Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 9 of 38)
From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,971 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
1 sectionThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,971 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
On May 2, 1864, Dole & Brother were paid the sum of two thousand dollars on account of the building of the bridge at San Leandro, while the time for finishing the same was extended to the ist of June. It was, however, completed and accepted by the county on May 23d, and the balance of two thousand four hundred and fortyfive dollars due to them paid; while, it was ordered, August 8th, that a fine of fifteen dollars be imposed for rapid driving over it. On May 5th, the Auditing Committee on the accounts of the Auditor and Treasurer, from February i, 1862, to February i, 1864, reported that they found these in a satisfactory state and correct; and on the 23d it was reported that a bridge over Alameda Creek, near the Bell Ranch, was imperatively necessary. On the sarhe date plans and specifications for repairing and replanking the Oakland Bridge were ordered and bids for doing the same called for. This contract was let to A. W. Hawkett & Co., for nineteen hundred and ninety-five dollars, to be paid in county warrants on completion, which was duly done August 8, 1864. The old lumber was thereafter sold, and the proceeds, seventy-seven dollars and fifty cents paid into the Treasury.
As is too well remembered, party feeling ran very high at this period, and many were the disloyal statements made by the unthinking portion of the community. The county, however, never had itself so startled as it was when the intelligence was received from San Francisco that its District Attorney had been apprehended by a United States Marshal for using seditious language, and incarcerated on Alcatraz Island. The crime, however, proved to be less serious than was at first imagined, for, soon after, Gen. J. S. Chipman was released on taking the oath of allegiance.
In June of this year the following excellent joke was perpetrated on Judge Church, the first County Clerk and Recorder of Alameda, and at present a very able and efificient Justice of the Peace of Oakland Township. It would appear that several gentlemen had determined to subscribe a monthly amount towards the Soldiers' Relief Fund, during the continuance of the war, and among those who subscribed ten dollars per month was our excellent friend. Upon the receipt of the contribution, the Committee of the Soldiers' Relief Fund published the acknowledgment in the Aita California - then, as now, a morning paper - of ten dollars from "A. M. Church, San Leandro," which appeared in the Bulletin of the same evening, transmogrified into the following: " African Methodist Church of San Leandro," thus taking a very strange, though innocent, liberty with Mr. Church's initials.
On November 8, 1864, the Presidential election showed a majority in this county for Lincoln of six hundred and fifty-eight votes, while his plurality throughout the ithousand six -Jiundredt-find; 1;hirty-four votes; and, for Congress, Higby rec6ived fourteen hundred and fifty-eight votes, as against seven hundred and ninety-seven for Coffroth.
The new Board of Supervisors met December 5, 1864, as follows: F. K. Shattuck, Oakland Township; L. Fassking, Alameda Township; R. S. Farrelly, Brooklyn Township; William Meek, Eden Township; H. Overacker, Washington Township; John Green, Murray Township. Mr. Shattuck was chosen Chairman. Standing Committees on Auditing and Finance, Roads and Bridges, Judiciary and Hospital, were appointed, and Dr. E. Gibbons, L. Fassking, and F. K. Shattuck, elected managers of the County Hospital. It should be mentioned that during the year 1864 was the first term that the Legislature sat under the biennial system inaugurated by the amended Constitution.
1865. - Besides a general activity in railroad building, there was notJiing of great "polificabsignificarice'b'ccurred in Alameda. County, although, the assassination of President Lincoln occupied much attention. The first item of note is the allowance, on February 11, 1865, of fifty dollars a month to the Hayward Guard for the purpose of providing an armory; while, August 21st, the like sum for the same object was granted to the Brooklyn Guard, another military organization. In this month the Supreme Court affirmed the judgment obtained by Contra Costa County against Alameda County, for the old Oakland (Twelfth Street) Bridge indebtedness, the amount being fifteen thousand dollars, and, on November 25th, under the Act approved April 26, 1862, the amount paid by Alameda to Contra Costa, if any, was directed to be apportioned, fifty per cent, to be applied to building a road from the Walnut Creek House, in Contra Costa County, to the Alameda County line, to superintend which, on the 27th of Decerpber, F. K. Shattuck was appointed Commissioner to meet a like official from Contra Costa. On March 2, 1865, the collection of the road poll tax was systematized, and Road Commissioners were directed to procure a sufficient number of receipts for the purpose of issuing them to Township Assessors, who were to make monthly and yearly reports of the same and be held liable, on bond, for any deficiency. On the same date the petition of the San Francisco and Alameda Railroad Company and others, for permission to lay their track through Alameda Street to Ward Street, and through the latter to the easterly sidcvof the county road, was granted, so far as crossing the county road at the termination of Ward Street was concerned; while, at the same session of the Board, the following apportionment of grand and trial jurors was made: Oakland Township, seventyeight; Alameda Township, fourteen; Brooklyn Township, thirty-six; Eden Town- ship, thirty-seven; Washington Township, fifty-six; Murray Township, nineteen. In the month of March, in this year, we find that the committee to whom was delegated the duty, examined and passed that now distinguished lawyer, A. A. Moore, who was admitted to practice in the District Court. Mr. Moore was the first law student from Alameda County to make such an application.
The profound , sensation caused on the receipt of the intelligence of President Lincoln's assassination may be more readily imagined than described. On April 17, 1865, the Board of Supervisors held a meeting, there being present Messrs. Fassking, Farrelly, Meek, Overacker, and Green. Mr. Farrelly being chosen Chairniafi p^d-'l^m.^: upon taking his seat he offered the following resolutions,' which were unanim'ously adopted: -
" Whereas, The sad intelligence has recently come to us of the death of our beloved President, Abraham Lincoln, who has been inhumanly murdered in cold blood by a brutal assassin, the like of which cowardly assault does not find its parallel in the history of the world, therefore be it
"Resolved, That as we have always loved and respected Honest Old Abe, our Good President, while he lived, and in common unison with our fellow-citizens throughout the Union, we are sad and sorrowing to-day at the great loss our nation has sustained, trusting in the God of our fathers, who has always sustained our nation, and who ever keeps her destiny in his hands to still uphold our country during this terrible affliction. It is hereby further
"Resolved, That we do now, as a Board of Supervisors, adjourn without transacting any business until the first Monday of May, and that all matters coming before us at this time be continued until the said first Monday of May, and that the Sheriff of the county be directed to drape the Court House with appropriate badges of mourning, the same to remain thirty days.
About this time the late Hon. J. B. Felton was a prominent candidate for the position of United States Senator, and many were the remarks made as to the means used to further his candidature, but with these we have nothing to do. His cause was warmly espoused by the Oakland News, and as strenuously opposed by the San Leandro Gazette. On the 5th of August the Union County Convention was held in San Leandro, and the Democratic Convention at the same place on the 24th, the platform adopted being: First - In favor of a hard money currency, with an extension of the Specific Contract Act, to include verbal contract for workingmen's wages. Second - Opposition to negro or Chinese suffrage. Third - In favor of the reconstruction of the Southern States on the principles established by President Johnson. At the general election which followed, on September 6th,- the Union candidates were successful in every instance; while, at the Judicial election held in the following month, S. W. Sanderson, the Republican nominee for Judge of the Supreme Court, received, in Alameda County, three hundred and ninety votes more than did Hartley, the Democratic candidate.
On October 23, 1865, the new Board of Supervisors, consisting of F. K. Shattuck, Oakland Township; A. Cummings, Alameda Township; R. S. Farrelly, Brooklyn Township; J. B. Marlin, Eden Township; H. Overacker, Washington Township; John Green, Murray Township, met, while among their first duties was the granting of a contract to E. Dole to build, for thirteen hundred dollars, a bridge acro.ss Alameda Creek near the Bell Ranch, which was completed and duly accepted November 10, 1865.
1866. - In the month of January, 1866, a bill was vetoed by the Governor which had for its object the granting to the Alameda Railroad Company a subsidy of ten thousand dollars a mile, to be raised by a tax of twenty-five cents on each one hundred dollars' worth of property, but fortunately it brought numerous remonstrants and was very properly demolished. The chief questions during the session of the Legislature in this year was what was known as the " No Fence Law," and the railroad subsidy. The first of these, introduced by Hon. Thomas Eager, was subsequently withdrawn, and the second, although it passed, was strongly opposed by the citizens, who, in meeting assembled at Oakland, March 27th, called upon the Governor to veto it, which he did. In this year Senator Robinson introduced yet another bill in the Legislature. It was for the purpose of imposing and regulating a dog tax.
On March 26, 1866, the Jackson Guards, another military organization, was allowed by the Board, the sum of fifty dollars per month for rent of an armory; on April 4th further payments to military companies were ordered suspended to await legislative action on the militia law, which subsequently allowed warrants to them up till April I, 1866, and no farther. A commission wasappointed jointly by the Alameda and Contra Costa Boards of Supervisors to survey the Telegraph Road with a view to its permanent improvement, about this time; while on Match 26th the salaries of the Auditor and Clerk of the Board were respectively fixed at nine hundred and two hundred and fifty dollars per annum.
In the beginning of March, 1866, the San Antonio (Twelfth-street) bridge question again cropped in the rendering of a judgment against the claimant, in the case of Oilman vs. Contra Costa County, in the Supreme Court at Sacramento. Early in this chapter we have touched upon this subject (pp. 191 to 195, and 200 to 204) and shown to the reader how an original claim of seven thousand four hundred dollars may be increased to eighty-five thousand dollars and upwards.
On the same date a change in the Road Districts was effected, while the road poll tax, and road tax, , collected for 1866-67 was directed to be set apart to the credit of its own especial district. On the 29th the following Road Commissioners were appointed: Henry P. Barlow, Alameda Township; M. C. LaGrange, Brooklyn Township; Hiram Madden, Eden Township; O. Morgan, Washington Township; J. Donlon, Murray Township; Samuel C. Percy, Oakland Township; whose bonds were fixed at one thousand dollars each. This scheme, it is presumed, did not work satisfactorily, for on September 10, 1866, the road tax was ordered to be distributed once more, the Auditor being directed to call in all outstanding road warrants drawn on the different Township Road Funds and issue, in lieu thereof, warrants on the General Road and Bridge Fund of the County for the amount of principal and interest of said warrants called in. The County Superintendent of Schools, Rev. C. E. Rich, presented a report on the re-establishing and more clearly defining boundaries of the several School Districts, which being fully considered at their meeting of June 5th, the Board then established: Oakland, Temescal, Peralta, Ocean View, Bay, Brooklyn, Lockwood, Redwood, Alameda, Encinal, Union, San Lorenzo, Eden Vale, Eureka, Alvarado, Alviso, Lincoln, Centpcville, Mowry's Landing, Washington, Mission San Jose, Warm Springs, Mission Peak, Murray, Pleasanton, Livermore, Suiiol. On June 1 2th, the Contra Costa Water Company were granted the privilege to lay pipes in Brooklyn Township.
In accordance with the law requiring all persons claiming the right to vote should be enrolled in their respective townships, the following Enrolling Clerks were appointed: Charles H. Haile, Alameda; , Brooklyn; Joel Russell, Eden; J. W.
On September 5, i865, the following Supervisors were elected: F. K. Shattuck, Oakland Township; Robert S. Farrelly, Brooklyn Township; J. B. Marlin, Eden Township; John Green, Murray Township; William Threlfall, Washington Township; A. Cummings, Alameda Township. There was a tie between Messrs. Cummings and Millington for the office of Supervisor for Alameda Township, each candidate receiving forty votes, but the special election held on the 22d of the same month resulted in the choice of Mr. Cummings.
Henry Dobbel, under date December 10, 1866, put in a claim for four hundred dollars, alleged value of a mule killed in crossing an insecure bridge near Dougherty's Station, which, on, being delegated to a committee, was finally rejected on January 6, 1867. The condition of the Court House would still appear to have been a cause of solicitude to the Board, for we find them on December loth appointing another committee to examine into its condition, who reported that thirty dollars would make all the repairs necessary. At the same time GofPs plan for fencing that building, long since "pigeon-holed," was once more brought to light, and subsequently a contract was entered into with John Taylor, for fourteen hundred dollars, it being paid for, and therefore completed, March 23, 1867.
The Board of Supervisors, on December loth, adopted a rule that the first day of each meeting should be devoted to petitions, reports of county officers and auditing bills, unless otherwise ordered by two-thirds of the members present; and also, decided upon explicit regulations for the government of Justices of the Peace and Constables in their reports; also for those of Road Commissioners.
In compliance with the requirements of the law, on December 3d the Board of Supervisors made a semi-annual statement of the revenue and finances of the county and the debt existing at that date. The receipts from all sources ware as follows: -
The total value of assessed property in Alameda County for the year was five millions six hundred and twenty thousand nine hundred and seventy-six dollars and fifty cents.
1 867. - This year is remarkable as one when the Sheriff's office was no sinecure ; crime was rife, and owing to the amount of individual lawlessness, the Grand Jury were three days in getting through the business of the January term. They returned into coiirt with eleven indictments, embracing all the range of crime from manslaughter to petit larceny. It appears that at thjs sitting of the court, one prisoner was tried for the grave offense of stealing a horSe, but was acquitted - so said the Gazette - by Yivs, peers. This legal phraseology, however correct, did not find favor with some of the jury in the case, who thought that the mighty wielder of the shears and paste-brush had branded them as horse-thieves, he was therefore called upon for an explanation, which no doubt he made^ as it is not recorded that vengeance fell upon his devoted head.
In January, 1867, an important decision was rendered by the Supreme Court, touching the question of damages and benefits to property by railroads. The particular case of which we speak was that of the San Francisco, Alameda, and Stockton Railroad vs. Andrew Caldwell and others, land-owners on the route of the road. It had been decided by Judge McKee that it was wrong for Commissioners to take the supposed benefits conferred -by a railroad as whole or part compensation for lands taken from an owner for right of way. This decision the Supreme Court reversed, maintaining that the difference in the value of property before and after the improvements should be taken into account in awarding damages and benefits. Justices Curry, Shafter, and Sanderson sustained this view, b,ut Justice Rhodes dissented, on the ground that " benefits'' could not be considered in ascertaining the "just compensation" to which the land-owner is entitled under the Constitution.
On February 4, 1867, the Board of Supervisors resolved to expend three hundred dollars in laying out Court House Square and planting trees therein, but that sum being considered insufficient for the purpose, two hundred and fifty dollars more were appropriated, and on April 13th a flag-staff, to cost fifty dollars, was ordered for the square. On April 23, 1867, Supervisors Green and Threlfall endeavored to rescind the order in force in regard to the distribution of the Road Fund, but were voted down by Messrs. Marlin, Cummings and Farrelly, but the old order was subsequently adopted on April 13th. The Board having heard that Dr. Haile had a claim against the county for medical. services rendered to prisoners in the jail, under order of the former Board, on April 13th, annulled such order and notified the doctor not to render service unless so ordered. At the following meeting he was allowed three hundred and twenty-fiv2 dollars. On this same date the Contra Costa Water Company obtained permission to lay pipes in Oakland Township; and, on May 27th, Dr. T. H. Pinkerton was elected resident physician of the County Hospital.
On June 8, 1867, the Union County Convention was convened at San Leandro, but discord had crept into the ranks of the party, and there was an undoubted diversity of opinion in the assembly. Judge A. M. Crane was chosen Chairman, and A. M. Church and William Gagan, Secretaries, while there were some fifty delegates in attendance from all the townships in the county, and the following emissaries were appointed to the State Convention at Sacramento: John W. Dwinelle and B. F. Ferris, Oakland Township; A. M. Church and B. F. Marston, Washington Township; William Meek, Eden Township; S. Milbury, Brooklyn Township; A. M. Crane, Alameda and Murray Townships jointly. Mr. Dwinelle offered two resolutions, which were adopted. The first presented Hon. E. D. Wheeler, as a candidate for the office of Attorney-General; the second indorsed the oiiScial course of Hon. William Higby as representative of the district in the United States Congress. Judge Crane (the Chairman) took the floor and offered a series of four resolutions, the first indorsing the reconstruction policy of Congreis; the second favoring the amendment of the Constitution, as proposed by the Thirtieth Congress, and the disfranchisement of the leaders of the Rebellion; the third favored the amendment of our State Constitution, removing the discrimination then made against the better educated of the colored people of the State; the fourth resolved that " while this Convention refrains from instructing the delegates to the State and Congressional Conventions in favor of any particular persons, yet we do instruct them to vote for no candidate known to be a crafty and unprincipled politician, seeking his own good and the consummation of corrupt schemes for the enriching and aggrandizement of a class at the expense of the people; for no one* heretofore known as a corrupt lobbyist, seeking to impose upon the people an immense public debt for .the sole benefit of already overgrown corporations or secret cliques and 'rings' of public thieves; for, no one, in short, whose record in public and private life is not pure and clear from all such corrupt contaminations." The mover sustained his resolutions in a lengthy speech, after which Mr. Dwinelle moved that they be voted on separately. The first and second resolutions were unanimously carried; the third gave rise to a discussion in which most of the members of the Convention took part. Mr. Dwinelle opposed the resolution at length, taking strong grounds against negro suffrage, contending that the negroes were inferior to the Chinese, and finally moved that the resolution be laid upon the table. Mr. Crane and Mr. Shinn replied, condemning Mr. Dwinelle's utterances, and said the speech of the gentleman from Oakland would have been a very proper one for a Democratic Convention. S. G. Nye defended the resolution as far as it went, but thought suffrage should not be based on complexion, but on manhood. On a division, it was found that twenty-five voted for Mr. Dwinelle's proposition, and twenty against, while four declined to vote, all the Oakland delegates but two voting in the majority. The fourth re.solution, which was evidently aimed at the candidacy of George C. Gorham for Governor, was withdrawn, and peace and harmony restored by Judge Hamilton moving that the word white be stricken out of the State Constitution, wherever it occurred.
On the iSth of June the Democratic County Convention was held at the same place, when J. West Martin, C. H. Gushing, J. W. Dougherty, William Moss, and John Threlfall were appointed delegates to the State Convention.
When the Convention met at Sacramento the name placed at the head of the ticket was that of George C. Gorham for Governor, who, it was afterwards charged, had secured his nomination by smart tactics and " trading;" the real choice of the Convention was General John Bidwell, of Chico. Be this charge as it may, the
Union men that were expected to have led him triumphantly to victory, became disaffected, and at the election held in the month of October, the ticket vi^as ingloriously defeated. The Democrats seeing this weakening of the opposing host, published a platform denouncing the Mongolian influx, declared labor to be the true foundation of all prosperity, and placed at the head of their ticket the name of Henry H. Haight of Alameda as Democratic candidate for Governor, who, amid much enthusiasm, obtained a signal majority over Gorham of eight thousand five hundred and twentyseven votes.
On July 6, 1867, the Contra Costa indebtedness was reported fully settled, and the Treasurer ordered to discontinue the fund set apart for that purpose, and to transfer all sums on hand or due to that fund to the General County Fund.
On July 22d, the Union County Convention met at San Leandro for the purpose of nominating County and Judicial officers; the Democrats meeting for that purpose on the loth of August. In the ticket presented by the last-mentioned party there was for the office of District Attorney, George M. Blake, a convert from the Union ranks, while, in the person of Captain Mayhew, who had been a prominent member of the other party, the Democracy also found a new follower, yet notwithstanding these recruits the Union ticket was that which won. The Board of Supervisors elected on October 4th was composed of, F. K. Shattuck, Oakland Township; Duncan Cameron, Brooklyn Township; E. M. Smith, Alameda Township; J. B. Marlin, Eden Township; John M. Horner, Washington Township; Dan. Inman, Murray Township; who appointed Mr. Shattuck, Chairman, and Messrs. Shattuck, Cameron, Smith, and Marlin, the Hospital Committee. December 12, 1867, it was ordered that no more armory claims would be allowed unless accompanied with evidence of approval by the State Board of Military Auditors.
1868. - Early in this year the late distinguished citizen of Alameda County, J. Ross Browne, was appointed Minister Plenipotentiary to the Court of Peking, but not being impressed either with the " Flowery Kingdom " or the officials thereof, he returned to these more congenial shores and at once set about unmercifully satirizing the Burlingame Treaty, that marvelous covenant which, in the language of its author and originator, was to establish the "comity of natiqns, and place a shining cross upon every hill " in China.
Once again in this year did the removal of the State Capital obtain prominence, and once more did Alameda County make an offer for the prize. At a meeting of the Board held February 3, 1868, on motion of Supervisor Horner, the following preamble and resolution were unanimously adopted: -
Messrs Shattuck, Cameron, and Smith were appointed such committee. On the 2 1st February, the State Legislature visited Oakland, but it is needless to say the Capital was not given to the county. On the 29th of this month County Surveyor Board man was requested to keep an office at the county seat and remove thither all public records of his department.
In this year a bill was introduced in the State Senate, the Committee on Commerce and Navigation recommending its passage, granting a tract of submerged lands with a frontage of nearly a mile on ship channel lying between Alameda and San Leandro to the Western Pacific Railroad Company for a terminus, the company to give bonds that the terminus would be there located and that a large amount of money would be expended in improvements. A bill was introduced by Mr. Church, in this year, recommending a considerable diminution in the emoluments of county officers, which gave rise to much discussion and was the cause of a good deal of pleasantry, as may be gleaned from the following suggestive advertisement which appeared in the columns of the Gazette: -
" County Clerk's Office. - Notice! Except duringthe sessions of the courts, or meetings of the Board of Supervisors, the Clerk will be found somewhere about the neighborhood, sawing wood. Any business connected with the office will be attended to after work hours. N. B. - Orders for wood-sawing left on the order-slate will be promptly attended to at two dollars per day, and board."
On March 1 8, 1 868, there passed the Legislature, an Act to provide for the erection of a jail and County Recorder's office in San Leandro; and another, concerning roads and highways in Alameda County. About the same time another bill was introduced by Mr. Church, having for its object the purchase of land for charitable purposes and the establishment of an institution thereon for the care of " unfortunates." This has since developed into the County Infirmary. The "Legislature in this year, too, failed to pass an Act in favor of granting a subsidy to the Alameda Railroad Company to aid it in extending their line to Washington Corners, which caused its abandonment.
In regard to political meetings, the Union County Convention assembled at San Leandro on March i8, i868, and elected delegates to the State Convention at Sacramento, while that of the Democrats was there convened on the 2Sth of April, when they passed resolutions highly complimentary to Governor Haight, and strongly urged his being put forward as the next Democratic candidate for the highest office in the gift of the people of the United States - the Presidential Chair.
On May ii, i868, the County Treasurer was directed to divide the late Alameda County Road and Bridge Fund equally among the several townships; but on the ist of June this order was amended, and that officer instructed to set apart ten per cent, of the road and bridge, tax and establish the " Special Road and Bridge Fund," from which appropriations were immediately made, as follows: one thousand dollars to each of the roads - from Alvarado to Centreville; Stockton Road, in Murray Township; Salt Marsh, in Eden Township; and five hundred dollars for a new bridge across Alameda Creek, south of Alvarado. On June 1st, a petition addressed to the Board of Supervisors by the County Superintendent of Schools for an increase of salary was received and the prayer granted, his stipend being then fixed at one hundred dollars a month, with the understanding that he devote his entire time to the duties of his office.
On Saturday, July i8, i868, a grand Democratic ratification meeting at San Leandro, in honor of the nomination of Seymour and Blair as candidates for the Presidency and Vice-Presidency of the United States, was held, among the speakers being Governor Haight and Lieutenant-Governor Holden. The chair was occupied by William S. Moss, while the Secretary was W. J. Collier, editor of the Democrat.
There was a great deal of excitement among politicians during the Presidential election of this year, mass meetings of both Republicans and Democrats being held throughout the county, while the most able speakers were arrayed on both sides. The Republican candidates were General U. S. Grant and Schuyler Colfax, and those of the Democracy already mentioned, the former of whom, at the election held October 3d, received a majority in Alameda County of five hundred and thirty-six votes, the winning candidates receiving one thousand eight hundred and sixty-one votes, and Seymour and Blair, Democratic nominees, twelve hundred and sixty-two. In this year there were enrolled on the Great Register, after the cancelled names were struck off, four thousand six hundred and twenty-three names, while there were recorded on the poll list only three thousand five hundred and ninety-six names, showing that there were two thousand and twenty-seven persons who did not feel sufficient interest to have their names registered; therefore, taking the number of votes cast, viz.: three thousand one hundred and' twenty-three, from the number on the Great R.egister, and we have fifteen hundred persons in the county who were entitled to vote but did not make use of the privilege.
On October 26, 1868, the county jail of San Francisco was designated as that for Alameda County also ; while, at their meeting of November 1 6th, the Board of Supervisors agreed upon plans for a new Court House, jail and Recorder's office, the latter to be a fire-proof brick building, and the prison to be provided with iron cells. The Board also appointed, at this time, a special committee to purchase a piece of ground on which to establish the County Infirmary, who were instructed to obtain 'fifty acres of land belonging to Mr. Puff, and located betwcii San Leandro and Haywards, above the county road. The Supervisors elected for this term were: F. K. Shattuck, Oakland Township; Duncan Cameron, Brooklyn Township; E. M. Smith, Alameda Township; J. B. Marlin, Eden Township; Dan. Inman, Murray Township; William Whidden, Washington Township. On December nth the county, conjointly with the city of Oakland, established a pest-house on the San Pablo Road; while, on the same date, rates of dockage, etc., were established for the Ocean View Wharf, under the Act of March 3, 1868.
1 869. - This year opened with the ranks of our citizens being decimated by small-pox, which was then prevalent in the county, and accounts for the establishment of the pest-house mentioned above, in which, in the first week in January, there were four patients, attended by a cook, nurse, and visiting physician; beyond this there was little of any moment.
At a previous meeting a petition was presented to the Board for widening Telegraph Road from the charter line of -the city of Oakland to the town of Berkeley, and February i, 1869, set as the day for hearing claims for damages resulting from same. Claims aggregating nearly forty thousand dollars were made, and proof brought before the Supervisors, who, on May 25th, awarded as such a little over eight thousand dollars. On August 8th a second petition was received for the same purpose, with claims totaling seven thousand five hundred and fifty dollars, of which six hundred dollars were allowed. The road was finally ordered opened. May 5, 1870. On February 13th, the report and field notes of survey of the boundary line between
Early in the year the new Court House was completed, but its appearance, style, 'and discomfort, excited general complaint; for its embellishment, however, a new national flag was ordered on June 6, 1869. On July 7th we find the first petition for the creation of a Swamp and Tide Land District, under the Act approved March 23, 1868; on the 17th the Union County Convention was held in San Leandro, while the Democrats made no nominations; but an Independent party was formed and a ticket put in the field, headed by Edward Tompkins for State Senator. On the ist of September the election was held, portions of both tickets being successful. For the office of County Recorder there was a tie vote between P. S. Marston and M. W. Levy, which, at a special election held on October 2Sth, was set at rest by the firstnamed gentleman being chosen. The Board of Supervisors elected were: A. C. Henry (Chairman), Oakland Township; Duncan Cameron, Brooklyn Township; Louis Fassking, Alameda Township; William Haywaid, Eden Township; M. W. Dixon, Washington Township; Thomas Scott, Murray Township; who commenced their duties on October 4th. On the 2d November it was ordered that the county printing should be thereafter done by contract, such being awarded, on December 1 2th, to the Oakland News, Transcript, and Alameda County Gazette for, one twelvemonth, at one hundred dollars each yearly On the 12th December E. L. Beard, for Swamp Land District No. 82, reported work commenced, in accordance with the Act, and made a demand for funds, when a warrant on the Swamp Land Fund for eleven hundred dollars was ordered to be issued -
1870. - Early in this year a bill was introduced in the Legislature providing for the building of a bridge over the estuary of the San Antonio, between Oakland and Alameda, but the people of Brooklyn, thinking that such would materially interfere with their commercial prosperity, strongly protested against its construction, to no avail, however, for the bridge was built and is now known as the Webster-street Bridge. Another scheme of the same nature was the introduction in the Legislature for an Act authorizing the construction of a bridge between Oakland and Brooklyn, for which plans and specifications were authorized to be called on March 14th. These, as prepared by W. F- Boardman, were adopted on the 2d of May, the county agreeing to pay fifteen thousand dollars in bonds, and the balance to be supplied from the Road Funds of Oakland and Brooklyn Townships. This action, however, was reconsidered on the 7th June, when all bids received in the matter of building were ordered to be rejected, and the Auditor directed to issue fifteen thousand dollars in bonds to the Road and Bridge Committee, who were empowered to commence the construction without delay, but under no circumstance was the expense to exceed the sum mentioned above. On July ist the contract to supply piles and lumber therefor was let to Samuel Merritt, and on the 20th August the work was commenced under the superintendence of Roadmasters Thorne, of Brooklyn, and Hersey, of Oakland, who did the preliminary grading, cut down the hill n the Clinton side, and filled in the roadway with earth. It was not until the clo.se of the year, however, that the work was completed.
It is always a pleasant task to chronicle tributes of praise to deserving public officials, as that which we here append. At the meeting of the Board, held February 7, 1870, the following preamble and resolutions were introduced by Supervisor Henry: -
" Resolved, By the Board of Supervisors of Alameda County, that we recognize in I. A. Amerman an honorable citizen, and one who has for the last four years discharged the duties of the office of County Clerk with fidelity and honor to the people and himself.
Besides this eulogium, that gentleman was presented with a handsome gold watch, chain and key, by the clerks in the Court House, Deputy Recorder, A. A. Moore, making the presentation speech. A few days later Mr. Amerman received from the members of the bar a set of silver table ware, the offering being made by Lewis Shearer, Esq.
March 7, 1870, the official bond of the County Treasurer was increased to sixty thousand dollars; and, on March 14th, the Board of Supervisors entered an earnest protest against the attempt being made by the city of Oakland to remove the county seat, setting forth that it is wrong and detrimental to the best interests of the taxpayers of the county. Thus we see the commencement of that bitter feud that so long existed between Oakland and the country residents. On the same date the Board also condemned the " draw-bridge project," to be built by parties resident at Alameda Point and Oakland, and declared it against the interests of the citizens of the county. Copies of these resolutions were sent to the Legislature.
The proposition authorizing the Board of Supervisors of Alameda County to issue bonds for the construction of a new bridge between Brooklyn and Oakland, to the value of twenty thousand dollars, was approved March 12, 1870, and became law; while, on the 4th April, petitions were received from F. K. Shattuck for a franchise to build a wharf from the south half of Plat No. 59, Oakland; another from Ezekiel Brown for similar privileges at Berkeley Point, whence a ferry was to be run to San Francisco; and a third from William A. Bray, to construct railroads in Oakland and Brooklyn Townships. On the same date Adeline or Regent Street was declared a public thoroughfare from Twenty-second Street to San Pablo. Road, Oakland. ~
On April 5, 1870, the Board of Supervisors declared themselves dissatisfied with the boundary lines of the county and called for a resurvey of the sarne " from junction of San Joaquin and Tuolumne Counties northwardly on the west line of San Joaquin County to the slough known as the Pescadero, and also to establish that portion of the boundary from the Pescadero Slough, westwardly, in a straight line, until it strikes the dividing ridge in the direction of the house of Joel Harlan in Amador Valley." This order was modified on June 7th, however, and Horace A. Higley was appointed Deputy Surveyor, by the Surveyor-General of California, to survey the boundary lines of the county of Alameda. He was directed first to establish the line between Alameda and San Joaquin, to be subsequently approved by the Surveyor-General, and afterwards erect monuments, execute maps for filing, etc., for which he was to receive one thousand dollars in county scrip. These duties being completed he received his warrant September 9, 1870, and on the nth November the Board of Supervisors of San Joaquin County were notified that the boundary line established by Mr. Higley was that recognized as the true one by Alameda County.
On May 2, 1870, Hiram Tubbs, J. West Martin, W. A. Bray, F. K. Shattuck, W. Van Voorhies, T. Le Roy, A. J. Snyder, George M. Blake, Harry Linden, and Allen J. Gladding, on petition, were allowed to lay down and operate for twenty-five years, a railroad from Fruit Vale to and upon Twelfth-street Bridge, Oakland; and one on Adeline Street to University Avenue. On the same date, B. F. Mann, Frederick Kapp, E. A. Haines, C. C. Webb, and S. Burpy et al., were granted similar privileges from the boundary line between Alameda and Contra Costa Counties on San Pablo Road to Broadway, and thence to the water front of the City of Oakland; while, on July 1st, the same company were granted the right to operate a horse railroad, as follows: Commencing at Washington Corners; thence along the main county highway, through Centreville, Alvarado, and San Lorenzo to San Leandro; thence along the public highway to Fruit Vale Avenue in Brooklyn Township; and thence to connect with the contemplated railroad to San Pablo in Contra Costa County.
Under the provisions of ±he "Gopher and Squirrel Act," passed March 2, 1870, a special tax of one and a half cents on each one hundred dollars' worth of property, to be called the Bounty Fund, was ordered to be levied; while, another special levy of one cent, with the same conditions, was ordered in accordance with the Act approved March 8, 1870, to be known as "Interest Bridge Fund." On June 7th the County Recorder was authorized to re-record in the proper book the following maps: Kellersberger's Map of the City of Oakland; Map of town of San Leandro, by H. A. Higley; and a map of Oakland showing the position of the property of Joseph Irving, deceased. At the same time the map of the ranchos of Vicente and Domingo Peralta were ordered to be framed.
On June 11, 1870, the articles of incorporation of the Decoto Land Company of Alameda County were filed in the office of the County Clerk of San Francisco; while, among other corporations connected with Alameda whose documents were iiled in this year, were the Bay Spring Water Company, in the office of the Secretary of State, April 4th; the Berkeley and Oakland Water Works Company, in the office of the County Clerk of Alameda County, April 12th; and the articles of association) amalgamation and consolidation of the Central Pacific of California with the Western Pacific Railroad, under the name of the Central Pacific Railroad, in the office of the Secretary of State, June 23d.
On July I, 1870, the petition of E. S. Moulton et al., to build a wharf in Alameda, was received and the prayer granted; while, from the report of the Grand Jury for fhe September term of this year, we find that the balance in the treasury vault on the 23d of that month was twelve thousand nine hundred and fourteen dollars; and the assessed value of the real and personal property in the county was eleven millions seven hundred and eighty-six thousand three hundred and eighty-one. dollars; the amount of tax levied for the year 1870 being two hundred and fifty-five thousand seven hundred and sixty-four dollars and forty-eight cents.
On October 3, 1870, the new Board of Supervisors took their seats and comprised: F. K. Shattuck (Chairman), Oakland Township; R. S. Farrelly, Brooklyn Township; Louis Fassking, Alameda Township; W. J. Stratton, Eden Township; M. W. Dixon, Washington Township; Thomas Scott, Murray Township. Among their first duties was the appointment of a eommittee to obtain plans and specifica- tions for a draw-bridge across the Alameda Creek, near Alvarado, and to order the Road Commissioners of Eden and Washington Townships to advertise for bids to build the same. On the 7th November, Mr. Burrell, to whom was granted the contract at eleven hundred and ninety dollars, invited examination of the work, and for this purpose the Board appointed a committee, who, on January 9, 1871, reported that the building of the bridge was not in accordance with the plans and specifications, and recommended its rejection. Upon this the contractor was granted thirty days' extension of time wherein to complete the work, and on the 2d February was allowed one thousand dollars on account, while John Caddy was appointed to inspect and report upon the work March 3d. Mr. Burrell demanded a settlement in full, but this the Board refused on the plea that the bridge had not been made in accordance with the plans adopted by them, but on the nth the Supervisors agree to examine the structure, evidently it was found to be unsatisfactory, however, for we find, under date March 20, that the Road Commissioners of Washington Township were required to put the bridge in proper order to subserve the purposes for which it was intended, that official, on April 14th, reporting its completion by B. F. Ingalls at a cost of four hundred and ninety-nine dollars and ninety-nine cents.
The certificate of incorporation of the San Jose Mission Land Company was filed, October 13th; and, on the 17th, the fifteen thousand dollars' worth of bonds issued on account of the Twelfth-street Bridge was reported as exhausted and the work unfinished; whereupon the Board ordered the issuance of three thousand dollars additional bonds to complete the work. A committee appointed for this purpose, December 5th, report all bills paid, and after selling the last-mentioned bonds at par, held a cash balance of four hundred and ninety dollars and forty-nine cents.
1 87 1. - It is said the year 1871 was remarkable in Alameda County for its homicides, criminal calendar, educational enterprises, and short crops.
On January 2d, Judge Nye, in his charge to the Grand Jury, dealt roughly with the California Legislature for passing an Act in opposition to the spirit of the Constitution of the State, permitting the Mercantile Library Lottery in San Francisco. He declared, that, without exaggeration, no single Legislative Act in the history of the State had been so baneful to society, and urged upon them to indict any parties getging up lotteries or raffles in the county, several of which were known to be in progress. This Grand Jury reported that they had found twelve true bills out of the seventeen cases examined ; while, an order was issued which transferred the famous case of Laura D. Fair, tried for the murder of A. P. Crittenden, in the month of October of the previous year, to the Third District Court. It will be remembered that Mrs. Fair shot Crittenden on the Oakland Ferry Boat after she had left the wharf, which as we all know, juts for a great distance into the bay; consequently a doubt arose in which county the crime was committed, and upon the survey of Surveyor- General Bost it was found that the offense took place outside of the boundaries of Alameda County, therefore it became necessary to transfer the case to San Francisco.
county, on January 30, 187 1, entered suit in the Tiiird District Court against County Treasurer McClure, to recover the amount of State and county taxes paid under protest by them, claiming, among other things, that the assessment roll was made by Edwin Hunt, who was not County Assessor, and who was not authorized by law to make such assessment. On the 6th February the District Attorney requested the Board of Supervisors to supply him with assistance in defending the suits, when Hon. John W. Dwinelle was employed. These were cases of great interest and moment to the county, and as a decision of the suits was not likely to be reached for some months, and as the legality of the assessment for the current fiscal year was involved, Mr. Dwinelle consulted Attorney-General Hamilton, who brought an action oiquo warranto against Edwin Hunt, the acting County Assessor, charging him with usurpation of office, setting out all the facts, including Mr. Hunt's election. A demurrer was entered by Mr. Dwinelle, the case argued in the Fourth District Court, before Judge Morrison, and a decision in Mr. Hunt's favor recorded. The case was appealed. On February 13th, it was resolved by the Board of Supervisors, "That it is expedient that proceedings be instituted to procure a speedy decision by the Supreme Court as to the rightful authority by which the assessment of State and county taxes can be made in the county of Alameda." It came on before that tribunal, who affirmed Judge Morrison's decision, and it was decided that the office of County Assessor of Alameda County is a county office; that Edwin Hunt was lawfully elected and was last year, and was then, lawfully in office.
On March 6, 1871, the boundary line between Eden and Washington Townships was rectified as follows: "Commencing at the junction of North and Alameda Creeks; thence running up said North Creek to the mouth of Mathewson Ditch, so called; thence up said ditch to its intersection with the Mountain Road; thence following the line of said ditch produced to its intersection with the old township line at a point on the lands of Andrew Patterson; thence following the old township line between Eden and Washington Townships easterly to the corner of Washington, Murray, and Eden Townships." t
Under the Act approved April 4, 1870, the Board of Supervisors authorized the building of the drawbridge at the foot of Webster Street, Oakland, the cost not to exceed forty-five thousand dollars, to be borne equally by the city of Oakland and township of Alameda, for which purpose, at this meeting, under the report of the Commissioners, a tax of three dollars and eighty cents on one hundred dollars of assessed property in Alameda Township was also levied. To this levy there was, however, some objection, and to test its validity suit was brought against the Board of Supervisors by Thomas A. Smith, in whose favor Justice McKee decided, on the ground that the levy was in excess of the amount authorized by the Act, and therefore void. The Board therefore ordered another levy of three dollars and sixty cents on each one hundred dollars' worth of taxable property. On March 20th, the Oakland Gas Light Company asked for further privilege to lay pipes across the Twelfth-street Bridge, while, on the loth April, E. L. Beard was paid seven thousand three hundred and twenty-one dollars on account of work done in Swamp Land District No. 82, from May, 1870 -to May, 1871. On May 9th, the deed of J. S. Emery's rock quarry was made by that gentleman to Road Commissioner Hersey, of Oakland Township, and his succcs- sors in office, which was duly accepted and ordered recorded, the rock from the quarry being directed to be used in the macadamizing of roads in Oakland Township. On June 1 2th, bonds were ordered to be issued to the amount of two thousand dollars for the purpose of completing the Twelfth-street Bridge, in accordance with the Act approved March 12, 1870, said bonds to be issued "out of the Oakland and San .Leandro Bridge Fund." This order was amended, however, August 25th, by omitting these words. On the 2d October, the repairs were reported as nearly completed; but these matters would appear to have rested for a time, for we find on the 6th November the attention of the Supervisors being called to its unfinished condition. On August 25th, two thousand dollars from the Special Road and Bridge Fund was directed to be set apart for constructing a bridge over the Arroyo de Laguna, in Murray Township, for which the plans and specifications were adopted on September 1 8th, and the contract awarded to E. Dole, who reported its completion at a cost of two thousand eight hundred dollars, on the 13th November. Eight hundred dollars of this sum was contributed by private individuals, the balance being paid by warrants on the county treasury. On the i8th September, another sum of one thousand seven hundred and five dollars was paid from the Swamp Land Fund to E. L. Beard for work performed between the 15th July and 15th September.
At the election of September 6, 1871, for Congressional, State, County, and Township officers, Newton Booth received a majority in Alameda of nine hundred and eighteen votes, a result which gave great pleasure to his adherents, more especially as it was thought that his opponent. Governor Haight, was almost certain of re-election. On the 2d October the new Board of Supervisors, composed of the following gentlemen, took their seats: F. K. Shattuck (Chairman), Oakland Township; W. B. Clement, Alameda Township; Isham Case, Brooklyn Township; J. B. Marlin, Eden Township; H. Overacker, Washington Township, Joshua A. Neal, Murray Township; and at once entered upon their duties.
1872. - The chief object of interest in this year was the question of the removal of the county seat. The first gun was fired on February 6th, when Supervisor Marlin introduced a resolution on the subject which was " simply received and filed." The Legislature was in session at this time, and there the city of Oakland, which was represented in the Senate by Hon. Ed. Tompkins, and in the Assembly by Doctor Pardee, felt that a better fight could be made than in the year 1870, when the matter was last contested. But the honor was not by any means to go undisputed, for the citizens, outside of Oakland, were all on the side of the residents of Eden Township, who wished the prize for San Leandro. This contest has been so fully described by different writers that we reproduce one of these: "Assemblyman Crane took up the cause for his country constituents; the Board of Supervisors, excepting the Oakland delegate, were a unit in favor of San Leandro; an able delegation, consisting of Hon. I. A. Amerman and John Nugent, watched over their interests at Sacramento, where they had the support of some of the ablest men on both sides of either house. On one side the cry raised was convenience, and, on the other, cost. The Oakland people maintained that they supplied the greater part of the business transacted at the county seat, which was nine miles distant from them. There were the principal lawyers and professional men, the banks and real estate agents of the county. The Edenites maintained that San Leandro was more central; that it was accessible and convenient for all parts of the county, and was served by two railroads; that the county was in possession of a valuable piece of property, which was donated to it by the Estudillo family, which would revert to the original owners in case of disuse of the purpose for which it was granted; that county offices, a Court House, and jail, sufficient for the wants of the county, were already erected; and that removal would entail great expense on the people for new county buildings and grounds upon which to erect them.
The Oaklanders met some of these objections by showing that the upper portion of the City Hall could be used for years yet to come for county offices; that a fireproof Hall of Records could be built on the city property adjoining the City Hall; or, in case of failure in this, the two city plazas, consisting of two town blocks in the lower part of the city, on Broadway, could be secured for the purpose of county buildings.
Oakland had a committee, or an association, established, called the Citizens' Union, which directed the agitation in favor of removal, and of which Harry Linden was agent. A petition was prepared and names sought for it all over the county, and active steps taken for legislative action. This aroused the Eden people, who also held meetings and organized. Their first public meeting was held in the Court House, San Leandro, on January lo, 1872. It was addressed by L A. Amerman and John Nugent, of Eden; R. S. Farrelly and' A. H. Griffith, of Brooklyn; and J. R. Palmer, of Murray. A committee was appointed to report a plan of action and resolutions, consisting of County Judge Nye and four of the gentlemen already mentioned. The following resolutions were adopted: -
Whereas, Certain people in the city of Oakland are endeavoring to remove the county seat of Alameda County from its-present central location to the city of Oakland; and
Resolved, That our Senator and meml lers of Assembly be, and they are hereby earnestly requested to delay any action upon the petition for the removal of the county seat until they receive a remonstrance of the tax-payers who are opposed to such removal.
Resolved, That a. copy of the above proceedings be forwarded to the Senator and members of Assembly of Alameda County, duly certified by the Chairman and Secretary.
A committee, having a representative in every school district in the county, was appointed to procure names to a remonstrance, which, in due time, was forwarded to Sacramento, largely signed.
Mr. Amerman, having been commissioned to go to Sacramento to watch legislation and defeat action there, immediately after his arrival addressed a communication to Senator Tompkins, in which he put to that gentleman six leading questions touching removal. Mr. A.'s communication was dated the 17th of January, and the Senator's answer came promptly on the i8th, and in which he took strong ground favorable to the Oakland agitation.
Then followed a public meeting in Brayton Hall, Oakland, on the 24th of January, at which the following preamble and resolutions were adopted: -
Whereas, It has become necessary for the accommodation of a large majority of the citizens of Alameda County, that the county seat of said county should be removed to the city of Oakland, and a petition of the voters of said county has been presented to the Legislature of the State asking the passage of a law authorizing such removal; and
Whereas, Objections to said removal are being made by some, on the ground that a .heavy debt would be incurred by such removal, in the purchase of land and the erection of the necessary buildings for county purposes; it is therefore
Resolved, By the citizens of Oakland, that the second story of the City Hall shall be finished at the expense of the city, and partitioned into suitable rooms for the District Court, the County and Probate Courts, the Sheriff, the District Attorney, the grand jury, the petit jury, the County Surveyor, and the Judge's chambers, and that rooms shall be provided on the first floor of said hall for the Board of Supervisors and the Superintendent of Public Schools, and in the basement of said hall, if required, room sufficient for a jail. And that the city will also dedicate to the county a lot of land, parcel of the City Hall lot, situated in the southwest corner of the same, fifty feet wide, on Fourteenth Street, by one hundred feet in depth, for the purpose of erecting a Hall of Records for the use of the County Recorder, County Clerk and County Treasurer. And that the use and control of said rooms and said land shall be vested in the Board of Supervisors of Alameda County, for so long a time as said Board may use and occupy them for the purposes aforesaid.
Resolved, That the Secretary of this meeting transmit to our Senator and Representatives, and to the City Council, a copy of these resolutions.
Messrs. F. K. Shattuck, E. C. Sessions, John Benton, and Dr. Samuel Merritt were appointed to see that the matter was brought before the Legislature.
At a meeting of the City Council, held on the 29th of January, a bill was presented and adopted, which was sent to the Hon. Mr. Tompkins for introduction in the Senate.
In case of the success of the latter, the City Hall of Oakland was to be fitted up for the use of the county officers; the basemsnt of the same given up for a jail; and furthermore, a pi :ce of ground, fifty feet front by one hundred and fifty feet in depth, granted on Fourteenth Street, for the purpose of building a fire-proof Hall of Records thereon; and bonds issued for the purpose of erecting the necessary buildings thereupon. The bill provided that the removal should be at the expense of the county; but the rooms in the City Hall were to be fitted up at the expense of the city of Oakland.
Tuesday, the 17th of February, was the day fixed for the discussion of the bill in the Senate. The bill was read by the Clerk, Mr. Ferrall, in a distinct voice, after which Senator Tompkins rose and off"ered a series of amendments, meeting some of the objections that had been raised to the bill; among which was one providing for the use of the plazas on Broadway for county purposes, and another making the city of Oakland liable for the election expenses in ease of a defeat at the polls. His argument was strong, plausible, and persuasive. In his masterly manner he portrayed the justice of his cause and delivered an exceeding able argument. No one in that Senate chamber knew better how. It had all the facts and figures of the case to perfection, and placed them in a manner best calculated to enforce his opinions. Oakland was fortunate in possessing so able an advocate. He was one of the most brilliant men that ever shone in a California Legislature, and in point of ability and effectiveness was superior to every man there. Not a point was lost, not an advantage left untouched. All he wanted was a vote on the question. Nothing was fairer than that the will of the majority should be respected and their demands granted.
Senator Pendergast, of Napa, was expected to reply. The San Leandro lobby depended upon him. He was considered, next to Alameda's Senator, the most eloquent man in the Senate. But no reply came from him. Senator Larkin, of El Dorado, objected to the bill because it was a species of special legislation, while there was a general law to cover the case. In Senator Farley, of Amador, however, the Edenites found their strongest champion. He espoused their cause warmly, and he was a power. He was Chairman pro tern, of the Senate, and the leader of the Democrats in that House. He referred to the remonstrance that had been presented against the bill, which, he said, contained five hundred more names than the petition in favor of it. The Board of Supervisors of the county, he said, were all opposed to it, with one exception, and had officially so declared; he showed that the townships represented by the Supervisors contained thirteen thousand one hundred and thirty-three inhabitants, while the population of the city of Oakland was but eleven thousand one hundred and four. He maintained that there were facts to show that the county seat was best situated where it then was, to serve a majority of the people of the county. He had seen so many discreditable proceedings in connection with county seat removals that he was cautious in such matters. Senators Maclay, of Santa Clara, and Minis, of Yolo, followed on the same side, and Mr. Tompkins had to reply to them all; and this he did ably and clearly, meeting their objections in the most forcible manner. But there was an asperity in his manner and a bitterness in his tone that was unpleasant.
On the 28th of February the vote on the passage of the bill was taken, when there appeared a majority of one against it. Senator Goodale, of Contra Costa, having reversed his former vote. The vote to reconsider, next day, stood nineteen for, to seventeen against.
There was rejoicing throughout the county precincts, and the San Leandroans received their lobby back from Sacramento with bon-fires, music, and the ringing of bells, followed by a public ball. But the contest was not yet over. On the 20tjh of March Assemblyman Pardee gave notice that he would introduce a new bill in his House in reference to the subject, but it was not necessary that he should, for the revised Codes provided the means for ending all such disputes, and of these the people of Oakland subsequently availed themselves.
At a meeting of the Board of Supervisors, on September 24th, a petition was presented to that body praying the Board to order an election for the purpose of allowing the citizens of the county to vote on the question of change of location of the county seat. W. W. Foote and William Van Voorhies appeared on behalf of the petitioners and R. B. Moyes and A. H. Grififith opposing the same. The petition was accompanied by the affidavit of Harry Linden as to the signatures upon the petition being those of qualified electors of the county, and also by the certificate of the County Clerk as to the number of votes cast at the last Gubernatorial election. Messrs. Moyes and Griffith opposed the petition upon the ground that the county seat had already been once removed, thereby making it necessary that twothirds of the voters upon the Great Register should sign a petition for removal of the county seat, and Joseph DuMont was sworn and testified that the county seat wasformerly located in Alvarado, and was removed from there some time in 1854- JB. Goodrich and C. B. Reed were each sworn and testified as to the number of uncancelled names upon the Great Register, both setting the number down at five thousand.
The Board appeard to be dissatisfied as to all the names upon the petition bemg those of qualified electors, on motion, the petitioners were allowed to withdraw the petition, for the purpose of presenting the same at the next meeting, with the necessary proofs as to all the signatures being thoseof qualified electors. Ata subsequent meeting of the Board of Supervisors, held on the 22d of October, Col. Harry Linden again presented the county seat removal petition, signed by over one-third of the voters at the last general election, one thousand seven hundred and seven names. W. W. Foote introduced Colonel Linden, who was sworn and testified that he obtained over fourteen hundred of the signatures on the petition. Richard Moyes asked Colonel Linden to point out the names he had obtained, which was done. John Coffee was sworn and testified that he had compared seventeen hundred and seven names on the petition with the Great Register, with the assistance of Mr. Collins and Mr. Knox.* He could point out all the names as he had marked them. Mr. Collins was sworn and testified that he had assisted in comparing about one hundred names on the petition, and found them on the Great Register. J. V. B. Goodrich, County Clerk, was sworn and testified that the Great Register presented contained all the names of the voters of the county. He knew that at the last general election four thousand and sixty votes were cast. On examination of Mr. Moyes, he said there were five thousand seven hundred and fifty-four names on the Great Register. Mr. Foote said the petition was presented under section three thousand nine hundred and seventy-six of the Political Code, under which the petitioners demanded that the Supervisors should act. Mr. Knox was here sworn and testified that he had compared down to fifteen hundred and sixty-two of the names on the petition.
The question whether the county seat had been once removed by a popular vote was brought up. Judge Williams was sworn on this point. In 1855 or 1856, the election was held for the re-location of the county seat from Alvarado to San Leandro. There was no Board of Supervisors at that time, and the Court of Sessions called the election. The election resulted in the removal. The county became a county in 1853. The county seat remained at Alvarado until 1855. A popular vote was taken in that year, and it was in favor of San Leandro. Subsequently it was removed back to Alvarado. In accordance with an Act of the Legislature, after that, the county seat was again removed to San Leandro.
Supervisor Case moved that the petition be received and the election ordered. Mr. Moyes objected on the ground of unauthenticity of the names. Mr Griffith argued against the motion. A writ of mandamus compelled the removal of the records from San Leandro to Alvarado. A similar case came up in Sutter Countv at that time, and the Supreme Court decided that the Courts of Record must be keot where they were prescribed by law. The District and County Court must be held at the county seat. The Legislature deemed it their duty to fix the place where th courts should be held. An election, called' by this Board, would amount to nothinp-
An Act of the Legislature must be had. He claimed that the p :tition did not come up to the requirements. The county seat had been once removed; to remove it again it must be done in the manner prescribed by the Act. One-third of the votes of the Great Register was required. There are five thousand seven hundred and fifty-four names on the Great Register, and the petition contains but fourteen hundred and fifty- three.
At the meeting held on October 7th, W. W. Foote appeared before the Board and stated that the parties who had been at work comparing the names on the petition for the county seat removal had as yet only compared about eight or nine hundred names. He stated that in two weeks from then the petition would be presented; and, if the Board refused to grant the petition, proceedings would be instituted to compel the Board to do so. Mr. Moyes arose to speak on the question. Mr. Shattuck said it was unnecessary to say any more on the subject. He was satisfied that a majority of the Board would vote against the petition. John R. Glascock read a decision of the Supreme Court, in the case of Upham vs. The Supervisors of Sutter County, in support of the argument .that the Supervisors have the power to order the election. Supervisor Case called upon the county's legal advisor for his opinion on the point as to whether the Board is requir ed to grant an election upon the petition of one-third of the voters of the last general election. Mr. Moore said he did not think the present case came under three thousand nine hundred and eighty-five, but does properly come under section three thousand nine hundred and seventy-six. Mr. Moyes requested that Judgs, Nye's opinion be asked. Mr. Moore said it was proper for him to state that Judge Nye differed from him. Judge Nye was sent for and returned word that he thought it bet ter for him not to give his opinion, as the matter might come before him judicially. A vote was taken, and the motion lost by the following vote : Neal, Overacker, Clement, Marlin, No; Chase, Shattuck, Yes. The petition was ordered on file.
The next step was to apply to the Supreme Court for a mandamus, which was done on the 12th of November, by Mr. Foote. The Court granted an alternative writ, returning on the following 19th. It commanded the Board of Supervisors to order an election or show cause for declining to do so. A demurrer was filed, and on the 19th of November the case was argued before Judge McKee, in the Third District Court; General Irvine of San Francisco and A. H. Griffith of San Lorenzo representing the Board, and William Van Voorhies of Oakland and W. W. Foote of San Francisco appearing for Linden. The Court sustained the demurrer, on the ground that Harry Linden was not the proper party to bring the action - he, in fact, having no more interest in the question than any other of the petitioners. The Court held that the suit should have been brought in the name of the people.
No further action was had in the matter during 1872; but, as will be seen hereafter, a new complication of the matter was in process by the annexation of the town of Brooklyn to the city of Oakland.
three spans of one hundred and thirty-three and one-third feet each, resting on stone or iron piers, all timber except the floor, to be preserved by the "Robins process, were called for, which. May 5th, brought out a series of bids ranging from ten thousand two hundred and fifty to fourteen thousand nine hundred dollars. On the nth of May the contract was awarded for a "Smith Truss" to the Pacific Bridge Company, at twelve thousand four hundred and ninety-six dollars, and 'the work at once proceeded. To meet this amount county bonds for fourteen thousand dollars were ordered to be issued; and on September 30, 1872, the bridge was reported completed and satisfactory, and the contractors paid.
Owing to the great destruction of roads and bridges, consequent upon the floods of the winter of 1871-72, the Road Commissioner of Washington Township issued certificates for labor and material expended in repairing, one thous,and and six dollars in excess of the amount apportioned to that township, but the Board of Supervisors doubting its authority to allow such an outlay, on March 5th resolved to prepare an empowering bill for presentation to the Legislature for the purpose of absolving him from any responsibility in the matter.
In the month of February of this year the Central Pacific Railroad Company brought suit against the city and county of San Francisco, and the county of Alameda, and the city of Oakland, for the purpose of determining in which county their wharf was situated, and to what corporation they were justly compelled to paj- taxes. This action brought about a considerable amount of discussion and the services of such eminent engineers as Surveyor-General Bost; S. J. Clarke (a member of the first California Legislature); Captain E. F. Rogers, of the Coast Survey; G. F. AUardt, chief engineer of the Tide Land Survey; Luis Castro, County Surveyor of Alameda; and Colonel Coffee, were called into requisition, it being finally arranged that the end of the wharf was in San Francisco County, which was competent to collect taxes from the company.
Under provisions of the Act approved February i , 1872, entitled "An Act supplemental to and amendatory of an Act entitled an Act to authorize the construction of a swing or draw-bridge across the San Antonio Creek in the county of Alameda, approved April fourth, eighteen hundred and seventy," authorizing the issue of bonds of the county to the amount of thirteen thousand three hundred and forty-four dollars and sixty-six cents, payable as follows: -
Was directed by the Board, the payment to be made in gold coin of the United States at ten per cent, per annum. On the same date, March 11, 1872, in response to a petition of citizens an election was ordered to be held at " Kelsey's Bowling Saloon " on Telegraph Avenue, Oakland, to decide as to the annexing of the following de- scribed territory to the city of Oakland: "Bounded on the north by the line of division between plots ten and eleven on Julius Kellersberger's Map of the Rancho of Vicente and Domingo Peralta, filed in the office of the County Recorder, January 21, 1857 said line being produced in a straight line with itself westerly till it intersects the westerly boundary of the county of Alameda in the bay of San Francisco, and produced in like manner easterly beyond the easterly line of Webster Avenue until it intersects the small creek known as Cemetery Creek, which rises in the grounds of the Mountain View Cemetery Association and flows southwesterly to its junction with another creek rising east of said Webster Avenue on the east by said Cemetery Creek, and the other creek aforesaid below their junction until they empty into Lake Merritt or Peralta, and thence southerly along the west shore line of the northwestern arm of said lake till the same intersects the northerly line of the city of Oakland; on the south by said north line of said city, and on the west by the westerly line of said county of Alameda in the bay of San Francisco, to its point of intersection with the north line already described of the territory sought to be annexed." To effect this plan an election was held with the following result : In favor of annexation, seventynine votes, and against it, forty-two.
Under provisions of an Act approved March 7, 1872, the town of Alameda was incorporated, while San Leandro had similar honors conferred upon it, March 21, 1872.
On July 28th, the Republican party held a Convention at San Leandro, with the object of electing delegates to the Congressional Convention, at Sacramento, when, after a keen contest, Hon. Nathan Porter, of Alameda, was put forward as the choice of the Republicans of the county. Although Mr. Porter appeared to be the favorite at Sacramento, there was present an unseen influence that gave the nomination to Horace F. Page, of Placerville, who was put forward by the friends of the Central Pacific Railroad, and thus that company commenced to work what cannot but otherwise be a questionable influence upon the politics of California.
At the meeting of the Board of Supervisors held October 7, 1872, a petition was received from the citizens of the town of Brooklyn, praying to be annexed to the city of Oakland under provisions of the Act passed February i, 1872, and requesting that an election be held to determine the question. The prayer was duly granted and an election called for October 21, 1872, when the following was the result: one hundred and eighty-six votes were in favor of annexation; seventy-three against it; while there was one rejected ballot. This scheme was mooted with the ultimate view of securing the county seat, for obtaining which there appeared to be a tacit understanding; there was also a feeling that a close union of the people on this side of the bay would be more likely to advance the improvement of the harbor facilities of San Antonio Creek in the eyes of the United States Congress, thus promoting the mercantile advantages and resources of the towns situated on the estuary. The opponents of the scheme, the minority, were those who saw a neglect of the interests of Brooklyn under a consolidated city government and squirmed at the ogre of increased taxation conjured up by themselves. The wisdom of the more far-seeing has since fully proved the sagacity of their views.
1872, and, on the 9th November, the election to decide the question was held, when it was ascertained that there were only forty-seven votes in favor of annexation, and one hundred and forty-one against it; thus the township-town was permitted to retain its pristine glories.
On October 22, 1872, the Oakland and Alameda Railroad Company, assignee of H. F. Shepardson, et al., was granted permission to lay their track upon the west side of the cross-road between the Webster-street Bridge and Euclid Street, and on the west side of Euclid Street, Alameda; while, on the same date, two additional bonds of five hundred dollars each were ordered to be issued to meet the remaining debt on the Niles Bridge.
Funded Debt Floating Debt
Whereas, Mr. F. K. Shattuck, now and for many years a member and Chairman of this Board, is now about to retire from his duties in this Board,
Resolved, That we do now extend to Mr. Shattuck the thanks of this Board for the able, untiring, and energetic manner in which he has for so long a time discharged his duties among us, and the cordial and uniform kindness and correctness which has always characterized his conduct as a Supervisor and Chairman of this Board..
On November 14, 1872, Alameda County lost one of its brightest ornaments and most efficient public servants in the person of Hon. Edward Tompkins. Senator
Tompkins was distinguished alikel for his vast learning as he was for his oratorical gifts, and when the Fell Reaper gathered him to his sheaf he was in the zenith of his fame.
The new Board of Supervisors, composed of W. B. Clement, Alameda Township; Isham Case, Brooklyn Township; J. B. Marlin, Eden Township; J. A. Neal, Murray Township; E. Bigelow, Oakland Township; H. Overacker, Washington Township, took their seats and elected Mr. Case Chairman of their meetings. They at once set apart ten per cent, of the Road Fund for the Special Road and Bridge Fund, as heretofore, the township of Alameda being excepted from the above; and, on the 30th, ordered that the rate of riding and driving across bridges should be restricted to a walk, and that the number of horses and cattle driven over a bridge at one time should be limited to fifteen.
1873. - Once more have we the county seat controversy, which was re-opened at a meeting of the Supervisors held February 3, 1873, when W. W. Foote and Col. Harry Linden appeared before the Board with the request that a new election be ordered, the gallant Colonel and R. G. Knox giving testimony in regard to the names on the petition. Supervisor Bigelow moved that an election be ordered, which was seconded by Mr. Clement, but was declared lost by the following vote: Ayes - Bigelow, Clement, Case. Noes - Marlin, Neal, and Overacker. A vote that showed a change in the aspect of affairs, for both the Supervisors from Brooklyn and Alameda Townships had changed their colors. It is thought that the reason for this lay in the hope that the Brooklyn portion of the city of Oakland would be chosen as the locality in which the Court House and public offices would be built.
Notwithstanding this last rebuff dealt by the Supervisors, Mr. Foote procured from the Supreme Court an order commanding the Board to call an election, a charge which they could not ignore after a certified copy of the order of the Supreme Court -directing a peremptory writ of mandate in the matter of the county seat removal had been served on the Chairman by Mr. Foote, on the 17th of February. It was thereupon moved that an election be called for Saturday, March 29, 1873, and that the Clerk be directed to give the proper order, all the members of the Board, save Supervisor Marlin, who was absent, voting in the affirmative. The following proclamation was subsequently promulgated: -
A petition having been heretofore presented to the Board of Supervisors of the county of Alameda, signed by more than thirteen hundred and fifty-five qualified electors of said county, praying the Board of Supervisors to order an election, to be held to determine the question of removing the county seat of Alameda County from the place where it is now fixed by law, and to determine to what place it shall be removed. And it having been determined and established satisfactorily, and it appearing to the Board that said petition does contain the requisite number of names of qualified electors, and is in all respects in compliance and conformity with law, it is therefore ordered by the Board that a special election be held in the county of Alameda on Saturday, March 29, 1873, to determine whether or not the county seat of Alameda County shall be removed from the town of San Leandro, in Alameda County, the place where the same is at present located by law, and to what place the same shall be removed. Said election to be held and conducted, and the returns made in all respects in the manner prescribed by law for general elections in said county.
At such election each elector must vote for the place in the county of Alameda which he prefers as the seat of justice, plainly designating it in his ballot. And it is further ordered by the Board that, at such election the election precincts, polling places, and officers of election of each precinct in said county shall be as follows: [Here follows the usual description of places constituting election precincts, polling places, officers of election, etc.] J. V. B. Goodrich,
The morning of the day big with fate broke clear and bright; the sympathizers with the opposing factions were early afield, but, seeing that Brooklyn had come up in line with Oakland, the result was a foregone conclusion. Yet a good fight was made on the part of the Edenites. The result was a total ballot of three thousand five hundred and twenty-seven votes, divided as follows: -
Thus giving the city of Oakland a majority of nine hundred and eighty-one votes- We have said the fight was keen, if possible the preliminary skirmishes were more so. The San Leandrans hoped against hope, but slackened not in the combat; they had learned to believe that discord had found its way into the Oakland camp, chiefly on account of the choice of location, an idea they fostered with much solicitude, for there is no doubt that those favoring the City Hall scheme, and those partial to the plaza plan, upheld their rival claims with a good deal of bitterness, thus should any breach occur it would incline to the benefit of the old county seat. Brooklyn, also, was at fever heat, supported as she was by a large number of citizens, but, on account of a compromise with Oakland, who threatened to place " Oakland Town- .ship" on their ballots instead of "Oakland City," which latter included Brooklyn as well as the original section of the city, she put no ticket in the field. But, though the indications pointed to victory, nothing was certain, therefore a number of the citizens of Oakland proceeded to the Council Chamber and presented to the City Fathers the following resolution, which, on being read, was fully discu.ssed, and the deputation alssured that the Council had been promised, by prominent citizens, sufficient money to fulfill the promises made in the resolution: -
"That in case the people of the county vote for the removal of the county seat, the Council hereby tender the county the free use of the unoccupied portion of the City Hall, the same to be finished by the Council, within sixty days after notice by the Supervisors. And that whenever the Supervisors deem it expedient to erect buildings, the Council will then dedicate public squares on Broadway for county purposes. And, in the meantime, to secure the county records, the Council will cause to be erected a fire-proof building adjoining the City Hall, for the use of the county, free of charge. And that we are opposed to a division of the county. "
We, the undersigned, residents and property-holders in the city of Oakland, respectfully ask that Your Honorable Body offer to the Board of Supervisors of Alameda County, for temporary county purposes, for such length of time as the said Board may deem proper to meet, the use of the City Hall of said city, and as much land mmediately adjacent thereto belonging to said city, as may be required for the erection of su ch other buildings as may be found necessary to the proper and safe management of county affairs. Also, that Your Honorable Body offer to the said Board the two plazas fronting on Broadway, between Fourth and Fifth Streets, in said city, as permanent locations for such county buildings as said Board may in future see fit to erect thereon.
Contrary arguments now sprang up like mushrooms. It was said that the city had neither the power nor the authority to give away pubHc squares which they held only for specific purposes; others declared that the completion of the City Hall would be of no ben46it to any other pjace in the county save Oakland; while should it become necessary to build, the county could ill afford the construction of expensive buildings suitable to such a rising city. All these various topics were, however, of no avail. Oakland City became the county seat March 29, 1873. On the sth of April, the Board of Supervisors paid a visit to Oakland to make choice of the three sites placed at their disposal, namely, the City Hall, the Broadway plazas, or Brooklyn (East Oakland) where Independence square, or failing that, a block of the Larue estate was signified for their acceptance. This duty having been performed by the Supervisors, who were escorted by several prominent citizens, among them being Mayor Spaulding, Councilman Ferris, ex-Supervisor Shattuck, Councilman Larue, Judge Glascock, etc., adjourned to hold their next meeting at San Leandro on the following Monday, when it was understood their choice should be determined upon. The matter was then taken up, when Councilman Larue, on behalf of the executors of the Larue estate, and the people of Brooklyn, handed in an offer donating for county purposes a certain block of land on Adams Avenue, numbered twenty-two on the map of the old town of San Antonio, and a tender of ten thousand dollars in coin, accompanied by properly executed bonds. Judge Glascock appeared on behalf of the City Council of Oakland, and read to the Board the resolutions offering to the county the use of the upper portion of the City Hall so long as they might require the same, and promising to place it in a fit condition for reception. The resolution also promised the erection of a fire-proof Hall of Records on the City Hall property, without charge, besides the donation of the plazas already noticed. He also stated that there were citizens present, who were willing to enter into . bonds in the sum of fifty thousand dollars, guaranteeing that the offers would be faithfully performed. The care of the Brooklyn interests was in the hands of Leonidas E. Pratt of San Francisco, who belittled the gift from Oakland, and praised that which he represented, stating, that that city had no title to the plazas and no power to turn aside any city property from its original destiny. These statements over, the Chairman declared that they should now proceed to make a selection, but Mr. Bigelow, the Supervisor from Oakland, stated as his opinion that the subject was worthy of further consideration, and suggested that it remain over for one week. A resolutian accepting the grant of the Larue estate in Brooklyn was next proposed by Supervisor Clement of Alameda and seconded by Marlin of Eden, and on being put to the vote, resulted in its adoption by a vote of si.x to one.
Here was a contretemps! Where Oakland wanted the county seat she was ignored; the Supervisors all, save Mr. Bigelow, the representative from that city, had voted that it should be located within a few hundred yards of the city's eastern limit, and one mile or more from the City Hall.
This decision gave the whole county, except the residents of Oakland, supreme satisfaction - their bete noir had been conquered. Yet this triumph was short-lived, but we may not anticipate.
once advertised for plans and specifications for a Hall of Records, to cost ten thousand dollars, while temporary arrangements were made by the citizens of Broo J for the reception of the county officers and the archives.
On. the 13th of April the Board met at San Leandro, when the matter of county seat removal once more came up. The Chair having made the announcement that the Board would now receive petitions, B. F. Ferris presented himself, and informed the meeting that he was Chairman of a special committee, deputed by the Council of the city of Oakland to wait upon the Board for the purpose of reading the following bond to them: -
Know all men by these presents, that we, the undersigned, undertake and promise, and hereby guarantee, that the City of Oakland will faithfully carry out all that is expressed and contained in the resolutions hereunto annexed.
Resolved, That in case the people of the county of Alameda, at the approaching election, vote for the removal of the county seat from San Leandro to the city of Oakland, the City Council of the city of Oakland do hereby tender to the county of Alameda the free use of the unoccupied portion of the City Hall, the same to be finished by the City Council, so as to accommodate the county government, within sixty days after notice from the Board of Supervisors of their acceptance, for such time as the Supervisors of said county may desire; and that whenever the Board of Supervisors deem it expedient to erect buildings for county seat purposes, the City Council will cause, free of cost to said county, to be dedicated for such purposes, the public squares, situated upon Broadway in said city, usually known as Washington and Franklin Squares, and also known as the plazas: and in the meantime, and for the purpose of securing the public records, the City Council will cause to be erected, free of cost to said county, a good and sufficient fire-proof building upon a lot adjoining the City Hall for the use of the county, free of charge, so long as the county may desire the use of the same for said purposes.
A resolution passed by the City Council April 13th, to build a Recorder's office, fire-proof throughout, free of expense to the county, and to cost not less than twenty thousand dollars, was also read by Mr. Ferris, while he, at the same time, presented the/ollowing petition from citizens of Washington Township: -
The undersigned citizens of Washington Township respectfully request that you will reconsider your action in locating the county seat of Alameda County on Block twenty-two, in the town of Brooklyn, for the reasons:
Next came a communication from Mr. Estudillo stating to the Board that on December 30, 1854, a plot of land for a Court House site had been deeded by his family for so long a period as the county offices should be retained at San Leandro, but now that their removal was contemplated, he requested the Supervisors to execute a quit-claim deed for the land, a statement which was referred to the Judiciary Committee and the District Attorney. The next step taken was the opening of plans for a Hall of Records, those of S. C. Bugbee & Son being adopted on motion. But here a difficulty arose, for the County Auditor, Mr. Goodrich, questioned his right to issue warrants to pay for these plans, should they be adopted, and on the matter being referred to District Attorney Moore that officer gave it as his opinion, guided by a decision in a similar case in Monterey County, that the power to erect county buildings without first being authorized to do so by a tax levy, was not vested in the Board. The whole subject was then referred to the Committee on Ordinance and Judiciary, who were directed to report at the next meeting. This was held on the 20th of April, when they stated that the point of authority of the Board to direct payment of premiums for plans and specifications, etc., had been carefully considered by them, and they, had arrived at the conclusion " that the Board had sufficient power under the law to order said payments, and it is its duty to do so; " therefore the plans of S. C. Bugbee & Son for the Hall of Records were adopted, the Clerk being ordered to advertise for building such, the bids to be received up till the 25th April. Bugbee & Son now presented a bill amounting to two hundred and fifty dollars for the plans, etc., which on being allowed, was handed to the Auditor, who refused its audit, thereupon, on ascertaining this action of Mr. Goodrich, Supervisor Clement moved that the Board employ counsel in the matter, for the Auditor was acting under the advice of the District Attorney. The motion was adopted. On April 25th George W. Babcock was awarded the contract to build a Hall of Records, the price to be eighteen thousand two hundred and forty dollars, while to superintend its construction, a Building Committee was appointed, but this movement was also doomed to failure, for on the 28th April, while in session, the Chairman and each member of the Board were served with a complaint made at the instance of Harry Linden, and an injunction granted by Samuel Bell McKee, Judge of the Third District Court, to restrain the Board from entering into any contract for the erection of any buildings for county purposes, or for the payment of any bills against the county for such purposes. The complaint was required to be answered within ten days.
Provenance
Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.