The Brush Street Encampment exemplifies the way many vacant lots in Oakland, California, have been repeatedly settled, cleared, and resettled by the area s unconventionally housed and unhoused populations in the twenty-first century. In Brush Street encampment residents settled in tents and automobiles along 6th Street and under the nearby overpass, forming one of the largest encampments in the city (Figures 1 and 2). 1 The City of Oakland cleared the original encampment in and placed a temporary navigation center, or a managed housing community, with on-site health, psychological, and housing resources, on the lot in In a few years after the navigation center vacated and after the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, the interior of the lot was again settled by the unhoused community.
The site demonstrates how patterns of cyclical inhabitation and removal of the unhoused relate to shifting government initiatives, attitudes toward the unhoused, and Oakland s complicated urban history. The Brush Street encampment provides an example of how such sites emerge on land that has been historically marginalized and devalued by processes like redlining, urban renewal, ecological contamination, and the construction of transportation infrastructure. Located at the point where two major highway overpasses diverge, it is subject to intense atmospheric and auditory pollution.
In the encampment was located on unused commercial land in the middle of a lot that, like many in the Castro-Brush Street corridor, was devalued, claimed through eminent domain, and destroyed to make way for the Interstate 2 Completed in I-980 cut through the center of Oakland, separating the previously redlined West Oakland from Downtown (see Figure 1). There is growing recognition that the I-980 created and reinforced a stark, racialized 1 Homelessness and the Affordability Crisis, City of Oakland, Accessed July 26, Dan Walters, Divisive Oakland freeway may be demolished, Cal Matters, June 1, 2 Mitchell Schwarzer, Oakland City Center: The Plan to Reposition Downtown within the Bay Region, Journal of Planning History 14, no. 2 93. BRUSH STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No.
CA-2977 (page 2) border zone in Oakland. The Congress for the New Urbanism named the interstate among their list of US freeways without futures, due to the way it segregated established working-class and ethnic neighborhoods from job opportunities in Oakland s downtown. In as a part of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, the federal government allocated to the City of Oakland and the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) to study strategies for demolition and replacement. 3 Before the Brush Street encampment emerged, the lot lay vacant for the decades after it was cleared as part of the I-980 construction process. In the twenty-first century, Brush Street encampment residents repeatedly settled this underutilized land in the shadow of twentieth-century infrastructure projects.
Description: In July the Brush Street encampment comprised a sprawling expanse of recreational vehicles burnt and stripped cars and trucks, discarded possessions, and illegally dumped debris and trash blanketing the area of a vacant commercially zoned lot at the intersection of 6th Street and Brush Street. At this time, the encampment was populated by automobile dwellings and tents, rather than the shanties and tiny homes that suggest a higher degree of permanence at other Oakland locations. The lot was encircled by chain-link fence that has been cut and peeled back at various intervals to function as gateways connecting the interior of the lot with the encircling sidewalk (Figure 3).
Both the lot and neighboring encampment were in the shadow of nearby overpasses where Interstates 980 and 880 diverge. Scorch marks from previous encampment fires marred the I-980 overpasses (Figure 4). The Kinetic Arts Center gymnastics center, Oaklandish clothing store, and a Shell gas station and car wash inhabited buildings in the lot across Brush Street to the northwest. A shipping company occupied the space across 6th Street to the south and under the I-880, and a parking lot inhabited the lot across Castro Street to the southeast. To the northeast across 7th Street were a series of city blocks (including the Brush Street block), once containing approximately 500 houses that were demolished in the late-1970s to make way for the multilevel I-980 freeway.
4 A fence divided the lot into two portions. In July the larger portion was scattered with approximately six RV dwellings. A dozen or so other vehicles were stripped to their frames and scorched by fire. The RV and bus dwellings were loosely clustered in the lot towards 7th Street and Castro Street, to the north and east. Fewer RV dwellings appeared near the main entrance to the lot on 6th Street, where a sizeable gap in the chain link fence provided entry for RVs and fire engines. City-supplied portable toilet cubicles and wash stations occupied the sidewalk outside this entrance. A large expanse of open space was located near the center of the lot.
While substantial piles of debris and possessions were near 3 Oakland, Caltrans receives funds to study removing Interstate 980 in downtown, CBS News Bay Area, February 24, study-freeway-removal/. 4 I-980, Connect Oakland, BRUSH STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No. CA-2977 (page 3) the lot s peripheries, more modest piles were intermediately in the center, creating walkable spaces between them. These central open spaces were also occupied by a collection of couches, barbeques, trashcans, desks, and workspaces. One workspace had plywood, wood glue, a first aid kit, paint cans, and a dolly (see Figure 4). Many of the vans and RVs were graffitied or covered in murals.
In the small southeast portion of the lot was fenced off where a former navigation center and temporary Tuff Shed or cabin housing project was located from to 5 This fenced portion, re-inhabited by encampment residents following the cabin community s closure, was distinguished from the larger adjacent lot by its tidiness. In its surface was covered with an even layer of gravel and pathways were clear. Mounds of bicycle components surrounded the largest trailer dwelling. The graffiti of the adjacent portion of the lot gave way to mural work on the sides of dwellings and storage sheds. There were a series of potted plants and a bird bath decorating the open spaces between dwellings. Residents here had wheeled municipal trashcans, as opposed to the smaller ones in the adjacent lot.
A sign by the central trailer read clean up your mess, and one of its doors was tagged repeatedly with the word NO. Further encampment structures like RVs and tents were located to the southeast on Castro St. underneath the Interstate 880 or Nimitz Freeway. History: The lot containing the Brush Street encampment had a complicated history. A Sanborn fire insurance map confirms that it was densely built up with wood frame dwellings by the beginning of the twentieth century (Figure 5). One structure, a marble works shop, is brick clad. Another, labeled Chinese Laundry, is shaded in green, indicating special hazards, or places that could be potential fire sources. A water tank and windmill are identified on the back lot of one frame residential structure.
The Brush and 6th Street block was not color-coded on a Home Owners Loan Corporation Residential Security Map, indicating that the HOLC did not consider it a residential area (Figure 6). However, redlined areas D8 and D9, making up the westmost portions of West Oakland, are located one block away. This may have been an inaccuracy when drafting these security maps, as Sanborn maps noted the presence of residential dwellings. By the early Sanborn maps showed a half a century of growth and change including additional one to three story dwellings and other structures including a garage and church room (Figure 7). These buildings were mostly offset from the sidewalk and street edge with open yards in the back.
An aerial photograph from around the same time reinforced that the Brush Street lot was a part of a dense residential and commercial neighborhood (Figure 8). 5 Tuff Shed has become a generic trademark term that popularly refers to any small, manufactured storage shed or building sold direct or through big-box home improvement retailers. BRUSH STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No. CA-2977 (page 4) In the the construction of Grove Shafter Freeway, or I-980, halted because of protests over the accompanying demolition of residential fabric and the displacement of residents. During these protests, the I-980 ended abruptly at halting before it connected with the I-880 or Nimitz Freeway to the south.
In Oakland business interest groups pressured Governor Jerry Brown to authorize completion of the freeway that would better connect the Bay Area suburbs to the downtown commercial district. Brown ordered the project s completion, while promising to dedicate a portion of the construction jobs and City Center jobs to minority populations like those displaced by demolition of the 500 homes (Figure 9). 6 Completed in the freeway and the City Center project never fully realized its intent of attracting white suburban consumers and helping Oakland compete with San Francisco and the other area malls and department stores. 7 The I-980 project did, however, wall off West Oakland from Downtown.
The City of Oakland cleared the encampment in following political pressure from neighborhood businesses and the proliferation of encampment-related public health hazards. 8 Repeated fires caused by arson and accidents were one justification. 9 The evidence of these fires could still be seen in July in the form of scorch marks on overpasses and the burnt shells of cars, busses, and Neighboring businesses also pressured the City of Oakland to evict and clear the encampment, citing concerns about rats, accumulating garbage, and encounters with the unhoused that they and their customers found uncomfortable. 10 A real estate listing showed the land at 6th and Brush Street as an uneven, grassy lot encircled by chain link fence, without encampment structures in sight.
11 Two years later, ownership of the lot transferred from the State of California or Caltrans to private ownership. Google Earth historical imagery shows homeless encampment structures first appearing as a strip of tents, and tarpaulins on the 6th Street sidewalk in March In immediately after the purchase, the new owners leased the lot to the City of Oakland for a temporary emergency housing projects or navigation centers composed of small 10 x 12 cabins or Tuff Shed kits purchased through Home Depot for each. 12 This project was the first of four such cabin communities planned at different Oakland sites 6 I-980. 7 Schwarzer, Oakland City Center, 91. 8 Can Tuff Sheds help Oakland ease the housing crisis?
KLAW Public Media, June 28, 9 Devin Katayama, Oakland Homeless Encampments: Too Big to Ignore, KQED, June 28, 10 Khevin LaGrone, West Oakland s class warfare, San Francisco Bay View: National Black Newspaper, March 3, 11 Brush, Castro, 6th and 7th Streets, LoopNet, July 23, 12 Can Tuff Sheds help Oakland ease the housing crisis? BRUSH STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No. CA-2977 (page 5) and funded through an emergency ordinance that declared a shelter crisis (Figure 13 After the clearance, forty out of almost 100 residents from the surrounding encampment were provided space in the small, gated cabin community and navigation center in the southeast portion of the lot. Seventy-four residents were housed over the course of a year, as the city attempted to find them stable housing.
14 This was the first of many Tuff Shed communities and navigation centers. 15 The structures were oriented diagonally in three uneven rows along a trapezoidal southeast portion of the lot. The individual sheds measured 10 x 12 with a single interior room, a front door, and a rear window. 16 The walls were insulated, and residents were given cots to sleep on and a battery powered lamp. They were allowed to bring a pet, a limited number of belongings, and had to share space with a roommate. 17 Priority was given to members of the encampment who could certify that they had resided in the encampment the longest, followed by those with health and mental conditions, older age, or substance dependency. Those not chosen had to leave and live elsewhere.
18 City officials called the community a success when the project transitioned most residents to permanent housing. 19 The community was meant to be temporary; a city administrator stated that This isn t housing. This is emergency shelter in a non-traditional way. 20 When the lease for the lot ended thirteen months later, in January the complex was removed thirteen and the sheds placed in storage for use elsewhere. 21 Google Earth historical imagery shows that the area remained unoccupied until between March and July when unhoused communities settled the interior of the lot and surrounding areas. In Oakland residents bemoaned the state of the block once more; various 13 Oakland approves homeless ordnance to allow tuff sheds as temporary solution, KTVU FOX 2, October 5, solution.
14 Oakland calls Tuff Sheds a success; first village removed as lease ends, KTVU FOX 2, January 29, 15 Oakland calls Tuff Sheds a success. 16 Larry Dang, High School Junior Tackles Temporary Housing for the Homeless in Oakland, Medium, June 1, af39fc9a3ae4. 17 Lucas Guilkey, Advocates push Oakland officials to treat homelessness as an emergency, Oakland North, December 14, an-emergency/. 18 Can Tuff Sheds help Oakland ease the housing crisis? 19 Rob Arias, Oakland Set to Open Latest Cabin Community and RV Homeless Camp Near Emeryville Target, The E Ville Eye, July 3, 20 Oakland calls Tuff Sheds a success. 21 Oakland mayor proposes navigation center for city s homeless population, KTVU FOX 2, September 26, Oakland calls Tuff Sheds a success. BRUSH STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No.
CA-2977 (page 6) postings on the chat website Reddit blamed conditions on the homeless, the City, and businesses who dump their junk and trash there illegally (see Figure 22 During the events around the Brush Street encampment, calls intensified for the removal and replacement of the Interstate In Mayor Libby Schaff requested funding for studies on removing the freeway. 23 In the same year, San Francisco Chronicle urban design critic, John King, proposed replacing I-980 with a residential boulevard with market rate and affordable housing. 24 In it was listed among the Congress for the New Urbanism s freeways without futures or top ten freeways to tear down.
25 Two years later, the Downtown Oakland Specific Plan released renderings of a multi-way boulevard in place of the I-980, with arrows pointing both ways, as if stitching West Oakland and Downtown back together. 26 In Caltrans and the City of Oakland received in federal money from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law s Reconnecting Communities Pilot Program to study ways to reintegrate the neighborhoods that the I-980 separated. 27 If the I-980 were to be removed, it would no longer cut across and above the Brush and 6th street lot, although the I- 880 would remain in place.