This building is a contributing structure to the Oakland Downtown district. The Oakland Cultural Heritage Survey describes the district as, "...an architecturally, historically, and functionally distinct area within central Oakland. It contains the City Hall and a strong concentration of well- preserved commercial buildings from about to spanning two boom periods for Oakland, the East Bay response to the San Francisco earthquake and fire of and the intense real estate and financial growth of the These urbane, mostly Beaux-Arts inspired buildings display a general unity of style and scale, and represent many of the better-known Bay Area commercial architects of the period.
In their siting and relation to each other, with 17-21-story "skyscrapers" punctuating lower construction, they represent an urban design termed "ideal" by City Beautiful planner Werner Hegemann in and gave Oakland a distinctive and much-photographed skyline.
Downtown's development was one of a series of distinct stages whereby Oakland's commercial center moved north along Broadway from its original waterfront location in the to Uptown (around in the The economics of the era in which the and Broadway district developed made it Oakland's office and financial center, in contrast to the Old Oakland district alterations and demolitions, in their historic relationships to one another, skyscrapers spaced among lower buildings creating a still-distinctive downtown Oakland skyline." The Coakley Hotel is one of several small residential hotels in the downtown district and is of interest for its use of reinforced concrete in a small-scale Colonial Revival building.
According to the Oakland Cultural Heritage Survey: "It contributes to a downtown historic district in age, scale, and use, and is typical of the clustering of hotels and smaller-scale buildings on the edges of the district." Description: The Coakley Hotel is a rectangular three-story, reinforced concrete structure with a basement level, retail space on the ground floor and 20 residential units above. The California Department of Parks and Recreation Office of Historic Preservation Primary Record, prepared by Bruno Giberti, states, "The street facade is finished in stucco, painted yellow with beige accents.
The site is an inside lot; the building is rectangular in plan and designed to be attached." The street facade consists of a storefront and two building entries; one to the two upper stories and one to the basement; two, two-story polygonal wood bays above; a bracketed, COAKLEY HOTEL HABS No. CA-2647 (Page 2) sheet-metal cornice with a red tile roof; a parapet with projecting piers at either end. "The bays have paneled spandrels, double-hung wood windows with leaded-glass transoms, modillion-block cornices, and flat roofs. Other windows are also double-hung wood. There is a metal fire-escape on the south side of the building, a light court on the east, and a penthouse clad in sheet metal on the roof.
The first floor has been extensively altered; only the transom and panel over the entry appear to be original." Openings at the rear facade include a roll-up door at the ground level and four double- hung windows on the upper levels. The interior of the building is composed of four levels: a basement, a first floor retail space and two floors of residential units. The basement extends six feet beneath the sidewalk, with a sidewalk elevator at the southwest corner. The space is divided longitudinally by a row of 8"x 8" wooden posts and is broken into two main spaces by a wall that connects with the light court.
The first floor retail space runs the length of the building along the eastern side with a retail space at the front, utility spaces including a lavatory, toilet room and kitchen at the central light court, and a rear storage area running the full width of the building. A storage loft extends above the utility spaces. Extensive remodeling at this floor has left minimal amounts of historic detail intact. Remaining historic fabric in the front /retail space includes the scored plaster wainscot. The second floor is accessed by a long stairway corridor that runs along the western edge of the building. The second and third floors have identical layouts and consist of a central corridor with sleeping rooms on each side, terminating at the north end with a communal kitchen.
Each of these floors contains ten sleeping rooms with lavatory and closet, and a communal toilet, shower room and kitchen. Four lightwells, now covered, originally ventillated the toilet and shower rooms and several of the sleeping rooms. Toward the rear of the building, along the west wall, a winding staircase leads to the roof and to the basement. These top two levels of the building appear to be minimally altered. Typical finishes include wooden baseboards throughout, and wooden chair rails in the kitchen areas. Historical Context: According to the Oakland Cultural Heritage Survey: "Building permit was issued January 26, for a lodging house and stores at a projected cost of The builder was Carl Jacobsen, and the architect D.L Coleman. City directories from to list a David C.
Coleman as an architect residing at Dover in Oakland; other works have not yet been found. The owner was listed as James Coakley of Coakley Bros. COAKLEY HOTEL HABS No. CA-2647 (Page 3) Meats, an Oakland business since the From to about the meat company occupied the storefront of the Coakley Hotel. James' son, J. Frank Coakley became District Attorney of Alameda County in