BlockBefore

Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 21 of 38)

From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,954 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,954 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

in which the town of Oakland was started. While Carpentier was at work perfecting his water-front scheme, other parties were in negotiations with Vicente Peralta for the purchase of the ground on which the town is built. The transaction was completed March 3, 1852, and the property deeded by Peralta and his wife to John Clar, B. de la Barra, J. R. Irving, Col. John C. Hays, John Caperton, and Jacob A. Cost for the absurdly small sum of ten thousand dollars. The first named being the one with whom the contract was made, the others afterwards becoming interested in the property with him, a deed of partition was duly executed in August, 1853, setting off their respective portions to each, at the same time making an equal division of the town plot, within the limits surveyed earlier in the year by Julius Kellersberger. The original town is described as being within the south line of Fourteenth Street, and east of a line running parallel with and distant three hundred feet westerly from West Street, dividing the property into blocks of the uniform size of two hundred by three hundred feet, with streets eighty feet wide, excepting only Main Street, now Broadway, which is one hundred and ten feet wide. Six blocks of land were reserved for public squares. An extension of the streets was subsequently made to the northward and westward, at right angles with each other, from the line of high-tide on San Antonio Creek, those running north extending two hundred feet northerly of what is described as "the northern line of Thirteenth Street;'' and those running westerly, from what was designated on the map as the westerly line of West Street.

On January 9, 1854, an ordinance providing for the better protection of shadetrees wa.s passed; while on the same date an enactment was made whereby the bridge (a history of which will be found in the Legislative History, in the first part of this work) in the town of Oakland should be exempt from taxation.

By the Act entitled "An Act to Incorporate the City of Oakland," approved March 25, 1854, the town of Oakland ceased to be, and she was distinguished by civic honors. The boundaries were declared to be: "Northerly, by a straight line drawn at right angles with Broadway, formerly Main Street, in said city, crossing the extended line of Broadway three hundred and sixty rods northerly from where stood the 'Oakland House,' on the northwest corner of Broadway and First Streets, and running from the bay of San Francisco, on the west, to the easterly or southeasterly line of that branch of the San Antonio Slough, or estuary, over which crosses the bridge from Oakland to Clinton; thence along the Eastern and southern highest-tide line of said slough, and of the estuary of San Antonio, following all the meanderings thereof to the mouth of said estuary, in the bay of San Francisco; thence southwesterly to ship channel; thence northerly along the line of ship channel to a point where the same intersects the said northerly boundary line extending westerly: provided, that nothing in this section contained shall be so construed as to prohibit or abridge the right of the Trustees of the town of Clinton and San Antonio, whenever the citizens thereof may elect to become a body corporate, under the provisions of any Act which may hereafter be passed, to provide for the construction of wharves and other improvements for the accommodation and convenience of the trade, travel, and commerce of the said towns or villages, at their respective sites." On April 29, 1854, Mayor Carpentier addressed to the City Council his first message. After stating to them that they have been called upon by the people of Oakland to conduct its municipal government, at a time, he says, "perhaps the most important and decisive in its whole history," he continues: "You find yourselves, on one hand, clothed with extraordinary powers, and on the other, confined within the narrowest limits, under a charter singularly careless in its provisions, and which affords but a doubtful security to the rights of property of citizens - a charter the errors of which, it is to be hoped, the more mature deliberation of the present, or the wisdom of a succeeding. Legislature will duly correct.

"Aware of the efforts being made by the enemies of the town to lessen its resources and prostrate some of its most important interests, the people have elected you with a flattering unanimity to watch over their common interests during the ensuing year. And in taking office at such a period, you have assumed a responsible trust which I feel assured you will discharge both with credit to yourselves and advantage to the city. Under these circumstances I have thought proper to call your attention to such matters as I deem of present importance, and to recommend certain interests to your favorable consideration." He further states: "It is gratifying to witness the healthy vigor with which a number of villages are springing up around us. Between these and Oakland there can be no rivalry, and should be no jealousy. Our interests are common and identical, and after a short time will probably be united under one corporation.

"The chief ornament and attraction of this city consists doubtless in the magnificent grove of evergreen oaks which covers its site, and from which it takes both its former name of 'Encinal' and its present one of 'Oakland.' Their preservation ought to be with you, as it shall be with me, a subject of peculiar care. In fact, the destruction of a single tree, on whose land soever it stands, should be considered a public injury. I recommend the passage of an ordinance for the protection of shadetrees, under the heaviest penalties authorized by the charter.

"There is no other city in California that can boast so wide and regular streets, or so numerous and beautiful parks as ours. The substantial and ornamental fence around Washingtpn Square affords a gratifying evidence of correct taste, and I recommend that others of the public squares be inclosed and embellished at as early a day as the finances of the city will permit.

"In the opening of new streets, as from time to time this may become necessary, to meet the wants of our rapidly increasing population, it will, I think, be best to follow the plans of the old ones, both as to the width and direction, so that the city may not lose in this respect her invaluable characteristics of regularity and beauty. No city on earth has a more perfect grade than that which is natural to Oakland- - a gentle slope from the center towards the waters of the bay - which almost surrounds it. The soil, too, is of so porous a quality as to afford sufficient drainage and entirely obviate the necessity for artificial drains and sewers. Here, then, in the items of grading, paving, drainage, and sewerage we have an immense saving of expenses, which are incident to most other cities, and which in San Francisco cost in some instances full fifty per cent, upon the value of property."

June 24, 1854, the Marshal was directed to clear Broadway of filth; and Mr. Kellersberger was ordered to run out Fourth, Seventh, Eighth, and Fourteenth Streets at right angles with the pre-emption claim of Mr. Hardy, and to mark the line.

About this time it was attempted, by ordinance, to vary the original plan of Oakland as regards its streets, which, had such been permitted, would have done much to make what is a beautiful city hideous in its outlines, therefore, on July 13th, the Mayor vetoed the ordinance and gave his reasons for so doing in the following able communication to the Council: "'An Ordinance concerning streets' is herewith returned without my approval. This ordinance provides that the streets running in an easterly and westerly direction shall be crooked from their course at acute and obtuse angles to coincide with certain private boundary lines which have neither certainty nor legal existence, and that a portion of the streets running, northerly and southerly shall cut others which have the same general direction obliquely.

"The original plan of the city of Oakland is well calculated, if carried out, to make this the most regular and beautiful city on the Pacific Coast. The advantage to the city to be gained by a change in that plan, such as is proposed by the ordinance herewith returned, I am wholly unable to see, whilst the disadvantage that would result from it are to my mind clearly apparent.

"Acute and obtuse angles in a city are opposed alike to beauty and convenience, and a careful examination of the map of the city of Oakland will show that a system of straight, uniform, and rectangular streets following out the plan and direction of those that have heretofore been opened would be best calculated to avoid waste of land and to promote public convenience. Instead of the magnificent vistas which a system of straight and rectangular streets would afford, looking out in every direction upon the craters of the bay or the mountains, by crooking them the view on all sides will be intercepted by buildings.

"Another serious objection to crooking the streets in the manner proposed is that the winds which prevail in this latitude nearly the whole year would sweep directly up through them without any check or obstacle, whereas, if the streets be continued straight in conformity to the present plan, the winds, striking them obliquely, will be broken and arrested by the buildings.

"The objections urged by those friendly to the passage of this ordinance against the straight Streets - that they would, in some instances, divide private land claims into fractional blocks^-is without weight and deserves but little consideration. Streets are laid out for the public convenience, and in the opening of public streets and highways the common good is mainly to be consulted and not private interests. Not that private interests should be disregarded or made to suffer unnecessarily. Our laws do not permit the property of individuals to be taken for public uses without remuneration. Whatever losses may be sustained by the claimants through whose lands new streets are opened, should, I think, be paid at a fair valuation out of the city treasury.

"It is with reluctance that I withhold my approval on grounds of policy alone from an ordinance which has been passed deliberately by the City Council after a full discussion of its merits. It interests the people of Oakland perhaps but little at present, how, or where the streets are opened. But as we are now laying the foundation, as it were, of a town which we may reasonably anticipate will, with a steady growth, become a great commercial city, with a population to be numbered by hundreds of thousands, to proceed correctly is important, and, as I am convinced that the continuation of our streets in direct lines from their respective termini to the waters of the bay would be the best plan that could be pursued and calculated in so small degree to preserve the beauty and promote the prosperity of the city, I am constrained to return the ordinance for your reconsideration." Notwithstanding the apparently very proper veto the ordinance was passed by the Council, with the following vote: Ayes - Aldermen Eames, Josselyn, Kelsey, and Gallagher. Noes - - Aldermen Blake and Marier.

On November 6, 1854, directions were issued for the survey of Eighth Street, from Market Street to the bay, and of Market Street from San Antonio Creek to the city limits.

A writer in December, 1854, in speaking of the city and its appearance, says: Oakland, located within thirty minutes' sail of and directly opposite the great emporium of the State, blessed with a most salubrious climate and unsurpassed in its natural adornments, became at an early day an object of interest to speculators. Had these speculators been half as judicious in the management of their interests in the town as they were in selecting its location, a majority of its blocks would have been occupied at present with handsome edifices, surrounded with flowers and ornamental shrubbery; its population would have been industrious, intelligent, and virtuous. And Oakland, screened from the cold winds by its removal from the coast and its embowering evergreens, would have been the most attractive place upon the Pacific. But how different is the reality! Turn which way you will, and comparatively few respectable dwellings meet the view - but instead, miserable dwellings meet the view - miserable redwood shanties - and these generally vacant. Some blocks, perhaps, you will find inclosed by what are termed 'jumper fences' (a class of fence never known until recently), consisting of a single redwood rail - so thin, irregular, and cracked that all lawful and respectable fences would disown it - tacked upon two sticks with burnt nails stolen from the embers of the last great fire in San Francisco. But the most of these fences have been torn down by the passing wind or passing traveler, and have wholly disappeared from the premises or been broken by the wayside, surpassed alone by the worthlessness of the characters of those who erected them. Oakland, to-day, notwithstanding all her natural advantages, seems really to be in a state of decline." What a contrast is this picture compared with that of the Oakland of 1883!

On April 25, 1855, the City Council petitioned the Board of Supervisors to have the bridge over Indian Creek (a small stream that runs into the eastern side of Lake Merritt) described as being situated between Oakland and the town of Clinton, declared free; while, on January 16, 1856, a resolution was passed recommending residents and owners of lots of land bounding Broadway to plant trees in front of the same at a uniform distance of twelve feet' from the line of the street. On the 6th April of the last-mentioned year Mayor Robinson, in his message, says : " The tollbridge across the north arm of the San Antonio Creek (Twelfth-street Bridge) is another great obstacle to the growth of our city. It is located upon one of the principal thoroughfares in our county, and several expensive and important bridges have been more recently erected at the expense of the county, upon the same highway. At the time the present owners of the bridge undertook to complete it under a contract made with the county, and which was afterwards approved and adopted by the town of Oakland, the county was in its infancy and not in a condition to make an appropriation for such purposes, but, now, all the most necessary bridges are completed, and the finances of our county are in as flourishing a condition as those of any other county in the State, and she should carry out her plan of using her revenue in making internal improvements by purchasing and making free the only obstruction to the travel on this great highway leading from Oakland to San Jose. The heavy debt already resting upon our city will not warrant you making any appropriation therefor; if it were otherwise, and our treasury full, we would still have the right as tax-payers to call upon the county to expend some portion of her revenue in the township of Oakland. This township pays more taxes than any other in the county, and as yet has had none of its revenue appropriated for her benefit, except some two or three hundred dollars for bridges in the valley. The united efforts of the authorities of the city and the citizens of Oakland generally, would, I am confident, secure successful action of the Board of Supervisors of the county in this matter, and the cry of ' tollbridge' that has been so long ringing in our ears will be heard no more." No action would appear, however, to have been taken on the prayer of the Council, by the Supervisors, for we find the succeeding Mayor, Mr. Williams, dealing with the subject in a communication to the Council in these words: "Another incubus on the prosperity of this city is the toll-bridge to Brooklyn across the northern arm of the San Antonio Creek. The importance to us of an untrammeled intercommunication with the surrounding country is incalculable. The already great and rapidly increasing amount of travel from the range of mountains southeast from us, and from the great Santa Clara Valley - a valley which, in an extent of sixty miles in length by ten to twelve in breadth, is capable of more agricultural production than the whole State of Massachusetts, or of many other States of the Union, and a large proportion of whose products for a distance of fifty miles, from the rich alluvial bottom-lands of San Pablo on the north to the fertile valley of San ]os6 on the south, seek a market in San Francisco from this side of the bay - and the great accommodation of an embarcadero at our wharves, present a strong argument for offering every facility in our power to our neighbors, whose ranchos are in our vicinity, to make this a viaduct to the metropolis, for the production of the ranchos within thirty miles around.

" It will promote and increase our daily and hourly business and social intercourse with our neighbors and the in-habitants of the whole country round about us; bring down to our markets the flocks and herds from the mountains, and the agricultural products of the valleys; fill our hotels and boarding-houses with the traveling public, increase the trade of our merchants, afford employment to our mechanics and artisans, and in a short time the whole face of our community will be changed from inactivity and want of employment to industrial activity and life. Your now tenantless houses will become habited by an industrious population; the lowness of rents and cheapness of living will invite an honest and thrifty population instead of dullness and inactivity; your streets will teem with animation and life, and the whole face of this city be changed. All this business and travel which would seek our city, were the passage over that bridge free, is now turned aside and stopped at other and sometimes inconvenient points, and, while the public is incornmoded our city is impoverished. The tolls now demanded and paid for passing the bridge, varying from twenty-five cents to one dollar and upwards, form no inconsiderable cash item to the farmer and others whose wants or inclinations require them to pass it daily, and sometimes several times a day throughout the year, and when they have well-founded doubts of the legality of the exaction it becomes still more onerous and objectionable, for the public sentiment throughout the land is anti-monopoly. The spirit of the age is for freedom from restrictions and shackles of every kind consistent with individual rights and the laws of the land. It is a spirit eminently American - promotion on the one hand of enterprise and industry, individual success and national advancement; while, on the other, every obstacle to the free business and social intercourse of society withers the fresh budding of enterprise, palsies the strong arm of industry, and hampers and manacles the free exercise of the highest and noblest powers, both mental and physical, of man. It is the free intercourse between the distant portions of this vast country by means of railroads, bridges, steamers, clippers, and lightning telegraph which has brought us together as neighbors, promoted our prosperity, strengthened the national arm, and bound us together with bonds of iron.

" You have a strong incentive for your exertions to procure a free bridge in the noble stand taken by the Honorable the Board of Supervisors of this county at their recent session at San Leandro - the county seat. The Supervisors are fresh from the people, represent every town in the county, are supposed to faithfully reflect the public wants and wishes, are themselves a body of great intelligence and gentlemen of varied and extensive business experience, and their almost unanimous action is deserving of your full approbation. Your zealous and hearty co-operation, therefore' with the Board of Supervisors in making a free bridge either by purchase of individual interests in the present bridge, or the construction of a new one, will receive the cordial approval of your con^ituents, carry out the public sentiment, and respond to the wishes and feelings of the entire community." Here the matter did not rest. This action, so important to the prosperity of the city, was strenuously urged, and a special appropriation for the construction of a bridge between Oakland and Brooklyn was strongly recommended. The Board of Supervisors had, with praiseworthy liberality, appropriated six thousand dollars of the county's funds for tliat object, and it was thought that the requisite balance could be easily supplied by private subscription and a vote from the Council. '

By decree of the Council under date May ii, 1859, the public square bounded by Fourth and Fifth Streets and Broadway and Washington Streets was given the name of Washington Square; and that bounded by Fourth and Fifth Streets, and Broadway and Franklin Streets, was to be hereafter known as Franklin Square. It may be be mentioned here en passant, that on the former of these is located the Court House, and on the latter the Hall of Records, both having been ceded to the county in consideration of the county seat being located in Oakland. May 25th Washington Square was leased by the city to the Alameda Agricultural Society, and on June 8th the City Marshal was directed to remove the wooden building occupied by Mr. Stuart, daguerreotypist, on Second Street near Broadway, as well as all stands, booths, tables, etc., erected on the public streets, sidewalks, and squares. In his message of March 28, 1 860, Mayor Davis suggested the advisability of extending Seventh or Eighth

Street to the shore of the bay, and of Adeline Street to the northerly limits of the city, as matters of great public convenience. On August 27, 1862, the names of West Second, West Fourth, West Sixth, West Eighth, West Tenth, West Twelfth, West Fourteenth, West Sixteenth, West Eighteenth, West Twentieth, and West Twenty-second were given to the streets at right angles with and west of Market Street, and running to the " wire fence."

Of the thoroughfares in the city Mayor Bovee, in his message to the Council of March 12, 1863, remarks: "One of the questions which has afforded to the corporation more trouble than any other is that of its streets, and although the new charter passed at the last session of the Legislature was designed to remedy the evils known to exist, yet some portions of it are so awkwardly drawn as to still leave great inconvenience and perplexity in dealing with the subject. Section fifty-seven of the Act referred to (Session Laws, 1862, p. 354) provides that notice of the application for opening streets shall be given to owners or applicants of the land through which the proposed street is to pass. In many cases, particularly where the property through which the street is to pass is unimproved, there are no occupants, and the owners cannot be found, and thereby the entire law is rendered inoperative. Would it not be well to seek such amendment as will provide for service of notice in the case referred to, by publications or placing notice upon the property ? And another objection to the present law is that the person petitioning cannot make any claim for the damage he may sustain by the opening of the street petitioned for. Now, as the Council can act only on petition, this enactment operates in many cases to delay much-needed improvements and deters parties interested from seeking them, because the cost may individually be more than the benefit to be derived. The subject of affording just compensation to parties whose property may be taken for public improvements has been at all times one of great perplexity, but I doubt «ot your wisdom will enable you to devise a mode of settling this difficulty. I would suggest, also, that such amendment be obtained to our charter as will provide for an equitable plan of assessing the damage of opening streets upon the property benefited thereby, instead of as at present making such dannage in effect a general charge on all the property of the city, by paying them from the General Fund. The present Act (Section fifty-sevenj provides that parties aggrieved by the action of the Council respecting the amounts of damages allowed them shall have the right to appeal to the County Court, and also the right to appeal from the decision of the County Court. I would suggest that the Legislature be asked to amend this section so as to provide that such appeal shall not in any manner delay the opening or laying out of the proposed streets, but that the appeal shall be deemed to be only on the question of the sufficiency of damages awarded. The above, and all other amendments you may deem desirable, should be presented to the attention of our Legislative delegation as soon as practicable, to insure their passage at the present session.

" Some time since the Council adopted a map by Mr. Whitcher as the official map of the streets of the city, the western boundary being Market Street. Since that time a plan of streets has been laid out extending from Market Street to a line heretofore known as the ' wire fence,' and now named Center Street, of which addition no map has yet been printed. As the city is now rapidly extending beyond the last- mentioned line, and as in all probability but a few years will elapse before all the property in that portion of the city will be built upon or otherwise improved, I would suggest that much trouble may be avoided by adopting a uniform system of streets extending to the bay of San Francisco, and that this be done before parties now improving lands in that neighborhood adopt particular thoroughfares. After improvements are once made ani private routes of travel laid out, the damage of openmg public streets is in many cases much enhanced. The first clause of Section fiftyseven of the charter looks to such action on the part of your Body."

Resolved, That it is the intention of this Council to order the following street work, viz. : That all that portion of Broadway Street, forty feet in width, that is to say, that portion lying twenty feet on each side of the center Una of said street, and extending from Broadway Wharf to the north line of Fourteenth Street, be macadamized upon the established grade of said street, with rock from the quarry of H. M. Whitmore, near this city, or with rock of the same quality, broken into pieces not exceeding two inches square, and laid at a depth of six inches, said work to be done under the direction and supervision and to the satisfaction of the City Marshal.

The Council at the same time resolving that such work would not be proceeded with without consulting property-owners. The contract was awarded, August 6th, for the portion from Fifth to Fourteenth Street, to A. W. Hawkett, the price being five and one-half cents per square foot, in gold or silver coin, or fifteen cents in legaltender notes. On November loth the portion lying between Fourth and Tenth Streets was let to the same person.

Whereas, It is desirable for all cities to have large parks, which greatly promote the health and the enjoyment of the inhabitants and offer an inducement to settle in and to visit such cities; and

Whereas, Only one large and well-wooded tract, at present known as the " Hardy Tract," is left intact in the city of Oakland, offering a site admirably adapted for the laying out of a park; and considering that the entire city will be much benefited by the possession of a fine park,

Resolved, That a committee of two be appointed by the Chair to ascertain on what terms the city could purchase the tract of land bounded by Market, West Sixth, McClellan, and West Fourteenth Streets, with a perfect title thereto.

So far nothing has been done towards obtaining a public park for the city, but this need has been effectually met by the establishment of such grounds 5s Badger's and other like places in and within easy access of the city; but perhaps no more suitable location for such could be found than that of Adams' Point, juttin^- into Lake Merritt.

On October 25, 1864, an ordinance was passed directing the widenino- of sidewalks on Broadway to twenty feet. It is curious, at this date, to notice who the petitioners were that presented this prayer, and how much property they represented: F. Delger, ten lots; J. E. Whitcher, three lots; C. Rooney, two lots; F. K. Shattuck & Co., nine lots; James J. Cadogan, two lots; I. Herzog, one lot; B. F. Ferris, five lots- P. Hayes, one lot; A. D. Eames, two lots; Edson Adams, twelve lots; S. B. McKee two lots; Joseph Becht, four lots; S. Hirshberg, one lot; R. Heyman, one lot- L6uis Meyer, three lots; Dr. de Taval, two lots; Frank Dufit - lots; W. S. Hurlburt eieht lots; W. W. McKenzie, two lots; James Brown, four lots; S. H. Robinson, one lof

S. Harris, five lots; First Presbyterian Church, eight lots; H. Jahn, four lots; Geo. H. Fogg, seven lots; F. Figel, eleven lots; C. Reier, three lots; T. Manl. Valde, four lots; Joseph Mayers, two lots; Thomas Mahoney, two lots; A. Anderson, two lots; Thomas Dombrowski, two lots; E. P. Sanford, four lots. September 26, 1865, sidewalks were ordered for the following streets: Fourth Street, from Oak to Jefferson Street; Sixth Street, from Oak to Grove Street; Eighth Street, from Oak to Castro Street; Tenth Street, from Oak to Jefferson Street; and, on October 3d, Seventh Street, from Broadway to Washington Street. January 16, 1866, the initial point of all surveys of the city was directed to be in accordance with the following resolution: -

Whereas, It is shown that the building known as "Ala Mariposa," situated at the southwest comer of Fourth Street and Broadway, is located in conformity with the original plan of the city by Julius Kellersberger;

Resolved, That the face of said building at the corner above mentioned be, and hereby is, established as the initial point for measure, and that all property be located by the City Engineer according to the said Kellersberger's plan.

On July 18, 1866, the first sewer in the city was ordered to be constructed between Fourth Street and the water front on Broadway; but this subject will be treated separately further on. December [9th of the same year the name of McClellan Street was changed to Linden Street; and on December 21st Twelfth Street was ordered to be macadamized from Broadway to the Oakland bridge. On February 22, 1867, an appropriation of three thousand dollars for lighting streets for the year 1867-8 was made; while, on May 25th, Mr. Little, a resident of Oakland, made a formal tender to the city of that part of Webster Street opened north of Seventeenth Street, through the old cemetery to the San Antonio Creek, eighty feet wide, a grant which, on motion of Mr. Barstow, was accepted by the Council.

Mayor Crane, in his message of September 28, 1867, says on the subject of streets, etc.: "As you are well aware, the Act touching street improvements, passed April 4, 1864, prohibits the Council from subjecting the city to any expense in the shape of compensation for opening new streets, I would suggest that the time has now arrived when this restriction carl with safety be removed and that the incoming Legislature should be asked to confer upon the Council the power of awarding compensation; or, if it is deemed inexpedient, to ask for the power generally, to request it with reference to the opening of some centrally located street between Broadway and the Point. First Street has thus far proved to be of little or no practical benefit to the city at large. Our increased population imperatively demands a thoroughfare more conveniently situated. In my opinion. Eighth or Twelfth Streets should be opened through to the Point, and I do not believe that the city would be subjected to any very serious expense, as the benefits accruing to adjoining proprietors would, in most cases, overbalance the damages awarded. If this suggestion meets the views of the Council, it is advisable to have the proper bill prepared at an early date so as to present it to the Legislature as soon as it convenes in December."

On December 21, 1867, Tenth Street, from Broadway to Market Street, was ordered to be macadamized; while, March 28, 1868, similar work was directed on Eighth Street from Oak to Market Street. Like improvements were ordered, June 1 2th, on Fourteenth Street from Broadway to Market Street; and, on the 22d, on Washington Street from First to Eighth Street, and on Market Street, from Four-

In his message to the Council, dated March 15, 1869, Doctor Merritt, then Mayor, states: "Within the limits of the city surveyed into ^blocks and streets by Kellersberger, seven blocks were set apart for public squares, and as such have been dedicated to public use. They are named as follows: Lafayette, Jefferson, Washington, Franklin, Oakland, Madison, and Caroline Squares. Having been informed that .some question existed as to the validity of the city's title to these squares, with the approval of the members of the Council, I had five of them inclosed with a good, substantial picket fence. The whole cost of inclosing these five plazas was nine hundred and ninety dollars and seventeen cents. The remaining two, Washington and Franklin, Squares were in the possession of the city." His Honor further remarks : " Section Twenty of 'An Act authorizing the City Council of Oakland to improve Streets, Lanes, Alleys, Courts, and Places in said City' (approved April 4, 1864) reads as follows: 'When one street or portion of a street has been, or shall hereafter be, constructed to the satisfaction of the City Council and Marshal of said city, under such regulations as said Council shall adopt, the same shall be accepted by said Council, and thereafter shall be kept open and improved by the said city, and the expense thereof to be paid out of the Street Department Fund.' I would recommend that an ordinance be passed defining the improvements requisite for such acceptance, and I think the same should include grading, macadamizing, sewering, curbing, culverts, and sidewalks, and in all cases practicable the gas and water pipes should be laid before the streets are macadamized.

" I have heard various ideas expressed and suggestions made relating to the most feasible system to be adopted to- connect existing irregularities in the location of streets and blocks. Some are for straight lines; some are for crooked lines; some are for new lines; and others are for no lines at all. I think that system should be adopted that most effectually harmonizes irregularities at the same, time interferes the least with existing improvements. The diffculty has been the result of inaccurate surveys by Kellersberger, who laid out and surveyed the town originally. These surveys were made at a time when land was of but little value, and the future destiny of Oakland was not appreciated. All the blocks were intended to be Itwo hundred by three hundred feet, and all the streets, with two or three exceptions, eighty feet in width. The surveys having been with a slack chain the most of the blocks and streets measured a few inches large. Now, by fixing an 'Initial Point' near the center of the city and running lines to the extreme limits of that paVt of the city originally laid out into blocks and streets, giving to each block and street the exact number of feet designed, the combined surplusage amounts to four or five feet at the extreme limits of the original survey. Had there been initial points established at the four sides of the city and the surplusage of streets and blocks fixed or equalized on the four sides of the city before the present system of accurate measurement from one initial point had been adopted, I think it would have been much better. The few inches more or less in a block or street could have done no harm, and by running short lines through the city, there could have been nothing objectionable to the eye."

section with Telegraph and San Pablo Roads to the charter line; and on July 12th, an ordinance was passed directing the numbering of houses. This, however, was repealed, July 26th, and left in abeyance for a time.

The extending of Broadway was accompanied with numerous legal difficulties and perplexities. The first step taken was the tearing down of the only fence in the proposed line by the Road Commissioner, armed with the proper authority from the Board of Supervisors, and then began the work of grading. The morning after this had been commenced that official found the fence restored to its original place, and in a short time an injunction was served upon him, ordering him to suspend operations. He thereupon entered suit in the County Court against the party obstructing.

Resolved, That a special Committee of three be appointed to prepare the draft of » bill to be forwarded to our Legislative delegation for an Act authorizing the city of Oakland to dispose of Washington and Franklin Squares, the proceeds to be applied to the payment of the indebtedness of the city, and that such Committee report the same to the Council at its next meeting.

To this Mr. Miller offered a substitute resolution, providing for the sale of the City Hall and lot, which was lost; the original motion was carried, and Messrs. Van Dyke, Spaulding, and Folger appointed a committee to report. On the 14th February the building of a bridge across San Antonio Creek was recommended and the following resolution passed: -

Resolved, That we approve the bill to authorize the construction of a swing or draw bridge across San Antonio Creek, in the county of Alameda, the draft of which has been submitted for our consideration; provided, the following amendment be made thereto, to wit: That when the road and bridge shall be completed they be turned over to the county, and thereafter be under the charge and control of the Board of Supervisors and subject to the same provisions as other county roads; and that being so amended we recommend to our Legislative delegation the passage of said bill.

On September 12th the bridge between Adeline and Peralta Streets on First Street was ordered to be rebuilt; while, on the 19th, Fourteenth Street, from San Pablo Road to the west line of the city, was ordered to be macadamized. On November 28th, in accordance with the petitions of certain citizens, an ordinance entitled "An Ordinance granting permission to certain persons to construct a bridge from the intersection of Jackson Street with the shore of the lake across the lake to Adams Point" was framed and referred to the Committee on Ordinances and Judiciary, who reported, "that the Council had no right to authorize the construction of such bridge across the waters of the lake."

Of the subject of streets. Mayor Spaulding, in his semi-annual message, stated : " Your Honorable Body is doubtless aware of the difficulty that at one time existed respecting the lines and surveys in all that part of the city lying east of Market Street, which received the careful attention of the late Board of Engineers, and were by them so ably and satisfactorily adjusted. It was not known to the City Council at that time what condition the surveys were in, in the western part of the city, but more particularly that part lying west of Adeline Street. Recent investigation has developed the fact that errors and inaccuracies exist to such an extent that only a thorough resurvey and the setting of a series of mortuments at proper points can correct these irregularities ard harmonize these difficulties. To accomplish this I would sug- gest that a series of check-lines be run through every third or fourth street running east and west, north and south, and placing at their intersection iron monuments.

" These irregularities have arisen from a variety of causes. The surveys have been made by different engineers at various times since the organization of the city, starting from different points, and, in many instances, the streets have been located with reference to property lines and personal interests. In some instances there have been found to exist discrepancies in the measurements made by the same engineer at different times, which do not agree within themselves and cannot be made to connect. There has not yet been any systematic survey made so as to correct these several surveys or tie them together.

" This matter has already been delayed too long and should be adjusted with as little delay as possible, not only for the welfare of the city but for the interest of the property-owners who have of late become fully alive to the importance and necessity of opening, widening, and straightening the streets. These lines should be established while the streets are being laid out and opened, and while there are comparatively but few improvements to be disturbed, and matters in this direction become more complicated.

"I would further recommend that a map be carefully prepared, showing the exact location of all improvements and indicating the position of the monuments, distances, etc., and to have the same filed in the office of the City Engineer for future reference. It is important that these should be done before the adoption of the city map, which is now before you for your inspection and approval."

The Mayor then draws the following picture : " Last, though not least, among the necessary improvements that ought to be made and which should claim a share of your attention is the construction of sidewalks upon our most thickly populated streets, but more especially those that have been graded and macadamized.

"The first noticeable feature that strikes the eye of a stranger when visiting our city is the crowd of straggling pedestrians as they diverge from the different stations along the route of the railroad, and wend their way hither and thither, some through weeds and sand where sidewalks ought to be; others, less brave, seek the middle of the streets, much to the annoyance and inconvenience of the travel of carriages and carts, as well as to the risk of life and limb.

" We now have about fourteen miles of macadamized streets and only about two miles of these streets have sidewalks in any m inner improved for the convenience of foot travel, and the improvements that have been made were made regardless of any general system, and some of the intended improvements are but little better than none.

" As each property-holder has his own individual notion in regard to the best method of improvement, and has exercised the privilege of putting his plan into execution in front of his own premises, it follows that we have about as many kinds of sidewalks as we have property- owners on the streets where improvements have been made. I would therefore suggest that some general plan be adopted .by you for improving the condition of our sidewalks in a uniform and economical manner. We have now had sufficient experience with the various kinds of material used, to be able to determine which is the best. Loose gravel or broken stone wherever exposed to foot travel is extremely unpleasant and difficult to walk upon and will require years to render it fit for use. The only macadam walks which have so far proved successful have been made from the decomposed rock taken from the Fowler Quarry and spread at a depth of about two inches, and well mixed with fine gravel, and rolled. This makes a good, serviceable walk, at a cost of about thirty cents per lineal foot; or, the white cement gravel found in the vicinity of Fruit Vale. The latter appears to be more preferable, because it becomes more solidified than any other material heretofore used, being less affected by the agencies of the weather. It has been used in some localities in this city for the last eighteen months. The peculiarities which recommend this cement gravel are that, when it is exposed to the elements it becomes adhesive and firm, is comparatively free from mud in winter and dust in summer. This makes it a complete and permanent improvement. Sidewalks made from this material are estimated to cost about thirty cents per lineal foot for walks eighteen feet wide. We have also had some experience with plank walks, laid four feet wide - two-inch plank; this makes a neat, commodious walk for temporary purposes, and recommends itself on account of its cheapness, and will probably be the most acceptable in localities where there are few improvements. This kind of sidewalk can be constructed for twenty-five cents per lineal foot."

From the foregoing it will be gathered that the thoroughfares of the city only little more than a dozen years ago were in what may be termed a state of nature. Such naturally acted as a determent against the progress of Oakland, and very properly was a source of anxiety to the head of the city government.

On November 13, 1 871, an ordinance was passed levying a tax in the matter of opening and widening Broadway from Fourteenth Street, northerly, to the charter line, the passage of the enactment being brought about by the issuance of a writ of mandamus from the County Court to the City Council commanding such levy; while, on December 4th, another ordinance was passed changing the names of Caroline Square to Lincoln Square, and Julia Street to Madison Street. An application from the land-owners on Ninth Street was received on January 2, 1872, to build .a bridge connecting that thoroughfare with Franklin Street, Brooklyn.

His Honor, Mayor Spaulding, in his message to the Council under date April 15, 1872, tells them: "We now have the advantage of an experience which has put to the severest test the material used in macadamizing our streets. The experience of the past severe winter has to my mind fully demonstrated the correctness of the principle upon which the work has been constructed. The only correction I have to suggest and which this experience has proved to be necessary is the omission of clay or any like material which has hitherto in some instances been employed. It is important that a system of repair should be established. It seems to be extremely difficult to eradicate from the minds of those who are most interested the idea that when a street is received from the hands of the contractor that it is done for all time. Macadamized roadways require constant and unremitting attention, and this attention should commence from the moment the work is delivered by the contractor; no one thing will add more to their durability and improve their condition than the sprinkling of them during the summer season. I trust that you will inaugurate some system by which the streets that have been macadamized may be kept sprinkled; it will be a gfeat saving to the property-owners as well as a convenience to the public.

"Gillespie, who is considered an authority, says, 'Suppose the road to be already in condition, that is, in proper shape and free from holes, ruts, mud, and dust, to keep it so requires two fundamental operations: First, the continued removal of the daily wear of the material, whether in the shape of mud or dust; and, Second, the employment of materials to replace those removed. The number of men required by this system of constant watchfulness may at first seem an objection to it, but the expense will be amply repaid by the advantages obtained. The labor of one man will keep in repair three miles of well-made and well-drained road for the first two years after its formation and four miles for the next two years by constantly spreading loose stone in the hollows, raking them from the middle to the sides, opening the ditches, etq.' Gillespie's experience has been in a country where the agencies of the weather have been much more destructive to macadamized roads than in ours, being subjected to the frequent rains of summer and frosts of winter, hence it is but reasonable to presume that a macadamized road can be kept in proper condition for much less expense in a climate like this of ours. Therefore, in view of the fact that a roadway may be kept in constant repair at less expense by a little well-directed care and attention, I would recommend that provision be made whereby the Marshal may be provided with the necessary means to accomplish this end."

Under the head of street-lines and grades the Mayor "would recommend that a plan of streets and system of grades be established as early as practicable for the territory recently annexed to the city.* Any improvements that are hereafter made should conform to the general plan, and it is evident that any delay in this important work will only complicate the satisfactory adjustment of the various questions which always present themselves in the solution of this intricate problem. To establish a plan, street surveys should be made to locate all the streets that have been laid out and opened by the property-owners, and where no streets have been laid out the property line should be accurately shown. The data thus obtained should be shown upon a map and a plan of streets should be projected by the Council after due notice to all parties concerned.

" After the plan has been adopted levels should be run through all the streets ; profiles should also be made of the streets, and monuments set at the intersection of such streets as the city engineer may propose. With the data thus obtained a system of grades should be devised that would provide surface and sewer drainage for the whole territory, and at the same time accommodate itself as near as practicable to the topography of the ground. It is important in connection with this subject that your attention should be directed to the following facts which have been furnished me by the city engineer, T. J. Arnold.

"During the heavy rains of the past winter a large area of ground in the vicinity of Twenty-first Street, and extending from Lake Merritt westward to the bay, was submerged for a considerable length of time. A very large portion of this water came from without the city limits where it had been diverted from its natural channels by the construction of roadways without proper outlets The natural water-shed north of the city slopes towards the bay, several streets, however, and notably San Pablo Road and Telegraph Avenue have been graded in such a manner as to obstruct the material flow of the water and force it into the low ground near the old charter line. A part of the water which caused the damage upon Mr. Booth's premises east of Broadway, came along Telegraph Avenue from a point within two hundred yards of Temescal Creek. It seems that special effort should be made to correct this evil before the approach of another winter. A part of the territory which supplied the water has been annexed to the city and it may be that improvement will be made during the summer that will relieve the difficulty, if the grades are promptly and properly established. It will, however, be necessary that the Supervisors of thfe county, or the district roadmaster, should provide water-ways between the present city limits and Temescal Creek. This is a matter of sufficient consequence to warrant a special effort on your part to meet and if possible overcome the difficulty.

" I will call your attention to the necessity of re-macadamizing Broadway from Fourteenth- Street to the water front. It is important that this work should be done soon, or at least before the advent of another winter. It must be apparent to you that as it now is it compares very unfavorably with other streets of much less importance."

On December 2, 1872, the numbering of houses was ordered by ordinance; while the Council proceeded with a will to general improvement of the thoroughfares. In May, 1873, these are remarked by Mayor Spaulding in the following words: "The most notable feature of our city improvements during the past year is the signal' betterments which are shown upon our streets. The City Marshal's report shows that there has been during the year eleven miles and three thousand two hundred and forty-five lineal feet of streets graded, curbed, and macadamized, at a cost to the property-owners of ninety-eight thousand one hundred and twenty-four dollars and eightynine cents; also that there has been constructed seven miles and nine hundred and twenty-five lineal feet of sidewalks and crosswalks, at a cost of sixteen thousand nine hundred and forty-three dollars and forty-one cents. Our streets now show, for the first year since they emerged from the dust a'nd ashes, of their primitive barbarity, that decent respectability for which they have so long apd patiently struggled. Their appearance does tolerable justice to the character and enterprise of our people; they now afford as pleasant walks and as delightful drives as can be found in any city on the shores of the Pacific. While it is with pleasure we comment upon the splendid improvements made upon our streets, I deem it right and just to state in behalf of the people, whose servants we are, that we have neglected a very important duty, one for which the Council cannot hold itself blameless. It is the matter of keeping our streets in repair. In my former communication I urged at length this important measure. I urged it then, and I now urge it again, on the strong ground of economy. It is painful to note that, after all the generous expenditures of money that have been employed in bringing our streets from their almost impassable condition of but a few years since, to their present state of excellence, that no system has yet been adopted for keeping them in repair. The old adage that 'a stitch in time saves nine,' may, with the greatest propriety, be applied to our public streets. They are suffered to be dug up by 'Tom, Dick, and Harry' for 'this, that, and the other' cause. The macadam broken up and replaced without regard to 'how or where,' regardless of law or ordinance regulating these matters. As a matter of economy alone, our macadamized roadways should have constant and intelligent care. A system of repairs should be inaugurated for this purpose, without further delay. All species of vandalism and unlawful spoliation should receive that kind of attention that will be most likely to prevent its recurrence. The streets should be kept clean, the gutters free and clear from all obstructions, all depressions should be promptly leveled up, etc. A team and all necessary implements should be provided for the purpose. By a little well-directed, prompt, and judicious action on your part the excellent condition of our streets (which are now a credit to the city) may be continued from year to year with but trifling expense. Otherwise, if the unlawful spoliations, the accumulation of dust and filth are allowed, and the ruts and holes to go unrepaired, they will go on from bad to worse until they become no longer endurable, when the cry will be raised for a general repairing, which will cost a great deal more and give much less satisfaction than the continued system, which i have formerly and now again recommend. The plan which has been adopted, and in a measure carried into effect, for the improvement of our sidewalks, has met with such universal favor that I deem it unnecessary at this time to make any further recommendations concerning them. The large number of trees which have been planted along our thoroughfares shows a sensible and praiseworthy effort on the part of our people to make their homes pleasant and attractive, as well as enhance the value of their property, and certainly it cannot be otherwise than devoutly wished that their patriotic example will in the future be more generally followed.

"I desire to call your special attention to the embarrassing and vexatious question of opening streets. The law, which should direct in such matters, and which should be so plain that it could be susceptible of but one interpretation, has been found so ambiguous that the efforts to open streets where such work was emphatically necessary, has in most cases been abortive; in some cases creating expensive litigation, engendering confusion and discord among the people, besides bringing the Council into contempt in its endeavor to do the people's will. I therefore would recommend that you suspend further action in all such cases until such time as some of the pending cases can be taken to the Supreme Court for final decision."

As the city increased in population, property-holders found it to their advantage to open streets by compromise among themselves, and in every case, or nearly so, where the law for the opening of streets was resisted in the Courts the city was defeated. The constitutionality of the method provided for the assessment of damages and benefits had frequently been argued, but the decisions were uniformly based upon points which, to non-professional men, seemed to be of minor importance- Fatal irregularities were discovered in the proceedings of the Council, or of the Commissioners who made the assessment. In a few instances parties consented to the opening of streets under proceedings instituted by the Council, because the amounts involved were not sufficient to justify litigation, or because those affected were satisfied with the justice of the assessment, and desired the improvement to be made In some localities, again, these were greatly retarded from the lack of suitable streets' and property-owners that resisted such improvements in any spirit of captiousness harmed themselves more than they did others. While on this subject. Mayor Webb under date February 28, 1876, says: "I do not think that the Council should hesitate to inaugurate proceedings when it is evident that an improvement should be made. We do not know that there is any valid defect in the law, and we should presume it to be sound, and attempt to comply with its requirements. The acceptance of streets is a subject that had frequently been brought to the attention of the Council, but upon which no definite action had been taken up to that time. Section Twenty of the law authorizing the city to improve streets, provides that the Council shall accept those improved according to such regulations as it may have adopted, and that the cost of improvements and repairs on said streets thereafter shall be paid out of the Street Fund. The Marshal is required to keep a register of all accepted streets. No streets have ever been accepted under this statute, and the city has no authority to expend money for repairs. The law is somewhat obscure, and extreme caution is necessary, for any mistake now might entail upon the city the cost of a class of improvements that should be paid by the property which they benefit. It is no more than equitable that the city should stand the expense of re-macadamizing a street, where the original improvement has been worn out by the pubhc, but it would be highly unjust to require the city to construct a pavement more valuable than the original one. If the city, under the law, accepts streets without incurring any liability other than I have mentioned, such action should be taken.''

,0n April 24, 1876, an ordinance was passed authorizing the construction of a bridge across the estuary of San Antonio, between Eighth Street and Fast Ninth Street, and fixing the dimensions thereof On the same date the name of Middle Street was changed to Ninth Street; and on November 27th the contract for building the Eighth-street Bridge was awarded to the Pacific Bridge Company, at thirty thousand dollars.

After the burning of the City Hall on August 25, 1877, a certain faction of the citizens of Oakland conceived the brilliant idea that now was the proper time to open Washington Street to the San Pablo Road. By so doing the line of the street would necessarily run through the City Hall lot, to which the City Council most naturally demurred. Meetings were held; some considerable feeling on the subject was engendered; letters were written to the Council reflecting upon their ideas in the matter; indeed, several pseudonymous letters were received by that body bearing on the affair. Eventually it took a tangible shape, and at their meeting held September 21, 1877, President Walter stated that they were ready to hear from the Committee appointed to confer with the Council relative to the opening of the street. Mr. Flint, as chairman of the Committee, read the resolutions adopted by the Merchants' Exchange and presented petitions from property-owners on Washington Street, and from citizens, in favor of the opening of said street; also submitting a proposition to buy the city's property, affected by the opening, for twenty thousand dollars, and for the improvements on the same ten thousand dollars, equal to thirty thousand dollars, cash, as soon as the city was ready to sell. Discussion here ensued relative to the proposition, and remarks were made by Councilmen Miller, Sohst, and Citizens Reier, Wetmore, Emerson, and Flint, after which the question was taken under advisement.

Let us now refer to the actions on record in regard to Lake Merritt, that beautiful sheet of water which is so justly a source of pride to the residents of Oakland. It had long been under the fostering care of the Council and citizens of the city. A very large extent of country is drained by the lake. On February 21, 1870, an ordinance was passed having for its purpose the prevention of the destruction of fish in it. It then was left in repose, save by the whipping winds, until February 9, 1874, when some hard-hearted individual attempted to dub it with another appellation, which very properly called forth a strong protest against it from the City Fathers. Lake Merritt had, however, met with a more formidable enemy in the shape of the Tide Land Commissioners. In the month of February, 1873, they appeared to have a settled determination to sell the tide lands in its vicinity, but some of the public citizens of Oakland - who are never weary in well-doing - circulated the following petition in the hope that the Commissioners would leave them that indispensable piece of property:

"To THE Board OF Tide Land Commissioners - Gentlemen: The undersigned citizens of Alameda County respectfully protest against the threatened spoliation of Lake Merritt, by the sale of any portion thereof

"The area of said lake is a natural tidal basin, the larger portion of which was formerly bare at low water. The part lying within the corporate limits of Oakland was long since abandoned to public use, and a large sum of money (say thirty thousand dollars) has been expended in building a permanent dam with tide-gates, so that said basin can be kept full, or may be partially emptied when desired.

"The lake is indispensable for drainage purposes to much of the surrounding country, including the entire city of Oakland; and the sewerage system of Oakland, as recommended by eminent engineers and adopted by the city, depends upon the waters thereof as confined by the dam. The area of the part of the basin outside of the city limits is about fifty-five acres, and if this should be filled - the bottom being deep, soft mud - it might convert the lake into an insupportable nuisance, or destroy it as a tidal basin for the purpose of drainage and sewerage, as described.

"The tidal basin of said lake also constitutes an important feature in the contemplated improvement of the estuary of San Antonio, for the purpose of navigation and commerce. We, therefore, respectfully but urgently petition your Honorable Body to abandon the portion of Lake Merritt belonging to the State, as a basin for the purpose of drainage and commerce, as provided in Section Two of the Act of 1870, or to withdraw the same from public sale, as provided in Section Nine of the Act of li

In his message of February 28, 1876, Mayor Mack Webber states in regard to the improvement of Lake Merritt: " By your direction temporary repairs have been made to the Lake Merritt dam. As long as the present structure can be maintained with a moderate outlay for repairs, it is not necessary to construct one of a more permanent nature: whenever replaced it should be by one that will last for all time. It is to serve a double purpose: It gives us a beautiful lake and has made po ssible the construction of the main sewer, just completed. [This work we shall treat of presently] The dam and roadway should be combined in a single structure, thereby saving a needless expenditure when it shall become necessary to build another bridge.

" I recommend that the Council take suitable steps to open a street over the designated route and cause the same to be improved, if it can be done under existing laws. This can easily be made one of the most magnificent water parks in the world. A moderate amount of dredging would deepen the water so that sail-boats could navigate any part of it, and also furnish material for the construction of one or more artificial islands. The completion of such a work would increase the reputation of our city and doubtless attract to it large numbers of gentlemen of fortune, v/ho, by the erection of costly houses, would add to the general wealth and prosperity. It would be equally important to thousands of our citizens, who would indulge in the pastime of boating if the navigable area of the lake were not so circumscribed as at present. Works of this nature cannot fail to exact a powerful and beneficial influence in favor of the community that have the energy and good taste to project them."

Most of these improvements have been carried out; while, on a fine afternoon or moonlight summer's evening, no more animated view is to be seen than the whitewinged^ boats flitting hither and thither, loaded with a merry freight of laughter-loving youths and maidens.

In the year 1870 the Webster-street Bridge was built. In this matter, at the meeting of the Council held February 21, 1870, Mr. Spauldjng offered the following resolutions:

Whereas, It has come to the knowledge of this Council that there is dissatisfaction among the residents and property-owners of Brooklyn and San Antonio respecting the action taken by this Council in the matter of giving their sanction for the passage of a law for the construction of a bridge at the foot of Webster Street to connect with Alameda; and

Whereas, It is not the wish nor desire of Oakland or its representatives to obstruct or in any way to impede the progress of our neighboring towns; therefore be it

Resolved, That the citizens of Brooklyn, San Antonio, and Alameda, by their representatives, be requested to meet this Council at their rooms at half-past seven o'clock p. M. on Friday evening, February 25th, to show wherein or how they will be injured or benefited by the construction of a bridge at the point above named.

This special meeting was called, but in the mean time a protest was received from Brooklyn Township to the following effect: "At a meeting of the citizens and propertyholders of Brooklyn Township, held at Swett's Hall, Wednesday evening, February 23, 1870, the following resolution was unanimously adopted, and the Secretary of the meeting was instructed to present a certified copy to the City Council of Oakland on Friday evening, February 25th:

Resolved, That it is the opinion of this meeting that the construction of a bridge over the San Antonio Creek will be detrimental to the inhabitants of Brooklyn Township in an eminent degree; also injurious to the interests of the county in general, by the creation of a very costly structure to be foisted upon the county at great expense for the care and keeping the same in repair.

A printed protest was also received from thirty-three citizens of Oakland, to the following effect: " The undersigned .hereby protest against the erection of a bridge across San Antonio Creek, as is now proposed by parties in Alameda. In our estimation a bridge would seriously obstruct navigation and impose unnecessary expense upon Oakland. We would suggest that the proposed connection, if necessary, be made solely at the expense of residents of Alameda, and by road and ferry only, in accordance with the original proposition." In furtherance of the subject, on February 28th, citizens of Alameda and Brooklyn being present, on motion of Mr. Van Dyke, these were invited to express their views on the bridge question. The Council having listened to the remarks, pro and con, Mr. Folger offered the following resolution:

Resolved, That the City Clerk be authorized to communicate with Messrs. Calvin Brown, George L. Gray, and A. F. Rogers, and ask them to give this Council, on or before Monday, March 7, 1870, their opinion of the effect that the erection of a bridge across San Antonio Creek, especially as affecting the depth of water therein, and thar the opinion of any other scientific gentlemen on the subject, who may favor us with the same, will be cheerfully received.

These gentlemen in due time sent in their reports, all being at one on the subject. What these views were, the following excerpt from the report of Mr. Rogers will inform the reader. After generalizing on the subject of bridges in general and drawbridges in particular, and explaining the trouble attending the passage through, whether it be during the day or night, at all stages of the tide, he goes on to say: " San Antonio Creek, at the foot of Webster Street, is ten hundred and fifty feet wide, with a depih in the channel of ten feet at mean low tide; going east this depth is increased, near the junction of the Lake Merritt arm with the main creek, to over twenty feet, probably the junction and combination of both tidal streams at this comparatively narrow point. Going west the depth varies from ten to eighteen feet, never less than ten or ovfer eighteen, until the waters are freed from the banks of the creek and enter the bay of San Francisco, and, spreading, lose their identity and force; too sluggish, any longer, to scour, they rapidly deposit sediment and add to what is known and felt as the Oakland Bar. The effect of accelerating or retarding the current is, I think, curiously and plainly marked by increased or diminished depths at several points in its course between the localities I have named.

" The effect upon the channel of throwing a pile-bridge across it at the point proposed would be serious; it would, I think, make it only a question of time when the draw would be useless; sediment would be deposited under the bridge, eddies formed around it, the current retarded, and gradually, but surely, the process of filling up would be extended both above and below the structure. This is so palpable a fact that I am sure any engineer who has looked at the effect of throwing wharves into, or bridges across, tide-waters, will corroborate the statement. I repeat that the effect would be to shoal the water both above and below the bridge, and I think that I may say so thus positively without the fear of honest contradiction.

" In order properly to estimate the value of the San Antonio Creek to Oakland, Alameda, and Brooklyn as a navigable channel, we must look back and ask what these places would have been without it; the creek channel as nature made it and entirely unimproved, afforded the opportunity, and the only opportunity, in early days, of combining a San Francisco business with an Oakland residence; this combination built houses by the thousand in Oakland and vicinity when there would otherwise have been to-day but tens to count. This route thus furnished the incentive to build a powerful rival and has afforded the only means since to prevent that rival from greatly abusing its pozver!

" From our experiences of the past we may estimate the possible future of San Antonio Creek, if the advantages nature here holds out shall be utilized for commer- cial purposes. Some of the principal elements for what is not elsewhere now in San Francisco Bay, are here ofifered to us - a perfectly sheltered harbor.

" It is to be hoped that the interests of the Water Front Company and our great railroad may be identical in developing these advantages; a third of the expenditure necessary to carry the Central Pacific Railroad over a permanent bridge to permanent improvement's at Verba Buena Island, would adapt San Antonio Creek, to the requirements of shipping, admit the largest vessels and open a water frontage of eight or ten miles, or as much effective front as San Francisco shozvs to-day.

"When Oakland has improved the channel of the Creek, it may be proper to build bridges, for then, and not till then, can the necessities of bridging command the capital and warrant the expenditure necessary to build such structures as may not obstruct navigation or injure that channel."

The bridge as then planned was to be one thousand feet in length with a " draw'' of two hundred feet, and to cost twenty-five thousand dollars. Early in March, 1 871, it was completed. On April loth, "An Ordinance levying a Special Tax upon Property in the City of Oakland for the purpose of defraying the proportion of the Expense assigned to the City of Oakland for the construction of a Swing or Draw Bridge across San Antonio Creek, in the county of Alameda, as provided in an Act of the Legislature of the State of California, entitled, 'An Act to authorize the construction of a Swing or Draw bridge across the San Antonio Creek, in the County of Alameda. Approved April 4, 1870,' -" was passed, and a special tax of twenty-five cents on each one hundred dollars of property ordered to be levied for the purpose of defraying the expense of the bridge. On July loth of the same year, an ordinance was passed, having as its object the protection of what is known and denominated "The Alameda Bridge" across San Antonio Creek.

We will now turn our attention to the sewerage of the city of Oakland. Mayor Spaulding, in his message to the Council, dated May 15, 1871, speaks of this subject as follows: "Another matter which I deem of eminent importance to the city, and to which I wish to call your attention, is the subject of sewerage, important because it comes directly home to every citizen. Nothing can be of more importance to the people of a city than that which tends to promote and secure its healthful condition. It seems strange that after so much has been said and so much time devoted to this matter, that so little has been accomplished. How can our citizens be so blind to their interests as to longer neglect it, while it is within their power to accomplish a perfect system of sewerage and at a cost that will not be burdensome to the most humble property-holder. It has not been the fault of the Council; for I. am well aware that its purposes have been negatived by protests from the property-holders in localities where these improvements were sought to be made. Another long and dry season is upon us with the evil consequences resulting from an imperfect system of sewerage. In view of this fact, I believe it to be your duty to lose no time in doing all within your power to put the city in a proper sanitary condition. In order to accomplish this end, as the law now stands, it is necessary that you should have the support and co-operation of the citizens, who have the power to annul all your efforts by majority protests.

"The subject of sewerage and drainage was brought before the City Council about two years ago, and by them submitted to a Board of Engineers. This Board was composed principally of the best engineering talent of the State - men of large practical experience - who spent a great deal of time in examining the topogra^phy of the city and of determining the best and most economical method of drainage. One of their number during their investigation (Mr. Hoadly) visited many of the eastern cities, among them Brooklyn, New York, and Chicago, where they have fully demonstrated the practicability of cement and stone or earthen-pipe sewers, and satisfied himself that they were a success, both as regards economy and practicability. With these investigations and information procured from scientific works, they submitted to the Council an able and elaborate report, recommending the adoption of the pipe system of sewerage. This report was unanimously adopted by the City Council.

" To relieve your minds of doubts and to corroborate more fully the correctness of this system of sewerage, permit me to call your attention to the following extracts taken from reports of engineers in some of the Eastern and European cities.

" Mr. Francis, in his report on the sewerage of Manchester, England, speaking of the pipe sewerage which is extensively used in that city, says : ' I think the idea of requiring that the main sewer of every street should be large enough for a man to go through, is absurd, because it involves an awful waste gf money. * * * jt soon appeared to me that the oval-shaped pipe was better for sewer purposes, and I get oval tubes made 'by a fire-brick-maker in this vicinity. * * * i am quite satisfied that the tubes are sufficient for large areas and that a pipe twenty by fifteen inches will be sufficient to drain thirty acres. * * * A tube sewer laid in 1847, size, fifteen by twenty inches, oval, drained an area of about five or six acres, with an inclination of one foot in one hundred and forty-four, or one-fourth of an inch per yard, has kept perfectly clear. * * * With regard to inclination, my views are as follows: Nature is the great guide, the large rivers have very slight inclinations, and as we pass up to their tributaries and minor streamlets, this is found constantly increasing. Sewerage should be a copy of nature's plan on the surface. The following rates of inclination should be adopted where practicable: nine-inch pipes one in fifty to one in two hundred feet; twelve-inch pipes one in fifty to one in four hundred feet; fifteeninch pipes one in fifty to one in four hundred and eight feet; eighteen-inch pipes one in fifty to one in four hundred and eighteen feet.

" Mr. Chesborough, City Engineer of Chicago, who was sent to Europe by the city authorities some years ago to examine the different systems of sewerage in use there, reported, that he found the pipe sewers in successful operation in almost every city that he visited. Upon his recommendation they are now used upon all the principal streets of that city. In his report on pipe sewerage in Liverpool, in speaking of the town of Rugeley, says: 'This town has been drained since 185 1 by circular stoneware pipes having socket joints filled with clay, the mains varying from six to twentyfour inches; they receive, not only the ordinary house drainage, but in some cases the surface water from the streets and all the contents of water-closets. Sorrie of them are seven by eight inch sewers, having an inclination of one foot in one hundred and thirty-seven, yet have never given any serious trouble. At this time,' he says ' the number of sewers in London is one hundred and twenty-seven, the least inclination of the pipe is one foot to two hundred and twenty feet'

"Mr. Kirkham in his report on the Brooklyn sewerage, pubHshed in 1865, after discussing the manner of laying the pipe and enumerating the many advantages to be derived from this system of sewerage, says: ' If the rate of inclination of a sewer is not flatter than one foot in four hundred and forty, the experience of Brooklyn and other cities equally well supplied with water, shows that the blind domestic sewerage of any street is competent to carry off daily all the heavier matters of s ewerage, and to keep the drains free and clear, provided that the form of the sewer is such as to concentrate these sewerage waters as much as possible. If the sewer is made unnecessarily large, the depth and velocity of the fluid passing through it are proportionately reduced and its ability to keep itself clear will be confined to high rates of inclination. It is important therefore to have it as small as the service required of it will admit. As regards the necessity of entering sewers, which was dwelt so much upon ten years ago, the successful use of the small sewers shows that this necessity does not exist; they have been found safe and effective when properly built, and less troublesome as regards cleansing than the old sewers.'

"Extract of a letter from Robert Rawlinson, Civil Engineer of London, to Mr. Kirkwood, Chief Engineer of the Brooklyn Water Works, under date March 4, 1858, says: ' I find that in Great Britain, within the last five years, not less than two thousand five hundred lineal miles of earthenware-pipe sewers and house-drains have been used, and for the five previous years some twelve hundred miles, making in all not less than three thousand seven hundred miles. I have completed sewerage and drainage works in some dozen towns, and have laid upwards of two hundred miles of earthenware-pipe sewers and drains without a single failure.'

" In Chicago, where pipe sewers of twelve inches in diameter are used with an inclination of one foot in five hundred, a tank is placed upon wheels and is used for flushing where water is not otherwise convenient. This may be done in Oakland, if necessary, where the termination of the sewers is not accessible to hydrants or cisterns. The experience we have had in the Broadway sewers shows that flushing is seldom necessary, as these sewers have been flushed but twice within the last year, and no stoppages have occurred to impair their usefulness. A late inspection finds them free and clear of all solid matter or obstructions, the house drainage furnishing sufficient water to keep them open. It may be observed that in general the contemplated sewers of our, city have a greater inclination than those above cited, as in but few instances will they have less than one foot in two hundred, and many of them one foot in one hundred. An important consideration in favor of the pipe sewer is the comparative cheapness of its construction, costing from one dollar to one dollar and a half per lineal foot, while the ordinary brick sewer costs from five to seven dollars, besides being much more expensive to keep clean and in repair. Hence, with the knowledge we now have and one year's successful experience with the cement-pipe sewers on Broadway, the most populous strpet in the city, there should be no question in your minds as to the ultimate success of this system of sewerage.

"Another point in connection \vith this subject to which I wish to call your attention is that many residing on the streets where sewers are laid have neglected to connect their house drainage with the sewers, thereby rendering void, to a certain extent, the salutary benefits calculated to be produced. I wo uld therefore recom- mend that necessary steps be taken by your Honorable Body to compel these connections to be made with as little delay as possible. To effect this object I would suggest that a police officer be detailed to act with the City Marshal and Health Officer for the purpose of seeing that these connections are made and maintained, and other nuisances which would impair the sanitary condition of the city promptly abated."

In this year (1871) the sewer on Webster Street from Twelfth Street to the water front was constructed, but no especial action was taken to establish a general system of sewerage, although a large majority of actual residents upon the principal streets favored the scheme, biit these intentions were usually defeated by non-residents. Late in the year 1871, the Board of Engineers recommended, as a part of the system of sewerage proposed by them to the Council, the '' construction of a main sewer, leaving Lake Merritt at Delger Street, and running thence along Delger Street to San Pablo Avenue; thence to Twenty-first Street; thence to Market Street; and thence continuing along Twenty-first Street to the shore of the bay, a total length of eighty-four one-hundredths miles. This sewer should be five feet wide at the bottom, and five and a half feet high in the clear. It should be built of the best quality of hard burnt brick, and provided with a self-acting tidal-gate at its outlet into the bay, and may be flushed when required from the waters of Lake Merritt." By this means all the sewerage and drainage of that section of the city lying north of the watershed, and of the sloping ground north of the sewer itself, and beyond the charter line would be received, while the southerly limit of the area that would drain into this sewer would correspond very nearly with the line of Twelfth Street. On April 15, 1872, Mayor Spaulding continued to urge upon the Council, as a duty incumbent upon them for the protection of the city against the. encroachment of sickness and disease, the construction of extended sewerage and the abatement of every nuisance which could in any way militate against the healthful condition of the city. The matter at last met with a pretty general approval, and the good work was proceeded with. During the year ending February 28, 1873, three miles and three thousand one hundred and fifty feet of sewerage wire laid at a cost of twenty-six thousand and seventy-five dollars and seven cents, a fact which certainly speaks well for the energy of one year.

The construction of the main sewer beo'ame now imperatively necessary, and attracted much discussion. The city, however, had no power to cause the work to be done; therefore the necessary steps to get an Act passed by the Legislature were taken. On December 22, 1873, the draft of the proposed bill entitled "An Act to provide for the construction of Main Sewers in the City of Oakland " was read at a meeting of the Council, while on the 29th December, a communication from the Secretary of the Oakland Citizens' Union was received by the Council, inclosing a report of a Committee on main sewer from Lake Merritt to San Francisco Bay and a profile map of the same, together with certain resolutions adopted by the Union, recommending the preparation of a new charter for the city and namino- a committee for the purpose. On March 23, 1874, "An Act -to authorize the City of Oakland to construct a Main Sewer" was approved, and on the i8th May, the City Council passed an ordinance directing the building of the sewer; on October 12th the contracts were awarded to Mr. Jordan and M. Miles & Co. At the meeting of the Council had

September 20, 1875, the City Clerk was directed to advertise for the period of twenty days for the sale of sixty thousand dollars in bonds of the city of Oakland authorized to be issued in accordance with the above Act of the Legislature.

The Main Lake Sewer is the most costly and important public improvement ever made in the city of Oakland. It was completed in 1876, and, as stated before, connects Lake Merritt with the bay of San Francisco. The tidal current steadily flowing through it from the east is of sufficient velocity to remove all extraneous matter that may be run into it, while the correctness of the engineering has been demonstrated, and the wisdom of the Board that directed an excellent system of sewerage is fully apparent.

The first contract for the two sections of the sewer was let to Dennis Jordan at an aggregate of one hundred and twelve thousand dollars, a sum far below the real cost. The contractor failed to prosecute the work according to agreement, and contracts were let' in October, 1874, for the entire work to Mr. Jordan, who agreed .to construct the first, or brick, section for eighty-eight thousand dollars, and M. Miles and F. Raesch, who agreed to construct the second, or wood section for thirty-four thousand dollars, the total being ten thousand dollars in excess of the price agreed upon with Dennis Jordan.

These parties also made default, and the contracts were a third time awarded. The Pacific Bridge Company contracted to construct the first section for one hundred and twenty-six thousand eight hundred and fifty dollars. The Alameda Macadamizing Company agreed to construct the second section for thirty-eight thousand two hundred dollars, making a total of one hundred and sixty-five thousand and fifty dollars.

By the terms of their contract the defaulting contractors were liable for the difference between the original price and the price finally paid, or fifty-three thousand and fifty dollars. The cost of the work is given below: -

The unpaid balance consisted of three hundred dollars retained until the contractors had removed surplus material and five per cent, on the amount of their contracts not payable until one year after the completion of the work. The deficit was caused by the extra work (one thousand and thirty-seven dollars and forty cents) and the discount on a portion of the bonds which had to be placed upon the market during a time of very great stringency and disorder in financial affairs. The material used and the workmanship have been first-class, for the Council very properly adopted the policy that it was the truest economy to have so important a public work done in the best manner possible. The sewer drains an area of one thousand two hundred and eleven and a half acres, while an ordinance was soon after passed prohibiting the further use of lateral sewers which discharged their sewerage into Lake Merritt. The sewer commences in the lake near the intersection of Delger Street with the west line of Harrison Street, and runs thence" along Delger Street to San Pablo Avenue; thence along that thoroughfare to Twenty-second Street, and afterwards through it to the bay, a total distance of nine thousand nine hundred and twenty-four feet, three inches. The first section, which, as has been heretofore remarked, is of brick, extends from the east line of Broadway to the west line of Adeline Street, a distance of five thousand five hundred and eighty-five feet, three inches. The second section, of wood, extends from the initial point in the lake to the east line of Broadway, and from the west line of Adeline Street to the bay, a distance of four thousand three hundred and thirty-nine feet. East of Broadway the sewer is five by five feet in the clear; west of Broadway it is five feet wide by five and one-half feet high in the clear. The brick portion of the sewer is of the form and dimensions recommended by the Board of Engineers, viz.: the bottom an inverted arch of six and a half feet radius, the sides vertical, and the top a semi-circular arch. The bottom of the sewer at the inlet is two feet six inches below ordinary high water in the lake; at the outlet it is four feet six inches below the same plane, giving an available descent at extreme low water sufficient to remove all ordinary deposits.

Ere concluding matters connected with the Engineers' Department of the government of the city of Oakland, it may be mentioned that at the meeting of the Council held June 6, 1878, consequent upon the lamented demise of the City Engineer, the following resolutions of condolence were unanimously passed : -

Whereas, It hath pleased Divine Providence to remove from our midst a useful and upright citizen, an honest and capable official, Thomas J. Arnold, and

Whereas, It is due to the deceased to recognize his ability and worth, as exemplified by his acts during his life, and pay a last sad token of respect to his memory: Thomas j. Arnold was loved and rfespected; a citizen whose character was ever resplendent with bright deeds and whose acts bore truth and honesty upon their surface. Oakland may well mourn, for it has lost a valuable public servant; one who was ever identified with the rise, progress, and material interests of the city, and whose name is coupled with the grandest of achievements. He desired to live, for he had a great deal to live for, but He who doeth all things well issued the decree which summoned him from the earth to a better realm beyond.

We drop this sprig of green in memoriam of him who dwells with us no longer, but whose deeds are in the possession of history and those who know him best.

We extend to the bereaved widow and the fatherless our sympathy in these moments of sadness. Knowing and feeling that we but echo the responses of a kindred nature from many of the citizens of this city and abroad. Therefore be it

Resolved, That this Council attend the funeral of our late lamented City Engineer, in a body, and that on to-morrow the City Hall will be closed to public business, so that city officials can attend the obsequies; and be it further

Resolved, That the City Clerk is hereby directed to spread these preambles and resolutions upon the minutes, and a copy thereof be transmitted to the widow of deceased.

In continuation of the official acts of the Board of Trustees of the Town of Oakland in the year 1853, we find that an election was held on the 9th May at the house of A. Marier, with A. S. Hurlburt as Inspector, and Julius Kellersberger and H.

Provenance

Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.