BlockBefore

Benicia Arsenal, Commanding Officer's Quarters, Benicia

Benicia Arsenal, Commanding Officer's Quarters, Benicia, Solano County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,48-BENI,4C-, with a 1,252-word written history.

From the record

“Fittingly one of the most gracious and elegant buildings on the arsenal grounds, the Commanding Officer's Quarters were built in”

Written record, HABS CAL,48-BENI,4C- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,48-BENI,4C- · the record runs 1252 words · one of 191 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

1155 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,48-BENI,4C-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Fittingly one of the most gracious and elegant buildings on the arsenal grounds, the Commanding Officer's Quarters were built in PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of erection: per datestone. 2. Architect: None known. 3. Original plans and construction: The first known plans for the Commanding Officer's Quarters are undated drawings in the National Archives entitled "Designs for Officer's Quarters at Benicia Arsenal, Cal." (HABS No. CA-1843-9). These drawings show a two-story, hipped-roof, T-shaped structure with a modillioned cornice. A one-story porch with Doric columns extends along the entire length of the east side. The front block was an essentially square, four-room center-hall house, with service functions located in the rear wing.

The plan shows that the main entrance was on the east side and the stairway was located north of the entrance hall. Another drawing in the National Archives, entitled "Commanding Officer and dated March 19, shows a more severe Greek Revival-style structure* While the shape and layout of the building were essentially the same, here the main entrance was located on the south side, with the stairway to the east. This was apparently the drawing that was used for construction. * 4. Alterations and additions: In plans that resemble the ones were published in a book, but shortly thereafter the building was altered considerably on both the exterior and the interior.

These alterations, perhaps an attempt to bring the building more in line with the Italianate style of the recently completed Duplex Officers' Quarters (HABS No. CA-1947), were indicated in pencil on the drawings. The original entrance BENICIA ARSENAL COMMANDING OFFICER'S QUARTERS {Quarters No, 1, Building No. 28) HABS No. CA-1843 (Page 2) on the south side of the Commanding Officer's Quarters was replaced by a one-story polygonal bay window similar to the windows used at the Duplex Officer's Quarters. The former side door on the east became the new main entrance. This required moving the stairway from the east side of the hallway to the former entrance way on the south.

At the same time, apparently, a new porch with Corinthian columns was constructed, replacing the original Doric-columned porch. A polygonal bay window was also added on the second floor above the new main entrance. Both the porch across the front and the bay window on the south side were surmounted by balustrades; these were removed after A parapet above the cornice was also removed after revealing a shallow hip roof. Historical Context: Julian McAllister was the commanding officer of the arsenal between 186 0 and with the exception of two years between and when he was called east to help with the defense of New York City in the Civil War.

The son of a prominent Savannah, Georgia, family, he was the brother of New York society leader Ward McAllister, and Hall McAllister, a prominent San Francisco lawyer. McAllister was much involved with the social life of Benicia and was instrumental in the planning and construction of St. Paul's Episcopal Church. The Commanding officer's Quarters were the first building at the arsenal constructed during his command. From to the arsenal had as its commander Colonel James Walker Benet, father of the well-known writers Stephen Vincent, William Rose, and Laura Benet, all of whom lived in the Commanding Officer's Quarters. PART II. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A.

Architectural drawings: The following drawings for this building are located in the National Archives, Cartographic Division, Record Group "Designs for Officer's Quarters at Benicia Arsenal, Cal." Black ink with purple, yellow, and blue watercolor on paper. Two plans and an elevation labeled "C. 0. Quarters," and two plans and an elevation labeled "Lieut's Quarters." Folder 3. {HABS No. CA- "Commanding Officer Notation in pen: "Ordnance Office, March 19, Plan and two elevations. These show the building as it was constructed with alterations made after indicated in pencil. Folder 3. BENICIA ARSENAL COMMANDING OFFICER'S QUARTERS {Charters No. 1, Building No. 28) HABS No. CA-1843 (Page 3) Unlabeled drawing. "First floor, in pencil. Black ink on linen.

Plan with labels "Main House" and "Ell Part" and specifications of some of the dimensions. Folder 3. Unlabled drawing. "Second floor, in pencil. Black ink on linen. Plan with labels "Main House" and "Ell Part" and specifications of some of the dimensions. Folder 2. Seven unlabeled sheets. Black ink with blue and yellow watercolor on paper. Sheets 1-4 are in folder 3, sheets 5-7 in folder 2. Sheet 1. Details of principal windows Sheet 2, Details of finish for interior doors Sheet 3. Details of doors and windows Sheet 4, Details of front entrance doors Sheet 5. Piazza sections and details with elevation of front entrance door. Sheet 6. Details of rear piazza Sheet 7. Section of capitals for columns Unlabeled sheet. Black ink on paper. Four window elevations. Folder 4. Unlabeled drawings.

Ink on linen. Plans with a prominent label stamped on one of the sheets: "Vellum tracing cloth." Folder 3. Another set of drawings for the building, apparently showing it as constructed, is published in a volume entitled Plans of Officers' Quarters at the Arsenals and Armory, compiled by the Army Ordnance Office in and published by the Government Printing Office.. Plate 8 shows the ground floor and first floor plan of the building. These are very similar to the plans in the National Archives. B. Old views: Photograph, apparently of the commanding officer's house, On the back is the notation: Craner's Personal Carriage, Reproduced from an original in,the possession of the Mare Island Naval Base in Vallejo, which supplied the identification and the date.

Collection Fred Kerstad, operator of a restaurant currently in the building. BENICIA ARSENAL COMMANDING OFFICER'S QUARTERS (Quarters No. 1, Building No. 28) HABS No. CA-1843 (Page 4) Photograph of the house, apparently from the top of the Clocktower Building/ ca. Reproduced in Laura Benet, When William Rose Stephen Vincent and I Were Young (New York, p. 88. Two photographs of the building from the east. U.S. Army Photograph, ca. and ca. Location of originals unknown; phtocopied for HABS in the 195 0s. (HABS No. CA-1843-7 and -8) Five or six photographs of the interior, ca. Collection Mr. and Norman Peltier, Benicia. Prepared by Robert Bruegmann Project Historian Historic American Buildings Survey August PART IV.

PROJECT INFORMATION This project was undertaken by the Historic American Buildings Survey in cooperation with Exxon Company, U.S.A. (a division of Exxon Corporation) and the Benicia Historical Society. Under the direction of John Poppeliers, Chief of H.A.B.S., the project was completed during the summer of at the Historic American Buildings Survey Field Office, Benicia, California, by John P. White (Assistant Professor, Texas Tech University), Project Supervisor; Robert Bruegmann (University of Pennsylvania), Project Historian; Kenneth Payson (Cornell University), Architect; and student assistant architects Scott Barnard (University of Pennsylvania); James L. Cook (Texas Tech University); and Gary A. Statkus (University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign).

The written data were edited by Alison K. Hoagland in the HABS Washington office in January,

In context

Benicia, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Solano County, California 258 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Benicia

24 of 57 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Benicia building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
American RacerHAER CA-34614,934 words
USNS CometHAER CA-3489,619 words
Benicia State CapitolHABS CAL,48-BENI,2-5,680 words
US Coast Guard Icebreaker GlacierHAER CA-3415,404 words
Esso GettysburgHAER CA-3545,367 words
WichitaHAER CA-3565,295 words
St. Paul's Episcopal ChurchHABS CAL,48-BENI,15A-4,754 words
General Edwin D. PatrickHAER CA-3444,661 words
Alaska StandardHAER CA-3474,624 words
Benicia ArsenalHABS CAL,48,BEN1,4-S-4,440 words
SperryHAER CA-3424,323 words
TalugaHAER CA-3364,106 words
General John PopeHAER CA-3433,965 words
Mission Santa YnezHAER CA-3373,807 words
SS PetersburgHAER CA-23323,637 words
BolsterHAER CA-3553,326 words
Benicia ArsenalHABS CAL,48-BENI,4T-2,980 words
Crooks HouseHABS CAL,48-BENI,7-2,938 words
Riddell Fish HouseHABS CAL,48-BENI,8-2,747 words
Winthrop VictoryHAER CA-3452,735 words
MispillionHAER CA-3382,700 words
Benicia ArsenalHABS CAL,48-BENI,4P-2,542 words
Fischer-Hanlon HouseHALS CA-272,442 words
Carr HouseHABS CAL,48-BENI,6-2,067 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,48-BENI,4C-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.