BlockBefore

Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 20 of 38)

From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,811 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,811 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

On February 26, 1869, an adjourned meeting of the City Council w:as held for the purpose of receiving a report of a special committee appointed to inquire into Dr. Merritt's title to certain water-front property in the city of Oakland. These gentlemen, through Mr. Moody, made the following report:

"Your committee, to whom was referred the duty of inquiring into the title by which Mayor Dr. Samuel Merritt holds certain property at or near the foot of Washington Street, and for what purpose he holds the same, beg leave to report that in the discharge of thfeir duties they addressed a note, of which the following is a copy, inclosing the resolution of inquiry, to his Honor, the Mayor, to Lloyd Tevis, Secretary of the Water Front Company, and to Messrs. John B. Felton and E. R. Carpentier:

"'Dear Sir: - Inclosed please find a resolution which will ekplain itself To assist the committee in the discharge of their duties, will you do us the favor to answer the following questions: By what title, if any, does Dr. Samuel Merritt hold the water-front property on "San Antonio Creek, lying between Broadway and Clay Streets, at or near the foot of Washington Street? Did he obtain the property in trust for the city, or for his own use and benefit? Please answer in time for the committee to report upon Friday evening, February 26th, and oblige, etc' "To this communication the following reply was received:

" ' Messrs. W. G. Moody and F. M. Campb'ell, Committee - Gents: The following statement is made in reply to your letter of the 24th instant: Some months ago Dr. Samuel Merritt applied to the Oakland Water Front Company for the land referred to by you. He represented that the building of the new bridge, as proposed by the railroad companies, would seriously damage his property at the old bridge by destroying his communication with the creek, and that all. he desired was a fair remuneration for the actual loss sustained by him. On the nth July last the Board passed a resolution appointing a committee to confer with Dr. Merritt on the subject. Up to this time no arrangement or understanding had been made with Dr. Merritt in reference to this land at the time of the settlement of the water-front compromise, nor has there been any since, except what might be inferred from expressions of members of the Water Front Company favorable to his request.

" ' Messrs. Moody, Campbell, and Barnes - Gents: I am in receipt of your favor of the 24th instant, inclosing a copy of a resolution pas.sed by the Council relating to the property which I have recently improved near the foot of Washington and Clay Streets in this city. The questions which you wish me to answer are as follows, viz.: By what title, if any, do you hold said property? If you have a title, from whom did you obtain it, and what was the consideration paid for the same? Did you obtain the property in trust for the city or for your own use and benefit? In reply, permit me to say: No conveyance has ever been made to me of the property in question. Some weeks, or perhaps months, after the settlement of the waterfront controversy, I made application to the Water Front Company for the property referred to, for the purpose of constructing a wharf, it being understood that the Western Pacific Railroad Company proposed to enter this city by building a bridge across the arm of the San Antonio Creek, without a draw, which would virtually cut off communication with my present place of business near the Oakland bridge. That application was referred to the Executive Committee with power to act. Since then, I am not aware that any action has been taken in the premises. I do not hold the property in trust for the city. I remain, etc., SAMUEL Merritt.'

" In these communications we noticed: First - That no valid title to this property has passed to Dr. Samuel Merritt. Second - That the doctor applied to the

Oakland Water Front Company for this property as compensation for damages sustained upon certain other desirable property, by certain contemplated improvements. Third - That no definite action has been taken upon this claim, and, Fourth - Ihat neither at the time of the water-front settlement, nor at any time since, was there any agreement or understanding other than expressions of members of the company to his request.

" In presenting this matter so that it may be thoroughly understood, your Committee feel compelled to make the following points: First - That the Mayor, Doctor Samuel Merritt, is in full possession of the property at or near the foot of Washington Street, claiming the ownership thereof, using it for his own profit, and has been for nearly one year. Second - That the property near the bridge, referred to, has suffered no damage by any contemplated improvements; and when these improvements are made it m,3.y be found that this property suffers no damage; or, it is possible that the plan of improvements may be so changed as that no damage can result; or, these improvements may be deferred at that point, using for a considerable time the present means for crossing the creek. In either event the doctor would be the apparent owner of both properties, with no damage to the upper property. Third - That Doctor Samuel Merritt has no title to a large, if any, part of the property near the bridge, as he himself has informed a member of your Committee. That being upon the property as a mere trespasser upon the city or its assigns, your Committee cannot see what legal or equitable claim he can possibly have for damages in this case. Fourth - That Doctor Samuel Merritt obtained possession in some manner, through the water-front settlement, at or near the foot of Washington Street, and that no consideration has passed for the same; and that at the time of the water-front settlement, and ever since, he was engaged in the water-front negotiations as agent for the city, and has ever since been a member of the directorship of the Oakland Water Front Company as representative of the city's interests.

"Your Committee therefore come to the conclusion that, inasmuch as Doctor Samuel Merritt obtained the property in some means through the water-front settlement, without the payment of any valuable or legal consideration, and during the time he was representing the city of Oakland, and in all those transactions, your Committee are compelled to believe that he, the Mayor, holds this property for the city, whatever may be the title under which he claims, and that the city should take the necessary steps to protect her interests. With this view, your Committee have not felt called upon to discuss the comparative value of the property near the bridge with that at or near the foot of Washington Street. Your Committee would, therefore, recommend that the City Attorney be directed to take the necessary steps to protect the city's interests in the water-front property, at or near the foot of Washinoton Street now held by Samuel Merritt, Mayor. With this view your Committee recommend the passage of the accompanying resolution. " W. G. MoODY

The resolution submitted was briefly to the effect that the City Attorney take the proper steps to recover the property at the foot of Washington Street.

The foregoing being the majority report, we now give that of the minority: Mr Campbell stated that he had not signed the report as the committee was instructed to ascertain and report facts, not to express opinions and make pleas. He had not seen the report until early in the evening. As a member of the Committee he would simply submit the documents from Dr. Merritt and Messrs. Felton and Tevis. It was for the Council to devise plans and to act. Mr. Moody then made a speech in which he asserted his bravery in daring to undertake anything for the public good; while Mr. Campbell considered that the letters referred to had not been submitted to him in time for him to consider them. The resolution submitted by Mr. Moody did not even meet with a seconder.

It may be mentioned here that a newspaper war had been waged between Messrs Moody and Merritt about this time, in which the former was very severely handled by the doctor.

In this year the Water Front Company entered suit against the city to quiet title, which, May loth was duly reported on by the City Attorney. In regard to the matter, August 9th, E. R. Carpentier forwarded the following communication to his Honor Mayor Felton: -

" I have this day entered a dismissal of the suit brought in the Twelfth District Court by the Oakland Water Front Company against the City of Oakland. As you will remember, that suit was instituted soon after the Water Front Compromise in pursuance of an understanding, then had, that a judgment should be obtained without opposition, quieting the title of the Water Front Company to its lands and franchises in accordance with the terms of the compromise. >

" The then Mayor, on whom process was first served, was a Trustee of the Water Front Company; and he was succeeded in office by yourself, also a Trustee of the company. Under such circumstances it was not thought proper to take a judgment by default against the city, and no judgment was entered.

" Recently the City Attorney has entered an appearance. But as the understanding in pursuance of which the suit was instituted seems to have been forgotten by some, and the object of the suit misapprehended by others, and there not being at this time any real dispute* by the city of the company's title, nor any doubt entertained of its validity, the company has thought it proper that the case be dismissed."

It is to be hoped that we may not be brought under the ban of prolixity. Our aim has been to place before our readers the true story of the water-front controversy itself; To follow it from its germ to its full fruition as the so-called property of the Central Pacific Railroad Company, which is, so far as this affair is concerned, an agglomeration of the railroads and companies mentioned in these remarks, and evidently the inspirer of all action since taken. In his message of February 28, 1876, Mayor Webber sounds the psean of the "Central Pacific " in these words: "Nearly the whole of the frontage on the line of the Oakland water front is owned by private parties, Council having at an early day transferred this property and a subsequent Council having ratified the transfer. This latter act was the inducement that influenced the Western Pacific Railroad Company to locate their terminus in this city. Extended improvements have been made by that corporation and its successor, the Central Pacific Railroad Company; and the importance and prosperity of the city has been immeasurably advanced. The right of the city to extend its streets to the line of ship channel has never been denied, and when necessity for such action arises I doubt not but that right will be asserted. There is no conflict of interest between the individuals and corporations owning this property and the city. Whatever improvements they may make will advance the public interests; they cannot turn their possessions to any valuable use without benefiting the whole city as much, if not more, than they benefit themselves. The public have a deep interest in the policy of the large corporations that have such an influence in promoting the common prosperity, and the time has fully arrived when a request should be made to the Water Front Company for the property which forms the extension of one or more streets, that wharves may be constructed there by the city. Operations upon the bar have so far advanced that we must soon have a commerce that will demand such facilities as suggested. We have ample reasons for the great faith we entertain as to Oakland's future. The wonderful growth of the last few years is but the forerunner of what is to come. We hold the position of center of the railroad system of the Pacific Coast. All railroads entering the State must seek San Francisco, and the easiest way to reach the metropolis is by Oakland. We must afford what privileges we can for the encouragement of such enterprises and render our city easy of approach by land and water. Railroads, commerce, and manufactures are to be the basis of our prosperity, and the policy of Oakland should be enlightened and liberal. Though there are few direct acts within the province of the Council which would have an important bearing, the general tenor of all your acts exerts a powerful influence. When it is seen that you are friendly to all enterprises that can increase Oakland's greatness, and that you duly appreciate their importance, the city becomes an inviting field for men of capital and energy Your policy has been, thus far, most praiseworthy, and it is bringing its merited reward."

The reward to which his Honor alludes to must be, to use his own words given above, " the time has fully arrived when a request should be made to the Water Front Company," and through them the Central Pacific Railroad Company, "for the property which forms the extension of one or more streets, that wharves may be constructed there by the city " - and this in the face, of a ruling of thb Supreme Court, already produced in extenso.

In the summer of 1877 ^ clamor was raised in favor of taking legal steps to open up the case from the beginning, the particular occasion for which was the dedication by the Oakland Water Front Company to the city of " the channel of San Antonio Creek from ship channel, in the bay of San Francisco, to the town of San Antonio, said channel or navigable water-course to be included between parallel lines, and to have an uniform width of four hundred feet," a width that was deemed insufficient for the future commercial wants of Oakland. On November 12, 1877, Henry Vrooman, the then City Attorney, addressed an able and lucid opinion on the subject to the Council. In this document he states ere concluding: "We have herein before shown: First - Not only that the Estuary of San Antonio, or ' Oakland Harbor,' is navigable in fact and in law, but as well that it is, in fact, navigated by vessels from both foreign and domestic ports. Second - That Congress- has the exclusive right to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several States; that this includes the right to prevent the obstruction of any of the navigable waters of the United States, of which the waters of ' Oakland Harbor ' are certainly a part, and that Congress has exercised its power, in regard to the Estuary of San Antonio, by appropriating for, and spending money in, the improvement thereof, with the intention and avowed purpose of increasing the capacity of said harbor. Third - That the National, State, County, and City Governments have spent large sums of money amounting in the aggregate to hundreds of thousands of dollars, in improving the very harbor over which this Oakland Water Front Company assumes to exercise the rights of ownership, which it pretends to own in fee-simple, and through which it now assumes to dedicate a limited channel four hundred feet wide. Fourth - That if the channel is limited to a width of four hundred feet, as by this company proposed, the capacity of the harbor will be greatly lessened, to the irremediable detriment, inconvenience, and interruption of commerce and navigation, and a consequent injury to the city of Oakland.

"«. That the Estuary of San Antonio, or "Oakland Harbor," and the whole thereof, between the lines of low tide, is a public highway for navigation, and that the Oakland Water Eront Ccwnpany has no right to use, build wharves within, or bridges across, or to exclusively occupy or appropriate to its own use any portion of said estuary or harbor (waiving in this report any question touching the title to the shore of the estuary).

"b. That the action of said company in assuming to dedicate a limited channel or Wjiter-way through the harbor, confers no additional rights upon the public, because the public have the prior and paramount right to the whole harbor.

"d. That if said company does not immediately relinquish its pretended claims to said estuary or harbor, and to the whole thereof, the best interests of the city demand the commencement and vigorous prosecution of such proceedings as will establish the rights of the public to said harbor, and for this: That the further impro.vement of the estuary by the United States Government will be prevented, unless this pretended claim can be set aside."

And now comes the last act of what may be termed the Water Front Tragedy. On November lo, 1879, the Central Pacific Railroad Company filed a complaint against the city of Oakland, in the Third District Court, in an action to quiet the title to the water front. Besides this the complaint, which was sworn to by Charles Crocker, seemed to claim an exclusive right of way into the city of Oakland, over all other railroads. Suit having been brought it was necessary to take steps towards making a defence; therefore, at a meeting of the Council held December i, 1879, a resolution was presented authorizing the Committee on Ordinances and Judiciary to " employ counsel to assist the City Attorney in defending the suits now commenced against the city in which the title to the water front of the city is involved." On motion to adopt, Mr. Hewes presented a communication from Judge A. Campbell, Senr., and Chief Justice A. L. Rhodes, and called for its reading, which was done. Mr. Hewes then addressed the Council at considerable length, approving the suggestions made in the communications and opposing the adoption of the resolution. Mr. Millan offered as a substitute a resolution directing the Committee on Ordinances and Judiciary to inquire into and report to the Council the probable cost of defending the water-front suits, and addressed the Council opposing the original resolutions and advocating the adoption of the substitute. The substitute was lost by : Ayes - -Messrs. Millan and Hewes, 2; Noes - Massrs. Cole, Will, Babcock, and President White, 4. Mr. Hewes offered as an amendment that the Committee on Ordinance and Judiciary be authorized and empowered to employ Messrs. Campbell and Rhodes to defend all the suits brought against the city by the Central Pacific Railroad Company, C. P. Huntington, and the Water Front Company. Mr. Hewes again addressed the Council, earnestlyadvocating the abilityof the above-named gentlemen. The amendment was lost, Messrs. Millan and Hewes voting for, and Messrs. Cole, Wall, Babcock, and White against it. Mr. Millan then raised a point of order that the committee could not be empowered or delegated, unless byunanimous voteof the Council and before a ruling was had from the Chair. Mr. Hewes offered an amendment, directing the committee to report to the Council the names of the attorneys to be employed, and the amount to be paid. The amendment was ruled out of order, as the matter had been already disposed of Mr. Millan then moved to lay the original resolution on the table, which was lost: Messrs. Millan and Hewes voting aye; and Messrs. Cole, Wall, Babcock, and White, no. An amendment was offered to add the words: "the action of said committee to be subject to ratification or rejection by this Council," which was adopted by the following vote: Ayes - Messrs. Millan, Cole, Hewes, Babcock, and White; No - - Mr. Wall. The resolution was then adopted as amended, there voting for it Messrs. Millan, Cole, Wall, Babcock, and White, and against it, Mr. Hewes. This gentleman next offered a resolution expressing the sense of the Council that "it" (presumably the Council) was antagonistic to the interests of the Central Pacific Railroad. After some discussion the resolution was laid on the table by a vote of five to one.

On December 4th a motion was made having as its purpose the employment of Albert A. Cohen as counsel to defend the water-front suits. It being read and motion made to adopt, Mr. Hewes addressed the Council, advocating the propriety of employing additional counsel and expressing a fear that by employing one at a tirne it would open the door for the approach of designing men. President White then called Mr. Babcock to the Chair and addressed the Council,acknow!edging the weight of responsibility he felt in the premises, and declared his intention to stand by the interests of the city. Mr. Millan next addressed the Council, approving the action of the committee and favored the adoption of the resolution. Mr. Hewes, in explanation, stated that he would vote for a resolution employing Mr. Cohen, with the understanding that it was the intention of the committee to employ other counsel, and would favor the employment of Mr. Vrooman, Judge Rhodes, or others who might be named; he could confide in the good judgment of the committee. The resolution was then adopted. On the 17th December, the attorneys in the water-front suits were directed to commence action against Samuel Merritt and others, to recover lands now in their possession on the water front; while on the 22d of that month Col. J. P. Hoge was employed as counsel for the city.

The last entry on this subject which we will place before the reader is that on January 12, 1882, there was passed "An Ordinance to prevent further litigation concerning the Oakland Water Front" - a consummation devoutly to be wished; but the citizens. of Oakland should never forget that Judge Baldwin has said: "The grant of the exclusive franchise by the Trustees is absolutely void." " The power to lay out and regulate wharves being given to the Council, cannot be exercised by Carpentier." ' "We think that the general grant of this exclusive privilege is wholly void as exceeding the powers of the corporation." Judge Hoffman has placed on record the opinion that "the legality of the grant of an exclusive franchise cannot for a moment be supported." The Supreme Court of California stated : "We think then that this general grant of this exclusive privilege is wholly void." The late Governor Haight gave it as his opinion that "The claim advanced by the Water Front Company is perfectly baseless." And in 46 Cal., 18, the reader will find these words: "Nothing short of a very explicit provision in the law will justify the Court in holding that the Legislature intended to permit the shore, between high and low water mark, to be converted into private ownership."

Closely allied to the water-front question is the subject of communication with San Francisco. It is now our purpose to follow the topic to the best of our ability.

We doubt not that if the records of some of the Mexican ports could be referred to we would find that the San Antonio Creek is mentioned therein. With the splendid adjunct of the bay of San Francisco it is unquestioned that droghers found their way to the embarcadero of San Antonio, there to ship hides and tallow from the ranches of the Peraltas. Upon the arrival of the earlier pioneers and their establishment in the San Antonio redwoods, its advantages as a navigable stream were still further tried, and with the advent of the gold-seekers its capabilities were still further put to the test. From the earliest times it has been practically an artery of navigation, and as such was the proper property of the "Lord of the Soil," and could not be handed over to the tender mercies of private individuals.

We have seen that communication with San Francisco was at a very early day kept up by means of whale-boats, and one of these named the Pirourette plied regularly as a ferry-boat between the embarcadero at San Antonio and San Francisco. The first official intelligence, however, of there being an actual ferry is to be found in the records of Contra Costa County, where, on August 4, 1851, the Court of Sessions granted a license to H. W. Carpentier and A. Moon to run a ferry "from Contra Costa, in the township of San Antonio,- to the city of San Francisco," and fixing the tariff as follows : -

And in that year regular communication was established. In 1852 the San Antonio Creek was declared to be a navigable stream by Act of the Legislature.

In 1850 the Kangaroo was put on the route, but made only two trips in the week, her point of departure being San Antonio (now East Oakland). A small steamer, name not remembered, ran from Oakland in 1 851, while, in 1852, the Boston, and the

Caleb Cope, Thomas Gray, Master, commenced to ply. The first-named was, however, shortly after this destroyed by fire. Towards the end of the year the Kate Hayes, the Red Jacket, and other boats were put on the route, until finally the Contra Costa Steam Navigation Company was established, with two steamers, making regular daily trips, and charging one dollar for each passage.

On January 15, 1853, the now famous Board of Trustees passed an ordinance granting to the Contra Costa Steam Navigation Company ferry privileges between Oakland and San Francisco, which, however, was repealed on the ist of March following. An attempt was made though to have a bill quietly passed through the Legislature granting the exclusive privilege to G. W. Ryckman to establish and run a ferry between Oakland and San Francisco, an action which brought forth the following resolutions from the Council at a meeting held April 18, 1854: -

Whereas, We have learned that a bill has been introduced into the Senate of this State, proposing to grant a monopoly of the ferry privilege between the cities of Oakland and San Francisco to Gartet W. Ryckman for fifteen years, at rates of ferriage exceeding those now charged upon the ferries already established, and to raise a revenue therefrom to the State, therefore be it

Resolved, By the City Council of the city of Oakland, that we view such a proposition with jealously and regret, as an unwarrantable attempt on the part of foreign speculators to cripple the commerce and resources, and to retard the prosperity of this city.

Resolved, That we regard all such monopolies as injurious, not only to the city of Oakland, but also to other towns in the vicinity. The Legislature has already declared San Antonio Creek to be a navigable stream. There are several towns situated upon it and it is the only outlet for the increasing trade of one of the most populous and fertile valleys of the State. Any individual or individuals, who, by Legislative enactment, may hold a monopoly of that trade, will thereby injure and retard the growth and enterprise of our city and surrounding country. We deem a fair and honorable competition in all ferry enterprises between this city aijd San Francisco as a matter of constitutional right, and we deprecate any attempt to curb the prosperity of our people by the granting of any monopolies in relation to the same.

Resolved, That we protest against any attempt to raise a public revenue by a special tax levied upon the citizens of Oakland as unjust, undemocratic, and oppressive.

Resolved, That his Honor, the Mayor, be requested to forward copies of the foregoing preamble and resolutions to our Senator and Assemblyman and to the branches of the Legislature.

In his message of April 29, 1854, Horace W. Carpentier, then occupying the civic chair, reverts to the subject of ferries in these words : " The subject of public ferries is an important one and worthy your consideration. Upon the proper regulation and the facilities for travel which they afford, Oakland is largely dependent, and I recommend that vigorous measures be taken to insure the speedy removal of the bar at the mouth of the San Antonio, so as to render communication with San Francisco easy and certain at all hours and stages of the tide. Your attention has already been directed to a bill now pending before the Legislature, granting to an individual a monopoly of ferry privileges for fifteen years at greatly increased rates of ferriage, and to raise therefrom a revenue to the State. A proposition more manifestly unjust to the city of Oakland, or more devoid of all guarantees for the public security and convenience could scarcely have been devised, nor one which will meet the more earnest disapprobation of every man living in Oakland or its environs, or in the least interested in its prosperity. The resolutions of remonstrance heretofore passed by the City Council, I have caused to be presented to the Senate, and I feel assured that no fears need be entertained of its passage." In the foregoing we can see the jealousy that was to prevent at all hazards the estabhshment of any line of communication in which the Carpentier faction had no interest. To them the navigable waters of the creek and bay were a part and parcel of the water-front concession - so-called - therefore the Mayor might well encourage the Council with the words, " that no fears need be entertained " of the passage of the bill through the Legislature. It is curious to watch also that what was a monopoly in one case was not so in the other - exclusive possession of ferry line was not akin to exclusive possession of a city's entire water front! A year later, in 1855, the Council passed another resolution earnestly remonstrating against the passage of any law by the Legislature granting to any person, persons, or body a monopoly of ferry privileges between Oakland and San Francisco; while, in accordance with the suggestion of the Mayor, a resolution was passed, January 10, 1855, that proposals for the removal of the bar at the mouth of San Antonio .Creek, or dredging the same, so as to admit of navigation at low stages of the tide be received, and that the same be handed in to the Clerk of the Council on or before February i,

We have shown before that Horace W. and E. R. Carpentier had been granted exclusive ferry rights in March, 1855, and that considerable dissatisfaction was being felt at the consequence of this concession, but still they held their own against all comers.

Mayor S. H. Robinson, on April 2, 1856, sent a message to the Council wherein he dwelt at length on this and the subject of the Oakland Bar. He said, " I would call the attention of the Council to the bar at the mouth of the San Antonio Creek, an obstruction to the navigation of the same, which is estimated can be moved for about five thousand dollars. The dredging of this bar, owing to exaggerated estimates of its cost, has heretofore been looked upon as an enterprise, the expense of which was far beyond the reach of the limited means of our city. Such, however, is not the case. There is not a property-holder or a business-man within its corporate limits that would not cheerfully pay an additional percentage' as taxes towards such an object, knowing that the value of property and the amount of business would be increased thereby. The citizens of Clinton and San Antonio profess a willingness to contribute to this object, but they 'cannot be expected to do anything in the matter until Oakland takes the lead. I particularly urge you to consider this matter and would recommend the passage of an ordinance appropriating the sum of two thousand dollars to be paid, provided the balance is made up by cash subscriptions from other sources. Every part of Alameda County, and every citizen living within its limits is directly interested in the matter and would, I have no doubt, if the subject was properly presented, contribute liberally towards the removal of its obstructions, without which a cheap, speedy, and certain access to the San Francisco market cannot well be found.

" And in this connection I desire to call your attention to the subject of the ferry, as one of vital importance to the prosperity of the city. That the present ferry between this city and San Francisco is not what it ought to be and that it is conducted in almost total disregard of the public wants and interests, is a fact notorious to all. What steps, if any, ought to be taken by you with a view to its improvement, I am not prepared at present definitely to recommend, but I commend to you the whole sub- ject matter as one eminently worthy of your careful consideration. Public improvements, either in dredging the bar, in placing the ferry upon a proper footing, or in constructing wharves, thereby increasing the means of access to our city, are public benefits and should be encouraged by all practical means, and in cases where private property is taken for public use, just and fair compensation should be made therefor." The outcry against the management of the ferry is continued by Mayor Williams, in his message of March lo, 1857. He there remarks: " The want of suitable and proper accommodations for passage between this city and San Francisco has produced great discomfort to passengers and worked a serious inj' ry to the prosperity of this city. The high charges for freight and passage; the want of comfortable accommodations; the uncertainty of time for trip; the length of time to effect a crossing of eight miles - generally one hour - the daily apprehension of remaining grounded on the bar for hours, have deterred hundreds from settling here, who, doing business in San Francisco, would otherwise, with their families, have been domiciliated with us. The rates for passage charged, for instance, one hundred and eighty dollars a year for commuters, or, three hundred and sixty-five dollars per annum for non-commuters, and for individuals for daily passage, and same rates of freight as charged two years ago, would seem to afford patronage sufficient to justify more convenient and enlarged accommodations, especially for females and children, to whom the want of suitable and proper arrangements, especially in inclement weather, is a serious inconvenience.

" San Francisco Bay is an arm of the sea, being a maritime highway, and San Antonio Creek declared by Legislature a navigable stream, there is not now, and cannot be, any legal ferry monopoly. The regulations of the wharf and dockage privileges are entirely under your legal control, independent of the question of the ownership of the water front; and it is believed that a competition of passenger boats would produce a great reduction of fare; increased speed on trips; more promptness in the time of starting; greater comfort in the passenger-seats on board; less annoyance of wharfage at each end of the trip, and still leave, for two rival lines, a far larger profit per cent, on the capital invested than any other business or investment in the State. It is believed that the wharfage and dockage receipts realized by individuals which justly belong to the city are far more than adequate to pay the whole expense of the City Government, including the public schools without any other source of revenue. I recommend your encouragement of any feasible plan for competition in passenger boats, and, also in connection with this subject, a careful revisal and re-enactment with amendments of Ordinance Number Twenty-two, 'to regulate the tolls, wharfage, and dockage on wharves, piers, and slips' - approved May 16, 1855, and the subsequent enforcement of a strict compliance with its provisions and an examination of the rights of the city to the wharfage and dockage collected at the wharves."

It needs no words of ours to impress the reader with the annoyance experienced and the baneful influences exercised by the Carpentier ferry, under the management of Minturn, to whom the honor of giving the name to the line is awarded. The Mayor in the above statement has most capably told the story, while, at the same time, in relation to the bar he says: "The dredging of the bar at the mouth of the San Antonio Creek is also a work of such general utility to the counties bordering on each side of the bay, and the whole country at large, and so unlikely of accomplish- ment under any present arrangement, that it would seem to present just claims to the consideration of the Legislature, and I therefore submit to you the propriety of an application for aid from the State to dredge and plank a channel of sufficient depth and width .to obviate any further danger or obstruction from that source in all time to come."

The discontent with the Minturn line continued and soon manifested itself by the establishment of the Oakland and San Antonio Steam Navigation Company. This association was duly launched towards the end of 1857, and with the feeling then existing towards the opposition company, it was not long- before all of the stock was taken up, and its originator, the lamented Hon. James B. Larue, installed as its President. Tiiey at once purchased the steamer Confidence, and from her built the San Antonio, which commenced to ply in April, 1858, the rate of fare being reduced to twenty-five cents. In the fall of that year the Oakland v/Sl^ constructed, and with her a very lively competition was inaugurated against the Contra Costa, both of which took the place of the Clinton and the San Antonio. But the newly formed Oakland and San Antonio Steam Navigation Company was not to be allowed to ply its boats unmolested. The suit of Minturn versus Larue et at. was instituted, in which the plaintiff prayed for an injunction on the ferry of which the latter was President; the case was taken before Judge Hoffman of theUnited States Circuit Court, and in the July term of the year 1858, that learned exponent of the law rendered the following decision, which declared that the ordinance granting an exclusive franchise was unconstitutional and illegal. It may be remembered that that also was the expressed opinion of Mayor Carpentier, when it was proposed to grant ferry privileges to Ryckman, in 1854: -

"The Bill in this case is filed for an injunction to restrain the defendants from interfering with the privilege of franchise of the complainant, in a ferry from the town of Oakland to this city, of which he claims to be the exclusive owner for a term of years.

"This franchise is alleged to have been conferred on the complainant by an ordinance and contract pursuant thereto, made by the Trustees of Oakland in the year 185- The authority of the Trustees to make the ordinance and contract is derived from the Act of the Legislature, passed May 4, 1852.

"Under the supposed authority of this Act, a contract was made by the Trustees, granting to the assignor of the complainant the privilege, claimed to be exclusive, of keeping and, running all ferries between the town of Oakland and the city of San Francisco and elsewhere. It is not denied that the defendants are running a ferryboat between this city and the town of San Antonio, touching at Oakland; nor that the profits and business of the complainants are seriously affected thereby. It is urged that the Court should not, at this stage of the cause, determine its whole merits, but that the injunction should be granted if the complainant has made out a prima facie case.

"But it is well settled that injunctions will not be granted to secure the enjoyment of a statutory privilege, unless the right be clear. (3 Cowen, 755; I Johns, Ph. R.,64.)

"In cases where an injunction is prayed to restrain an act which, if committed, will work irreparable mischief, it will be granted ^ex necessitate^ even in doubtful cases, as the only means of keeping the parties Hn statu quo', and preventing the parties final decree from being abortive. Such are the cases of the threatened destruction of heirlooms, or works of art, or objects having a 'pietum affectionis,' like family portraits, etc.; or the publication of private letters, or the erecting of nuisances calculated to work irreparable mischief, etc. In all such cases it is clear that the Court, by refusing the injunction, permits the act to be done, its subsequent decree, granting the injunction, would be but a 'brutum fulman!

"But when an exclusive privilege under a statute is claimed, and the Court is asked to forbid the commission of an act, otherwise lawful, because it interferes with the exclusive privilege claimed, the legal right of the complainant must be clear. It is said that in this case the Court should interfere because the tresspass on the complainant is continuous, and Cannot be estimated in damages.

"But the damages to the defendants, if they are prevented from running their boat until their cause is heard, are equally unsusceptible of calculation, and may be greater than the complainant can sustain by the competition. The Court should therefore be fully satisfied that the right exists, before, by its injunction, it will cause to the defendants an injury quite as irreparable .and perhaps more extensive than that apprehended by the complainant.

"The supposed authority of the Trustees to make the ordinance and contract relied on by the complainant, is contained in the third section of the Act to incorporate the town of Oakland, passed May 4, 1854.* This section provides 'that the Board of Trustees shall have power to make such by-laws and ordinances as they may deem fit, proper, and necessary; to regulate, improve, sell, or otherwise dispose of the common property; to prevent and extinguish fires; to lay out, make, open, widen, regulate, and keep in repair all streets, roads, bridges, ferries, public places and grounds, wharves, docks, piers, slips, sewers, wells, and alleys, and to authorize the construction of the same; and with a view to facilitate the construction of wharves and other improvements, the lands lying within the limits aforesaid, between high-tide and ship channel, are hereby granted and released to said town.'

" It is urged, however, that they amount to a delegation to the Trustees of all the legislative and sovereign power possessed by the State, over the subject of ferries from that town. That, in the exercise of that power, the trustees could make any contract and confer any rights, with regard to ferries, they might deem proper, and that, having done so, the rights thereby conferred rested and remain indefeasible, either by the Trustees or the State, except in the exercise of the right of eminent domain.

"The first question to be considered is, what were the nature and extent of the authority conferred upon the Trustees by the Act above cited?

"The only words in the clause which can be construed to confer the powers supposeJ, are the words 'make' and 'authorize the construction of.'

"It is evident that most of the empowering words in the phrase do not apply to all the objects in reference to which the- powers are to be exercised. For instance: The word 'open' cannot refer to 'ferries,' nor the word 'widen' to 'wells.' The words 'lay out' evidently refer to 'streets,' 'roads,' 'public places' and 'grounds;' and the words 'authorize the construction' have obviously a more specific reference to the docks, wharves, bridges, and sewers mentioned, or to the ferries.

" It is clear, therefore, that the various empowering words in the phrase must be construed distributively ' reddendo singula singulis; ' and they must be distributed among the objects mentioned, in such a way as to give, with respect to each, only those powers which would naturally be conferred upon a municipal corporation, with reference to such objects.

" To apply the word ' make ' to ' ferries ' and to construe it as conferring the absolute right of leasing indefinitely, or granting the franchise for all ferries, from the town to any individual, would seem a forced interpretation, suggested rather by the desire to find in the Act the authority sought for, than by the natural construction of the phrase itself If ' make' were the only word which could apply to ferries, or if 'ferries' was the only word which would satisfy and give effect to the word 'make,' the construction contended for would be more plausible.

"But the word 'regulate' not only can be applied to the ferries, but is sufficient to confer all the authority with respect to them which would naturally and appropriately be given to a municipal corporation from whom a grant of the franchise in property is withheld; while the word ' make' has a similar operation if applied to the bridges, wharves, piers, docks, sewers, wells, etc.

" ' To make ferries ' is certainly an unusual and awkward expression. The more appropriate phrase would obviously be 'to establish ferries;' and had the extensive powers with regard to them which are now claimed, been intended to be conferred, it is hardly possible that the Legislature would have omitted in specific terms to grant and enumerate them. The construction contended for assumes that while the Legislature withheld the grant of the franchise from the corporation as property, it nevertheless intended to give them full power to grant the exclusive franchise as property to any individual; to be assigned or sold by him at pleasure, and capable of being owned by a foreigner or a citizen of another State; and all this by the force of the word ' make' which is wrested from its natural application to other objects and made to refer to ferries by an ingenious and forced construction.

"The words 'authorize the construction of cannot be appealed to as conferring the powers attempted to be exercised in this case. Whatever propriety there might be in the phrase ' construct a ferry,' the power to do so can hardly be deemed a power to grant or lease an exclusive franchise and privilege of establishing it, especially when such franchise is not conferred upon the donee of the power to construct; and in this case the power is not given to 'construct,' but to 'authorize the construction of ferries, if, indeed, it refers to ferries at all. It is, therefore, merely a power to permit, or to allow them to be constructed. It would surely be an unwarrantable latitude of construction, to hold that a power to permit the construction of a ferry unaccompanied by a grant of the franchise; authorized the absolute grant of an exclusive franchise to any one the party empowered to permit might see fit to give it. But for the reasons before assigned, I think the words - authorize the construction of apply to wharves, docks, piers, bridges, etc., and not to ferries; with reference to which they are obviously inappropriate. But assuming that the words 'make' and 'authorize the construction of apply to ferries, the question recurs, whether the trustees were authorized by the power thus given, to confer the right now claimed.

" The ordinance under which the contract with Edward R. Carpentier was made, provides that 'the Trustees, etc., do hereby make, open, widen, lay out, grant, create, ordain, establish, and regulate a public ferry between said town of Oakland and the city of San Francisco, to be called the Oakland Ferry; and they do hereby bargain and contract with Edward R. Carpentier, his heirs, agents, and assigns, to run said ferry for the period of twenty years, according to the terms of this ordinance, either as a separate ferry, or in connection with, or continuance of the one already established and used between said town and said city, hereby granting, selling, and releasing, and conveying to his successors in interest and assigns, exclusively, for the period of twenty years, the right to keep and run a public ferry, or public ferries so as to demand and receive compensation therefor, between the said town of Oakland and the city of San Francisco, or between the said town of Oakland and any other place! together with all and singular the ferry rights, privileges, and franchises which now are or may hereafter bs owned by said town.' The contract made in pursuance of this ordinance is in substantially the same language.

"Admitting that so much of this ordinance as purports to establish, create, and make a public ferry between Oakland and San Francisco is a valid exercise of the power conferred on the Trustees, we are next to inquire whether the grant and the subsequent contract was also within the power of the Trustees.

" It will be seen that the Trustees in express terms convey and grant for twenty years to Carpentier and his successors, exclusively, the right of running and keeping a ferry or ferries between Oakland and San Francisco, and between Oakland and any other places, and they undertake to convey to him " all the ferry rights, privileges, and franchises which now are, or may hereafter be, owned by said town.'

It is not contended that the town of Oakland was the owner of any exclusive ferry franchise whatever. The grant, therefore, of the ferry franchises owned by the town would, of course, pass for nothing. As to the grant of all ferry franchises which might thereafter be owned by it, no observations are necessary; but it is said that the Trustees, in the exercise of their power to establish ferries, had incidentally and as the appropriate means of establishing them, the right to lease them to individuals. It is not necessary to inquire into the authority of the corporation to establish a particular ferry, and to lease it to an individual.

" The right they have attempted to convey to Carpentier was not a lease of a particular ferry between a certain point in the town of Oakland and the city of San Francisco, but the exclusive right to keep and run a ferry or ferries between Oakland or any other place. Thus they abdicated and renounced the exercise of all the powers with respect to ferries with which they were intrusted, except that of ' regulating.' For the power to establish other ferries could be of no avail, so long as Carpentier retained the exclusive right to run and keep them.

" It would perhaps be difficult to find in the history of municipal corporations another instance of so extraordinary a grant. It was not only not an exercise of any power they may have possessed to establish ferries, but it was, in effect, the surrender of the whole power to establish them, and it amounted to an agreement that no ferry should be established from Oakland to any place whatever, unless by the permission of the person to whom they had given the exclusive right to run them. It seems to me that the legality of the grant cannot, for a moment, be supported.

" The authority vested in the Board was conferred upon them as Trustees for the public, to be exercised for the public good. They had not only the right, but it was their duty, and that of their successors, to exercise the power of establishing ferries as agents and trustees of the public, whenever the public good might require.

" The power to establish ferries, if it existed at all, was a continuing power and duty, which existed in every Board of Trustees for the time being; and no contract by one Board not to exercise it, or for the exclusive enjoyment of the franchise by an individual, ,could prohibit or restrain their successors from exercising the powers vested in them by the statute to establish and license other ferries required by public convenience and necessity. (Fay, Petitioner, etc., 1 5 Pick. 243.)

" But to ascertain more certainly the intention of the law, and the nature and extent of the powers conferred upon the Trustees, the Legislature of the State with regard to ferries must be considered.

" By the Act of March, 1850, all persons were forbidden to keep ferries without a license, except for their own use, or of that of their families. The Courts of Sessions were empowered to establish ferries across bays, creeks, or sloughs bounding or within their respective counties, as they might deem necessary, and were authorized to issue a license to keep a public ferry to any suitable person applying therefor, for a term not to exceed one year, on the fulfillment by the applicant of certain prerequisites. They could also license and establish additional ferries within less than two miles from a regularly established ferry, when necessary for public convenience, and on notice to the proprietor of such previously established ferry. The Act further provides for the establishment of ferries on private property, for the occupation of ground at either end of the ferry, and for the publication of a notice of the application of a ferry. It also prescribes the duties and privileges of ferry-men, and provides for the rates of ferriage, revoking licenses, and for the penalties to be imposed for a refusal to transfer persons or property.

" All those provisions were of a general character, and applied to all the counties of the State. They were evidently designed to provide by general law for the establishment of ferries, for conferring the franchise in suitable cases, with proper checks and securities, and with the express reservation of the right to confer a similar franchise upon persons other than the proprietor of the first established ferry, wherever it might be deemed necessary or advantageous to the public.

" The same provisions, in substance, remain as part of the general law of this State, to the present day, except that it having been determined that under the Constitution of this State, the Courts of Sessions could not exercise the functions assigned to them by the Act, the same powers, in substance, were by the Act of 1855, vested in the Boards of Supervisors.

"On the 14th of April, 1853, an Act was passed, declaring that the second section of the Act creating and regulating public ferries should not be construed to apply to the bays of San Pablo, Suisun, San Francisco, or Monterey; and the navigation of said bays, and the transportation of freight or passengers over, across, or through the sanne was declared to be free and exempt from the restriction of any ferry laws then in force in the State. These provisions have been repealed, in substance, in all the succeeding ferry laws passed on the subject.

"It will not be disputed that these laws indicate and establish the settled policy of the State, with regard to public ferries; that it was intended to confer the franchise, for a limited time, on persons found to be suitable, and with certain privileges, checks, securities, and penalties provided by law; that such privileges were not to be exclusive, but other ferries could be established contiguous to any established ferry, whenever deemed necessary; and that the State was to derive a revenue from the issuing of the licenses.

"The law of 1853, and subsequent enactments to the same effect, show that the great arms of the sea therein mentioned were not regarded as fit for the establishment of any ferries whatever, but that the navigation and transportation of freight and passengers across, through, and over them were to be left free and exempt from the restriction of any ferry laws in force in this State. Such being the settled policy and law of this State with regard to public ferries, and with reference to the bays mentioned, it is not to be presumed, without the clearest evidence of a contrary intention, that the Legislature intended to confer upon the trustees of a small town on the bay of San Francisco, the power to grant an exclusive privilege to establish ferries across the most important of these bodies of water, the navigation of which was, the next year, declared free and exempt from all ferry laws.

"If the general ferry law, under which no exclusive rights could be acquired, nor license granted for more than a year, was deemed unfit to be applied to the bay of San Francisco, the inference is irresistible, that it could not have been the intention, only one year previously, to confer upon the trustees of a town an unlimited power to grant exclusive privileges, for any period, with reference to the same waters, to any individual they might choose.

"It is admitted that the law by which the power claimed was conferred, might at anytime have been repealed. Had the Legislature, when, in 1853, it declared the bays mentioned to be exempt from the operation of all ferry laws, and the navigation over and across them to be free, supposed that the Trustees of Oakland were empowered to grant an exclusive right to an individual to establish ferries to the most important city of the State, they would surely not have omitted to revoke the powers and repeal the law by which they were conferred.

"The question we have been considering is purely one of construction, and even if the language of the Act were more doubtful, yet, when read by the light of the previous and immediately subsequent legislation of the State, its true interpretation would seem to be unmistakable.

"But, it is said that the power to estabUsh a ferry imparts 'ex vi termini,' a power to confer exclusive rights in the ferry so established; that without such rights it would not be a ferry in the legal sense of the term. But on this point the case of

Fanning vs. Gregoire (i6 Howard, 524) is decisive. In that case Fanning claimed under a direct grant from the Legislature, authorizing him to keep a ferry at the town of Dubuque, across the Mississippi River, for the term of twenty years. This he accordingly established. Subsequently, the State conferred upon the City Council of Dubuque power to license and establish public ferries across the Mississippi; and under the power a license was granted. On a suit by Fanning against the license, it was held that his franchise was not exclusive, but that the Legislature had a right to license other ferries.

"It is clear that if a direct grant, to an individual, of authority to establish and keep a ferry at a particular place does not vest in him an exclusive franchise, the grant to a municipal corporation power to establish ferries, does not authorize them to bestow exclusive privileges. If the term 'ferry' in the grant to Fanning did not impart any exclusive franchise, it cannot have that meaning in the Act incorporating Oakland. It can surely make no difference whether the State is supposed to have duly surrendered to an individual its power of improvement and accommodation in a great and important line of public travel, or whether it is supposed to have authorized a municipal corporation to surrender it; in either case 'its abandonment ought to be presumed, when the deliberate purpose of the State to abandon it does not appear.' (I Peters, 514.)

"It is urged that, even if the town of Oakland or the State had power to license other ferries, yet the right of complainant to the exclusive enjoyment of the ferry on the particular ferry-ways established by him ought to be protected. But in the case above referred to no such distinction appears to have been taken. The right claimed was like this - an exclusive right to run a ferry from a certain town across the Mississippi for twenty years. The infringement complained of was the licensing and establishment of another from the same town, across the same river. The Court decided that the franchise claimed was not exclusive, and that the establishment of the second ferry was legal. It is nowhere suggested that the second licensee could not run his boat from any part of the town of Dubuque, and even from the same wharf as that used by the first licensee.

"The privilege attempted to be granted in this case was not the privilege of keeping and running a ferry from any specified dock or wharf in the town of Oakland to any other point across the bay. It was the right to keep and run a ferry or ferries from the town of Oakland generally to any place whatever. Whether, if the trustees had established a ferry from a certain wharf, and leased the same to an individual, his rights in such ferry would have been exclusive, it is not necessary to inquire, for the right granted was the exclusive right to run 'a ferry or ferries ' from the town of Oakland to any place, with all the ferry rights, privileges, and franchises then owned or thereafter to be owned by the town.

"But admitting, for the sake of argument, not only that the trustees were empowered to establish ferries, but that the Legislature intended to confer upon them powers to grant to an individual the exclusive franchise for any period of running and keeping the ferries so established, such a construction affords an argument almost irresistible: that those powers could only have been conferred with regard to ferries wholly within the corporate limits.

"Within those limits is the creek San Antonio, which can only be crossed bybridges or boats. If, then, the power to grant a franchise in property was intended to be conferred, it is surely more reasonable, and more in accordance with every rule relating to the construction of grants of this description, to construe it as referring to ferries across waters wholly within the corporate limits, than to suppose it to extend to ferries across a bay, the navigation of which was, in less than a year afterwards, declared free and open to all.

"With reference to the streets, docks, wharves, and sewers this limitation is necessarily understood. Why not with regard to ferries, if the power to grant the franchise was intended to be given ? The ferry from Oakland to this city affords the principal, if not the only means of convenient access to the commercial center and chief seaport of the State, not only to the citizens of Oakland, but to the inhabitants of a considerable district, and the possession of an exclusive franchise of running and keeping all ferries between Oakland and this city, gives to the possessor the practical control of the means of communication. Can it be supposed that the Legislature intended to give the power to grant such a right to the corporate authorities of a town situated at one terminus of the ferry, and to take away or render nugatory the rights of the county at the other terminus to license ferries across the water forming their common boundary? That this right existed in both counties, under the law of 1851, is cleair. But the privileges conferred by the license under the ferry laws are limited, and not exclusive in the person obtaining the license. To suppose, then, that the power contended for was conferred upon the Trustees of Oakland, we must suppose that the power given to every county on the bay of San Francisco, between which and Oakland a ferry might be established, were revoked, and the general ferry laws on that subject repealed by implication. And this by force of the word 'm^ke,' which we are asked first to apply to ferries, and then to construe as has been explained. It may be said that the question is not now as to the right of other counties to license ferries under the general ferry laws. This is true. But the question is, as to the exclusive right of the complainant to a ferry between Oakland and this city - as against defendants; and in construing the law under which this his alleged rights are claimed, it is of importance to show that the power to confer such rights was incompatible with the then existing laws, conferring powers over ferries to other counties, and could only have been given by repealing pro tanto these laws; as also that it was incompatible with subsequent laws, by which all power to establish ferries over the waters in question was taken away.

" It is n.ot denied that grants of privileges, franchises, etc., are to be strictly construed, and that nothing is to be taken by intendment.

" It is claimed, however, that this is a delegation of legislative authority, and not a grant of a franchise, and that therefore a different rule must be applied. I confess myself unable to see the propriety of this distinction in the present case.

" The State is the sovereign from whom the power is derived, whether it is supposed to have granted directly to a corporation the exclusive franchise as property, as was done in the case of the city of New York, or to have granted to the corpora- tion power to make an exclusive grant of the franchise to an individual; in either case the rules of construction must be the same. It can surely make no difference whether the corporation is the direct grantee of the franchise or the donee of a power to make a grant of it and receive the consideration.

"First. - That it is at least doubtful whether the Act incorporating the town of Oakland gave to the Trustees any other power with regard to ferries than that of regulating them.

" Second. - That if the power to establish ferries was conferred, such power was held by them as a public trust, to be exercised by them and their successors when the public good might require. They had, therefore, no authority to confer upon any individual the exclusive right to keep and run a ferry or ferries between Oakland and San Francisco, still less such a right with regard to ferries ' between Oakland and any other place.'

" Third. - That if such powers were intended to be given the Trustees, they could only have referred to ferries across waters wholly within the corporate limits of the town.

"Fourth. - That under any possible view of the case, the right of the complainant is doubtful; and that therefore the injunction ought not now to be granted.

" The contract between the town of Oakland and Carpentier must be deemed a fraud upon the law and a complete evasion of its policy and object. A public trust was confined to the authorities of Oakland, to be executed by them as agents of the public. It was not in their power to denude themselves of the trust. It was not their "common property,' and by the charter could not be sold or disposed of It was a public trust to be exercised by them as agents of the community, which they could not discard so as to prevent their successors from establishing additional ferries required by the public convenience. By the contract they 'granted, sold, released^ and conveyed ' to an individual, his successors and assigns, exclusively, for the space of twenty years, the right to keep and run a public ferry or ferries, so as to demand and receive compensation therefor, between the town of Oakland and the city of San Francisco, and between ' the said town and any other place ' together with all and singular, the ferry rights, privileges, and franchises which now are, or may hereafter be, held and owned by said town. By such contract the then authorities of Oakland attempted to convert a public trust to private and individual use, and to place for twenty years under the exclusive control of an individual and his assigns all, even future means of ferry communication across the navigable waters from Oakland to any other place. Such never was the intention of the Legislature. Such an Act it was not in the power of the authorities of Oakland to do, and such a transaction a Court of Equity cannot sustain.

" This tribunal could not interpose by the extraordinary process of injunction, to support rights derived from such a source; and maintain a title, which, so far from being free from doubt, was executed under a contract in fraud of the law, under which it proposes to be executed, and to sustain restrictions over the navigable waters of this State, which the Legislature has declared shall be exempt from all such restrictions."

The case was taken on appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States, when the judgment of the Lower Courts was sustained, as will be gleaned from the following decision of Mr. Justice Nelson: -

" The bill was filed by the complainant in the Court below to restrain the defendants from running a ferry between the city of San Francisco and the city of Oakland, on the opposite side of the bay, and which, it is claimed, is in violation of the exclusive privileges belonging to him under the authority of law. The authority, as set forth in the bill, is derived from the charter of the town (now city) of Oakland. The third section of the charter (passed May 4, 1852) provided that 'the Board of Trustees shall have power to make such by-laws and ordinances as they may deem proper and necessary;' among other things, 'to lay out, make, open, widen, regulate, and keep in repair all streets, roads, bridges, ferries,' etc., ' wharves, docks, piers, slips,' etc., ' and to authorize the construction of the same; and with a view to facilitate the constructions of wharves and other improvements the land lying within the limits aforesaid, (that is of the corporation) between high tide and ship channel, are hereby granted and released to said town.'

"It is admitted, if the authorities of the town of Oakland possessed the power under the charter to grant an exclusive right of ferries between that place and the city of San Francisco, the complainant has become vested with it. The question in the case, therefore, is whether or not the power was conferred by this third section of the charter.

" It is a well-settled rule of construction of grants by the Legislature to corporations, whether public or private, that only such powers and rights can be exercised under them as are clearly comprehended within the words of the Act, or derived the'refrom by necessary implication, regard being had to the objects of the grant. Any ambiguity or doubt arising out of the terms used by the Legislature must be resolved in favor of the public. This principle has been so often applied in the construction of corporate powers, that we need not stop to refer to authorities.

" Now, looking at the terms of the grant in this case, and giving to them their widest meaning, either separately or in the connection in which they are found, or with the object for which the power was conferred, we find, indeed, a power to establish and regulate ferries within the corporate limits of the town, but not an exclusive power. Full effect is given to the words in which the power is granted, when the simple right is conceded tip establish and regulate ferries. If the grant had been made to an individual in the terms here used, the question would have been too plain for argument. In our judgment we can have no wider interpretation, though made to a corporation- It must be remembered that this is not the case where the Crown or the Legislature has aliened to a municipal corporation its whole power to establish and regulate ferries within its limits, as may be found in some of the ancient charters of cities of

England and in this countr})-. In these cases the municipal Body in respect to this legislature or public trust, represents the sovereign power and may make grants of ferry rights in as simple a manner as the sovereign. The error, we think, in the argument for the appellant, is in confounding this grant with these ancient charters, or those of a like character. But, on referring to them, it will be seen that the form of the grant is very different - much more particular and comprehensive, leaving no doubt as to the extent of the power (Costar vs. Brush., 25 Wend. R. 31J. So here if the Legislature had intended to confer their whole power upon this corporation to establish and regulate ferries within its limits, or a power to grant exclusive ferry rights therein, a very different form of grant would have been used - one that would have expressed the intent of the law-maker to part with the exclusive power over the subject, and vest it in the grantee. In the form used, no such intent appears or can be reached except by a very forced interpretation, which we are not at liberty to give, according to well-settled authority (11 Pat. 422; 8 How. 569; Mills gjf a/, vs. St. Clair Co. e( a/., 16 id. 524; Fanning vs. Gregoire). In Mills vs. St. Clair Co. the Court speaking of a ferry grant, said that in a grant like this by the sovereign power, the rule of construction is, that if the meaning of the words be doubtful, they .shall be taken most strongly against the granted and for the government, and therefore should not be extended by implication beyond the natural and obvious meaning of the words; and if these do not support the claim, it'must fall. And again, in Fanning vs. Gregoire, speaking on the same subject, the Court says: The exclusive right set up must be clearly expressed, or necessarily inferred, and the Court think that neither the one nor the other is found in the grant to the plaintiff nor in the circumstances connected with it.

" As the town of Oakland had no power, according to the above construction of the charter, to establish an exclusive right of ferries within its limits, it follows that it did not possess the power to confer upon others an exclusive privilege to establish them.

" The power conferred is to make (meaning to establish) and regulate ferries, or to authorize the construction (meaning the establishment) of the same.

Too much credit cannot be accorded to the late Mr. Larue for the persistency with which he fought this monster imposition, finally proving beyond a peradventure that the first or subsequent Boards of Trustees had no authority in law to grant either property or privileges belonging to the city of Oakland to individuals.

The obstruction at the mouth of San Antonio Creek continued to offer many difficulties to free communication with San Francisco, and, to push the matter, some gentlemen formed themselves into a committee for the purpose of raising subscriptions to defray expenses of dredging, etc. The sum of eleven thousand dollars was soon collected, but three thousand dollars more were wanted; therefore in August, 1859, a circular letter was issued by these gentlemen, in which they remarked: "The channel is to be thoroughly dredged, from the deep water of the bay to the San Antonio Channel, two hundred feet wide and five feet deep at extreme low tide - to be marked with piles on each side through the whole length, at a distance of forty feet from each other. The whole work is to be done, and materials furnished, for the sum of fourteen thousand dollars, the contractor giving the most satisfactory securities for the faithful performance of the work. The United States Government has given the gratuitous use of the splendid dredging-machine which has been in use at Mare Island, and the work will be commenced as soon as the contract money is paid in to the treasurer, W. A. Bray, Esq.

Meeting with success, the harbor was soon cleared of its hinderances, and for a time at least something like certainty in duration of transit prevailed; while, an Act was passed in the Legislature for the improvement of San Antonio Creek, the Board of Supervisors being appointed to superintend the work. The Act also provided for plans and specifications being drawn up; stated that the county should not be responsible stockholders, but that it might purchase the work when the sum of forty thousand dollars was paid in, and directed that the privileges should expire in ten years. The scheme, however, did not result satisfactorily; therefore, in i860, a bill was introduced in the Legislature to enable the Board of Supervisors to tax the county for the work, which duly became law. The Commissioners appointed under this enactment were James Dougherty, Alfred L. Tubbs, and W. A. Bray.

Much enthusiasm was evinced in Oakland on August 2, 1862, on the commencement of the ferry railroad, and the initial steps being taken towards the construction ot the wharf, proceedings which caused an immediate advance of about fifty per cent, in the value of real estate. On September 2, 1863, the railroad ferry went into operation with the following time-table, which is produced simply as a matter of comparison between now and then: -

The steamer Clinton continued on the creek route, carrying freight and the San. Antonio passengers, making five trips per day. By October, 1864, the railroad"had been extended to San Antonio, and soon six daily trips between that place and San Francisco were made besides an extra " night trip" every Saturday, leaving San Antonio at 6:30 P. M., and returning from San Francisco at 11:30 P.M. In 1863 James B. Larue, A. W. Swett, and William Hayward obtained a franchise to construct a wharf in San Francisco for the accommodation of their line of steamers.

It may be mentioned that up to this time all previous efforts to place the bar at the mouth of San Antonio Creek in a good navigable condition had proved comparative failures; therefore, in January, 1864, Mr. Larue, in the name of the Oakland and San Antonio Steam Navigation Company, presented to the Board of Supervisors for their approval a scheme for dredging the bar, and keeping it clear, provided they would grant him a franchise and permit him to take toll. He argued that there was no danger of such a franchise proving a monopoly as there were two ferries communicating with Oakland and Alameda, irrespective of the creek. The proposition was subsequently approved by the Supervisors, and the project embodied in a bill, which^ although it passed the Legislature, was, as the sequel has shown, very properly vetoed by the Governor.

The Oakland and San Antonio Steam Navigation Company did not prosper financially as well as its promoters expected. The California Steam Navigation Company purchased a large amount of their stock and strove to get tjie majority of it. The President, Mr. Larue, was forced to buy a sufficient amount to control the whole business, or allow the scheme to fail; in doing so he became largely involved. The steamers, were sold to the Oakland and San Francisco Railroad and Ferry line, but the great desideratum of cheap rates was established in the place of most exorbitant demands. In March, 1865, the Contra Costa or Minturn ferry hne of steamers, consisting of the Contra Costa and Clinton were sold to the San Francisco and Oakland Railroad Company, who continued the service.

Whereas, The population of the city of Oakland and vicinity being wholly made up of the families of those who do business in San Francisco, and of those who, not having business m San Francisco, are sustained by the business created here by those who daily cross the bay, and the Oakland Ferry and Railroad being the only means by which this large population can travel between their homes and places of business; and

Whereas, It being only by the extension of proper facilities, in frequency, regularity, speed, and safety of transit, combined with comfort upon the boats and convenience of stations upon the road, that homes here may become desirable and property valuable; and

Whereas, The facilities for transit afforded by the Oakland Ferry and Railroad not having been such as to give entire satisfaction to the community, and satisfaction and confidence being indispensable to our prosperity,

Resolved, That this matter be referred to a special Committee to devise ways and means to obtain more satisfactory ferry facilities between Oakland and San Francisco, wherein the community can have some voice or guarantee for the facilities afforded; and that said Committee be instructed to consider and report with the view of obtaining Legislative aid if necessary.

On October 28, 1869, notice was given at Sacramento that the Western Pacific and San Francisco and Bay Railroad Companies, the latter of which had been in existence only a short time, had amalgamated and consolidated into a new company, and on the 1st November the Western Pacific took formal possession of the Oakland Ferry, the rates for commutation tickets being then established at three dollars per month, and hourly trips introduced. On May i, 1871, the strips were increased from twelve to fourteen in number, and on the 30th of the same month the passenger-shed was opened.

March 16, 1868, a special meeting of the City Council was convened to take action in regard to a bill introduced in the Legislature granting a franchise to certain persons for cutting a channel through the bar at the mouth of San Antonio Creek, when Mr. Barstow introduced the following resolutions, which were unanimously agreed to: -

Whereas, It is reported in the newspapers that a bill has been introduced into the Assembly to grant to certain persons the right to improve the navigation of San Antonio Creek and to collect tolls at the rate of five cents per ton on all vessels navigating said creek; and

Whereas, The county of Alameda has expended the sum of forty thousand dollars and upwards in cribbing and dredging the bar at the mouth of said creek, thereby rendering the same passable for all vessels which are suited to the depth of water in the channel of said creek, except at the lowest stages of the tide, and affording all the facilities for navigating said creek which the demands of commerce will require for some time to come; and

Whereas, There has been no public demand on the part of the citizens of the county for the passage of any such bill or the granting of any Such exclusive privileges, and said bill has been prepared in the interests of private parties, without reference to the public wants or the public good; therefore,

Resolved, That we regard the granting of a franchise to collect tolls on vessels navigating San Antonio Creek, as a measure highly detrimental to the interests of our city and of the county as well.

Resolved, That there is no present necessity for the improvements contemplated by said bill, and that when such necessity shall arise it will be for the public interests that such improvements be made at the public expense, and the navigation of the creek remain free to the public.

Subsequently steps were taken to effect the dredging necessary, and on September 1 6, 1873, the bid of Ball & Weatherby was accepted by the Council and the work proceeded with. On January 19, 1874, Mr. Warner presented a communication from his Honor, the Mayor, transmitting the preamble and resolution of the Board of Trustees of the town of San Leandro, petitioning Congress to make an appropriation for the construction of a ship channel from the bay of San Francisco, along the southerly line of the city of Oakland, and connecting with San Leandro Bay, which was received. Mr. Spaulding then presented the following preamble and resolution:

The Common Council of the city of Oakland, duly convened for official business this 19th day of January, A. D. 1874, the president and all the members being present, on motion of Councilman Spaulding, seconded by Councilman Warner, it is resolved to memorialize the honorable Congress of the United States upon the importance of improving the harbor of Oakland for commercial purposes, and for the reasons which the following recital of facts will show;

First. - The commerce of the United States in traffic and travel, as connected with the Pacific Coast and the great Continental roads, is now and has been for several years carried on over the water front of the city o Oakland in the State of California.

Second. - That while this commercial business is rapidly increasing, it had already attained, in 1872 and 1873, the aggregate of four hundred and fifty thousand tons of general freight, and in the year ending July i, 1873, no less than one hundred and ten ships were loaded at the Oakland Wharf vidth California wheat, amounting to one hundred and sixty-one thousand tons, to be distributed to the markets of the world.

Third. - The transit of passengers from Asiatic and other foreign ports, from San Francisco and from the cities east of the Rocky Mountains, arriving and departing at Oakland by the great overland railroads, amounted to an aggregate of sixty-seven thousand souls for the year ending January 31, 1873. The local travel by ferryboat between Oakland and San Francisco shows a rapid yearly increase and now requires the constant use of half-hourly boats and trains, carrying a daily average of five thousand persons, equal to a yearly total of nearly two million passengers. During the year 1873 the treasure from all sources in the interior of the State of California, and from the Nevada mines reaching the Oakland dock, amounted to no less than thirty-one millions of dollars in value. The two staples of the Pacific Slope, wheat and bullion, find readiest access to deep water upon the Oakland water front. The location of the city of Oakland relative to the range of mountains known as the Coast Range of Cahfornia, and the great bay of San Francisco, is such as to make the Oakland water front the nearest practicable railroad approach to deep water in the bay, alike adjacent to the city of San Francisco and the Pacific Ocean. And

Whereas, The present wharf, although erected by the railroad companies at a cost of nearly one million of dollars, can only be regarded as a temporary structure, entirely inadequate to the present and prospective demands of commerce. Now, therefore, be it

Resolved, That the City Council of the city of Oakland, California, do hereby most respectfully call the attention of Congress to the above plain recital of facts, and ask that a suitable appropriation may be made for the improvement of the estuary of San Antonio, the harbor of Oakland, in accordance with such plans as may be recommended or considered expedient by the Board of Engineers for the Pacific Coast and the Chief of Engineers of the United States Army.

In the same month, January 12th, the Board of Supervisors adopted a memorial to the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States Congress, couched in similar language, the result of these being that appropriations were, and are being, made to perfect the cDntemplated improvement. On February 28, 1876, the Mayor informs the Council in this regard: "It affords me great pleasure to be able to announce that the improvements of the Oakland Harbor by the United States Government have been progressing rapidly and with gratifying results. From the engineer in charge I learn that the work of constructing the channel training-walls has advanced satisfactorily and with few interruptions. Each of the two walls have now reached a respective length of nine thousand feet, linear, consuming collectively about ninety-five thousand tons of stone, and their further extension still progressing. The recent heavy weather has set at rest the disputed question as to their stability, and their anticipated settlement has been so small a per cent, that the funds at the disposal of the Board will accomplish an amount of work beyond the most sanguine expectation. The effect of the building of the said walls has been to increase the tidal current to such an extent as to scour out the channel on the bar to a present depth of eight feet; at United States Coast Survey, mean low water, and it is continually increasing. Vessels drawing six feet of water and piloted by suitable men, can, at the present day, go and return through this channel at all stages of the tide, without danger.

" In regard to future operations I am informed that a channel two hundred feet in width and twelve feet deep at low water is to be dredged, and work will be commenced very shortly. Should our representative in Congress have reasonable success, within one year from this date Oakland will enjoy shipping advantages far beyond all present expectations.

" Merchant vessels of three hundred tons and four hundred tons registered burthen, drawing sixteen feet of water, will be able to receive and discharge cargoes along the present city front, even during ordinary tide. These facilities must necessarily give rise in the immediate future to a commercial prosperity of paramount importance to our city and county."

It is only necessary to say that these improvements are being still carried out with eminent success, and the day is not far distant when Oakland will possess commercial advantages in respect to her harbor second to no other port on the Pacific^ Coast.

In regard to the ferries we shall simply observe that no better service exists anywhere. The building of the mole and new depot by the Central Pacific Railroad have added materially to the comfort of passengers on the main local line, while the creek route has its fair share of patronage; add to these the boon conferred by the South Pacific Coast Railroad Company and their excellent line of ferry-boats which, landing on the Alameda side of the San Antonii? Creek, transfer their passengers by a local line over Webster-street Bridge into the heart of the city, and we have the summum siunmaruiii of comfortable travel.

In times past several steamers have been used on the creek route. One of these, the Express, is said to be laid up in Napa Creek, dismantled and fast rotting to pieces. She was run by Wingate, and made trips from San Francisco to Oakland and Brooklyn. Oaklanders of some ten years back will recall the Chin-du- Wan, another sternwheeler of small capacity, which was on the creek route in opposition to the regular ferry and to two small side-wheelers, the Louise and another, run by the Central

Pacific Railroad, all three making their landings at the old tumble-down wharf at the foot of Broadway. The Chm-du- Wan carried passengers across for ten cents, and had a horrible instrument of torture, called a calliope, which went by steam and was played upon by turning a crank. This cross between a hand-organ and a steam-whistle went with forty thousand fog-horn power, and went at all hours of the day and night. Its services were popularly supposed to be efficacious against the " bloated monopoly," much as a Chinese tom-tom makes against the devil's machinations. It was exhilarating to view the brave spectacle of the Chin-du- Wan, loaded down to the guards with passengers, move out from the wharf, its automatic brass band playing its one tune, whose pianissimos, even, smote upon the ear at a distance of five miles, and whose " ffo" aroused the dogs of two whole townships. At such times the Louise or her consort would creep forth from her berth with usually not enough of passengers to keep her captain from nearly dying of loneliness. One paid five cents to cross on the Louise. The rivals invariably raced, and the Chin-du- Wan invariably got left. To be beat never troubled the calliope voice, and, though distanced, the discordant hobgoblin always played its song of triumph. After a while the Chin-du- Wan was put on the Stockton route, and the people of the city of the tules cannot have forgotten their sensations when the calliope gave forth its notes on the vessel's first arrival in the slough, at two o'clock in the morning. The sleep-destroying monster never became popular in that town, perhaps because of a too close trenching upon the religious scruples in favor of Gabriel and his trumpet.

The .S. M. Whipple, also a stern-wheeler, did service on the creek route for a while, and received as a legacy the calliope. But the novelty of the thing was gone, and the machine came to be regarded as a nuisance; as indeed it was.

. Let us now conclude the official acts of the Board of Trustees during the year 1852. On May 12th of that year an ordinance (No. i) was passed, fixing the time and place of holding their stated meetings; on May 26th, Ordinance No. 4, providing for the protection of oyster-beds within the corporate limits, and Ordinance No. 5, prohibiting the taking of oysters at certain seasons, were passed, thus early establish- ^ ing a proper care for the luscious bivalve.

1853. - The first subject to which we will turn our attention in the year 1853 is that which comes under the head of the city, its streets, bridges, public highways, plazas, and such like. We have not the space to devote to the intricate action taken on the opening of each thoroughfare throughout the city; indeed such is unnecessary; it has therefore been thought that only the salient points in regard thereto should be mentioned.

On January 29, 1853, an ordinance was passed, consequent upon a petition received from the citizens, that all shade-trees should be protected under the fostering care of the Town Trustees; and on August 27th the stumps remaining on Broadway, after its being laid out as a thoroughfare, were directed to be removed; while on December 24th the road, as surveyed and located, one hundred feet wide and running from Broadway to Cerito and known as the "County Road," was declared to be a municipal highway to be called "Contra Costa Avenue."

Provenance

Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.