BlockBefore

Lakeshore Highlands, Bounded by Mandana Boulevard on the north, Excelsior Avenue and Park Boulevard on the south, Lakeshore Avenue on the west, and Carlston Avenue on the east, Oakland

Lakeshore Highlands, Bounded by Mandana Boulevard on the north, Excelsior Avenue and Park Boulevard on the south, Lakeshore Avenue on the west, and Carlston Avenue on the east, Oakland, Alameda County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-167, with a 3,890-word written history.

From the record

“The Lakeshore Highlands development exemplifies a historically significant era of residential development in Oakland, when aesthetics, transportation advances, and new methods of real estate development combined to create a residential typology that reflected national trends and influenced the pattern of residential development in Oakland and beyond.”

Written record, HALS CA-167 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-167 · the record runs 3890 words · one of 198 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

46 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-167. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Bounded by Mandana Boulevard on the north, Excelsior and Park Boulevard on the south, Lakeshore on the west and Carlston Avenue on the east in Oakland, Alameda County, California. Olmsted Job Name and Number: Lake Shore Highlands, (Entry to Lakeshore Highlands on Longridge Road, Google Earth,

Significance

3529 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-167. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Lakeshore Highlands development exemplifies a historically significant era of residential development in Oakland, when aesthetics, transportation advances, and new methods of real estate development combined to create a residential typology that reflected national trends and influenced the pattern of residential development in Oakland and beyond. Lakeshore Highlands became an early model for its developer, Walter H. Leimert Co., in partnership with the Olmsted Brothers, for later developments along the West Coast. Leimert attributed the success of Lakeshore Highlands notably to its homeowners association, one of the earliest in the West Coast.

The association and its governing documents, still operating, guide and regulate the occupancy and use of lots, buildings, and use of common park areas. The impact of this mechanism, popularized alongside the development pattern, is both site-specific and far-reaching. Some restrictions are defunct, like the racial covenant restricting the race of homeowners and residents, while others remain, requiring lots to be used only for single family homes and grass to be well-mowed. As a result, the location, appearance, construction pedigree, and design integrity of Lakeshore Highlands continues to express the story of this significant era of residential development in Oakland.

Description: Landscape Features Street Layout and Topography The site s topography was a driving force in the development of this property. Three major streets Mandana, Longridge and Rosemount/Sunnyhills run east to west at ridgelines following the topography. The shorter streets in the eastern portion of the development also are parallel to the topographic contours. Mandana was planned as an arterial having greater width in the street right-of- way and the planting strips. The street is 50 wide with 6 sidewalks on both sides, a 6 planting strip on the north and a 16 planting strip on the south. Other streets in the development are narrower 24 wide road with 6 sidewalks and planting strips that vary from 2 to 11 . For example, Rosemount has a LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO.

CA-167 PAGE 2 narrower street, 5 sidewalks and planting strips that are only 26 wide these reductions make the street feel less gracious. The generous widths of street cross sections are further enhanced by deep setbacks of homes which vary from 20 to 28 from the property line. Throughout the development the road alignment includes gentle curves. Pedestrian Circulation Because this neighborhood was intended to utilize the streetcar network, care was taken in the design to accommodate pedestrians. The generous sidewalks throughout the development are the primary component of the pedestrian circulation. The sidewalks are concrete with a consistent scoring pattern throughout. Most lots include a paved connection between the curb and sidewalk.

In most cases this consists of a path of 6 wide plain concrete. In other locations the material and width match the path materials of the adjacent home. In addition, the planners incorporated narrow pedestrian paths and stairways that enabled residents to take a shortcut between streets to access the streetcar. Connecting paths are shown on the master plan at regular intervals. Several occur between private lots while others utilize the park spaces to provide the pedestrian connection. They all have a north-south orientation leading to the streetcar line. Most involved traversing steep sections of the topography so incorporated steps.

Landscape Features Planting The Lakeshore Highlands master plan drawing dated February by the Olmsted Brothers firm shows very regular plantings of street trees. Typically, trees are shown close to the property lines between parcels, and when planted in a widened planting strip the placement of the tree is shown close to the curb not in the middle of the planting strip. While few planting plans from that era exist it appears today that black oaks (Quercus kelloggi) were specified for Mandana providing a broad canopy to shade both parked cars and the sidewalk. Sycamore (Platanus acerifolia) were planted on Longridge and Sunnyhills.

A planting plan for the entrance to the development at Lakeshore and Longridge shows Peppermint Gum (Eucalyptus amygdalina) as the primary street tree, Santa Cruz Ironwood (Lyonothamnus floribundus asplenifolius) on Mandana and Black Acacia (Acacia melanoxylon) on Wesley Avenue. A portion of Lakeshore is included and was to be planted with Peppermint Gum. The plant list on the plan for the entrance lists a total of thirty-five species not all of which are used on this particular plan, which suggests that it may have been intended as a plant list for the entire development. The species include LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 3 other trees, shrubs, perennials and vines all of which are typically drought tolerant, sturdy enough for urban conditions and many known to be fast growing.

A separate plan dated October shows a typical planting plan for the sidewalk planting strip. This drawing, which does not identify a street name, shows Carolina Poplar (Populus x canadensis) and Lombardy Poplar (Populus nigra Italica ) street trees with four different shrub species planted in clusters between trees. The layout left gaps between shrubs to provide for circulation. The shrub species shown are Laurustinus (Viburnum tinus), cross-leaved speedwell (Veronica decussada), Japanese euonymus (Euonymus japonicus) and coast tea tree (Leptospermum laevigatum). Parks In addition to street trees and generous planting strips the plan incorporates eight small parks. These occur where the grades are too steep to build on or where street mergers leave small triangular-shaped parcels.

The two largest of these parks are linear. One, now known as Oak Grove, fills the space behind lots that face Mandana and Longridge. A duff covered footpath extends through the park with occasional benches. Across the width of the park there is substantial grade-change; the path is set at approximately mid-slope. Some homeowners have added backyard gates that enable them to access the path. It is a pleasant shady space. There is a similar, yet smaller space and a little park off the east end of Mandana. The parks that fill the left-over triangular spaces are planted with trees, shrubs and ground cover. They have places to sit and one at Longridge and Rosemount has a little free library and an interpretive sign about the history of the Lakeshore Highlands development.

The teardrop shaped park at the center of Hillcroft Circle features a specimen dawn redwood (Metasequoia glyptostroboides) that shelters a bench in its shade. The park at the gore of Rosemount and Sunnyhills is densely shaded by a grove of Paperbark trees (Melaleuca linariifolia). The understory is compacted earth with a few shrubs at the perimeter, plus benches and a terrific tree swing in the middle of the park. This park has a significant grade change at its widest point. At the gore of Northdale and Sunnyhills there is another specimen Melaluca surrounded by juniper and a low stone wall. The park on Longridge and Carlson is one of the few on level ground. Like the other parks it is planted with a variety of trees, shrubs and groundcover and has wide mulched paths and benches.

Character Defining Features LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 4 A notable character defining feature of the development is the lack of fences or hedges that define property lines. Lot widths are very consistent and the space between homes is narrow, i.e., 5 side setbacks. If individual lots were marked off by fences, particularly on their front property line, it would change the feeling of the neighborhood profoundly. The lack of fences creates a gracious, open feeling. Changes in plant species and paving materials from lot to lot is sufficient for demarking ownership. The deep front yard setbacks are also character-defining.

It is notable that the Olmsted Brothers firm and the Wickham Havens development company chose to give more space to the public front yards while minimizing backyards. Many of the residents have added benches in their front yards that, whether empty or occupied, imply a desire to be actively engaged with the public realm. The lighting is noteworthy in that power lines are undergrounded a tremendous enhancement to the neighborhood and something rarely done in most neighborhoods of Oakland. Light fixtures are ornamental iron posts with acorn lamps. There are matching gateway features at Lakeshore and Trestle Glen and at Lakeshore and Longridge. Each consists of highly ornamented wrought iron posts and fencing.

Integrated light fixtures shown in the original drawing details were either never completed or have been removed. Lakeshore Homes Association, and the associated governing documents, (Declaration of Restrictions [as they were originally called, and are often known as s, Covenants, Conditions, & Restrictions]), Bylaws, Articles of Incorporation) are a character defining feature of the subdivision. These documents empower the association to enforce a wide range of restrictions in the subdivision. All homeowners are dues-paying members through their deed. The Association and these restrictions covered the broader Lakeshore Highlands development, which included, in addition to Lakeshore Highlands, Lakeshore Glen, South Lakeshore Glen, and Lakeshore Hills.

Restrictive clauses that have an enduring impact on landscape character address: minimum cost of homes, prohibition of nuisances and non-residential use of buildings, limiting each lot to one single-family home, park and lighting maintenance, tree removal, heights of fences and hedges, easements and rights of way, setbacks, and, originally, a racial covenant. Changes Over Time Plantings: In the predominant tree on Mandana is still black oak - some that appear to be original trees and many that have been replanted, plus a few other species added. LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 5 Sycamore remains the dominant tree species on Longridge and Rosemount. These have been pollarded. The planting strips are as individual as the adjacent homes.

The understory plantings are mostly planted with a large variety of shrubs and a few have turfgrass. Many are planted with lawns and others a random collection of shrubs in great variety. There are no remaining Eucalyptus trees at the Lakeshore entry nor is there a median that appeared on the plan. Existing species here are crape myrtle (Lagerstroemia indica) and brush box (Lophostema confertus). On the shorter streets like Hubert (now Paramount) and Grosvenor it is difficult to ascertain the original species. Pedestrian Circulation: Most of the original shortcut pedestrian paths and stairs still exist and have been maintained. In some cases, concrete has been added or replaced. Handrails have been added.

Some paths have deteriorated to the point of being unusable and some have disappeared completely, or it is possible that they were never built. Parks: Detailed plans of the original park designs are not available. What exists in is likely different but similar to what was originally designed. These spaces continue to offer a mixture of plantings and places to sit. They do not include play or exercise equipment. Removal of the Electric Railway: The master plan shows the route of the planned electric railway that was to run parallel with Longridge, Rosemount, Northvale and Underhill on the south side of the development. When the track and trestle were removed new homes were constructed on either side of a new street named Trestle Glen Road.

Details of the new development are similar in character to those found in Lakeshore Highlands so this change could be seen as an enhancement in that it provided more quality housing, or as a negative because of the loss of public transit. Loss of Open Space at the Entrance: As planned there was a large open space in front of the paired sets of entry gates at Lakeshore between Longridge and Trestle Glen Road. A semicircle was ringed with trees. Today that space is occupied by a two-story commercial building, incongruous in its style and siting within the curved space. The building and vegetation fill the planned open space and blocks the view of the ornamental gates at the entrance.

Freeway Encroachment: At some point, probably in the Excelsior Avenue was widened and converted to an onramp to highway Caltrans s insensitive approach cut through this portion of the development that was already compromised by its separation from the rest of the development. Alma Avenue and Chatham Road abruptly terminate in an oversized concrete block wall. The LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 6 remnants of this neighborhood feel disjointed and crammed between a busy freeway and Park Boulevard, a major arterial. Evolution of the Declaration of Restrictions: The association has amended its governing documents in various ways over the century of its existence.

One significant amendment was made to the development s racial restrictions following a federal ruling on civil rights and homeownership. The original "carefully worked out" declaration included "Clause XIV Limitation of Ownership: No person of African, Japanese, Chinese, or of any Mongolian descent, shall be allowed to purchase, own or lease said property or any part thereof or to live upon said property or any part thereof except in the capacity of domestic servants of the occupant thereof." The Association removed this racial covenant from the document in although the U.S. Supreme Court Case Shelley v. Kraemer had rendered it legally unenforceable decades earlier.

History: Before colonization and occupation, this site was used by seasonal Ohlone Indian communities and retained the moniker Indian Gulch through the second half of the century. In the land came under the ownership of the Peralta family via a massive Spanish Land Grant that covered most of what is now Alameda County and was used primarily for grazing cattle. Following incorporation in residential settlement in Oakland clustered close to the urban core and was limited by the distance people could travel by foot or horse between their homes and their workplaces. This changed in with the establishment of a horsecar line that ran from First Street and Broadway, onto Telegraph Avenue, and up to Street.

The introduction of a network of electric trolley systems after transformed the geographic spread of residential development in Oakland and opened up hilly and remote sections that had previously been difficult to access. Electric trolleys profoundly shaped the course of residential construction in Oakland: 191 subdivision plats were filed in the 30 years prior to universal transit electrification, while in the 30 years between and this number rose to By over 85% percent of building permits issued for residential construction were issued for sites within three blocks of a trolley line. Lakeshore Highlands subdivision reflects this era of residential transformation in Oakland.

In the the area came under the ownership of the Norwegian American banker Peder Sather, and his estate became known in the decades after his death in as Sather Park. In transportation magnate F. M. Borax Smith constructed a large wooden train trestle across the area s natural topography and extended an existing trolley line from downtown Oakland up Park Boulevard all the way to Grosvenor Place. This trolley line brought a steady stream of picnickers and LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 7 other recreational activity seekers to the area and connected what had previously been regarded as a remote section of the city to the developed area of Oakland. In real estate magnate Frank C. Havens joined with F. M. Smith to form the Realty Syndicate Real Estate Development Company.

Together they built trolley lines convenient to potential real estate development, and in turn amassed land for real estate development adjacent to trolley lines. The Realty Syndicate acquired the Sather Estate in and began the area s transformation from parkland to residential settlement. In the newly established Lakeshore Highlands Company, with Wickham Havens as president and Walter H. Leimert as a founding partner, filed a subdivision map covering a portion of what had been the Sather Estate. This subdivision was called Lakeshore Highlands. To create a distinct residential environment in Lakeshore Highlands, Havens and Leimert retained the landscape design services of the Olmsted Brothers. Frederick Law Olmsted Jr.

and John Charles Olmsted were designers of national recognition, working after the style of their pioneering father, Frederick Law Olmsted, who had designed New York's Central Park, Oakland s Mountain View Cemetery, and some of the nation s earliest suburban neighborhoods. The Olmsted model of planning advanced the work of British urban theorist Ebenezer Howard. Howard s book The Garden Cities of Tomorrow advocated for the integration of architecture, planning, and landscape design to create multifaceted residential parks. These residential parks were seen as a healthful, sustainable alternative to the unplanned, dense residential environments that had heretofore characterized urban residential settlement.

Adding their own naturalistic emphasis by incorporating existing topography in the development of street plans, Frederick Law Olmsted and the continued work of his sons firm created a suburban typology that has had a lasting effect on American suburban planning. This is exemplified in their work in Lakeshore Highlands. The development was promoted as an exclusive subdivision, ideal for a professional class of workers who desired an easy commute to Oakland or San Francisco. To make permanent this promise of both the landscape s aesthetic and culture of exclusivity, Walter H. Leimert established the still-extant Lakeshore Homes Association and Declarations of Restrictions.

This selling point was included in Oakland Tribune newspaper advertisements from and respectively: "These tracts are permanently restricted to fine residences ," and "here sensible building restrictions insure [sic] a permanent and distinctive home environment." Commuting and transportation drove much of the development s layout. The area was serviced by the Key Route s B Line, which was routed through downtown Oakland, up Grand Avenue, across Lakeshore Avenue, and entered LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 8 the neighborhood in the tree-lined ridge just north of Trestle Glen Road, terminating at a small station on Underhills Road. The line, like others of the Key Route System, connected to San Francisco via ferry service at the Key Route Pier.

In a advertisement for Lakeshore Highlands published in The San Francisco Bulletin, developer Walter H. Leimert emphasized the Key Route trolley s metaphorical ability to fly a resident of Lakeshore Highlands from their new home to their workplace in San Francisco. However, the trolley system at this time was being challenged by a rise in automobile ownership. Henry Ford began to mass produce the Ford Model T around and by American consumers were purchasing over three million automobiles annually. This rise in automobile ownership can be noted in the rapid shift in the promotional materials associated with Lakeshore Highlands.

As early as Walter Leimert, in contrast to the flying trolley pictured several years earlier, was describing Lakeshore Highlands in terms of its motoring distance to downtown Oakland: ...a veritable fairyland of rolling hills and wooded dales right in the heart of Oakland near famous Lake Merritt and its flower filled parks six minutes by motor car from Oakland City Hall. The importance of the new era of automobile ownership can be seen in the physical form of the homes constructed in the neighborhood. In general, the inclusion of single and double automobile garages was not an afterthought but rather integral to the placement of the dwelling on the lot.

Constructed at the same time as the dwelling, and often matching the dwelling in both material and style, the automobile garage was an important complementary component of the site plan. Many dwellings in Lakeshore Highlands are sited slightly off-center, to accommodate a driveway and garage. Further, on many lots, the garage was not hidden from the streetscape, but placed in a way to be visible directly from the street. Lakeshore Highlands also illustrates the changing relationship between residential development companies, home builders, and homeowners during this era of residential development. This era marks the evolution of the subdivision.

Prior to the century, residential development surrounding cities took place in small incremental steps, and areas grew slowly as new housing was constructed adjacent to existing housing. However, directly after the turn of the century, companies like the Realty Syndicate and its subsidiary the Lakeshore Highlands Company began to purchase larger tracts of land and subdivide them, carving out attractive street plans, installing basic infrastructure improvements, and creating individual building sites. These sites could in turn be sold at a profit, either to independent home builders or, more commonly, to small, medium, or large-scale home building companies, which constructed homes on speculation, or spec, and sold them to private home buyers. LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO.

CA-167 PAGE 9 While some people who purchased lots in Lakeshore Highlands and other subdivisions contracted directly with architects to design their new homes, houses were most often built on spec by builders. Spec builders, talented craftsmen, largely eschewed designing homes individually and generally relied on pattern books to design and construct homes. Pattern books emerged in the second half of the century and offered standardized plans and elevations for homebuilders. The most influential pattern book, authored by Andrew Jackson Downing in promoted period revival styles including Italianate, Tudor Revival, Gothic Revival, and other European influenced design styles.

Patterns often relied on a similar basic form with variation in specific design details such as doors, windows, and fa ade treatments. This format allowed builders such as Fred N. Strang to construct multiples of homes while retaining a visually appealing sense of variety. The decorative elements of many of the properties within Lakeshore Highlands subdivision, constructed by Strang and other builders, indicates a strongly likelihood that pattern books played a role in shaping residential development in Lakeshore Highlands.

Sources

113 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-167. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Bagwell, Beth. Oakland: The Story of a City. Presidio Press: Novato, CA, Farr, Stacy and Betty Marvin. City of Oakland Heritage Property Application for 676 Longridge Road. Declaration of Restrictions. Lakeshore Glen, South Lakeshore Glen, and Lakeshore Hills. Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws of Lakeshore Homes Association. Kitazawa, Yosuke. Walter H. Leimert and the Selling of a Perfect Planned Community. KCET, September 19, Accessed: July 22, perfect-planned-community. Lakeshore Homes Association. Oakland, California. Accessed: July 22, http://lakeshorehomes.net/. Shefler, Deborah. Lakeshore Highlands: Twenties Residence Park in Trestle Glen. Oakland Heritage Alliance News. Vol. 8, No.

1, Spring United States Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Frederick Law Olmsted National Historic Site, accessed July 28,

Written history

129 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-167. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Stacy Farr, Architectural Historian, Chris Pattillo, FASLA, HALS Northern California Chapter, Petra Marar, Ellen Monroe, and Cathy Garrett, PGAdesign and Betty Marvin, Planner III, Historic Preservation, City of Oakland. LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 10 July 30, Third Place Winner - HALS Challenge: Olmsted Landscapes Entry gate at Longridge Road looking toward Lakeshore Avenue. Photo by Chris Pattillo June LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 11 Stairs from Hillcroft Circle to Larkspur Rd. Photo by Chris Pattillo June LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO. CA-167 PAGE 12 Looking up Longridge from the entry gate showing the gently curving street alignment, wide planting strips and pollarded sycamore street trees. Photo by Chris Pattillo June LAKESHORE HIGHLANDS HALS NO.

CA-167 PAGE 13 Teardrop shaped park at Larkspur. Photo by Chris Pattillo June

In context

Oakland, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Alameda County, California 231 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Oakland

24 of 125 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Oakland building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Highland HospitalHALS CA-11147,087 words
Paramount TheatreHABS CAL,1-OAK,9-20,127 words
Oakland Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,1-OAK,16-16,186 words
St. Francis de Sales ChurchHABS CAL,1-OAK,24-15,258 words
First Unitarian Church of OaklandHABS CAL,1-OAK,22-14,198 words
Mission MotelHABS CAL,1-OAK,14-13,306 words
City Hall ParkHALS CA-15711,540 words
Oakland Harbor Training WallsHAER CAL,1-OAK,28-10,638 words
Wood Street CommonsHABS CA-29757,834 words
Fourth Church of ChristHABS CAL,1-OAK,13-5,772 words
John Breuner & Company BuildingHABS CAL,1-OAK,20-4,641 words
Oakland Army BaseHAER CAL,1-OAK,12-A-4,437 words
J. Mora Moss HouseHABS CAL,1-OAK,2-4,383 words
Southern Pacific Mole & PierHABS CAL,1-OAK,1-4,341 words
Cob on WoodHABS CA-29764,193 words
Pacific Telephone & Telegraph Company BuildingHABS CAL,1-OAK,18-4,074 words
Interurban Electric Railway Bridge Yard ShopHAER CAL,1-OAK.V,1-3,906 words
Brush Street EncampmentHABS CA-29773,613 words
Oakland Army BaseHAER CAL,1-OAK,12-3,488 words
Southern Pacific Railroad Sixteenth Street StationHABS CA-28053,361 words
Interurban Electric Railway Twenty-Sixth Street Junction BridgeHAER CA-22662,967 words
5th Street EncampmentHABS CA-29782,805 words
Governor Pardee HouseHABS CAL,1-OAK,3-2,641 words
Oakland Municipal Rose Garden HALS CA-1062,511 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-167. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.