BlockBefore

Guilford Town (part 11 of 15)

Part 11 of 15 of the account of this town in A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897. 15,885 words, covering 8 settlements. Source changes inside the text are labelled at the exact paragraph where the next book begins.

Contents

2 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter, on this part. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

15 pages

The source prints this as one continuous account. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs straight on across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The chapter

15,885 words

Reproduced complete and unedited from A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897. The text is machine-read from scans, so expect recognition errors: misspelled names, dropped words, and stray characters. Nothing has been corrected, because correcting a proper name invents one. The headings below are the books' own; source changes are labelled in place.

It does not appear that the presentment by the grand jurors was acted upon. It is probable that a partial pacification was brought about; for in April, 1730, at the County Court, Edmund Ward and 10 of his flock appeared, took the oaths, and the declaration prescribed for " sober dissenters " and Rev. Mr. Ward himself assented to the 39 articles, save the 34th, 35th and 36th and part of the 20th.' On April 20th the minority again wrote to Mr. Moss and he answered their letter the next day, saying: " You have gained the point at the County Court and that layeth an almost infallible foundation for your gaining the point in the General Court in May next; either to be set ofif with parochial bounds, or that which is really better for you viz: to be delivered from paying rates to support a minister that is none of your choosing, but imposed upon you by virtue of a law of the Government, which is void in itself, as being contrary to Christ's institutions, as I have proved in the enclosed paper, which I have sent with a design to answer some scruples of conscience, yt may be with some good men, yt may be among you, concerning incorporating into church estate, without being set off by the General Court." If the paper is not enough, he " will write more upon that head. You may depend upon my drawing your memorial to the General Court . . . and I am. almost assured, I shall gain the point for you; for they dare not deny it, when I shall prove it by plain arguments, that, if they deny it, it will amount to persecution and that, under colour of a law which is contrary to the Law of England - so contrary to the charter & contrary to the laws of Christ also - & the leading men know that I can make this appear at White Hall & before the whole world.' You need not mind the insults of your little adversaries at home, for I hear from all quarters abroad, that the scale is turning in the Country & that the great men, both civil & sacred, seem to be less smart in their opposition to you & some of them begin to condemn your adversaries & to justify & plead for the righteousness of your cause." In a long postscript he recommends that from 9 to 10 o'clock every Friday until the meeting of General Court, " all the serious Christians in your party, with as much secrecy as possible . . . each one by himself, spend the time in prayer for the success of your petition." The paper enclosed by this ofBcious clergyman, who seems always to try to add fuel to the flames, is quite long. His argument is that, (I) that must be " lawful which is agreeable to the institutions of Christ, . . . discoverable by the apostolical practice," i. e., " when a number of men . . . were converted, . . . they were incorporated into a Church estate by an agreement among themselves, . . . which agreement as to the choosing & settling a pastor over them was always universal (unanimous), . . . For there was no civil magistrate in all the Christian world for 300 years after Christ, . . . that made the choice of a majority . , . sufficient to force a minister upon their brethren. . ." (II) That choice by a majority " sets up a minister to be a Lord over God's heritage," . . . contrary to " My Kingdom is not of this world, etc," from which text the Lord Bishop of Bangor' . . . learnedly proves . . . that no civil power upon earth hath any authority to make any laws about ecclesiastical matters." He then sketches the Bangorian controversy and concludes with quoting the course of the first settlers, who " did not think they needed any help from human laws for 40 years together after their first coming into this land."

On May 14, 1730, the minority presented to the General Court the memorial composed by Mr. Moss. After reciting their previous course, they beg to be freed from paying any rates or charges to the I St Society from the preceding May, for (i) this freedom has been granted to all other societies of dissenters; (2) to deny the "request will . . . amount to the imposition of a minister upon us by a human law " and part of Mr. Moss's former argument is quoted to prove this improper; (3) the law they desire to be freed from " is not warrantable by our charter, because it is contrary to the laws of England. . . For as much as the laws of England . . . doth not oblige any one party of dissenters ... to pay money to support the clergy of any other party that dissent from the Church of England," as the Connecticut law does. (4) " That which we complain of, is an hardship & yoke of bondage, which was never put on the necks of our fathers, . . . nor is now imposed on the necks of our brethren at Boston, nor in all the province of New York & the Jersies, & the Colony of Rhode Island, nor on our dissenting brethren in England itself." This flimsy and remarkable argument was sent with another petition repeating for the third time the request to be made a separate society and dated May 30, 1730. Both houses "passed in the negative"' the latter petition, but voted to free the minority from paying taxes to the ist Society. There is no record of any meeting of the old society to oppose either of these petitions.

A short time' after their establishment as " sober dissenters," Mr. Samuel Leete, who lived on the north end of the Green, gave the new societv a small tract of land for a meeting-house, as long as it should be used for such purpose and no longer, provided he should have his choice of a pew in the meeting-house, to be a free estate for him and his heirs forever.'

The dissenting party at once set about building tlieir meeting house and proceeded with so much energy that, on November 30, 1730, Messrs. Moss and ]\Iather write that they " have now built a good new meeting house at their own charge."

On October 5, 1730, the ist Society met and voted that it understood onlv the 11, who had appeared at County Court, were exempted from paving taxes by the General Court, ordered taxes to be collected from * all others, and appointed a committee of three to represent the Society before the Assembly, if necessar)-. On October 8 the minority send a petition to the General Assembly, asking leave " to embody ourselves in Church Estate & to get a teacher ordained by the assistance & under the conduct of such ministers and churches, as we can prevail with to assist in that affair, altho' the next neighboring ministers & churches should decline." They also complain of the harsh action of the ist Society in regard to levying taxes and, to avoid all doubt, beseech that the Assembly give freedom from ecclesiastical taxes to all their members. Thirdly, they ask that all in the future, who shall separate from the 1st Society and take the oaths as dissenters, be also freed from ecclesiastical taxes to the ist Society. The Legislature, says Trumbull, "fixed in their idea of uniting the parties, were slow & reluctant in granting them any privileges," and " appointed a large council to meet in Guilford to hear the parties & judge between them & make report to the Assembly " " the next May. Soon aftenvards the dissenting party applied to Mr. Moss for help and, on November 23, 1730, he writes them, enclosing a letter to be sent to the clergymen in Boston, and which he desires them to get signed also by Rev. Azariah Mather of Saybrook. If he is unwilling to sign, Mr. Moss wishes " another visit " from " Mr. Ward, or some other of your leading men," to plan

* 57 Rrantecs arc mentioned, of whom 18 were not signers of the second petition. * .\ most unjustifiable action. 'Trumbull's Conn. II, p. 119.

Other measures. If Mr. Mather sign, then minute directions are given: copies of all important papers are to be gotten, wrapped all up together carefully, sealed " well under a general wrapper of good thick paper," superscribed to Rev. Mr. Thacher, and " it will be a handsome thing for you to write a few lines yourselves in the wrapper, craving help & advice from the Rev*^ Gentlemen & telling them that our letter hath stated your case as it is . . , and you must put in some money, three or four shillings, to pay the postage , . . that the Gentlemen may not be burdened with the postage, and keep copies of all the letters sent, you may improve young Mr. Nortoji,^ your scribe, for copies for he writes well and quick . . . that is, I mean, if the work of writing being pretty large, be too much a burden to Capt. Ward or Mr. Ward, or any other scribe." He tells them they must exercise faith and patience and all will come out aright; but " I don't wonder some of you are desponding and ready to give up the cause as hopeless." He quotes David's long probation and Ezekiel's vision of wheels within wheels and says, " It seems to me, brethren, that there may be many wheels of the Revolutions of Divine providence moving for your good & for your help, that neither you nor yet your enemies yet perceive." He then refers to the fact that the second temple was 46 years building, and closes with a promise to continue to pray and work for them. It seems to me that Rev. Mr. Moss was largely responsible for the success of the schism in the Guilford church.

The enclosed letter, from which we have already often quoted, gave a sketch of the history of affairs, stated that the ist Society, " the neighboring ministers and mostly thro' the colony . . . are greatly clamoring at & reproaching a few of us, that think well of them and are inclined to pity and help them." The letter was sent to have " advice & council from some of the Rev'd Ministers of Boston, whose names & characters are highly exalted among us in Connecticut ... so that your countenancing the affair of their settlement in ch. order & ordination of their minister will very much abate the clamours of their adversaries & be much of a shelter & screen to some of us that probably may be called on to assist them in that office." Consequently two questions are propounded: (i) Whether the narration given in the letter being true, it be proper for the dissenting party " to embody into church estate & get their minister ordained," and (2) Whether it be proper for other churches and ministers to assist therein.

an answer, which was looked forward to as a thing of so much consequence, should have been lost, so that not only nothing of it should be found, but that no allusion to it should be made in the many communications of the two societies. If an answer was ever returned it is probable that it advised the two parts of the society to call a mutual council to agree upon some plan of peace. It appears that soon afterwards a communication from the minority to the majority was made, which is lost as is its answer,* but the reply following thereupon is preserved and is in the handwriting of Mr. Edmund Ward. It begins by stating that the answer of the ist Society had complained of the paper sent it, " as very deficient in point of Clerkship, in so much that you pretend that it is ambiguous and unintelligible to you; to which we reply that we cannot believe, but you fully understand what we desire & ask of you, . . . but readily acknowledge that we are not so accurate in clerkship as perhaps many are in your party, who are known to yourselves & others roundabout to be superior men to us, both in natural & acquired abilities." They return no answer to the first two enquiries of the ist Society's letter whatever they were. In answer to the 3d enquiry, " the purport of which is to know of us, what favor & assistance we desire of you, in order to our settlement, which you say we have not so much as hinted at in our letter ... we think you cannot but understand what we would; . . . but, if you must have it in the plainest perhaps imaginable, we then say that our society, whose name & character are known upon the County Court Records at New Haven & upon the Gen'l Court Records at Hartford; whom the law owns to be a lawful Ecc'l Society, ... we are desirous of embodying into a church & to get our teacher ordained according to Gospel order, &, therefore, desire your good will & favor in that matter." The 4th enquiry, probably another proposal for union, receives this answer, " you cannot but know what our different sentiments are, that make it impracticable for you & us to unite in one society ... so long as you have gotten a man set over you as your Pastor (whom we desire & pray he may do much good among you), yet is so unacceptable to us that we cannot in conscience set down under his pastoral charge & care." On February 18, 1730-1, " at a meeting of the new society," it was voted to apply to Rev. Messrs. Joseph Moss of Derby, Azariah Mather of Saybrook, Jonathan Merrick of North Branford. and Seth Shove of Danbury to come with messengers on the 2nd Wednesday of March, " and assist in advising & counselling us, under present difiliculties, what may be our duty, always provided our brethren of the old Society choose the like number of Rev'd Divines with their mes- sengers, to join in said counsel & advice." The ist Society, probably, did not accept this proposition for a mutual council and, on March 10, 1 730-1, the great council appointed by the Legislature, in October, 1730, met at Guilford. It does not appear from the records at whose instance they were convened. Prior to the plan for a mutual council, ''the new society," on February 16, 1730-1, drew up a narrative to lay before the General Council. By this they " endeavor to clear ourselves of that aspersion cast upon us not only by our brethren, but others, of our being disorderly, wilful, heady, & factious company, governed wholly by our perverse wills & not by a good conscience in our seeking to be a separate society."

They then rehearse the case, how Mr. Ruggles "was not such an edifying preacher " to them and how no other man was tried " as a probationer for any small time," how they were a minority and though unable to prevent the distasteful settlement, were " willing that our brethren should have a minister, that was so agreeable & acceptable to them." How they petitioned for a dismission and got it, " provided the General Court would allow it (which without doubt they would if our brethren had not opposed it in court & blocked up our way all they could)"; how they separated themselves, hired Mr. Edmund Ward to preach for them, and did not join in Mr. Ruggles' call. How Mr. Ruggles was ordained over the whole church and so made " a Lord over God's heritage," if they are included, and, if they are not, that they " were left as sheep without a shepherd scattered upon the mountains, and, surely, it can't be disorderly for us to seek a settlement "; how they had twice petitioned the General Court to be made a separate society and had failed through the ist Society's opposition; how they had then taken advantage of the law about dissenters. Tliey state that their minister, Mr. Edmund Ward, is to them " an edifying Gospel minister, who hath ministerial gifts and graces, also, so far as we are able to judge, & in this matter of gifts & graces, we have the opinion of some Revd ministers, whom we value & esteem capable judges & we know his conversation is good & as becomes the Gospel." They desire him ordained and they beseech the council not to hinder but to advance that end.^

Tlie narrative of the " Dissenting Party " and a declaration of the 1st Society were presented to the Council; members of both parties appeared and testified, and other papers, not specified, were considered. The Council decided: (i) that they " cannot but approve of" the " sev-

' Thus addressed to the " Rev. Council now sitting." Did the council hold a preliminary sitting then or rather was the paper drawn up in anticipation of their meeting but not dated forward?

eral steps" of the ist Society in settling and ordaining INIr. Ruggles." & judge them " very agreeable to such rules as . . . they ought to regard & haue their eyes upon"; (2) that they judge "insufficient" the reasons alleged by the Dissenting Party for their separation, and consider "that separation as sinful & justly offensive"; (3) that the dissenting party, " in setting up a separate assembly for public worship, without the countenance & liberty of the General Assembly or approbation of Neighboring churches, or the allowance of the settled ministry' of the place, & contrary to the advice of the association of the county, we judge to be disorderly & sinful & disallowed by the 5th article in the 13th chapter of the Cambridge platform,"' and that their qualifying themselves as " sober dissenters " under the colonial law, "was an abuse of that law & unjustifiable"; (4) "After an invitation, made by this Council & the said church, to those dissenting brethren ... to return to the Communion," if " they do not in some reasonable time do so, that they shall be suspended from the Communion of the Ch. of Christ, which sentence shall be pronounced against them, either by Rev. Mr. Ruggles & church, or by the Rev. Jacob Heminway & j\Ir. Tared Elliott in conjunction with them"; (5) that the Council do " declare & judge them, the sd. dissenting brethren, incapable of entering into a church state until such time as they have returned back to their Pastor & Brethren of the church from which they have separated themselves, with such reflections on themselves as this council have thought proper, and, if any ministers & churches shall assist in so embodying them ... it will be disorderly & sinful " ; (6) they find " a separate meeting for public worship set up by the Dissenting party in this place a disorderly assembly, do judge that Mr. Edmund Ward preaching to sd. assembly is disorderly & sinful and will be so, if he persists therein, & by the authority of this council, do charge him to desist preaching to them & that he do not presume to submit to ordination, or take upon him the pastoral charge"; (7) " Finally, whereas some reflections have been cast upon the Revd Mr. Ruggles, as though he were weak, insufficient, unworthy, & unqualified for the work of Gospel, unsound in his doctrine, of a party spirit & little religion, this council declares that nothing of this nature hath appeared to us, he having given us a specimen of his ministerial abilities - partly from his personal acc|uaintance & partly from credible testimony, we esteem him a worthy minister of Jesus Christ, endowed with a good measure of ministerial gifts, sound in the faith, of a serious, religious & peaceable spirit - a sweet temper - a becoming conversation and worthy of honour & respect." Trumbull says this was " an extraordinary result," and that the " dissenting party considered the Council as having no more authority over them, than they had over any church in Massachusetts, or New York, or of any other place, or denomination." They refused to obey its commands and continued to meet and listen to Mr. Ward's sermons."

The 1st Society proceeded according to the directions of the Council. Soon after this their collector, Samuel Collins, enforced the taxes of the dissenters. On March 26, 1731, Mr. Samuel Leete's tax was collected by warrant, as were probably others.

I. That they be declared a " lawfull Ecc'l assembly & their teacher, Edmund Ward, a lawful Ecc'l teacher to them." This they beg because the council, whom they think " have got a little beyond their own province " in determining " the meaning of the statutes of the land," have declared them " disorderly."

II. That the Guilford dissenters may embody into church estate, without lying " exposed to any punishment, as breakers of the laws of government, nor for rebellion toward the governing powers therein."*

III. That " this Hon. Court would please not frown upon, discountenance, much less punish any minister or church that may . . . help & assist this people in the concerns of their settlement in church order." '

IV. " That, if this Hon. Court do not see cause to indulge us with the grant of these things, ... it is our humble prayer to them to find out . . . some other way for us to be a separate society . . . that we may not be forced to be one with our brethren again, whose sentiments about the government of the ch. so widely differ from us (this by the

^Trumbull, II, pp. 126-127. He says the dissenting party contained over onehalf the church members. This is incorrect; at no time do they seem to number more than a third, which was what they claimed to be when incorporated

' This they pray for, because the council forbade their embodying into church estate. They claim that " such an assembly as we . . . are, whom the law could protect from insulting disturbers and was secure from the penal laws made against unlawful assemblies, might lawfully so do and get their minister ordained."

' This is asked for, " because our adversaries do industriously spread reports, . . . that any ministers or churches, that shall assist us therein, incur the frowns of the Gov't and are counted as rebells, which maketh some afraid to help us, who think well of us."

Alas, it seems that the General Court took no notice of this petition, but left them " to the mercy of their persecuting brethren "! On June 24. 1731, the ist church and pastor gave notice to the dissenting members to return to communion, pursuant to the order of the Ecclesiastical Council. A notice to Mr. Andrew Ward and his wife is preserved, w'hich states that, unless they return to communion with the 1st church on or before June 30. they will be suspended from' "the conmnmion of the Church of Christ." J\Iany, if not all, refused the invitation and Rev. Messrs. Heminw^ay and Eliot having come over on June 30, sentence of suspension from the church was pronounced on 21 men and 25 women for "having, without justifying reasons, withdrawn yourselves from the worship & communion," and having, "by means justly offensive & sinful, continued and strengthened yourselves in your separation."

At the time of Mr. Ruggles' ordination there were about 80 males, members of the church, and, doubtless, there were as many females, so " that this list contained about one-quarter of the members of the church, and not six more than one half. This," writes Mr. Smyth, " is a specimen of the manner in which Trumbull, wath his biased mind, viewed the dissention at Guilford." The movement of the majority, following the direction of the council, was calculated greatly to injure the minority in the community, and, for the purpose of strengthening themselves in their present position, they applied to their old friend. Rev. Joseph Moss, who, for the last time, gave them his advice. His opinion, addressed " to whom it may concern," was dated Derby, July 16, 1731. In his letter he states "that, in my opinion, the Rev^ Mr. Thomas Ruggles hath not a pastoral care over those ancient members of the church at Guilford, w^ho were never active in choosing & calling him. but always protested against it . . . &, inasmuch as a considerable number of such persons . . , are become a lawful Ecc'l Society, . ... & haue a lawful teacher, that preacheth the gospel to them, who is a man of ministerial gifts, of a good life & free from scandal, that, therefore, it is a lawful thing in them to seek for an ordination of their teacher ... & consequently, that it is lawful & agreeable to the common rules of charity for any minister or churches to assist them in that

' This is sought for, " lest we be kept to the mercy of our persecuting brethren at liotiic: . . . this wc can not bear . . . &, when all the king's subjects enjoy full liberty of conscience, we cannot but count it very hard measure to be singled out to tyranny and oppression, not by our civil rulers, but by our brethren under the conduct of some ecc'l men."

On September 27, 1731, at Hartford, a memorial was draw^n up to be presented to the October session of the Assembly. It is signed by six men, all prominent clergymen, and " in consideration of the Distressed circumstances of the Dissenting party in Guilford," recommends the appointment " of some of each Association in this Colony," as had been done in the case of the Stratford Church, " to enquire into that case in order to bringing matters to a comfortable issue, , . . in their enjoyment of a distinct Christian Society," since there is no prospect of reunion. About the 14th of October another source of assistance was found. Then fourteen "of the ist Society" petition the General Court, " considering . . . the sorrowful conditions that are amongst us and that there is no prospect of a happy reunion . . . whether it may not be for the interest of religion, & the peace & good agreement of the parties, for the dissenting party to be made a distinct ecc'l society & that liberty be given for others to join with them, & be freed from other ministerial charges."

The Assembly listened to the former petition ' and, " Observing that the Society in Guilford having not come into the Established Platform of Church Discipline, as allowed & confirmed by the lazvs of this Colony, and more especially that the dissenting party . . , have . . . declared their dissent from said platform ... & thence, suppose they cannot be holden, nor obliged to abide by the determination of any association so appointed, . . . this assembly consider that it is not reasonable . . . to oblige, or direct, the several associations ... to send their delegates to hear the said Society and dissenting party. . . . Yet, nevertheless, if the dissenting part . . . shall themselves move the elders of the several associations in this Gov't to send their delegates to consider of the difficulties, that have arisen ... at the proper charge of the dissenting party, that then this Assembly advise that the several Associations appoint & send delegates to Guilford, giving suitable notice to all parties, concerning the time of their meeting &, being met, that they use all proper measures and endeavors, to bring each party to a sense of any errors they find them to have been in & to endeavor to moderate their tempers & bring said Society into Christian love, Peace, & unity." If the delegates fail they are directed to report with recommendations to the Assembly at its next session. The minor part did make the application and the delegates from the associations convened at Guilford, November 23, 1731. On November 24 the ist Society chose a committee of nine to represent it before " the Gen'l Association now convened," and the new Society appointed a similar committee of four, who drew^ up a statement on the next day, reiterating former complaints. The General Association heard the parties and then, being not agreed in their opinion with respect to the difificulties, adjourned to meet in Hartford during election week. There is no evidence as to their meeting again and they certainly made no report to the Assembly.^ Consequently, on May 15, 1732, Caleb and Peletiah Leete, for the minor party, petition the Legislature again to be made a distinct society to be freed from paying taxes to the ist Society, and that Edmund Ward, their minister, might be freed from paying all taxes, as other clergymen are. The Legislature, the same month, appointed Matthew Allyn, Roger Wolcott, and Capt. John Marsh, " at a cost of the minor party," to repair to Guilford, " hear those parties ... & endeavor to reconcile them " and, if this be impossible, to report with recommendations to the next session of the Assembly, and ordered " that no distraint be made upon the minor party for taxes, for the support of the worship of God," before October, provided they apply to the council before July. At the notice and request of the minor party, on an unknown date, the committee met in Guilford and heard both parties. The first Society, on June 6, 1732, appointed a committee of six to represent it before the committee. A report was made by two of the committee to the Assembly in October. This states the case briefly and fairly, tells us ' " The Minor Party have built a Meeting House," 55 by 36 feet, " and almost glazed & finished it on the inside, the Pulpit is built &: the floor laid," and that " both the parties declare themselves to be of the Congregational principles, religiously adhering to the Platform printed 1649." This last overthrows the minor party's dissenting plea completely. We learn that " the list of them that hear Mr. Ruggles, in 1 73 1, was £9144.18.4 and of which are sundry' members who declare they had rather be with Mr. Ward, whose list come to £521. The list of those that hear Mr. Ward is £3001.13.6." The continued refusal of the Assembly to make the minority a distinct society and the distraining them for taxes to support Mr. Ruggles were real grievances and were, of course, laid by them at the door of the ist Society, who denied having any share in the former grievance. The committee, very sensibly, conclude by saying, " we are of opinion that the minor party is so considerable & that they have such an aversion to Mr. Ruggles that

'Trumhiill. II. 131; Conn. Col. Rcc. VI, 416. Trumbull is wrong. Mr. Allyn cither did not come to Guilford or for some reason failed to sign the report.

'tis not likely that the forcing them to sit under his ministry will have any good effect. We rather think the allowing them to be a distinct society will be the likeliest way to restore peace and order . . . and we know not of anything that might hinder the Assembly from giving them that liberty, but an Ecclesiastical Censure that so many of them are under, and whether that censure was right ... or wrong , , . your committee think it is not proper for them to determine ; but . . . since it is pronounced, we think those, against whom it is given, are not proper persons to embody into church estate 'till it be removed." Therefore, the committee recommend the appointment of another council finally to " determine upon it, & if such council shall revoke (the) sentence, or affirm it in whole or in part, & their sentence be complied with, upon application of the minor party to the Assembly they be immediately allowed to be a distinct society . . . &, in the meantime, be no further taxed towards Mr. Ruggles' maintenance." In regard to previous taxation no recommendation is made. The report was approved by both houses and the recommendations of the committee adopted. The Legislature decided previously laid taxes must be paid. Only four of the eight ministers invited to the Council and five messengers came to Guilford on November 21 and 22, 1732. Both parties appeared before the Council. The minority said, unanimously, that they could not comply with the directions of the Council of March and presented a paper justifying themselves: (I) Their separation from the majority was not censurable for: (i) " It was no breach of any moral law of righteousness . . . for the major part, granting us liberty to be distinct, did at least release us from that." (2) " It cannot appear that we broke " any " rule of Religion," . . . till the majority can clear themselves of being causers of division ... by refusing the motion to choose another minister, in hopes of a greater unanimity." (3) If the minority's conduct be said to be " scandalous schism " and breach of " the law of the state," they point to more than one Church in Boston, to the South Church in Hartford, " nay the first churches in this country & all of them succeeding," as precedents for separating from unwelcome preaching. (II) " The Council censuring us had no authority so to do, but what they themselves assumed," the Guilford church never having acceded to the Saybrook Platform. (Ill) " The manner of the Council's procedure seems very failing: (i) too high," c. g.. " We require you in the name of Christ, the King of the Church to appear." (2) " Hasty & without the air ... of that love . . . with which divisions were wont to be removed in apostolic times.'' (3) " without previous citation or conviction of some of those censured." Furthermore some of the council were disqualified because of having prejudg-ed the case. The paper ends by stating that " the difficukies of the minoritv are indeed dreadful in themselves, their sufferings are in their names & estates & then finally in their souls, the spiritual food thereof denied them."

Rev. Mr. Ruggles and the church were asked to reply to this and denied the authority of this new council, for reasons to be learned later on. The council overruled this plea and the church " refused to submit the case ... by which the Council was laid under a disadvantage as to discovering the reasons & grounds upon which the Ch. & council judged the withdrawing ... & the means they used to continue and strengthen themselves in sd. separation justly offensive and sinful." From what the Council could learn, they decided " that their withdrawing from the worship & communion of the Church & continuance therein was (not?) so gross & criminal as to deserve their exclusion from the Church of Christ. Yet we think they had not justifying reasons for so doing; but were faulty & disorderly and failed of . . . suitable endeavors to keep the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace, which we think it becomes them . . . candidly to confess, according to a draught drawn for them by this council, which we hope the Rev. Mr. Ruggles & the Church . . . will accept, upon its being signed by those that lie under the censure & . , . being publicly read in his congregation." The confession^ read as follows: " We . . . acknowledge, from a sense of the corruption that is in our hearts, we have reason to suspect, that we have in many things been faulty in the eyes of a holy God, both in words & actions, relating to the contentions that have been amongst us & just reason to suspect, we had not such grounds for our withdrawing from the worship & communion of this Church & continuing therein, as will excuse us from fault in our so doing & some of us may have failed of paying a suitable respect to the officers of Christ Sc messengers of his churches and, wherein we have failed in these or any other respects, we are heartily sorry for it & humbly ask forgiveness of God and request the charity of the Rev, Mr. Ruggles & the Church in this place & all who have been offended at any speeches or doings of ours, during this sad day of temptation that hath been anif»ng us. and we heartily desire the restoring of peace and brotherly love between us and that we may for the future walk together as it becomes those that are one in Christ, though we may attend the worship of God in distinct assemblies." This was signed by 43 of the excommunicated members ' and handed to Mr. Ruggles on December

I. The confession was laid before the church by him and rejected by it, and on December 28, 1732, the ist Society voted to lay no tax for the settlement or support of Mr. Ruggles until it be definitely known who are excepted from paying such taxes, but that any one may pay voluntarily, what he " can conveniently," and have the sum credited against him when the tax be laid.

At the May session of the Assembly, 1733, the ist Society protested* against the acceptance of the council's report, because: (I) " The General Assembly hath no power or authority to impose any decisive council upon any Church of Christ," by law of God and, if by law of man, the church would ** ofTend the Kingly power of Jesus Christ, our only Lord & Lawgiver, by submitting thereto." (II) The charter gives the Assembly no "power to call synods & councils." (Ill) The case had been decided by the council of March 10, 1731, called by the church. If the church should submit to the second council it would be " a betraying ye right of churches to call in the help of councils." (2) The second council, if it acted by authority from Christ, had no more power than the first council and so could not sit in judgment upon it; if by the authority of the law, it had less authority than the former council. (3) The tendency of permitting a council to judge the acts of another is evil, as tending to set up " altar against altar," " separate ministers, divide the churches, and introduce confusion." The former council should have been summoned to vindicate itself, if its conduct was to be passed in review by the latter. (4) The Saybrook Platform of 1708 states that it shall not prevent any allowed society, not agreeing with it, " from exercising worship and discipline in their own way," and the ist church being such an one, " ought to enjoy the privilege reserved to them, which privilege they are deprived of if a Council be imposed on them & vested with power to revoke their acts."

They plead that the Council of March 10, 1731, is binding on the minority, though they " did not consent & concur in calling " it: (i) for they declined an invitation to do so and to choose one-half the council; (2) and they had no right to claim the privilege of joining in calling it, for they were members of the church, which need not obtain " the consent of the brethren supposed to be under delinquency."

Further (i) the recent council had only one-half of its members present; (2) refused to hear the statement of the church unless it " would acknowledge their authority to judge and decide on the case," which it could not do; (3) did not order an a])ology and confession sufficient for tlic faults tln-v found in the niini)ritv.'

The protest, however, was useless ; the Assembly had sensibly arrived at the conclusion that it was a vain effort to try to unite the two parties and, as Trumbull ' says, " after a contention of between four & five years, great irritations & alienations between brethren & neighbours, & great expense of time & money before courts. General Assembly, & councils, a final separation was made in the Church and Town," and the 4tli Society in Guilford was established with the same bounds as

The new society seems to have been immediately organized and the 4th Church soon after. The ist Society met on June 29, 1733, reorganized, and laid a rate for Mr. Ruggles' salar^^ About this time the ist church accepted the acknowledgments made by the excommunicated persons, who formed the 4th church, and subsequently dismissed members to them in the spirit of Christian kindness and courtesy.

The Rev. Edmund Ward was ordained over the 4th Church on September 21, 1733, the sermon being preached by Rev. John Graham of Southbury, from the text, " And that from a child thou hast known the Holv Scriptures." ' ]\Ir. Ward was the ninth child and fifth son of Capt. Andrew Ward, Jr., and was born in Guilford," September 22, 1706. His mother was Deborah, daughter of Jacob Joy of Fairfield and Killingworth. He was graduated at Yale College in 1727, studied divinity for a few months, then preached for a year in the Presbyterian churches of Rye and White Plains, N. Y. Then he returned to Guilford to enter the ecclesiastical fray there. Before he had been pastor for two years he was, to quote Mr. Smyth's words, " arraigned & charged with certain acts of grossly licentious & scandalous conduct, to which he did not directly plead not guilty and witnesses were also examined & testimony brought forward, as to certain miscarriages in his study and during a pleasure party to Long Island, which charges were considered so fully proved " by a council that met in the summer of 1735, " that he was dismissed from said church & society & silenced from acting any longer as a Gospel minister." On February 4, 1734-5' Rev. John Graham wrote a letter regretting his inability to come to Guilford and visit the 4th Church, and congratulating them in being " so well provided for in a person of so good character ° and under the advice of sundry ministers," and says that Mr. Ward speaks falsely in stating that Mr. Graham never gave him any private advice; for. writes Mr. Graham. " my public charge & advice to him . . . was little to what I said to him in private, and the hints I had received concerning some of his former conduct . . . were such as I thought in justice obliged me to it. ... I think he has disgraced the sacred office & cast such scandalous reflections ... on the ministers in general that it is high time for him to stop." On March 12, 1734-5, Rev. Timothy Edwards of East Windsor writes, answering a letter of the 4th Church, dated February 19, saying that he cannot come to visit them at present, that they must not accept of Mr. Ward any confession, less than they have already required; that, if they send him copies of the evidence against Mr. Ward and what he ofifers to confess, he will, after reading them, send letters to the Church and to Mr. Ward, " which possibly may be as serviceable as if I were personally present." After his deposition, Mr. Ward remained in Guilford, but lived mostly secluded from general society. He joined the Episcopalians and used to read the service for that society, when they were without a minister. He represented the town in three sessions of the General Assembly and died in poverty at Guilford, November 15, 1779, aged y-^^ years. He married, in 1731, Mehitabel, daughter of Thomas Robinson, Jr., and had several children.

On December 26, 1734, the ist Society unanimously requested its committee to inform the 4th Society that, as they " have at present no settled preaching among them, the said 4th .Society . . . shall be welcome to attend the public worship of God with us. . . . And, further, if the said 4th Society shall think fit to reconcile with the first Society and become one society again as formerly . . . we shall rejoice in such a union & desire that whatsoever may have been the cause of separation between us, may be overlooked & buried in oblivion." This proposal for union is said to have been considered by the Council that condemned Mr. Ward. The ministers of the county advised a union and on October 16, 1735, the 4th Church made proposals thereto which are now lost. From the answer of the ist Church, however, we learn that the 4th Church said the first step towards a union must be a removal of the impediment which prevented them from communing with the 1st Church. The reasons for non-communing were that the 1st Church had pronounced separation from the church for the 46 excommunicated persons, instead of suspension as the council of March 10, 1731, had directed. This objection the ist Church, in its answer of December 4, 1735, speedily answers by declaring that by separation they meant suspension. The ist Church declines to call a council, saying they have " no case of conscience to present." Rather naturally the 1st Church expresses sorrow that the 4th Church has stumbled on the very threshold of union, and closes in the finest passage of writing in all this dreary quarrel. " Upon the whole. Brethren, we cannot but think it time to lav aside strife and debate and not to trouble yourselves, nor us, any more in the afifair. Must the sword devour forever? There is a considerable number of your church, who have shewn such a becoming Christian spirit as to communicate with us at the table of our common Lord, and we see nothing that should hinder any of you, any more than them, and we cannot but think your wisdom would be in it, as well as you would discover your Christian spirit by so doing. We invite you to make a common grave & let us bury all these things in Eternal oblivion. This we think the most reasonable way and beyond comparison the most prudent and Christian part - most for the glory of God and for the peace & welfare of religion." To this the Church answered that month in a spirit of some bitterness, cavilling at expressions in the ist Church's letter, and complaining that they who left the church for spiritual welfare had suffered, what those did not who for worldly gain left the town and, consequently, the church. They say that a Council might consider that the ist Church was wrong in excommunicating them when that church " should ask forgiveness of God & man " and, if the Council should decide that " great act " was right, " it would take ofT our hard thoughts of you." ' On February 10, 1734-5, the 4th Church followed this up by a remarkable document, stating that, since the ist Church would not "join and call a Council to show us that we are mistaken, or convince you that you have wronged us . . . we despair of convincing you ourselves; yet, believing you to be a Church of Christ, and considering how much Christ commands brethren to love one another, we do desire to forgive you and hope God will, and we desire to partake with you." So the noncommunion difficulty seemed settled, but union remained afar off. It is curious to see how tenacious of their rights both parties are.

On May 20, 1736, the 4th Church sent to the ist Church, requesting it to send its pastor and a messenger to assist in settling as pastor Mr. Daniel Bliss (Y, C, 1732), who was later pastor at Concord, Mass. This request was answered in the negative on June 8. The answer is rather Pharisaic in tone, states that their refusal may be accounted for from the fact that they have received no notice of a repeal of the noncommunion vote of the 4th Church, which seems a strange statement. It further states that " we hope there has been nothing wanting on our part to obtain a reunion," and that the only reason the ist Church knows for their separation is their " want of Christian & Brotherly love to the Pastor & Brethren of this church and, whenever it shall please God to remove the Cause, we may hope the effect will cease."

charity ' that they did not disown the ist Church as a church of Christ, nor invite others to withdraw from it, which they suppose would be necessary had they declared non-communion, but they mentioned " scruples of conscience," which then prevented them from communing with the 1st Church and which they hoped a council would remove. The letter, in a spirit of friendliness, refers to the ist Church's letter of December 4, 1735, states that "We now profess that we would live in Christian love & charity, joyfully owning you for a sister (yea our mother) church in Christ, desiring that, from this day forever, all our former misunderstandings may be far from us . . . that every thing displeasing to a holy God may be forgiven and forgotten by us all, and that we may henceforth live in peace & love." This was followed up by another letter on the 15th, proposing a union of the two churches and a settlement of Mr. Bliss as colleague pastor to Mr. Ruggles. On June 21 the ist Church answers this, agreeing to the proposition, provided: (i) that Mr. Bliss and Mr. Ruggles preach alternately in the 1st Society's meeting house before the united congregations until the of October; (2) that Mr. Bliss be paid during that time by the two societies proportionably at the rate of iioo per annum; (3) that the two societies jointly pray the General Assembly for a reunion; (4) that the societies are united, a vote of the whole be taken as to calling I^Ir. Bliss. If he be called that the 4th Society pay his settlement, as they expect to do if there is no union, and that he and Mr. Ruggles get the same salary, to be raised by a rate on the vmited society; (5) that if the united society do not call Mr. Bliss the 4th Society may name another man to preach with Mr. Ruggles for three months, under the same conditions, and so on till one be chosen ; or the second choice may be made by the ministers of the county, if the 4th Society prefer. No answer to these conditions is extant, if one w^as ever given. On August 28, 1736, Rev. Messrs. Stephen Mix and Wm. Russel write to the 4th Society, enjoining on it care in calling Mr. Bliss, urging it to consider " the carnall workings, the beginning of your separation . . . and whatever ill steps may have been taken . . . therein &, particularly, . . . that the oath taken by some for qualifying you for liberty of worship together " may have been ill, suggesting that the Society employ one or more clergymen to act as its agents in promoting union with the 1st Society, and advising them to leave "the timcing of your settlement unto those who may be made use of therein."

and with that Society to invite Messrs. Samuel Lynde, Wilham Pitkin, Rev. Jared Eliot and Rev. William Russel to come to Guilford on December 29, and give advice concerning union. This council met in due season and advised: (i) that the 4th Society should make another attempt "to sit under" 'Sir. Ruggles' ministry; (2) that, if this will not do, that application be made first to Mr. William Adams (Y. C, 1730), and then to Mr. Timothy Woodbridge, Jr., " to preach alternatelv with Mr, Ruggles in the old meeting house 'till the end of April," and then, if the majority can agree to call either man, that both societies petition the Legislature to be reunited. The same day the 1st Society voted to accept the Council's advice and apparently an agreement was made, whereby ^Ir. Adams did preach alternately with Mr. Ruggles for three months; but no result came from this. In the meantime, ^^Ir. Bliss had disappeared from view. The ist Society offered to call Mr. Adams as Colleague Pastor on April 27, 1737, if he would accept. Apparently he w-as w-illing to do so, for on May 6 the 1st Society empowered its committee to join the 4th Society's committee in petitioning the Assembly for a reunion, as soon as IMr. Adams should be settled. The 4th Church had some unknown objection. Apparently, some change in church discipline in connection with Cambridge, Boston, or Saybrook platform w^as desired, for the ist Church declines " to remove the ancient landmarks " and expresses wonder tiiat " you should spoil so good a work for what seems to be trifles "; but spoil it they did and for a time we hear no more of union.

Early in 1738 the 4th Society sought and received' advice from Rev. Stephen Mix. They begged a visit from him and seemed somewhat discouraged, he advises them to summon a few ministers and laymen to come to Guilford and advise them. He evidently thinks they have not been well treated, but says that, when " we come to ask counsel we should not antecedently intend to follow it no further than it suits our own inclinations," evidently fearing that the 4th Society will do this.

(Jn April 25, 1738, the 4th Society called a council of four clergymen. This council, on June 14, stated they thought "the 4th Society have been too stiffly fixed in opposing the union . . . but, if after suitable pains hath been taken ... a union can not be obtained, we advise that Ihcy apply to some suitable person to settle among them in the work of the ministry." Pursuant to this advice the 4th Society, on August 8. vote to "join the ist Society in hiring Mr. Timothy Woodbridge, Jr. (Y. C, 1732). to preach with Mr. Ruggles a quarter of a year." This plan fell through for some unknown reason, and on October 2. 173S, the 4th Society voted to hire some one for three months. On October 16 Caleb Stone was chosen " to keep their minister." A separate school was started, for which Abraham Bradley was chosen schoolmaster on February 6, 1738-9.

In December, 1739, Rev. Joseph Lamb (Y. C, 1717), was called by a majority of the 4th Society and, on February 5, 1739-40, they voted to give him " £150 a year salary & a suitable supply of wood " and to have him " reinstalled," as soon as possible. He apparently encouraged them at first, and preached regularly, but when the council was called to install him, in January, 1740-1, he " refused to take office" and so, on July I, 1 741, the society voted to call the brother of Rev. Mr. Mills of Stratford for three months at a salary of iioo per annum.

On December 22, 1741, they voted in vain to apply to Mr. Chauncey Whittlesey (Y. C, 1738), the Tutor David Brainerd thought had no more grace than a chair, to supply the pulpit and, on May 20, 1742, Rev. Hobart Estabrook (Y, C, 1736), was invited to preach and did so for some time, receiving 40s. per Sabbath and his board. During this time, on March 17, 1742, the 4th Society voted to build' " 17 pews on the high ground of the Meeting-house, & 3 on the rear of each square body & 2 on the East flank, on the women's side, & 2 on the west flank, on the men's side . . . and that the pews in the square body be raised higher than the seats & that there be bannisters to them." This vote seems to show some prosperity.

On October 8, 1742, the Rev. James Sproat (or Sproutt) was hired to preach for three months and proved so acceptable that he was called to the pastorate on December 14. He did not at once accept and on June 8, 1743, they voted to give him a settlement of £300, to be paid in two years, and a salary of iioo for those years and then an increase of iio yearly till the sum amounted to £150 old tenor, that he be installed as soon as possible, and that " a contribution be taken every Sabbath evening after prayer before singing, at the conclusion of the meeting," which money is to be used towards the minister's salary. These terms apparently did not suit Mr. Sproat and on June 13 the Society changed them to £150 salary for two years in Bills of credit, old tenor & then £150 in old tenor yearly, and for settlement a quarteracre of land and a house" like Mr. Edmund Ward's. These terms Mr. Sproat accepted and, on August 16, 1743, the council met to ordain him. The next day Mr. Sproat was examined, the creed and covenant of the Church approved of, objections, from three members of the 1st Church to ordaining any pastor over the 4tli Church, and from the

' Dec. 14, 1742. " Voted that the meeting-house be ceiled overhead & not clastered." ^ Dec. 6, 1743, rate laid for building his house with a lean-to.

1st Church clechning to sit in the council, read and judged insufficient to stop proceedings, and the ordination proceeded with in due form. Mr. Sproat was the son of Lt. Ebenezer Sproat of Scituate, Mass., who removed to the neighboring town of Middleboro', where James Sproat was born,' April ii, 1722. He was graduated at Yale in 1741. During the time of his study there he became converted by a discourse delivered by the celebrated Gilbert Tennent, whom he succeeded in the 2nd Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia. Before coming to Guilford he had preached some time at New Haven to the seceding party in the 1st Church there, being himself rather prominent among the young leaders of the New Lights, as they were called. Under the act ot May. 1742, passed under the advice of the General Association that met at Guilford in November, 1741, providing that any one not an inhabitant of Connecticut, who shall " preach, teach or publicly exhort in any town, or society . . . without license of the settled minister & the major part of the church . . . shall be sent as a vagrant person . . . from Constable to Constable out .of the bounds of this colony," Mr. Sproat was arrested at New Haven for preaching and was carried by the constables as far as Saybrook. There ]\Ir. Samuel Brown of Guilford found him in a destitute condition. He brought him back to Guilford, clothed him, and furnished him with other necessaries and induced the 4th Society to have him preach for them. After the 4th Society had called him, and before his acceptance, Mr. Sproat was again at New Haven and, on January 18, 1742-3, he, with "others of the separate meeting," requested the County Court to permit him " to take oath & make subscription, according to ... the law of this Colony relating to sober dissenters." The Court decided " that the said James Sproutt hath not shewn himself to have a right by said law, to what is asked for." " Most clearly," writes Mr. Smyth, " he had no right, being a New Light Congregationalist, to the benefit of the Toleration Act which had relation only to members of the Church of England, Quakers, & Baptists. The court were governed by the law, as it then was, not as wc in these days think it should have been."

On August 28, 1743, the 4th Church voted that the pastor might " invite, whom he thought proper in this society," that he might " preach occasionally, where he thought Providence called him," and " that the table of the Lord should be supported by Contributions." Mr. Sproat threw himself at once into the revival movements of the day, and by his zeal and eloquence secured very gratifying progress in his church. The course of the church, however, drew down upon it the wrath of the Association, which on May 29, 1744, voted not to hold communion with the 4th Church, " who had allowed Mr. Allen, Amos IMunson, and others to preach among them." This vote was not rescinded until 1758.

Apparently the ist Society claimed the right to tax the young men of the community, regardless of their father's connections. So to make a test case, on January 3, 1743-4, Caleb Stone, Jr., John Davis, Jr., Elisha Smith and Stephen Rogers stated they belonged to the 4th Society and proposed to pay taxes to it only. Nothing was done fora time; but on December 18, 1744, the 4th Society appointed two agents to act in the defense of any of its members who were " rated in the 1st Society."' On the third Tuesday of January, 1744-5, the case of John Davis & others of the 4th Society vs. the ist Society was heard by the county court and apparently decided in the ist Society's favor. Soon after, however, on March 4, 1744-5, on the verbal petition of Peletiah Leete, 18 persons were freed by the ist Society from paying any charges to it."

The agitation against the ist Society's rates being assessed on all new-comers in town, whether they attended the ist or 4th Church, was vigorously kept up by the latter, which had justice on its side. On February 8, 1750, it appointed a new committee to present memorials on this subject to the General Assembly. The ist Society on May 7, 1750, protested against these memorials; but it was no use, the General Assembly decided " that all such strangers,^ as have or shall come to inhabit within the limits of sd. Societies, . . . by entering their names with the Clerk of that Society, to which he shall so join himself, within 3 months, after they shall become inhabitants, . . . shall pay his rates and taxes only to that Society."

On June 28, 1750, the 4th Church decided that it would " come into the concert of prayer, agreeable to the memorial from Scotland," and that persons owning the Covenant should have their children baptized. It may be interesting to give this Half-Way Covenant, that the responsibilities taken by those owning it may be clear. " (i) You desire to be thankful that you were born in a land of light & have been given to God in Baptism. (2) And, since of the Patience & forbearance of God to poor sinners you have been spared to adult years. You desire now to ozun your Baptism & accordingly do, before God & his people, acknowledge your baptismal obligations. (3) And you purpose by Grace

' Special acts were passed by the Legislature quite frequently annexing men to one society or the other. ^ In 1746 the 1st Society's rate was 5d. and tlie 4th Society's ud. in tlie pound. * Conn. Col. Rec. IX, 520.

to forsake the vanities of this evil world & to be seeking after Christ for your Redeemer & Saviour. (4) You also believe the Doctrine of the Christian Religion, as owned among us and submit yourself to the watch & discipline of this church. (5) You purpose by Grace to be labouring, after preparations, to come to the Lord's Table & that you will endeavor to bring up your Children in the Nurture & Admonition of the Lord."

Diflficulties still continued to exist between the two societies, and on March 20, 1753, the 4th Society appointed an agent to present a memorial to the Assembly. On Februar>' 18, 1755, the 4th Society voted to receive any members of the ist Society that should desire to change their membership, and deduct from their rates what they were forced to pay " to Mr. Ruggles's Rate."

In the spring of 1757 they presented another memorial to the Assemblv which the ist Society on May 12 voted to oppose. Since the latter were about to settle Mr. Amos Fowler as Colleague Pastor to Mr. Ruggles, and there seemed likelihood of the 4th Society's losing Mr. Sproat, they thought it a good plan to revive the idea of reunion. So they sent the 4th Society their votes in regard to settling Mr. Fowler and voted " that it would be exceedingly desirable & acceptable to this Society, that the 4th Society concur with us & come unitedly into the settlement of Mr. Fowler, ... as a happy &, to us appearing, the most likely means to put an amicable end to our long unhappy differences & settle & establish a lasting peace among us & that, if the sd. 4th Society can persuade themselves to compliance, they shall be received & admitted freely to ye enjoyment of all the privileges that any of the members of this Society enjoy ... & shall be freed from bearing any part of the charge of Mr. Fowler's settlement." At the time this liberal ofifer was made, the ist Society had received certain imknown proposals from the 4th Society. On May 30th the 4th Society voted to decline the proposals made by the 1st Society; but, since they also desired that " some measures might be taken that we may live in peace . . . &, tho' we do not find ourselves willing that wc. or our ciiildren, should be deprived of the ministry of the Revd. Mr. .Sproutt, yet we are freely willing to join with our brethren of sd. 1st Soc. & be one body with them under the ministry of the Revd. Mr. Sprout & either tlic Revd. Mr. Ruggles or Mr. Amos Fowler." This was probably unacceptable to the ist Church, for we hear no more of tile matter.

At the same meeting of the 4th Society it voted that " we think it very likely U) make peace between the Societys. . . . that all persons, upon application to cither the ist or 4th Society, should be dismissed from either Society & attend public worship of God, where they shall choose & that, as long as they are contributing to one, they shall be freed from paying taxes to the other." This seems to us the only fair and just way, but the ist Society held out for what it thought were its rights until the Gen'l Assembly decided the question in 1760 in favor of the 4th Society. The law as enacted,^ provided that all within the limits of the ist & 4th Societies, on arriving at 21 years of age, may within a year " elect & choose to which of said societies they will belong & cause their names to be entered with the clerk of that So-- ciety, ... & on failure so to enter their names, they shall continue where brought up ... & that all others within said limits, who have not been personally rated in either of said Societies, may on or before the 1st Day of September next elect to which of the Societies they will belong." '

Mr. Sproat had become very popular as a preacher and evidently was growing discontented with his situation in Guilford. In 1757 the Society of Plymouth, the most ancient in New England, being Avithout a minister, Mr. Sproat preached for them some time.^ A meeting was held June 29, at which " sundry articles were read to the Ch., shewing reasons of the Pastor's desire for a Council of neighbouring Elders & messengers to be called to give advice with respect to a Call of the minister to settle in Plymouth." This request the church denied, as the Society had done the day before.

On September 19 another church meeting^ was held "to consider further, on the affairs relating " to Mr. Sproat's " removal." At this he read a letter " from Plymouth, shewing the importance of his removal thither & advice from sundry ministers " given at the Yale commencement, September 15, " relating to calling a council to advise respecting " this call. There was " much discussion," but nothing was done. At an adjourned meeting, held September 23, the church a second time voted not to join in calling a council. In October Mr. Sproat called a church meeting to hear the entreaties of representatives of the Plymouth Church, who had come to Guilford; but the meeting adjourned, without doing them the courtesy of listening to them. For two years now the matter was dropped; but on September 17, 1759,

' For some years the two societies kept a joint school. This was given up in 1762 on account of the increase of children. 'Thatcher, Hist, of Plymouth, p. 285.

* In writing to the Tabernacle Church of Salem, July 9, 1768, the 4th Church says: "The plea of more extensive usefulness . . . has been thoroughly weighed here in Council in the case of Plymouth and was determined in our favour."

we find a last church meeting on this question. A representative of the Plymouth Church was present and read an address, but it produced no effect. The church would not even consent to leave the question of their pastor's removal to a mutual council.*

On November 30, 1767, Mr. Sproat wrote a letter to the 4th Society, showing that trouble had arisen." He writes that " the present temper and conduct of the Society gives me great uneasiness, that people are backward in paying dues " and try " to crowd anything on me instead of money," that some " complain my salary is too high, others wholly refuse to pay," there is " a very great and almost general complaint " " that there is no living in these hard times because there are so many ministers to maintain," that people think to keep both a school and a minister is too expensive and that, if either is to be given up, the latter had better be dispensed with, and that many complain that " they are uneasv & disaffected with the present method of singing." ^ For these causes Mr. Sproat thinks that he is " a burden to a considerable part of the Society, which thing must necessarily afford me sorrow of heart." In addition, he feels that his remaining is " not absolutely necessary." for " the same doctrines may be attended upon, with as little trouble . . . and vastly less charge, delivered with as much plainness and power as I can reasonably lay claim to." Therefore he asks for a dismission and reminds them that he had said a year ago: " I had rather be dismissed from my people, than to quarrel with them and go to law for )uy support." He still feels thus and believes he " must do the one, or the other." If the Society is unable to pay him he does not wish to be a burden ; if unwilling, he had rather be dismissed, than to quarrel. But, at the annual meeting of the Society, December 2, no action was taken.

Mr. Sproat became more and more discontented. He went away from time to time to preach in different parts of the country. On May 18.1768, he was given a call by the 3d Congregational Church (Tabernacle Church) of Salem, Mass. On July 9 a letter was sent from the 4th Church to the Salem Church, stating that they decline to give up Mr. ."Sproat, because of "the perfect union there is among this people,

' The 4tli Church was received into fellowsliip by the Association in 1758, and met at Mr. Sproat's house on May 27, 1760. He and his " messenger " figure in several councils.

' His salary was £60 from 1755 to 1757, wlicn hi> pasture and wood were added. In 1759 it was increased to £66 with pasture and wood, and in 1763 to £80 without pasture and wood.

* Dec. 2. 1767, James Evarts, Jr.. was added as Chorister to John Hall and .-\rrhaus Parmelcc, who had been chosen " to tune the Psalm " for nine previous years.

with regard to his continuance here and the many ill consequences that will unavoidably follow his removal." They speak of the " almost unparalleled trials & expences " they have passed through before obtaining Mr. Sproat, and say that Salem being " near one of the largest seminaries of learning on the Continent," can easily get another man.

They were not, however, to keep him long. On August 30, 1768^ the 2nd Presbyterian Church of Philadelphia called him, and on October II a church meeting was held, which voted to join with Mr. Sproat in calling a council to decide as to his leaving. The council did not dismiss him, but advised the church and Society to grant his request for a dismission. There was evidently some ill-feeling, the church met twice and adjourned, and after a third meeting on the third consecutive day " the minds of the Elders were expressed, that it was not best for the Pastor to preach on the Sabbath." The Society met on October 24 and sent a committee to ask Mr. Sproat whether he considered himself pastor of the Philadelphia church or of the Guilford one. He refused to answer, but desired them to dismiss him as the council had advised. The Societv voted not to do this, but that if he would yet perform his ministerial office with them, " they were ready & willing to shew him all honor and respect." If he would leave them, they suggest that a committee " see on what conditions he will agree with him with respect to his settlement."

On October 31 Mr. Sproat sent his answer to the Society. He says: " Things being as they are, it appears to be my duty to depart, as soon as may be, and, though you do not see lit to grant me a dismission, with regard to the Council's advice; yet it may be you will do it; because I think it my indispensable duty to be dismissed & heartily desire it. Unless I am here, wholly Usclessl as to the ministry. It may be, I may be made use of elsewhere. My Brethren, I have labored amongst you more than twenty five years in the w^ork of the ministry. I have publicly preached the gospel, according to the grace given me, I have been with you in nuich weakness, I must own. Yet sure I am that I have had the most tender sympathy with you in all your afflictions; there are but few of your houses, in which I haA-e not mingled my tears with yours, and poured out my broken prayers day and night with you for your sick and dying friends. Never have I refused, when able, to leave my bed by night, or to go through storms and cold by day, to afiford all the relief in my power under your distresses. I mention these things not to boast - If I secretly do, I pray my God to humble me. From God I know I deserve utter and eternal ruin and I attribute every thing this side of final despair to mere grace and mercy. Put from you, my Brethren! I don't know that I deserve cruelty - supposing that I have been misled in my own mind . . . >et I trust . , . you will peaceably dismiss me." He says he has not refused to do manual labor, that he has " no disposition to wrong- you in your temporal interests," that he will refund £50 of his settlement, " which I suppose to be more than is strictly just; or I will leave it to indifferent judges, mutually chosen, to determine " how much of his settlement he should repay. He concludes by asking their forgiveness of him and expressing his of them. This touching letter produced no effect. He left, without a dismission, in November and was installed at Philadelphia, March 30, 1769. The Society prepared to prosecute him for a return of his settlement, and refused, in March, 1769, to accept £50 and the arrears of his salary, which he offered. Mr. Sproat had received his salary in full to January, 1768, as appears by his receipts. On November 6, 1769, Dea. David Austin, his ageni, on receipt of £50 discharges the 4th Society " from all demands whatever from the beginning of the world to this day."

Col. Andrew Ward was so bitter over Mr. Sproat's departure that he is supposed to have written a somewhat scurrilous article which appeared in the Connecticut Journal, printed at New Haven: '

" Mr. Sproutt continued in charge of this Society in Philadelphia until the 4th Society was mostly broken up. He occasionally, though very rarely, visited his former people here. The hostile feelings, excited at the time of his removal, must have made his visits here rather unpleasant. The gradual decay and dissolution of this formerly flourishing Church and Society must have created in his mind many mournful reflections. Besides, after a time, his situation at Philadelphia became fraught with many painful incidents. He was becoming advanced in life & had lost much of the old vigour & raciness of his former style of preaching. Old sermons repeated lose much of their original vitality & point. A new race had sprung up around him and a revolutionar)^ period had materially changed the habits & tastes of the people. Young men of a new style of eloquence had sprung up and were attracting the attention of the multitude. Still he was a man of great talent and fervour and was justly esteemed, wherever he was known, for his vigour & resources as a man, for his sincerity & depth of feeling as a Christian, & for his clearness and eloquence as a preacher. He was given the degree of Doctor of Divinity by the College of New Jersey, in 1780. He died at Philadelphia, Oct. 18, 1793, of the Yellow fever, which proved fatal also to his wife & several of his children. He was 71 years old and had been 50 years in the ministry, dividing his time almost equally between his two pastorates."

His only publication was a funeral discourse occasioned by the death of Rev. George Whitefield in 1770. His engraved portrait and parts of his diary for four months preceding his death, were printed in the General Assembly's " Missionary Magazine " for 1805 (vol. I).

" Dr. Ashbell Green, his colleague & successor, subsequently president of the College of New Jersey, in a funeral sermon, described him as excelling in the graces of the Gospel, as a good proficient in scholastic attainments, and as an eminent theologian. As a preacher, he had but few equals in his day, dwelt much on the doctrines of grace & was highly evangelical. His exertions in the early part of his ministry were directed to the extension of the Great Revival. Throughout his whole life, his labours were admirably adapted to the promotion of experimental & vital Religion."

On December 7, 1768, the Society voted to have the pulpit supplied and in January, 1769, it voted to " endeavor to continue to he a Society & to maintain the worship of God." At the same time they voted to have Mr. James Eells (Y. C. 1763) supply the pulpit, but reconsidered this and voted to apply to Rev. Joseph Fish of North Stonington, In March they voted to have Mr. Jonathan Murdock (Y. C. 1766) preach for them. A long course of candidating was begun. On May 30 they voted to have Mr. Ephraim Judson (Y. C. 1763) supply the pulpit and, on August 29, to apply to Mr. John Hunt. Mr. Hunt came, was liked, was asked, on September 26, to preach as a candidate on " tryal " for a month " in order for a settlement " and, at the end of the month, on October 30, he was called as pastor if he " would settle " on the Cambridge Platform. The society offered to give him one-third of an acre and build a house on it like Mr. Sproutt's for a settlement, provided he give it up, if he leave except through death. For salary they offer £70 a year for two years, then an increase of iio or 20 cords of walnut or oak wood. On June 7, 1770, the offer of a settlement is reiterated, but for some reason he did not accept the call.

On October i, 1770, the society voted to apply first to Mr. Joseph Lyman (Y. C. 1767). Mr. Lyman came and, on December 5, the society voted to have him preach two Sundays more, that they might " get acquainted with his principles with respect to Church discipline." These were so satisfactory that he was called as pastor on December 17, with the same offers as were made to Mr. Hunt, save that the increase of salary was to come when he arrives at " family state." But Mr. Lyman declined to come.

Mr. Daniel Brewer (Y. C. 1765) was next applied to and, on March 13, 1771, the society voted they had "such a regard for . . . his performances," that they invite him to preach further, with view to a settlement. On March 25, 1771, the church called him to be its pastor land the society agreed with that vote the same day, and made him the -same offers as they did Mr. Hunt, save that his house was to be " of any imodel " which would cost the same amount as Mr. Sproat's. There [was some hitch in the matter and the society renewed the call on May \6, July 15. and August 6. Mr. Brewer finally accepted and the i8th <>i September was appointed for his ordination. A number of the , church opposed to Mr. Brewer presented a petition to the council at [its meeting on September 17, but their objections were thought insuffi- Icient and the ordination was performed, Rev. Benjamin Trumbull ^preaching the sermon. The petition is dated September 6; objects to Mr. Brewer because he declines to baptize on the Half-way Covenant plan and states that, if he be ordained, " we shall look upon ourselves jas disregarded by the church & Society, and desire that the Society (would not have the least expectation of any assistance from us in supporting " him. It is signed by 19 men and had been presented to the church the ven,- same day. The church, answermg it, said that some of these very men had voted to call Mr. Brewer, and that they have not been regular in attending meetings and so are out of touch 'with the rest of the society. On December 4, 1771, 17 of these complainants were freed by' the Society from paying all taxes to it, save for schools, provided they pay taxes to some " other worshipping society.'' The ist Society, on December 16, 1771, voted to receive all those who should wish to join it and 16 of them did so, together with one not previously mentioned as connected with the movement.

The Rev. Daniel Brewer w-as from Springfield, Mass., and was born 1744. Not long after his settlement he embraced the sentiments of the Sandemanians. On December 9, 1774, in consequence of this, the society desired Mr. Brewer to '" come . . . and discourse of some matters relative to the church " and, on December 20, it voted to join with the church in calling the same Council that ordained Mr. Brewer, " to endeavor to settle the grievances " between him and the Church and to permit him to add to the Council a number, not exceeding its original number. The Council met on March 8, 1775, and advised the dismission of Mr. P^rewer, to which advice the society agreed. On April 19. 1775, ^ committee was appointed "to settle with Mr. Brewer in the best way they can," and on I'^ebruary 22, 1776. a vote was passed to rent the house originally built for Mr. Brewer.

Ill" remained in Guilford until i77<;, when lie removed to Newtown, Conn., where there was a society of the Sandemanians. He remained there .some years and removed next to Taunton, Mass.. where he died December 1825. aged 81. He- retained his Sandemanian sentiments unchanged through Hfe, Hving a quiet & rather retired hfe. Of course he never preached after leaving his charge in Guilford, that denomination admitting none as preachers except Christ & the Apostles. He sustained the rank, if it can be so called, of an Elder and as such used to take the lead of his congregation at Newtovv^n and afterwards at Taunton, in the duties of prayer, expounding the scriptures, & exhorting. It is said of him that he was a man of good natural abilities, respectable as a scholar, of a peculiarly blameless & passive temper, and ap])arcntly sincere & pious."

After the dismission of Mr. Brewer there are no records of any attempt to employ a minister until April 27, 1780, when the society voted that it would grant a rate of two shillings in the pound for the purpose of paying for moving the family of Rev. Mr. Smith to Middletown. Who he was, how long he had been there, and whether he was ever settled are unknown.

After gap of four years more, and nine years after the last pastor was dismissed, the society voted, on August 26, 1784, to hire Mr. Beriah Hotchkin to preach for six months. He continued to preach after the six months were concluded, and on June 10, 1785, presented the Church " a draught of his sentiments respecting the form, order, & discipline of a Gospel church," which the Church examined and found satisfactory, and, after considering " its present broken circumstances," voted unanimously to call him to their pastorate. On June 13 the society concurred with the church and offered Mr. Hotchkin £60 salary for one year. An ordaining council was called for August 16, 1785. Mr. Hotchkin was pastor until 1789. On February 9 of that year the society voted " that we will consent that Mr. Beriah Hotchkin shall be liberated from his ministerial charge over this society ": for the vote 14, against it 13, neutral 3. He was probably dismissed March 4, 1789, and no attempt was made to settle a minister in that society afterwards.

" The Rev. Mr. Hotchkin ' was a native of Guilford and was born March 2y, 1752. He was not a college graduate, but a plain man of good abilities - rather a moderate preacher. After his dismission he removed to Greenville. N. Y., whither some of his people had gone before him. He was installed there about 1793 and remained in connexion with them until 1824 or 5, when he was dismissed and removed

' Rev. C. E. Stovve (Quarto-Millennial Celebration) says his mother having lost four children, consecrated him to the Lord before birth while in a period of great spiritual exaltation in attendance on divine worsliip. He read the Bible through before reaching the age of seven, sat under Dr. Sproat's preaching, moved to Cornwall, united with the church there in 1780, and studied for the ministry with Rev. Amzi Lewis of Goshen, N. Y.

The Fourth Church And Society In Guilford

to Steuben County, N. Y. He was able to supply a destitute congregation there and died February - , 1829, aged yj. When he removed to Greenville the northern parts of New York, from the Hudson to the region of Oneida County, as far west as English settlements had then extended, were almost wholly destitute of religious instruction. There was not a single Congregational minister in that region besides himself, & but few others of any denomination. He had a happy influence in promoting the cause of the Redeemer in Greenville & vicinity & in other parts of the State."

After his dismission from the 4th Society, " some of the members died, others removed or joined the ist Society until the church became extinct. Still, however, meetings were kept up in the old meetinghouse from time to time. Occasionally a subscription was raised and some itinerant minister was employed for a time. No great care seems to have been had in the selection and persons were occasionally employed of other denominations. ]\Iany of the members of the 4th Society afterwards embodied themselves into the Baptist Society, when it was established. In May, 1809, the Legislature transferred 24 persons from the 4th to the ist Society, and this virtually put an end to the former. On December 3, 1810, it was voted to board up the meeting house windows and the last meeting, at which nothing was done, was held on March 4, 181 1.

The existence of the society was one long struggle against misfortunes and opposition and, except under Mr. Sproat, it seems never to have enjoyed prosperity.

Chapter Xlv

As has been stated this church was formed from the First Church by the dismission from the latter of 123 of the more pronounced Abohtionists, and of the friends of Rev. Mr. Button, by an ecclesiastical council on November 23, 1843.

The present house of worship was built in 1844, the corner stone being laid on July 17, and was dedicated to the service of God, January i, 1845. I^ ^^^s remodeled in 1862, and supplied with a suitable organ in 1873. The chapel in the rear of the church was built in 1879. Rev. Arthur L. Seward is the only minister it has raised up. as far as is known.

The church is connected with the New Haven East Consociation. Its membership (December, 1893) is 294. It was incorporated in 1893, and the society was thus done away with. The first pastor was the Rev. David Root, who was born at Piermont, N. H., June 17, 1791. He graduated at Middlebury College in 18 - , and there studied for the ministry. About 1818 he went to Georgia to preach and there married Miss Almira Alden of Connecticut. About 1820 he became pastor of the Second Presbyterian Church in Cincinnati, Ohio. Thence he removed to Dover, N. H., where he married, as his second wife, Miss Mary Gordon. Next he went to Philadelphia, where he became pastor of the First Congregational Church, after which he removed to Waterbury. Conn., where he was installed, in July, 1841, pastor of the First Congregational Church. Having been duly dismissed from this church in 1844, he was installed pastor of the Third Church, Guilford, January i, 1845. He did not resume ministerial labors, after being dismissed at his own request from this church, April 6, 1851. The remainder of his days was spent in retirement in New Haven and Chicago, at which latter place he died August 30, 1873. His remains were brought to Guilford and interred in Alderbrook Cemetery. His monument there characterizes him as: "A faithful and fearless servant of God the father of our Lord Jesus Christ. A pioneer and untiring laborer in the anti-slavery cause. A man of active benevolence, and a diligent promoter of Christian education. His memory is lovingly cherished by those with whom he dwelt, and his influence remains to bless coming generations."

The Story is told that, when he was called to the Third Church, some unfriendly wag in the North Church quoted the text, " I have seen the foolish taking Root."

The Rev. Richard Manning Chipman, the second pastor, was born at Salem, Mass., January 12, 1806, the eldest of twelve children of Deacon Richard M. and Elizabeth (Grey) Chipman. He prepared for college at Kimball Union Academy, Moriton, N. H., and graduated at Dartmouth College, 1832. He studied for the ministry at Princeton and Union Seminaries and, during 1833 and 1834, he was corresponding secretary of the American Peace Society, and editor of their periodical, The Calumet, in New York. He was ordained pastor of the Congregational Church in Harwinton, Conn., March 4, 1835, and dismissed from it March 13, 1839. He was pastor of the Evangelical Congregational Church in Athol, Mass., from August 15, 1839, to December 1851, and of the Third Church, Guilford, from January 14, 1852, to May 19, 1858. After this he served as acting pastor of Congregational Churches at Wolcottville in Torrington 1859-61, at Middle Haddam 1861-63, at Hyde Park, Mass., 1864-66, at East Granby 1866-70, and in 1871 at Lisbon. In 1863-64 he was in the service of the National Freedman's Relief Commission of Salem, Mass. He married June 11, 1835, Mary, second daughter of the Rev. Fosdic and Elizabeth (Bunnel) Harrison, then of Roxbury, Conn. He has published: (i) Discourse of Ecclesiastical Prosperity, delivered at the dedication of a church at Terryville in Plymouth, Conn., 1838. (2) Discourses on Free Discussion, delivered at Harwinton, Conn., 1839. (3) Discourses on IMaintenance of Moral Purity, delivered at Athol, Mass., 1841. (4) Memoir of Eli Thorpe, 1842. (5) History of Harwinton, Conn., i860. (6) The Chipman Lineage, particularly as in Essex County, Mass., 1872.

Rev. Mr. Chipman died on August 15, 1893, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, at the residence of his son, with whom he had lived for twenty-two years. During the latter years of his life he was engaged in work for the Century Dictionary.

Provenance

Text from A History of the Plantation of Menunkatuck and of the Original Town of Guilford, Connecticut : Comprising the Present Towns of Guilford and Madison, published 1897, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive. The settlements listed against this township are matched by point-in-polygon test of each Geographic Names Information System coordinate against the Census Bureau's county subdivision boundary, not by name.