BlockBefore

City Creek Ditch, Highland

City Creek Ditch, Highland, San Bernardino County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-2315, with a 4,070-word written history.

From the record

“The City Creek Ditch was determined eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places on May 14, under Criterion C at the local level of significance, as a rare intact example of a century, Southern Californian, stone-lined canal.”

Written record, HAER CA-2315 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-2315 · the record runs 4070 words · one of 145 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

54 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2315. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

1 Intake: Harrison Calif, Township 2N, NW of NW of Section 27, San Bernardino Base Line Meridian Approximately 250 south of the Section 22-Section 27 line. Latitude: 34 N; Longitude: 117 W Terminus: Harrison Calif, Township 2N, NE of SE of Section 28, San Bernardino Base Line Meridian Latitude: 34 N; Longitude: 117 W

Significance

67 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2315. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The City Creek Ditch was determined eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places on May 14, under Criterion C at the local level of significance, as a rare intact example of a century, Southern Californian, stone-lined canal. Its period of significance is to Report Prepared By:Margo Nayyar, Architectural Historian California Department of Transportation Division of Environmental Analysis Cultural Studies Office N Street, Sacramento, CA

Written history

3881 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2315. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The City Creek Ditch recordation was completed as mitigation for the State Route 330 Highway Improvement Project (Caltrans and was prepared as stipulated in the July 17, Memorandum of Agreement submitted to the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, in compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of as amended. Photographs were taken by Don Tateishi in Approximately feet of the City Creek Ditch was destroyed in during construction along State Route Date: February 1 This locational information is approximate and represents only the portion of the canal built in CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 2) Part I. Historical Information A. Physical History: 2 1.

Date of Construction: According to William Hammond Hall, who served as California s State Engineer between City Creek Ditch was surveyed in and constructed in by the City Creek Water Company. 3 2. Engineer: Unknown 3. Builder/Contractor: City Creek Water Company The City Creek Water Company incorporated in May and consisted of private property owners planning to construct an irrigation canal through their properties. Two known owners included William Henry Randall and William Tobey Noyes. 4 Randall was born in Pownal, Cumberland County, Maine. He originally worked at the family mill in Pownal until when he moved to Virginia City, Nevada to work in the quartz mines. In he briefly relocated to Riverside, California before purchasing land along City Creek in San Bernardino County.

He purchased 120 acres of land in conjunction with Noyes. 5 Randall worked as the foreman for the City Creek Ditch project and oversaw a gang of Chinamen [who completed the] digging, paving, and cementing. 6 Noyes was born in Dunham, Cumberland County, Maine. He worked as a carpenter until when he relocated to Virginia City, Nevada to work in the lumber industry. In he moved to San Francisco and worked as a foreman of carpenters at Alcatraz Island. He subsequently operated his own builder and contractor 2 Information in this section has been adapted and extensively edited from the California Department of Transportation s unpublished report: Historical Resources Evaluation Report Historic North Fork Canal, Highlands Canal and City Creek Ditch, by Stephen D. Mikesell.

Unless otherwise noted, all information is derived from the original report. Sources used are cited in the bibliography. 3 William Hammond Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, the Field, Water Supply, and Works, Organization and Operation in San Diego, San Bernardino, and Los Angeles Counties Report of the State Engineer (Sacramento: Young, Supt. State Printing, 4 John Brown Jr. and James Boyd, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties (Chicago, Illinois: Lewis Publishing Company, L.A. Ingersoll, Ingersoll s Century Annals of San Bernardino County, to (Los Angeles: L.A. Ingersoll, George William Beattie, Origin and Early Development of Water Rights in the East San Bernardino Valley, Bulletin No.

4 (Redlands: San Bernardino Valley Water Conservation District, 16; Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, 5 Ingersoll, Ingersoll s Century Annals, 6 Beattie, Origin and Early Development of Water Rights, CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 3) business in Oakland until he purchased the land along City Creek with Randall where he farmed fruit and vine crops. 7 4. Original plans and construction: The City Creek Ditch intake was originally located further north along City Creek at an unknown location. The majority of the main canal is unchanged from its original appearance. It is constructed of local cobble stones laid in and lined with concrete mortar, two sandboxes, a tunnel, and is constructed along the cliff side.

The trapezoidal shaped canal is roughly 1.5 feet wide at the base, three feet wide at the top, and two feet deep. The total length of the canal built in was approximately feet long. 5. Alterations and additions: A number of alterations to the original canal have taken place throughout the years. In the canal was extended approximately feet west of the current State Route In the this segment was piped as part of a large housing project and serves as storm water drainage. In circa a farmer installed a 200 foot long concrete cover over the canal where it passed through his land. In the canal was realigned to accommodate construction of State Route 30 (now known as State Route An inverted concrete siphon was constructed to carry the canal under the highway.

The siphon measures approximately 50 feet long. The original intake, a masonry dam, was located further north along City Creek at an unknown location. It failed shortly after it was constructed; since then the intake has been replaced and repaired on a continual basis. The current intake dates to the and is comprised of a series of cement blocks positioned across a portion of City Creek. At an unknown date, the California Department of Water Resources installed a small stream measurement gauge approximately half way between the intake and the tunnel. Furthermore, a metal pipe was installed along the canal several hundred feet downstream from the gauge at an unknown date. Lastly, approximately feet of the canal was destroyed in when State Route 330 was realigned and widened.

7 Ingersoll, Ingersoll s Century Annals, Ancestry.com. California, Death Index, [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 4) B. Historical Context: 8 The City Creek Ditch is located in the east San Bernardino Valley within the City Creek Canyon at the base of McKinley Mountain. Irrigation Development in the San Bernardino Valley Development of irrigation systems within the Santa Ana River basin began in the early century by Spanish and Mexican settlers. Spanish efforts were largely restricted to construction of water conveyance systems off of Mill Creek through modern day Redlands (approximately four miles south of City Creek Ditch).

Small implementations and expansions of irrigation systems continued throughout the century, but the largest expansion in the region began in the during a period of population increase and economic growth throughout Southern California; the City Creek Ditch was built during this time. 9 There were two phases of irrigation development in the east San Bernardino Valley. The phases are defined by small private company irrigation development from and large private company development from During the first phase a series of small individual water companies constructed large canals throughout the region. Most of these canals delivered water from the Santa Ana River to agricultural lands south and west of the Santa Ana River canyon.

Smaller streams in the area, such as City Creek, were also utilized for irrigation. To create a dependable water supply these companies developed reservoirs on the Santa Ana River to store water and generate hydroelectric power. One such company, the Bear Valley Land and Water Company built the Bear Valley Dam The dam, measuring 53 , created the Bear Valley Reservoir which provided dependable irrigation water to a large part of the east San Bernardino Valley; however, due to the economic recession, the company declared bankruptcy in stunting irrigation development in the region until the turn of the century.

10 During the second phase of irrigation development, various small private water companies consolidated to form larger companies, such as the Bear Valley Mutual Water Company The incorporated in acquired assets of firms including the In the built a larger dam at Bear Valley, creating Big Bear Lake reservoir. The new dam, measuring approximately 78 tall, vastly increased water capacity allowing for further expansion of the region s irrigation systems. After the dominated irrigation water distribution in the region.

As it gained prominence as a dependable 8 This context has been adapted and extensively edited from the California Department of Transportation s unpublished report: Historical Resources Evaluation Report Historic North Fork Canal, Highlands Canal and City Creek Ditch, by Stephen D. Mikesell. Unless otherwise noted, all information is derived from the original report. The report did not included footnotes stating the sources used. Sources used are cited in the bibliography.

9 Ingersoll, Ingersoll s Century Annals, Brown and Boyd, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 10 Ingersoll, Ingersoll s Century Annals, Brown and Boyd, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, Beattie, Origin and Early Development of Water Rights, Scott, Development of Water Facilities in the Santa Ana River Basin, California, (Menlo Park, California: United States Geological Survey, May CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 5) irrigation provider, it continued purchasing many of the smaller water companies in the area, thereby, increasing its irrigation distribution acreage. 11 Nineteenth century Southern California irrigation development was defined by the development of private water companies.

This sharply contrasts that of irrigation development in the California Central Valley where, beginning in the publically owned irrigation districts were the prominent irrigation developers. 12 The City Creek Ditch was constructed in by the City Creek Water Company. Additional century canals in the region include the North Fork Canal originally built by the North Fork Water Company, and the Highland Canal built by the Highland Ditch Company. Both companies were ultimately incorporated in the early in the early century.

Unlike the other early canals in the region, the City Creek Ditch remained independently owned until its acquisition by the East Valley Water District (EVWD) in As east San Bernardino County began urbanizing in the canals in the region refocused their efforts from agricultural irrigation to groundwater maintenance. Water was used for incidental, non- agricultural purposes, including water treatment and groundwater recharge. 13 Canals in the Region The first major canal to irrigate land west of the Santa Ana River canyon was the Cram and Van Leuven Ditch, constructed in Built to irrigate the lands of Lewis Cram and Frederick Van Leuven, the canal diverted water from the Santa Ana River, near the mouth of the canyon, approximately eight miles east of City Creek Ditch.

This canal was incorporated into the North Fork Canal and serves as the initial feet of the The entire approximately eight-mile NFC was built in phases between and to carry water to settlements between the Santa Ana River canyon and the townsite of Highland. William Hammond Hall, California s State Engineer from recorded physical characteristics of the NFC during his survey of irrigated agriculture in Southern California. According to Hall, the canal was excavated and lined with boulders in concrete mortar. The canal was carried by flume across streams, particularly City Creek. In the NFC irrigated approximately acres. 14 The Highland Canal was constructed in by the Highland Ditch Company. Designed as an extension to the it expanded the service area of the North Fork system.

Initially, it diverted water from the NFC on the east side of City Creek. 15 The City Creek Ditch, a modest canal in comparison to the North Fork and Highland Canals, is the last remaining of three small City Creek canals built to divert City Creek water. The first 11 Ingersoll, Ingersoll s Century Annals, Scott, Development of Water Facilities, 32.

12 JRP Historical Consulting Services and California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), Water Conveyance Systems in California: Historic Context Development and Evaluation Procedures (Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, December 13 Scott, Development of Water Facilities in the Santa Ana River Basin, and Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, and 14 Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, Scott, Development of Water Facilities, 15 Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, Scott, Development of Water Facilities, 33. CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 6) canal, known as the Baseline Ditch diverted City Creek water north of present day Highlands Avenue.

A second canal, built along Highlands Avenue in was incorporated into the North Fork Canal in The third canal, City Creek Ditch, built in diverted water further upstream than the other two canals. It followed a meandering course through the foothills, terminating near Baldridge Wash, a natural watershed which drained into the Highland Canal. City Creek Ditch is a cobblestone and concrete mortar canal. It was extended an additional feet west in and by it was approximately feet long and irrigated 200 acres. 16 Portion of Harrison Calif. USGS Topographic Quadrangle showing City Creek Ditch, Highland Canal, and North Fork Canal.

16 Hall, Report of the Special Committee of the United State Senate on the Irrigation and Reclamation of Arid Lands, (Government Printing Press: Washington, Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, Scott, Development of Water Facilities in the Santa Ana River Basin, CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 7) A similar canal to the City Creek Ditch was described for a larger project on Lytle Creek. In the Grapeland Irrigation District developed plans for a reservoir and irrigation canal to deliver water to the Rialto and Etiwanda areas, about 10 miles west of Highland. The dam was designed by James D. Schuyler, a well-known California dam engineer who built the Sweetwater Dam in San Diego.

The lead hydraulic engineer was Finckle, who later became the chief engineer for the Edison Company of Los Angeles (now known as the Southern California Edison). In Finckle s Chief Engineer s Report, he described the method of construction for the stone-lined canal, as well as the canal dimensions, cobblestone dimensions, the radius of the sidewall curves, and the quality of the cement and sand. City Creek Ditch Construction According to Hall, City Creek Ditch was surveyed in and constructed in The Ditch originally measured approximately feet long and cost By Hall s calculations, construction should have cost $1 per foot, or and according to Hall it is doubtful whether it would at that time have been constructed, but for the very low offer made.

17 The canal was extended approximately feet west in By the Ditch measured approximately feet long and irrigated approximately 200 acres, all in the benchland north of present day Highland Avenue and east of Palm Avenue. 18 The City Creek Ditch was constructed during the last decade of stone canal construction. The earliest American built canals in San Bernardino County were open, earthen canals. However, earthen canals proved inefficient in a number of ways including water evaporation, water seepage, and the high cost of canal maintenance due to erosion and labor. Stone-lined canals were commonly built in the area between the and The popularity of stone-lined canals was due to their cost effectiveness, water efficiency, and durability of the local cobblestones used for construction.

A cobblestone canal, such as the City Creek Ditch, has a very low rate of water seepage, and was more durable and required less maintenance costs when compared to earthen lined canals. On the other hand, cobblestones required a substantial amount of initial construction investment. They were naturally available in the area; however, they required high labor costs during construction. After canal builders in Southern California commonly utilized an all-concrete design because concrete was a low cost material, required low labor costs, had a greater carrying capacity than earthen canals, and required less maintenance than both earthen and stone canals. Cement was the most efficient development in water conveyance systems for the era.

19 17 Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, 18 Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, Scott, Development of Water Facilities, 19 JRP and Caltrans, Water Conveyance Systems in California, 86. CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 8) Part II. Structural/ Design Information A. General Statement: 1. Character: The City Creek Ditch is significant as a rare intact example of a century, Southern Californian, stone-lined canal. It was hand dug and constructed with local cobble stones and concrete mortar shortly before concrete became widely used in canal construction. Because of its small size and trivial use in water conveyance in the region, it remained mostly unchanged from its original appearance.

The Ditch was determined eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places on May 14, under Criterion C at the local level of significance, as a rare intact example of a century, Southern Californian, stone-lined canal. Its period of significance is to The eligible segment of the canal includes the original feet of the canal from the intake to the western terminus of the tunnel; the additional feet of the canal built in which has been piped is not eligible for the 2. Condition of Fabric: The ditch is in fair condition. B. Description: 1. Materials: The majority of City Creek Ditch is composed of local cobble stones laid in and lined with concrete mortar. 2.

Overall dimensions: The trapezoidal shaped canal is roughly 1.5 feet wide at the base, three feet wide at the top, and two feet deep. The total length of the canal built in is approximately feet. The grade of the canal was described by William Hammond Hall as 1 inch to the rod, or a ratio of 20 3. Layout: From the intake on City Creek, the canal meandered following the ridge line paralleling the creek. It crossed under State Route 330 approximately feet downstream. The canal is comprised of four major elements including the intake, main canal; tunnel; and the canal extension used to distribute water beyond the tunnel. i. Intake: The intake is comprised of a series of cement blocks positioned across a portion of City Creek.

The temporary dam dates to the late The original masonry dam was located further upstream but washed out shortly after its construction. According to East Valley Water District officials, the ditch intake had been replaced and repaired on an annual basis since it was built. ii. Main Canal: The main canal extends from the intake to the tunnel. The canal is composed of local cobble stones set in concrete mortar and lining. 20 Hall, Irrigation in Southern California, CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 9) The most impressive portion of the main canal includes a foot segment cut from solid rock along the cliff face. The remainder of the canal was excavated through a gentle grade on the bluff along the west side of City Creek. iii.

Tunnel: The tunnel, located just west of State Route was cut through solid rock and measured approximately 225 feet long, three feet tall, and three feet wide. iv. Canal extension: The canal west of the tunnel was originally designed to distribute water to agricultural land. The approximately foot canal extension terminated near Baldridge Wash which drained into the Highland Canal. This segment of City Creek Ditch was constructed in but in the this segment was piped as part of a large housing project. 4. Features: Several distinctive features located along the canal include a stream gauge, concrete cover, metal pipe, concrete siphon, and two sandboxes. i. Sandboxes: An original component of the canal includes sandboxes which collected and flushed out debris from the canal.

Debris build up diminishes the canal carrying capacity and compromises the water supply. Sandboxes for the City Creek Ditch are located at two critical points along the canal: the beginning of the system just downstream from the intake, and just upstream from the tunnel (where siltation cannot be removed without closing down the entire canal). ii. Concrete Cover: In circa a farmer installed a 200 foot long concrete cover over the canal where it passed through his land. It is located just upstream from the second sandbox. iii. Stream Gauge: At an unknown date, the California Department of Water Resources installed a small stream measurement gauge approximately half way between the intake and the tunnel. iv.

Metal pipe culvert: A metal pipe was installed along the canal several hundred feet downstream from the gauge at an unknown date. v. Concrete Siphon: In the canal was rerouted to accommodate the newly constructed State Route 30 (now known as State Route An inverted concrete siphon was constructed to carry the canal under the highway. The siphon measures approximately 50 feet long. C. Site Information: The City Creek Ditch extends from City Creek within the City Creek Canyon, at the base of McKinley Mountain. Shrubland surrounds the canal and canyon at the canal intake. The canal has flowed through orchards beginning near the gauging station from the until c. CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 10) After the agricultural land was developed as part of residential developments.

State Route 30 (now State Route was constructed along the City Creek Canyon in and in State Route 330 was realigned and widened. CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 11) Part III. Sources of Information Adams, Frank. Irrigation Districts in California. State of California, Department of Public Works, Alexander, J.A. The Life of George Chaffey: Story of Irrigation Beginnings in California and Australia. Melbourne: Macmilland & Co., Ancestry.com. California, Death Index, [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., Beattie, George William. Origin and Early Development of Water Rights in the East San Bernardino Valley, Bulletin No. 4. Redlands: San Bernardino Valley Water Conservation District, Brown, John, and James Boyd.

History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties. Chicago: Western Historical Association, Dumke, Glenn S. The Boom of the Eighties in Southern California. San Marino: Huntington Library, Finckle, Chief Engineer s Report on the Grapeland Irrigation District: Its Physical and Engineering Problems and Business Status with a Brief History of Its Organization and Confirmation. Los Angeles: Times-Mirror Printing and Binding House, Gallup, Aaron and Bonnie Parks. Cobblestone Architecture in California s Pomona Valley. Paper presented at Building the West: Vernacular Architecture West of the Rockies, conference in Reno, Nevada, September 22, Hall. William Hammond. Report of the State Engineer to the Legislature of the State of California Session of Sacramento: Young, Supt.

State Printing, Irrigation in Southern California, the Field, Water Supply, and Works, Organization and Operation in San Diego, San Bernardino, and Los Angeles Counties Report of the State Engineer. Sacramento: Young, Supt. State Printing, Report of the Special Committee of the United State Senate on the Irrigation and Reclamation of Arid Lands. Washington: Government Printing Press, The Santa Ana Canal of the Bear Valley Irrigation Company. American Society of Civil Engineers, Hinckley, Horace P. An History of Bear Valley Mutual Water Company, Big Bear Lake: Bear Valley Mutual Water Company, CITY CREEK DITCH HAER No. CA-2315 (Page 12) Hornbeck, David and Howard Botts. Seven Oaks Dam Project: Water Systems. Prepared for U.S.

Army Corps of Engineers, Los Angeles District, March 1, Ingersoll, L.A. Ingersoll s Century Annals of San Bernardino County, to Los Angeles: L.A. Ingersoll, Jelinek, Lawrence J. Harvest Empire: History of California Agriculture. San Francisco: Boyd & Fraser, JRP Historical Consulting Services and California Department of Transportation. Water Conveyance Systems in California: Historic Context Development and Evaluation Procedures. Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, December Lippincott, Joseph Barlow. Development and Application of Water Near San Bernardino, Colton, and Riverside, California. In Water Supply and Irrigation Papers of the United States Geological Survey, Washington: Government Printing Press, Mikesell, Stephen D.

Historic Resource Evaluation Report Historic North Fork Canal, Highlands Canal, and City Creek Ditch, Unpublished report on file at the California Department of Transportation Cultural Studies Office, N Street, Sacramento, CA Myers, William. Iron Men and Copper Wires: A centennial History of the Southern California Edison Company. Glendale: Trans-Anglo Books, Schuiling, Walter C. San Bernardino County: Land of Contrasts. Woodland Hills, California: Windsor Publications, Shallot, Todd A. Fresno s Water Rivalry: Competition for a Scarce Resource Chicago: Public Works Historical Society, Scott, Development of Water Facilities in the Santa Ana River Basin, California, A Compilation Of Historical Notes Derived From Many Sources Describing Ditch and Canal Companies, Diversions, and Water Rights.

Menlo Park, California: United States Geological Survey, May

In context

Highland, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Bernardino County, California 963 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Bernardino County

24 of 144 records shown

The federal survey recorded these other structures elsewhere in San Bernardino County. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Santa Ana River Hydroelectric SystemHAER CAL,36-REDLD.V,1-62,521 words
Colorado River AqueductHAER CAL,36-PARD.V,1-33,648 words
Lost Horse Gold MillHAER CAL,36-TNPAL.V,5-29,579 words
Wall Street Gold MillHAER CAL,36-TNPAL.V,2-26,849 words
Sam & Alfreda Maloof CompoundHABS CAL,36-RANCU,3-15,953 words
Desert Queen RanchHABS CAL,36-TNPAL.V,1-11,866 words
Barstow-Daggett AirportHAER CAL,3-DAGT.V,1A-10,618 words
Pinto Wye ArrastraHAER CAL,36-TNPAL.V,4-10,447 words
Goerlitz HouseHABS CAL,36-RANCU,2-9,198 words
Getchell RanchHABS CA-29548,511 words
Euclid AvenueHAER CAL,36-UPLD,18,430 words
Mill Creek 2 and 3 Hydroelectric SystemsHAER CA-22728,010 words
Chaffey-Isle HouseHABS CAL,36-RANCU,1-6,772 words
Desert Queen RanchHAER CAL,36-TNPAL.V,3A-5,538 words
U.S. Route 66HAER CA-23455,387 words
Sainsevain PropertyHABS CAL,36-FONT,1-5,233 words
Burlington Northern Santa Fe RailroadHAER CA-22595,098 words
Desert Queen RanchHABS CAL,36-TNPAL.V,1A-4,920 words
San Bernardino Valley CollegeHABS CA-2729-A4,558 words
Mill Creek 2 and 3 Hydroelectric SystemsHAER CA-2272-Q4,238 words
San Bernardino Valley CollegeHABS CA-2729-C4,087 words
Parker DamHAER AZ-54-A3,568 words
Casa Del DesiertoHABS CAL,36-BAR,1-3,384 words
Latimer Packing HouseHABS CAL,36-ONT,1-3,255 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-2315. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.