William Rutledge, an employee of Western Division, Naval Facilities Engineering Command, San Bruno, prepared this documentation in and 86. Woodruff Minor, an architectural historian3also wrote portions of this report. Catherine Taylor edited. Laura Kahapea typed the report. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1S48 (page 2 ) m INTRODUCTION: This report documents the buildings and history of the U.S. Naval Hospital in San Diego in the event that new uses bring alteration or demolition to the twenty-two original buildings, built in the years through This report pursues four investigative thenes set by the Historic American Buildings Survey: (1) The role of the Naval Hospital within the context of Naval facilities in the San Diego area.
(2) The specific history of the Hospital's site, including: (a) initial planning and development; (b) changes in the plan and evolution of the site; (c) architects, planners, and other significant individuals associated with the site; and (d) historical events or developnents associated with the site. (3) The relationship of the Naval Hospital to the physical and developmental history of Balboa Park and the City of San Diego. (4) A physical description of the Hospital complex: (a) according to the original architectural plan; (b) as it changed over time; and (c) at present.
This report's first chapter places the program to build the Naval Hospital into perspective as part of a larger program to shift Navy facilities into San Diego in the That massive shift came of the convergence of the Navy's program to build a Pacific chain of naval bases and the city's effort to interest the Navy in developing San Diego harbor and thus further local economic development. 3an Diego donated land, including the Hospital site in Balboa Park, to bring the city economic well-being. Chapter Two analyzes the Hospital's original architectural design for the sources of its layout and its styling. The Balboa Park site was a product of earlier events in Balboa Park and of the city's promotional efforts to bring the Navy to San Diego.
The Hospital's open-ward type buildings were in the older pavillion hospital tradition and the buildings were grouped according to Beaux Arts planning principles. The Mission architectural style narked the Navy's earnest adoption of a regional style to serve political ends. In Chapter Three San Diego witnesses the Navy's largest building program in the years between the wars. The Hospital was but one of four architecturally significant complexes the Navy's Bureau of Yards and Docks built in San Diego in the The construction program brought the economic activity the city had bargained for, but the ever-increasing patient loads caused the Naval Hospital to expand onto additional Balboa Park land.
Continued growth and specialization caused the original buildings' interiors to be altered and their functions to be changed. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA (page 3) Finally Chapter Four, Architectural Effects, looks at the structural and decorative changes in the Hospital up to this time. This chapter considers the growing interdependence of the buildings and landscaping as they cane to forti the visually nore acceptable whole that won the Hospital complex eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places. Discussions within each of the chapters are arranged under subhead titles to allow the reader to use this report as a reference work. The table of contents allows the reader to locate specific topics. Scholarly readers nay wish to turn directly to the bibliography.
TABLE OF CONTENTS: CHAPTER 1: HISTORY OF THE
The San Diego Chamber of Commerce 5 Great White Fleet, 5 San Diego Courts Development, 7 Will "fan Kettner - City Booster, Congressman 7 Pendleton's Campaign for an Advanced Marine Base 8 High Level Navy Interest in San Diego Land, 9 Roles for West Coast Bases, .11 Final Gifts of City Land, 12 Summary of Navy Land Acquisition 15 CHAPTER 2: THE ARCHITECTURAL
Hospital Site in Balboa Park . 16 History of Park Setting, .16 Architectural Design: The Original "Groups As Projected" 17 Sources in the History of Hospital Design. . . , . 20 Sources in the Architectural Ideas of the Tine 21 The California Mission Style 22 The Influence of Goodhue 23 Precedents in Other Bureau Designs 24 Credits for Designing The Hospital ?5 The Hospital as Part of the Navy's Architectural Progran .29 Line Drawings 31 CHAPTER 3:
The Bureau of Yards and Docks 41 Sense of Architectural Mission 42 Construction Managers: The Navy's Civil Engineers Corps 42 The Pro iran for San Diego 43 The Value of the Program to San Diego. . . , .45 Building Out the Original Design .46 Internal Changes 50 Pressure from Growing Hospital Operations 53 More Land Grants to the Hospital 54 HABS Building Numbers 57 Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS Ho. CA-1.648 (page -i) CHAPTER 4:
The Community Reacts 58 Original Landscaping Plans 59 Landscaping -- A Response to Public Criticisn .50 Landscaping the Interior Courts 61 Original Surface Effects 62 Alterations to the Original Buildings. 63 The Hospital in 64 SOURCES 66 LIKELY SOURCES NOT YET INVESTIGATED . ,*9 APPENDIX A: THE LAND EXCHANGE 70 APPENDIX B: SIGNATURES ON ORIGINAL HOSPITAL CONSTRUCTION DRAWINGS. . . .73 APPENDIX C: SAN DIEGO PUBLIC WORKS OFFICE EMPLOYEES 77 Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 5 ) # CHAPTER 1: HISTORY OF THE NAVY IN SAN DIEGO The Navy base we see in San Diego seems a part of the natural setting. But San Diego was not always a U.S. Navy base.
Up to the beginning of this century, the Navy had no base in San Diego and it was not a foregone conclusion that the Navy would ever select San Diego. The San Diego Chamber of Commerce [1] As early as the San Diego Chamber of Commerce had stated its goal of making San Diego the headquarters of a military district. The Chamber's emphasis was on attracting Army facilities. Appropriations for Army harbor defense facilities (for building Point Loma's Fort Rosecrans) and for improving the inner harbor (a downtown wharf to land supplies for inland Army posts) did lay some basis for naval facilities. During the Spanish American War, the Navy chose Army land on Point Loma, the most southwesterly point in the United States, as a place to fuel passing warships.
The Point Loma Headland extends into the sea, protecting the San Diego Harbor from northern storms. In those days Point Loma was two hours west of downtown San Diego. The Navy began building a coaling wharf on the Army's Point Loma Military Reservation land where water was deep enough for shallow-draft destroyers to come up to shore. The coaling station was not completed in time for the v/ar, but the Navy held onto its wartime permission to use the Army land until In that year the 241 acres of hillside land were finally transferred from Army to Navy custody, and the history of permanent Navy facilities in San Diego began. The San Diego Chamber of Commerce used the tiny Point Loma coaling station to argue for Congressional appropriations to dredge their beautiful 22-square-mile harbor.
San Diego had grown sporadically through booms and busts as a garrison town, a promoter's paper town, a remote railhead, and later as a resort and retirement community. The population had declined after each successive boom (after a peak in the boom of it had dropped to by and the Chamber of Commerce believed that improving the shallow harbor for Navy use would hasten the harbor's commercial development. The Chamber had so far achieved only moderate success playing on national interest to pull in appropriations for their harbor ^This account is based on Kettner's Why It Was Done And How and Klaus' History of the San Diego Chamber of Commerce. Please see bibliography.
^Congress appropriated in to rechannel the San Diego River into False Bay (now Mission Bay) after the river changed its course, dumping silt into San Diego Bay. In as part of nationwide harbor fortifications for war with Spain, the Army Corps of Engineers had begun a 7,500-foot, breakwater at the mouth of the bay. The breakwater, completed in at a cost of allowed larger ships to stop at San Diego. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 6 ) The Navy's strategic planning had not accorded San Diego any importance and the tiny city yearned for some role in the nineteenth-century naval expansion that had passed it by. In San Diego's Chamber of Commerce sent its secretary, Wood, to lobby in Washington for further harbor appropriations and resumption of the dormant Panama Canal project.
Whereas San Diego was then only a small port of call on a remote coast, the new canal would situate San Diego on the new 10,000-mile-shorter main route of American naval and merchant ships to the Orient. San Diego would be the first American port of call above the border. But the Navy's interest in San Diego remained limited to deep water berths off Point Loma rather than locations farther into the shallow harbor of San Diego. In November of the first high-level Navy officers visited San Diego, at the invitation of the Chamber of Commerce, to explore Point Loma for further Navy use. Asst. Secretary of the Navy Charles H. Darling and Frank L.
Sargent of the California Naval Militia were accompanied by John Akernan, President of the Chamber of Commerce, on a tour of the harbor en route to an inspection of the Coaling Station on the Point Loma Naval Reservation at deep water. Darling looked at Point Loma as a possible dry dock site. The Navy also wanted to build a naval radio station on Point Loma rather so that it would not have to rely on a dispatch boat or carrier pigeons to communicate 160 miles to its Pacific Sguadron at Magdalena Bay in Lower California, its regular winter drill ground.
The squadron would then be able to radio messages back through that Point Loma shore station to its home port in San Francisco Bay or even to Washington, On the air in Point Loma had enough power on good days to communicate miles up to North Head, Washington, and 550 miles down to Magdalena Bay, Lower California. In February after asking the harbor pilot whether the Pacific Squadron's flagship Charleston could enter San Diego Harbor, the Point Loma radio station told the Squadron commander: "Pilot Keith informs me that 26 feet can be carried over outer bar at mean low water....
Pilot does not think Charleston can come in" Great White Fleet, For San Diegans, the visit of the Great White Fleet on its round-the-world show of force in seemed to herald the city's arrival on the national and international scene. The official program, which referred to the fleet as the Famous Peace Squadron making the rounds of the nation's new Floating Empire, gave this order of march through downtown San Diego: the Fort Rosecrans Coastal Artillery Corps, a brigade of Marines, four brigades of sailors, the local National Guard, Naval Reserves, the Grand Army of the Republic, Confederate Veterans, Spanish War Veterans, Uniformed Civic Societies (e.g. Knights of Columbus), the News Boys' Brigade, and the City Fire Department.
Local boosters like to think that the Great White Fleet's visit made San Diego a Navy port of call, as if the Fleet's 16 battleships had steamed straight into the harbor and its sailors had swarmed ashore. But the Fleet's battleships had to lay in deep water off the coast while small tenders ^Records of the San Diego Naval Coal Depot. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 7 ) brought in only of its men to parade through downtown San Diego. Local dignitaries departed from the municipal pier on a shallow draft destroyer to make a courtesy call to the Admiral on his flagship.
Photographs of the arrival of the Great White Fleet are provided in the Field Records section of this report, identified as photographs 001 and San Diego Courts Harbor Development, In to attract attention to the harbor's potential for maritime commerce, the Chamber of Commerce proposed that San Diego stage an exposition to identify itself with the opening of the Panama Canal. The Panama-California Exposition Company, organized in selected Collier, a prominent developer and civic leader, to organize and promote the fair. Collier chose a site in Balboa Park and recommended Spanish Colonial Revival as the architectural style for the exposition buildings.
In spite of San Francisco's announcement (on the day the Panama-California Exposition Company was organized) that it would host the only "official" exposition to celebrate the completion of the Panama Canal, San Diego proceeded with its plans. With a population of around in less than one-tenth the size of San Francisco, San Diego became the smallest city ever to attempt a world's fair. Ironically, the State Board of Harbor Commissioners, formed in to oversee the development of state tidelands, did little in the way of bringing harbor improvements for San Diego. Finally, in the City of San Diego, led by the developer and exposition promoter Collier, persuaded the State Legislature to transfer the jurisdiction and control of the tidelands along San Diego Bay to the city.
The legislation stipulated that within five years the city would expend on dredging and on constructing a pier and a seawall. Bond issues approved in and provided and supported deepening the channel sandbar and building the Broadway Pier. Although these improvements enhanced the commercial value of the harbor, the city's new control over the tidelands was much more significant. San Diego had large tideland areas remaining open for development. City ownership allowed the community to engage in long-range planning and development and to court large developers, including the Navy. William Kettner - City Booster, Congressman The new Chamber of Commerce board of directors elected January 7, focused the business community's attention on port development goals.
The Chamber's officers included William Kettner. This board introduced San Diego newcomer William Kettner to men of influence and led to his election to Congress several years later. Kettner proved extremely effective in his two terms of office in Washington His first action, before even assuming his seat in the House of Representatives, was to secure a Naval officer's memorandum that spoke favorably of San Diego. In March Kettner secured a appropriation from the House Committee on Rivers and Harbors for the city's dredging project, which went on to gain the approval of the Senate Commerce Committee through the support of Senator John D. Works of California. Kettner was appointed to the Committee on Rivers and Harbors in June a coup for Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page S ) a freshman Congressman. During Kettner*s tenure on the committee, four different appropriations totaling were made for harbor improvements in San Diego Bay. He culminated his career in Congress as a member of the House Naval Affairs Committee, to which he was appointed January [4] Kettner helped secure appropriations in May for the construction of naval shore facilities in San Diego. The earliest construction was on Army land, the Point Loma Military Reservation. The appropriations were toward completing the wharf at the coaling station (started in and toward converting its coal depot into a fuel oil station. (Navy ships were being converted from coal to oil.) In March Kettner came home to San Diego and met Marine Corps Colonel Pendleton for the first time.
Pendleton gave Kettner a copy of the speech he had made the previous September praising San Diego as the site of a new Marine Advanced Base. Although Kettner had been thinking about more naval installations for San Diego, the idea of the new Marine Corps unit there apparently had not occurred to him until this meeting. Pendleton's Campaign for an Advanced Marine 8ase at San Diego, Immediately prior to the war, the Marine Corps had been evolving toward a new structure of permanently organized expeditionary units with fixed bases of their own. The new units, called Advanced Base Forces, would be of regimental size or larger and located near the potential theaters of operation, ready to support fleet actions. U.S.
Presidents had used Marines with naval forces in Panama Colombia (several times), Nicaragua and Mexico Wilson had ordered the naval occupation of Vera Cruz and deployed naval forces off the west coast of Mexico as well. A new West Coast Marine Corps regiment of troops at Mare Island and Bremerton was deployed in May down the coast of Mexico. When that regiment came back in July it camped on the tip of the sand spit now called North Island. ^William Kettner, an insurance salesman who moved to San Diego from Visalia in was elected in to represent the congressional district, a vast territory which included San Diego.
Kettner was born in Michigan in He moved to California in lost his savings in a mining scheme in the mountains east of San Diego, and eventually settled in Visalia in where he was a realtor and insurance agent active in fraternal organizations and civic affairs. Following a divorce, he moved with his second wife to San Diego in the fall of Kettner was at home in the promotional ambience of San Diego. He joined numerous organizations, achieving local recognition in by organizing the Chamber of Commerce's festivities for the visit of the Great White Fleet. It is remarkable that he was elected to Congress after only five years in San Diego. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 9 ) The Panama Canal was scheduled to open in August of that year.
San Diego and San Francisco would hold their separate expositions that winter to celebrate the canal. San Diego ilarine Commanding Officer Colonel Joseph H. Pendleton participated in both expositions. He sent his 1st Sattalion to the San Francisco Exposition to set up a demonstration camp for public relations and recruiting purposes. His 2nd Battalion remained in San Diego to demonstrate for its exposition there. Ilarine Corps Headquarters had assuned Pendleton would establish his regimental headquarters near the Navy's West Coast battle fleet headquarters at San Francisco Bay, at least for the duration of the two expositions, but Pendleton surprised them.
He established his headquarters in the San Diego Exposition grounds, and he began to lobby for a permanent Marine base in San Diego On September 16, Colonel Pendleton spoke of San Diego as the site for a Ilarine Advanced Base at a banquet celebrating the renaning of an armored cruiser the San Diego. He praised its location's strategic advantages and local training areas, and he recognized the fine welcome the locals had given his Marines. Pendleton sent a copy of his speech to the Commandant of the Marine Corps.
In February a Marine Colonel friend of Pendleton's reminded hin that Headquarters had had no plans whatsoever to establish any Marines in San Diego until the moment Pendleton and Aubrey Davidson, president of the Exposition, had asked Headquarters for a Marine detachment for the fair. High-Level Navy Interest in San Diego Land, In Navy Secretary Daniels sent his Assistant Secretary of the Navy Franklin Delano Roosevelt as advance nan to plan presidential visits to the forthcoming San Francisco and San Diego Expositions.
On this same trip the Navy asked Roosevelt to look at the Point Lona Coaling Station land as a potential site for either the Naval Training Station that might be transferred from San Francisco Bay or as the base for a mobile regiment of Marines The ranking naval officer in San Diego, Commander Davis of the Recruiting Office, escorted Mr. and Roosevelt on a tour of Naval facilities. Because there were no naval craft in the harbor, Commander Davis arranged for them be taken on John Spreckel's yacht, with lunch en route, to the Coaling 5 This account is based on Gordon's The Marines Have Landed and San Diego i"s Well in Hand. ^Because Mr.
Roosevelt had been interested in the use of the Colonial Revival style of architecture in New York state, we looked into the possibility that Roosevelt might have taken a personal interest in the design of naval facilities in the Spanish Colonial Revival style. We also thought that Roosevelt might have been interested in the Naval Hospital because her work toward improving conditions for sailors and Marines in St. Elizabeth's asylum in Washington had marked her entry into public life. But an examination of the Roosevelts' papers (in the Roosevelt presidential library in Hyde Park) failed to reveal either had any role in the planning or construction of the San Diego facilities. When he and his wife visited those facilities during World War II, they apparently took no personal credit.
Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 10 ) Station. There, the Boatswain in charge demonstrated where coal was stored on the United amount of level ground next to the water. The second day Commander Davis took the Roosevelts in a touring car, with golf at the Point Lorna Country Club en route, to the Naval Radio Station high above the Coaling Station. There a Navy officer who was visiting to "test ether wave distance," showed Roosevelt the plans for the new high-powered station at Choi las Heights, several Miles inland. After a Chamber of Conmerce luncheon and a tour of the area, a noving picture cameraman took several hundred feet of newsreel as Roosevelt's car was the first to cross the Cabrillo Canyon Bridge to enter the exposition grounds.
According to a San Diego Union reporter, when Roosevelt was pressed to comment on the Navy's future role in San Diego, he "let it be inferred" that the Navy might transfer a few torpedo boats to San Diego after the canal was open. The Union headlined the story, "San Diego To 8e Great Navy Base, Says Roosevelt." After his first visit, Roosevelt's only official action was a sinple memo increasing the Coaling Depot staff by one mechanic, one laborer, and one watchman.
He also stated that "in view of the probable gradual increased use of this Station in the near future, the facilities for coal handling should be increased and improved." In Roosevelt accompanied Vice President Marshall to the San Francisco and San Diego Expositions when President Wilson cancelled his scheduled visit and sent Marshall on his behalf. On this second trip, Roosevelt found the San Francisco climate to be cold and damp and became a strong advocate of moving the naval training facility already established in San Francisco Bay to San Diego. In response to Roosevelt's enthusiasm, the Chamber of Commerce invited the Navy Training Station Commander to investigate training facility sites in San Diego.
Secretary of the Navy Josephus Daniels also visited San Diego in Daniels, like Roosevelt, was converted to the idea of San Diego as a location for naval shore facilities.
An excerpt from Daniel's autobiography (published in suggests San Diego's promotional panache in those years: "At San Diego our reception had a cordiality all its own Its representative in Congress, 'Sill' Kettner (he was affectionately called 'Bill' by his associates in Congress as well as by his home folks) had talked to me in Washington on the advantages of San Diego as a Naval base, and the whole population was united to convince the new Secretary that San Diego was by far the best site for Naval bases on the Pacific We were the guests of the grandson of President Grant, who owned the most modern hotel, and upon leaving San Diego for Los Angeles en route to Washington, we were the guests of John D. Spreckels on his yacht.
Spreckels owned the chief newspaper in San Diego and boosted the place with persistence.) It was a voyage so delightful it remains fixed in my own and my wife's lasting recollection As a result of that visit and my knowledge of the climate and the fact that San Diego was the nearest port on the Pacific to the Panama Canal, before my term of office expired [several naval facilities] had been established at San Diego." Upon returning to Washington, Daniels ordered Marine Commandant Barnett to choose among the sites being offered within the San Diego area. Barnett chose Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 11 ) a 232.24-acre tract along the bay shore offered by its private owners for approximately While Kettner lobbied at his end in Washington, Pendleton worked in San Diego on Washington visitors. He took particular care to entertain the members of the House Rivers and Harbors Committee who visited San Diego at a1post the same time as General Barnett. In January Kettner introduced legislation funding the land purchase Barnett had favored. A municipal referendum approved, by a vote of to the city's offer to donate 500 acres of submerged tidal flats adjacent to the tract that the Marines wished to purchase. The city considered a Marine Corps base an esthetic improvement over the mud flats.
The House Committee on Naval Affairs travelled to San Diego to view Kettner's proposed site for themselves. They were impressed. Congress approved it on August 29, and the Navy Department took an important step in acquiring land for a major naval base. Up to this point, the Navy had begun establishing itself in a very small way by transfers of government land on Point Loma. All the early sites were at the mouth of the harbor to serve passing ships. None were well inside the harbor or on purchased land.
(The Navy had set aside acres of the Coaling Station for a Point Loma Naval Radio Station in In the Navy gained custody of an old Army Torpedo Station for the sort of torpedos now termed harbor mines to established a Navy Torpedo Station.) Then by the eve of World War I the Navy made its first three purchases within the heart of San Diego. In when the Navy was building its first high-powered worldwide radio network, Kettner persuaded the Navy that its West Coast relay station (relaying messages from Arlington headquarters to Pearl Harbor and on to Cavite) belonged in San Diego.
The Navy purchased the Choi las Heights Naval Radio Station site from a private owner for In Congress authorized the Navy to buy the 232-acre privately owned parcel that Marine Corps Commandant Barnett had selected (a purchase that brought with it the City of San Diego's donation of adjoining tidelands). Then in the process accelerated when Congress passed bills to purchase part of North Island for an Army Flying Corps base and the remainder for a Naval Air Station. The Navy was acquiring these components through a seemingly ad hoc process. We have not found any reference to a master plan that speaks of bringing those components together to create an all-around naval base.
The driving forces behind this scattering of new naval facilities were the most recent naval doctrine and technology: radio communications, torpedo boats, deployment of marine infantry for overseas operations, and naval aviation. The outbreak of World War I interrupted the possibility of building facilities on any land the Navy and Marines might acquire in San Diego. Yet staff planning for the Pacific chain of bases gained momentum as a result of the war, Roles for West Coast 3ases, By the end of World War I the American West Coast had emerged in Navy planning as the stem for supply and material that earlier planning had assumed would come around the Horn or later through the canal.
The West Coast would at last become a base for operations, even though the ships it would supply might be Nava] Hospital, San Diego HA6S No. CA-1548 (page 12 ) last-minute transfers from the Atlantic Fleet. A major share of the Navy's million budget would go for building shore facilities on the West Coast and Hawaii. San Diego aspired for a role in this new arrangement. Despite years of planning for San Francisco Bay and earlier priorities which saw no advantage to locations farther south than San Francisco, the issue was eventually resolved in favor of Los Angeles. Los Angeles emerged as a great industrial base with a modern harbor closer to the fleet assembly point at Hawaii. San Diego was less well suited than Los Angeles for a naval base.
San Diego was less well fortified and more vulnerable to land attacks across the Mexican border; its railroad and steamship connections were inferior; it was a smaller hinterland and of less commercial importance; it had restricted areas of foot anchoring depths; and it had a limited supply of skilled labor and neither large machine shops nor ship repair facilities. Yet after the battleship group was headquartered in San Pedro with its capital ships tying up in the Long Beach portion of the Los Angeles harbor, San Diego began to benefit, as the Navy transferred component after component to Southern California, because San Diego could offer a southern defense for Los Angeles and provide it with supplies and personnel.
The place of San Diego in the Navy's planning process shows the Navy's plans had always been elastic enough, intellectually and geographically, to allow arguments in favor of disparate locations all the way from Puget Sound to San Diego. The process was also flexible enough to accommodate political pressures toward one site or another. It is ironic that San Diego's craving for a naval base, founded on a groundless belief in its destiny as a natural harbor, did succeed in attracting naval facilities, yet not the types that required a deepwater harbor.
(Not until Federal expenditures continued into the was the harbor dredged deeply enough take the first aircraft carrier.} Final Gifts of City Land, The Naval Affairs Committee visited San Diego immediately after the war to look over the wartime concrete ship plan (owned by the U.S. Shipping Board's Emergency Fleet Corporation) as a possible Naval Ship Repair Station site. They passed favorably on the site and transferred it to Navy custody in September In a related exchange of small parcels with the city under terms favorable to the Navy, the city donated its vestigal rights to the site and to adjoining tidelands. The site quickly became the home port for a destroyer squadron, and thereafter was known as the Destroyer Base.
Not until did Congress authorize the Navy to accept a donation of land for a naval training station. Back in the Chamber had shown the San Francisco Training Station commander one site on False Bay (now Mission Bay), another on the lower end of Silver Strand, and a third on privately owned land at the near end of Point Loma. The commander had convinced the Chamber that the Training Station would relocate only to the tideland site next to the prospective Marine Corps Base. The Chamber agreed to raise money, buy the site, and give it to the Navy. Naval Hospital, San Dieqo HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 13 ) But the Chamber's offer gave Congress pause for considering the overall size of the buildup in San Diego not only the cost of building facilities on all the aforementioned land parcels, but also the cost of building support facilities such as a hospital and a supply depot. Accordingly, Congress stipulated that the governnent would accept the training station site only if the government were given a site for a hospital. The City decided to donate Balboa Park land in return for the agreement to build the Naval Training Station.
The process of city land donation culminated when Secretary Daniels asked for the block of city-owned land adjoining the municipal pier for a supply depot and the city deeded the 1.55-acre parcel to the Navy in June The choice of a Balboa Park hospital location grew out of the historical circumstances of World War 1 in San Diego. Locating a hospital in a public park has vexed some people as inappropriate since that time. During the War the Chamber had invited newly arriving Navy units to camp in the abandoned exposition grounds in the park, along with the Marines still camped there waiting for the Navy to build facilities on the newly purchased Marine Base site. The Training Station set up a large Naval Training Camp inland from the Marine Corps area.
The Naval Aviation contingent ran ground school in the park until their North Island flight school got underway. The Navy Medical Corps dispensary, which had accompanied the Marines from their arrival, became another large separate camp. In June the first units of the medical department reported to the training camp's Sick Quarters to increase the level of specialization. 8y the time of the November Armistice, that field hospital's tent colonies had reached a bed capacity of over The Training Canp was abandoned May but the Navy designated the camp's old Sick Quarters as a hospital in its own. That field hospital remained in full operation when the influenza epidemic struck. The Navy wished to continue in that location.
But after long discussions, the Navy and the city agreed that the field hospital would have to move away from the exposition area to a permanent site, but to a site still within the park. They agreed on an undeveloped site on the fringe of the park called Inspiration Point. Who selected Inspiration Point is not clear. Congressman Kettner recalled that it was City Councilman Moore who first suggested that site. The Navy was active in the matter of a hospital site. In the Navy's Chief Pharmacist suggested at a Chamber of Commerce luncneon that the city donate a tract of land for a permanent naval hospital to serve San Diego's growing Navy base. In the fall of under Public Works Officer Commander Leonard M.
Cox, "investigations were made upon the best location for a Naval Hospital at San Diego, to accomodate the needs of the local stations and the needs of the ships attached to the Pacific Fleet when in neighboring waters." Secretary of the Navy Josephus Daniels and members of the House Naval Affairs Committee (including Kettner) visited to look at the proposed sites in March of Local Navy officers likely briefed Daniels concerning the preferable hospital sites. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 14 ) Years later, Secretary Daniels recalled, "Leading citizens showed ne half a dozen sites for a Naval Hospital. All the time ny heart was set on an elevation in Balboa Park for a Naval Hospital, but the committee showed me every other possible location.
I was not impressed with any of them. I finally said 'Let us drive through Balboa Park.1 When we reached the eminence I had in my mind picked out for the Hospital I asKed 'Bill' [Kettner] to stop so that we could stand upon the hill in Balboa Park and get a view of the Pacific Ocean and beautiful Point Lo.na in the distance. If you will deed this site, I said to 'Bill' and the committee, I will recommend to Congress the erection of a modern hospital at San Diego." The site they agreed on for the U.S. Naval Hospital was acres on a southern promontory in Balboa Park.
The promontory, a spur of the park's central mesa, is a quarter-mile long north-south ridge that declines only slightly in elevation before dropping off steeply to Florida Canyon on the east and sloping into a fairly shallow arroyo on the west. The southern tip affords a panoramic view of downtown San Diego and Coronado and so was named Inspiration Point. In May Daniels changed the designation of the existing medical camp in Balboa Park from "War Dispensary" to "Naval Hospital," a formality that placed the Navy in a better position to accept a land grant and to receive federal appropriations. In July the Navy accepted the Chamber's gift of a 135-acre Training Station site along with adjacent city-owned tidal lands, and also the acre hospital site in Balboa Park.
The lands were deeded to the Navy by the City of San Diego on September 4, and the donations were ratified by San Diego voters on August 3, Thus, by the end of the decade the Navy had a complete array of specialized sites for a naval operating base. The first sites were hand-me-downs from the Army's Point Loma land to be used for Navy coastal services. The second sites were purchased from private property owners to be used for high technology naval facilities. The last sites, including that for a hospital, were gifts to the Navy for bringing the Training Station and the warships into the harbor area. The community expected the Navy, in exchange, to spend large sums on construction and bring a steady payroll into the city.
The community, moreover, expected the Navy to build architecturally significant complexes on the four major sites. (Those four were: (1) the Marine Corps Base, {Z) the Air Station, (3) the Training Station, and (4) the Hospital.) Thus the new Naval Hospital was to be part of a larger architectural program to beautify the city. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 15 ) Here is a summary of the land the Navy acquired from to NAVY LAND
Sep Coaling Station 241 ac Transfer from War Dept. Sep Radio Station ac Transfer fron Coaling Station Mar Torpedo Station n.a. Transfer from War Dept. Aug Chollas Heights Radio Station ac Purchase from Henry Carling Aug Marine Corps Advanced Base 232 ac Purchase from San Diego Securities Co. Aug Naval Air Station, North Island 554 ac Forced purchase from Coronado Beach Co. Jul Naval Training Station 135 ac Donation from Chanber of Commerce Jul Naval Hospital ac Donation from City of San Diego Sep Destroyer Base ac Transfer fron U.S.
Shipping Board (and City donation of adjacent tideland) Jun Naval Supply Depot ac Donation from City of San Diego (The Imperial Beach Radio Compass Station is not included in this list because it was strictly speaking not part of the San Diego complex, but was established in as part of the Pt. Arguello, Port Huenene, Pt. Fermin, Avalon, Point Loma, and Imperial Beach radio compass navigation system.) Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 16) CHAPTER 2: THE ARCHITECTURAL HISTORY OF THE HOSPITAL A architectural sketch shows the hospital was planned to be an attractive group of Mission style buildings on a promontory of Balboa Park. That sketch is shown on page 3 1 of this report.
The group is noteworthy for its harmonious architectural styling, unified planning, and spectacular siting. This chapter traces sources of that original design. Hospital Site in Balboa Park A topographic map of the Naval Hospital site shows an old concrete foundation on Inspiration Point, a cottage and stable on a knoll to the southeast, and an unpaved road that ran along the east edge of the ridge and wound down the south face of the promontory to the city grid below. The hospital site was a spectacular back door into the park, a vista point accessible only by the unpaved road and removed from the mainstream of Balboa Park's improvements.
It was an idyllic place with grass, scattered eucalyptus trees, quiet gravelled carriage drives, and distant views of the harbor We can see the condition of Inspiration Point immediately before construction of the hospital in the site plans identified as HABS-CA-1548-63 and HABS-CA-1548-64, and also in the Field Record photographs numbered 012 through 015 which show the site being cleared for construction. History of the Park Setting, In the San Diego Board of Trustees set aside acres for a city park. San Diego's was the second largest urban park in the United States after New York's Central Park, and it preceded San Francisco's Golden Gate Park by two years. The area was nearly square, measuring one and one-half miles across, a high flat mesa overlooking the town and bay.
Deep arroyos cut through the mesa from north to south. The landscape was dry and barren. Chaparral and cacti were the only vegetation, except in spring, when wildf lowers carpeted the hills. Water and topsoil had to be imported before this land would become the English-style park of grass and trees it is today.
^The foundation may have been the remnant of a home for indigent women, later converted to an orphanage that was built by the Women's Home Association in (One of the few buildings erected in Balboa Park in the nineteenth century, the orphanage had an address on Street, a city street which came into the park from the south before its severance by the Crosstown Freeway in and which remains on the north-south axis of the Hospital site.) The road indicated on the topographic map is almost certainly the old northward extension of Street. While the cottage and stable have not been documented, they probably were erected after as part of the comprehensive park improvements begun that year. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 17) Little was done to the land until the when local volunteers began planting the western edge under the direction of locally celebrated horticulturist Kate Sessions. In the Chamber of Commerce appointed a Park Improvement Committee that invited John McLaren, Superintendent of Golden Gate Park, to visit the park. On McLaren's suggestion in October of that year the committee retained Samuel Parsons, consulting landscape architect for New York's park system. Grading and landscaping began in the summer of according to Parson's plan, which called for preserving the natural contours of the land. By roadways had been built, a partial water system installed, and landscaping was completed along the length of the park's western edge.
The work was initially financed by private donations. After municipal taxes came to be administered by a Park Commission for further landscaping and improvements. In the Park Commission sponsored a contest to find a name for this hitherto unnamed park. They named it Balboa Park. This marked a major new phase of the park's development. The Panama-California Exposition Company selected Balboa Park as its fair site, and in August voters approved a bond issue to improve the park. These funds, along with eventually raised by the fair's organizers, supported an ambitious scheme that permanently altered the park and set precedents for its future uses. The main exposition buildings stood along an east-west axis (El Prado) on the central mesa of the park.
Visitors approached them by a spectacular new bridge crossing the arroyo to the west. Secondary buildings and concession stands extended to the north and south. Park Boulevard with its electric streetcar line was cut through the park to run northeast past the exposition site, and coincidentally past inspiration Point. Most of the exposition buildings were meant to stand only for the duration of the fair, but popular acclaim won their retention and eventual reconstruction. This unforeseen city-within-a-park, with its paved boulevard and streetcar access from downtown giving access also to Inspiration Point, set a precedent for the construction of other independent groupings of buildings in Balboa Park.
Architectural Design: The Original Drawing of the Hospital "Groups As Projected" The design produced by the Bureau of Yards and Docks for the U.S. Naval Hospital shows an architecturally harmonious grouping of two- to four-story buildings organized axially and for the most part symmetrically around open courts. The original perspective drawing, reproduced here, was titled "Groups As Projected." Its basic layout and design were realized to a great degree in the hospital's construction. The original drawing's bird's-eye view shows a major axis running true north-to-south along the ridge of the Inspiration Point promontory, parallel to the sides of the long rectangular 17-acre Navy parcel.
The principal buildings of the hospital formed three quadrangles interconnecting along the main axis; arcaded or cloistered courts formed the core of each quadrangle. The three squares that made up the long north-south rectangle we will call the Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 18) centra] compound. At the far north end of the site next to Park Boulevard, residential structures were to be grouped around a central green. The underlying functional pattern was of three groups: (!) a working hospital in the central compound, (2) the support facilities on the eastern slope, and (3) a residential green to the north. These were the three "Groups" that the original drawing caption refered to.
A horseshoe-shaped access road from Park Boulevard ran south into the hospital grounds past a gate house, continued south along the western border of the site past the central compound, looped around Inspiration Point at the south end, and returned back up the east side of the central compound past support structures {power house, store house, shop building, and enlisted personnel quarters). The hospital was a new Park Boulevard streetcar stop and its personnel would cone and go by trolley. Its few service trucks, ambulances, and visitors' autos were provided ample parking on the hospital grounds. Parking was adequate for about a decade. When the site's last open spaces were built over, the plan became suddenly obsolete.
The apparent architectural orientation of the hospital group, however, was not the same as its functional orientation to the main road and rail entrance on the north. Its architectural orientation was to the west, with its principal facade facing downtown San Diego and the Bay for tourists to view and its utilitarian rear backing onto Florida Canyon to the east. The twin towers of the Administration Building presented a formal entry from the west, but patients, visitors, and employees actually came and went from the north. All its buildings, with minor exceptions, were to be finished with pastel stuccoed walls and red-tiled roofs. Host buildings were ornamented sparingly with cast-stone trim of restrained Renaissance-Baroque derivation.
The overall style of the group, though often called Mission at the time, would be termed Spanish Colonial Revival, or Mediterranean by today's nomenclature. The focal point of the composition was the Administration Building, the centerpiece of the group's west facade, facing downtown San Diego. The front elevation of this building, with two massive towers flanking an arcaded entrance, powerfully evoked Spanish colonial cathedral and mission architecture. It unmistakably announced the stylistic intentions of the designers, particularly when seen in silhouette from the park and from downtown. It was the visual symbol of the Hospital group. The Administration Building was flanked by matching ward buildings which together formed the long west side on the central compound.
The western facade grew in height from each end toward the center, beginning with a small flat-roofed two-story facade at each end, rising to the height of a hipped roof over most of the two-story wards' lengths, and then to three stories where the cross-axial buildings intersected from behind, and finally to an open roof-top third-story solaria covered by pergolas at the inner ends of the wards where they met the central three-story Administration Building. The corresponding east side of the compound was formed by a three-story central Subsistence Building (dining hall) on east-west axis behind the Administration Building, also flanked by two-story matching ward buildings. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 19) The north and south ends of the court between the Administration and the Subsistence buildings were closed by two-story buildings on east-west axis. These two lower interior buildings, an Operating building on the north and a receiving (Out Patient) building on the south of the central court, were set at right angles to the long sides of the compound, thus separating the long rectangle into three interior courts, or quadrangles, of equal size. All the buildings of this central compound were connected by sidewalks that followed the perimeters of the interior courts. The sidewalks were covered, their collonades giving a cloistered effect. There were none of the present-day second-story gallery-type walkways in the original plans.
Around the nain compound were added the remaining buildings of the hospital: a detached isolation ward to the south that repeated the high center and low wing motif; an industrial (shop) building to the east on the same east-west axis with the administration and subsistence buildings; an unidentified building also on the east, with steep gables and a residential appearance that may have been an early sketch for the Red Cross Convalescent House; and to the north, an officer's ward in a slightly Palladian style. That Sick Officers' Ward formed one side of the proposed northern residential green, facing the staff officers' single-family houses on the north side of the green, whose backyards were the part of the hospital nearest to Fork Boulevard.
(The City gave the hospital no frontage along Park Boulevard, only a narrow entrance road.) The focal point of the residential group, at the eastern end of the green, was the Nurses' Quarters, again a massive neo-classical building with the three-story center and two-story wings. One plan shows an oval-shaped street around the green, a naturalistic contrast to the generally geometric plan. Finally, the utility buildings and whatever else was left over were placed out of sight on the east side along the visually isolated back road. The enlisted men who served as orderlies Hospital Corpsmen--were to be housed in a building at the rear of the compound, at a location that is not clear from the original perspective and plot plans.
(It is interesting, and revealing, to contrast the conspicuous siting of the Officers' Ward in the residential section of the compound with the uncertain placement of the enlisted personnel quarters somewhere along the rear service road.) The design did not turn verandas outward toward the city views (with the initial exception of the ward buildings' third-floor solaria in the original drawings, which the next drawings showed walled-in to provide third-floor bed space). Instead, the buildings faced onto cloistered courts, while their rear walls faced outward to give the public an impersonal visual effect. The compound resembled a penitentiary in that respect.
In summary, the original "As Projected" design for the hospital compound incorporated three primary groupings of buildings, segregated according to function, but unified by a single architectural style, a consistent use of materials, and a strongly axial plan reinforced by symmetry. The central compound -the actual working hospital-~was a self-contained unit turned in upon itself around the three interior courts. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 20) Although that original scheme was an ideal projection that was modified somewhat during subsequent design and construction to meet functional needs, the main grouping was realized to a remarkable degree, both in terms of general layout and architectural appearance, over eighteen years of construction.
Once the Dasic concept had been set, the Bureau admitted little change in its execution. As the years went by, its continuity was reinforced by the officers who had personally overseen the original design of the hospital as they rose into higher positions in the Navy's Bureau of Yards and Docks. Let us look into the sources of ideas for that original "Groups As Projected" drawing for the Hospital. Sources in the History of Hospital Design Hospitals as institutions for the care of the sick and wounded date at least as far back as Roman military hospitals. Their courtyard plans were not much different from the plans for principal hospitals in the Middle Ages housed in monasteries.
A new era in hospital design began in the nineteenth century based on new theoretical understandings of disease and on the efforts of Florence Nightingale. The idea that miasma (infectious vapor) of disease could be alleviated by exposure to clean, fresh air resulted in hospitals built as separate, free-standing pavilions of only one or two stories and usually connected by arcades or covered walkways. The pavilion hospital flourished in the United States and continued to influence hospital design long after the scientific basis for this type had been discredited. Pasteur's and Lister's discoveries in the and the identification of bacteria rather than miasma as the source of disease introduced a new basis for hospital design by the first decade of the twentieth century.
Sterilization, rather than access to fresh air, became the determining factor. This new understanding of the transmission of disease allowed a tighter grouping of wards and rooms and ushered in an era of high-density hospitals. The pavilion form eventually gave way to the skyscraper in the late But in the interim, more coupact buildings (seen as more efficient) were the dominant type. These were often a taller two- to six-story cruciform of H-shaped buildings, affording all rooms sunlight, but in a more efficient way.
In this transitional period, circulation, efficiency of operation, and management techniques began to have a greater influence on hospital design, and, following the nineteenth-century tendency to specialize hospitals by type, now each hospital tended to specialize by department (i.e., maternity, contagious diseases, surgery, etc.) on separate floors or in separate wings. Also, open wards allowing free air circulation in the pavilion hospitals gave way to smaller wards and private rooms. Military hospitals played a central role in the history and development of hospitals as a building type and were similar to other hospitals in function Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 21) and appearance.
Their major differences lie in the traditional military concern with security, in the strictly hierarchical nature of the military bureaucracy, and in the practice of housing personnel on the premises. Military hospitals, like most military facilities, and unlike civilian hospitals, are typically isolated behind fences and entered via a gate house; separate areas segregate patients who are officers from patients who are enlisted personnel; and the grounds usually include auxiliary structures for housing the hospital staff. The higher status of officers within the military hierarchy is reflected in their individual detached houses or private rooMS. Enlisted personnel are housed together in barracks.
In the case of hospital wards, officers are typically placed with other officers in a private room while enlisted men are placed in an open ward with rows of beds, often in a separate building. The U.S. Naval Hospital design in San Diego incorporated all these considerations of security, hierarchy, and segregated housing. The Naval Hospital in San Diego is transitional in type between the pavilion hospital and the later skyscraper hospital. Elevators make its buildings work, yet it does not strongly exemplify the dominant, high-density type of its period. Its unusual courtyard plan may derive from considerations of style or security and, despite its relationship to the early centuries of hospital design, is largely without contemporary models as a low-scaled courtyard plan.
Few such pavilion hospitals appear to have been built with courtyard plans. The courtyard may have come from the Mission architectural style. As a two- to four-story courtyard complex with separate structures for auxiliary purposes, a predominance of open wards over small rooms, and an emphasis on natural ventilation, the San Diego Naval Hospital is closer in spirit, if not in actual appearance, to the older pavilion hospital type than to the later high-density type.
Sources in the Architectural Ideas of the Time To understand the original significance of the architecture and planning of the Naval Hospital, it is necessary first to look at the larger development of which the hospital was a part, namely, the project to design and build four related architecturally important facilities in San Diego: the Marine Corps Advanced Base, the North Island Naval Air Station, the Naval Hospital, and the Naval Training Center. These four facilities were planned between and with a unified architectural expression a simplified version of the Spanish Colonial Revival Style and according to a common set of planning principles. They were planned in the Beaux Arts style.
The arrangement of all four facilities buildings into groups was based on the Ecole des Beaux Arts principles of symmetry, axiality, and ordered proportions that dominated many other large-scale planning efforts of the period. Like the city plans, civic centers, world's fairs, and institutional complexes built during the City Beautiful Movement, these four facilities could only be a product of the four decades after the World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago which introduced the Beaux Arts potential for unified planning. The Beaux Arts approach was especially appropriate for the San Diego facilities because its design process was originally developed for and applied Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 22) to creating a series of government and military buildings.
Yet the San Diego facilities were not exclusively products of the City Beautiful Movement and the teachings of the Ecole des Beaux Arts. The California Mission Style The simplified Spanish Colonial Revival style seemed an obvious complement to San Diego's Mission and Old Town, to the expanding body of Hispanic revival architecture in the city, and, in the case of the hospital especially, to the exposition buildings still standing nearby in the park. The Spanish Colonial Revival was part of a movement in the late nineteenth century to revive interest in the regional architectures of the colonial period. In New England, for example, there was renewed interest in English Georgian architecture.
In California, and to a lesser degree throughout the Southwest, the region's Spanish colonial architecture was rediscovered. In Southern California, particularly with regards to California missions, the revival was informed as much by a taste for the picturesque as by enthusiasm for the colonial past. The Spanish Colonial Revival occured in two distinct yet overlapping phases. The first phase was the Mission Revival, extending from the to approximately The second phase, termed Spanish Colonial Revival or simply Mediterranean, flourished between and The Mission Revival was part of a romantic fascination with the missions, which was exploited by the railroads and land promoters, particularly in Southern California during the boom of the late and after.
It also led to a mission preservation movement and to a serious appraisal by architects of the possibilities of incorporating elements of mission architecture into contemporary design. The original missions, built in the frontier of Alta California in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, were simplified versions of Renaissance-Baroque Hispanic churches, usually constructed of adobe brick with whitewashed walls. Common design elements included massive buttressed walls, low-pitched red-tiled gable roofs, curved and scalloped pediments, domed bell towers, round-arched arcaded corridors, and large patios with fountains or gardens. The Mission Revival was popularized by A.
Page Brown's California Building a pastiche of mission facades and arcades at the World's Columbian Exposition. It reached its fullest development in the first decade of the twentieth century. The style was associated in particular with Southern California, where Mission Revival train stations, resort hotels, residences, schools, libraries, clubs, and churches conveyed a collective image both exotic and indigenous to visitor and resident alike. The second phase of the Spanish Colonial Revival is actually more Mediterranean because it brings together architectural elements from Italy and Islamic North Africa as well as from Spain and Mexico. This latter phase tended to more carefully reproduce the historically inspired architectural elements, particularly in ornamentation.
As popularized by Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue's buildings at the Panama-California Exposition, the style was characterized by large bare-wall surfaces punctuated with intense concentrations of ornamental detail. However, the spectrum of building style Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 23) types ranged from simple vernacular farmhouses to high-art cathedrals, and architects in the often produced designs with little or no ornament, characterized simply by stuccoed walls and red-tiled roofs. The growing influence of the modern movement, with its precept of abstract massing devoid of ornament, led some practitioners of the Spanish Colonial Revival style toward greater simplification.
Goodhue's later simplified Spanish Colonial Revival, for example, represented his efforts to move beyond literal interpretation to achieve a more Modern effect. The Influence of Goodhue The Navy's projects were all influenced by Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue, a highly individualistic and influential New England architect. Goodhue himself designed the Marine Corps Advanced Base, working in collaboration with Navy Bureau of Yards and Docks architects. San Diego had hired Goodhue to be chief architect of the Panama-California Exposition in Balboa Park. San Diego was so delighted by Goodhue's Exposition building designs that it required the Navy hire Goodhue as a consulting architect for the Marine Corps Base and Naval Air Station as a condition for receiving their gifts of city land.
Although the Bureau's architects had already drawn preliminary sketches of the San Diego facilities, when those sketches reached Secretary Daniels he vetoed their English Georgian style. "Tear them up," Daniels ordered, "and study the type of architecture that prevails in Southern California.
It would be an architectural crime to adopt Newport or Norfolk architecture in Southern California." Bertram Goodhue and the Bureau began their collaborative design of the San Diego Marine Corps Base in Goodhue was no longer a consultant to the Navy in when the Hospital was designed, but he influenced the planning and design of all four facilities including the Hospital through the power of his Panama-California Exposition complex in Balboa Park - especially the California Building - and his work on the Marine Corps Base. Goodhue was an outspoken critic of the City Beautiful Movement, of the influence of the cole des Beaux Arts, and of the classical styles usually associated with them.
Goodhue's distinctive solutions, rather than imposing order on the land, as he felt the City Beautiful Movement aspired to do, addressed the site's particularities and local history to produce a more appropriately tailored image. While his San Diego work shared some overall characteristics with contemporary Beaux-Arts work, his courtyards with fountains, and other stylistic features derive also from his interest in the architectures of Mexico, Spain, and Persia, especially the Spanish Colonial architecture of Mexico about which he wrote a book. His overall intention was to not impose m ideal classical order, but to adapt carefully chosen elements into an indigenous local order.
Goodhue popularized a new Spanish Colonial Revival architecture style at the Exposition which spread through much of the United States and became strongly identified with San Diego and other California cities such as Santa Barbara. He designed a number of houses and public buildings in Southern California and had a second home near Santa Barbara. In that sense, the New Eng'lander Goodhue can be regarded a California architect. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 24) Goodhue's Exposition style was more highly decorated than his later works. All four San Diego naval facilities, whether by Goodhue or not, display this more modern, simplified version of the Spanish Colonial Revival, with a minimum of literal Spanish details.
The light plain stucco wall surfaces, the red tile roofs, the arcades, the courtyards and fountains of the Marine Corps Base, all suggest his earlier Hispanic architecture without the bombast. [2] Precedents in Other Bureau Designs The Hospital shared some basic architectural characteristics with other Bureau designs. The Bureau used the same structural system in San Diego it was using elsewhere - a reinforced concrete frame, the walls of which were infilled with hollow tile blocks. It was a reinforced concrete skeleton. Its block walls and gypsun slab roofs were light enough to allow such a slender frame. The Bureau had found these frames preferable to steel--cheaper and faster to build, and providing superior headroom, daylighting, and fireproofing.
This structural system was best suited for industrial warehouse buildings, but it was put to nearly e^/ery use. (The concrete structural system is described in the HABS Outline Form concerning the Hospital's Administration Building.) The Marine Corps Base and the Naval Air Station had already set a precedent for grouping standard Navy buildings in San Diego: a string of three narrow two- to three-story buildings abutting end to end, like boxcars ^We examined the Bureau's correspondence with Goodhue and concluded that he no longer played a significant role in the Navy's design process by late when the Hospital was designed.
Goodhue began working for the Navy in mid-1917 when, at the instigation of the San Diego Chamber of Commerce, the Bureau invited him to Washington to look at its preliminary layout sketches for the Marine Corps Base. There he agreed to become "consulting architect" for the Marine Corps Base. (The contract was a fixed fee plus expenses.) As collaboration on the design for the Marine Corps Base progressed in the Bureau then also hired Goodhue to help design an Air Station for San Diego. But in the case of the Air Station, the Navy's officers and architects imposed so many changes upon Goodhue's ideas that he began to reconsider having his name associated with the Air Station's design.
Goodhue was having serious problems with his health, the exchanges with Navy architects grew rancorous, the Bureau's Chief decided not to renew Goodhue's contract for the Air Station, and by early Goodhue was doing no more for the Navy than meeting his remaining obligations for the Marine Corps Base. It seems noteworthy that his name is not lettered on the drawings for the Naval Air Station. For reasons for economy also, the Bureau did not approach Goodhue to design the Naval Training Station or the Naval Hospital. However, his influence on each is apparent. See Richard Oliver's book for an account of Goodhue's career. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 {page 25) in a train.
The middle building had the higher and more interesting roof (usually a tile hipped roof with an interesting ventilator along the ridge) flanked by the two less interesting flat-roofed buildings that gave the group a symmetrical effect. In the Hospital's original "As Proposed" drawing, the central building in the fancier western facade had the higher, more interesting Mission towers motif in the center, while the lower flanking buildings had those ventilators on their tiled hipped roofs. The Hospital's solaria had precedents in Navy Hospitals all over the country. Its courtyards had precedents in the way the San Diego Marine Corps Base designers had placed buildings around an open square.
The closest precedent was the Naval Air Station's dispensary in Navy architect Huntington Barker's drawing shows a beautiful small hospital situated around an atrium court. The facade notif is the same high central section flanked by lower-roofed wings we see in the San Diego Naval Hospital. Internal functions such as wards, a dental office, and quarters for the Hospital Corpsmen, were all arranged around a Hispanic or Moorish central patio with arcades on one side and a collonade on the other, interconnected with covered walks. None of the dispensary's exquisite architectural detailing, such as the tiled octagonal fountain or the scrolled capitals on the colut/ins, however, came to be included in the larger Naval Hospital in Balboa Park.
Drawings and photographs of architectural precedents at the Marine Corps Base, the Naval Training Station, and the Exposition are provided in the Field Records section of this report, identified as photographs 004 through Oil. Credits for Designing the Hospital That first sketch of the Naval Hospital was in the Beaux Arts manner of beginning with a bloc of uniform buildings to later be drawn out individually and in more detail. A sketch of that kind served the Navy's immediate purpose of courting San Diegans for the Balboa Park site donation. Later, the Bureau would assign its individual architects to design the separate buildings within those facades and cornice lines. Finally, staff specialists would make the final drawings of floor plans, mechanicals, and decoration.
The first sketch of the Hospital group was sent to San Diego April by the Navy project manager having overall responsibility for its design and construction, Frederick Southworth. Southworth was the Bureau of Yards and Docks project manager who specialized in hospital projects and worked with all the major figures in the Navy's design program. He had been wartime Chairman of the Bureau's Architectural Review Committee, together with Fenton, Hiss, and Partridge. In Bertrand Goodhue mentioned having designed the San Diego Marine Corps Base dispensary in accord with "the drawing prepared by Mr. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 26) Southworth." It is nevertheless unlikely that Southworth himself personally designed much of the San Diego Naval Hospital because he was too busy supervising the architects who designed it. [3] ^Frederick Southworth began his Navy architectural career as a construction manager and eventually became the chief administrator (Chief Architect) for all Navy designs. Born in Massachusetts in Southworth graduated from MIT in architectural engineering in and began designing and supervising construction for private Massachusetts architects. After Southworth had four years of civilian experience, the head of the U.S.
Naval Academy appointed him inspector of construction for six Academy buildings in In the Navy Surgeon General requested Southworth be transferred to the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery to supervise hospital construction in Washington but the Chief of the Bureau of Yards and Docks requested that Southworth be transferred instead to the Washington Navy Yard as an architectural draftsman in charge of all hospital plans and specifications then being prepared by the Bureau of Yards and Docks for the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery. In Southworth began a career that required constant travel for hospital site selection, contract management, and construction inspection.
He lived in Washington only two years, and until his retirement in He was a career civilian employee, a member of the American Institute of Architects, and during World War I changed pay status to Naval Reserve Force Commander while still working in the same Navy job. A recommendation for promotion noted he had designed a standard floor plan for Navy hospitals that featured economical construction and adaption to changing needs and to future extension. It also stated that the exactness of Southworth"s blueprints and written structural specifications were superior in clarity to those of private architects and so brought the Navy lower construction bids. In he managed construction of the Navy hospital.
He wrote the hospital portion of the Bureau's account of its World War I accomplishments, and in was detailed to assist the Veteran's Bureau. During the he was the "special consultant to the Navy's Bureau of Medicine and Surgery and in charge of all design and construction projects and contracts for hospital and subsidiary buildings for that Bureau, including dispensary buildings for all yards and stations." He designed the first multi-story Navy hospital (Philadelphia) and the largest Naval Medical Center (Bethesda). Within the Bureau of Yards and Docks Southworth served as Chairman for the Committee on Design and as Federal Specifications Board representative. He was responsible for a wide range of building types.
He eventually was named Chief Architect in charge of the Bureau's program during World War II. He retired in late to begin consulting work in Washington Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 27) Today we know the buildings' designers only by their initials on the architectural drawings. Their relative anonymity has given rise to some confusion over authorship of the Hospital. The January 1, San Diego Union claimed the forthcoming "buildings for the Magnificent San Diego naval hospital were designed by Bertram Goodhue, fanous New York architect," while allowing that the "plans and specifications were drawn under the supervision of Commander F. W.
Southworth, project manager of hospitals, Bureau and Yards and Docks." On June 3 the Union published the first bird's-eye sketch and stated more accurately that "the drawing was made by architects of the Bureau of Yards and Docks." In the the Hospital's commanding officer claimed, "it becomes difficult to find a name to which we can attach more responsibility for the planning" of the Hospital than Rear Admiral Edward R. Stitt who, as Surgeon General of the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery, had intense interest "in the inception and development of the San Diego Hospital...
and followed eyery detail of it with closest attention." But Navy architect Lincoln Rogers told the Union on March 22, that the hospital had been designed by the Bureau of Yards and Docks in Washington while he was on other duties there, and he claimed no credit for himself. Each building Must be attributed to a separate architect, and in many cases a single building must be attributed to several architects, all of whom were working simultaneously in the Bureau's drafting rooms in the The original bird's-eye sketch for the Hospital group does not carry a name, but it was likely drawn by the same designer who did the Administration Building. The Administration Building's elevation and the Hospital group plot plan were both- signed "W. probably William Partridge.
This attribution of the overall hospital design to Partridge is appropriate in view of his deep Beaux Arts background, his well-known facility for beautiful perspective drawings capable of swaying public opinion, and his position as an architect on the Bureau's review committee that had been charged with providing a Mission-style design for San Diego. Partridge was the Bureau's go-between for disputed architectural situations 4 William T. Partridge's career illustrates how deeply an architect could become involved in public buildings and public planning. Born in in the District of Columbia, Partridge apprenticed to an architect after grammar school. In he enrolled in Columbia University to read classics and take some architectural courses.
Partridge later won travelling scholarships to measure and draw ancient Italian and French buildings and then returned to teach "free use of classical orders" at Columbia. His first work was for a Boston architectural services firm that supplied drawings to architectural firms, including perspective drawings for Charles Follen McKin's proposals for the Boston Public Library competition and perspectives for John Galen Howard in several competitions, including Stanford University. Partridge moved back to Washington in to be McKim's assistant on the McMillan Park Commission, to be personally in charge of perspective drawings and tabletop models for replanning of Washington By Partridge had laid out 40 perspective drawings for Guerin and made a model of Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1S48 {page 23) the city in miniature to solve problems in site designs for the Municipal Center, the National Gallery of Art, and the Jefferson Memorial. He analyzed the origins of the city's original L'Enfant plan to learn in what historically consistent ways that plan night be extended. From to Partridge then worked for the Navy's Bureau of Yards and Docks. He instilled aesthetic awareness in its operations by helping establish an Architectural Review Committee, by bringing architects into the initial design phase of engineering projects, and by teaching incoming engineer officers about the application of basic architectural and aesthetic principles to engineering design.
In his resume, Partridge stated that he had been consulting architect for a naval hospital, but he does not say which hospital. It appears that in his position on the Architectural Review Committee and with his earlier ties to the McMillan Commission, Partridge served as the Navy's go-between when the Navy needed a plan approval from either the Federal Fine Arts Commission or the National Capitol Planning Commission. Partridge left the Bureau in to work for the National Capitol Park and Planning Commission. His perspective drawings for the Commission's report stressed historical continuity with the original plan. He helped Secretary Mellon prepare a film concerning redevelopment of the Triangle area.
He formulated extensions of the city's plans for: the Northwest Rectangle (the Interior, War, and Navy Department buildings), the Southwest Area (Social Security, Railroad Retirement, and Census Bureau buildings), the Municipal center, the Watergate Underpass near the Lincoln Memorial, the Museum of Natural History extension, and East Capitol Street. He retired from the Commission in at the age of 85. Partridge's talent for designing buildings is not clear. He won recognition for working through committees and commissions to win acceptance for other architects' designs. The American Institute of Architects thanked him for helping architects to "regain their foothold in the development of the National Capitol. . .
and to participate in its expansion" and for keeping architects involved in the city's planning process that would otherwise have fallen to engineers or landscape designers. The Institute lauded him in for city planning techniques, i.e., his "facility in perspective and model making which has helped planners to reshape many projects and clarify undertakings with the public." Again, in the Institute recounted his "phenomenal" facility with perspective drawings and stated that "his models have carried conviction in many a planning crisis." Partridge documents are in the American Institute of Architects library, Washington U.C. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 29) W. P. designed the Hospital Administration Building's exterior while designed its floor plans and A.E.F.
and drew its foundation and concrete framing plans. A year later, who designed the Hospital's Power House, was assigned to revise W. original drawings for the Administration Building's exterior. The Operating Building was designed by probably George P. Hales, the Bureau architect who had been stationed in Bertram Goodhue's New York office in to collaborate designing the Marine Corps Base. also drew the Naval Training Station plot plan.) The Operating Building, with its two dramatic skylit surgery rooms, is the most functionally expressive of all the Hospital buildings.
(The Administration Building, on the other hand, although looking something like a cathedral, has no central nave or bells in its towers to carry out the function that the exterior expresses.) was assisted in the Operating Building's design by probably Frederick W, Southworth, whom we know to have been a hospital specialist. We have not found names to fit many of the initials on the drawings for the other buildings. All the drawings and initials are listed in Appendix B. The individual designer's assignments to work on San Diego buildings as they came along gave the four major facilities a continuity of design. William Partridge worked on the Naval Air Station's Bachelor Officers Quarters before he drew the Hospital's Administration Building and two ward buildings.
Both Southworth and Hales worked on the Marine Corps Base before they designed the Hospital's Operating Building. worked on the Air Station Administration Building before drawing the Hospital Subsistence Building. Huot and Menzies worked on the Marine Corps barracks designs before Huot drew a Hospital site map in and Menzies drew the Training Station's Officers Quarters in and the Hospital Laboratory Building and North Ward Building in That interchangeable ity of designers from one of the San Diego programs to another gave the four facilities slight architectural variations without allowing the distinct identity of one particular architectural team to emerge in one particular facility.
The Hospital as Part of the Navy's San Diego Architectural Program The four important San Diego military facilities shared certain planning and architectural themes: the influence of Bertram Goodhue's Exposition designs in the arcaded courts and restrained Spanish Colonial Revival styling; the symmetry and axiality of the pervasive Beaux-Arts principles of the era; and the local fashion for Spanish Revival architecture, which the Navy had taken for its own. On one hand, the Hospital was a uniform product of the same repetitive Navy architectural program as the other facilities. On the other hand, the Hospital did not share their more robust and elaborate construction.
The other three facilities' porticos had stout columns and arcades running across open spaces from building to the other, while the Hospital's roofed walkways had only thin columns and did not go beyond the length of the buildings. The other three facilities were elaborated with literal Spanish details such as spindle grilles, timber balconies, iron railings, and tile inserts. The Hospital, aside from its Administration Building, was but sparsely decorated, Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 30) and then with subdued Hispanic details. The Hospital was the most slender and austere of the four facilities. At first we might suspect that the Navy's design program had gone through the same chronological sequence as Gebhard had described for the Mission style.
The first phase, as might be represented by the Marine Corps Base, had more massive Mission proportions with strong Spanish details. The later phase, as might be represented by the Hospital, had more refined Mediterranean proportions with finely detailed, eclectic ornamentation. But when we look into the origins of the plans we learn that the Bureau had begun drawing plans for the San Diego buildings before the negotiations for the city's land donations had been concluded, and that Secretary Daniels had rejected the Bureau's first plans because they were not "in keeping with the Spanish architecture of Southern California and Mexico". (Those drawings were probably in an English Georgian classical revival style.
Daniels said they were more appropriate to Newport, Rhode Island, or Norfolk, Virigina.) Though Daniels ordered Bureau architects to "study the type of architecture that prevails in Southern California!1, and to begin designs anew, it is reasonable to assume that the architects carried the same basic ideas of building arrangements and floor plans forward from their early East Coast style drawings to their Southern California style drawings. The eastern influences were especially strong in the Hospital designed entirely in Washington. Its Spanish influences were more superficial than the others'.
Thus it is probably better to see the four major Navy projects in a continuum that runs from the most local and original in styling at one end to the most bureaucratically repetitive and Eastern at the other. The Marine Corps Base is the most local and seminal concept, and it retains its spatial grandeur to the present. The Naval Air Station was as grand and nearly as original in its day, but has lost its spatial effects to intruding construction. The Training Station was less original than the earlier two and was designed by a Bureau team dispatched from the East. Finally, the Hospital's cloistered and slightly cramped utilitarian styling was designed completely on the East Coast.
Though the Navy's Mission Style now seems indigenous to Southern California, it was produced by Eastern-bred designers striving for an appropriately local and picturesque effect. The Bureau was using that local style, at the orders of the Secretary of the Navy, to accomplish a political purpose. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 31) o o ml C to -3- o o *. ii CO u to .a o a. o <2\ ^ o P CO o ^J u ex CO o Q W - p CO n CJ < o W H o CO QJ O u W CO P^ ei co TJ r-H CO. c> >+ <u Pi. H PK PK O &* <. O 4J C& CO fi H Pi -U o 13 H & CO iH rH CO- w MH 1=1 pq. a) o O !-J & OJ J-t CO H I t bO fi H [5 (0 W T3 CO -H .e EH i-h H O 9 fD O rt 0 rt IT 0 o rt to ffl ^ o "- H* ( ; ' W El rt g Hi H O % c l-t 8 Hi C/i vO ft tj w H O H. rt 0 M cr o 6 o (D 0 Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 35) WAf^D A (feLDG Z) HAM"..U* ATJ54 _& &OLAKIUM TOILET UT/UTY KOOP WAKD . COVe.R6P WALK C* n NUH&BS WORK ROOM f-^.roiLer en / NURses TOILET t TotL&r oi&r t BATH ' ^ coveitep WALK. uriurr c RECREATION ^H-ELfcVAfOR "Z. DRESSINGS 4 hjui*^fa,* WOP. K - i- ri . KOOM LINEN - ENTRY AT SECOMD A FLOOR POKC H QUIET ROOM T PIK^T
Oa/^OOp'pLAtJ " e&CCNP *JAilLAf\ v ORIGINAL FLOOR FLANS o' io ~"ao' ao'. IH1 Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 36) SPACE BETWEEN ADDED "} WARD A .): ttS65-U XA-l546 & 'FLOOK ..EXISTING FLOOR PLANS O1 10' 20' 30' San Diego (page 37) AREA UNDEH CONSTRUCTION ,&= 1 / 1 ^. :: . >* /. : /; ..Naval Hospital, .San Diego'""'-'* j?HABS:No. CA-1548 (page 1' ?1 1 i Hr,>^^r^'siv^^r !*' * , -< r # ><" ' *' Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 40) PACIFIC * Naval Hospital, San Diego HA3S No. CA-1548 (page 41) CHAPTER 3: BUILDING THE HOSPITAL The Navy followed its original design over the next eighteen years of construction with few modifications.
Once the concept had been set, the Navy admitted little change in the hospital's basic layout and architectural appearance, yet all the while fostered a constant evolution of hospital functions within that unchanging shell. The Bureau of Yards and Docks [1] The Navy's Bureau of Yards and Docks was responsible for new facilities for the entire Naval establishnent. It designed each new building (or hired a consultant to design it), drew up blueprints, put working drawings out for private construction firms to bid on, and supervised construction. The Bureau of Yards and Docks was nade up of civil service employees (engineers, architects, draftsmen, clerks) directed by Navy officers.
Thus when we speak of the Navy as having built a building, we are speaking of its design by civil service employees and its construction by private construction finis, all on behalf of the Navy. The Bureau Chief was a career military officer while the officers directing the civilians under them were recruited from civilian engineering practice These engineer and architect officers were called the Navy's Civil Engineer Corps (CEC) and the Bureau Chief was the head of that corps. The Bureau Chief kept his civilian staff under tight control by not allowing them to speak for the Bureau. Only the Chief and his highest ranking assistants could sign the outgoing letters that conveyed design and management instructions to contractors and the Bureau's construction managers.
Every sheet of drawings needed the signature of the top officers of the Bureau, including the Bureau Chief, before it could go to a contractor. Written correspondence constituted virtually all the Bureau's communication with its project managers in the field. Personal visits and telephone calls played an insignificant role. The Bureau required a monthly photograph of progress of each construction project. Those reports and photos, preserved in the Bureau's archives, give us a first-hand view of every building the Navy built. ^The archives of the Bureau of Yards and Docks are kept by the Command Historian of the Naval Facilities Engineering Command, Port Hueneme, California.
^Applicants for the Bureau's five-day written examination were pen 22 to 30 years old with 20 months of professional experience beyond their civil engineering degrees. Top scoring applicants were commissioned in Navy at officers pay levels and were addressed as Civil Engineer rather than by military rank. After all commissioned officers were thenceforth addressed as Lieutenant, Commander, and so on. The Naval Academy did not have an engineering school at the start of the century. In the Navy began preparing career officers to take control of the Bureau of Yards and Docks by sending two Academy graduates to three-year engineering programs. The first of those officers entered the Bureau in Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No.
CA-1548 (page 42) Sense of Architectural Mission The Bureau's architects, like other architects of the era, had been bred to traditional masonry buildings. They had a notion of "permanence" in their architectural goals. That sense of architectural mission was expressed in when they created a Board of Uesiqn. In the Bureau's Architectural Review Committee described its purpose this way: "Architecturally appropriate designs [are] to be used for buildings and structures. In order that buildings and structures of all kinds designed or built under the cognizance of the Bureau may be pleasing in appearance, as well as serve the particular utility for which intended, the Bureau has established the Architectural Committee as a consulting section apart from the Design Division.
It is the intention of the Bureau that designs shall be appropriate from the architectural standpoint without interference in the function or utility of the building or structure. The Bureau's experience has shown that these objects may often be accomplished at no increase in cost, and frequently with a saving in expense. The designs shall preferably be plain and dignified, with the minimum of ornamentation and free from ostentation." The Committee worked to instill this aesthetic sensibility into incoming engineer officers through lectures introducing them to the basic principles of architectural design. Their concern for buildings merged into a Beaux Arts concern for groups of buildings, and for what we would call urban design and city planning today.
{A Bureau Planning Board concerned itself with standardizing plans for new Navy bases.) The Architectural Review Committee thus provided a general sense of aesthetic purpose and brought about the harmonious effects we see in the Navy bases of the Construction Managers: The Navy's Civil Engineer Corps After the Bureau put its drawings out for bid, its officers supervised the firm that won the construction contract. The Civil Engineer Corps (C C) had the responsibility for supervising construction. Some CEC officers spent their careers in the field, supervising one construction project after another. As we have seen, the Navy civil engineers were a separate occupational group, analogous to medical officers in the Navy Medical Corps.
Its members were not "officers of the line" trained at the Naval Academy for commanding ships, but rather civilians who had been educated as civil engineers and had begun their work in civilian jobs outside the Navy, only later in life to enter the Navy's engineering corps. In their backgrounds they resembled the civilians who enter the service at mid-career in wartime and then stay in the military after the war. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 43) In by posting a CEC officer at each Naval Station to be responsible for all utilities, the Bureau became a nationwide organization.
The CEC officer who operated the base utilities served as the Bureau's representative there, conveyed the base commander's wishes for new construction up to the Bureau, and supervised Bureau construction projects in that locality. (The Bureau held all design and contracting authority in its Washington office.) The Program for San Diego In October the Bureau sent CEC Officer Leonard Cox from the Twelfth Naval District Public Works Office in San Francisco south to San Diego to implement the growing construction program. Commander Cox established an office in the Balboa Park training camp. Sone construction projects were already underway at the Coaling Station and Radio Station before Cox arrived.
During his short tour of duty Cox oversaw the surveying and acquisition of sites for the new construction, sent information on topography and utility lines to the Bureau, and reviewed the Bureau's preliminary architectural plans for their "fit" into local terrain and utilities. Cox's offfice, in addition, oversaw the wartime construction programs for the local Naval Militia base, Coal Depot, San Pedro submarine base, two radio transmitter sites, and alterations of the exposition buildings to be used for the Training Camp. Commander Norman Smith was the CEC officer who replaced Cox for his next tour of duty on November 14, Smith was to supervise construction of the largest naval complex built in American between the end of the First World War and the buildup for the Second World War.
The Marine Corps Advanced Base would be the largest Bureau of Yards and Docks project ever built for the Marines and was intended as a model of its kind. Moreover the construction program was to be executed "to a unified architectural style." More specifically, the buildings were to be "rendered in the Mission style, as the purpose has been to make all the naval establishments at San Diego conserve the ends of taste as well of utility." Smith increased the local staff of designers through a transfer of Bureau architects and engineers from East Coast to West Coast that amounted to a decentralization of its workforce from Washington.
In Smith recruited four designers from the Bureau and in nine from the Naval Experimental and Research Laboratory (Bellevue, plus others from other Navy offices. (Appendix D lists the men transferred to San Diego.) 3 Norman Murray Smith eventually became an Admiral and the Chief of the Bureau of Yards and Docks. Smith, from Williston South Carolina, graduated from the Naval Academy in and was among the first Academy graduates sent to Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (Troy, for three years, engineering school. He was therefore one of the first career officers to take control of the Navy's civil engineering program. The tradition of sending Academy men to Rensselaer continued many years.
The greatest number of the officers who had begun their engineering careers outside the Navy, however, were graduates of MIT. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 44) The Bureau transferred part of its workforce to San Diego; first, to continue designing increments to the Marine Corps Base and Air Station projects it already had underway there, and second to design a Naval Traininq Station. The Training Station was designed in a separate Public Works Office established for that purpose in San Jiego under a New York architect, H. Lincoln Rogers, who was serving Naval Reserve Force duties during the war. The project to design the Naval Hospital was held back from San Diego and executed in the Washington office.
Indeed, the transfer of workers to San Diego was so substantial that in January the Bureau delegated to Snith's office the job of preparing plans and specifications for certain roads at the Marine Corps Base "owing to lack of an adequate drafting force" in the Bureau. The autocratic Bureau did not transfer authority for snaking decisions to San Diego.
The San Diego office, for example, was not authorized to improve specifications for reinforcing concrete; and in December San Diego wrote for permission to change the steel reinforcing in concrete barracks floors because cracking "has not only been a source for criticism [at the Marine Corps barracks and Air Station] but also in washing down decks, the water passes through to the next floor." And in the Bureau was still sending completed architectural plans to San Diego asking "preparation of finished drawings for advertising" but instructing the Public Works Officer to complete them "without modifications other than those that are necessary for structural reasons." The Bureau assigned the Public Works Office the more menial tasks: asking it for site data on drainage and utility lines early in the project; sending it sketches midway in the design process for review; and sending it completed drawings when the construction contract was let so the Public Works inspectors could monitor progress.
It often sent architectural plans and asked Public Works draftsmen to do the corresponding working drawings. After a few years, the bureau eventually delegated more small architectural design tasks to San Diego, until some of the later and less important Hospital buildings were designed completely in San Diego.
The turning point came in March when the Bureau allowed the drawings and specifications for a Marine Corps Base garage and gun shed to have a chain of signatures acknowledging that some designs could cone from the bottom up: "Submitted by Commander (CEC) USN, Public Works Officer; Recommended by _ Project Manager; and, Approved by Chief of Bureau." The Bureau probably held the design of the Hospital particularly close to its Washington office because its Hospital Section there had the specialized experience and the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery was nearby to suggest floor plans and review every final drawing. The round of reviews included San Diego.
For example, in the San Diego (Balboa Park) Hospital Commanding Officer, the tenant for whom the buildings were being designed, reviewed the North Ward plans and wrote the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery asking whether they intended a third story. The Hospital represents the Bureau's usual design process more closely than the other three architecturally important facilities in San Diego. It was designed completely in Washington by Navy in-house architects, whereas the Marine Corps Base and Air Station involved consulting architects and the Training Station involved a West Coast office. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 45) The four facilities' construction prograns overlapped one another.
The Marine Corps Base was first to be initiated, but the Naval Air Station was second to be initiated and first to be completed and occupied.
The first Marine Corps Base contract January 31, was for dredging the site, but the first barracks construction contract in preparation since but not awarded until March 17, was not completed until the end of (The Marines had set up an organizational headquarters for the base in a downtown office building October 15, However, the first Naval Air Station construction contract, was June 29, for barracks completed in July The Hospital was the third facility started, with contract on Noveuber 27, and the Training Station was fourth, with on March 29, The Value of the Program to San Diego The Chamber of Commerce kept tabs on every dollar the Navy spent on the construction program to relieve the public's uneasiness over having given so much prime land to the Navy.
By the end of when the Marine Corps Base was substantially completed and the Naval Air Station was about half completed, the total value of "work in place" was million. By mid-1923, phases had been added to the Marine Corps Base and the Air Station, while the Naval Hospital (the first buildings of which were occupied August 22, was moving toward completion of its original plan, and the first construction phase of the Training Station was nearly ready to be occupied. The total value of the Navy's construction in nid-1923 was million. By mid-1926 the Navy had spent million on Eleventh Naval District construction projects.
To give the public "an appreciation of the peacetime returns on the investment," the Chamber reported in that while "a conservative appraiser says the present value of the gift lands is $10 million," in return the "Naval structural improvements ashore represent an investment of approximately $20 million," from which it expends a monthly million for payroll, materials, and supplies, or a total of approximately $20 million per year.
An August 2, Union editorial went so far as to claim that the quarter-million dollar Hospital parcel would "net San Diego within 10 years no less than $45 million conservatively estimated." Marine Corps Major Osterhaut, moreover, wrote a public relations piece telling the public that the peacetime advantages went beyond payrolls and constructions dollars, because Aside from money considerations there have been other features of inestimable value to the city by virtue of its being the location of the Marine Corps Base. Amonth these is the national and international publicity given the city, including that resulting from customary inspection visits by men of national importance.
A very unattractive site of swamp and marsh lands has been transformed into a place of striking beauty, enhancing adjoining properties, and making an additional center of great interest to the city as a whole. It makes available a strong body of an internationally known corps of men and officers together with their Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 46} resources for civic purposes, parades, ceremonies, for protective purposes, and even for fire fighting. The men and officers of the U.S. Marine Corps, drawn here by reason of the presence of the Marine Corps Base, have in many instances invested their savings in this vicinity, besides making it their permanent hone and place of residence upon retirement.
By Kettner could say, perhaps with relief, that San Diego had finally been vindicated for paying such a high price to strengthen its economic base: "When history is written fifty years from now, the establishment of these [nilitary] units between and will be cited as the starting point of San Diego's real permanent growth and stabilized prosperity." Building Out the Original Design [4] The Navy hired contractors to build out the original "As Projected" Hospital plan in several pnases extending from to The original design v/as realized in large part. The main central cloistered compound with its three courtyard units v/as built with only Minor changes from the original plan.
(The Medical officers asked for fully developed basement floors and for a last-minute change from two-story to three-story ward buildings to increase capacity.) The buildings along the eastern service road, never clearly identified to begin with, were built generally as projected. Of the northern residential group only one building, the Nurses Quarters, was built as projected. (The northern area was used for additional ward buildings instead. Staff quarters originally intended for the northern area were eventually built farther south.) The original proposal had gone no farther south than the southern boundary of the original grounds. The hospital group was eventually built out farther south on an additional grant of land.
That extension increased the horizontal effect of the facade lines (the cornice, fenestration, and water table lines), extending them all the way south. The same visual level was accomplished all down the line, at the cost of perching the most southerly building on hiqh basements where the terrain sloped off. The sequence of construction is described building-by-building in the list below. This list is nearly the same as the list of buildings found eligible for the National Register because the Advisory Council's fifty-year cutoff for historic eligibility quite fortunately took in the early architecturally important Hospital compound and excluded the later architecturally unimportant buildings on the periphery.
The eligible buildings' Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) identification numbers are given on the last page of this chapter. Thus the buildings are identified under three systems: the Navy building name, the Navy building number, and the HABS building identification number. The buildings demolished by were not given HA8S building identification numbers. The buildings that had been merged into others and lost their separate identities were not given HABS numbers. ^(This section is based on original Navy construction documents, correspondence, early photographs, and field inspections.) Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 47}
Year Cost Buildings Beds (accumulative) (accumulative # 1: Administration 275 ($I,000,U0U) # 2: Ward A # 3: Operating # 4: Subsistence # 5: Ward B # 6: Power House # 7: Red Cross $ 50U,000 # 8: Transformer House 518 ($1,500,ooo; # 9: Ward C Ward D Service $ Oisinfector Incinerator Lab. & Out Patient North Ward Nurses' Quarters 822 Guinea Pig and Rabbit House Garage at Nurses Quarters Mortuary Contagious Ward Hosp. Corps Barracks Sick Officers Gate House #81 : Quarters B Quarters C Quarters D & E $ South Ward Field Record photographs 017 through 025 show some of the Hospital buildings newly conpleted. These are construction progress photos in the archives of the Bureau of Yards and Docks.
The contract for the initial construction of the Hospital was awarded jointly to the Kier Construction Company of San Diego and the Simpson Construction Company of Los Angeles in October The contract was for the construction of the first six buildings: the Administration Building Ward A the Operating Building the Subsistence Building Ward B and the Power House Work began in November Kier had been awarded the contract for the Naval Air Station's Administration Building. The next stage of the Hospital was awarded to Lange Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 43) and Bergstrom, who had been awarded the and contracts for the Naval Air Station and who would be awarded the contract for the Naval Training Station.
The original drawings show what cross-sectional shape the hilltop was graded into. The access road was to run fairly level along the western facade and then drop in elevation to return along the east side. The western row of buildings was set on generally level sites that natch the levels of the courtyards. The eastern row of buildings gives the visitor the impression that they rest on the sane level base as the interior court, but the eastern row is actually split-level because it has more stories built on the east sides than on the west. For example, Building 9 has four stories on the west and five on the east. The eastern road (Wieber Avenue) services the eastern buildings' loading docks.
The design also disguises the gradual drop in elevation toward the south, where ground level is one story below the central patio. The buildings farther south stand on full height, with basements above ground to carry out the group's horizontal lines. The six buildings specified in the first contract were constructed over an 18-nonth period and placed in comission on August 8, Hospital capacity was about 275 beds.
(The goal for the hospital's ultimate bed capacity was rising even as construction went along.) The first phase cost of construction was approximately A seventh building - the Red Cross Convalescent House now denolished) - was constructed under separate Navy contract and paid for by the local Red Cross at a cost of about in the spring of and was included in this first group of buildings. That building was not foreseen in the original scheme and was the first deviation from the original overall plan.
The next group of buildings constructed were the small Transformer House now denolished), Ward C Ward D and the Service Building Construction of the Service Building and the two wards began in October and was conpleted by October The Service Building was designed to house miscellaneous functions to service the Hospital, such as shops and a laundry. The Transformer House, a snail utilitarian structure located at the eastern edge of the site, was built early in Each of the new wards had a capacity of 172 ueds, increasing the total capacity of the Hospital to 618 beds.
The cost for this phase of construction was approximately In the summer of construction began on the Disinfector Building now demolished), the Incinerator Building the Laboratory & Out Patients Building the North Ward and the Nurses' Quarters now demolished). The Out Patients building served the families of servicemen. All these buildings were completed by the following summer, with the exception of the Disinfector Building; although its foundation had been poured during the summer of it was completed only in as part of the adjoining Mortuary discussed (.ie1ow). The completion of the dorth Ward created an Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 49) enclosed north court, which was finished with geometrical walks.
The new ward had a capacity of 204 beds, bringing the total to 322 beds. The cost of construction for this phase was also approximately Between the summer of and the fall of nearly all the remaining buildings of the original Hospital were constructed. The Guinea Pig and Rabbit House a small utilitarian structure used for detecting diseases, was built in June a garage for the Nurses' Quarters was built in October and the Mortuary was built soon after.
By July the following buildings had been completed: the Contagious Ward the Hospital Corps Barracks the Sick Officers Quarters the Gate House and several detacned houses for some of the Hospital's officers -- the Executive Officer's Quarters or Quarters 3), the Surgeon's Quarters or Quarters C), and a duplex called Double Quarters or Quarters D & E). The 150-bed capacity of the Contagious Ward and the 58-bed capacity of the Sick Officers Quarters brought the total capacity of the Hospital to the desired beds.
The total cost of construction for this group of buildings, including roads, walks, and landscaping, was approximately We have the Bureau's construction progress photographs of the Adninistration Building 1) in the Field Records identified as photographs 032 through the construction progress photographs for the Nurses' Quarters Lxtension (an addition to 16) identified as Field Record Photographs 036 through and, the construction progress photographs for the Executive Officer's Quarters (Quarters B) identified as 043 through The South Ward filled in the last part of the original compound. It was constructed at a cost of between December and December It is not of the same construction era as the other buildings, but it derives from the sketch plans of that earlier era.
Its construction created an enclosed south court which became equipped with a fountain, walks, and landscaping. The completion of the new ward and last courtyard marked the completion of the original - though modified - scheme for the Hospital as prepared by the Bureau of Yards and Docks in We can see the fully filled out form of the hospital in aerial photographs taken in and which have been reproduced in the Field Records as photographs 026 through The new south court squeezed out the last of the tent wards that had formed part of the Hospital since its expeditionary beginnings.
The annual report had told how the year's epidemics of mumps, measles, diptheria, and scarlet fever had been isolated in a new "model hospital tent canp provided with independent latrines, bathing, and washing facilities ... connected with the city sewer system." (Similar platform tent housing was also seen in the Marine Corps Base and the Training Station of the time). In addition to tents, the hospital built canvass-walled temporary cottages "for Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 50) the tuberculosis cases transferred to us." By the Hospital had removed and stored the covers from 31 of the tent platforms because Navy Hospital corpsr.ien had been able to move into the newly completed Service Building.
The 35-year period following completion of the original conpound was Marked by a dramatic expansion of grounds and buildings beyond the boundaries of the original land grant. In April San Diego voters approved leasing the Navy acres of parkland directly west of the Hospital for use as recreational open space for the patients and staff. In during the buildup for World War II, voters approved an additional acres of land for the Hospital, adjoining the conpound to the southeast. In April the city deeded acres imediately east of the previously granted parcel. On the new property the Navy began construction of "H-type" wards (temporary-type wood-frame construction), which would number fifteen by the end of World War II.
The original compound was filled out further on the north end during this period. The Bureau stopped ouilding concrete frames with tile infilled walls. The Medical Storehouse was a utilitarian reinforced-concrete structure erected. The Sick Officers and Out Patients Building was built directly east of the Sick Officers Quarters, in a style that carefully matched the older building. A flat-roofed stuccoed wing joined the north wings of these two buildings, filling in a crosswalk to create interior circulation between the wards. We have included those buildings in the HABS Data Forms, even though they are neither part of the original design nor fifty years old, because they serve to visually integrate the original compound.
The Second World War brought the most dramatic but temporary expansion of the Hospital into other areas of the park. From a total of 56 buildings and beds in the Hospital grew to a total of 241 buildings and beds by Once again the Navy took over the buildings of the and Expositions, paying the City of San Diego for their use, and built a pedestrian tunnel under Park boulevard to connect the Hospital with the Exposition area. In the pressure from several sources led to further Hospital development. Between and in response to crowding from Korean War casualties and a growing number of convalescent veterans, a nine-story reinforced-concrete surgical building was constructed on the lower ground directly behind the Service Building (on the site of the old Tranformer Building).
Its hundreds of beds freed ward buildings in the original compound for new functions. Finally, with the completion of a medical library on the west slope in and of an outpatient clinic at the north end of the original compound in major new construction ceased until more Florida Canyon land was acquired in the Internal Changes The function of the U.S. Naval Hospital evolved through three general stages: (1) In the first years during the first phases of construction the Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 51) limited number of buildings served multiple purposes (functions were "doubled up" in buildings designed for single purposes).
(2) With the completion of the original compound in the the separate functions tended to move out from their earliest locations into their intended separate buildings. (3) Finally, new construction in the 30-year period after allowed functions to diversify further and move out beyond the original compound. While the interiors of the original buildings were often severely modified to neet the altered functional requirements, their exterior appearances and overall layouts were left largely intact. No major buildings of the original compound were demolished until the and then only as part of clearing a site for the new Florida Canyon facility.
The central conpound appears remarkably much as it did in The most condensed functional pattern was in The Administration Building at first housed not only the administrative offices and boardroom (on the first and second floors) but also 15 bedrooms, mess room, diet kitchen, and recreation room (all for sick officers on the third and fourth floors) plus a solarium on the roof and the hospital's pharmacy in the basement. Ward B had eye, ear, nose, and throat beds on the first floor, the medical ward on the second, and infectious diseases on the third, with a brig and storage in the basement. The "Operating Pavilion" (Building #3) had the laboratory, x-ray, dentistry, and EENT outpatients on the first floor and general surgery on the second.
The Subsistence Building had cold food storage in the basement, galleys and mess halls on the next two floors, and quarters for mess attendants on top. Then specific functions moved out of the early multiple-function buildings into single-purpose buildings. For example, the sick officers quarters began in floors three and four of the Administration Building, then moved to a new and larger single-purpose Sick Officer Quarters in (thus allowing Building #1 to fill out with purely administrative functions), and then growing further to occupy half of the new Building #38 in The sick officers quarters provided private rooms with attached private toilets, as well as a lounge and dining room for ambulatory patients.
The enlisted men got long, open wards with rows of beds, shared toilets and bathrooms, and quiet (seclusion) rooms grouped at one end of each floor. Occasional bed shortages were handled by temporary tent wards. Nurses had the most acute problem finding living quarters at the Hospital. Nurses were not commissioned officers until the and they could not live among the male enlisted personnel. In the Hospital reported that of its 30 nurses, 26 lived in a house a nile away where two rooms had 2 nurses to a room, three rooms held 3 nurses each, and in two rooms there were 4 nurses to a room.
"This congested condition has resulted in numerous cases of dissatisfaction, quarrels, requests for change of duty, and resignations, and in my opinion should be remedied as soon as possible." said the Commanding Officer. In he ordered the upper two floors of Ward Building 9 to be partitioned off into individual nurses' sleeping areas. Plans then accelerated for constructing a separate nurses quarters building to allow Building 9 to return to the ward function for which it had been designed, Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS Ho. CA-1548 (page 52) Field Record photographs 086 through 091 are photographs of Navy nurses, probably posed for recruiting or public relations purposes.
With the completion of the original compound in the the Hospital attained the beds eventually established as its goal. The geographical pattern was the central Administration Subsistence and Service buildings providing the managerial and logistical support for the staff and for the patients in the flanking ward ouildings with operating rooms, laboratories, X-ray rooms, and outpatient facilities grouped in two separate buildings (#3 and within the central quadrangle. The two earliest ward buildings were each broken into three separate wards for the eye, nose, and throat department, and the urological departnent (responsible for treating venereal disease). The North Ward housed orthopedic, neuropsychiatry, and convalescent wards on its three floors.
Housing for Hospital staff was provided at the north and south ends of the compound (Nurses' Quarters, #lo, and Officers' Quarters, respectively.) The new school and barracks building for Hospital Corpsmen solved, at least in part, the persistent problein of providing housing for the Hospital's enlisted men. This new dormitory freed up space in the Service Building for the quasi-industrial uses (shops, workrooms, laundry, etc.) for which it was eventually intended, just as the construction of the Sick Officers Quarters had allowed the Administration Building to assume exclusively the administrative and managerial functions for which it was designed.
The group of buildings along the rear (east) side of the compound met miscellaneous requirements of a large, self-contained hospital: the so-called Power House in actuality a boiler plant that supplied steam heat and hot water for all buildings, the Transformer House (#o), the Disinfector Building the Incinerator Building the Guinea Pig and Rabbit House and the Mortuary The alterations to individual building interiors were often part of the general evolutionary tendency for the administrative functions to build up within the original buildings as newer patient services were relocated into newer buildings added onto the neriphery. Growth and specialization of medical functions caused the Hospital managers to re-locate medical functions and to small specialized rooms.
Examples are Building 37, 15, and 2. The pharmacy outgrew a room in Building 1 and took all of Building open storage space to build small office, storage, and dispensary rooms. EENT outgrew a room in Building 14 and took all Ward A (Building open hospital bay space to build small waiting cubicles and examination cubicles. Family health care outgrew an outpatients room in Building 14 and took all of North Ward (Building open hospital bay space to build many small examination and recovery rooms. Ward A (Building floor plan sketches are included in the line drawings section of this report as an example of how large original rooms were broken into small specialized spaces. Alterations that partitioned tne original ward bays into small office cubicles often cut off natural light and air.
Our historical vantage point allows us to see that the Bureau gradually relinquished a number of natural Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 53) heating, ventilating, and air conditioning (HVAC) features in exchange for power-driven HVAC. The Bureau first sacrificed solaria when it redrew the ward buildings into three-story designs. It later installed dropped ceilings to bring more powerful illumination and controlled heating, but shut off the transom windows that had brought Jaylight and ventilation into the originally high-ceilinged rooms. Field Record photographs 059 through 070 show different hospital wards. Please note high ceilings, natural light, and natural ventilation.
The original pedestrian circulation pattern was gradually altered with numerous snail improvements such as cutting doors between buildings, extending the covered sidewalks, building suspended vestibules between upper stories of adjacent buildings, and converting short flights of stairs into inclined ramps. In the first year of operation, for example, the Hospital's Commanding Officer asked the bureau to build stn'rways up to the second-story porticos in order "to facilitate outside communication and to limit traffic in the interior of the buildings." The outside walkways evolved into a najor network of passageways between the different buildings and levels.
Pressure from Growing Hospital Operations The Hospital cared not only for personnel of the Navy, Marine Corps, and Army, but also for veterans of the Civil War, the Spanish-American War, and World War I. The statistics snowed an average load of 646 beds per day, of which 148 were filled by ex-servicemen hospitalized on behalf of the Veteran's Bureau. The patient load at the original Hospital compound increased from about [)er year in (with an average daily census of to about in (with an average daily census of Outpatient treatment was a najor component of the Hospital's activity; such consultations were given in the year alone. This figure covers routine health maintenance such as checkups and innoculations, not only for sailors but also for their family i.ienbers.
Field Record photographs 071 through 078 depict Navy men and women at work in the Hospital. The Hospital Corps School opened on September 1, as a separate component of the Hospital. The school's mission was to train enlisted personnel as hospital orderlies. The school initially had a staff of five medical officers, two nurses, and fifteen enlisted men who conducted a basic course of instruction lasting 12 weeks. The Barracks that housed the school was designed to accomodate 18O-2U0 students. With increased enrollment during World War II, the school moved to other buildings on the Hospital grounds leaving Building #21 exclusively as a dormitory for corpsmen. Field Record photographs 079 through 085 depict training and educating Navy medical personnel. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 54) The peak years of the Hospital's operation v/ere during World War II. Between and approximately patients were treated; the highest daily census .luring the war was around 12,QUO, in late Many were outpatients, but the number hospitalized was so great that the covered walkways became open-air wards filled with bedridden servicenen. The hospital went from 56 buildings with a bed capacity of in to 241 buildings covering 247 acres, including the Exposition grounds and a convalescent branch in Rancho Santa Fe with a bed capacity of in The Hospital's daily newspaper the Dry Oock, listed famous visitors and dignitaries such as Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt, and entertainers such as Jimmy Durante and Harpo Marx.
The Red Cross and Gray Ladies led connunity participation in the Hospital's programs. Field Record photographs 092 through 100 are Navy public relations and news photos. The Hospital had many civilian employees involved in logistical matters such as [Maintenance, groundsKeeping, cooking, and laundering, rather than technical medical work. Growing Naval operations pressed the hospital to grow far beyond its original intentions. The Hospital staff grew connensurately with increases in patient loads: Medical officers 50* 93 159 Nurses 50* 60* 92 530 Hospital corpstnen 517 *approximate More Land Grants to the Hospital The land issue emerged time and again as the Hospital grew. The map here shows the sequence of park land grants that built up the Hospital grounds.
Beyond the original 17-acre grant in the center of the ridge, the first additional grant was toward the south end of the ridge that topographically rounded out the Navy's ownership of Inspiration Point. San Diego chose the ridge's central portion for the original hospital land grant in order to keep Park Boulevard's landscaping under city control and to keep Inspiration Point proper (at the south end of the ridge) open for public use. Originally a public road passed through the Hospital grounds to give public access to Inspiration Point. The first Bureau of Yards and Docks drawing (number approved September had the capacity for 350 beds.
That original size was based on the total medical requirements for the various naval facilities that the Navy expected to be approved for San Diego in the period. But San Diego's advocates were so successful that Congressional appropriations began adding up to a full Uaval Operating Hase for San Diego. Even as earth was Naval Hospital, San Diego HAJS No. CA-1548 (page 55) being noved to build a 350-bed hospital, the Commanding Officer of the Davy's Balboa Park Hospital unit asked the Bureau to reconsider the size of the facility. He termed the original plans "totally inadequate" because "the most conservative estimate here would indicate the need for a Hospital of at least eight hundred beds." His suggestions brought the first major changes to the original "As Projected" plan.
H e suggested increased building heights and changes in the layout rather than requesting additional city land. He asked the Bureau if full uasenents coul d be included and a third floor added to the two-story ward buildings shown in the plan. He also suggested that the various residential structures (the Nur ses1 Quarters, the higher-ranking officers' individual houses, and the Sic k Officers Quarters) could be built elsewhere so the "north end of the Hospital grounds [could] be reserved for further ward construction.' The question of land for residential structures arose again in when the Navy sent a sketch of a proposed Hospital Corpsnan's Barracks to the city, asking that a barracks site be demarcated to the south exactly on Inspiration Point.
The San Diego City Council, as required by the city charter, put the proposal for additional land on the ballot in Public sentinent was so strongly for the Navy that San Diego told the Bureau to go ahead with designs for the barracks on the south promontory before the election. The Council continued to comply with the charter by placing each land grant proposal on the ballot, and ad the years went by the slipping margin of approval, shown in the table below (from Amero's The U.S. Naval Hospital and Balboa Park) discliosed. the Hospital 's long fall from piiblic: favor. VOTES ON QUESTIONS OF GRANTING OF
Year Acreage Yes No % Approved 137 exchange 36 ac. for 39 The trend was already clear in when the city, instead of granting outright ownership of the shallow western arroyo for patients' recreational use, granted only a lease until In the city built a parking lot there to earn an income from hospital visitors. The later grant deeds had "reverter clauses," stipulations that the land would revert to the city under certain conditions. Naval Hospital, San Diego HAt3S No. CA-1548 (page 55) The steady shift in transportation from streetcars to autotiobiles brought increasing obsolescence to the Hospital. At first the grounds had space for parking and deliveries, but it did not nake a successful transition from a streetcar stop to drive-in nedical center.
The Hospital's connection to the city and the Navy bases gradually deteriorated. New construction filled the grounds and forced parking to the perimeter. The western recreation area's conversion to a city parking lot did not cure the functional obsolescence of the nil Itop site. The land issue was raised again in when a Navy Master Plan study concluded that the Hospital complex as a whole, including the original and the later buildings, suffered from functional obsolescence. The concrete frane and tile block structural system lacked seismic resistance. The Hospital had only short-tern renewals of its accreditation.
The study stated that the complex contained certain older buildings that should be replaced, probably by new construction at the eastern edge of the existing group, or that the whole hospital should be abandoned and replaced by a new conplex elsewhere. It recommended a completely new hospital be built on an alternative site called ilurphy Canyon, but eventually the Navy decided to build the new medical center in Florida Canyon, on additional park land immediately adjacent to Inspiration Point. The Navy and the city the arranged land exchange now in progress in which the Navy gives the city acres, including Inspiration Point and nost of the buildings described here, in exchange for the Florida Canyon land.
(The events and controversies leading to that exchange are described in Appendix A of this report. The new Naval Regional Medical Center is now under construction in Florida Canyon.) Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 57) HABS BUILDING NUMBERS # HABS # Original Name on Construction Drawings 1 CA--1548 A Atiui-iistration Building 2 B Ward A 3 C Operating Building 4 D Subsistence Building 5 E Ward B 6 F Power House 7 - Red Cross Convalescent House 8 _ Transformer House 9 G Ward C 10 H Ward D 11 I Service Building 12 - Disinfector Building 13 1-1 Incinerator Building 14 J Laboratory & Out Patients Building 15 K North Ward 16 - Nurses Quarters 17 L Guinea Pig and Rabbit House 18 - Garage at Nurses Quarters 19 - Mortuary 20 N Contagious Ward 21 0 Hospital Corps Barracks 22 P Sick Officers Quarters 23 T Gate House 36 U South Ward 37 V Medical Storehouse 38 W Sick Officers & Out Patients 49 X Horth Crosswalk 81 (Quarters B) Q Executive Officer's Quarters 82 (Quarters 0 R Surgeon's Quarters 83 (Quarters D & E) S Double Quarters This narrative is a part of a larger project that also docunented each individual building on a separate Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) Data Fon.i.
The Administration building and Quarters B are described more fully in Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) Outline Forms. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 58) CHAPTER 4: ARCHITECTURAL EFFECTS The Community Reacts Bureau public relations statements spoke proudly of the San Diego facilities for their "effective use of red-tile roofing ... [and] buff-colored stucco, trowelled in an irregular wavy pattern to simulate the weathered effect of local specimens of Spanish Mission architecture," and for their success in expressing the "principles of architectural harmony," whose effects were "imposing if not magnificent." But the general public was not so pleased.
It did not understand why the Navy's designs moved away from the ornate Mission style San Diegans expected, and toward a simplicity they did not like. San Diegans assumed that consulting architect Bertrand Goodhue would give them further ornate Exposition-style buildings. But by Goodhue himself was turning toward i.iore modern, simple designs. He told the Bureau that the new sketches for the Naval Air Station were "vastly better for having the Churriqueresque ornament deleted." He explained to Marine Corps Base construction managers that "the success of buildings of such simplicity of design as these depends on the manner in which they are stuccoed and in which the various details are carried out." Austere postwar budgets were another force for simplification.
The Navy was obliged to comb out orrtnamental and luxurious details from construction plans already drawn and to extend construction schedules to keep the programs going on fewer dollars per year.
Of the four architecturally important facilities the Navy would build in San Diego (the Marine tfase, the Air Station, the Training Station, and the Hospital), the Naval Hospital exemplifies how that austerity influenced design, In the earliest stages of the Hospital's design, the Chamber of Commerce told the public the Hospital design would "conform to the general character of other buildings within the park" and the "character of the architecture [would be the] same as the Marine Base and Naval Air Station." In May the Bureau sent Congressman Xettner a preliminary perspective sketch of how the Hospital would look, assuring him that "the architectural style used will harmonize with the mission type of California" and that the Bureau would "cooperate in every way to make the Hospital grounds in keeping with the adjacent beautiful city parklands." By the end of however, General Pendleton and the Chamber of Commerce were accusing the Bureau of making ruinous simplifications to the agreed-upon layout for the Marine Corps Base.
The Bureau pleaded "that the plans could be modified to reduce the ultimate expenditure without injury to the Post," and that, although it was "impossible for people located in San Diego, at such a great distance from rfasm'ngton, to grasp the necessity for economy in Governmental expenditures, ... it is hoped that they will soon appreciate the conditions and will be pleased with the efforts that are being made to complete projects in San Diego to such an extent that they will be fully usable to the Government." Naval Hospital, San Diego HA8S No. CA-1548 (page 59) By the end of v/hen construction was well underway at the Hospital site, a Chamber of Commerce Member protested: "I was on the committee that recommended the giving of the present site to the Government, and the ...
Navy Department pledgefd] itself to the construction of a most beautiful and artistic building.... We were shown a print of plans and front elevation of a very fine looking building for the central and principal building of the group, but ...
I can hardly imagine a more severe, plain and unattractive structure than the one they have erected on the most prominent spot in Balboa Park." The Chamber forwarded this view to Congressman Kettner and noted that "the lack of harmony of the Hospital buildings with the Exposition buildings and their lack of beauty was expressed by quite a number at the joint meeting on Thursday, from which the Committee judges that a considerable portion of our citizens feel the Navy has not successfully carried out its announced intention of installing Hospital buildings which would not only be of use to the government, but also assets to the city from the standpoint of beauty.
However, others at the meeting expressed the opinion that the buildings were exceptionally pleasing, but agreed that much could be done to render the present lay-out more attractive." Kettner carried these criticisms to the Bureau in person, and the Bureau explained its position as best it could: "The Bureau's design for the Hospital follows the general type of mission architecture insofar as it can be applied advantageously to buildings of the character required. The structures were intentionally made plain but it does not appear that they are unattractive. The Bureau has had most satisfactory comment on the simplicity and dignity of the architectural effect of the buildings.
The Balboa Park exposition buildings, not far from the Hospital, are very much decorated with stucco ornamentation which is unsuitable for ii&vy Hospital Buildings, not only for the type of building required but also on account of the amount of upkeep necessary for repairs to such ornamentation The Bureau has followed closely its sketches for the project. The building on the extreme South of the Hospite site ... will have an ornamental treatment which will enhance the corporative effect of the group. Trees and shrubbery will be developed around all the buildings and will add to their beauty." Original Landscaping Plans The Hospital' s initial planning and construction were undertaken without a comprehensive landscaping scheme.
The original perspective drawing gives only a vague representation of landscaping. Lawns with occasional trees and shruboery are sketched in casually along the site's western edge (the side the public would see), in the northern residential group, and in the interior courts. The courts are devoid of any special landscaping treatment except for the paths that cut the central court into parterres. Neither do subsequent site plans or aerial photographs made during construction in the reveal any particular consideration for landscaping. Naval Hospital, San Diego HA3S No. CA-1548 (page 60) The two small nursery buildings built in the first stage of construction show the riureau intended a modest, self-sufficient program for landscaping the grounds.
The Bureau generally left new facilities bare and expected the tenants and local Public Works teams to plant as time went along. The Bureau's expectations /ere especially nodest for the Hospital site where soil test bores had shown a thin soil layer over adobe and hardpan, all on top of sandstone bedrock only two feet below the surface. The entire site required extensive surface drains because of the clay below. The thin soil overlay would support vegetation only after conditioning; breaking up the clayey hardpan below. Rather than treating the soil as the Bureau suggested, the Public Works Officer had loam shifted from one part of the grounds to where it was lacking. His immediate objective was to cover the fine soil that penetrated the Hospital in summer and turned to mud in winter.
In addition he expressed concerning that road "grading requires blasting, adds to the dust, and certainly is not conducive to the welfare of the patients." In he told the Bureau that the area from the entrance gate to the Administration Building door had "been graded, top soiled and planted by the Hospital Force, and is now growing grass Some other griding and planting has also been done in the south portion of the reservation around the tent camp, and the Hospital Force has constructed a fountain in the central court, which area is also being top soiled and planted The terrace around the Red Cross Convalescent Building will be top soiled and planted in the near future, and the north court, as soon as new construction will allow, will also be top soiled and planted." Landscaping -- A Response to Public Criticism Largely in response to public criticism, the Navy began directing resources into ornamental landscaping that would soften the Hospital's spartan visual effect.
This phase of development was of a comprehensive plan but v/as accomplished piecemeal over the next two decades. The cumulative effect was eventually so successful that the Hospital was nominated for the Register of Historic Places as nuch on the oasis of its landscaping as on the basis of its architectural design. Lush vegetation was gradually built up by a small gardening staff and such crews as the Public Works Officer could spare. By gardening was far enough along for the then-Commanding Officer to write a public relations piece extolling the gardener's work: "As soon as the equipment and patients were moved to the new Hospital from the old War Dispensary, Captain Weiber [the Hospital's first Commanding Officer] turned his attention to the landscaping of the grounds.
An English gardener, Mr. Uilliam H. Crofts, who had established a reputation as a master gardener and landscaper during ten years on the Duke of Norfolk's estate in Sheffield, England and another ten years in America, had arrived in Southern California to try his success at landscaping in a Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 61) subtropical climate. Captain Weiber took him on as the Hospital's head gardener. The result, after 13 years, is a display which can only bring amazing admiration to the hearts of all lovers of symmetry and design, to those capable of seeing and feeling the perfection of beauty that can be attained with California trees, flowers and shrubs when grouped and nursed by the master strokes of an artist. After 13 years, Mr.
Crofts is no less active in his ministration to the shrubs and flower beds." Croft created a gardenlike setting for the Hospital that was in harmony with Balboa Park. Like Kate Sessions, he drew from the local horticultural traditions. His selection of plant varieties is so similar to Kate Sessions' that she is sometimes credited with landscaping the Hospital. Three of the most striking plant groupings in the Hospital the stately queen palms of the central court, the Hollywood junipers of the south court, and the feathery fern pines lining Stitt Avenue -- are all species popularized by Sessions. The rich variety of plants listed on the drawings describing landscaping on the Hospital grounds also include a number of other species introduced or made popular by Sessions.
Among these are the eucalyptus, king palm, Italian cypress, jacaranda, silk oak, poinsettia, bougainvillea, primrose, and bird of paradise. (We have drawn a map showing the locations of the various types of plants. The map is in detail in six large sheets and is found elsewhere in this documentation package.) landscaping the Interior Courts The Hospital's courtyards originated as simple architectural open spaces with one-story covered walkways along their sides, not as tropical gardens with two-story galleries we see there today. Such courtyards with geometric gardens and tall open collonades were well-loved elements of the Exposition buildings nearby, and came to be used in the Hospital as well.
The process of elaborating the original walkways into a two-story network grew quickly from circulation problems in the original plan. Landscaping the courtyards came more slowly. Initially the only court to receive landscaping was the central court (behind the Administration Building) which received only an oval green, simple pedestrian walks, and a small fish pond. Young palm tress were planted in the The north court was enclosed by buildings but apparently remained dirt without landscaping (and without any plans for landscaping) several years. The north court was graded in and from to Navy civilian employees brought in topsoil, sprinkler lines, seeded grass, and poured concrete walks that crossed diagonally at the center. They laid out shrubs and hedges in a concentric circle.
In WPA Project 09-81-NEC improved the central court fish pond by raising and tiling the walls of the basin. The WPA's colorful tiles include Navy emblems. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1S48 (page 62) The now lush and sunken south court was a tent camp area and not enclosed by buildings until the late In and two WPA Projects and #S09-2-4/7-lo) renoved the platform tents, excavated the ground down two to four feet to the present level, built the walks and the lily pond, and planted lawns and shrubs. The same WPA Project extended and elaborated the formal stairway running down to the western recreation area from the Administration Suilding.
This grand, formal approach with branching stairs, also on axis with the Administration Building entrance, reinforced the secondary east-west axis across the nain north-south axis beyond what the original designers had intended. (Other WPA projects installed game courts in the western recreation area because earlier tennis courts had been displaced by continued construction. The WPA also widened Farenholt and Wieber Avenues.) In the longer view, the Hospital's courtyard gardens, porticos, and staircases grew one at a tine inco the intricate three-dimensional structure we see today. Those landscape-architecture elements wove the architectural "fabric" nore tightly and nore richly. The Hospital gradually becane a visually interdependant ensemble of buildings and landscaping.
It eventually became eligible for the National Register on that strength as a landscaped ensemble, not on the basis of its original design. Host of the Hospital's architectural character and charn can be experienced moving through courtyards and walkways from one building to another. Field Record photographs 048 through 058 show various phases of landscaping the Hospital grounds. Original Surface Effects The buildings when new had earthy low-keyed textures and colors that blended into the rural setting. The buildings' exteriors were light buff-colored stucco with a sandy (unpainted) texture.
The contract called for a stucco finish coat "trowelled in an irregular, wavy surface similar to that on the California State Building at the San Diego Exposition." Further, the stucco was to be tinted with mineral colors a "light buff similar to the color of the aviation barracks at San Diego." The lower bands of stucco on the Hospital Administration Building arcade parapet were to be "brown" where shown on the drawings. Similarities between the stucco work on the Hospital and the California State Building are difficult to see today. The Hospital's walls are caked with waterproofing paints that mask irregularities. The California State Building shows only sericircular coarse jrush strokes on a smooth finish coat that may have been added during repairs and maintenance.
The Naval Air Station Administration Building's stucco displays the most surface movement of the group and may be closest to its original state. The aviation barracks' contract was the most detailed, talking about working the stucco into "an irregular and wavy surface, representing Old Spanish work." But the Air Station's contract called for a harder-looking, Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 63) more light-reflective stucco of "good, hard, durable white marble dust" mixed with specially prepared hydrated lime. The Public Works Officer reported that the new Air Station's stucco was being tinted "with soft shades, such as creart and pink as the color scheme." The Hospital was rustic by comparison.
The Hospital's artificial cut-stone ornaments, such as the fancy architraves over the doorways, were colored buff to match the stucco and bush-hammered for texture, iThe casting mixture was one part white cei-ient to three parts grit sand.) The bolster blocks of the walkways's columns were of contrasting brown cast stone. Exposed eaves were painted buff to blend in with the stucco. The wooden doors and window sashes were in light green paint, perhaps to complement the cupric oxide accumulation on the copper gutters and downspouts. The interior finish was unpainted pure white lime plaster "trowelled to a smooth hard glossy surface." Its brilliantly light-reflective surface made efficient use of the daylight and the feeble incandescent lighting.
The only painted walls were in the toilets, kitchens, and operating rooms. The doctors using the Hospital were primarily interested in practicality. Within the first year of operations they asked the Bureau to paint the Hospital inside and out. This routine painting built up the leathery coat we see today. A recent shade was a light Florida pink, which in was being repainted to a light cream, with columns and basements in light gray and tower details in terra-cotta-colored paint. Alterations to the Original Buildings Because the buildings' exteriors have not been altered to any significant degree, the iy85 photographs of the exteriors adequately describe the original ones.
The camera tends to bring out the classical architectural proportions of the original construction drawings, whereas the firsthand observer finds the original architectural details difficult to make out under the leathery paint. The buildings' interiors, on the other hand, have in many cases been altered in significant ways. For example, the dropped ceilings, partitions, and floor coverings added since World War II have covered over nearly all the original interiors. Changes in floor plan are documented in the HABS Data Forms for individual buildings.
There are few early photographs of the original interiors, and the National Hark Service did not request t.iany photographs of the interiors in because they are not as unusual or significant as the exteriors and the arranges lent of the complex as a whole. Moreover, the buildings' interiors have a threadbare quality after fifty years of heavy daily pedestrian traffic. Wearing surfaces have been covered by successively more modern materials. The condition of the buildings is generally good. They are structurally intact but do not meet current seismic standards. The tile roofing appears to be the original. Functional maintenance has been consistent and adequate. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No.
CA-1548 (page 64) The Hospital in The original Hospital group still commands its hilltop site with the sane presence as described fifty years ago by its conmanding officer: "From [Park Boulevard] one looks to the east across the canyon and sees the wide sloping lawns spotted with shade trees - pines, eucalyptus, acacias, cypresses and peppers - the lawns rising to the main thoroughfare of the grounds. This street ... runs directly in front of the three original buildings. The Administration Building rises to four stories and has a tower or two more floors on either side of the nain entrance.
This, like all the other buildings, is of Spanish architecture Although the newer buildings were added by stages to the earlier ones over a period of ten years, there was never a change in the essential design, and the present ensemble gives the appearance of a simultaneous and unified growth from one original plan, all the present parts being natural and iogical elements of an integral whole." The group still shows that harmony of style and unity of plan. The group has changed little in silhouette because physical modifications to the site since the have been at the lower elevations around the periphery of the original Hospital.
The "wide sloping lawns" to the west were reduced to a relatively narrow slope when the city did not renew the lease and filled in the shallow canyon recreation area to create a large parking lot. Flanking the compound on the south and east, for the most part on the lower slopes of the Inspiration Point promontory, are complexes of buildings constructed primarily during and since World War II. The most visually obtrusive of these is an enormous nine-story ward building built in the Its nore or less axial placement directly east of the Administration Building overwhelns the scale of the original two- to four-story compound.
Several newer buildings have been added to the utilitarian structures along the back (east) side of the compound, and an outpatient clinic was attached to its north end in the Otherwise, the exterior appearance of the compound retains a high degree of integrity. Stylistic harmony arises partly from the consistent use of pastel-painted stucco walls, red-tiled roofs, and cast-stone trim of a restrained Renaissance-Baroque derivation within an overall Spanish Colonial Revival, or Mediterranean, architectural style. Seen from above, the visual unity derives primarily from the strongly axial and symmetrical arrangement of the central buildings around the three interior courtyards.
Seen from the side, visual unity is maintained, even though the site drops off gradually to the south, by using consistent height for windows, belt courses, and cornices to create strong horizontal lines. Wood-sash transoms, which once provided natural ventilation and daylight high up inside the rooms of the original Hospital, remain as an important horizontal visual element. In addition, the drop of the rear (east) road behind the main group minimizes the potential visual disruption by the less orderly utilitarian buildings behind. Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 65) The group is visually the better for its fifty years of ageing.
The process of tailoring individual gardens and walkways to mend individual problems in appearance and circulation softened and unified the original design. Those landscape architecture elements wove the architectural "fabric" into a richer more unified whole. In its original form the Hospital might not have qualified for the National Kegister. But that original architectural character was changed by the addition of the porticos and gardens, and, in the Woodbridge architectural resources survey found the original complex eligible for the National Register as a landscaped ensemble: "[While] the architecture is not distinguished by originality or by refinement of detail, ...
of particular note is the contribution of landscaping and elements such as pools, fountains, and walkways to enrich the relatively restrained architectural treatment of the buildings The stark simplicity of the architecture is a fine backdrop for romantic landscaping." Naval Hospital, San Diego HABS No. CA-1548 (page 55)