San Diego, California - City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California (part 4 of 13)
From City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. 15,903 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
5 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,903 wordsMachine-read from scans of City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
One result of the removal of the county offices to the new town was that the telegraph company, which had been installed in the building at Sixth and G streets, was forced to seek new quarters. These were quickly made under the supervision of Col. Stauchon, the agent, and rooms were taken for the operators on the first floor of the Horton House.
!^an Diego of fifty years ago - that is, in 1871 - is pictured with a striking degree of accuracy in the city's only daily newsi)aper of that time, the San Diego Union, which was started as a daily that year in answer to a demand which was impressive at the time and which kept on growing with the }ears. Take the advertisements, reflecting the city's commercial and business activities. Among the principal advertisers from the beginning of the newspaper was A. E. Horton, whose promise to support the weekly Union with his patronage had been the controlling reason for its removal the year before fro:n Old Town. The first issue of the newspaper as a daily contained a notice setting forth that Horton was ''proprietor of Horton's extension of New Town." with offices in the Express building. Sixth and G streets, and would "sell lots and blocks in 'Horton's extension' to suit those who desire to settle and improve them, upon the most reasonable terms."
Tones & Leach (formerly Jones & Scott), law office and real estate agencv : the firm members were G. A. Jones and A. M. Leach, and their office was at Fifth and F streets.
Valentine & Steels, agents for National City lands, "on the bay of San Diego, the proposed terminus of the proposed southern transcontinental railroad."
Joseph Nash, general merchandise, Fifth street. It was at this store that George W. Marston, who in more recent years has become one of the city's foremost merchants, worked for a time, driving a delivery wagon at first and later being promoted to a clerkship. Nash's store was the first general store in New San Diego.
There were three hotels advertising in that issue, the head of the column being taken by the Horton House, described as "new, complete, elegant and commodious." S. W. Churchill, from San Jose, was in charge. Next came the Cosmopolitan Hotel, A. L. Seelev, proprietor, at Old Town ; this contained a Los Angeles stage office. Then followed the New San Diego Hotel, S. S. Dunnells, proprietor, near Culverwell's wharf. The Horton House was more fullv described in advertisements of the time as as having 100 rooms, all furnished in the best style, "lighted with gas, supplied with fresh soft water, half of them warmed by steam heaters and everyone made wholesome and cheerful by the loveliest of sunshine some part of the day." The situation was advertised as "admirably chosen," with "a mag^nificent view of harbor, ocean, islands, mountains, city and country." The dining room was 40 by 60 feet, "affording a feast of beauty to the eye and more substantial and varied satisfaction to the 'inner man.' "
The steamship advertisements began with that of the Pacific Mail, which announced that beginning with March 17, all its steamers would call at San Diego, "down and up," and that freight and passengers would be carried at "greatly reduced prices." The second steamship advertisement was that of the N. P. T. Company steamships, Orizaba and California, leaving for vSan Francisco every six days. Then came the California Southern Coast (opposition) Steamship line, which ran "the new and commodious steamer William Taber."
The stage line advertisements comprise a fair picture of the methods of travel overland to and from San Diego, at that time when there was no railroad to the port. A U. S. mail line, of which John G. Capron, well known as a San Diego pioneer, was proprietor, gave a tri-weekly service with four-horse coaches between San Diego and Tucson. The time set for the trip was live days, and the fare to Tucson was $90. Capron's office was in the Union building, Fourth and D (now Broadway). Between San Diego and Los Angeles stages ran every day except Sunday, leaving the Horton House at 5 a. m., the Cosmopolitan Hotel, Old Town, at 6 a. m., and arriving at San Juan Capistrano at 7 p. m. There the passengers waited over night, starting again at 4 a. m. and reaching Los Angeles at 1 p. m. The fare was $10. The route lay through Anaheim and Los Nietos. Seeley and Wright were the proprietors. William Tweed's passenger and mail line ran up the mountains three times a week to "Julian and Branson Cities." The fare up was $7. while that on the way back, on the down grade, was $6.
Among other advertisements of about that time were those of Arnold & Choate, real estate dealers, whose name became well established in formal city records by the Arnold and Choate Addition, one of the largest in the city ; L. W. Kimball of National City, who had an office two doors from the W^ells-Fargo express office ; Steiner & Klauber, Seventh and I streets, general merchandise ; Stewart and Reed ( Wellington .Stewart and D. C. Reed, who later became mayor of San Diego), attorneys and real estate dealers: the Bay \'iew Hotel, the Union House at Eighth and K streets.
The only bank advertisement in the first issue was that of the Bank of San Diego, of which "Father" Horton was president and whose directors at that time included J. .M. Pierce, E. W. Morse, Brvant floward, W. H. Cleveland. M. Sherman. A. M. Hathawny, C. Durham and J. Nash.
Other more or less grai)hic i>rinl-j)ictures of that period are furnished in the news columns of the L'nion's early issues. One of the earliest editorial appeals made by San Diego's first daily newspaper, for instance, was for better fire protection, the article directing attention to the fact that "San Diego has over 800 buildings" and that fire apparatus was needed. .Xnother editorial topic at the time was the need of uniform street grades and sidewalks, not two of which.
it was asserted, were of the same width. They were "up and down, narrow and wide/' and the wayfarer at night usually took to the middle of the streets to save his shins. No little interest was taken in horse-racing, as several paragraphs of the time indicate, the races being matches arranged by owners of thorough-breds. The stage line to Tucson was meeting with trouble from Apaches, who were frequently on the warpath in Arizona. Sandstorms on the desert also made travel by stage to the east very disagreeable at times. Building operations in 1871 were active, many new dwellings and oflfice structures, most of them of frame construction, being listed in early issues of the daily newspaper. Real estate sales were numerous for the time and size of the city. I take one example as of more than mere passing interest. It was a sale of a twenty-five-foot lot opposite the Horton House, whose site the U. S. Grant hotel now occupies, and it brought $500. A. E. Horton sold it. His sales for one day at about that time amounted to $10,200, a fairly good day's work for a real estate dealer in a new and small town such as San Diego was. Water was then a question of great importance, as no method had been employed to bring the mountain streams down for domestic supply. The Union, for instance, remarked : "The people are bound to have water, and wells go down and windmills go up in every quarter of the town. We notice a fine windmill at the side of Mr. Truman's residence ; another, nearly finished, on Third street, built by Mr. Horton, and a third in course of construction on the premises of Air. D. W. Briant."
The editor received gifts in those days - not merely the humble potatoes and turnips which are said to have been the subscription fees turned over to many a publisher in those and later days, but something more pleasing by far. One such was a box of delicious oranges from Col. C. J. Couts, who grew them on his famous Guajome ranch, not far from San Luis Rey. The editor thankfully acknowledged the gift in print.
Wool shipments through this port were considerable in those days, and much of the wool came from El Cajon and vicinity - then called "the Cajon." An item appearing in the Union early in 1871 reports that W. G. Hill of the Cajon rancho had just brought in and sold to Pauly & Sons 4.000 pounds clipped from 1.100 sheep and sold to Gordon, Stewart & Co., at Culverwell's wharf.
Notices printed in the first Sunday issue of the Union, March 26, 1871, give a good idea of the religious services held in those days at the new town. The Episcopal church. Rev. Dr. Kellogg pastor, met at Trinity hall, on Sixth street, between B and C. The Presbyterian church of which the Rev. I. S. AlcDonald was pastor, met in Horton's new hall. Sixth and F streets. Rev. Father Ubach, beloved Catholic priest, was conducting services here then. The Methodist Episcopal Church, was at Fourth and D streets, the Rev. M. Tansey officiating. The Rev. B. S. McLafiferty conducted services for the Baptist Church.
The Doctor Kellogg just mentioned served here only a few weeks. He came from Cleveland, Ohio. Daniel Cleveland, the well known attorney, was active in the church and in January, 1871, at the request of the vestry, was licensed as lay reader ; he often acted as such when no rector was present. The Episcopalians built the first church in New San Diego. Trinity Hall, which was built on the same site, at the northeast corner of Sixth and C streets, was erected late in 1869 or early in 1870. It was at Sixth and C streets only a short time after the notice in the Union to which reference has just been made. Then it was removed to the southeast corner of Fourth and C streets, the new land having been obtained by an exchange with "Father" Horton, who had given the original site. Rev. Sidney Wilbur was responsible for the organization of this church. He remained with it nearly to the end of 1870.
The Presbyterian flock at this time was led by the Rev. J. S. McDonald, who had organized two churches in Northern California and had been chaplain of the senate before he came to San Diego in the spring of 1870. He was an ardent supporter of the temperance movement and was active in the formation here, in the summer of that year, of the San Diego Temperance Union. He also is said to have preached the first Protestant sermon ever delivered in El Cajon valley, delivering it at the residence of Uri Hill on June 19, 1870. From a historical sketch of the First Presbyterian Church written by Allen H. Wright, city clerk of San Diego, in 1919, when the church was fifty years old, are taken the following extracts :
"The women of the church, in those days, as in these, played a very important part, and in June of that year ( 1870) it is recorded that an organ, secured from proceeds of a concert held under the auspices of the women, was dedicated at Horton's hall, Mr. Mc- Donald preaching a special sermon on 'Sacred Music'
"Among the visitors to San Diego in 1870 was J. W. Edwards, of Marquette, Michigan, and when he attended the Presbyterian meetings in a hired hall, even though it had a seating capacity of 400, he became impressed with the idea that the society should have a church building of its own, and ofifered to pay $500 toward the project. 'Father' A. E. Horton, the founder of the present city of San Diego, had given a site for a church at Eighth and D (now Broadway), and soon the plans for building were under way, the members being encouraged by a gift of $300 from Calvary Presbyterian church of San Francisco. The building fund grew rapidly, and where some did not feel able to give in money, they sul)scribed in labor or material. The women held sociables and festivals, and finally the required amount was reached to insure a debt- free structure, and on June 18, 1871, it was dedicated, the sermon being preached by the Rev. W. A. Scott, D. D.. pastor of St. John's Presbyterian Church of San PVancisco, a man widely known as a preacher, traveler and lecturer. He was assisted by the Rev. John R. Tansey, pastor of the First Methodist Church.
"The building committee, which consisted of th.e trustees and A. H. Gilbert, with W. 15. r)Urns as chairman, received many words of commendation for their work, and the structure, though very small as compared with church edifices of today, was declared to mark a great advance in the progress of the community. The building, still familiar in memory to many residents of the city, was 42 feet long by 26 feet wide and 20 feet high. It had 28 pews, seating 200 people in all. The outer walls were in rustic finish, painted a light drab. The six windows had Gothic tops, and the gables of the building were pierced by trefoils. The one five-foot aisle and the pulpit platform were carpeted, largely through the enterprise of the women of the church. For the dedicatory services the other churches gave up their own programs to assist in making the event one worthy of the day."
The Baptist Church was dedicated October 31, 1869. The Rev. B. S. McLafi^erty who had come from Alarysville to take the pulpit, remained in San Diego until January, 1873. The Baptists had the first church bell ever used in the New San Diego. That was in the old church building on Seventh street near F, on a lot donated by Horton.
The Methodist Church at Fourth and D streets, was dedicated Feb. 13, 1870. Their land, too, was given by Horton. Their first minister was the Rev. G. W. B. McDonald, who was succeeded by the Rev. D. A. Dryden.
"San Diego was the portal through which the Christian religion was introduced into Alta California. On the 18th of July, 1769, the Catholic padre, Junipero Serra, laid the foundation of the Old Mission Church of San Diego. Three years ago a new era dawned upon this region. Newcomers poured in, and being of the Los Americanos species, began the erection of school houses and churches. The corner-stone of a new Catholic Church was laid in North San Diego, July 18, 1869, just 100 years from the similar act of Junipero Serra. Later in the same year, to-wit, Oct. 31, 1869, the Baptists dedicated their edifice. Then the Methodists followed at the beginning of the next year, namely, Feb. 13, 1870. And now the Presbyterian building is dedicated, June 18, 1871. Each year, in short, of the new era in San Diego has been marked by the erection of a church building. The Episcopalians took precedence of other denominations in establishing services, but the hall which they occupy has not, we believe, been dedicated."
A report on public school activities shows that 200 pupils were enrolled on the registers of the three departments, grammar, intermediate and primary. The average number of pupils belonging to the school, however, was given as only 170.
In those days there was much gold mining activity in the Julian and Banner districts. Among the mines operated in those sections in 1871 were the "Kentuck," Redman, Owens, Madden and the famous Stonewall. The greatest difiiculty reported from the mining sections arose from the lack of good roads in the mountains. Several companies spent large sums to build roads on which to haul quartz to the mills.
Amusements at that time were not by any means plentiful. Lectures, theatrical performances and concerts were given occasionally at Horton's Hall, which seated 400 persons and contained a stage 16 by 32 feet. Downstairs at Horton's Hall there was a roller skating rink, at which "skating assemblies" were welcome. Another rink, Garland's, was built soon after this on Second street between D and E.
The roller skating "craze" was prevalent at the time, and many enjoyable occasions were held at the rinks. This led to the formation of at least one club, the Excelsior .Skating Club, whose organization is thus reported in the Union of June 5, 1871 :
"Excelsior Skating Club. - .\t the assembly hall on Saturday evening last, a skating club was formed with the above name. Over seventy j^ersons were enrolled as charter members. The club will have its first meeting this evening, when business related to the fixing of evenings for skating, etc., will be attended to. A full attendance of all the members is requested. A good time can be expected. The officers of the club are: T. C. Stockton, president; R. D. Case, vice president ; C. S. Hamilton, secretary": W. \V. Stewart, treasurer."
llaseball games were not imcommon at the time, the business men of the city often indulging in this healthful form of exercise, playing on a field in the neighborhood of what is now Sixth street and Broadway. Other games were played on various other grounds in the city. It must be remembered that those were the olden days of baseball, when masks and gloves were unknown and the finer points of the game had not been developed But many played it and got much pleasure and profit in health from it. The catcher stood far back from the batter to avoid "foul ti])s" and resultant injuries to fingers and face, and the rules w^ere much more lenient than in later days. Also, the scores were usually large. This newspaper account of a game on May 27, 1871, between a club from Old Town, which showed up with only seven players, and a team from "New San Diego," as the city then was called, will illustrate the way in which the game was played in those days :
The match game yesterday, between the Extempore B. B. C, of Old Town, and the New San Diego B. B. C, was witnessed by a very large number of s])ectators, ladies and gentlemen. Owing to the high wind prevailing during the afternoon, the playing was not remarkable. We append the names of the "nines," noting that to offset the deficiency of two players in the Extempore nine, the last inning of the New San Diegos was not counted :
This game seems to have aroused considerable interest among local baseball players and enthusiasts, for in June the Lone Star Baseball Club was organized at a meeting in Rosario hall, and the following officers were elected : Daniel UUman, president : Frank Buttrick, vice president ; James Russell, recording secretary ; William E. AIc- Kean, treasurer, and the following as directors : A. Gregg, J. Parsons and W. McKean. John Harral was made captain of the first nine and Walt McKean of the second. Club practice was set for every Wednesday and Saturday, and this notice was published :
Of course in those days there were fishing and hunting trips, as now. In winter ducks were plentiful near the city. Indeed it is only within camparatively recent years that False Bay (now Mission Bay) has not been a paradise for duck hunters. And on shore rabbits were nearly everywhere. At a distance of a few city blocks from the present business centre at Fifth street and Broadway one could find plenty of them scurrying around in the sagebrush and rough undergrowth.
A vivid picture of the hunter's paradise which remained here until the '80s is drawn by Theodore S. Van Dyke in his "City and County of San Diego," written while the excitement of the "great boom" gripped all Southern California. He wrote:
"The valley quail of California abounded in numbers quite inconceivable to eastern sportsmen. One hundred and fifty to 200 a day was an ordinary bag for a good shot, and in any of the canyons within a mile from the postoffice one could quickly load himself down with all he cared to carry back on foot. Fifty or sixty were a common score for one shooting only from a wagon in traveling from El Cajon or Spring Valley to San Diego in the morning or evening, and that many have often been shot there by one who knew nothing of wing shooting. This quail was found as high as 6,000 feet, above sea level, though not very abundant above 3,000 feet, and most abundant along the coast, where they could always be found in great numbers with absolute certainty. No attention was paid to the law, and no impression was made upon their numbers until the building of the railroad brought in a host of market shooters. These generally hunted in pairs, and two men have shipped in one winter from San Diego, 35,()00 quail, nearly all killed singly.
"The small hare, commonly called 'cotton tail,' and the large hare, or 'jack rabbit,' also abounded in incredible numbers. Morning and evening they played over every acre of mesa, hopped in scores around the edge of everv brush-clad hill or patch of cactus. A bushel or two of them could be shot from a wagon in a few miles drive along any of the roads. But three years ago 135 were counted along the road in a single trip from San Diego to Old Town, about three miles. By nearly everyone they were considered a great nuisance and they certainly were destructive to gardens and vines and young trees. There are. however, few of the old settlers who would care to exhibit a balance-sheet with rabbit meat on the credit side at even three cents a pound. The flesh of the cotton tail is as fresh and fine as chicken, and in no way resembling that of the eastern rabbit. It runs with a swift, zigzag motion that makes very pretty shooting, especially on bright moonlight nights, the flickering white tail making a fine mark for snap-shooting.
'T)ucks of nearly all \arieties were found in every lagoon and slough. In many i)]act'S. such as Warner's ranch, Temecula, San Jacinto, Elsinore and Santa ^largarita, geese and sandhill cranes were very plenty during the winter. They covered the mesas and vallevs of Santa ^largarita at times by the hundred thousand.
"The sloughs and bays along the coast were lined with curlew, snipe, willet, dowitchers. ])lover, etc., and there was no prettier sight than the thousands of water-fowl riding on the smooth face of San Diego bay on a bright winter day. Where nearly all is now a watery blank and where even the sea-gull scarcely dares to fly, pelicans, divers, mergansers, shags, ducks of nearly all varieties, brant, seagulls, fish-hawks, terns and what-not were everywhere. So tame were they that from the wharf one could watch the divers beneath him swimming along under water behind a school of little fish, picking them up right and left with dexterous motion. The black brant, the finest of American water-fowl, not known on the Atlantic coast, and rare on this coast south of Oregon, dotted the bay far and wide. Down Spanish bight, the dividing inlet of Coronado beach, where one mav now watch for a month without seeing any, from 50,000 to 100,000 could be seen at the ebb-tide coming into the bay from the sea. Reckless, idiotic shooting, the white man's hoggish disposition to waste and destroy, has reft this bay of one of its chief attractions.
"The antelope played over the plains of San Jacinto, Temecula and the mesa between Otay and El Cajon. The last of the latter band was killed about five years ago, (in 1883), the last of the Temecula band about two years ago (in 1886). and the sole survivor of the San Tacinto band was killed this last fall.
"There never was much trout-fishing in this county. Trout were killed out of the Santa Ysabel creek many years ago by the Indians, by the use, it is .said, of 'soap-weed.' They were swept out of Temecula creek by the flood of 1862. A few yet remain in the Pauma creek, though sadly dwindled in both numbers and size.
"Fair fishing may yet be had in San Diego bay. and the fishing outside the bar is about as good as ever. The barracouda and Spanish mackerel afford fine trolling, are gamey. ravenous and very plenty in season. In the kelp is found an abundance of rock-cod, red-fish, and other good fish, which can be caught in great quantities about all the year round."
George W. Marston, the well known San Diego merchant and citizen, was in San Diego at that time, and he recalled recently an incident of the times which strikingly illustrates the small size of the San Diego of those days and its country-like surroundings. There had been heavy, late rains that year, and weeds had grown so tall on the lot at what is now C Street between Third and Fourth that when a man rode on horseback through them his head barely appeared above the luxuriant growth.
Many San Diegans went fishing in the bay and on the ocean. Then, as now. there were excursions for those who liked this exciting sport, as witness this newspaper notice :
"Fishing Excursion. - The yacht Restless sails for the fishing grounds this morning at 9 o'clock. Captain Niles invites those who are partial to the sport of fishing to bring their tackle and dollar and spend the day in fishing barracouta an.d red fish."
In the evening perhaps there was a dance. More or less formal balls were held at not infrequent intervals, and some of these were at Old Town. The Union of September 16. 1871, refers quaintly to one of these as follows :
"The ball at Old Town yesterday evening was, as we predicted it would be, a delightful affair. Several gentleman went over from New Town to enjoy the dance, and report themselves as thoroughly pleased with the way they were treated, and declare they will be sure to watch for the next Old Town ball."
Lack of transportation facilities in the city were beginning to be felt, and particularly was there thought to be need of a railroad between the new and old towns. A company, indeed, had been formed to build such a road, prominent in its affairs being William Jeff'. Gatewood, who had founded the San Diego Union but had sold his interest in the paper; E. W. Morse, another well known pioneer, and others. In June, 1871, the company decided that it would try to go ahead with actual construction, but was forced to delay it. The following account of the stockholders' meeting on June 1 of that year is, however, of interest :
"At a meeting of the stockholders of the San Diego and Bay Shore R. R. Co., held at the office of W. A. Winder yesterday afternoon the following named gentlemen were elected to act as directors for one year: William Jeff. Gatewood, James McCoy, S. S. Culverwell, George A. Johnson, W. A. Winder, E. W. Morse, C. L. Carr. The board then proceeded to the election of officers, with the following result : William Jeff. Gatew^ood. president : James McCoy, vice president ; C. L. Carr. secretary. The company proposes commencing work at an early date. An assessment of ten percent on an amount equal to $1,000 per mile of the entire length of the road was levied and paid in. A survey of the route from Horton's addition to Old San Diego has been made by C. J. Fox, C. E., upon which the sum of $300 was expended."
City Of Sax Diego Axd San Diego Col'Xty 103
An interesting little view of the San Diego of this period was given to the writer recently by Judge M. A. Luce, who came to San Diego early in 1873.
that lime," he said, '"practically the whole city of San Diego was in what is now the downtown district. There were no houses on the hill (where the Florence Hotel was later built) except Horton's : he had built at ]""irst and Elm streets, about half way u]). One of the most pleasing sights in town was the Horton garden, which was on the site now occupied by the Academy of Our Lady of Peace, at Third and B streets. Here he grew a number of vegetables and had flowers and fruit trees in abundance, to show j)eople what could be
A. E. Hortox'S Famous Gardex
A. E. HORTOX'S FAMOUS GARDEX At what is now Third and B streets. The site is now occupied by the Academy of Our Lady of Peace. The photograph was taken in December, 1874, and appeared in a Chamber of Commerce booklet at al)Out that time.
done when water was put on the soil in San Diego. The water he obtained from a well on the B street side of the property, the low part. X'isitors were taken there to obtain a view of what could be done here.
"Captain A. H. Wilcox had a place just north of the Hc^rton garden, on the site for some time occupied by the King's Daughters' home. That place, too. had a well. Cai^tain \\'ilcox. it will l)e recalled, was a captain in the civil war. and when he came t(T San Diego was attacbect to the commissary department and ftirnished supplies to the soldiers at Fort Yuma.
"The water supply of the city at that time - except for those well-to-do residents who had sunk wells and had windmills to pump the water out - was obtained from wells which had been mide in the vicinity of the courthouse. This water was put in hogsheads, loaded on wagons and then peddled over town by several men. One of them was Joe Tasker, who died only this summer."
The growth of the city at that time soon made evident the necessity for adequate protection against fire. This demand in fact had been discussed for some time, and frequent newspaper reference was made to it. As the first step a benefit was given at Horton's Hall by which $250 was raised, and this was soon followed by another entertainment. In May, 1871, the movement resulted in the formation of the Pioneer Hook and Ladder Company, the first fire-fighting organization of San Diego. A number of the leading citizens of San Diego were present and "manifested much interest in the success oi the movement," according to an account of the meeting. The following committee was appointed to solicit subscriptions : A. H. Julian, John N. McKean and G. W. Swain. A committee was also named to obtain a truck and the necessary apparatus. It was reported that the truck should cost $800, and as the company had only $280 at the time the hope was expressed that solicitations of the committee seeking subscriptions would meet with a liberal response. Subscriptions, however, were slow in coming in, and the truck w^as not completed until late in 1871. It was built by a man named Whitaker, who used great care in seasoning the timbers and preparing the fittings.
The first officers of the Pioneer Plook and Ladder Company were: Foreman, W. G. McCormick ; first assistant, John M. Young; second assistant, William P. Anderson ; secretary, B. C. Brown ; treasurer, A. H. Julian. Others who were prominent in the movement included Chalmers Scott, George W. Hazzard, who had come to San Diego in 1868, and for a time lived in a tent in the vicinity of Thirteenth and F streets : E. W. Nottage, John H. Todman and John M. Heidelring. The following is from the L^nion's account of the annual meeting held by the company on May 3, 1871 :
"The annual meeting of the Pioneer Hook and Ladder Company of San Diego was held last evening. We are indebted to the secretary, Mr. William Lacy, for a report of the proceedings. The following named gentlemen were elected officers for the ensuing year : President, Chalmers Scott ; Foreman, W. J. McCormick ; First Assistant, John M. Young ; Second Assistant, William P. Henderson ; Treasurer, A. H. Julian; Secretary William Lacy. The company, by a unanimous vote, recommended E. W. Nottage as a proper person for the office of fire marshal for the city. Now that the organization of this company is complete, it is intended to push matters so that the proper apparatus shall be obtained without delav. Messrs. Overshiner and Tollmer were present at the meeting last evening and exhibited drawings of trucks, etc., and gave their opinions as to cost. It is to be hoped that all good citizens will aid this laudable endeavor to the full extent of their ability."
newspapers not only of San Diego but of other cities devoted considerable space. This was for a line between San Diego and Los Angeles. San Francisco newspapers reported that it would probably be "pushed ahead" at once, but nothing came of it or anything like it until the Santa Fe system, years later, built the connecting link. Yet the Union in San Diego submitted the matter as one of great importance, declaring that it was "the great enterprise of all others demanded just now" and that "no personal jealousies or conflicting interests should be permitted to endanger its accomplishment." It was reported that eastern capitalists were ready to build the road if proper inducements were ofifered and that negotiations with them had resulted in "flattering prospects of success."
"It is to be hoped," said the Union, that there will be but one feeling in San Diego in regard to this matter ; and for the sake of this part of the state - and especially of this city - that those of our citizens who are at variance as to other measures, will be united in favor of this, and lend to it, if not material aid, at least their moral support."
Interesting comment on the character of San Diego's population at this time is made in an article which appeared in the Union of Sept. 13, 1871, as follows:
"Occupation of A'oters of San Diego County. - A list of the various trades and advocations pursued by the citizens of San Diego whose names appear on the Great Register of this county, has been handed us for publication. The list embraces 85 different classes of pursuits, divided among 1,796 citizens. The number of farmers is greatly in excess of that of any other pursuit, and the mining interest has the next largest mmiber of followers. The occupation of 'Gentleman' is confined to one single person, and but one 'capitalist' figures on the page of the Register. Three 'speculators' is a small number for a town accused of being populated wholly by men of that profession, A'et. only three voters plead guilty to being engaged in speculation. We have six clergymen, twenty-two physicians and fifteen printers, showing conclusively that our moral, physical and intellectual health is well looked after. Our rival city, Duluth, sometime since intimated that we had more than our share of drinking saloons, but we think that there are few counties which have over 4,000 inhabitants that can show less than 20 saloons, that being the exact mmiber of saloon keepers who have enrolled on our Register, and, as a rule saloon keepers do not neglect to exercise their privilege of voting. The lawvers from quite a respectable comjiany in point of numbers, there beintr thirty-three, enough, we think, to enable us to dispense with outside assistance."
Reference already has been made to the fact that the Great Register of the county in 1871 showed 1.796 voters. By 1875 the number had grown to 2,304.
A view of conditions has been afiforded. Now a few words about some of the San Diego men of the times. As a rule they were hardy, unafraid, full of the courage and convictions which actuated the pioneers of those days. A review of their names and their biographies shows that many of them are of Irish descent : some of the most prominent citizens of San Diego in 1871 fall into that list. Some were from the New England States and New York. Others - quite a large percentage of the total number - came from ,the Southern States ; their presence and influence were felt during the Civil War period. As will be seen, a large proportion of them arrived in San Diego in 1869.
One notable survivor of that period in San Diego is Daniel Cleveland, who as those words are written, is the oldest practicing attorney of San Diego - filling out a record which he began here in 1869, when he arrived in the city and began the practice of law in partnership with his brother, William H. Cleveland, who had begun practice here in the Civil War days. Daniel Cle\eland, who was born in Poughkeepsie, N. Y., on March 21. 1838, had gone to Texas in 1859. In August, 1865, as the Civil War was closing, he was commissioned mayor of San Antonio and in his term which lasted about a year, is credited with having put the city's finances into good condition. He had been pronounced in the support of the Union cause and was put in charge of the San Antonio Express, the first Republican paper of Texas. Late in 1866 he went to New York, remaining a year, then returned to the Pacific coast, practicing law at San Francisco for about two yearc;. Here Mr. Cleveland was always prominent and active. Early attempts to get a railroad to San Diego enlisted his loyal support ; he was actively identified with the negotiations of Tom Scott's proposed Texas & Pacific and was attorney for that road for about five years. He was also attorney for the Bank of San Diego. In 1869 he became senior warden of St. Paul's Episcopal Church and not only held that place for many years but also acted as lav-reader when there was no rector, as was often the case. Trained early on commercial lines, later for the law, active in his practice for half a century, jirominent in church and benevolent work, enthusiastic in the study of botany, with his knowledge of and services in that field recognized by distinguished experts, a considerable and successful investor in real estate, he has indeed marked out a notable career in San Diego - and all this he has done although for a number of years he has not been in robust health. His first marriage was in July, 1921. A member of a distinguished old family which included Grover Cleveland, President of the United States, he has kept the family name bright.
Another who arri\ed here at that time and who i)layed an active part in the history of the '70s was Thomas L. Nesmith, a New Hampshire man. In 1870, when he set foot on San Diego soil, there was nothing much to indicate that some day a real city would be built here. Sagebrush and cactus were everywhere except in the little downtown section where, due to Horton's determination and activity, there were half a dozen buildings. The Horton House, to be sure, was going- up, but it took courage for a new-comer to accjuire full satisfaction of the future from the signs then visible ; yet Nesmith, like many others, was confident and he remained with his family. It was Nesmith who was made chairman of the Citizens' Committee of Forty which started early negotiations for a railroad to the East and kept u]) the hope of San Diego until Tom Scott's plan failed. He was chairman of the big meeting which welcomed Scott and his distinguished party here in the summer of 1872. He was a leading citizen, respected by all who knew him. Incidentally, Nesmith's (laughter, Henrietta, became the wife of Gen. A. W. Greely, chief of the signal service bureau and noted Arctic explorer.
Still another was Aaron Pauly, an Ohioan, who came to California overland among the first of the gold-seekers of the days of *49, and who remained in the northern part of the state until 1869, when he came to San Diego. He had been running a store at Maryville, and on arrival here he opened another, landing his first stock of goods of Horton's wharf, then recently finished. He too played a large part in the early history of the city, became prominent in real estate dealings and investments, was first President of the Chamber of Commerce, had a part in the work whose ]Hirpose was a transcontinental railroad ending at the port of San Diego; in association with D. C. Reed, who later became mayor, he l)uilt the Reed-Pauly block in what then was thought likely to become the business centre and was identified in many other ways with the progress of San Diego. Also, he was head of a company which l)uilt a wagon road from San Diego to ^'uma, Ariz. One son. C. W. Pauly, is still a resident of San Diego and has been actively identified in recent years with banking interests of the city.
A remarkal)le sturdy San Diegan of those days was John G. Capron, who since 1867 had been in charge of the overland mail transportation. The mail was discontinued during the Civil War. l)ut when that struggle was over the service was resumed. At that time the mail came across Imperial \^alley from the East, a stop being made at Warner's, but then the line went up to Los Angeles and San Francisco, missing San Diego. In 1867 the route was changed to include San Diego. The contractors had been losing money, it is related, and when the change was ordered they took that as a good excuse to throw up the contract. Capron, who had been mail driver, came to San Diego to reside and took the contract to carry the mail from El Paso to Los Angeles. He kept it until 1874. Mr. Capron died several years ago.
Capt. Samuel Warren Hackett was another "old-timer" who was a resident of San Diego at the time. From 1870 to 1878 he was engaged in cattle-raising in Lower California having sold out the whaling interests which had taken up most of his attention, but he was of course identified with the life of the community even in his absence, although not to such an extent as he had been with the progress of Old Town.
William E. High, a Pennsylvanian, had come here in 1869 and had bought 160 acres 18 miles southeast of the new town, but sold it in a few months for a larger section nearer town, adjoining the big National Rancho, and after a few years more came in as far as Chollas Valley and began raising fruit. That was in 1874, and High soon built up a reputation for excellent products. He was later identified with several institutions of the city and county including the Cuyamaca Railroad and the Consolidated National Bank.
George B. Hensley, a native of England, was another of the period. He too came in 1869 and, like High, w^ent to ranching, his land being in the Tia Juana Valley. He and a brother have been credited Avith the discovery of the famous Stonewall gold mine at Julian. In 1872 he was made deputy county clerk, held the place a year and then opened an abstract office. He was active later in real estate business in the development of Pacific Beach and the attempt to build a railroad from San Diego to Old Town.
Still another who came here in 1869 w'as D. Choate, whose loyalty to San Diego is matched by that of his son, Rufus Choate, whose services in the Chamber of Commerce, in harbor development and in other ways in recent years have been such as to entitle him to much praise. The older Choate came from Maine to California wuth the gold-hunters of '49, landed at San Francisco when it was a straggling hamlet and went to the mines near Yuba. There he met with scant success, so went into the mercantile btisiness at Ophir, where he remained for 17 years. Then, the mining business being none too good, he entered business in San Francisco, and after several months there came to San Diego on a visit, largely for his health. He did not even return north but wrote instructions for the closing out of his business and went into the real estate field in San Diego. He bovight much of what was then "outside" propertv bv the acre and split it up into city additii^ns. In 1888 he had laid out 10 dififerent additions and marketed them. The map of the city gives ample evidence of his activity, the Arnold and Choate addition being one of the best known in all the wide expanse of San Diego. He was postmaster of San Diego from 187.^ to 1882.
A notable addition to those w^ho reached San Diego in 1869 is the name of W. T. McNealy. He was a young Georgian who though onlv about 17 years old when the Civil War was ending was attached to the Confederate troops in the last few months of the great struggle.
City Of San Diego And San Diego Couxty 109
He studied law for three years thereafter in Florida and then came to Cahfornia, to which at the time many southerners were attracted. He went first to San Francisco, then came south to Los Angeles and, after a visit of a few days there, came by the old stage line to San Diego. He remained and soon became one of the city's leading attorneys. How rapid his progress was may be judged from the fact that after being here only a few months he was nominated and elected district attorney on the Democratic ticket. He was re-elected at the next election. He made an excellent and popular record in office and in 1873 was elected judge of the district court, his district comprising San Diego and San Bernardino counties. In 1879 the district court was abolished, and Judge McXealy was elected to the superior court which had been created, and thus was the first to hold that distinguished place in San Diego County. He resigned in 1886 on account of ill health and for a time practiced law in the city, but retired in 188x^ after a remarkable career.
Still another prominent citizen who came to San Diego in 1869 and who was active in the city's life of 50 years ago was A. Klauber, whose name has been carried on through the years by the firm of Steiner & Klauber, its successor, Steiner, Klauber & Co., then Klauber & Levi, and, in recent years the Klauber-Wangenheim Company, wholesale dealers in groceries. The firm began as a general merchandise store in the early days, dry goods being included in its list of extensive transactions. In all the years it has been one of the largest houses in the Southern California field. Klauber wa.<5 an Austrian, born in 1830, who came to this country when young. Soon after his arrival here the firm of Steiner & Klauber was organized and although San Diego of course was only a small town in those days, it was growing and the surrounding country was building up gradually and surely. Meeting the demands of the time, the firm's importance grew with the years. In 1871, the i^eriod to which this section of the book is devoted, Steiner & Klauber's store was at Seventh and I streets, as has already been noted. It was not until about 15 years later that the firm gave up retail business and devoted itself to the wholesale field. At that time the firm, then Klauber & Levi, had c|uarters at Fifth and Market (then H) streets. Klauber was prominent in the Masonic order, as was his old partner Simon Levi. ]>oth took active parr in the building up of San Diego in the early days, Levi entering the local field in 1876, after spending several years in general merchandise business at Temecula.
Another "Sixty-niner" of San Diego history was Charles JFox. the civil engineer whose name already has l)een mentioned in connection with a survey ordered as a preliminar\' to a railroad between Old Town and New Town in 1871. He was elected county surveyor twice, and was identified with a number of surveys important in the development of San Diego as a railroad termiiuis. Among these were surveys for the old Memphis & El Paso Railroad the Texas & Pacific and the California Southern, the beginning of the Santa Fe's line into San Diego. He and his partner. H. I. Willey, afterwards surveyor-general of the state, prepared an official map of San Diego Countv, an important and arduous task in those days of difficult travel. Fte also was identifietl with the enterprise by which a road was buiU through San Diego County and across what was then the desert of Imperial Valley to Fort Yuma ; he was active in real estate transactions and in 1876 organized the Bee Keepers Association of San Diego County. All in all, his was a prettv notable contribution to San Diego's advancement that began in the early seventies. He belonged to a noted Massachusetts family and was born in Boston in 1834.
Another on the role of those who came to the city in 1869 was William Jorres, whose name w^as plainly stamped into San Diego history by what became known as the Jorres wharf, the first started in San Diego although not the first finished, for the Horton wharf, project of the indefatigable A. E. Horton, w'as rushed to completion in accordance with his plans to speed the progress of the town W'hich he had mapped our. Jorres was a German who left his native land when a young man and spent several years in Buenos Ayres and Montevideo, then sailed to San Francisco with the later of the Argonauts and went to the gold mines. When the San P>ancisco fire of 1851 occured he went to that city to help build it up again, became a contractor and remained in that business until he came to San Diego. Here he formed a partnership with S. S. Culvervvell and built the Culverwell & Jorres wharf, to which reference has been made. This was generally known at first as the Culverwell wharf at the foot of F street, but in 1872 Jorres bought out his partner's interest, and the enterprise took his name. The year before he had started work on the new courthouse, as already noted, and that structure was completed by him in 1872. Several other old-time structures in San Diego - large and important buildings for those days - were put up by Jorres as contractor. Among them were the Commercial Bank, Fifth and G streets, and the Central ^Market, above the bank on Fifth street. He was county treasurer from 1878 to 1884. His son, G. W. Jorres, who had been connected with several banks of San Diego and was postmaster of the city from 1885 to 1887, died in 1921.
Of course Judge Clliver S. Witherby was in San Diego. With a residence spanning nearly half a century in San Diego, he built up a real rejiutation as a jurist and citizen and in a striking way linked the life of old San Diego, the life of the Spanish Old Town, with the life of the new San Diego, the town that Horton pushed into actuality. He was a veteran of the Mexican war, having gone into the service from Butler County, Ohio, where he had been prosecuting attorney, and came to San Diego with the boundary commission whose duty was to fix the line between the United States and Mexico. Here he remained and was elected to represent San Diego County as assemblyman in the first California legislature which met at Monterey in 1850 to frame the first law\s of the Golden State. In 1851 he became the first judge of the Southern district of California and held that place until 1853, when President Pierce appointed him collector of customs for the port of San Diego. Leaving that post in 1857, Judge Witherby bought a ranch in Escondido and made a success of it, according to accounts of the period. After about ten vears of ranching, he returned to San Diego, where he died Dec. 18, 1896.
Here too at the time was Ephraini W. Morse, who was one of the most noted of the early citizens of San Diego, a man of fine character, from the best of pioneer stock, and a real force in the upbuilding of the new city. Like many others who came to California at the height of the gold rush, he was a Massachusetts boy - he was only 26 years old when he sailed from Boston in 1849 with a company made up largely of friends and acquaintances. After a few weeks in the Yuba River section he fell a victim to illness and left with many of the comjjany who were in similar plight for San I'rancisco. There, still ill, he heard of San Diego, and came here to regain health and gain a competence. He got back his health and got a start on a competence. In 1851 he went home to claim a bride, Miss Lydia A. Gray of Amesbury, his old home, and brought her back to San Diego with him. She died five years later but left him a son, Edward W. In 1852 Mr. Morse was elected associate judge of the court of sessions of San Diego County and in 1853 was made a member of the board of trustees. In 1865 he took another wife. Miss Mary O. Walker, who had come from Manchester, N. H. to teach at the O'ld Town school. In 1869, when Horton's '"boom" had begun to make the New Town's influence felt, Morse moved from ( )ld Town to South San Diego, as it then was, selling out his mercantile business when he made the change. He was one of the founders of the Ikink of San Diego in 1870 and also aided in organizing the Consolidated National Bank, which succeeded the Bank of San Diego in later years, and was a director of the new institution for many years. He was active in many lines which the city took in its advancement, including, of course, the railroad agitation, and held two countv offices. He was identified with the erection of two of the largest buildings put up in San Diego in the '80s ; one of these was the five-story Pierce- Morse Pjlock, at Sixth and^ F streets, which he built in i)artnershi|) with James M. Pierce, and which was described at the time as '"the first building thoroughly metropolitan in appearance erected in San Diego." The other was Morse, Whaley and Dalton building on Fifth Street next to the old home of the First National Bank. Mr. Morse was active also in the improvement of San Diego's growing school system and in the ])reservation of the great city jjark, now Balboa Park. He died Jan. 17, 1906.
The Whaley associated with ^forse in the Fifth Street building just mentioned was Thomas W'haley, who came from New York to San Diego, .\lthough not so fortunate in business as his activities warranted, he left a real mark in local history and deserves more than mere passing mention - all the more so because of the interesting details of his career. lie was an associate at various times of E. W. Morse, JMiilip Crosthwaite. Ch:irles P. Noell and R. H. Dalton. all well known San Dicgrms. Mr. Whaley, who was of Irish ancestry, came around the 1 lorn in 184*^' with the gold-seeking swarm of Americans who S(uight fortune in California, and went into mercantile business in San hVancisco. Prosperity was looming up for him in his venture when a change of grade was made on Montgomery Street that left his building 15 feet below the mark set by the authorities. The tenants of the building which he and his associates had erected moved out and his business was lost. In 1851 two new business associates who had joined with him - Lewis A. Franklin and George H. Davis - came to San Diego and decided to stay here. They persuaded Whaley to follow them. With Franklin he formed a partnership and opened a general store on the old plaza at Old Town. After a few months of that business connection ^Ir. Whaley went in with John Hinton in another similar venture in Old Town which was remarkably successful. It is related that the net profits in the first year were more than $18,000. The next year, 1853, Morse entered the firm, and that summer Mr. Whaley went on a visit to New York. There he married Miss Anna E. Lannay, a descendant of two French families, and brought his bride from the comforts and culture of the Eastern metropolis to share his fortunes in the rough little settlement on the shores of far away San Diego Bay. Mrs. fWhaley's impressions of the place on her arrival and shortly thereafter are themselves of no small interest. It is not strange that the young bride found it hard to accustom herself to the wildlooking Indians and the rather primitive customs of some of the whites here at that time. Morse retired from the store partnership three years later, and Whaley carried it on alone for some time, also engaging in brick-making. His brick house, erected in 1856, is said to have been the first of the kind built on the California coast south of San Francisco. In 1859 he went to San Francisco to act as commissary for the Government and later went to Alaska, on its transfer from Russia. He did not return to San Diego until late in 1868, when he engaged again in business at Old Town. Although Old Town was still a hustling little place, the new town was acquiring an importance which pointed to its success, and in 1869 Whaley went there, buying out his old partner, Morse, to get a site, as related in \"an Dyke's history of the county, in order to obtain a good site. He was not successful, however, and a few years later went to New York, where he remained for five years. When he came back in 1879 it was, it is related, with only a small amount of money. He entered the real estate field, however, and did so well that he was able to retire in 1888. For a time, as has been mentioned, the county records were kept in a building owned by Whaley at Old Town and were removed from that place to the new town in 1871. His daughter. Miss Whaley, has been for some time a valued member of the public library stafT and instrumental in preserving many of the valuable historical data of San Diego. At one time he was a large property owner in San Diego.
Mention already has been made of Judge M. A. Luce, who had been prominent as a citizen and attorney for nearly fifty years. He has seen San Diego from the days of the Tom Scott boom to the present and in many of those days he had been an active figure - spare of figure and far from robust but still keenly active. He was born in Illinois in 1842 of New England parents and lived with them until he left to prepare for college at Hillsdale, Mich. Fle spent part of his time educating himself and the rest in educating others that he might have the money to go ahead with his own training. In 1861 when the call to arms was sounded in the great Civil war, he left his studies and enlisted. He not only saw all the fighting that one man could well see but took an active part in it and acquitted himself with notable bravery and fidelity. The space alloted to the writer does not permit a full account of it all here, but it may be said that his record was one of which any patriot might be proud. His record extends from Bull Run to Gettysburg and through to Cold Harbor and Petersburg. The war over, he went back to Hillsdale, graduating in 1866. Then he studied law and soon began practice in his native state.
"I came here." said Judge Luce recently, "because I had developed a weak throat. It troubled me so much that I could not well deliver an address to a jury, and I thought that it was time that I was coming to a gentler climate. I had subscribed to the San Diego Union in the fall of 1872, and what I read in that newspaper about San Diego proved so satisfactory that I started here, arriving in May, 1873. My first oflfice was on the south side of the Plaza, in a twostory building on the site of what is now the Cabrillo theatre. My first partner was H. H. Wildey, a former soldier in the Confederate army. I had been in the Federal army, of course, but we got along very well. Mr. Wildey afterwards became district attorney of San Diego County."
In 1875 Mr. Luce was elected judge of the county court and served in that capacity for four years, when the new state constitution abolished that court, or, rather, combined that court and the district court in the superior court of the present day. Soon after leaving the bench he became identified with the work which succeeded in bringing the Santa Fe to the Pacific shore. He was vice president and attorney of the California Southern Railroad Company, organized in 1880 as the connecting link for the Santa Fe. He also has served as attorney in several other notable ways, was for a time active in politics and has been prominent and active in the affairs of the First L^itarian Church of San Diego ever since its organization. He and Mrs. Luce, who was Miss Adelaide Mantania of Avon, Illinois, have had six children, one of whom is Edgar A. Luce, Superior Judge of San Diego County, formerly state senator.
.-\ little less than a year after Judge Luce arrived in San Diego there came to the city a man of truly remarkable attainments and ability - a young surgeon of foreign birth who had served through part of the American Ci\il war and all of the Franco- Prussian war and who had started to San Diego to build up a physique which had undergone a hard strain in his service abroad. He is Dr. P. C. Remondino, the dean of the medical fraternitv in San Diego. Still living, and still working, he has not only retained his ability but has continued to add richly even through his later years, to his vast store of knowledge. Possessed of a marvelously retentive and accurate memory, he is a perfect storehouse of information and historical facts. Doctor Reiuondino was born in Turin. Italy, Feb. 10. 18-k>. and received his early education in a Catholic scho(il. His father brought him to .America in 1854 and settled at Wabasha, Minnesota, where the older Remondino engaged in mercantile business. When he was only sixteen years old he entered Jefferson College at Philadelphia and began the study of medicine. The Civil war had started at the time and in 1864 the demand for surgeons to attend to wounded Federal troops was so urgent that the young student volun- teered with somie of his college mates and was assigned to hospital duty. Later he did field duty with a Pennsylvania artillery regiment, witii which, at the close of the war, he was mustered out. Then he went back to his home in Minnesota and practiced there until the Franco- Prussian war broke out. Love of adventure and admiration for the French took him overseas for service with the French army. With him he took enthusiastic credentials from State and Washington officials and had no trouble in getting an appointment as surgeon. Not only that, he obtained a commission which Doctor Remondino recently said was the only one thus granted to an American - a 'fact which caused one of the French high officers some surprise when the mustering-out process began. The French commander at the time was paying the way of each man to his home, and when the officer learned w^here the young surgeon's home was he was nonplused. The best he could do was to pay Doctor Remondino's way to the most convenient seaport. Doctor Remondino, however, delayed his departure for the United States until he had made an extensive trip through Italy, Switzerland and England. He resumed his practice late in 1871. Coming here in January, 1874, he met an old classmate, Dr. Robert J. Gregg, wdio had started practice in Old Town in 1868 and had moved to the new town ; Doctor Remondino opened an office next door on the west side of Fifth street between E and F and began practice in his new home. He was city physician in 1875 and 1876 and was several times county physician, besides being surgeon for several corporations. In 1879 he built a hospital in partnership with Dr. Thomas C. Stockton, a pioneer physician of the new town, but had to abandon the plan because it did not pay. In 1885 Doctor Remondino built the old St. James Hotel which was at Sixth and F streets and which was opened in February, 1886 - a fine building for the times. He has not only remained in practice but has kept in touch with developments of his profession and has written a number of works on medical subjects which have commanded attention both at home and abroad. In addition he has been an expert student of climatology and has contributed a valuable addition to its literature, his subject being San Diego's climate. He is now at work on an exhaustive history of medicine. His library is a remarkable collection of books. His home also contains a remarkable collection of rifles and other guns in which he has taken a marked interest. It may be added that Doctor Remondino has upheld the finest traditions of his calling by paying devoted attention to many cases when little or no monetary remuneration for his services could be expected. He was married in 1877 to Miss Sophie Earle. They had four children, Carrie Katherine, now ]\Irs. B. V. Franklin, wife of Doctor Franklin ; Frederick Earle Remondino. Louise Remondino, now Mrs. Alfred Stahel, and Dr. Charles Henry Earle Remondino.
George W. Hazzard, whose name has become well known by San Diegans and who is credited with having opened the first grocery store in San Diego, came to the city late in 1868. He was a native of Indiana. His first venture here was to take up 160 acres of land in the Otay valley. He found, however, that he could not improve it and after several changes came into the city and opened a grocery at Fifth and I streets. Success followed this step, but in 1871, be- lieving that National City, by reason of the proposed Texas & Pacific Railroad, was to be important, he went there, taking some land from the Kimball brothers. Three years later, he returned to San Diego and soon erected a brick store building, one of the first in the city, at Sixth and H streets, and engaged in general merchandise business until 1882 when he sold out. Later he entered the real estate field and was highly successful. Mr. Hazzard was one of the incorporators of the San Diego Water Company, was interested in the city's gas company in the late 70s and early '80s, was an incorporator of the Masonic Building Association and was active for years in the Chamber of Commerce, of which he was president in 1880 and 1881. He retired from active work some vears ago. He was born in February, 1845.
Another San Diegan of the same period is Philip Morse, who has been identified with the lumber business in San Diego almost continuously since his arrival here in March, 1869, when he came from San Francisco to represent a firm of that city. For about four years - from 1879 to 1883 - he was in Arizona on lumber business, being associated with Jacob Gruendike. On his return he and his father-in-law, George W. B. McDonald, formed the firm of Mc- Donald and Co. Soon after that Mr. Morse became associated with several San Francisco men in the formation of the San Diego Lum"- ber Company, of which Morse was made general manager. He also was interested at times in other business enterprises and for some time, in recent years, has been a director of the Southern Trust and Commerce Bank. In 1875 and 1876 he served as city treasurer, has served on the city board of education and has taken an active interest for many years in the Y. M. C. A. Mr. Morse's literary accomplishments have induced him to make a number of contributions to newspapers and magazines, his verse and humor finding ready acceptance. He was born in Favette, Maine, on ]\lay 23>, 1845. On Mav 23. 1870, he married Miss Sarah McDonald of San Diego, daughter of a prominent resident of the city.
( )f influence in the civic and religious life of .'>an Diego in those davs was George W. B. McDonald, well remembered bv many older residents of the city. He came to San Diego from San Francisco in 1869 and was one of the founders of the b^irst Methodist Episcopal Church, of which for many years he was Sunday school superintendent. He was one of the early supervisors of the county, served later as deputy collector of customs at this port and was one of the leaders in the Philharmonic Society, which during the first six years of the city did n^uch to provide wholesome enjoyment for San Diegans. He died on Feb. 8, 1886. One of his two daughters is Mrs. Philip Morse.
Another prominent resident of San Diego at the time was Major Levi Chase, a native of Maine and a veteran of the Civil war. who came here in 1868. engaged at once in the practice of law and ultimately was connected with much of the important litigation arising in San Diego County for many years thereafter. At the time of his death. May 31. 1906, he was referred to as the oldest member of the San Diego Bar .Vssociation. One of the imi)()rtant pieces of litigation which he undertook was to settle the title and boundaries
The list of the men who were in San Diego fifty years ago and who attained prominence in the life of the little city of those days is a long one. It has been impossible to do more in the space allotted than to present a somewhat representative list. Other names, which do not appear here, might well have been included but for that reason.
Horiox Comes To Sax Dikgo
Considering^ the means at his conmiand and weighing the ohstacles against which he had to struggle, Alonzo Erastus Horton almost literally accomplished wonders in San Diego. For he came here to the i^ort when the new town of Davis and Gray had faded away almost to notliing, saw almost at a glance that their site, the site which the city now occupies - if sjjread from that "new town" of the '50s - was the real site and thereon built a city. He started with nothing but the site and its adxantages and a small capital and out of it all made what he had dreamed could and would be made.
-A. E. Horton was a really remarkable man. Powerful in build, with shrewd yet kindly eyes, firm chin - a man who at first glance might have been thought to be little more than a clever, bold trader - he possessed withal a tremendously broad vision and the creative faculty to make such a vision count. He was not, strictly speaking, a philanthropist ; yet he was generous to a degree, giving of his land to all civic enterprises of merit and often lifting the burden from, some unfortunate purchaser, lie wanted, of course, to make a city at San Diego and to profit thereby and realized that to foster worthy enterprise, to encourage home-building and the construction of churches and hotels was good ])olicy ; but his donations were made in a broadminded, generous way. As it turned out, he did not die a wealthy man ; yet his late years were filled, according to the one best qualified to speak on that subject - his wife - with a complete satisfaction that around his home there had grown up a great city.
"fie had a great, broad vision," said Mrs. Horton in a recent talk with the writer of this history. "He foresaw all that came to pass in San Diego in his life time. He was never surjirised at any of the great imj^rovements which were made here in his later years. One might think that he would have been sorry when the old Horton House, the fine hotel he had built, was torn down to make room for a modern structure. Rut he was not sorry ; to the contrary, he was glad to see the fine new building go up."
."^o he was with all other improvements which the tuen who came after him. working on the beginnings he had made, improved upon his plan and broadened the city out.
vSmythe has directed attention to the fact that the previous and unsuccessful attemi)t of Gray and Davis to establish a town at what is now San Diego did not work in Horton's favor: there were many who looked on Horton's attempt as due to fail because of the earlier failure. Yet Horton realized that the time in which he came was better for such an attemi)t than was that of the Gray-Davis ettort, and he had the force of character to see it through. As Snivthe adds, "it is easy enough to criticize the man who did it; it is not so easy to duplicate the achievement, nor was it ever done before by the will of a single individual, without capital, without the support of some religious, social or commercial organization. Horton well deserves the tribute, x^lso he well deserves the kindly name "Father" which San Diegans bestowed on the founder of the city in his later years.
Horton first came to San Diego in April, 1867. He was a Connecticut Yankee and at the time was in his 54th year. As a boy he was brought up in humble circumstances in Northern New York, where, to help support the family, he worked at various tasks - as a timber-cutter, a grocery clerk, a lake' sailor and in other lines of endeavor. Incidentally, he gained a reputation as a wrestler of great strength. Despite this physical prowess, he developed a cough, which led his doctor to believe that young Horton had consumption and to advise the young man to go west. So Horton went to Wisconsin, where he traded in land and cattle, using his natural shrewdness in what was then a new land for most Americans. When the [Mexican war ended, he bought some soldiers' land warrants at a good price for the buyer and laid out the town of Hortonville, Wisconsin. In a few years he had cleaned up a good amount of money and decided to go on to the Pacific coast with the many then bound on the hunt for gold. That was in 1851. In the mining region he worked with some degree of success in purchases of gold dust. In 1856 he pulled up his stakes and went back East by way of Panama, where the passengers got into a fight with natives with the result that many were robbed. Horton himself lost $10,000, but saved $5,000 which he carried in a belt. He fought for several years at Washington, making frequent trips to the capital, to have steps for redress taken.
Horton in the early '60s returned to the Pacific coast and in 1867 w^as in San Francisco where he had a small furniture business. Horton at the time had a bad cough, and perhaps he remembered the warning which the doctor had sounded many years before. At any rate, when he heard of the climatic and other advantages of San Diego, he quickly made up his mind to move there. These advantages were spread forth by a speaker at a meeting to which Horton happened to be invited. The speaker told of the harbors on the Pacific Coast, starting at Seattle and working south with his description. At last he came to San Diego, which, according to Horton, he described as one of the most healthful places on 'earth and possessing a great harbor. Horton looked the place up on a map and then decided to sell out his business and move. The sale took him only three days, and then Horton took passage on the steamer Pacific. The Wells- Fargo agent on the boat was as enthusiastic about San Diego as had been the speaker whose glowing praise of San Diego had sent Horton away from San Francisco, and by the time the steamer reached the narrow old wharf at "New Town," Horton's expectations had been keyed up to high pitch. In those days passengers from the steamer went by wagon from the wharf to Old Town. Horton later related that when he arrived at Old Town he expressed himself forcibly as being very doubtful about the Old Town site.
City Of .San Diego And San Diego County 119
That remark led to the famous auction at which Horton bought a thousand acres at an average price of twenty-six cents an acre. E. W. Morse, the kindly, thoughtful, loyal San Diegan who later became well known in the city, was Wells-Fargo agent at Old Town, and he had stood by as Horton had spoken for a new San Diego. It was Morse who suggested the auction, and the two soon began a friendship which lasted until death took Morse away. Horton paid $10 to have a special election of trustees called so there would be no doubt as to the legality of the auction plan and then went shooting quail, which abounded here in those days and in so doing lost his cough. He also went out with Morse and looked over the new townsite. When Sunday came he went to Fr. Antonio D. Ubach's little Catholic church and attracted considerable attention to himself by putting $5 into the collection plate. At the special election Morse, Toseph S. Mannassee and Thomas H. Bush, men for whom Horton had declared a preference, were unanimously elected. Then the auction of the j^ueblo lands was held, with Morse as auctioneer. Horton got the land he wanted practically without opposition, and then, having had the deeds recorded, went back to San Francisco to tell his friends about San Diego.
Lieutenant Derby (John Phoenix) in his jovial description of the city as "Sandyago" had not done much to advertise it in the best way, and it may be that there were many scotYers when Horton returned to the north and began to talk about the town which he had bo'ight. Yet Horton said later that "large crowds" gathered around him when he told of what he hod seen and surveyed and bought and that all were interested. Among those who heard what Horton had to '-ay was Gen. William S. Rosecrans. who was considering a plan to build a railroad ihrough to ("alifornia and he evinced real interest in what Horton. related. The upshot of this was that the ger;eral took passage witli Horton when the latter started back to San Diego. Horton and Rosecrans got a team and rode out to Jacumba Pass, looked over into Imperial W.lley and took observations along the road. Horton had been quotjd as saying that Rosecrans declared this southern loutc the best he had seen for a railroad to enter California. The two went back to San Francisco together and soon after that, according to Horton. he received an olifer. through Rosecrans, of $250,000 for Horton's land in San Diego. Horton made up his mind that if it was worth that much, he would hatig to it and make what profits there were to be made, and the deal was called off.
llorton soon returned to S.m Diego and started the building of the city of which he had dreamed. He bought from William 11. Davis a small building down on the waterfront and got ^'apt. S. S. Dunnells to start a hotel in it. He began building a wharf which cost about $45,000, at the foot of Fifth Street and then began selling lots or even offering some of them free if those who took them would build. Soon a score of buildings were started on Fifth Street dowii near the bavshore. Others soon followed.
or sympathizers with the South in the war, had settled here. Horton, however, was an ardent Repiihlican and seemed to be determined to do somthing for the party of his choice while buildings up a new city. To use his own words, he was "a Black Republican" and he was rather e^jven to expressing his i:)olitical views. In an interview given in 1905 Horton said that on one occasion soon after his arrival in San Diego he was warned that it would be dangerous for him to talk freely on Republican lines, the man who gave the warning saying that San Diego was "the worst Copperhead hole in California."
Horton kept his word. He gave it out that he would employ i-;<,ne but Repuljlicans and as he had the work for men to do and the money with which -:o i)ay them, his influence was, to say the least, strong. The Republicans elected a number of their candidates in the fall of 1871, and since then, with few exceptions, the county and city have been strongly Republican.
Horton's venture v.'as successful almost from the start. Newcomers began to arrive, and the demand for ])roperty here sent the price of Plorton's lots up. Horton himself said later that some times after the arrival of a steamer from the north he would take in from $5,000 to $20,000 a day. He took money in so fast that he became tired of handling it, much as the later real estate dealers of the boom days of 18<S7 and 1888 became tired of taking in money for San Diego lots.
In January, 1870. Horton began building the Horton House, which cost about $150,000. His widow said recently that when this j)lan was annoiuiced, some indignation was expressed, some of the residents of the new San Diego accusing him of ''starting a town 'wav out upon D street." In nine months the hotel was finished, and for many a year it Vvas known throughout the Southwest as the finest hotel in that section. It contained 100 r(n>m>>. was three stories high, had all of the conveniences of the period and soon became famous. George W. Marston, who later became well known as a merchant, was the first clerk. .Not long after that Marston started his store at Fifth and F streets, and that was the farthest store "uptown" for some time. The hotel Inn'lding was constructed jxtrtly of brick and partly of wood, of wliich two steamer loads were brought to ."^an Diego for the purpose.
Striking evidence of the rather isolated situation of the Horton House is afiforded in an old I'liotograjih, taken in 1872. of r)roadway looking west from l-'ifth Street. C^n the northwest corner where- nnw towers the Holzwasser building was a grocery store. .Apparently only one other building was between that and the Horton House. ( hi the southwest corner of Third and IVoadway, where the fine I'nioii building now stands, was shown the old Horton bank building in jirocess of construction. The only animate objects shown in this photogra]ili from what is now the city's "busiest corner" were a horse and three men, one of whom sat, comjfortably tilted back, in a chair at the entrance of the l)uilding east of the corner grocery. It was a peaceful scene this which the photographer caught, and if a man had stood by him and had discharged a caimon with only reasonably
Not long after starting the hotel, Horton began construction of the Horton bank building at the southwest corner of Third and D streets. It was intended originally to contain the offices of Colonel Scott's Texas & Pacific Railroad, which did not materialize. When this structure was completed, there probably was no finer building south of San Francisco in the whole state. When it was razed in 1906 to make room for the present Union building, this account of the old structure was printed in the Union :
"At that timie 'Father' Horton was in the prime of his life, and probably the richest and most powerful man in Southern California. The Union building was his particular pet project. Into it he put thought and efifort. It was to stand in the future as a monument to the far sightedness of its builder. And during his Hfe it was such.
" 'Father' Horton spared no expense in its construction. He did not figure whether by decreasing its cost in some particular he could add to the percentage its revenues would return. He merely sought what was the best material to put into it and the best inen to do the work. The rest was simple. He gathered the material, and the men to do the work were found and told to go ahead.
"They were hired by the day and were constantly under the eye of Mr. Horton. They had no object in working hastily or in substituting cheap material, and they did not do so.
"As an instance of the thoroughness of construction one might rhention the bank vault in the corner room of the building. A base was laid for it nine or ten feet thick. Not content with mixing merely broken rock and mortar together, Mr. Horton had collected all the empty bottles in town. These were broken up and thoroughly mixed with the cement, not only to add strength but to make the way more dangerous for any possible burglar who might seek to burrow under the vault upward into it."
The new town began to grow in a remarkably fast manner. Horton kept the pace fast. He gave away lots to each of the church organizations, and some of them soon became very valuable. An instance of this was seen in the old Methodist Church block at Fourth Street and Broadway; by 1888 this had reached a value of $60,000. It was then asserted that the real estate which Horton had given away would reach the value of a million dollars and that in addition he had put more than $700,000 of his own money into the improvement of the city. His receipts at first were small, but by 1869, two years after he started the city, they had reached $85,000 a year. One writer says that in all Horton gave away more than a score of blocks and many lots. On one of these blocks the courthouse was built. When financial conditions were bad, Horton kept up his good work, employing men, encouraging building, providing homes, assuming financial burdens and asserting his faith in San Diego. When a church could not raise money for its building, to be put on a lot already given by Horton, the father of the town often helped to swell the building fund and to make it large enough for the purpose outlined.
lo 1869 the new town claimed some 3,000 inhabitants, and "additions" were being laid out and marketed. Hundreds of newcomers were pouring in, and the little hotel run by Captain Dunnells was by no means able to take care of the new arrivals, so new hotels were {)lanned. The Bay View Hotel at Fifth and F streets was the first erected in Horton's addition; it was started in 1868: Horton's big hotel, "the finest in Southern California," was opened in 1870. The steamers from San P'rancisco were bringing in many who wanted homes in San Diego. There was complaint of ''high rents" and the scarcity of homes. At the close of 1869, so the newspapers reported, there were nearly 450 buildings in the city.
The spirit of the new and growing town was strikingly shown in its Fourth of July celebration of 1869. It lasted three days and nights and was long a pleasant topic of conversation among old San Diegans. On Saturday, the first day of the program, there was a large meeting in Horton's warehouse. Daniel Cleveland, who had arrived only in the previous May, gave the ovation of the day - a notable address, according to newspaper comment. G. W. B. 'Slc- Donald, father-in-law of Philip Morse, still residing here, was president of the day. Rev. Sidney Wilbur, who organized an Episcopalian j)arish in San Diego - the first regular church in the new town - gave the prayer. Capt. Matthew Sherman, who later laid out Sherman's addition and who became mayor in 1891, read the declaration of Independence. There was celebration all around San Diego, Old Town and Mommient City sharing in the festivities.
San Diego's activity in building and other progress was marked in 1870. Horton was instrumental in getting the Western Union Telegraph Company to extend its line here and headed a movement for an $8,000 subsid\-. The line was opened up Aug. 19. 1870, and has been open ever since except for short periods such as that following the great flood of 1916 which rii:)])ed out poles and wires all along the coast of Southern California. Daily mail service between Los Angeles and San Diego also was established, and the city began to be a real citv as far as communication with the outside world is concerned. Horton's Hall at Sixth and F streets, and the Bank of San Diego, the first of the city, were started and completed. Horton was first president of the bank. The national census of that year gave the city 2,300 inhabitants and 915 houses.
The Horton House, erected at a cost of $125,000, with about $25,000 added for furnishings : the residence then occupied bv Thomas L. Nesmith, $9,000: Horton's Hall. $10,000: wharf, later bought by the Pacific Mail Steamship Comjiany. $40,000: bank building at Third and D streets, $50,000: building at' Sixth and G streets. $8,000: residence Sixth and A streets, $4,500: building Ninth and H streets, $1,500, and several other smaller buildings.
Col. Thomas A. Scott could not build the proposed Texas & Pacific into San Diego - a matter told in some detail in another part of this book - and for several years after that San Diego was a quiet place. It was natural that it should be, for the hard times which began in the nation in 1873 soon spread to the Pacific coast and put the brakes effectually on progress there. Still the town grew even in those dull times. Some there were who had come to San Diego, had been unable to ""make a go of it" and who turned to Horton for aid. If he held a contract from such a man, this contract was taken up and the original purchaser paid back "dollar for dollar." Such was Horton's faith in the town, and such was his way of doing business. This place seems an appropriate one for a few ntore words concerning the personal side of Horton. Reference already has been made to the fact that he was physically a powerful man. Mrs. Horton recently recalled in a conversation with the writer a little incident to which the pioneer often referred with a chuckle in his later years.
"On one occasion," said Mrs. Horton, "Mr. Horton went to San Francisco to get the gold coin to start his bank at the southwest corner of Third and D streets. He brought the gold back in a bag and when he left the steamer he carried it without apparent effort, for although it was very heavy he was a very strong man, and such burdens meant nothing to him. When the porter came up, Mr. Horton said, 'How much will you carry this bag up for?' I suppose the man said he would do it for two bits or four bits, whatever his price was. At any rate, Mr. Horton gave him the bag to carry, and he simply staggered under the load. Mr. Horton was very much amused at this and often told about it with a merry laugh at the recollection of the incident."
Horton was about 5 feet, 10 inches in height and weighed about 180 pounds. Even in his later years - he lived to be more than ninetyfive - he nearly always was healthy and vigorous and always optimistic. He did not smoke or drink, and Mrs. Horton says that for many years he did not like the odor of tobacco smoke. But in his late vears he became a member of the San Diego lodge of Elks and often after attending their meetings came home uncomplaining with the odor of his fellow-lodgemen's cigar smoke lingering in his garments. He nearly always wore a black frock coat and black silk hat when on the street. He was very fond of music, sang a little and liked to attend the theatres.
Mr. Horton's first wife was a Miss Sarah Babe. She died in the late '80s. Mr. Horton in November, 1890, married the present Mrs. Horton, then the widow of William Knapp, a retired navv officer.
The father of San Diego passed away in January, 1909, after an illness of about six weeks. He suffered in his last twenty years on occasions from a recurrence of poison oak poisoning, and this in his last few days caused him much pain.
there thinking what a beautiful location this was for a great city. He also often told me of going to the rise in ground at about Date or Elm streets, and in later years he said: 'I am not surprised at what has happened here in San Diego. I have seen it all - the tall buildings and great ships at anchor, taller buildings and greater ships than I had ever seen. I dreamed it all.' Mr. Horton actuallv did have dreams like this ; they were not mere pictures of the fancy but actual dreams.
Provenance
Text from City of San Diego and San Diego County : the Birthplace of California, published 1922, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.