Guilford Town (part 5 of 15)
Part 5 of 15 of the account of this town in A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897. 15,727 words, covering 8 settlements. Source changes inside the text are labelled at the exact paragraph where the next book begins.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter, on this part. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
15 pagesThe source prints this as one continuous account. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs straight on across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The chapter
15,727 wordsReproduced complete and unedited from A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897. The text is machine-read from scans, so expect recognition errors: misspelled names, dropped words, and stray characters. Nothing has been corrected, because correcting a proper name invents one. The headings below are the books' own; source changes are labelled in place.
" The first, chosen for that purpose, were probably Mr. Desborow, Mr. Leete, Mr. Mepham, and Mr. Hoadley. They may have continued until October, 1645, when Mr. Samuel Disborow was chosen Magistrate and Mr. Leete, Mr. Mepham, and Mr. Hoadley Deputies."
It is supposed that Mr. Desborough was not earlier chosen magistrate on account of his youth. Previous to August, 1645, there is no record of cases tried before this court.' Then the records begin and are continued with some degree of completeness' until 1661, when they are discontinued, owing probably to the troublous times connected with the union with Connecticut.
Mr. Desborough served as magistrate until 1651, when Mr. William Leete succeeded him and held the position so long as New Haven was a separate colony. Tlie deputies were as follows:
" In these Courts, civil causes and minor felonies were tried and their power extended also originally to the probate of wills, to granting letters of administration and to the division and settlement of estates. The probate of wills, etc., was later transferred to the judiciary of the combination.
* At their election the first two took the oath, but Hubbard. " wanting light for renewing the same oath to the same person for the same worke, did forbeare for a time."
The Plantation Court
The stability of the membership of the court, which was elected yearly, is noteworthy. ]\Ir. Leete was dropped because he became magistrate; Mr. Jordan returned to England in 1655; Mr. Chittenden died in 1660; and Mr. Kitchell left Guilford at the time of the union. This shows that the decisions of the court must have been recognized as just. In 1666 the court was superseded by the New Haven County Court, of which Mr. William Leete was chief magistrate. Since then the magistrates of the town have been the assistants and the justices of the peace.
I. Military Cases. (See chapter on Colonial Military History). 11. Failure to pay school rates. (See chapter on Education). Cases of fines for being " defective in watch," of insubordination to military officers, and of failure to pay for the schooling of children are elsewhere discussed. HI. Sedition and Offenses against the Government. " Speaking against the government" was one crime often laid to the charge of early Guilford men at odds with the majority. The very first trial recorded was on this charge, of which Francis Chatiicld was accused. He was an opponent of union with New Haven and " exprest much in a sinful passion agt. the govermt of this place, charging y' it was now vile & we were better separate than upon New Haven." This he confessed " to proceed from a heat of passion." But that w^as not all his guilt, for he had libeled Mr. Gregson of New Haven, in stating that he had discouraged his man from coming to Guilford by asking " would he come hither to be ruled by them?" This was disproved by both Mr. Gregson and his man.
A third charge was, that he had quoted Mr. Gregson as saying " he did wonder, we are not all to peeces, with other passages vented by him and confirmed by many witnesses," such as, " that Mr. Leet was checked by Mr. Gregson, . . . whicli reports were false."
Contempt of court comes close to contempt of government, and at the same time Goodman Crittenden was heard on a " charg for refusing his hearing at ye apointmcnt of ye Magistrate." This was con-
' These assistants were confirmed by the legislature in case of Milford and Stamford, but there is no evidence of such confirmation in case of Guilford.
The court voted on these cases: that, "there being much evil in these carriages of contempt and slight of ye govermt; yet, being confest with sorrow for ym, their cases were levifyed, though ye things, in themselves considered, deserve punishment. Though there is sorrow expressed for them; yet, when they are the first beginnings, I should pass it over in way of favor in passing upon them." This wise leniency was characteristic of Guilford justice.
The next case of the sort was that of John Bishop, Jr. He was accused of " sundry uncivel speeches and immodest expressions," " or," as it is elsewhere put, '' wanton and lascivious speeches and prophane expressions." As far as the records show, these speeches consisted in saying that it was " best to be in the quarter of gant squaws " and that ^' Mr. Higginson, in his sermon, did so teare at ye young men that, if he had been there, he would have gone out of the meeting-house and not have endured them." He was examined and confessed in part these expressions of discontent; but, on April i, 1647, when he was sent for to attend court, he wilfully absented himself. The court, in view of this contempt, ordered the marshal to " keep a warrant in constant readiness " for him and, on finding him, to apprehend him and keep him safe in ward until the court should take further action. All persons having knowledge of his whereabouts were also commanded to make it known. On August 19, 1647, ^^^ appeared and being questioned in court, he acknowledged his former confession; but denied further charges and, as he did not seem " to have any real sense of sin," the court deferred sentence. On February 16, 1647-8, he was again called up and " saith, he hath had many thoughts " as to his speeches " and scene much evill in them, more than formerly, and desireth the Court to passe it by, hoping that he shall never let such speeches any more come out of his mouth to defile and corrupt others." The Court fined him £5, which his father promised to see paid. The reason for the fine was stated to be " the corrupting nature of such speeches, spoken to youth, who are most apt to drink in such pollu-
^ There is also this mysterious entry: "Expressed by Mr. Whitfield, as expressed by Goodm: Crittenden, that he refused him a load of hay, therefore ff. appointed him to help at the Mill tho' it was cleared yt. Mr. Leet appointed him to the mill, before yt. Crittenden spoke of his hay: witnessed by Will: Plaine. Appreliciiding Mr. Leet to be displeased, w'^h. other slanders by apprehended not." " This he denied.
tions, as temptations to fleshly lusts and prophaneness." This fine was not paid on September 4, 165 1, when he promised to pay it before the next particular court,
IVillia))! StoJic was the next to " speak against the Government " and be tried therefor.. There were two charges against him. The first that he " peremptory affirmed, w**" heat & passion in open Court, y*^ he thought & did verily believe, he had wrong in the quantity of his cotton wool." The Jurisdiction ' court ordered that every planter should have a canvas coat, quilted with cotton wool, so as to be a defense against Indian arrows. The town had bought a quantity of cotton wool and distributed it, and the secretary's bill, showing " everyone's just proportion," was "proved to be right and true.'" In apology, " Brother " John Stone said he had no " end to asperse any man or the Court with unfaithfulness or injustice," but confessed that he had said the words charged.
The other accusation was that he gave out " in a slanderous and whispering way, some speeches to that purpose, that things were not rightly carryed, in that he was left to be one of the last in apointing & setting out ye place, where he should have his proportions of land." ' This was testified to by three witnesses, who " did always look upon the said speeches, as charging the Court with partiality." The surveyor, John ]Mepham. informed the Court that Stone's land was equal in value to that of others, " in the quarter where it lies." Stone himself confessed that the witnesses had reported him correctly and added, "yt he did and doth still think, that there was no favor showed him, for always others were preferred before him." The Court reserved judgment, which was delivered on October 21, 1647, a"<^l then stated that it was not satisfied with his acknowledgment, " as not fully comprehending the evil of his miscarriage & every particular of passion in ye charge proved against him." Therefore, he was summoned to "another, full confession and more manifest humbling selfe, unless he can cleare himself." He, accordingly, stated that " he was deeply guilty of irreverence, passion, and slandering & of an unbridled tongue, & is heartily sorry for the same, desiring yt. ye Court and all others would passe it by, hoping it shall be a warning for him forever after."
' Ale.xandcr Chalkcr and Ricliard Guttridge " showed much rashness and confidence " about this business, and, being called before the Court. April. 1647, acknowedged their fault and craved forgiveness, which was granted.
'John Hodely testified. Stone said, "if it were not more for ye providence of God, than men, he should do ill enough in this place and, were it not for some oth-jr things, he would nut tarry in the place."
The Court " did passe it by, witliont fine or penal censure, admonishing him to be more careful for the future, lest he let loose his tongue and spirit to such passions, jealousies, boldness, & such other rash slanderous expressions prejudicial to the names, or credit, either of publique, or particular persons."
The next case of a contempt for the authority of the Court is that of Benjamin Wright. This case first appears on October 12, 1648, when " the Court took into consideration a case w'^'^ ye Magistrate propounded concerning ye buying of Mr. Caffinch his lot by Benjamin Wright & declared y* he was no fit planter for so great an accommodation and therefore they disallow the said act contrary to order & warned the said Wright not to proceed in the business."
" Benjamin Wright being called appeared & it was laid to his charge y* he had miscarryed himselfe in sundrye thinges against the orders of the Magistrate & government of this place in 6 particulars then declared against him expressed in court by the magistrate, to which he answered,
" Tliat he desired time to give answer to the things charged against him & did with the same boldness, height and loudness of speech maintaine the speech he had formerly spoken against the Magistrate - wh'^'^ he denyed & Wright affirmed as also affirming that nothing hath beene done by him contrary to the order in the business with Standish; desiring that the case may be transferred to the Court of Magistrates next in May, to be heard there."
The Court bound him to make his appearance there and to answer such things as should be laid to his charge, hereof he is not to fail upon the penalty of £30.
" I. That he proceeded in a business of bargaining with Thomas Standish of Wethersfield for a certaine Accomodatio of houses & landes late John Caffinches, contrary to an order or orders made to hinder such proceedings, y* none should be sold to any, whether planter or other, unless the Court approved of them as fit planters for such an accomodatio. - The said Wright having been told by the Magistrate that he was no fit planter for such an Accomodatio & warned not to proceed in it; yet he proceeded in a secret & suble way of seeming exchange seeking thereby to undermine & frustrate the said order.'
' All i)In Titers were allowed to occupy lands on an outlay of £500, £250 or £100, or £50 estate, after which rule all estates were to be rated. Mr. Cafifinch's
" II. That he being called to the court for his miscarriage & then the thing witnessed against as disorderly & he warned not to proceed further in the business, but to desert and cease from going on in the same, he neglected or resisted the court's admonition & went about again in a like subtle & fraudulent way to disappoint the said order.
" III. That he cast aspersions upon the ^lagistrate charging him in publique that he should tell him the said Wright, that if he would forbeare to proceed w^*^ Standish for the said lot, then ere long he would be weary of it & the towne should haue it for little or nothing: w'^" words he did not proue, but upon the Magistrats rehearsal of what he said to him, - viz that if he were not hasty or eager to proceed with Standish then he might be brought to reasonable term & the towne might buy it of him, & he then promised Wright y*^ if it fell into the townes hands, he would do his utmost y* he might have such part as he desired or seemed to desire - he could not but acknowledge those to the expression, yet he boldly maintained that it was all to one effect or purpose.
" IV. That having thus sublely & fraudulently proceeded to get a title to said lot notw'^^standing such advice and admonition given him, he also went on in a like secret suble & fraudulent way to possesse himselfe of the said houses & grounds either by creeping into the house at the windows or elsewhere, or breaking in through some part of the house or doors by force & violence w^*^ were shut & lockt ag^* him by the Magistrates order and appointment.
" \'. That he (after the Magistrates solemne profession in court that what he had done in advising or opposing him in this business, was out of tenderness to him & his family, purposing to gratify his desire so farre as was fit, when it lay in his power) he tauntingly replyed: " You keep back my wages due for my worke whereon my wife and family should live: is that tenderness?" or words to y^ effect: of which uncomely & ungrateful expressions he being admonished & told y* he thereby manifested a revengeful frame of spirit: he replyed that he lot was a £500 estate and Benjamin Wright's was £50. The order referred to is on T. R. Vol. B. p. 11, entitled against engrossing lots, and is as follows: " Whereas much experience shewcs that sundry inconveniences do arise to the burdening, disturbing or depopulating of smaller plantations when either sundry lots or accommodations are engrossed into one hand and possessed and held by unsuitable or unfit persons, It is therefore agreed and ordered that none shall exchange fraudulently, let or give, either all or any part of his lots or accommodations unto any, whether planter or others, without the consent of the court first publicly procured and accorded, together witli the sale or exchange particularly expressed and set down in a book of trrrit i'^ of lands.
found nothing else, by w*^*^ expressions the court couicl not but concieue y^ he aspersed y". at best to be men of revenge only towards him.
" VI. That when the Court told him y* they required he should depart from his possession of the said lot so disorderly gotten as he would answer the contrary for contempt of the authority here established & notwithstanding the Court told & promised him that they would answer him for w' they did herein at ye court of Magistrates, if he required them, yet he replyed that he would not depart fro his possession unless they cast him out by force and violence."
" Benjamin Wright of Guilford, having bine at a court of Magistrats held at New Haven in May last charged w**^ and proved guilty of sundry grave miscarriages, for w'^'^ he deserved seveere correction, but ye Court seeing some show of remorse and hoping for better fruit than they now see, upon Mr. Disborows request, past it by, upon condition that he should make a full acknowledgement at Guilford of his several miscarriages as he had done in court & promised to do then as appeared by the proceedings of that court which were now read, - but when he came to Guilford & should have made his acknowledgement, he refused, and in a stubborn and bold way said he must fall under many because he wanted proofe, as appears by a note under ye hand of Mr. Leete Secretary at Guilford, and said that he acknowledged he went aboute to delude the townes order, because the Governor did so threaten him, as testified by Mr. Leete, Mr. Chittendin & Mr. Jordan upon oath taken before Mr. Disbrowe July 2d, 1649."
"At a General Court held the 15 of lune, 1649, Benjamin Wright being called & enquired of whether he were ready according to the Court order & his promise to make full acknowledgement before this gen" Court of those miscarriages w'^^ being those charged upon him were confessed by him, he answered that he was not as yet prepared & therefore desired further time of consideration, he also saying that his conscience would not suffer him to owne somethings wh^*^ he had acknovv^ledged, namely that in going about to procure Standish his lot, he did it to decieue the order: neither did he appeare in any penitent satisfactory frame, l)ut rather stubborne & saying that he nuist fall under many things because he wanted proofe yet he doubted not or hoped that God would one day cleare him or bring things further to light: Upon consideration of wh''*', his frame & carriage the Court warned him to Depart fro the house & to leaue the whole accomodatio to Standish, the owner of the same, who hath not as yet legally dispossessed himself of the same according to order."
At the General Court at New Haven, July 3d, as aforesaid,' " Wright was asked what threatening was used but he answered not, Hee was told that he had bine brought to corporal punishment before, but y* he made that acknowledgement he did, and gave hopes of better fruit than appears, for instead of doing what he promised, he returnes to his former pride and stubborness againe, and when he was bound to appear at this courte, and put in baile to do it, he came to ye Magistrate and told him plainly he would not come then, as Mr. Disbrowe affirmed before and he denyed it not. Hee was therefore desired to speake if he could shew any reason why he should not now have sharpe punish*^ inflicted, Hee said he can say nothing against it but it is just, but though he had thought when he went from the court to doe what he had saide, yett God left him and he returned to his former course again, because he was not faithfull to those purposes that God had put in his heart.
" The sentence of the Court concerning Benjamin Wright is that he be severely whipped heare at Newhaven, and a month hence at Guilford, and that he paye as a fine to ye Court of Jurisdiction io£ for the charge & trouble he hath put them too."
" At a generall Court held the 24th of August, 1649, Benjamin Wright was called to receive the punishment appointed by the last court of Magistrates & it was demanded of him w'. acknowledgem't of his miscarriages he had to make further for mitigation of his punishment, but he answering ' he was here to suffer,' he was led forth to receive his punishment."
Out of the town's suits against Wright came one by him against Thomas Standish, from whom he had purchased the disputed property. On December 5, 1650, Benjamin Wright " desired an attachment upon the Steere & all other the estate of Thomas Standish extant in this plantatio," to compel him to answer a suit Wright intended to bring against him at the next particular court. The suit did not come to a trial until May, 1651, when Wright "pleaded, upon an action on the case, tliat he received damage to the value of £100"; in that Standish did not give him " full & quiet possession of certaine houses & landes, that he hath purchased " from Standish. Standish did not appear at tlie Court, though it was proved he had had notice. The
Court asked Wright for the evidence of the bargain, which he said he had left with the Court of Magistrates in New Haven when he was tried there. Thereupon the Court ordered him to present the evidence at the next session and deferred the case until then. Unluckily, we are ignorant as to whether he ever did so, for the records are silent as regards the further course of the case.
Thomas French was called before the court, on February 5, 1651-2, for " claimorous & scandalizing expressions, tending to charge the towne with unmercifulness and exaction." Two witnesses testified that " he should say that he, nor his family, were not relieved, according to their need, nor that he could get any corn in the towne for pay, unless he came and offered them half so much more as it was worth; but, when he did so, then they had corne enough for him, otherwise not; wherefore he was forced to goe out of the towne to get corne for his family." He acknowledged this speech and that he had done evil, " for the thing was true but of some particular persons, & that they too had given him satisfaction for their exaction; whereas his speech did & might include all, or any of the inhabitants of the towne, who had never so carryed it towards him, wherefore he was sorry that he had so spoken & wronged them." The Court thought that his confession was "in a base & dry manner; yet, out of tenderness to him & his family," they pass his fault over with an admonition, that he do so no more, or expect sharper dealing. These charges of the Court are noticeable for their quaintness and for tempering justice with mercy.
IV. - Criminal Cases. If we ma}' judge from the records, the morality of Guilford must have been high. Few criminal cases came before the Court. Indeed, Guilford has ever maintained a good reputation for morality. The only man from Guilford ever executed was William Plaine ^ who was convicted of sodomy and corrupting of youth and was executed in New Haven in 1646. There is no record of his trial on the Guilford books; but the case was considered of sufficient importance to cause Gov. Eaton write to the magistrates and elders of Massachusetts for advice.^
For theft,^ Agnes Wilde, apparently a servant of Mr. Kitchel, was sentenced, on January 21, 1646-7, to restore double the value of the things ' stolen from him. Some of the articles she had exchanged with
' The articles were a cambrick band, 4 pair of cuffs, 5 neckcloths and crosscloths, several " pieces of old and new together," some wampum, 2 handkerchiefs, 4 laced crosscloths, a Holland coif, a cap, a pair of Holland gloves, and a silver sixpence.
On September 4, 1651, Win. Boreman " was questioned about lying," but this case of false accusation was deferred until February 5, 165 1-2, when he confessed with penitence, he had lied " about the matter of taking- a canister and charging it to Mr. Thomas Jordan & Stephen Bishop." The Court " passed him over with a Check and Admonition; that, if he were found to miscarry himself again, they would make use of these aggravations to after faults to encrease their punishment."
On ]\Iarch i, 1654-5, Thomas Stevens was accused of "selling flax, not currantly dressed & wanting about an ounce in each pound; his weight and balance, being proved, was found defective; the scales uneven, the weight too light." Thomas Stevens plead that he had sold much flax formerly, which did hold weight, and that the reason of this parcel being deficient was that " he had lost ofif from the spring of his scales a piece of lead, being a pistol bullet beaten out, which was to even the scales," and that " he made up the parcel of flax in moist w^eather." The Court told him " it was a grosse mistake not to have his weight proved for sundry years " and that his excuse was not sufificient. Further, though " they were willing to conceive and hope the best, that he might not knowingly deceive," yet they thought it just to fine him 10 shillings and compel him to make up the loss to others from his scales.
But one case of drunkenness is on record. On January i, 1656-7, John Parmelin, Jr., was " called to answer, about a comon fame or report of his inordinate drinking upon a Trayneing day of late, apearing in his gestures et &c. - Answered that he did acknowledge that he fell down at the stile at Bro: Cooke's doore & hit his drumme' agt. the pales there: also that he did wade thro' the water against Mr, Kitchel's lott & that he againe went fro the way to ye pales ag'st Henry Goldam's Lott & then hit his drumme agt the pales and, further, he doth confesse that he had drunk too much strong drink that day, considering that he was empty & had eaten little & so acknowledgeth, yt he did evill & was not watchfull over himselfe, nor so carefull to avoid giving ofTence, as he should, for which he was sorry." Notwithstanding this confession, three witnesses were called in, who, in a deliciously naive way, reminding one of Dame Quickly, confirmed the confession, whereupon the Court sentenced him to pay a fine, as " he was disabled in his understanding by drinking.'"
' On September 3, 1652, Nicholas Munger, John Rossiter, and si.x young women were examined " upon a comon fame or report of some miscarryages,
With all the strictness of the observance of the Lord's Day, we find but one accusation against any one of violating it. This is a most curious complaint and characteristic of Puritan morals. On December 4, 1657, John Meigs was brought up for having come " with his cart fro Athomohossock, late in the night on the Lord's Day/ making a noise, as he came with his cart, to the ofTence of many yt. heard it." He plead that " he was mistaken in the time of day, thinking that he had time enough for the journey; but, being somewhat more laden than he expected, & the cattell came more slowly than usual, & so cast him behinde, it proving to be more late of the day, than he had thought."
" But he professeth to be sorry for his mistake & the offence justly given thereby, promising to be more careful for time to come." The Court, " seeing the matter seemed to be done upon a surprisall," passed it over with a reproof and commanded him to make " a publique acknowledgement of his evill on the next lecture or fast day."
V. - Cases about Animals and Fences. Animals of various sorts, and especially hogs, occupy a large part of the records, and suits concerning them are very frequent.
As early as October 9, 1645, ^o^r men are fined for neglecting to keep up a fence against cattle, and on May 28, 1646, the second civil case recorded was heard, that of Relf vs. Bishop & Jordan, for trespass by " hoggs " on the plaintiff's corn." Thomas Relf claimed that he was damnifyed to the value of fifty shillings, by injury done by the defendants' animals to 2 acres of Indian Corn in the East Creek quarter. John Bishop confessed that the hogs were his and was fined 5 bushels of Indian corn and 7 shillings in wampum; but Thomas Jordan denied ownership of the hogs and was, apparently, acquitted.
This suit led to another," Bishop vs. Sheaffe, in which the plaintiff claimed that his hogs had gotten into Relf's corn, through the " default " of Mr. Sheaffe's fence, and that the fine should be repaid him by the defendant. Mr. Sheaffe, by his attorneys, Messrs. Kitchel and Chittenden,* acknowledged that his fence was unmade, but claimed by disorderly night meeting, Unnecessary familiarity, or unfit company keeping." The Court judged them all more or less guilty of these rather vague offences, which may have been nothing more than undue merriment, and ordered them to " make a publique acknowledgement of their evills."
^ Novemljcr 7, 1648, Thomas Jones sued Richard Bristow, John Parmelin, and goodwife Bushncll for damages done his corn by their hogs; but the case was postponed and is no more heard of.
that Mr. Bishop's " hoggs were disorderly, viz: unyoked, &c." As no proof of neglect on Mr. Bishop's part was given, the Court sentenced Mr. Sheaffe to repay the fine.
A third suit followed from the second one, on the same day. This is the suit of Shcaffc vs. Stci'ois for breach of contract. In this, Mr. Sheafife's attorney said that, in September, 1645, the plaintiff agreed with the defendant to build 30 rods of fence for his East Creek lot and to have it finished by the first of the succeeding May, and from his failure to fulfill the contract Mr. SheafTe had to repay Mr. Bishop's fine. John Stevens acknowledged that the agreement was made as stated and that the fence was not made; but claimed that the hogs were disorderly and " that he was hindered by being taken out to work ten dayes & a halfe about the mill by the magistrate." This pretext was regarded by the Court as flimsy and he was sentenced to pay Mr. SheafTe's judgment and the costs of the two latter suits.^
Two cases with the same parties, French vs. Evarts, were heard on May 3, 1655. The first was brought by Thomas French against John Evarts, on the ground that his sow, on a Sunday, early in April, was drowned in Evarts's uncovered well, the gate of the yard being open; wherefore he sued Evarts for four pounds damages. Evarts claimed that at night he shut and fastened his gate and in the morning found a pale broken down, " in a place yt was usually left firm before." French said that the same morning he passed by and saw no pale down and that his hogs were not in the habit of going into Evarts's grounds. William Seward, as a witness, said that French's " hoggs are apt to leap & to break fences; but he remembers not, yt. ye Sow was such a harmful hogg." The Court, seemingly, decided for the plaintifY, adjudging that the defendant should pay costs; but, as the sow was not yoked, her loss is to be divided equally between the two parties.
In the second suit, French complained of " Damages, wch he had sustained in parsnips. Cabbages, & Pease, by the hoggs of John Evarts Senr. for severall years," which damage he put at 20 shillings. Evarts plead that his hogs got into French's land on account of defects in the plaintiff's fence and that, though it was not his fault, " he had tendered satisfaction in Cabbages " & French had stopped a pound of flax due him. Further, Evarts brought witnesses to prove tliat Goodwife French had said Samuel Blachley's sow had eaten their
' Anotlicr suit caused on account of damage done by hogs was that of Stone vs. Goldani, brought December 5, 1650, and postponed till February, 165 1. It was, however, arranged out of Court, in all probability, as there is no further record.
The case of Meigs vs. Chapman and Parker, October 31, 1657, " in an action for tresspass," was one of the few in which parties from outside the Jurisdiction appeared. John Meigs claimed that after he had " fenced his land at Athamonossock, w^^ such an orderly fence, as was sufficient to keep out great cattell; yet the Defendants' hoggs came into his field «& destroyed his corne." He, therefore, claimed damages. A witness testified to bringing out of the corn 15 hogs of Parker's, at one time, and to having seen, " sundry other times, the Defendants' hoggs in Corne doing spoile." Chapman and Parker pleaded that the fence was not sufficient and, as they were strangers, living in Saybrook, whence the " hoggs " must have strayed, the Court sent viewers to examine the fence. These reported the fence not " sufficient to keep out great Cattell." At this, the Court declared it could not relieve the plaintiff; " but desired y^ the defendants would consider the great losse the plaintiff sustained by their hoggs & that, therefore, in a neighborly way, they would consider to afTord some supply, as themselves would desire in a like case. That amity & good agreement might be the better maintained betwixt the persons & Towns of Seabrooke and Guilford as formerly."
The unfortunate Benjamin Wright was the defendant in the next suit^ about hogs, that of Crittenden vs. Wright. Abraham Crittenden, Sr., complained that " by his wife & one of his children " Wright had taken away his hogs from Thomas Crittenden, who was driving them out of his father's land to the pound. Wright said he knew nothing of the charge. " But, in a very loud, passionate, & proud manner, he told the magistrate, yt he looked upon it, that he acted out of prejudice, or ill will agst. him, &, speaking after a slighting manner, bid him doe his worst & said he expected no less fro him." Considering his treatment some time before, there might be some excuse for this behavior, but it was certainly impolitic. The magistrate, we learn, had much ado to silence him and to induce him to speak " in court, according to peaceable and comely behaviour." On February 4, 1657-8, the case came up again. Wright's wife and daughter, who had taken the hogs from Crittenden, were then present. The magistrate, it seems, had been present at the time and had reproved them, saying to Mrs. Wright, " that she ought to have sought the recovery of them in a legail & orderly way." On Mr. Leete's stating this in court, Wright asked " that wt. had been so-charged & said, might be proved in a legal way." Mr. Leete answered that the magistrate, being sworn " to doe justice in all causes brought before him in Court, needed not to take a new oath to confirm anything" he said there. Wright and his wife were not satisfied and, when Leete offered to confirm his statement with an oath, they said it was false and they could prove it. This they had difBculty in doing, and finally the Court decided against them and sentenced Wright to pay a fine. During the trial, Wright again lost his temper and was admonished " that a corrupt, proud, passionate spirit fro within did seem to act in him in those unruly carryages & misdemeanors against God, his ordinances, trampling upo all authority, as formerly he had done, when other men were in place before." This did not check him, '' for he went on still, in his reviling the magistrate in open Court." After another speech of Mr. Leete, Wright said he spoke according to his conscience, and this edifying dialogue was continued by " some of the Deputyes of the Court telling him his conscience was a corrupt & rotten conscience, not being a word to guide it, nor must be suffered in such a wicked course." The Court put him under bond of £50 to appear at the next General Court in New Haven. This he refused to give; though they consented to take his own bond; "but he w^illfuUy wanted rather to be sent to prison." He was heard at New Haven, on May 31, 1658. In the morning the session was interrupted by his falling in a faint " which the Governour wisht him to consider the providence of God towards him, that, as he had beene smiteing at the authority of God, so now God came upon him, as if he would kill him." In the afternoon he " said he should apply himself to consider of his sin in ye sight of God." The Court decided to let him off for the present, under bond of £50 for good behaviour, the magistrates and deputies of Guilford, now, as always, merciful, petitioning them to it.' Probably at a later court, whose record is missing, he was fined; for, at the October session in 1668, the General Assembly of Connecticut refused to grant his petition to have his case reopened, as it had " passed to an issue in the Court at New Haven.""
Other domestic animals, besides hogs, were causes of litigation. Cows were frequently troublesome and drew their owners into quarrels. The first case found of this kind is that of Ilubball vs. CJiiffenden, attorney for Whitfield. Richard Hubball claimed £5 damages for the loss of a cow, who died, being " pushed " by Mr. Whitfield's bull. Witnesses testified to the goring of the cow and to the bull's being ** a dogheafl beast, or surley, or used to attack some of the steere cattle formerly " and to attack people. The Court, after weighing the evidence, " doe conclude it to bee the case of a mere afflicting Providence & doe, therefore, apoint that the Bull shall be sold & the pay equally divided between Richard Hubball & Mr. Whitfield." '
John Fowler found a stray colt and brought him before the Court on July i8, 1657, claiming that it was one of his own which had formerly strayed away. The Court was not fully satisfied with his evidence, but ordered the horse to " rest in his hands, until some other do make out a better title in a legal way."
Abraham Crittenden, Sr., took and kept a stray colt and was called before the Court therefor on April 2, 1660. He had lost a colt two years before and produced witnesses to prove that this was the one. It was testified for the town that Abraham Crittenden had previously claimed two other different horses as his lost one, and considering this, the Court decided that " wee see not how in justice to grant him the sole interest in this horse, which appears to be a stray, not having a legal owner. Therefore, Abraham Crittenden is to have half the horse's value for taking him up and, if he desire to keep him. to pay the other half to the Town." The Court further censured him " for being too inordinately affected or covetous, in straining or endeavoring to get some horse of three for his, all of them appearing to have some difference in their naturall marks, & one of them, especially, being notoriously unlike the rest, in w'^'^ contrast wee see not how some passages by him spoken, may be reconciled with truth."
A third stray horse was taken up by Andrczu Benton and, being handed over to William Parker of Saybrook, he promised to be accountable for the horse, whenever it shall be called for " to answer anv better title or clavme," "
Kindred to the cases caused by cattle are those caused by defective fencing. The most important of these is that of Wm. Chittenden & John Fowler, in behalf of the Company of the East River quarter, vs. Abraham Crittenden, Jr. The plaintiffs state that they are much " damnifycd " by the defendant's neglect to fence in his land in that quarter. The case covers three pages of the record, but is of little interest. The Court ordered him to repair his fence and to pay all damages arising from his previous neglect.
' On February 3, 1658-9, William Stone asked the Court to make decision, as to a stray bull he found three years before. It was, tlierefore, appraised at 35s. and sold, and 8s. being deducted for charges, the remainder was divided equally between Wm. Stone and the Town.
'John Bishop and Dennis Crampton were charged with stealing a marc in November. 1666, " the said Dennis being one that hath beene found tardy in several pilferings before." - IV. Mass. Hist. Coll. VII, pp. 559 to 563.
On February 3, 1658-9, JVilliam Stone made a similar complaint against Richard Giitfridge for neglect to fence in land at East River. The case was referred to the " 7 men who are appointed to set out waves " for fuller information, and does not appear again upon the record.
The cases of Cooke and Dudley vs. Wright, on May 28, 1646, are the first of the kind. In the first of these, Thomas Cooke complained that the pugnacious Benjamin Wright had slandered him, in saying " that he was a man of a large conscience & yt' he was a whibbling man & }t he came fawning upo him & that he was a tale bearer." The case was postponed until October 13, when Wright made an acknowledgment of the slander, with which Cooke was satisfied.
The second case was similar, William Dudley complaining that Wright said " he was a man of a large conscience and had a cuntry Conscience," whatever that may be. There is no record of a decision of the case.
The next case of slander, that of Duuck vs. Johnson, was tried on May 4. 1650. John Johnson, it seems, had stated to several his suspicions that Thomas Dunck had stolen butter and a "hand bill"' of his. Before the Court, he stated he was induced to believe that Dunck had taken the butter, because he was alone in another part of the house at the time, dressing flax, and when Johnson and his wife went out they left a hen shut up in the house, which was outside on their return. The Court, however, decided for the plaintiff and adjudged that Johnson make " a publicjue acknowledgement in some towne meeting of the wrong done by slander to Thomas Dunck "'' and pay the costs of the suit. This acknowledgment was made on February 4. 1 650- 1.
The suit of Gnttridge vs. Linsley was heard " at a particular court called out of Course " on February 26, 1653-4. Richard Guttridge charged that John Linsley had slandered his wife, by saying at various times to different persons " that she had told a thousand & a thousand lyes," " that she lied basely," that " she was a lyar & that he would remove his dwelling for her, & yt she was a Divell's bird & had mischieved his dogg & they, who would doc it to his dogg, would doe it to himself & family, so yt he should be afraid to goe out of his house without company." Part of these expressions were proved on liim and part he confessed, and so the Court sentenced him " for punishment of the fact and, in some measure for the reparation of her good name," to pay £5 and costs.
The case of Mnugcr vs. Evarts was heard on September 7, 1654. In this, Nicholas Munger complained that Elizabeth Evarts slandered him, in accusing him of an attempted assault on her. The Court thought " she did evill by so speaking to persons, whereby she might instill or insinuate her own jealousies & suspicions of him into others, before and without legal triall or proofe of the fact against him." Therefore, they ordered her to " make publique acknowledgment of this her fault upo the next Lecture day, before the whole Assembly, w° met together."
Dennis Crampton was the defendant in two suits for slander on June 12, 1656. These were the suits of Doudc & IV right vs. Craiiipton. Elizabeth Doude complained of his spreading scandalous reports of her, which he had to confess. The well-known figure in the court, Benjamin Wright, complained that Crampton tried to throw suspicion on him of being the thief of flax stolen from Goodman Fowler. Crampton, it seems, said that the thief ** was a little man & was the man, who was so angry when the searchers w'ere at his house: all which descriptions were apprehended to agree more with Goodman Wright than any other in the Towne." For punishment, the Court decided that, in a third suit brought at the same time against Crampton, as he, being an apprentice, had no estate, " Denise be immediately corporally punished by whipping."
Hnbball vs. Hill is the next case^ of slander on the records. Richard Hubball complained that John Hill said that he " made no more of lyeing, than a dogg did to wagg his Taile." The Court concluded that " ye proofe was legal and cleare & that Hill was too commonly subject to such kinde of miscarryages " and awarded Hubball £5 and sentenced Hill to pay costs.
On the same day another suit for slander was decided against Hill. Hill complained that Thomas Clarke " scandalously reported that he, the said John Hill, laid violent hands upo him & tooke him by the collar or throat & shooke him & offered, one while to strike him with his fork, and another while with his fist: w''^ the said Hill dcnyed." The Court, however, after " considering the case & finding the proofe cleare for what the defendant had charged the plaintifif with all." sentenced Hill to pay the costs.
On February 3, 1658-9, Thomas Clarke brought a countersuit against Hill for " unjust molestation." The plaintiff stated that Hill said that Clarke's oxen destroyed his hay and, on his bidding Hill to prove it, Hill took him " by the Throat or Collar & shooke him " and said " what if I should now take you a blow on the Chopps, howwould you prove it," thinking they were alone. The Court " doe looke upon it as a very offensive carryage, tending to the breach of peace & to disorder." Therefore, they " appointed Hill to make such Acknowledgement in publique on the next Lecture day or at the next Town meeting as might fully reach the nature of the offence," and to pay a fine. Clarke, however, " is to pay Hill for the damage in his hay according to a .just valuation of indifferent men & to bear his owne part of the charge of this action."
Yet another suit for slander against Hill was heard the same day. Nathan Bradley complained that Hill slandered him, by accusing him " of a false witness bearing " and " so to disable him for witnessing in the case of Hubball vs. Hill." At that time. Hill said Bradley " had spoken false, about some days work, w'^'' the Plaintiff affirmed he had done " for Hill. This work Hill said he had not done. The suit was arranged between the parties, however, without waiting for the decision of the court.
VH. - Transfer of Houses and Land. Difficulties about the transfer of lands and houses often occurred.' In the first of these, on November 4, 1645, Wm. Boreman claimed damages from William Chitten den, because he " refused to give possession of a house called Stiles his house, according to a bargaine made betwixt John Stodder & ye sd. Willm Chittenden for ye one half of ye said house." But, as Boreman did not prove his authority from Stodder to begin the suit, the Court decided against him and sentenced him to pay Chittenden is.
The well-known litigant, Benjamin Wright, had a controversy with William Dudley on May 28, 1646, about an acre of land, whether Wright should have it from Dudley " by way of guift," or one-half by exchange and half " by guift." The decision Wright left " to the liberty of the said Dudley." '
'The case of Jordan vs. Crittenden, heard on October 13, 1646. is of little interest. Thomas Jordan and .A.braham Crittenden. Sr., had made an exchange of lands and apparently repented of their bargain, but Crittenden afterwards feared loss if he returned the land. The Court, as nearly as can be told from the records, which are obscurely worded, permitted them to return to their former holdings, if this would be just. A committee, appointed to investigate the matter, reported on December 10, 1646. that the retransfer would be fair to both parties.
On the first Thursday of December, 1656, the case of Meigs vs. Stevens was tried. John Meigs claimed that Thomas Stevens had sold him land at Hammonassett for 10 shillings, which statement was confirmed by Mrs. Meigs, whereupon Thomas Stevens said Meigs and his wife were " no fit witnesses, whereby he went about to impeach one or both of their credits & so to breed great difference and trouble between them & him & others & yet in a matter of no great moment." The Court advised that they should " rather between themselves, or by mediatio of some friends to end the controversy & not to hazzard such hurtful events, as might proceed from yt way they were going on in." This benevolent advice they were sensible enough to take. Meigs,' however, who was engaged in almost as many suits as Wright, was plaintiff in another suit of the same character, on February 4, 1657-8. This was the case of Meigs vs. Johnson. John Meigs declared that John Johnson had exchanged some land with him at " the Gulfe at Athamonossock," which Johnson now refused to deliver at the terms agreed upon. Johnson objected to the testimony of Meigs and his wife, and in course of the trial, as Meigs denied something that Johnson and others affirmed he had said previously, the Court fined him los. for lying. Furthermore, Johnson brought testimony as to two other exchanges of land which Meigs had falsely pretended to have made, and the Court, weighing the testimony, " saw no cause to allow or confirme his pretence of right." The Court also thought it " not safe to admit his wife's testimony," as he had urged her to testify. It seems Meigs had built a house on Johnson's land, and this the Court ordered him to remove and to pay los. to witnesses and the defendant. Johnson, nevertheless, is to pay " w* appears due upo account."
VIII. - Fraud. Actions for fraud are not common. On June 12, 1654, Dennis Crampton was convicted of " cousening " Nicholas Munger of flax. He took a parcel of flax from Munger and only returned part. The Court ordered him to return the rest and, as has been noted, ordered him whipped for this and for two slanderous reports.
The only other case of the sort was heard December 2, 1658. Thomas Stevens complained of William Dudley, Jr., " for deceitfully working up shoes." " The shoes were showed in Court, w""^ appeared both shorter than other shoes of yt size & to be made up of many shreds of leather, instead of a middle sole, w'''' being an unusual
'The same Meigs gave the only mortgage deed recorded by the Court: it was for £27, and was given to William Stone on April 18. 1658, the security being three oxen and three cows.
manner & much wrong to the wearer of the shoes, as was judged by 3 shoemakers in Court, for w''^ offence he was adjudged to pay 5s. to the Complainer, for his Costs & damage, & los. to the Treasury, for injury to the Comonwealth, & was admonished to looke to it better hereafter, both for his sizes, & making,' &c."
At a similar suit in New Haven in 1647 against John Meigs. John Parmelee testified that he bought a pair of russet shoes from him, the soles of which ripped from the uppers after 7 days' wearing.
IX. - Miscellaneous Cases. The failure of men to pay taxes occasioned some suits before the courts at Guilford (1650) and New Haven," in which trials William Stone, Richard Hues, John Caflftnch, and Thomas Standish ' were ordered to pay rates.
The quarrelsome John Meigs entered suit against JVilliam Chittenden, as agent for Mr. Nathaniel Whitfield, for debt in December. i6s6. Meigs said that William Stone hired for him, about four years before, a vessel to carry goods from Hartford to Saybrook, and that Mr. Whitfield laded the vessel with " Tarre to the quantity of near halfe the freight." For this he had never been paid; but the decision of the Court upon the case is unknown, for the records are silent."
The last of these miscellaneous cases was one in which George Hubbard claimed that Daniel Benton kept a gun of his, " w<=^ he never sold to him &, therefore, it might be restored to him again." Benton claimed that Daniel Hubbard, George's son, had exchanged it for another, with his father's consent. This George Hubbard denied, saying the guns were only exchanged for the summer, and the Court taking this view of it, made Benton return the gun and take his own again.'
X. - Probate Cases. In addition to suits between living persons, the court acted as a Court of Probate, with large powers. The first will proved before it was that of Francis Bushnell, the elder, on October 13, 1646. The second estate administered by the court was that of Francis Austin, who was lost in the Lamberton ship. Statements
* On September 3, 1652, Mr. Bryan Rossiter and Edward Sewers came to the Court and said they would arrange by arbitration the case of Rossiter vs. Sewers for false imprisonment. What this case was is unknown. On the same day there is reference made to an unknown case, wherein Wm. Case, having put VVm. Stone as security for his appearance, did not appear. The Court required Stone to pay the sum, £10.
' On April 7, 1646, a suit for some unknown cause between " some of Guilford and Elias Parkman of Windsor," was postponed at New Haven. - I. N. H. Col. Rec. p. 229.
of debts were brought against him ^ by WilHam Leete and Richard Hues, and were allowed by the Court. Tliomas Dunck and Richard Hues, also, tried to recover from the estate money they had given Austin to spend for them in England ; but this the Court refused, seeing " no cause that Francis Austin should beare the venture by the danger of the sea." John Stone also complained at the same time that he had hired a new milch cow from Austin, which had proved barren and the Court therefore abated part of the hire.
On December 31," 1646, Thomas Dunck again brought suit against Austin's estate. He stated that when Austin " was about to prepare to take voyage for England in ye shipp yt. went fro New Haven," he came to Dunck and borrowed £2 los., that he " might accommodate & fit himself with some handsome coat & sword to goe to his father wthall & said yt, if he would, he should take it as a kindness from him and lay it out for him in England, in such things as he should appoint. '' Dunck said he lent the money, and asked to have it returned to him from Austin's estate. The Court, " considering ye premises &, looking upo the case as difficult & themselves as wanting insight and experience in the laws of merchandising & sea adventures, did refer the business to be tryed at ye next court of Magistrates &, if the said Dunck did require ye issue in ye case, they appointed him their to attend." '
It seems to the writer that the proceedings of the Court show that the settlers of Guilford were men of wisdom and prudence. The decisions given by the Court show a great amount of leniency, a clear respect for the provisions of the law of the country whence they came, an evident anxiety to render justice to all. That there was a general agreement that these decisions were righteous is shown by the repeated election of the members of the Court. The lack of bigotry is also much greater than would be noticed in the proceedings of any similar court of that day known to the author. That Guilford had such a Court, presided over by such remarkable men, is surely ground for pride.
Chapter Ix
In the affairs of New Haven Jurisdiction, into which the town entered in 1643, Guilford took a prominent part. These do not fall within the strict province of a local history, and we can but allude to the commission' in 1653 of two Guilford men, Air. William Leete and Mr. Thomas Jordan, to plead the case of New Haven in regard to dangers from the Dutch before the General Court of Massachusetts ; and, again, to treat on the same matter with Cromwell's commissioners. Air. William Leete was one of the commissioners for the United Colonies every year after 1655, was deputy governor from 1658 to 1660, and then, to quote Hubbard's quaint language, " the hands of Mr. Wm. Leete, who was next chosen Governor, were strengthened to hold up the walls of this building for many years, even to the dissolution of the Colony & its conjunction with Connecticut, of both which Colonies so united he was the late Governor & his praise is in the gates.""
The town lived on peacefully under Mr. Higginson's ministry," but after he had gone, unsettled times began in church and state.* The " Capital and all other laws " of the General Court were regularly read in town meeting. On February 14, 1649-50, at town meeting, " the whole frame of the foundation agreements, orders, & conclusions were read and all new orders were voted, as they stand in ye draught, then read to ye planters in publique." It was a pure democracy voting on its Constitution. But, even in pure democracies, especially those engaged in opening up a new country, it is at times difficult to secure attendance on the meetings of the commonwealth, and so we find in
' II. N. H. Col. Rec. p. 10 sq. May 25, 1653, the Colony voted to have 12 horses at the four towns on the mainland, of which Guilford was to have two for "the publique occasions of the country." " I. Hubbard p. 331.
* Capt. John Manning had a vessel seized by New Haven Colony in 1654 for unlawful trading with the Dutch, and on February 26, 1665-6, Samuel Kitchel and Thomas Cooke were appointed from Guilford " to attend the Committee att New Haven about Capt. Manning's case." As a result of the deliberations thereat Capt. Manning was paid for his vessel and gave a receipt for £120 therefor on September 26, 1666, to Mr. Alexander Bryan of Milford. which receipt is found on a fly leaf of Vol. I. Com. Ct. Records of N. II. County. * \'ii!e January 31, 1649-50.
this Constitution an article " About attendance to meetings or Gen" Courts." This article provides that, whosoever, after notice of a meeting given by the marshal or his deputy, shall be late or absent from a town meeting, shall be fined: a freeman, for being over an hour late I2d., for absence 2s. 6d.; a planter, for late coming 6d., for absence I2d. These fines were levied on the person's estates, " only before distresse bee taken, the party shall have liberty to make his apologie at the next particular Court &, if they shall allow his excuse, hee shall be free." " Neither shall any depart «& neglect to give constant attendance at the said Courts, or meetings, until orderly dismissed, upon the like penaltyes as for late coming, impartial attendance, or as for total absence." All persons present, whether freemen or not, were allowed to speak; provided they, " both in expressions and in all other manner of behavyor, so comely and respectfully demeane themselves, as may hold forth an honorable esteem of the authority then present and a due attendance to peace." No one was allowed to speak without being recognized by the Court, nor to continue " speech longer by impertinencies, needless repetitions, or multiplication of words, w^*" rather tends to darken, than cleare the truth or right of the matter."
When Dr. Brian Rossiter became discontented with the government of New Haven Jurisdiction we know not; but, for some cause, he w^as disaflfccted towards it and set himself to the task of fanning the halfdead embers of dislike towards the union with New Haven. An early intimation of trouble is found in a letter ' of Gov. Leete to Gov. Winthrop on April ii, 1661, wherein he says "that Mr. Rossiter had had a man arrested for slander in reporting that when I (Gov. Leete) heard how Mr. Rossiter had reported against me, that I had taken 20 li. per annum severall years, which was, (as he saith) granted me but for one yeare;' showed myself troubled at his speech, & expressed that I thought it was in effect, as to say, that I had cousened the Towne of 20 li. per annum." This suit Gov. Leete took up and says Dr. Rossiter began it " out of his slight esteeme of publicjue instruments in this Colony, & confident boasting of his great interest with you." ' A postscript seems to state that Dr. Rossiter is displeased at the Leetes' getting medicine from Gov. Winthrop. Rossiter appeared in
* On January 15, 1660-1, Dr. Rossiter said in Town Meeting that "for the i20 there were some considerations to be taken in how the grant was made. But the freemen generally said it was passed as a thing to be constant & to be continued upO condition of my settlement according as I had propounded in my writing formerly w" it was by vote granted."
opposition to the established authorities on November lo, 1661, when " he made objectio, agst the jurisdictio rate or charge, & against the Town Treasurer, for paying or allowing it to be paid to any out of the Town rates, upo that Acco'." He also complained that the town accounts were not audited, and, together with Thomas Stevens, "raised up offensive objections ag'st the Governor & Townsmen, for that sundry parts of the Towne goodes, or estates, were or seemed to be, taken away & not accounted for; instancing in dung fro Mr. Higginson's yarde, nameing about 20 loads so taken away belonging to the Towne."
Further complaints were that there had been a failure to account for rent for the Barn^ there," for " cloth bought with Town Apples and sold with advance of price," and for " Clapboards taken away from the jVIeeting House." It is suggested to one reading these charges and going over the whole controversy that there was some personal quarrel between Dr. Rossiter and Gov. Leete, for most of these charges are aimed at the latter. The charges were all answered, it is presumed, satisfactorily to the majority of the townspeople, for we hear no more of them.
Concerning the general controversy, which preceded the union with Connecticut, the town records give us no help, for they are blank from May, 1662, to February, 1665-6. There was doubtless too much to do to keep up records. Other sources, however, fill up the gap to some extent. In the early part of 1662, Dr. Rossiter and his son John, with sundry others, including Thomas Stevens, Richard Hubball, John Bishop, William Stevens, Thomas Cruttenden and John Sheather, " subscribed some offensive papers," a copy of which Thomas Stevens handed to Gov. Leete, and other copies of which were '' spread abroad to the disturbance of the peace of this jurisdiction."^
Dr. Rossiter was also in hot water for refusing to pay rates for his person and horse, on the ground of his being an allowed physician,' pleading such were exempted by the law of nations from personal service and their estates from rates and assessments, and that they were not required in the Bay, nor previously in New Haven, nor of him when he lived in Connecticut. The marshal was sent to collect these rates. Dr. Rossiter being away, his son, John Rossiter, told him " yt he did not question but his father would pay ye town rates (for he had heard his father say soe), if they would stay, while his father
'January 15, 1660-1, "Mr. Lccte propounded lo know w^ rent lie sliould pay for Mr. Higginson's Barn for 2 years, unto w'^^ many expressed themselves that they expected none and the rest present were silent " came home," and. further, " yt. if cattle would do, he did not question but they would be payd." However, when Dr. Rossiter came home, the marshal was told by him that " he would not pay it then, nor next morning neither." " Then ye marshall, he went away to take two cowes & told the men yt. was with him, which they was, &, as he turned away, he heard Jno Rossiter say, yt. they should haue noe cowes there & then came & tooke up an axe & went to the gate." The Governor thinking " it high time to suppress these things," gave a warrant to arrest the Rossiters and they were brought to his house. There Goodman Bartlett asked John Rossiter why his father had struck the marshal and was answered, " may he not resist a theife, when he comes into the yard to take away any cattle or goods, he would knock him downe." After this they were brought to New Haven and tried on May 7, 1662. The trial was more or less mixed up with the trial of the Rossiters and others for the writings already referred to. There were two of these writings, both of which are lost; but they probably contained a statement of grievances against New Haven, because that non-freemen were not allowed privileges and liberties. Dr. Rossiter, after consultation with Mr. James Fitch, wrote these and they were signed by those formerly mentioned.'
Next to the Rossiters, Thomas Stevens seems to have been the chief man in the business, and he was made to " confesse, yt. he now sees yt. he had done yt. which he ought not to haue done, nor should have done it, if hee had considered it, & yt. he was sorry for it, & desired to haue it passed by & confest, yt. he had grieued ye spirits of those, among whom he Hues." The other five men whose names were signed to the paper seem to have been mere submissive followers and to have had little idea of what they subscribed.
The Rossiters were not dealt with until May 28, when Mr. Allyn and Mr. Wyllys of Connecticut were present at court, " prtcnding to be friends to us and friends to peace, labouring with Mr. Rossiter & his son, to bring him to some acknowledgement of evill." As a result, after some time, the Court did " accept of ye acknowledgm't & p'mises of Mr. Rossef & his son John, .... together w*"^ their solemne engagem^ made not to act any thing of psecutio or molestation against court or courts, officer or officers, or other psons belonging to ye colony of Newhaven, anywhere, to disturb their peace." Dr. Rossiter's confession stated that, " whereas much trouble hath ensued upon his deniall of this present govcrm* of Newhaven, he did sec cause to owne,
' Tlie first ij.'ipcr was censured by tlic Court on May 29, t66i, and John Bcnham, who brought it to New Haven, made to beg pardon. - II. N. H. Col. Rcc. p. 403. The second paper was written later.
yt., in severall passages & expressions, he had been very rash & inconsiderate &, he could freely say, offensive & he was truly sorry that he had noe better rule of his owne spirit . . ., soe far as any writing hath been given forth by him to pmote any unjust or publicke disturbance &, for ye future, he resolves against the disturbance of the place & gouerm't." John Rossiter's confession is much the same, adding that he would acknowledge his fault, " according to rule, unto ye persons injured.'" The promise to submit to the government they did not keep long, if, as is probable, they were among the " severall inhabitants of Guilford, tendering themselves, their p'"sons, and estates under the Government and Protection " of Connecticut, in October, 1662. These persons Connecticut voted' it would " accept and owne, as members of this Colony, and shalbe ready to affoard what protection is necessary. . . . And this Court doth advise the said persons to carry, peaceably and religiously in their places, towards the rest of ye Inhabit'^^ that yet have not submitted in like manner. And also to pay their just dues, unto ye Minister of their Towne; and also all publique charges due to this day." This submission to Connecticut was doubtless caused by the arrival of her charter, dated April 23, 1662, which gave her the territory of New Haven Jurisdiction, at least by implication, and so might seem to release its inhabitants from their allegiance to the latter.
John Meigs was chosen constable over those submitting to Connecticut, and Connecticut's only answer to a letter,' written by New Haven on May 6, 1663, complaining of this, was to confirm Meigs in office, on May 14. Matters changed but little until December 9, 1663, when the New Haven General Court ordered " all members and inhabitants of this colony ... to returne to their due obedience and paying their arrears of rates for defraying the necessary charges of the Colony & other dues, within six dayes." * After the order was published at Guilford, Dr. Brian Rossiter, his son John, John Bishop and Isaac Crittenden hastened to Hartford, where they met the Council on December 28. Dr. Rossiter showed the Council this ordinance and complained " of some threatening expressions, that haue bin by some vented against divers, that have submitted " to Connecticut. The Council appointed Mr. Wyllys. John AUyn and Mr. Wait Winthrop to go to Guilford and treat with Gov. Leete. If no conclusion could at once be arrived at, they were to appoint another meeting at Middletown. If New Haven refused to treat with them, they were. " in his
Ma"" name & by order from the councill of this colony, to require them to forbear putting into execution there aforesaid declaration . . . &, allso, to administer the oath of a constable to John Meggs and to require him to use his utmost endeavor to mayntayne the peace of this colony, amongst those at Guilford that have joyned it." '
On the 30th of December, " with sundry young men " and the marshal, these members of the council accompanied " Rossiter & his son " to Guilford. The story is all told in the little pamphlet, " New Haven's Case Stated," written the next March. Connecticut " was countenancing them & their party, against the authority of this gener" court, though yow' knowe how obnoxious they were formerly to this jurisdiction, for contempt of authority & seditious practises, & that they have been the ringleaders of this rent, & that Bray Rossiter, the father, hath been long & still is a man of a turbulent, restless, factious spiritt, & whose designe you have cause to suspect to be to cause a warre between these two colonies, or to ruine New Haven Colonic; yet him yow accompanied in opposition to this colonic, without sending or writeing before to our governor to be informed concerning the trueth in this matter. Sundry horses, as we are informed, accompanied them to Guilford, whither they came at unseasonable houre, about tenn aclock in the night these short dayes, when yow might rationally thinke that all the people were gone to bed, & by shooting of sundry gunns, some of yo" or of theyr partie in Guilford allarmed the towne, w'^'^ when the governor took notice of, & of the unsatisfieing answer given to such as inquired the reason of that disturbance, he suspected, & that not without cause, that hostile attempts were intended by theyr company, whereupon he sent a letter to Newhaven to informe the magistrates there concerning matters at Guilford, that many were afifrighted, & he desired that the magistrates of Newhaven would prsently come to theyr succour & as many of the troopers, as could be gott, alleadging for a reason, his apprihension of theyr desperate resolutions. The governor's messenger also excited to haste, as apprehending danger & reporting to them that Brandford went up in armes, hastening to theyr reliefe at Guilford, wch the governor required with speed. Hereupon Newhaven was also allarmed that night by beating the drume, &c., to warne the towne militia to be readie."^ New Haven sent over six troopers with orders not to provoke disturbance by word or action ; but to keep the peace.' The fear, though " not causeless." was not justified by the results; for, besides threatening Gov. Leete, "that, if any thing was done against those men, i. e. Rosseter & his party, Connecticut would take it, as done against themselves," the party did nothing but ask for a conference with Gov. Leete, which he refused. The Connecticut men seem then to have retired. New Haven persistently refused to treat/ save on the precondition of Connecticut's '' redintegrating " the colony, " by restoring our members at Stamford and Gilford." Connecticut agreed to this on February 24, 1663-4, ordering her partisans " to submitt to ye same authority with their neighbors in those places."' This was not unsatisfactory to Dr. Rossiter, and on March 19, 1663-4, he addressed a petition to the Connecticut Assembly, pleading for a speedy decision in his favor," saying " if tenne dayes be your resolve, to a man perishing in a famine, it would prove a languishing return &, in the eighth day, you may p'bably invite to a funeral!. "* He had been forced to flee at midnight from Guilford to Hartford, and prays to have granted " my exspences in my city of refuge, making my escape to neighbors & friends." This, he says, " would be some small ease to a distressed mind & give occasion, in some degree, to speake well of you: Thoe my reall exspectation is for a full & an efifectuall & allowance to the injoym*. of the full benefitt of the law." His party was as much distressed as he, and on March 29, 1664. they send a petition from Guilford to the Connecticut Assembly. The spelling of this document is more wonderful than usual. The memorialists were afraid they would again be levied on for taxes and piteously cry, " if ye have no power to p'tect us from the injury of others, why did you admit us under the shadow of youre winges? & ingage to be reall in ptecting & defending our persons & estates? if you have power, why are not such solemn covenants fulfilled? why is it we are in danger to be surprised & damnified every day." Then turning to the Scriptures, the familiar Puritan storehouse of argument, they ask why did not Connecticut keep its agreement with them: "was not God's rath dredful against all Ezerall, &. especially Sals house therein, for breech of covenant with very slaves, who were before apoynted to destruction? did not Josua, the instrumental! saviour of Ezerall & a tipe of our greate Saviour, prsently march forth to the sucker, eaid. & releife of Gibon? and yt because of the covenant made with them." They go on to state that they had hopes of speedy relief when the magistrates from Hartford came down in December; "but our times . . . are in God's hand ... & it becomes us to weat his leasurc." Yet,
' February 16, 1663-4. A committee of 4 sent from Connecticut to Guilford and New Haven to treat, " grant and confirm to them all such privileges as they shall desire, which arc not repugnant to the tenor of our charter." - XV. Conn. Col. Rec. p. 540. 'II. N. H. Col. Rec. p. 516.
" yt. we may live as Christians & sit under our one vine & fig tree with peace and safety; we beg of yu to conseder our prsent streats." * This Connecticut could not do, after her agreement with New Haven, and on May 20, 1664, " Brayan Rosseter " sent in another petition. He says that he has made application, " at least tenn times," " for some redress of those insufferable inuries & pressures, the loade & burden under which I lye bowed downe," but had received no relief/ This petition also was unanswered, and, in despair, Rossiter and his party settled Kenilworth, or Killingworth, as it was later called, on the east side of the Hammonassett River. The rest of the Guilford people remained staunch to the New Haven Government until the end;' though but few of them were as bitter against union as the New Haven people were.
It was a heavy blow to the good people, it is true, to lose the old existence and to become an integral part of lax and grasping Connecticut, which had so long supported the stubborn faction of the Rossiters Yet but few^ were extreme enough to join Rev. Abraham Pierson and his Branford followers, and aid in establishing a new settlement, where the original severity of manners might be maintained. The majority, led by the wise and moderate William Leete, accepted the situation and tried to make the best of it. Guilford deputies appeared at the General Assembly at Hartford on May 11, 1665, and at that time Mr. Sherman and Mr. John Allyn were chosen to go to the four adjoining towns of the old New Haven colony and " administer the freeman's oath to al those that were formerly freemen there, or to so many of them as wil accept of it, and to as many others, as by suf^cient evidence, they may judge qualifeid according to law." ' For legal business, " Mr. Robert Kitchel and Georg Hubbard are chosen Comrs. for the towne of Guilford and are invested with magestraticall power, they taking their oaths, the one of freeman and both of Comrs. ; to assist in keeping court at Guilford ' . . . ; and the Towne of Guilford have hereby power to choose one or two selectmen to
* The signers to this were Thomas Clarke, Thomas Stevens, Thomas Cruttenden, Thomas Smith, William Stevens, Abraham Crittenden, George Hylend, Dennis Crampton, John Stevens, John Bishop, John Grave, John Hill, John Sheather, George Chatfield, Isaac Cruttenden, Henry Crane, John Meigs. (17) - II. N. H. Col. Rec. p. 539. ' II. N. H. Col. Rec. p. 540, dated at Hartford.
* February 26, 1665-6, Mr. Samuel Kitchel and Thomas Cooke were chosen to auditate and settell the last Jurisdiction Acounts and to make a divicion of the corTion stocke unto the severall plantations."
One reminiscence of the old life dragged on for some time, in a continuation of the quarrel with Dr. Rossiter. He moved back from Kenihvorth as stubborn and quarrelsome as ever. In the spring of 1665 he procured a summons for the appearance of Gov. Leete and Lt. William Seward before the court at Hartford ' to answer an " action of unjust molestation, mannadged in an hostil manner," because of their treatment of him, previous to the union. Upon this, Mr. Leete went over to New Haven, to see if the people would stand by him in upholding what he did as Governor of the colony. New Haven voted that he was justified;' but at a particular court held in Hartford, July 13, 1665, the court and jury gave Mr. Rossiter costs, but could not agree on a verdict for damages. The case was then appealed by Mr. Leete to General Court and heard on October 13, 1665, when the vote was that the suit was " included in the act of oblivion and Mr. Leet by that act indemnified." Three assistants and ten deputies, however, had their names put on record as opposed to this vote.* It was felt just that Dr. Rossiter should receive some recompense; so, considering the loss he " hath undoubtedly sustained, the many distractions and troubles that he hath passed throw both in his owne person and his family w'^ him." and on condition that no further trouble be given nor any more suits brought by him. the colony granted him £100. Of this sum New Haven, Guilford, Branford and I^Iilford were to pay i6o.^ This imposition on these four towns was, however, remitted in May, 1667. All persons were also forbidden to cause further trouble to Dr. Rossiter " about any matter referring to former administracon of Government."
Still peace did not come, and for some not very clearly known reason, probably having to do with his refusal to pay rates on himself and his horse," he was summoned before the County Court in October, 1668. This summons he refused to obey, claiming that it was not legal, and appealed to the Legislature. As he did not appear, a verdict was given against him, and after waiting until May, an execution issued, to avoid which he wrote to Gov. Winthrop on June 30, 1669. Singularly enough, according to Mr. Smyth, who searched the County Court records carefully, there is no reference to Mr. Rossiter at this court, and this letter contains almost all the information existing concerning the suit. Gov. Winthrop wrote to Gov. Leete at once, desiring him to stop the execution. This letter Gov. Leete answered on July 5, stating that the execution had been granted in May, when he was not present; that the writ had been already served, but he had obtained a postponement of the " apprisment & issue," though with some difficulty. Mr. Leete hints that he had not been as bitter against Mr. Rossiter as others who " are apt to wonder that Mr. Rossiter should so long be borne with while he goes on to trouble both County, Town & Cuntry with unnecessary pleas and papers so abusive.'"
" In the ship which arrived at Boston from London, the 27th of July, 1660, there came passengers Colonel Whalley and Colonel Gofife, two of the late King's judges," says Hutchinson. The Restoration had come and it was time for Commonwealth men to flee. These two pasengers had such a romantic connection with Guilford that it cannot be passed over, though part of the tradition is probably untrue. On March 7, 1 660-1, they arrived in the staunch Puritan Jurisdiction of New Haven, of which William Leete was Governor. They appeared publicly at first; but soon were forced to hide, through fear of the King's commissioners. Kellond and Kirk, two zealous royalists, were on their track like bloodhounds, and they must be straitly hidden. On May 11 these pursuivants arrived at Governor Leete's in Guilford to ask for authority to search for the judges. They had only the copy of the King's orders and a letter from Gov. Endicott with them. Gov. Leete did not act decidedly for them, as they had hoped, but, in the presence of several persons, he perused the papers and then " began to read them audibly, whereupon we told him," the messengers say, " it was convenient to be more private in such concernments as that was: upon which, withdrawing to a chamber, he told us he had not seen the two Colonels, not in nine weeks." They told him they had heard they were in New Haven since then and desired to be furnished with horses, &c, for their further progress, " which was prepared with some delays." They spoke to him of this and then, going out to the ordinary, they were met by Dennis Crampton, who, we have seen, had previously been sentenced to a whipping by Gov. Leete and may, therefore, have desired to revenge himself. He told them " he would warrant " that the colonels were then hidden at Mr. Davenport's and that Goodman Bishop " was able to give the like account and that, without all question. Deputy Leet knew as much." On hearing this and more of the same sort, they " went back to the Deputy's and required our horses, with aid and a power to search and apprehend them; horses were provided for us. but he refused to give us any power to apprehenfl them, or order any other, and said he could do nothing, until he had spoken witii one Mr. Gilbert and the rest of his magistrates." As Palfrey says, " it was now Saturday afternoon, and for a New England Governor to break the Sabbath, by setting ofif on a journey, was impossible." While they were parleying with Governor Leete, Dennis Crampton, as he afterwards told them, saw an Indian start off toward New Haven, presumably to give notice of the danger. That must have been an anxious and tediovis Sunday to Kellond and Kirk, and doubtless they were glad enough to get away on Monday morning. " But, to our certain knowledge," write they, " one John Meigs was sent a horse back before us, and by his speedy and unexpected going so early before day, was to give them an information; and the rather because by the delays was used, it was break of day before we got to horse; so he got there before us. Upon our suspicion, we required the Deputy, that the said John Meigs might be examined what his business was, that might occasion him so early going, to which the Deputy answered that he did not know any such thing and refused to examine him." Governor Leete himself was in so little haste that he arrived in New Haven two hours after the pursuivants, and so anxious to save the fugitives as to incur from the royal agents the blame of being " obstinate and pertinacious in contempt of his Majesty." Two of Governor Leete's remarks are worthy of preservation: when asked if "he would honor and obey the King or no in this affair," he said " we honor his Majesty, but we have tender consciences," and at the very end of the discussion he said in a moment of despair, he " wished he had been a ploughman and had never been in the ofifice, since he found it so weighty."^
Prest. Stiles says the Judges were twice in Guilford. The first visit he mentions on their way from Boston to New Haven is quite probable and is of little importance. The latter visit is much disputed and some of the details of the tradition are clearly wrong. Dr. Stiles thinks that, on June nth, fearing to bring down ruin on New Haven colony, the Judges went from their cave on West Rock to Guilford and put themselves in Gov. Leete's hands to be given up, if it should be judged expedient. " The Governor's house was situated on the eastern bank of the rivulet (West River) that passes through Guilford. He had a store on the bank a few rods from his house and under it a cellar,' remaining to this day. ... It is . . . still in the general and concurrent tradition at Guilford, that the Judges were concealed and lodged in this cellar several nights, most say three days and three nights, when the Governor was afraid to see them."' " Finally, their friends would not suffer them to surrender at this time, and it was concluded that they should retire again to their concealment. Upon which they returned to New Haven " and disappear from Guilford history. Dr. Stiles thinks they may also have been concealed at Dr. Rossiter's, because, on May 7, 1662, at General Court, mention is made of charges due him "about the Colonels"; but these were much more probably incurred in connection with the pursuit. In another point. Dr. Stiles makes a laughable mistake; Anna, daughter of Gov. Leete, who afterwards married Mr. John Trowbridge of New Haven, was born March 10, 1661-2. The Regicides were hidden, if at all, in June, 1661. Yet Dr. Stiles gravely says, that "it is an anecdote still preserved in that family that she used often to say that when she was a little girl these good men lay concealed some time in this cellar of her father's store ; but that she did not know it till afterwards : that she well remembered that at the time of it, she and the rest of the children were strictly prohibited from going near that store for some days, and that she and the children wondered at it and could not perceive the reason of it at that time, though they knew it afterwards. Tradition says that they were, however, constantly supplied with victuals from the Governor's table, sent to them by the maid, who long after was wont to glory in it, that she had fed those heavenly men."
Chapter Xi
A few years after the town was through with the difficulty with the Rossiters, it was involved in another with Mr. Thomas Robinson, Sr. The trouble here, like the case of Benjamin Wright, arose from taking up land " disorderly." Mr. Robinson had bought Mr. Caffinch's " accommodation," now owned by his descendants, and had fenced in land lying north and east of his outlot. This proceeding the town, on November 6, 1676, unanimously refused to ratify, and sent Thomas Cooke, Jr.,^ and William Stone to pull up his fence. They did this, and Robinson claimed that damage was thereby done" to him to the amount of £40. On June 7, 1677, the town voted to sue and prosecute Mr. Thomas Robinson, Sr., in an action on the case, for breaking the peace by oflfensive carriages, traducing, quarrelling with contemptuous and scandalous speeches against the Messenger of God's Word.^ Lt. William Seward and Deacon William Johnson were appointed the town's attorneys and authorized to call on the help of a lawyer, if need be, and the cost of the suit was to be paid by the town. Apparently the town won in the county court, for in October, 1677, on Mr. Robinson's petition for a rehearing " for the farther quiating of the disquiat spirit of the petitioner, and that there may be a finall issue of the case and be fully convinced of his irregularities, . . . grant him liberty to review the same at New Haven Court in November next." This caused the town to vote, on November 6, 1677, that Lt. William Seward and Deacon William Johnson should act as the town's attorneys, " both as plaintive and defendive, in any action or actions that they shall judge necessary for the town's good, until the town see cause to call in their power again."
We hear no more of the suit until October, 1681, when the General Assembly was petitioned by Mr. Robinson that " those differences that he hath with the towne of Guilford about pulling down of fence," and with William Stone, of which more hereafter, be referred to Mr. Daniel Buckingham and Mr. Samuel Eells. Mr. Robinson " hath
' Rev. Joseph Eliot. Was it then that Wm. Stone boarded Thos. Robinson, Sr., for two weeks for which the Town paid him on January 30, 1683-4?
given under his hand that he engage . . . that he will abide by and stand to their issue and never make any more trouble, suit, or complaint about the same for the future." The Court recommended to Guilford and Stone to take this method of ending the difficulty, instructed the arbitrators to " attend rules of justice and equity," and recommended that the case be tried as soon as possible. These recommendations were published at a Guilford town meeting on December 28, 1681, together with a letter from the Court of Assistants, dated December i6, and one from Messrs. Buckingham and Eells. The town took these letters into consideration, chose the selectmen Deacon Wm. Johnson, Mr. Josiah Rosseter, Mr. John Grave and Abraham Fowler to examine the matter and report at the next town meeting, and directed the recorder, with the selectmen, to inform Messrs. Buckingham and Eells of the town's action. On February 21, 1681-2, the town voted, in adoption of a report of the committee, that, though they had thought the case finally settled, as it had been heard by several courts, " yet notwithstanding, seeing the Hon*^ General Court have recommended it," the town is willing to have the case reopened, if notified of the time of hearing. " The Town will be ready to open the true state of the case, and answer Mr. Robinson's allegations & when you have heard the case, if then you shall hold forth any further light, differing from the judgements of the several courts, the Towne will be willing to consider their duty and act accordingl}'."' The referees came to Guilford, heard the case and the General Assembly at the May session ordered the parties to be satisfied with the decision, whatever it may have been.'
Provenance
Text from A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive. The settlements listed against this township are matched by point-in-polygon test of each Geographic Names Information System coordinate against the Census Bureau's county subdivision boundary, not by name.