Highland Hospital, 1411 East 31st Street, Oakland, Alameda County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-111, with a 47,087-word written history.
From the record
“The original portions of Highland Hospital were formally determined eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C in the areas of architecture, community planning, and medicine at the local level of significance in Based on this determination of eligibility, Highland Hospital is also listed on the California Register of Historical Resources (California Register).”
Written record, HALS CA-111 survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-111 · the record runs 47087 words · one of 198 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HALS CA-111.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
East Street, Oakland, Alameda County, California. Latitude: Longitude: (Historic Main Entrance Gate, Google Earth, Highland Hospital is located on a 14.14-acre triangular-shaped parcel that is bounded on the north by East Street, on the east by Avenue, and on the west by Vallecito Place. Vallecito Place and Avenue meet at a sharp angle at the south end of the parcel, forming the tip of the triangle. The base of the triangle is formed by East Street. The site slopes downward from an elevation of at East Street to 87' at its south end at Vallecito Place and Avenue. The southern portion of the site contains the remaining buildings, structures, and landscape features from the original campus development.
The historic main entrance gate to the hospital is located at the intersection of Vallecito Place and Avenue. Newer hospital facilities) that are not part of the original hospital campus are located on the northern portion of the site; these include the Clinic and Auditorium buildings, the Acute Care Tower, the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center, two parking garages, and their related landscape features. 1 New Highland Park Hospital Name Adopted, Oakland Tribune, 16 October Siegel & Strain Architects, Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey iii.
Highland Hospital Hals
No. CA-111 (Page 2) Residential neighborhoods characterized by single-family houses and multi-family apartment buildings surround the Highland Hospital site. Interstate 580 (I-580) is located less than two-tenths of a mile to the north. Lake Merritt, a key geographical feature in Oakland, is located approximately one and two-tenths miles to the west, and the downtown core of the city is located just west of the lake.
Present Use
45 words
Source document
Quoted word for word from HALS CA-111.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Highland Hospital is Alameda County s principal acute-care and trauma facility for medically indigent and uninsured patients. The facility also has an Emergency Department, an Obstetric service that is available to all pregnant women in the county, and a comprehensive array of medical specialty clinics.
Significance
792 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HALS CA-111.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The original portions of Highland Hospital were formally determined eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C in the areas of architecture, community planning, and medicine at the local level of significance in Based on this determination of eligibility, Highland Hospital is also listed on the California Register of Historical Resources (California Register). The California Register-listed historical resources include the Administration Building, the five Ward Buildings, the Service Building, the Power Plant, and the Landscaping.
3 The Highland Hospital landscape is a relatively intact example of Beaux- Arts public landscape architecture from the and appears to be significant as an example of the application of Beaux-Arts design principles to a pavilion-style hospital site plan and landscape design, as an example of the use of the Spanish Colonial Revival style in public landscape architecture in California in the and as an example of the 2 National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places, Highland Hospital. E.O. Determination of Eligibility Notification, 2 May 3 Milford Wayne Donaldson (California Office of Historic Preservation), Letter to Bruce Jenner (Senior Planner, Alameda County Planning Department).
No. CA-111 (Page 3) work of architect Henry H. Meyers and landscape architect Howard Gilkey. Henry Haight Meyers was a life-long Alameda County resident who began his architecture practice in as an apprentice with the firm of Percy and Hamilton, which was one of California s most respected architectural offices during the late nineteenth century. He retired from practice in Over the course of his career, Meyers designed over 200 buildings in the San Francisco Bay Area, Northern California, Hawaii, and Guam in his private practice and in conjunction with his role as the Alameda County Architect.
During the 24 years he served as the county s architect, Meyers prepared designs for Highland Hospital, the office for the Assessor and Tax Collector, the Juvenile Court and Detention Home, the County Morgue, a recreation center, veterans memorial buildings for ten of the county s municipalities, additions and an annex to the Court House, additions and alterations to the Hall of Records, and alterations to the County Jail.
Howard Ellsworth Gilkey was a locally-prominent landscape architect who practiced in Oakland from the late through the After his graduation from the University of California, Berkeley in Gilkey was involved in work for private estates and for a wide range of public projects, including work at Mills College, for the city of Oakland, and as a longtime consultant to the Alameda County Institutions Commission, the board overseeing the county s hospitals. During his lifetime, Gilkey was probably best known for his role as the designer and director of the California Spring Garden Show in Oakland that featured thematic, stage-set spectacles with evocative names such as the Moorish Gardens, the Rain Forests of the Pacific, Shangri-La, Fantasia, El Dorado, and From Kew to Kyoto.
The site design, landscape features, and the health-care, support, and residential buildings at Highland Hospital were designed by Meyers. His site design exhibited the hallmark Beaux-Arts principles of balance, symmetry, proportion, and axiality. The use of similar materials and detailing for the landscape s built features and site furnishings as those used in the exterior treatment of the buildings extended the Spanish Colonial Revival style into the landscape setting and helped to unify the overall design for the hospital facility. The formal outdoor spaces and refined landscape setting were considered a critical component of the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 4) health-restoring activities of the institution, 4 and the landscape including the main entrance gate, monumental entrance staircase feature and entrance plaza, and the stands of evergreen trees formed a critical part of the public image of the hospital.
Gilkey prepared the plans for the planting design after Meyers site design was developed, and although the ideas from these initial plans were never fully realized, key vegetation features that are closely identified with the hospital s landscape the surviving stands of evergreen trees located along the sides of the campus next to Avenue and Vallecito Place, the incense cedars located at the corners of the landings for the Main Stairs and along the base of the Main Terrace walls, the location of lawns in the slopes in front of the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, and the use of palms to frame entrances and key features are based on Gilkey s design.
Gilkey oversaw the establishment of the vegetation features through the initial stages of development and contributed to the hospital s landscape design by selecting the species and location of plant materials and by overseeing planting during the years following the official opening of the hospital.
Written history
45802 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 D. Sources Not Yet Investigated. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 E. Supplemental Material.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 PART IV. PROJECT INFORMATION. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 8) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date(s) of Establishment5 The Alameda County Board of Supervisors attempted to establish a new county hospital in Oakland as early as and went as far as evaluating a number of sites for the future facility.
This effort was delayed when voters rejected a bond issue in In the county adopted a new health-care plan that called for separate institutions with specialized functions rather than one general facility. As part of this new strategy, the county spent to acquire a hillside tract in the Highland district of east Oakland as the site for its proposed acute-care facility. The initial land purchase covered about 9.5 acres, and by the full site, slightly more than 14 acres, had been acquired.6 The roughly triangular site was bounded by Avenue on the east, Vallecito Place on the west, and East Street on the north. This section of Oakland had begun to develop in the late nineteenth century, providing a semi- rural setting for scattered houses overlooking the city s downtown and shoreline.
By World War I, the district was more urbanized, though still primarily residential, and was solidly built up with bungalows and apartment buildings. 7 The property had previously been used as the campus for the California College, an institution of higher learning operated by the Baptist Church, but the college was closed by When the county purchased the property there were only a few, vacant, wood-frame buildings located in the northern portion of the site.8 Design and construction of the new hospital was overseen by Henry H. Meyers, the county architect. In early the county hired Dr. Richard G.
Brodrick, the director of the San Francisco Hospital, to supervise the construction of the new hospital.9 Brodrick was expected to 5 Information in the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for Alameda County by Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in was used in the preparation of this section of the report. 6 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 7. 7 Ibid. 8 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 9 Brodrick, who graduated from Cooper Medical College in initially had a one-year contract to focus on the design for Highland; county architect Henry Meyers paid of Brodrick s salary year out of the budget he received from the county for the hospital s architectural plans.
In February Brodrick s contract was extended ,and he remained the director of the Alameda County hospitals through supervising the completion of HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 9) outline plans for the acute-care facility and was hired based on the strength of the technical knowledge he had acquired during the construction of the San Francisco Hospital.10 This was a fairly typical arrangement during the and when physicians with expertise in planning and construction were often hired to assist and serve as consultants to the architect.11 Brodrick was listed on the title block of Meyers site plan as a Consultant. Brodrick was influential in helping to shape a more progressive direction for the new hospital.
The initial plan to construct a bungalow type of hospital was replaced with a more ambitious pavilion plan and reinforced concrete construction in July and cost estimates for the new facility rose from million to between $2 and 2.5 million. The decision to change the plan and the added costs were justified since these would make the institution the rival of any hospital in the entire country. 12 In October, the Board of Supervisors voted to name the new facility the Highland Hospital of Alameda County. Brodrick advocated the selection of a name that would relieve the hospital of the onus that usually attaches in the mind of people to a public institution.
He helped to persuade the board by explaining that in other places the practice of getting away from the county name is being followed and gave the example of a county hospital in Los Angeles that was given the name The Olive View Hospital because it overlooks the largest olive orchard in the world. 13 It had been the intention of the county government to complete the hospital rapidly, with funds provided by voter-approved bonds that were placed on the ballot in However, the bond issue failed to pass, as had an earlier one in As a result, construction on the hospital stretched over seven years, from to and occurred in tandem with the design process.
During the first five years of the project, costs were covered by the county s general tax fund, in yearly appropriations ranging from under to over The passage of a million bond issue at a special election in May in the midst of a rebounding economy Highland Hospital and overseeing the establishment of a modern hospital system for the county. He left in April to become physician superintendent of the Stanford Hospital and professor of hospital administration in the Stanford Medical School (Oakland Tribune, 9 February California and Western Medicine [May 10 Contract Is Offered to Dr.
Brodrick, Oakland Tribune, 9 February 11 Annmarie Adams , Medicine by Design: The Architect and the Modern Hospital, (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 12 Building Cost of Hospital is Increasing, Oakland Tribune, 17 July 13 New Highland Park Hospital Name Adopted, Oakland Tribune, 16 October The board officially declared that the of Alameda County would be dropped in common parlance and the facility would be known simply as Highland Hospital. The official name was a compromise since certain members of the board objected to the elimination entirely of the name of the county and so the of Alameda County was tacked on at the end. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 10) recently recovered from the postwar recession allowed the work to be brought to completion over the next two years, at a total construction cost of over $3 million. 14 Highland Hospital was completed in October and the formal dedication took place on 12 December before citizens of the county with appropriate exercises to officially open the service of the new institution. 16 2. Landscape designers Architect Henry H. Meyers was the primary designer for the original Highland Hospital. In addition to the design of the buildings, he prepared the site plan and the plans and details for the landscape design between and as part of his duties as county architect.
His design for the landscape encompassed the grading plan, the circulation system, site furnishings such as fountains and light fixtures, and the built landscape features including the boundary retaining wall, the entrance gate structures, the Main Terrace (the entrance plaza and staircase feature in front of the Administration Building), the East and West Gardens (formal landscape spaces adjacent to the Administration Building), the three courtyards between the ward buildings, and the courtyard and terrace for the Nurses Home.17 Landscape architect Howard Gilkey prepared a planting design for the campus sometime toward the end of the construction phase of the original facility or soon after the hospital s completion in late the planting plans by Gilkey for Highland Hospital are undated.
His plan was never fully implemented, and only limited portions of the plant materials specified on his plans were actually installed. Extant examples of the vegetation from his design include the stands of evergreen trees along the frontages next to Avenue and Vallecito Place, the incense cedars located at the corners of the landings for the Main Terrace s twin staircases and along the bases of its retaining walls, and the palms framing entrances or key features (i.e., the fountains in the East and West Gardens).
Gilkey oversaw the establishment of the vegetation features through at least the initial stages of development and contributed to the hospital s landscape design by making decisions concerning the selection and location of plant materials and overseeing planting for, at least, several years following the official opening of the hospital. Very little 14 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 9. 15 Henry Meyers, Highland Hospital Now Stands Complete; Its Story Told by Architect, Oakland Tribune, 24 October 16 New Highland Hospital Dedicated by Leaders, Oakland Tribune, 13 December 17 Dr. Richard G. Brodrick served as a consultant to Meyers on the design of the hospital plan. Glenn B. Ashcroft served as structural engineer. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 11) documentation was located about how long it took to install the vegetation or the length of Gilkey s continued involvement. a. Henry H. Meyers Henry Haight Meyers a life-long resident of Alameda County, was born in rural Livermore into a pioneer Alameda County family. He was the oldest of the nine children of Jacob and Mary Meyers. His father was a pioneer builder and contractor who came to California with an immigrant train from Pennsylvania in the and his mother, born in Alsace- Lorraine, came to the State as a young woman by sailing vessel and a trip across the Isthmus of Panama.
18 After he graduated from high school, Meyers studied architecture at night in San Francisco and in became an apprentice with the firm of Percy and Hamilton, one of California s most respected architectural offices during the late nineteenth century. Meyers advanced to become the firm s chief draftsman and then following the principals deaths (Hamilton in and Percy in took over the firm. Between and Meyers practiced in partnership with Clarence R. Ward as Meyers & Ward. The firm played an important role in the reconstruction of San Francisco after the earthquake, designing skyscrapers, office buildings, retail stores, factories, and warehouses for the devastated districts of the city. After the firm disbanded in Meyers worked under his own name, without partners.
He took on associates George R. Klinkhardt in and his oldest daughter, Mildred S. Meyers, a graduate of the University of California Berkeley School of Architecture, around During his forty-year practice, Meyers designed over 200 buildings in the San Francisco Bay Area, Northern California, Hawaii, and Guam. His work for his private practice included commercial buildings, churches, hotels, schools, and residences.20 Meyers began his association with the Alameda County Board of Supervisors in initially as a consulting architect for the Alameda County Infirmary competition (Fairmont Hospital) and later as the officially-appointed county architect, a position he continued to hold until shortly before his retirement from private professional practice in (During the period that he 18 Henry H.
Meyers, Architect, Dies, Oakland Tribune, 27 May 22. 19 Both individuals are listed on the site plan for the addition to the hospital that connected Wing A/Ward 2 to the porte cochere (the ambulance entrance) on the east end of the Administration Building. 20 University of California, Environmental Design Archives, Henry H. Meyers Biography Henry H. Meyers, Architect, Dies, Oakland Tribune, 27 May 22; Online Archive of California, Collection Guide, Henry H. Meyer Collection, Siegel & Strain Architects 4; David Parry, Percy & Hamilton in Encyclopedia of San Francisco HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 12) worked as the county architect, Meyers also continued his private practice.) Meyers produced designs for a wide range of county facilities including the office for the Assessor and Tax Collector, the Juvenile Court and Detention Home, the County Morgue, a recreation center, veterans memorial buildings for ten of the county s municipalities, additions and an annex to the Court House, additions and alterations to the Hall of Records, and alterations to the County Jail.21 Meyers had extensive experience in hospital design.
The preponderance of his work for Alameda County involved hospitals, including new and remodeled facilities built at the Alameda County Infirmary Complex (Fairmont Hospital) between and the Alameda County Tuberculosis Sanitarium (Arroyo Sanitarium) and Del Valle Farm in Livermore, and Highland Hospital in Oakland. Meyers also designed hospitals in his private practice, and the project list for the Henry H.
Meyers Collection in the Environmental Design Archive at the University of California, Berkeley included designs for a Standard County Hospital Layout the Hahnemann Hospital in San Francisco, the Siskiyou County Hospital (unbuilt; in Yreka, the California Sanitorium Children's Hospital in Belmont, and the San Francisco Tuberculosis Preventorium located in San Mateo County.22 Meyers displayed an adherence to Beaux-Arts principles in his designs for buildings throughout his career, and this was particularly evident in his site plan for Highland Hospital and in the relationships between its components.
His use of Spanish Colonial Revival imagery at Highland was consistent with the Beaux-Arts notion of proportion and reflected the popularity of this style in public architecture in California, which was associated with efforts to identify California with its Hispanic past and in doing so to distinguish California from other parts of the United States. In Meyers married Bertha May, whose father was a prominent rancher in Alvarado, California. The couple had three daughters: Mildred an architect who practiced with her father, Edith a physician, and Jeanette who oversaw the family s 1,200-acre Dry Creek Ranch near Union City. In Meyers designed a house for his family on Alameda Avenue in the city of Alameda, where he lived with his family for the rest of his life.
The family s ranch is now a public park owned by the East Bay Regional Park District, County of Alameda. The Meyers family home, located at Alameda Avenue in Alameda, is now a house museum.23 21 Siegel & Strain Architects, Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey . . . 4; University of California, Environmental Design Archives, Henry H. Meyers Biography 22 Ibid. 23 Alameda Museum, Meyers House & Garden website, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 13) Meyers died on 26 May at the age of 75, after a two-week illness.
His obituary in the Oakland Tribune stated that he had been on the City Planning Commission for Alameda for six years and was a member of the California Horticultural Society, the American Institute of Architects, the California State Association of Architects, the Oak Grove Lodge No. 215 F & A.M. (Free & Accepted Masons), and the Alameda Chapter No. 70 Royal Arch Masons.24 b. Howard Gilkey Howard Ellsworth Gilkey was a locally-prominent landscape architect who practiced in Oakland from the late through the Gilkey was born in Winthrop, Iowa but spent his earliest years in Greenbriar, Tennessee, a small town about 30 miles north of Nashville.
In his family moved to Peoria, Illinois and from there to Santa Rosa, California in Gilkey recognized his affinity for horticulture at a very early age, and in a newspaper article written in he described his attempt at age four to plant a wild gentian and a wild violet together with the hope of mixing them. He interrupted his high school education for two years when he had the opportunity to work for the famed horticulturist Luther Burbank between and Part of his work for Burbank included cross-pollenization experiments that resulted in a spineless cactus.
26 In Gilkey returned to complete his high school education at Santa Rosa High School and graduated from there in In he enrolled at the University of California, Berkeley, in the College of Agriculture s Division of Landscape Gardening and Floriculture, the forerunner of the Department of Landscape Architecture in the College of Environmental Design. (He paid his way to attend the university by taking orders for a new variety of gladiolus bulb, which had been given to him by Burbank.) At the university, his education was in the Beaux-Arts tradition of landscape design, which was the basis for all landscape architectural education during this period, and furthered his horticultural expertise.
He graduated from the university in In Gilkey worked on a number of endeavors that provided him with valuable experience and that helped to further his early career as a landscape architect. He worked with Carl Purdy on 24 Henry H. Meyers, Architect, Dies, Oakland Tribune, 27 May 22. 25 Jack Burroughs, Your Town: Block House To Expo Building, Oakland Tribune, 26 December 26 Burroughs 27 Burroughs Vonn Marie May, Robert Sabbatini, and Karen Fiene, Celebrating the Cultural Landscape Heritage of Mills College (Oakland: Center for the Book, Mills College, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 14) the design and installation of the exhibits in the Hall of Horticulture at the Panama-Pacific International Exposition in San Francisco. He also teamed with Charles W. Dickey and John J.
Donovan to prepare a comprehensive plan for Oakland s Mills College campus. Although this campus plan was never implemented, it led to his association with the college during the as a consulting landscape architect where he worked hand in hand with campus architect [Walter Ratcliff]. Among the projects he worked on at Mills College were a civil engineering survey to prepare a detailed base map of the campus, the Ethel Moore Hall landscape (the interior courtyards and the surrounding landscape), and the Music Building landscape (the landscape across the front elevation of the building, the front courtyard, and the adjacent naturalistic pond).
He also taught briefly at the college in and Gilkey s association with the Oakland and Alameda County governments began when he worked as a payroll clerk for the Oakland Board of Education for eighteen months during and During his off hours he reportedly laid out Lakeside Drive and several small parks around the city. Then during and Gilkey was the city park engineer and acting city planning engineer for the City of Oakland. He was responsible for the original duck pond at Lake Merritt, the landscaping along the Lake Merritt shoreline (including the Lakeshore Drive parkway and the Cleveland Cascade), and bedding designs for the front of City Hall.
Gilkey served as a longtime consultant to the Alameda County Institutions Commission, the board overseeing the county s hospitals, and it was likely that it was in this capacity that he prepared the planting design for Highland Hospital.29 During the Gilkey worked on both private and public projects as he established his practice. An advertisement in the Oakland Tribune s Yearbook, listed St. Mary s College in Moraga, the Modesto Junior College, the San Luis Obispo High School, the Piedmont schools, the Congregational Church in Oakland, Auburn High School, and the grounds surrounding many private mansions as examples of recent Gilkey projects. (Identifiable examples of private estate work included two gardens in Piedmont, one belonging to William Mainland and the other to C. J.
Hesseman, that were featured in photographs in articles by Gilkey in the American Landscape Architect in and respectively.) Other known projects in Oakland included 28 Burroughs May et. al. and H.E. Gilkey, Garden Show Architect, Sued by Wife, Oakland Post-Enquirer, 8 May Several of these sources also mentioned that he taught briefly at the University of California, Berkeley. 29 Burroughs Oakland Post-Enquirer, 8 May Seigel & Strain 5. Gilkey also worked as a substitute high school teacher in the Oakland Public Schools for a year.
This position may have contributed to the report School Grounds, their design and development that he prepared in with his wife, Frances Hessel Gilkey, for the state s superintendent of secondary schools; the University of California, Berkeley, Bancroft Library has a copy of this report. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 15) the early work that led to the Woodminister Cascades at the Joaquin Miller Park and the arboretum for the Joseph Knowland Arboretum and Park.30 During his lifetime, Gilkey was probably best known for his role as the designer and director of the California Spring Garden Show in Oakland.
He was a founding member of the Businessmen s Garden Club that started the event in the late and it was generally accepted that it was his idea to create the thematic, stage-set spectacles for which the show became known. These creations were given descriptive names such as Moorish Gardens, Rain Forests of the Pacific, Shangri-La, Fantasia, El Dorado, and From Kew to Kyoto. Long-time friend and associate Arthur Navlet stated that Gilkey s concept for the show was unique when they started the show: At the time, the Philadelphia, New York, and Boston shows were tops in the nation. These shows used the unlimited resources of wealthy eastern estates.
Their individual exhibits surpassed ours in quality of plant material, but each exhibit was unrelated, so their shows were a beautiful collection of exhibits. There was no thought of a unified picture or theme.31 The use of themes or narratives and intricate plant palettes were characteristic of Gilkey s designs even before his work with the Garden Show. Vonn Marie May, in her history of the landscape at Mills College, described Gilkey s design for Moore Hall in (several years prior to the first Garden Show and around the same time that he prepared his planting plan for Highland Hospital) as a series of themed courtyards with different narratives and species of plants.
32 She noted that in his narrative descriptions of these spaces, Gilkey was very specific about the use of color and that his planting palette seemed nearly unlimited, displaying a variety of colors such as flame scarlet, copper, henna orange, soft buff yellows, and crimson. 33 His planting plan for Highland Hospital also involved this same type of detailed use of vegetation. Additionally, the Garden Shows and his other known works from this period all reflected historical references and typical Beaux-Arts tenets. 30 Garden Estates in Some Beautiful East Bay Homes. Comprising recent works executed by Howard Gilkey, noted landscape Architect . . . Oakland Tribune Yearbook, (Oakland: Oakland Tribune, advertisement located between pp.
80 and 81; Howard Gilkey, Importance of Garden Design, American Landscape Architect, Vol I (November Howard Gilkey, The role of the Landscape Architect. American Landscape Architect, Vol IV, No. 3 (March 41. 31 Navlet, Arthur E, Howard Gilkey and the California Spring Garden Shows, Pacific Horticulture, Vol. 37, No. 2 (October 29. 32 May et. al. 63. 33 Ibid. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 16) In Gilkey achieved national recognition when the Garden Show and his work were featured in an article in the Saturday Evening Post.
In recognition of his work, he was chosen by the Oakland Eastbay Garden Center, an association of 55 garden clubs, as their "Man of the Year for In accepting this award, Gilkey reflected on his perennial approach to his designs for the Garden Show and other projects and characterized himself as "a devotee of the goddess of the wildflowers.''34 Gilkey died in Berkeley on 9 September at the age of 82. His obituary, in the Oakland Tribune, noted that although he was best known for his 23 designs for the Garden Shows, Gilkey was a prominent Oakland landscape architect for more than a half century. In a tribute to him in Pacific Horticulture, Arthur Navlet described Gilkey as a man blessed with vigor and boundless energy.
He was also a man of wide-ranging interests and talents who developed a strain of colored astroemerias for recreation, was an authority on plant identification and nomenclature, wrote an opera, and published an illustrated epic poem, The Great Design, which told the story of man's evolution "from the primeval ooze."35 3. Builder, Contractor, Laborers, and Suppliers A succession of Oakland and San Francisco contractors worked on the construction of Highland Hospital. Contracts were awarded on the basis of competitive bids and were issued over the course of several funding cycles. The first contract, for grading and retaining walls, was let to J. P. Holland in the summer of 34 Burroughs Navlet 29; Taylor, Frank, The World s Most Colorful Club, The Saturday Evening Post, Vol. No.
18 and Gilkey Garden Man of Year, Oakland Tribune, 16 January Gilkey Gets Trophy at Garden Ceremony, Oakland Tribune, 23 January 12. 35 Howard E. Gilkey Rites in Private, Oakland Tribune, 12 September 20; Navlet Gilkey Publishes The Great Design, Oakland Tribune, 2 May Gilkey began writing his epic poem at the beginning of the Depression. It stayed in rough form until when he started to revise it to "gain clearer meaning and sound." He revised it again in and finalized it in early The University of California, Berkeley, Bancroft Library has a copy. 36 Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 9.
Subsequent contracts through related to the buildings and were for the structural reinforced concrete components (the frames, walls, floors, and roofs), cement plaster veneer, terra cotta trim, and roof tile, and doors and windows of the main building complex. The Clinton Construction Company received the first such contract, for the Service Building and Ward 1 (Wing E) and Ward 2 (Wing A), in December completing the job about 18 months later. M. C. Vaughn was awarded the contract for Ward 4 (Wing B), Ward 6 (Wing C), and Ward 8 (Wing D), in October due to his default, the job took about two years to finish, under the receivership of the Globe Indemnity Company.
Schuler & McDonald began work on the Administration Building in and completed the work in (Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 9). HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 17) Very little information was located about the contractors for the landscape structures, the roads, the sidewalks, etc. Construction of these features would likely have not begun until early based on the dates of Meyers plans for the Approaches. The record of the Board of Supervisors meetings in the Oakland Tribune between and provided no direct references found to landscape-related contracts. An article that outlined the general progress for the construction of the hospital for written by Dr. R. G.
Brodrick in the Oakland Tribune Yearbook, state that the contract for the completion of the grounds had been awarded.37 N. Clark & Sons provided the architectural terra cotta for the buildings, and it is assumed that they also provided terra cotta for the landscape structures, which has the same appearance as that on the buildings.38 Gladding, McBean & Co. provided the terra cotta tile for the fountains in the East and West Gardens.39 No specific information was located on the manufacturer or contract for the two terra cotta light fixtures at the entrance to the Administration Building or the metal light fixtures located along the balustrades in the formal landscape areas.
No specific information was located on any contracts for the wrought iron work used on entrance structures, the lighting, or the vegetation. 4. Original and Subsequent Owners/Occupants When it opened in Highland Hospital was the County of Alameda s acute-care medical facility and has continued in that capacity to the present day. The three major expansions that occurred at the hospital after World War II, in and were a response to operational changes at the facility, but the general program of the campus has remained the same. 5. Periods of Development a. Original Plans and Construction Construction on the hospital stretched over seven years, from to and occurred in tandem with the design process.
The majority of the design and construction of the built landscape features occurred during late and and the planting of the grounds appears to have begun in and continued for several years thereafter. 37 Dr. R. G. Brodrick, Alameda County Notes Great Progress During Year in its System of Hospitals and Institutions, Oakland Tribune Yearbook, (Oakland: Oakland Tribune Company), 29. 38 Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 10. 39 Henry H. Meyers, Approaches, Highland Hospital . . . Drawing No. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 18) i. Grading Plan Initial work on the site appears to have begun in early when architect Henry H.
Meyers prepared a grading plan in February (revised in April that showed the existing topography of the site with sections that indicated the proposed finish grade for the roads and other key areas.
This plan showed that Meyers had established the following key components of the site plan in conjunction with preparing the grading plan: (1) a primary design axis a line that bisected the angle at the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place that established the geometric order for the Beaux-Arts style site plan; (2) the front orientation of the hospital toward the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place; (3) the general location for the buildings, (4) the location of the roads (the two entrance roads and a service road); and (5) the concept for a monumental staircase approach to the hospital as a solution to integrating the steep grade changes in front of the Administration Building with a visually impressive entrance into the hospital.40 ii.
Plot Plan By fall Meyers had established the footprint for the hospital s Service Building and pavilion-style ward buildings. The location of the buildings for administration were shown in front of the Service Building, but the design had not been resolved; the area is labeled Future Administration Group. The locations of the support and residential buildings were not identified on the October plot plan, and the area on the hillside behind the Service Building and Service Yard was simply labeled as Space for Future Buildings. Other than the location of the Main Terrace staircase approach to the Administration building, none of the designs for the built landscape features had been addressed by this point.41 iii.
Plans for Buildings Meyers designed the original buildings for the hospital between and and they were completed between and under a series of contracts. Dates for the design and construction of these original buildings are as follows: Service Building (design 1919/construction completed in Ward Buildings (design 1919-20/construction completed by Administration Building (design 1923/construction completed in Nurses Home (design 1924/construction completed in Female Employees Building (design 1924/construction completed in Male Employees Building (design 1924/construction completed in Garage (March 1925/construction completed in Pathological 40 Henry H. Meyers, Grading Plan . . . Drawing No. 8 February revised 4 April 41 Henry H. Meyers, Plot Plan . . . Drawing No. 1.
29 October HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 19) Building (design/construction completed in Power House (design March 1925/construction completed in and Gate House (designed December 1925/construction completed in iv.
Plans and Details for Landscape Features Meyers prepared a series of the designs titled Approaches (dated October and December that provided designs for a wide array of built landscape components for the hospital site including circulation features (roads, walks, and stairs), retaining and decorative walls, the main pedestrian plaza and entrance staircase feature (the Main Terrace and the Main Stairs), two outdoor garden rooms (the East and West Gardens), entrance gate structures (the Main Entrance, the Gatehouse Entrance, the Service Entrance, the West Entrance, and the Staff Entrance), courtyards for secondary outdoor spaces (between Wards 2, 4, 6, and 8 and at the Nurses Building), site furnishings (such as light fixtures and signage), and utilitarian details (such as curbs and grates).
The exact dates for the construction of these features are not known. Based on the appearance of the site in historical photographs taken in October it is reasonable to conclude that the grading and built landscape features around the Administration Building including the circulation features (roads, walks, and stairs), the retaining and decorative walls, the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, and the East and West Gardens along with key site furnishings (such as light fixtures and signage) were completed in time for the official dedication of the hospital in December While the location, dimensions, and overall design of the built landscape features matches the designs on the Approaches drawings, the final appearance of the as-built features often differs slightly.
Most of these differences are due to the substitution of less expensive materials or more simplified detailing than those originally shown on the Approaches drawings prepared by Meyers in late Examples of these changes included using simplified paving patterns and the substitution of concrete paving for travertite and brick for the Main Terrace and Main Stairs; the substitution of concrete for terra cotta in the cornices on the retaining walls around the East and West Gardens, in the balustrades on retaining walls, and in detailing at the Gatehouse Entrance, the West Entrance, and the Service Entrance gates; the elimination of benches in the East and West Gardens; the substitution of decorative iron work for terra cotta in the Main Entrance gate; and the elimination of light fixtures at the Garage Road entrance.
Some of these 42 Construction dates refer to exterior only; interior work was completed under separate contract during and (Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson Refer to the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey (Siegel & Strain Architects for more detailed description information on these buildings. 43 Gabriel Moulin, photographs, October HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 20) changes are shown as revisions on the Approaches drawings, but most are not. Plans and details for the as-built conditions were not located in the Alameda County, Government Services Administration (GSA) plan file collection. v.
Planting Plan Landscape architect Howard Gilkey prepared the campus planting plan (undated) sometime after Meyers site plan and his designs for the landscape features.
Gilkey s planting plan is documented in a seven-sheet set of plan drawings that provide planting designs for the formal garden spaces around the Administration Building (the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, the East Garden, and the West Garden), on the east, west, and south slopes in front of the Main Terrace, in the two boundary planting areas along the frontages next to Street and Vallecito Place, in the courtyards between the ward buildings, in areas around the Power House, Garage, and Pathological Building, and in the areas around the three residential buildings (the Nurses Home and the Female and Male Employees buildings) on East Street.
Gilkey s drawings indicated plant selection primarily by number; however, the plant selection key was not a part of the drawing set found in the GSA plan file collections. Limited information on his plant choices has been determined by comparing the appearance of vegetation in historical photographs with the location and numbering key on his drawings and by comparing extant plant materials that appear to be old enough to have been planted in the late with his plans. For example, the plant labeled as 46 in the two boundary planting areas along the frontages next to Vallecito Place and Avenue generally corresponds to the locations and numbers of deodar cedars that exist today in these two areas.
Unlike the landscape structures which were built at one time, the vegetation features were added to the campus over an extended period of time. Based on a review of historical photographs taken in the late and early the planting of the grounds occurred in stages, and Gilkey s original ideas, as shown on the drawings of his planting design, were adapted as the development of the grounds proceeded. The locations of key vegetation features the lawns, the stands of trees along the boundaries, and the beds next to the foundations of the buildings and within the formal landscape spaces were similar to what was shown on Gilkey s original plans. However, his elaborate and detailed designs for the foundation and parterre beds were either eliminated or simplified when planted.
Lawns were established on the east, west, and south slopes in front of the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, on the slope on the east side of the Ambulance Road, and on the slope on the west side of the Automobile Road by late these lawns helped to prevent erosion and gave the hospital grounds an appearance of being finished for the official dedication in December Trees and shrubs were planted at a later date along the building and wall foundations around the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 21) Administration Building, in the East and West gardens, and in the two boundary areas.
Sometime after stands of evergreen trees were planted on the slope along the Avenue frontage (referred to as the East Boundary Planting Area in plans that accompany this report), on the slope along the Vallecito Place frontage (referred to as the West Boundary Planting Area in plans that accompany this report), and on the slopes behind the Nurses Home and two employees buildings (now the location of Acute Care Tower and the Koret Foundation Critical Care Building and its Parking Garage); Gilkey s original plan showed masses of plants that correspond to these locations. Additionally, a stand of evergreen trees was also established in the undeveloped northwest corner of the site; this area was not shown on Gilkey s original plan.
None of these trees were visible on a circa aerial photograph but were well established in the aerial photographs taken in the b. Description i. Site Design Meyers site plan and landscape design for Highland Hospital were shaped by a number of factors including practical concerns imposed by the physical characteristics of the site, the contemporary guidelines for hospital design, needs related to the functioning of the hospital, and the stylistic norms of the day. Meyers determined the internal plan for the hospital buildings, arranged in accordance with the prevailing standards for a pavilion-style hospital, at the outset of the process.
This decision, in turn, led to the arrangement of the various buildings that housed the functions within the hospital complex, such as administration, patient wards, and employee housing. The orientation of the hospital complex toward the southern tip of the site was a response to the contemporary concern for maximizing light and sunshine within the ward buildings and also took advantage of the topography of the site in a way that provided a dramatic, highly visible entrance into the facility. Meyers established a primary design axis for the site plan by bisecting the angle of Fourteenth avenue and Vallecito place 45 and then arranged the buildings, formal landscape spaces, and primary circulation in relation to this axis.
He produced a plan that was based on the Beaux-Arts principles of balance, symmetry, and proportion and that used a variant of the Spanish Colonial Revival style based on cathedral architecture in Mexico according to Meyers for both the buildings and the key landscape structures. Meyers choices for materials for the landscape structures and the site furnishings were similar to those used on the exteriors of the main buildings. The same decorative terra cotta tiles were used on the Main Entrance gate structure as were used around the entrances to the Administration Building. The 44 Ford E. Samuels, photographs, ca. Moulin and Fairchild Aerial Surveys ca. Pacific Aerial Surveys and 45 Meyers HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 22) retaining walls for the Main Terrace and East and West gardens, the retaining walls along the site s boundary, the entrance gate structures, and the Gate House had the same cement plaster finish and paint color as the exterior walls of the hospital buildings. Meyers use of decorative terra cotta in the two light fixtures framing the entrance to the Administration Building, the use of bright blue-colored tile for the fountains in the East and West gardens, and the use of wrought iron as a decorative element all contributed to the extension of the Spanish Colonial Revival style into the landscape. ii.
Topography The 14.14-acre size and triangular shape of the parcel and the original topography (shown on the grading plan as sloping from an elevation of at the north side near Stuart Street to 86' at the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place) placed limitations on the site plan. In an article in the Oakland Tribune written to celebrate the hospital s opening, Meyers explained how these factors affected his design process: In studying the site . . . several problems were involved. First, the shape of the property was unusual and had to be considered in connection with the topography. A cross section of the block from Fourteenth avenue to Vallecito place indicated a rise from the street of from twenty to thirty feet.
A certain elevation above the street had to be established for the buildings and the hill site graded to suit. If this elevation were established at a low level, grading across would be increased enormously. If at a higher level to economize in grading costs, care had to be exercised that roadways would not be at a prohibitive grade. The decision was finally reached that the maximum grade for the main roadways should be ten per cent and this determined the elevation of the plateau formed to receive the buildings.46 The site s topography was altered through a series of cuts and fills that created terraces for the buildings foundations and level areas for the formal outdoor spaces adjacent to the main buildings.
Given the site s size and the steepness of the original grade, the necessary cut and fill for these terraces meant that the areas along the Vallecito Place and Avenue sides of the site were steeply sloped. Reinforced concrete retaining walls were built along the west and south sides of the site s boundary to contain the difference in elevation between the site s finished grade and the public right-of-ways along Vallecito Place and Avenue. 46 Henry Meyers, Highland Hospital Now Stands Complete; its Story Told by Architect, Oakland Tribune, 24 October HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 23) iii.
Building Locations The original hospital complex, completed in included three groupings of buildings those that housed the primary medical functions, those for support functions, and those for employee housing. The primary medical buildings the Administration Building, the Service Building, and the ward buildings were situated in the southern portion of the property. The Administration Building, located near the south point of the site s triangle on axis with the entrance gate, was the most prominent building both in terms of its siting and its architectural treatment. The Service Building was located directly behind the Administration Building.
Extending from the Service Building were two wings of ward buildings in a V configuration one along the Avenue side of the property and the other along the Vallecito Place side. As designed by Meyers, the east wing contained four ward buildings, and the west wing contained three ward buildings; the ward buildings were linked by a three-story corridor structure that originated at the Service Building. The wing along Avenue was completed as designed, but only one ward was ever built in the west wing. A row of three buildings that housed support functions the Pathological Building (with autopsy rooms and the morgue), the Garage-Incinerator Building, and the Power House was located in the northeast corner of the site in alignment with the east wing of the ward buildings along Avenue.
A row of three residential buildings the Nurses Home, the Female Employees Building, and the Male Employees Building was located at the north (or uphill) edge of the site, next to East Street. The fronts of these buildings faced East Street. The northwest corner of the property was left undeveloped.47 iv. Formal Landscape Spaces The formal landscape spaces included the Main Terrace and the East and West gardens at the Administration Building, the three courtyards between the ward buildings in the east wing of the hospital, and a courtyard and terrace for the Nurses Building. 47 Meyers Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 8. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 24) Main Terrace and Main Stairs Meyers extended the terrace for the Administration Building out past the footprint of the building to create the Main Terrace which provided an entrance plaza that extended across the front of the building. The Main Stairs, grandly-scaled, double staircases, descended down the slope in front of this plaza along the primary design axis. Two pedestrian entrances to the hospital connected to these staircases (one each on the east and west sides) so that in addition to providing the visual focal point for the entrance to the hospital, the Main Terrace and Main Stairs also were a part of the actual physical experience of entering the hospital. This entrance plaza and the steps were paved with exposed aggregate concrete.
The base paving was a light pinkish-beige color with bands of contrasting colors in shades of dark gray/black and red/dark-pink that formed a pattern of alternating large squares and rectangles.48 A cast-stone balustrade was located along the outer edge of the Main Terrace and along both sides of the Main Stairs.49 East and West Gardens Enclosed garden rooms called the East Garden and West Garden on Meyers plans were connected to the east and west ends of the Main Terrace. The two gardens had similar but not identical designs. The enclosures around each garden were created by the outer retaining wall of the Main Terrace, a wall of the Administration Building, a short retaining wall between the garden and the Main Terrace, and a free-standing wall at the far end of each garden.
In each garden, a brick sidewalk paralleled the outer edge of the space creating narrow planting beds along the sides and a large rectangular lawn area in the middle. A fountain, of blue-colored glazed tile, was located on the wall at the far end of each garden.50 48 Meyers initially specified a more elaborate paving pattern of Travertite (apparently a trade name for cast stone) and brick for the staircases and Main Terrace on Drawing No. prepared in October The brick paving was repeated in the sidewalks for the East and West gardens, helping to tie the two areas together. However, the travertite and brick were replaced with exposed aggregate concrete in a simpler pattern on Drawing No.
prepared several months later in December These two drawings illustrate the evolving nature of the design for the landscape structures. A note on Drawing No. 111 states that the brick sidewalks in the East and West gardens were to be replaced with cement when in fact brick was actually used (Meyers, Approaches . . .Drawing No. [19 October and Drawing No. 111 [14 December 49 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. (14 December Drawing No. showed the balustrade and its base course in terra cotta. On Drawing No. G- prepared several months later, this specification had been changed to a cast stone balustrade and reinforced concrete with a cement plaster finish for the base course.
This substitution of concrete for terra cotta is found in the Main Terrace, the entrance gate structures, and the East and West gardens. 50 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. October Ibid., Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. 109 (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. No. (14 December Fairchild Aerial Surveys ca. Pacific Aerial Surveys and HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 25) Ward Courtyards The pavilion-style plan of the ward buildings and the connecting corridors created a series of sheltered outdoor spaces between the ward buildings in the hospital s east wing. Meyers designed three formal landscape spaces within these areas (between Wards 2 and 4, 4 and 6, and 6 and 8). The design for each was identical.
A sidewalk was located around the outer edge of each courtyard creating narrow, planting beds along the sides and a large rectangular lawn area in the middle. This lawn area was bisected by a crosswalk. There was a small circular bed in the center of each courtyard located along this crosswalk. At the open end of each courtyard, a set of steps and a sidewalk connected to a path, which was oriented parallel to Street, that ran along the ends of the wards providing a connection between the Ambulance Road, the ward courtyards, and the Garage Road.51 Courtyard and Terrace at the Nurses Home There were two, terraced areas on the rear (south) side of the Nurses Home. The upper terrace was on the same level as the building; this courtyard was surrounded on three sides by the building.
A second terrace was located to the south of this one at a lightly lower level; this terrace was open on all four sides. Both the courtyard and the terrace had formal paths that divided the groundplane into parterre beds. The center path of the courtyard aligned with that of the lower terrace, and the courtyard s outer two paths aligned with paths in the lower terrace. There was a water feature in the center of each a fountain in the courtyard and a round pool in the lower terrace. A stand of evergreen trees planted in the area between the Nurses Home and the Service Road provided a visual background for the courtyard and terrace and screened these residential outdoor spaces from the hospital complex.52 v.
Vegetation Unlike the landscape structures which were all completed in time for the formal dedication of the hospital in December the addition of the plant materials occurred over the first decade. Gilkey s original ideas, as shown on the drawings of his planting design, were adapted as the grounds development proceeded. For example, his elaborate arrangement of flowering plants and boxwood edging for the area between the twin staircases of the Main Stairs was simplified when installed, and the detailed combinations of plants in the side beds in the East and West gardens 51 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., Drawing No. (19 October Fairchild Aerial Surveys ca. Pacific Aerial Surveys and 52 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No.
(19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Gilkey, Planting Plan of Highland Hospital for County of Alameda, Oakland, California (No date). HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 26) were simplified to a single groundcover or a row of shrubs. The locations of the lawns, the locations of the plants at the entries to the Administration Building and in the East and West gardens, the locations of the major plants along the base of the Main Terrace and at the landings for the Main Stairs, and the locations of the major stands of trees appear to be the features that most closely adhere to Gilkey s original plans.
Gilkey remained involved in the development of the grounds after he prepared his planting plan and continued to guide the planting efforts.53 Historical photographs from the late and early provide the only accurate but limited information about the original vegetation types and locations. Some areas such as the area in front of the Administration Building are shown in photographs, but other areas of the landscape are not shown in any photographs. Additionally, the resolution in the photographs limits plant identification. Primary Formal Landscape Spaces Main Terrace and Main Stairs The two beds on either side of the entrance to the Administration Building contained mature specimens of Senegal date palms (Phoenix reclinata).
These palms were transplanted in from the Oakland Hall of Records to Highland Hospital and were estimated, at the time, to have been more than 75 years old.54 (These were probably the Senegal date palms described in the Determination of National Register Eligibility report as some of the best specimens in Northern California. 55) The most visible landscape spaces were those located in front of the Main Terrace in the three triangular-shaped areas created by the sides of the Main Terrace retaining walls, the side walls of the Main Stairs, and the two entrance roads. These three areas are labeled as the East Slope, South Slope, and West Slope on the plans that accompany this report. 53 No definitive information was located on how long Gilkey remained in an oversight role at the hospital.
54 Highland to Get Ancient Palms from Records Hall, Oakland Tribune, 21 October 15. Gilkey requested permission from the Board of Supervisors to transplant the palms in May (Oakland Tribune, 13 May but had to wait until the following May when climatic conditions were favorable to move undertake the actual move. One of the reasons for the move was that the palms were in poor condition and he believed that the Highland Hospital location would provide a better environment for them. The May article mentioned four trees, but the October one mentioned only two. 55 Oakland City Planning Department, Highland Hospital, Determination of National Register Eligibility (March in appendices for Siegel & Strain Architects et al. 49. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 27) The grounds were not planted when the hospital opened in late but lawns were established in this area to protect the sloping grade from erosion and to provide the appearance of a finished landscape. Gilkey s elaborate planting scheme was never fully implemented, but by the early the addition of the planting beds generally followed the locations shown in his design. Beds were located at the corners of the lawn area in front of the Main Stairs, along both sides of the outside walls of the Main Stairs, and along the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall.
Various species of low mounding or spreading shrubs were planted in these beds.56 Incense cedars (Calocedrus decurrens) were planted at regular intervals along the base of the Main Terrace wall and at the corners of landings along the outside walls of the Main Stairs. Yews (Taxus were planted at the corresponding locations of the landings along the inside wall of each of the twin staircases that made up the Main Stairs. The area between the twin staircases was initially planted with a much simplified version of Gilkey s parterre design; low, clipped boxwood edging surrounded the beds on the two sloping sections, and the interior of these beds had low mounded vegetation in a photograph dating from the late-1920s or early-1930s.
Trees which generally correspond to the location of the present-day deodar cedars were scattered in the two side lawn areas (the East Slope and West Slope). East and West Gardens The main vegetation features in the East and West gardens included a grass lawn in the large rectangular area in the center of the garden created by a brick sidewalk, a row of tall columnar shrubs (possibly incense cedars) spaced equidistantly along the Administration Building wall, and windmill palms (Trachycarpus fortunei) on both sides of the entrance steps into the garden from the Main Terrace and on both sides of the fountain. The narrow beds along the sides of the garden had low vegetation.
Secondary Formal Landscape Spaces Ward Courtyards The only information that was found about the original vegetation in the three courtyards between the ward buildings was from partial views in historical aerial photographs.57 The aerials confirmed that the sidewalk system was laid out similar to that shown on Meyers Approaches Drawing No. and that the majority of the landscape area was maintained as a lawn. As was the case for the other landscape areas throughout the hospital s grounds, Gilkey s planting 56 The only information available on the original species of these shrubs and the other vegetation is from their general appearance or character in historical photographs. 57 Pacific Aerial Surveys and HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 28) design for these three courtyards was never fully implemented. The side beds next to the foundations of the buildings may have been planted with shrubs similar to those in the East and West gardens.
Additionally, an oblique aerial from the showed large, columnar shrubs planted at the corners of the east end of each of the ward buildings that looked similar to the incense cedars that were planted along the base of the Main Terrace.58 Nurses Home Courtyard and Terrace The only information that was found about the original vegetation in the courtyard and terrace behind (southwest) of the Nurses Home were partial views in historical aerial photographs.59 The aerials confirmed that the sidewalk and parterre arrangements shown on Gilkey s planting design were laid out; however the extent to which his planting scheme for the beds in these areas were implemented is not known. The four, square parterres in the courtyard appear to be lawns in the various aerials.
The appearance of the smaller parterres in the terrace area, located south of the courtyard, varies in different photographs, but it appears that there was some type of planting other than simply grass. Boundary Planting Areas East Boundary Planting Area The sloped frontage along the Avenue and the corresponding one along East 31 Street were treated more informally than the areas next to the buildings.
Based on the comparison of the present-day trees and Gilkey s planting plan for this area, a combination of evergreens including deodar cedar (Cedrus deodara), blue atlas cedar (Dedrus atlantica Glauca ), flax-leaf paperbark (Melaleuca linariifolia), and coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) were planted in East Boundary Planting Area.60 Because of the prominence of the Avenue side of the property due to the location of the streetcar line along Avenue and the main pedestrian entrance at the Gate House Gilkey s plan for this area included trees and a complex grouping of shrubs (the planting list is missing for these trees and shrubs) separated by mass plantings (which he identified on the plan) of 58 Oakland Public Library. Oakland History Room. Oakland. Buildings.
Hospitals, historical photograph folder. 59 Pacific Aerial Surveys and Oakland Public Library, Oakland History Room, [ca. oblique aerial photograph], Oakland. Buildings. Hospitals historical photograph folder. 60 The key to Gilkey s original planting plan is missing, and so the exact plants he designated are not known. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 29) Coprosma bauerii, Chorizema illicifolia, Vinca minor interspersed with japonica, Mesembryanthemum aurantiacum interplanted with Gladiolus ackermanni and Juniperus sabina tamariscifolia. Due to the restrained plantings that occurred in other areas, it is doubtful that these shrub groupings were planted exactly as shown on Gilkey s plan.
No historical photographs were located that were taken of this area before the canopies of the trees obscured the view of the groundcovers. West Boundary Planting Area Based on the comparison of the present-day trees and Gilkey s planting plan for this area, a stand of evergreens that consisted mainly of deodar cedars was planted in this area. Gilkey identified mass plantings of Coprosma bauerii, Acacia armata ( trained prostrate ), and Cotoneaster horizontalis on his planting plan for this area. In a historical photograph from the (before the hospital s name was changed to Alameda County Hospital in the West Boundary Planting Area is clearly visible.
Although it is not possible to positively identify these plants from the photograph, there were low spreading plants similar in character and location as those specified by Gilkey. Secondary Vegetation Areas Main Entrance Gate A planting island located in front (southwest) of the Main Entrance Gate was part of the original development of the hospital campus and appears in historical photographs taken soon after the opening of the hospital; however, this island was not shown on Gilkey s plan. Plant materials in photographs from the and consist of bedding plants within the island and shrubs planted on the outer sides of the entrance gate.
Public Right-of-Way Narrow planting beds located between the base of the boundary walls along Avenue and Vallecito Place and the sidewalks in the public right-of-way are shown on Meyers plans and appear in historical photographs. However, Gilkey did not include these beds in his planting design. Based on a historic photograph from the late in the Oakland History Room collection, there was a row of shrubs in the bed along Avenue. In contrast, the bed along Vallecito Place was bare except for shrubs clustered on the sides of the West Entrance. This difference in treatment likely relates to the fact that when the hospital opened in the bed along Avenue had a higher profile since a streetcar in the Key System ran along Avenue and the Gate House was the primary pedestrian entrance.
HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 30) Automobile Parking Lot There were narrow beds located around the outer edges of the Automobile Parking Lot. Gilkey included a planting design for this area in his plan, but based on a review of historical photographs, his planting plan was ever fully implemented. Initially, these beds may been left unplanted or maintained as lawn since no vegetation is visible in these beds in aerial photograph from the late However, by the small trees or large shrubs alternating with low mounded shrubs had been added to these beds. Tall columnar specimens were used at the corners of the buildings and to frame the central bay of windows in Ward 1's south-facing, exterior wall.
Ambulance Entrance Area Narrow beds located around the outer edges of the Ambulance Drive turnaround and a center island between the upper and lower portions of the turnaround are shown on Meyers Approaches drawings. Gilkey included a planting design for this area in his plan, but based on a review of historical photographs, his planting plan was ever fully implemented. The center island was expanded in when the extension to the Administration Building was added. An aerial from around shows rows of shrubs next to the building s foundations and a lawn in the center island. By the the plantings in this area were similar to those around the edges of the Automobile Parking Lot single specimen shrubs that appear to be incense cedar or yews alternating with low hedges.
A photograph from the also shows clusters of tall palms at the north end of this area next to the corridor connecting Ward 2 to the Service Building. Power House The entrance to the Power House is in a highly visible location near the corner of Avenue at East Street, and Gilkey included this area in his planting design. None of the historical photographs used in the preparation of this report provided a clear view of this area, but it is doubtful that Gilkey s planting plan was ever fully implemented. Garage Road Gilkey included a planting design for this area in his plan. Until the mid-to-late the area along the north side of the Garage Road was left unplanted or maintained in lawn. By the a mass of large trees similar in character to that shown on Gilkey s plan had been planted here.
There were narrow planting beds located around the edges of the parking lot at the end of the Garage Road (between Ward 8 and the Pathological Building). None of the historical photographs used in the preparation of this report provided a clear view of this area; however, it seems safe to assume that, as was the case in other areas throughout the hospital grounds, Gilkey s planting plan for the beds around the parking lot was never implemented. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 31) Service Road This road was one of the least visible places within the original hospital campus, and given its service function, the original plantings along this road probably were probably limited. Gilkey s plan did not show any plantings in the area along the south side of the road.
(His plan provided a design for the area above [north] the Service Road as part of the landscape around the Nurses Home and Female and Male Employees buildings.) No historical photographs showing this area were located. vi. Circulation Vehicular Entrances and Roads There were four vehicular entrances and associated roads that provided access into the site. These included the Main Entrance and the Automobile and Ambulance roads that provided the primary public entrance, the Service and Garage entrances and roads near the northeast corner of the site, and the Employees Service Road that provided vehicular access to the residential facilities located on East Street.
Main Entrance Gate, Ambulance Road, and Automobile Road The primary vehicular entrance to the hospital was at the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place. The Main Entrance Gate was a symmetrical design on axis with the Main Stairs, which led up to the Main Terrace, and to the front doors to the Administration Building. The gate was clad in terra cotta tile with wrought iron balustrades and had wrought iron arches over the two roadways that entered the facility from this point. The Ambulance Road entered the property on the east side of the gate and led directly from the Main Entrance Gate to the porte cochere on the east end of the Administration Building; the resulting roadway s alignment was slightly askew from Avenue.
The Automobile Road entering the property from the west side of the Main Entrance Gate was designated for private automobiles and led from the gate to the Automobile Parking Lot that was located between the Administration Building and Ward 1; this lot was reserved for doctors.61 Service Entrance and Service Road A service entrance was located in the northeast corner of the site near the intersection of Avenue and East Street. This entrance and road provided access to the loading dock on the 61 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (14 December Ibid., No. (December HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 32) north side of the Service Building.
An entrance gate structure marked this entrance; this gate consisted of a tall column, finished with cement plaster, on each side of the Service Road connected by a double-leaf, metal gate across the road.62 Garage Entrance and Garage Road A second service entrance, called the Garage Road Entrance on Meyers plans, was located just south of the Power House on Avenue and provided access via the Garage Road to the Garage-Incinerator Building and Pathological Building. This road also provided an ambulance entrance to the isolation ward building (Ward 8).
Meyers plans originally showed an elaborate gate with columns and lighting; however, this design was revised at some point and the entrance was marked by a simple opening in the boundary retaining wall.63 Employees Service Road A fourth road, called the Employees Service Road on Meyers plans, provided access from East Street to a drop-off to the Employees Building and the Nurses Home, which was located between these two buildings.64 Parking Areas There were two parking lots on the campus, although only one of these was designed by Meyers. The concrete-paved lot designed by Meyers was located adjacent to the Staff entrance on the west side of the Administration Building. The second lot was located behind (north) of Ward 1 and was accessed from Vallecito Place.
This lot appears to have been a staging area during the construction of the hospital that developed into an unpaved or graveled parking lot after the hospital was completed. According to signs located at the beginning of the Automobile Road, visible in a photograph from the the paved lot was reserved for doctors and the one behind Ward 1 was designated for public use.65 62 Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (December 63 Ibid. 64 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October 65 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October Oakland Public Library, Oakland History Room, Oakland. Buildings. Hospitals, historical photograph folder. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 33) Pedestrian Circulation Pedestrian Entrances There were three pedestrian entrances to the hospital property the main public entrance located on Avenue at the Gate House66 and two on Vallecito Place. The first entrance on Vallecito Place, identified as the West Entrance on Meyers plans, was the western compliment to the primary pedestrian entrance on Avenue through the Gate House.67 The second entrance on Vallecito Place, identified as the Staff Entrance on Meyers plans, was located north of the West Entrance;68 the Staff Entrance was designated for use by the doctors and led to the Automobile Parking Lot, also used by the doctors.
The Gate House entrance connected via a tunnel under the Ambulance Road to steps that led up to the east side of the Main Stairs, and the West Entrance connected via a tunnel under the Automobile Road to identical steps on the west side of the Main Stairs.69 Pedestrian Paths The hospital buildings and landscape spaces were connected by a series of pedestrian paths.70 There was a hierarchy of paving materials for the pedestrian paths based on the prominence of their location and the intensity of usage.
Paths along the roads (the Ambulance, Automobile, and Service roads) and the primary paths that connected the residential area on the north portion of the site (at the Nurses Home and the two Employees buildings) to the hospital were paved with concrete (scored with a double row of squares); those in the East and West gardens were brick (in a running bond pattern); and secondary paths within the secondary formal spaces (the ward courtyards and at the Nurses Home) as well as those paths connecting to secondary spaces (the path at the west end of Ward 1 and the path along the east side of the east wing of ward 66 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October 1925/revised 27 February Ibid., No. G- 113 (December 67 Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (December 68 Ibid., No.
(19 October 69 Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (14 December 70 Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (14 December HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 34) buildings) were gravel with brick edging.71 A covered pedestrian bridge spanned the Service Road and provided a link between the pedestrian circulation north of the Service Road and a staff entrance on the north side of Ward vii. Lighting Main Entrance Gate and Around the Administration Building At the Main Entrance Gate, there were wrought iron light fixtures mounted on top of the columns that framed the two road entrances. Glass panels with back lighting that identified each entrance (i.e., Emergency and Automobile ) were mounted on the face of each column.
Two, large, light standards were located on either side of the steps leading from the Main Terrace up to the Administration Building s central entrance doors; the bases and posts of these two fixtures were terra cotta whose design and colors were similar to that used around the building s entrances. Smaller, decorative, cast metal fixtures were spaced along the top of the balustrade that formed the outer sides of the Main Terrace and the East and West gardens; identical fixtures were located along the outer sides of the Main Stairs balustrades. Street lights mounted on metal poles with decorative bases were located along the Ambulance and Automobile roads.
Pedestrian Entrances Meyers plans showed a light mounted on the right-hand side of the Gate House entrance, a light on top of the two columns that flanked the West Entrance, and a light mounted on the wrought iron arch above the entrance at the Staff Entrance.73 Historical photographs confirm that lights were installed at the Gate House and West Entrance;74 however, it seems likely that the arch and light were not installed at the Staff Entrance since the extant concrete wall shows no evidence of the arch ever being mounted there. 71 Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (14 December 72 Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (19 October 73 Meyers, Approaches. . . [Missing title block] (no date); Ibid., Approaches . . . Drawing No.
(19 October 1925/revised 27 February Ibid., No. (19 October Ibid., No. (December 74 Samuel ca. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 35) Pedestrian Paths Lights on poles extended past the Ambulance Road along the pedestrian path between the Ambulance Road and the Garage Road. There was also a light located at the north end of each of the three ward building courtyards. There may have been similar lighting along the paths around the Nurses Home and the two employees buildings, but no lighting plans were located for this area.75 Service Entrances Lighting was incorporated into the Service Entrance with a light mounted on top of each column. A partial plan of the lighting along the Service Road showed lights located along the north side of the road.76 viii.
Signage Main Entrance Gate For the Main Entrance Gate: (1) the decorative wrought iron arches that spanned both roads incorporated the identification of each road into the arch (i.e., EMERGENCY and AUTOMOBILE ), (2) the wrought iron panel that spanned the top of the center portion of the structure incorporated HIGHLAND HOSPITAL into the metal work, and (3) there was an illuminated sign (4-inch-high letters in a backlit, rectangular panel that read EMERGENCY and AUTOMOBILE ) located in the middle of each of the columns located on each side of the two roads.77 Gate House For the Gate House entrance, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL was incorporated in raised letters in a cast stone panel in the balustrade atop the building.
This panel was centered above the entrance to the pedestrian tunnel.78 75 Meyers, Missing title block [Approaches, Highland Hospital] (no date). 76 Meyers, Missing title block [Approaches, Highland Hospital] (no date) and Approaches . . . Drawing No. (December 77 Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (December 78 Ibid., [Missing title block] (no date); Ibid., No. (19 October 1925/revised 27 February Ibid., No. 113 (December HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 36) Staff Entrance For the Staff Entrance on Vallecito Place, Meyers plan showed a metal panel that read STAFF hung from the arch above the entrance,79 but it is doubtful that this arch and the sign were actually installed since the extant concrete wall shows no evidence of the arch ever being mounted here.
West Entrance There is no evidence that Meyers plan incorporated any signage into the design for the West Entrance on Vallecito Place, and none appears in early photographs of the hospital. Service Entrance Gate At the Service Entrance Gate, Meyers plan showed an Electric Illuminated Sign that read HIGHLAND HOSPITAL SERVICE ENTRANCE, 80 and based on the remains of wiring in the extant gate structure some type of backlit sign was installed. Garage Entrance For the Garage Entrance, Meyers plan showed an Electric Illuminated Sign that read AMBULANCE & GARAGE, 81 but this sign does not appear to have been installed in the simplified design that was ultimately built at this entrance. ix.
Perimeter Features The stands of evergreen trees, retaining walls, and public right-of-way sidewalks contributed to the visual and physical delineation of the property s boundary. As the stands of evergreen trees next to the perimeters of the site matured, the contrast between these forested areas and the surrounding urban neighborhood environment created a visual boundary for the hospital campus. These stands included the two boundary planting areas along Avenue and Vallecito Place and the stand in the undeveloped northwest corner of the property. 79 Ibid., No. (19 October 80 Ibid. 81 Ibid. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 37) Reinforced concrete retaining walls were located along the perimeter of the east Avenue) and west (Vallecito Place) sides of the campus, and a decorative metal rail fence ran along the north perimeter (East Street) of the campus. Concrete sidewalks (about 5' or 6' wide and scored with rows of or squares) were located in the public right-of-ways along the perimeter of the campus. There were narrow gravel strips along both the inside and outside edge of these sidewalks; in some cases, such as along Avenue near the Main and Gate House entrances, the strips had vegetation. c. Changes and Additions In a new wing, which spanned the looped end of the Ambulance Road, was added that connected the Administration Building s porte cochere to the Ward 2.
The width of the planting island on the slope between the upper and lower portions of this loop was expanded on the east side to doubled its original width.82 During the and trees were planted on (1) the slopes between the ends of Wards 2 to 8 and the retaining wall along Avenue, (2) on the slopes behind the Nurses Home and the two Employees buildings, and (3) in the undeveloped northwest corner of the site. The trees in the first two areas were shown on Gilkey s planting plan.
The trees in the third area were not shown on Gilkey s plans but, based on a review of historical aerial photographs, appear to have had the same general species composition as the other areas.83 Sometime between and part of the outer retaining wall that extended along the south side of the Main Terrace and the south side of the East Garden was removed; no records were found about the wall s removal, but based on the current appearance of the slope, the wall appears to have failed. As a result the portion of the wall between the front edge of the Main Terrace (on the south side) and the staircase leading up to the south side of the East Garden was removed, and a hedge was planted along the outer edge of the terrace where the wall had previously been located.
An original section of the brick sidewalk between the two sets of steps in the East Garden was removed or was destroyed when the retaining wall failed. A replacement section of sidewalk, with the same materials and pattern (red brick laid out in running bond) as the original, was built between the East Garden s two entrances. The new sidewalk was laid out 82 Meyers, Building for Alterations & Additions Highland Hospital . . . Drawing No. 1 (10 September 83 Samuel ca. Moulin October and October Fairchild Aerial Surveys ca. Pacific Aerial Survey and HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 38) several feet northwest of the where the original one had been as a result altered the original sidewalk s original rectilinear alignment around the outer edge of the garden.84 In the Auditorium and Clinic Building, designed by Corlett & Anderson, were added to the northwest corner of the campus. This building program added the Auditorium and Clinic buildings, the associated plaza and sidewalks around the buildings, new or transplanted vegetation around the buildings, a new parking lot or drop-off with access to East Street that connected to the east end of the Clinic Building, and a new stand of trees between this lot and the Auditorium s plaza. An informal, unpaved parking lot north of Ward 1, with access to Vallecito Place, was expanded and paved at this time.
As a result of this building program, a house located approximately where the Clinic Building now stands, the stand of trees planted in the that covered most of the open space in the northwest portion of the property, and tennis courts located next to East Street at the west end of the Nurses Home were all removed. In the the design of the courtyard located between Wards 2 and 4 was altered. The sidewalk that bisected this courtyard, and which connected to the perimeter sidewalk to create a rectilinear path around the edges of the courtyard, was removed, and a large rectangular-shaped paved area was added to the center of the courtyard.
During this decade, some of the trees in the portion of the Avenue boundary stand, in the area between the Gate House and Ward 2, were removed or died, and the tree canopies appear noticeably thinner in aerial photographs from the The landscaped areas and trees that were located between the south side of the Pathological Building/Garage/Power House complex and the Garage Road were removed, and this area was paved over. Also, some of the trees in the area east of Ward 8 were removed, and this newly cleared area appears to have been used as an informal parking lot or storage area.
Over the next several decades, this cleared area gradually expanded as more trees were removed.85 In the Acute Care Tower, designed by Ratcliff, Slama & Cadwalader and Rex Whitaker Allen was completed in the center of the campus.
This location on the upper side of the Service Road appears to have been chosen so that the new facility could use this existing road.86 The following features from the original hospital complex were removed from the northern portion of the campus (between the Service Road and East Street) to clear the area for the Acute Care Tower construction: (1) the Nurses Home (Nightingale Hall); (2) landscape features associated with the two parterre gardens behind the Nurses Home including the gravel sidewalks, brick edging, the fountain in the upper garden, the pool in the lower garden, and all vegetation; 84 Pacific Aerial Surveys and 85 Pacific Aerial Surveys and 86 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 17. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 39) (3) pedestrian circulation features connecting the Nurses Home to East Street, to the two employees buildings, and to the main hospital complex; and (4) plantings around the Nurses Home and the stand of trees on the slope behind the building. The following features were added: (1) the nine-story Acute Care Tower, located directly behind the original hospital s Service Court; (2) the entrance road to the Acute Care Tower and surface parking lots, which were all accessed via East Street; (3) a new, two-level, parking deck structure which replaced the parking lot along Vallecito Place between the Clinic Building and Ward 1.
In the the increasing need for more parking was accommodated by tearing down buildings and removing landscape features that were part of the Meyers design for the hospital campus. Between and the Female Employees and the Male Employees buildings, all of their landscape features (both hardscape and vegetation), and part of the remaining stand of trees on the slope between these buildings and the Service Road were removed. A surface parking lot, accessed via East Street, was added to this location. By the the southern ends of the three ward courtyards were being used for parking. This change required the removal of the sidewalk and steps, the lawn, and any vegetation located in the south end of each courtyard; the slope at this end of each courtyard was also modified.
The sidewalk that paralleled the ends of the ward buildings was widened so it could function as a road to provide access to the new courtyard parking lots.87 Between and the Senegal date palms that were located on each side of the entrance to the Administration were removed. These trees were transplanted from the Oakland Hall of Records around and were estimated to have been 75 years old at that time. In the surface parking was again expanded. As a result, the remaining landscape features in the three ward courtyards were completely removed sometime between and to expand the paving and enlarge the parking lots.
More trees were removed from the slope above the Service Road to accommodate parking so that by only about four or five trees from the original stand north of this road remained extant.88 In the five-story Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center and a multi-level parking garage were added to the remaining open land in the east corner of the site. Changes to original features that resulted from this project included (1) the removal of the remaining four or 87 Pacific Aerial Surveys and 88 Pacific Aerial Surveys and HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 40) five trees north of the Service Road and (2) the replacement of the sidewalks in front of the Power House.89 B. Historical Contexts 1.
Healthcare in Alameda County90 Under early California law, county governments were mandated to provide health care for the poor (the indigent sick ) within their jurisdictions. Laws enacted in and enabled counties to levy taxes to buy land, erect buildings, and hire staff for the care of the poor and infirm. These facilities were called county infirmaries. Alameda County, established in initially provided medical services by contract with private practitioners and, for a brief period, in a rented house in Oakland. In the Alameda County Board of Supervisors purchased nearly 125 acres in the foothills above San Leandro and proceeded to erect a variety of wood-frame buildings on the site over the next forty years.
Known as the Alameda County Infirmary, the hospital grounds covered a relatively small area of the site at the base of the hills. Most of the land was given over to a county-operated farm that supplied milk, eggs, pork, and bacon to the infirmary and, then later, to the other county hospitals. Because this farm shared the site for many years, the Alameda County Infirmary (today s Fairmont Hospital) was commonly known as The Farm. By the turn of the twentieth century, the overcrowded infirmary, which included a number of tent wards, was considered inadequate for the county s needs. In the Alameda County Board of Supervisors retained local architect Henry H. Meyers to oversee an architectural competition for a totally new hospital campus on the infirmary site (Fairmont Hospital).
The winning, pavilion-plan entry by San Francisco architect Charles Peter Weeks, remained unrealized except for two ward buildings and a meeting hall which were erected in and Meyers himself took over the reconstruction of the hospital and designed all of the new buildings on the campus after Meyers was appointed the county architect soon after he was hired to oversee the infirmary competition, and he designed the new infirmary buildings and Highland Hospital in this role. 89 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 17. 90 This section is based on an excerpt from pages six and seven of the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for Alameda County by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 41) The infirmary complex was not built according to the competition design due to funding problems as well as to a new county health-care plan, adopted in that called for separate institutions with specialized functions, rather than one general facility. Under the new plan, the Alameda County Infirmary (renamed Fairmont Hospital when Highland Hospital opened) specialized in long-term care for convalescent patients, the aged and infirm, and persons suffering from chronic and contagious diseases. The Arroyo Sanitarium, opened in on an outlying rural site near Livermore, provided long-term care for curable tuberculosis patients; this facility was enlarged in with Del Valle Farm, an adjoining campus for tubercular children.
A new acute-care facility was planned for Oakland, the county s population center. The county made the initial 9.5-acre purchase of land for the proposed acute-care facility in the Highland Park neighborhood in and over the next nine-year period purchased an additional fifteen acres and built the new hospital Highland Hospital which opened in late Patients treated at Highland Hospital were transferred to Fairmont for recovery, and incurable tuberculosis patients were domiciled there rather than at Arroyo or Del Valle. Small outpatient clinics were also maintained in cooperation with the municipal governments of Oakland, Berkeley, Alameda, San Leandro, and Hayward. Since World War II, Alameda County s health-care system has undergone substantial change.
The discovery of penicillin, that provided a cure for tuberculosis, led to the phasing out of the Arroyo Sanitarium and the Del Valle Farm in the late and Fairmont Hospital was largely rebuilt between and when the facility shifted its focus from the aged and infirm to convalescent care and chronic rehabilitation. Major construction at Fairmont during this period included an administration building and four ward buildings, followed by a fifth ward building in Facilities added to Fairmont since the Villa Fairmont the Eden Outpatient Facility and the John George Psychiatric Pavilion are all dedicated to long term, mental health care. Highland Hospital, which has had three major expansions since World War II, remains the county s principal acute-care and trauma facility. 2.
Hospital Design in the Twentieth Century91 Hospital design in the United States underwent dramatic changes in the twentieth century which reflected advances in the understanding of disease and medical treatment. Prior to World War II, most hospitals in the United States followed the pavilion plan, which dispersed patients in separate buildings to maximize exposure to fresh air and sunlight. Since World War II, most American hospitals have been of the tower or skyscraper type which group patients and functions in a single large structure to enhance efficiency and to promote a sterilized environment.
91 This section is based on an excerpt from pages five and six of the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for Alameda County by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 42) Institutions for the care of the sick and wounded date back at least to Roman military hospitals. Roman hospital courtyard plans were not much different from the plans for the principal hospitals of the Middles Ages, which were housed in monasteries. A new era in hospital design began in the mid-nineteenth century based on new theoretical approaches to the treatment of disease.
The traditional view of disease that it was transmitted by miasma (i.e., infectious vapor) gave rise to the theory that miasma could be alleviated by exposure to fresh air and sunlight. This understanding eventually resulted in hospitals built as separate, freestanding pavilions lined with windows and connected by arcades or covered walkways. The concept received widespread notice in the mid-century book Hospital Construction by the celebrated English nurse Florence Nightingale, which included a plan for such a facility.
A prototype of the pavilion-plan hospital was built in Paris in the This plan was the subject of numerous articles in the early nineteenth century, but another pavilion hospital was not built (once again, in Paris) until the The United States proved to be a receptive home for pavilion hospitals. During the Civil War, military doctors noted that wounded soldiers isolated in smaller tents or barracks recovered faster, leading many to promote the pavilion plan as a model for new hospitals. Their case was bolstered by Nightingale s influential book.
The first pavilion hospitals in the United States the Hospital of the Protestant Episcopal Church in Philadelphia, and a new hospital at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore opened in the Due to rapid population growth and widespread urbanization, numerous hospitals were built in the Unites States in the late nineteenth century, and many of these were of the pavilion type. The pavilion hospital flourished in the United States through the early twentieth century and continued to influence hospital design long after the scientific basis for the type had been discredited. The to the was a transitional period in modern hospital design.
Some theorists continued to promote the pavilion plan as an appropriate response to the new discoveries about contagious transmission of disease, since patients could be isolated in separate wards. In other ways, the pavilion plan was modified to reflect the need for greater efficiency in providing health care to large urban populations. More compact buildings (seen as more efficient), typically of two-to-six stories, with a cruciform or H-shaped plan in order to expose all rooms to sunlight more efficiently, became the norm. Managerial concerns also began to have a greater influence on hospital design.
Following the nineteenth century tendency to specialize hospitals by type, each hospital tended to specialize by department (e.g., administration, surgery, maternity, etc.) on separate floors or in separate wings. The identification of bacteria, rather than miasma, as the source of disease introduced an entirely new basis for hospital design by the first decade of the twentieth century. Sterilization, rather than access to fresh air, became the determining factor for hospital design. This new understanding of the transmission of disease permitted a tighter grouping of wards and other rooms, ushering in the modern era of high-density hospitals. By the the pavilion hospital HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 43) began to give way to the tower or skyscraper form in larger American cities. Rapid advances in medical technology and drug therapy during World War II contributed to the transformation of hospital design in the postwar era. By the the modern hospital, with all functions concentrated in a single, large building often a tower or skyscraper had replaced the low-rise, pavilion-plan model that had dominated hospital design over the previous one hundred years. 3. Landscape Design for Hospitals in the Early Twentieth Century During the interwar era, a handful of popular books on hospital design, written by architects or doctors, promulgated the standards for the design of modern hospital plans.
The American Hospital of the Twentieth Century (published in three editions in and written by Edward Stevens who was probably the best known of this era s experts, included guidance on the treatment and role of the landscape in relation to the function of the hospital. S. This book provides an example of the generally accepted concerns on hospital site design.93 In referring to the hospital s landscape features, Stevens advised that all these things help the patients who are just recovering from an operation or convalescing from a fever to enjoy God s great out-of-doors.
94 During the late nineteenth century when the hospital was still viewed as long-term convalescent institution rather than a place for treatment and cure, the preferred location for an urban hospital was removed from the city s noise and pollution.95 Even with the changes in medicine that were altering this reality, much of the advice on the site and setting for the modern hospital, even in the third decade of the twentieth century, was still rooted in the view of the patient as a convalescent and in a picturesque treatment of the landscape surrounding the facility.
Although not directly addressed by Stevens in the text of his book, the examples of plans showed accommodations for the functional aspects of the hospital, such as separate entrances and roads for ambulances, laundry yards, service yards and service buildings, and domestic facilities. However rather than being a driving force in shaping the site s design, these functional features were laid out based on the established notions of how a landscape should look. A more direct expression between a landscape s form and its function the hallmark of modernism in landscape design had not taken root in the and the plans for the examples of the hospital grounds included in Stevens book could easily have been mistaken for large estates or parks. 92 Edward F.
Stevens, The American Hospital of the Twentieth Century . . . (New York: Architectural Record Company, 93 Adams 90 and 96. 94 Stevens 95 Ibid., 6. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 44) Annmarie Adams, in Medicine by Design, noted that at hospitals with larger grounds, picturesque gardens surrounded the pavilions and provided patients with the experience or impression of a trip outside the city.96 During the early twentieth century, functional concerns related to the site focused primarily on its exposure and size. Stevens directed that a site should have a southern exposure and if sloping should ideally slope toward the south and include enough land for future expansion.
Within the site, the hospital itself should be oriented based on concerns for light and sunshine and in relation to protection from prevailing winds. Diagrams, included in Stevens book, illustrated the advantages of orienting the open side of the U formed by pavilion-style wards to the southeast or southwest to provide for the most light and least amount of shadow.97 The concern for sunlight extended out into the landscape, and Stevens directed that the grounds surrounding the hospital should be flooded with sunlight and that care should be taken to not shade buildings with plantings because of the therapeutic and healing benefits of the sun s rays.
Views from the hospital and vistas from the wards or balconies were to be considered as part of the therapeutic process and Stevens directed that [i]f the outlook is depressing in one direction it should be screened by a slight change in location or by planting out the view. Grades within the site and accompanying circulation paths were to be gentle out of recognition of the patients condition ( the convalescent must be encouraged ). There was to be plenty of green grass. The patients lawn or grass courts were a standard component of the hospital grounds, and plantings were to be used to screen these from the public s view. Finally, Stevens directed that fountains and pools, a rustic bridge and acoustic [sic] plants . . . add materially to the interest. 98 4.
Influences of Beaux-Arts Design Traditions and the Spanish Colonial Revival Style 99 The modernism of the and that was at the forefront of international design in architecture did not touch the design or the exterior appearance of hospitals. As Annmarie Adams explained, in her book Medicine by Design, hospitals in the interwar period were more likely to resemble Georgian mansions or Italian paillasse than the revolutionary, machinelike forms of 96 Adams 39. 97 Stevens 2. 98 Ibid., 99 This section utilizes excerpts from page thirteen of the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for the County by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 45) modernism.
100 While the interior of the interwar era hospital incorporated the latest technologies, designers continued to look to revivalist styles and traditional materials to create conservative exteriors that were accepted as appropriate expressions of the multi-functional role of the hospital as a civic monument and a philanthropic enterprise and that helped to project an image of stability. These styles also provided a means of disguising the hospital s association with illness.101 Edward Stevens, in his contemporary guidance on hospital design, grounded the aesthetics of the hospital s exterior in terms of its psychological impact on the patient and the public.
He wrote that the severe, barren forbidding exterior of the old hospital has given way to a studied architectural treatment, pleasing to the patient and the public. The small extra cost of a well designed exterior is more than repaid in its psychological effect on the entering patient and the visitor. If the patient can enter with the right impression of the institution, such impression reacts for the good of the patient s convalescence. 102 Highland Hospital s architect Henry Meyers echoed this view in an article in the Oakland Tribune in written to garner support for the upcoming Highland Hospital bond election, in which he explained that his elaborate detailing and design choices for the exterior appearance of the hospital complex were intended . . .
to break away from the customary monotony and dreariness of the average hospital building and to design in a style that will be pleasing and interesting and that may in itself be a factor in the health-restoring activities of the institution. 103 Beaux-Arts design traditions were followed by Meyers in his design for Highland Hospital s buildings and landscape. In terms of style, the architectural treatment of the original group of hospital buildings was characteristic of mainstream architecture of the period, known generally as academic eclecticism or historicism. The hospital s buildings combined Beaux-Arts planning methods with the Spanish Colonial Revival, a popular revivalist style in California at the time.
104 These design elements were evident throughout the landscape in the entrance plaza and staircase feature (the Main Terrace and Main Stairs) and in the formal garden spaces around 100 Adams xix. Adams states that the white, undecorated, hard-edged architectural forms we associate with International Style architecture did not appear on the exteriors of urban general hospitals until the and really not in full force until the (p. 101 Ibid., 3, 39, and 102 Edward Stevens, The Trend in Hospital Construction on the North American Continent, Canadian Hospital 9, No. 1 (Jan. 24 as quoted in Adams 103 Meyers 2. 104 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 13. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 46) the Administration Building (the East and West gardens), at the hospital s residential buildings on East Street, and in the various entrance gate structures. Architects working in the Beaux-Arts tradition, as promulgated by the Ecole des Beaux-Arts in Paris, looked to the past for inspiration. Classical ideals of balance, symmetry, proportion, and axiality were determinants of the design process, from the planning of entire complexes to the layout of individual buildings, the composition of elevations, and the details of applied ornament. Meyers apprenticed in the office of Percy & Hamilton, a firm that was strongly influenced by the work of the Boston architect H. H. Richardson, a graduate of the Ecole des Beaux-Arts.
The work of Percy & Hamilton displayed an adherence to Beaux-Arts principles in its persistent use of symmetry, balance, and axiality, and Meyers exhibited a similar allegiance throughout his career.105 Meyers was also influenced by the work of Bertram Goodhue, a masterful eclectic architect who launched the Spanish Colonial Revival at the Panama-California Exposition in San Diego. Drawing from Spanish Baroque and Spanish Colonial (Mexican) sources, Goodhue s exposition buildings combined ornate appliqu s of carved stone and terra cotta around doorways and windows, in striking contrast with broad expanses of wall surface plainly finished in cement plaster. Roofs were clad or trimmed with terra cotta tile.
The Spanish Colonial Revival style enjoyed great popularity in California between the two world wars, and Highland Hospital remains one of the most monumental and intact examples of this style in the region.106 Beaux-Arts ideals and principles shaped the landscape design of virtually all public spaces in the country during this period. Books, such as An Introduction to the Study of Landscape Design by Henry Hubbard and Theodora Kimball (first published in codified appropriate spatial organization, style, and features for various types of landscapes and emphasized that the designer s skill or creative input should be focused on how to adapt these standards to a particular site.
During the first half of the twentieth century, all university landscape architecture programs in the country, including the local program at the University of California in Berkeley, taught within this Beaux-Arts framework.
Built elements (such as paved terraces, grand staircases, fountains, or oblong reflecting pools) and details (such as statuary, arbors, and seating) were selected or adapted from multiple eras (typically Arabic, Renaissance, or Baroque) and 105 Excerpt from page thirteen of the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for the County by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in 106 Excerpt from page thirteen of the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for the County by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 47) European traditions (usually Italian, French, or British).
The result was a formal organization of the landscape space with an eclectic mix of historical references.107 The application of the Spanish Colonial Revival style was another variant of the Beaux-Arts design tradition. In California, designers created outdoor spaces particularly for large estates and public facilities that adhered to the Beaux-Arts preference for formality, symmetry, and axial relationships to organize the space and then used decorative elements and materials (such as fountains, ceramic tile, finishes that resembled adobe, and wrought iron) and ornamental vegetation that were considered to be Mediterranean to reflect the Spanish Colonial Revival.
In addition to plants from the European Mediterranean region, an extensive plant palette that included imported plant materials native to the Mediterranean climates of Asia, Australia, and South Africa were used in California in Spanish Colonial Revival plans. The characteristic components of Spanish Colonial Revival style in the California landscape were based on a highly romanticized view of Spanish Colonial or Mexican era gardens. This view developed during the latter decades of the nineteenth century and early years of the twentieth century in tandem with efforts to preserve the missions and other historic buildings from California s colonial past and with a rise in the state s celebration of its Hispanic history and culture.
At Highland Hospital examples of decoration influenced by the Spanish Colonial Revival include the fountains with their bright blue colored tile used in the East and West Garden rooms and the wrought iron balusters in the Main Entrance Gate at Highland Hospital.
The most prominent examples of Mediterranean plant materials were the large specimens of Senegal date palms planted at the main entrance to the Administration Building, the Pindo palms at the entrance to the Power House, and the windmill palms at both ends of the East and West Gardens.108 107 The Cultural Landscape Foundation, Designed Landscape Styles: Beaux Arts/Neoclassical (accessed 22 January Phoebe Cutler, Mills College Glory Years Celebrating the Cultural Landscape Heritage of Mills College by Vonn Marie May, Robert Sabbatini, and Karen Fiene (Oakland: Center for the Book, Mills College, 108 The Cultural Landscape Foundation, Designed Landscape Styles: Spanish Colonial Revival (Hispano- Moorish) (accessed 22 January Nathan Gerald Weinberg, Historic Preservation and Tradition in California: The Restoration of the Missions and the Spanish Colonial Revival (University of California, Davis: PhD Dissertation, 6.
HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 48) 5.
Expansion of Highland Hospital Following the completion of the original facilities in Highland Hospital was subsequently expanded in three major building campaigns the Clinic Building and Auditorium the Acute Care Tower and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center These three building campaigns reflected the evolving approach to hospital design during the twentieth century, from the pavilion plan to the tower form, which followed advances in the understanding of disease and changes in the practice of medical treatment.111 The buildings constructed also reflected the changing architectural styles that were used for public buildings as the century progressed.112 As the history in the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation explained, the crowded conditions at Highland Hospital during the economically distressed worsened during World War II, when the Bay Area s population rose sharply in tandem with the military- industrial war effort.
Population growth continued unabated after the war, straining the resources of Alameda County s public health-care system . . . As early as there had been calls for a new outpatient clinic at the hospital to replace the county s antiquated Oakland Clinic, at and Grove Streets. A bond issue placed on the ballot in that year for a new clinical building at Highland Hospital and three new wards at Fairmont Hospital was rejected by voters still mired in the Depression. By a year after World War II ended, Highland Hospital was seriously overcrowded, with nearly 500 active beds distributed among five ward buildings designed to hold 375 beds.
The needed expansion at Highland would not be completed for another ten years, while the board of supervisors dealt with more urgent upgrades to the substandard facilities at Fairmont Hospital. 113 Meyers original site plan set aside the undeveloped northwest corner of the campus, at Vallecito Place and East Street, for expansion.
He explained in an article written for the Oakland Tribune at the hospital s completion in October that [f]uture growth will be along 109 Excerpts from the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation report prepared for the County by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in 2007and the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey prepared by Siegel & Strain Architects in were used in the preparation of this section, as noted. 110 Siegel & Strain Architects 3. 111 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson, 5. 112 Siegel & Strain Architects 16. 113 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 13. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 49) Vallecito place, where ample room exists to more than double the present capacity of the hospital. 114 Additionally, only one of the three ward buildings planned for the west wing adjoining the Service Building was ever built Ward 1 (Wing E) leaving the sites for the unbuilt ward buildings along Vallecito Place open. This area along with the undeveloped northwest corner of the site, provided ample space for new construction on the campus and became the site for new facilities added during the first building campaign in the mid-1950s. In the county retained the Oakland firm of Corlett & Anderson, architects of the postwar facilities at Fairmont Hospital, to design the long-awaited outpatient clinic building at Highland.
As an add-on to the contract, the supervisors also commissioned a separate auditorium building. 115 Construction of these two buildings, located in the northwest corner of the site, and on a new paved parking lot between the Clinic Building and Ward 1, to replace the existing unpaved parking area north of Ward 1, was completed in As explained in the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey, the Clinic Building and Auditorium, with their vestigial Moderne ornamental detailing, were conservative and transitional examples of mid-century Modernism.
116 In terms of mass, height, and architectural treatment, the Clinic Building served as a transitional element on the hospital campus between the Beaux-Arts/Spanish Colonial Revival complex and the Acute Care Tower that was added to the site in In the Acute Care Tower was built at the center of the campus. This location appears to have been chosen so that the new facility could use the existing Service Road.118 Designed by Ratcliff, Slama & Cadwalader and Rex Whitaker Allen, this building embodied contemporary concepts of hospital design both functionally and architecturally.
The tower had a bed capacity that nearly matched that of the entire complex it overlooked,119 and, as the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey noted, the large scale and Brutalist styling of the tower were emblematic of late twentieth century modernism. 120 114 Henry Meyers, New Highland Hospital Completed. Oakland Tribune, 115 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 12. 116 Siegel & Strain Architects 17. 117 Ibid., 17. 118 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 17. 119 Ibid., 12. 120 Siegel & Strain Architects 17. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 50) In the five-story Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center and an attached, multi- level parking garage were built on the north side of the campus with the buildings facing East Street.121 The Koret Critical Care and Clinical Center characterized more by mass and bulk than height, typifies contemporary approaches to single-building hospital design. 122 121 Siegel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 17. 122 Siegel & Strain Architects 17. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 51) PART II. PHYSICAL INFORMATION A. Landscape Character and Description Summary 1.
Description Summary Highland Hospital is located on a 14.14-acre, triangular-shaped parcel that is bounded on the north by East Street, on the east by Avenue, and on the west by Vallecito Place. Vallecito Place and Avenue meet at a sharp angle at the lower, south end of the parcel, forming the tip of the triangle. The base of the triangle is formed by Street. The site slopes downward from an elevation of at its north boundary along East Street to 87' at the entrance to the hospital, framed by the original Main Entrance Gate, at Vallecito Place and Avenue. The two original public vehicular roads enter the property at the Main Entrance Gate.
Ambulance Road enters the property on the east side of the Main Entrance Gate and leads directly to a porte cochere on the east end of the Administration Building that was originally the Ambulance Entrance to the hospital. Automobile Road enters the property from the west side of the Main Entrance Gate and leads to the Automobile Parking Lot that is located on the west side of the Administration Building; this lot was historically reserved for the hospital s doctors. The front of the historic Administration Building faces south toward the Main Entrance Gate. Its central entrance is aligned with the Main Entrance Gate along the original primary design axis.
The three formal landscape spaces associated with the hospital campus are located in front and on the east and west sides of the Administration Building; these features are referred to as the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, the East Garden, and the West Garden in this report. The Main Terrace, an entrance plaza, extends across the front of the Administration Building. The Main Stairs, grandly-scaled, twin staircases, descend down the slope in front of this plaza along the primary design axis.
The two historic pedestrian entrances to the hospital grounds the Gate House Entrance on the east side at Avenue and the West Entrance on the west side at Vallecito Place connect to the Main Stairs so that in addition to providing the visual focal point for the entrance to the hospital, the Main Terrace and Main Stairs were originally a part of the physical experience of entering the hospital. The East Garden and the West Garden are garden rooms enclosed by walls that connect to the east and west ends of the Main Plaza, respectively. The alignments of Ambulance and Automobile roads create narrow bands of landscape along the Avenue and Vallecito Place sides of the property; these areas are identified as the East and HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 52) West Boundary Planting areas in this report. These two areas contain stands of mature evergreen trees and are treated more informally than the landscape areas next to the Administration Building. The historic Service Building is located immediately behind (northeast) of the Administration Building. Ward 1 is connected to the west side of the Service Building, and the wing with Wards 2, 4, 6, and 8, connected to its east side, stretches out along the Avenue side of the property. Extending to the east of this wing of ward buildings is a row of three original buildings that historically housed support functions the Pathological Building with autopsy rooms and the morgue, the Garage-Incinerator Building, and the Power House.
These support buildings are located in the northeast corner of the site near the intersection of Avenue and East Street; this area was the rear of the site in Two original service entrances the Service Entrance and road and the Garage Entrance and road provide access to this rear portion of the historic core of the campus. 2. Historic Character Summary Based on the analysis of the development of the Highland Hospital campus, the site can be divided into two sections the southern portion of the site where the hospital campus (buildings and landscape) remains largely intact and the northern portion where later hospital construction is located.
The present-day landscape (including the spatial organization, location of buildings, circulation features, topography, and vegetation features) north of Ward 1, the Service Building, and the Service Road no longer relates to the design by Henry Meyers for the Highland Hospital campus and is not described in this report. The site design, landscape features, and the health-care, support, and residential123 buildings within the historic core of the Highland Hospital campus were designed by architect Henry H. Meyers.
Landscape architect Howard Gilkey prepared planting plans based on Meyers design, and although his ideas were never fully realized, key vegetation features that are closely identified with the hospital s landscape such as the surviving stands of evergreen trees located in the East and West Boundary Planting areas, the incense cedars located at the corners of the landings for the Main Stairs and along the base of the Main Terrace s retaining walls, and the use of palms to frame entrances or key features are based on his design and were developed under his oversight.
The historic core of the Highland Hospital campus is significant as an example of the application of Beaux-Arts design principles to a pavilion-style hospital s site plan and landscape design and as an example of a relatively intact example of Beaux-Arts public landscape 123 None of the residential buildings are extant. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 53) architecture from the The historic core of the hospital campus exhibits the hallmark Beaux-Arts principles of balance, symmetry, proportion, and axiality. The primary design axis, a line that bisects the angle at the intersection at Avenue and Vallecito Place, establishes the geometric order for the Beaux-Arts style site plan for the historic core of the hospital campus.
The topographic modifications of the site and the historic hospital buildings, the formal landscape spaces, and the primary circulation are arranged in relation to this axis. The unity of the campus design is further reinforced by the repetition of the materials and detailing, derived from the Spanish Colonial Revival style, for both the exterior treatment of the historic buildings and the landscape s built features and site furnishings. When constructed, the design and character of the landscape were considered a critical component of the health-restoring activities of the institution. 124 Today, the remaining character-defining landscape features within the historic core of the hospital are a critical part of Highland Hospital s public image. 3. Integrity and Condition Summary a.
Changes Related to the Three Major Building Campaigns and The most dramatic changes to the Highland Hospital landscape have occurred in relation to the additions of new medical buildings.
Following the completion of the original facilities Highland Hospital was expanded in three major building campaigns the Clinic Building and Auditorium the Acute Care Tower and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center that reflected the evolving approach to hospital design during the twentieth century from the pavilion plan to the tower form.125 Because these additions were confined to the northwest corner and along the northern portion of the site, the original hospital buildings and the spatial relationships within the complex (between the original hospital buildings and between the buildings and the landscape) remain intact.
The original hospital buildings were not torn down, and no buildings were built within the courtyards or other open spaces immediately adjacent to the historic buildings. The spatial organization between the buildings and landscape in the historic core remain intact. Additionally, the stylistic features of the landscape s structures, which relate to the exterior appearance and detailing of the original buildings, and the general character of the vegetation in the historic core were not altered by these additions. As a result, the original hospital complex still retains a recognizable identity. The Clinic Building and Auditorium-related expansion in in the northwest corner of the campus had little impact on the original hospital complex s spatial organization and function and 124 Henry H.
Meyers, Highland Hospital Plans Told by County Architect, Oakland Tribune, 4 May 2. 125 Ibid., 5; Siegel & Strain Architects 3 and 16. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 54) did not alter any of the key character-defining characteristics of Meyers design or Gilkey s plantings. In fact, this area had been designated by Meyers for future construction, and his plan made allowances for expansion along the west side of the campus, facing Vallecito Place. The Clinic and Auditorium buildings and their related plaza and parking lot were stylistically distinct and functionally separate from the original hospital.
The use of incense cedars around the new buildings and the planting of a new stand of cedars next to East Street between the new parking lot and the Auditorium s plaza reflected a similar use of these species as was found in the original complex. The additions of the Acute Care Tower in and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center in changed the campus setting north of the core group of historic hospital buildings. The construction of these new facilities required the removal of the Nurses Home and the two employees residence buildings along East Street.
Residential buildings for staff were often a typical part of hospitals during the and the residential facilities at Highland (the Nurses Home, the Male Employees Building, and the Female Employees Building) were connected stylistically and functionally to the main hospital complex. The removal of the Nurses Home, the Male Employees Building, and the Female Employees Building did not alter the characteristics within the historic hospital core area, but did result in a loss of the entire residential complex, an original component in the development of the overall hospital complex. The residence buildings were surrounded by stands of trees that were similar in appearance and species to those along Avenue and Vallecito Place and in the northwest corner of the campus.
The locations of these trees on the interior slopes and along the edges of the property contributed to the visual identity to the campus. A consequence of the removal of the evergreen trees in the north portion of the campus to make way for the Acute Care Tower and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center is that the original hospital core no longer appears to be set within a forest of evergreen trees.
(The portion of the stand in the northwest corner had been removed in when the Clinic Building and Auditorium were built.) The height of the new facilities, their location on the northern portion of the campus which is at a higher elevation than the historic core, and the loss of the trees increase the visual prominence of the Acute Care Tower and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center. These buildings loom over the original hospital. The public s interaction with the site has been reoriented. The fronts of the Acute Care Tower and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center face onto East Street and this street is now the functional entrance to the Highland Hospital campus.
However, the and additions did not require the removal of any historic building or key landscape features from the main historic hospital complex; nor did they require the addition of new buildings or landscape features in these areas; and this has allowed the historic core to retain its own identity. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 55) The and additions changed the functional connections between the hospital and its external environment. The main entrance to Highland Hospital is now functionally through the facilities on East Street. The Main Stairs and the Main Terrace are no longer used by the public as the primary entrance to the hospital; both are closed to public access due to safety issues related to their current physical condition.
The three original pedestrian entrances into the hospital campus on Avenue and Vallecito Place the Gate House, the West Entrance, and the Staff Entrance are also closed. So although the original pedestrian entrances associated with the Administration Building are extant, the entry experience, a key characteristic of Meyers original campus design, is no longer functional. Additionally, the pedestrian circulation features associated with the ward buildings and the three residential buildings (Nurses Building and the two employees buildings) have been removed.
The circulation features associated with the ward courtyards were removed when parking was added to these areas and those associated with the residential buildings along East Street were removed when these buildings were demolished to make way for the Acute Care Tower and its related features. Internal movement across the campus is now segregated between the original complex on the southern part of the site and the new facilities along East Street. b. Incremental Changes Other changes, which resulted from new or changing needs related to site use and the limited resources devoted to maintenance, occurred incrementally.
A key example of this type of change was the removal of both formally and informally landscaped spaces in order to provide more parking as the personal automobile became an increasingly dominant transportation option. First, the ends of the ward courtyards, between the ward buildings, were used for parking; this resulted in minor changes to the topography and the removal of the portions of the sidewalks and vegetation at the end of the courtyards. Ultimately, the entire area within each courtyard was converted to parking, and all of the landscape features were removed and replaced with pavement. A similar evolution occurred on the south side of the Garage complex when trees were removed so that this area could be paved.
The limited scale of these incremental changes has meant that most of the stylistic features of the Spanish Colonial Revival (and the related materials and workmanship) that characterize the buildings and the built landscape features remain and that enough of the vegetation features are extant to provide a sense of how the plants were used in the original design. Today, the original features are almost eighty-five years old, and issues related to the impacts of time on the landscape are now evident.
For example, portions of the decorative terra cotta on the Main Entrance Gate and Gate House have been damaged; much of the fountain in the West Garden is missing; the luminaires for the cast metal light fixtures mounted to the balustrades associated with the Main Terrace, the Main Stairs, and East and West gardens are missing; and the concrete features are deteriorating. (These changes are more fully described in Part II. Physical Information, B. Description of Character Defining Features. ) The Beaux-Arts splendor while still evident is now diminished or tarnished by these incremental HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 56) changes in the landscape, and the integrity of the landscape is threatened by the deteriorating condition of the landscape structures due to their advancing age and deferred maintenance. Vegetation is particularly susceptible to the effects of incremental change, which may occur when plants are not suited to their growing environment and do not thrive and die; when plant materials age, die, and are not replaced; when plants outgrow their original design function or are not maintained in a way that maintains this function; or when limited resources for maintenance or changing priorities results in the lack of attention to plants.
As would be expected in a landscape that is over 80 years old, all of these have occurred at Highland Hospital so that some of the key plants are missing, many are aged and overgrown, and there have been additions of new plants. These incremental changes have weakened the present-day landscape s connection to the original vegetation features and characteristics. Although, Howard Gilkey s planting design was never fully implemented on the Highland Hospital campus, the original vegetation features, as documented in historical photographs, were based on his design and were a tangible connection to Gilkey s ideas.
The incremental changes to the vegetation features are most identifiable in the following areas: (1) in the gradual loss of trees along the East and West Boundary Planting areas, (2) in the loss of the distinction between the original planting beds and the lawn in the East, West, and South slopes around the Administration Building, and (3) in the loss of key plants such as the Senegal date palms at the entrance to the Administration Building and the windmill palms in the East and West gardens. c. Changes Related to Structural Conditions Problems related to the structural condition of the Main Terrace have the potential to drastically alter Meyers original design.
Some time between and part of the outer retaining wall for the east side of the Main Terrace and southeast side of the East Garden failed. This wall was a structural and aesthetic component of the landscape design around the Administration Building and its loss altered the symmetrical quality of the design. Part of the paving for the Main Terrace and the East Side Terrace was damaged in this incident and was subsequently removed and replaced with asphalt. The retaining wall that extends along the west sides of the Main Terrace, the West Side Terrace, and the West Garden is currently failing; this wall is cracked and has separated from the wall on the south end of the West Garden. At this date, the reason for these structure problems has not been fully documented.
Portions of the historic pavement on the Main Terrace and in the West Garden are cracked, and the ground has slipped or subsided in places resulting in uneven areas in the paved groundplane. Additionally, the Main Terrace, where it connects to the Main Stairs, and the ground in the East Garden both show signs of subsidence. The reasons for the problems have not been fully documented. In addition to the safety concerns, these issues in combination with the loss of the Main Terrace retaining wall mentioned in the preceding paragraph threaten the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 57) integrity of the Main Terrace, the Main Stairs, the East Garden, and the West Garden all of which are character-defining features of Meyers landscape design and which contribute to the National Register significance of Highland Hospital. B. Description of Character Defining Features 1. Spatial Organization The spatial organization of the remaining portion of the original hospital complex reflects the limits imposed by the site s topography, size, and shape as resolved through the tenets of Beaux- Arts classicism that valued symmetry in the organization of site features.
Additionally, the buildings and their associated formal landscape spaces are arranged based on the standards for pavilion-style hospital plans in the The historic main entrance to the hospital (the Main Entrance Gate) remains in place at the south corner of the site at the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place. The front of the historic Administration Building the centerpiece of the public face of the institution faces southwest toward this intersection and the Main Entrance Gate and is centered on the primary design axis set up by Meyers to organize the campus. The hospital s Service Building is located immediately behind (northeast) of the Administration Building in line with the primary design axis. Ward 1 is connected to the west side of the Service Building.
A wing with Wards 2, 4, 6, and 8 is connected to the Service Building s east side. This wing stretches out along the Avenue side of the property. A group of support structures (the Pathological Building, the Garage, and the Power House) is located east of this wing in the southeast corner of the site near the intersection of Avenue and East Street. The steeply sloping topography of the site has been manipulated through a series of cuts and fills to create level platforms for the campus buildings. These terraces extend beyond the buildings footprints and contain the formal outdoor spaces immediately adjacent to the buildings.
The Main Terrace (the entrance plaza) and the East and West gardens (enclosed garden rooms) are located next to the Administration Building on its south, east, and west sides, respectively. The three Ward Courtyards are located between the four ward buildings in the east wing. These courtyards were designed to offer contemplative outdoor spaces for patients and helped to facilitate light and air movement within the buildings. These spaces remain but their use has changed. Today, given the premium on level land on the site and the increased demand for parking, these courtyards are used as parking lots. They are all paved with asphalt and none of the original landscape features remain extant.
These formal outdoor spaces provide a transition between the buildings and the informal landscape of the East and West Boundary Plantings Areas of the frontages next to the Avenue and Vallecito Place sides of the property. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 58) The spatial organization of the original landscape remains in place south of Ward 1, the Service Building, and the Service Road. In this area, the structure of the landscape is provided by the cluster of original hospital buildings, the terraces next to these buildings that contain the formal landscape spaces, the sloping terrain located along the sides of the property, and the location of the roads.
The two entrance roads (Ambulance Road and Automobile Road) separate the buildings and the adjacent formal landscape areas from the informally landscaped boundary areas that are planted with mature evergreen trees. An extension of Ambulance Road along the alignment of an original sidewalk that parallels the ends of Ward Buildings 2, 4, 6, and 8 and connects to the Garage Road extends this separation between the buildings and formal landscape areas and the forested slopes along the Avenue side of the site. The Service Road located north of these ward buildings originally separated the main hospital buildings from the residential facilities.
Today, this road separates the historic hospital core (south of the road) from non- historic facilities to the north; the historic residential facilities are no longer extant. The spatial organization of the portion of the property north of Ward 1, the Service Building, and the Service Road relates to newer facilities rather than to Meyers plan for the hospital site and landscape. Located in this area are the Clinic and Auditorium buildings, the Acute Care Tower, the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center, two parking garages, and their related landscape features. Because of this clear delineation between the campus and the newer facilities, the historic core of the hospital retains its original spatial organization characteristics. 2.
Topography The site slopes downward from an elevation of at its north boundary along East Street to 87' at the entrance to the hospital at Vallecito Place and Avenue. This elevation gradient reflects that of Meyers design.
The topographic characteristics associated with the design remain largely intact south of Ward 1, the Service Building, and the Service Road and include the following: (1) leveled terraces for the buildings, the Main Terrace, the West Garden, the East Garden, the Staff parking lot between Ward 1 and the Administration Building, the former courtyards (now parking lots) between the ward buildings, the parking lot between Ward 8 and the Pathological Building, the courtyard associated with the Garage, and the Service Court behind the Service Building; (2) the grading associated with the vertical and horizontal alignment for Automobile Road, Ambulance Road, Garage Road, and Service Road; and (3) the slope that runs the length of the site between Ambulance Road and the Avenue boundary (the East Boundary Planting Area) and the corresponding slope between Automobile Road and the Vallecito Place boundary (the West Boundary Planting Area).
HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 59) Alterations to the topography within the historic core of the hospital campus are minimal and include the following: (1) changes to the slope between the east side of the Main Terrace and Ambulance Road as a result of the removal of the Main Terrace retaining wall between and (2) some minor leveling at the ends of the Ward Courtyards associated with the removal of the sidewalk and steps when these areas were converted to parking, and (3) the widening of an original path to a roadway (the Ambulance Road Extension) in association with the conversion of the Ward Courtyards to parking areas.
The topographic features in the portion of the property north of Ward 1, the Service Building, and Service Road are the result of the construction of the non-historic facilities and are not associated with Meyers plan for the hospital campus. 3. Views a.
Principal Views Into the Campus When the hospital was completed in the principal views from points beyond the site into the hospital campus include the following: (1) the view along the primary design axis through the Main Entrance Gate, up the Main Stairs, and across the Main Terrace to the front of the Administration Building; (2) views of the centerpiece of the public face of the institution the Main Stairs, the Main Terrace, and the Administration Building from Avenue and from Vallecito Place; (3) views of the wing of ward buildings (Wards 2, 4, 6, and 8) from Avenue; and (4) views of Ward 1 and the west side of the campus from Vallecito Place.
As the trees in front of the Main Terrace and along the East and West Boundary Planting areas matured, they eventually obscured these views of the hospital. Today, the Main Stairs, the Main Terrace, and the Administration Building can be glimpsed through these stands of mature trees from areas immediately adjacent to the hospital. Because of the way the hospital is sited on the downward slope of a hillside and its relationship to the topography of the surrounding environment, there are distant views of the hospital from the surrounding neighborhoods. As the trees in front of the Main Terrace, in the East Boundary Planting Area along the Avenue, and in the West Boundary Planting Area along Vallecito Place have matured, they have obscured these distant views of the hospital buildings.
Today, the hospital grounds can be identified in these distant views by the presence of the tree canopies which provide a contrast to the houses and apartment buildings on the surrounding properties. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 60) b. Principal Views Within the Campus i. Main Terrace The Main Terrace in front of the Administration Building provides a viewing platform to surrounding areas. However, the mature trees that surround the Main Terrace (on the East and West slopes and in the East and West Boundary Planting areas) have partially blocked these views outward giving the terrace a sense of enclosure that it would not have had originally. ii.
Ward Courtyards Originally, there were views from the east wing of wards onto the landscaped Ward Courtyards, but these views are now of the paved parking lots that replaced the original landscaping. As the trees in the adjacent East Boundary Planting Area have matured, they have provided a screen that filtered the views of the adjacent neighborhood and provided a sense of privacy within the Ward Courtyards, thereby increasing the perceived size of the grounds. (These trees also screened views from the neighborhood into the Ward Courtyards.) iii. Ward 1 The original views to the south from Ward 1 were of the paved Automobile Parking Lot, the West Garden, the Main Terrace, the West Slope in front of the Main Terrace, and the West Boundary Planting Area.
These views remain largely unchanged today. The original views to the north from Ward 1 outward were of an unpaved parking lot and to the trees, beyond the parking lot, in the northwest corner of the site. The surface lot and trees were removed to make way for the Auditorium and Clinic Building complex Today, views to the north from Ward 1 are of the Clinic, Auditorium, and the top deck of an adjacent parking structure. 4. Circulation a. Vehicular Circulation i. Entrances The Main Entrance, the Service Entrance, and the Garage Entrance the three vehicular entrances that were part of the hospital campus design remain in place. Other vehicular entrances on East Street (to the parking garage, the Koret Foundation Critical Care and HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 61) Clinic Center, and parking lots) and to the parking structure on Vallecito Place are not part of the hospital campus design. A description of the three original vehicular entrances is provided below. Main Entrance Gate The Main Entrance Gate located at the south corner of the site at the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place is framed by a large gate structure (described under Structures ). This gate structure is aligned with the primary design axis that Meyers established for the campus design. As designed by Meyers, this entrance was intended to be used by ambulances that entered through the east side of the gate and by private automobiles that entered through the west side of the gate.
The design remains intact; however the Main Entrance Gate no longer provides the primary vehicular entrance to the hospital and the use of the roads has changed. Service Entrance The Service Entrance is a secondary entrance to the hospital grounds located on Avenue near the intersection of Avenue and East Street. It is framed by an entrance structure (described under Structures ) that provides access to the rear of the Service Building via the Service Road. The Service Entrance design remains intact and still provides access to the rear of the Service Building.
Garage Entrance The Garage Entrance, an opening in the concrete retaining wall that runs along Avenue (described in more detail under Structures ), is a secondary entrance to the hospital grounds located on Avenue just south of the Power House. It provides vehicular access to the three service buildings located along the Garage Road the Power House, the Garage, and the Pathological Building and to the parking lot or service court located at the end of the road, between Ward 8 (Wing D), and the Pathological Building. ii. Roads and Parking The four roads that were part of the original hospital campus include Ambulance Road and Automobile Road, both originating at the Main Entrance Gate, and Service Road and Garage Road, located to the north and south of the Power House, respectively.
Other existing roads including the roads or drives associated with the parking structures, the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center on East Street, and the extension of Ambulance Road that connects to three Ward Courtyard parking lots are not part of the original hospital campus design. Similarly, surface parking lots associated with the buildings along East Street and the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 62) three parking areas in the former Ward Courtyards are not part of the original hospital campus design. A description of the four historic roads and the one historic parking lot is provided below.
Ambulance Road Ambulance Road begins at the east gate of the Main Entrance Gate, continues northeast to Ward 2, where it turns north/northwest to form a looped drive that provides access to the porte cochere (the original entrance for ambulances), which connects the end of the Administration Building to its addition. The original alignment for the road was modified slightly in when the Administration Building addition was built. The Ambulance Road is approximately 18' wide, and its outer edges are defined by a concrete curb and gutter system, some of which appears to be original and some of which has been replaced. Asphalt has been added on top of the original scored concrete pavement for much of the road s alignment.
The extension of this road begins at the southeast corner of Ward 2 and continues parallel with Avenue to the Garage Road. This section of the road was designed in as a pedestrian path and was widened to a roadway around the mid-1990s when the Ward Courtyards were converted to parking areas. Automobile Road and Parking Lot Automobile Road begins at the west gate of the Main Entrance Gate and continues north to provide access to the Automobile Parking Lot that is located between Ward 1 and the Administration Building. The road retains its original width (approximately 18' ), concrete curb and gutter system along the outer edges, and scored concrete pavement; asphalt has been added on top of the concrete at the road s north end.
The major change is located at its south end where concrete islands have been added to both sides of the road to accommodate a modern parking gate, whose purpose is to control access into the Automobile Parking Lot. The Automobile Parking Lot fills the space between the west side of the Administration Building, the Service Building, and Ward 1. Access to this parking lot is via the Automobile Road at its southwest corner. The parking lot s design (size, shape, and original, scored concrete pavement) remains largely unchanged, and it continues to provide parking for the hospital s staff, as originally designed.
Service Road Service Road begins at Avenue near the intersection of Avenue and East Street, continues in a southwesterly direction passing between the Koret Center parking garage (on the north side) and the Power House and an original retaining wall (on the south side), and ends at HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 63) the Service Court, an expanded paved area, located behind the Service Building. The original purpose for this road was to provide access to the Service Building, and it continues to serve this function. The road is paved with asphalt between Avenue and the entrance gate. The rest of the road is paved with concrete, and the sides are defined by concrete curbs.
This two-lane road retains its original alignment but has been widened; an original sidewalk on its south side (shown on Meyers Approaches plan, Drawing No. was removed when the road was widened. Garage Road and Parking Lot Garage Road begins at Avenue just south of the Power House, continues to the southwest, and ends in a paved area, now used as a parking lot, that is located between Ward 8 (Wing D) and the Pathological Building. The original purpose for this road was to provide access to a group of hospital support facilities, and it continues to serve this function. The road is paved with asphalt. The parking lot is paved with concrete, although asphalt has been added to areas along its edges.
The sides of the road and parking lot are generally defined by concrete curbs, some of which appear to be original and some of which have been replaced. This road was designed to be approximately 12' wide on the original plans, but it has been widened on its north side to incorporate the landscape area between the original road and the Pathological Building and Garage. b. Pedestrian Circulation i. Pedestrian Entrances The three pedestrian entrances that were part of the original hospital campus remain in place and include the Gate House Entrance on Avenue and the West and Staff entrances on Vallecito Place. There is also a pedestrian entrance incorporated into the Service Entrance Gate that spans the Service Road.
Pedestrian entrances associated with the original residential facilities located along East Street (the Nurses Home, the Female Employees Building, and the Male Employees Building) were removed as a result of the demolition of these facilities in the mid-1960s and Other pedestrian entrances including those associated with the Clinic and Auditorium and all extant entrances along East Street are not part of the original hospital campus design. A description of the four remaining original pedestrian entrances is provided below. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 64) Gate House Entrance The Gate House Entrance was designed to be the primary pedestrian entrance to the hospital campus and was located on Avenue to coordinate with the Key System streetcar line along Avenue that provided public transportation to this part of the city when the hospital opened in This entrance is marked by a gate house (described under Entrance Structures ). A concrete-paved incline in a pedestrian tunnel leads downward from Avenue, through the Gate House, and under the Ambulance Road to a narrow landing on the north side of the Ambulance Road. Two sets of concrete stairs connect to this landing.
The widest set (approximately 14' wide) leads northwestward to the bottom landing of the Main Stairs east staircase (labeled as East Landing #2" on the plan that accompanies this report). The narrower set (approximately 5' wide) connects to the sidewalk that runs along the north side of the Ambulance Road. The Gate House Entrance is no longer used, and its three access points from Avenue, from the Main Stairs, and from the Ambulance Road are all blocked with non- historic gates or fences. West Entrance The West Entrance is located on Vallecito Place approximately north of the Main Entrance Gate.
Meyers design for the landscape around the Administration Building was symmetrical, and the location and features of the West Entrance balance those associated with the Gate House Entrance on Avenue. The West Entrance was intended as a secondary public entrance and as such had a simpler design than the Gate House, which was the primary pedestrian entrance. (See Structures for a description of the West Entrance structure.) A set of stairs (approximately 14' wide) leads downward from the West Entrance to a pedestrian tunnel which goes under the Automobile Road. On the opposite side of the tunnel, a second set of stairs connects to the bottom landing of the Main Stairs west staircase (labeled as West Landing #2" on the plan that accompanies this report).
The pavement in the pedestrian tunnel and on the two sets of stairs is concrete. The West Entrance is no longer used, and its access point from Vallecito Place is blocked with a non-historic gate. Staff Entrance The Staff Entrance is located on Vallecito Place approximately north of the West Entrance. As designed by Meyers, this entrance was intended to provide access from the street to the staff entrance on the west side of the Administration Building. The original design showed a decorative, wrought iron arch over the opening in the concrete retaining wall at this pedestrian entrance; a sign that read STAFF hung from the arch and a decorative light, incorporated into HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 65) the arch, lit this sign.126 This arch, sign, and light are not present today.
No as-built drawings were located to indicate that the arch was installed, and no historical photographs show this area. The lack of any evidence (such as patching) in the extant concrete wall supports the conclusion that the arch was never installed. The Staff Entrance connects to a set of concrete stairs (approximately 6' wide) that lead up to a landing near the southwest corner of Ward 1 and the northwest corner of the Automobile Parking Lot. There is a pipe handrail down the center of the stairs; based on patches in the concrete, it appears that this handrail was added after the original construction of the stairs. The Staff Entrance is no longer used, and its two access points from Vallecito Place and from the Automobile Parking Lot are blocked with gates.
Service Entrance A pedestrian entrance is incorporated into the south side of the Service Entrance Gate that spans the Service Road. A description of the Service Entrance Gate is provided in the Structures section under the Entrance Structures subsection. ii. Sidewalks and Stairs Sidewalks that were part of the original hospital campus design remain in place within the East and West gardens, at the West End of Ward 1, along the north side of the Ambulance Road, at the Power House, and around the perimeter of the campus in the public right-of-way. The sidewalks and stairs that were around the Nurses Home, the Female Employees Building, and the Male Employees Building were removed in the and when these buildings were demolished.
Also, the pedestrian bridge that spanned the Service Road, to provide a connection between these residential buildings and the main hospital complex, is gone. The path that connected the Ambulance Road, the Ward Courtyards, and the Garage Road has been widened into a road to provide vehicular access to the parking lots in the Ward Courtyards; this road is referred to as the Ambulance Road Extension on the plan that accompanies this report. The paths within the Ward Courtyards were removed when these areas were paved for parking in the mid-1990s.
Sidewalks and other pedestrian circulation features that are not associated with the original hospital campus design include those around the Clinic and Auditorium buildings and the parking structure in the northwest corner of the property and those in the north part of the property around the Acute Care Tower the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center complex, and its associated parking structure 126 Henry H. Meyers, Approaches . . . Drawing No. (19 October HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 66) The original hierarchy of paving materials for the pedestrian paths based on the prominence of their location and the intensity of usage has been altered.
As shown on Meyers Approaches drawings for the landscape, sidewalks along the roads (Ambulance, Automobile, and Service) and the primary paths that connected the residential area to the hospital were paved with concrete (scored with a double row of squares); the paths in the secondary formal spaces (the Ward Courtyards and at the Nurses Home) and those connecting the secondary spaces (at the west end of Ward 1 and connecting Ambulance Road, the Ward Courtyards, and Garage Road) were gravel with brick edging. Because all of the gravel sidewalks have been removed from the campus, this aspect of Meyers design the hierarchy that was implied between sidewalks with different pavement materials is no longer evident.
The one remaining sidewalk that was originally gravel, located at the west end of Ward 1, is now concrete. The sidewalks in the East and West gardens are brick laid out in a running bond pattern. The use of brick in these areas was originally intended to reflect the use of brick and travertite in a preliminary pavement scheme for the Main Terrace, and although this preliminary pavement scheme was replaced by one using colored concrete on the Main Terrace, the East and West gardens sidewalks were nevertheless constructed of brick. A description of the remaining original pedestrian paths is provided below.
Sidewalks Associated with the Formal Landscape Features The circulation paths and pavement features within the formal landscape spaces the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, the East Garden, and the West Garden are described with these features under Structures. Sidewalk at the West End of Ward 1 A concrete sidewalk parallels the west end of Ward 1. The south end of this sidewalk (approximately 6' wide) begins at the northwest corner of the Automobile Parking Lot, and its north end connects to a set of stairs located just north of the west end of Ward 1. On Meyers original plans, this sidewalk was shown as being gravel with brick curbs; the date when the concrete replaced the original paving materials was not found.
Ambulance Road Sidewalk A concrete sidewalk (approximately 5' wide) parallels the north side of the Ambulance Road. This sidewalk begins at the top of the stairs that connect to the Gate House pedestrian tunnel and ends at the base of the stairs that lead up to the East Garden. The concrete in this sidewalk is scored to create two rows of rectangular panels. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 67) Power House Sidewalks A concrete sidewalk connects the Power House entrance with the sidewalk in the public right-of- way along Avenue.
The alignment for this sidewalk is the same as the original walk that was part of the hospital campus design; however, the concrete was replaced in the early A second sidewalk, aligned parallel to the front of the Power House, connects the building s entrance with steps that lead up to the Service Road and the pedestrian gate in the Service Entrance Gate. This sidewalk was part of hospital campus design; its original alignment remains intact, but portions of the concrete have been replaced. Public Right-of-Way Sidewalks Sidewalks are located in the public right-of-way along the length of Avenue, Vallecito Place, and East Street. The original scoring pattern for these sidewalks consisted of rows of rectangular panels.
A section of the original sidewalk with the original scoring pattern remains on Vallecito Place between the Main Gate and the Staff Entrance, although the sidewalk has been widened by paving the original planting strip along the outer side of the walk. Along Street, the original scoring pattern is still evident near the Main Gate and the Gate House; however, the sidewalk has been widened by paving the original planting strip that ran along the inner side of the walk (at the base of the boundary wall). Along East Street, the original concrete for the sidewalk has been replaced. 5. Buildings Extant buildings that were part of the original complex include the Administration Building, the Service Building, Wards 1, 2, 4, 6, and 8, the Pathological Building, the Garage, and the Power House.
Detailed descriptions of these buildings are provided in the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation127 and the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey reports.128 The following discussion describes the buildings in relation to the original landscape design. Meyers stylistic choices for the exterior of the buildings reflected the popularity of the Spanish Colonial Revival design vocabulary for public architecture in the Bay Area and throughout California during the The Historic Resource Evaluation report, prepared for the buildings in described the exterior as an amalgam of Beaux-Arts planning and the Spanish Colonial 127 Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson 128 Seigel & Strain Architects HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 68) Revival style. Exterior walls are clad in cement plaster, ornamented with cement plaster belt courses, and cream-colored and light blue-colored polychrome terra cotta. Meyers used a profusion of ornamentation to identify the internal programmatic hierarchy on the exterior of the buildings and to create design continuity for the many wings that make up the complex. The terra cotta ornamentation is concentrated at entrances, on elevations that front on public streets, on transitions between some non-planar portions of the building, and in the center of long, otherwise unornamented walls as a way to break-up the building masses.
The juxtaposition of the flat cement plaster wall surfaces and the highly decorative character of the terra cotta serves to set off the ornamentation.129 The Spanish Colonial Revival style is extended into the landscape setting by the repetition of the same colors and materials (cement plaster and decorative terra cotta tile) on retaining walls and entrance structures. The connection between the exterior treatment of the buildings and that of the built landscape features was a critical component in Meyers original design and contributed to a unified design for the hospital campus. The buildings that comprised the hospital s residential complex along East Street the Nurses Home, the Female Employees Building, and the Male Employees Building are no longer extant.
These buildings were removed in the late and early to clear the north portion of the site for the construction of the Acute Care Tower and its associated surface parking lots. Buildings that are not part of the original campus design include the Clinic and Auditorium buildings and an associated parking structure located in the northwest corner of the property, the Acute Care Tower located north of the Service Building, and the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center complex and its associated parking structure located in the north part of the property along East Street. 6. Structures a. Boundary Structures i. Boundary Walls Reinforced concrete retaining walls are located along the property line on the Avenue and Vallecito Place sides of the property.
These retaining walls, designed by Meyers, are necessary due to the difference in elevation between the edge of the hospital grounds and that of the street level. The walls have a flat face, are painted an off-white or cream color, and are unadorned except for a simple cap wide x 4" high). Round drainage holes are spaced along the bases. 129 Based on an excerpt from page eighteen in the Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation prepared by Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson in HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 69) The 8'-high chainlink fence that is located just behind the top of the walls (bolted to the back of some sections or mounted in the ground in other areas) is not part of the original design; otherwise, the walls retain their original character. The retaining wall along the Avenue property line consists of the following three sections: (1) from the Main Entrance Gate to the southwest end of the Gate House, (2) from the northeast end of the Gate House to the south side of the Garage Entrance, and (3) from the north side of the Garage Entrance to the end of the wall that connects into the southeast corner of the Power House. These three sections were all part of the original design by Meyers.
The wall decreases in height as it proceeds along Avenue; it is approximately 8' high where it connects to the Main Entrance Gate decreasing to about 4' high at the Garage Entrance. The retaining wall along the Vallecito Place property line consists of the following three sections: (1) from the Main Entrance Gate to the south side of the West Entrance, (2) from the north side of the West Entrance to the south side of the Staff Entrance, and (3) from the north side of the Staff Entrance to the south side of the parking structure. Originally, the wall extended farther north to the general vicinity of the present-day Clinic; however this section of wall was removed in when the parking structure was constructed.
The three remaining sections, which are approximately 6' high, were all part of the original design by Meyers. ii. Boundary Fence A metal rail fence (approximately long), mounted on a low concrete curb wide x 6" high), remains in place at the east end of East Street near its intersection with Avenue. The rest of this fence and its associated concrete curb, which originally stretched across the entire boundary along East 31 Street, was removed sometime after when construction on the newer hospital facilities began; the fence and curb remained extant through and were shown on a survey of the site.130 The extant fence consists of three types of metal railings mounted into the historic concrete curb, which extends the entire length of the fence.
A long section of the original 8'-high, metal rail fence remains in place between two, historic, concrete columns at the far west end. A 30'-long section of the railing at the far east end, near the intersection of East and streets, consists of non-historic, metal, pipe railing. An 85'-long section of non-historic, 8'-high, metal rail fence spans middle portion of the boundary fence. The non-historic sections were probably added in the early as part of the construction of the Koret Center facilities. 130 Ratcliff, Slama, Calwalader HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 70) b. Entrance Structures i.
Main Entrance Gate The Main Entrance Gate, located at the south corner of the site at the intersection of Avenue and Vallecito Place, spans the Ambulance and the Automobile roads and frames the original primary vehicular entrance to the hospital. The Main Entrance Gate as designed by Meyers consisted of a west gate and an east gate linked by a central, wrought iron rail fence between the two roadways. Each of these three parts remain; however, a non-historic metal gate has been added to both the west and east gate openings to control access to the two roadways and to the hospital grounds. The original parts of the Main Entrance Gate are described below. The east and west gates are mirror images of each other, except for signage.
Each gate includes a pair of square columns, one on each side of its respective roadway. Originally, there was a decorative iron frame between the columns that arched over each roadway. The word EMERGENCY was incorporated between the bottom and top chords of the arch over the east gate, and AUTOMOBILE was incorporated between the bottom and top chords of the arch over the west gate; these two arches have been removed and are currently in storage. The wrought iron rail fence continues to span the area between the two inner columns. Originally a wrought iron panel with the hospital s name spanned the top of this fence (originally HIGHLAND HOSPITAL and later when the name changed, HIGHLAND ALAMEDA COUNTY HOSPITAL ); this wrought iron name panel has been removed.
The four columns located on the sides of the two entrance roads are faced with glazed terra cotta tile that is similar in appearance and detailing (cream-colored base tile with details that are tan and light blue) to that used around the entrances to the Administration Building. Some of the tile at the corners of the columns has been chipped off. In other areas, the tile is deteriorated and has places where the glaze has blistered or spalled. The two columns at the outer ends of the gateway structure are visually buttressed by a wall that provides a transition between the gate structure and the boundary retaining walls along Avenue and Vallecito Place. This wall curves in plan to meet a pilaster oriented to the angle of the retaining walls.
Past the pilaster, the wall drops in height to meet the top of the retaining wall. This part of the gate structure is also faced with cream-colored terra cotta tile; there is similar damage and deterioration to this tile as that observed on the four columns that flank the roadways. A granite wheel guard, painted red, is located at the roadside base of the four columns that flank the two roads. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 71) Original features that are missing from the Main Entrance Gate include the following: (1) the wrought iron panel with the hospital s name that spanned the top of the wrought iron fence in the center portion of the structure, (2) the decorative wrought iron arch that spanned each road and that incorporated the identification of the road s use into the arch (i.e., EMERGENCY and AUTOMOBILE ), (3) the original light standard that sat atop each of the four columns that flank the two roads, and (4) the illuminated backlit sign (4"-high letters in a rectangular panel that read EMERGENCY or AUTOMOBILE ) located in the middle of each of these four columns. ii.
Service Entrance Gate The Service Entrance Gate is located near the east end of the Service Road and except for a missing sign panel retains its original appearance as designed by Meyers. The Service Entrance Gate consists of a short wall on each side of the road and a double-leaf iron gate located between the two columns. The short walls are in most respects mirror images of each other. Each consists of a column or pilaster flanking a recessed wall. There is a decorative iron and glass light standard on top of the two columns adjacent to the road. Centered at the top of each recessed wall is a recessed panel that encloses a raised circle. The structure is concrete and is finished with cement plaster that is painted the same off-white or cream color as the boundary retaining walls.
In the north or right-hand wall there was originally a sign panel (an Electric Illuminated Sign ) in the wall that read Highland Hospital Service Entrance ; this panel is missing. The south or left-hand wall is attached to the Power House. It incorporates a pedestrian passage consisting of a rectangular opening and a hinged wrought-iron gate. Like the double-leaf gates at the road, this one consists of horizontal rails at the top and bottom which are attached to vertical bars with spiked tops. iii. Garage Entrance The Garage Entrance is an opening in the boundary retaining wall along the Avenue side of the property framed in a distinctive design that denotes an entrance.
Each section is a mirror of the other and consists of two square columns of unequal height, spaced several feet apart and linked by a wall that curves downward from the high column to the low column next to the road. The taller column is attached to the Avenue retaining wall. This entrance structure has a cap that is identical to that of the boundary retaining walls. There is a granite wheel guard, painted red, located at the roadside base of each side of the entrance structure. The appearance of this entrance gate structure does not match that shown on the original plans that were reviewed for this report; as built, this entrance is less elaborate than the structure shown on Meyers original plans. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 72) iv.
Gate House The Gate House on the Avenue side of the property marks the original primary pedestrian entrance to the hospital grounds and is a one story, four-sided structure in a linear plan along the Avenue boundary of the property. Its floor plan is a trapezoid with its short end walls perpendicular to Avenue; its main facade is parallel to Avenue; and its rear wall aligns with the Ambulance Road. The walls are angled so that they are closer to each other at the southwest end than at the northeast end. The building consists of three principle parts an enclosed space on either side of an open pedestrian tunnel (that measures roughly x ) that leads through the Gate House and under the Ambulance Road to a narrow landing on the north side of the Ambulance Road.
Each of the two enclosed spaces, on either side of the tunnel, are entered through a door in the pedestrian tunnel.131 The inside of the Gate House structure was not inspected during the field work for this report. The building is a reinforced concrete structure with a flat roof paved in quarry tile. The walls have a cement plaster finish and cast concrete ornamental details. The principal ornamentation is along the Avenue facade with an order of rusticated pilasters culminating in a walled railing that encloses the roof terrace. Framing the tunnel entrance on Avenue is a richly decorated glazed terra cotta pilaster order and spandrels that continues upward where a terra cotta balustrade and a panel with the name HIGHLAND HOSPITAL break the otherwise walled railing.
This terra cotta is similar in appearance and detailing (cream-colored base tile with details that are tan and light blue) to that used on the Main Entrance Gate and has the same types of damage as is found on that structure. The three principal windows on Avenue are screened with decorative iron grilles. v. West Entrance The West Entrance, an opening in the boundary retaining wall along the Vallecito Place side of the property, is an original secondary pedestrian entrance to the hospital grounds. Meyers design for the landscape around the Administration Building was symmetrical, and the location and features of the West Entrance balance those associated with the Gate House Entrance on 131 One of Meyers drawings for this building (Approaches . . . Drawing No.
[19 October 1925/revised 27 February labeled the small space measuring roughly x at the southwest end as Custodian and showed the space divided into a closet and toilet room. At the northeast end, this plan showed a suite of spaces labeled "Play Room" that included a main children's play area with blackboards, a smaller area with a lower ceiling and a drinking fountain, a closet, and a toilet room. This drawing also showed an exterior staircase in an L-plan from the Street sidewalk, up the end wall to the roof terrace. There is no outside staircase now, and it is not known whether it was ever built. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 73) Avenue.
The West Entrance was intended as a secondary public entrance and as such had a simpler design than the Gate House, which was the primary pedestrian entrance. The West Entrance is framed on either side by sections of the boundary wall in a distinctive design that denotes an entrance. Each section is a mirror of the other and consists of a buttressed pier on either side the opening. The buttresses are rusticated concrete walls that step up from the lower height of the adjacent boundary wall to the height of the piers that frame the entrance in a series of steps and curves that are designed to resemble the decorative terra cotta tilework that is used on the side columns and panels on either side of the Main Entrance Gate.
Changes to the original design of the gate include the loss of the iron and glass light that was originally attached to the top of each pier and the addition of the non-historic, double-leaf, iron gate that blocks the opening between the piers. c. Main Terrace and Main Stairs The Main Terrace and Main Stairs are a highly visible public entrance feature located in front of the historic Administration Building. The Main Terrace is the wide entrance plaza that spans the front of the Administration Building. The Main Stairs, which traverse the slope in front of the Administration building, begin in the center of the outside (southwest) edge of the Main Terrace and are aligned with the Main Entrance Gate and the central entrance to the Administration Building along the primary design axis.
The Main Stairs and the Main Terrace are no longer used by the public as the primary entrance to the hospital, and access to both is limited due to safety issues related to their current condition. The three original pedestrian entrances into the hospital campus on Avenue and Vallecito Place the Gate House, the West Entrance, and the Staff Entrance are also closed. As a result, the experiential qualities associated with entering the hospital via these entrances, traveling up the monumental Main Stairs, and arriving at the Main Terrace to enter the Administration Building are lost; this entry experience was a key characteristic of Meyers original campus design. A more detailed description of the Main Terrace and Main Stairs is provided below. i.
Main Terrace Three Sections of the Main Terrace The Main Terrace consists of a central plaza and two side areas, identified as the Main Terrace, East Side Terrace, and West Side Terrace on the plan that accompanies this report. The Main Terrace, the central portion of the plaza, is rectangular in shape and is located directly in front of the Administration Building. It connects to the central entrance into the building on its northeast side and to the Main Stairs on its southwest side. The pavement continues at an angle around both sides of the Administration Building to form two, trapezoidal-shaped, side terraces at the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 74) east and west ends of the central plaza, respectively.
Each of these side terraces provides access to a secondary building entrance, one for Patients and the other for Staff. Additionally, the side terraces provide a link to the East and West gardens, the two walled garden rooms located in front of the Administration Building s east and west wings, respectively. Steps from the Administration Building s Patients entrance connect to the north side of the East Side Terrace, and steps located at the terrace s northeast end lead to the East Garden. Steps from the Staff entrance connect to the northeast side of the West Side Terrace, and steps located at the terrace s north end lead to the West Garden.
Outer Retaining Wall A concrete retaining wall topped by a series of short, square, concrete columns, which are connected by a concrete balustrade and cornice, forms the outer side of all three sections of the Main Terrace. Originally, this retaining wall continued past the east and west ends of the East Side Terrace and West Side Terrace to form the outer wall for the East Garden and the West Garden, respectively. The section of the wall along the East Side Terrace and half of the wall along the outer side of the East Garden were removed sometime between and Today, the sections along the Main Terrace, West Side Terrace, and West Garden and the section at the far east end of the East Garden remain extant.
This retaining wall is both an aesthetic and structural component of the landscape design around the Administration Building, and the removal of the East Side Terrace and the East Garden sections of this wall altered the symmetrical quality of Meyers original design and created structural problems for the Main Terrace, East Side Terrace, and East Garden. The remaining sections of the balustrade, columns, and bench wall on the west side of the Main Terrace, along the outer edge of the West Side Terrace, and the outer edge of the West Garden are also in poor condition. Additionally, the retaining wall in these locations is cracked and has separated from the wall on the south end of the West Garden.
A non-historic, metal rail fence with gates has been added around the edges of the three sections of the Main Terrace to control access into this area. Specifically, this fence is located along the outer (southwest) edge of the Main Terrace to block access to the Main Stairs, along the east side of the East Side Terrace to control access into this area from the East Garden during hours when the hospital is closed, and across the north and south sides of the West Side Terrace to block access into this badly damaged section of the plaza. The current deteriorating condition of the Main Terrace in combination with the loss of the outer retaining wall threatens the structural and historic integrity of this character-defining feature of Meyers landscape design. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 75) Light Fixtures The Main Terrace connects to the central front entrance of the Administration Building by a set of steps that span the width of the entrance. Two, large, terra cotta light fixtures at either end of this set of steps frame the entrance to the building; the decorative detailing and color scheme (cream, tan, and light blue) for these lights are the same as the architectural terra cotta around the entrance to the Administration Building. Most of the original cast metal light fixtures remain in place affixed to the top of columns in the Main Terrace retaining wall; however the luminaires for these lights are missing.
The decorative detailing and color scheme (cream, tan, and light blue) for these lights are based on the design of architectural terra cotta that is used around the entrance to the Administration Building. Paving The Main Terrace is paved with light pinkish-beige-colored concrete with bands of contrasting colors (in shades of dark gray/black and red/dark pink) that form a pattern of alternating large squares and rectangles.132 The color in the concrete comes from the aggregate; this paving material resembles terrazzo although it does not have the highly polished surface of terrazzo. The same pattern, colors, and materials in the paving of the East Side Terrace and West Side Terrace form contrasting bands reflect the trapizoidal shape of these two side terraces.
There are damaged and missing portions of the paving in all three sections of the Main Terrace; the missing portions have been filled with asphalt. Portions of the paving in the West Side Terrace are cracked and buckled due to the underlying structural problems. ii. Main Stairs The Main Stairs begin in the center of the outer (southwest) edge of the Main Terrace and traverse down the sloping grade in a southward direction to meet the grade of the South Slope, which is located in front (southwest) of the stairs. An 84'-0-wide set of twelve steps connects the edge of the Main Terrace to a paved landing (rectangular in plan view) that is the same width as the steps. This landing is referred to as the Lower Terrace on the plan that accompanies this report.
A curved bench is incorporated into the retaining wall and balustrade at both ends of the Lower Terrace. At the outer (southwest) side of the Lower Terrace, the Main Stairs splits into twin staircases that bracket a planting bed. Each staircase is approximately wide and has two flights of twenty- 132 This pattern is shown on Drawing No. in Meyers Approaches plan (Meyers HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 76) two steps separated by an intermediate landing. The ground between the twin staircases reflects the grading for the staircases two slopes separated by a level terrace. The intermediate landing between the first and second flight of stairs, in both of the twin staircases, is rectangular in plan (approximately x ).
The landings are referred to as the East Landing #1" (for the east staircase) and the West Landing #1" (for the west staircase) on the plan that accompanies this report. A concrete bench is incorporated into the balustrade on the east and west ends of each intermediate landing (i.e. into East Landing #1 and West Landing The landings at the bottom of the second flight of stairs, in both of the twin staircases, are referred to as the East Landing #2" and the West Landing #2" on the plan that accompanies this report. Each landing is approximately 18' x 16' ; the interior sides of these two landings are connected by pavement that stretches across the width of the interior planting bed, located above the landing.
A flagpole, aligned with the primary design axis, is located at the center of this paved area; refer to the Small-Scale Elements for a description of the flagpole. Stairs at the east end of East Landing #2 connect to the pedestrian tunnel that leads under the Ambulance Road to the Gate House Entrance. Stairs at the west end of West Landing #2 connect to the pedestrian tunnel that leads under the Automobile Road to the West Entrance. Decorative concrete balustrades identical to those along the Main Terrace retaining wall continue along the sides of the twin staircases and the landings.
There is a curved, solid concrete wall on the front (southwest) side of the bottom landings (East Landing #2 and West Landing the area between these two walls was originally open but currently is blocked by a non-historic chain-link fence. Decorative, cast metal lights that are identical to those found along the Main Terrace retaining wall are located at the four corners of each landing on top of the balustrade; however only the base and posts of these light fixtures are extant; the luminaires are missing. The stairs are concrete, and the same concrete paving on the landings have the same colors and patterns as the paving on the Main Terrace.
Sections of the balustrades are missing or have damaged or missing balusters, portions of the paving is cracked on the landings, and there are chips and cracks in the steps of the twin staircases. d. East Garden The East Garden, located southeast of the east wing of the Administration Building, is one of the three formal public landscape spaces around the Administration Building and is the symmetrical balance to the West Garden in the original hospital campus design. The rectangular space HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 77) within the East Garden is approximately 75' long, along the side that parallels the east wing of the Administration Building, and 50' wide. There are two entrances to the East Garden.
The entrance on its southwest side connects to the East Side Terrace of the Main Terrace via a set of concrete stairs; this entrance is aligned with a fountain at the opposite (northeast) end of the garden. The entrance on its southeast side is centered in the middle of the southeast-facing side of the garden; this entrance connects via a staircase to the concrete sidewalk located along the north side of the Ambulance Road. The stairs in this staircase are faced with red brick to match the sidewalk in the East Garden, and the original pipe handrails and decorative metal balusters are still intact on both sides of the staircase. The sides of the East Garden are enclosed by four walls of varying heights.
The southeast-facing exterior wall of the Administration Building defines the northwest side of the East Garden. A low concrete retaining wall (approximately high), along the northwest side of the garden, separates a planting area, which is next to the Administration Building and at the same elevation as the East Side Terrace, from the lower level of the groundplane in the East Garden. Proceeding clockwise, a concrete wall, plain except for its cornice, encloses the northeast end of the garden; a tile fountain (described under Small-Scale Elements ) is located in the middle of this wall and provides the primary vocal point within the garden.
The continuation of the Main Terrace retaining wall and balustrade originally formed the southeast side of the East Garden; today only the portion of this retaining wall northeast of the brick staircase (described in the preceding paragraph on the entrances to the garden) remains extant. The portion of the wall southwest of the staircase is missing; based on images of the garden from aerial photographs, it was removed sometime between and a hedge has been planted to define the edge of the garden in place of this missing wall and balustrade.
A low, concrete, retaining wall (approximately high) separates the southwest end of the East Garden from the East Side Terrace; the only decoration on this wall is a simple concrete cap; a set of concrete stairs, on axis with the fountain at the opposite end of the East Garden, are located in the middle of this wall and provide the transition between the East Garden and the East Side Terrace. A 4'-0-wide, red brick sidewalk, paved in a running bond pattern, forms a rectangular path around the edges of the garden.
The portion of this sidewalk between the stairs on its southwest end (leading up to the East Side Terrace) and the staircase on the southeast side (leading down to the Ambulance Road) is not original; sometime after the Main Terrace retaining wall was removed this portion of the sidewalk was moved inward; it is shown in its current location in a aerial photograph. The two main planting areas within the East Garden are formed by the garden walls and the perimeter sidewalk. There is a planting bed along each of the four sides of the garden in the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 78) narrow area between the brick sidewalk and the exterior walls of the garden.
This narrow planting bed is interrupted by the two entrances to the garden (on its southeast side and southwest end) and by the base of the fountain (on its northeast end). A rectangular lawn is located within the area defined by the perimeter sidewalk. A secondary planting bed is located on the northwest side of the garden; this planting bed is defined by the low retaining wall on the garden s northwest side and the southeast-facing exterior wall of the Administration Building. It is at the same elevation as the East Side Terrace and approximately higher than the elevation of the primary groundplane in the East Garden. There are a number of issues related to the condition of the East Garden.
As noted above, half of the southeast-side retaining wall and balustrade are missing; this loss has resulted in a change in the original alignment to the brick perimeter sidewalk and altered the symmetrical design within the East Garden. There are a number of problems that may be connected to continuing subsidence including (1) cracks in the brick perimeter sidewalk and in the wall that encloses the northeast end of the garden, (2) settling of the perimeter sidewalk so that it no longer provides a flush connection with the brick staircase that connects to Ambulance Road, and (3) settling of the staircase that connects to the Ambulance Road. Additionally, the concrete stairs that connect the East Garden to the East Side Terrace are chipped. e.
West Garden The West Garden, located west of the west wing of the Administration Building, is one of the three formal public landscape spaces around the Administration Building in the original hospital campus design and is the symmetrical balance to the East Garden. The rectangular space within the West Garden is approximately 75' long, along the side that parallels the west wing of the Administration Building, and 50' wide. There are three entrances to the West Garden. The entrance on its south end connects to the West Side Terrace via a set of concrete stairs; this entrance is aligned with a fountain at the opposite (north) end of the garden.
The two entrances on its north end are located on either side of the fountain; each of these two entrances connects via brick stairs and a short brick sidewalk to the Automobile Parking Lot that is located immediately north of the West Garden. The sides of the West Garden are enclosed by four walls of varying heights. On the east side of the garden, the west-facing exterior wall of the Administration Building defines the east side of the East Garden; a low concrete retaining wall, along the east side of the garden, separates a secondary planting area which is next to the Administration Building and at the same elevation as the West Side Terrace, from the lower level of the ground plane in the West Garden.
Proceeding in a clockwise direction, a low, concrete, retaining wall (approximately high) separates the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 79) south end of West Garden from the West Side Terrace; the only decoration on this wall is a simple concrete cap; a set of concrete stairs, on axis with the fountain at the opposite end of the West Garden, in the middle of this wall provides the transition between the West Garden and the West Side Terrace. The continuation of the Main Terrace retaining wall and balustrade form the west side of the West Garden.
A concrete wall, plain except for its cornice, encloses the north end of the garden; the remains of a glazed-tile fountain (described under Small-Scale Elements ), that originally provided the primary vocal point within the West Garden, is located in the middle of this wall; two openings, one on either side of the fountain, provide connections via brick stairs and a short brick sidewalk to the Automobile Parking Lot. A 4'-0-wide, red brick sidewalk, paved in a running bond pattern, forms a rectangular path around the edges of the garden. The two main planting areas within the West Garden are formed by the garden walls and this perimeter sidewalk.
There is a planting bed along each of the four sides of the garden in the narrow area between the brick sidewalk and the exterior walls of the garden; this narrow planting bed is interrupted on the south end by the entrance into the garden and on the north end by the two entrances and the base of the fountain (this base is not extant). A rectangular lawn is located within the area defined by the perimeter sidewalk. A secondary planting bed is located on the east side of the garden; this planting bed is defined by the low retaining wall (approximately high) on the garden s east side and the west-facing exterior wall of the Administration Building.
The planting be is at the same elevation as the West Side Terrace and is approximately higher than the elevation of the primary ground plane in the West Garden. There are a number of issues related to the condition of the West Garden. The ground on the west side of the West Garden has subsided resulting in cracks to the brick perimeter sidewalk along the garden s west side and north and south ends. The concrete stairs at the south end of the garden are uneven due to subsidence. The west wall and balustrade are still extant, but they are threatened by the same underlying structural problems that have already severely damaged the West Side Terrace. The fountain (described under Small-Scale Elements ) that was originally located in the center of the north wall is non-extant.
These problems and the threat of a major structural failure of the west-side wall threaten the integrity of the West Garden, a character- defining feature of Meyers landscape design which contributes to the National Register significance of Highland Hospital. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 80) 7. Vegetation Features a.
Overview Based on a review of Gilkey s original planting plan and of the historical photographs that show the initial development of the hospital landscape in the late and the extant primary vegetation areas associated with the original development of the Highland Hospital campus include (1) the beds at the entrances to the Administration Building on the Main Terrace, (2) the bed between the twin staircases of the Main Stairs, (3) the East, West, and South slopes in front of the Main Terrace and Main Stairs, (4) the East and West gardens, and (5) the East and West Boundary Planting areas.
Extant secondary vegetation areas include the Automobile Parking Lot, the Ambulance Entrance Area, the Power House, the Garage Road, the Service Road, and the narrow planting beds in the public right-of-way along the Vallecito Place boundary wall. Several factors make it difficult to identify original plant materials. First, the planting key to Gilkey s planting design was not with the plans that were located in the research for this report, so there is no list of the original plants that Gilkey intended to use; only the locations and an unidentified number key are available. Additionally, Gilkey s planting design was only the starting point for the development of the vegetation element on the hospital campus.
Following the opening of the hospital in December the planting of the grounds occurred in stages, and Gilkey s original ideas, as shown on the drawings of his planting design, were adapted as the grounds development proceeded. Historical photographs from the late and early provide the only accurate information about the original vegetation types and locations. However, these photographs provide only limited views of the areas around the Administration Building and along the two boundary planting areas; some areas, such as the Ward Courtyards, are not shown in any photographs; and the resolution in the photographs limits plant identification. Finally, an accurate age for the extant plant materials is difficult to determine since many factors affect growth rate.
Additionally, trees and shrubs that may have been added in the some twenty years after the completion of the hospital would now be sixty years old.
The plant materials that appear most likely to be associated with the original development of the Highland Hospital campus include the following: (1) the lawn areas on the South Slope in front of the Main Stairs and in the center of the East and West gardens; (2) the large incense cedars (Calocedrus decurrens) located (a) at regular intervals along the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall, (b) at the corners of landings along the outside walls of the Main Stairs, and (c) in various foundation beds in the Automobile Parking Lot, Ambulance Entrance area, etc; (3) the yews planted at intervals next to the inner walls of the Main Stairs twin staircases are in locations consistent with those shown in historical photographs (it is not clear if these yews are original or have replaced earlier specimens); (4) several large leptospermum (Leptospermum laevigatum) which may be the lone remaining examples of what were originally more extensive plantings in the East and West Boundary Planting areas; (5) the mature stands of evergreen trees HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 81) in the East and West Boundary planting areas; (6) the palms used as accent trees to frame entrances and features; and (7) other large trees, as described within the subsections for key vegetation areas, appear to be large enough to be associated with the original development of the hospital campus. The following description of the vegetation features associated with the original development of the Highland Hospital campus is based on a comparison of Gilkey s planting plan and historical photographs, with information obtained during site visits in and from an arborist report prepared in for this report.
In addition to a description of the extant primary and secondary vegetation features, summaries of the missing vegetation features that were part of the original development of the Highland Hospital campus and of the non-historic vegetation areas are provided to document the extent of changes. b. Primary Vegetation Features i. Main Terrace The two beds on either side of the central entrance to the Administration Building originally contained mature specimens of Senegal date palms (Phoenix reclinata).
These palms were transplanted in from the Oakland Hall of Records to Highland Hospital at the direction of Gilkey and were estimated, at the time, to have been more than 75 years old.133 These are the Senegal date palms described in the Determination of National Register Eligibility report as some of the best specimens in Northern California. 134 The Senegal date palms are no longer extant, and none of the vegetation that is currently in these two beds (ivy [Hedera helix] and hibiscus [Hibiscus and barberry [Berberis is part of the original design for the Main Terrace. The planting bed along the outer edge of the East Side Terrace was not part of the original design for this area.
This planting area was created as a result of the removal of the Main Terrace retaining wall that occurred in the or Hence, none of the vegetation in this area (including the ivy, a hedge in the general area of the non-extant retaining wall, and a loquat tree [Eriobotrya is part of the original design for the Main Terrace. 133 Highland to Get Ancient Palms from Records Hall, Oakland Tribune, (21 October 15. 134 Oakland City Planning Department, Highland Hospital, Determination of National Register Eligibility (March in appendices for Siegel & Strain Architects et al. 49. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 82) ii. Main Stairs The location of a planting area bracketed by the twin staircases of the Main Stairs is part of the original hospital design.
In photographs from the late-1920s or early-1930s, this area had low, clipped boxwood edging enclosing a bed on each of the two sloping sections; the interior of these two beds had a mass planting of some type of low perennial vegetation. The level terrace corresponding to the level grade for the East and West Landing #1 appears to have been lawn. This planting scheme was used instead of Gilkey s original parterre design. None of these vegetation features are extant. Today, the upper slope and level terrace are bare, and the lower slope has a mass planting of agapanthus (Agapanthus iii.
South, East, and West Slopes The landscape in front of the Main Terrace and Main Stairs is divided into three triangular- shaped areas that are created by the sides of the Main Terrace retaining wall, the side walls of the Main Stairs, and the two entrance roads. The South Slope is the area in front (southwest) of the Main Stairs between the Ambulance and Automobile roads. The East Slope is the area east of the Main Stairs between the Main Terrace retaining wall and the Ambulance Road. The West Slope is the area west of the Main Stairs between the Main Terrace retaining wall and the Automobile Road.
Gilkey s original elaborate planting scheme for these areas was never fully implemented, but by the early the locations of the planting beds, the lawn areas, and trees generally adhered to those shown in his design. Beds were located at the upper corners of the South Slope, along both sides of the outside walls of the Main Stairs, and along the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall. Various species of low mounding or spreading shrubs were planted in these beds.135 Tall columnar shrubs that appear to be incense cedars (Calocedrus decurrens) were planted at regular intervals along the base of the Main Terrace wall and at the corners of landings along the outside walls of the Main Stairs.
Smaller columnar shrubs that appear to be yews (Taxus were planted at the corresponding locations of the landings along the inside wall of each of the twin staircases that make up the Main Stairs. The remaining portions of the East and West Slopes were maintained as lawn; trees were scattered throughout the lawn. The current appearance of the South, East, and West slopes in relation to this original appearance is described below. 135 The only information available on the original species of these shrubs and the other vegetation is from their general appearance or character in historical photographs. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 83) South Slope Today, the South Slope continues to be maintained as a lawn, consistent with Gilkey s design and with the original appearance of this area as shown in historical photographs. There are two planting beds located in the northeast and northwest corners next to the Main Stairs. The general location of beds at these two corners is consistent with Gilkey s design and with the original appearance of this area as shown in historical photographs; however, none of the current vegetation is original.
During the field survey for this report, the plantings in these two beds were dominated by Cape honeysuckle (Tecoma and geraniums (Pelargonium East Slope Some of the original incense cedars remain in place along the outer wall of the Main Stairs and along the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall; however most of the incense cedars along the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall were lost when the wall was removed. The yews planted at intervals next to the inner wall of the Main Stairs east staircase are in locations consistent with those shown in historical photographs; it is not clear if these yews are original or have replaced earlier specimens.
The distinction between the bed (along the outer wall of the Main Stairs and at the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall) and the lawn is no longer extant. Today, there is no distinguishable design, and the majority of the plantings are groundcovers and perennials (including Cape honeysuckle, ivy, and agapanthus). There is no lawn. Trees include several deodar cedars (Cedrus deodara), a Canary Island date palm (Phoenix canariensis), and a flax-leaf paperbark (Melaleuca linariifolia); these trees appear to be old enough to date from the original landscape development. None of the other vegetation is old enough to date from the initial development of the landscape.
West Slope Some of the original incense cedars remain in place along the outer wall of the Main Stairs and along the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall; however some are missing and as a result the the repetitive character of the original planting has been diminished. The yews planted at intervals next to the inner wall of the Main Stairs west staircase remain in locations that are consistent with those shown in historical photographs; it is not clear if these yews are original or have replaced earlier specimens. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 84) The distinction between the bed (along the outer wall of the Main Stairs and at the base of the Main Terrace retaining wall) and the lawn is no longer extant.
Today, there is no distinguishable design, and the majority of the West Slope is covered with ivy interspersed with some grass in irregular patches. There are the remains of shrubs (including ceanothus [Ceanothus pittosporum [Pittosporum tobira], oleander [Nerium oleander], and Cape plumbago [Plumbago auriculata]) along the outer wall of the Main Stairs that do not appear to be old enough to be original. Trees in the former lawn area include a blackwood acacia [Acacia melanoxylon], a blue atlas cedar [Cedrus atlantica Glauca ], and a deodar cedar; the two cedar trees appear to be old enough to date from the original landscape development. iv. Boundary Planting Areas There are two major planting areas in the sloped frontages along the Avenue and Vallecito Place sides of the property.
The East Boundary Planting Area is the frontage along Avenue. The West Boundary Planting Area is the frontage along Vallecito Place. In Gilkey s plan, these two areas were treated more informally than the areas next to the buildings, and the stands of evergreen trees that were established in these two areasgenerally reflected his design. Based on their appearance in historical photographs, the East Boundary Planting Area was planted with a mixed stand of trees, and the stand in the West Boundary Planting Area was predominantly one type of tree. Gilkey had specified mass plantings of varieties of low-growing shrubs, perennials, and groundcovers to stabilize the steep slopes in these two areas, and a simplified version of this scheme was implemented.
The current appearance of the East and West Boundary Planting areas in relation to this historical appearance is described below. East Boundary Planting Area Today, the combination of evergreens including deodar cedar, blue atlas cedar, flax-leaf paperbark, and coast redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) that stretch along the East Boundary Planting Area are the remnants of the original stand of trees in this area; however there are fewer trees today within the overall stand than when this area was initially planted due to the fact that some of the original trees have died or have been removed. The ivy and scattered clumps of herbaceous plants along the slopes are relatively recent plantings, although they provide a similar function to those specified by Gilkey (i.e., to prevent erosion).
West Boundary Planting Area Today, the deodar cedar trees located toward the north end of the West Boundary Planting Area and the four trees (coast redwood, deodar cedar, Italian stone pine [Pinus pinea], and blue atlas HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 85) cedar) located adjacent to the west end of Ward 1 all correspond to the location of trees on Gilkey s plan. Additionally, the one large flax-leaf paperbark tree located on the north side of the West Entrance and a large leptospermum located north of the flax-leaf paperbark appear to be old enough to have been part of the initial plantings.
The various shrubs (oleanders, junipers [Juniperus and pittosporum) and the ivy are relatively recent and are not old enough to have part of the initial landscape development for the hospital campus. v. East and West Gardens The locations of the planting beds was established by Meyers plans for hardscape features in the East and West Gardens. Gilkey s design provided a planting plan for these beds. Based on information from historical photographs, a much simpler planting scheme than that shown on Gilkey s plans was installed.
The main vegetation features in each garden included (1) a grass lawn in the large rectangular area in the center of the garden, (2) a row of tall columnar shrubs (probably incense cedars) spaced equidistantly along the Administration Building wall, (3) windmill palms (Trachycarpus fortunei) on both sides of the entrance steps to the garden from the Main Terrace and on both sides of the fountain, and (4) narrow beds around the sides of the garden with low vegetation. The current appearance of the East and West gardens in relation to this historical appearance is described below.
East Garden The original configuration of the planting beds created by the sidewalk and the walls in the East Garden remains in place except along the southeast side where the removal of the Main Terrace retaining wall resulted in the relocation of a portion of the original brick sidewalk. Beginning on the northwest side of the garden next to the Administration Building and proceeding clockwise, the planting beds contain the following plant materials. In the upper bed on the northwest side, a incense cedar and a lone Australian brush cherry (Syzygium paniculatum) are all that remains of what was once a continuous row of shrubs next to Administration Building wall; there are also some clumps of African daisies (Osteospermum in the narrow lower bed next to the perimeter sidewalk.
In the bed in northeast end, the original windmill palm remains on the north side of the fountain; the palm on the south side is missing; junipers flanking both sides of the fountain; and a large specimen of New Zealand flax (Phormium tenax) is in the southeast corner. In the bed on the southeast side, a yew flanks both sides of the staircase; a mass of roses (Rosa is located at the east end; and a hedge of Australian brush cherry is planted on the west end where the retaining wall was originally located. In the bed on the southwest end, the original windmill palm on the north side of the stairs remains but the one on the south side is missing; a low hedge is located north of the stairs.
In summary, the only remaining original plants are the grass lawn in the area bounded by the perimeter brick sidewalk and two of the four windmill palms; all other vegetation was added at a later date. The overall condition of the vegetation HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 86) features in the East Garden is poor due to the condition of the remaining plants, missing plants, and the loss of the original symmetry in the design. West Garden The original configuration of the planting beds created by the sidewalk and the walls in the West Garden remain in place. Beginning on the east side of the garden next to the Administration Building and proceeding clockwise, the planting beds contain the following plant materials.
On the east side, an incomplete rows of shrubs (ligustrum [Ligustrum and abelia [Abelia grandiflora]) with groundcovers (predominantly agapanthus and ivy) are planted in the upper bed next to the Administration Building wall; a yew is located at the north end of the narrow lower bed and African daisies fill the rest of the bed. At the south end, the original windmill palms remain in place on both sides of the stairs that connect to the West Side Terrace. On the west side, a yew is located at the north end of the narrow bed between the perimeter sidewalk and the wall that forms the west side of the garden; and African daisies fill the rest of the bed.
At the north end, there is no vegetation in the bed in front of the fountain; both windmill palms that originally flanked the fountain are missing. In summary, the only remaining original vegetation is the rectangular grass lawn bounded by the perimeter brick sidewalk and the two windmill palms beside the stairs on the south end; all other vegetation was added at a later date. The overall condition of the vegetation features in the West Garden is fair to poor due to missing plants and to the loss of the symmetry in the design. c. Secondary Vegetation Areas i.
Main Entrance Gate The planting island located in front of the Main Entrance Gate was part of the original development of the hospital campus and appears in historical photographs that were taken soon after the opening of the hospital; however, this island was not shown on Gilkey s planting design plan. Plant materials in photographs from the and consist of bedding plants with shrubs planted on the outer sides of the entrance gate structure. Today, the planting island remains in place and retains its original shape, although the southern end has been paved with concrete. The original vegetation in the island has been replaced with individual mounds of low, pruned shrubs; similar shrubs are also located at the outer corners of the Main Entrance Gate. ii.
Public Right-of-Way Originally, there were narrow planting beds between the base of the boundary walls, along Avenue and Vallecito Place, and the sidewalks in the public right-of-way. Gilkey did not include these beds in his planting design. Based on historical photographs, there was a row of shrubs in HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 87) the bed along Avenue in the late and early In contrast, in similar historical photographs, the bed along Vallecito Place was bare except for shrubs clustered on the sides of the West Entrance. This difference in treatment likely related to the fact that when the hospital opened in the bed along Avenue had a higher profile since a streetcar in the Key System ran along Avenue and the Gate House was the primary pedestrian entrance to the grounds.
Today, the original planting bed next to the base of the boundary wall along Avenue is paved over with concrete. The one along Vallecito Place remains in place but is currently unplanted; the trees and the vegetation in the planting strip along the outer side of the public right-of-way sidewalk, next to Vallecito Place, is a recent planting. iii. Automobile Parking Lot The narrow beds around the outer edges of the Automobile Parking Lot are part of the original development of the hospital campus, and Gilkey included a planting design for this area in his plan. However, based on a review of historical photographs, this planting plan was never implemented.
Initially, these beds may been left unplanted or maintained as lawn since no vegetation is visible in aerial photograph from the late However, by the small trees or large shrubs alternating with low mounded shrubs had been added to these beds. Tall columnar specimens were used at the corners of the buildings and to frame the central bay of windows in Ward 1's south-facing exterior wall. Today, all of the early vegetation except for a few individual specimens (such as the coast redwood located in the southeastern corner) is gone. The current vegetation consists of a variety of individual shrubs (predominantly junipers interspersed with camellias [Camellia nandinas [Nandina domestica], abelias, and Australian brush cherries); the ground plane is sometimes bare and sometimes covered with ivy.
iv. Ambulance Entrance Area Narrow beds around the outer edges of the Ambulance Drive turnaround and a center island between the upper and lower portions of the turnaround are shown on Meyers Approaches drawings. Gilkey included a planting design for this area in his plan, but based on a review of historical photographs, this planting plan was never implemented. Historical photographs from the late show the large shrubs spaced throughout the foundation beds. The center island, which was expanded in when the extension to the Administration Building was added, was maintained as a lawn. By the the vegetation along the foundations consisted of individual shrubs, possibly incense cedar or yews, separated by low hedges. A photograph from the HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 88) also shows clusters of tall palms at the north end of this area next to the corridor connecting Ward 2 to the Service Building. Today, remnants of the plantings shown in historical photographs are limited a windmill palm and a tall incense cedar located at the north end of this area, two tall incense cedars located at the north end of the southern half of the center island, and possibly two California bay laurels (Umbrelluraria californica) now grown to tree-size located next to the wall that forms the northeast end of the East Garden. The orderly character of the initial arrangement of the vegetation from the late-1920s is missing today.
Currently, plants consist of a variety of shrubs (including juniper, cotoneaster [Cotoneaster Australian brush cherry, camellia, and nandina) of different sizes (and ages) and perennials in the foundation bed next to the buildings; a variety of perennials and azaleas are growing in the center island. v. Power House Although a secondary vegetation area, the entrance to the Power House has a highly visible location near the corner of Avenue at East Street, and Gilkey included this area in his planting design. None of the historical photographs used in the preparation of this report provided a clear view of this area, but it is doubtful that Gilkey s plan was ever fully implemented.
Today, the only plants that could be remnants from the initial development of the hospital campus include the pindo palms (Butia capitata) that frame the entrance door to the Power House, a corral tree (Erythrina variegata) and a large leptospermum (that has been pruned into a topiary) near the southeast corner the Power House, and the three windmill palms located at the northeast corner of the Power House near the Service Entrance Gate. The sidewalk that leads from Avenue to the Power House entrance divides the landscape in front of the Power House into two parts. The area north of the sidewalk has no plants and is covered with bark mulch.
The ground south of the sidewalk is also covered with mulch but has about ten, tightly pruned shrubs informally arranged in the area next to the Power House. There is also a short, windmill palm located on the south side of the sidewalk at its intersection with Avenue. vi. Garage Road and Parking Lot Gilkey s plan included a planting design for the area on both sides of the Garage Road which was never fully implemented. Until the mid-to-late the area along the north side of the Garage Road was left unplanted or maintained in lawn. By the a mass of large evergreen trees similar in character to the stand along the Street boundary (in the East Boundary Planting Area) had been planted here.
Today, most of the area between the road and the Garage has been paved and the stand of trees is no longer extant. The small remaining portion of this landscape, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 89) between the Power House and the north side of the Garage Road, is covered with bark mulch; a lone deodar cedar at the far east end is the only remaining tree from the original planting. Gilkey s plan also included the narrow beds around the parking lot (between Ward 8 and the Pathological Building) at the west end of the road. None of the historical photographs used in the preparation of this report provided a clear view of this area, but it seems safe to assume the original plantings in this area were much simpler than what he initially intended.
Today, there are tightly-pruned Australian brush cherries and yews spaced throughout the beds; the area between these shrubs is bare or planted with agapanthus. There is a small orange tree (Citrus at the entrance to Ward 8 in the northwest corner of this area. The narrow space next to the Pathological Building is filled with agapanthus. None of these vegetation dates from the original landscape development, and the shrubs are in poor condition. vii. Service Road This road was one of the least visible places in the original hospital campus, and given its service function, the original planting along this road was probably limited.
Gilkey s plan did not show any vegetation in the area along the south side of the Service Road, and none of the historical photographs used in the preparation of this report provided a clear view of this area. Today, there is only a narrow planting bed near the west end on the south side of the road which contains several large shrubs (abelia and pittosporum) that are overgrown for this location; none of these shrubs appear to be old enough to date from the original landscape development. d. Missing Features i. Primary Vegetation Areas Main Terrace The National Register of Historic Places, Highland Hospital, Determination of Eligibility Notification (DOE), prepared in referred to Senegal date palms (Phoenix reclinata) at the hospital as some of the best specimens in Northern California.
These trees are no longer extant and were removed sometime after the DOE was prepared in These specific trees were already large specimens when they were transplanted from the Oakland Hall of Records, around as fully grown trees, and palms with long curving trunks (a characteristic of this species) are visible in historical photographs on both sides of the central entrance to the Administration Building. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 90) ii. Secondary Vegetation Areas Ward Courtyards The central lawns and foundation plantings that were located in the three Ward Courtyards were removed in the when these areas were converted to parking.
Nurses Homes and Employees Buildings The two parterre gardens at the rear of the Nurses Home, the landscaping around this building and the two employees buildings, and the stands of trees in the area north of the Service Road were removed in the and when these buildings were demolished to make way for the construction of the Acute Tower and its associated parking lots. Northwest Corner of the Campus The original stand of trees planted in the open, northwest quadrant of the site was removed in the mid-1950s as part of the construction for the Clinic and Auditorium. e.
Non-Historic Vegetation Areas As is the case with other landscape features and characteristics, all existing vegetation in the portion of the property north of Ward 1, the Service Building, and the Service Road are associated with the newer facilities (Clinic and Auditorium, Acute Tower, the Koret Foundation Critical Care and Clinic Center) and are not associated with the original development of the hospital campus that was implement during the late and The one exception to this is a single, large, flax-leaf paperbark tree located along the north edge of the property just east of the entrance to the parking garage on East Street; this tree is all that remains from the original mass planting of trees in the area north of the Service Road. 8. Small-Scale Elements a. Light Fixtures i.
Central Entrance to the Administration Building The Main Terrace is connected to the central front entrance of the Administration Building by a set of stairs that span the width of this entrance. A light fixture is located on either end of this set of steps to frame the central entrance to the building. The bases and posts of these large fixtures are terra cotta and are designed to have the same decorative detailing and color scheme (cream, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 91) tan, and light blue) as that used in the architectural terra cotta around the central entrance to the Administration Building. ii.
Along the Outer Walls for the Main Terrace, Main Stairs, East Garden, and West Garden Some (but not all) of the original, cast metal light fixtures remain in place along the top of the balustrade for the Main Terrace s outer retaining wall, the outer walls of the Main Stairs, the East Garden s southwest wall, and the West Garden s west wall; only the posts and bases of the remaining fixtures are extant; the luminaires for these lights are missing. The decorative detailing in the metal for these lights is designed to be compatible with that used in the architectural terra cotta around the entrances to the Administration Building. iii.
Along the Ambulance and Automobile Roads The light fixtures along the outer side of the Ambulance and Automobile roads have decorative pressed metal bases (silver colored), round poles, and box-style luminaires. The location of these lights corresponds to that shown on the lighting plan for the original campus design, and while the bases may be original, the poles and luminaires are not. iv. Entrance Structures Originally, there were hexagonal luminaires attached to the top of the square columns that flank the Main Entrance Gate, the Service Entrance Gate, and the West Entrance; only the two at the Service Entrance Gate remain extant. There was also a hexagonal luminaire mounted on the right-hand side of the entrance at the Gate House; this fixture is missing.
Meyers Approaches drawings showed a decorative, four-sided luminaire incorporated into the wrought iron arch above the Staff Entrance. This arch and light are not present today, and the lack of any evidence (such as patching) in the extant concrete wall supports the conclusion that the arch and light were never installed. (No as-built drawings were located for this feature, and no historical photographs show this area.) b. Signage Originally, there was signs incorporated into the Main Entrance Gate, the Service Entrance Gate, and the Gate House; see pages 36 and 37 in the history for a description of these signs; currently HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 92) all of the signs, except the one incorporated into the balustrade above the Gate House, are missing.
Additionally, Meyers Approaches drawings showed a sign incorporated into an arch over the Staff Entrance structure. This arch is not present today, and the lack of any evidence (such as patching) in the extant concrete wall supports the conclusion that the arch and sign were never installed. (No as-built drawings were located for this feature, and no historical photographs show this area.) c. East Garden Fountain The original fountain mounted on the northeast end wall of the East Garden remains in place, and the original design is mostly intact. A glazed terra cotta tile panel (approximately wide x 6'- 6" tall) is attached to the concrete wall on the east side of the garden. The tile on the panel consists of a border of patterned, 6"-square, tiles (with blue, green, and yellow glaze).
The interior portion of the panel is faced with 6"-square, glazed tiles (blue). A basin (approximately x 3' and 9" deep) at the base of this panel is lined with the same blue tile and its outside edge is faced with the same patterned tile border. A head of a (glazed the same blue color as the interior portion of the panel) is located in the upper portion of the wall-mounted panel. Originally, water came out of the mouth of the and fell for about onto a shallow shelf. As the water filled this shelf, it fell into the fountain s basin.
From the basin, the water was re-circulated up to the s head, via pipes embedded in the concrete wall.136 The current condition of the interior piping is not known; during the field survey for this report, the fountain was not functioning, and there was no water in the base. d. West Garden Fountain The fountain that was originally mounted on the north wall of the West Garden was identical to the one described for the East Garden. Today, only the back panel attached to the north wall remains intact. The entire basin, its associated piping, and the shallow catch basin or shelf, below the head, are all missing. Additionally, there are chips on the extant fountain head and in the tiles on the flat back panel. 136 Drawing No.
of Meyers Approaches Plan provides the Gladding McBean tile specifications for the fountain. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 93) e. Flagpole A flagpole, with a fluted metal pole and a decorative concrete base, is located in the center of the bottom landing of the Main Stairs, along the primary design axis. The design of the cast concrete base replicates the detailing of the architectural terra cotta at the entrance to the Administration Building. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 94) PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Drawings and Plans Alameda County, Government Services Administration (GSA), Technical Services Department, Highland Hospital plan collection. Corlett, Will and Arthur W. Anderson, Architects & Engineers.
Plot and Site Plans, Clinic Building, Highland Hospital, Alameda County, Vallecito Place and East Street, Oakland, California. Sheet A. December Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Gilkey, Howard. Planting Plan of Highland Hospital. Section 1. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department. Note: The key to the planting plan was not located in the GSA collections. Also each sheet of these drawings provided the proposed planting plant, and Gilkey s original ideas were adapted when the actual plantings were installed. No as-built drawings were located. Section 1 provides the proposed planting plan for Main Terrace and Main Entrance. . Planting Plan of Highland Hospital.
Section 1A, Detail of Parterre. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department. This sheet provides the proposed planting plan for the area between the Main Terrace staircases. . Planting Plan of Highland Hospital. Section 2. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department. This sheet provides the proposed planting plan for the East Garden, Ambulance Entrance, boundary along Street, and the courtyard between Wards 2 and 4. . Planting Plan of Highland Hospital. Section 3. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department. This sheet provides the proposed planting plan for the West Garden, Automobile Parking Lot, and boundary area along Vallecito Place. .
Planting Plan of Highland Hospital. Section 4. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department. This sheet provides the proposed planting plan for the courtyards between Wards 4 and 6 and Wards 6 and 8 and the boundary area along Avenue. . Planting Plan of Highland Hospital. Section 5. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department. This sheet provides the planting plan HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 95) for the landscape around the Pathological Building, Garage, and Power House and the boundary area along Avenue. . Planting Plan of Highland Hospital. [Section 6]. (no date). Located in Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department.
This sheet provides the proposed planting plan for the landscape around the Nurses Home and the Male and Female Employees buildings. Meyers, Henry H. Grading Plan, Building for Alameda County Hospital Situated on Ave- Vallecito Pl, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 8 February revised 4 April Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. . Plot Plan, Hospital Situated of Alameda County, Ave-Vallecito Pl, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 1. 29 October Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. . Plot Plan, Hospital Situated of Alameda County, Ave-Vallecito Pl, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 1A.
14 August Checked 20 Nov 22 Aug Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. . Administration Building, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 52. 18 November Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. . Grading Plan, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 4 March Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. .
Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides details for the Staff (doctor s) Entrance on Vallecito Place and shows an earlier and more elaborate paving pattern for hardscape features for the Main Terrace Staircases and East and West Gardens than was built. The simplification of details for the landscape features (i.e., simplified paving pattern, elimination of light fixtures, use of concrete rather than terra cotta tile, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page 96) simplified concrete detailing, etc.) is evident in the comparison between plans prepared in October and December and the as-built conditions. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides the proposed overall layout of circulation, hardscape, and irrigation for the areas around (1) the Power House, Garage, Pathological Building and Service Building and (2) the Nurses Home and Male and Female Employees buildings.
Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October revised 27 February Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides details for (1) the concrete balustrade, (2) the fountain at the Nurses Home, (3) the rear walls for East and West Gardens, (4) the Main Terrace stairs, and (5) the outside wall of Main Terrace. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No.
19 October Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides information on the wall along the Service Road, a pedestrian bridge, and pergola. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. [no date]. Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides (1) east and west elevations of the outside wall of the Main Terrace, (2) elevations of the rear wall in the East and West Gardens, (3) footing details of the balustrades and the walls enclosing the East and West Gardens and Main Terrace.
Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides (1) an early version of the details for the Main Entrance Gate (more elaborate than as- built), (2) plan and elevation for the Garage Road Gate (more elaborate than as-built), (3) plan and elevation for the Service Entrance, (4) plan, elevation, and section for the West (pedestrian) HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 97) Entrance. See Drawing No. for revisions.
Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October revised 27 February Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides the plans for the Gate House. Note: See Drawing No. for revisions. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October revised 27 February Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No.
provides (1) Detail of Ironwork and Fixture at Doctor s Entrance (the far north entrance on Vallecito Place), (2) Detail of Metal Stair Rail at East Garden, (3) details for the wall fountains in the East and West gardens, (4) details for the flag pole base, (5) details for the Main Entrance (which are different than as-built conditions), (6) detail for the Service Entrance gate, (7) lighting fixture details for the retaining wall along the service road, along ambulance and automobile roads, on the Administration Building terrace, and in East and West gardens, and (8) section and plan of the fountain at the Nurses House. Note: See Drawing No. G- 113 for revisions to the entrances. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. .
Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 19 October Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Plan provides the overall layout of circulation and hardscape and irrigation for the areas around the Administration Building and in the courtyard between Wards 2 and 4. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 14 December Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No.
provides a revised plan paving pattern for the hardscape features (Main Terrace twin staircases and East and West Gardens) at the Administration Building that closely resembles as-built conditions. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. December Located in the Alameda County, HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 98) General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. provides (1) a partial plan, partial elevation, and detail for Main Entrance (a revision to Drawing Nos. and (2) West Entrance detail (a revision to Drawing No. (3) the Garage Road sign (a revision to Drawing No.
(4) the Service Entrance sign (a revision to Drawing No. (5) a revised floor plan for Gate House and detail (a revision to Drawing No. revisions for the Main, West, and Service entrances that resemble as-built conditions (these are revisions to Drawing Nos. and Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. [Drawing No. Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. This drawing which is missing the title block provides the location of the exterior light fixtures.
The layout of the Service Road on this sheet resembles the as-built conditions with the road ending at the Service Building rather than extending to Vallecito Place as shown on earlier drawings. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. . Approaches, Highland Hospital of Alameda County, Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing provides footing details for the Gate House and specifications for column, wall, slab, beam reinforcing. Plans or details for the as-built conditions were not located in the GSA plan file collection. .
Building for Alterations & Additions Highland Hospital situated on 14 Avenue and Vallecito Place, Oakland, California. Drawing No. 1. 10 September Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. Drawing No. 1 provides the plot plan for the new wing that connected to the porte cochere/ambulance entrance. Ratcliff, Slama, Calwalader. Highland-Alameda County Hospital, Survey: Sheet Sheet N.E. Sheet Sheet and S.E. Sheet 14 June Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. . Highland-Alameda County Hospital, Site Plan - Location Map, Sheet 14 June Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. .
Highland-Alameda County Hospital, Parking Structure Plans, Sheet 14 June Located in the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department collections. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page 99) B. Historic Views and Photographs Fairchild Aerial Surveys. [Aerial Photograph], ca. Located in the Oakland History Room, Oakland Public Library, Oakland. Buildings. Hospitals historical photograph folder. Google Earth. [Aerial photograph]. 25 August Moulin, Gabriel. Photographs in the Henry H. Meyers Collection, University of California, Environmental Design Archive. and Oakland Public Library. Oakland History Room. Oakland. Buildings. Hospitals historical photograph folder. Pacific Aerial Surveys. [Aerial photograph]. and Samuel, Ford E. Photographs in the Henry H.
Meyers Collection, University of California, Environmental Design Archive. No dates. United State Geological Survey. [Aerial photograph]. 10 July 15 March 18 March 31 October 31 December 29 February 13 April and 22 April Accessed on Google Earth. C. Bibliography 1. Primary and Unpublished Sources Ancestry.com. Obit: Joseph L. Minutoli. (Information on the Travertite Marble and Stone Works, San Francisco, largest ornamental cast stone and plaster operation on the West Coast ). (accessed 28 December Brodrick, R. G., Dr. Alameda County Notes Great Progress During Year in its System of Hospitals and Institutions, Oakland Tribune Yearbook, Oakland: Oakland Tribune Company. Burroughs, Jack. Your Town: Block House To Expo Building. Oakland Tribune, 26 December HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No.
CA-111 (Page California and Western Medicine. Physician Superintendent of Stanford Hospital in News, California and Western Medicine, Vol. XXVI, No. 5 (May (accessed 22 January2010) Donaldson, Milford Wayne (California Office of Historic Preservation). Letter to Bruce Jenner (Senior Planner, Alameda County Planning Department). RE: Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Draft Environmental Impact Report DEIR # 8 April Leffingwell, John. Inventory Report and Tree Survey, Highland Hospital, Oakland California, December Prepared by HortScience Inc for County of Alameda, Government Services Administration, Technical Services Department. Meyers, Henry H . Highland Hospital Plans Told by County Architect. Oakland Tribune, 4 May 2. .
Highland Hospital Now Stands Complete; its Story Told by Architect, Oakland Tribune, 24 October Navlet, Arthur E. Howard Gilkey and the California Spring Garden Shows, Pacific Horticulture, Vol.37, No. 2 (October Oakland Post-Enquirer. H.E. Gilkey, Garden Show Architect, Sued by Wife, Oakland Post- Enquirer, 8 May (accessed 1 December Oakland Tribune. Hospital Plans to be Told at Lunch. Oakland Tribune, 18 March . Building Cost of Hospital Increasing. Oakland Tribune, 17 July 2. . New Highland Park Hospital Named Adopted. 6 October 3. . Contract is Offered to Dr. Brodrick. Oakland Tribune, 9 February 7. . New Highland Hospital Completed. Oakland Tribune, 24 October 2-M and 3- M. Includes advertisements by contractors and suppliers. . New Highland Hospital Dedicated by Leaders.
Oakland Tribune, 13 December 2. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page . Dread Disease Or Something Amuck in City, Whatchamacallums to Be Either Caged or Sent to Hospital. Oakland Tribune, 6 May 18. . Permits Granted. Oakland Tribune, 13 May 46. . Garden Estates in Some Beautiful East Bay Homes. Comprising recent works executed by Howard Gilkey, noted landscape Architect . . . Oakland Tribune Yearbook, Oakland: Oakland Tribune, . Highland gets Ancient Palms from Records Hall. Oakland Tribune, 21 October 15. . Garden Estates in Some Beautiful East Bay Homes. Comprising recent works executed by Howard Gilkey, noted landscape Architect . . . Oakland Tribune Yearbook, Oakland: Oakland Tribune, . Henry H. Meyers, Architect, Dies. Oakland Tribune, 27 May 22. . Gilkey Garden Man of Year.
Oakland Tribune, 16 January . Gilkey Publishes The Great Design. Oakland Tribune, 2 May . Howard E. Gilkey Rites in Private. Oakland Tribune, 12 September 20. Online Archive of California. Collection Guide, Henry H. Meyer Collection, (accessed on 28 December Parry, David. Percy & Hamilton. Encyclopedia of San Francisco. (accessed 28 December Taylor, Frank. The World s Most Colorful Club. The Saturday Evening Post, Vol. 223 No. 18 and University of California, Environmental Design Archives. The Henry H. Meyers Collection. . Henry H. Meyers Biography. (accessed 28 December HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page . Meyers Project Index. (accessed 28 December 2. Secondary and Published Sources Adams, Annmarie.
Medicine by Design: The Architect and the Modern Hospital, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, [City of] Alameda Museum, Meyers House & Garden. History, (accessed 28 December Friends of the Cleveland Cascade. Howard Gilkey, designer of the Cleveland Cascade. (accessed 1 December . Cleveland Cascade Bibliography. (accessed 1 December Gebhard, David, Eric Sandweiss, and Robert Winter. The Guide to Architecture in San Francisco and Northern California, Revised Edition. Salt Lake City: Gibbs M. Smith, Gilkey, Howard. Importance of Garden Design, American Landscape Architect, Vol I (November . Kern River Park in the San Joaquin Valley. Landscape Architecture, Vo. 21 (October . Modern Treatment in Park Design as Applied in Kern River Park, Near Bakersfield.
American Landscape Architect, Vol. 2 (February . The role of the Landscape Architect. American Landscape Architect, Vol IV, No. 3 (March 41. . The Great Design. Berkeley, CA: no publisher, Gilkey, Howard and Frances Hessel Gilkey. School Grounds, their design and development, written by Howard Gilkey, assessed by Frances Hessel Gilkey, submitted by commissioner of secondary schools. Sacramento: California State Printing Office, Hulbert, Mark. Highland Hospital Historic Site Evaluation. Prepared by Mark Hulbert, Preservation Architecture, Oakland, CA, 20 May HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page . Highland Hospital Historic Resources Site Plan. Prepared by Mark Hulbert, Preservation Architecture, Oakland, CA, [20 May Komorous-Towey Architects.
Highland Hospital ATR EIR Mitigation and Improvements Historical Resources Preservation Study. Prepared for the County of Alameda, General Services Agency, 30 June May, Vonn Marie, Robert Sabbatini, and Karen Fiene. Celebrating the Cultural Landscape Heritage of Mills College. Oakland: Center for the Book, Mills College, National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places. Highland Hospital. E.O. Determination of Eligibility Notification, National Register of Historic Places, National Park Service. 2 May Appendix in Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson, Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation, 15 May Oakland City Planning Department.
Highland Hospital, Determination of National Register Eligibility, March Appendix in Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson, Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation, 15 May Siegel & Strain Architects. Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey: Ward 6 Ward 8 Pathological Building (F) Clinic Building (V) and Auditorium (VA). Prepared for the County of Alameda, General Services Agency, 10 July Seigel & Strain Architects, Woodruff Minor, and Jill Johnson. Highland Hospital, Historic Resource Evaluation. Prepared for the County of Alameda, General Services Agency, 15 May Stevens, Edward Fletcher.
The American Hospital of the Twentieth Century, A treatise on the development of medical institutions, both in Europe and in America, since the beginning of the present century, Revised Edition. New York: Architectural Record Company, . The Trend in Hospital Construction on the North American Continent, Canadian Hospital 9, No. 1 (Jan. 24 Quoted in Annmarie Adams, Medicine by Design: The Architect and the Modern Hospital, (Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Designed Landscape Styles: Beaux Arts/Neoclassical. (accessed 22 January HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Designed Landscape Styles: Spanish Colonial Revival (Hispano-Moorish). (accessed 22 January Weinberg, Nathan Gerald.
Historic Preservation and Tradition in California: The Restoration of the Missions and the Spanish Colonial Revival. University of California, Davis: PhD Dissertation, D. Sources Not Yet Investigated Highland Hospital Records MSS Archives and Special Collections, University of California, San Francisco Library, San Francisco, California. This collection is only partially processed but is listed as including records of the Highland Hospital School of Nursing, student materials, Cadet Nurse Corps records, and photographs; Highland Hospital medical staff records and selected patient records; and correspondence. Plans in the Highland Hospital Project Records, Henry H. Meyers Collection, University of California, Environmental Design Archive. These plans are stored off-campus.
See the Online Archive of California for the finding aid to this collection; (accessed 22 January A complete review of the records in Henry H. Meyers Collection and the Alameda County, General Services Agency, Technical Services Department for possible information on contractors for the landscape and for additional plans related to the landscape. E. Supplemental Material Location Map HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page
Part Iv. Project Information
This Historic American Landscapes Survey (HALS) documentation of Highland Hospital s historic landscape was undertaken as a partial fulfillment of mitigation measures related to the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project. This project will result in the removal of several of the historical buildings and portions of the historical landscape. The HALS documentation was initiated by Ann Ludwig, the County of Alameda General Services Agency's Project Manager for the Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project. Project oversight was provided by Klara Komorous-Towey of Komorous-Towey Architects. Wyman Yee, Komorous-Towey Architects, prepared the measured drawings, and Robert Komorous-King prepared the rendering of the hospital on the cover sheet.
Landscape historian Denise Bradley was the principal author for the report and provided assistance in project oversight. Architectural historian Michael Corbett provided the narrative descriptions for the vehicular and pedestrian entrance structures in the report. Consulting arborist John Leffingwell, HortScience Inc., prepared the Highland Hospital Inventory Report for the trees located within the historic core of the hospital campus; this information was utilized in preparing the measured drawings and in the descriptions in the report. Brian Grogan, Photography + Preservation Associates, prepared the large-format photographs.
A separate report the Highland Hospital Historic Landscape Documentation Report prepared by Denise Bradley and Komorous-Towey Architects includes 140 digital photographs that document the existing conditions of the landscape, historical photographs, and historical plans. This report is available through the County of Alameda General Services Agency. The Highland Hospital Acute Tower Replacement Project Historic Documentation Survey prepared by Seigel & Strain Architects, Berkeley, California, provides a separate narrative report, a set of measured drawings, and digital photographs of the interior and exterior of the hospital s historical buildings.
This report is available through the California Office of Historic Preservation, the California Northwest Information Center, and a number of local repositories. HIGHLAND HOSPITAL HALS No. CA-111 (Page N (Not to Scale) Location Map
The federal surveyors worked through Oakland building by building. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-111. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.