BlockBefore

City Hall Park, Oakland

City Hall Park, Oakland, Alameda County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-157, with a 11,540-word written history.

From the record

“Oscar Grant Plaza unofficially eponymously named in honor of the Black East Bay resident killed by San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) police in served as a central destination for protests, civil disobedience, vigils, art, and other public actions of the summer Black Lives Matter uprising for racial justice.”

Written record, HALS CA-157 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-157 · the record runs 11540 words · one of 198 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

9925 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-157. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Oscar Grant Plaza unofficially eponymously named in honor of the Black East Bay resident killed by San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) police in served as a central destination for protests, civil disobedience, vigils, art, and other public actions of the summer Black Lives Matter uprising for racial justice. Across the United States, the uprising galvanized people in small towns and large cities to call for an end to police brutality, state-backed violence against Black people, and white supremacy and systemic racism infiltrating all aspects of society.

We understand this recent history, influenced by the racial justice movement s roots in Oakland, cements this plaza as a historic Black landscape.1,2 Randolph Belle and De Ana Brownfield, who have worked at Black Cultural Zone in East Oakland and are leaders in preserving the murals that arose during the uprising,3,4 agreed that Oscar Grant Plaza well represents the historic Black cultural landscape associated with this uprising. This plaza is one of many significant Black landscapes in Oakland that exists because of multi-generational and relentless initiatives working for racial justice and to end police brutality.

Many of these landscapes are in East and West Oakland, and many are majority 1 During the California Preservation Foundation s Conference Panel Discussion Preserving Memories, Stories, & Expressions, architect Kennedy Whiters noted the importance of replacing the passive voice with the active voice in relation to actions and participation in historic preservation. 2 A note on our methodology for identifying a historic Black landscape and defining its historic importance: Our team of Historians consists of white and Asian San Francisco Bay Area residents who work locally in a landscape architecture firm.

We acknowledge the white privilege inherent in our white-dominant profession and firm that feed into the white supremacy undergirding the preservation of landscapes in the US, including the identification and definition of historic Black landscapes. In April our team selected a site as a historic Black Landscape: the murals painted on the plywood affixed to storefronts along Broadway in downtown Oakland during the uprising. We surveyed an area to document their physicality before re-orienting our focus to the plaza. We elaborate further on this in the Description.

3 Oakland Arts and Culture Community Lead Effort to Uplift Black Voices via the Preservation and Presentation of Oakland Murals, Oakland Museum of California, accessed July 29, 4 Babette Thomas, How Oakland Community Organizers Are Preserving Street Art That Captures a Historic Moment, Crosscurrents, KALW Public Media, October 7, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 2 Black and heavily policed. Unlike Oscar Grant Plaza s location in downtown Oakland, these landscapes did not benefit from urban centrality or widely broadcasted protests.

A note on the plaza s name: to emphasize the period of significance for this Black cultural landscape, the plaza is described using the name Oscar Grant Plaza.5 This renaming (and the recording team s decision) is not without ambivalence.6 It is formally recorded as Frank H. Ogawa Plaza and is also known as City Hall Park. In the History section, we describe the people and activism associated with these names. Description: Oscar Grant Plaza: General Description, Spatial Organization, and Circulation Oscar Grant Plaza, formally and officially known as Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, is triangularly shaped and centrally located in downtown Oakland at the foot of City Hall (HALS CA-419).

The plaza is nestled between five to eighteen story buildings, where the street grid is bisected by a regionally significant road thus creating a triangular form that is approximately 3.3 acres. To understand the spatial organization of the plaza is to understand the geography of the city. The grid in downtown Oakland, askew to north, runs northeast and southwest on one axis, and northwest and southeast on the other. This is not random. It aligns orthogonally to the city s early, natural history: the shoreline of the San Francisco Bay to the south and west, Lake Merritt and its estuary to the east, and hills to the north. Bisecting this grid at an angle is San Pablo Avenue.

Tracing a historic and significant Ohlone route that travels the flatlands for over seven miles, it follows the shoreline of the San Francisco Bay north to San Pablo Bay. From downtown Oakland, San Pablo Avenue crosses West Oakland, and the cities of Emeryville, Berkeley, Albany, El Cerrito, Richmond, San Pablo, Pinole, and Hercules to meet the Carquinez Strait. This tidal strait, in turn, meets one of the largest inland river deltas in the world, the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta. The southeasterly trajectory of this long route finishes in Oscar Grant Plaza, thus interrupting the city grid in the heart of downtown Oakland.

Where San Pablo 5 The phrase Black cultural landscape reflects the contemporary use of cultural landscapes as places of distinction encompassing those with good physical integrity as well as places where important events or ephemeral events occurred. In this HALS recordation, historic Black landscape is used interchangeably with Black cultural landscape. 6 As articulated and depicted by Kim Tran and Kenji Liu (please see Sources), the renaming of the plaza situates the experiences of Grant and Ogawa in opposition, rather than illuminating their shared struggle against racism and marginalization. Our team acknowledges this divisiveness, which is not the spirit with which we have chosen to use this name. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 3 Avenue ends as a roadway, at Street, it transforms with paving, signage, curbs, trees, planters, lighting, and furnishings into a plaza. The roadway meets a small parking lot and circular vehicular drop-off, and then continues its final linear trajectory as a pedestrian-oriented passageway. This passageway makes the hypotenuse of the triangular shaped plaza. The culmination of this long route is the intersection of Street and Broadway, two prominent streets of the downtown grid and layout of the city. From the drop-off, a second side of the plaza veers southwest, away from the hypotenuse. It is a similarly constructed passageway that passes large agency buildings, including the primary impetus and focus of the plaza: the 335-foot-tall Beaux Arts-style Oakland City Hall.

This side leads to the intersection of Street and Oakland City Center (another pedestrian-oriented conglomerate of urban development). The third side of the plaza is the Street sidewalk. Matching in materiality, it fits neatly into the plaza s design, and also serves the adjacent roadway that spans the neighborhoods of West Oakland and East Oakland, where its name changes from East Street to International Boulevard. Broadway is more than an edge of the plaza: it possesses its own prominence as it strikes the plaza s southern terminus, contributing to the plaza s centrality. The wide boulevard leads south to Broadway Plaza in Jack London Square, on the waterfront, and north, through neighborhoods, to the Oakland and Berkeley hills.

City Hall, the plaza, and portions of Broadway, are all included in the 26-acre National Register of Historic Places Downtown Oakland Historic District. The intersection of Broadway, the plaza, and Street is also a hub for regional and local transportation. Here, the Street BART station elevator and escalator-stair structures shuttle pedestrians to and from the underground platforms. Unlike the Street sidewalk, the other two primary sides of the plaza are isolated from the street grid by City Hall and other buildings occupying the area bifurcated by San Pablo Avenue and its pedestrianized terminus. Therefore, two additional pedestrian-only passageways connect the plaza to other parts of the grid.

Stemming from the primary organizing form of the triangle, these passageways are heretofore distinguished as secondary. One runs perpendicular from the midpoint of the plaza s hypotenuse eastward to Latham Square (a smaller public space formed by the acute angular intersection of Telegraph Avenue meeting the grid of Broadway and Street). Across the plaza, the other runs perpendicular from the side fronting City Hall, connecting to the Office of the Attorney General on Clay Street. To summarize the plaza s bounds: forming a triangle, one side is Street, the perpendicular side fronts City Hall and other buildings that extend to San Pablo Avenue, and the hypotenuse reaches from San Pablo Avenue back toward CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 4 Street, where it intersects with Broadway.

Two secondary passageways are perpendicular to two sides: one from the hypotenuse east to Broadway, and the other from City Hall west to Clay Street. Oscar Grant Plaza: Primary Land Uses, Views, and Landmarks, and Topography The eclectic sides and endpoints binding the plaza busy arterial streets, regional commuter transportation, City Hall, public agencies, and large buildings with large storefronts walling in the plaza frame a vivacious space, free of vehicles, for cultural traditions of both daily use and large events. On a Tuesday morning in late July after the city has begun to reopen from pandemic- caused closures, sounds emanated from the life in and around the plaza. Music overlapped from a nearby restaurant, a parked car s speaker, and a portable wheeled speaker.

Airplanes flew overhead and seagulls squawked. Tree leaves rustled and birds wings flapped. A wheelchair creaked on pavers. People conversed in person or by phone, grooved and whistled along to something in their headphones; an individual suspicious of this surveying process reported the recorder to the police, and a proselytizer proselytized. A leaf blower motor rumbled, the water fountain flowed, crosswalk signals and real birds chirped, materials thudded into a dumpster while a church bell chimed noon. A truck driving backwards beeped, and sirens and motorcycle, car, and truck engines all blared. Quietly, some people napped, read, smoked, ate, or commuted, a dog- walker walked, and uniformed police officers patrolled on foot.

People of all ages visited the plaza by foot, bike, scooter, skateboard, wheelchair, or with walker, stroller, or suitcase. Many people at the plaza wore masks covering their mouths and nose, evidence of the ongoing pandemic. Some entered and left the buildings lining the plaza s primary and secondary passageways. The building fa ades are eclectic in material and architectural style. Their materials include granite, brick, terra cotta, stucco, decorative concrete modular units and breezeblocks, and painted veneer stone.

In addition to the public agencies inside City Hall and other buildings on the plaza, there are restaurants advertising cheesesteaks, deli sandwiches, coffee, burritos, and Vietnamese food, a non-profit arts organization, a credit union, community acupuncture, a theater, a co-working space, a fitness club, a foundation, and a parking garage. A few storefronts are vacant, including one long strip of windows and glass door covered with plywood. Some plywood is painted with graffiti and some is left unfinished. The above buildings and passageways surround the plaza s central form, which is a large, raised lawn area, whose shape is derived from a scaled-down triangle of the plaza itself. The shape has notable irregularities that improve circulation and define seating areas.

One side of the raised lawn follows the Street sidewalk without deviation. The second side follows the pedestrian walkway CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 5 passing in front of City Hall. In axial alignment with the hall s entry, The Forum, a sunken, half-circle amphitheater, dramatically cuts into the raised lawn. It faces a raised circular platform ideal for oration and performance. The third side of the raised lawn, along to the plaza s hypotenuse, is composed of zig-zagging walls that form seating areas at both finish grade and atop the raised lawn. Finally, what would be the two acute angles of the raised lawn are severed to make two more edges.

Northwest, the severed tip accommodates greater circulation between the two secondary passageways that lead to Clay Street and Latham Square, and creates an open hardscape leading to a seating area near the vehicular drop-off at San Pablo Avenue. Southeast, the severed tip accommodates a larger open hardscape area near the intersection of Street and Broadway. This area has developed into a multi-modal commuter interchange, with bike racks, bike storage, and bike and scooter rentals, in addition to the Street BART station entry structures. The artificially constructed topography of the central raised lawn and sunken amphitheater contains the plaza s highest and lowest grades. The lawn, nearly flat, is two to three feet higher than the surrounding finish grade of the plaza.

The top of The Forum, flush with the lawn, descends four feet, or one foot below finish grade. Along the raised lawn s edge, concrete formwork creates a range of uses catering to cultural traditions of accessibility and leisure in urban outdoor spaces. Interspersed along stairs of standard riser and run dimensions (either four or six steps, approximately six inches high) are long bands of monumental steps (either two or three steps, double the standard size), accessible ramps and sloped walks, and small, balcony-like square rooms with seating overlooking the surrounding plaza and neighborhood. Lighting is mounted to pedestals at each of the four corners of these seating areas. In one of the rooms, a person or group of people lives with a tent, handmade sign, bicycle, and suitcases nearby.

People use the large steps as gathering areas that face outward toward the neighborhood along Street and Broadway, and inward toward the hypotenuse and the interior hardscape of the plaza. On either side of the Forum, facing City Hall, ramps connect to the raised lawn s high point and the Forum s low point. The ramps walls have lights and are widened to plant hedges atop. The lawn, with its modest elevation, is significantly more open and visually unobstructed than the rest of the plaza. This allows for composed views of two city landmarks: City Hall and the Jack London Oak, a coast live oak (Quercus agrifolia) planted in the midpoint of the Street side of the raised lawn. Its roughly 80-foot diameter canopy shades the leaf-covered soil beneath it.

A one- foot wide, three-inch raised concrete curb, with a low green chain-link barrier, protects the tree from people. Inside, a ring of uplights light the tree at night. Oscar Grant Plaza: Secondary Uses and Views, Vegetation, and Small-Scale Landscape Features CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 6 In contrast with the open lawn and forum, the relatively narrow passageways and angular spaces that abut tall buildings are more scripted and discrete in layout, furnishings, and vegetation. Near the vehicular drop-off zone at San Pablo Avenue, where the hypotenuse and City Hall sides of the plaza converge, pairs of benches are installed against eight dispersed, rectangular, raised concrete planters planted with sago palms (Cycas revoluta). These low palms are evergreen and bright in color.

Matching the lighting at the raised lawn s rooms, lights perch on each of the planters four corners. Also in this area is a rectangular kiosk, currently occupied by a chocolatier. Arriving at this grid-non-conforming plaza from San Pablo Avenue, a visitor might appreciate this composed view for navigational guidance: beyond the seating area, the enmeshed canopy of two mature coast live oaks forms a wedge between the two primary passageways leading to City Hall and the intersection of Broadway and Street. The evergreen canopy is low, large, and dense enough to block the view of the raised plaza and forum beyond, and in turn emphasizes the tall light standards along the passageways on either side. (The plaza s informational signage is easily missed.

It has three tall, slim signs that display an axonometric map, a business directory, and arrows to adjoining streets. Faded and worn, they seem to blend into the plaza and orient only those who happen upon them. In one obscure location, a Park Rules sign states the hours of the park as 6 A.M. to 10 and prohibits amplified sound without permit, skateboards, and dogs. In another obscure location, a plaque describes the namesake of the landmark Jack London Oak.) These oaks roughly mark a center point in between the two secondary passageways leading to Latham Square and to Clay Street. These secondary passageways lack permanent places to sit.

Toward Clay Street, the passageway is shaded by an all e of adolescent water gum trees (Tristaniopsis laurina) and is lined with bike racks, bollards, and prefabricated planters (mostly unplanted). The parking garage behind City Hall features a City of Oakland Public Notices bulletin board. Another fa ade has a citation pay-kiosk station. Two porta potties and a hand-washing station smell pungently clean. Across the plaza, toward Latham Square, the passageway has light standards, but no trees, permanent seating, or bollards. A cafe located here has moveable chairs and tables outside its storefront. One building extends into the passageway to create a massive granite colonnade.

To unify the idiosyncrasies of the raised plaza, sunken forum, primary and secondary passageways, transit amenities, discrete seating areas, and building fa ades, the plaza is constructed with a shared language of plants, materials, colors, and standards. Integral color concrete pavers (mainly four-inch and one- foot squares) and four-foot square paving in the small parking lot, unify the entirety of the hardscape in shades of soft red, dark tan, and grey. A complementary, integral, light tan color is used in cast-in-place concrete CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 7 planters, walls, steps, and ramps.

This language is interrupted only at some building entries, such as the granite pavers at the entry to City Hall (their color complements the concrete pavers), or the painted concrete aprons and recessed entries at storefronts. London planetrees (Platanus x acerifolia Columbia ) frame the plaza entry at San Pablo Avenue and continue as a row along the pedestrianized hypotenuse toward the BART station. It briefly becomes an all e, giving extra shade to the stair and seating niches created by the raised lawn s zig-zagged edge. More sago palms grow here. Older London planetrees shade most of the twenty-foot-wide Street sidewalk and adjacent raised lawn. In most areas of the plaza, shade is provided at some point in the day either by shade trees or adjacent buildings.

Standardized, prefabricated furnishings and structures throughout the plaza bollards, light standards, waste receptacles, bench frames, a vehicular gate, chain link, the kiosk, the roof of the BART elevator shaft, awnings are metals and fabrics consistently colored a dark, forest green. Some furnishings do not use this primary color but are consistent within their own specification. The one style of bench used in the entire plaza has tan-colored recycled plastic slats and end and middle armrests. Tree grates and trench drains share a matching dark bronze metal and an ornamental pattern. The light standards at Street and Broadway are painted a glossy black instead of green. Ornamental guardrails along the raised lawn rooms are black.

Handrails, bike racks, and a flagpole near the Street and Broadway intersection are satin finished, unpainted grey metals. Three works of public art are designed into the plaza, which is a common method for a city park to highlight and celebrate shared history and values. In between the raised lawn and the granite colonnade to Latham Square, a bronze bust of Frank H. Ogawa is surrounded by four plaques narrating his life: A Personal History, World Statesman, Community Service, and Public Service ; all are pedestal mounted. In the center of the circular vehicular drop off at San Pablo Avenue, a 30-foot bronze abstract sculpture, Vitality, by Bruce Beasley, is positioned atop a tiered, raised concrete basin water feature.

Lastly, the bottom of The Forum illustrates City Hall, boats, waves, animals, and other naturalistic abstractions in an ornate terrazzo mosaic. More ephemeral forms of expression, often political or artistic and in a variety of aesthetics, are scattered throughout the park in various materials. Stickers, posters, and graffiti tags and imagery are applied to building fa ades, light poles and bulbs, and signposts. In June a vigil for a recently deceased community member was sited against a wall on the north end of the plaza. During open hours, owners and workers set out sandwich boards in the passageways advertising their goods and services. On business storefronts, taped letter-size copy paper and posters advertise events, directions, or values. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 8 Oscar Grant Plaza: Small-Scale Landscape Ephemera of the Protests Ephemeral, small-scale landscape features specifically related to the summer uprising, protests, and civil disobedience were located throughout the park. Activists installed three Oscar Grant Plaza signs near the transportation hub and intersection of Street and Broadway. The rectangular signs, roughly eight inches by thirty inches, are painted dark brown behind white-painted capitalized text and a thin border, with inverted radii at the corners, to match formal park signage. Two of the signs, removed as of July 22, were mounted to brown-painted wood and posts, which were set into empty raised planters at the corner of the raised lawn, and frame the view of City Hall from the top of the BART escalator.

The third sign is mounted to the exterior concrete BART elevator shaft wall, facing the intersection of Street and Broadway. The following features were removed before July 27, Standing on the raised lawn, facing the Forum and City Hall, provided a comprehensive view of these elements in axial alignment. Painted between the Forum s stage and the entry to City Hall, within the passageway that defines the plaza s edge, were two circular protest murals, one closer to the amphitheater-style seating, the other closer to the entry to City Hall. The former, a painting titled Freedom, depicted butterflies in a blue sky fluttering around the green canopy of a tree, whose trunk rose from the ground as brown arms forming one large fist.

The latter, a large red-and-black circle titled Defund the Police, depicted a police officer receiving $0 dollar bills. The bills, in flames, were portrayed coming from oil wells. City Hall s entrance, framed by three-story tall columns and light fixtures on pedestals, was boarded up with plywood. The pieces of plywood covering the doors were eight- to ten-feet tall and painted in patches of three different greys and pale yellow. The first row of windows above door height were also covered, in between each mullion, with unpainted plywood. An by 11-inch sheet of copy paper was tacked to the plywood, at eye level, on precisely the same centerline as The Forum, the circular murals, and City Hall s entry.

It stated: CITY OF OAKLAND LODGING / CAMPING NOT PERMITTED California Penal Code 647(e) NO LOITERING California Health and Safety Code NO OBSTRUCTING PEDESTRIANS IN ANY WALKWAYS CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 9 OMC / OMC Between Street and the pedestrian passageway leading to Clay Street, benches, bike racks, and planters with Japanese maple trees and shrubs line the fa ade of City Hall. A long row of galvanized steel barricades, held together with interlocking mechanisms and zip-ties, prevented access to these furnishings and the entry to City Hall from the Forum and the rest of the plaza. On buildings facades facing and visible from the plaza, owners have mounted plywood similarly to the City Hall entry.

In contrast, many of the plywood window, door, and building coverings on these storefronts are painted with murals depicting images and text relating to the Black Lives Matter movement. Murals painted on plywood had been mounted on all the buildings at the intersection of Broadway and Street Broadway, Broadway, 436 Street), the Rotunda Building Frank H. Ogawa Plaza), and the First National Bank Building Broadway). Some were removed by June Contextual Description: Protest Murals on Broadway Near Oscar Grant Plaza A Note from the Recording Team The team began this report focused on the protest murals on Broadway in downtown Oakland.

After the initial documentation fieldwork was complete, several members had a pivotal conversation with Randolph Belle and De Ana Brownfield, of Black Cultural Zone, that guided the re-orientation of this survey to Oscar Grant Plaza. Having worked to preserve the murals and having interviewed associated artists and business and property owners, Belle and Brownfield found the murals had insubstantial evidence of motive supporting the Black Lives Matter movement, and insufficient Black artist representation, for these murals to comprise a historic Black landscape. In their findings, mural production became weighted with opportunism for individual artists, privilege for those with access to resources, and the social acceptability of whiteness and professionalism.

Many artists were motivated primarily by monetary gain and personal recognition. Belle and Brownfield estimated only one-fifth of the muralists were Black. They did, however, support recognizing the historic nature of last summer s protests and the physical spaces in which they unfolded. It is this recent and ephemeral Black landscape the team strives to document. The lack of Black representation in the how, who, and why the murals were made, is to be distinguished from the murals content, whose message conveyed solidarity, protection of Black lives, and an immediate end to police brutality, and whose broader history can be traced back to protests and marches CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 10 rooted in Black culture.7 Our team worked to balance redefining the site of study while also recognizing the murals as a notable small-scale landscape feature that lingered beyond the historic events at the plaza. Given the significance of this conversation to this document, the team recognizes that continued research would reveal greater richness and accuracy, particularly through continued engagement, well-established partnerships, or a team including a historian of Black landscapes or history. Broadway: Land Use, Spatial Organization, Circulation, Vegetation, Cultural Traditions, and Small-Scale Landscape Features At the midpoint of the Downtown Oakland Historic District, the southwest corner of Oscar Grant Plaza meets Broadway, a wide boulevard.

Spanning over 100 feet between building fa ades, Broadway accommodates the city s densest downtown area. People use the thoroughfare to access the plaza, businesses, homes, and public agencies. In addition to the Street BART station at the plaza, there are additional entries as well as the Street BART station elsewhere on Broadway. The thoroughfare sometimes hosts large public gatherings that close the street to vehicles and provides spillover space from the plaza during large gatherings, such as NBA championship tickertape parades, long distance bicycle and running races, and social and political events. Broadway is lined by mature London planetrees, which shade brick, concrete, and exposed aggregate sidewalks, 12- to 22-feet wide, and parking, bus, and driving lanes.

Concrete medians sometimes divide the width of the street, and some are planted with low groundcover or mature street trees. Broadway has no major barriers for 1.8 miles, until the street becomes an underpass south of 6th Street and north of Street. The sidewalk caters to commuters, cyclists, residents, tourists, and workers, with furnishings including planters, parklets, bike racks, bus stop benches and signage, waste receptacles, BART entries, light standards, and wayfinding signs. People, pets, passing traffic, storefronts, and a small homeless encampment create an urban sidewalk experience that fronts buildings seven to twenty-four stories tall.

Broadway Mural Descriptions As with the plaza s buildings, many property or business owners, regardless of use or vacancy, have mounted plywood or oriented strand board (OSB; in this 7 Karen Mack, Mizan Alkebulan-Abakah, De'Ana Brownfield, and K. Kennedy Whiters, Black Lives Matter: Preserving Memories, Stories, and Expressions, panel discussion at the annual California Preservation Foundation Conference, virtual, June 8, Glance-5.10.21-sessions.pdf. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 11 survey we refer to both as plywood) to windows, door glass, or the entire storefront.

Plywood is either directly screwed to the door or window frame (either plate-glass window or standard-size glass window), or screwed or nailed into dimensional lumber framing, such as which was then screwed into the door or window frame. In one case, the framing appeared to be entirely self- supporting. On the afternoon of May 5, the authors walked Broadway from 8th Street to Street to survey the murals on plywood. We also saw murals painted directly onto buildings, storefront signage relating to the movement, and BLACK LIVES MATTER in worn yellow paint covering three blocks of asphalt. We counted 70 murals in the survey area (simplifying the orientation, we counted 42 on the east and 28 on the west sides of the street).

These numbers are approximate; murals were defined as having an uninterrupted surface area or a cohesive aesthetic. As with the plywood affixed to City Hall, mural plywood dimensions frequently adopt standard plywood dimensions, usually 8-feet high by 4-feet wide. Often plywood was custom cut to fit the architecture, like mullions, deep-set windows, and entry alcoves. The longest mural documented, long, wrapped around the corner of and Broadway Apartments. Muralists used spray paint and acrylic paint, applied by brush, roller, marker, or hand, and sometimes used stencils. Wheat-pasted or otherwise affixed letter- or poster-size copy paper, photographs, and objects like rhinestones or incense holders were affixed to some murals.

Murals without a signed name often included an Instagram account handle, or occasionally referenced a collective organization. Some murals were dated with the year or Mural content frequently depicted imagery and text associated with racial justice for Black people, the Black Lives Matter movement, and related movements expressing solidarity.

Imagery includes: iconography (Black Power fist, multi-racial hands, fists), Black Panther portraits (Angela Davis), plants (poppies), animals (hummingbird, lion, panther), cosmic elements (moon, constellations with the names of those murdered by police), people (hearts; Black protesters in Oakland; portraits of Black individuals, including a woman wearing a Covid-era mask; portraits of Black people murdered by police, including George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Sandra Bland, Oscar Grant, Michael Brown), patterns (waves), symbols (religious, flags, peace sign, Port of Oakland container cranes, the Bay Bridge), and hybrids, including a fist growing from a tree s roots.

In addition to graffiti tags, text (original capitalization not preserved here) includes: For George, Global movement, God s people will rise, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 12 Grow, Know your power, Love heal free, Native lands forever, No fear, No justice, it s just us, No justice no peace, Oakland resilient forever, Peace love justice, Protect life, Save the hood, Say her name, Breonna Taylor, Seize the time, Stay woke, Trust your struggle, Unity, Unity for the people, What are you waiting for, What brings you joy? Black joy is love. Black joy is community, Yellow peril supports Black power. Where people removed murals, we found mullions, window and door frames, fa ades, and sidewalks with paint drippings from brushes and aerosol spray droplets.

Some removed murals were relocated inside storefronts and displayed through glass, either hung from fishing line or resting on the ground or counter. History: Plaza Naming Conventions Frank H. Ogawa Plaza has been known by many names throughout its history: City Hall Park, then City Hall Plaza, and, after World War I, it became Memorial Plaza. It was renamed Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, after the civil rights leader and long-serving Oakland City Council member, in Since the Occupy Oakland movement in the plaza has been colloquially and controversially called Oscar Grant Plaza by many activists organizing in justice movements.9 Plaza Early History City Hall Plaza sits on what was once the East Bay s coastal plain.

It was covered with "wild grass and a cluster of native oak trees."10 Oak trees the city s namesake, logo, and even the genus of the city landmark planted in Oscar Grant Plaza fed the ancestors of the Indigenous Ohlone people who today live in the San Francisco Bay Area.11 The Ohlone, who comprise over fifty independent nations, are one of the Indigenous groups that have lived between Vallejo and Monterey for at least years. More recently, beginning in the eighteenth century, three eras of genocidal occupation controlled the land, spanning control by Spain, Mexico, and the United States of America.12 Today, 8 Ibid. 9 Kim Tran, A More Fitting Way to Honor Oscar Grant, East Bay Express, September 3, 10 Victor Stier, City Plans Rededication of Remodeled Plaza, Oakland Tribune, October 10, 15.

11 Liam O Donoghue, Oakland s Most Iconic Tree is Named After a Socialist Firebrand: Jack London (Of Course), East Bay Express, February 21, 12 Daniel Potter, Who Were the First People to Live in the Bay Area? Bay Curious, KQED, July 15, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 13 the plaza exists on land to whom the Confederated Villages of Lisjan, an Ohlone tribe, belong.13 In the nineteenth century, the parcel comprised part of the "grazing lands of Rancho San Antonio, which stretched from present-day San Leandro to El Cerrito. In the Oakland street grid was laid out as far north as Street by surveyor Julius Kellersberger.

The only other street was San Pablo Road, an old Spanish trail connecting various ranchos of the East Bay."14 By then, "farms and orchards" covered the site and other "land north of Street. upper Broadway and Telegraph Avenue had been laid out and the street grid extended north of Street. In that year, 'City Hall Tract,' bounded by San Pablo Avenue, Clay, and Streets, was surveyed by William Boardman. 15 Land for City Hall and the plaza was purchased from a farmer for When the deal went through the then mayor, Dr. Samuel Merritt, went into hiding for a short time because of violent reactions from citizens who thought the hall should be situated nearer the heart of town, Eighth Street and Broadway.

16 The original plaza was located to the east of the current (third) City Hall and fac[ed] Street...on what is now Washington Street. 17 It was a "fenced, public garden filled with oak trees."18 In the "park was laid . . . out by Chief of Police, David H. Rand."19 The first city hall, "an old wooden hall...burned to the ground August 25, Another hall was built."20 In the third city hall, today's, was complete and the second was demolished. "Washington Street was extended north of Street to San Pablo Avenue, and City Hall Plaza became a separate city block, no longer physically connected to City Hall. 21 During the late and early the plaza was similar to the part plazas play in Mexican and Spanish cities. It was the center of municipal community life.

It had an octagonal shaped wooden bandstand and every Friday night a band gave a concert. Board walks surrounded the park, which was protected by a 13 Lisjan (Ohlone) History & Territory, Sogorea Te Land Trust, accessed July 30, https://sogoreate- 14 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign of City Hall Plaza, Oakland, CA, 2. 15 Ibid. 16 Victor Stier, City Plans Rededication of Remodeled Plaza, Oakland Tribune, October 10, 15. 17 Ibid. 18 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign, 2. 19 Passing of City Hall Park Evokes Reminiscences, Observer, August 16, 5. 20 Victor Stier, City Plans Rededication of Remodeled Plaza, Oakland Tribune, October 10, 15. 21 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign of City Hall Plaza, Oakland, CA, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 14 white picket fence, connected at the corners by a row of 14 hitching posts laid out in an arc. 22 The plaza from almost the beginning had a cannon. Oakland s was captured by Admiral [George] Dewey in Manila. One Fourth of July night, pranksters loaded the old gun with powder to celebrate Independence Day and blew all the windows out of a nearby store.

Because of this the cannon was moved to the gore of Broadway and Telegraph Avenue 23 Jack London, the Oakland-born, renowned writer, socialist, and activist, died in The following year, on January 16, in celebration of Jack London s legacy, a 20-year-old oak was removed from Mosswood Park to the center of the plaza where it stands today.25 In extensive damage throughout Oakland caused by the Loma Prieta earthquake prompted a tree preservation plan for the oak. The City Arborist and a consulting arborist (from PGAdesign, Inc.) noted that poor pruning of the tree caused too much weight at the ends of the branches. A branch failed in breaking another branch while falling, and left a huge hole in the tree s canopy.

New tree management strategies were implemented as a result.26 One-hundred years after the original dedication, the Alameda County Historical Society rededicated the tree in In City Hall Plaza became known as Memorial Plaza in honor of Oakland soldiers who gave their lives for their country. The Board of Park Commissioners granted authorization in to erect a veterans war memorial flagpole at Memorial Plaza on Armistice Day, which is still there today.30 Presumably during World War II, a victory garden was planted in the plaza. In the Information Hut (also known as Plaza Hut, Adobe Hut, and The Hut) was built as a community project and a landmark in City Hall Plaza.

This brick building served as the hub of community hospitality for men in uniform" during WWII to provide information to servicemen on recreation, transportation, cultural activities, sports events, and points of interest in the Metropolitan Oakland area to men mobilizing for Korea (USO Information Center for 22 Victor Stier, City Plans Rededication of Remodeled Plaza, Oakland Tribune, October 10, 15. 23 Ibid. 24 O Donoghue, Oakland s Most Iconic Tree. 25 Ibid. 26 Jack London Oak. Localwiki Oakland Wiki July 29, 27 O Donoghue, Oakland s Most Iconic Tree. 28 Oakland Plaza to be Dedicated as Memorial. City Grounds to be Set Aside in Honor of Those Who Fell in War, Oakland Tribune, May 23, 18. 29 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign, 2. 30 Flagpole On Plaza Okehed.

Oakland Tribune, May 22, 12. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 15 Service Men).31 In subsequent years, it became headquarters for various other drives.32 In post-war years, the plaza s shape further evolved. In April the Information Hut was demolished overnight. Underutilized, the Board of Park Directors decided it should be demolished, thereby opening up a view of the Memorial Plaza from Street and Broadway. 33 This openness remains today; during protests and other large gatherings people move freely between the intersection and the plaza. Around this time, Washington Street became a one- way southbound street, and San Pablo Avenue was made one-way northbound.

34 In the plaza had pools (upper and lower), and a place for a future sculpture when funds were available.35 In November of the Hassler Plaza Fountain was built. A memorial to the late John F. Hassler, Oakland s city manager for 18 years, the fountain was privately financed by the Hassler family, his friends, and fellow workers in the city.36 The fountain and pools were later covered during the drought to make a stage.37 "Early in the San Pablo Avenue was closed at Street, and the present diagonal parking arrangement was introduced.

Washington Street became two- way north of Street, and was closed south of Street to make way for the City Center development."38 In SWA revealed a plan to redesign City Hall Plaza into a people-oriented, "green plaza to soften the urban atmosphere" and included street closures. 39 However, the plan was never implemented due to the uncertainty of the effects of closing Washington Street on City Center garage access and AC Transit bus routes, unresolved questions about access to adjacent businesses due to the closing of San Pablo Avenue, a feeling that the design was not of an appropriate style for the front of City Hall, and general lack of funds. 40 31 USO to Open Center Tonight, Oakland Tribune, June 1, 12. 32 City Hall Plaza Bursts into Bloom.

500 Rhododendrons Replace Landmark Overnight, Oakland Tribune, April 27, 18. 33 Ibid. 34 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign, 2. 35 Stier, City Plans, 15. 36 Hassler Plaza Fountain Unveiled, Oakland Tribune, November 20, 12. 37 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign, 2. 38 Ibid, 3. 39 Tree Preserved. City Plaza Plan Calls for Relaxing Oasis, Oakland Tribune, October 21, 10. 40 City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee, The Redesign, 3. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 16 "On July 1, [the plaza s] name was officially changed to City Hall Plaza and the address of City Hall became One City Hall Plaza."41 s Plaza Renovation Following earthquake, earthquake damage and pedestrian inactivity blighted the plaza, which was "used by the media as a symbol of economic decline."42 The City Hall Plaza Area Revitalization Project (CHPARP) was introduced to provide space for displaced city workers. CHPARP sought to "restore the neighborhood s finest historic buildings, to reaffirm the democratic tradition of a civic plaza and to ignite private investment in an area once given up for dead." The San Pablo Avenue throughways to Street and Street, and the drive-in front of City Hall, would be closed to cars and become pedestrian passageways.

City Hall Plaza would become the public ground it was meant to be. 43 City Hall Plaza, part of the CHPARP Seven Interrelated Projects, planned to restore and expand the plaza to serve as a place for rallies, dignitaries, cultural events, outdoor cafes, an urban greenspace, and a general destination point for tourists and residents. 44 With a capacity of people, a restored City Hall Plaza will serve as a place for concerts, rallies, cultural events, outdoor cafes, and political speeches. The plaza renovation "will make many events possible for the central downtown which simply cannot happen there now (such as big name concerts, sports rallies for the Oakland Athletics, political rallies, etc.).

45 A campus setting program was developed for the plaza, and the city "met with the winner of the plaza design competition, . . ., to discuss modifying the winning Plaza design, given the campus setting program that has been developed."46 In the decade old CHPARP renovation project celebrated the plaza s renaissance and grand re-opening, marking the point at which the plaza took the form that is experienced today.47 Black Lives Matter Protests In the powerful confluence of a global pandemic and increasing mainstream and social media documentation of police killings of Black people 41 Ibid. 42 City of Oakland, City Hall Plaza Area Revitalization Project, Oakland, CA, July 2. 43 Rick DelVecchio, Curtain Rises on New Oakland.

Hopes Pinned on City Hall Extension Plan, San Francisco Chronicle, August 3, A13, A16. 44 City of Oakland, City Hall Plaza, 3. 45 Craig Kocian, City Manager s Report, July 12, 2, 3, 10. 46 Craig, City Manager s Report, 10. 47 Torri Minton, Oakland Celebrates Renaissance of Its Historic Downtown / City hopes new civic center plaza will revitalize area, SF Gate, October 31, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 17 led to an environment out of which significant Black cultural landscapes emerged.

Many called this a double or twin pandemic: loss of life due to the virus and loss of Black life at the hands of state-backed violence.48 The circumstances of the pandemic with much of the country under shelter-in- place orders, and people either working from home or on the frontlines exacerbated and exposed the underlying structural inequity prevalent throughout the country. Varying degrees of access to safety and exposure to risk lead to racially inequitable hospitalization and death rates, particularly for American Indian or Alaska Native, Black or African American, and Hispanic or Latinx people.49,50 Three killings of Black Americans by active and former police officers in the first half of garnered national and global attention: Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, and George Floyd.

Of the three, Floyd became the most prominent. Particularly impactful was the function of social media as a news source and organizing tool. Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin murdered George Floyd on May 25, An explicit video of the murder was immediately and widely shared on social media and inspired the organization of civil disobedience, unrest, and protests across the country beginning that same night.51 Social media continued to play a significant role in communicating quickly and reaching many, for documenting police killings and organizing to call for an to end police violence and for defunding or abolishing the police. Protests occurred across the Bay Area.

As a response to social distancing measures implemented during the pandemic, many protests in Oakland formed as car caravans and bike routes. As a centralized location at the foot of City Hall, Oscar Grant Plaza was the starting or ending place for many Black Lives Matter protests and marches, and a common site for vigils, civil disobedience, and memorials, honoring Black individuals killed by police, during in the following months of 48 Landscape Architecture Magazine with Diane Jones Allen, M. Austin Allen III, Charles Cross, June Grant, Elizabeth Kennedy, Jescelle R. Major, Douglas A.

Williams, The Twin Pandemics, Landscape Architecture Magazine, August 49 Risk for COVID-19 Infection, Hospitalization, and Death By Race/Ethnicity, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, updated July 16, 50 American Civil Liberties Union, The Other Epidemic: Fatal Police Shootings in the Time of COVID-19, American Civil Liberties Union, covid-19. 51 Darwin BondGraham, How 2 Oakland students got people to march against police violence on Monday, Berkeleyside, June 2, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 18 May (George Floyd52,53, Breonna Taylor54) June (Ahmaud Arbery, Tony McDade55) July (Philando Castile, Alton Sterling56) August (Jacob Blake57) September (Breonna Taylor Grand Jury Decision58) Early protests and actions were well-attended.

Two days after George Floyd s murder, two 19-year-old Oakland natives, home from college, organized a protest with Oakland Technical High School students, to show solidarity to Minneapolis and to everybody that lost lives at the hands of police brutality, the hands of the brutal police system We out here for George Floyd, we out here to show love to him, and his family, and to the people explained by Akil Riley, one of the organizers. Gaining support from established local Bay Area justice organizations, approximately people participated. The protest began with speeches and chants at the high school and included pandemic precautions such as face masks, hand sanitizer, and social distancing.

While the route was originally planned to end at the Oakland Police Department Headquarters on Broadway in downtown Oakland, the march was redirected to Oscar Grant Plaza for more speeches.59 At the same moment that thousands marched the two-mile route on Broadway to the Plaza, the Alameda County Sheriff s Office and Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf announced an 8 curfew, with no definite ending date, and threatened protesters who stayed out later with arrest. On June 3, thousands of people met at Oscar Grant Plaza in an act of civil disobedience against the curfew.

The curfew was lifted the next day.60 In addition to the protests mentioned above, many other events within this timeframe used Oscar Grant Plaza as a destination to both uplift and celebrate Black people or decry police brutality and state-backed violence against them, or 52 Ibid. 53 Precious J. Green, Peaceful Oakland Protest Marred by OPD Response, 1A, KALW Public Media, June 2, 54 Ren e Ater, In Memoriam: I Can t Breathe, personal blog, May 29, https://www.reneeater.com/on- 55 Laura Thompson, The Police Killing You Probably Didn t Hear About This Week, Mother Jones, May 29, 56 Ren e Ater, In Memoriam. 57 George Kelly, Oakland: Agitators Vandalize courthouse following mostly peaceful Jacob Blake Protest, East Bay Times, August 26, gather-downtown/.

58 Terry McSweeney, Jean Elle, and Ian Cull, Breonna Taylor Grand Jury Decision Sparks Protests Across the Bay Area, NBC Bay Area, September 24, 59 BondGraham, How Two Oakland Students. 60 Meka Boyle, Oakland Lifts City Curfew After Thousands Defied It Wednesday, San Francisco Public Press, June 4, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 19 both. The events, sometimes organized anonymously and to deter documentation, referred to the plaza as either Oscar Grant Plaza or Frank Ogawa Plaza.

Some events advertised on the Internet include: National Day of Action (June Whatever it takes to bring change: demonstrate against injustice (June 63 Oakland Community in Solidarity with Black Lives Matter (June Juneteenth Stop Police Terror/West Coast Port Shutdown & Caravan, from the Port of Oakland to Oakland City Hall (June Black Women s Pride Rally (June 67 Black Kings March & Peaceful Protest from the Plaza to the Oakland Police Department Headquarters (June Black Lives Matter Mural Art Appreciation and Street Clean-up (June Class of Grads Celebration at New Black Lives Matter Mural (June Fuck the Fourth Rally and March (July Wall of Moms Supporting BLM and Solidarity with Portland and No Fascist Feds in Oakland Rally (July Justice for Jacob Blake Rally and March (August Stand Up Against OPD s Brutality Rally (September Sit, Walk, Listen Because Black Lives Matter (September 61 This event, advertised on Instagram by Any Means Necessary, was organized to meet at Oscar Grant Plaza.

According to the discussion on Instagram, a commenter attending the event noted they relocated the event to East Oakland. While we are unable to confirm the details of every event listed here, this example illustrates the provisional nature of cultural landscapes. The relocation of the event from downtown to East Oakland re-iterates the point that the Plaza was not the only area, or necessarily the most important area, associated with the movement for racial justice in Oakland.

62 joinbamn, Instagram post, June 7, 63 Bay Area Community Services, La Familia Counseling Service, and Legal Services for Prisoners with Children, Whatever it takes to bring change: demonstrate against injustice, Facebook event, accessed July 29, 64 Oakland Community in Solidarity with Black Lives Matter, Funcheap SF, accessed July 29, 65 surbur, Instagram post, June 16, 66 Juneteenth, June 19, JuneteenthSPT, accessed July 29, 67 Black Women s Pride at Oscar Grant Plaza, Funcheap SF, accessed July 29, 68 protestsbayarea, Instagram post, June 12, 69 Oakland: Black Kings March, Do The Bay, accessed July 29, 70 NBC Bay Area staff, Live Blog: Protests, Rallies Continue in Bay Area, NBC Bay Area, July 2, 71 Upcoming List of Bay Area Protests (July-August Funcheap SF, accessed July 29, 72 bayarea.protests, Instagram post, June 23, 73 bayarea.protests, Instagram photo, July 1, 74 Upcoming List of Bay Area Protests (July-August 75 Wall of Many, Vigil for Democracy, Refuse Fascism Bay Area, and Resistance SF, Wall of Moms against Feds in Oakland!

Facebook event, accessed July 29, 76 George Kelly, Oakland: Agitators Vandalize courthouse following mostly peaceful Jacob Blake Protest, East Bay Times, August 26, gather-downtown/. 77 Stand Up Against OPD s Brutality Rally, Funcheap SF, accessed July 29, opds-brutality-rally/. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 20 Public gatherings continued into at Oscar Grant Plaza. As one example, a vigil took place at the plaza on April 12, in memory Daunte Wright, who was killed by police in a suburb of Minneapolis the previous day.79 The size of these events varied. Like the May protest described in detail above, the Juneteenth protest also included thousands of people, where speakers included labor union organizers and activist and philosopher Angela Davis.

When public actions began in May, building and business owners sought to protect their property from vandalism associated with protests and public anger, City Hall, public and private entities covered their doors, windows, and walls with plywood. People literally just immediately went out there and started painting, says Randolph Belle.80 The painting expanded not only to plywood, but also to the asphalt streets and plaza hardscape, commonly with messages relating to the Black Lives Matter movement. The phenomenon of these murals occurred on the plaza s hardscape and on plywood mounted to buildings surrounding Oscar Grant Plaza, as described in the previous section.

While the murals are not unique to Oscar Grant Plaza s location they appeared throughout Oakland and the Bay Area, and weave into a broader tradition of mural painting their continued presence remains after other more ephemeral aspects (such as the protests themselves) have gone. While many murals have been taken down, some remain by summer of History of Protests and Social Action at the Plaza The Black Lives Matter protests were not the first time people came together in this central location to decry racial injustice, though in they were situated within a national and historic context that allowed for greater participation and recognition. Protests on this same site in and are documented moments of protest that brought attention to police brutality and racial discrimination.

A direct link can be drawn from the protests at City Hall Plaza in support of civil rights in Alabama to the Black Lives Matter protests at Oscar Grant Plaza in Archived newspaper articles suggest that the plaza has become a chosen gathering place in part for its direct access to Oakland City Hall. Government officials can readily take notice of protestors actions. Moreover, the plaza is 78 Sit, Walk & Listen Because Black Lives Matter, Funcheap SF, accessed July 29, 79 Brian Boyle and Jungho Kim, Oakland activists honor Daunte Wright with candlelight vigil at Oscar Grant Plaza, San Francisco Gate, April 14, 80 Alex Brady, What is the fate of Black Lives Matter protest murals? Salon, July 25, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 21 sizeable enough to accommodate large gatherings of people, and it is at the heart of downtown Oakland. The local chapter of the Socialist Party organized an early act of protest at the plaza. In member and landmark namesake Jack London was arrested while challeng[ing] the constitutionality of an ordinance that forbade public speaking without the mayor s permission. Notable within the design today is the Forum and the stage, for its form takes from a cultural tradition of using public space for free speech. Over a century ago, London s daughter Joan confirmed the same forms and uses at this plaza when she said, He was hauled off the box and marched to jail.

81 Civil Rights Protests The Plaza had historically been the meeting point for civil rights protests, particularly those in the One notable protest took place on September 18, A civil rights demonstration, comprised of mostly high school students, gathered to protest the killing of four young girls bombed in the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama.83 The protest began at deFremery Park (which soon after became a local meeting place for the Black Panther Party (HALS-CA one mile west of the plaza in West Oakland, and ended at City Hall Plaza.

On March 10, a march protesting police brutality against civil rights demonstrators in Selma, Alabama (Bloody Sunday), began at UC Berkeley, over four miles to the north, and ended at City Hall Plaza, where a second rally took place.85 Information on protests surrounding racial justice at the plaza could not be found during the subsequent decades. Then, two significant renamings of the plaza occurred in association with racial justice. Plaza Renaming In Oakland City Council renamed City Hall Plaza to Frank H. Ogawa Plaza in honor of Oakland s civil rights and civic leader.

Frank Ogawa was first appointed to city council in and remained on the council until his death in He was the first Japanese American on the Oakland City Council and the first Japanese American to hold a city council seat in a major city in the continental US. Ogawa s accomplishments came after a life marked by racial discrimination and resistance. During World War II, Frank Ogawa, his wife, son, and daughter were involuntarily sent to a detention camp where they remained 81 O Donoghue, Oakland s Most Iconic Tree. 82 Andrew Chamings, Oakland in protest: A city of defiance and progress, SF Gate, June 7, 83 Thousands In Rights Parades, Oakland Tribune, September 19, 1.

84 Defremery Park, Oakland Parks and Recreation Foundation, accessed July 29, 85 Floodtide of Protest Sweeps U.S, Oakland Tribune, March 10, 1. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 22 for four years. Frank s daughter, age two, died during internment. After the war, Frank Ogawa and his family returned to Oakland. Ogawa was discriminated against when trying to move his family to a more affluent neighborhood. Undeterred, he purchased his home and became an essential member of the neighborhood and many all-white organizations that sought to exclude him.86 Occupy Oakland The other significant, though unofficial, renaming of Frank Ogawa Plaza occurred 13 years later in tandem with a new wave of protest.

In October Occupy Oakland formed as a local movement that echoed the Occupy Wall Street movement in New York City at the same time, which famously occupied Zuccotti Park in the city s financial district. The protest began as an encampment at the plaza and General Assembly on October 10. The protestors unofficially renamed the plaza for Oscar Grant, a Black resident of the East Bay city Hayward who was shot by a BART police officer in Occupy Oakland s work centered on critiquing police misconduct and brutality.

Throughout the protests, there were numerous reports of beatings and excessive force by police towards protesters.87 From Sunday, November 13, to Monday, November 14, local reporters provided a minute-by-minute account of both the city s eviction of the plaza encampment and the turbulent atmosphere of city politics, including the resignation of the deputy mayor. They also recounted the recent resignations of the mayor s legal adviser, the police chief, and the mayor s crisis communications expert. On Sunday night, around 500 people prepared for an imminent police raid to remove the tents. At A.M. early Monday morning, police from Oakland and nearby cities prepared to do so; in a few hours, they declare[d] crime scene and move[d] out media.

By evening, police and occupiers removed over 100 tents and police arrested 33 people.88 To this day, both names, Frank Ogawa Plaza and Oscar Grant Plaza, are used locally, though Frank H. Ogawa Plaza remains its official name. While this report focuses on the plaza as a historic Black landscape during the Black Lives Matter protests, tracing the current movement of racial justice for Black people back to the local development of the Black Panther Party is a rich, expansive history that is physically embedded and preserved within the city. In our conversation with Belle and Brownfield, they drew from this lineage, to highlight the following points: The renaming of Frank Ogawa Plaza to Oscar Grant Plaza echoes another park renaming. DeFremery Park was a key location 86 Tribute to Frank H.

Ogawa, Congressional Record Vol. No. 96 (July 21, E, 87 About Occupy Oakland, Occupy Oakland, 88 Kristin J. Bender, Sean Maher, Thomas Peele, and Josh Richman, Occupy Oakland Live Blog: Police outnumber protesters at Ogawa plaza, The Mercury News, November 13, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 23 for Black Panther Party community outreach and activism. Bobby Hutton, a Black Panther, was killed by Oakland police on April 6, After his death, the park was unofficially renamed Lil Bobby Hutton Memorial Park. In Oakland City Council unanimously approved an official naming of a grove within the park, Bobby Hutton Grove.

Point Seven of the Black Panther Party s Ten-Point Program connects the long lineage of resistance to police brutality and murder of those mentioned in this report: We want an immediate end to police brutality and murder of Black people, other people of color, and all oppressed people inside the United States. 89 Protests Against Police Killings Between Occupy Oakland s founding in and the protests of two police killings of Black Americans inspired protests located at the plaza. In July Eric Garner was killed by police in Staten Island, New York, and in August, teenager Michael Brown was killed by police in Ferguson, Missouri. Hundreds of people gathered at the plaza on August 14 for a moment of silence in honor of Michael Brown and others killed by police.

The protest was organized by Occupy Oakland and the Labor Solidarity Committee.90 On December 13, the Millions March against police brutality was organized across the country, including New York, Washington, San Francisco, and Oakland. The local protest began at the Plaza.91

Sources

1528 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-157. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

About Occupy Oakland, Occupy Oakland, Aleaziz, Hamed, Greta Kaul, Kurtis Alexander, and John King, Thousands in Oakland join Millions March protests, SF Gate, December 14, American Civil Liberties Union. The Other Epidemic: Fatal Police Shootings in the Time of COVID-19. American Civil Liberties Union, covid-19. 89 The Black Panther Party Ten-Point Program, Dr. Huey P. Newton Foundation, accessed July 29, 90 Demonstrators in Oakland, Berkeley Protest Fatal Missouri Police Shooting of Michael Brown, KPIX CBS SF BayArea, August 15, police-shooting/. 91 Hamed Aleaziz, Greta Kaul, Kurtis Alexander, and John King, Thousands in Oakland join Millions March protests, SF Gate, December 14, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 24 Ater, Ren e. In Memoriam: I Can t Breathe.

Personal blog, May 29, Bay Area Community Services, La Familia Counseling Service, and Legal Services for Prisoners with Children. Whatever it takes to bring change: demonstrate against injustice. Facebook event. Accessed July 29, sion. bayarea.protests. Instagram photo, July 1, bayarea.protests. Instagram post, June 23, Bender, Kristin J., Sean Maher, Thomas Peele, and Josh Richman. Occupy Oakland Live Blog: Police outnumber protesters at Ogawa plaza. The Mercury News, November 13, Black Panther Party Landmarks: A Partial List. Oakland Museum of California. Accessed July 29, party-landmarks. Black Women s Pride at Oscar Grant Plaza. Funcheap SF. Accessed July 29, BondGraham, Darwin. How 2 Oakland students got people to march against police violence on Monday.

Berkeleyside, June 2, Boyle, Brian and Kim, Jungho. Oakland activists honor Daunte Wright with candlelight vigil at Oscar Grant Plaza. San Francisco Gate, April 14, Boyle, Meka. Oakland Lifts City Curfew After Thousands Defied It Wednesday. San Francisco Public Press, June 4, defied-it-wednesday/. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 25 Brady, Alex. What is the fate of Black Lives Matter protest murals? Salon, July 25, Brown, Patricia Leigh. Tree Project Aims to Put the Oak Back in Oakland. New York Times, May 23, oak-back-in-oakland.html. Chamings, Andrew. Oakland in protest: A city of defiance and progress. SF Gate, June 7, City Hall Plaza Bursts into Bloom. 500 Rhododendrons Replace Landmark Overnight. Oakland Tribune, April 27, 18. City Hall Plaza Redesign Committee.

The Redesign of City Hall Plaza. Oakland, CA, 2. City of Oakland. City Hall Plaza Area Revitalization Project. Oakland, CA, July 2. Defremery Park. Oakland Parks and Recreation Foundation. Accessed July 29, DelVecchio, Rick. Curtain Rises on New Oakland. Hopes Pinned on City Hall extension plan. San Francisco Chronicle, August 3, A13, A16. Demonstrators in Oakland, Berkeley Protest Fatal Missouri Police Shooting of Michael Brown. KPIX CBS SF BayArea. August 15, Encyclopaedia Britannica, Oakland, California, United States, accessed July 29, Explore the Black Panther Party s History in Oakland, CA. Visit Oakland, July 23, Flagpole On Plaza Okehed. Oakland Tribune, May 22, 12. Floodtide of Protest Sweeps U.S. Oakland Tribune, March 10, 1. Green, Precious J.

Peaceful Oakland Protest Marred by OPD Response. 1A, KALW Public Media, June 2, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 26 Hassler Plaza Fountain Unveiled. Oakland Tribune, November 20, 12. joinbamn. Instagram post, June 7, Juneteenth, June 19. JuneteenthSPT. Accessed July 29, Kelly, George. Oakland: Agitators Vandalize courthouse following mostly peaceful Jacob Blake Protest. East Bay Times, August 26, Klein, Christopher. How Selma s Bloody Sunday Became a Turning Point in the Civil Rights Movement. History, updated July 18, movement. Kocian, Craig. City Manager s Report. July 12, 2, Landscape Architecture Magazine with Diane Jones Allen, M. Austin Allen III, Charles Cross, June Grant, Elizabeth Kennedy, Jescelle R. Major, and Douglas A. Williams. The Twin Pandemics.

Landscape Architecture Magazine, August pandemics/. Lisjan (Ohlone) History & Territory. Sogorea Te Land Trust. Accessed July 30, Liu, Kenji. Memory is Solidarity: Ogawa-Grant Plaza as Opportunity. Reproductive Justice Blog, November 1, grant-plaza.html Mack, Karen, Mizan Alkebulan-Abakah, De'Ana Brownfield, and K. Kennedy Whiters. Black Lives Matter: Preserving Memories, Stories, and Expressions. Panel discussion at the annual California Preservation Foundation Conference, virtual, June 8, McSweeney, Terry, Jean Elle, and Ian Cull. Breonna Taylor Grand Jury Decision Sparks Protests Across the Bay Area. NBC Bay Area, September 24, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 27 Minton, Torri.

Oakland Celebrates Renaissance of Its Historic Downtown / City hopes new civic center plaza will revitalize area. SF Gate, October 31, Nakano, Andrea. Eighth Day of George Floyd Protests in Oakland Ends Peacefully. KPIX CBS SF BayArea, June 4, NBC Bay Area staff. Live Blog: Protests, Rallies Continue in Bay Area. NBC Bay Area, July 2, New Oakland police policy draws protests. USA Today, May 25, california-protest/27907347/. Oakland Community in Solidarity with Black Lives Matter, Funcheap SF. Accessed July 29, Oakland Plaza to be Dedicated as Memorial. City Grounds to be Set Aside in Honor of Those Who Fell in War. Oakland Tribune, May 23, 18. Oakland: Black Kings March. Do The Bay. Accessed July 29, Oakland Museum of California.

Oakland Arts and Culture Community Lead Effort to Uplift Black Voices via the Preservation and Presentation of Oakland Murals. Accessed July 29, O Donoghue, Liam. Oakland s Most Iconic Tree is Named After a Socialist Firebrand: Jack London (Of Course). East Bay Express, February 21, Palomino, Joaquin. Windows smashed, courthouse lobby set ablaze following huge Saturday night rally in Oakland. San Francisco Chronicle, July 26, Passing of City Hall Park Evokes Reminiscences. Observer, August 16, 5. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 28 P is for Plaza. Oakland Tribune, June 29, Potter, Daniel. Who Were the First People to Live in the Bay Area? Bay Curious, KQED, July 15, in-the-bay-area. protestsbayarea.

Instagram post, June 12, Risk for COVID-19 Infection, Hospitalization, and Death By Race/Ethnicity. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Updated July 16, Stand Up Against OPD s Brutality Rally. Funcheap SF. September 11, Stier, Victor. City Plans Rededication of Remodeled Plaza. Oakland Tribune, October 10, 15. surbur. Instagram post, June 16, The Black Panther Party Ten-Point Program. Dr. Huey P. Newton Foundation. Accessed July 29, Thomas, Babette. How Oakland Community Organizers Are Preserving Street Art That Captures a Historic Moment. Crosscurrents, KALW Public Media. October 7, captures-a-historic-moment. Thompson, Laura. The Police Killing You Probably Didn t Hear About This Week. Mother Jones, May 29, Thousands In Rights Parades. Oakland Tribune, September 19, 1. Tran, Kim.

A More Fitting Way to Honor Oscar Grant. East Bay Express, September 3, honor-oscar-grant-1/. Tree Preserved. City Plaza Plan Calls for Relaxing Oasis. Oakland Tribune, October 21, 10. CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 29 Tribute to Frank H. Ogawa. Congressional Record Vol. No. 96 (July 21, E. Upcoming List of Bay Area Protests (July-August Funcheap SF. Accessed July 29, . USO to Open Center Tonight. Oakland Tribune, June 1, 12. Wall of Many, Vigil for Democracy, Refuse Fascism Bay Area, and Resistance SF, Wall of Moms against Feds in Oakland! Facebook event. Accessed July 29, Weber, Brendan, Rhea Mahbubani, and Bay City News. Donald Trump Has Got to Go : Second Wave of Election Protests Sweeps Bay Area. NBC Bay Area, May 30, protests/66352/.

Historians: Cecilia Distefano Kelly Flairty Cathy Garrett, CA PLA, NVLA, LEED AP, CLARB, ASLA Evan MacGregor Petra Marar, ASLA Adrienne Newton, CA PLA, ASLA Grace Tada, ASLA Kari Tanaka, CA PLA, ULI & Photographers: Cecilia Distefano and Petra Marar, ASLA July 30, Third Place Winner (Tie) - HALS Challenge: Historic Black Landscapes CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 30 Oscar Grant Plaza, officially and commonly known as Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, as seen from the main entrance at Street and Broadway. Petra Marar, June CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 31 Oscar Grant Plaza from the San Pablo Avenue terminus. Cecilia Distefano, July CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 32 Oscar Grant Plaza from near the Street and Broadway Intersection. Petra Marar, June CITY HALL PARK HALS NO.

CA-157 PAGE 33 Two circular protest paintings. In the background is City Hall s entrance. In between, plywood, a No Loitering sign, and barricades. Petra Marar, June CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 34 Detail of Defund the Police mural. Petra Marar, June CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 35 Barricades at City Hall span its fa ade. Petra Marar, June CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 36 City Hall with No Loitering sign. Petra Marar, June CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 37 View from Oscar Grant Park across Street. Cecilia Distefano, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 38 At the Street entrance (left) to Oscar Grant Plaza where Telegraph Avenue merges with Broadway.

Murals depict the Black Panther Party logo, working class Black faces and Black Panther Emory Douglas Seize the Time message. Cecilia Distefano, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 39 This artwork, no longer in place, features an Eagle with bold-colored feathers metamorphosing into an image of Oakland in flames, preceded by a large dollar sign and surrounded by protestors carrying signs and bullhorns. It was painted on a single long board protecting the windows of the Broadway branch of the Chase Bank at the Southeast corner of Street and diagonally across from the main entrance to Oscar Grant Plaza. Cecilia Distefano, CITY HALL PARK HALS NO. CA-157 PAGE 40 Map of Oscar Grant Plaza (Frank H. Ogawa Plaza) Protest Ephemera. Cecilia Distefano and Kelly Flairty,

In context

Oakland, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Alameda County, California 231 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Oakland

24 of 125 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Oakland building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Highland HospitalHALS CA-11147,087 words
Paramount TheatreHABS CAL,1-OAK,9-20,127 words
Oakland Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,1-OAK,16-16,186 words
St. Francis de Sales ChurchHABS CAL,1-OAK,24-15,258 words
First Unitarian Church of OaklandHABS CAL,1-OAK,22-14,198 words
Mission MotelHABS CAL,1-OAK,14-13,306 words
Oakland Harbor Training WallsHAER CAL,1-OAK,28-10,638 words
Wood Street CommonsHABS CA-29757,834 words
Fourth Church of ChristHABS CAL,1-OAK,13-5,772 words
John Breuner & Company BuildingHABS CAL,1-OAK,20-4,641 words
Oakland Army BaseHAER CAL,1-OAK,12-A-4,437 words
J. Mora Moss HouseHABS CAL,1-OAK,2-4,383 words
Southern Pacific Mole & PierHABS CAL,1-OAK,1-4,341 words
Cob on WoodHABS CA-29764,193 words
Pacific Telephone & Telegraph Company BuildingHABS CAL,1-OAK,18-4,074 words
Interurban Electric Railway Bridge Yard ShopHAER CAL,1-OAK.V,1-3,906 words
Lakeshore HighlandsHALS CA-1673,890 words
Brush Street EncampmentHABS CA-29773,613 words
Oakland Army BaseHAER CAL,1-OAK,12-3,488 words
Southern Pacific Railroad Sixteenth Street StationHABS CA-28053,361 words
Interurban Electric Railway Twenty-Sixth Street Junction BridgeHAER CA-22662,967 words
5th Street EncampmentHABS CA-29782,805 words
Governor Pardee HouseHABS CAL,1-OAK,3-2,641 words
Oakland Municipal Rose Garden HALS CA-1062,511 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-157. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.