OPERATIONS AND PROCESS A. Operation: This section describes the process that creates hydroelectric power at Powerhouse No. 5, in the context of Power Plant 5 and the chain of power plants that comprise the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System. This section is divided into two subsections: (1) Basic Components of Hydroelectric Systems, which provides a general background for understanding the operations of hydroelectric plants; and (2) Operation of Plant 5, which describes how water moves through the power plant in order to drive turbines and generate electricity that is transmitted long distances. Basic Components of Hydroelectric Systems In a hydroelectric power generating unit, the force of moving water is used to spin a turbine (or water wheel ).
A turbine is connected via a shaft to a rotor, the moving part of an electric generator. The movement of the turbine spins the rotor within the generator and sweeps coils of wire past the generator s stationary coil, or stator, which produces electricity. Once electricity is produced, transformers raise the voltage to allow transmission over long distances through power lines.16 There are two basic types of hydroelectric systems. The first of these, low-head hydro, uses a large volume or mass of water from relatively low dams in order to turn the angled surfaces of screw-shaped turbines.
The other type, high-head hydro, uses streams with relatively low volume flows, where water is diverted away from the natural stream course and elevated by artificially reduced fall far above the natural stream through a man-made canal or pipeline. At some point downstream the water is directed downslope were it achieves a very high pressure. The water at the base of the slope is directed against a bucketed wheel which receives an energy impulse by its impact. The basic features of a high-head hydro system, of which the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System is an example, are outlined below. 1. Water from a stream channel is separated from the natural stream using a diversion dam, headgates, screens and a spillway.
The headgate regulates the flow of water, while the screens prevent debris from entering the water conduit. The reservoir behind the intake dam acts as the principal regulator of the water flow, allowing excess water to escape into the natural water channel. The dam, headgate, and regulating and cleaning apparatus are all known collectively as the intake. 2. Following intake, water is conducted by flumes or canal systems, pipes, tunnels or siphons (pipes in the case of Bishop Creek). The length of the system varies 16 U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Reclamation Power Resources Office, Reclamation: Managing Power in the West Hydroelectric Power, July unpaginated. Found at accessed on January 30, Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No.
5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 15) greatly, depending on the area's topography and amount of water-pressure desired. Sluices and sandboxes are usually built into the system to allow sand and gravel, which could clog or damage the downstream equipment, to settle out of the water. Flowlines generally incorporate pressure-relief valves, installed at regular intervals along their length. These open and permit outside air to enter the line to prevent the line from collapsing should there be an accidental break in the pipe. A large vacuum would normally be formed by the sudden acceleration of water through a break, which could easily destroy either wood or steel pipe. 3.
At the end of the canal system, a pipe is installed as nearly vertical as conditions will allow providing the water pressure needed to operate the water wheel(s). This pressure pipe is known as a penstock. At the top of this pipe is a small reservoir, expansion tank or standpipe (standpipe in the case of Bishop Creek) which helps to regulate and smooth the flow of water within the penstock. 4. A powerhouse is located at the bottom of the penstock. This consists of a building within which is housed the power generation and distribution equipment. The machinery within the building includes water wheels, generators, batteries and exciters. Exciters provide direct current to energize the electromagnets within the larger alternating current generator(s).
The powerhouse also includes the distribution equipment used to initiate transmission of electricity. This equipment consists of switches, circuit breakers and related controls which are connected to a nearby transformer. The transformer increases voltage so that power can be transmitted over long distances. The powerhouse also contains a variety of other apparatus used in the operation of the system. This often includes a small generating unit to operate the powerhouse lights and equipment, as well as telephone links with other system components. Other buildings associated with the operation of the hydro system are usually located in close proximity to the powerhouse(s).
These may include such facilities as administrative headquarters, garages, housing for system personnel, equipment storage sheds, pump houses, and machine shops. 5. Where there is more than one power-generating source, it is not uncommon for there to be a control station where the transmission of energy may be monitored and regulated. If electrical generating facilities are close by, many functions may be automated or operated from a centralized control point; the control station may serve this additional function. 6. Transmission lines carry power to users. Normally a step-down transformer is used near the point-of-use to reduce the voltage to normal house currents.17 17 Diamond, Helmich, and Hicks, Evaluation of the Historic Resources, p.
Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 16) Operation of Power Plant 5 At Plant 5, the static head of water (or vertical drop in elevation from intake to water wheel) is only 407 feet, which is the second lowest operating head in the Bishop Creek system (with only Plant 6 operating at lower head). The water that operates Plant 5 is delivered from distant Intake No. 5, an equalizing pond located to the southwest directly below the tailrace of Plant 4. Water is transferred from the intake over a distance of feet by Flowline No. 5, a metal pipeline (originally a redwood stave pipe) which runs along the lowest portion of the moraine that terminates at the bottom of Bishop Creek Canyon.
The water is conveyed from the flowline to the powerhouse via Penstock No. 5, a metal pipeline that begins at the height of the flowline and descends from the southwest, thereby using gravity to deliver water at substantial velocity to the plant. The penstock encounters an uneven Y-split and enters the powerhouse as two separate feeder pipelines on the west side. The original southern penstock feeder pipeline constructed in is located partially above grade where it enters the west wall on its path to Unit No. 1. The northern penstock feeder pipeline that was put into operation in for Unit No. 2 in the expanded plant runs entirely below grade and within the substructure. The complex substructure of Powerhouse No. 5 was originally designed to house a reaction turbine unit (No.
1) which relied on large volumes of water moving under constant pressure. However, operation of the original reaction turbine was not successful and after eighteen months service it was taken out, completely ruined by the sharp sand and gravel carried in the water during the flood season. 18 The original reaction turbine was replaced by a pair of impulse wheels similar to those used in other Bishop Creek plants. Nonetheless, the technology of reaction turbines progressed substantially during the first quarter of the twentieth century and when plant facilities were expanded, the power company saw fit to implement newer reaction turbines. In an additional power generation unit (No. 2) with a reaction-type wheel was installed and operated concurrently with the older impulse turbine unit.
Then in the older impulse turbine at Unit No. 1 was replaced with a newer reaction turbine, which completed the conversion of the plant. Currently, Powerhouse No. 5 contains two power generation units with reaction turbines encased in spiral-shaped housing or volutes . Water is delivered to the volutes via the penstock feeder pipelines. The wicket gates pass pressurized water through to the propeller-shaped wheels, which rotate and turn the direct-connected generators. Water passes through the center of the wheels and into curved, vertical draft tubes that create moving pressurized columns of water. The draft tubes connect with separate 8 0 wide, square-bottomed concrete tailraces that convey water out of the powerhouse substructure and into Bishop Creek and nearby Intake No. 4.
At Unit No. 1, the tailrace runs at a southeasterly angle away from the unit and exits the foundation at the southeast corner. At Unit No. 2, the tailrace runs east away from the unit and exits the foundation at the northeast corner. 18 Poole, Hydraulic and electric features of stations Nos. 4 and 5, p. 30. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 17) B. Machines: This section provides an inventory of extant machinery within Powerhouse No. 5, including descriptions of purposes, manufacturer names and dates of installation (as available), and information regarding changed and removed machinery (as available).
This section is divided into several subsections beginning with a general description of the power generation units, followed by detailed descriptions of individual machines and sets of machines. The individual machinery is described in the following order: turbines (water wheels); generators; exciters; transformers and switchwork; and additional machinery. Power Generation Units The power generation machinery in Powerhouse No. 5 has changed substantially over time. The original installation included a Francis reaction turbine assembly, which was the only one of its type in the Bishop Creek system.
This reaction turbine operated by submerging the wheel and its blades entirely within a flowing volume of water, rather than striking buckets with a high-velocity stream of water as occurred with an impulse wheel. To accommodate the reaction turbine, the foundation housed a steel vertical draft tube with inside diameter of 4 0 and depth of 6 0 . The vertical draft tube pierced the floor plate and connected to a subsurface tailrace 8 0 wide and 9 9 deep at a point directly beneath the turbine. However, the original reaction turbine in Powerhouse No. 5 was not successful. According to the Journal of Electricity Power and Gas in Formerly the prime mover for this unit was a Francis [reaction] type water wheel.
This proved unsatisfactory in operation from the fact that the water, while apparently clear and pure, carries much glacial sand and the cost of renewing chutes and runners due to erosion from this suspended matter resulted in the substitution of wheels of the tangential type.19 The replacement unit, an impulse water wheel/generator assembly with a water-driven exciter similar to those installed at other Bishop Creek plants, was put into operation in The double-wheel, main-and-auxiliary-nozzles configuration was most similar to the machinery that was installed at Powerhouse No. 6, which like No. 5 was located in a low-head, low-volume environment below Bishop Creek. In the power generation machinery was described and its operation was evaluated by Charles O.
Poole, chief engineer of the Nevada-California Power Company, in Electrical World: [Powerhouse No. 5] contains one unit at the present time. This is a kw Allis-Chalmers machine wound for volts, three-phase, and operated at 400 by a Doble tangential waterwheel. The two wheels are mounted on the extended shaft of the generator with an extra outboard bearing. Water passes to the wheels through a 42-in. hydraulically 19 Van Norden, System of Nevada-California Power Company, p. 15. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 18) operated gate valve, the wheels being equipped with auxiliary nozzles and controlled by a Lombard governor.
The needles can be connected either singly or doubly to the governor and can be set in any position by hand and locked to any predetermined load. A Allis-Chalmers exciter is driven by a Doble water-wheel. The unit has been in operation for six years and has given excellent service Another unit will be installed in this plant.20 As chief engineer Poole indicated, the power company expanded Powerhouse No. 5 in and began operation of additional facilities in At that time, the building was extended to the north, the main generator room was increased in size, and a second power generation unit was installed in the expanded area, in line with the original impulse-wheel unit. The newer unit utilized a Pelton-manufactured reaction (Francis) water wheel made of steel with a 32 diameter.
The wheel operated at 720 rpm (rotations per minute) and water flow was regulated by 14 wicket gates. The reaction turbine connected to a Westinghouse-manufactured generator rated at kw that delivered current at volts. In the older impulse wheels at Unit No. 1 were removed and replaced with a reaction turbine similar to that found at Unit No. 2. The installation of the reaction turbine at Unit No. 1 included a Worthington-manufactured steel water wheel with a 40 diameter, which was somewhat larger than the wheel at Unit No. 2. The wheel operated at 720 rpm and it was regulated by 14 wicket gates, similar to Unit No. 2.
Also, a Westinghouse-manufactured generator that previously operated at another of the company s hydroelectric plants located to the northwest on the Lee Vining River was relocated to Powerhouse No. 5 and installed at Unit No. 1. This generator rated at kw and delivered current at volts. In order to install the reaction-turbine unit, a new concrete foundation pit was poured to accommodate the machinery. However, the existing tailrace was reused. Also, an existing draft tube, which may have been present since the original Francis wheel unit operated in was reduced in length by 37 and reused in the installation. Currently, from north to south, each generating unit within Powerhouse No.
5 consists of the following: a curved draft tube that creates a pressurizing column of water between the turbine and the tailrace; a reaction wheel that rotates within a spiral-shaped volute (wheel housing); a central bearing mount that supports the shaft; a direct-connected rotary generator that produces electricity; and an end bearing mount. At Unit No. 1, two shaft bearings are found between the wheel and the generator in the location where the second of two impulse wheels was mounted when the unit operated with two tangential runners. The shaft length at Unit No. 1 is approximately 26 6- and the center-to-center distance between the wheel and generator is 10 8 . The rotary generator at Unit No. 1 occupies a pit that is 4 1 deep with a floor opening 6 9 x 5 10 . Unit No.
2 is smaller with a shaft 20 Poole, Hydraulic and electric features of stations Nos. 4 and 5, p. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 19) length of approximately 16 10- and center-to-center separation between the wheel and generator of 5 9 . The generator at Unit No. 2 occupies a pit that is 2 0 deep with a floor opening 6 5 x 5 6 . Turbines (Water Wheels) Since the reaction turbines were installed in and the wheels have been serviced and upgraded. In the Pelton-manufactured wheel in Unit No. 2 was replaced with a Leffel-manufactured steel wheel with an equivalent runner diameter of 32 , rotation speed of 720 and 14 wicket gates.
Likewise, in the Worthington- manufactured wheel at Unit No. 1 was replaced with an equivalent 40 -diameter Worthington steel wheel that operated at 600 rpm with 14 wicket gates. These wheel replacements did not change the operating specifications of the power generation units and they occurred within the original cast iron machine housings and mountings which are extant. At Unit No. 1, a massive curved metal draft tube connects to the center of the wheel and arcs down into the substructure on the north side. The draft tube extends 8 5 below the floor surface into the tailrace chamber, which is 11 2 deep at a point directly below the draft tube.
Directly to the east of the turbine, a 30 gate valve is mounted atop the penstock feeder pipeline that is located partially above grade and that provides water to the unit. Directly to the west of the turbine, an 11 relay valve is found adjacent to a governor. The gate valve and relay valve display stylized metal plate that read: WORTHINGTON PUMP AND MACHINERY CORPORATION, WORTHINGTON WORKS, HARRISON, U.S.A. The governor consists of a Woodward motor- operated governor head married to a Worthington governor body that was relocated from the company s Lee Vining plant in At Unit No. 2, a curved metal draft tube 30 in diameter connects to the center of the wheel and arcs down into the substructure on the north side.
The draft tube extends 7 11 below the floor surface into the tailrace chamber, which is 11 2 deep at a point directly below the draft tube. A gate valve with hand wheel is attached to the front of the volute where the penstock feeder pipe connects to the unit. Directly to the east of the turbine is found a governor with a Woodward motor-operated governor head adapted to the original Pelton Type O-5 governor mechanism. Generators Additionally, the rotary generators were serviced at various times during their operation. The Westinghouse generator at Unit No. 2 was serviced in and On April 1, the Westinghouse Electric Corporation installed generator components that increased the rating of Unit No. 2 to kw and current delivery to volts.
In the stator core in the Westinghouse generator at Unit No. 2 (which was previously located and operated at the company s Lee Vining plant) was replaced and rewound by the Westinghouse Electric Co. with no change in capacity. These generator upgrades retained the original rotors and the original generator housings which are extant. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 20) Exciters Until recently, both power generation units had Westinghouse 125-volt exciters attached at the south ends of the unit shafts. These older exciters were removed and replaced by Speed Indication & Control panels.
Newer solid-state exciter units were installed at the northwest corner of the generator room in the former location of the switchboard. Transformers Transformers originally occupied the northwest corner of the room underneath a rectangular concrete platform with steel post-and-beam frame that held circuit breakers. The four transformer units (including one spare) were water-cooled models by Stanley. Powerhouses No. 4 and No. 5, which were the earliest to be constructed in the Bishop Creek system, were the only plants that originally contained transformers within the powerhouses. By plans were underway to relocate the transformers at Powerhouse No. 4 outside of the building; removal of transformers from inside Powerhouse No. 5 probably occurred at about the same time.
Additional Equipment Other notable details of operating machinery within the powerhouse include: an air compressor located along the east wall; service water strainers located on top of the above-grade penstock feeder pipeline to Unit No. 1; batteries lined up along the south wall; and various electrical panels located on the west wall. C. Technology: This section describes the technology of reaction turbines, also known as Francis wheels, which are used to create hydroelectric power at Powerhouse No. 5. Reaction Turbines (Francis Wheels) The Francis or reaction wheel is the most common type of water wheel currently used in the United States.
The Francis wheel was named for its inventor, James Bicheno Francis of Lowell, Massachusetts, who established the technology in the However, power plant development in typical high-head environments such as the steep eastern slopes of the Sierra Nevada favored Pelton wheels, not Francis wheels, during the early period of great expansion in commercial power markets and facilities.
The application of the Francis turbine in its early stage of development was rather limited to a narrow range of head, due to a number of circumstances the fact should not be overlooked that the early Francis turbine appeared at a time when electrical transmission of energy was practically unknown Successful Francis turbines for operating heads exceeding 400 feet were an unknown quantity prior to A few attempts to install this type were made at an earlier date, the results, Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No.
CA-145-5-A (Page 21) however, were such that it seems to be advisable to eliminate same from the records.21 Nonetheless, as operating thresholds for Pelton water wheels were encountered, and more varied environments were considered, it behooved hydroelectric engineers to explore using variations of the Francis wheel as a hydraulic prime mover. With the development of electrical transmission of energy an enormous field of application of water was power was at once opened up.
The ever increasing demands in regard to speed and capacity of turbines suitable for direct connection with generators, and the greater possibilities for commercial development of water power with heads heretofore outside of the practical range, made it imperative to develop the hydraulic prime movers to such an extent that they now cover the entire range of head found within the limits of nature. The intense studies made have brought about an almost entire elimination of the numerous designs previously used, and today we find only two principal types applied the Francis type, or reaction turbine, and the impulse type, or action turbine. The Francis turbine is designed for low and medium heads exclusively and for moderately high heads when large capacities are involved.
The impulse wheel is limited to very high heads exclusively and moderately high heads when moderate capacities are involved. From the above it follows that there is a so-called twilight-zone of application of both types.22 A reaction turbine ( Francis wheel ) is a propeller-like wheel mounted horizontally or vertically that uses the constant pressure of flowing water against its blades to cause rotation. A reaction turbine is completely submerged and/or encased within a spiral- shaped volute in order to contain water pressure. Water flow enters the larger end of the volute and is directed inward towards the turbine which spins in reaction to the water pressure.
The volume of water that reaches the turbine is regulated by adjusting the position of a wicket gate (also referred to as guide vane ), which can variously restrict or permit the flow of water that reaches the turbine. The wicket gate is comprised of adjustable elements located around the circumference of the wheel within the volute casing. Water that passes through the turbine is funneled to a draft tube , a water conduit that maintains a moving column of water between the turbine outlet and the tailrace.
The draft tube extends from the center of the turbine housing and terminates at the tailrace, and it may be either straight or curved based on the axial orientation of the turbine.23 21 Arnold Pfau, High-head Francis turbines and their operating records, Journal of Electricity, February 1, Vol. 49, No. 3, p. 22 Pfau, High-head Francis turbines, p. 23 U.S. Department of the Interior, Reclamation: Managing Power in the West Hydroelectric Power, unpaginated. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 22) Currently and historically, Plant 5 contains the only reaction turbines located in the Bishop Creek system.
The powerhouse at Plant 5, which is located at the lower reaches of Bishop Creek where low-head (low-pressure) conditions prevail, was originally outfitted with a single reaction turbine in This original reaction turbine was ruined by sediments suspended in the water flow and it was removed after eighteen months of service. It was replaced with a pair of impulse wheels arranged similarly to the double- wheel power generation unit in Plant 6 which was also established in low-head conditions. However, improvements in reaction wheel technology during the early twentieth century prompted further changes at Plant 5.
In the facilities at the powerhouse were expanded to include a second power generation unit operated by a reaction turbine; and in the impulse wheels were removed from the original unit and replaced with a reaction wheel, which resulted in a total of two reaction turbines at Plant 5 and within the Bishop Creek system. This is the current arrangement. Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System, Plant 5, Powerhouse No. 5 Bishop Creek, Bishop vicinity, Inyo County, California HAER No. CA-145-5-A (Page 23) PART IV: SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Primary