Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 13 of 38)
From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,865 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,865 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
We the jury, summoned by A. F. Dyer, Justice of the Peace, acting Coroner, to inquire into the cause of the death of the man now before us, do find that deceased came to his death by a gun-shot wound in the upper portion of his abdomen, passing through the intestine and coming out on the left side. We find that the name of the deceased is Narrato Ponce, a native of Chili, about thirty-five years of age. We are of the opinion that the shot was fired by H. N. Morse, Sheriff of Alameda County, while endeavoring to arrest deceased on a charge of murder.
A reward of five hundred dollars was offered by Governor Low for the arrest and conviction of Narrato, a sum hardly sufficient to compensate the officers for the expense, trouble, and danger to which they were put in ridding the State of a desperado said to be the superior in criminality of the famous Joaquin Murietta.
While scouting among the hills in search of Ponce, Sheriff Morse discovered an old offender named Antonio Martinez alias Jesus Torres, an ex-convict, who had been evading the officers for six months previously. There were several charges against him - ^one at Sonoma and one at Santa Clara. Not long previously he was reported as having been shot by an officer who was trying to arrest him in Monterey for cattle-stealing; while, it was said, he was one of the gang that committed the Pacific Street robbery in San Francisco about three years before. When he was taken nto custody he denied his identity to the Sheriff, but when brought into the presence of Conway and Swain, whom he knew, he lost courage and acknowledged. He was taken to San Leandro, from whence he was sent to Sonoma County, to answer the demands of justice.
Among the profoundest sensations of this year was the murder of Officer Richardson in Oakland. On October 22, 1867, complaint was made in, the Police Court that John Thomas, as principal, and his wife Margaret, as accessory, had shot and killed R. B. Richardson, on that date, on block No. 113, situated at the corner of Ninth and Castro Streets, in the city of Oakland.
The account of this affair is substantially as follows: The man Thomas, an old negro, had been living for some time upon a small lot of land near Market-street Station, the property of General Wright, who, Thomas claimed, had given him permission to occupy the land until they should meet again. General Wright was drowned on the ill-fated Brother Jonathan, and upon this quasi title Thomas held possession. He was generally accounted a peaceable man, being of a religious turn, and occasionally preaching to his colored brethren. Some parties had been trying -to gain possession of a portion of the lot in question, and a man who was on the ground for some purpose was driven off lay Thomas with a shot-gun. The party thus expelled procured on his oath a warrant for the arrest of Thomas, which was placed in the hands of Officer Richardson, who proceeded to serve it. The report of a pistol coming from the house of Thomas shortly after drew a crowd to the spot, where the officer was found dead, lying on his back, his feet on the door-step and a ghastly wound in his throat, caused by a charge of shot that had severed the carotid artery producing almost instant death. It is supposed that the negro met him at the door shooting him down before he had time to defend himself
Thomas was arrested and hurried to the jail at San Leandro, as rumors of lynching were rife. The shooting was done with an old-fashioned double-barreled pistol, one barrel of which remained loaded, filled nearly to the muzzle with bullets, inferentially showing the nature of the shot that nearly decapitated the unfortunate ..officer. Richard B. Richardson had been a member of the police force of the city of 'Oakland for about three years, is described as a fine specimen of manhood, tall, and of commanding presence, and of fearless courage in the discharge of his duties. His ;S0cial qualities were on a par ' with his physique and personal popularity, and had made him a prominent candidate for the office of City Marshal. He was but thirtyfive years of age, had just built a home for himself, where, with his wife and three little ones, he was about entering upon the happiness and comfort of accruing independence, when his life was cut short by the red hand of murder.
Upon the case coming up for trial a change of venue was asked and denied, the cause being transferred from the County to the District Court; but, March 23, 1868, the death of the defendant was announced in Court, and the case dismissed in consequence.
1868. - On March 4, 1868, Henry Crieger was found murdered in the hills at the back of Haywards, for which crime a saloon-keeper of that town was apprehended on suspicion, but, on examination, no evidence was forthcoming to connect him with the deed, he was therefore discharged.
On September 20, 1868, Joseph Newell shot with a pistol Morgan Layton, from the effects of which he died on the 26th of the same month. The slayer was indicted at the January Term, 1869, tried, found guilty of manslaughter, and sentenced to five years imprisonment in the State Prison.
In this year Alameda County furnishes one of the most remarkable cases of mistaken identity on record. Sheriff Morse arrested a man named John Slack, in San Luis Obispo County, in the month of May, supposing him to have murdered, thirteen years before, a son of Don Antonio Suiiol, in the valley which bears his name. The story is thus narrated in the San Leandro Gazette, of May 30, 1868: -
" Most of the old residents about Mission San Jose, and many of our readers, will remember the circumstances of the killing of young Suftol, on account of some land difficulty; the attempted arrest by the Sheriff; the resistance of the murderer, and his escape and disappearance. This occurred in the spring of 1855. Twelve years passed, and no clue to Wilson's .whereabouts could be obtained. About a year ago, a Spaniard, who had been acquainted with the parties, while passing through the 'lower country,' saw at San Luis Obispo a man whom he took to be Wilson, and on returning informed the friends of Sunol of the fact. About two months since the matter was put into the hands of Sheriff Morse to be worked up. The Sheriff immediately set at work. He at once ascertained the whereabouts of the man, corresponded with the officers of the county, who quietly made inquiries and informed Morse of the result. Everything pointed to this man. The necessary warrant was taken out, and the Sheriff started for San Luis Obispo, to make the arrest. On making the arrest some little show of resistance was made by the father-in-law of the prisoner, but he was soon quieted. On examination of his charge the Sheriff was more confident than ever that he had his man. The description was perfect - the height, complexion, color of the hair and eyes were the same. The prisoner had the same stoop of the shoulders, downcast look, and restless eye that characterized Wilson, and the absence of a tooth from the corner of his mouth. He was brought to San Leandro and placed in jail, although he protested and insisted that his name was Slack, and not Wilson. He stated that in the spring of 1855 he was at work in the mines; that subsequently he removed to San Josd, where he was at work on a ranch till the spring of 1 860, when he went to Monterey County with a drove of cattle; and finally located in San Luis Obispo, where he resided till the time of his arrest. Upon the examination of Slack before Judge Nye, on Monday, the i8th instant, two witnesses, one a brother of the murdered man, swore positively that Slack and Wilson were the same person. Other witnesses thought they were the same, but were not positive. One of these latter was present when the murder was committed. When the prosecution closed the case seemed strong against the prisoner. The accused had three witnesses; one a Mr. Jameson, of Santa Clara County, who swore that he brought Slack across the plains from Missouri in the fall of 1854, and knew of his whereabouts in the spring of 1855, at the time the deed for which he was arrested was committed. A gentleman residing in San Francisco, named Cooksie, swore that he knew the accused in Missouri, and had known him from childhood; that his name was Slack^ and that he always bore a good character. A Mr. Eaton, living in San Francisco, testified that he knew the prisoner in the spring of 1855; that his name was Slack; that they worked together that spring in the mines at Coon Hill, between Mud Springs and Diamond Springs, near Placerville, El Dorado County; that he had met Slack in Santa Clara in i860. When the defense closed the prosecution asked for a postponement until the following Saturday, for the purpose of procuring the atten- dance of an important witness, whose wherealiouts had been ascertained since the commencement of the examination. The motion was granted. On the reopening of the examination on Saturday, two other witnesses were examined for the prosecution. One testified that this was the man Wilson. A woman who was called as a witness said that the prisoner was not Wilson; that Wilson had lost two front teeth; that she knew they were front teeth from the fact that on one occasion in conversation Wilson told her that he had lost his teeth in a fight with a grizzly bear, but did not know whether they were from the upper or lower jaw, or from the front or the corner of the mouth. The former witness had sworn that Wilson had lost one or two teeth. The prisoner showed that he had had a tooth pulled, about a year before, at San Luis Obispo. After the summing up by the respective attorneys, Judge Nye decided that the evidence was insufficient, and discharged the prisoner."
On the night of June 29, 1868, another bloody affray occurred, a circumstance which would appear to have beein more than ordinarily common in this year. It would appear that two Mexicans, named Lazra Higuerra and Rafael Altamareno, got into a dispute over a game of cards in Laddsville, Murray Township, and from words came to blows, when the former drew a knife and made a deadly assault upon the latter, cutting him about the face and almost severing his arm above the elbow. At this stage Agatone Ruis interfered, telling Higuerra not to kill Altamareno, but so infuriated was he that he turned upon Ruis, who was compelled to shoot him in self-defense, three shots taking effect, one through the breast, another through the arm, and the third through the neck, causing him to become so weak that he could not be removed by Sheriff Morse.
Another affair of this nature occurred at Laddsville, about a month later, under the following circumstances: On Sunday, August 9, 1868, a man named Hyde, a desperate character, came into Ladd's Hotel, in the Livermore Valley, and demanded a drink, but being already under the influence of liquor, he was refused the beverage he sought by the proprietor. He then stepped behind the counter, and seizing a large water-pitcher struck Ladd on the head, cutting an ugly gash upon the temple. This blow he followed with another from a lager-beer-jug. Ladd, however, managed to grapple with him, but being no match for so powerful an adversary was thrown down to the ground and held there. At this juncture the bar-keeper of the establishment came upon the scene, but failing in his endeavors to separate the combatants, proceeded to procure assistance, which he found in the person of J:wo Mexicans, with whom he returned. As they entered, the report of two pistols was heard, and on pullmg Hyde off Ladd, they found he held a pistol in one hand, his finger on the trigger, and Ladd clutching it by the njiddle. Hyde was found to be shot in the abdomen, and, from the effects of the wound, died on the following day. During an examination into the cause of the man's death before Justice Kottinger, Ladd stated that after being struck with the pitcher, he remembered nothing until the firing of the pistol brought him to his senses, and then he thought that he himself was the victim of the shot. A statement was made by another who had that day heard Hyde say he would " have a man for his supper" that night, and went into Ladd's house with the deliberate mtention of killing Ladd, who, when he was down.^had turned away the muzzle from his own breast towards that of Hyde, when the latter pulling the trigger shot himself, Ladd's hand being considerably lacerated by the powder. The death having been the result of a scuffle in self-defense, Ladd of course was discharged. The man Hyde is he whom we have shown above killed the mulatto barber named Manley, at Mission San Jos^ in October, 1866.
An attempt was made on the 6th October of this year, by two men named Jackson and Mann, who were in prison, to escape, in doing which they ineffectually tried to overpower Under Sheriff Borein, who, however, made a determined resistance, and whose cries fortunately brought assistance. Mr. Borein managed to keep firm hold of Jackson, but Mann contrived to get clear, but was soon captured. The story goes that among the prominent pursuers was District Attorney Gilchrist, who seized an old pistol, the same with which Thomas had shot Officer Richardson in Oakland. When Mann beheld the noble attorney arm-ed with an old pistol, which had probably not been loaded for many years, he cried out with fear and trembling - " Don't shoot; for God's sake, don't shoot!" Thus he was taken, and the normal quiet of the prison and the excited community restored.
On September 20, 1868, two men named Lighton and Newell had a dispute over a dog-fight, in Castro Valley, at the rear of Haywards, Eden Township, when the latter shot the former through the head with a pistol, causing a wound from the effects of which he died on the 26th of the same month. Newell immediately thereafter mounting a horse escaped. So soon as this discovery was made the indefatigable Harry Morse was on his track, accompanied by Constable Morehouse (now a member of the State Board of Equalization). The extent of the search made for the murderer may be imagined when we mention that upwards of two hundred miles of country were covered. To no avail they ransacked the coal-mines of Contra Costa and Alameda. After being absent for a considerable period they returned and now heard of Newell's whereabouts in the southern country and were once more in chase. Following him through deserts and over sierras, sometimes hearing of him, and again losing all trace of him, they at last came across the decomposed remains of his defunct quadruped, and subsequently met the man himself flying false colors as a workman on the Los Angeles and Anaheim Railroad. The Sheriff arrived with him at San Leandro on the 7th November, where he was lodged in prison, subsequently tried, convicted, and sentenced to six years imprisonment in the State Prison.
1869. - Early in this year another shooting affair occurred at Laddsville, but one which showed no criminal intent. A man named John Alty shot a Spaniard who was trying to force an entrance one night into a stable where he slept. He told him several times to go away, which he declined to do, he then shot him, the ball taking effect in one of the arms, and in a few days he died from the effects of the wound. Alty, after giving bail to appear, was dismissed by the Grand Jury.
A notorious desperado and thief, named S. F. Robinson, was arrested by Sheriff Morse, on April 5, 1869, in Palmyras Cafion, on the charge of stealing a set of harness from the barn of Thomas Livingston, San Lorenzo; while on June 6th, Patrick Glancy was arrested on a warrant from the Coroner's Court, dated the same day, for causing the death of Robert Lightbody, but what the result of this was, farther than he was admitted to bail in one thousand dollars, we have been unable to trace. The same remark bears on the case of Jesus Paredas and two others, names unknown, who were indicted January 7, 1870, for entering the house of Joshua Wahab, on the evenmg o October 5, 1869, and severely wounding him with a pistol.
1870. - In the month of May of this year. Sheriff Morse, accompanied by Constable Morehouse, captured a Californian named Jesus Tejada, who had been charged with being a participant in a dreadful crime in San Joaquin County, about twenty miles from Stockton, on December 9, 1869. He and a number of others, belonging to the same band, brutally and in cold blood, mtirdered a man named Frank Medina, an Italian store-keeper, his clerk, two Mexicans, and a ne^ro on the occasion referred to, and then escaped. Sheriff Morse was commissioned with the arrest. About the latter part of April he received information that led him to believe that Tejada, one of the murderers, was encamped with a band of outlaws in the mountains, about one hundred miles south of Ellis Station, and with his companion started in pursuit. They found the band alluded to, but could not identify their man, and had tq return. Subsequently, having received further information, they again proce2ded to effect the arrest and in the night-time made a descent upon the outlaws' hiding-place, when within a few hundred yards of the spot where Tejada and four companions were sleeping, the officers came upon a sentinel that had been posted to warn the sleepers of the approach of danger. The sentry, on perceiving the officers, started for the tree where the murderer lay in the arms of Morpheus, but the Sheriff and his aids overhauled him before he could give the alarm. Creeping up softly, they got within a few feet of the party, and getting their rifles in position called upon them to surrender. Tejada in surprise and consternation threw up his hands, evidently aware that he was the object sought. He was handcuffed and the officers took him off, leaving the others to their reflections. Tejada wa? about twenty-four years of age, and six feet in height.
Another life was sacrificed on July 27, 1870, on this occasion at the Haywards Trotting Park; the victim and principal being two youthful jockeys. It would appear that they were skylarking or playing when Charles Roos drew a pistol and shot John McCue through the head, for which he was tried at the following session of the County Court and acquitted, the grounds taken being that the shooting had no malicious intent. Of this case the Grand Jury for the September term, 1870, in their report speak in the following words: "The Grand Jury cannot but feel the hardship imposed by their finding against the boy Charles Roos, for murder in the second degree While the evidence by which we were compelled to decide this case, left no alternative to our action, we cannot but observe a serious deficiency in our criminal law> which threatens not only the punishment of mature felons, but a child of the tender age of from twelve to fourteen years, whose education has been neglected and who needs instruction and information rather than punishment. The hardening companionship of the State Prison can only confirm him in a life-long career of crime. Such cases ought to be sent to an Industrial School; and since the abolition of the institution formerly located at Marysville, we would suggest that the next Legislature be called upon to make some other provision for the reformation of juvenile offenders throughout the State."
On July 17, 1870, John Ignacio was killed by Joaquin Silva, who was indicted on the 23d September, but there are no documents on file to show whether he was convicted or not. '
The following diabolical deed, illustrative of the blood-thirsty character of the Indian, which occurred in Washington Township, is gathered from the columns of the Alameda County Gazette, of November 12, 1870: "On the evening of Thursday, the loth instant, an Indian woman, supposed to be insane, named Anistaba, killed her daughter, aged ten years, the child of a 'greaser' (who was himself killed about three years ago at Gilroy), and a man named Cohuacho, a native of Sonora, Mexico, aged about forty years. The killing was done with an ax, in a house near the Alviso hills, where the woman had been put by her Indian friends for safe-keeping, and the man, Cohuacho, set to watch her. From the surroundings it appears that the woman took the man by surprise, in the house, his head being chopped and smashed to a jelly. The body of the little girl was found in a swamp near by, with the head mangled in the same way as the man's. Dr. Yates, who held the inquest upon the bodies, says the sight was an exceedingly horriblie one. After the killing the woman wandered from the house, and was not found until the following Friday evening; she was then discovered at an Indian house, at Baylis' Mills. When she presented herself to the inmates of this house she appeared to be drunk. Her head was covered with gashes, more than a dozen in number, which were evidently self-inflicted, and her clothes clotted with blood from head to foot. Constable Trefry, of Centreville, lodged the woman in the County Jail yesterday morning, to which she was committed by the acting Justice. Since the commission of the crime she has acted as a perfectly sane person, except when she first appeared at the house at the mills. Before the arrest she acknowledged the murder, and gave as her motive a desire to kill herself, as she had no way of making her living. Violent deaths run among these people - the last husband of this woman having been killed, a few weeks ago, in a drunken row, by an Indian." At the January terra of the County Court, 1871, Anistaba was duly indicted, and the cause transferred to the Third District Court.
On November 11, 1870, Joaquin Augusta was convicted of murder in the second degree and sentenced to eleven years in the State Prison, but who his victim was the records do not show, the only documents on file being a copy of the judgment and a subpoena.
1871. - On the evening of January 10, 1871, ex-Supervisor Thomas Scott, a storekeeper at Sunol, and several other persons, among them Otto Ludovisci, Mr. Scott's clerk, were sitting in the store engaged in conversation. The place is a wild-looking, lonesome locality, and as there were many lawless characters prowling about the neighborhood, the doors of the store were usually kept locked after dark, and customers who visited the establishment for supplies had only to rap to gain admittance. Some time during the evening mentioned above, a knock was heard at the front door. It was answered by the clerk, who, upon opening it, was confronted by three men, among whom was a notorious Mexican named Juan Soto, with bandages over the lower part of their faces to disguise themselves. They entered, and, paying no attention to the other inmates, attacked the clerk and shot him, inflicting a wound from which he died shortly afterwards. The murderers at once cleared out, and being all well mounted escaped pursuit, but before leaving helped themselves to sixty-five dollars in cash from the till. On the next day Harry Morse was at their heels. He first proceeded to San Jose, visited the New Almaden Mines, scoured the country as far south as the Pacheco Pass, and penetrated into Meroed County, but with no success. However, a colony of Mexicans, all armed and desperate characters, had been discovered in the Panoche Mountains by Sheriff Harris, of Santa Clara, and from among their number had taken an escaped convict from his county. This information he imparted to Sheriff Morse, but in the mean time the band had dispersed. Intelligence, however, was soon received by Morse of the whereabouts of some of the gang, and, therefore, without delay, accompanied by Sheriff Harris and Constable Winchell, of San ]us6, and a small party of trusty men, he made for the Panoche Mountains. The exact position having been obtained from certain guides procured, three houses, near to each other, wherein they lay, were pointed out, therefore it became necessary to divide the party, to make a search so that all within should be arrested. . Accompanied by Winchell, Morse proceeded into one of the houses, unfortunately, however, leaving his Henry rifle slung on the horn of his saddle, and there found, seated at a table with three others, Juan Soto, the murderer of Ludovisci. He was unprepared for so sudden a rencontre, but determined at once to secure his man, therefore, drawing his revolver, he called upon the Mexican to "throw up his hands,'' covering him with his pistol as he spoke. No response came to this command. Thrice was it repeated and thrice was it defiantly ignored. Morse now, keeping his. eye steadily fixed upon the murderer, produced a pair of handcuffs, which, throwing- upon the table, he directed his companion to place upon Soto's wrists; but at this critical moment a large, muscular female sprang from behind upon the Sheriff, seized his right arm in a vise-like grip, his left was clutched by a man who was near, while, quick as thought, seeing Morse thus encumbered, Soto leapt from where he stood at bay to a position behind a companion and drew his pistol. Minutes now became momentous, and a struggle for life lay before the officers. With a prodigious effort Morse threw off his assailants, and fired his pistol at the bandit's head, but only carried away his hat. Juan now retaliated. The Sheriff thereupon made a dash for the door, succeeded in making a safe exit, but on turning a corner found himself looking down the barrel of his opponent's pistol. Both now discharged their weapons at each other, the outlaw's shot being in advance, and how he missed is strange, for he was reputed a "dead shot." Four times were shots exchanged without a casualty, but now a bullet from Morse's revolver struck that of Soto, which it is believed so numbed his arm that he at once made for the house.
While beating this hasty retreat, Winchell appeared on the scene, armed with a double-barreled shot-gun, heavily loaded ' with shot, and commenced a fusilade upon the vanishing figure of the outlaw, but without effect. Morse then ran for and secured his Henry rifle. In the interval Soto had been indulging in a little habilitation, in the shape of putting his blue soldier's overcoat on the back of a companion. This effected, both ran for a saddled horse, hitched to a tree standing opposite the house, and Sheriff Harris was about to fire at the blue-coated runner, when he was hailed by Moi'se, that a ruse had been perpetrated, and thus checked his fire. Fate seemed to be against the bandit on that fatal 12th of May. At the juncture last mentioned Soto's horse broke away from him, and while in the act of running to another, which stood ready at a little distance, a bullet from Morse's "Henry" hit his right shoulder. With this he turned around with demoniacal resolve in his eyes. Holding a revolver in either hand he boldly advanced to meet his enemy, the Sheriff. This was no time for parley : Morse raised his rifle, a cloud of smoke, a report, and the desperado lay stretched upon the ground shot through the brain, and once more was the gallows cheated of its proper prey.
The entire party of desperadoes was afterwards captured, at their headquarters, close by, and among them was found the notorious cattle-thief, Gonzales, who had escaped from the Santa Cruz prison only a short time previously.
Soto, as we have already stated, was a large and powerful man, a complete type of the traditional Mexican bandit, with long, black hair, heavy, bushy eyebrows, large eyes of an undefined color, with, altogether, a tigerish aspect. He had served two terms in the State Prison, and was generally regarded as the most formidable and desperate character living on this coast. He was known to all the Mexican inhabitants in the lower counties, and was held in such dread that few or none of them dared to offend him or make known his hiding-places. It appears that, like many other celebrated men of his class, he at length fell a victim to the ruling passion of mankind, having come from the rendezvous to visit certain seductive seiioritas in that secluded valley, where he had the ill-luck to encounter the redoubtable and vengeful Harry Mor.se. The rest of the gang had returned to headquarters, leaving the hapless chieftain to the society of his lady-love. It must be said for the dare-devil of the mountains that he made one of the most gallant fights on record, and fell in a conflict with a foeman worthy of his lion-like courage. The Sheriff, having secured his splendid black horse, and his three formidable revolvers, left him to be buried by his Mexican friends, who through the fight manifested very little excitement, and seemed to regard the bloody work as an incident of their wild life. The old women made some little outcry, but the girls manifested the utmost composure.
Too much praise cannot be awarded to Sheriff Morse for this capture. In it he distinguished himself by one of the most desperate and daring acts that has ever been performed in the history of detective work on the Pacific Coast, and his own life was preserved only by the manifestation of astonishing self-possession and presence of mind. It so happened that circumstances placed him in the focus of danger, out of reach of his companions, where he had to rely wholly upon that steadfast courage and steadiness of nerve which have given him deserved celebrity among the foremost detective officers of the country. He had previously been through many perilous adventures among tlje more desperate characters of California, but we suppose this hand-to-hand and long-continued conflict with the chief of the brigands was the most exciting and desperate of all.
In regard to the foregoing it may be mentioned that during the month of March, 1873, one Bartolo Sepulveda, against whom there had been a warrant out for two years, accusing him of being concerned in the murder of Ludovisci, came to San Leandro and delivered himself up to Sheriff Morse, demanding a trial to exonerate himself from the charge. He was duly indicted, twice tried, and sentenced by Judge McKee to imprisonment for life in the State Prison.
On January i6, 1871, a man named Hiscock, a hunter, was murdered hy Ramon Amador, near Pleasanton, Murray Township. Amador had beguiled his victim into the chaparral in search of deer that the scoundrel had informed him were in that neighborhood, when, being previously possessed of a gun belonging to Hiscock, he deliberately discharged its contents into the back and head of his victim. After a vigilant search he was captured, and admitted the killing, but said it was in selfdefense. Amador was duly indicted, tried, July 20th, found guilty, and sentenced to be hanged, which was carried into execution September 9, 1871.
On February 17, 1871, a man named Zelbtus Reed was shot and killed by F. W. Clarke, at a ranch in the foot-hills near Ocean View, about seven miles from Oakland, in the township of that name. The following statement of the crime is taken from the columns of the Oakland News: For a long time past the case of Gustave Mahe vs. John Reynolds has been progressing, involving the title of about eighteen settlers to a portion of the Peralta Rancho, at Cardoneces Creek, commonly known as the Williamson property. Final judgment was at last obtained, and a writ of assistance was issued and placed in the hand of Sheriff Morse for service. In many instances the settlers acknowledged the title that had been judicially established and took leases of the property they had occupied, which were given on nominal terms. One of those who refused to recognize the title was the deceased, Reed, and by .virtue of the writ of assistance the Sheriff ejected him and placed H. K. W. Clarke, the actual owner, in possession. Mr. Clarke, in turn, placed his son, F. W. Clarke,, a young man about twenty-seven years of age, in charge of the premises. When Reed was ejected, on Thursday (February i6th), he said that he was " prepared to shed his blood; that it should flow as freely as water," etc., in the presence of Mr. Clarke and his son. They were at the time informed that Reed was a dangerous mar(^ as we learn from the friends of young Clarke. At the time of the ejectment a large quantity of personal property belonging to Reed was on the premises, and he was told to come the next day and take it off On Friday he went to the premises occupied by Clarke and proceeded to load on his wagon the property belonging to him, and which he had permission to remove. He was told to put it all on the wagon and not to return. He paid no attention to this, except to reply that he would do as he pleased. About half-past two in the afternoon he approached the premises in a wagon, he being seated, but a man of the name of Charles Huntsman was standing. When about to enter the inclosure Clarke told them to keep off, saying that he had possession and would not be disturbed in it. Reed entered a portion of the premises and occupied a small building in defiance of Clarke, saying that he was able to take care of himself and could shoot as well as anybody else. They told him to shoot if he wanted to, and continued their course. Clarke had a four-barreled Sharpe's pistol, and he discharged the contents of one of the barrels, probably at Huntsman, no harm being done. Three other shots were fired, and two of them took effect on Reed, who fell back, saying, "I am killed!" Huntsman immediately summoned the nearest physician, hastened to Oakland and notified the police, who apprehended Clarke and a man named C. F. Waite, who was with him. Reed, who was shot through the heart, was a middle-aged, single man, who had made his home with Williamson, working for his board, for several years, and is represented to have been usually quiet and peaceable.
Justice Lentell held a Coroner's inquest on the body of the deceased on the following Saturday, when the accompanying verdict was returned: -
We, the undersigned, the jurors summoned to appear before James Lentell, acting Coroner of the county of Alameda, on the l8th day of February, 1871, to inquire into the cause of the death of Zelotus Reed, who was killed on Williamson's Ranch, having been duly sworn according to law, and having made such inquisitions, after inspecting the body and hearing the testimony adduced, upon our oath, each and all do say that we find the deceased was named Zelotus Reed, aged about forty-six or forty-seven years; that he came to his death on the 17th day of February, 1871, in this county; and we further find that we believe F. W^ Clarke to be the person by whose act the death of the said Zelotus Reed was occasioned, by shooting him, the said Reed, with pistolshot, killing him; and we further believe that Charles F. Waite was accessory thereto; all of which we duly certify by this inquisition in writing, by us signed this 1 8th day of February, 1871.
On February 2 1st, a preliminary examination was had before Judge Jayne of the Police Court, Oakland, which continued for no less than five days, there being a great amount of legal talent arrayed on the contending sides. The prosecution was conducted by District Attorney Wright, aided by City Attorney Havens, Zach Montgomery, and W. W. Foote; the defense being in the hands of Harvey S. Brown, Blake & Van Voorhies, W. H. Glascock, and Alexander Campbell. At the conclusion of the inquiry, Judge Jayne delivered the following judgment: -
I have listened attentively to every word of the testimony, and have studied over it by night as well as by day, and can come to a conclusion now. I find from the evidence adduced in the examination, that a crime- has been committed as charged in the complaint, and that there is sufficient cause' to believe the defendant, Frederick W. Clarke, guilty thereof. It is ordered that he be committed to the Sheriff of Alameda County. In regard to the defendant, Waite, I considered his evidence against himself to be the clearest of all the evidence brought forward, except as to the statement by Huntsman that he saw him show a weapon before the shooting. He does not seem to attempt to screen his friend. I am constrained to believe that he has narrated the transaction as he believes it to be. I believe that he has told the truth. There is no evidence to charge him with being accessory. He is therefore discharged.
On February 28, 1871, Clarke was brought before Judge Crockett of the Supreme Court upon a writ of habeas corpus, when the prisoner was admitted to bail in the sum of thirty thousand dollars, and at the following term of the County Court in April, 1871, the case was submitted to a Grand Jury composed of W. G. Hunt, Foreman; Robert Carr, C. P. Hanson, F. Garcia, F. Devoll, C. B. Rutherford, A. Chabot, J. A. Folger, E, Gallagher, Fred. Runkle, David Scully, W. A. Bray, H. F. Shepardson, W. Benitz, who ignored the bill, whereupon the defendant was discharged and his bail exonerated.
This decision of the Grand Jury produced mark-;d wonder among citizens; their conduct was vehemently denounced by the press, and the District Attorney, S. P. Wright, was loudly condemned. In refutation he appeared in print answering his traducers. He stated that the case for the people had been presented in as clear and lucid a manner as it well could be; that they had the testimony untrammeled of a large number of witnesses that the defendant.produced before the committing magistrate, as to the general reputation of the deceased. He observed : "When I left the Grand Jury-room, and as I was closing the door after me, I heard some one of the Grand Jurors say, 'I move to ignore the bill;' and, hearing such a motion as that, I felt
The District Attorney forthwith applied to the Court for an order to resubmit the case to another Grand Jury, there appearing in favor of the application, Mr. Wright, and against it, Harvey S. Brown, H. K. W. Clarke, William Van Voorhies, and George M. Blake. Judge Nye, in his decision stated that the points in favor of the motion made by the District Attorney were not sustained, but the Judge discovered a point not there raised, viz., that the jury erred in listening to the testimony of the defendant, Clarke, and remarks in the opinion, after quoting from the Criminal Practice Act:
The defendant then becomes a competent witness only after indictment found or complaint made or other proceedings instituted, and the issue of fact made by a plea interposed and upon trial of the issue. Wherefore, the Grand Jury erred in hearing the defendant as a witness.
It is suggested that the latter point was not made by the prosecution and no argument had thereon, and that the resubmission be had without argument as to that point, and some showing formerly made by the District Attorney. Reserving a decision on this point, I will permit the District Attorney to make such showing further as he may see fit, and hear arguments thereon on the first day of the next term, Court -being now about to adjourn.
At this subsequent term Judge Nye made an order resubmitting the case to the Grand Jury, from which the defendant appealed to the Supreme Court, who held that the order was not appealable. The case was again submitted by the County Judge, when the defendant sued out a writ of review before Judge Dwinelle, who held the case for about two years without rendering a decision, until the press and the public became so clamorous about it that he at length dismissed the writ and the case went before another Grand Jury, which in turn also ignored the bill.
Of this cause ceiebre, Mr. Halley, who edited a paper in Oakland about this time, says: "There was a great deal of feeling in this case, not only in Alameda County, but outside of it. It was presumed that the wealth of the accused and his social position had much to do with his escape; it was charged that he received the favor of the legal fraternity; that his father was a lawyer; that members of the judiciary became his bondsmen; that the Supreme Court Judges favored him; that all the land-grabbers in the country gathered around him; that Horace W. Carpentier had used his wealth and influence unsparingly for his protection; and all because the man who was slain had in his capacity, as a settler on some disputed lands in Contra Costa County, rendered himself obnoxious to these parties in defending his own and his neighbors' rights against their encroachments.
" Much space is given here to this celebrated case, because it is looked upon as one to be ever held up as an example, showing the danger to life and liberty, even under our free and popular system of government, when certain influences are allowed to be exercised. Indeed, the whole affair is looked upon as marvelous, and such as not to be credited only that the evidence of it is so recent, and all the facts are so patent, with what assiduity and ability the mind must have worked and the hand directed, that produced such extraordinary results and defeated justice, shielding a a culprit and threw the darkest shades of suspicion on the machinery of the law!"
We are sorry to state that later on it will be our painful duty to once more refer to F. W. Clarke, upon whom suspicion rested as having been in some manner concerned in the death- of a relative.
And yet another homicide occurred in the year 1871. On the 26th of March, WiUiam Powers, in a drunken quarrel that occurred on the Haas place, about six miles east of Haywards, " on the divide," stabbed and killed a Norwegian named Nelson Larsen. At the Coroner's inquest held before Justice of the Peace Graham, the jury returned the following verdict in accordance with the facts adduced : -
We the undersigned, convened as jurors to hold an inquest on a dead body, do find as follows, viz. -. That the body is that of one Larsen; that his age was about forty-seven years; nativity, Norway; and that he came to his death on the 26th of March, at Haas' Ranch, in Eden Township, from a wound inflicted by a knife in the hands of one William Powers.
At the April term of the County Court, 1871, the murderer was tried, convicted, and sentenced to thirteen years imprisonment in the State Prison.
On June 15, 1871, a man who went by the name of " Dutch Frank" ahas Michael Frendar , shot and killed Edward Lavin, on the Dublin Road, in Eden Vale, about a mile and a half from Haywards: The cause of quarrel between the men, who were neighbors, was a trivial one, and may be shortly described as follows : Frendar had accused Lavin's son of stealing one of his chickens, and caught him roughly, when his father went to the rescue. Taking hold of Frendar he stigmatized him as " an old thief," following the expression with coarse and abusive language, finally striking him on the neck. With an imprecation Frendar raised a gun which he carried, and fired at Lavin, who staggering fell, and while falling received another shot from Frendar. The culprit gave himself up to the authorities, was subsequently tried, found guilty of murder in the second degree on July 21st, and sentenced to fifteen years imprisonment in San Quentin, but in 1872 was pardoned.
On July 23, 1871, John Dorsey shot and killed Edward Donahue at Mission San Jose. He was indicted at the September term of the County Court, found guilty of murder in the second degree, and on November 15th, sentenced to thirteen years imprisonment in the State Prison.
This slaying was followed by another shooting affair which took place near Livermore, Murray Township, on Sunday, July 30, 1871, when a man named Bradley desperatelj? wounded another named Knuckles. To elude his creditors the former had placed a .sum of money in the hands of the latter, which he refused to refund, upon which Bradley deliberately shot him in the lower jaw, tearing away the entire chin and ripping the flesh down close to the windpipe.
We have alluded to a shooting affair that occurred in Alameda, in the history of that township, in September, 1871, therefore it will be unnecessary to do more than refer to it in this place.
It apjjearing to the Court that the Grand Jury have found and presented herein a true bill of Indictment for Murder against said defendant. It is ordered that the Clerk transmit said Indictment to the Clerk of the District Court in and for the county of Alameda.
It will be remembered that the shooting of A. P. Crittenden took place on the ferry-boat during its passage across the bay, and upon the question of jurisdiction it was decided to have taken place within the limits of the city and county of San Francisco, the cause being accordingly transferred thither.
1872. - On March 6, 1872, William Steele was placed on trial at San Leandro for the murder of Silverio Monjas, on a change of venue, when he was returned not guilty. The circumstances of the case we will now relate.
Of this affair the Contra Costa Gazette, of July 8, 1871, has the following: "During the past week or more, the people of the central portion of the county have been intensely excited by occurrences growing out of the disputed ownership and possession of a certain portion of the Moraga grant, about which there has been much litigation and contention for several years. The land in question is claimed on one side by Isaac Yoakum, and on the other by members of the Moraga family. Some two months or more ago the Sheriff, by writ of the District Court, was directed to put Yoakum in possession of the lands then occupied by a portion of the Moraga family, but he had, as is claimed, no authority in executing the writ, to remove and dispossess such of the Moraga children as were not named in the instrument, and he refused to do so. Yoakum, or his agent, as is said, refusing at the time to accept possession unless all the Moragas and their personal effects were removed. Yoakum subsequently, however, went into occupancy of the portion of the premises to which the writ entitled him; and the Moragas remained in possession as the Sheriff had left them, of a portion of the land claimed by Yoakum, and to which, as we understand, he would have been entitled under the judgment of the Court, but for an error of omission in the complaint in action, upon which the judgment was rendered in his favor. From this situation of affairs, both parties claiming and believing they had legal and equitable rights which they were justified in asserting and defending, much heat and bitterness of feeling has arisen, and several serious collisions have occurred to the imminent peril of life on both sides. Some time early in May several rifle-shots were fired at one of the Moragas, and the horse he was riding was killed by a man in the employ of Yoakum, named William Steele, who was at that time, together with one of the Yoakum boys, under one thousand dollar bonds to answer before the Grand Jury of the county.
"Since that time the temper of the hostile parties has not imprpved, and threatening demonstrations and preparations have been made on both sides, with no very serious results, however, until last Saturday (July ist) when Silverio Monjas, one of the Moraga party, was shot by William Steele, as he affirms, in self-defense. On the previous day there had been a collision between the parties and a good deal of shooting. In the mil^e, one of the Moraga girls was struck with a gun and severely hurt by Mr. Yoakum, and the horse he was riding was fatally shot. Reports of these occurrences spread rapidly about the county, and created a degree of excitement and manifestations of indignation seldom produced in our usually quiet and moderate community; and the excitement and indignation reached a higher pitch on Saturday, after the shooting of Monjas, threatening to culminate in a vengeful outbreak against the Yoakum party. In the heat of the excitement many intemperate and improper charges and threats were made, which a cooler judgment and a fuller knowledge of facts would not justify.
"Sheriff Brown was on the ground shortly after the shooting of Monjas, on Saturday, and, on the information of Yoakum, found and arrested Steele. Yoakum voluntarily offered to surrender himself to the Sheriff for examination before any competent magistrate, upon any charge that might be preferred against him, and accompanied the Sheriff -to Walnut Creek, where, on finding Justice Slitz was absent, they proceeded to Pacheco, and, on reaching that place, found that Justice Ashbrook was also from home. Yoakum here declined to accompany the officer farther, though he offered to give his word or bond for appearance, whenever, and for whatever purpose required. As the Sheriff had no warrant or authority whatever for detaining him, he was allowed to go; and the Sheriff has been highly censured therefor, but, so far as we can see, without the slightest good reason."
Monjas, who was shot by Steele, died about three o'clock on Saturday morning,, and a Jury of Inquest, summoned and sworn on Sunday by Justice Allen, continued their inquiries until Monday evening, when the inquest was adjourned to ten o'clock,. Saturday morning, at Walnut Creek.
Steele was brought before Justice Ashbrook for examination on Thursday; the People in the conduct of the case were represented by District Attorney Mills, and the defendant by Judge Blake, of Oakland. The examination was concluded on Friday afternoon, and Steele was held to answer for murder without admission to bail.
He was brought before Justice Ashbrook, of Pacheco, on July loth, to answer to the charge of assault with a deadly weapon, with intent to commit bodily injury upon the person of Gunecinda Moraga, in Moraga Valley, on June 30, 1871. On motion of Judge Warmcastle, acting for District Attorney Mills, the charge was modified to one of assault and battery. The defendant, contrary to the expressed desire of the Court and the prosecution, objected to trial of the charge by jury, and in deference to his objection the case was tried without a jury. The trial occupied the greater part of the loth and nth. The defendant conducted the case in his own behalf, assisted by a young lady, his daughter, who wrote out the testimony as given in by the witnesses. The evidence produced clearly sustained the charge, and established that the defendant had proved an aggravated assault upon the Moraga girl, striking her twice with his gun and inflicting severe hurts upon her person, while, at request of his herder, she and her sister were assisting him to drive the defendant's sheep away from the inclosure held by the Moraga family. Yoakum was found guilty and fined five hundred dollars, but gave notice of appeal.
Monjas, Isaac Yoakum was brought before Justice Wood, of Da nville, on July 24th, being continued till the 27th, and at the conclusion of the examinat ion was held upon bail of three thousand dollars to answer to the charge.
Steele was tried and disposed of as mentioned above; and then held on another charge of assault with intent to murder Joaquin Moraga on April 13, 1871, when the plaintiff had his horse shot under him. The defendant was liberated on bail, to appear at the next session of the Court on this charge. The case was tried in the April term of the County Court, and the prisoner found guilty. He was sentenced to pay a fine of five hundred dollars, or be imprisoned at the rate of two dollars a day until paid.
On April 25, 1872, Rodendo alias Procopio, one of the most noted and desperate cattle-thieves that ever infested Alameda County, was convicted of the larceny of a cow. His counsel asking until the 3d of May, for time to show cause why a new trial should be granted, but which was denied after lengthy argument on that day. Procopio was sentenced to ten years' imprisonment in San Quentin'
Tomaso Rodendo alias Procopio, the above-mentioned bandit, a nephew of the celebrated Joaquin Murietta, was suspected of being connected with the murder of John Rains, in Los Angeles, in 1859. He escaped from thence and came to Alameda County. In 1863 he was arrested for the murder of the Golden family in Alameda, his accomplices being supposed to have been Narcisco Borjorques and Celano Ortego. In attempting to arrest Borjorques Sheriff Morse shot him off his horse, but he escaped to the bushes. An account of this event will be found in the history of Murray Township. Afterward he was killed in the lower country. Some time subsequently Tomaso Rodendo was arrested in Alameda County for cattle-stealing. When apprehended he shot the Constable and got away, swimming the stream with his pistol in his mouth, persons shooting at him the while. He was subsequently captured and sent to the State Prison for seven years, his time expiring in 1870. As soon as he was set free he was suspected, and not without reason, of being connected with all the daring mail robberies in the lower counties, and had become a terror to the entire State. His seizure was effected in a restaurant in Morton Street, San Francisco, and when taken had two pistols in his belt, so arranged that he could easily draw them. When he observed two officers entering the front door he made a motion to draw a pistol, but turning about and seeing himself covered by pistols at che other door, he submitted to fate. Procopio is described as an ugly-looking desperado, over six feet high, and known to most of the Sheriffs in California.
In the month of March of this year Ah Sam, convicted of assault to murder in 1867, and sentenced to ten years' imprisonment, and William Hoffman, who received five years for grand larceny, were pardoned.
1873. - On August 12, Sebastian Flores killed Francisco Garcia near the house of Senor Higuerra, at the Warm Springs, Washington Township. It would appear that each had borne the other a grudge for a long time, and meeting at a wake held over the body of a young Spanish girl at the place stated above, a slight difficulty occurred between them during the evening. At about ten o'clock they left the house and went a short distance together down a road, where another altercation took place between them, and Garcia received a wound from which he died on the 2ist of September. When found he lay on the ground with his throat cut. After several days' trial and an elaborate charge by Judge McKee, the jury brought in a verdict of manslaughter, the prisoner being sentenced on the 2ist November, 1873, to five years, imprisonment in the State Prison.
1874. - In this year the famous Harry Morse started on an unsuccessful hunt after the noted bandit, Tiburcio Vasquez, "but," says the News, " newspaper correspondents were too much for the hunters to contend with, for although Morse traveled by unfrequented trails, avoiding public highways and human habitations, thS enterprising ' gatherer up of unconsidered trifles ' kept in his wake and wafted by telegraph to the whole country the whereabouts of the searchers. Vasquez had thus been kept better posted about the movements of his pursuers than the public had been." The robber was captured, however, a few days after, May 14, 1874, by Major Mitchell's party, not far from Los Angeles. The daring deeds of Tiburcio Vasquez, the wily and active bandit, whose scoundrelisms eclipse those of Joaquin Murietta, had won for him a national notoriety. He had roamed through the southern counties of the State, and apparently held rodeos of the desperadoes of his own ilk, gathering all the outcasts together under his command, and planning and plotting and executing raids upon travelers, ranches, and towns. He had defied the authorities with the audacity of a Vidocq, and baffled every attempt at capture. The story of his repeated triumphs over law and order impressed many of his adventurous countrymen with the idea that he was a chosen leader in rascality, one of the anointed, and ought to be assisted with kindly encouragement in word and deed. The fellow had actually recruited his gang on several occasions with young Californians whom he enticed to the broad trail leading to distinction, by the narration of his triumphs and the practice of the seductive arts in which he seemed to abound. Several members of his gang were boys, who bore fair reputations for honesty prior to uniting their fortunes with the outlaws. Others were young men who never were promoted to the grand larceny grade until Vasquez admitted them to his advanced class of rogues. This outlaw had a notable prison record. He entered the State Prison on August 26, 1857, from Los Angeles County, having been convicted of grand larceny and sentenced to imprisonment for a space of five years, He was then only nineteen years old. He escaped June 25, 1859, and the following August was apprehended in Amador County on a charge of grand larceny. He was convicted and returned to San Quentin to serve a term of one year. The fact of his previous escape does not seem to have been taken into consideration by the Amador Court. The term of his imprisonment began January 18, 1867, when he was sent from Sonoma County for grand larceny and held for a period of four years, after which, and until the tima of his capture, he had been constantly engaged in robbing and murdering people in the southern counties.
A shocking tragedy occurred at the farm of Patrick Feeney, on the county road to Moraga Valley, about one mile and a half beyond East Oakland, on the morning of May 27, 1874, the details of which are as follows: Mr. Feeney, who lived with his wife and three small children on the farm, had at intervals for about a year previous, suffered from an affection of the brain, caused by falling on his head from a load of hay, and several months before it was thought advisable to commit him to the State Insane Asylum. His wife, however, desired to keep him at home, and as she apprehended no danger to herself or children, he was not taken before a Commission of Lunacy, as was the intention at that time.
About three o'clock on the morning mentioned above, Feeney arose from his bed, complaining that he had been unable to sleep all night, and went out of the house. He returned a few minutes afterwards, and as he entered the room in which Mrs. Feeney was lying in bed, she observed that he carefully held his hands behind him, as though enjjeavoring to conceal something from her view. His manner alarmed her, and she raised herself up in bed, and asked him what he was going to do. He simply answered " nothing," and at the same moment a hatchet fell from his hands to the floor. Mrs. Feeney, now very much frightened, and springing from the bed, begged her husband to quiet himself and to do no harm. Before she had scarcely spoken, he grasped the hatchet from the floor and rushed upon the children, who had by this time come into the room, and brandished the murderous weapon over their heads and aimed several blows at them. The mother sprang to their rescue and warding off the blows of the maniac saved their lives, but could not prevent them from receiving several cuts upon the head, none of which, however, were of a serious nature. The insane man's murderous freak seemed suddenly to leave him, for he turned and rushed from the house still retaining the bloody hatchet in his hand. Mrs. Feeney, alarmed for his safety, took her children and proceeded t6 the house of her nearest neighbor, about a quarter of a mile distant, narrated there the horrible occurrence, and besought the assistance of the inmates to find her husband. One of the men started immediately for East Oakland to summon a physician and police aid, and another proceeded to search for Feeney. After seeking some time the insane man was found, lying upon his side, with his knees drawn up to his chin, as though to bring his body into as small a space as possible, in a hollow known as Sessions' Ravine, about three hundred yards from Feeney's house. When discovered, his first words were that he was cold and wished some one to cover him up. He then asked for a drink of water, and the man went to the house to procure some for him. On his return to the spot Feeney had turned upon his back, and it was then discovered that he was shockingly wounded. His clothes were saturated with blood, and several streams of the life-current were issuing from wounds in his left breast. Constable Nedderman, of East Oakland, and Doctor Bamford arrived at this moment, and Feeney was carried into the house. Upon examination the doctor found no less than eight wounds in the left breast, which had been inflicted with a short knife, such as butchers use in skinning animals, which had been ground very sharp and pointed. Some of the stabs had evidently penetrated the left lung, as at every inhalation of the breath, air flowed with some force out from the wounds. Loss of blood had rendered the unfortunate man extremely weak. Feeney was represented as a man of temperate habits and the owner of about forty or fifty thousand dollars worth of property.
On August 4, 1874, Thomas Thornton and Edward Edwards were sentenced to thirteen years' imprisonment in San Quentin for the robbery of W. J. Keating in Oakland, on the night of May 4th. When being taken over the bay, Edwards complained of the tightness of the handcuff by which he was chained to the other prisoners, and upon examination the Sheriff found that it had cut into his flesh; he therefore loosened it one notch. The fellow returned his gratitude by quietly slipping his hand through the handcuff, and as the boat was about to leave, jumped ashore and managed to make his escape.
On the evening of Friday, December ii, 1874, San Leandro was the scene of a fearful tragedy, resulting in the death of two persons, man and wife. The circumstances of the event are thus told: Leonard Watkins, formerly a station agent and subsequently a Deputy County Clerk at San Leandro, but more recently Deputy County Clerk of Santa Clara County, shot his wife on the street in front of the old Court House, killing her instantly, and then shot himself through the head. There was no accounting for this murder, for the lady was beyond reproach, and its commission must have been the result of a disordered brain.
1875. - At the January Term, 1875, Joseph Ratto was indicted for a murderous assault upon his wife, Louisa Ratto, on October 2, 1874, and was tried, January 291 1875, found guilty, and sentenced to one year's imprisonment in the State Prison.
On April 16, 1875, a shooting affray with fatal results occurred near the farm of a Mr. McGeery, about five miles northeast of Livermore. It seems that two brothers, George and Jack McGeery, pre-empted adjoining quarter-sections which were confirmed to them. George McGeery died in the interim and his brother held his Antonio Garcia, a Spaniard, who claimed to have had previous possession, had since the death of George McGeery attempted to dispossess the brother and regain the land. The parties had been quarreling for some time, with many threats of violence on either side. On the date mentioned, as Jack McGeery Avas returning with his family, he was assaulted by Garcia and a man named Davis. He tried to escape from them, and sent his family on with a neighbor. Garcia and Davis continued to pursue, while McGeery retreated. Davis was armed with a re- -volver, and Garcia is said to have had a knife. McGeery was unarmed. Finding they could not overtake him, the pursuers mounted their horses, which were near, and stopped'McGeery near his place. Here he was knocked under the fence by one of the persons. McGeery succeeded in getting partly over the fence, when Garcia and Davis got hold of him and dragged him back. McGeery's wife then came to her husband's assistance, bringing a loaded revolver, with which the tables were quickly turned, McGeery shooting Garcia in the breast, causing death in a few moments. The Coroner's jury acquitted him, finding the killing to be justifiable.
In the April term of this year Louis Hanson was indicted for assault to murder Lizzie Hanson, his wife, on or about February 23, 1875; he was duly tried, found guilty and. May 5, 1875, sentenced to two years in the State Prison.
Joseph Newell was indicted for assault with a deadly weapon upon Thomas Harly, and July 1 5, 1875, was sentenced to nine months' imprisonment in San Quentin.
1876. - During this year Alameda County was the scene of a trial more extraordinary than which possibly never occurred in any country. Harry D. Wakefield was arraigned for having married in several States no feWer than eight wives, all of them being alive. His mother, who was a resident of East Oakland, appears to have been aware of his matrimonial ventures, for when about to commit himself to the nuptial knot for the last time, she wrote to him the following few words of caution: " Be careful that you don't get deceived again - -you know you've been deceived so often."
On the night of Friday, June 30, 1876, officer W. D. Thomas was desperately wounded by one Louis Strand, a Norwegian, at East Oakland, under the following circumstances: While Officer Thomas was strolling along East Eleventh Street, on the evening mentioned, he saw his assailant, whom he at once recognized, come along with a box upon his shoulders, but upon being seen Strand turned sharply up another street. This movement aroused the suspicion of Thomas, who knew that Herman Drucker had been moving his large stock of liquors into his new saloon on Thirteenth Avenue, near the Brooklyn railroad station, and that Strand had been working there the day before as a carpenter, and thought that he might have helped himself to a box of liquor. He accordingly walked after the retreating form until he overtook Strand, when he discovered that he had a large box filled with bottles on his shoulder. On being accosted Strand replied that the bottles in the box contained wine, with which he intended to celebrate the 4th of July. Thomas then asked him to set the box down. During this colloquy the parties had reached the corner of East Twelfth Street and Tenth Avenue, where there was a carpenter bench and a pile of lumber. There was a hatchet and a drawing-knife lying on top or among the bottles, and as Strand set the box upon the bench he picked these up. Officer Thomas noticed the movement, but thinking that it was done that he might more readily get at the contents of the box, paid no attention to it. This accommodating move and the fact that the man was a hard-working mechanic disarmed him of suspicion, and he carelessly leaned over the box to inspect its contents. As he was thus stooping over, baring the back of his neck, Strand dealt a murderous blow at him with the hatchet, with the evident intention of severing the officer's spine, or of cutting the jugular vein. Fortunately Thomas caught a glimpse of the quick movement of his antagonist and dodged, throwing up his left arm to ward off the blow. The blade of the hatchet fell heavily across the back of the left forearm about five inches back from the wrist, opening a gash three and a half inches in length and in depth to the bone from one side of the arm to the other. The blow deadened the arm and stunned the officer slightly, and before he had fairly recovered, or could get out his pistol - almost before he had time to think at all. Strand aimed another bfow at him, which struck the hand of the same arm, opening the flesh and muscles to the bone, from the junction-knuckle of the middle finger diagonally toward the base of the thumb for a distance of an inch and a half This wound, however, the officer scarcely felt, as that on the arm had already benumbed the hand. Thomas kept attempting to get his pistol, but a third blow fell heavily against his right jaw, near the point of the chin, and knocked him to his knees. Luckily he fell against the pile of lumber, and this doubtless saved his life, as the contact threw him forward upon one foot and one knee and left his pistol hand and arm free. Before the would-be assassin could advance to follow up his advantage, Thomas got his pistol out and fired, almost in his face, shooting him in the forehead. This staggered Strand and he fell back a pace or two, but for which Thomas would doubtless have killed him on the spot. The ball, however, must have struck him on the right side of the forehead, glanced over the skull and come out near the crown of the head, as indicated by two holes and blood in Strand's hat, which was left on the ground. Rallying, the assassin was about rushing upon the officer again, when Thomas fired a second shot, but it is doubtful if this took effect, but it served the purpose of saving his life, for now Strand fairly "bolted," with the officer in hot pursuit. He was duly arrested, tried at the July Term, 1876, and on August 2d sentenced to one year's imprisonment in the State Penitentiary.
It may be mentioned that on the night when the tragedy just alluded to was being acted in Brooklyn, Oakland was the scene of no less than three daring burglaries, the perpetrators of which succeeded in effecting their escape.
During the month of March, 1 876, Peter Chisholm and T. B. Mortee were employed as clerks in the office of Higgins& Conkling, stock-brokers, at 322 Montgomery Street, San Francisco. Forsome reason Mortee was discharged from his position and he accused Chisholm with being instrumental in his removal. On June 5th, together with a friend, H. La Grange, he went to Badger's Park, where the picnic of the California Theater Boat Club was being held. There he fell in with Mortee, and angry words immediately passed between them, which resulted in Chisholm's proposing that they go outside and settle their affair by fighting. Mortee objected fo this manly way of terminating the difficulty, however, and instead picked up a piece of two by three scantling, with which he struck his opponent just over the ear, crushing the skull and making a horrible wound, from which he died. The slayer claimed to have acted in selfdefense, and was held to answer before the next Grand Jury. He was duly tried, but on the jury failing to agree, was discharged March 15, 1877.
During a quarrel about a woman at Alameda on July 13, 1876, Amedee Joseph Deligne was shot by Alfred Janin; while, on the 7th August, Carlos Quinthero was sentenced to imprisonment for life in the State Prison for the murder of "Indian Jim," near Niles, on the nth of March. On August 4, 1876, the trial of Felix Polzinsky commenced in the Third District Court for the murder of a man named Joseph Kreuchefski, both being Russians. The crime was committed in the central part of the county in April, 1876, on the ranch of Mr. Sinkwitz, near Haywards. The deceased had recently rented the ranch. Soon after taking possession of the farm he suddenly disappeared. The defendant was subsequently found with some of the effects of the dead man, and some time in June the dead body was found, buried in a shallow grave on the ranch, with a bullet wound in the throat. Polzinsky admitted the killing, but claimed that the gun was accidentally discharged in a scuffle, the two men having quarreled about the measurement of some wood. He was ii^dicted on July 13, 1876, the cause being transferred to the Third District Court, and sentenced to life imprisonment, August 7, 1876.
1877. - The pistol was early at work in this year On the evening of January 19, 1877, Lewis Shearer, of San Francisco, was shot and wounded by Henry W. Kind, the affair being the result of a personal matter which need not be here reverted to.
Of an other affair that occurred in the same month the Tribune, of January 23, 1877, says: "Last spring there appeared in Oakland a Frenchman, Leon Castangauby name, claiming to have recently lived in Chicago, before that in New Orleans. Being of a jovial and convivial nature, and exceedingly liberal with his means, he soon acquired a large number of friends. He was also an expert at billiards, and became acquainted with the sporting portion of the community, by playing several public match games of billiards in this city. In the middle of July he took -charge of the Grand Central Hotel billiard-room, and it was while in that situation that he got mto the difficulty which has kept him a prisoner in the county jail for over three months. Castangau and one Henry Zweifel, a bar-keeper at the Grand Central, were m the habit of enjoying a convivial glass together, occasionally, and while liquor tended to make the excitable Frenchman still more vehement in his actions, the phlegmatic Zweifel would become stupidly prone to fits of alternate courtesy and discourtesy. On the afternoon that Cooper & Bailey's Circus gave its first exhibition in this city, Zweifel and Castangau attended that institution in company. Arriving back at the hotel after the performance, a dispute arose between the two and a fight occurred, during which the Frenchman suffered the loss of a portion of his left thumb, either by one of the two pistol shots fired at him by Zweifel, or by the latter's biting the member off, and the bar-keeper was stabbed in the loin. Castangau was arrested and held by the Police Judge to appear before the Grand Jury, who found a true bill against him of assault with intent to commit murder." He was duly tried, and adjudged not guilty.
On March 8, 1877, the trial of Jose Rodrigues for the killing of Joseph McDonald, at San Leandro, some three months previously, was commenced before Judge McKee of the Third District Court, when he was found guilty of manslaughter, and sentenced to three years' imprisonment in the- State Prison.
At the July term, 1877, Edward Clancey was tried for the murder of Manuel Silva, the circumstances of the case being as follows: An intimacy had been formed between Clancey and Silva's wife, who was an Irishwoman. Clancey* stated that Mrs. Silva had agreed to raise the window of her chamber on the night of the 4th of June last, in case Silva was not at home. Clancey was to give a signal by throwing pebbles against the side of the house. He gave the signal agreed upon, and did not await a response, but ran round to an outhouse near the Methodist Church, Haywards. He had a pistol in his pants' pocket. Silva followed and attacked him with a heavy club, and after receiving two blows, Clancey fired his pistol upon Silva and fled. He did not deny the killing, but claimed that it was in self-defense. He was found guilty of murder in the second degree.
Among the items of criminal history mentioned by us as occurring during the year 1869, was the arrest of Patrick Glancy for causing the death of Robert Lightbody. Glancy or Clancey was convicted of this murder in the July term 1877, and sentenced to fifteen years' imprisonment in the State Prison.
1878. - At the April term, 1878, Chung Wong, a Chinaman, was indicted for murder. The case was transferred to the Third District Court, but on September 12, 1878, he was declared insane and committed to the Napa Asylum.
1879. - During the year 1879, the only very serious case that we find in the records, was the conviction and imprisonment of Clark De Forrest, June 30th, for ten years in the State Penitentiary, for an assault to commit murder; other than this there were the usual quota of burglaries, and cases of larceny, but none of sufficient gravity that they should be remembered, save by the victims.
1880. - The reader may remember the case of Frederick W. Clarke, who shot Zelotus Reed in 1871. In the meantime he had been charged with embezzling money due the estate of his father, H. K. W. Clarke, and on January 24, 1880, was once more arrested, on the complaint of A. B. Lawson, for the original crime. The case was eventually taken to the Supreme Court, under a writ of habeas corpus and that tribunal under date March 23,* 1880, rendered its decision. The Court held that the fact that Clarke had already been before two Grand Juries, was no bar to the case being again examined into. Judge McKinstry delivered the opinion, in the course of which he said: -
Inasmuch as there is no limitation of time appUcable to prosecution for murder, and as a defendant in whose order a dismissal of the action has been made, has never been p Jt in jeopardy, within the meaning of the Constitution, a new action on behalf of the people may in such case be initiated at any subsequent day, either by presentment of a Grand Jury or by a complaint filed with any magistrate.
As we have seen, if the Superior Court retains the power to resubmit a charge once or oftener dismissed by - a Grand Jury, for any length of time after 'Ave. prosecution has been dismissed, the power may be employed at the option of the Judge or of any number of successive judges, without complaint or evidence or any cause shown. The practicable difficulties inseparable from such construction of the statute seemed to have occurred to counsel, who suggested at the argument that the power should be exercised by the Superior Court only after the defendant had been rearrested under warrant issued out of that Court and his case re-examined. To authorize such a proceeding we would have to supplement the section of the Code with other sections providing for the issue of such warrants, the admission to bail in certain cases, etc. In the first place the language of section 942 is plain, and does not contemplate any new warrant and examination in such case; in the second place, we are not empow. ered to legislate or provide machinery which the law-makers have not provided, but which they have rejected; and, in the third place, no benefit would accrue to a party charged with crime, since the result of the proposed changes in the law would only be to confer on the Judge of the Superior Court in another form the same power which he now possesses in common with all other magistrates, to wit: the power to issue a warrant and to examine and to hold to answer.
We have only to add that the main question involved in the present application was expressly decided in ex parte Cahill, 52 Cal., 463. In that case the facts were like those of the present, except that there the County Court had made an order resubmitting to the next Grand Jury, after it had dismissed the action, or discharged the defendant from custody. But the Court did not there hold that the power to resubmit continued after the prosecution had been dismissed, and there could have been no pretense that the order of resubmission in and of itself constituted a warrant or process which justified the Sheriff in restraining the party of his liberty. The Court in terms declared that the Sheriff was justified in holding his prisoner by the warrant of the Justice of the Peace. "The Court say: No bar to another prosecution having occurred, and the prisoner being at large without bail in consequence of the order of the County Court discharging him from custody, it was competent for any committing magistrate of the proper county to exatnine the charge made against him, and if, upon such examination, he appeared to be guilty, to hold him to answer."
Judge McKee dissented from this opinion, and on the 29th May, in Department No. 2 of the Superior Court of Alameda County, Judge Greene, after listening to argument by General Irvine, and remarks by District Attorney Gibson, reviewed the case of F W. Clarke, charged with murder, dismissed the prosecution, and discharged the defendant, thus setting him once more free.
On the night of Monday, February 2, 1880, a ferocious assault was made on two Chinamen named Chu Fun and Chu Long, at a Chinese gambling-house on Webster Street, midway between Eighth and Ninth, by which the two Celestials named were terribly cut about the head and face. The affray occurred about eight o'clock over a game of tan, and the assaulting heathens were from Spofford Alley, San Francisco. As soon as the affair was known, officers Ross, Field, and Coughlan hastened to the scene of the probably fatal occurrence, and found the interior of the rooms bespattered with blood on all sides. Stains of blood were also found at the door-sill and on the boards leading to the side-walk. The mutilated Chinamen were carried out of the house soon after they had received their injuries and placed under the care of Doctor Li-Pu-Tai, a Chinese physician of San Francisco. They were subsequently taken to the San Francisco Hospital. Chu Fun was gashed ^fearfully across the middle of the face and through his nose, and from above the ri^t temple through the cheek into the mouth. Chu Long was cut on the head, face, back, shoulder, and arm. On the 6th February Officer Ross captured Loh Ah Wing, one of the five murderous assailants, on Eighth Street, Oakland, and took him to the City Prison, and on the following day he was arraigned in the Police Court on a charge of assault with a deadly weapon. The case was, however, continued, as one of the wounded men was thought likely to die.
On Saturday, February 7, 1880, a very painful accident occurred on Second Street, when an unfortunate woman was shot while walking along the thoroughfare.
At the inquest eight of the jurors agreed upon the following verdict, and the ninth juror would not add his signature without the additional words which are given below : -
We, the undersigned jurors, after inspecting the body and hearins; the -testimony adduced, do find the deceased was named Ellen Stetson, a native of Wales, aged thirty-seven years. That she came to her death on the 7th day of February, a. d. 1880, by a pistolshot wound in the neck, causing immediate death, while she was crossing Second Street, near her residence. And the jury find that the shot was fired by one Jacob Lenz, from the grocery store of William Lenz, while in an altercation with Patrick McFadden.
Perhaps no more exciting time was ever witnessed in Oakland than when the intelligence became public that Alfred Lefevre, a dentist, having his office at the corner of Eighth Street and Broadway, had been shot and killed by Edward F. Schroeder, a clerk in the London and San Francisco Bank, San Francisco, on Monday, July 26, 1880. The circumstances of the case need not be here repeated; the details will be found most elaborately portrayed in the periodicals of that time; the page of history is not the place to pamper to a morbid taste for meretricious literature. Suffice it to say that the most eminent legal talent was arrayed on either side; the speeches for the prosecution and defense teemed with erudition, notably those of Messrs. Hall McAllister, Foote, and Gibson, while the charge of Police Judge Yule will take rank side by side with the best efforts of older lawyers. It will not be readily forgotten with what thrilling interest Mr. McAllister held his audience as he defined the fine points of mania, transitory insanity, monomania, and malice, which were successful in clearing Schroeder from this most horrible crime.
On May 17, 1880, Low-Kee, a Chinaman, was indicted for the crime of murder, and on July 12th was sentenced to ten years in the State Prison.
1881. - On November 9, 1881, A. J. Ross, charged with an attempt to kill special officer Martin, was discharged from custody, and Martin, who was then arraigned, was convicted, but in consideration of the fact that he had suffered severely from knife wounds inflicted during the fight, the Court did not think it necessary to impose a fine.
On August 7, 1 88 1, a man named John Taylor was grievously assaulted by one Poblec, near Livermore, from the effects of which he died. He was duly tried before the Superior Court.
Since this time the red hand of murder has happily been stayed, although several lives have been taken by accident, but as there did not appear to be any criminality connected with these it has not been thought advisable to mention them in this place. Suicides have been too common, and so will they continue, it is to be feared, so long as the public countenance this means of "shuffling off the mortal coil " and consider it as a right that every individual has. Surely, the life given us to maintain is no more ours to destroy thaji is that of our neighbor. To take both by violent means is equally heinous, and suicides will continue to be the part of the callous as long as the public look upon it as no particular sin. Thefts are too common to notice, and while we pen these lines a young man who had hitherto held a high position in the esteem of his fellows, is under order for trial for embezzlement of the public funds intrusted to his care. As the trial has not yet taken place, no good purpose would be served by making further mention of the circumstance. That crime is on the decrease is due to the efficiency of the officials of Alameda County.
("> EOGRAPHY. - Alameda Township is bounded on the north by San Antonio -J- Creek and Oakland Township; on the east by Brooklyn Township; on the south ^ by the Bay of San Francisco; and on the west by the Bay of San Francisco.
Topography. - The township of Alameda bears, in outline, some resemblance to the elbow of the human frame; is about one mile in width and three and a half in' length, and has an area approximating twenty-two thousand acres. It has, however, no very marked topographical features, and may be described as a level, sandy plain coyered with umbrageous oaks, which still give to the place an air of sylvan retirement. Its southern boundary is a well-defined water-front, somewhat abrupt, merging northward into marsh or overflowed lands, all of which are susceptible of reclamation.
Stream^. - There are no streams in the Encinal or Alameda, but being a peninsula, as its name implies, it is necessarily washed on three sides by water, those ofthe San Antonio Creek and San Leandro Bay being all-important, for here are we to have the capacious Oakland Harbor, with its adjuncts of shipping and commerce, in which Alameda will naturally share as well as its greater sister of Oakland.
Climate. - Compared with San Francisco and Oakland the climate of Alameda is remarkably mild. The westerly sea winds of summer which sweep over the former and round the bay, are less than a mile high. They are gradually arrested by the Coast Range of mountains, and partly by the easterly current of air which overlaps the lower stratum. This easterly current is always dry in summer, coming, as it does over the arid soil of the San Joaquin Valley, where it encounters a solar temperature of nearly one hundred degrees Fahrenheit. First, then, we see that the resistance which is offered to the westerly current either modifies its force, or entirely overcomes it before it reaches the Encinal; and, as a secondary consequence, the fog-bank is not only held at bay, but it is absorbed by the hot, dry, easterly current which is continually pushing seaward. Together these causes conspire to lessen the amount of summer winds, and to make fogs the exception to the general rule. Thus, while the citizens of San Francisco are immersed in dense fogs and subjected to high winds, Alameda, but twenty minutes of time distant, is enjoying the clear, calm sunshine of a delightful climate, which is neither so cold as to be uncomfortable, nor so hot as to be oppressive.
Though the same remarks will apply, to some extent, to the climate of Oakland, yet, owing to the fact that the northern boundary of that city being covered by the waters of the bay, and the city itself being nearly opposite the Golden Gate and thus more exposed to the direct force of the trade-winds, there is probably as much difference between the climate of Oakland and Alameda as there is between San Francisco and Oakland.
Soil. - Nothing can be said in this regard but that nature has been more than usually benign to this favored spot. The soil though sandy is extremely productive, being especially adapted to the growing of small fruits and vegetables, while Ray Farm Island bears a reputation for its fertility which is unsurpassed.
Products. - Alameda Township is not a farming district in the proper sense of the term. Its products are almost entirely confined to the raising of fruits, tubers, and vegetables, which, owing to the peculiarity of its climate, and to its warm, sandy soil, are usually the first in the San Francisco market. Flowers, too, grow with marked luxuriance as the many well-kept gardens can testify, while its nurseries are industries which fully sustain the above remarks.
Early in the year 1870, a correspondent of the Scientific Press while dilating on the delights of Alameda's temperature and its adaptability for the production of semitropical fruits, says: " At Mrs. Doctor Haile's residence I was shown the noted lemon tree, the seed of which the late Doctor Haile brought from Panama in his vest pocket and planted fifteen years ago, where it is now growing. The tree stands eighteen feet high, is very symmetrically formed, vigorous and thrifty, branching low, and spreading sixteen feet across. The lady informed me that at least two hundred and fifty lemons had been gathered from the tree that season, and I estimate the number on the tree now at three hundred and fifty. The tree has produced fruit several seasons. I saw lemons in all stages of growth from the blossom to the ripened fruit. The full-grown fruit is of medium size and very beautiful. The quality is excellent. The skin is rather thicker than the imported lemon, while the pulp, though acid, is exceedingly pleasant." It will thus be seen that the lemon and the orangejwill withstand here the frosts of winter, while who shall say of what the spring and summer months are capable ? The yield of such delicacies as asparagus and tomatoes is enormous and most profitable - five hundred dollars per acre of the first named has been cleared on Bay Farm Island - while all land for such purposes commands high rents. Of the numerous orchards what shall we say: As early as the month of February the eye is gladdened with the almond tree in full bloom; then come the white, snow-like blossoms of the cherry, to be followed in quick succession by those of the plum, the apple, and the quince, which brings this gorgeous floral fete half-way into the month of April. Then comes with unerring certainty the growth and ripening of the fruits, accompanied by the springing of flowers. He who visits Alameda in the spring-time will be ravished by the beauties which surround him; his autuninal visit though not so kaleidoscopic still bears the sense of fruitful plenty and quiescent comfort, twin benefits that make man feel at rest with himself and the whole world.
Provenance
Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.