delay. The railroad, however, was put through as have been most enteri)rises to wliicli John D. .*^])reckels has set his shoulder.
It has developed since the i)lan of the San Diego & Arizona was announced that John D. Spreckels was not the originator of the road. Records of the courts in a dispute, happily settled, with the Southern Pacific Railway show that he was approached by men high in the councils of that great railway system to act in behalf of the Southern I'acific in Iniilding a line from San Diego across the mountains into Imjierial \'alley. The Southern Pacific, for reasons sufficient to its controlling interests, did not wish, at the time, to be identified with the project. To quote from an address made several years ago by William Clayton, vice president of the Spreckels companies in San Diego and always enjoving Mr. Spreckels' fullest confidence, "it was not possible for them (the Southern Pacific interests) to come in either under their own name or as some other small corporation without being suspected, but as long as Mr. Spreckels would announce his intention to build the road, it could be done without suspicion."
So Spreckels announced the plan. The news created one of the greatest real estate booms which San Diego ever had, but it was a "good" boom, based on actuality, and the city began to forge ahead rapidly. Few doubted Spreckels' ability to complete the task as he promised he would. Evidence of this is found in the columns of the San Diego Sun, then going under the merger name of the San Diegan-Sun, an independent newspaper which on occasion has fought the Spreckels interests in matters of public discussion. After the announcement was made, the Sun gave Spreckels credit "for securing to San Diego what has long been San Diego's most urgent need - a railway direct to the East." Confidence also was expressed by the Sun's editor that Spreckels would carry the plan to success and called on the people of the city "to lift their hats to him." Smythe in his history, written just about the time the announcement was made, referred to it as starting "a new epoch" in San Diego.
The articles of incorporation of the San Diego & Arizona were drawn up June 14, 1906, although they were not filed until Dec. 14 of that vear. The incorporators were John D. Spreckels, his brother, Adolph B. Spreckels. his son, John D. Spreckels, Jr., William Clayton, to whom reference already has been made, and Harry L. Titus, for vears the highly trusted legal advisor of the Spreckels interests in San Diego.
Typical of President Spreckels was his generous announcement, soon after the papers were filed, that he would repay, dollar for dollar, the sum collected by those loyal San Diegans who had tried so valiantly before to put through a railroad under the name of the San Diego-Eastern. And the whole sum was paid back by him. He also announced the filing of condemnation suits to obtain rights-of-way in the city, instead of asking at the very start for a generous subsidy, as others had done before him.
Actual work on the railroad was started in a short time. Yet the task was monumental and progress was distressingly slow - or thus it seemed to the loyal but long-waiting people of San Diego. In 1911, for instance, it was announced to the world through a Chamber of Commerce booklet that sixty miles of grading had been done anr! fifty-five miles of track had been laid. F)Ut, impressive as those figures were, the road was far from being finished four years after it was begun.
E. H. Harriman, the great railroad wizard, was of course interested in the work, but his most active interest seems to have been aroused no sooner than the spring of 1910, when he came to the Pacific coast in his private car and paid John D. Spreckels a visit at the latter's home in Coronado. Again to quote William Clayton :
"John D. and Mr. Harriman had a heart-to-heart talk. ]\Ir. Harriman took a liking to Mr. Spreckels and Mr. Spreckels took a liking to him, and they became fast friends. Mr. Harriman told Mr. Spreckels to go ahead, and he would stand behind the enterprise.
Mr. Spreckels was to finish the road, and any pledges Mr. Spreckels made were to be cared for by the Southern Pacific and would be fully and completely redeemed. Mr. Spreckels went ahead. Then Mr. Harriman died. (That was on Sept. 9, 1909). A sudden change came over the policies of the Southern Pacific. They went back on Mr. Harriman's word and literally left Mr. Spreckels up in the air. He went on to New York to see the Southern Pacific. They seemed obdurate and disinclined to do anything. They refused to accept Mr. Harriman's pledges. As an outcome of this meeting a sort of agreement was entered into whereby Mr. Spreckels claims he had the right to take over the railroad within a ])eriod of twelve months under certain conditions."
The controlling forces in the Southern Pacific at the time, however, contended that they had actually sold the road to Spreckels. The question was taken to the courts, and at last was settled to the satisfaction of all concerned - for the road was continued. P>ut there w^as a long delav. At the completion of the line Mr. Spreckels himself threw light on this part of the affair when he told about the refusal of the Southern Pacific to go ahead with the Harriman plan. He had asked the new president of the Southern Pacific why he wanted to stop, and got this reply :
'* 'Well,' I said, 'then let me do it.' and from that moment on T did it, and continued the building with such funds as I could spare from mv business, and such funds as my brother aided me with.
"I continued the building of the road until we reached Campo. \\'lien that point was reached, there was a new change in the administration of the Southern Pacific and by the good effort of ^^r. Kruttschnitt, Mr. Sproule and mv eood friend. I\lr. Gillis. we then at that point formed a partnership to go ahead with it. and we agreed we would build a road jointK' on a 50-.^0 basis. 1 realize<i that if the road was to be completed that was the best thing that could happen, as it would form a trans-continental line, somethini^' that otherwise might not ever ha\e baiipened to the citv of San Diego."
The outbreak of the Great War in F,urope delayed nrogre'^s on the road for a long time. Attempts to float bond issues abroad failed because canital was being diverted into war channel-^. P>ut that was not all. Here may be quoted a section of an article which D. W. Pontius, then manager of the San Diesf<> >Jv .\rizona. wrote for the S(nUhern r:\af\c I'uUetin of Mav. l''Jl :
"Then after the I'tiited States entered the war. construction work on all railroads was stopjied wiien the Federal Government took over the \\ue<.
"President Spreckels and representatives of the Southern Pacific Company took the matter up with Director General of the Railroads and with President Wilson, and owing to the importance of the line as a factor of protection when the country was at war - providing as it does, a transcontinental line adjacent to the border from the Pacific Coast to the Gulf of Mexico, a direct avenue for supplies to the great army and naval bases at San Diego - it was released from Federal control and continued under construction during the entire period of the war. It is the only railroad in the United States which received such permission.
"The flood at San Diego in 1916 was another set back washing out portions of the completed road, causing a loss of half a million dollars and interrupting the w-ork.
"In completing the road many difficult engineering problems were encountered and solved. The Carriso Gorge, one of the scenic v;onders of the line, presented puzzling difficulties. To build a railroad along its ragged edges had long been considered impossible, but was finally accomplished by blasting a broad and secure avenue on an easy gradient out of solid rock. The eleven mile stretch through this gorge cost $3,939,000 alone. A large amount of tunneling was made necessary in the construction of the road, and seventeen of the twenty-one tunnels on the line are located in Carriso Gorge. This success in construction is due to the engineering genius of William Hood, chief engineer of the Southern Pacific Company, who has thus added another notable achievement to his record, which includes the construction of the Tehachapi loop and the Lucin cut-ofif."
Certain other features of the road merit notice. It runs for 44 miles in Mexican territory, entering Mexico at Tijuana and crossing back into the United States near Tecate. There are 2.98 miles of tunnels on the San Diego & Arizona, the sum of $1,760,000 having been spent on that work alone. The longest of the tunnels is 2,604 feet long; the shortest is 287 feet long. A remarkable freedom from smoke and disagreeable fumes is noticed, however, by all travelers, as the tunnels are of large bore, and well ventilated and the atmosphere is light at that altitude. The highest and longest bridge on the line is the Campo Creek viaduct, which is 600 feet long, and 180 feet high. The highest point on the line is Hipass, whose elevation is 3,360 feet and the lowest is El Centro, 49 feet below sea level. At Redondo, Mexico, is a great double horseshoe curve, where the track can be seen on the mountain slope in three dififerent elevations at one time.
It has been officially declared that the San Diego S: Arizona Railway, in connection with the .Southern Pacific road, furnishes a route to the east 140 miles shorter than any other line running from Chicago to the Pacific coast. The railway has the lowest grades of any transcontinental line entering California, or any other Pacific coast state, from the East.
City Of Sax Diego Axd Sax Diego Couxty 173
by Southern California and especially Imperial Valley: Arizona, New Mexico and Utah. The trade of the Orient and the West coast is now opened to San Diego to a greater and more comprehensive extent. Vast sums of money were expended on improvements to the harbor in anticipation of the S. D. & A."
As noted before, the actual completion of the San Diego & Arizona was marked by the driving of a golden spike. The ceremony was held in Carriso Gorge N^ov. 15, 1919, and was attended by many residents of San Diego and Imperial counties. In the crowd that went from San Diego was many an old-timer who had waited long for such a dav, whose hopes had been battered down by disappointment as plan after {)lan failed but who on this day wore a happy smile, marking his rejoicing that the dream had come true. President Spreckels of course was the central figure in the exercises, and before he stripped oflf his coat to drive ihe spike, he made a short talk in which he gave E. H. Harriman. "the biggest railroad man of the countrv," credit for originating the plan for the railway, told about his later difficulties with the Southern Pacific and their hapjiy ending and gave in a few words his view of what the road meant to San Diego and Imperial X'alley. Melville Klauber. then president of the Chamber of Commerce, presided and made an address of which this is part :
"You have seen the physical difficulties in the construction of this road, but ^Fr. Spreckels found other difficulties fully as great. Thev were difficulties that any other man would have found unsurmountable. This is really the 30th anniversary of the first attempt made to construct this railway. I read in a copy of The Union of 1871 that a meeting was called to vote SIO.OOO in bonds to build the railroad. Thev little realized what it all meant. This railroad today has cost manv millions. It needed an unusual man. of imusual pluck and unusual patience to put it through. We are not only here to celebrate the completion of the road, but to do honor in a simple way to the man who completed it. Others of San Diego who could not attend this celebration are here in spirit."
The first speaker was Mayor L. J. Wilde of San Diego, who referred to the occasion as a ''wedding day." in which the Harbor of the Golden Sun and the great Imperial \'alley were united. He also spoke a note which appealed to all his hearers when he said :
"I wish wo could bring back some of the old-timers for this occasion, and refer with feeling to old. dear, respected Father Norton, to old Tesse Gilmore and some of the old-timers who -trug-gled to raise the first $10,000 with which to build this road. I believe we should think a moment of the great man who assisted in the work which will be completed when Mr. Spreckels drives the golden spike. I mean Mr. Harry L. Titus, to whom we owe a debt of gratitude for the wav he struggled and worked for the success of this great road."
Cantu, governor of Lower California : D. VV. Pontius, general manager of the railway, and Frank Hevener, president of the Associated Chambers of Commerce of Imperial Valley. E. J. Kallright, chief engineer of the line during construction, was cheered when the crowd got a view of the modest worker.
A pretty little ceremony took place at the Mexican town of Tecate, where President Spreckels left the train and was welcomed by the ofificials of that city. Juan Prieto Quemper, judge of the court at Tecate, was the speaker. In congratulating Mr. Spreckels and the people of San Diego on the completion of the new road he said:
"I rejoice myself in having the opportunity to welcome you; and whv not, if opportunity is the great science of life? To grasp opportunity means to be intelligent ; means to be aggressive ; means to be alive to possibilities, and you gentlemen, owners of this railroad, have done a great, transcendental and magnificent achievement, because vou grasped the opportunity. You have made possible dreams of long ago ; you have brought into realization hopes born and cherished at the warmth of civilization. Yours is a brotherly w^ork, yours is a patriotic and noble impulse which will start a new era of development and betterment which \x\\\ reach from one end of our country to the other. This date in which you are going to nail down the last spike on the San Diego & Arizona Railway will be hailed by the people of this community as a day never to be forgotten ; young and old ones will ever think of it as a token of God, because we come nearer to vou in a spirit of justice and fairness, and it equally brings you closer to us in a spirit of friendship and hope. Hope for the best, hope for new days to shine on your land and the land of ours. It is not chimerical to assume that the day is fast approaching when both the American and the ^Mexican people, knowing themselves better, will each have perfect confidence in the other.
"You are great, powerful and prosperous ; we are passing through a nainful evolution of our life as a nation; but we are supremely confident of our future, we have deep faith in our destiny and we firmly believe in better days. If God Almighty made us forever neighbors, let Him make us forever friends."
The following account of the elaborate celebration held Dec. 1 to Dec. 6. 1919, to mark the completion of the San Diego & Arizona is taken from an article in the San Diego Union of Jan. 1, 1920:
Transcontinental Railway Week from start to finish. Dec. 1 to 6, established for San Diego a new and even more brilliant record in way of festival. It eclipsed even the glittering pageantrv and ceremonies of exposition times. For six glorious days and nights the people of the Sun Harbor and Imperial Vallev entered heart and soul into the most elaborate program of festivities that the Southland has ever seen. And in this they were joined by thousands of visitors from Southern California, Arizona, New Mexico and many of the Eastern states.
features, went to Carl H. Heilbron, general chairman. Capably assisted by Vice-Chairman Duncan MacKinnon, (]. A. Davidson, Frank J. Belcher, H. H. Jones, and scores of other willing workers, Mr. Heilbron worked night and day. Just how well he succeeded is a matter of record. Full share of the credit also is given those who hel]jed him to overcome numerous obstacles and give to San Diego something of which it can well be proud.
Four days of hesta were staged in San Diego - John D. Spreckels Day, Harbor Day, Stadium Day and Balboa Park Day. Then the scene shifted to the great Imperial Valley, where for two days the people of the Inland Empire proved that they are ecpially talented as entertainers.
Through the celebration publicity bureau, headed by Sam Porter, proprietor of the San Diego Hotel, news of the approaching opening of San Diego's new transcontinental line and details of the big celebration was spread boardcast. Almost every newspaper in the country carried stories, many with pictures. The magazines went to it hard, and the i)ul)lications of Southern California, realizing that it was a big story and an equally big event, literally ate up the matter furnished them. The San Francisco Chronicle published a special section descripti\e of the new railway, the celebratit)n and San Diego in general.
The wonderful enthusiasm of the people had also much to do with the success of Transcontinental Railway Week. It was an event for which San Diego had waited for half a century, and when the dream of the people was at last realized, they went wild with joy. Never before did the people of the city get together and co-operate more fully in any undertaking.
Transcontinental Railway Week was officially opened with the arrival of the first through train from El Centro, Imperial \'alley, on the afternoon of Monday, Dec. 1. At that hour the city was overflowing with visitors, and almost every man, woman and child in San Diego was out to see the big doings. The business district was beautifully decorated. Broadway, from .Sixth Street to the Union station, was jammed with merrymakers.
The demonstration when the train rolled up to the station was one that will never be forgotten by those who witnessed it. The event was acce^^ted by all as the most im])orant in the historv of the city. ( )ld-timers, who had prayed ftir a transcontinental railroad during the long years, wej^t from joy.
Aboard this tram was John 1). Sprcckels, president and builder of the new railway, and on the station platform to. greet him was Governor William D. Stephens of California. President Spreckels was given a rousing ovation, and many crowded forward to grasp his hand.
With President Spreckels on the first train from El Centro was Governor Thomas E. Campbell of .Arizona and many prominent railroad men. A large Imperial Valley delegation also came over on this train. Among the distinguished men at the station t<> greet the builder were Mayor James Rolph of San Francisco. Brig.-Gen. Joseph H. Pendleton, .Admiral Hugh Rodman, commander of the Pacific
Fleet ; Admiral Hugh Wiley, Gen. Joseph E. Kuhn. commander at Camp Kearny ; Hon. W. R. Armstrong, representing Governor Simon Bamberger of Utah ; Mayor L. J. Wilde, and many others.
After the movie cameras of a dozen national weekly companies had been leveled on the distinguished men and women in the party, a great parade was formed, traversing the principal streets and disbanding at Balboa Park, where exercises were conducted at the Spreckels Organ Pavilion. Here each of the visiting dignitaries extended congratulations to Mr. Spreckels and to San Diego. On the evening of that day an elaborate banquet was tendered President Snreckels and the distinguished guests at the Hotel del Coronado. There were many speeches. Lyman J. Gage acted as toastmaster.
Then came Harbor Day, Tuesday, Dec. 2, a day set aside to exemplify the value of San Diego's superb land-locked harbor as an outlet for the new railroad. The afternoon was devoted to water sports, in which all the aquatic clubs of the city 'participated, and at night a great water carnival and naval display was held. Superbly illuminated and with their flash lights and signal lights playing over the waters of the bay and upon the city, the 71 warships, at anchor in the harbor, played a leading part in the spectacle. Among these ships were the superdreadnaughts New Alexico, Idaho and Mississippi, and the Australian battle cruiser New Zealand. It was the most formidable array of fighting ships ever mobilized in Pacific waters.
Next came Stadium Day. Celebrated with athletic events of all kinds in the city's big $150,000 stadium, it constituted one of the most popular features of ihe celebration. The army and navy figured prominently. So did all. the athletic organizations of the city. A series of chariot races, recalling the days of ancient Rome, thrilled the thousands of spectators.
Balboa Park Day, Dec. 4, closed the San Diego end of the celebration. Held in the 1,400- acre municipal park, where partically all of the beautiful exposition buildings are still intact, and where the flowers and foliage are more beautiful than in 1915, this part of the program, despite a persistent rain, scored a real hit. Thousands spent the entire day in the park. There were organ resitals on the great Spreckels pipe organ, community singing, band concerts, renditions by famous soloists, an old-timers' picnic, and many other attractions. On that evening a gay crowd enjoyed a carnival and dance on the downtown stvets.
Nearly 500 San Diegans boarded the special train for the Imperial Valley on the following morning. It was a great trip over the new line, and all marveled at the wonders of the scenery. In the valley all the cities were visited. Governor William D. Stephens, lohn D. Spreckels, Brig.-Gen. Joseph H. Pendleton, Mayor L. J. Wilde and other prominent men marched at the head of the parade in each town. Mr. Spreckels addressed crowds in every city and was loudly cheered.
Transcontinental Week closed at El Centro with a great barbecue, at which 20,000 persons were fed. San Diegans and \"alleyites thus formed a friendship which will mean much in the future development of both regions. The Valley people predicted big things for Valley and Harbor, at last connected with rails of steel.
City Of Sax Diego And San Diego Couxty 177
A distinctive feature of the San Diego & Arizona Railway is its solid construction. No expense, apparently, was spared to make the roadbed as heavy as practicable and as safe as possible. To this end and to obtain easy grades and as easy curves as obtainable, numerous costly fills and cuts were made and tunnels constructed. Such has been' the policy of the road since its beginning.
Chapter Xv The Last Fifteen Years
In the period extending over the last fifteen years San Diego has made her greatest material development. In that time the port of San Diego has become a great naval base and remarkable gains have been recorded in other directions. Postofiice receipts in 1906, for instance, were only a little more than $74,000; in 1920 they had grown to $415,000, the high water mark of $584,000 in the fifteen-year period having been reached in 1918, when the city contained a large number of men training for the w-ar. Bank deposits in 1906 were slightly under $7,000,000; by 1920 they had grown to more than $43,000,000. The greatest period of new building so far recorded was in 1912, when the total number of permits was 4,559 and their value was stated as more than $10,000,000, that high figure being swelled materially, of course, by the construction of the great group of Exposition buildings in Balboa Park. The school census in 1906 showed only 4,379 pupils in the city schools ; the number had grown in 1920 to 16,705 - practically quadrupled. Water consumers in the city increased in the same time from 5,072 to 16,385. The growth indicated by these few figures has been steady, each year, with slight exceptions, bringing an increase over the one just preceding; in only one year, 1913, did the bank deposits of San Diego fail to show a gain over the year before. This is certainly a record which is surpassed by few communities anywhere in the United States.
The beginning of the 15-year period was as bright as the ending has been. The year 1906 saw a great increase in building, the total being more than twice as large as that for 1905. In 1906 John D. vSpreckels began the series of buildings which have made Broadway, the city's great downtown thoroughfare, what it is now, and his example was followed by many others, individuals and organizations. Following the institution of a notable suit between the Spreckels interests and the E. S. Babcock interests, there was a -complete separation of the two, and Spreckels went ahead with more vigor than before. The Spreckels interests bought out all the holdings of E. S. Babcock and his son, Graham Babcock, in the Southern California Mountain Water Company, in May, 1906. the sale being followed by an announcement in Mr. Spreckels' newspaper, the Union, to this effect :
"This means that the plans of the present owners of the company will push forward without interruption or delay by suits in court. It means the turning of all the supply of mountain water into the distributing pipes of the city that the city can use." The promise here made was carried out in full, and the assurance that the city
The list of buildings actually started in 1906 or planned in that year includes the Union Building, at the southwest corner of Third Street and Broadway, the building later being extended to Second Street, so as to take all of the Broadway frontage on that block. It also includes the large Scripps Building, built at Sixth and C streets by Frederick T. Scrijjps, half-brother of the news})aper publisher, E. W. Scripps. Each is of six stories, and the building of each did much to establish San Diego as a modern city.
Early in 1906 the Chamber of Commerce began a campaign to obtain a thousand new members, and its efforts were backed up by William E. Smythe, the historian, who wrote as follows :
"Memorials to state and national legislative bodies wdiich have protected and fostered San Diego interests at every session of those bodies during the past thirty-six years.
"The chamber is fighting for a naval training station and an extension of the Salt Lake railroad to San Diego, and, in addition to all these things, it has given the most loyal support to every railroad movement which has been organized from 1870 to 1906.
"Look over this list and you will realize that without an organized body like the chamber of commerce it would be impossible for the public spirit of San Diego to find effective expression. Every man who regards himself of any importance in the life of this community should be enrolled in the membership, and give his moral and financial support to an institution without which San Diego could not have been the city it is today, but with which it will surely become the city it desires to be tomorrow."
San Diego's prosperity for 1906 was \oiced to the world in a special edition of the L'nion appearing- on the morning of July 13. It contained the following :
"The city is riding on the crest of the wave of prosperity, a wave that holds out every promise of landing San Diego in the position to which its numerous advantages gives it ever\- right of title, that of one of the largest ports in the world.
".\'o city could today offer a more attractive inducement to investors than San Diego can boast of. due to the unprecedented business advantages here.
San Diego'S Fixe High School
SAN DIEGO'S FIXE HIGH SCHOOL It stands on one of the most beautiful sites in the city, overlooking the great City Park, the mountains at the cast and the bay and ocean at the south and west.
"bor the btisiness man looking lor rest and recreation; for the invalid .seeking renewed health and happiness, and for the pleasureseekers San Diego offers every inducement.
"San Diego has a population of 32,000 and is amuially visited by 60,000 people ; on August 1 it will be receiving an abundant supply of mountain water from a $3,000,000 system ; it has 24 churches of all denominations; three daily newspapers besides several weeklies; eight banks ; modern electric street railway systems, with numerous extensions under construction; $1.000.CKX) C S. Grant Hotel under construction ; 1,400 acre city park ; good fire department ; marine repair docks, electric lighting and gas; two telephone systems: 71 miles of graded streets ; several miles of paved streets ; many miles of oiled boulevards and parks ; 80 miles of cement sidewalks ; modern sewer system costing more than $400,000; three modern theatres; $80,000
A fine example of San Diego spirit was afforded in April of 1906, when the news was flashed over the wire of San Francisco's earthquake and fire of the 18th. The battleship Chicago, bearing Admiral Caspar Goodrich, commanding the Pacific Squadron, was on its way from San Diego to northern ports when the news of the disaster was received in San Diego, and a description of what had happened was sent to him by Mayor John L. Sehon, of San Diego, resulting in the dispatch of navy vessels to San F"rancisco to relieve the situation there. In the days that immediately followed San Diego raised a fund of more than $25,000 to aid the suft'ering in San Francisco and also sent to that city large quantities of provisions, clothing, beds, tents, camp stoves and other supplies to help the people of her big neighbor in the northern part of the state. In connection with this event it might be mentioned that no earthquake ever did any appreciable damage in San Diego, although the shocks of a few distant "shakes" have been felt in the city to a small degree.
An indication of San Diego's growing importance is seen in the campaign begun by the Chamber of Commerce and real estate men in 1906 to have the city authorities place street signs on the corners of all grade crossings, both in the business and residence districts of San Diego. Petitions asking that the common council take action on this line were prepared and sent, and a good beginning was made at that time.
On June 9, 1906, the Rev. A. Gibbons, then pastor of the First Methodist Episcopal Church, spoke at a ceremony to mark the laymg of the cornerstone of the Agnew Sanitarium and Hospital, at Fifth and Beech streets. Dr. David Gochenauer presided.
On the very next day the cornerstone of the new home of the Elks was laid, and on July 1 the cornerstone of the new home of the First Methodist Church, at Ninth and C streets, was laid. On July 28 of the same year the cornerstone of the Church of Our Lady of Angels, at 24th and G streets, was laid.
On Aug. 14 at the University Heights reservoir some 500 residents of San Diego gathered to witness the turning on of the water furnished by the Southern California Mountain Water Company to the city. William Clayton, managing director of the Spreckels companies, officiated on behalf of the company and Mayor John L. Sehon for the city. The gathering included most of the local officers of the water company, the members of the city board of works, nearly all the members of the city council, heads of the various departments and prominent men of the city. The ceremony was important in that it marked the beginning of delivery to the city by the company of mountain water from the Otay reservoirs. Agreement was made that this delivery should extend over a period of ten years and that the price should be four cents for every thousand gallons - a remarkably low price for water in Southern California, or, for that matter, in almost any section.
A newspaper item of the period that has more than ordinary interest in view of the recent naval development at San Diego was concerning the arrival of a steam schooner at the port by night. The fact that this craft was able to come in by the aid of her searchlight was one which caused keen interest at the time, whereas in these days the coming and going of navy craft after dark is of so common occurrence that hardly anybody pays any attention to it.
U. S. Grant Hotel
U. S. GRANT HOTEL This i)hotograph; although it was taken about five jears ago, makes a striking contrast witli that of the Old Horton House, famous old hotel, which stood on the same site as that now occupied by the U. S. Grant Hotel, occupying the center of the picture. Street cars and automobiles had almost entirely replaced the old horse-drawn vehicles. Modern buildings had arisen in place of I he quaint structures of former decades. The City Plaza in the foreground has the appearance of the present day.
Remarkable progress was made by the city in 1*X)~. The total of building jiermits was far in excess of the $2,000,000 mark ; and in Horton's addition, which embraces the business section of San Diego, the building amounted to more than $630,000. more than 100 buildings being inchided. University Heights came next, while Hillcrest, then a comparatively new sub-tli vision, made a good showing. In the same year John D. Spreckels began the constriiction of his fine home and the i)ublic library at Coronado. Harry L. Titus built another fine home in Coronado. E. I'.artlett Webster spent a large sum in developing South Park and in street railway construction. The year also saw the completion of the Union Building and the Scripps Building.
Normal Heights had only one building at the beginning of the year; at the end it had more than 40, a good beginning toward its present size. There was also considerable building in South San Diego, Chula Vista and National City. The construction of the U. S. Grant Hotel was carried on throughout most of the year. The coaling station at Point Loma also was built at a cost of $350,000.
Freight shipped out of San Diego in that year through the port showed an increase of 95 per cent, over that of 1906, while imports by water increased 35 per cent. Rail shipments brought to San Diego in 1907 amounted to more than 3,500 carloads, while freight shipped from the city by rail amounted to more than 3,500 carloads. A large increase in trade with Lower California was noticed. The construction of the H (Market) street line from 16th to 25th street was completed by the San Diego Electric Railway Company in the closing months of 1907 and other improvements in the system and its service were made. The H street line was made a continuation of the Third street line which then ran one to Second and Washington streets, INIission Hills then having no car service beyond that point.
Several notable additions to the public school system were either made or planned in 1907. The foundation of the large Florence school was laid in December of that year.
In view of the comparative scarcity of horses on the city streets in these days, it is interesting to note that in 1907, considerable trouble was made for the police by the fact that many drivers of horse-drawn vehicles in 1907 neglected to obey the city ordinance providing that animals must be hitched. The Union on December 15, 1907, remarked that on the previous afternoon a reporter had counted eighteen violations of this ordinance in five blocks on Fifth street between C and H streets.
On December 5, 1907, there arrived at San Diego what was then described as "the largest fleet of warships ever in the harbor." It consisted of the flagship Charleston, with Rear Admiral Swinburne aboard ; the Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Louis, Albany, Yorktown, Perry and Preble, comprising the principal part of the second division of the Pacific Squadron. It was only a small group of war vessels, all of which long ago became obsolete in design, and would be almost unnoticed in the great array of navy vessels now to be seen in San Diego harbor on almost any day ; but the event was one of no small importance in those days. It may be added that the arrival of this little squadron was really a beginning of similar naval activity at San Diego San Diego paid much attention to the vessels and their officers arrd men, and that did much to cement a friendly feeling between the city and navy men - a sentiment which has grown stronger and stronger with the years.
Another notable event of the year 1907 was the coming here of John Nolen, noted landscape architect of Cambridge, Mass.. at the invitation of the Civic Improvement Committee, of which Julius Wangenheim, well known banker, was chairman and in which George W. Marston was active. Mr. Nolen was author of the so-called "Nolen Plan" for the development and beautification of San Diego and its suburbs, and although this plan has not been carried out in its entirety by any means, it and its supporters have exerted a decided influence on the city.
San Diego has grown up as many another city has, as most American cities have, without much regard for landscape design, for which San Diego was peculiarly and superbly fitted. If a man like Nolen had come with "Father" Horton and had induced Horton and the city builders and eager real estate men of that and later periods to adopt some com[)rehensive plan by which contours and natural lines might have been followed, San Diego today would be more beautiful than it is. But American cities, with a few exceptions, are not built that way. On the other hand, San Diego's waste of opportunity and easily understood mistakes (according to the view of the aesthetic city designer) have not been large or by any means criminal. Nolen referred to the city plan which he found here as "not thoughtful but, on the contrary, ignorant and wasteful," which, to the average visitor of today probably will seem a too harsh arraignment. Yet he made certain suggestions which have appealed to thoughtful, public-sjMrited citizens of San Diego and which have borne and will bear fruit. One suggestion which may yet be carried into actuality is that of a grouping of jniblic buildings at a civic centre, b'inancial burdens of a growing city, coupled with a degree of indifference to the advisability of such a plan, have prevented this from being built. Playgrounds, which Nolen advocated heartily, have been wisely provided. The city's guardianship of the bay front, an uncciualed ex])anse. has been marked by some attention to the i)lan whicli he outlined - and it was a plan obvious to him who would keep his eyes open.
the building of an elaborate (and costly) "paseo" from Balboa Parkto the bay between Date and Elm streets, for a beach reservation and the making of a new "plaza" from Broadway to C street between Fiont and First streets. Nolen was enthusiastic over the "boundless and indescribable resources of this lovable land," and declared that San Diego "appears to stand on the threshold of an almost unbelievable future."
The extent to which the city had grown in 1907 and the confidence which its citizens felt in its future are shown plainly in the size of various bond issues favored of that year. The total of bonds issued for various improvements, principally for water improvements, in 1907, was slightly more than $712,000. Of this more than half went for water development. The year's total issues were by far larger than those of any other previous year in San Diego's history except 1901, when bonds for $600,000 for water were issued.
Louis J. Wilde, who became prominent in San Diego at about this time and who in this and later years left marks in the city's political and business life for which he will be long remembered, came to San Diego in 1903. He was active and largely instrumental in completing and furnishing the U. S. Grant Hotel, progress on which languished after the financial depression of 1907 ; he built the Pickwick theatre, the Frances apartments on Broadway and a fine residence on Broadway. He was active also in financing the Americaji National Bank Building, which later became the First National Building. Reference to his political activities is made elsewhere in this volume.
Wilde was born in Iowa City, Iowa, in the late '60s. In 1883 he worked as an elevator boy for some time and later worked in other fields, including the insurance business. In 1893 he went to St. Paul, dealing in farm lands, country merchandise and commercial paper and also invested wisely in Texas oil lands, obtaining a large financial return. In 1902 he returned to California, remaining in Los Angeles about a year and then coming to San Diego, where he remained, except for a short time, until 1921, when he went to Los Angeles again.
When the U. S. Grant Hotel project Jaegan to be referred to as a "white elephant" after the financial storm of 1907, and some pessimists declared it was "too large" for San Diego and was a bad investment, Wilde became interested in the hotel, and evolved a plan of issuing bonds for its completion. This plan was approved by many others prominent in financial circles in San Diego, and the hotel was finished, becoming a success almost from the opening day.
Another of Wilde's accomplishments was the organization of the U. S. National Bank. He also established and was first president of the Citizens' Savings Bank and was first president of the First National of Escondido.
In the course of his stay in San Diego Wilde had a number of opponents and some enemies ; none of these ever accused him of lack of vigor in speech and deed. For a time he maintained a weekly newspaper, in which he voiced with considerable force, and in an epigrammatic way which is wholly his own, various views which he wished to convey to the public. Later, when this newspaper, the Examiner, was discontinued, he continued to write, finding the daily newspapers usually glad to allow him space.
One of the most interesting events of the last 20 years in the history of San Diego, and an event not without importance, is the visit i)aid to this port in 1908 by the fleet under command of Rear Admiral Robley D. Evans, the "Fighting Bob" Evans of Spanish war fame and an idol of the navy. The fleet, of course, had come "round the Horn," as the Panama Canal was not yet completed, and its departure to the Pacific, which up to that time had not seen so formidable an array of American navy craft, attracted almost as much attention in Atlantic Coast communities as it did on the Pacific Coast. On the western coast, however, great celebrations were arranged and carried out to mark the arrival of the great battleship fleet, which brought some 16,000 officers and bluejackets. In these celebrations San Diego, Los Angeles and San Francisco led, and San Diego's program, extending over four days, April 14 to 18. attracted much ii;terest all over the nation - largely, of course, because it was the first, the port being the southernmost of the United States Pacific Coast, but in addition because it was well planned and executed. In this, as in similar programs prepared to show the officers and men of the navy that here was a hospitable port and that here was a true western patriotic hospitality, the citizens of San Diego all worked together unselfishly and loyally.
The celebration was marred by the inability of .\dmiral Evans, who had become ill on the trip, to come here. He was taken on ahead, indeed, to Paso Robles Hot Springs, far to the north, for treatment. Admiral Evans was represented here by Rear Admiral Charles M. Thomas. Other rear admirals with the fleet were Charles S. Sperry and William H. Emery.
The city literally threw open its doors to the navy on this occasion, theatres and other ])laces of amusement admitting men in navy uniform as their guests, and the elaborate decorations of the four days bespoke a real hospitality which must have been doubly pleasing to officers and bluejackets after their long cruise.
William Clayton was director-general of the celebration and was assisted bv the following committee chairmen in arranging the program ; D. C. Collier, U. S. Grant, Jr., W. V.. Smythe. Charles S. Hardy, L. A. Wright. W. L. Frevert, George W. Marston. .\rthur Cosgrove, John S. .Akerman, Dr. Edward Grove. W. F. Ludington. Maj.-Gen. William S. McCaskey, Dan V. Jones, Vx\. IHetcher, George F. Bowles, Dr. R. M. Powers, E. M. Burbeck, Julius Wangenheim,
The program for the day included an official visit of welcome by Governor J. N. Gillett of California to Rear Admiral Thomas, on the Connecticut ; banquet for the admirals at the Hotel del Coronado and illumination of the warships and city. That for the second day included a parade of several thousand officers and men from the foot of Broadway to the City Park, now Balboa Park, where addresses were made by Gov. Gillet, Rear Admiral Thomas, Mayor John'F. Forward and others, and a sword was presented to Rear Admiral Evans, represented by Rear Admiral Thomas. An automobile picnic at El Monte for the officers was a feature of the third day's program, while on the fourth the principal event was a ball for the junior officers at the U. S. Grant Hotel.
An interesting sidelight on the condition of business in San Diego during the so-called panic of 1908 is contained in a booklet issued by the Chamber of Commerce and Board of Supervisors in that year.
"When almost every city of importance in the nation issued scrip as its legal tender for the transaction of business," says the statement, "San Diego stood out alone as the only Pacific Coast city which continued to do business with gold and silver and national bank notes. Scrip was unknown, save as it came from other cities."
The booklet goes into much more detail than previous Chamber of Commerce publications, and furnishes a good deal of information about the city's condition in 1908, and about its progress in the years just previous.
Bank deposits for 1908 are given as $7,028,000, nearly $3,000,000 more than the deposits of 1905. Although there was a slight slump in harbor business, the booklet states that this slump was less apparent in San Diego than in the other California harbor, San Francisco. The number of vessels entering port was 543, with a net tonnage of 488,873, the report states.
In a section headed "Opportunities," the booklet calls attention to a number of productive lines in which there seemed to be a promising field for outside capital. Among them were the brick-making industry, ship-building, furniture-making and the glassware industry.
Interesting information is furnished under the caption "Cost of Living." Rates in family hotels were from $30 a month upward, the booklet states, while single rooms were $7.50 up. The minimum cost of a meal is given as 15 cents.
"Close-in cottages and bungalows, furnished, may be had for $20 per month up,'' the booklet states. "Unfurnished, $15 upward. Like accommodations, removed from the business center, but conveniently reached by car lines, are cheaper."
A large section is devoted to information about the county's back country, and concludes with articles on bee keeping, dairy farming, poultry raising and the like.
Gold production for the county during 1907 is valued at more than $350,000. Statistics in a summary pubhshed give the total of fruit and nut trees in the county, both bearing and non-bearing, as about 1,125,000 - quite different from the 6,475 recorded in 1895.
According to this table, 39,000 acres were planted to grain, producing 13,600 tons of grain with a value of $481,300. Nearly $70,000 worth of olives and olive products was produced, the booklet says, while the year's hay crop was valued at $654,000. The poultry industry is credited with a total production valued at $638,875, and the bee industry with wax and honey to the value of about $85,000.
A list of thirty-two classes of "manufactories"' is given, ranging in number of emploves from four to 151, and in value of j,roduct from $2,520 to $423,000.'
One of the most important changes ever made in the form of San Diego's city government came in January, 1909, when the voters adopted charter amendments which eliminated the board of public works and the fire and police commissions which had been in existence for some time and also abolished the ward system of electing members of the common council. The amendments also reduced the number of councilmen from nine to five and provided for their election at large and for nominations in non-partisan primaries. The newly elected officers took office on May 3. 190'>. The new plan was a modification of the commission form of government which was receiving some attention in the country at the time, and San Diego was the first city on the Pacific coast to put such a plan into efi'ect. This fact was widely commented U])on in newspapers and magazines of the time. The new city government spent more than $1,000,000 in expanding the sewer system and w.iter mains, thus {providing for the increase of population which was then starting in full force. The water department l.iid 92.000 feet of pii)e under a bond issue and also laid and paid for out of current receijits about 124.00() more feet of such pipe in the year. The sewer department put down more than 96,000 feet of pipe, costing nearly $83,000; this, with the 75 miles already laid in San Diego, gave the city more than 92 miles of sewer pipe. At the time the city had about 150 miles of graded streets, of which twelve miles were paved. In the year about eight more miles were graded and proceedings were prepared for the paving of ten more miles in 1910. The city at the time also had about twentyfive miles of boulevard, providing not only good roads for business traffic but for visitors. The fire department was enlarged by the purchase of a new chemical engine, putting it in fairly good shape ; the creation of the ofifiice of fire marshal and the cleaning up of vacant lots and removal of rubbish did much to improve the appearance of the city and to lessen fire risks.
School enrollment at this time showed a steady increase, the total for 1909 being 6,627 as against 4,277 for 1908 and 3,712 for 1907. In 1909 three new schools were finished, being erected at Chollas Valley, University Heights and Ocean Beach, bringing the total number of school buildings in the city to nineteen, and the total valuation of the school structures up to $354,000. The number of teachers was increased from 130 to 150 and the annual payroll increased from about $98,000 to more than $165,000.
Active work on the San Diego & Arizona Railway was started in the spring of 1909 and was continued with vigor throughout the year, lending much encouragement to all residents of the city. Early in May of that year a contract was awarded to Robert Sherer & Sons to grade from San Diego to the Mexican line, at Tijuana, a distance of about fifteen miles. Before this contract was let, Mr. Spreckels had spent about a million and a half dollars in getting rights of way in San Diego and National City, it being necessary to demolish a number of substantial buildings in the downtown district to prov'de a route into the city near the waterfront. Before the Sherers had finished their first grading contract, the firm obtained another contract, for the grading of fourteen more miles in Mexican territory, just below the international boundary line. Only eight miles of steel rails had been laid by the end of 1909, but the railway had already purchased a considerable c^uantity of rolling stock and was ready for continuation of its work. All construction work, it might be mentioned at this point, was under the direct supervision of E. J. Kaliright, chief engineer of the railway.
In 1909 exhibits sent by San Diego County to the Alaska-Yukon- Pacific Exposition at Seattle did much to direct attention to the advantages and products of this section. Six grand prizes were awarded to San Diego exhibits, the displays being of gems, silk, nuts, onyx from the New Pedrara Onyx Company, and lemons from Chula Vista. In addition, there were awarded to San Diego exhibits twentyseven gold medals, fifteen silver medals and nine bronze. It is of interest that in this year the output of cut gems from San Diego County was $72,000. At that time the gem industry in the county was about eight years old, the first variety of gem discovered here being kunzite, named after George F. Kunz, the noted gem expert of Tiffany's. With the discovery of this crystal a more determined search was made, with the result that in a short time more than a score o*f other varieties of gems were found ; they inckule tourmaHnes, rubies, sapphires and hyacinths, all of which are turned out in considerable quantities.
In the same year the county produced fruits and vegetables whose estimated value was nearly $2,000,000 - a creditable showing for any community in Southern California; of this more than $1,000,000 was credited to the lemon groves.
The year 1909 saw the completion of the Timken Building, an eight-story structure of massive type at Sixth and E streets, and the beginning of construction of the ten-story American National Bank Building, now the First National Building, and the tallest building in San Diego, at the northeast comer of Fifth Street and Broadway. Another bank building started in 1909 was the home of the Marine National Bank. Many fine homes and ajxirtments were constructed in the same period, the total of building permits in the city for 1909 being $2,632,100, a slight increase over 1908.
Even in 1909 the fishing industry, now of great importance to San Diego, was not without significance. In 1908 the small and almost casual fishing fleet from the port brought in more than 3,000,000 pounds of fish from some of the richest fishing grounds of all the seven seas. In 1909 the total was increased to a total reported as more than $304,000. About twenty boats, at least in part of the season, more than 4,000,000 pounds and valued at more than $304,000. About twentv boats, at least in i)art of the season, as against the more than 180 boats now employed, were engaged in the lucrative work.
Reference is made elsewhere to the waterfront grant to the city. By act of the state legislature in May, 1911, the city obtained absolute control of its water front and the tidelands adjacent to it. This grant was made on the condition that the city expend within three years the sum of $1,000,000 in improvements in the Bay of San Diego. The city immediately proceeded to comply with this obligation. On November 14, 1911, the citizens voted almost unanimously the $1,000,000 required.
The act referred to carried with it clauses whicli prevent the ciiy government from ever disposing of any portion of the tideland-; or leasing them for abnormal periods, and it furtlier protects the municipality by forbidding excessive areas being leased to any party or aggregation of parties. Saving clauses are also inserted of a like character which prevent the monopoly of the berth or dock space.
The improvements im])oscd under the terms of the act were started in 1912. They consisted of one i)ier 130 feet in width and 800 feet in length, 2,675 lineal feet of bulkhead, and the reclamation of be- . tween fifty and sixty acres of tidelands. Both the pier and the bulkhead were constructed entirely of concrete and steel in substantial and enduring manner.
The pier was provided with standard gauge railroad tracks, and for the temporary storage of cargo a substantial steel warehouse was erected upon the jiier. This warehouse is 72 feet clear in width, and 76.^ feet in length, and was provided with steel roller doors, skylights and ventilators.
to the exposition, the chamber of commerce got out one of its most ambitious booklets. It is entitled, "Why Not San Diego County, California ?"
The population of the city in 1910 is given as 39,578. The assessed value of all property in the city is given at $43,299,019, while the total county value is placed at $41,815,697. Bank clearings are given as $66,708,874, and the deposits as $11,016,000. Exports are credited with a $500,000 increase over the previous year, and customs collections with an increase of about $10,000.
Provenance
Text from City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.