Alameda County, California - The whole text, 1883 (part 18 of 38)
From History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. 15,934 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,934 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
and the most casual observer could not fail to note the vast amount of labor that would be required to level off these hills and fill in the bay so as to make room for the thousands of buildings that must be quickly erected. But the temporary difficulties on the eastern side of the bay were still more grave. A flat extended out for a distance of two miles, timber suitable for the purposes of wharf-building was not easily obtained and commanded an enormous price, and no hope was entertained of building the metropolis on the present site of Oakland.
The sandy peninsula was covered by a dense growth of oak-trees, which subsequently gave to the place its name, and beneath the trees were numerous thickets of chaparral and tangled underbrush. Some four miles to the north was the residence of Vicente Peralta, and around it were settled a few other native Californians. The only use made of the peninsula of Oakland was to obtain from it the necessary supplies of fuel. At some remote period there had been Indian camps upon the northern bank of the San Antonio Creek, and the mounds, composed mainly of oyster-shells, are not yet entirely obliterated. San Pablo was a flourishing sub-mission, and San Antonio (Brooklyn) was a town before there was a solitary settler in Oakland. Indeed, for a year or two after the settlement of Oakland, San Antonio ^yas in advance. It had been, as we have shown, an embarcadero, from which were shipped the lumber from the redwoods, and the hides and horns collected in the adjoining country.
The first actual settler in what is the city of Oakland is Moses Chase, who pitched his tent at what is now the foot of Broadway in the winter of 1849-50, and commenced hunting. Here he was found by the Patten Brothers on their arrival in February, 1850, which we have mentioned in the history of Brooklyn Township. Next came Col. Henry S. Fitch, and Colonel Whitney, who made an unsuccessful attempt to purchase the tract of land, and then in the summer of 1850 appeared the muchabused trio. Moon, Carpentier, and Adams, who squatted upon the land, holding that it belonged to the Government and not to Peralta, and erected a shanty near the foot of Broadway of to-day. The Spanish owner now made an attempt to ou.st these men, and got a writ of ejectment from the County Court at Martinez, and, says Mr. Halley, "a posse of men, under Deputy Sheriff Kelly, was sent to eject them." This was never done, and the upshot of the whole affair was that Moon, Carpentier, and Adams obtained a lease of a number of acres of land on certain conditions; they then laid out a town, and, be their short-comings what they may, were the first persons to attract public attention to Oakland, and soon they were joined by many others. The part of the city then laid out was its eastern portion, that bordering on San Antonio Creek, of which they made a map, and in accordance with its lines sold lots and blocks, giving quitclaim deeds, transferring their right, title, and interest. They erected the first buildings, and were the actual founders of the city.
During the first few years after the settlement of the city it was the popular belief that the "Squatter Title" was valid, and most of the property was purchased from those who had originally taken possession. After the amount of litigation that is usually required to establish the legality of a Mexican grant, the Peralta title obtained recognition, and has withstood every attack subsequently made upon it. We append the outlines of an abstract of title to any city lot :^^
2. In 1842 Luis Maria Peralta made a division of the Rancho San Antonio among his four sons, Ignacio, Antonio, Domingo, and Vicente, and put them m pos-. session of their respective portions. Vicente Peralta received that portion on which the city of Oakland is situated.
3. In 1851, Luis Maria Peralta executed an instrument purporting to be a will, wherein he ratified and confirmed the division of the Rancho San Antonio among his four sons, which instrument, the Supreme Court of California says, estops the heirs of Luis Maria Peralta from denying said gift to his sons. [See 17 Cal. Reps., Adams vs. Lansing-.] The invalidity of title derived from the other heirs than the sons of Luis Maria Peralta is also declared by the United States Supreme Court, in a case growing out of the "Pretermitted Heirs" title, decided in the early part of 1872.
4. In 1854 the Board of Land Commissioners confirmed the northern portion of the Rancho, embracing the city of Oakland, to Vicente and Domingo Peralta; and the same was afterwards, in 1855, confirmed by the United States District Court, and still later, at the December term in 1856, by the Supreme Court of the United States. [See 17 Howard.]
5. Ignacio, Antonio, and Domingo Peralta to Vicente Peralta release and deed all of their interest in and to that portion of the Rancho embracing the city of Oakland. Dated November 28, 1853. Recorded in Liber "8" of Deeds, Recorder's office, Alameda County.
6. Vicente Peralta to John Clar (}i); B. De La Barra (1-12); Joseph K. Irving {%); Jacob A. Cost (%); John C. iHays and John Capenton (}(). Deed dated March 13, 1852. Recorded in Contra Costa County, in which Oakland was at that
8. B. De La Barra (1-12) deed to J. K. Irving, J. M. Goggin, and William Claude Jones; William Claude Jones to Eugene Casserly; J. M. Goggin and Eugene Casserly to J. K. Irving, Hays, Caperton, and heirs of Cost, deceased.
9. J. K. Irving, party of the first part; John C. Hays and John Caperton, parties of the second part; Anna R. Poole, Catherine S. Lyons and her husband, Joseph Lyons; Serena S. Young and her husband, Alexander H. Young (heirs of Cost, deceased), "by William Poole, their attorney," execute a partition deed, duly proven, certified to, and recorded in Alameda County.
11. Power of attorney to Montgomery Blair, from same parties (except Serena S. Young, who was deceased, and left minor heirs, for whom Alexander H. Young signed as guardian) February 2, 1852.
12. Proceedings in Probate Court in the same year, by which the interest of the minor heirs of Serena S. Young became vested in Alexander H. Young.
off in former deed, reciting and approving the former; the same in all other respects, between the same parties (except in place of Serena S. Young, deceased, was Alexander H. Young, "by M. Blair, their attorney in fact"). Dated May i, 1854.
14. Deed from Anna R. Poole to John C. Hays, ratifying and confirming the former deed of partition, and confirming the acts of Blair and Black as agents, September I, 1858.
Subsequent to the chain of conveyances traced, title is vested in numerous owners, there being no other general claims. All the technicalities and defects which ingenuity can discover have been brought to notice. The numerous adverse titles had for years hung over property-holders like an incubus, and, in the early part of the year 1869, the people began an organized movement to defeat them. The position of affairs was somewhat critical. The city was rapidly growing, and to allow the idea to go abroad that titles were insecure, would check the progress of the city and cause incalculable mischief Sound business policy overcame the desire to make a bitter fight, however, and the holders of the claims were induced to dispose of them at rates that were trivial. The specific claims were the Pretermitted Heirs' title, the Sisters' title, the Irving title, and the Cost title, and these comprised all general titles asserted by anybody to land within the city of Oakland. These titles were by their several owners conveyed to Henry Hillebrand, the City Clerk, who acted as a trustee, and by him conveyances were made to the several property-holders. Nearly all the land in the city is now held by a perfect title, the Hillebrand deeds removing all the clouds. These titles, except the Cost title, still cloud property outside of the old charter line. The principal ones - -the Sisters' and the Pretermitted Heirs' - are virtually defeated, and the property-holders, to save trouble and annoyance, have quite generally purchased the other claims.
The Kate Hayes' title covers that portion of Oakland Township outside of the "Encinal Line," as laid down on the map. The Supreme Court of the State has sustained a decision rendered by E. W. McKinstry, Judge of the late Twelfth District Court, granting a new trial on the motion made by the defendants (the property-holders). That decision was fatal to the claim, which in itself was but for a trifling interest.
1852. - In accordance with the provisions of the Act entitled "An Act to Provide for the Incorporation of Towns" (passed March 27, 1850), in the year 1852 Horace W. Carpentier, who was a lawyer by profession, and had held an official position in the Legislature, had passed, on May 4th, an Act incorporating the Town of Oakland, the boundaries of which were declared to be as follows: "On the northeast by a straight line at right angles with Main Street, running from the Bay of San Francisco, -on the north to the southerly line of the San Antonio Creek or estuary.^crossing Main Street at a point three hundred and sixty rods northeasterly from 'Oakland House,' -on the corner of Main and First Streets, as represented on Porter's Map of Contra -Costa, on file in the office of the Secretary of State; thence down the southerly line of said creek or slough to its mouth in the Bay; thence to ship's channel; thence northerly and easterly by the line of ship's channel to a point where the same bisects the said northeastern boundary-line." Section Two of the Act declared the corporate powers and duties of the town to be vested in a Board of Trustees to consist of five members, to be elected on the second Monday of May in each year, who were to hold office for the term of one year, provided that they should receive no compensation for their services; and Section Three stated what should be their official duties. On May I, 1852, the town charter was signed at Benicia, where the Legislature was in session, by Richard P. Hammond, Speaker of the Assembly; Samuel Purdy, President of the Senate, and approved on the same date by Governor John Bigler.
The election was duly held, and A. W. Burrell, A. J. Moon, Edson Adams, Amedee Marier, and H. W. Carpentier chosen, the latter of whom, however, did not qualify; and on the 1 2th of May they held their first meeting in the office of Mr. Justice Adams. At this time, only Messrs. Marier, Burrell, and Adams presented their certificates of election, who, on having the constitutional oath administered to them, took their seats under the temporary presidency of Mr. Marier, with Mr. Burrell acting as Secretary. The charter having been ordered transcribed on the minutes of proceedings, the Board passed Ordinance Number One, entitled "An Ordinance to fix the time and place of holding stated meetings of the Board of Trustees," and thus was the official machinery of Oakland set in motion. On the 17th Andrew Moon took his seat at the Board, Mr. Marier being elected permanently to fill the presidential chair, and F. K. Shattuck to perform the duties of Town Clerk. Besides these transactions, the following Ordinances were passed: "An Ordinance declaring certain streets public highways," "An Ordinance concerning bonds of officers," and "An Ordinance for the disposal of the water-front belonging to the town of Oakland, and to provide for the construction of wharves.''
On May 17, 1852, there was introduced by A. W. Burrell, one of the Board of Trustees, "An Ordinance for the disposal of the water-front belonging to the Town of Oakland, and to provide for the construction of wharves," and which was as follows:
Section One. - The exclusive right and privilege of constructing wharves, piers, and docks at any points within the corporate limits of the town of Oakland, with the right of collecting wharfage and dockage at such rates as he may deem reasonable, is hereby granted and confirmed unto Horace W. Carpentier and his legal representatives, for the period of thirty-seven years; provided that the said grantee or his representatives shall within six months provide a wharf at the foot of Main Street, at least twenty feet wide, and extending'towards deep water fifteen feet beyond the present wharf at the foot of said street; that he or they shall within one year construct a wharf at the foot of F street or G Street, extending out to boat channel, and also within twenty months another wharf at the foot of D Street or E Street ; provided that two per cent, of the receipts for wharfage shall be able to the town of Oakland. " "
Section Two. - With a view the more speedily to carry out the intentions and purposes of the A t Legislature, passed May 4, 1852, entitled An Act to incorporate the town of Oakland, and to provide*^ fo tV construction of wharves thereat, in which certain property is granted and released to the town of O kl facilitate the making of certain improvements ; now, therefore, in consideration of the premises herein c t ' ' 1 and of a certain obligation made by said Horace W. Carpentier with the town of Oakland, in which h H ' ' takes to build for said town a public school house, the water front of said town, that is to say, the land lying within the limits of the town of Oakland between high tide and ship channel, as described in said Act, together with all the right, title, and interest of the town of Oakland therein is hereby sold, granted, and released unto the said Horace W. Carpentier and to his assigns or legal representatives, with all the improvements, rights, and interests thereunto belonging.
Section Three - The President of the Board of Trustees is hereby charged with the duty of executing on behalf of the town of Oakland a grant and conveyance in accordance with the provisions of this ordinance.
In consonance with the provisions of the third section of the above ordinance therefore, Carpentier obtained from Mr. Marier, the President of the Board of Trustees, the accompanying deed: -
Know all men by these presents that I, Am6d6e Marier, President of the Board of Trustees of the town of Oakland, in the county of Contra Costa, and State of California, in conformity to the provisions of an ordinance passed by said Board of Trustees bearing date May 27, 1852, and entitled "An ordinance for the disposal of the Water Front, belonging to the town of Oakland, and to Provide for the Construction of Wharves," and by virtue of the authority vested in me as said President of the Board of Trustees by the Constitution and Laws of the State of California, and especially by an Act of the Legislature approved May 4, 1852, and entitled "An Act to Incorporate the town of Oakland and to Provide for the construction of Wharves thereat, " in my official capacity as said President, and in view of the public convenience, have granted unto Horace W. Carpentier and his legal representatives, the exclusive right and privilege of constructing wharves, docks, and piers, at any point or points within the now corporate limits of the town of Oakland, with the right of collecting wharfage and dockage for the period of thirty-seven years, and in consideration of the covenants hereinafter mentioned, and of five dollars paid to the town of Oakland, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, in obedience to the ordinance aforesaid, and by virtue of the authority as aforesaid vested in me as President of the Board of Trustee? as aforesaid, now by virtue of said office I have sold, and by these presents do sell, transfer, grant, and release unto the said Horace W. Carpentier, and his legal representatives, all the right, title, and interest of the sai:l town of Oakland, in and to the Water Front of said town, that is to say,- all the land lying within the now corporate limits of the town of Oakland, and situated between high tide and ship channel, as granted to said town by, and as described in the said above entitled Act, to have and to hold the same, provided : That the said Carpentier or his legal representatives shall within six months provide a wharf at the foot of Main Street at least twenty feet wide and extending towards deep water fifteen feet beyond the present wharf at the foot of Main Street ; that he or they will, within one year, construct a wharf at the foot of F Street or G Street, extending out to boat channel, and also, within eighteen months, ainother wharf at the foot of D Street or E Street, and provided also that two per cent, of the receipts for wharfage shall be payable to the town of Oakland. In witness whereof, I, the said President of the Board of Trustees of the town of Oakland, have hereunto set my hand and private seal at Oakland, May 31, 1852.
On this first day of June, A. D. 1852, before me, R. S. Lammott, a Notary Public, duly commissioned and sworn in and for the county aforesaid, personally appeared Amfed^e Marier, to me known to be the person described in and who executed the foregoing conveyance, who acknowledged that he executed the same freely and voluntarily, and for the use and purposes therein expressed.
agree to carry out the objects and purposes of this grant and conveyance, to construct the wharves as herein provided for and to build for the town of Oalcland a public school house agreeably to the terms of an obligation in reference therefo, made by me and bearing earlier date.
It is to be assumed that Carpentier lost no time in unnecessary delay, for on December 30, 1852, the ordinance entitled "An Ordinance to approve the wharf at the foot of Main Street, and to extend the time for constructing the other wharves," was introduced, and is as follows:
Section One. - The Board of Trustees having examined the wharf built by Horace W. Carpentier at the foot of Main Street in said town, and having had the matjer under consideration, do find that the same is built and completed to their entire satisfaction, and according to the terms and within the time specified in an ordi, nance of the Board passed May 18, 1852, and entitled, "An Ordinance for the disposal of the Water Front belonging 10 the town of Oakland, and to provide for the construction of Wharves," and to accept the same.
Section Two. - In consideration of the memorial of the said Carpentier to this Board, and of five dollars paid by him to the Treasurer of the said town, the time allowed to the said Carpentier in which to construct a wharf at the foot of F Street or G Street, extending out to boat channel, as required in said ordinance above recited, and in the dual conveyance to said Carpentier of the Water Front of said town, is hereby extended for the period of twelve months from the expiration of the time limited and expressed in said Ordinance and Conveyance, and the time for building a wharf at the foot of D or E Streets is hereby extended in like manner for the term of eight months from its expiration.
Mr. Carpentier at once entered upon his newly acquired possesSidflS, and in accordance with the ordinance and its provisions, on the 30th December fflade a report respecting wharfage, accompanied by an affidavit that the due percentage ©f wharfage and dockage had been paid to the town of Oakland, up to date. On July 12, 1853, he reports, in further contemplation of what was required from him, that " I have built a substantial, elegant^ and commodious school house for said town, which is now completed and ready for delivery. In the plan and construction of the building I have intended to go beyond rather than to fall short of the obligation of my contract. I would also state for the official information of the Board that a free school is at present maintained at my expense in the building above referred to, which, I am happy to inform you, is well attended and promises to be the beginning of an important system of free schools. I herewith transmit to you a conveyance of the' school house together with a deed for the lots upon which it is erected; I trust that the building will meet your approval, and that the additional present of the lots will prove acceptable to your Honorable Body." This "substantial, elegant, and commodious " building stood near the corner of Fourth and Clay Streets, but would hardly be recognized from the foregoing description. On the 26th August Mr. Carpentier addressed the following communication to the Board of Trustees which speaks for itself: "In pursuance of my contract with the town of Oakland in accepting the conveyance of its water front, I have already expended about twenty thousand dollars in wharves, besides those referred to in said contract, at a very heavy expense. Believing that the wharfage will be the source of but little profit to myself, and that exemption from wharfage might be pleasing to some who seem to regard the wharves as at present conducted as a monopoly to be complained of, I propose to abandon the collection o{ wharfage, provided, the Board of Trustees will undertake perpetually to keep all the wharves in good order and repair. As some of my plans may be altered by your decision and as those plans would suffer from delay unless this proposal be accepted at the next meeting, of the Board, I shall consider it as withdrawn and void." These propositions were, however, declined on the following day* but an ordinance was passed at the same time, entitled, " An Ordinance concerning Wharves and Water Front," whereby, on the completion of the wharf at the foot of Main Street (Broadway), and satisfactory arrangements being made in respect to the others - that is the handing over of the school house, etc. - the water front of the town of Oakland would be granted to Carpentier "in fee simple forever."
It was now felt by the citizens of Oakland that the Board of Trustees had overstepped the bounds of their legitimate authority, that it was not in their power to sell, grant, or release unto any individual, for any consideration, what had been ceded to them in trust for the benefit of the people; therefore with one consent they rose in their majesty and demanded from the Board of Trustees, that legal proceedings should be instituted forthwith to recover the water front, which belonged to them. This petition is not among the city records, but was presented September lo, 1853, and on the 19th the committee to whom the matter was referred made a report in writing recommending that the prayer be not granted, a suggestion which was unanimously adopted on the motion of Trustee Edson Adams.
And now the controversy assumes another phase. Immediately after the signing of the deed which conveyed the water front to him, Carpentier places himself in communication with his niece in New York, Harriet N. Carpentier, and from her receives an absolute power of attorney " to purchase, rent, receive, and hold property, real or personal " in the State of California, " and to sell, lease, grant, assign, and convey any and all property, either which I now hold or which I may hereafter acquire in said State, using his entire discretion in the premises," under date June 14, 1852. Then, on January 18, 1853, he sells one-fourth undivided interest of the water front to Edward R. Carpentier, who was at the time Commissioner of Deeds for the State of California and residing in New York, for the sum of two thousand eight hundred and fifty dollars, together with an equal one-fourth of all rights, titles, and claims either present or prospective; and, on August 2, 1854, while Mayor of the city of Oakland (to which office he had been elected in the month of April of that year), he disposes of the remaining three-fourths to Harriet N. Carpentier, for the sum of sixty thousand dollars. We next find, under date April 4, 1855, Harriet N. Carpentier purchasing from Edward R. Carpentier all the " right, title, claim, and interest in and to the water front of the city of Oakland, in the county of Alameda, State aforesaid, that is to say, all the lands or land and water lying within the limits of said city between high-tide mark and ships' channel, the same being the one undivided one-fourth part of the premises herein before described" for the sum of twelve thousand dollars; and on August i6, 1855, John B. Watson sells the entire water front property to Harriet N. Carpentier for the sum of six thousand dollars- How it ever passed into the hands of Mr. Watson, however, is a matter of the profoundest mystery; no official records divulge the secret, neither are we in a position to state why these inscrutable transfers should have taken place, nor is it our duty to hazard conjecture on the subject.
But let us have a glance at what was transpiring on the spot. On December 5, 1853, Horace W. and Edward R. Carpentier executed* a lease to Edson Adams and Andrew Moon, "for the period of twenty years, an equal, undivided two-third interest" in and to the following described premises in the town of Oakland, county of Alameda, California, the same being a beach and water lot, bounded as follows: Commencing at a point in the easterly line of Broadway, protracted four hundred and twenty feet southerly from the southern line of First Street; thence running easterly on a line parallel with First Street one hundred and five feet; thence running northerly on a line parallel with Broadway fifty feet; thence running westerly on a line parallel with First Street one hundred and five feet to the easterly line of Broadway continued; thence southerly along said line fifty feet to the place of beginning, being the same lot on which the store-house erected by the said parties is now standing," for the the sum of two thousand dollars. It is in this transaction that either Edson Adams or Andrew Moon appear in the roll of lessees, although it was pretty generally acknowledged that the former claimed one-half of the entire property, and, indeed, did eventually obtain his share by forcible measures, subsequently selling it to the Central Pacific Railroad Company for a large sum.
We last left the citizens of Oakland entertaining a dim idea that all was not as it should be in regard to the transfer of the water front to Horace W. Carpentier, and that the Board of Trustees had declined to entertain their petition that steps should be taken to recover them. For this and several other cogent reasons a riot was apprehended; therefore, on October 22, 1853, it was ordered that "circumstances appearing to endanger the destruction by riot of the town records, the clerk is authorized to remove them to a place of safety." This was done, a fact which may account for the non-appearance of several very valuable documents. That the exasperated mob took their revenge upon the property of Carpentier is, however, to be gleaned from the statement of the records, as on November 19th of the same year we find that the President laid before the Board of Trustees a certified copy of a summons and complaint in the case of Horace W. Carpentier versus The Town of Oakland, in a suit for four thousand five hundred dollars, damages to the plaintiff's property from a mob or riotous assemblage, to which, on motion of Mr. Moo i, the President, an answer was directed to be filed. This was ordered to be transferred, by consent, from the District Court of Alameda County to the Superior Court of the city of San Francisco on January 18, 1854, ^"^^ o" the i ith February H. P. Watkins was employed as counsel to defend the cause, but on February iSth an ordinance was passed compromising the suit.
And now followed the incorporation of the city of Oakland on March 2^,, 1854, and in accordance with the charter an election was duly held, and Horace W. Car- pentier receiving one hundred and ninety-two votes was chosen the first Mayor, who, on April 29th, forwarded to the City Council his first message, an able and exhaustive document. But soon the air became oppressive, for trouble commenced to break through the clouds; the councilmen elected were decidedly antagonistic to Mr. Carpentier, and to his claims upon the water front. Besides, the Board of Trustees displayed much unwillingness to transfer the papers and public moneys in their charge to the newly-elected City Council, although they subsequently did so in a very confused and incomplete condition, that is, as regards the papers, for the treasury had been attached in the hands of the Marshal by Colonel John C. Hays, and legal process was necess ry to release it. The storm soon burst. On August S, 1854, at the meeting of the City Council, Alderman A. D. Eames presented Ordinance No. 34, entitled, "An Ordinance to provide for the construction and maintenance of a Wharf in the city of Oakland," and which reads as follows: -
Section One. - For the purpose of facilitating the commerce of said city and the travel to and from the same, there shall be and there is hereby established a street and wharf from a point on the Encinal in the southerly part of the city limits (to be selected and designated as hereinafter provided) to the nearest deep water in a westerly direction from said point and within the city limits, on the following conditions, viz. :
Section Two. - There is hereby granted to the person or persons who shall become the best bidder for the same under the following conditions - the right and franchise of building a wharf and collecting the wharfage thereon, on a wharf to be constructed at said point and to said deep water, for the term of fifty years.
Section Three. - The said grantee or grantees shall also have the right to take, use, possess, and enjoy for said term of years a lot, strip, or parcel of land and water one hundred yards in width along the line of said wharf from the beach to the boundary line of the city.
Section Four. - Said grantee or grantees shall have the right to form an association and stock company for the construction of said wharf, or to make the same into stock of convenient shares.
Section Five. - The said right of franchise for the construction and maintenance of said wharf, together with the use of the land for the same, shall be offered at public auction as required by the charter of said city, and the person or persons responsible for the same, who will offer the largest percentage on the business of said wharf, shall be declared the best bidder, and to him and them shall be awarded the said right, title, and franchise for the term aforesaid.
Section Six. - It shall be the duty of the Council to enter into a written covenant with the said contractor and grantee, expressing the foregoing contract and conveying such franchise, and the use of said land in appropriate language.
Section Seven. - There is hereby granted to said grantee or grantees, the exclusive right to regulate the use, terms of landing, and rates of wharfage of said wharf, land and water, to the extent above expressed, providing they don't exceed the rates of wharfage at present charged in Oakland.
Section Nine. - H. P. Watkins, S. B. McKee, and William Hillegass are hereby appointed commissioners to locate said wharf and lands and to advertise and conduct the sale of the same, and to make a report thereof to the Council when such sale shall have been concluded.
Section Ten. - The grantee or grantees shall not hold the city responsible for any damages accruing to them from such grant as is made under this ordinance. But nothing herein contained shall be construed into any acknowledgment on the part of the city of the right of ownership of others to any part of the water front of the city except herein provided.
The ordinance was passed at the regular meeting of the Council held August 6, 1854, and on the 19th four separate petitions, signed in all by one hundred and seventy citizens, were received in favor of building the wharf on the southwestern corner of the Encinal. At the same session, August 19th, the ordinance above mentioned having previously been sent to Mayor Carpentier for his signature and approval, was returned to the Council with the following message, which, being in a measure his views on his tenure of the city water front, we produce in extenso: -
"To THE Common Council: - A bill for an ordinance entitled 'An Ordinance to provide for the construction and maintenance of a wharf in the city of Oakland, has been presented to me and is herewith returned without my approval.
"My objections to the ordinance go both to its form and its substance: to its form because it is careless and illegal in its terms, and contains no provisions of safeguard to the city: to its substance, because, first, it is calculated to involve the city in long and costly litigation, and exposes her to ruinous losses by way of awarded damages, and, secondly, because it is in open violation of private rights and in contempt of that good faith which should mark the transactions of corporations as well as of individuals.
" In Section First of this ordinance the corporation, by an act of positive and arbitrary legislation, lays and establishes a wharf upon private property without the consent of the owner thereof, and, in Section Second, it sells the right and franchise of building the same and of collecting wharfage thereon. If this ordinance proposed merely to part with the right and interest of the city, unless that right and interest were clearly ascertained and definite, it would still be an act of sufficient gravity and importance. In this case, however, the city undertakes to grant and convey real property already granted and regranted to others, and to sell certain positive, specific and substantive rights and franchises not owned by the city, under the terms and obligations of a contract of bargain and sale, which she is bound by every rule of law to make good and defend.
" ' Right and Franchise ' is a term of definite legal signification, and the sale of a right and franchise is in contemplation of law a declaration of ownership on the part of the granter, and is equivalent to a special warranty from the consequence of which nothing short of a release in clear and explicit language can relieve the grantor. In such covenants it is the rule of law to interpret them most strongly against the grantor. Nothing is taken in his favor by implication or intendment.
" Section Four provides for the formation of a private corporation. Corporations are the creatures of sovereign power, and a mere municipality cannot, as such, provide for their establishment. The charter of Oakland has not delegated to the City Council the exercise of any such extraordinary power, and nothing can legally be done under the charter but what is therein specially authorized, or is necessarily incident thereto. Besides, the Constitution has imposed certain restrictions and limitations to the power of the Legislature to create corporations and joint-stock companies which the City Council in this proposed creation have entirely neglected.
" Section Five provides for selling the right of franchise for the construction and maintenance of the wharf and the use of certain lands to the person who will offer the largest percentage on the business of the wharf, who is to be declared the ' best bidder.' ' This is an evasion of the section of the charter, which provides that sales or leases shall be to the the highest bidder. It authorizes the sale of lands and franchises with a limitation in effect that none shall bid beyond a certain price, whilst it leaves it entirely with the grantee to determine whether the city shall ever receive a farthing by giving him full power to fix the rates of wharfage and terms of landing.
Such a .sale does not allow the competition which the Legislature intended, and is not the kind of sale to the highest bidder which is contemplated in the charter.
" Section Six provides that the Council shall enter into a covenant, etc., with the grantee. This the Council cannot properly do. The Mayor is the executive officer of the corporation, and the charter provides that he shall sign all contracts on behalf of the city. Experience has generally shown that the public interest is best subserved by leaving the responsibility of public acts where the law has placed it, and nothing has occurred to warrant the inference that the present executive will hesitate to perform any duty which may devolve upon him. The City Council are the mere creatures of the charter, and they cannot provide a new way of performing an act or discharging a duty when the charter has directed that it shall be done in a specified manner.
" Section Eight provides that the wharf ' fit for use ' shall be constructed within one year. Here there is no guarantee that a suitable wharf will ever be constructed. It is not provided that it shall be of a certain length, width, or strength, that it shall be built after one or another plan, or that it shall be subject to the approval of the city, or equal to the demands of public convenience. ' A wharf fit for use ' is the language of the ordinance. One ten feet wide and five yards in length answers this description. There are no provisions for keeping the wharf in repair, nor is even the building of it ' fit for use ' made a condition precedent to the grant. There are no conditions precedent or of avoidance or forfeiture.
" The grant is in terms positive, final, and absolute, and a total and willful failure on the part of the grantee to carry out any of the objects or intentions of the ordinance so far from working a forfeiture of the lands and franchise conveyed would not even afford sufficient grounds for a suit to annul the grant.
" So bald is the whole thing of any guarantees of remuneration to the city, or of performance on the part of the grantee as to induce the belief that the ordinance was artfully drawn and imposed upon the City Council under specious pretexts by some designing person whose only object is to involve the city in an expensive litigation with some of her own citizens under the hope of gaining large advantage from the losses of others by speculating in a grant so promising in its pretensions and which imposes no real obligations.
" There are unfortunately persons in every community not particularly distinguished for enterprise or attention to their own business, who are always eager to agitate and embroil under the hope that out of confusion there will come spoils.
"The proviso in Section Ten is adroitly worded and amounts to nothing as a security to the city. It provides that the ' grantee or grantees shall not hold the city responsible for any damages accruing to them from such grant as is made under this ordinance.' This neither relieves the city from the legal consequences of 2^ failure of the title and franchise which it undertakes to grant, nor does it save her from the payment of such damages and costs of litigation as she would certainly incur by thus arbitrarily disposing of the private property and vested rights of others.
" And in this connection I ask your candid consideration of the fact that the franchise of wharfage and the land proposed to be granted do not belong to the city to grant or control.
"The-land mentioned is a part of the 'water front of Oakland,' which was ceded by ;the State to the town in the first Act of Incorporation passed May 4, 1852; for the purpose of enabhng the town to construct 'wharves and other improvements,' for which purpose the Act authorized the Trustees of the town to dispose of the land so granted.
" At that time the town had no public improvements nor the means of constructing them. There were but few inhabitants and but little taxable property in the city. It became then a matter of the first importance and anxiety in the minds of those -who wished to see the young town thrive and prosper that suitable wharves should be built as contemplated by the Legislature, and that common schools should be at once established. But how were these desirable- and necessary objects to be accomplished? " The town had received the water front from the State for the very purpose, and for that purpose was it disposed of by the Board of Trustees. They sold and conveyed the land, including that mentioned in the bill herewith returned to you to one of her citizens under ample guarantee for the faithful performance of the contract which he entered into to construct three wharves and a school house. And in consideration of a percentage upon the income of the wharves, and the care and repairs of the same, and in consideration of the premises, the exclusive right and franchise of wharfage was granted for a term of years to the contractor, and has passed from him into the hands of other citizens.
"This grant was made under an ordinance passed May 27, 1852, to which your attention is respectfully directed. The grantee at once constructed at a large expense the substantial wharf at the foot of Broadway, which was duly approved by ordinance passed December 30, 1852. He also built and delivered to the town the commodious school house now in use on the corner of Clay and Fourth Streets, and subsequently erected the wharf at the foot of Webster Street, both of which were approved and accepted, and the grant reaffirmed in all of its provisions by ordinance passed August 27, 1853, to which you are also referred. The third wharf has also recently been built at the foot of E, now Washington, Street, in final completion on the part of the grantee with the terms and conditions of the contract, and the percentages have been duly paid over from time to time and received by the city.
"These are public acts and matters of record in the office of the City Clerk and of the Recorder of Alameda County, and are existing legal facts not depending upon hearsay nor the treacherous memories of men.
"A report of a Select Committee of the late Board of Trustees on this subject was made in October, 1853, a copy of which is hereunto annexed as exhibiting some of the facts referred to more fully than I have deemed it necessary in this communication.
"To suppose that the grantee would volunteer these costly improvements with no object but to invest his private fortune for the common benefit of the public would be doing violence to common sense and common experience. And for the city to endeavor to retake, or by her consent to permit others to appropriate, the legitimate consideration for those public benefits would be equal violence to common justice and to vested legal rights. Corporations are as much bound to keep faith- as individuals and a disregard of this principle will prove disastrous to the credit and finances of any city.
"I am enabled to state for the information of the City Council that the present owners and holders of the water front and of the franchise connected therewith have expended in this behalf a very large sum, say one hundred thousand dollars, and I am assured they will not submit to any interference with their rights, but will demand and recover from the city full compensation for any losses, costs, or expenses which they may sustain by reason of her illegal acts.
"The conveyance of the water front was a contract binding upon the town and its successor and successors in interest. The consideration in this contract was on one side the percentage payable to the city and the capital invested for her benefit; on the other side the use and enjoyment of the lands and franchise purchased and conveyed, and of the advantages naturally flowing therefrom. On the faith of this contract large sums have been expended and much time and labor employed, and any acts on the part of the city, whether directly or constructively, in violation of this contract is in fraud of private rights and will meet with no favor from any Court of Justice.
"If the city has cause of complaint, or fancies that she has cause, she should resort to the Courts, which are open to all. But whilst her deeds of conveyance remain of record, and the contracts which bind her conscience are unimpeached, she cannot, with any regard to morality or law, make the grant contemplated by the proposed ordinance.
" The Legislature has wisely declared it to be a felony, punishable by heavy penalty, for a person who has once conveyed lands knowingly shall ab initio null and void (sic). If in this case the proposed regrant would not be a criminal offense it is simply because corporations are not in the same manner as individuals amenable to penitentiary punishments, but at least the moral force of such a statute should deter public officers from a willful infraction of the spirit of the law.
"The question of the diversion of travel and business from the neighborhood of the present landiryg, and the consequent injury to those who have made investments there, I do not propose now to discuss. The injustice and illegality of the measure and the amount of litigation and expense which would fall so heavily upon our young city if it were accomplished, and the injury which would result to her from the further discredit thrown upon her titles, is sufficient to point out the path of my duty, and I therefore withhold my approval of the bill and return it for your reconsideration.
The Council, however, were not to be intimidated; they therefore referred the ordinance to a Special Committee, consisting o{ Messrs. Eames, Blake, and Kelsey, who were empowered to take the advice of counsel in San Francisco on the subject. Having consulted the law firm of Crittenden & Ingo, these gentlemen gave their opinion - this document is nowhere to be found - which it is presumable was favorable to the city, for, at the meeting of the Council, held September 13th, it was moved by Alderman Marier that the ordinance providing for the maintenance and construction of a wharf be taken up, and carried. This was done notwithstanding the veto of the Mayor, by the following vote: Ayes - ^Aldermen Eames, Gallagher, Marier, and Kelsey. Noes - Alderman Josselyn. On the 23d September the following com- munication, with its inclosure (no trace of which is to be found in the records), was received and referred to the Committee on Pubhc Buildings: -
"To THE Common Council : - Herewith is transmitted to you a copy of a communication from the owners of the water front concerning the wharf lately constructed at the foot of Washington Street, formerly E Street, in this city.
"I have carefully examined said wharf and I find it to have been well and substantially built from the shore to deep water, a distance of five hundred feet, according to the terms and within the time specified in the contracts providing for its construction, and I have accepted it on behalf of the city and in full and final satisfaction and discharge of the terms and conditions of the ordinances, grants, and contracts for the sale, disposal, and conveyance of the water front of the town of Oakland. Horace W. Carpentier, Mayor."
It is curious to note the fact that Mr. Carpentier in this communication arrogated unto himself a prerogative that no single member of a corporation possesses, but which is usually delegated to a committee previous to final acceptance, namely, that of accepting on behalf of a city work in which the individual may be personally interested, as in this case, and which he had performed himself.
On October 7, 1854, we find that a communication from the Attorney-General, having reference to the water front, was presented by Alderman Josselyn, and ordered placed on file, but this important document has also vanished from the records, as has the resolution proposed by Mr. Marier, and passed on the 21st of the same month, whereby the Marshal was instructed to erase from the Assessment Books the impost on the water front. At this juncture the tables were completely turned, and the Carpentier faction were elated, but what suasion was brought to bear upon the Council so that they should pass the ordinance to repeal "An Ordinance to provide for the construction and maintenance of a wharf in the city of Oakland," which had been passed finally on the previous 1 5th of September, may never transpire, suffice it to say that his Honor the Mayor won the day and and gave his approval to it (it was passed December 9, 1854) on December 11, 1854.
As a proof of the navigability of the San Antonio Creek, and the consequent incalculable value of the water front to the city, it may be here mentioned that on January 10, 1855, a resolution to advertise for proposals to remove the bar at the mouth of that stream to admit of free passage was adopted; but let us not anticipate, this subject will be especially treated elsewhere.
At a special meeting of the City Council, held January 24, 1855, the President gave official information that an outrage had been perpetrated on the previous evening which took the shape of an attempt to destroy or abstract the whole or a portion of the records of the city. Mayhap it was in the confusion consequent upon this violent proceeding that the several important documents mentioned were lost, while it is a remarkable coincidence that nearly all of the missing papers refer to this question of the water front. A reward of a thousand dollars was offered for the apprehension and conviction of the perpetrators, but whether they were ever arrested is a matter clothed in the profoundest mystery.
At the election of March 5, 1855, Charles Campbell succeeded Mr. Carpentier as Mayor, and a new Council was chosen, all of whom held their offices intact until the 28th April, when Messrs. Gallagher and Williams resigning, on the 29th May Messrs. E. Gibbons and Robert Worthington were elected in their stead.
On May i6th, in accordance with the report of a committee appointed to acquaint the Council in regard to certain motleys paid in by Horace W. Carpentier, the following resolution was passed: -
Resolved, That the sum of twenty dollars and sixteen cents for wharf percentage, and fifty dollars for ferry money reported by the Treasurer (May 2d) as being received by him from H. W. Carpentier be rejected by the city and not received by them, as not being money belonging to the city.
There now entered into the breasts of the City Fathers an evident desire to "put their house in order," and at once strike at the root of the evil, for on June 6, 1855, Alderman Gibbons presented the ordinance entitled "An Ordinance repealing an ordinance entitled 'An Ordinance concerning Wharves,' " passed October 29, 1853, which abrogated all concessions made in regard to the water front. It was duly approved by Mayor Campbell, became law, and there is no record extant to show that it was ever cancelled by official decree. The next move of the Council, which seemed bent upon giving a death-blow to monopolies, was directed against an ordinance passed in April, 1853, granting to Edward R. Carpentier, the brother of the ex-Mayor, the exclusive right of ferry privileges between Oakland and San Francisco. The initial step in the matter was taken by Alderman Williams, who offered the following resolution : -
To THE Honorable, the Legislature of the State of California: The Mayor and Council of the city of Oakland, in obedience to what they consider the popular wish in said city, respectfully but strongly and earnestly remonstrate against the passage of any law granting to any person or persons, or body, a monopoly of ferry privileges, between this city and the city of San Francisco.
The resolution was duly carried. On June 6th Alderman Gibbons introduced an ordinance in reference to ferry laws, which, having passed its second reading, was referred to the Committee on Ordinances, who, under date June 14, 1855, made the subjoined report:
The Committee to whom was referred the ordinance for the repeal of an ordinance entitled "An Ordinance to create a Public Ferry between the town of Oakland and the city of San Francisco, and to provide for the keeping up and running of the same," respectfully report; The ordinance which it is proposed to repeal was passed by the Board of Trustees of the town of Oakland, on March 5, 1855.* It authorizes and directs the conveyance to E. R. Carpentier, his heirs, agents, or assigns of exclusive ferry privileges "between Oakland and San Francisco, or between the said town or any other place, " for the term of twenty years, together with all the ferry rights, privileges, and franchises which now are or may hereafter be held or owned by the town of Oakland.
The ordinance directing this conveyance to Mr. Carpentier is but one of similar ordinances by which the town of Oakland has been unlawfully despoiled of her property, divested of her rights, and retarded in her prosperity. Prior to the passage of this ordinance, the trustees of the town granted to the brother of said Carpentier all the water front of the town extending to ship channel in the bay of San Francisco, together with the exclusive right of constructing wharves and collecting wharfage (without limit or restriction), for thirty-seven years. A mere nominal percentage, without guarantee or security to the town, and amounting, in the course of two or three years to about one hundred dollars, is the only consideration (with the exception of a small frame school house for which no deed can be found) proffered to the town for the aforesaid grants. As trifling as this consideration is, the grantee in the latter case applied to the Board of Trustees, and obtained the passage of an ordinance by which the town assumes all taxes which might be levied upon any wharf or wharves which he had constructed or might hereafter construct. This would render the city liable for the State and County taxes upon said wharves, which, at a moderate estimate, would amount in one year to more than the aforesaid has amounted to in two years; thus compelling the city to pay a premium to the grantees for taking all the property, ferry rights, privileges, and franchises which the town of Oakland had, present or prospective, to give away. Under this arrangement the people of the town are plundered of their property, and then taxed to pay the taxes of those who have plundered them, and to support a monopoly which adds its exactions to the measure of iniquity thus imposed upon the community.
As matters now stand, two individuals claim exclusive and entire control over the only outlet through which the farmer can gain access to the market, or the merchant transport his goods. If the grants to these two individuals be valid, they can charge whatever rates of freight and wharfage they may choose to exact, and if the article transported should be thus taxed to double its value, the owner thereof could have no redress. A monopoly which so completely subjects a whole community to the caprice of an individual, cannot stand the test of the law. In the case before us, your committee would suggest that the ordinance which it is proposed to repeal is of itself null and void. To suppose that the town of Oakland has any right to establish such a ferry across the bay of San Francisco, is about equivalent to supposing that she has a right to grant exclusive ferry privileges to the Sandwich Islands. But, however absurd the ordinance in question may be, the impression prevails to some extent that so long as said ordinance stands unrepealed,' so long does the city of Oakland indorse the nefarious contract of a Board of Trustees who administered the town government for the especial benefit of two or three individuals, and to the detriment of the community at large. That this impression may be removed, and that any mere shadow of right on which the present ferry monopoly pretends to exist may be dissipated, and that the public may know that the door is open for unlimited competition, your committee report back the ordinance and recommend its passage, with an amendment declaring any contract made under or by virtue of said ordinance null and void.
No time was lost. At the same meeting the committee introduced an ordinance entitled "An Ordinance Repealing an Ordinance entitled 'An Ordinance to create a Public Ferry between the Town of Oakland and the City of San Francisco, and to provide for and the Iceeping up and running the same.' " This ordinance, which was passed on June 14, 1855, and approved by Mayor Campbell on the following day, reads: - The Council of the City of Oakland do Ordain as follows :
Section One. - The ordinance entitled "An Ordinance to create a Public Feriy between the town of Oakland and the City of San Francisco, and to provide for the keeping up and lunning the same," passed by the Board of Trustees of the town of Oakland, March 5, 1853, is hereby repealed.
Thus was war declared against monopolies and Carpentier's Water-front claim. To support their action in repealing the ordinance concerning wharves on August 8, 1855, the Committee on Streets and Buildings was authorized to advertise for proposals to build a wharf at the foot of Bay Street, opened August i, 1855. The jetty to be not less than eight hundred and fifty yards long, with a T at the end one hundred feet in length and fifty feet broad. This wharf was never completed; its remains may be seen in a few piles at Oakland Point, on the north of the railroad mole.
The passage of the Ferry ordinance was the cause of the establishment of a ferry by the late Hon. James B. Larue, of Brooklyn, and which led to the famous suit of Minturn versus Larue, in which the following most interesting and valuable affidavits of Doctor Gibbons and A. Marier, which are here produced, were taken in evidence:
" Edward Gibbons, being duly-isworn, deposes and says^that he is a resident of the city of Oakland, in the County of Alameda, State of California, and has resided in
Oakland since the year 185 1; that he was residing in Oakland at the time of the passage of the Act to incorporate the town of Oakland, to wit: on the 4th day of May, 1852, and had been residing there for several months previous to that date; that so far as he knowi or is informed, there was no petition or request of the people of that place (which was then, and had been previously, known by the name of Contra Costa and never by the name of Oakland) to the Legislature for the incorporation of said town, nor was the subject of its incorporation previously discussed among the people, nor the intention to incorporate it known to them; that there has been no public meeting in regard to any intended incorporation of said town, and that the population of the place did not exceed seventy or eighty persons; that when the news reached the people of the incorporation of the town of Oakland by said Act of the Legislature, it was received by them with great surprise; that it was afterwards ascertained, as deponent was informed and believes, that the town had been so incorporated at the instigation and through the agency of Horace W. Carpentier.
" That a few days after the passage of said Act of Incorporation, to wit: on the loth day of May, 1852, an election for Trustees and other Town officers was held, and the following persons were elected Trustees, viz.: Amfedee Marier, A. W. Burrell, A. Moon, E. Adams, and the said Horace W. Carpentier; that a day or two before the said election, the said Carpentier showed to deponent a ticket containing the names of persons to be voted for at the election, on which were the names of the five Trustees above named and who were afterwards elected; that at the time the said Horace W. Carpentier, A. Moon, and E. Adams were partners, and as such dealing in town lots, and deponent advised the said Carpentier to strike off from the ticket the name of A. Moon or E. Adams, for the reason that it was not right that three partners should be on the Board of Trustees, but he refused to do so,and the three were elected; that the said Horace W. Carpentier never qualified or took his seat as a member of the Board of Trustees, and no election was ordered or held to fill the place to which he had been elected, but until the next 'annual election the four remaining Trustees composed the Board.
"And deponent says that afterwards, to wit: about the i8th day of May, 1852, he, deponent, heard of the passage, by s^id Board of Trustees, of an ordinance giving the water front of the town to the said Carpentier, and immediately went to said Carpentier and inquired of him the nature of it; that said Carpentier in reply said that it was to secure the water front to the town; that there was some talk of a called session of the Legislature, and if there should be a called session of the Legislature the Act incorporating the town of Oakland would be repealed, and he did not want to see the town deprived of so munificent an endowment; moreover, that it would enable settlers to make better terms with the Spanish claimants, in case the Spanish grant were confirmed; that he would rather deponent would take it, or any other responsible person, than hold it himself; that it was a mere conveyance in trust for the safe-keeping of the property, and that he would give bonds, if necessary, to restore it to the town; and added, that there was no necessity for the people knowing anything about the transaction; that the said Carpentier requested deponent to call upon the said Marier, who was President of the Board, and say to him that he (Carpentier) would give bonds to restore the property to the town, and to repeat to the said Marier
" Deponent further says that on the night of the same day, to wit, the i8th day of May, and after the conversation had as aforesaid, deponent was present at a meeting of the Board of Trustees, the said Carpentier was present, and stated publicly to the Board in the hearing of all present, that as some dissatisfaction had been expressed in relation to that ordinance, he would alter it to a term of years, or to a limited time, or words to that effect; that the words ' thirty-seven years,' or the words 'for the period of thirty-seven years 'were then inserted by the said Carpentier (the ordinance having been reconsidered) as deponent supposed, and from the declarations of said Carpentier, so as to limit the estate or interest in the water frOnt of the town to be vested in said Carpentier, to the period of thirty-seven years, or such shorter period as the authorities of the town might at any time thereafter determine, and it was not until after the lapse of six or eight months that deponent discovered that the said words had been so inserted as only to apply to the right to collect wharfage and dockage, and not to the grant of the water front; that the said ordinance appeared to be in the handwriting of said Carpentier, who, in the presence of the Board, himself inserted the said words. . The' amendment was adopted and the ordinance passed, and deponent says that the ordinance now on file amongst the papers in the oiifice of the Clerk of the city is not the same paper which was then before the Board; that other amendments beside the one mentioned as aforesaid were made by the Board, as the journal of the Board will show; that any such amendments as the one suggested aforesaid by the said Carpentier, were either proposed to or adopted by the Board, nor does said journal contain any notice whatever of the same; that the ordinance now on file in the office of the Clerk of the city appears to be in the handwriting of the said Carpentier; that it contains no interlineations or erasures, and cannot therefore be the ordinance that was passed by the Board at the said meeting; that only three members of the Board were present at that m:;eting, viz.: A. Marier, A. Moon, and E. Adams; that the journal of the proceedings of that and other meetings of the Board appear to be in the handwriting of the said Horace W. Carpentier.
" And deponent says further that afterwards, to wit: in the summer and fall of the year 1852, that Carpentier stated to deponent in the course of conversation, that he, Carpentier, had promised to give to Gen. James M. Estill a portion of the water front, and that he had been obliged to do so in order to get the bill incorporating the town of Oakland through (the said Estill being at the time of the passage of said Act a member of the State Senate), and afterwards, in the winter of 1852 and 1853, the said Carpentier again stated to deponent that he, Carpentier, was under bonds to the said Estill to convey to him the one-fourth of said water front, and that in the spring of 1853 the said Estill told deponent that he held the said Carpentier so bound as aforesaid, adding that it was in consideration of using his (Estill's) influence with the Governor to induce him to approve the bill incorporating the town of Oakland; that at or about the same time some conversation occurred between the said Carpentier and Estill, in the presence of deponent, in relation to the value of said one-fourth of the water front; that this last statement of the said Carpentier, and the conversation between the latter and said Estill, occurred in consequence of an application made by deponent to said Carpentier, to purchase from him that part of the water front opposite deponent's premises.
"And deponent further says that the said Board of Trustees also passed an ordinance entitled ' An Ordinance to approve the Wharf at the foot of Main Street, and to extend the Time for constructing the other Wharves,' which ordinance appears to be in the handwriting of the said Carpentier, and that on the 5th day of March, 1853, according to the minutes of said Board, the said Adams introduced an ordinance entitled ' An Ordinance to create a Public Ferry between the Town of Oakland and the City of San Francisco, and to Provide for keeping up and running the same,' which ordinance according to said minutes was passed; and said minutes show, that the only members of the Board who were then present, were the said Adams, Burrell, and Moon; and no previous notice appears on the journal of said Board, of the introduction of said ordinance, nor does it appear that any petition was before the Board for the passage of the same, nor did the nature of said ordinance or its passage become generally known, as deponent believes, until several weeks thereafter.
"And deponent says further, that from the circumstances attending the passage of the Act incorporating the town of Oakland, the secrecy practiced, the agency through which it was effected, the manner in which the Board of Trustees was elected - two of its members being partners of said Carpentier - the failure of ^ the said Carpentier to qualify or take his seat as a member, although elected by his own choice, the action of the Board in the passage of the ordinance giving to said Carpentier the exclusive privilege of erecting wharves and collecting wharfage, and granting him the water front of the town; the circumstances attending the amendment of that ordinance, and the other facts herein stated, he, deponent, became convinced and verily believes that the incorporation of said town and all that was done by the Board of Trustees in the premises was the contrivance of the said Carpentier, fraudulently to get into his hands a valuable property and valuable rights, and convert to his own use what had been intended and should have been used for the public benefit, and deponent says that such has been the general conviction and belief of the people of Oakland, and that all subsequent actings and doings of the said Carpentier and his confederates have tended to strengthen that conviction and belief
" And deponent says further, that when the facts above stated became generally known, and it was ascertained that under the ordinance first above referred to, and a contract made in pursuance thereof, the said Carpentier claimed for his own use the exclusive privilege of constructing wharves and collecting wharfage, and to hold an absolute grant of the water front of the town, and that the said Board of Trustees, had conveyed to E. R. Carpentier (who was generally believed claimed a one-fourth undivided interest in said water front) exclusive ferry privileges under the ordinance passed as aforesaid on the 5th day of March, 1853, it excited great public indignation, and with a view to check the fraudulent practices of said Carpentier and his partners and creatures in said Board of Trustees, and to assert the rights of the town, the people attempted at the second municipal election which took place (to the best of deponent's recollection) on the 9th day of May, 1853, to elect a Board of Trustees composed of men in whom they had confidence, but the appointment of Judges and Inspector of the election being in the hands of the former Board, and the Board having the power to determine upon the election and qualifications of its own members, it was declared by the Board that the following persons were elected, viz. : Alpheus Staples, A. W. Burrell, A. Moon, E. Adams, and A. Marier, the last four of whom were members of the former Board; that at said election, when the tickets were consulted, it appeared that only some forty odd votes had been cast for the candidates who were declared to have been defeated while about seventy or eighty had been cast for those declared elected, but in the course of thirty-six or forty-eight hours after the election, not less than seventy voters made their affidavits that they had voted for the former. And the deponent says that the returns of said election together with the tally-list are not on file in the office of the Clerk of the city, nor from the best information he can obtain, does not believe that the same were ever handed over to the authorities which succeeded to the town of Oakland.
" And deponent further says, that A. Marier, one of the Trustees declared elected, and whose name had been on both tickets, and who for some time had refused to attend the meetings of the Board, did not qualify or take his seat as one of the Trustees, and the four remaining members composed the Board during the year; that said Board so elected and so constituted, did, as appears by the minutes of the proceedings of said Board, on the 27th of August, 1853, pass an ordinance entitled 'An Ordinance concerning Wharves and the Water Front;' and that said Board also passed an ordinance on the 29th of October, 1853, entitled 'An Ordinance concerning Wharves' - That the passage of said ordinances as deponent believes, and has been informed, was not publicly known for several weeks or months thereafter.
" And deponent further says, that the journal of the said Board of Trustees shows that the said A. Marier did not attend any of the meetings of said Board held after the 3d of March, 1853, and that from that date to the i6th of May, 1853, the business of said Board was conducted by the said A. W. Burrell, A. Moon, and E. Adams, that the journal of the proceedings of the aforesaid second Board of Trustees shows that only four members qualified and took their seats, viz.: A. W. Burrell, A. Moon, E. Adams, and Alpheus Staples, and that nowhere does it appear that five members organized, constituted, or were present at any meeting or meetings of any Board of Trustees that ever exi.sted in the town of Oakland.
"And deponent further says, that to the best of his knowledge and belief, the city of Oakland has never recognized the claims of the said Horace W. Carpentier and E. R. Carpentier under the grants aforesaid, as being valid, but on the contrary have passed sundry ordinances and resolutions asserting the rights of the city in the premises; certified copies of which ordinances and proceedings accompany this deposition, and the others being 'An Ordinance concerning Ferries ' approved June 5, 1855; 'An Ordinance Repealing an Ordinance, entitled An Ordinance to create a Public Ferry between the Town of Oakland and the Cityof San Francisco.and to Provide for keeping up and running the same;' passed June 15, 1855; 'An Ordinance concerning Ferries,' approved May 19, 1855; an Ordinance passed on the 13th of September, 1855, under which a contract was made with Rodman Gibbons for the constrilction of a wharf; ' An Ordinance to extend the time for completing the wharf on Bay Street.'
" And deponent says that under authority of the Council of the city of Oakland an action was brought in the District Court of the Third Judicial District, for the county of Alameda, in the name of said city and against Horace W. Carpentier and Harriet N. Carpentier to set aside and have declared void the ordinances and deeds under which said Carpentier claimed the said water front and said exclusive privilege of erecting wharves and collecting wharfage, and for the delivecy to the plaintiff of the wharf and property claimed under said ordinances and deeds, and that said action is now pending in the Supreme Court of this State.
"And deponent says, that he is the Treasurer of the city of Oakland and ex officio Clerk of the city, and has the custody of the journals of said- Boards of Trustees of the town of Oakland and Council of the city of Oakland, and of the original ordinances and papers of said bodies.
" AMiiDfiE Marier, being duly sworn, deposes and says, that he is a resident of the city of Oakland, in the county of Alameda, and has resided in said city, formerly town of Oakland, since April, 1851; that at the first election of Trustees for said town, held on the loth day of May, 1852, he was elected a member of the Board of Trustees, and at the third meeting of said Trustees he was chosen President of the Board; that he was present at the meeting of the Board, at which was passed the 'Ordinance for the Disposal of the Water Front of the Town of Oakland, and to Provide for the construction of Wharves; ' that said ordinance was introduced on the 17th of May, 1852, and was finally passed on the i8th of May; that the ordinance as presented was in the handwriting of Horace W. Carpentier; that on the 17th of Ma}-, 1852, before the meeting of the Board, said Carpentier exhibited the proposed ordinance to the deponent, and wished deponent to vote for it; that deponent refused to do so, whereupon said Carpentier stated to deponent that the object of having the ordinance passed was to secure the water front to the town of Oakland, and to enable the settlers to compromise with the claimants to the land on which the town of Oakland was situated; that there was some talk of a called session of the Legislature, and if there was a called session, the Act of Incorporation would be repealed; and upon this subject he made to deponent various representations to induce him to support said ordinance, all which tended to show that the ordinance would benefit and could not injure the people of the/town; that deponent did not then read the ordinance, but said Carpentier stated its contents to be that it was a grant to himself of the water front, and the exclusive privilege of constructing wharves at Oakland; but he said that he did not care to have the grant to himself; that he would rather that some other person should take it than himself; that he would hold it in trust for the town, and reconvey it to the town whenever requested; that deponent, relying upon these representations and promises, consented to support the ordinance, and at the meeting of the Board did vote for it; that before its final passage there were some amendments made to it by striding out the word ' forever,' and inserting the words ' for the period of thirty-seven years,' which alterations, as deponent then supposed and still believes, applied to the grant of the water front as well as to the privilege of constructing wharves; that deponent afterwards signed the ordinance, now on file, under the same impression, believing that it was a true copy of the ordinance and amendments as passed, and did not know until some time afterwards that it was incorrect m not limiting the grant of the water front to the period of thirty-seven years.
"And deponent says that some time afterwards, as President of the Board of Trustees, he signed the grant or contract, dated May 31, 1852, made in pursuance of said ordinance; that said contract had been previously drawn up by said Carpentier, and was laid with other papers on the table in the room where the Board met, where it remained for some days, but deponent was reluctant to sign it, and was determined not to do so until said Carpentier should give bonds according to his promise, to reconvey the property whenever requested; that at length the said contract was pre-, sented to deponent by said Carpentier in person, on board the ferry-steamer Erastus Corning, at the wharf in the city of San Francisco, and deponent was requested by said Carpentier then to sign it; that said Carpentier represented that he wanted it immediately for some important purposes, deponent thinks to submit it to the Land Commissioners, and that it was very important thkt it should be executed at once; that deponent asked said Carpentier where was- the bond that he was to -give to reconvey, to which said Carpentier replied that he had not time to give it then, but would give it as soon as he came over to Oakland, and thereupon, relying upon the representations and promises of said Carpentier, deponent signed said contract.
"And deponent says, that at that time he knew very little of the nature and effects of deeds and grants, or of the forms and modes of doing business in municipal bodies, and had unlimited confidence in said Carpentier, who used to act as Clerk and draw up papers for the Board of Trustees and its members, and advise and counsel them in all matters connected with municipal matters, no member of the Board being able, unassisted, to draw up an ordinance.
" And deponent says that prior to the passage of the Act of the Legislature incorporating the town of Oakland, the name of the place was Contra Costra, and it had never been called Oakland so far as deponent knew; that no proposition had ever been made amongst the residents of the place to change its name or to have it incorporated, nor had there ever been any discussion upon these matters, nor any wish expressed for the incorporation of the town; that at the time of the passage of the Act there were only about seventy-five persons residing at the place; that when it became known amongst them, through the newspapers, that a town called Oakland, in Contra Costa County, had been incorporated, the people did not know that it was the town where they lived, and it was a subject of discussion amongst them where the town of Oakland was.
It is unnecessary for us to dilate upon these two documents; they breathe the air of truth; better, therefore, is it to leave them in the hands of the contemplative reader, while we return to the official acts of the City Fathers.
At the meeting of August 8, 1855, Alderman Gibbons introduced an ordinance having reference to wharfage and dockage, prescribing and regulating the amount thereof; that, after passing its second reading, was referred to the Committee on
Streets and Wharves. The intention of this enactment was a material reduction of the rates then in force, and being favorably reported upon by the committee, was, on the 15th August, read a third time, and unanimously adopted on the motion of Alderman Worthington. At this same session a resolution was passed refusing to recognize E. R. Carpentier, who had been appointed counsel for the town during the regime of his brother, as attorney for the city in the suit of S. J. Clark against the city, and forbidding him to act as counsel in her behalf in any action, matter, or proceeding. On September 12th Aldermen Williams, Johnson, and Harwood were appointed a committee to draw up a contract with Rodman Gibbons for the building of the wharf at Bay Street, there being subsequently another ordinance passed confirming the contract to him, while on January 17, 1856, he was granted an extension of time to August, 1856, for its completion.
The election for the third Council of the city of Oakland resulted in the choice of S. H. Robinson as Mayor, and although his seat was contested by Mr. Campbell, his immediate predecessor, resulted in the confirmation of the former gentleman. It is thought by some that the reason of Mr. Campbell's defeat is to be found in the implacable detestation he had for the water-front scheme and all that belonged to it, while it is hinted that many illegal votes were cast for Mr. Robinson. However, in the ranks of the new Council, Carpentier had several opponents to his claim, and they soon opened fire upon the enemy. Their first move was a petition to the State Legislature, praying for a confirmation to Rodman Gibbons of the contract to build the Bay-street Wharf.
In obedience to the provisions of the charter, the newly elected Mayor now dispatched his first message to the City Council, in which he called their attention to the urgent necessity that existed for removing the bar at the mouth of the San Antonio Creek, and also to the manner in which the ferry between Oakland and San Francisco was being conducted. In regard to the latter, we quote his own words: "That the present ferry between this city and San Francisco is not what it ought to be, and is conducted in almost total disregard of the public wants and interests is a fact notorious to all. What steps, if any, ought to be taken by you with a view to an improvement, I am not at present prepared definitely to recommend; but I commend to you the whole subject-matter as one eminently worthy your careful consideration."
Water-front matters were comparatively tranquil during the tenure of the third Council, the only action worthy of notice being the granting of further time, to May, 1857, to Rodman Gibbons for the completion of the Bay street wharf, on which work had been commenced, however, without let or hinderance on the part of the waterfront claimants. It is just possible that even at that early date they recognized the feebleness of the reed on which they leant.
On March 4, 1857, Andrew Williams was elected Mayor, and among the Councilmen we once more have the name of Mr. Marier. In his message we find Mayor Williams referring to the vexed ferry, question, while he strenuously urged upon the minds of the Council the fact that there existed no ferry monopoly; that they had under their sole control the matter of wharfage and dockage privileges, and were free and independent from the water-front ownership. In regard to the water front he remarked: "The question of the city's title to its water front is of such paramount interest that I propose to make it tlie subject of a special communication to your Honorable Body at an early day. The great extent of the water front, bounding the city on three sides and part of the fourth, for a distance of eight or ten miles, and its future incalculable value, entitled it to your special and prompt attention. There have been put forth some claims of individuals to this large patrimony which we believe to be without foundation, and there is also a question as to its ownership by the proprietors of the Mexican grant of the adjacent shore. To obviate any preten.se of the individual claims against the city first above named acquiring any plausibility by five years' adverse possession, I recommend the immediate commencement of a suit at law to quiet the title to this large and valuable property. It is believed an amicable arrangement can be made with the proprietors of the Spanish grant to save the city harmless from expense in case of the eventual confirmation of their title to this immense domain. The great importance of this subject is my apology for reiterating my earnest recommendation of this subject to you for your immediate action." Acting upon the advice of the Mayor, at the meeting held April i, 1857, Alderman Davis offered the following resolution': -
Resolved, That the Judiciary Committee be, and they are hereby authorized and directed to confer with competent counsel upon the subject of the title to the water front of the city, and also to confer with the claimants thereto under the Spanish grant and ascertain and report to this Council what arrangements can be made, and what steps may be necessary and expedient to take for settling the claim of the city thereto,
Which, on motion of Alderman 'Marier, was adopted. On the 15th April they reported progress, and on May 13th the Judiciary Committee last mentioned in the matter (the water front) presented the following communication from Joseph Z. Baldwin and Henry P. Irving, attorneys: -
"Having been requested by Mr. Marier to state in writing the terms on which ,we would act as Counsel of the city of Oakland in a suit proposed to be instituted by the city for the purpose of setting aside a conveyance purporting to have been made by the town of Oakland to Horace W. Carpentier, we agree to render our professional services for that purpose on these terms : Two hundred dollars to be paid to each of us in cash, or as soon as convenient, and seven hundred and fifty to be paid to each in case of success in the judgment. The services to be rendered not only in the District Court, but, in case of an appeal, in the Supreme Court of California."
The committee also reported an agreement upon the part of certain claimants to the marsh-lands within the limits of the city, to bear their proportion of the expenses attending a suit for the recovery 0/ the water front, which agreement' they would present in writing at a subsequent meeting. This report was accepted in due form, and the annexed resolution adopted: -
Resolved, That the proposal of H. P. Irving,,.and Joseph Baldwin be hereby accepted, and that they be instructed to commence suit immediately for the recovery of the water front.
Nothing more of interest in regard to water-front matters occurred durino- the year 1857, save that W. M. La Roche was granted until May, 1858, to complete the wharf at Bay Street.
In March, 1858, Mayor Williams was re-elected to the civic chair, and on May 19, 1858, an ordinance was passed granting permission to the San Antonio Steam
Navigation Company to run a ferry between the cities of Oakland and San Francisco, the passenger rates of which were not to exceed twenty-five cents for each passenger. The president of this company was the late James B. Larue, and he was licensed to run the ferry-boat San Antonio between the cities above named. The ordinance provided also that nothing in it should be so construed as to prohibit any other company or individual from running boats between Oakland and any other place.
During 1859 and until the election of the sevenj:h Council in March i860, no mention is made of water-front matters. In his message of March 28, i860, however, Mayor J. P. M. Davis refers to the subject in these terms: "Prior to the organization of the city government, Oakland had fallen a prey to the passions of designing men, who, in an avaricious desire to accumulate wealth, regardless of the means by which it was to be obtained, seemed to set at defiance all rights of property, public and private. The results of this were oftentimes manifested in scenes of lawlessness and disorder on the one hand and a reckless regulation and control of municipal affairs on the other. The consequences were that when the city was organized under the charter of 1854 she was found despoiled of all the marsh-lands which had been donated to the town by the Legislature of the State, and burdened with an enormous debt, incurred by most reckless means. For the recovery of the land a suit has been instituted by the city which is now pending in the Supreme Court of the State."
"Resolved, That Messrs. Irving & Thompson, Attorneys for the city in the case of the City of Oakland H. W. Carpentier et al., be and they are hereby requested to take such steps as they may deem necessary to obtain from the proper Court the appointment of a Receiver of the rents and revenues of the property involved in said suits."
In reply to which the Council received a communication from Irving & Thompson, informing them that the remittitur in the case of City of Oakland versus H. W. Carpentier et al. had been sent down and that the costs were due thereon. These were ordered paid on May 9th.
In the mean time Mr. Carpentier attempted to steal a march upon his antagonists in the hope that he might be enabled to keep the water-front property. To this end he obtained the passage of an Act through the Legislature, entitled "An Act to amend an Act entitled an Act to Incorporate the City of Oakland,'" confirming all the ordinances passed by the town of Oakland. Of this proceeding the Council and the citizens of Oakland were supremely ignorant. Suddenly the startling intelligence burst upon them as they read the twelfth section of the Act, which is as follows: "The Corporation created by this Act shall succeed to all the legal and equitable rights, clauses, and privileges, and be subject to all the legal or equitable liabilities and obligations of the town of Oakland; and the ordinances of the Board of Trustees of said town are hereby ratified and confirmed, and the Common Council shall have power to maintain suits in the proper Courts to recover any right or interest, or property which may have accrued to the town of Oakland." When the news reached the city officials of the passage of the Act it seemed as if a shell had burst in their ranks. A meeting was immediately convened, and on July 24, 1861, the following resolution was passed and ordered published three times in the Alta California and the Alameda Gazette: -
Whereas, At the late session of the Legislature of the State of California, a bill was introduced by F. F. Fargo, at the instigation, as we believe, of H. W. Carpentier, entitled " An Act to amend an Act entitled, ' An Act to Incorporate the City of Oakland, passed March 25, 1854,'" and
Whereas, The said Act so passed, ratified and confirmed all the ordinances passed by the Board of Trustees of the town of Oakland, thereby designing to confirm to said Carpentier the entire water front of the city of Oakland, exclusive ferry privileges, and other grants and franchises unlawfully made by the Trustees of the said town, therefore
Resolved, That said Act of Confirmation was introduced and passed without the knowledge, consent, or approval, or application of the city of Oakland, or of any officer or agent of the same, and will be resisted by all legal means that the city can command.
These machinations of Carpentier, however, were soon to be thwarted. Recognizing the manifest impoHcy of such a movement, the Legislature, at its next session, repealed the obnoxious Act, and there the subject rested for some time.
At the election held in March, 1863, William H. Bovee was elected Mayor, and in the Council were Messrs. O. L. Shafter, James de Fremery, and W. W. Crane, Jr. In their reign the water-front question assumed a new phase, as will be gathered from the following resolution, introduced by Alderman de Fremery and passed on motion of Alderman Woolsey: -
Provenance
Text from History of Alameda County, California : Including Its Geology, Topography, Soil, and Productions : Together with a Full and Particular Record of the Spanish Grants : the Early History and Settlement, Compiled from the Most Authentic Sources, the Names of Original Spanish and American Pioneers, a Full Political History, Comprising a Tabular Statement of Officers of the County Since Its Formation : Separate Histories of Each of the Townships, Showing Their Advancement and Progress : Also Incidents of Pioneer Life, the Raising of the Bear Flag, and Prominent Citizens and Representative Men : and of Its Cities, Towns, Churches, Schools, Secret Societies, Etc, published 1883, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.