The Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) is a long-range program that documents and interprets historically significant engineering sites and structures throughout the United States. HAER is part of Heritage Documentation Programs (Richard O Connor, Manager), a division of the National Park Service United States Department of the Interior. The Transformer House recording project was undertaken by Galvin Preservation Associates (GPA) for the Southern California Edison Company (SCE) in cooperation with Justine Christianson, HAER Historian SCE initiated the project with the intention of making a donation to As recommended by Justine Christianson a vital component of the report documents changes in operating machinery that have occurred over time.
Archaeologist Crystal West (SCE) oversaw the project and provided access to the site. Historian Andrea Galvin (GPA) served as project leader. Architectural Historian Matthew Weintraub (GPA) served as the project historian. James Sanderson produced the large format photographs. The field team consisted of Andrea Galvin (GPA), Matthew Weintraub (GPA), Crystal West (SCE), Neil Sliger (SCE), James Sanderson (photographer) and Matthew Pegler (photographer assistant). Researchers can be directed to also see: HAER No. CA-145-2, Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2; HAER No. CA-145-2-A, Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Lake Sabrina Dam; and HAER No. Ca-145-2-B, Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Powerhouse No. 2.
Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-2-C (Page 3) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History of Building: The physical history of the Transformer House was determined by reviewing original construction drawings including architectural elevations,1 a foundation plan,2 and a roof plan.3 Also, drawings for alterations to the Transformer House which occurred after its original construction were reviewed.4 These plans were retained by the power companies that successively owned and operated the plant (currently SCE).
In addition, articles describing construction and operation of the power plant which originally appeared in the trade journals Journal of Electricity Power and Gas5 and Electrical World6 and reprinted by SCE were reviewed. They included a series of articles written by Charles O. Poole, who served as chief engineer of the Nevada-California Power Company. The building itself provided physical evidence of its history and development via field inspection,7 as did historical photographs and contemporary drawings in the possession of SCE.
Further information was found in previously completed HAER documentation8 and evaluations of eligibility for listing in the National Register of Historic Places.9 These sources provided thorough and detailed information regarding the historic design, construction, improvement and operation of the building. 1 Nevada-California Power Company Plans for Transformer House To Accompany Power House No. 2. Elevation of Northeasterly End, Sheet 1 of 5, March Elevation of Southeasterly Side, Sheet 2 of 5, March 2 Transformer Plan, Sheet 3 of 5, March revised March 2, and May 22, 3 Roof System Transformer House No.
2, Sheet 5 of 5, March 4 California Electric Power Company, Transformer House General Arrangement, Sheet 2 of 4, April 4, first revised September 25, most recent revision December 9, SCE, Transformer House Electrical Equipment Plan, February 14, first revised July 29, most recent revision May 4, SCE, Transformer House Electrical Equipment Section Evaluation, February 16, first revised July 21, most recent revision December 9, 5 Rudolph W. Van Norden, System of Nevada-California Power Company and the Southern Sierras Power Company. Part 1 Power Plants, Properties and Power Developments of the Nevada-California Power Company and the Southern Sierras Power Company. Reprinted from the Journal of Electricity Power and Gas, Volume XXXI, Numbers July p. 6 C. O.
Poole, Hydraulic and electric features of stations No. 2 and No. 3 of the Nevada-California Power Company Tailrace water of former discharges directly into intake of latter, Power Development and Transmission Systems of The Nevada-California Power Company and the Southern Sierras Power Company, p. Reprinted from Electrical World, New York, 7 Field inspections were conducted on October 20 and December 7, 8 Thomas T. Taylor, Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, HAER No. CA-145, Historic American Engineering Record, National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior, p.
9 Robert Clerico and Ana Beth Koval, An Architectural and Historical Evaluation of Structures Associated with the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric Power System, Inyo County, California, Southern California Edison Company, December p. Valerie Diamond, Stephan G. Helmich, and Robert A. Hicks, Evaluation of the Historic Resources of the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Southern California Edison Company, July p. A-166- Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-2-C (Page 4) Overview The Transformer House at Power Plant 2 was constructed in by the Nevada- California Power Company. Plant 2 was the third of five plants to be established in the Bishop Creek system (preceded by No. 4 and No.
5), and it is the highest plant at an elevation of feet. The Transformer House is a single-story, reinforced concrete industrial building designed in the Mission Revival architectural style. The Transformer House is the only example in the Bishop Creek system of a separate, enclosed building originally designed to house transformers. In the transformers within the building were able to raise the voltage of electricity produced at the plant from to which facilitated long-distance transmission. Currently, the Transformer House continues to function as the transmission facility for Plant 2. The power plant is situated on the northwest bank of Bishop Creek in the upper reaches of Bishop Creek Canyon.
The plant originally consisted of the powerhouse (extant), a matching transformer house (extant), four residence cottages (not extant), and two outbuildings (extant). In the Journal of Electricity Power and Gas provided this general description of the Transformer House, which was constructed five years previously: The transformers are housed in a separate building of similar construction to that of the power house. It is 63 x 25 ft. and is placed at right angles in relation to the main building. Within the building, mounted on concrete rails about 18 in. above the floor and placed in a line are 7 kw. Westinghouse oil insulated and water cooled raising transformers, one being a spare.
These are wound to volts primary to volts secondary and are star connected on the high tension side for volts. Paralleling the line of transformers is a track on which runs a transfer car onto which any transformer may be moved and transferred. This method of handling transformers is consistently maintained at all points of the system. Two sets of Pacific Electric Company s volt oil switches are mounted on reinforced concrete platforms placed over the transfer track and from the lines pass through window openings to the pole line of the Nevada-California system.10 1. Date of Construction: Construction of the Transformer House occurred in based on the top sheet of architectural drawings dated March As stated in by Charles O.
Poole, chief engineer of the Nevada-California Power Company, The plant was constructed in and has been in continuous use ever since, excepting the twenty days when the steel Y failed. 11 10 Van Norden, System of Nevada-California Power Company, p. 11 Poole, Hydraulic and electric features of stations No. 2 and No. 3, p. 21. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-2-C (Page 5) 2. Architect/Engineer: The engineers of the construction of the Transformer House were (R.
G.) Manifold & (Charles O.) Poole of Los Angeles, who are listed as such on the top sheet of construction drawings dated Poole served as chief engineer of the Nevada Power, Mining and Milling Company, later the Nevada-California Power Company. The top sheet of construction drawings included the notation by Paul H. Ehlers, who was probably the draftsman and possibly an architect. Other architects and/or engineers are not known. 3. Builder/Contractor/Supplier: The builder of the Transformer House was the Engineering-Contracting Co., which is listed on construction drawings dated Other builders, contractors and material suppliers are not known. 4. Original Plans: The Transformer House was designed as rectangular in plan with exterior wall-to- wall dimensions of 26 8 x 64 8 .
It was built of concrete reinforced with new style corrugated metal bars and finished in stucco. The building was constructed two bays wide and four bays long as defined by regularly spaced columns that extended to the interior. The concrete columns, or pilasters , were spaced 13 0 center-to-center at the building ends (north and south walls) and 16 0 center-to- center at the long sides (east and west walls). Between the columns were suspended curtain walls 4 thick. End walls terminated in three-level stepped parapets with square-profile coping that reached a maximum height of 31 9 . The parapets were composed of first tiers 3 0 in height, second and third tiers 2 0 in height, and coping 5 tall across the tops and 12 wide at the sides.
The building was originally designed with a moderately pitched gable roof composed of reinforced concrete roof slabs 5 4 wide and supported by reinforced concrete roof beams 10 wide at the top surfaces and 8 wide at the undersides. The reinforced concrete roof was designed with a height of 23 6 to the tops of the eaves, which projected 8 beyond the side walls, and ridge height of 29 6 (more than a foot shorter than the parapet coping). However, the actual roof construction and dimensions differed from the original plans. As constructed, the roof was supported on three Fink steel trusses and sheathed in interlocking, barrel-shaped pressed metal tiles that matched that of Powerhouse No. 2.
The roof was built with a slightly steeper slope than originally planned for the reinforced concrete roof so that the ridge of the metal roof terminated just below the parapet coping. The long side walls were identically fenestrated in a regular pattern with pairs of 16-light-over-4-light wood windows in each bay. The side walls were also pierced by four diamond-shaped, 12-light windows centrally located in the upper portions of each bay. At the symmetrical building ends, the bilateral arrangement of bays Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No.
CA-145-2-C (Page 6) included a single 16-light-over-4-light wood window below a square 16-light window at one side and large double-leaf doors with three metal side hinges and central latches at the other side. The building was originally designed with the doors located on the west side of the end walls. However, it was constructed in reverse with the doors located on the east side of the end walls and the windows on the west side. At the south end wall, another square 16-light window was found above the doors. At the north end, the upper wall above the doors contained a 3-light transom filled with double-strength glass panes and 6 circular holes cut in the centers.
A small platform on knee-braces projected from the wall at the base of the transom and supported insulated bushings that connected to the transmission wires that passed through the transom panes. At both end walls, the gable ends contained centrally located circular louvered vents. At the interior, the single room that occupied the structure measured 26 0 x 64 0 . The room was open in plan without partitions. The long walls contained recessed bays formed by the pilasters that extended to the interior and the windowed curtain-wall panels. The building was open vertically through the trusses.
The floor plan was divided bilaterally along the long axis, with transformer equipment and mountings occupying one side and extending over the centerline of the building, and a transfer car track at the other side running between the service doors in the building ends. The building was originally designed with the transfer car track located on the west side, which corresponded to the originally designed locations of the service doors. However, it was constructed in reverse with the transfer car track located on the east side, aligned with the doors, and the transformer equipment and housings on the west side. The steel rails of the transfer car track were embedded in the concrete floor with their centerline located 7 0 from the east wall.
Above the track, at the third interior bay of the east wall (counting from south to north), concrete platforms on a post-and-beam system and 14 0 above the floor supported two sets of oil switches. At the interior north wall, between the transom and the doors, a knee- braced platform with insulated bushings for three transmission wires corresponded and connected to its identical counterpart at the exterior. The concrete foundation was constructed with mountings and channels for transformer equipment. The transformer mountings consisted of trapezoidal-in- profile concrete bars, two per unit and fourteen in total, aligned in parallel directly west of the centerline of the building. The concrete bar mountings were 12 high, 12 wide at the top and 24 wide at the base, and 7 0 long.
A steel rail was embedded in the surface of each concrete bar mounting. The bars of each mounting set were separated by 16 . A pipe duct ran directly beneath the centerline of the parallel mountings along the length of the room. The concrete pipe duct was square in profile, 14 wide and 12 deep. Another square-in-profile concrete channel, the wire duct, ran along the length of the room directly to the west of the mountings, 12 from the rail ends. The wire duct was 61 0 long, 24 Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-2-C (Page 7) wide and 18 deep. It was covered with 15 steel plates, 24 x 48 and thick, bolted into the concrete foundation.
Each set of transformer mounts was located in a floor bay defined at the sides by short concrete pits 12 wide and 3 0 long that sloped down from grade to the depth of the wire duct. 5. Alterations and Additions: The Transformer House has undergone noticeable changes to its exterior and interior fabric. The barrel-shaped pressed metal tiles that sheathed the roof were replaced with sheet metal panels sometime before approximately Sometime after approximately and before various wall openings were altered and/or eliminated. At the long side walls, all of the diamond-shaped windows and one in each pair of rectangular windows, including the two outermost and two innermost on each wall, were removed and filled with stucco- clad wall surface.
At the building ends, all of the windows and vents were similarly removed and filled, with the exception of the 3-light transom with circular wire passages located above the north end doors. Steel sash replaced original wood sash in remaining window openings. At the south end, a corrugated metal roll-up door replaced the double-leaf doors in the original opening and a solid metal man-door was installed at the west side in the former window bay. At the interior, the elevated concrete platforms were removed from the east side of the room.
At the west side and center of the room, the complex arrangement of concrete transformer mountings and wire and pipe ducts was replaced by a simple rectangular concrete platform, 5- high, 10 0 wide and extending most of the length of the room, upon which transformer equipment was installed. Behind the concrete pad, steel frameworks for equipment support were constructed along the west wall. B. Historical Context: The following historical context was included in previously completed documentation which established the eligibility of the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System for listing in the National Register of Historic Places.12 The turn of the twentieth century saw a dramatic change in technological history.
The production of cheap, dependable hydroelectric power, and the ability to transport the power over great distances, was perfected at this time. In short order, drainages with sufficient flow for hydroelectric power generation began to be developed. By the only suitable streams draining the east slope of the Sierra Nevada which were not being used for electricity production were the Carson and Walker river systems. The first hydroelectric power generation along Bishop Creek was a small plant operated by the Bishop Light and Power Company. The facility was reported to be a half mile west of the Standard Flouring Mills (present site of Plant 6) and two and a half miles from the town 12 Clerico and Koval, An Architectural and Historical Evaluation, p.
Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-2-C (Page 8) of Bishop. The plant consisted of a Stanley polyphase generator (capable of 150 horsepower) driven by a 48-inch Pelton wheel. The power was generated for local use. Through the efforts of Loren B. Curtis, an engineer, and Charles M. Hobbs, a banker and financier, the Nevada Power, Mining and Milling Company was incorporated on December 24, The first facility built by the Nevada Power, Mining and Milling Company was put into operation in September, supplying hydroelectric power to the mining communities of Tonopah and Goldfield, Nevada.
Executives of the power company had purchased controlling interest in the locally operated facilities in Tonopah and Goldfield, so that, when production began, there was a market ready for their product. The original transmission line extended east across Owens valley, the White Mountains, Fishlake Valley, and the Silver Peak Range to the town of Silver Peak in Clayton Valley. Here the line split, diverging northeast to Tonopah and due east to Goldfield. The line distance from Bishop Creek to Goldfield was 95 miles, and that to Tonopah was 118 miles. This was a new record for long distance transmission.
On January 5, the Nevada-California Power Company, successor to the Nevada power, Mining and Milling Company, was incorporated; most of the original corporate officers remained with the new company. Between and four more generating plants were placed on line, in tandem along Bishop Creek, and additional generators were placed in existing plants. As a result of this additional power generation, the Tower Line from Bishop to San Bernardino was completed in and put into operation, again creating a new record for long distance transmission miles). The directors of the Nevada Power, Mining and Milling Company were well aware of the vicissitudes of the boom-bust mining industry and took steps to secure a more constant market for their product.
In the Southern Sierra Power Company was incorporated with the main purpose of creating and servicing the power needs of southeast California. From then until several smaller power companies were purchased by the new company. The development of southern California's Imperial Valley corresponds directly with Bishop Creek's production of cheap, reliable electricity. By the end of the Bishop Creek system was essentially complete with all five plants operating. In descending order down the drainage, the Bishop Creek facility then consisted of: Power Plant 2: Three Westinghouse generators, each capable of kw of power (total output of Units 1 and 2 were driven by Pelton wheels and unit 3 by a Doble wheel.
Power Plant 3: Three Crocker-Wheeler generators, each capable of kw of power (total output of All three units were direct connected to Henry impulse wheels. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No.
CA-145-2-C (Page 9) Power Plant 4: Five generating units consisting of: two National Electric Company, 750 kw, generators connected to Pelton wheels; one Bullock, kw, generator driven by a Pelton wheel; one Allis-Chalmers, kw, connected to a Pelton wheel; and one Allis-Chalmers, kw, machine driven by a Doble wheel (total output of Power Plant 5: Two generating units, one of which was a kw, Allis- Chalmers machine driven by a Doble wheel and the other a kw unit connected to a Pelton-Francis wheel (total output of Power Plant 6: A single generator capable of kw driven by a Pelton-Doble wheel. It is interesting to note that Power Plant 1 was to have been built at the present site of Intake No. 2, but the plant was never built due to the vulnerability of the site to avalanches.
The plant number designators were not adjusted accordingly, so that there is no Power Plant 1, nor has there ever been. In the Nevada-California Electric Corporation again was reorganized to become an operating company. The corporation became California Electric Power Co. and continued to operate under this name until when the company known as Calectric was subsumed by Southern California Edison Company. Since as a result of acquisition through merger consolidation, Southern California Edison (SCE) has owned and operated the Bishop Creek plants. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 2, Transformer House Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-2-C (Page 10)