1. The United States Inspection Station & Custom House at San Ysidro is significant for its role in politics and government, and for its function as a local example of a national federal architectural initiative. The U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House has served as the site for the direct implementation of economic and international relations between the United States and Mexico since its construction in The rise of automobile traffic, the effects of Prohibition, and changes in immigration policy brought a significant increase in traffic to the land ports of entry during this time. The crossing between Tijuana and San Ysidro became and remains one of the busiest land ports of entry in the United States.2 Architecturally, the U.S.
Inspection Station & Custom House at San Ysidro is a prime example of how a standardized form was adapted to fit the needs of a particular site and how a geographical stylistic idiom was applied to that form. The Spanish Colonial Revival style was applied at San Ysidro to one of the building types developed by the Supervising Architect of the Treasury as part of a massive federal building program initiated in the late This program produced smaller-scale custom houses and inspection stations for existing and new border stations, along with post offices, and on a large scale, federal office buildings and courthouses. The U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House at San Ysidro is the largest surviving example of this adapted standard custom house form in California.
It is also significant as part of a set of the nation s first purpose-built customs and immigration inspection stations at land ports of entry.4 1 Fields and Devereaux Architects, Historic Building Preservation Plan, San Ysidro Border Station Existing Main Building 2. 2 Fraser, Clayton B., National Register of Historic Places Nomination Form: U.S. Custom House, San Ysidro, California 3 Fields and Devereaux, page 2; Richard Starzak et al., National Register of Historic Places Multiple Property Documentation Form, U.S. Border Inspection Stations 3. 4 Starzak, et al., 19. UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No. CA-2897 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1.
Date of Construction: Designed Constructed Completed in May Construction drawings were completed in and bids were accepted starting on April of that year. Ten contracting firms submitted bids, and the winning contract of the lowest bid, was awarded to Robert E. McKee of El Paso, TX. Construction began in early summer of and was competed in May of 2. Architect: James A. Wetmore Born in Bath, NY, in James A. Wetmore was appointed Acting Supervising Architect of the Treasury in and served until Wetmore was not an architect, and his title of Acting Supervising Architect reflected that.
A career bureaucrat, Wetmore worked his way upward from court stenographer, acquired a law degree from George Washington University in and became executive officer to Supervising Architect James Knox Taylor in In that position he had charge of all nontechnical operations in the Supervising Architect s office, and this deep institutional knowledge allowed him to serve competently despite his decidedly non- architectural background.7 Wetmore acknowledged his own lack of training and relied on his staff, like Louis Simon, who succeeded him as Supervising Architect, for architectural decisions while he deftly handled the administrative matters that the position required of him.8 As Acting Supervising Architect, Wetmore oversaw the transition of the office from the era of the dominance of the classical style in federal architecture and moved it towards standardized building design for federal buildings.9 He also oversaw the planning and initiation of the massive, years-long construction effort that came out of the passage of the Public Buildings Act of which had authorized funding for the construction of new facilities at many of the nation s land ports of entry in addition to many other buildings.
James Wetmore retired from his position as Supervising Architect in after 19 years. During that time he oversaw the design and construction of hundreds of federal buildings of various styles and sizes. 3. Original and subsequent owners: United States Federal Government 5 Fraser 6 Antionette Lee, Architects to the Nation, New York and Oxford 7 Ibid. 8 Ibid., 9 Ibid., UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No. CA-2897 (Page 3) 4. Contractor: General contractor: Robert E. McKee (El Paso, 5. Original plans and construction: U.S. Department of Treasury, Public Buildings Service. Original; Construction drawings for the U.S. Inspection Station, San Ysidro, California. By Supervising Architect s Office, Washington U.S.
General Services Administration Region 9 Office, San Francisco, California. The original drawings for this building show an irregular plan for a structure consisting of a main central section that has two wings, one a single-story garage to the north, and the other a two-story extension that continues at an angle of approximately 110 degrees to the south. The primary fa ade at the west had a canopy or porte-coch re that could accommodate two lanes of traffic, and that was intended to serve as a vehicle inspection point. The U.S. government acquired the title to the land that would become the site of the U.S.
Inspection Station & Custom House in June of Construction drawings were completed early in ground was broken in early summer of that year, and the building was completed by mid-May of The general contracting firm Robert E. McKee of El Paso, TX, submitted the winning bid of for the work. 6. Alterations and additions: The U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House has had exterior and interior alterations since its completion in 12 In four wooden, raised panel vehicular doors serving the Inspection Shed at the west fa ade of the north wing were removed. The arched openings were filled in and made into blind arches similar to the west fa ade of the south wing, with matching rectangular window openings.
Another series of alterations occurred in approximately A larger canopy replaced the original three-bay canopy at the west fa ade. At the south end of the main wing, a new entrance replaced a projecting window bay, while around the corner at the south fa ade the original entrance to the Immigration Inspector s office was replaced with a window. The small projecting hood above the original door was removed as well. At the east (rear) fa ade, a one-story, concrete-block addition with a square floor plan was added for mechanical equipment. A small projecting hood over the previous rear entrance likely was removed at this time. At the north wing, a cartouche at the west fa ade was removed in when a metal fascia (also since removed) was installed across the arcade.
In some of the earlier alterations were reversed. The larger, non-original canopy was removed and a smaller one-bay ornamental projecting porch, similar to the pedestrian bay in the original canopy, was installed. The projecting window bay at the south end of the main wing was reconstructed. A number of alterations whose dates are unknown were also made, including the removal of large original double-leaf glazed wood doors. The door opening was reduced in size and a single-leaf glazed door with a solid-panel transom installed. On the north fa ade, three large and two small window openings were removed and filled in to create a flat plane wall at the west end.
One of the four arched vehicular openings at the east end had its upper arched area filled in and its original raised-panel, wooden door replaced with a more contemporary metal, roll-up door. On the interior, major revisions in circulation, 11 Fraser 12 Page, Anderson & Turnbull, Inc, Historic Structures Report The United States Inspection Station, UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No. CA-2897 (Page 4) rooms, placement of walls, doors, and public access altered the first floor plan. The original main stairway between the first and second floors was removed. Many of the original interior partitions were removed and new permanent and temporary partitions added in the main and south wings.
The ceiling was lowered in office areas with a suspended acoustic tile system to accommodate HVAC equipment and includes integrated fluorescent lighting. Interior flooring consists of carpeting and asphalt tile. Interior doors have been replaced with hollow-core doors. B. Historical Context The construction of the historic U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House at San Ysidro arose from a need to expand the facilities at what had become one of the nation s busiest border crossings, a position that it still holds today.
The border with Mexico was created by the signing of the Treaty of Guadalupe-Hidalgo in and by the temporary markers stood at the border.13 Officers were first sent to patrol the border in and by a customs building was constructed on the Mexican side of the border.14 A series of wood-framed buildings was erected on the US side of the border to house customs and immigration offices during this period; these buildings were supplanted by the existing U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House.
A rise in illegal immigration following the passage of the Immigration Act of and the Emergency Quota Act of both of which restricted immigration into the United States, the illegal importation of alcohol after the passage of the Amendment in and an increase in motor vehicle traffic on the border highways in the all combined to create an urgent need for enlargement and replacement of the border stations throughout the nation.15 A report by H.A. Benner of the Bureau of Customs and Hughes of the Bureau of Immigration recommended that the existing border stations, which had been outgrown and were often in spaces rented from private entities, be replaced with buildings owned by the U.S. Government.
These structures would demonstrate federal authority and presence and be sited, planned, and programmed with proper facilities, dignified and attractive surroundings, fair and adequate service to the public, and decent living quarters for officers.16 This report suggested 48 locations for these purpose-built inspection stations, advising the government to purchase land for new locations, and calling for the replacement of existing facilities in already established locations.17 San Ysidro had served as a border crossing for several decades by this time, and its facilities were among those in need of updating and replacement. Also at this time, the Public Buildings Act of initiated a massive construction program by the federal government.
Between and the early approximately federal buildings were constructed.18 These were the result of the original authorizations of the act and of subsequent appropriations that Congress enacted in and then again in and as the Depression worsened its hold on the national economy. This program served three functions: 1) to reduce the growing costs incurred by housing federal agencies in leased space; 2) to allow members of Congress to award political presents in the form of courthouses and post offices; and 13 City of San Diego and Page & Turnbull, San Ysidro Historic Context Statement 11. 14 Ibid. 15 Starzak , et al., 3. 16 Ibid. 17 Ibid. 18 Fraser, UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No.
CA-2897 (Page 5) 3) to provide work for unemployed people at the local level as the effects of the Deppression spread.19 The program was eventually absorbed by the array of New Deal programs after Roosevelt took office in The U.S. Bureaus of Customs and of Immigration also saw tremendous change during this period. On the customs side, the majority of traffic had come over water routes, with customs houses erected at the major sea ports on the sea coasts and the lakes and waterways that formed the border with Canada.
Most construction dollars for customs houses had been allotted for buildings on the Atlantic and later Pacific seaboards, while in other locations, such as along the Canadian and Mexican borders, customs offices were housed in multipurpose federal buildings such as post offices and courthouses, or in private buildings like hotels, taverns, railroad depots, and even private residences. The increase in immigration and the response to the immigration laws passed in and also compelled that Bureau to increase its level of enforcement, especially in the wake of the Quota Act. Permanent, spacious housing was desirable to all agencies that worked along the border.
Three building types with their own basic spatial and program requirements that differed more in scale than in function had been suggested by the Benner and Hughes report: a standard office building, a standard office building with living quarters, and a special office building; the U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House at San Ysidro is a representative of this third type.20 The adaptation of a standardized form is apparent in the building s plan in relation to the site: main wing of the building runs parallel to the road, now Interstate 5, that fronted the building originally, while the south wing runs parallel to the international border line, accounting for the irregularity in the angle at which the south wing joins the main wing.
The unique needs of the site were easily addressed by the adaptability of the plans that were devised by James Wetmore s staff. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural Character The U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House is an approximately square foot building that occupies a U-shaped footprint. As a standardized form that was adapted to suit the needs of the site, this building shows a successful use of Spanish Colonial architectural elements to create a style sympathetic to the building s setting. By the time the U.S.
Inspection Station & Custom House was constructed, the eclectic revivalism seen here at San Ysidro was a hallmark of buildings designed by the Office of the Supervising Architect, and is evident in the smaller-scale custom house and inspection station buildings that were constructed all along the United States southern and northern borders during the and The use of stucco, dark painted wood windows and doors, ceramic roof tiles, and decorative tile all are elements of a harmonious whole that results in the U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House remaining stylistically faithful to its Spanish antecedents while utilizing a form that was standard in custom houses throughout the nation.21 The Spanish 19 Fraser, 20 Ibid. 21 Ibid.,, UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No.
CA-2897 (Page 6) Colonial style was also applied to the port facilities at Tecate, CA, and Calexico, CA, which feature buildings of a standardized type that were tailored to the needs of the site both in terms of function and style. 2. Condition of Fabric The majority of the building s exterior features are intact, and are in good-to-fair condition. Original exterior features that have been either removed or remodeled have largely been restored in-kind and closely match their original appearance. A few areas of deterioration are present, and include the following: A textured paint coating has been applied to the building s exterior stucco surface, as well as other elements such as architectural terra cotta, brackets and vent grills.
The coating has failed in a number of areas and appears to be holding moisture within areas of the cement plaster stucco. Some of the building s copper gutters and downspouts are damaged, displaced, warped or missing. Improper drainage from the damaged gutters and downspouts has resulted in isolated deterioration of the exterior cement plaster stucco. The terra cotta cupola has large fissure cracks that run the length of the columns. Areas of glaze and material spalling are also present on the cupola. The patterns of deterioration are consistent with the corrosion and expansion of embedded steel elements in the terra cotta assembly. Some of the wood window sills and sashes appear to have suffered from ultraviolet light degradation. B. Description of Exterior 1.
Overall Dimensions22 The U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House consists of a two-and-a-half story main wing with adjoining wings of one and two stories. The main wing is rectangular in plan, and is approximately 95 x 43 . The two side wings are also rectangular, with the north approximately 84 x 43 , and the south 101 x 43 . These two wings extend to the west to create an overall U-shaped plan for the building, resulting in a picturesque and rambling building form. The main wing houses office space. The single-story north wing contains utility areas and extends at a 90-degree angle from the main wing; the two-story south wing also contains office space and extends from the building at an angle of 110 degrees, running parallel to the international border line. 2.
Foundations 22 Page, Anderson & Turnbull, Historic Structures Report, 8. UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No. CA-2897 (Page 7) The central and south wings of the building both have a reinforced concrete foundation system resting on driven wood piles. The first floor of the central and south wings is composed of a reinforced concrete slab framed with reinforced concrete beams. The north wing, which has only a single story, has a slab-on-grade floor, part of which is supported on a perimeter pile foundation, and the remainder on spread footings.23 3. Walls The building is sheathed in sand-finish stucco with a yellow-buff integral color that was troweled to an even surface.
The cement plaster-covered masonry walls of the building received a texturized paint coating during the which today obscures both the subtle texture and color variations of the original stucco walls as the glazed terra cotta sills and ornaments. 4. Structural System & Framing The central and south wings of the building s structure are supported at its perimeter by unreinforced brick bearing walls. The upper floors of those wings are framed with steel I-beams supported at the perimeter brick wall. Steel columns support the interior. Steel floor framing supports wood floor joists and a diaphragm consisting of wood sheathing. The attic framing differs from the second level in that it has no diaphragm. The roof structure is framed in wood.
The north wing has a wood-framed roof structure which is supported by brick bearing walls.24 5. Porches and balconies25 The primary fa ade of the main wing of the Inspection Station is dominated by the porch that covers the primary entrance to the building. Originally a canopy that could accommodate two lanes of vehicular traffic, the existing porch is a shortened replacement of the original. Stuccoed squared columns decorated with ceramic tiles have simple bases and capitals, and support stuccoed spandrels that are also inlaid with tiles; these spandrels in turn support a decorative second-storey balcony that has tile-inlaid posts over the columns and wrought-iron railings. The porch is constructed of reinforced concrete.
Of particular note is a concrete exterior stair located on the south fa ade of the building. The stair and balcony are covered in the same stucco as the building. The stair provides access to a second floor balcony, which in turn provides access to a second floor corridor. The balcony has three arched openings on the south side and is supported by two large terra cotta brackets. The larger roof of the south wing extends over the balcony to form a shed style roof. The floor of the balcony and stair are terra cotta tile. 6. Openings a. Doorways and doors 23 Page & Turnbull, US Custom House - Relocation Study 66. 24 Ibid., 66. 25 Fraser, UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No.
CA-2897 (Page 8) Door configurations vary depending on their uses, and range from a double-leaf door- way with multi-paned transom above at the main entrance, to simple single-leaf entries to large sectional garage doors on the north side of the end wing. Overhead, mission-tiled canopies are featured over some entrances. b. Windows and shutters The fenestration of the building consists of 6-over-6 double-hung windows.26 The windows on the first story are taller than those on the second story. These first floor windows also feature plain terra cotta lug sills, while the windows on the second story have sills that are continuous terra cotta. Windows on both floors are framed with stucco heads and jambs. The second-story windows are framed by ornamental wood shutters. 7.
Roof27 A dominant element of the building is its roofline. The majority of the roof is pitched and comprised of multiple surfaces covered in red clay tiles, and punctuated with small cupolas, chimneys, and a prominent large cupola centered on the ridgeline of the main wing. The roofs vary in pitch, and are either flat roofs with composite and copper covering or shallowly-pitched gables. The eaves are composed of tiles that wrap around the outer wall edges. C. Description of Interior 1. Floor Plans and Stairway The first and second floors of the main wing were originally designed to include a number of rooms which primarily served as offices and work rooms for customs and immigration operations.
Most of those spaces had at least one exterior window as well as direct access to a central stair corridor which ran from the front to the rear of the building. Most of the original walls as well as the central hall and staircase that characterized the interior spaces of this wing have been removed. New partition walls have largely reorganized the floor plan, so that the original layout of the space is no longer recognizable. New suspended acoustical tile ceilings lowered the ceiling heights throughout the various offices and corridors. In many cases, the ceiling height has been reduced, requiring them to be boxed around the uppermost portions of the windows.
The south wing extends at a nearly 110-degree angle from the main wing, and has a change in elevation at its rear, sitting nearly a half-story above the main wing, with the different levels connected by a series of internal and external steps that accommodate this variation. This wing originally contained a variety of immigration work rooms, including a laboratory, assembly room, disinfecting room, as well as changing and bathing rooms for both men and woman. Most of the original walls that characterized the interior spaces of the south wing have since been removed, and as in the main wing, new partition walls have reorganized the floor plan. The toilet rooms located on the second level of the south wing still retain their original fixtures and finishes.
A small singl- story cyanide room 26 Fraser, 27 Ibid., UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No. CA-2897 (Page 9) was originally located off the rear of this wing, which has since been removed. Only the floor and entrance steps to that room remain. The north wing is one story high, and extends at a 90-degree angle from the central wing. This wing was designed to accommodate functions distinctly different from the other portions of the building, and has served as a garage and service area since its construction. 2. Flooring The majority of the floor surfaces throughout the building are covered with contemporary carpeting or vinyl flooring. 3.
Wall and ceiling finish Many of the original interior walls have been relocated, thus causing the loss of original wall and ceiling finishes. Painted drywall surfaces now replace the original lath and plaster wall surfaces. Suspended acoustical ceiling systems have replaced the original lath and plaster ceilings. 4. Doors, windows, decorative features, trim and hardware Although the original wooden windows are still present, most of the interior doors, trim, baseboards and hardware have been removed. D. Site 1. Historic landscape design The building s surroundings and landscape have been significantly altered since The U.S. Inspection Station & Custom House occupied an open landscape, giving a pastoral feel to the building.
The area of San Ysidro has become more urbanized as the amount of traffic through the border crossing has increased; the historic road that fronted the building in the has been replaced by Interstate 5 and its twenty-four inspection lanes. The increase in traffic has also required the addition of significant security features, such as concrete walls and metal fences. 28 The replacement of the inspection canopy at the front of the building has already been noted; the plantings there are limited to a narrow lawns and deciduous trees that shade what is now the northbound pedestrian crossing from Mexico. It is unknown how much of the original landscape plan was actually planted in the rear of the building, but the extant pepper trees correspond to the historic plans.
The slope that rises to the rear of the building has been planted with grass and not the cacti and ice plants specified in the original plans, and the original site furniture has been replaced with concrete tables and benches. 29 PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings 28 Page, Anderson & Turnbull, Historic Structures Report, 3. 29 Ibid., 5. UNITED STATES INSPECTION STATION & CUSTOM HOUSE HABS No. CA-2897 (Page 10) Sheets of original architectural drawings exist for the subject property, and are located within the drawings database maintained by the U.S. General Services Administration, Region 9.
These drawings include: X1 Site Plan 3B Second Floor Plan Exterior Elevations (various) Elevations, Sections and Details (various) Elevations, Sections and Details (various) Foundation Plan and Details First Floor Framing B. Early views: no early views have been identified for this project. C. Interviews: no interviews were conducted for this project. D. Selected