Guilford Town (part 10 of 15)
Part 10 of 15 of the account of this town in A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897. 15,429 words, covering 8 settlements. Source changes inside the text are labelled at the exact paragraph where the next book begins.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter, on this part. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
15 pagesThe source prints this as one continuous account. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs straight on across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The chapter
15,429 wordsReproduced complete and unedited from A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897. The text is machine-read from scans, so expect recognition errors: misspelled names, dropped words, and stray characters. Nothing has been corrected, because correcting a proper name invents one. The headings below are the books' own; source changes are labelled in place.
The familiar horse-sheds first come to our notice on September 18, 1705, when, on petition of Caleb Leete, John Collins, Josiah Everitt, Sam'l Stone, Benajah Stone, Tho. Hall, and Benajah Stone, Jr., liberty was granted to them " to build an open shelter to set their horses under on Sabbath & other public days, against Mr. Wm. Leete's lot near the meeting house."
Meantime the meeting house was growing too old and small to be suitable for the congregation, and on August 18, 1703, it was voted " to have a meeting in November next, to consider and agree about building a new meeting house." No such meeting appears on the records and the plan was probably given up for the time on account of the East Guilford people, now obtaining a church of their own and so diminishing the congregation at the old church. The subject came up again on September 19, 1710, when a committee was chosen "to prepare something about building a new meeting house, as to the dimentions and plan." A year later, on November 20, 1711, the town voted to build a new meeting house, " with convenient speed, provided the place be agreed upon." A committee of seven, for managing the work and hiring workmen, was appointed, and it was voted to make the house 68 by 46 feet and 24 feet between joists. The site decided upon was on the Green, south of the old schoolhouse, and the timber for the church was to be gotten and drawn home, framed and covered before winter. This was too much to expect accomplished in the short time before winter, and not until June 23, 1712, did the town vote "to raise the new meeting house at free cost gratis." Even then the work was not to be soon completed and, on December 16, 17 12, the town voted to have the work finished by the next October. At the same time it was decided to make the seats " with boards down to the floor & the pews also." This was a moot point and as there was so near a " Tyc " in the vote, the matter was postponed until February 3,
1712-13, when it was voted that the new meeting- house "be pewed round the side," " according to a Platform shewed," and that a new pulpit be made, while the " two windows left between the middle parts " are to be clapboarded up.
The house was finished with double galleries and on November 25, 1713, it was voted to go into it as soon as the committee can make the new meeting house " fit to sit in." At the same time a committee was appointed to seat the meeting house " and that age & the lists shall be the rule of seating & that men & women sit together in the meeting house in the pews," an early instance of this. The debts ^ incurred in building this new house were ordered, on January 5, 1713-14, to be paid by selling staves, the glass of the old meeting house, and that house itself, " if they can light of a good market." On February' 4, 1713-14, the seating committee are directed to seat the galleries also "with males not seated from 16 yrs. old & upward, & Females from 14 yrs. old & upward." " At the same time a horse block was ordered to be set up within two rods of the meeting house, within which distance from the house no horses were to be tied, lest they disturb the worshippers. On February 22, 1713-14, it was voted that the upper gallery " be banistered."
An attempt was made to put a chimney in the old meeting house and use it for school and training day purposes, on January 4, 1 714-15, but on February 5, 1 716-17, the town again voted to sell it, probably as it was found to be of no use. On December 13, 1722, it was voted to bring forward the pews in the lower gallery, so as to have the " alley " behind them, and to finish the upper gallery with seats " built round."
The town, finding a surplus of £35 on hand from the income of the town mill, etc., on December 15, 1724, voted to appropriate it to buy a bell " for the meeting house, and the society accepting this gift a week later, voted to procure a bell like that in " Air. Colman's meeting house in Boston." Capt. Thos Hall received " £^^ in Bills of Credit and 28s. 8d. silver money at 15 pennyweight," on June 6, 1725, and the bell was bought. It still hangs in the steeple of the First Church, having been recast in 1735, 1792, 1837 a"<^ 1888.'
' Fi\c were on the committee, only four acted; their report was accepted on Feb. 22, 1713-14. Dec. 19. 1723, "Voted that it be a disorder for any person to sit needlessly out of the seats provided to sit in."
' Dec. 28, 1732, voted to turn the bell frame so the bell swing east and west to prevent the rocking of the meeting-house. Rev. Joseph Eliot left iio for a bell in his will.
* Dec. 26, 1734, voted to have bell new cast and increased to 500 pounds in wciglit. 1792 Society bore one-half the expense. 1837. increased to over 1000 pounds.
The obtaining a bell probably incited the Society to appoint a committee on December 29, 1725, to build a steeple ^ at the west end of the meeting house, " with a suitable belfn,' and spire." The belfry was built and on December 20, 1726, liberty was "granted to any of the Inhabitants of this parish to set up & fix a suitable Clock in the meeting house, with a hammer to strike on the great bell; . , . provided the charge of purchasing sd. clock be raised by a voluntary contribution."
The clock was made and given to the society by Ebenezer Parmelee, an ingenious mechanic. " This is said to have been the first meeting house in Connecticut furnished with a steeple, bell and clock."' The clock was in use until 1893 and was probably the oldest in New England if not in the United States. Ebenezer Parmelee for many years rectified and kept in order the clock, which was " beneficial " to the inhabitants, and on December 15, 1741, he was freed from serving in town offices so long as he continued to do so. From the spire at nine o'clock each night save Saturday, rang forth the peals of the bell to summon the good people to seek their beds.^ The sexton, in addition to this, rang the bell for funerals, for all public meetings, and swept the meeting house,* and for this, Ephraim Pierson received iio on December 19, 1727. On December 18, 1744, it was decided to glaze the windows " with sash glass," to cover the south side of the roof, and the south side and east end of the wall with cedar, and to change the position of the windows in the south side. Further changes were ordered on December 22, 1747, when it was voted to clapboard the edifice anew, to fit it with new sash windows and to replace the two windows over the pulpit canopy with one. The steeple was struck by lightning on July 14, 1800, and repaired " by splicing the mast," at which time a lightning rod was procured."
In 1811 the project of arching the roof was discussed and the house was replastered and whitewashed, while " moulding caps " were substituted for banisters in the galleries.
'Dec. 5, 1759, pulpit to be lowered. Feb. 4, 1772, voted to put in a window over the i)ulpit. Dec. 1809, north side of house to have a " sill," window frames to be repaired, and other necessary repairs to be done and " stepping stones " for the doors to be procured.
the meeting house, so as to report, " whether it is expedient to repair and paint it or not." These first mutterings of discontent increased, and on February 4, 1828, the Society voted to build a new meeting house. In the previous November a committee of ten had been appointed to sohcit subscriptions therefor. Over $5,000 was raised in that way and a pubhc meeting of the subscribers was held on February 18, 1828. At that time a committee of five, Nathaniel Griffing, Wm, Todd, Daniel Loper, George Landon and Amos Seward were appointed to inquire into the cost of a meeting house and to report on a site. It was also decided that the house be built of stone, by a vote of 94^ shares to 15 for brick and 18 for wood. On April 27, however, the decision was made for wood by a vote of 80 shares to 36J/2 for stone and 8 for none at present. There were 103 subscribers, contributing in all $6,179.00. Those contributing $100 or over were: Nathaniel Griffing, $250, Justus S. Chittenden, and Bille Chittenden each $100, Samuel Robinson and Anna H. Chittenden each $200, George Landon and William Todd each $150, Comfort Starr and Joel Canfield each $100, William Hart and George Griswold each $150, Sam'l and John Burgis together the same amount, Asher Dudley and Joel Tuttle each $200. Hannah and Elizabeth Burgis, Aaron Dutton, Jason Seward, Eber Cruttenden, Abm. and Jno. B. Chittenden, Ambrose Leete and son, Jonathan Bishop, Abm. Fowler and son, Henry E. Hodges, Joel Davis 2nd, Miner Fowler and son, Andrew Norton, each $100.
The preamble to the subscription paper states that " the Meeting house in the first ecclesiastical society in Guilford has been built 115 years & has become much decayed & is far from being comfortable in consequence of its shattered condition " and that " our fathers, within 70 years from the first settlement of the Town, with much less means than we possess, with a spirit that did them much honor, erected the present house, which they determined should be and which was inferior to none in the State," and that the subscribers have set down their names for the sums they will give, " feeling desirous of handing down to our posterity that form of religious worship which has been transmitted to us from our ancestors & believing that, in the course of Divine Providence, the time has arrived & the duty cast upon us to l)uil(I a house for the worship of the Lord."
" The proposition was that those, who would subscribe, should have libtTty to bid off slips in the house, when built, to the amount of their subscription, and that all other members of the Society should have the same liberty. After the above-named sum was raised it seemed difficult to obtain any more money in that way. Some very judicious members of the Society thought the old house would do a while longer and some objected to its being built by subscription & the slips owned by individuals, preferring to have it built by a tax and then seated by age as the old one had been. In this situation about 30 members of the Society became responsible for finishing the house and ran the risk of getting their pay out of the sale of the pews. At a meeting of the subscribers held November 28, 1828, it was voted to proceed to the building of the house & a Committee was chosen to superintend the building, make the contract, & to purchase the Lot Benton Place, to set the church on. They made a contract with Ira Atwater & Wilson Booth of New Haven to build it for $6500, and they purchased the Lot Benton Place, for $925. On the 5th of June, 1S29, the cornerstone was laid and an address made by the Revd. Mr. Button. The corner-stone contains a plate of copper, enclosed in lead, with the names of the Building Committee, the Master Builder, & the clergymen & Deacons of the parish. Also a wooden Box is deposited in the Corner-stone, containing the Records of the Church and some of the newspapers of the day, with some other publications."
On the loth day of June the raising of the meeting house was commenced and proceeded with much regularity till the i8th, when it was finished. The old town was divided into districts and each district came on its appointed day, and assisted the carpenters in the raising without expense. The ladies furnished a good supply of cake, which was carried daily on the ground. No accident occurred during the raising. On the 19th of May, A. D. 1830, the meeting house was dedicated and the next day the slips were offered for sale, in pursuance of the original intention. They sold for more than enough to pay the expenses of the house and a great degree of harmony and unanimity prevailed, the society, almost to a man coming forward and bidding for such slips as suited them best.
The edifice is large, beautiful, and convenient. It is built of wood, is 80 feet in length by 60 in width, with a projection of six feet in front, and cost $7,400. Horse sheds were built in the rear of the meeting house in 1830.
" After the erection of the new house the pews were held as private property by the original purchasers, and their heirs and assigns, and the expenses of public worship, as had always been the custom, were provided for by a tax on the list in the same manner as the expenses of the town. This tax, in 1828, was five cents on the dollar of the assessment list (which was 3 per cent of the property valuation) in
1849, the last year in which a tax was laid it was twelve cents on the dollar. In 1850 the members of the society owning pews gave them to the society by a joint deed, and the pews that were owned by members of other societies, or by persons who had moved away, were purchased at about one-half the original cost. After this the society proceeded to make provision for the support of public worship by the annual renting of the pews, which is the method adopted at the present time." The parsonage was erected in the pastorate of Rev. Mr. Wickes. "The meeting house remained substantially unchanged until 1861, when extensive alterations were made and the whole structure was improved and modernized. The pulpit and galleries were lowered, the pews made more comfortable, the walls frescoed, and the lecture room was enlarged." In 1891 the lecture room was repaired at a cost of $300 and was made much more attractive. In 1868 a superb organ was generously presented to the society by Mrs. Mary G. Chittenden, and in 1893 Miss Anna Chittenden gave an electric clock which is placed in the steeple.
Until the East Guilford Society was set ofif in 1703, during the elder iMr. Ruggles' pastorship, the First Society was co-extensive with the town and the history of it has accordingly been given with the early history of the town itself. On the town records the " Old Society " is first spoken of, in distinction from the town, December 16, 1712, and the Society records were not kept in a distinct book until January 2, 1716-17.
How the various societies and churches were set off from time to time will be found described under each particular organization, and here it is intended to give merely a sketch of the internal affairs of the First Church and Society, and of its pastors. The trials and commotions, which were caused by the settlement of Rev. Thomas Ruggles, Jr.,' are told in connection with the rise of the Fourth Society. Mr. Ruggles was granted a salary' of £100 a year and £400 for his settlement, of which latter sum i8o was voted on December 30, 1729.
'June 10, 1729, he writes to Rev. Thos. Prince: "The great earthquake of Oct. 30 was much the same at Guilford as it was elsewhere. The houses and buildings shook in an awful and awakening manner." Conn. Hist. Soc. Colls. III. 287.
' The depreciation of the old tenor money is clearly shown by the fact that the clergyman's salary cjf £600 therein, in 1754, became only £50 " Proclamation Money " in the next year.
for on June 29, 1733, Daniel Bishop, Jr., and Joseph Hodgkin, Jr., were appointed to " tune the Psalm." The old practice of lining out the words was discountenanced by a vote of December 20, 1748, " that it is the desire of the Society that (after three months) singing Psalms in the Public worship shall be performed without any more reading than what the minister reads, if it be agreeable to Mr. Ruggles,' ye minister."
Rev. Mr. Ruggles' was the elder son and fourth child of Rev. Thomas Ruggles, Sr., and his first wife, Sarah Fiske, and was born at Guilford, November 27, 1704. He graduated at Yale in 1723 and studied theology with an unknown preceptor, probably his father. He was a successful pastor of the First Society, after the Fourth Society had been set off, and was a Fellow of Yale College from September, 1746, until his death, which occurred in Guilford on November 20, 1770.
His powers, like his father's, failed early, a colleague pastor was settled in 1757, and the latter part of his life was attended with much distress. He married Rebecca, eldest daughter of Rev. John Hart of East Guilford, and had two daughters. His funeral sermon was delivered on the next Lord's Day after his death by Rev. Jonathan Todd, A. M., of East Guilford, on "Judgment and Mercy; or Aaron dead and Eleazer in his office," from Numbers xx. 28, 29. Mr. Todd speaks of him as a man of sound understanding, a solid judgment, a penetrating genius, a very strong and tenacious memory. " His attainments in valuable and useful learning were very considerable. The metaphysical and unintelligible jargon of the schools he always disliked. But true philosophy he loved and was well acquainted with the principles thereof. Divinity was the chosen study to which he chiefly applied himself. . . . He was a judicious, orthodox divine. He was a plain, instructive preacher. His study was not rhetoric, and the enticing words of man's wisdom. Nor was he happy in his elocution. But his preaching- was solid and weighty, practical and serious. He was of a cautious temper; an able counselor; grave but affable, pleasant and facetious in his converse; he loved peace, was noted for his hospitality in his house; was a lover of good men, and a friend to mankind." He sided with the " Old Light " party in theology, though Mr. Todd emphatically claims him as " a friend to free enquiry, no bigot to his own persuasions." The epithet which he pre-eminently applies to Mr. Ruggles is " prudent." *
Dr. Trumbull gives a less favorable picture. " Mr. Ruggles was a scholar and a wise man; his morals were not impeachable, but he was a dull, unanimating preacher; had a great talent at hiding his real sentiments, never coming fully out, either as to doctrinal or experimental religion."
He published i. " The Usefulness and Expedience of Souldiers. . . . A Sermon (from Luke iii. 14), Preached to an Artillery Company at Guilford, May 25, 1736. On the Day of their first Choosing Their Officers." N. London, 1737.
2. " The Right Improvement of Life and its Advantages Discovered and Enforced. A Sermon (on Eccl. xii. 5), Preached at Guilford December 15, 1745." N. London, 1747.
3. " Ministerial Faithfulness Considered and Described and the Re^ wards thereof Asserted." Rev. Samuel Russell's funeral sermon. N^ London, 1747.
5. Having devoted much attention to local history he left in manuscript a History of Guilford to 1769, printed in Massachusetts Historical Society Collections, Series I, vol. IV, pp. 182-188, & vol. X, pp. 92-101, and in vol. 5 of the 2nd series of the Historical Magazine (April, 1869), pp. 225-233.
During Mr. Ruggles' ministry, in October, 1741, the general assembly ' called a general consociation of three ministers and three messengers from each consociation to meet at Guilford on November 24. to consider the " unhappy misunderstanding and divisions existing in this Colony." Col. Sanmel Hill provided for their entertainment, and was paid £32.11.3 therefor' in May, 1742. The proceedings of the consociation are lost, but it was doubtless called to consider the theological troubles and, as a result of its deliberations, in the next May the general assembly passed strict laws against unlicensed preachers.
Twenty-five years later, on the 3d Tuesday of June, 1766, at the meeting of the General Association of the Ministers in the Colony of Connecticut,' at Guilford, in the house of the Rev. Mr. Ruggles, the preliminary steps were taken for forming the " Plan of Union between the Congregational and Presbyterian churches."
and was the son of Daniel Fowler and Grace Barron. He graduated at Yale in 1753 and, after studying theology, preached for some months in 1756 in New Britain. He was called by the First Society of Guilford, August 17, 1756, to preach on probation till December, " in order for settlement as a Colleague with ye Revd. Mr. Ruggles." He proved satisfactory and on December i the Society offered him a settlement of £150, to be paid in three yearly installments, if he would become Mr. Ruggles' colleague. For salary they voted ipo, to be divided by the two ministers, " as they shall agree." On the 29th the Society voted a salary of £30 to Mr. Ruggles and of £50 to Mr. Fowler. Mr. Fowler did not at once agree to come and, on January 26, 1757, the Society promised him that on Mr. Ruggles' resignation or death he should have £80. This arrangement was satisfactory and Rev. Mr. Fowler and Rev. Mr. Ely of North Bristol were ordained in the meeting house on June 8. 1757. During Mr. Fowlers ministry the Society voted, on December 2, 1767, "that for the future Dr. Watts' Version of Psalms may be sung one half of the time in Public Worship," and on December 17, 1770, they were entirely substituted for the old version.
When Mr. Fowler grew old the Society \oted, on August 16, 1797, to " employ some young man, who is a candidate for the ministry, that shall be agreeable to our Rev'd Pastor, to assist him in the work of the ministry." A committee appointed to hire " some respectable young man," procured Mr. Erastus Ripley (Y. C., 1795), who proved so satisfactory that he was called as a probationer on November 7, and as a colleague pastor on January 29, 1798. The Society voted f 120 to the two clergymen, and promised Mr. Ripley a fixed salary of iioo at Mr. Fowler's death. They further agreed to give him a settlement of £300. There was some unknown objection in Mr. Ripley's mind to settling in Guilford; but, after twice raising the amount of his promised salary, the date for his ordination was fixed. Even then negotiations failed and on July 4, 1798, the Society voted to look for an assistant elsewhere. Mr. Zechariah Lewis (Y. C., 1794), and others were tried; but the people were set on having Mr. Ripley, and in 1799 gave him another call, which he declined as he did the first.
Mr. Asa Lyman (Y. C., 1797) was next tried, and on September 3, 1799, he was called as colleague pastor after delivering " his sentiments respecting baptism to the Society and having them approved " by it. He finally declined the call and the Society was at sea again.
On December 20, 1799, it was voted to apply to Tutor Henry Davis (Y. C., 1796) to supply ihc i)ul])it for a while. He probably declined, for on January 31, 1800, the Society voted to have Mr. Israel Brainerd supply the pulpit until May I. Just after that, on February 10, 1800,
Rev. Amos Fowler died, aged 72 years." At his funeral the Rev. Thomas Wells Bray, A. M., of North Guilford, preached the sermon on " The Dutv of Living- and Dying to the Lord," from Romans xiv. 8. The speaker had been a fellow-laborer for almost thirty-four years and spoke of Mr. Fowler, as " by nature of a placid, grave, patient and meek spirit, with amiable qualities, being greatly brightened by divine grace, rendered him eminent for constant serenity and uninterrupted calmness of temper under all trials. His whole deportment appeared to be most remote from pride, envy and ostentation. Such was his unaffected modesty and humility that his work appeared to much greater advantage to those who improved their acquaintance with him. He was amiable for his hospitality; his esteem of good men; his peaceable and friendly disposition to all. He was ever cautious of speaking evil of any man; and not only desirous of living peaceably with all, but possessed a wonderful talent of cooling down the wrath and violence of those whose passions were tumultuous. That wisdom which is from above seemed to be eminent in him, which is first pure, &c. He was ever cool and judicious in counsel - was a man of prayer; with plainness and pertinency adapting his expressions to every case on which he was called to speak. ]Mr. Fowler was a constant father to the people of his charge, manifesting a readiness in season and out of season to spend and be spent for them, to live and die with them." Another sermon was delivered on the occasion of Mr. Fowlers death by Dr. John Elliott of East Guilford on 2 Kings ii. 14, " Where is the Lord God of Elijah," in w^hich Elliott says Rev. Mr. Fowler " read with care the primitive fathers, but his system of faith was founded on the Bible."
Mr. Fowler published (i) A sermon delivered at Rev. Jonathan Todd's funeral. (2) A sermon preached at the ordination of the Rev. Timothy Stone, at Goshen, in 1767.
Mr. Fowler married, April 12, 1763, widow Sarah (Adams) Hill, a sister of Mrs. Ruggles. She died June 30, 1789, aged 63. He married again Lucy Evarts, July 2, 1790. She died November 7, 1806, aged 65.
After Mr. Fowler's death on April 21, 1800, the Society resolved to treat with Mr. Israel Brainerd respecting his settlement w'ith us " and to let iiim choose either to have his support all in Sailer)- or part in Settlement." They also voted him a settlement of £250 and a salary of £120. He accepted the call, and on May 14 arrangements were made for the ordination,' which took place on June 11. Mr. Brainerd, for
' Toward the end of his life, it is said that he gave up the half-way covenant, and some parishioners, displeased that he would no longer baptize their children on that basis, joined the Episcopal Church.
some reason, did not prove acceptable, and on December 3, 1805, the Society appointed a committee to treat with him " on the Uneasiness, that exists in the Society and hkewise to treat upon terms of Reconcihation." On December 31, reconcihation having failed, another committee was appointed to treat with Mr. Brainerd " with regard toa separation from this Society as their minister." The church seems, not to have been so much opposed to him as was the Society; on January 14 the latter body requested the church to meet and appoint a committee to unite with the Society's committee just mentioned, and on February 6, 1806, the Society resolved to call an advisory council in regard to ]\Ir. Brainerd's dismissal. On March 11, at another meeting, the Society asked the church that its committee might have an equal voice with the church committee in naming the council. This, would further tend to show that the church was not so bitter against Mr. Brainerd. The Society voted to " comply with the first proposal of Mr. Brainerd, viz: That the Society shall bring forward all the charges, or matters of Grievance, which they have against their minister, together with a true state of the Society, in every particular, at least 10 days before the sitting of the Council, that the Ministermay have time to make his defence.'' On May 12 Mr. Brainerd, in answer to queries from the Society, said: " I have always stood ready to take a dismission from the Society, whenever the request should be made in the Gospel way, viz: by the voice of the Church and Society," and that he would expect compensation for damages, the amount of which might be determined by referees from the Governor's. Council or the Judges of the Superior Court. The Society then resolved to ask the church to unite with it in calling a council, dismissing Mr. Brainerd and allowing Mr. Brainerd to keep his settlement. As to the amount of " damages " discussion ran high. The Society first demanded that Mr. Brainerd should name his amount; then voted $200; then rescinded that, and finally offered $300, which he accepted. The Society also voted " that it is the desire of this Society, that a man be settled in the Gospel ministry over this people, that shall adhere to the doctrine of faith rec'd & held in this Church," which we infer Mr. Brainerd' did not. He was dismissed on June 11, 1806, and on September 29 the Society voted that it was " well pleased with the past ministerial services of Mr. Aaron Dutton," that he be requested tO' stay for a month, and that it concurred " with the doings of the Church in inviting & calling Mr. Aaron Dutton, to accept the pastoral oi^ce in and over this Church and Society."
Rev. Air. Brainerd was born in 1772, made a profession of religion at the age of sixteen, and graduated creditably at Yale in the class of 1797, which contained such men as Dr. Lyman Beecher, Dr. James Murdock, and Judge Henry Baldwin. He taught a year at Albany, then pursued theological studies with Dr. Chas. Backus of Somers, and was licensed to preach in October, 1799. The writer of this obituar\-, in a Presbyterian paper, says that during his ministry here gross errors had crept into the church, and that, although the influential part of his " cried for smooth things," his faith in the fundamental doctrines of grace was so strong, and his sense of personal responsibility to the great Head of the Church was so vivid, that he was unable to yield to their wishes; but, on the other hand, was earnest and bold to declare the whole counsel of God, whether men would hear or forbear. After his dismissal from Guilford he was commissioned by the Connecticut Home Missionary Society as a missionary to Oneida County, N. Y., and was subsequently settled in Verona, where he remained pastor for thirty years. After closing his pastoral labors in Verona, "he served " the Church as a missionary, an agent, or as a colporteur, till the last week of his life." He died in Syracuse on the 5th of September, 1852.
Rev. Aaron Dntton^ the ninth and youngest child of Deacon Thomas and Anna (Rice) Dutton, was born at Watertown, Conn., on May 21, 1780. He prepared for college w^ith the Rev. Azel Backus of Bethlem and graduated from Yale in 1803. He also received from the college the degree of A. M., but declined that of D. D., as contrary to the divine injunction in Matt, xxiii. 8. In 1825 he was elected a member of the Corporation of the College, and took part in its management until his death. He made a profession of religion and connected himself with the college church in 1802. After graduation he studied theology with President Dwight and was ordained in Guilford, December 10, 1806, Rev. Mr. Backus preaching the sermon^ at that occasion.
On October 6, 1806, the Society voted him a salary of $600. and on this he reared a family of eight children. He married Miss Dorcas Southmayd of Watertown, shortly before his settlement in Guilford.
In 1 8 16 the Sunday school in connection with the First Church was instituted by Col. Wm. Hart and others. It was reorganized in 1826 and has had a continuous and successful existence since that time. It is in all probability the oldest Sunday school in the limits of the original town. During Mr. Dutton's ministry, tlio Fourth Society gave up the ghost and the present meeting-house was built. As a preacher he was plain and practical, not eloquent nor displaying the graces of oratory, but forcible and pointed in his sermons, and had the high satisfaction of knowing that his labors were not in vain. More than 600 persons made a profession of religion during his ministry/ and the church, which numbered less than 30 when he came, had increased to 400 when he left. " He was kind and attentive in the visitation of the sick, making daily visits in cases of dangerous sickness. He was active and efificient in promoting the cause of education; notwithstanding he was personally engaged in teaching a school for the higher branches, he acted as school visitor almost every year, and was able to state from personal knowledge who were efificient as teachers and successful as scholars."
In the latter part of Mr. Button's ministry dissatisfaction with him sprung up, partly owing to his having taken a decided position as an " abolitionist."' At first only a minority opposed him, and they made no public move until November 11, 1839. Their number gradually increased, until the dissatisfied party had a majority in the Society, though not for some time in the church. The course of both parties seems to have been marked with great firmness and no little acerbity, and in February, 1842, the dissatisfied party asked to be dismissed, as a new church, to be called the " Whitfield Church." This request was refused, and a council held April 20, 1842, decided against the dissatisfied party. But the situation had become too strained for Mr. Button to remain, and he was dismissed on June 8, 1842.
On October 6, 1842, the church called Rev. Frederic T. Perkins (Y. C. 1839), who declined to come, and May 24, 1843, Rev. E. Edwin Hall, who also declined.
Meanwhile the slavery question and the troubles occasioned by Mr. Button's departure occasioned great difficulty, which was increased by a vote of the Society, on March 27, 1843, refusing to let the meetinghouse be used for the meetings of the local Anti-Slavery Society.
Mr. Button was voted an indemnity of $1,200 at his departure and there was some difificulty in the collection of that sum. In despair of smoothing the troubled waters, another council was called and met on September 19, 1843. Its labors were not successful, and on November 23, 1843, the Abolitionists and Mr. Button's friends were dismissed to form the Third Congregational Church.
the service of the American Home Missionary Society; there he was gratefully welcomed and was called to become pastor of the church in Burlington. In August, 1843, he returned to New England to make preparations for moving westward; but was attacked with sickness, from which his recovery was long doubtful. He recovered somewhat and preached a few times, but his last years were years of great infirmity. In June, 1849, he became worse and died in New Haven, at his daughter's residence. He is buried in Guilford. Dr. Leonard Bacon, who preached his funeral sermon, thus speaks of him: " Few men in his day were more respected, than he, among the churches of his neighborhood, or among the ministers throughout the State. He was eminently without pretence or affectation of professional dignity and gravity - he was constitutionally and by habit cheerful and even mirthful; and yet there was no lack of gravity or true dignity in his deportment. His manner in the pulpit was solemn and earnest, rather than vehement; and those who saw him in social intercourse always felt that, with all his pleasant good humor, he was a thoroughly serious and earnest man, a Christian gentleman. He had no ambition to shine or excel; as a preacher he did not cultivate the art of making great sermons, but his discourses, so far as I had any knowledge of them, were always full of weighty thought, clearly expressed. His great business was to do good in old Guilford; and he did good by preaching, by teaching, by talking, by all sorts of personal influence, as long as he lived there."
Mr. Dutton was a contributor to various periodicals, among which was the Christian Spectator. He published (i) A Sermon at the Ordination of Rev. Thomas Ruggles at Derby, 1809; (2) a Sermon delivered before the Connecticut Society for the Promotion of Good Morals, October 18, 1815.
On July 30, 1843, a second call was extended to Rev. Eli Edwin Hall, which he accepted, and he was ordained as pastor on October 25, 1843. He was born in Blandford, Mass., April 11, 1814. went west in 1832, graduated at Illinois College in 1838 and at the Yale Divinity School in 184 1. He continued pastor at Guilford until July 24, 1855, when, wishing to visit Europe, he was dismissed at his own request. He edited the New Englander, 1855-6. and was chaplain of the American Church at Rome, Italy, from 1856 to 1859. From 1859 to 1861 he lived in Guilford in retirement, and then going to Europe became superintendent of the missions in Italy of the American and Foreign Christian Union, and Chaplain of the American Church at Florence.
Italy, from 1861 to 1866. He supplied the pulpit of the ist Church in Guilford from 1866 to 1869, and represented the town in the Legislature in 1868. After leaving Guilford the second time he preached for some time at Mt. Carmel, then studied law, and graduated from the Yale Law School in 1874. In 1870 he removed to New Haven, having his residence in the borough of Fair Haven East. During a trip to Europe in 1850 he married, on August 29, at Geneva, Switzerland, Cecile, a daughter of the distinguished clergyman Rev. Cesar H. A. Malan. He never practiced law, owing to a severe injury he received in a railway accident shortly after his admission to the bar. After a year or more of greatly broken health he died in May 2, 1896, having just entered his 83d year. He was buried at Guilford in Alderbrook Cemetery, where, at his request, his funeral discourse was pronounced by Rev. Geo. W. Banks of the Third Church. Mr. Banks spoke of him as " a thorough scholar, a good theologian and an accomplished Christian gentleman."
Rev. Henry M. Wickes, born February 11, 182 1, at Jamaica, N. Y., and a graduate of Marietta College in 1848, was settled as pastor on May 22, 1856, and after a pastorate of two years was dismissed July 21, 1858, by mutual consent. He graduated from the Yale Divinity School in 1851, was ordained at Princeton, Mass., June 18, 1852, and continued there as pastor until September 4, 1855. After leaving Guilford he was pastor of the church at Deep River from December i, 1858, to October 31, 1869. He supplied the pulpit at Brighton, N. Y., from 1869 to 1874; at Gates. N. Y., from 1875 to 1877; at Alden, N. Y., from 1877 to 1881; and at Corfu, N. Y., from 1881 to 1884. He resides now at Rochester, N. Y.
Rev. William Spooncr Smith, born July 10, 1821, at Leverett, Mass., a graduate of Amherst College in 1848, was next settled over the church as pastor, May 3, 1859; but after continuing in that relation for more than six years, vvas dismissed July 3, 1865, on account of ill-health. Mr. Smith has never had another charge, but resides at Auburndale, Mass. His ministry in Guilford was eminently successful.
The church remained without a settled pastor for nearly five years after Mr. Smith's resignation, during a part of which time Rci'. E. Edzvin Hall acted as stated supply from September, t866, to August, 1869. On April 12, 1868, by a majority of one the church voted not to settle him as a pastor. The Society, however, on May 17, 1868, voted to hire him for three years. It was claimed by the opposition that this vote was passed by the votes of persons present at the meeting who were not members of the Society. The Society on November 23. 1868, declared tliat that vote being taken in a(i\aiicc of action by the church was void and that Mr. Hall's relations with the church should cease in December. Mr. Hall refused to go and nothing was done for some months. A church meeting was finally held on June 13, 1869, when the church again voted not to call Rev. Mr. Hall. He now concluded to leave Guilford and preached a farewell sermon on August 29, 1869, in which he bitterly denounced all who opposed him. Finally Rev. Cornelius Ladd Kitchel, born July 5, 1841, at Thomaston, Conn., a graduate of Yale College in 1862, and of the Yale Divinity School in 1867, and a tutor at Yale in 1865, was settled as pastor, April 13, 1870, and remained until his resignation and dismission on account of his wife's ill health, March 24, 1873. He has since been a banker at Altoona, Penn. (1874-77), pastor at Salisbury, Conn. (1878-86), and Instructor in Greek at Yale, which last position he still holds. He is a descendant of Mr. Robert Kitchel, one of the first settlers of the town.
Rev. Theodore Lansing Day, born September 18, 1845, ^^ Boston, Mass.. a graduate of Yale College in 1867, and of the Yale Divinity School in 1871, was then engaged as a stated supply, from November, 1874, remaining as such until February, 1877. He was tutor at Yale, 1869 to 1872, and pastor at Holyoke, Mass., 1872 to 1874. He suffered from mental trouble, at the time of his leaving Guilford, and traveled in the South for his health. That being restored, he took charge of churches at Talcottville, Conn. (1879 to 1883) and Framingham. Mass. (1883 to 1884); but finally his old trouble returned, all work had to be given up, and he died in Worcester, Mass., June 27, 1885. He married, May 13, 1873, Miss Nettie T. Eastman of New Haven. He was a preacher of great ability.
Rev. Henry Orton Finch, born June 7, 1853, at Keeseville, N. Y., a graduate of the University of Vermont in 1874, and of the Yale Divinity School in 1878, was next called, and after preaching a year as stated supply, was soon to be ordained, when he was drowned at Sachem's Head, on August 27, 1879. O^ h'wa, as of his Master, it might be said, " He went about doing good." His sunny face and winning ways made him beloved by all, while the intense earnestness witli which he preached and labored to bring Christ's kingdom to pass was most impressive. He worked much among those not always approached by Christ's messengers, and his remembrance, like that of the just, is blessed. He is the only minister who has died in the service of the church since Rev. Amos Fowler.
RnK Prank Hudson Taylor, born November 14. 1855. at Oberlin. Ohio, a graduate of Oberlin I'niversity in 1874, and a class-mate of Rev. Mr. Finch in the Yale Divinitv School, was ordained here, Marcli
10, 1880. Previously he had supplied the church in Stony Creek. He was dismissed September 3, 1883, and in the following November became acting pastor of the Plymouth Congregational Church, Seattle, Washington Territory. While hunting, July 18, 1884, he accidentally shot himself in the shoulder and died two days later. On September I, 1880, he married Jessalyn Couch of Middlefield, and left t\vo sons. He was greatly mourned and seemed cut off in the midst of his usefulness. He was a man of rare maturity of intellect.
Rev. Edmund March Vittiim, born Oct.- 24, 1855, at North Sandwich, N. H., a graduate of Dartmouth College in 1878, Professor of Mathematics in Robert College, Constantinople, for several years, and a graduate of the Yale Divinity School in 1884, was ordained as pastor on June 5, 1884. During his pastorate the Young People's Society of Christian Endeavor was organized. He was dismissed at his own request on December 15, 1888, and became pastor at Cedar Rapids, Iowa, whence he was called to the Congregational Church at Grinnell, Iowa. His ministry was very successful and his sermons were exceedingly eloquent. He married. May 16, 1889, Annie Linsley, daughter of Capt. Chas. Griswold of Guilford. He is the author of several books, one of them being a collection of sermons delivered at Guilford.
Rev. Charles H. Mcintosh was born in Canada and was a student at Victoria College, Coburg, and McGill University, Montreal, but did not graduate. He was stated supply for a year from the spring of 1889. Before coming to Guilford he was in the employ of the American Missionary Association. He was originally trained for the Methodist ministry. Since leaving Guilford he has had charge of churches in Plantsville, Ct., Port Chester, N. Y., and Windsor and River Falls, Wisconsin.
The Rev. Frederick Elkanah Snow (Y. C. 1875), a class-mate of Rev. Messrs. Finch and Taylor in the Yale Divinity School, became acting pastor on March i, 1891. On June 2, 1893, the church celebrated its Quarto-Millennial with appropriate exercises, consisting of an historical sermon by the pastor and sketches of the pastors' since 1840, by the Pastor, Deacons J. W. Norton and E. W. Leete and Mr. Bernard C. Steiner. A pamphlet was published containing the addresses then delivered. Mr. Snow was born at Waterbury, Ct., March 10, 1851, and was ordained at Oxford, Ct., April 21, 1880, where he continued pastor until July 30, 1883. He was pastor at South Windsor from September 12, 1883. to November 19, 1888, and acting pastor at
Harwinton from 1888 to 1891. His ministry has been successful in the steady spiritual upbuilding of the church. Quite a revival occurred during the winter of 1894-95. Mr. Snow is the author of several graceful occasional poems, written to commemorate historic events. From 1895 to 1897 he published a church paper, the " First Church Re\new." In the fall of 1895 electric lights were introduced into the church.
'' The articles of faith or covenant originally adopted, w^hich were modeled on those of the Salem Church, were used in the church until 1837, when they were amended in only a few particulars, although some other prior unimportant alterations w^ere perhaps made by the Rev. Mr. Button. A public relation of experience was required in order to admission into the church until 1762, when a vote was passed by the church that they would not insist upon such a relation from those who should be indisposed to give it. Since then relations have been given generally in a private manner."
It has already been noticed that a large proportion of the first settlers of the town were professors of religion. Many of their descendants from generation to generation were doubtless of the same character, but as no records of the First Church exist of a date prior to January, 1747, it is impossible to state precisely how many belonged to this church before that period. There were then 172 members. From that period onward until the death of Mr. Fowler, 116 were added. Mr. Brainerd admitted 86 and Mr. Button about 600.'
In 1735 there was a revival in Guilford. In 1801 some special interest in religion prevailed, and during the two succeeding years more than 50 were added to the church. In the beginning of 1808 a revival prevailed and 119 were soon after admitted. In all, 150 persons united with the church by profession in the first three years of ]\Ir. Button's ministry. Another revival prevailed about the close of 1820 and the beginning of 1821, and 118 were added to the church soon after. In 1827, 35 were gathered into the church from a revival that occurred during that year, and from another revival in 1831 about 80. In 1834, 1840, 1852, 1862 and 1879 seasons of especial interest prevailed.
The following persons have entered the ministry from the First Church, viz.: Jared Eliot, Baniel Collins, Timothy Collins, Edmund Ward. Bela Hubbard. B. B. (P. E.), Samuel Johnson. B. B. (P. E.), Thomas Ruggles, William Seward, Timothy Stone, Andrew Fowler (P. E.), Thomas Ruggles, Jr., Joy H. Fairchild, William Leete, Jr.. Thomas Button, Edwin H. Seward. Theodore A. Leete, Beriah Hotchkin, John H. Fowler, Henry Robinson, Sherman Griswold
History Of The Plantation Of Menunkatuck
To this list should be added the names of the following ladies who have gone out as foreign missionaries: Clarissa Leete (Mrs. James C. Hepburn), to Japan; Lucretia Parker (Mrs. Henry S. Barnum), to Turkey; Elizabeth Starr (Mrs. J. H. De Forest), to Japan, and Florence Griswold, to Turkey.
Chapter Xliii
The people of North Guilford, having been incorporated as a Society by an act of Legislature passed in May, 1720, went forward and erected a house of worship in 1723. Their second house was built in 1814 and the Proprietors of the Common and Undivided Lands gave $26 towards it/ A neat and attractive chapel was built in the summer of 1888 during the pastorate of Rev. F. R. Kahler and largely through his persevering and energetic efforts. Rev. Ebenezer Rosseter of Guilford (Y. C. 1 71 8) was the first man called as pastor over this church, November 28, 1721, but declined the call.
Rev. Samuel Riissel (Y. C. 171 2) was the first pastor,^ beginning to preach there in 1722, and being called February 22, 1722-3 and April 2, 1723. He declined those calls; but accepted a later one and was ordained, when the church was formed, June 15, 1725. During the interval, Mr. Josiah Frisbie (Y. C. 1722) was invited, January 15, 1723-4, to preach three months as a candidate. Mr. Russel was the second son of Rev. Samuel Russel of Branford and Abigail Whiting, and was born at Branford, September 28, 1693. He studied theology with his father, and from 1714 to 1716 was tutor in the college at Saybrook. He preached in various places, and in 1719 was invited to succeed Rector Cutler at Stratford; but declined, on account of the large minority opposed to him. He married Dorothy Smithson of Guilford, and continued pastor at North Guilford until his death, January 19, 1745-6. Rev. Thomas Ruggles preached his funeral sermon. His estate was valued at upwards of £5,000, nearly one-fourth of it in books, showing he must have had a remarkable library for that day. He bore the character of a faithful and worthy minister of the Gospel and was much lamented. He published a sermon on " Man's liablcncss to be deceiv'd about Religion, Shewn and Cautioned against. Worldly Wisdom only seeming Wisdom, Religion true Wisdom," in 1742. The number admitted by him to the church
'Yale Biog. and Ann. I, 107; Spraguc's Annals, I, 261. Dec. 10, 1723, town granted £10 yearly to North Society until five years after they settle a minister.
is unknown. After Mr. Russel's death ^ division arose on the question of settling Mr. Elnathan Chauncey (Y. C. 1743), a son of Rev. Mr. Chauncey of Durham. The tradition is that " a majority feared that he was not sound in the faith and therefore voted against him, w^hereupon a minority who were strongly in favor of him seceded and formed an Episcopal Church." The Society Records, however, show that he was given a call on June 16, 1746, and declined it. After this the Society called Rev. Edward Dorr (Y. C. 1742) on March 17, 1747. He had been preaching as a probationer, but declined the call. The Society next, June 16, 1747, voted to appoint a committee " to go to the association to appoint a probationer to preach among us and, meanwhile, to hire Mr. John Hubbard (Y. C. 1744), or Mr. Samuel Fisk (Y. C. 1742) to preach 2 or 3 Sabbaths." Mr. Hubbard was probably satisfactory, for on August 17 they " voted to see further respecting " him, " notwithstanding his refusal to come as a probationer."
After appointing another committee to go to the Association for a probationer on October 27, the Society voted, December i, 1747, "to treat with " Mr. John Norton (Y. C. 1737) as such, and March i, 1748, they gave him a call. On April 5 and 21 they desire the Association to appoint a committee to come there respecting Mr. Norton's settlement; but, April 28, a committee was appointed " to supply the Pulpit, till the next Association," and. May 24, another committee to ask the Association " whether we proceed further towards the settlement of Mr. Norton." For some reason he did not come, and, June 6, they apply to the man they finally obtained as second pastor, the Rev. John Richards (Y. C. 1745), whom they then desired " to preach occasionally for some time." He was so satisfactory that on July 4 they requested him " to come as a probationer, under the advice of the Association," and on August 29 they gave him a call, with a settlement of $1,200 in three years, and £80 salary in wheat at 6s., Indian corn at 3s., rye at 3s. 8d., pork 4d., beef 2d., and the use of the parsonage. The third Wednesday in October was appointed a fast day, which Messrs. Ruggles and Todd of the ist and 2nd Churches were to conduct, and as Mr. Richards accepted the call, he was ordained on November 2 by a council.
Mr. Richards married ' in 1749, Dorothea Russel, the daughter of his predecessor, and was a successful pastor for many years, admitting 85 persons to the church, whose increase in so small a community from 20, the number when it was organized, to 70 in 43 years shows a good measure of religious prosperity. Mr. Richards finally left/ probably on account of trouble with Lt. IMichael Baldwin, father of an illustrious family, who " said the minister lied " and " reviled " him in other ways " with highhanded and scandalous defamation." The Association told him to apologize, which advice Rev. Amos Fowler seconded in a letter to Congregational Church of North Guilford, written August 22, 1765.' He would not do so and Mr. Richards determined to leave. So, at a Society's meeting, December 25, 1765, the decision was made that the " representation & request of the Rev*^ Mr. Richards be considered & decided by the Consociation ... of New Haven County now convened in this place ... & that they proceed according to what they find." Air. Richards' representation was " that, in his opinion, his usefullness in the public work of the ministry in this society is so at an End, that it is now necessary that he be dismissed &, therefore, do pray the consideration & decision of the Consociation hereupon." The majority favored Mr. Richards and were " willing and desirous that the Rev. Mr. Richards should continue in this place, if, upon inquiry into the matters submitted to the decision of the present Council, they find he may continue upon good & peaceable terms."
The Consociation dismissed him, however, on the same day at his request. Lieut. Baldwin was suspended from the church, and on September 26, 1766, in " An Appeal from Members of the Congregational Church of North Guilford to the Reverend Association Convened at New Haven," 17 complain against him and say " they can not receive him in good standing, till he apologize.'"'
Rev. John Richards was the son of Lt. Thomas Richards and Susanna Turner and was born in Waterbury, June 23, 1726. He studied theolog}' after graduation from Yale and was licensed to preach May 31, 1748. After his dismission from North Guilford he resided some time at Waterbury, where he had no charge. Then he removed to New Concord in the town of Chatham, New York, where he gathered a church and was installed its pastor, 1771, but was dismissed at the close of 1773. He removed about 1775 to Piermont, New Hampshire, where, on February 5, 1776, he was called as pastor of the Congregational Church there. In advanced life he was dismissed a third time and then retired to New Hampton, in the same
' Charges were made against ^fr. Richards of absorption in secular concerns to the neglect of the parochial duties and of harshness towards certain individuals in the church. Dexter, Yale Annals, II. 51. Hon. Simeon Baldwin described Lt. Baldwin as " a man of powerful but uncultivated mind."
State, where he died in 181 1, aged 85. Another account makes his death 181 4 in Piermont or in Weybridge, Addison County, Vermont.' After Mr. Richards left, the Society, March 3, 1766, empowered " the Committee to supply the pulpit with preaching for 2 months, Also to lease the Parsonage i year." No one was obtained as pastor, and, September 29, a committee was appointed to go to the New Haven County Association and ask what had best be done, '' under our destitute circumstances, to be resettled in the Gospel." On October 7 they voted to ask " the Committee of the Association to meet at North Guilford & assist in keeping a day of fasting and to advise us to some proper candidate to improve upon probation, in order to settlement." The committee met and advised them to employ Rev. Thomas Wells Bray (Y. C. 1765) as a probationer until the end of November. He had been preaching there since April. He was so pleasing that on November 24 they gave him " to the Gospel Ministry in this place " and voted to " give him, for his encouragement, ii8o L. M. for his settlement: viz. 6o£ for the 3 first years . . . and . . . £90 for his salary in specie & the use of the Parsonage, so long as he continues our settled minister." He accepted at once, and on December i the Society voted to have the 17th a day of fasting and the 31st the time for the ordination.
Rev. Mr. Bray' was born in Springfield, February 23, 1743. He spent most of his youth at Farmington, and after graduation studied theology. He continued pastor at North Guilford 42 years, until his death, April 23, t8o8, aged 69 years. He married Sarah, only child of Jonathan Robinson of Guilford, and had 8 children. He was a man of good judgment and exemplary piety; a plain, serious preacher. Fie admitted 152 members to communion, and 15 more were admitted in the interval between his death and the ordination of his successor. There were in almost every year of his pastorate additions to the church, and nearly always individuals in the congregation were under solemn religious impressions. During his pastorate, three or four families left the Congregational for the Episcopal Society, when he refused to baptize on the " half-way covenant plan." The same thing happened when Rev. Mr. Vaill, his successor, preached zealously on the doctrines of Divine Sovereignty and Election.
' He published a sermon occasioned by the dcatli of Abel Chittenden, student at Yale College and son of Simeon Chittenden of North Guilford, preached on Sept. 2, 1770. It is entitled " The knowledge of our end with the advantage and importance of it."
religion. The work continued, with increased power, after the settlement of Rev. Mr. Vaill. Then began also the era of social prayer meetino-s and benevolent contributions, and thenceforward the church has been blessed with pentacostal visits of the Divine Spirit, almost all who were added to it for sixty years after Rev. Mr. Bray's day having been converted in seasons of revival." ' Revivals occurred in 1808, 1820, 1827 and 1 83 1.
The Rro. William Fozvler Vaill, of East Haddam, was ordained pastor, December 21, 1808. He was a graduate (1806) of Yale College and fitted quite a number of young men for that institution. On April 20, 1820, he was invited to become a missionary to the Osage Indians at Union, in Arkansas Territory. He accepted the call and removed thither soon afterwards, remaining there until 1833, w^hen he returned to the East and preached in various parts of Connecticut. He was born in May, 1783, at Hadlyme, and died on February 24, 1865, at Wethersfield, 111. He studied theology with the Rev. Asahel Hooker of Goshen and was licensed to preach Sept. 15, 1807. During his ministry here and previous to the ordination of his successor, 34 persons were admitted to the church.
The Rez'. Zolva Whitmore was settled here September 5, 1821. He was bom at Rutland, Vt., and graduated at Union College in 1818.' Towards the close of his ministry here several persons, for " unfounded and frivolous " causes, took a dislike to him, absented themselves from church, and finally induced the Society to refuse to pay him his salary. For these causes he was dismissed, at his own request, August 31, 1846, in the twenty-fifth year of his ministry. He removed first to Great Barrington, Mass., thence to Vermont, where he was in charge of a church for two years, thence to North Becket and Chester Factory, Mass., where he died August 5, 1867.
In 1848 the Rev. John L. Ambler was acting pastor. He was not a college graduate and came to the Congregational ministry from that of the Methodist Church.
From January, 1849, to March, 185 1, the Rcz'. Henry Eddy (Y. C. 1832) was the acting pastor. He took the degree of Doctor of Medicine at Yale in 1851 and engaged in the practice of that profession in North Dridgewater, Mass. Later he became an inventor and farmer. He died .September 23, 1872. aged 67. He studied theology at Andovcr and Yale and was ordained in 1836. The failure of his voice caused him to leave the ministry.
The RezK Fosdic Harrison was the acting pastor from November, 185 1, to November, 1854. During his ministrations there was a revival in the summer of 1853 and 11 were added to the church by profession. He was not a college graduate. Deacon J. R. Rossiter writes that " his intelligence, sterling good sense and sincere piety rendered him a beloved and useful pastor."
The Rev. Abraham C. Baldzvin (A. M. Yale, 1843) acted as pastor from December 10, 1854, to October 28, 1855. During his service the church edifice was repaired and the interior entirely renewed at a cost of $1,100. He was the author of a number of sermons and sketches, among the latter, one of Joel Barlow, and of a prize essay, " Letters to a Christian Slaveholder," Boston, 1857. He was born at North Guilford, April 26, 1804, and graduated from Bowdoin College in 1827 and from the Yale Divinity School in 1830. He was ordained at Berlin, Mass., Sept. 16, 1830, and was pastor there until October 25, 1832. He was pastor of the Olivet Church, Springfield, Mass., from December 4, 1833, to January 8, 1839; was principal of a young ladies' seminary at Newburgh, N. Y., in 1839 and 1840; and was pastor of the Howe Street Church, New Haven, from January 27, 1842, to November, 1845. He was family guardian and steward at the American Asylum for the Deaf and Dumb at Hartford from 1847 to 1854, and then became pastor at North Guilford. From October 28, 1857, to September 24, i860, he was pastor at Durham, Conn.; from 1861 to 1866 he supplied the pulpit at Black Rock, Ct., and then resided without charge in Hartford and Yonkers, N. Y., where he died July 6, 1887.
The Rev. Thomas Dntton was the acting pastor from December 9, 1855, to May I, 1859. His ministrations were zealous and faithful, and 37 were added to the membership of the church, 24 of whom were the result of a revival during the spring and summer of 1858. He was a son of the Rev. Aaron Dutton and was born in Guilford, March 2, 1812. Graduating at Williams College, 1832, with high honors, he was tutor there 1836-7. In 1836 he graduated at the Yale Divinity School. From 1838-42 he was engaged in teaching and he resided in Mendon, III, from 1841 to 185 1. There he was ordained April ii, 1847. and continued as pastor until 1850. He supplied the pulpit at Ashford, Ct., from 1855 to 1866, and then resided in Durant, Iowa, until his death, March 8, 1885.
The Rev. Richard Crittenden (Oberlin College, 18 - ) acted as supply from July 16, 1859, was ordained pastor August i, i860, remained until April 17. 1864, and was dismissed September. 1864. He was active in the Sundav-school.
The Rev. William Hozcard acted as supply from August, 1864, was installed December 20, 1865, and dismissed September, 1875, removing to Xorthfield in Litchfield County. His ministry was exceedingly acceptable to his people and eminently successful. He is a native of England and began his ministry in the Methodist denomination. Deacon J. R. Rossiter writes of him: " Through all his life he has been a diligent student and has thus acquired an education of which a college graduate might well be proud."
Thf Rev. William Bronso-n Curtis (Y. C. 1840) was acting pastor from July, 1875, until November, 1877. He was born in Exeter, Otsego County, N. Y., June 5, 1812, and died in North Branford, June 7, 1888. He studied theology at Yale and was ordained August 27, 1843.
From Mr. Curtis's departure until April, 1879, the pulpit was occupied by Rev. James Clarkson Naughton Johnson, a graduate of Westminster College, Pa., in 1868 and of the Yale Divinity School in
In 1880 and 1881 the Rev. Charles Wesley Drake filled the pulpit. He was bom in Miamisburg, Ohio, August 18, 1840. He studied two years at the Yale Divinity School and was ordained as an evangelist at South Windsor, November 23, 1871. He supplied the pulpit there until 1873, was at Angola, N. Y., from 1874-79; at the Cheltenham Church, St. Louis, Mo., 1882-84; at Millville, N. Y., 1884-87; and at Bridge water, N. Y., 1888 - .
The Rev. Frank Roland Kahlcr (B. A. Pennsylvania College, 1881) was ordained pastor here on June 17, 1886. He was born at Millersburg. Penn., October 16, 1857, and graduated from the Yale Divinity School in 1886. He was dismissed, after a very successful ministry, on December 5, 1888, and took charge of the Congregational Church in Southington, Conn. Towards the close of 1889, sulTering from nervous prostration, he went to friends in Pennsylvania for rest. There his mind gave way and he committed suicide at Allentown, February 24, 1890. He was a clear and forcible preacher and a man of more than ordinary ability.
The Rev. Henry Chapman McKniglit (Y. C. 1882; Y. D. S. 1885) was installed pastor early in 1889. He resigned in 1892 to accept a pastorate in Sherman, Ct. He was born at Enfield, Ct., j\Iarch 13, 1859, and was ordained at Falmouth, Me.. October 7, 1885, where he continued as pastor until September 3, 1888.
Rez'. Harry Elmer Small succeeded Rev. Mr. McKnight and continued as pastor until January, 1895. He is a native of Machias, Maine, and a graduate of Amherst College in 1890 and of the Yale Divinity School in 1893.
The members of the society have a fund for the support of the Gospel, derived from the sale of lands given by the Proprietors of the Common and Undivided Land. The income of the fund is now reported to be somewhat over $300.
The following ministers have been raised up by this church: Nathaniel Bartlett, Amos Fowler, Daniel Collins, Aaron C. Collins, Augustus C. Collins, Jared Tyler, Abraham C. Baldwin, John E. Bray, and Stephen A. Loper.
Chapter Xliv
The Rev. Thomas Ruggles, St., died June i, 1728, and on the 26th of the month the ist Society voted to have a " day of humiliation and prayer, kept on Wednesday next, to invite several neighboring ministers to assist in the services of the ' day of humiliation,' and to advise in the calling of a Minister," and that Capt. Andrew Ward, Mr. Caleb Leete, Joseph Stone, Capt. Thos. Hall, Mr. Jas. Hooker and Mr. Daniel Bartlett be a committee to supply the pulpit during the vacancy and to represent the Society in seeking advice from the above-mentioned ministers.
On July 3d the day of fasting was held and the ministers present were asked for " advice, about calling one as a probationer for settlement, if approved upon trial made." " After some animadversion," wrote Rev. Messrs. Moss and Thatcher of Saybrook, two years later, " upon the suddenness of the motion - it being so soon after the death of their former pastor & receiving their justifying replies upon it, they had advice to this purpose, viz: To apply to Mr. Thomas Ruggles Jun'r. ... to supply his father's pulpit, as a probationer for settlement in the work of the ministry, if after tryal, he were approved and could be settled there, with a general view of peace and according to gospel order and rule, and if, after trial made, he should not suit them or they him, then to apply to Mr. Benj'n Pierpont of New Haven (Y. C. 1726) as a probationer," and, if he should not suit, to ask for further advice. A week later the Society voted to take the ministers' advice and hire Mr. Ruggles for three months. " At first the opposition and uneasy party to his settlement were about 12, but they were very considerable men, chief men in the Town and church." Mr. Ruggles' preaching was, however, acceptable to the majority, so the Society voted, on October 29, to " further improve " him " in the work of the ministry, in order to his being further settled." Throughout the winter the same feeling prevailed, though the dissatisfied party grew, and on February 4, 1728-9, the Society voted to pay him £40 for preaching " since iiis father's decease " and to have on the next Wednesday a " day of fasting and prayer," in which Revs. Messrs. Whittlesey of Wallingford and Russel of Middletown should be asked to take part.
The day of fasting and prayer did not bring harmony, and on February 13 the following petition, with forty-tw^o signers, was presented to the Society: "We the subscribers humbly Petition the Society that we may have a dismission from this Society, in order to the setting up the ministry among ourselves." To this petition the Society granted assent at once, " provided that the Petitioners continue to pay all Society rates, till that year in which the General Court shall grant them liberty to be a society by themselves." The Society also voted, almost in defiance of so numerous a petition and one formidable, not only from the number of signers, but also because it bore the influence of the powerful families of Leete and Ward, to " give Mr. Thos. Ruggles for his yearly salary iioo a year, to advance his salary, as his circumstances shall require it, so as to aliford him a comfortable maintenance, during the time he shall be our minister," and also to pay him £400 " for his settlement," in five equal yearly instalments.
On February 24 the committee appointed to notify Mr. Ruggles reported " That, in God's time and way, he was willing to be settled amongst us," and the Society, accepting this reply, voted to keep the second Wednesday in March as a " day of fasting and prayer, preparatory for the ordination of our minister," in which service of fasting and prayer Rev. Messrs. Chauncey of Durham and Russel of North Guilford were requested to assist. The Society further appointed Mr. James Hooker, Capt. Thos. Hall, Mr. Wm. Stone, Sr., and Capt. Jno. Seward a committee to invite to the ordination, which w^as to be held on the 26th of March, 1729, the ministers who advised hearing Mr. Ruggles, and in addition, four other clergymen with " a messenger or messengers from each of their several churches."
Rev. Messrs. Moss and. Mather say the " major " party, " having the advantage of the law on their side and fearing that advantage could not always be in their hands, pushed forward the ordination, with all violence, and refused to hear the entreaties of their uneasy brethren, to delay the matter awhile until (at least) the General Court could be applied to in this affair." After the vote of February 13 permitting the minority to be a distinct society, they " went no more nor acted with their brethren about settling Mr. Ruggles, either in society meetings, or church meetings, but acted by themselves, and got a young man to preach to them in a private house, viz. Mr. Edmund Ward, brought up at Yale College in New Haven (A. B. 1727), who had been examined by the ministers of the New Haven Association and had gained his recommendatory certificate from them, as a candidate for the ministry." This was probably largely the cause of the disaffection, that Capt. Andrew Ward and his friends were angry that young Mr.
Ruggles was preferred to his son Edmund. The ordination was about 10 months after Air. Thomas Ruggles Sr.'s death. Before the ceremony the council sent for those of the uneasy party who were in full communion, 29 in number, who declared that " they could not, in conscience, consent to his ordination at that time." Six of the 29, however, " declared they were not so much against the man, simply, but thought it unreasonable to ordain him then, when there was such a feud & contention arisen among them.'"' The whole number of church members was about 80, so about ^ opposed the ordination. The council debated whether to proceed with the ordination, and decided to do so by a vote of 7 out of 9 of the ministers, and a " small majority among the messengers." " The uneasy part separated themselves from their brethren and would not sit with them at meeting, in the time of ordination." Rev. Mr. Moss of Derby refused to assist in the ordination, which went on in due form. His refusal was, ist, because '" it seemed to him to have no likely prospect of future peace in the place, nor likely to be for the interest of religion, or the flourishing state of Christ's Kingdom for the future in that place"; and 2nd, because to settle a pastor over the ivhole church, " when above one-third of the church never chose him & declared that they . . . could not choose him as their pastor," seemed " to be setting up a Lord over God's heritage (at least in part) and . . . looked too much toward that prelatical tyranny, from which our fathers fled, . . . and a breaking in upon the natural liberty, which belongs to all churches and Christians."
After the ordination the minority sent a petition to the Legislature in May, the whole 42 members of the opposition in the Society signing it. Rev. Mr. Moss said the majority opposed the petition with all vehemency, but no trace of the opposition appears. Mr. Moss himself sent to the General Assembly, at the minority's request, a letter, dated Derby, April 16, 1729, stating that, " altho' I foresee many ill consequences, that possibly may attend such a liberty for separation; yet it seems to me that, under present circumstances, the peace of Guilford cannot be attained any other way." " I am afraid the blending together of such contending parties by coercive power, will prove a fatal mischief to the whole."
The petition stated that its signers, being about one-third of the Society and about the same portion of the church, " being dissatisfied with the man, whom our brethren chose for a minister, we could not be easy in our minds; but thought it our duty to oppose his settlement, at least for the present, and to persuade our brethren (whom we acknowledge to be the greater part of the society) to be moderate and low in proceeding to settle such a man, whom (tho' we honor him and do not despise his youth) yet (do) not think suitable . . . and we prayed our brethren to try some other person, at least for occasional preaching, ... It being . . . probable that we might get a man, that might suit us all, and so the smart contention arisen among us and like to increase further, would immediately cease; but this was denied us and our brethren would press forward for settlement & would not hear of any delays whatsoever, neither did call any council with authority to determine, in our broken and distressed circumstances, what was meet to be done, for healing and quieting the divisions that w-ere among us, therefore, since they had the law in their favor, because of their majority and we saw they would improve it to the utmost severity upon us, as to a present settlement, and we finding ourselves more and more uneasy with their proceedings, we thought it best, in this desperate case, ... to endeavor to become two Societies, as to our Ecclesiastical affairs, and, therefore, lovingly proposed to our brethren, met together in a Society meeting, and requested it of them to allows us to draw off and be a Society by ourselves . . . and our brethren fell in with and granted our request, with a full vote, provided this Hon. Assembly should . . . grant us this privilege of embodying into an Ecclesiastical Society and Church estate."
After discussion of this memorial, the Legislature, " observing that the Inhabitants of Guilford have lately been at great expense in raising a meeting house, which stands conveniently and has capacity to accommodate the whole Society, as it now is," thought " that the peace, religion, wealth, and good order of the inhabitants will be best promoted in their keeping together in one society, if the present misunderstanding can be removed, which good thing it is hoped may be obtained by Counsel." Therefore Rev. Messrs. Timothy Woodbridge, Eliphalet Adams, and Wm. Russell are appointed to go to Guilford, " hear, consider and advise both parties," " as they shall find there is reason in their case," " endeavor to effect an accommodation of the divisions " and " bring that people to unite themselves in love and peace in carrying on the worship of God in the house of prayer, they have built to his name." The council was to report to the Legislature at its next session and to advise what further action, if any, should be taken.
The first week in June, 1729, was assigned by this committee for a hearing, and accordingly, a meeting of the First Society was held May 28. At that time it was voted to pay the expenses of the council and to entertain its members, and a committee of 9 were appointed to represent the Society. When the council met, the disaffected party preferred the following charges against j\Ir. Ruggles, viz. : " I. That he was an imprudent man and a party man in his common discourse." To prove this, Mr. Caleb Leete and Lt. Cruttenden asserted that " at Mr. Ruggles' chamber," he said to them " Providence had called him, the law chosen him, he would not be talked out - he did not regard the talk more than a bumble bee - as for the opposite party he did not account himself bound in conscience to have any regard to them," and to Mr. Leete he said, " You talk like men without religion or conscience." Mr. Ruggles admitted this speech as far as the reference to the bumble bee, but denied uttering the rest, and Deacon Hall, the other witness to the conversation, supported him. His friends urged further " that, supposing he did say " all this, " the discourse was in his own chamber & but once in his whole Hfe & therefore does not prove him an imprudent man & a party man in his common discourse," the truth of which cannot be denied. H. The other charge was " That sometimes he doth preach and teach that which is false or untrue " :
(a) " That in a sermon he called the young people the crown & glory of the Congregation." Ruggles said he may have expressed himself near those terms but had no other design but to signify that the young people, being in their strength, were the flower or crown of the Congregation, not meaning to exalt them above the older ones."
(b) " That he said of Solomon, his wisdom was infinite, but Adam in his innocency was wiser than he." Mr. Ruggles justified his saying Solomon's wisdom was infinite by referring to Xahum iii. 9, " where the word infinite is figuratively used," and as to " Adam's being wiser than he," this " he justified by the opinion of Divines." (c) " Speaking of minister's duty, he said partiality in a minister was an unpardonable sin or guilt." He replied "in his notes it was written, partiality is a crime of unpardonable guilt in Ecclesiastical Rulers." The trivial and worthless character of these charges, which were all the - )pposition could trump up against him, is truly amusing. The council saw through their flimsiness and proposed: (i) "That the disaffected party do all of them accept & submit to the Reverend Mr. Ruggles as their minister"; (2) "That the Rev. Mr. Ruggles do accept the disaffected Brethren ... as a part of his flock and charge"; (3) "That the major part & the dissatisfied party shall receive one another as brethren."
Three other proposals relate to choosing another minister, probably as colleague pa.stor, to satisfy the minority. After much unavailing effort and time spent in endeavoring to bring about a reconciliation of the dissentient parts of the Society, and after a variety of plans pro- posed and debated, only eventually to be rejected, at the close of the week (June 6, 1729), the committees of the two parties in the Society received a communication from the council. This stated that the council agreed with the assembly, that the town would be better off in one society; that, on considering the charges against Mr. Ruggles, they find no sufficient grounds why the minority " should separate from Mr. Ruggles, or refuse to accept him as their minister and, there being a settlement actually made, tho' there may have been imcomfortable things, unsuitable heats and speeches among divers of the members of the society in this day of temptation; yet there appears nothing to us, but that they may, consistent with the rules of the gospel, forgive one another and bury all their controversies . . . and it is our advice and earnest exhortation that they so do."
The next day the Society, " the dissatisfied party absenting themselves," received from its committee their report and accepted the advice of the council. The minority took no present action; but, satisfied with nothing but separation, they again petitioned the Assembly, in October, 1729, to be made a separate society. While the matter was under discussion there, the ist Society, on October 20, appointed a committee of 7 to attend the General Assembly at New Haven and " signify " to it " that this society is very desirous of promoting the peace, religion, wealth & good order of the Society and, for that end, are willing to continue together in one society, under the minister ordained among us, which, if our dissatisfied brethren shall see cause to join with us in, we shall rejoice at it & shall show them the favor & respect due to Christian Brethren; but, if the dissatisfied party do not see cause to comply with this offer, we leave it to the wisdom of the Honorable Gen'l Assembly, whether it be best to continue together, or to dismiss the party . . . reserving to this society all their ancient privileges & immunities - those persons only excepted."
The Legislature, still "very desirous to put an end to said divisions, . . . that they might still continue one society," appointed a second council, consisting of the three ministers on the former one and in addition Rev. Messrs. Thomas Buckingham, Stephen Mix, Samuel Whitman, and Jonathan Marsh to endeavor " to put an end to the divisions and contentions in said Society, by uniting the spirits of those good people that now differ, and if they cannot cause union, " to report their opinion "' to the Assembly in May.
reference to a council appears to have been unsatisfactory to the dissenting party. They were opposed to the Saybrook platform as a law of the colony binding the consciences of men. They wished division at all hazards and would listen to nothing else. Neither does the appointment of the council seem to have been entirely satisfactory to the majority, as they had never come into the Saybrook plan of consociating the churches and chose rather to rest themselves with the Scriptures on their own articles and confession of faith than upon any platform, rule of faith, or conduct established by any council platform." ^ On December 30, 1729, the ist Society, however, made overtures to the minority, offering to bear the expenses of this council if " the dissatisfied party shall desire it, or comply with it."
Before that, on October 31, 1729, Mr. Joseph Moss of Derby WTote to 'Sir. Edmund Ward (I) that he thought " the uneasy party " ought to have been " set off ... a distinct society " by the General Assembly, and " if they keep on petitioning, they will surely attain it erelong." (II) That the minority in their memorial had " publicly declared their dissent from the established discipline & so have well prepared their way for taking the benefit of our law made for the ease of consciencious dissenters." (HI) That, if they, according to that law, " set upon ecclesiastical society & move to you for their preacher or teacher & you accept of it; yet I think you are safe & cannot be hurt by any Civil or Ecclesiastical Authority; any more than their scornfull & diminutive thoughts & speeches of you may hurt you; and of that sort of punishment or persecution . . . you may expect a very plentiful portion." (IV) That, if they " make conscience of the thing they have sought or moved for, viz: the bread of life in an edifying ministry, it is their duty, as well as prudence, to move forward in such an affair, though they have been so buffetted by some great men heretofore." The advice was taken, and on November 11, 1729, the New Haven County Court received a petition ' from the minority saying they " dissent from yt platform of discipline which is by law established " and declare themselves " of the congregational profession according to the practice of our fathers in the primitive times and, according to the platform compiled at Boston . . . in . . . 1649, which greatly differs from what is established by law^ in this Colony"; therefore they "humbly pray this honorable court to allow us the liberty & privilege of the aforesaid law." The petition has 48 signers,' including two women. Miss Eliz"' Fowler and Hannah Parmelee. There is a net gain of six, four men and two women. On November 6, 1729, "the uneasy party" voted to meet for divine service at Mr. Samuel Leete's house. The 1st Society apparently took no action in regard to the petition. The Court postponed action until April, and the minority began on January 4, 1729-30, to hold public meetings, with Mr. Edmund Ward as their " preacher." This caused a very great excitement and the ist Society, fearing lest it should be broken up by these proceedings, so manifestly against the colonial laws, applied ^ to Gov. Joseph Talcott for advice and also respecting a presentment of " the disorderly party by the Grand jurors of the Town." To this petition Gov. Talcott replied^ that he and Col. Matthew Allyn, Capt. Nath' Stanley, and Capt. Ozias Pitkin agree with the ist Society " that the right or wrong management of the affair you mention may have a good or a bad influence on the peace and good order of the churches in this Goverm't & . . . that, if the Grand jurors are cautious (conscientious?) that it is their duty to present said people upon the law you mention, that the presentment ought to be directly to the County Court ... & not to a single minister of Justice, . . . that the presentment be of the W'hole or a considerable number of them . . . And you, being scrupulous whether you, being of one party, your judgment will be so acceptable as some more indifferent person, . . . we look on it that your consideration is good, ... if only for the avoiding grounds of suspicion & clamor . . . And for me to direct others of the authority to join you in the tryal would be a further unreasonable enhanceing of the charge and therefore that which I do not incline to do." As a result of this, William Seward and Benjamin Fowler, Grand Jurors, on January 26, presented to the adjourned County Court (probably called for that purpose) 16 men and the wives of six of them, for their assembling each Sunday of the month " to attend and carry on the public worship of God," " which is contrary to the laws of this colony." Of these men, 13 are signers of both petitions, one of the second only, and one, John Bishop, here first appears, while one, Thomas Norton, is a signer of the first and not of the second petition. Just before this, on January 21, 1728-9, Rev. Messrs. Joseph Moss'' of Derby, Jacob Hemingway of East Haven, and Samuel Russel of Branford answered a letter of the minority written to them on the i8th. They say they can give no advice, unless they are on the spot, and, " therefore, we intend, God willing, to come to Guilford on Thursday next & to make an assay for making peace ... by such counsel & advice, as we would hope would tend to the tranquility & good of the church & Town of Guilford; not pretending to come with any authority for judicial determination of anv controversy among you, but only to do the good office of peacemakers . . . and we shall be very glad ... to see yourselves . . . and it will doubtless be very desirable & likely for a good issue for yourselves to join with your brethren (who differ in opinion from you . . .) in asking advice ... of those who . . . are sincerely desirous of promoting the peace & welfare of your whole society." Mr. Joseph Noyes of New Haven added a postscript, stating he thought of coming over with the others, as he was " much concerned for Guilford." There is no evidence as to whether this visit was made or not.
Provenance
Text from A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive. The settlements listed against this township are matched by point-in-polygon test of each Geographic Names Information System coordinate against the Census Bureau's county subdivision boundary, not by name.