Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 12 of 38)
From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,934 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,934 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
The land in question before the Court, and of which the Court was speaking, is one of the tracts which your office directed to be included in the new survey.
After so much has been said, it is hardly necessary to discuss the proposition that this is a grant by name. Surplus is undoubtedly a name, because it is a noun, but it was not a proper noun as used by the Castros in their petition. There is nothing in the case to show that it was ever the name of this rancho at or before the date of this grant. Sobrante means in English surplus or overplus. The three words mean the same. There is probably no foreign word that can be translated into our English with more exactness of definition than the Spanish word "sobrante" by the English word "surplus." If the Board in its decree had put in parentheses the word "overplus," instead of "sobrante," after the word "surplus," the decree would have meant exactly what it does now, each word being the exact equivalent of the other. The use of the word "sobrante" in parenthesis simply shows that the Board translated it by the word "surplus." The Castros asked for vacant, surplus land.
Whether surplus of vacant public land left in the general tract occupied by the five ranchos outside of and defined by their exterior boundaries, or of that which should remain within the exterior boundaries after the quantities of said grants should be surveyed, will be determined next in order. They did not ask for a place known by the name of Surplus, or Lo Sobrante, or El Sobrante; but for a piece of vacant, surplus land. That is all the name the rancho had. That does not fill the well-known definition of a Mexican grant, by name of the place granted, nor the old common law case or illustration of " Black Acre."
The expressed, recorded decree describes the land confirmed as the surplus "which, on the 23d day of April, 1841, the date of the decree of the concession to the present claimants, existed, lying between the tracts known as Ranchos of San Antonio, San Pablo, Pinole, Moraga, and Valencia."
The Supreme Court of the United States has, in several instances, described the different kinds of grants which could be made under Mexican law and regulations by Governors of the Department of California, thus: ist, grants by specific boundaries where the donee was entitled to the. entire tract described; 2d, grants by quantity, as of one or more leagues situated at some designated place, or within a larger tract described by out-boundaries, where the donee was entitled out of the general tract only to the quantity specified; and, 3d, grants, or places by name, where the donee was entitled to the tract named according to the limits, as shown by its settlement and possession, or other competent evidence. (Higueras vs. U. S., S Wall., 828; Alviso vs. U. S., 8 Id., 339; and Hornsby vs. U. S., 10 Id., 224.)
'The claim of the Castros, having been decreed to be valid, should belong to one of the kinds of grants thus defined. It is clear upon the face of the decree that it was not a grant of quantity nor one of place by name. It therefore necessarily falls into the category of grants by boundaries; and as no calls are given for boundaries, except the five ranches named, it must be limited by their boundaries and lie between them all. If this be not so, then, although confirmed as valid, the claim is void for uncertainty.
In United States vs. Fossatt (21 How., 449), the Supreme Court said that "in affirming a claim to land under a Spanish or Mexican gi-ant to be valid within the law of nations, the stipulations of the treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, and the usages of those Governments, we imply something more than that certain papers are genuine, lega, land translative of property. We affirm that ownership and possession of land of definite boundaries rightfully attach to the grantee." See also Fossatt's case (2 Wall.; 707),' and United States w. Sepulveda (i Wall., 107 and 108). In United States vs. Grimes (2 Black, 613), the Court, speaking of the duty of the Land Commissioners under the Act of 185 1, said: "It is their duty to establish the boundaries as well as the validity of the Mexican grant as between him (the grantee) and the Government." The Board and Court, then, had power to fix the boundaries as they did.
Now, the presumption in favor of the validity of the decree, and that the Board and Court performed their duties under the law, forces the conclusion that the decree in some manner indicates the boundaries of the claim with more or less certainty, which in executing it must be ascertained with reasonable exactitude; for not to ascertain them would render that void which the Board and Court have affirmed to be valid; hence the decree must be construed, if possible, so as not to make void that which has thus been affirmed as valid, whether the construction be as to patent or latent ambiguity. In doing this, so far as ascertaining the boundaries is concerned, that which is certain should be preferred to that which is uncertain.
Now, as regards these boundaries, the expressed decree seems to be ambiguous, but the ambiguity is mainly latent, and, wherein it is so, it may be explained by matters dehors the decree or the documents referred to therein.
While there may be no uncertainty as to the ordinary meaning of the word "surplus" or "sobrante," yet, when applied to land, it seems to me that it may embrace lands differing in condition or status, although it is strongly maintained that it cannot. The ordinary definition of "surplus" is that which remains when use is satisfied; excess beyond what is prescribed or wanted - overplus. Now, was the land confirmed surplus of vacant public land which was left of the general tract out of which the said five ranchos were to be satisfied, and which was never within the exterior boundaries mentioned in the Governor's grants of the said surrounding ranchos, and bounded by their exterior boundaries; or was it surplus of those ranchos, or of any of them - that which should remain of the larger tracts when the quantity to which the donees were severally entitled should be satisfied - bounded by said ranchos after they should be measured off" and segregated ?
The decree does not clearly state of what the land confirmed was surplus. But it is insisted that what here may appear to be ambiguitas latens and subject to expla- nation by extrinsic evidence is explained by subsequent terms in the decree, and no other evidence is admissible; that wherein the decree describes the surplus as that "which, on the 23d day of April, A. D. 1841, * * * existed, lying between the tracts known as Ranches of San Antonio," etc., the Board and Court necessarily meant a tract of vacant public land, in the sense of lying without the exterior boundaries named by the Governor in the grants of said tracts, and hence surplus of the general tract of public land out of which the several ranches mentioned were taken, and bounded by their exterior boundaries; that in describing the land as surplus, which existed in 1841, lying between tracts known by the names mentioned, those tra^cts must have had known boundaries, and that a grant of quantity which might be located anywhere within the exterior limits mentioned would not have been referred to as a known tract.
But it will be seen that these subsequent terms necessarily lead for explanation and certainty to matters outside the decree itself To ascertain what surplus existed in 1 841, we certainly must look to matters not set forth in the decree. Were the ranchos mentioned grants from the Mexican Government ? Were they completed grants ? Were they grants by names of places, or by specific boundaries, or of quanity within larger exterior limits? If of quantity, had they been set off and segregated? If not, what were their exterior boundaries ? These and divers other necessary questions are not answered by the decree, and the decree itself necessarily refers us to extrinsic matters. This is latent ambiguity, and the decree is by no means peculiar in this respect.
It is well settled that even the instruments referred to in the decree cannot be read to vary the natural import of the language used, if there be no uncertainty therein, nor to control the description of boundaries that are certain and free from ambiguity, but only to explain an ambiguity (U. S. vs. Halleck, i Wall., 455; decision in San Jacinto Nuevo y Potrero, above cited), and the same may be said of all extrinsic evidence resorted to.
Now, looking at the petition and grant referred to in the decree we find that the Castros petitioned for "apiece of vacant land which is situated on the immediate limits (inmediaciones) of San Antonio, San Pablo, Pinole, the farm (rancho) of Valencia, and the farm of Moraga, which land is the overplus {sobrante) of the ranchos aforesaid." Here we find the land described as both "vacant" and "sobrante;" but in terms as sobrante of the ranchos mentioned in the petition. What is meant by the word " vacant " as used in the petition ? Does it mean land that was vacant in the sense of not being or having been within the exterior limits of any of the ranchos mentioned, or vacant in the sense that it was not occupied by any of the grantees of the said ranchos, nor claimed as being included in the quantity to which they were respectively entitled and hence subject to grant ? It would appear from the further description thereof, " which land is the overplus (sobrante) of the ranchos aforesaid," that the latter was meant.
The Governor granted to the Castros the land of which they made mention in the petition, and by no other description than that which they had employed, holding them " under obligation to present themselves anew, accompanied by a map of the land, so soon as the boundaries of the neighboring ranchos should be regulated."
It would appear from this that the boundaries by which the tract was to be defined were not then fixed and certain, and that the hnes of the neighboring ranches had not then been regulated.
As has been explained, San Antonio was a grant by boundaries, which were as certain then as now; but San Pablo, Pinole, Acalanes, and Laguna de los Palos Colorados were grants of quantity, which quantity had not been segregated in 1841. Enough appears in the records of the Land Commissioners to show that as San Pablo and Acalanes were claimed and occupied in 1841, there was land in the locality named by the Castros, which would not be taken to satisfy the quantity to which these grants were respectively limited.
The establishment of the Castros, owners of San Pablo, was on the part of the rancho adjoining the bays of San Francisco and San Pablo, and that of Valencia was considerably east of the western exterior boundary of the large tract. It was well known that there was more land lying between these ranchos as thus possessed than would be required in satisfying the quantity to which the respective donees were entitled- The northern limit of Moraga's Rancho would not interfere with this sobrante. The boundaries of San Antonio and the exterior boundaries of Pinole, as defined in the grant in 1842, were natural objects; and if surplus was thrown off of neither of them there would still be a large tract between them, surplus of San Pablo and Acalanes. Now, if all the exterior boundaries of San Pablo, Acalanes, and Moraga's Rancho were clear, then there would have been no difficulty in presenting a map of the sobrante asked for, if it was composed of a tract bounded by the exterior boundaries of the five ranchos mentioned. But it does not appear that it was customary to regulate exterior boundaries of grants of quantity in the sense of establishing them permanently. Consideration was, of course, to be given them, so far as to locate the quantity granted within them; but I think it cannot be questioned that the boundaries to be regulated were such as defined the quantity of the land actually granted, and remained as the boundaries of the land to which the donee was legally entitled under the grant.
This seems to be the view taken by the Board and the Court; for in the finding of facts the Commissioners say that Alvarado issued a grant to the petitioners " requiring them to report a plat of the same as soon as the adjoining ranchos could be surveyed and the extent of the sobrante ascertained, which survey has not been had of said ranchos so as to enable the petitioners herein to define with certainty the boundaries of their said sobrante" If the exterior boundaries of the adjoining ranchos were the ones to be regulated, then that could have been done much better in 1 84 1, when witnesses were living who would be more likely to know of them than those that can be produced at this late day. Moreover, if the Board had supposed that such boundaries were to be regulated, then as it was their duty to fix the boundaries with as much certainty as the case would admit, and having the Governor's grants of the said ranchos before them, and living witnesses to point out their boundaries, they would have found them and set them forth in the decree. But they found that the boundaries to be regulated were to be ascertained by surveys. No survey, to this .day, has been made of those exterior boundaries of the grants of quantity. When will the surveys that were to make these boundaries clear and develop the extent of the sobrante be made, if the exterior boundaries of the grants were the ones intended ?
Thsre will have to be further legislation by the Government to accomplish this, for there is no provision for surveying other than the land confirmpd by the decrees of the Board of Land Commissioners and the Courts, and the five ranches have been surveyed and patented. Undoubtedly the Governor referred to the regulation of boundaries that took place under the Mexican land system upon juridical measurement, for that was the " regulation'' of boundaries required by law and ordinance, and which usually was expressly provided for in grants. In all cases in which the juridical measurement had not been had under the Mexican Government, this duty of measuring and segregating the lands granted was transferred to and devolved upon our Government; and it is fully performed by our final surveys and patents. Our official surveys take (or rather fill) the place of the juridical measurement required under Mexican law. This has been settled beyond question by the decisions of the Supreme Court. It would therefore appear that the boundaries to be regulated or the surveys to be made, which were to develop the sobrante granted and show its boundaries and extent, are those carried into the patents of the said ranchos.
But suppose this view should be incorrect, then, looking into the condition of the surrounding ranchos in 1841, no independent, vacant tract, with certain boundaries can be found. The San Pablo grant was to be located within the following limits, taking the description in the Governor's concessions of 1834 and 1835: "Bounded by the Ranchos of San Antonio and El Pinole, and by a portion of the port of San Francisco." The southeastern boundary, according to these calls, was clearly not definite and certain. It is suggested that the diseiio accompanying the petition will make the southeastern boundary more certain, but examination thereof throws very little light on this matter. It will not indicate from what points on the boundaries of El Pinole and San Antonio a line should be drawn to form this boundary. The map or diseno here referred to is found in Volume 2 of maps, Land Commission Records, page 421, on which the southeastern portion of the tract, within which the quantity was to be surveyed, is limited only by the border of the map.
The southeastern exterior line of San Pablo, drawn on the Boardman map attached to the objections of Edson Adams, does not agree with that drawn by the Surveyor- General upon the connected map hereinbefore referred to. So it seems that, with all the light afforded by the Surveyor-General's office, and by actual examination in the field (see Surveyor-General's certificate on connected map), skilled surveyors cannot to-day agree as to the southeastern exterior of San Pablo.
In the third and fourth conditions, both in the decree of 1834 and that of 1835, the donees were to solicit juridical possession of the proper Judge, who should measure the tract according to law, for the purpose of having the boundaries of the grant marked out, the surplus to remain to the nation for proper uses.
But this measurement was not made by the Mexican Government, and it devolved upon our Government to finish the work that was left undone by the former Government. Our Government has measured the quantity and given it certain boundaries. Were not these certain boundaries the ones that the Governor and the Board referred to as requiring regulation in order to define the boundaries and_show the extent of the sobrante granted and confirmed, rather than boundaries that are never to be regulated in the sense of being accurately surveyed and established, that are shown to be uncertain and possibly impossible of ascertainment?
Again, take Valencia's Rancho Acalanes. The Governor's grant describes it as "the tract of land known by the name of Acalanes, bounded by the Ranchos of San Pablo, San Antonio, and El Pinole."
It is contended that the large tract out of which the quantity granted to Valencia was to be measured was not bounded by San Pablo, notwithstanding the calls in the grant; because in limiting the quantity in the fourth condition, and directing the Judge who should give Valencia possession to measure it conformably to ordinance, the overplus remaining for the use of the nation, etc., it was said that the tract to be measured was " one league in length by three-quarters of a league in width, according as is explained on the map," which was with the record of proceedings; and the map had written on its margin that the place asked for was " situated between the arroyo Galindo and the arroyo Grande," those streams baing delineated on the map or diseno. In other words, that the map on which was sketched the country to the northwest as far as the coast should control, instead of the aforesaid calls of the grant, because it showed the situation of the three-quarters of a square league that was granted as being between the arroyos aforesaid. Upon this showing it is insisted that a vacant tract is developed between the line formed by those two arroyos (Galindo being a tributary to the arroyo Grande or San Pablo Creek, with junction southeast of the claimed southeastern exterior line of the rancho San Pablo) and the southeastern exterior of San Pablo.
Now, if this were true, there would still be the uncertainty as to San Pablo's southeastern boundary; and it is not clear how this -boundary could be " regulated " so as to define such tract. But the vacant tract disappears, admitting the arroyos Grande and Galindo to be the northwestern exterior boundary of Acalanes, for then the southeastern exterior line of San Pablo becomes certain, and comes up to said arroyos. The grant of Acalanes ought not to be held repugnant in its terms if they can be made harmonious. Then if the arroyos Grande and Galindo are the western and northwestern boundaries of Acalanes, the call expressed in the grant for San Pablo as a boundary should not be repugnant thereto; and as the southeastern boundary of Pablo was uncertain, this call brought it to the arroyos aforesaid. But I look upon the language of the fourth condition in Valencia's grant as simply a more specific designation of the locality in which the quantity was to be measured, and not as contradicting the general boundaries within which it was to be located.
. It follows, then, that the mentioned ranchos had coterminous boundaries, and that the land confirmed was the surplus of some of them that should be defined by their boundaries as established or regulated by final survey.
This fulfills the legal proposition that the grant, having been confirmed as valid, necessarily has definite boundaries; and this was its condition in 1841, under the wellknown rule that in law that is certain which is capable of being rendered certain. Any other conclusion would result, it seems to me, in inextricable confusion.
It is contended that the tract confirmed could not have been sobrante of any of the grants, because the grantees had the right of possession of the entire tract until segregation of quantity, and hence the Castros could not have had possession of other than land not within the exterior boundaries of the grants of quantity. Such an objection might be made to any grant of sobrante; still sobrante grants have been confirmed, surveyed, and patented. While it is true, as held by the Supreme Court in Van Reynegan vs. Bolton (5 Otto, 33), that the right to make selection of the quantity granted rested exclusively with the Government, and could be exercised only by its officers, and that until segregation the grantee had the right of possession of the entire tract within which the quantity was to be measured, yet the discretion to be exercised by the officers charged by law with the execution of decrees in such cases was not arbitrary but reasonable, and was to be so exercised, in view of the record of the case, the situation of the land, the improvements and possession of the donees, and all other circumstances proper and necessary to be considered, as to fulfill the i ntent and requirements of the decree, and thus do substantial justice between the United States and the confirmees.
For example, no survey would be deemed a proper one that excluded the improvements and actual possession of the donee against his selection of land thus improved and possessed, provided it was within the boundaries called for.
Now, notwithstanding the donees of the grants of quantity in the case might have had the right of possession to the limits of the larger tracts, yet they did not object to the occupancy and possession of the Castros in this case. Why they permitted the Castros to occupy the land is not a matter of just concern of this department. The Castros received a concession of a tract of vacant, surplus land, and the claim thereunder has been confirmed, and the regulation of boundaries of the neighboring ranchos has developed such a tract in the place called for in the grant and decree. Beyond this it is not {Srofitable or pertinent to inquire.
A tract or piece of land, no portion of which shall lie east of the western line of Acalanes, or sotith of the northern line of Mora ja, or west of the eastern lines of San Antonio and San Pablo, or north of the southern line of El Pinole, as tho&e lines have been established by the final surveys and patents of said ranchos, will substantially fulfill the decree, and do justice according to the record of the case as between the United States and the owners of the sobrante grant.
The next question for consideration is, should the survey of El Sobrante embrace any portion of the Rancho La Boca de la Canada del Pinole ?
As regards the La Boca tract, it is contended by the owners of the sobrante title that it was a part of the sobrante which existed April 23, 1841, and which on that date was granted to the Castros, and subsequently confirmed to them under the Act of 1851; that as it is the duty of the Surveyor-General to follow the decree of confirmation, he has no right to look at the fact that said tract has been patented in -making surV'ey of the sobrante; that it is the duty of the Land Department, under the Act of 1864, to include in the survey all the lands included in the decree.
Against this the owners of the La Boca tract refer to the fact that the survey of their claim was ordered into Court under the Act of 1860(12 Stats., 33); that the . owners of El Sobrante intervened in that matter and 'were made parties thereto; that the decree of the Court approving the final survey of that claim was entered by consent of all the parties; and that, therefore, the sobrante claimants are estopped from demanding that any portion of the La Boca shall be included in their survey, and your predecessor so decided. Cases are cited as supporting this proposition, effect that under the Act of 1851 the Land Commissioners and Courts had no jurisdiction to adjudicate upon title as between third parties, but only as between the United States and claimants; that the primary object of the said Act was to separate lands owned by private individuals from the public domain; that confirmation under the Act of 185 1 simply affirmed that the land embraced by the decree was private land; that the patent of the United States under said Act is but a relinquishment of claim, or a quit-claim, to the tract confirmed, and record evidence of the action of our Government upon the claim, operating by relation from the time when the claim was presented to the Board of Land Commissioners; that such patent is simply conclusive as between the United States and the claimants and the privies of the respective parties; that the District Court of California, under the Act of i860, had no greater jurisdiction, to say the least, than the tribunal created by the Act of 1851, for ascertaining and settling private claims; that the matter before the Court under the Act of i860 was simply upon the question of the correctness of the survey, in other words, to determine the question as to whether the survey was an execution of the decree of confirmation, the same as that of the Surveyor-General now under the Act of 1864, or formerly under the Act of 185 1; that parties to proceedings before the Court upon approval of a survey under the Act of i860 are only bound by the decrees, and estopped as to the subject-matter before and within the jurisdiction of the Court, and that all questions of title between third parties, claiming under grants of Mexican origin were necessarily referred to the judiciary; and cases in support of these propositions are cited.
The foregoing statement is made in order to develop the positions of the contending parties in this matter. However; I do not think myself called upon, as I understand the case, to decide or express an opinion as to which is the correct one. It would undoubtedly be necessary to decide the question were it shown that the land patented as the La Boca de la Cafiada del Pinole was vacant, sobrante, land within the meaning of and embraced by the decree in the sobrante case. To my mind not only is this not shown, but it seems to me that the records of your office and of the Surveyor-General's office show beyond question that the land patented to the La Boca claimants was not vacant, sobrante, or surplus of any of the five ranches mentioned, existing z.s such April 23, 1841, within the true intent and meaning of the decree of confirmation of this case.
The records prove with reasonable clearness that it was neither vacant nor sobrante at that time, and it was well said by one of the contestants in argument, that as the Government has patented the La Boca, the survey of the sobrante should not, in any view of the case, invade such patented territory except upon clear proof that the land so patented is embraced by the decree of confirmation to the Castros.
The question whether the La Boca was vacant and sobrante or surplus land of any of the ranchos mentioned in 1841, and is embraced by the decree of confirmation, . is one to be determined by the officers or tribunal upon whom the duty of executing the decree is imposed by law; as only vacant, surplus land, within the meaning of the decree, can be surveyed.
In the first place, the La Boca was not a grant of the surplus or sobrante of El Pinole, or any of the other ranchos mentioned as boundaries of El Sobrante. It was
The Land Commission record shows that Ignacio Martinez claimed to have received a grant of the place called El Pinole as early as 1823; he so represented to the Mexican authorities in 1834, stating that he had lost his title-papers, and solicitmg a renewal of the same. Record evidence was not found to support his allegations, and he was required to petition anew, which he accordingly did November 10, 1837! stating that as he had mislaid or lost the grant issued to him in 1 823,' and as it was impossible for him to make it appear that such a grant had been made, he was under the necessity of making a second petition. In this petition he described the land as "three sitios, which are 'Canada del Pinole,' and that which is called 'La Hambre,' straits of Carquinez, running towards the ' Mar de la Norte,' that is called the bay of Sonoma, adjoining the mouth of the same Canada del Pinole, as is explained in the adjoining plan." For reasons set forth in the petition he asked for an additional league. (Record of Evidence, vol. 1 5, p. 427.)
Thus it will be observed there was nothing in the archives of the Mexican Government in 1837 designating boundaries to the place known as El Pinole; and, as proceedings on the petition of Martinez were pending in 1841, when the grant was made to the Castros, and were not terminated until June i, 1842, when the first and only recorded grant to Ignacio Martinez was issued, it follows that El Pinole had no boundaries recognized by the Mexican Government in 1841, and consequently that the boundaries declared in the grant to Martinez, in 1842, are the true boundaries of EI Pinole, within which the four leagues granted to Martinez were to be surveyed, and within which the boundaries of quantity were to be regulated, as provided in the grant and decree in the sobrante case. That these boundaries did not include La Boca de la Canada del Pinole will appear from what follows.
While proceedings were pending upon the petition of Ignacio Martinez, Felipe Briones, on the 24th day of July, 1839, petitioned for the grant of the place known by the name of El Pinole, stating that it was then more than ten years that he had possessed said place, comprising three "sitios de ganado mayor," more or less, as designated upon the plan accompanying the petition. Briones further alleged that he had built a house on the land prayed for, "planted a garden of much consideration, and cultivated some lands," by which and "some milking cattle " he had maintained his family, composed of eighteen persons. This petition was referred to Ignacio Peralta a Justice of the Peace, who reported thereon July 29, 1839, that the Rancho of El Pinole had been occupied by Don Ignacio Martinez since 1824, by order of the Governor /w tern., Don Luis Arguello, and that Briones, in his petition, did not make mention of the land that he (Briones) had occupied, called "El Corral de Galindo " where he kept his cattle, and hence that it would appear as though his petition operated injuriously by asking for the Canada del Pinole, and not stating that he held the aforesaid "Corral de Galindo." Peralta further reported that Briones went on the land under an arrangement with Martinez, entered into in 183 1, the parties "agreeine that their ends should meet;" that Briones "should assist at rodeos, and place his small houses immediate for company."
a grant of all the land occupied by Martinez and himself, or only for that occupied by himself, giving the land he desired the wrong name. But the tract called "Corral de Galindo" embraced a part of the Canada of Pinole, and it is probable that Briones intended to ask for the land occupied by himself, known as well by the name of La Boca de la Canada del Pinole and San Felipe, as Corral de Galindo, as facts hereinafter mentioned will show. Howe^^r this may be, the matter of the several petitions was pending when the Governor made the grant to the Castros, and was not finally settled until more than a year afterward by the issuance of grants to Martinez and the widow of Briones, respectively (Briones having died about the year 1840). That the Governor considered Briones entitled to the land occupied by him, and so decided before he issued a grant to Martinez; that Martinez so understood the matter, and acquiesced in the Governor's decision; and that it was well understood that the tract known as La Boca de la Canada del Pinole, in the possession of Briones, was not included within the exterior boundaries named by the Governor in his grant of El Pinole to Martinez, will appear from the following: -
On the 1st of June, 1842, evidently having in view bbth of the petitions of Martinez and Briones, and of the report of Peralta, the Governor, Alvarado, who made the grant to the Castros, issued a grant to Ignacio Martinez. In the concession of that date, the tract within which the quantity was to be surveyed was described as "commencing at the mouth of the Canada del Pinole, eastwardly along the same until it adjoins with the Corral de Galindo, from this place to La Canada de la Hambre, and from thence to the straits of Carquinez."
In the formal title issued the same day the four square leagues granted were to be surveyed within the following boundaries: "By the name of Pinole its limits beingfrom the mouth of the ravine (Canada) of the same name, in an easterly direction by the same until it joins with the ' Corral de Galindo;' from this place to the Canada de la Hambre, and along the same to the Straits of Carquinez, the boundaries to terminate at the mouth of said Caiiada del Pinole into the Bay of San Francisco."
Evidently this description was not to include the "place"' called "Corral de Galindo," otherwise La Boca, etc. The ravine (Caiiada del Pinole) was to be followed until it adjoined with the "Corral de Galindo; from this place to the Caiiada de la Hambre," etc.
The same facts appear, and are placed beyond doubt by the language of the grant to the widow Briones, made twenty days after the grant to Martinez.
The grjint to Maria Manuela Valencia, widow of Briones, was made upon her petition of the 8th of June, 1842, in which she set forth inter alia that she was the "widow of the late Felipe Briones, and established in the mouth of the Canada of Pinole (en la Boca de la Canada del Pinole);" that for more than eleven years she had "lived in peaceable possession of said place, with a considerable amount of stock, consisting of four hundred head of cattle, having also an adobe house, and more than one thousand grapevines, together with some fruit-trees;" and she prayed the Governor to concede to her "the legal ownership of the said place, containing three square leagues, as shown by the accompanying diseno." The accompanying diseno distinctly called for the land of Ignacio Martinez as a northwestern, northern, and northeastern boundary (see Record of Maps, vol. 2, p. 489). Her allegations accorded with those of her husband in his petition of 1839 as regards possession and the length of time that the Briones family had occupied the place, as also with the report of Peralta upon the petition of Briones. The widow's petition, having been referred to the proper judge for investigation and report, was presented to Ignacio Martinez, adjoining owner, who stated concerning the same, June 13, 1842, as follows: "The. Sefiora Manuela Valencia, who petitions for the place, as shown by the annexed diseno, is worthy of being heard, and what she asks may be granted to her, since it does not prejudice my land!' (The underscoring in the foregoing quotation is my own.)
On the 14th of the same month, the Judge to whom the petition was referred, Guillermo Castro, reported that, in view of the report of Ignacio Martinez, the tract asked for might be granted to the petitioner.
On the 2 1st of June, 1842, the land was granted to the widow of Briones, the Governor stating that, in view of the petition, the foregoing reports, "and all other matters necessary to be considered (the other matters necessary to be considered undoubtedly included the former petition of Briones and Peralto's report thereon). Dona Maria Manuela Valencia is declared owner of the place named in Boca de la Canada de Pinole, bounding with the Rancho of Don Ignacio Martinez, with that of Don Julio Wil, and with that of Candelario Valencia;" and in the formal grant of the same date the land is described by the same boundaries, being limited in the third condition to three square leagues, as shown by the disefio annexed, the sobrante remaining to the convenient uses of the nation. (Exhibit 32, Adams, from the archives in the Surveyor-General's office.) In bounding the general tract out of which the quantity .should be surveyed to Mrs. Briones with "the Rancho of Don Ignacio Martinez," the boundaries of El Pinole, as declared by the Governor a few days before in the grant to Martinez, were unquestionably meant.
When this claim was before the District Court upon petition for confirmation, the testimony of Josd de Jesus, son of Ignacio Martinez, was taken. Being asked. what he knew in regard to the boundaries of the tract, the witness stated that on the north it was bounded by the Rancho of Ignacio Martinez, father of the witness, called El Pinole; that the original map {disefld) was made by him in 1841, and that it was correct; that it was the original map presented by Dona M. M. Valencia to the Governor when she petitioned for the land, and that he made it for that purpose; and that when he made it the houses, corral, and garden were on the Rancho as represented on the map. The witness further stated that he became acquainted with the boundaries of La' Boca by going over the land with a son of Mrs. Briones for the purpose of making the map; that he had lived on his father's Rancho since April, 1830, and ridden over the La Boca Rancho "thousands of times," and that he was well acquainted with everything connected with it. (Exhibit 58, Blum, from archives in Surveyor-General's office.)
From the foregoing I conclude that the La Boca Rancho was not within the boundaries of El Pinole as established by the Governor's grant in 1842, the first official definition of the exterior boundaries of that place. And taking the facts above stated in connection with the testimony of William Richardson (vol. 5, 245, Evidence), C. Briones, and Napoleon B. Smith (vol. 4, pp. 561 and 720, Evidence), delivered to the Board in the case of El Pinole, and the location of the tract called
Corral de Galirido, and the Cuchilla de Chemisal, as laid down on the connected map hereinbefore mentioned and on the official map of Mr. Minto's survey, it would appear that the northern patented litie of La Boca very nearly represents the calls of the grant and decree in the Pinole case for Pinole's southern exterior boundary in this locality. It follows, therefore, that La Boca was not surplus {sobrante) of El Pinole, and as the District Court decreed the claim of Mrs. Briones to be good and valid to the land known by the name of " La Boca de la Canada del Pinole" to the extent of three square leagues " within the boundaries so described in the grant and map on file in the records," and as the grant and diseHo call for Acalanes and Pinole for boundaries, and as Acalanes calls for Pinole as one of its boundaries, it necessarily follows, from the situation of these several grants, that La Boca was not surplus of any of the five grants mentioned in the grant to the Castros of 1841, the presumption of law being that La Boca was located within the boundaries called for in the decree of confirmation.
-Again, La Boca was not vacant land in 1841, within the meaning of the decree of confirmation in the sobrante case. The evidence in the case of the La Boca upon petition for confirmation, as well as that of Josd de Jesus Martinez, hereinbefore referred to, and that of Peralta in his report, show a continued occupancy and possession from about 1831 till long after April, 1841, by the Briones family, the widow continuing in occupancy and possession after the death of her husband, and that the land was improved by them as alleged in the petitions therefor of 1839 and 1842. It was the very land occupied and in the possession of her husband that Mrs. Briones petitioned for, and it makes no difference whether it is called La Boca de la Canada del Pinole, San Felipe, or Corral de Galindo.
In the opinion of the Board in that case, it was stated that the depositions on file showed a long residence on the land by the grantee, and established very clearly a substantial compliance with the conditions of the grant, and that the only obstacle to confirmation was to be found in the proof of boundaries. The decree of the Board rejecting the claim was reversed by the District Court, and the claim was decreed to be good and valid, and it has been surveyed and patented accordingly.
It was manifestly against the policy of the Mexican Government to grant lands to one party that were improved and in possession of another; and petitions were referred to the proper magistrate for the purpose of ascertaining whether they called for lands occupied by others. In the very matter of the petition of Martinez it is seen that, although he asked for land by the name of a place that might have embraced the establishment of Briones, and Briones had no grant from the Government, yet the possession of Briones was recognized as well as that of Martinez, and the land possessed by him was carefully excluded from the grant to Martinez.
Now, as the Governor recognized and protected the possession of Briones; as that possession was continued by his widow, and was of the same land; as proceedings were pending before the Government for a grant of this land at the time of the grant to the Castros; as upon the death of Briones the claim for the grant was continued in the name of his widow, she alleging the possession that had continued since 1831; and as the grant to the widow was made in view of all the proceedings mentioned, and necessarily in consideration of the uninterrupted possession of the Briones family since 1831, it follows that the possession was not a trespass. The presumption is that the final survey followed the decree of confirmation; that it embraces the quantity of land thus possessed as limited in the decree; that it correctly shows the boundaries thereof, and that the land was surveyed within the boundaries mentioned in the decree; and, as the possession which continued from 1831 was not a trespass, it extended to the boundaries of the claim as surveyed and patented; all of which results in this conclusion: That in 1841 the land surveyed as the Rancho La Boca de la Canada del Pinole was not vacant.
Finally, it seems to me that the Mexican authorities, having jurisdiction in the premises, decided, in 1842, that the land known as La Boca de la Canada del Pinole was not embraced within any former grant. The reference of the petition of Mrs. Briones to the auxiliary Judge of Contra Costa required him to report whether "the land referred to belonged to any individual, with all other matters that may be necessary." His report, as well as that of Martinez, and that of Estrado, the Seflor Prefect of the district, and the action of the Governor thereon in making the grant to Mrs. Briones, which, he stated, was in consideration of those reports, and all other matters necessary to be considered, amounted to a decision that the land granted was not included in any former grant.
In view of the facts and the legal conclusions relative to this matter, it would be just as consistent to hold that the land surveyed under the grant to Martinez was vacant sobrante land in 1841, as to hold that that which was surveyed under the Briones grant was vacant sobrante land at that time; and the survey of El Sobrante might as well include the one tract as the other. The grants of Pinole and La Boc i are precisely similar in character, and were virtually the result of the final determination of the same proceedings before the Mexican Government pending and undecided April 23, 1 841.
The Minto survey not only embraces the larger portion of the La Boca, but also a small part of the Rancho Laguna de los Palos Colorados (Moraga's claim), as patented, and does not include all of the land embraced in the decree as herein construed. It is therefore set aside.
The remaining question is with regard to the tract marked " No. 7" on the Boardman map, and as public land on the Minto plat of survey of El Sobrante. I do not consider that that tract lies between the five ranchos mentioned, within the meaning of the decree, and it will accordingly be excluded from the final survey.
You will therefore direct a new survey to be made of the following boundaries: Beginning at post S. P. No. 67, at the terminus of course No. 195 in the patented line of the San Pablo Rancho; thence in a direct line to post P. R. No. 4, terminus of course No. 4, in the patented line of El Pinole Rancho; thence with the patented line of El Pinole to a point therein at which the westernmost line of the Rancho La Boca de la Canada del Pinole as patented extended northwardly intersects said line of El Pinole; thence with the patented line of the Rancho La Boca de la Canada del Pinole to the point at which the western patented line of Acalanes intersects the same; thence with, the said line of Acalanes to the north patented line of the Rancho Laguna de los Palos Colorados; thence with the last-named line and the same extended west to the eastern patented line of the Rancho San Antonio; thence northward with the patented lines of the RanchOs San Antonio and San Pablo to the place of beginning. The decision of your office is modified accordingly, and the papers of the case are herewith returned. Very respectfully,
Table Of Land Claims
Domingo and Vicente Peralta, claimants for San Antonio, granted August i6, 1820, by Don Pablo Vicente de Sala to Luis Peralta; claim filed January 21, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 7, 1854, by the District Court January 26, 1855, and by the Supreme Court in 19 Howard, 343; containing 18,848.98 acres. Patented, February 10, 1877.
Josd Dolores Pacheco, claimant for Santa Rita, granted April 10, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado to J. D. Pacheco; claim filed, February 21, 1852, rejected by the Commission, April 25, 1854, confirmed by the District Court August 13, 1855, and decree afifirmed by the United States Supreme Court in 23 Howard, 495; containing 8,894.01 acres. Patented March 18, 1865.
Jos6 Noriega and Roberto Livermore, claimants for Las Positas, two square leagues, granted April 10, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado to Salvio Pacheco; claim filed February 27, 1852, confirmed by the Commission, February 14, 1854, and by the District Court February 18, 1859; containing 8,880 acres. Patented May 25, 1872.
Fulgencio Higuera, claimant for Agua Caliente, two square leagues, granted October 13, 1836, by Nicolas Gutierrez, and April 4, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado, to F. Higuera; claim filed February 27, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 14, 1854, and appeal dismissed November 24, 1856; containing 9,563.87 acres. Patented April 17, 1858.
Jos6 de Jesus Vallejo, claimant for Arroyo del Alameda, four square leagues, granted August 30, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado to J. de Jesus Vallejo; claim filed March 2, 1852, confirmed by the Commission October 18, 1853, by the District Court March 2, 1857, and appeal dismissed July 28, 1857; containing 17,705.38 acres. Patented January i, 1858.
Juan Jos6 Castro, claimant for El Sobrante, eleven square leagues, granted April 23, 1841, by Juan B. Alvarado to J. J. Castro; claim filed March 9, 1852, confirmed by the Commission July 3, 1855, and appeal dismissed April 6, 1857.
Andres Pico et al., claimants for Mission San Jose, 30,000 acres, granted May 5, 1846, by Pio Pico to Andres Pico and Juan B. Alvarado; claim filed March 22, 1852, fconfirmed by the Commission December 18, 1855, and rejected by the District Court June 30, 1859.
Jos^ Maria Amador, claimant for San Ramon four square leagues and eighteen hundred varas, granted August 17, 1835, by ]os6 Figueroa to J. M. Amador, claim filed March 23, 1852, confirmed by the Commission August i, 1854, by the District Court January 14, 1856, and appeal dismissed January 10, 1857. Patented March 18, 1865.
Antonio Sufiol et ai, claimants for El Valle de San Jose, described by boundaries, granted April 10, 1839, by Juan B. Alvarado to Antonio Maria Pico et al., claim filed May 18, 1852, confirmed by the Commission January 31, 1854, by the District Court January 14, 1856, and decision of the United States Supreme Court as to the right of appeal in 2q Howard, 261; containing 48,435.92 acres. Patented March 15, 1865.
Josd Joaquin Estudillo, claimant for San Leandro, one square league, granted October 16, 1842, by Juan B. Alvarado to Joaquin Estudillo; claim filed May 31, 1852, confirmed by the Commission January 9, 1855, by the District Court May 7, 1857, and by the U. S. Supreme Court; containing 6,829.58 acres. Patented July I5> 1863.
Tomas Pacheco and Augustin Alviso, claimants for Potrero de los Cerritos, three square leagues, granted March 23, 1844, by Manuel Micheltorena to T. Pacheco and A. Alviso; claim filed May 31, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 14, 1854, by the District Court October 29, 1855, and by the United States Supreme Court; containing 10,610.26 acres. Patented February 21, 1866.
Antonio Maria Peralta, claimant for part of San Antonio, two square leagues, granted August 16, 1820, by Pablo V. de Sola to Luis Peralta; claim filed June 18, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 7, 1854, by the District Court December 4, 1855, and appeal dismissed October 20, 1857. Patented February 3, 1858.
Ignacio Peralta, claimant for part of San Antonio, two square leagues, granted August 16, 1820, by Pablo V. de Sola to Luis Peralta; claim filed June 18, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 7, 1854, by the District Court January 13, 1857, and appeal dismissed April 20, 18.57. Patented February 10, 1877.
Guillermo Castro, claimant for 'part of San Lorenzo, six hundred varas square, granted February 23, 1841, by Juan B. Alvarado to G. Castro and for San Lorenzo, six square leagues, granted October 24, 1843,- by Manuel Micheltorena to G. Castro; claim filed July 8, 1852, confirmed by the Commission February 14, 1853, by the District Court July 6, 1855, and appeal dismissed January 16, 1858. Patented April 14, 1877.
Barbara Soto et al., claimants for San Lorenzo, one and a half square leagues, granted October 10, 1842, by Manuel Micheltorena and January 20, 1844, by Juan B. Alvarado to Francisco Soto; claim filed January 22, 1853, confirmed by the Commission April 24, 1855, by the District Court April 23, 1857, and appeal dismissed April 29, 1857. Patented February 14, 1865.
Archbishop Joseph Sadoc Alemany, claimant for Mission San Jos6, in Alameda County, founded under Carlos IV., June ii, 1797; claim filed February 19, 1853, confirmed by the Commission December 18, 1855, appeal dismissed in Northern District, March 16, 1857, and in Southern District March 15, 1858; containing 28.33 acres. Patented March 3, 1858.
Guillermo Castro, claimant for land granted January 14, 1840, by Juan^ B. Alvarado to G. Castro; claim filed March 2, 1853, rejected by the Commission, May IS, 185s, and appeal dismissed for failure of prosecution March 9, 1857.
Charles B. Strode, claimant for part of San Antonio, 5,000 acres, granted by P. V. de Sola and Luis Antonio Arguello to Luis Peralta; claim filed March 2, 1853. Discontinued.
Charles B. Strode, claimant for part of San Antonio, 10,000 acres, grantedjby P. V. de Sola and Luis Antonio Arguello to Luis Peralta; claim filed March 2, 1853. Discontinued.
Table
Showing the Number of Land C.^vimissitner Claims, Name of Ranch, Name of Confirmee, Number ]of Acres, and Date of Patent of the Different Spanish and Mexican Grants in Alameda County, Supplied by the Surveyor- Genbral of California. '
AND the Lord said unto Cain, Where is thy brother? And he said, I know not: am I my brother's keeper ? And he said, what has thou done ? The voice of thy brother's blood crieth unto me from the ground. And now art thou cursed from the earth, which had opened her mouth to receive thy brother's blood from thy hand; when thou tillest the ground, it shall not henceforth yield to thee her stfength; a fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth." Thus is graphically given us on the page of divine history the record of the first murder that ever the sun shone upon or the eye of God looked upon, and the woful curse pronounced upon the author of that foulest of all crimes by the Supreme Judge of the universe. And how tenaciously has that curse followed the generations of life-takers down from Cain to the present day. "A fugitive and a vagabond shalt thou be in the earth!" How natural when a man has taken that from a fellow-man which no power of his can restore, no amends make any adequate reparation, has taken his life and shed his blood, to become a fugitive! The first impulse is to flee. A power he knows not of until the horrid deed is done impels him on, and ere he is aware he has become a fugitive. And he becomes a vagabond too! No matter if the lax operations of the Courts allow him to return to society, the deed has been committed, the blood is on his hands just the same, and all who know him can see it. He can see it, too, far more plainly than others, for it is burned into his consciousness by, the flaniing tongue of conscience, a chasm is riven between him and human society, and wherever he goes, if it is known that he has blood upon his hands, the finger of humanity is pointed at him, and he hears the voice of outraged and, oftentimes, cheated justice, exclaiming in loudest tones: "He is a murderer!" The vengeance of the Author of mankind justly follows him up who presumes to take the life of a human being - a being created in the image of the Divine Creator. After the waters of the flood had subsided, and the generations of men were again starting out to run the course of destiny, God spake to Noah and his sons, saying: "And surely your blood of your lives will I require * * * at the hand of every man's brother will I require the life of man. Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed; for in the image of God made he man." And when the people of his choice were upon the road to enter the rich inheritance which had been given to their fathers hundreds of years before, he caused them to halt, and amid the thunderings of Sinai he declared to them in language explicit, simple, and grand: "Thou shalt not kill." And when the great master, Jesus, came, he embraced all law, all gospel, and all ethical codes into one grand, glorious sentence which stands emblazoned upon the sacred page in letters of living light, and which shall shed forth rays of brightest effulgence all down the ages of the great eternity of God when time shall 'have ceased, and only immortality exists: "Whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them."
On the leaves of a leather-bound memorandum-book, found in the heart of an Arizona desert, the following self-reproaches and self-accusations were written in pencil.
Near by it the half-decomposed remains of a human being - a murderer - whose cUrse had truly been more than he could bear. How he suffered let his own simple story relate, as placed on record by the same hand that had sent a human soul unprepared into the presence of its Maker: -
" Blood on my hands ! A blur of crimson before my eyes ! The skies are brazen above me. The sun is sick with g6re. The winds from the desert shriek at me - shriek and howl; and this one word only do they wail in my ears - this dreadful word, 'Murder!' I stop my ears with my hands; I cry aloud to drown their wailing voices; I cannot drown it; I cannot keep it out. It pierces me - pierces me through and through.
" What is it? I am bewildered. Why am I flyihg as one who seeks the ends of the earth? Yesterday earth had no h6rror for me. The winds were only winds^ not demon voices. Ah, now I recollect. God pity me! Pity? I forgot! He can only curse me. Annihilate me, O God! Blot me out from the universe. TAai would be pity.
"It all comes back to me now. It is seared in my brain. The long search for the mine; the days in the desert, in the mountains; and then, behind that hill that overlooks the ' Valley of Death,' the vein of white, shining silver - wealth for a king. Then it swept over me - my years of poverty and toil, the cold sneer of the rich as they saw my penury - and here was wealth. I would have it all - aU. Not even my partner should share the treasure. I was mad. He stooped to pick up the precious metal, and I struck him - kim, the friend of my toils, and one who had never failed me - him, who had shared his food with me, who had slept upon the desert, in the mountains, under the same blanket; who had nursed me in sickness - I struck Aim to the earth. God, I was mad! Then I was alone with my wealth; with my wealth - ah! and the dead. I had not thought of the cold, still face that would lie there a/Ur the. blow; of the sightless eyes staring to heaven. TAen the madness left me. I threw myself beside him; prayed him to awake; felt for the heart-beat. Dead - dead. O my God ! Dead ! the friend of my toils. And I was a murderer - a murderer!"
" Wandering, still wandering. Earth has no rest for my feet; and I am so weary ! When I step the earth spurns me, and the pitiless skies cry: 'On! On!' Starving! Penniless! and there, back there, is wealth untold. Yet I dare not seek it, dare not tell of it; for there, too, is that cold, still face with the sightless eyes gazing at the heavens, and the red blood crying, ever crying to God. I wander on, and I can feel upon my brow a brand like Cain. It is a brand of blood - hot, burning blood. I walk among men and I feel that they must see it - it is there. I pull my hat over my brow - closely; oh, so closely - down to my eyes, but they must see it. The, brand of Cain!
The brand of Cain! O God, it is upon me! For days I have wandered in the mountains, thirsting, hungering, trembling at the stir of a leaf. Yet death comes not to me. The wild beasts avoid me. The savages pass me by, and harm me not I suffer, faint - -but do not die."
How vividly has Thomas Hood been inspired to portray the feelings of a man whose hands have b^en imbued with a fellow-man's blood, and whose heart-throb has been stilled by one fell blow. Ay, indeed: -
IL And tell how murderers walk the earth Beneath the curse of Cain, With crimson clouds before their eyes, And flames about their brain; For blood has left upon their souls
One that had never done me wrong - A feeble man, and old; I led him to a lonely field, The moon shone clear and cold: Now, here, said I, this man shall die, And I will have his gold:
IV. Two sudden blows with a ragged stick. And one with a heavy stone, One hurried gash with a hasty knife - And then the deed was done ! There was nothing lying at my foot But lifeless flesh and bone !
But lo! the universal air Seemed lit with ghastly flame - Ten thousand thousand dreadful eyes Were looking down in blame; I took the dead man by his hand
VII. Then down I cast me on my face, And first began to weep. For I knew my secret then was one That earth refused to keep; Or land or sea, though he should be Ten thousand fathoms deep.
' Indeed this love of crime is a fatality that would appear to follow the Indian into his partial civilization, the Mexican-Spaniard from his native clime, the Anglo- Saxon from his far-off land, and the Mongolian from his Flowery Kingdom. All would seem lost to the natural cry which springs alike from instinct and religion, for chilling murders are not committed by the violent and passionate alone; we might almost say, would that they were, then would the horrid deed be confined to the crouching assassin and the hellish act of suicide be the work of the insane. But human nature is various and confusing in its many failings; temper will outstrip discretion, a blow will be struck, a shot fired, and life will be sacrificed, and though escape of present punishment may be effected, happily it is assured that a dread fear of detection in the future will haunt the criminal, for it is truly said, " conscience doth make cowards of us all."
1853. - The first serious criminal act that we have been enabled to trace as having been committed in Alameda County took place shortly after its segregation from Contra Costa and Santa Clara, and was the shooting of Albert Scott.
This man was shot by Franklin Uray on September 9, 1853. From the evidence eUcited before the Justice of the Peace it would appear that the parties were residents of Clinton Township. Uray being a farmer, and the land which he occupied being' in dispute. Scott was 'employed to guard a fence erected on Uray's claim, which the latter tore down, when a dispute ensued, resulting in the shooting of the former. The Justice of the Peace did not think the case of sufficient gravity to commit Uray for trial. On October 20, 1853, a man named Henry Colvin was shot by Frank Hale, near San Leandro Creek. From the evidence adduced it seems that the parties had been disputing, when Colvin pursued Hale with a club, striking him several' times, when the latter turned round and shot him. Hale was discharged by the Justice, and a verdict of " self-defense" recorded. The next case is that of the shooting of Henry Blake by Charles Martinez on August 7, 1853. At the preliminary examination had before the Justice of the Peace, bail was fixed at five hundred dollars, and from the evidence then heard it would appear that Blake and some others went to the house of Martinez, when a quarrel ensued and there the shooting took place.
1854. - Among the criminal papers of the year 1854, evidence was taken before the Justice of the Peace on March 14th of shooting at Constable Carpenter by J. B. Heap. The crime took place at the " Gate House," in Clinton Township, where the constable was called to quell a disturbance, the inmates having a dance, and being all more or less drunk and disorderly. It does not appear, however, that Carpenter was hurt. On June 15, 1854, Antonio Garcia, Domingo, Marshall, and William McCoy were complained of as the murderers of William Wettig. It seems that these men had gone to the foot-hills to hunt cattle-thieves, and from the statements made in evidence by them, came upon Wettig, with freshly-killed beef upon his horse. They made accusation, which resulted in a quarrel, when one of the Spaniards, Domingo, killed him, and then made his escape. Garcia, McCoy, and Marshall were apprehended, and the last named held to answer as an accessory before the fact. Somewhere, about this date George Zimmerman, Charles Wilson, and Israel C. Townley had a preliminary examination in the matter of an assault with intent to take the hfe of John C. Pelton, at San Leandro, the dispute being in regard to the ownership of some hogs. Wilson and Zimmerman were held to answer, bail for the former being fixed at seven hundred dollars, and one thousand for the latter.
1855. - On July 7, 185s, we find \.\i-aX John Doewz.s indicted for the killing of John Fanning; while, at the same term, a man called "Mack" (his other name being unknown), and H. Hastings were indicted for killing Peter Rochblam, and Amada Canute, on or about the 23d or 24th August of the previous year. Among the criminal papers, we find the case of the People vs. Hosea (possibly meant for Jos6) Antonio. This individual was indicted by the Grand jury at a Special Term of the Court of Sessions, held August 17, 1855 (the minutes of the Grand Jury accompany the papers) for killing Joqquen {sic) by stabbing him in the back. The indictment was set aside on motion of defendant's counsel, Benjamin Williams, on the ground that the County Judge had no authority of law to call a Special Term of said Court. The defendant gave bonds for his appearance to answer any indictment that might be found by a regularly constituted Grand Jury.
1856-1857. - There is now either a discontinuity in the records or a reign of terror signalized, for there appear to have been no very serious crimes committed in the county during the next two years.
1858. - On May 10, 1858, a man nained Cruz was indicted for the tnurder of one Frederico; was tried at the July term of the Court of Sessions and found not guilty. We also find that there was a criminal case, entitled the People vs. Francisco Routires, recorded in this year, but there are no documents on file to show what the circumstances of the affair were. A reward was offered by Governor John B. Weller> November 25th of this year, for the arrest of the murderer of Ciriaco Sacre, a Chileho, who was cruelly slain on a little island near Alvarado about eighteen months previously.
1859. - On April 11, 1859, there commenced a trial for murder, before the Third District Court, at San Leandro, Judge McKee presiding, in which great public interest was manifested. The circumstances which led to the case of the people vs. Thomas Seale, took place in Santa Clara on January 6, 1859. It would appear that Scale and a family named Shore were joint proprietors of a certain portion of the Rinconada de San Francisquito Rancho in that county. Each had bought out an interest in the ranch - Seale holding several shares and the Shores had bought out but one heir, the property remaining undivided between them. But Seale had gone on to the premises, had improved and inclosed a large body of the land, a thousand acres or more, and was in the enjoyment of it - in fact had appropriated to his own use land that was common property. On the date mentioned above, Richard E. and Paul C. Shore, assisted by a youth named Lewis, were putting up a house on these lands, when Thomas Seale and S. J. Crosby came up and an altercation ensued between Seale and Richard Shore. In the meantime there appeared on the scene one Alexander Robb. Continuing his work, Richard Shore stepped up on a bench, when he was pitched off by Seale. Shore then ordered him to keep back, when Seale drew a pistol half-way out of his pocket. Near by, Paul C. Shore was standing leaning on the handle of an ax. Seeing him, Seale ordered him to put down the ax in very rough language, which was not complied with, when Seale made for him with the drawn pistol, he received a blow from the ax, and dropped his pistol, for which a grab was made by Crosby and Robb, Seale then drew another weapon, and firing, it took effect, the victim never afterwards speaking. Seale then went to San Josd and gave himself up to the authorities, while Cipsby and Robb were apprehended as accessories. At the session of the Grand Jury which convened in the month of March, true bills were found against Seale and Robb, but that against Crosby was ignored. During the session of the District Court at San Jos4 on Monday, March 28, 1859, the case of the people vs. Thomas Seale and Alexander Robb, indicted for the murder of Paul C. Shore, being set for the following day, an indiscriminate shooting affray took place, which resulted in the death of S. J. Crosby, the Coroner's jury finding that the deceased came to his death by three or more shots from pistols, by the hand of Thomas Shore or Richard Shore. But this was not the end of this bloody chapter. While the tragedy last mentioned was being performed without the Court House, ode of a nature still more painful was being acted within. L. Posey Fergusson, a miner from Gra^s Valley, who visited San ]os6 to accompany an old friend home to Missouri, had entered the court-room and was listening to the proceedings, when firing was heard. Remarking, "What does that mean?" he went towards the door and got upon a bench, when a ball from the outside, after passing through planking three inches and a quarter in thickness, struck him on the breast, when he cried out to a friend named Stewart, standing by, "John, I am a dead man !" He stepped back a few paces, then sank on a bench, and died in half an hour. The Coroner's jury found that the shot had been fired by the hand of Samuel J. Crosby, at certain persons standing in front of the Court House. Under these circumstances it was deemed advisable to change the scene of trial from Santa Clara to Alameda County. After a trial lasting five days the jury failed to agree on a verdict, therefore another jury was immediately impaneled, and after three days trial the case was given to the jury, who, after occupying two days more, returned a verdict of " Not guilty."
In 1859, we ascertain from the records that Miguel Marquis was tried for the crime of murder when, October 9th, a verdict of guilty was rendered. He was sentenced to be hanged on the 25th of November, but a new trial being granted, he was convicted, at the July term, of murder in the second degree and sent to the State Prison for life.
On December 2, 1859, Ventura Aipen stabbed to death Marcus Castillo, and was indicted under the name of "Ventura" at the January term following. He was tried, found guilty of manslaughter, and sentenced to two years in the State Prison.
i860. - At the September term of the Court of. Sessions Ah Path was indicted for stabbing and cutting to death, in Oakland, How Sam on September 9, i860, the cause of quarrel being a sum of money owed Ah Path by How Sam. The slayer was tried, found guilty of murder, and. sentenced to be hanged January 11, 1861. Meanwhile a motion for a new trial was made and denied; the case was then appealed, to the Supreme Court, who affirmed the judgment of the Court below.
On November 19, i860, Ramon Romero was indicted for the crime of murder, was tried and convicted at the November term of the District Court, i860; found guilty and sentenced to be executed on January i, 1861; but on a new trial being granted he was acquitted, November 22, 1861. He subsequently found his way to Sacramento, where he was guilty of killing another man with a knife.
1861. - In the Court of Sessions of the city and county of San Francisco, at the February terni, 1861, James H.. Hardy was indicted for aiding and abetting the killing of Samuel NewelLby Horace Smith, on January i, 1861. Motion for a new trial was ii)ade and granted and the cause transferred to Alameda County, where it, was tried and a verdict of " not guilty" rendered.
At the January term of the Court of Sessions in this year, Edward W. Bonney was indicted for stabbing to death Augusto G. Hirsch on January 13, 1861. The case came to trial in July following, and on, the 27th of that month a verdict of "guilty of murder in the first degrpe as charged in the indictment" was rendered. Motion fo^. arrest pf judgment and a new trial was made and overruled by thp Court, and on
August 2d, he was sentenced to be hanged on September 7, 1861. An appeal was taken to the Supreme Court, the judgment affirmed, and date of execution again fixed for April 25, 1862, but a respite of fourteen days was granted by Governor Stanford. He was ultimately executed May 9, 1862. Both parties were residents of San Francisco and had been friends. The hanging of Bonney was the first legal execution for any crime that ever took place in Alameda County. He died protesting his innocence although the evidence against him was very conclusive.
1863. - On November 12, 1863, a quarrel occurred at San Antonio (Brooklyn) which resulted in the death of Juan Andrada, a Chilean, by the hand of ]os6 Pizarro (Cosa), a Mexican. It commenced about a small bill ; from words it proceeded to a hand-to-hand fight. The parties were separated by the spectators, when Pizarro went away, but returned in about half an hour armed with a bowie-knife. He found Andrada in the kitchen of Cruz Edilla, opposite the hotel then kept by Tom. Hill, and demanding his hat from him was answered that he knew nothing about the sombrero. Pizarro then dragged Andrada through the door, when in the tussle that followed both fell to the ground from the outside platform, some three or four steps high. As they got lip Pizarro stabbed his opponent with the bowie-knife under the left arm outside of the chest, running upward and slightly inward, severing the subclavian artery and vein of the arm. Andrada did not live three minutes. Pizarro was duly tried at the January term, 1864, found guilty of murder in the second degree, and on being recommended to the merCy of the Court, February 20, 1864, was s'entenced- to4mprisonment in the State Prison for ten years.
1865. - A terrible murder occurred at San Antonio (Brooklyn) on the night of September 36, 1865. The circumstances are briefly these: A dance was being held at Louis Lerreaux's hotel. About half past eleven o'clock, Samuel S. Kennedy, a Scotchman, who had been a resident of Brooklyn for some five or six years, somewhat intoxicated, approached the door-keeper and desired admission, which was refused. A Frenchman, named Cora, of San Pablo, was standing outside the door at the time, and angry words were passed between himself and Kennedy, but no blows were, at that time, exchanged. Cora crossed over the street, returning after a short time and recommenced the war of words. Taking off his hat Kennedy shoved it close up to Cora's face, when the latter returned the insult by giving the former a blow with a sling-shot, or some other dangerous weapon, on the right temple, causing him to totter and fall against the side of the house. Recovering himself Kennedy rushed towards Cora, but was so drunk that he fell flat on his face. While in this position, Cora struck him on the head several times, breaking the skull so that the brain protruded, and at the same time kicked him heavily in the face. Cora was perfectly sober at the time. From the effects of the wound Kennedy died two days afterwards. Cora was indicted at the January term, 1866, tried and found guilty of manslaughter
March 2, 1866, the Judge being recommended to "give the full extent of the law." He was sentenced to three years imprisonment in the State Prison.
On September 24, 1865, Jos^ Ruparda stabbed one Rosindo, who died from the effects of the wound on October 9, 1865. The murderer was indicted in the January term, 1 866, tried, found guilty of murder in the second degree, and, February 24, 1 866, sentenced to thirteen years imprisonment in the State Prison.
About this period Murray and Washington townships were infested by bands of horse and cattle thieves, stock poisoners, and incendiaries, and so incessant and daring were their depredations that a firm determination to put a stop to their maraudings was come to by the citizens. To this end a meeting was held at Centreville, April I, 1865, when they resolved to form theijiselves into a Vigilance Committee, Thomas Scott being chosen President, Dr. J. M. Selfridge, Secretary, and William Tyson, Treasurer, in addition to whom an executive committee of twelve members was appointed. A salutary effect was the immediate result of this move, causing the rogues to be more on their guard. A reward of five hundred dollars for the conviction of the person or persons who a short time previously poisoned a wheat-field ' belonging to Mr. Ellsworth, was at this time offered by the committee.
In the month of October of this year the house of Charles Garthwait, near Pleasanton, was robbed during his absence. The burglars, however, received a warm reception from Mrs. Garthwait, who wounded one of them named Welch, who was subsequently arrested, tried, and convicted of grand larceny in the County Court and sentenced by Judge Hamilton to eighteen months imprisonment in the State Prison. Mr. Halley says he told a tale of his hardships, which, if true, entitled him to sympathy, and reminds one of some of the incidents in the play of the Ticket of Leave Man. Welch stated that after serving a term some time previously at San Quentin, he resolved to lead a correct life, and went honestly to work on a ranch in Santa Clara County. Pretty soon, however, some of his acquaintances, formed during the term of his confinement, came along and recognizing him threatened to " blow" on him if he did not give them money. He stood this as long as he could, but finally fled from them to avoid exposure, and went over among the Amador Hills, where he thought himself secure from his vile tormentors. He had been there but a little while when his confederates in the crime for which he was then suffering made their appearance and recognized him. They declared if he did not go with them and assist to commit robbery they would kill him, and he yielded.
1866. - The following particulars of a horrible murder perpetrated at Corral Hollow, are gleaned from the columns of the Alta California of May 19, 1866: Edward, or better known as " Sandy," Simpson, who was well to do, and the owner a store on the Stockton Road, near Amador Valley,,was foully murdered by two men on Friday morning the 12th instant, and it is supposed for money he had about him at the time. It seems that on last Thursday evening two men, one a black-whiskered man and the other wearing no beard, stopped at Simpson's store and requested something to eat and a night's lodging, which was granted them. Next morning, at an «arly hour, the shepherds attached to the ranch went to attend to their daily labors. During the day the deceased's brother discovered the body, with a horrible wound on the right side of the head, caused by a rifle-shot from the rifle of the deceased. The alarm was given, but though every effort was made to capture the assassins there is no record to show that they were ever apprehended.
A murder occurred in Murray Township, at Pleasanton, on Friday evening, August lO, 1866, the victim and the murderer being both Mexicans, the former named Ricardo, the latter Marcus Chavoya. The origin of the difficulty was a lawsuit which took place a short time before between the parties, and which occasioned ill-feeling since it transpired. The murderer surrendered himself on the day following to Sheriff Morse, at San Leandro, and also the pistol with which he committed the deed. On giving himself up to the authorities he made the following statement : On the evening in. question, he said, that Ricardo, who was drunk at the time, came to his house and tried to effect an entrance by cutting through the door with a long knife with which he threatened to kill Chavoya. The latter armed himself with a revolver, opened the door and told Ricardo to go away - that he did not wish to have any quarrel with him. Ricardo refused and Chavoya fired at him twice - or, rather, in the air - so as to scare him off". Ricardo instead of retreating made a rush at Chavoya for the purpose of stabbing him, when the latter shot him fatally. He was discharged on the ground of justifiable homicide.
A mulatto barber by the name of Manley, says the San Leandro Gazette of October 30, 1866, who was in a shop adjoining the Exchange Saloon at the Mission San Jos^, was discovered lying in the street on Wednesday morning, near his shop, with one ear nearly severed from his head, and so terribly bruised and beaten as to be unable to speak, and he died during the day. It appears that during the previous evening some difficulty occurred between him and a young man named Hyde, at Elbridge's Saloon. Manley subsequently went to his shop and to bed. About midnight, Hyde and one Griffin awoke him and endeavored to induce him to come outside, but failed. They then dragged him out and in self-defense Manley used a razor on his assailants, wounding Hyde in the abdomen and shoulder. Hyde succeeded in getting him into the street and there brutally beat him with a bottle and kicked him until, as stated, death resulted from the injuries. Hyde was arrested, and, after examination before Justice Bond, committed to await the action of the Grand Jury.
1867. - In the July term of this year, Jos^ Guliful Choreen was indicted, tried, and acquitted of the charge of having shot and killed Amilio Higuera on June 25, 1864.
On June 6, 1867, a fracas of a fatal character occurred at the ranch of Robert Livermore, in Livermore Valley. A Californian named Moche, who had been drinking heavily, made an attack with a knife upon a young man called Foscalini, who avoided him several times, but finally turned upon him and discharged his pistol at him, emptying three chambers of the weapon, each shot taking eifect. Both parties were on horseback. The wounded man insta;ntly wheeled his horse, rode away rapidly and soon disappeared. When about three miles from the place of shooting, Moche fell heavily from his horse, head foremost, to the ground, and when approached was found to be dead, his neck having been broken by the fall. It was found however, that either of the shots was sufficient to kill him. Foscalini surrendered himself and after an examination before Justice Mark of Pleasanton was dismissed. Moche, who was partly paralyzed, was, nevertheless, considered a desperate and dangerous man. Some ten years previous it was said he attacked a stage single-handed, and on the refusal of the driver to pull up, sent a shot from his revolver through it.
On June 30, 1867, a very tragic affair occurred at Mount Eden; a Dane, named Peter Jobson Schmidt, having murdered his sister and then shot and killed himself Contrary to his wish, his sister, whom he had sent for to his native land some time previously, had determined to marry a young man in the neighborhood, and it seems that this drove him crazy. Schmidt was a farmer, owning one hundred and twelve acres, and unmarried, his sister keeping house for him. The poorgirlmade a desperate struggle for life, and the contest was a severe one. Two shots from his gun had entered her body; the first below her right nipple and the second in her heart. Whether the affection the man had for his sister, or the weight of his financial troubles, with which he was beset, had upset his reason, is not known; but he had formerly proved himself a man of good character. Indeed, he had previously made a will, in which he devised all his estate to his sister Jane, the girl whose life he took, and whose fate he thus horribly ended with his own.
At the July term, 1867, Charles M. Diel was indicted for the crime of assault with intent to murder, committed at Centreville upon the person of William Neal, whom he wounded above the hip no less than three times, on June 28, 1867. He was tried, found guilty, and sentenced to imprisonment for one year in the State Prison.
At the January term, 1867, John Hyde was indicted for beating one Manley on October 23, 1866, so that he died on the following day; while, at the September term, a man named Hill was indicted for beating to death with a club an individual called Manuel, on August 8, 1867. Hill was tried, found guilty of manslaughter and, November nth, sentenced to seven years imprisonment at San Quentin.
On October 3, 1867, about two o'clock in the morning, several persons were engaged in a game of poker in Greavenor's saloon at Haywards, when a dispute arose, and one of the party, a Chileno, named Narrato Ponce, left the room, and shortly after returned with a pistol, which he pointed at those present, and, firing, eventually shot Lewis Joy in the left side, the ball passing through the lung and body and lodging in the right arm. He then walked a few steps into an adjoining room and fell dead. As soon as the firing commenced the lights were extinguished, and under cover of the darkness the slayer effected his escape, leaving his horse behind him in the corral. The redoubtable Sheriff, Harry Morse, was soon placed in full information of the dastardly deed, and kept a sharp lookout for the Chileno, but it was not until late in the month of October that he had any reliable information as to whither he had fled. This intelligence was at last received: it was that Ponce had made his retreat to the mountainous regions of Murray Township at the back of Liverpiore Valley. ,On November ist. Officer Conway, of Oakland, who, having obtained authority from the Mayor and Marshal of the city, joined Sheriff Morse, and both proceeded to Dublin, in the Amador Valley, where, leaving their buggy, thence started on horseback for the place where the murderer was supposed to be concealed. Sheriff Morse was in possession of secret information that during that night the Chileno would pass down a by-road and into the telegraph or main traveled road for the purpose of escaping to the lower country. The Sheriff and Officer Conway accordingly took positions' at the gate leading into the by-path, in the shadow of a hay-stack, there to await the coming of their man. About half-past nine o'clock horse's footsteps were heard coming up on the gallop, when the Sheriff recognized the voice of the murderer and a companion. The officers had the gate tied so as to prevent hrs escape. The Chileno opened the gate, tied it, and came towards the officers. When he got within ten feet of Sheriff Morse the latter drew a shot-gun and ordered him to stop, which he refused to do, but turned his horse round quickly and started back, only to be met by Officer Conway, who leveled a six-shooter and commenced firing at him, Sheriff Morse having discharged a load of buck-shot at the murderer, striking him in the back, the Chileno drew his revolver and banged away twice at Conway without effect. With the last shot fired by Conway, Ponce fell from his horse; but he was not so badly wounded as to prevent his running on foot down alongside the fence. Conway had to go back to the hay-stack after his Henry rifle, which took him a little time, thus enabling the murderer to hide himself in the darkness. Sheriff Morse fired three shots; Conway five, his last missing fire. The officers hunted about for their quarry in the darkness until two o'clock in the morning, but could find no traces of him. When daylight came they made a further search up towards the hills, having employed eight or ten Mexicans to aid them, and discovered the Chileno's coat completely riddled with buck-shot and balls. Haifa mile from where this garment was found his boots were picked up, which, for some reason or other,. Ponce had pulled off and left. The murderer's horse, a small Mexican mare, was wounded in the thigh, and was not worth bringing away.
Nothing further was heard of Narrato Ponce until the 7th of November, when Sheriff Morse received a letter from Sheriff Classen, of Contra Costa County, informing him that if he repaired to Martinez he would give him information as to the whereabouts of him whom they sought. At eight o'clock the energetic Morse was at the rendezvous, prompt and prepared. The intelligence received was that Ponce was supposed to be in Cisco, Placer County. For Cisco, Morse started, accompanied by Deputy Sheriff Swain, of Contra Costa County. The intention was to take steamboat for Sacramento at Antioch, and to that place they proceeded. Here they learned that instead of being at Cisco, Narrato was concealed in Rigg's Canon, near Monte Diablo. To reach the place designated they had to return, by boat, to San Francisco, cross from there to San Leandro, where, taking saddle-horses, they proceeded to the Black Hills, north of Livermore Valley. Officer Conway, of Oakland, again accompanied the gallant Sheriff from San Leandro, and at eleven o'clock at night the party arrived at the canon specified. They at once surrounded the house where the murderer was supposed to be concealed, but no further action was taken until break of day. When dawn came a thorough search failed to discover the object of their solicitude, and scouting parties in the hills brought no tidings save the discovery of his hiding-place, where he had been in the habit of concealing himself before his first skirmish with the Sheriff.
At this juncture they met an old native, who, upon being examined and threatened, conveyed the information that Narrato's hiding-place at that particular time was near the bay, at Pinole. A rapid return was made to San Leandro; from there they went to San Francisco, where they took passage for Martinez, the place to which they had originally set out. On the following morning they started for Pinole, which is eleven miles south of Martinez and seven east of San Pablo. They searched all the houses through the valley as they went. Arriving at the house of one Jose Rojos they saw a man on the mountain side with a bundle on one arm and a shotgun on the other, whom they thought might be the person they were looking for. Conway and Swain went into the house with instructions to let no one out until Morse had ascertained who it was that was on the hill-side. At the moment of the Sheriff getting to the hill, he heard Swain cry out, "He's here," and directly thereafter was heard the report of a pistol-shot. Morse immediately directed his horse to the house on a run, when he discovered Narrato Ponce running away, trying to escape from the officers, who were shooting after him as rapidly as possible. A ravine intervening, Morse had to dismount. He immediately called upon the fugitive to stop and lay down a pistol he carried in his right hand, but the latter paid no attention to this command and kept on running, endeavoring to make good his escape. A shot from Conway here struck him in the right hand, causing him to change his weapon to the other, with which he kept his pursuers covered. Finding that the villain was determined not to be taken "alive, the Sheriff concluded to finish the affair, he therefore sent four shots from his Henry rifle after him, and all failing, a fifth was dispatched, and found its billet, sending him forward on his face, in which position he died, his pistol being firmly clinched in his hand. His body was removed and a Coroner's jury summoned, who returned the following verdict: -
Provenance
Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.