The 5th Street Encampment is an example of the many informal dwellings that have proliferated in Oakland, California, in the twenty-first century. Marked by fires, floods, and eviction, the encampment s five year history, from its inception in to the time of this report in exemplifies both the resourcefulness and desperation of Oakland s unhoused residents. With a new apartment development called Golden West in the works on the abutting lot, the 5th Street Encampment s future is equally uncertain.1 In the encampment was architecturally cohesive, comprising not just tents and recreational vehicles designed to be relocated, but also walls made of scrap bound materials and lean- tos enclosing a series of rooms connected by open-air passageways.
Located in a historically Black neighborhood that was once redlined, subjected to urban renewal demolition, and partitioned by the Cypress Freeway, the encampment physically manifested the historic upheavals and inequities of West Oakland. The 5th Street encampment was a significant sanctuary for those with few alternatives. It was established in by women fleeing abusive partnerships at a neighboring encampment on Kirkham Street. I didn t want to live under a man, said one resident, referring to domestic partnerships and landlord/tenant relationships. The same resident was laid off from her office job during the recession and did not economically recover.
Others had felony convictions that diminished job prospects and caused minor infractions to result in more jail time.2 These events combined to make local housing costs unaffordable. Simultan- eously, encampment life offered more freedom than homeless shelters or cabin communities. The resulting encampment at 5th Street was a home to both humans and pets, imbued with a sense of place, decorated with a successive series of colorful hand-painted signs, and furnished with couches and common areas. 1 Ayla Burnett, Major West Oakland housing development delayed again, The Oaklandside (April 21, 2 Field notes, July 22, 5th STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No.
CA-2978 (page 2) Description: The 5th Street Encampment comprised a single block long strip of lean-tos, repurposed carports, tents, and enclosures utilized by an unhoused community. The encampment occupied a sidewalk that had been partially reduced to rubble. It extends south onto the paved asphalt of 5th Street and north against a fence separating it from a vacant lot that is slated for apartment construction. The encampment was located across the street from a warehouse where semi-trucks often entered and exited. Its front entrance emptied into the path of east and westbound vehicular traffic. The noise from cars and trucks, as well as the overhead Bay Area Rapid Transit trains heading into the nearby West Oakland Station, permeated the site at all hours (Figure 1).
The most prominent encampment structure was located at the center of the block and distinguished itself from its RV and tent neighbors through its bricolage walls featuring colorful paintings and political messages, as well as a scavenged front door in an improvised frame (Figures 2 and 3). Its fa ade, composed of scrap materials like forklift pallets and chain link fence, was covered with tarpaulin to provide a visual as well as physical barrier. Although it was not possible to obtain precise measurements, the orthogonal structure measured approximately 72 x 18 , enclosing about square feet. Beyond the front door, a 12 long north/south entryway led to an east/west open- air passageway of about 60 (Figures 4 and 5).
The peripheries of this passage adjacent to the back chain link fence were used for the storage of tools and salvaged materials. The floor was comprised of earth, concrete, and rubble, with rugs placed to increase walkability. Water occasionally pooled and stagnated in troughs in the passageway s uneven surface. In the main east/west passageway connected four distinct rooms, including a kitchen, a bedroom, storage shed, and an office room with a shower. The approximately 12 x 16 kitchen featured scavenged couches as seating, aluminum tables as countertops, and an ice-cooled filing cabinet for food storage. The kitchen was formed by three walls of chain link fence draped with tarpaulin. The bedroom was a camper tent on a wooden base to distance it from pests and flooding water.
The sleeper tent contained a mattress, bedside table, and a dresser. The storage shed was composed of fastened plywood sheets leaning against the front fa ade and back wall. A frame structure with plastic posts and a tarp covering backed against the private lot s chain link fence was used as an office. It contained a desk, couches, a clothing storage area, and an improvised shower that drained into the space below the raised encampment platforms (Figure 6). Draped quilts formed the office entrance. History: In July the 5th Street Encampment was located at the edge of the Acorn neighborhood of West Oakland, which has been repeatedly fractured by a history of de jure and de facto segregation, urban renewal, demolitions, and arson.
The area was redlined in one of the Home Owners Loan Corporation s Residential Security Maps in meaning it was classified as high-risk for home mortgage 5th STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No. CA-2978 (page 3) lenders based on environmental concerns and explicitly racist criteria.3 The area s red color coding or hazardous status was attributed to a growing population of Black and Asian people, as well as odors, smoke, and grime from local industrial facilities like the 5th Street Red Star Yeast plant.4 The Oakland Citizens Committee for Urban Renewal (OCCUR), composed of bankers, industrialists, and real estate magnates, mobilized in the to produce the General Neighborhood Renewal Plan aimed at clearing what they considered urban blight.
5 The so-called blighted neighborhoods consistently matched those that had previously been redlined. In the Oakland Redevelopment Agency designated fifty blocks just north of 5th Street for demolition, in what would be the city s first slum clearance initiative.6 The resulting Acorn Project displaced Black residents to create a housing complex for just This involved clearing the 7th Street commercial corridor, a bustling cultural and economic center for the local Black community.8 A report to the city characterized the corridor as Mixed commercial and residential in same buildings, seriously substandard; obsolete buildings, and Probable total clearance.
9 The Acorn Redevelopment Project replaced the cleared buildings with a middle-income residential neighborhood and intended to attract affluent white people back to West Oakland in what was called reverse integration. 10 Meanwhile, industries already present on 5th Street were allowed to remain. The same report stated that the Most desirable use of area is industrial. 11 In the contracting firm, Grove, Wilson, Shepard and Kruge, completed construction on a double decker freeway overpass called the Cypress Freeway viaduct, which passed through the neighborhood directly adjacent to the future 5th Street encampment s block, with a southbound entrance located at 7th Street and Kirkham Street.
The viaduct cut a large portion of West Oakland off from the rest of the city, forming a physical barrier as well as a source of noise and air pollution. Some residents referred to the structure as the Berlin Wall. 12 After the Cypress Freeway collapsed during the Loma Prieta earthquake in (the same year the actual Berlin Wall fell), the freeway was moved to the west and a park 3 Paige Glotzer, Developing Spaces of Exclusion in Segregation and Resistance in the Landscapes of the Americas, edited by Eric Avila and Tha sa Way (Washington DC: Dumbarton Oaks, 24. 4 See the Oakland HOLC map at the Mapping Inequality: Redlining in New Deal America project, 5 Brandi Summers, Untimely Futures, Places Journal, November 6 Acorn Project is the First City Slum Clearance, Oakland Tribune, March 5, 31.
7 Teron McGrew, The History of Residential Segregation in the United States and Title VIII, The Black Scholar 27, no. 2 26. 8 Summers, Untimely Futures. 9 Acorn Urban Renewal Project: Progress Report to City Council, 1. 10 Jim Wood, Acorn Project Aims to Attract Whites, Oakland Tribune, May 26, 31. 11 Acorn Urban Renewal Project: Progress Report to City Council, 2. 12 Frederick Douzet, The Color of Power: Racial Coalitions and Political Power in Oakland (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 19. 5th STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No. CA-2978 (page 4) boulevard and restoration project called Mandela Parkway replaced it. The 5th Street Encampment resides near the southern end of Mandela Parkway.
While thousands of working class West Oakland homes were demolished for the Cypress Freeway and Acorn Urban Renewal Project, Goebel Brewing Company and Consumer s Yeast plant remained on the 5th Street and Kirkham block (Figure 7).
The brewery was demolished in The yeast plant, renamed Red Star Yeast, was a heavy polluter of the neighborhood for almost a century, and was associated by activists with health effects such as high asthma and cancer rates in the surrounding predominantly Black community.14 It was community and environmentalist groups like the Coalition for West Oakland Revitalization and Greenaction that ultimately succeeded in having the plant shut down and demolished in After the demolition of the Red Star plant, the lot was acquired by a private firm intending to build market rate condominiums. Those plans were derailed both by the financial crisis and the need for environmental remediation on the site following discovery of fuel tanks and soil contamination.
Soil remediation procedures and the removal of underground storage tanks destroyed portions of the sidewalk and gutter, where the 5th Street Encampment is located today.16 The lot was acquired by the New Jersey-based Michaels Organization, a developer of affordable and market rate housing, and new construction began on the Red Star Senior Apartments. While under construction in the complex burned down in what was considered an act of arson.17 In women members of the homeless encampment on the neighboring Kirkham Street seceded and formed the 5th Street Encampment to escape abusive partners and to form a new community.18 They constructed a new encampment using the abundant junk and refuse found in their area.
These materials originated from illegal dumping as well as nearby dumpsters and industrial facilities, commercial and industrial dump sites, and the massive Port of Oakland located nearby. Community members provided materials like locks for the front door and painting materials for the signs that adorned the encampment s fa ade. 13 Paul Groth, A Profile of West Oakland Work in in Sights and Sounds: Essays in Celebration of West Oakland, eds. Suzanne Stewart and Mary Praetzellis (Oakland: California Department of Transportation with the Anthropological Studies Center, Sonoma State University, 14 Gordy Slack, Red Star s Rising Opposition, East Bay Express, February 20, 15 Mary Vance, Red Star Falls, Ecology Center, May 15, 2003/red-star-falls/.
16 Red Star Yeast / Fifth Street State Water Resource Control Board GeoTracker, accessed September 4, 17 Nina Thorsen, Burned West Oakland Building Stood on Site with Long History, KQED, June 14, 18 Ben Jameson-Ellsmore, Curbside Castle: Architecture and Aspiration at and Oakland Homeless Encampment, PLATFORM, January 10, 5th STREET ENCAMPMENT HABS No. CA-2978 (page 5) Currently, a new apartment complex called Golden West, after the former brewery on the site, is planned for the vacant lot at 5th Street.
While the labor group East Bay Residents for Responsible Development opposes its construction based on environmental remediation concerns and the fact that only sixteen of the 222 units are affordable, Oakland City Council approved its construction in While the press coverage of the Golden West project does not mention the 5th Street encampment explicitly, street-level renderings of the site depict an unimpeded street and sidewalk with bike racks, affluent pedestrians, and cars of recent make in the shadow of the 8-story complex. The implication is that the encampment will be cleared at some point as the project moves forward.19