Innovative and radically different design approach in the museum design concept dropped a majority of the building below grade and created an overgrown villa with plants, maintaining a natural relationship between a site and its surroundings. History: Occupying four city blocks, the current site of the Oakland Museum was initially a marshy inlet. In Oakland mayor, Dr. Samuel Merritt, proposed and funded construction of a dam at the Street Bridge and turned the surrounding area from a tidal slough into a lake (Lake Merritt in Oakland, California). Inspired by the City Beautiful movement in the United States and under the aegis of Oakland Mayor Frank K.
Mott, the City of Oakland embarked on several city improvements, including new parks, libraries and museums, including the Oakland Public Museum Oakland Art Gallery and Snow Museum predecessors of today's Oakland Museum of California. The stock market crash of eliminated the idea of a new museum complex. All three museums struggled during the Great Depression and World War II. In Paul Mills, then a part-time curator, proposed a new building to house new collections that would feature Californian art. Voters passed a million bond issue to construct a new museum. All three separate city-owned facilities would be combined to form the new Oakland Museum of California.
Architect Eero Saarinen, who was commissioned originally to design the museum, unexpectedly died, and a competition was established to find a new architect. Architects Kevin Roche (surviving business partner of Saarinen) and John Dinkeloo won the contract out of 37 entrants in with an innovative design; they maintained a natural relationship with the site and its surroundings by setting much of the building below grade and creating a seven acre green city park its roofs. This design was part of the "mega block" thinking of the Three basic materials were used in the architecture: concrete, plate glass, and wood. Roche and Dinkeloo and Associates (Connecticut) and Reynolds and Chamberlain Associate Architects (Oakland, California) made up the architects' team.
Landscape architect Dan Kiley (Charlotte, Vermont), local landscape architect Geraldine Knight Scott, and local horticultural advisor Mai Arbegast comprised the landscape architecture team; Heuttig & Schromm of Palo Alto was the landscape contractor. Kiley envisioned an overgrown villa with a primarily OAKLAND MUSEUM OF CALIFORNIA HALS NO. CA-20 PAGE 2 evergreen and a color palate limited to red, white and blue/purple. Scott was hired as Mr. Kiley's consultant on design and knowledge of Californian plants. Together, they worked on the technical and aesthetic aspects of the planting design and the gardens showcase over thirty-five thousand native and exotic species, "suited to the dry climate and shallow concrete planters as extensions of the museum's exhibits".
To achieve the overgrown villa appearance, plantings started in and were maintained and nurtured for three years before the museum's opening in after an extremely wet winter. At the time, the Museum took radically different and ground-breaking design risks with its roof gardens. Technical information about roof gardens was scarce and post-war roof gardens were so new that their ultimate success or failure was still unknown. The Museum's roofs were waterproofed with the latest built-up asphaltic membrane, with a life expectancy of about 15 years. To prevent the soil from washing away, a filter barrier was crucial.
Since polypropylene filter fabric would not be developed until the late burlap was wrapped around perforated pipe which allowed water to flow and temporarily prevented soil from entering the drains. The irrigation was designed originally as a state-of-the-art galvanized system with fertilizer solution injected into the irrigation system. The roofs structural slab dictated the garden's load limitations. For soil, a UC Davis soil mix was used by nurseries starting plants in containers- 40% sand, 60% redwood sawdust and a mix of peat moss and fir bark for acid-loving plants. The soil was easy to mix uniformly, drained well, yet retained enough moisture to promote growth.
While the museum was hailed for its pioneering design, a number of its techniques, innovative for the were untested and proved to have flaws. Early after construction, leaks appeared due to poorly graded roofs and planters, and decayed burlap allowed sand to drain into pipes without sand traps or cleanouts. Since a protective concrete slab did not cover the waterproofing which was done at Oakland's Kaiser Center was in on warm days, the low melting point of the built-up tar membrane oozed from expansion joints, connections around wall light fixtures, and openings around steeling railings.
Fertilizer in the irrigation system accelerated the corrosion of the pipes' interiors and loose corroded particles clogged the spray heads; fluctuations in the water pressure caused the irrigation reduced the throw of spray heads, and plants with different watering needs were grouped together on the same valve. Since the organic material in the UC Davis soil mix broke down and was not replaced regularly; soils shrank between and in some planters, up to leaving plantings stranded on insufficient depths of sand, a quick draining material low in organic matter. Many Californian public gardens faced several major challenges: the freeze of the drought of and Proposition 13. For the Oakland Museum, OAKLAND MUSEUM OF CALIFORNIA HALS NO.
CA-20 PAGE 3 the freeze of killed all of the tender plants, including bougainvillea, eugenia, and carissa which were either replaced with other species or not at all. Two years of continuous drought in and destroyed other plants and required strict water rationing measures. Proposition 13 affected the personnel budget and reduced the full time garden staff from six to two people. As the Museum's anniversary loomed, renovation work became crucial. With the Museum's architectural complexity, a thorough investigation and analysis of its problems was needed first. Between and the Museum's landscaped areas underwent exploratory work and analysis and portions of the planting and irrigation plans were renovated. The Oakland Museum was designated a City of Oakland landmark in...
In December the California Cultural and Historical Endowment Board has specified for the Oakland of Museum Foundation.