Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 26 of 38)
From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,946 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,946 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
" Mr. Burnham, from the Committee appointed to confer with the Messrs. Redstone, announced that those gentlemen would confer with, their Committee and give an answer to the Council in half an hour; if they decided to forego the meeting he did not see the necessity of issuing the address. Doctor Merritt here detailed the subjectmatter of the Conference to the effect that the Messrs. Redstone would cheerfully comply with what was right.
"Mr. Miller considered that the address was opportune and should not be rescinded, which was concurred in by others who spoke on the subject.
" Mr. Sohst moved that the address be signed by the Mayor and Council, and attested by the City Clerk, and so published and issued, which was adopted.
Resolved, That Dr. S. Merritt, L. G. Cole, A. C. Henry, J. M. Walker, George H. Wheaton, and J. F. Houghton, be and are hereby authorized to have enrolled upon a Committee of Safety, all good citizens of each ward to assist the City Authorities in preserving the peace and good name of our city.
"Mayor Pardee suggested that when the City Council adjourn they repair to the Union Club Rooms and enroll their names as members of the Union Protection Association.
" The Messrs. Redstone here entered the Council Room and J. H. Redstone, in behalf of the Committee, reported that ths Committee of Workingmen had agreed not to hold a mass-meeting; but would have one one week from to-night to discuss the Coolie Question and its bearings, and desired the co-operation of the Council; they had been to some expense in postponing the mass-meeting, which he thought should be defrayed by the Council. Mr. Miller here interposed and stated the Council had no legal right to use its funds for that purpose. The mieeting then adjourned.'"
On the 2d of August the Committee of Safety made a report to the City Council : let us see what they did towards a system of protection. They say: "Immediately upon receiving such authority (that conferred by the resolution quoted above) we appointed a sub-committee of three in each ward to canvass and enroll for active duty the citizens of their several wards in such numbers as would insure the effectual suppression of any breach of the peace within our city. The result of this canvass was the enrollment of nine hundred and fifty-two names from among our best citizens, divided into seven separate organizations, one for each ward, each under the command of a captain, two lieutenants and other officers, all duly elected by their respective organizations and the whole placed under the command of Col. William C. Little, who was appointed by us the Executive Officer of the whole organization to act under orders of the City Authorities.
" The several companies have met at their respective' headquarters every night since their organization for drill and instruction, and have attained a proficiency which will render them of great assistance to the authorities in case their services should be hereafter required; and, although the immediate cause which called it into existence seems to have passed and active drill and regular meetings will from this time be dispensed with, the organization will be kept up ready to respond to your call whenever occasion may require.''
President Walter then stated that some expre.ssion should be given by the Council and thanks tendered to the community for their indefatigable exertions in maintaining order and preserving the peace of the city, and called upon his Honor, Mayor Pardee, who eloquently responded, alluding to the labors of the Committee, and concluded by thanking them and those who had enrolled to prevent insurrection and riot in the city. Mr. Miner next moved that the thanks of the Council be tendered to the Executive Committee of the Committee of Safety, which was unanimously adopted viva voce.
Whereas, Through the interposition of Divine Providence we have suffered thi loss of an excellent citizen and the city of Oakland an honest and capable judicial, one who was ever foremost in the maintenance of the right', and the true vindication of the law, therefore be it
Resolved, That in the death of the Hon. A. H. Jayne, Police Judge of the city of Oakland, this city has sustained an irreparable loss. He was free from the taint of corruption; a man whose character and reputation were both commendable and respected; a strict observer of the law in all respects, and dealing with evil-doers to the fullest extent, it can be said of him that he leaves behind a record spotless as a bright and shining example to those who desire to live uprightly and profit thereby.
Resolved, That this preamble and these resolutions be spread upon the minutes of the City Council and a copy of the same be transmitted to the relatives of deceased.
1878. - On May 6th an ordinance levying a Library Tax was passed, sind on the 27th the Oakland Library Association and Union Reading-room Association handed over their property to the city, and on the same date Messrs; A.P.Flint, O.H. Burnham, W. W. Crane, Jr., G. M. Fisher, and J. P. Moore, were elected Trustees thereof; and, on June 3d, an ordinance calling for the numbering of public vehicles was passed; while on July 1st, an ordinance to establish and regulate a street market, was promulgated and A. M. Church appointed Superintendent thereof On August 5th a memorial was received from E. J. Kelly and others praying the City Council to abolish the collecting of licenses, and employ idle citizens to make bricks and construct the Mainlake Sewer; and, August 5th, the Golden Gate District Agricultural Fair Association was granted a lease for five years of Lafayette Square to erect buildings thereon.
On December 2, 1878, the Council ordered the sum of fifty dollars per month each to be paid to the Oakland Ladies' Relief Society and Orphans' Home, and Oakland Benevolent Society, such amounts to be paid out of the fines collected in the Police Court. On January 20, 1879, however, the Mayor vetoed the ordinance granting monthly stipends, which was sustained by the Council, but afterwards passed with certain modifications. It was again vetoed by the Mayor, but on the 3d February passed over his veto.
1879. - On January 6th, the names of West Twelfth, Twelfth, and East Twelfth Streets were changed so that the whole should in future be known as Central Avenue,
" The interest-bearing debt of the city amounts to six hundred and fifty-four thousand ($654,000) dollars. Of this amount one hundred and seventy-three thousand ($173,000) dollars are for the Main-lake Sewer, which will ultimately be refunded to the city, the Supreme Court having decided that such bonds must be paid b}- the owners of the property benefited by the improvement. This reduces the actual fur.ded debt of the city to four hundred and eighty-one thousand ($481,000) dollars, or one and seven-tenths (i ' ) of one per cent, on the amount of the city assessment-roll. There are certainly but very few American cities as large as this that can show as good a financial condition. To offset this debt of less than half a million dollars, the city is the owner of property valued at seven hundred and seventy-five thousand two hundred and twenty ($775,220) dollars, consisting of City Hall, engine and school houses; so that Oakland is practically out of debt, according to the rules that any individual would apply to his own business. The condition of the city's General Expense Fund is not so flattering. On the 1st of January, the Treasurer reports that the bills payable from the general fund, and not paid for want of money, amounted to twenty-nine thousand four hundred and fifty-four and eighty one-hundredths ($29,-
454.80) dollars. This is the floating debt of the city. Instead of beginning the year with all debts paid and cash enough to meet expenses for the next ten months, we commence with this deficit in one of its funds.
"The following statement shows the probable condition of the city finances next November, when the proceeds of the next tax levy will be realized: -
"I have based this estimate entirely upon various official reports, and I am confident that it is within the limit. There must be very close economy or the figures will be a good deal larger. This floating debt has been accumulating for a long time. For several years the rate of taxation was not high enough to- give the needed revenue. There have been large expenditures incidental to the City Hall fire; many thousands of dollars were wasted in military demonstrations and needless preparations, at the time of the eastern riots in 1877; and the building of the roadway, to take the place of the Twelfth-street Bridge, has been one incessant drain upon the public treasury, having absorbed $17,000 last year. These unusual expenditures are thus itemized: -
""But when these things are taken into account, the finances of the city will be found to be in a deranged condition. The practice of using the funds of one fiscal year to pay the debts of a previous year has been most pernicious. It has drawn away scrutiny from financial matters, and extravagance or carelessness becarne easy- About four years ago, bonds were issued to pay off just such a debt as we are rolling up now, and a fresh start was made, with money enough to meet all requirements. The several Councils that have had control ought to have kept the city in the -same respectable financial position. If the floating debt is to go on accumulating,- as it has been, we shall not long have occasion to boast of our freedom from a vast issue of bonds. The great depression in every branch of industry prevailing throughout the year, and continually growing more severe, could not help but affect, unfavorably, the city finances, and in many ways diminish the income of the treasury.
"The School Department should have limited its expenses to its probable revenue. Neither the Board of Education nor the City Council has the right to contract bills when there is no legal mode of raising money to meet them. No matter what possible results may have been predicted, the city officials should have laid their plans in strict accordance with the amount of money placed at their disposal. If, as may be claimed.
the Legislature has placed too many restrictions upon local authorities, relief should have been sought at the State capitol, not by disregarding what were intended to be safeguards.
"This deficiency must come, for the machinery of the^City Government cannot be stopped. The pressure of public opinion and the dictates of common-sense require the Council to maintain the means of preserving the peace and security of the city, and the safety of the property of the people. The Council cannot now be expected to suspend the affairs of the city, as of a broken bank, nor do I know of any legal requirement that makes it necessary for them to do more than limit their contracts to what would have been under their control had the debts of previous years been paid.
"The amount is not enormous when the wealth of the city is considered, but there should have been a funding bill, or the power to levy an extra tax, a year ago, when these facts were almost as evident as they are now. It will be^ necessary to seek Legislative relief next winter."
" Annexed are reports showing the nature and value of real estate, buildings, and personal property belonging to the city. I summarize these statements as follows: - School lots .__ $125,500 00
" In addition, there are several public squares. If private property, and placed upon the market, they would probably bring half a million dollars. I think that the city has not duly considered the importance of retaining and ornamenting these grounds. They should be held sacred for the use of the people. As soon as the city is densely built, they will be regarded as priceless. The work of beautifying them should be commenced at once, and be carried on as unremittingly as the finances of the city may permit."
"Doubtless every citizen of Oakland feels a pride in our system of public schools which is here carried to an unusual degree of perfection. The annual report of Superintendent Campbell is a complete showing of the present condition of the schools, and facts and figures will give the answer to almost any question that can be possibly asked. I wilhnot attempt a summary of its figures, but would direct careful attention to therh. The connection between the School Department and the Mayor and Council is not close enough. Though required to pass upon appropriations, there are not adequate means for coming to a correct judgment. The Department is a government within itself, and it might be managed very badly for some time before the Council could become aware of it. The repairing of buildings that are almost new; the repainting of the Cole School House, so soon after its erection, are facts which indicate carelessness, neglect, or dishonesty somewhere. I cannot specify or charge anything wrong, but I allude to these appearances for the purpose of stimulating inquiry by the proper parties. Education is the foundation of our social and political system. It is essential to the well-being and existence of our free republic, and by generously devoting to it a proper share of our resources, we perform a high and patriotic duty- The high regard we all have for works of patriotism, education, religion, or charity often leads us to overlook defects through the too common fallacy that criticism must be hostile. The professed friends of an institution may sometimes place it in greater peril than could result from the active opposition of its enemies. This thought is suggested by the' scandals which now fill the air relative to the sale of examination questions. As yet, the reputations of those connected with the schools of Oakland have not been injured, and we should all feel gratified that our city has been free from exposures that have carried consternation to so many other places. Here is an instance where the friends of the schools have, in some respects, been causing them harm. Perhaps our own citizens have not been sufficiently close in the investigation of the financial affairs of the department. We all want the best educational facilities that can be obtained; but it is also expected that they shall cost no more than they are reasonably and properly worth. We can approximate to that by instituting comparisons with other cities where the schools are as nearly perfect as they can be made. The average cost per pupil for one year, including interest on permanent improvements, was $45.33; without interest, it was $29.82. This is less than in San Francisco, where expenditures are supposed to be on even a more liberal scale than in Oakland, but higher than in nearly all other cities in America. Pride in the schools should not blind the judgment. When there is a fixed sum placed at the disposal of our Board of Education, however, it is a wrong upon the community to exceed it. The officers are under the most solemn instructions that can be given to make use of just so much money to the best possible advantage, and all their plans must be shaped accordingly. If the present schedule of salaries cannot be maintained, stern necessity should compel revision. There should not be a continued adherence to any policy which is known to be too expensive for the funds that are available. I believe that the general management of the schools has been efficient, and that there has been competent and intelligent supervision."
" W. F Fletcher, Captain of Police, has prepared a very complete report of the workings of his department during the year. The standing of the department has been improved, its discipline is better, and there seems to be no reasonable cause for complaint as to its efficiency. The statistics have already been submitted to your honorable body. The reputation of a Police Department has great effect upon the order and quietness of any city. It is cheaper and easier to prevent crime than to detect it. The knowledge that policemen are vigilant and intelligent, and are present in the places where required, exerts a powerful influence in preventing the commission of crime. Temperate habits, cool and deliberate judgment, tact and shrewdness, combined with firmness and decision of character, are among the requirements ot a police officer. Gentlemanly deportment, coupled with the ability to cope with unruly characters, are required. The number of arrests is not a test of efficiency, for that must, to a great extent, depend upon the respectability of the neighborhood in which an officer is stationed for duty. They should be chosen solely with reference to their fitness for the position. Appointments should not be a reward for political service, nor should they be conferred upon persons through considerations of family connection, or sympathy for those who may have failed in other pursuits. There should be a standard of health, age, and stature, to be applied to all new appointees. If unworthy men have been placed in positions, if there has been dishonesty, those who are guilty should be promptly removed; but their misdeeds should not be the occasion for the condemnation of men who are above such unworthy practices.
"There have been rumors that some of the laws governing the department have not been strictly enforced, but no definite charges have been brought to my attention. Thorough discipline is essential to efficiency, and the power of my office will be exerted to enforce it.
" Captain Fletcher recommends that the number of officers be increased from twenty-two to forty. I think that there should be, on an average, one policeman for each fifteen hundred of population, which would give us thirty men. This seems to be the ratio most commonly found in other cities. Every policeman should be, also, a detective. He should be charged with the investigation of crime occurring in his beat, which would increase his vigilance and be a stimulus to his ambition. It would develop the faculties of the men, and indicate those who, at the proper time, should be promoted to the highest department of police service.
" Tenure of office should be secure. Officers who have long been in service, and who have made honorable records, should not be harassed by the fear that they mayat any time be displaced by men who have not shown any merits superior to their own.
"The Captain of Police calls attention to the necessity of enlarging the City Prison. The basement of the City Hall should be filled with cells, built of brick and iron, instead of building only two iron ones. It might cost about three thousand dollars. Prisoners could be kept separate; boys and petty offenders would not be brought into contact with hardened criminals, an evil which is of enormous proportions in most cities. The overcrowding of jails is a too common act of inhumanity. Such an enlargement of the present prison will suffice for a number of years; but the time will come when a separate building will become necessary.
"There are objections to the special police system, but it is difficult to see why there should be any opposition to giving police authority to private watchmen whom the people may desire to employ. It would be unwise to entirely abolish the system, but there must be great care and discrimination in regulating it, on account of the liability to abuse. I have no doubt that there are times when the influence of the special police counteracts the efforts of our regular officers in ferreting out crime, but such cases are the exceptions, not the r;ule."
" The Chief Engineer of the Fire Department has already submitted to you his annual report, which is a very complete and exhaustive document. He recommends the placing of hydrants in certain localities. It is the result of my observation that it is cheaper to erect hydrants near together than to buy hose; and that these sources of water for our engines should be so near to each other that in any possible case one reel of hose would be sufficient to reach the fire. In neighborhoods remote from engine-houses, it would be possible to extinguish incipient fires before the arrival of engines. Property-owners might procure hose of their own, to be used in such emergencies.
" The old Hook and Ladder apparatus in East Oakland would be of great use if a horse were purchased and a driver hired. The expense would not be much, and in a few minutes it might save thousands of dollars worth of property. East Oakland covers a large area; it has but one fire-engine, and it seems to rhe that it should have better means for extinguishing conflagrations.
" The house of Phoenix^Engine Company, No. i, is not fit for the purpose for which it is used, and, instead of being located on a side street, it should be on some one of our prominent thoroughfares, and I would suggest San Pablo Avenue. A commodious structure should be erected so that ordinarily decent quarters may be provided, not only for the firemen, but for the horses. This improvement ought to be made at once. In this connection, I desire to make a suggestion in reference to salaries paid to firemen. By comparison I find that they are forty per cent, lower in Oakland than in other cities on the Pacific Coast. In Oakland the engineers receive $60 per month; in San Francisco, $140; Sacramento and Virginia City, $100; and the same disparity exists as to the other employes. I think that the pay of our firemen is too small. They have to be ready for duty at all times, and I do not think that the compensation is fair. I would suggest a remodeling of the schedule of salaries so that the men may be paid what their services are reasonably worth. The fire-alarm apparatus, etc., in Oakland is probably more complete than in any other city in the United States. This is a very broad statement, but is fully justified by the municipal reports that come from all quarters. The automatic system is most complete, and the planning and operation of the fire-alarm telegraph reflects great credit upon Mr. Carleton, the Superintendent. It has. been erected at a cost that seems nominal when compared with what is expended for similar purposes elsewhere. The efficiency of the Fire Department is largely due to the promptness with which the alarms are given." On the subject of public improvements Mayor Andrus says: - " In the opening portion of my message I intimated the great value of having a system for our street grades and sewers. Large numbers of lateral sewers have been constructed, and Lake Merritt has been connected with the bay by a main sewer. To preserve the high level of water in the lake, the construction of a permanent dam was necessary, and some seventeen thousand dollars have been expended during the last year. The building of a roadway was incidental to this. For years public money has been expended upon this work, and the results do not promise to be commensuate with the expenditures. In attempting to do this work cheaply, there has been a considerable waste of funds. Had this Council, in the beginning, projected an improvement that would have lasted for all time, it would have been the most economical course. Temporary work is rarely cheap or profitable.
"The City Hall has been rebuilt at a cost of about $22,000. It affords ample accommodations for the various city offices and is creditable to the city. It has been appropriately furnished, and there are suitable safeguards against future conflagrations. A convenient office has been fitted up for the Mayor, and I may here observe that I have kept ordinary office hours except when called to other parts of the city by public business. The necessity for this has been made evident by the great number of persons who call to lodge information upon various matters of general interest,, and also to ascertain points in which citizens are interested. I find that there is quite enough business to occupy the time of the Mayor for several hours each day in his. office.
" The report of the City Engineer shows that there are thirty-eight miles of sewers in the streets of Oakland, excepting main lake sewer, which is two and one half miles long, and that there are fifty-one and one-half miles of macadamized streets. Last year the property-owners paid for sewers and grading and macadamizing $254,140, which itemized, shows that twenty-four thousand feet of sewer-pipe was laid, or about four and one-half miles, costing $24,140.
"The length of streets macadamized, thirty-six thousand feet, or seven miles, costing $180,000; length of streets graded, forty thousand four hundred and fortyseven feet, or about eight miles, which cost $50,000; all of which speaks well for our property-owners, who are so liberal to improve our city. There is a resolution of the Council against macadamizing streets until sewer, gas, and water pipes are laid. This rule ought to be adhered to most rigidly; the damage caused by tearing up improved streets is very great; and it is a burden which should not be imposed upon propertyholders.
" Plans and specifications for the main creek sewer have been submitted to the City Council. The work, if done, will be under an Act of the Legislature passed April 3, 1876. The cost is to be assessed upon property according to area, and is to be paid when the work is completed. This cost is not likely to be less than $300,- 000, and it is estimated that the charge upon a twenty-five foot lot will be something more than $31.00. The sewer will be three and one-third miles long, and it is designed to carry into the bay of San Francisco the sewerage of the part of Oakland capable of being drained into it. At present this sewerage is taken away by the tidal flow of the San Antonio Creek. The necessity for building the sewer now may be questioned, but I do not propose to discuss the reasons that may be given for or against it. I think that the improvement should not be made under such a law as we now have. The work ought to be done in small sections, so that there can be full competition among the great body of contractors, and property-holders should not be expected to pay so heavy an amount at one time. It would be almost ruin to hundreds of people who own property that does not yield large rents. The lake sewer was paid for by the proceeds of the sale of bonds, though its cost is only a trifle, over half of the estimated cost of the present work. Besides the contractors would have to be kept out of their money for a long time, as it would take many months to do the work. They will be obliged to increase the amount of their bids so as to cover interest and contingencies. At the next session of the Legislature, there may be obtained a law more simple in its workings, and one which will provide for an easier mode of payment. If this work can be given out in sections, paid for as it progresses, the total cost will probably be less by forty or fifty thousand dollars, and the people can well afford to wait for a year to save that amount of money.
"There have been many complaints about the leakage from the main lake sewer at the bay end. I have examined into the matter, and am satisfied that the only remedy is to ceil it on the inside with tongue and groove lumber, covering the bottom and sides only. It would require about forty-two thousand feet of lumber, and, with the needed labor, would cost about $2,100. The street might be filled in, which would cost about $6,000. This would not, of course, prevent the leakage, but might counteract its effects. The health and comfort of a large community require that this should receive early attention.
"The Eighth- street Bridge has proven to be an important work. The streets connecting with it have been graded and macadamized, and a large amount of travel passes daily. It has exerted an appreciable effect upon real estate values.'' In dealing with the Free Library his Honor states: -
" The Free Library is a new institution, and it is only becoming known that it is open to every resident of Oakland. The Secretary submits a report that shows -the history and present condition of the library and reading-rooms. It will strike every one that the number of volumes is insignificant. Only four thousand books and a population of forty thousand people ! There ought to be a large surplus over the amount needed for current expenses, to be used for the purchase of books. The Library is sadly deficient in works of a scientific nature, books pertaining to agriculture, and to mechanic arts. The Secretary does not report it, but it is understood that seventy or eighty per cent, of the circulation consists of works of fiction. As the collection becomes more comprehensive, this proportion will be reduced. There has been much complaint because tax-payers who live beyond the city limits are not allowed to draw books. It is but common justice that this rule should be reversed. I cannot too strongly commend the idea upon which our Library is based. The diffusion of intelligence among the people is an object of the highest importance. The benefits of free books and periodicals cannot be estimated in money. The city is wise in giving encouragement to the project, and if the management is discreet and economical, their institution will, in a few years, be Oakland's pride. Appropriations have been liberal, and we have the right to anticipate a grand success and to be an exemplar for other cities."
" No greater calamity ever befell the property-holders of San Francisco than the locating of the Chinese quarters in the very heart of the city. The district inhabited by Asiatics has been steadily increasing its boundaries, and a blight has fallen upon real estate, in what might have been a center of business. It is time that the authorities of this city should take proper precautions, if possible, to prevent such a misfortune from occurring here. If the measures pending in Congress become enacted into laws, there will be a cessation of Chinese emigration; but our past experience leads us to be slow in building up expectations of this kind. We should proceed as if we knew that the Chinese were to continue coming, and do what we can to mitigate the evils that are threatening. The Council has the power to regulate such trades or occupations as may be nuisances, and under its general police powers, it could regulate the location of laundries or wash-houses. In some neighborhoods they are nuisances, while in others the people have no objection to them. It has often happened that one of these establishments would, be started in quiet neighborhoods, given up to residence purposes, which would seriously detract from the value of surrounding property. One individual should not have it in his power to depreciate the value of the real pstate of others. The consent of at least a majority of the persons owning property in a block ought to be obtained before a license should be given for carrying on a laundry. I believe that the Countil has the undoubted right to do this. It con- 'cerns the welfare of real estate owners, and would be a very great protection. As the wash-houses here are centers from which Chinese quarters are likely to extend, such a regulation as proposed would drive the Mongolian population to portions of the city where their presence would not depreciate the value of property. As a strictly sanitary regulation, all prisoners in the City Jail undergoing sentences should have their hair cut short. It is a rule dictated by constitutions of cleanliness, and one that has been enforced in many American prisons from time out of mind. It should not be violated through any plea of religion or superstition. Its result might be the pa)'- ment of fines by Chinese criminals, which is preferable to keeping them at public cost, and would be regarded by them as a more severe punishment. The presence of these people is in every way undesirable, and should be discouraged by every legal method, direct or indirect. Our own citizens cannot compete with them as laborers, because people who are American citizens, are usually burdened with the responsibility of providing for a wife and children, while the Chinese are not. Not only the more humble laborers, but the whole body of mechanics arfe theatened with pauperization. The . fears of most of the capitalists are becoming aroused, because they see that the life and energy of the country depend upon the prosperity of the masses, who must meet the wants and gratify some of the tastes of civilized life. The hordes of Asiatics ha\e not these wants and tastes. They are an incubus upon our development, and the public opinion of the nation is fast recognizing this fact.
"The pure air ordinance, it is believed, is not enforced in many cases to which it is intended to apply. The law is a good one, whether applied to Chinese or to white men, and I hope that greater attention will be given to it. The Chinese, it is notorious, are almost the only offenders, Caucasians not needing such law to compel them to observe one of the fundamental rules of health."
Of affairs on the water front he speaks in the following strain : - " The City Wharfinger has submitted a report showing the amount of business transacted since it was built, in 1873. The steady increase in the amount of business is noteworthy as, lately, there have been built other wharves at which equally large quantities of merchandise are landed. The city wharf was first used in August, 1873, and its gross earnings have been $47,944.67. Its cost was $20,000. The losses have aggregated only $270.20 for the entire period. A credit of thirty days is authorized, and certainly this number of bad bills has been astonishingly small. During the last year, a deep channel was dredged around it in response to a petition by merchants, fortified by the action of the Merchants' Exchange. Any ship that can cross the bar can now lay at the wharf without grounding during low tide. The rates of wharfage and dockage have been reduced, but are notyet on a level with those in San Francisco. The charges for large vessels are about the same, the reduction effecting principally the small crafts. I do not think that harbor charges in Oakland should be greater than in San Francisco, for it is proverbial that the course of commerce may be changed by the scale of port charges.
" The city has power to regulate the anchorage of vessels and other matters, and I think that our local commerce is extensive enough to warrant the Council in taking some action in this matter. It need entail no extra expense, and would lessen the danger of collision and damage to public and private property. It might be proper to confer upon the Wharfinger the powers usually exercised by a Harbor Master.
"The improvement of the Oakland Harbor is a subject of paramount importance to our city. Officially, the Mayor has no connection with this matter, and possesses no information which is not common to the people. It is a matter of deep regret that parties owning the tide lands have not come to an agreement with the United States Government and executed an abandonment of the property needed. I believe that an adjustment of the controversy is near at hand,.and that the city will suffer no longer from the delay. If it be not settled, the contest must be taken by the Government to the courts, and there would be long and vexatious delays. The value of the work already accomplished is very great, as ships of twelve and fifteen hundred tons now come into the harbor, saving the cost of rehandling freight in the bay. It will be a great step in advance when ships can be laden with wheat in the estuary, and will give a powerful impulse to the development of home business. This portion of the city fixes it as the railway terminus of the Pacific Coast, and it must, ultimately, have a large share of the general commerce of the State. Wonderful advances have been made and still greater changes are sure to come. We do not expect to take anything from the prosperity of San Francisco, but we do have faith in the future of Oaklaind as a place of equal importance with the present metropolis. The aid of the Government is invaluable, and whenever it may suggest any practical measure to the Council to help along the project, it will be most heartily seconded. An imperfect knowledge of the plans of action, necessarily withheld by the Chief of Engineers, renders it impossible to make more extended reference to what is our most important interest."
Mr. Andrus then winds up his message with the following very apposite remarks on retrenchment, public economy, and concludes with a laudatory peroration on the Workingmen's Party of which he was the choice for the high office of Mayor of the city of Oakland.
" There is no patent remedy for municipal extravagances. There is not any one measure that will produce such a change as may be needed. Every officer, in all departments, must devote his attention to the smallest details, and see where it is possible to retrench. There can be some retrenchment in the Police Department. The salaries received by officers exceed those paid to mechanics or men in quite responsible clerical pursuits. I have already expressed my opinion of the high standard that should be required, but it is no higher than is expected of a master mechanic or the leading book-keeper in a mercantile house. Unlike a mechanic the pay is continuous; sick or well, it goes on, and very properly. In most of the Eastern cities, the cost of living is much higher, while the pay of officers will not average more than one thousand dollars per annum. I do not see the necessity for two detectives, always dressed in citizens' clothes. The designation of officers as Sergeants, etc., necessarily takes some from the number of active policemen, but there is not enough crime committed, or possible of detection, to require the services of two men continuously. There might be greater economy in procuring supplies for the Fire Department and a closer system of checks in making repairs. I am of this opinion because of the rather large reported expenditures for this purpose and not specifically accounted for. A few years ago, a Council proceeded systematically to investigate every city office, and as a result of its work, minor changes were made, which saved niany thousands of dollars in the current expense account. It seems to be a proper time to have another such overhauling. The importance of a low rate of taxation, a light debt, and a reputation for careful municipal management, are powerful influences in determining real estate values. If there were recklessness in incurring debt it would deter thousands of people from taking up residences in our city. The growth and prosperity of Oakland cannot be promoted more effectively than by maintaining a cheap government and conducting its affairs upon a sound basis.
" When the Workingmen of Oakland elected their candidate for Mayor, there were many reckless and unfair statements, to the effect that property would decline in value; that communism would- prevail, and woes unutterable overtake our fair and prosperous city. The false statements made as to the objects and aims of the party, may have induced some to believe these sweeping assertions; but their incorrectness has long since been shown. The Workingmen have wanted nothing but exact and equal justice in the administration of public affairs. They want to protect their own homes from the needless burdens of taxation, and to make it easier for those who are fighting the battle of life to obtain homes for themselves. Honest men have nothing to fear from the success of this party. Its mission is to protect and save; not to tear down and destroy. It is to prevent legislation that gives privileges to the few at the expense of the many; to prevent public robbery under any and every name. It is also devoted to the prevention of Chinese immigration and the freeing of the country from the presence of a class of people who are paralyzing our industries and driving our laboring classes to the verge of want. Faith in it by the masses is shown in this city by its progress last year. The number of houses erected, and their value, is but a trifle less than during our most pr'osperous year, yet the season has been one of unprecedented financial stringency. The people have long ago learned that the cries of communism, and many other isms, are false alarms raised to prevent the success of great reforms. The discourteous treatment at first shown to officials selected by this party has almost disappeared. It is recognized as having great and important objects, which will promote the welfare of the whole people, and will remain in power as long as it is faithful to its high and important duties.
"The effect upon national legislation is becoming evident. Public men and public journals no longer favor the presence of Chinese. It is admitted now that the considerations of the loftiest statesmanship require restrictions to be placed upon their fcoming. So gratifying a result is due wholly to the uprising of the masses in this State, their success at the ballot-box, their determination to rely no longer upon promises by politicians of the older parties. As a successful candidate of that party, I have done the very best I could to fulfill the duties of my office properly. Others who have held the office have been conspicuous for their learning, their attainments in the professions, their wealth, or high influences. I have had none of the advantages that may come from such sources, and if I have at any time erred, I hope that critics will not be harsh in their censure. I have given my strictest personal attention to all questions upon which I have the right to act, and in some cases I have come in conflict with the City Council. It is natural that men of different political parties should think differently upo.n public questions, and, in the interposition of vetoes, I have been governed by my own sense of what was right or politic. I can forget the little acts of unpleasantness that might be recalled, and endeavor to remember only the pleasant things of my official term. I feel that a more thorough acquaintance of the Councilmen with the Workingmen's Mayor has by degrees increased their regard, and dispelled some of the unpleasant anticipations that may have been formed.
"If the city of Oakland comes under the government of men of this party, some of the errors of the past will not be repeated. There will be a substantial promise and an economical administration. Tax-payers will feel that their burdens are as light as possible, and that their money is applied with care, fidelity, and honesty. The name and fame of Oakland will increase in brightness with another political victory. Its reputation, for good government, for safety of .life and property; its success in the race for municipal renown, will be promoted if its destinies are committed to the Workingmen's Party.''
Perhaps the most noteworthy event of the year was the visit to Oakland of General Grant, the hero of the War of the' Rebellion, and twice President of the United States. Every city, town, village, and hamlet that he visited were unanimously demonstrative in their efforts to do him honor; and the citizens of Oakland were not behindhand in the heartiness of their welcome to him, after a "royal progress" around the world. It was a spontaneous greeting to his native shores, from a people who acknowledged all that he had done towards keeping the integrity and honor of the nation.
At a meeting of the City Council held on the 15th September, the following preanibles and resolutions were passed, showing the steps intended to be taken by the authorities on his arrival on this side of San Francisco Bay: -
Whereas, Information has reached the City Council that his Excellency Ulysses S. Grant, ex-President of the United States, is on his way from Japan, and will probably arrive in the city, of San Francisco within a few days, and that it is his intention to remain in California some time before proceeding to his home; and
Whereas, The people of this city, as well as those of the State of-California and of the whole country, without regard to party or section, profoundly esteem his many distinguished services as soldier, statesman, and private citizen.
Now, Therefore, The Mayor and City Council of the city of Oakland do hereby, in behalf of the citizens of said city, and of the municipal government thereof, tender and present to General Grant the freedom of the city of Oakland, and request that he will visit the same at such time as he may name for that purpose; and
Whereas, At a public meeting of citizens held in this city, to take preliminary action to tender to General Grant a public reception, a committee was appointed by that body, consisting of nine p"sons; therefore
Resolved, That the Mayor and members of this Council will cooperate with said committee of citizens in making necessary arrangements for the purpose above indicated.
Resolved, That upon receiving telegraphic notice of the signaling of the steamship City of Tokio off the "Heads," the Mayor be requested to cause the American Flag to be hoisted on the City Hall, and the Superintendent of Fire Alarm be and he is hereby authorized and directed to cause the fire-alarm bell to be sounded for five consecutive minutes, to give notice of the return to his country of America's most distinguished citizen.
The President of the Council then appointed Messrs. Babcock, Hewes, and Cole a committee to cooperate with the committee of citizens, to act as a business committee for the purpose of carrying into effect any arrangements which may be made in relation to the proposed visit.
As we have said, the reception tendered to the famous General by Oakland and her citizens was a perfect ovation. So soon as he touched the soil of Alameda County, he was met by Mayor Andrus and the City Council of Oakland, when his Honor, stepping forward, said: -
General Grant; Your merited ovations have encircled the world. They have been as grand and as varied as the nations who have offered them. And, yet, among them all, there has not been a more earnest, sincere, and cordial welcome than that which the city of Oakland now extends to you. This is preeminently a city of homes and of families; of .husbands and of wives; of parents and of children; of churches and of schools. There is no earthly tie more sacred and lasting than that of the family. At the family altar the fires of liberty are first enkindled, and there patriotism is born. The love of home, of kindred, and of country, is one. This is the source and the fountain of our welcome to you, the defender of our country, our firesides, and our families. I am authorized to further present to you this official expression of good-will from our city authorities.
The freedom of the city, with the resolutions quoted above, were then tendered to and accepted by General Grant, who thereupon grasped the hand of the Mayor, and gave expression to the following characteristic speech: -
At a meeting of the Board of Supervisors held December 8, 1 879, the District Attorney presented a written opinion that the Board had no power to grant the right of way over the Webster-street Bridge, arguing that the Board can only act within its delegated powers; that the bridge is a public highway; and that the Board holds the bridge in trust to maintain, repair, and renew the same in the manner provided originally to be done by the town of Alameda and the city of Oakland. It was a question whether the Supervisors had any right vested in them, specially, to grant such a privilege. It was asserted that, by statute, any steam railroad has the right to run upon, along, and across any navigable stream, watercourse, street, avenue, and highway, without asking for such privilege from the Supervisors, although any person or corporation might not attempt to exercise such a right without making a respectful request to the Supervisors. At the instance of Theodore Meetz, the President of the Alameda and Oakland Horse Railroad, Judge Daingerfield, of the Twelfth District Court, in and for the city and county of San Francisco, granted a temporary injunction, commanding the Supervisors of Alameda County to desist from granting any franchise to A. E. Davis (President of the South Pacific Coast Railroad Company) or anybody else, to use Webster-street Bridge for railroad purposes.
It will thus be seen that there were a few persons making extraordinary efforts to head off the narrow-gauge railroad from entering the city. It may be remembered that Mr. Meetz enjoyed,?and still enjoys, a portion of the bridge for his horse rail- road, and it is not unforgotten, perhaps, how his rails were laid over the bridge between a Saturday night and a Monday morning, while it can be readily understood that a question would arise naturally enough in Mr. Meetz' mind as to the probable effect the construction of the narrow-gauge railroad into Oakland would have upon the profits of his line. But that benefit would undoubtedly result was certain, for it was absolutely necessary that means of communication with the northern portion of the city should be opened. To this end the right was ultimately very properly granted, and after considerable opposition, power was given to lay their track along Webster Street, March 6, 1880, after a very stormy discussion.
1880. - On January Sth, a resolution indorsing the new charter was passed. This document was a tolerably faithful copy of the existing laws, as far as they did' not conflict with the new Constitution. The portions which related to street work were radically changed. It abolisbed the office of City Marshal and substituted a Tax- Collector and a Superintendent of Streets. It required the funds for a year to be divided into four equal parts, while many other changes were made calculated to facilitate the working of the various departments of the city government. On February 2, 1880, an ordinance repealing certain other ordinances passed by the Trustees of the town of Oakland was passed. There were; ist. "An Ordinance for the disposal of the Water Front belonging to the Town of Oakland," passed finally, May 18, 1852; 2d. " An Ordinance to approve the Wharf at the foot of Main Street, and to extend the time for constructing the other Wharves," passed December 30, 1852; 3d. "An Ordinance concerning Wharves and the Water Front" passed August 27, 1853.
" The last year has been characterized by an unusual activity in railroad enterprises, and there is a prospect that at no distant day the Southern Road, projected by Boston capitalists, will connect the Atlantic and Pacific coasts. A railway company which already has extensive connections is asking for admission to our city. We should cherish the hope that in due time an independent transcontinental railroad would seek Oakland as its western terminus. The great prosperity that has resulted from the location of the terminus of the Central Pacific in this city, is a proper guide for estimating the benefits that may follow the construction of other railroads. The city must have open gates for all railway companies that are willing and able to extend to us their lines. The interests of the city will be best promoted by the location of depots and stations in a central part, and it is a proper time now for the Council to outline a railroad policy that will serve in future contingencies. The Central Pacific extends through the city from east to west. It is proposed that another road shall pass through the city from north to south. Such seems to be a necessity that results from our geographical situation. Whenever the property-holders who are immediately concerned give their consent to the use of a street, it will doubtless be designated as a thoroughfare for the railway that will connect u^ with a part of the Statp which has not heretofore been tributary. It will double our ferry facilities, and t'.ius greatly increase the desirability of Oakland as a place of residence for persons whose business is in San Francisco. It will give to Oakland merchants the trade and traffic of an extensive territory not otherwise reached by rail. It is of prime importance to the people of Oakland that some strong corporation should have an apparent and powerful interest in the improvement of the Oakland harbor. A railway company whose road terminates at docks inside of the estuary could not fail to be a powerful ally of the city in securing from the Federal Government the aid that is needed for the improvement of navigation. It is presumed that the influence of one corporation has checked the progress of this work. It will be fortunate if more corporations of equal strength are just as much interested in having the work carried on. It should be the policy of Oakland to extend a welcome to any railroad corporation that wishes to gain an entrance into the city. It is not enough that we are connected with one system of California roads; we should have connections with others that now exist, or which may hereafter be built. The property rights of every citizen should be most thoroughly guarded, but care should be taken that the plea for property rights is not an argument in a disguised form for the prevention of railway competition. Any applications for franchises .should be viewed in a liberal and far-seeing way. It should never be a matter of doubt abroad whether the people of Oakland will permit the extension of another railroad into their city. It should be heralded far and wide that our citizens realize that they occupy the terminal city, as designated by mountain chains, rivers, and arms of the ocean, and are opening wide doors to all who can bring business and prosperity."
" Early in the history of the city the entire water front was conveyed to private parties for a consideration that seems frivolous, and it has been the prevailing opinion that the transaction was illegal, and probably fraudulent. In the year 1868 there was a compromise by which the title was conveyed to the Water Front Company, as far as it was in the power of the Council to make such a transfer. The city obtained nothing from the compromise, except the small area of overflowed land now occupied by the city wharf Subsequently Congress authorized various appropriations for the improvement of the Oakland harbor, and considerable sums of money have been expended, so that vessels having a thousand' tons of freight can now be brought to our wharves. The last Congressional appropriation was coupled with the condition that it should not be used unless the claimants to the bed of the estuary and the water frontage, on which the training-walls are constructed, should abandon whatever title they may have asserted to that property. The United States engineer's lines were located so that the harbor would come up to the demands of an extensive commerce, and be accessible from many points on the mainland without passing over any intervening strip of private property. The Water Front Company has not abandoned its claim to the arm of the Bay which is included within the Government lines, and in consequence there has been no further expenditure of money to carry on the improvement. This refusal on the part of the Water Front Company has brought the whole question very prominently before the people of this city. The work that was thus summarily checked was universally regarded as of prime importance to Oakland, and its completion as an event that would bring with it a new era of commercial prosperity. The legality of the private claims that had been, asserted with such, damaging effect was disputed, much legal authority concurring in the opinion that the title to the whole water front still remains in the city. The right to fix and collect dockage and tolls is considered to be one of the attributes of government which cannot be alienated. _ If the Water Front Company's ownership of the bed of the estuary could be disproved, there would be nothing to prevent the Federal Government from resuming work, and many citizens advised the commencing of suits to that end. In the mean time the Central Pacific Railroad Company, and one of its Directors, individually, brought suits against the city to quiet the title to certain property held under conveyances from the Water Front Company, Carpentier, and other claimants. If a default were permitted in these cases, it would cut off any hope of relief to the city, and your honorable body determined to retain counsel and thoroughly test the rights of the city. I have approved the ordinances which were necessary for the proper commencement of proceedings.
" The great object which I hope to see accomplished is the defeat of all private claims of ownership to property needed for the construction of the harbor. If these claims can be declared void, Oakland will become an open port. No man or corporation can have a monopoly of water-front privileges, with the power to take what toll they may choose from every person or pound of merchandise coming into or going from the city. I cannot believe that it is possible for individuals to become legally possessed of the title to an arm of the bay navigable for large vessels. The recognition of such a right would place the fortunes of the city entirely at the mercy of a few men, which could not fail to be perilous in the extreme. There must be free access to the city for all the shipping that may seek our port, and easy facilities for all ferry companies that may seek for business. The benefits to them and to the people of Oakland will be mutual. It is unfortunate that this city must wait the tedious routine of litigation before it will be in her power to adopt a libsral commercial policy. But nothing will be accomplished until the rights of the public and of the water-front claimants are definitely settled by the decree of a court of competent jurisdiction. It is to be regretted that there should ever have been the shadow of a private claim to what is really a part of the Pacific Ocean. It has brought into controversy other matters that would have remained undisturbed, had such a course been possible. The one thing that is desired, and for which the people of Oakland will contend with all their energy, is the prosecution and completion of the public work which has been planned by the engineers according to their original designs. I do not believe that it is for the public welfare to molest the Central Pacific Railroad Company in the use and enjoyment of the property it needs for its terminal improvements. That is not the aim and object of the present litigation, as I understand it. Oakland seeks for no controversy with that company, nor does she, desire to do it any injury or harm; but it is only a measure of .self-defense to contend for the free navigation of the estuary and for unrestricted communication between the mainland and the harbor for freight and passengers. The only regulations that should ever be enacted, or the only charges that should ever be imposed, should be such as ordained by the city government. Prolonged litigation- should be avoided if possible. If the concessions demanded by the United States. Government were allowed by the claimants to the water front with a fair compliance with what is- demanded in the public interest, I do not think that there is a person in Oakland who would desire the continuation of suits that involve the title to property used and needed for railroad improvements. The real cause of the present controversy is the claim of private ownership in the estuary, and whenever that may be abandoned I should hope for the termination of litigation."
" The almost unanimous vote of the people against Chinese immigration has had a moral effect abroad far greater than the speeches of our representatives in Congress, the platforms of our political parties, or the utterances of the press.
" The idea that only the laboring classes in this State were opposed to the further coming of Asiatics has been dispelled. The humble toilers have long since ceased to be the only ones who suffered by an unnatural competition between civilization and barbarism. Unfortunately there were many who remained indifferent as long as the presence of Chinese only caused privation and hardship to those who earn their subsistence by toil, but when the value of rentals, the rate of interest, the worth of real estate, the profits of professional men, and the earnings of the merchant became affected, everybody united in an appeal for relief Modern civilization has never before had to contend with such an element, and for that reason there has been but little sympathy for us in this remote part of the Union. The changes in Eastern sentiment are now quite perceptible.
" The masses are becoming aware that the many arguments made thus on high moral and religious grounds, were prompted by grasping and greedy men, who thought that they saw in Chinese immigration the means of still further reducing the wages of labor.
" The intelligence and the religious sentiments of the people of California are as general and as advanced as prevail in any other community in America, and a protest has been uttered that has been heard throughout the nation,
" It is reported that negotiations have for some time been conducted with the Chinese Empire to secure a modification of the Burlingame Treaty, so that it shall become strictly commercial. But it is the evident policy of China to send away its surplus subjects, and in that manner put an end to a famine that has prevailed in that overcrowded country ever since its history has been known to us. The prospect of any relief from that source is very slight. Legislation by Congress can keep on, and in the absence of that, there is considerable that we may do to help ourselves. Our Legislature might follow the example of some of the British Colonies similarly afflicted, and impose heavy licenses on aliens incapable of becoming citizens, as an offset to the charges that must be borne by the public for the support of the Chinese paupers and criminals. -
. "Great benefit will result from the passage of a law prohibiting the issuance of a business license to aliens of this class. It should also be_ provided that any citizen who wishes to employ these aliens should procure a license for doing so. Goods manufactured in this State should bear a stamp indicating whether or not Chinese labor had been used. This would enable the public to carry out their desire to employ only the labor of people who' may legally become citizens. Of course the use of a false label should be severely punished.
" The City Council, by its authority to enact sanitary regulations, and by its power over the municipal license system, is in a position to do much for the people in this matter. Under existing laws it can suppress many places maintained by Chinese, because they are actual nuisances. The buildings occupied by many of them, in the central part of the city, are reeking with filth, and vile orders permeate the air in their immediate neighborhood, depreciating the value of property. If laundries were allowed only in some designated part of the city, it would be a great benefit to' many localities that are now undesirable.
"Another nuisance is the presence of Chinese with their baskets on the sidewalks of crowded thoroughfares. This should be stopped, for it wiDuld be just as proper to allow the sidewalks to be used by hand-carts or drays.
" I do not suggest these things through a desire to persecute these people, nor to subject them to any grievance, but because they will not stop coming here until they see that the general spirit of our law is against them. They will continue to immigrate here as long as they can enter into full and free competition with Americans, but the influx of Asiatics will cease when it is a certainty that our people are doing everything in their power to keep them away.
" We have protection for our commercial interests. It has been the- traditional policy of Congress to maintain a high protective tariff to shut off goods manufactured by pauper labor elsewhere. There are still stronger reasons for preventing the landing of men who are paupers, who can never become citizens, and whose presence defeats the whole aim and object of the protective system that has been established for the benefit of American industries."
It will be remembered that California was honored by a visit from Rutherford B. Hayes, President of the United States, and though his reception was not characterized by the demonstrative joy with which General Grant was received, still Mr. Hayes was cordially welcomed with the patriotism which the traditions of his office demanded- On the 6th September, the Cit)' Council passed the following preamble and resolution in this regard: -
Whereas, The people of Ihe State of California are upon the eVe of celebrating the thirtieth anniversary of its birth into the American Union, and
Whereas, The citizens of Oakland have manifested their intention to celebrate the day in a manner worthy of an event so grand as the coming of a new and bright star into the constellation of States, and that will bear witness of their profound satisfaction at the proud eminence their young State has won, of their confidence in the brighter future which lies open before its boundless natural resources, and its vigorous and patriotic citizens, and of their reverent gratitude to the Divine Ruler of the Universe, whose beneficent grace has showered unnumbered blessings over mountain and valley, from the sierras to the sea; and
Whereas, Our people are about to be honored by a visit from his Excellency, the President of the United States - the first time in the history of the State, that a Chief Executive of the nation has crossed its boundaries; and
Whereas, His Excellency has kindly consented to visit our city and participate in the festivities in commemoration of our natal day, and we are desirous of showing in a fitting manner our regard for him as a man and our respect for the high office which he holds; now therefore
Resolved, That the people of the city of Oakland, through its Mayor and Council, tender to his Excellency, the President, the hospitalities and freedom of the city.
Whereas, It hath pleased Divine Providence to remove from our midst one whose influence and deeds have ever been given to the advancement of the material interests of Alameda County, and prominent in the establish- ment of our State University, the boast and pride of this city, and as an ex-Mayor of Oakland, it is befitting that the Council should take some action and pay a proper tribute to the memory of Hon. John W. Dwinelle; therefore be it
Resolved, That this Council will attend his obsequies in a body, and it is ordered that the Council Chamber be draped in mourning for thirty days; and be it further
_ Resolved, That a certified copy of this preamble and resolutions be transmitted to the family of the deceased, and be under the seal of the city spread upon the minutes by the City Clerk.
Like in every cluster of houses throughout the Union, in the city of Oakland the grief that marked the death of General Garfield was intense. It partook of deep sorrow, more like the mourning for a lost relative thin for the untimely death of the Chief Executive of a great nation. For a month the prominent buildings and many private establishments -were draped with the insignia of woe, while the fervor of sorrow was intense. On September 20th the following resolutions were unanimously adopted by a standing vote of the City Council: -
Whereas, In the midst of our deliberations, while seeking in our own small sphere to do for the public welfare, at a time when, though deeply and anxiously solicitous for the ultimate, complete, and entire recovery of the victim of the assassin's bullet, the man who was the pride and glory of the nation, the man of all men best fitted by his spotless public and private character, his eitperience, his ability, learning, and wisdom, and his unswerving devotion to the best interests of our whole country, and by the confidence reposed in him by the people of all classes and of every political complexion throughout the length and breadth of the land, to fill with honor and glory to himself and the American people, that office, than which there is nor has been no greater or nobler in the history of nations at a time, after months of anxiety and suspense, we yet cherished a hope and a faith - almost hoping against hope - that the Divine Ruler of the universe, He who marks the sparrow's fall, would finally restore to us the maij on whose life or death depended more than in all the history of the world ever depended on the life of one man - midst hoping and fearing, lightning has borne to us the crashing and disheartening message, " President Garfield is dead;" and
Whereas, We realize in the death of James A. Garfield, the late President of the United States, not only we, but our country and the whole world, have lost that which cannot be replaced, we have lost, than which there is no nobler work of God - a man without fear and without reproach, a man whose interest and desire was the good of our entire people, a man who knew what was the best and right to be done, and who dared to do what he believed to be right and just, to all men and before all men - a man who was at all times and in all places the brave, true, and untiring friend of his brother man, and the devoted servant of his country; now, therefore, by the CounciJ of the city of Oakland, be it
Resolved, That we feel most deeply and sincerely the loss to the people of the United States in the death ol our late President; that we believe that James A. Garfield, had he lived, with his ability, his opportunity, and his disposition, would have continued to be the grandest and brightest figure in the history of mankind, and that in his death, our people, and the people of all nations of the earth have lost a friend than whom no better or more powerful friend of mankind has been in the past, or will be for generations yet to come; and be it further
Resolved, That for the people of our city we most earnestly and sincerely present our heartfelt sympathy and condolence to the bereaved widow, the fatherless children, and aged and stricken mother of our President. We fully realize that tho' our heart-strings may be sorely wrung by the loss of him who w as our protector, as he was the friend and protector of our whole country and the friend of every man on the face of the earth - yet the loss of the widow and fatherless and that aged mother is greater than ours^we lose a friend and protector and they a kind and loving husband and father and a devoted son, and in their bereavement we ask the widow, the orphans, and the noble mother to remember, as a slight solace in their deep affliction, that tho' he has gone in the full flush of manhood, just when arm and mind were strongest; just when the eyes of all the world were turned upon him; he died in the service of mankind, he died in harness, died after the grandest and most prolonged struggle for life ever made by mortal man, a struggle made not through fear of death - for he feared it not, nor thro' any love of life for its own sake - for he cared not for himself. Through all those gloomy months of pain and suffering he struggled to live as he has ever struggled to live, for his mother, for his wife, for his children, and for his country; and be it further
Resolved, That as the only token of public respect in our power is manifest, we recommend our citizens to drape their residences and places of business in mourning for a period of thirty days; that all public business shall be suspended on the day appointed for the President's funeral, and that public worship be held in all the churches on Sunday, September 25th, when the people may assemble to mourn our loss, and pray for the safety of the Republic; and be it
1882-83. - During the year 1882 there was nothing of any especial momgnt occurred that need find a place in this work, but the 12th of March, 1883, saw the election of a Democratic Mayor in the person of J. West Martin, who, with the City Council, inaugurated a system of retrenchment by dismissing some subordinates in the several departments, and reducing the salaries of the remainder. The efficient Captain of Police is abolished for the nonce and an acting Captain installed, while, as a move to further economy, the streets are but half lighted by gas.
It may be mentioned, though not belonging properly to the city of Oakland, that Maro P. Kay, a former deputy and trusted officer of the County Treasurer, was sentenced May 22, 1883, to fourteen years imprisonment in the State Prison for the crime of forgery and embezzlement of the public funds.
The Oakland of to-day is one of the most beautiful cities in the world. It is a credit to all concerned in guiding it to its present position, while the day is not far distant when it will add the importance of a great manufacturing and commercial center to its already numerous attractions.
T A B L E - Continued. Showing the Officers of the Town of Oakland and the City of Oakland, Compiled from tht Records of the Board of Trustees aW City Council, front 1832 to 1S83, Inclusive.
June 24 - James Grey to be Pound Master. Jan. ID - E. W. Cohea to be Pound Master. Jan. 23 - Micah M. Howe to be City Marshal, vice Hogan, absconded.
March 14 - E. Hoskins to be President of Council. Dec. 7 - J. P. M, Davis to be Mayor, vice Shattuck. " " - W, H. Bovee to be Member of Council, z/zc^ Marier, resigned.
March 14 - F. K. Shattuck to be President of Council. ' Sep. 27 - E. D. Waters to be Member of Council. Jan. 3 - A. F. Rogers to be Member of Council, vice Palmer, resigned.
, July 23 - Sextus Shearer to be Police Judge, vice Watson, deceased. Nov. 2 - Dr. S. Merritt to be Mayor, vice Crane, resigned. Nov. 16 - F. M. Campbell to be Member of Council, vice
" 17 - A. L. Warner to be Fire Commissioner. April 7 - J. H. Howard and- H. E. Winslow to be Fire Commissioners, zizVi' Chase and Warner, resigned.
Department, 7'ice Halley, resigned. Feb. I - Mack Webber to be Mayor, z/zV^ Durant, deceased. " 15 - F. Warner to be Member of Council, vice Webber,
1877, March ig - W. A. Walter to be President of the Council. '^ April 30 - F. O. Fuller to be Chief Engineer Fire Department, vice Montanya, resigned.
Commissioners. " July 23 - L. G. Cole to be Water Commissioner, vice bessions, resigned. " July 27 - Ed. Hoskins to be Police Judge, vice Jayne, de
Miller, resigned. 187B, Jan. 7 - James Hill to be Chief Engineer Fire Department, vice Fuller. " 'March i8 - Samuel Mitbury to be Member of Council,
Churches. - There are nearly forty churches in the city of Oakland of. all denominations, but our space will only admit of our giving histories of the oldest of these. From the days when "two or three were gathered together" under the shade of one of Oakland's spreading oaks, up to the present the city has been the home of churches that have grown in beauty of design and magnificence of architecture, as the years flew by. She is sometimes called the "City of Spires," as she deserves to be, for more graceful outlines are not to be found anywhere. Her number of devotees is large, and, in truth, Oakland is a city of families, boasting in her churches and her schools.
First Presbyterian Church. - This church was organized in April, 1853, being one of the oldest of any denomination in Oakland. The first services were held in a cloth tent, and afterwards in the public school house, under the pastoral charge of Rev. S. B.
Bell. He was succeeded by Rev. E. B. Walsworth, who officiated until December, 1865, when Rev. L. Hamilton was called to the pastorate, and continued in charge until February 24, 1869. On August 17, 1869, the Rev. Daniel W. Poor, D. D., succeeded to the duties, since when the following have been the pastors: From June, 1872, to November, 1879, Rev. James Eels, D. D.; from November, 1879, to November, 1882, Rev. Samuel P. Sprecher, D. D. The present pastor. Rev. Francis A. Horton, assumed the pastorate April 8, 1883.
The present church edifice, on the northeast corner of Fourteenth and Franklin Streets, was built in the year 1875, at a cost of about fifty-two thousand dollars, and was dedicated for public worship January 16, 1876. It is one of the handsomest structures in the city. The original church building occupied by this society waserected about 1856, at the corner of Webster and Sixth Streets, at a cost of about six thousand dollars. It was afterwards removed to the southeast corner of Broadway and Thirteenth Streets, and enlarged to meet the requirements of the growing congregation. It now stands on Thirteenth Street, between Broadway and Franklin Streets, and is used as an armory.
The present membership of the church is eight hundred and forty-two, the largest accession to the church in any one day w^s on March 6, 1881, when two hundred and twenty persons were admitted to its membership. The present officers are as follows: Pastor, Rev. Francis A. Horton; Elders, E. Bigelow, G.W. Armes,C. W. Armes, J. B. Ford, J. J. Gardiner, J. C. Raymond, C. H. Fish, G. D. Gray, P. D. Browne, A. J. Ralston, H. L. King, Jr., C. A. Bailey; Deacons, W. H. Knight, W. F. Curtis, R. W. Poindexter, A. Elder, F. S. Page; Trustees, A. Miller, D. E. Martin, E. C. Sessions, E. B. Beck, A. J. Ralston, M. W. Upton, C. L. Watson; President of the Society, W. H. Friend; Secretary, M. W. Upton; Treasurer, W. P. Wheeler.
The Sunday-school connected with this church was organized in April, 1853, under the superintendency of John Kelsey, with four teachers and six scholars. The present membership is, officers and teachers, eighty-four; scholars, six hundred and seventy- three; total, seven hundred and fifty-seven. Officers, 1882-83 - Pastor, Rev. Francis A. Horton; Superintendent, G. W. Armes; Assistant Superintendent, H. L. King, Jr.; Secretary, M. S. Hill; Treasurer, G. W. Armes; Librarian, J. E. Simmons; Assistant Librarians, J. H. Henderson, Geo. Henderson; Chorister, Miss Jennie Harrison; Organist, J. F. Kendall; Pianist, Miss Mollie Andrews; Advisory Committee, H. L. King, Jr., P. D. Browne, C. H. Fish, Chas. A. Bailey, G. D. Gray. Primary Department - Superintendent, Mrs. William Sublette; Assistant Superintendent, Miss Kate S. Van Arsdale; Secretary, Mrs. M. B. Holmes; Treasurer, Mrs. James E. Gordon; Librarian, Mrs. Edward Hackett; Assistant Librarian, Miss Bessie Goodfellow.
Independent Presbyterian Church. - This church was organized February 28, 1869, and is the only one of a similar character in California. The first pastor. Rev. L. Hamilton, officiated for several years as minister of the First Presbyterian Church in Oakland, but for opinions expressed by him he was tried before the Presbytery, and subsequently before the Synod, resulting in his being deposed by those bodies, February 24, 1869. A large portion of Mr. Hamilton's congregation, who were opposed to this decision of the Presbytery and Synod, determined upon organizing another society.
and secured Brayton Hall as a temporary place of worship, where services were held until the spring of 1870, when the edifice, situated at the southeast corner of Thirteenth and Jefferson Streets, was erected, at a cost, including lot, of about twenty-two thousand five hundred dollars. The pastor, since Mr. Hamilton's' death, which occurred April 9, 1882, has been Clarence Fowler, who began his pastorate June S, 1 882, when the society assumed the name of Hamilton Church of Oakland.
The Sunday-school connected with the church was organized March 6, 1869, and at present has an attendance of one hundred scholars, and ten teachers. The church officers are: Trustees, N. W. Spaulding, P. N. Remillard, J. VV. Ward, Thomas Varney, J. D. Haines, O. M. Sanford, A. T. Dewey, and J. W. Mackie. Clarence Fowler .is Superintendent of the Sunday-school. The church is essentially Unitarian, of the broadest Christian sentiment.
St. John's {Episcopal) Church. - This church had an humble origin when Oakland numbered but a few houses, and not over one thousand inhabitants. During the summer of 1852 two families met and worshiped unitedly, until a member of one of the families fell seriously ill, when the services were discontinued. In August, 1853, Rev. Doctor Ver Mehr, Rector of Grace Church, San Francisco, visited Oakland, to aid in the establishment of a church; and with much diiificulty a meeting of twelve persons was convened. For various reasons, however, the project was for the time abandoned. Toward the close of the same year, the Rev. John Morgan appeared, and preached a sermon to a small but attentive audience beneath the branches of one of Oakland's shady trees, and so favorable was the impression then made that it was determined that a covered church of some kind should be procured by the following Sunday, if the reverend gentleman would repeat his visit. A large tent, twentyfive by seventy feet, was erected, with a cross upon the apex to designate the object of the structure, and a temporary pulpit fitted up. Mr. Morgan, however, was in some manner detained, but a Presbyterian, the Rev. Mr. Walworth, who had incidentally visited Oakland, being present in the congregation, was invited to officiate. The same week the tent and appurtenances were sold to the Presbyterians. In December, 1854, the Right Rev. Bishop Kip celebrated divine service in a room that had been prepared for the purpose. In January, 1855, the missionary. Rev. E. W. Syle, arrived, and became acting rector of th^ embryo parish. The first communion service was celebrated on Sunday, February 4th, when eleven communed with the rector. On March 5th of the same year, the parish was regularly incorporated and trustees elected, but it was not until the 8th of August following that a constitution and by-laws were finally adopted. During the same month a rented room was fitted up as a church, with benches, at a cost of one hundred and fifty dollars, current expenses being met by collections every Sunday. The Rev. Mr. Syle resigned January, 1856, and from that time lay services were regularly held, Bishop Kip ofificiating occasionally. In July, 1856, the Rev. James W. Caper became rector, and continued in charge until 1857, when he resigned, and the Rev. Benj. Akerly became rector, officially, March i, 1858,' although he had officiated regularly from December, 1857. A lot was purchased in i860 for the sum of four hundred and fifty dollars, and a church edifice erected thereon, at a cost of two thousand six hundred dollars, which has since been enlarged twice. The church was consecrated to divine service March I, i860, while the number of communicants in June, 1872, was one hundred and fifty. The Rev. Benjamin Akerly, D. D., has been rector over twenty-five year^.
The Sunday-school connected with the church was organized April, 1858, and has an attendance now of two hundred and fifty scholars, and a library containing five hundred volumes. The church officers are : R. W. Kirkham, Senior Warden ; Chas. D. Haven, Junior Warden; Chauncey Taylor, James de Fremery, Van Leer Eastland, J. Harvey Fish, Pieter J. Van Loben Sels, and of the Sunday-school, the rector is Superintendent; Wm. M. Cubery, Assistant Superintendent, and twenty teachers. This church has also a chapel at Temescal, whene services are held every Sunday afternoon at 2 o'clock, with Sunday-school of an average attendance of about seventy.
St. Paul's {Episcopar) Church. - This church affords a striking example of what may be accomplished by a few persons in a short time. It has derived its remarkable prosperity through the zeal and wisdom of a few vestrymen, materially aided by a popular and energetic rector. Its inception was begun in a desultory way by a few small gatherings of persons uncomprehending the magnitude which the enterpri.se thus born was shortly to attain. Speedily, however, they realized the work before them, and the church was duly organized in February, 1871. It has drawn within its doors a congregation comprising large influence and wealth from a field comparatively unoccupied before, and is solidly established on a broad temporal and spiritual basis as a great and growing Christian power. The organizers were peculiarly happy in the purchase of the church property. It consisted of a chapel with a rectory, belonging formerly to the California College, and a lot one hundred feet square situated at the corner of Twelfth and Webster Streets. The purchase price was ten thousand dollars, payable in ten years, and was secured by an individual note of four of the vestrymen, with mortgage on the property. The deed was made a third party in trust, for conveyance to the church whenever, within a certain, time, it should pay one-fourth the purchase price. The chapel was arranged interiorly to fit it for church purposes at an extreme of two thousand dollars, obtained on loan by individual members of the vestry. Sixty pews were put in, capable of seating comfortably two hundred persons. They were tastefully upholstered, carpets laid, an organ purchased, and real work was then begun. Pew rates were fixed to produce two hundred and twenty dollars monthly, allowing free seats for forty persons. The first twelve months showed an increase from pew rentals from fifty-seven to one hundred and fifty-three dollars, demonstrating a steady growth of membership. Fifty dollars a month was received for rental of the basement for school purposes, and of the rectory for a residence. By the end of a' year the regular income, including offertories and subscriptions met all current expenses, comprising interest, salaries, and incidentals^ and it has since kept pace with the increased expenses. In 1880 the church building was moved to the corner of Fourteenth and Harrison Streets where it is now located. The rectors in charge of the parish up to date have been Rev. Charles W. Turner, 1 871; Rev. J. L. Parks from 1874 to 1879, the first of July in which latter year the present Rector, Rev. Hobart Chetwood entered on the Rectorship.
Watson Webb, Junior Warden, and Secretary; R. C. Alden, Treasurer; Hon. John A. Stanley, John B. Harmon, Dr. W. C. Parker, Thomas J. Hyde, Dr. H. P. Babcock, Thomas Yolland. Those at present serving are Allen I. Gladding. Senior Warden; William. R. Wheaton, Junior Warden and Secretary; D. M Kent, Treasurer; S. W. Bugbee, Secretary.
The Sunday-school in connection with the church was organized in 1871, and at present consists of two hundred and twenty-five scholars and twenty teachers under the superintendency of the Rector.
St. Andrew's Mission (Episcopal). - This mission is under charge of the Rev. Charles L. Miel, and is doing good work in the cause. There is an average attendance of about forty-five families, with fifty-eight communicants. The property it possesses is valued at twelve hundred dollars, but as yet no church has been built^ services being conducted in a room temporarily fitted up for the purpose. It supplies a want long felt in the western portion of the town, and bids fair to become a permanency in that locality.
First Baptist Church of Oakland. - This church was organized with the following constituent members: Rev. E. J. Willis, Mrs. A. N. Willis, Mr. L. W. Taylor, Mr. S. Ayers, Mrs. Mary Potter, and Mr. J. N. Thompson. Rev. E. J. Willis was chosen Pastor, N. J. Thompson, Deacon, and L. W. Taylor, Clerk. In December, 1854, under the labors of Rev. E. J. Willis, missionary, the first house of worship being dedicated at that time, and was the first Protestant church completed in the city. It was located at the corner of Fifth and Jefferson Streets, and cost, with the land, about two thousand dollars. Mr. Willis' pastorate terminated in June, 1856, leaving the church without a pastor for about a year. In May, 1857, Rev. Harvey Gilbert began to preach, and, four months later, was settled as pastor. He resigned in December, 1858, and was succeeded in April, 1859, by Rev. J. B. Saxton. In May, 1863, Mr. Saxton having left. Rev. John Francis became pastor of the church. Soon thereafter the house of worship was removed to the corner of Clay and Ninth Streets, a more eligible situation in view of the rapid growth of the city. This house, and the lot on which it was located, were sold, when the new edifice was rented to the German Turn Verein, who occupy it during the week, religious services having been frequently held there on the Sabbath. Mr. Francis resigned in July, 1864, and was succeeded in November of the same year, by Rev. A. L. Baker, a recent graduate from Rochester. He, however, was compelled to resign in a few months on account of ill-health. In July, 1865, Rev. B. T. Martin was called to the pastorate and continued pastor for nearly six years. During Mr. Martin's pastorate the present handsome edifice at the southeast corner of Fourteenth and Brush Streets was erected at a cost of thirty thousand dollars, the lot whereon it stands having cost twenty-five hundred dollars. It was formally dedicated in March, 1869, the chapel in the rear having been occupied three months before, and used while the main building was being completed: Since that time the following pastors with the dates of their induction have supplied the pulpit: Rev. T. C. Jameson as supply, from August 1871 to May 1873; Rev. R. F. Parshall as pastor, from May 1873 to October 12, 1873; Rev. R. Patterson and Rev. C. B.
Post as supplies, from October 1873 to May 1874; Rev. B. S. McLafferty as Pastor from May 10, 1874 to March 30, 1879; Rev. Granville S. Abbott, D.D., Pastor, from April 2, 1879 to Dec. 31, 1881; Rev. E. Nisbett and Rev. E. H. Gray as supplies (awaiting the arrival of the Rev. Evan Davis* to whom a call had been extended and accepted, but sickness prevented his fulfilling his engagement); Rev. E. H. Gray D.D., Pastor, August 30, 1882.
The Sunday-school connected with the church was organized in 1854. It has in attendance thirty teachers and two hundred and sixty-seven scholars, and a library of six hundred volumes. The officers of the church are, Pastor, Rev. E. H. Gray, D. D.; Deacons, J. T. Latimer, Cyrus Dam, C. W. Dearborn, H. Garthwaite, J. Z. Dudley; Clerk, H. Garthwaite; Treasurer, Dr. J. R. Bradway; Trustees, J. P. Cogswell, J. L. Lyon, Ch. Schrieber, James Dalziel, G. F. Lamson.
Church of the Immaculate Conception {Roman Catholic). - Thirty years ago a room in a private house served as a place of worship for the Roman Catholics of Oakland and nearly the whole of the present county of Alameda. A priest from the Mission of San Josd occasionally made a visit to celebrate mass and administer the sacraments, and even these occasional visits had to be omitted during the rainy season, owing to the bad roads. The first church, a building of the most modest description, was erected in 1853 through the exertions of a few of the congregation, and for some time was the only Roman Catholic place of worship in the whole of Alameda and Contra Costa Counties, with the exception of the old Mission. Subsequent additions made by the Revs. Fathers Croke and King increased the size of this edifice until it was capable of holding a congregation of several hundreds, b,ut this, too, became entirely inadequate to the needs of the population of Oakland, although three new parishes had been formed in the county. In 1869 Father King determined to erect a church on a scale commensurate with the promised importance of the city. Plans accordingly were prepared for a building surpassing in dimensions anything in the State, though only with the intention of erecting a part of it at first, a design which has been carried out in the ^present structure. The foundations were laid in that year, but various causes retarded any further progress until May, 1871 when the superstructure was commenced and pushed vigorously forward. Although not quite completed the church was dedicated on June 23, 1872, the ceremony being performed by Archbishop Alemany. The sermon was preached by Father Gallagher, to whom, nearly thirty years before, the Roman Catholics of Oakland were in a great measure indebted for their first place of worship.
Provenance
Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.