Cob on Wood was a community center serving members of West Oakland s unhoused population (Figure 1). It was significant as a humanitarian intervention conducted by nonprofit organizations and volunteers for the benefit of the larger Wood Street encampment that extended along Wood Street and underneath Interstate 880 for dozens of blocks (Figure 2). Cob on Wood arose from collaborative efforts with residents to improve encampment living conditions by providing mutual aid and creating a hub where volunteers worked to distribute donated clothes, food, and medical supplies to the surrounding encampment community. The nonprofits involved included the Oakland based Artists Building Communities and Essential Food and Medicine.
Construction was led by Miguel Elliott of Petaluma and the California based organization, Living Earth Structures, a contractor specializing in constructing earthen huts, ovens, benches, and classroom buildings in U.S. cities. They constructed Cob on Wood with help from volunteers from the larger Oakland community and paid members of the Wood Street encampment. Cob on Wood was a small complex of earth-colored tiny houses with windows of repurposed glass and reliefs of trees sculpted into their sides. The assembly of buildings included a community free store, health clinic, kitchen, sleeping cabin, and restroom. The site also contained a community bulletin board, pizza oven, seating areas, performance stage, and gardens (see Figure 1).
Miguel Elliott hoped that because of the cheap construction and beauty of the cob structures, they would catch on as a new, humane, and community-based strategy to ameliorate living conditions in encampments around the United States.1 The aesthetics of Cob on Wood were also important as a political tool for the Wood Street encampment. Referred to as hobbit houses, gingerbread houses, and a miracle village, Cob on Wood captured the interest of the general public 1 Author s field notes, July 31, COB ON WOOD HABS No.
CA-2976 (page 2) differently than typical encampment spaces.2 Instead of the morbid fascination, pity, fear, or disgust that often characterize the outsider s perception of encampments (due in part to misconceptions and stigmas regarding homelessness and the unintelligibility of some sites), the cob structures lent an impression of safety and familiarity, despite also being constructed illegally and without permission or permits.
Gardens and botanical themes like the ones at Cob on Wood can also be seen at other Oakland encampments, prompting empathetic responses from more affluent and housed members of the public.3 The contrast of familiar gardens and the cottage-like cabin structures with the community center s placement beneath soaring Interstate 880 overpasses made it a photogenic public face for the larger Wood Street encampment. Miguel Elliott recounted Caltrans workers bemused interest in the cob structures, despite the illegality of the structures.4 Cob on Wood was also significant in the everyday lives of Wood Street encampment residents.
The free store or cobissary was used to stock and distribute donated items like socks, shoes, blankets, soap, toilet paper, and naloxone (to treat overdoses).5 The community kitchen was used to store food and prepare meals; it was equipped with a refrigerator and stovetops, which in a fire- resistant cob building were safer to use than in many makeshift encampment kitchens. Annmarie, of Artists Building Communities, recounted how the large circular seating area on the north side of Cob on Wood was the perfect size for residents to sit and talk together while maintaining social distance following the Covid-19 outbreak.6 Film screenings, Superbowl parties, benefit concerts, volunteer orientations, and community meetings took place at Cob on Wood throughout its short lifespan.
Cob on Wood became a symbol of community cohesion and care for the larger Wood Street encampment. Yellow carnation flowers came to decorate the site as well as fences and structures in the surrounding encampment. The flowers, found in a large wreath among nearby piles of illegally dumped debris, symbolized tenacity and the ability of unhoused communities to repurpose and beautify 2 Erin Baladassari, The End of Wood Street: Inside the Struggle for Stability, Housing on the Margins of the Bay Area, KQED, May 17, Gabrielle Canon, Homeless Oaklanders were tired of the housing crisis.
So they built a miracle village, The Guardian, May 11, 3 Ben Jameson-Ellsmore, Curbside Castle: Architecture and Aspiration at an Oakland Homeless Encampment, PLATFORM, January 10, 4 Miguel Elliott, The Palletable Cobin: Natural, Quick, and Affordable Pallet Structures, The Last Straw, August 25, 5 Cob on Wood (@cobonwood) Instagram, March 29, 6 Author s field notes, July 21, COB ON WOOD HABS No. CA-2976 (page 3) materials and spaces cast off by mainstream society.7 Cob on Wood s structures, which utilized trash for insulation and discarded wood from local businesses, indicated a similar relationship to the surrounding neglected land. Wood Street encampment residents expressed delight at the simplicity and practicality of Cob on Wood.
Not only were its resources free to residents, but its building techniques were accessible to non-professionals. A Wood Street resident named Calvin remarked: I think it s beautiful [ ] Everything s simple, everything works, it s not, you know, no need for code compliance or anything like that because everything s just simply workable. 8 Cob on Wood became a site of political organizing and protest during the incremental clearance of the surrounding encampment in Its perimeter fence and gateway were repositories for protest messages and signs. In fall an archway made of fencing boards was painted with the words here at Cob on Wood we are one family, and respect existence, expect resistance (Figure 3). Signs affixed to the fence read this is not removing homeless people.
This is removing people s homes (Figure 4). Along with the Wood Street Commons a few blocks away, Cob on Wood hosted meetings strategizing how to apply political pressure to City and State officials to allow the Wood Street encampment to remain in place. Residents, volunteers, and activists ran workshops on community fire prevention, workdays for cleaning the spaces surrounding encampment structures to improve their public image, as well as a final protest and a closing ceremony on October 12, before Caltrans cleared Cob on Wood s site and evicted its residents.
Description: Cob on Wood served as a community plaza for the Wood Street encampment.9 Within a fenced perimeter, its collection of cob buildings included a community free store, health clinic, kitchen, sleeping cabin, and restroom, each within their own structures. Cob refers to the material a mixture of sand, clay, straw, and water that coats the interiors and exteriors of Cob on Wood s buildings and lends them a distinctive gingerbread appearance. The structures were arranged around a series of walkways winding between garden planters, a bulletin board, and benches, with a seating area, performance stage, and pizza oven at its northern end. The walkways were separated from planters by bricks embedded in the soil (see Figure 1).
There were plans to expand Cob on Wood to include an additional dozen sleeping cobins, fruit trees, native plant gardens, and a sauna, but the Caltrans evictions made their construction impossible (Figure 7 Cob on Wood (@cobonwood) The #yellowflowers @woodstreetcommons represent the #tenacity #creativity and #willpower needed in #mutualaid, Instagram, November 30, 8 Cob on Wood (@cobonwood) Instagram, April 27, 9 Elliott, The Palletable Cobin. 10 Author s field notes, July 31, COB ON WOOD HABS No. CA-2976 (page 4) The cob structures were built in the portion of the Wood Street encampment that stretched for blocks along Caltrans-owned land beneath the Interstate 880 overpass and along the railroad infrastructure owned by the Southern Pacific and railways.
The overpasses and piers above Cob on Wood, constructed as a part of the Cypress Replacement Project after the original Cypress Freeway structure to the east collapsed during the Loma Prieta earthquake, were decorated periodically with murals and graffiti. Cob on Wood was constructed on land inaccessible by paved roads, to the northwest of the intersection of Wood Street and Street and north of the intersection of W Grand Ave and Wood Street. One accessed Cob on Wood by moving west on Grand Ave past Wood Street, through an opening in a series of chain link fences and turning to the north underneath the I-880 overpasses.
Cob on Wood was located amidst other clusters of dwellings composed of tents, and shanties often surrounded by tarpaulin-draped chain-link fences in the spaces between railroad tracks and concrete k-rail (or Jersey ) barriers. The freeway overpasses overhead connect drivers on the Interstate 880 with Interstates 80 and 580 through the massive Macarthur Maze interchange to the north, as well as with Frontage Road that empties into West Oakland. To the west lies the remnants of the decommissioned Oakland Army Base, the East Bay Municipal Utility District Wastewater Treatment Plant, and a series of logistic and transportation warehouses.
To the east lies an RV safe parking facility run by BOSS (Building Opportunities for Self Sufficiency) and a series of recording studios and building supply warehouses across Wood Street. The Wood Street Commons, another encampment community center formed in was located two blocks to the south, across Grand Avenue. The Cob on Wood tiny house structures or cobins were wood framed with 4" x 4" corner posts and 2" x 4" uprights between them. Heat treated forklift pallets donated by a roofing company near the Wood Street encampment were set between the posts and uprights to create walls. Builders were careful to select heat treated, rather than chemically treated, pallets (Figure 6). Those with broken boards were repaired using scrap wood from waste dumped at the encampment.
The pallets were insulated with clothes and plastic from onsite dumpsters and some were also elaborated with shelves, bottles, and glass blocks before being installed as walls.11 Cobin roofs were made of 12 long, 2" x 4" rafters and donated plywood sheets. They were constructed to have 2 overhangs on each side. Lastly, an impermeable layer was added to the roofs for weatherproofing and to support green roof-type soil and vegetation plantings.12 11 Elliott, The Palletable Cobin. 12 Elliott, The Palletable Cobin. COB ON WOOD HABS No. CA-2976 (page 5) The cobins took local landscape and environmental factors into account.
Cob applied to the pallet walls was sourced from local recycling companies instead of from Wood Street because of local contamination from commercial and industrial dumping and pollution from the freeway. Primer and a clay slip were first applied to the bare walls to help the 1" thick cob adhere to the surface.13 The cobins were also built with local political conditions in mind. Because they were constructed on Caltrans land without the legal right to do so, they were subject to demolition at any time. Builders constructed the cobins on skids so that they could move them using a trailer and forklift.
Their 8 x 12 dimensions also enabled their transportation on a standard trailer bed.14 History: Cob on Wood developed on land that was taken by the United State from Mexico after the Mexican-American War and Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in By the the Central Pacific Railroad had completed construction on the Long Wharf at Oakland Point in West Oakland, which received and ferried railway passengers to San Francisco. The Central Pacific consolidated under the Southern Pacific Railway before constructing the Street Station in The Station was located along Wood Street, about 5 blocks south of the future Cob on Wood site.15 A Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC) Residential Security Map included the land later occupied by Cob on Wood in a West Oakland redlined district (Figure 7).
These maps are pre-Civil Rights segregation documents that evaluated risk for lending institutions within certain city districts, with the highest risk colored in red for hazardous, followed by yellow ( definitely declining ), blue ( still desirable ), and green ( best ). These documents identified as lower risk those neighborhoods with predominantly or completely white populations and the presence of natural or artificial barriers to deter demographic change. Higher risk was unambiguously attributed to the presence of industrial functions and the influx of immigrants and people of color.
The accompanying Area Description for the land that the Wood Street encampment would later occupy says the following, using racially explicit language: In the small, triangular portion of this area, lying east of Market Street, there are but very few Negroes, but west of Market Street the number steadily increases until the vicinity of Peralta, where they constitute approximately 80% of the population. Parts of this area might be designated as a slum district. It is zoned for Light Industry, but as yet the amount in the area is negligible. Many of the residents are employed in the yards and shops, which are a short 13 Elliott, The Palletable Cobin. 14 Elliott, The Palletable Cobin.
15 John Snyder, Southern Pacific Railroad Sixteenth Street Station, Historic American Buildings Survey, COB ON WOOD HABS No. CA-2976 (page 6) distance south. The new U.S. Naval Base which will be locaed [sic] on Harbor Lands in the vicinity of this area, will cause increased demand for cheap multiple-family dwellings and will probably have a beneficial effect.16 The presence of odors, smoke from the railroad, tenements, unusually high taxes, and people of color were listed as detrimental factors adding to the risk of lending agencies financing properties and extending credit to those within the district.
This practice led to the physical and economic immobilization of people of color in major US cities by denying them access to credit for home improvement and home ownership and the generational wealth that accompanied it.17 The same document also listed some of what it called favorable influences, which included proximity to transportation infrastructure and shopping districts and a short walking distance to laboring people s workplaces. Such discriminatory maps primed West Oakland for the racialized slum clearance and urban renewal projects of the mid-twentieth century. A Sanborn map shows no built structures in the area surrounding the future Cob on Wood site, and no infrastructure beyond some roads and the Southern Pacific railroad tracks.
Forty years later, another Sanborn map shows that little had changed on the Cob on Wood site, while the area to its east has developed significantly. The nearest structure was a long freight warehouse to the east owned by the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company, with a stone floor, truss roof, and a wood frame office and overhang. An ice cream factory, flour warehouse, auto workshops, and paved parking spaces appeared across Wood Street on the block between and streets (Figure 8). The freeway overpasses that shaded Cob on Wood and much of the surrounding Wood Street encampment in the twenty-first century were constructed as a part of the Cypress Replacement Project after the original Cypress Freeway structure to the east collapsed during the Loma Prieta earthquake.
When the Loma Prieta Earthquake destroyed most of the Cypress Viaduct that had bisected West Oakland since traffic congestion in neighborhood streets and on the Interstate 980 on the way to San Francisco resulted in political pressure to replace the freeway. The City of Oakland, the Citizens Emergency Relief Team (CERT), and neighborhood groups successfully pressured Caltrans to plan a replacement farther from West Oakland residential communities.
Planning for what would be called the Cypress Freeway Replacement or Realignment began in The Replacement would route Interstate 880 around West Oakland residential neighborhoods instead of through them, while still disrupting the marginal West 16 Mapping Inequality: Redlining in New Deal America, accessed August 2, 17 Eric Avila and Tha sa Way, Segregation and Resistance in the Landscapes of the Americas (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, COB ON WOOD HABS No.
CA-2976 (page 7) Oakland Prescott neighborhoods that bordered the city s ports and military installations.18 Unhoused Oaklanders began to settle on Wood Street as early as Over the next decade the site grew from a scattered collection of temporary dwellings to a massive, bustling community becoming the largest encampment of unhoused people in Northern California.19 Along with the Wood Street Commons, Cob on Wood availed its services free of charge to those living in the Wood Street encampment, a welcoming source of support and community for Oakland s most marginalized people. Incremental clearance of the parts of the Wood Street encampment located on Caltrans land began in the summer months of following a visit by California Governor Gavin Newsom.
The Governor s office began applying pressure on the City of Oakland to take responsibility for providing housing alternatives to those Wood Street residents who were on state-owned (Caltrans) land but still within the city boundaries.20 Caltrans began removing most of the extensive encampment structures beneath the Interstate many residents fled to the Wood Street Commons, which is on city land and subject to a different eviction timeline. Cob on Wood was among the last of the encampment clusters on Caltrans land to be removed. When the site was cleared, Miguel Elliot oversaw the transportation of several cobins safely to the Wood Street Commons, using a forklift and trailer.
They remained there until the Wood Street Commons was also cleared by the City of Oakland in May (Figures 9 and In July the encampment structures and communities that had been expelled from Wood Street were scattered onto the peripheries of surrounding blocks. The former Wood Street Commons lot was surrounded by high-security expanded metal fencing rather than chain link fencing that can be more easily breached to make entrances. The pathway from Grand Ave into the space beneath the I-880 overpasses where Cob on Wood was located was also closed off. At this point encampment structures, materials, and vehicles accrued around the edges or Raimondi park, on and Campbell streets.
Only a few structures 18 Cecily Burt, West Oakland Citizens Band Together to Fight Freeway after Loma Prieta, Oakland Tribune, October 12, after-loma-prieta/. 19 David Bacon, The Final Stand of Wood Street Commons, LA Progressive, April 25, Phoebe Lefebvre, Wood Street Commons: When Your Neighbors are Forced to Leave, KQED, June 1, are-forced-to-leave. 20 At Oakland Encampment, Governor Newsom and Cabinet Members Discuss California s Homelessness Crisis and Solutions, Office of Governor Gavin Newsom, April 15, Newsom slams Oakland over handling of Wood Street homeless encampment, KTVU, August 18, COB ON WOOD HABS No. CA-2976 (page 8) remained on Wood Street across from the site of the Commons.
Notices from the City of Oakland titled Notice to Vacate Illegal Encampment were posted on nearby sign poles on June 30, warning that the Public Works Department will clear any remaining people and belongings on July 12, A large concentration of relocated encampment structures could be found on blocks at the intersection of Willow and streets, including two community cobins. Miguel Elliot stated that the cobins were moved improperly the second time, resulting in damage.21 Originally two cobins were moved, but in July only the former community clinic was visible. Community members imparted that the mound next to the clinic was the remains of another cobin that burned down when its resident fell asleep with a candle burning (Figure This individual fortunately escaped the blaze.