As part of the cultural resources study of the property, the Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property was found to have a high degree of integrity and is considered eligible for inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion C. Wendy L. Tinsley Becker, AICP, and John Hyche, MAA, Associate Historian and Preservation Planner; of Urbana Preservation & Planning, prepared this report. Existing conditions photographs by Dennis Hill, of Dennis Hill Content Creation, El Molino Avenue Altadena, California This HABS documentation project was requested and funded by Affordable Development LLC part of a development project that will result in the demolition of the building at the site.
Additional information and text were obtained from the October Historic Resource Technical Report Prepared by Urbana Preservation & Planning, PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 3) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A.
Dates of Erection: The Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property was originally commissioned by the original property owner, Perry D. Griswold and constructed in by the real estate and building firm McFadden & Buxton. It was constructed and used as a duplex until at least when the property changed ownership. By half the building was converted to a commercial shop space, and it continued that pattern of use until through subsequent occupants and proprietors. The Mission Hills Pet House occupied the shop space from to In Marielle and Pascal Giai opened Maison en Provence, also known as The Little French Store at the property, which operated in Mission Hills until The building has remained largely unaltered on the exterior in its original location.
The original separate entry porches, asymmetrical fa ades, cross gable roofs, battered porch piers with adjacent half columns (at the west porch), and post and lintel framing with half columns (at the south porch) are all essentially intact. The building is currently unoccupied and is owned by Affordable Development, LLC who plan to demolish the structure if relocation or adaptive reuse initiatives are not feasible. Architect: William Henry Wheeler Original and Subsequent Owners, Occupants, Uses: The Perry D. and Olive B.
Griswold Rental Property was originally valued at after construction of the home commissioned by Griswold.1 He received additional permits for adjacent dwellings at 818 Fort Stockton Drive, described as a five room residence [on] Getti between Goldfinch and Falcon and the Goldfinch Street, described as a five room residence [on] Goldfinch between Getti and Lewis. 2 Mr. Griswold regularly appeared in the San Diego Union having received permits for (and commissioned construction of) several Mission Hills buildings including on Washington Street and Falcon Street, cementing his historical reputation as an early resident, investor, and developer of the Mission Hills area of Uptown. Griswold, with his wife Olive B. lived at and Goldfinch Street, within blocks of the subject property. Perry D.
Griswold died in May leaving his widow Olive B. Griswold, ownership of the duplex from ca. through ca. when it was transferred to Isabel T. Ayres.3 Griswold was a member of the Woman s Christian Temperance Union wherein she frequently hosted union meetings at her Mission Hills home to discuss important issues of the day including prohibition, suffrage, and missionary work. Olive Griswold died in April In her advanced years, Griswold sold off much of the property that she and her husband had acquired in Mission Hills, including the subject property which was sold in 1 Notice of Completion, Miscellaneous Book 39, Pages 417 Recorded October 2, 2 Day s Permits Total The San Diego Union, Friday June 14, 2). 3 Deaths Griswold The San Diego Union, Thursday May 25, 5). PERRY D. AND OLIVE B.
GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 4) Griswold s obituary lauds her as a Woman Pioneer one of the earliest residents of Mission Hills who, with her husband, built the first home on the corner of Washington and Goldfinch Streets.4 San Diego City Directories confirm that Perry and Olive Griswold did not occupy the subject property. It was constructed for rental purposes and remained as such for the duration of their ownership.5 The second owners, Henry C. and Isabel Ayres maintained ownership, but not occupancy, through when the duplex was sold to Frank Keeley who quickly transferred the property to Sidelle and Edith Pearl in that same year. Ayres, a native of Ohio lived at Trias Street, at the west side of Mission Hills, east of Presidio Park.
She died in corresponding to the property s transfer to Frank Keeley.6 The Pearls owned and occupied the home in when it was sold to the Albert and Gladys Greene, who maintained ownership through In ca. the Greene s established and served as the first proprietors of the Missions Hills Pet House at 820 Fort Stockton Drive, signaling conversion of one duplex unit to commercial use.
This change in use is reflected on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map for the property which notates the building as D and S verifying that one of the duplex units had been converted to a shop / commercial use, and although the alteration is not delineated on the or Sanborn Map, conversion to the pet shop likely resulted in the infill of the porch roof at the rear of the building.8 The property was acquired by James and Kathryn Marlow in who transferred it to Roy B. and Hilda Olson. The Olsons owned the property through like previous long term owners, the Olsons did not occupy the property. Current owner, the Carole J.
Regis Trust and predecessors Albert and Carole Regis acquired the property in from the Olsons and similarly, did not occupy the property.9 As a business, the pet shop at 820 Fort Stockton Drive was owned by multiple proprietors including Layton Layton Pet Shop), Ms. Mary Mullican, Clifford L. Duke, and Laurance and Peggy Foster at various times when the property was occupied by the Mission Hills Pet Shop Establishment of the pet shop and conversion of the Fort Stockton Street unit to commercial purposes eliminated listing of the Goldfinch Street unit in San Diego City Directories. The last occupants of the Goldfinch unit were Jake Layton, a United States Navy member, and his wife Helen, proprietor of the 4 Rites Friday For Woman Pioneer Evening Tribune, Thursday April 30, 5).
5 City Directories, City of San Diego, accessed August 24, directories 6 Obituaries Ayres The San Diego Union, Sunday January 16, 2). 7 City of San Diego, City Directories. 8 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, San Diego Volume 3, Sheet Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, San Diego Volume 3, Sheet 9 City of San Diego, City Directories. PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 5) Layton Pet Shop.10 In the pet shop, known as the Mission Hills Pet Shop from closed and the building was leased by Marielle and Pascal Giai, who in opened Maison en Provence, also known as The Little French Store.
The Little French Shop closed its doors in Builder: The property s original builder was McFadden & Buxton, a real estate and building firm established in October when Joseph McFadden and George Buxton consolidated their real estate agencies to form their partnership.11 The company operated from D Street, and later, Fourth Street between B and C Streets. By the fall of the firm had dissolved; however, for its brief duration, the firm represented and constructed several notable subdivision projects including the North Park Addition (east of Arnold & Choates Addition), West End, Hollywood Park, Hector Square, South Orchard Tract, and Burlingame. In December McFadden & Buxton reported completion of 72 houses in the West End tract sited east and north of Balboa Park.
The company is specifically cited as the builder of the homes; the article additionally credits the firm for negotiating a large number of real estate deals. 12 In the firm begin to develop the Burlingame Subdivision wherein they utilized a team of specialists to develop, market, and construct the community including consulting architect William Henry Wheeler who served as the firm s Principal Architect and head of its building department. The company pioneered the concept of specialization rather than generalization of different work expertise. The company s system consisted of twenty four employees who each commanded a specialty in some aspect of real estate investment and development.
Included within the system were land developers, architects, builders, sales managers, investment brokers, and insurance underwriters. While the McFadden and Buxton Company existed for only two years, it proved to be one of the most innovative and enterprising real estate development firms experimenting in the concept of modern housing tract development.13 McFadden & Buxton s three year run corresponds to local anticipation of the Panama California Exposition. Search of the San Diego Union and Evening Tribune newspapers published between and located references to hundreds of building permit and construction notices for McFadden & Buxton built projects, primarily via the West End and Burlingame tracts.
The firm s new construction projects appear to have tapered off into early Its Pacific Beach tent cottages were regularly advertised for rent and the firm continued to represent real estate transactions. In the Spring of the firm moved to its new location in the McFadden & Buxton Arcade building located between B and C and Fourth and Fifth Streets, coinciding with the initial construction activities in its North Park Addition. By August of McFadden & Buxton sought out a real estate partner in Arizona. By October of local newspapers advertised the dissolution of McFadden & 10 Ibid. 11 Advertisement McFadden & Buxton The San Diego Union, Monday October 30, 2). 12 Firm Builds 72 Houses in Year The San Diego Union, Sunday December 31, 3).
13 City of San Diego, Burlingame Historic District: The Tract of Character PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 6) Buxton, with each man publishing notice of his new separate entity.14 Table 1, on the following page, includes projects attributed to the duo. William Henry Wheeler appears to have produced or supervised the designs for all buildings from May through the firm s dissolution in October A native of Australia, Wheeler was born in the state of Victoria on January 9, He received his architectural education and training in Melbourne prior to emigrating to Vancouver, Canada in Mr. Wheeler practiced from Vancouver through circa at which time he ceased to be listed in British Columbia Directories.
By he had relocated to the United States, first settling in San Francisco, California then Tucson, Arizona where he served as the Supervising Architect for the Southern Pacific Railway then San Diego where he continued his private architectural practice while simultaneously serving as the Principal Architect and Building Department Head for McFadden & Buxton.16 Wheeler continued to practice architecture long after the dissolution of McFadden & Buxton. He is recognized as a Master Architect by the City of San Diego with eleven known works included in the City s California Historical Resources Inventory Database (CHRID).
Many of these properties are designated under Local Register Criterion C and D for their architectural qualities and for representing the work of a master.17 Original Plans and Construction: A San Diego Union section on the day s permits from Friday, June 14, states that Griswold received a building permit for an eight room residence, [between] Getti and Goldfinch streets in addition to tow other permits for buildings at Goldfinch Street and 818 Fort Stockton Drive.18 Alterations and Additions: There are no additions to the building apart from the enclosure of the east patio space. In ca. Albert and Gladys Greene established and served as the first proprietors of the Missions Hills Pet House at 820 Fort Stockton Drive, signaling conversion of one duplex unit to commercial use.
This change in use is reflected on the Sanborn Fire Insurance Map for the property which notates the building as D and S verifying that one of the duplex units had been converted to a shop / commercial use, and although the alteration is not delineated on the or Sanborn Map, conversion to the pet shop likely resulted in the infill of the porch roof at the rear of the building.19 There are no permits from the City of San Diego related to the western porch enclosure and photographic evidence is inconclusive. 14 NewsBank, Inc., McFadden & Buxton Results, GeneologyBank, accessed August 25, 15 Many Buildings Will Be Erected Evening Tribune, Wednesday, May 29, 16 Wheeler, William Henry Biographical Dictionary of Architects in Canada.
Accessed October 17 City of San Diego, California Historical Resources Inventory Database. Search Architect: William Wheeler . Accessed October 18 Day s Permits Total The San Diego Union, Friday June 14, 2). 19 Sanborn Maps, San Diego Volume 3, Sheet PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 7) B.
Uptown Early History: While the history of permanent European settlement in the San Diego area dates to when Gaspar de Portol constructed the Presidio of San Diego and Junipero Serra established Mission San Diego de Alcal , one of the earliest significant developments in the region known as Uptown occurred when Alonzo Horton purchased 960 acres of land in and established Horton s Addition. Horton s real estate investment spurred other investors and speculators to follow in his footsteps thereafter and purchase their own additions. In tandem with land investment in the the Texas and Pacific Railway Company announced its intent to construct a railway to San Diego. However, in the wake of the Panic of the Company was unable to find funding for the venture.
Construction in Uptown stalled and the area failed to immediately evolve into the neighborhood envisioned by investors. Instead, the area remained undeveloped and under populated. As a result, very few built resources from this period remain extant in Uptown.20 The Railroad Boom and Early Residential Development: Once the California Southern Railroad was completed in the area experienced a population boom and rural outposts in San Diego were transformed into neighborhoods. Major development in the Uptown mesa began to take shape, at first with single family homes built in Victorian era styles.
However, the Southern California real estate market crashed in and surveyed / subdivided tracts from the previous three years were left vacant.21 The population of San Diego decreased, and its real estate plummeted in value. Still, a group of politicians, boosters and entrepreneurs initiated various capital improvement projects around the city. In Uptown, streets were graded, mass transit networks were extended, and municipal parks were installed with a state college by the These improvements served to indirectly incentivize residential development and helped shape established communities within the larger Uptown area. Additional improvements in transportation made the northern ends of Uptown easily accessible.
Gradually, new development activity extended into vacant areas of Uptown, including University Heights, Hillcrest and Mission Hills by the turn of the twentieth century. New properties largely consisted of single family homes during this time, as the first wave of suburbanization began to take shape. As communities developed, other necessities, including schools, fire stations and medical facilities, were also built to meet the needs of Uptown s growing population.22 20 City of San Diego. Uptown Community Plan Historical Resource Survey 12. 21 Ibid, 12 13. 22 Ibid., 13. PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No.
CA (Page 8) As a result of the improvement projects across Uptown and the first wave of residential development, by approximately a quarter of Uptown was considered developed. By that time, construction had occurred in the northern half of Park West, Hillcrest, Mission Hills and University Heights, although development in these areas was still not densely concentrated. After the initial construction of Queen Anne and Folk Victorian structures, later residential properties incorporated Craftsman, Prairie, Spanish Eclectic and other period revival styles.23 The Panama California Exposition and Streetcar Suburbs: One broad historical context, developed by the San Diego Planning Department in the Uptown Community Plan Area Historic Resources Survey Report applies to the Perry D. and Olive B.
Griswold Rental Property and its environs, The Panama California Exposition and Streetcar Suburbs: This was a transitional period in the city and Uptown, beginning in when local planners initiated preparations for the Panama California Exposition to celebrate the opening of the Panama Canal, which resulted in a speculative uptick in housing starts and commercial construction. Relevant excerpts of the Uptown survey are included below. Between the Exposition s inception in and its opening celebration in San Diego experienced an economic upswing and its population nearly doubled in size.
The increased demand for permanent housing, coupled with an associated rise in real estate values throughout the city, meant that Uptown s constituent communities all experienced a period of sharp and intensive growth at this time. After the Exposition, the Planning Area had been transformed into several populous and developed communities. Similar to previous waves of development in Uptown, new construction in the Exposition era consisted primarily of residential structures. At this time, a substantial number of single family [sic] homes were constructed on previously vacant parcels.
Prior to the Exposition, development had been largely confined to the southernmost section of the Planning Area, but by the density of residential development in Hillcrest, Mission Hills and University Heights increased. Prior to the Exposition, homes in Uptown were designed primarily in the Craftsman and Prairie styles, but the Churrigueresque motifs of the Exposition grounds sparked a widespread interest in Spanish architecture. Accordingly, many homes erected in the and were designed in the Spanish Eclectic and Mission Revival styles, though others continued to assume Craftsman style characteristics As the city continued to grow, the heightened demand for permanent housing also created a market niche for multifamily structures.
In addition to individual homes, a substantial number of residential flats and rooming houses were built. These were interspersed among several Uptown neighborhoods, particularly those neighborhoods bordering Balboa Park. Many of the flats and rooming houses were constructed as such, but others were identified as single family [sic] homes in and were subsequently modified to house more residents 23 Ibid., 13. PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 9) Throughout Uptown, the rapid rate of residential development gave rise to the construction of small commercial nodes along the Fifth Avenue, University Avenue, Washington Street and Park Boulevard streetcar lines.
Among the first commercial establishments in the area was the University Avenue Bank in Hillcrest, constructed in and nearby on Fifth Street the Hillcrest Theatre and Nelson s Dry Goods Store were erected in At the intersection of Washington and Goldfinch streets in Mission Hills, the Griswold Pharmacy # constructed in emerged as a hub of community life and boasted a soda fountain, a post office and a branch of the public library Patterns of development in Uptown, both during and after the Exposition, underscore the relationship between mass transit and city building. The majority of new construction occurred near the streetcar routes on First, Fourth, Fifth, Washington and Lewis streets, Fort Stockton Drive, University Avenue and Park Boulevard.
In contrast, development was considerably less dense in areas that were not in close proximity to a streetcar line, including the southeastern section of Hillcrest, as well as the southern and western reaches of Mission Hills.24 Uptown Craftsman Bungalow Construction: Craftsman Bungalows were the primary architectural style constructed within the Arnold & Choate s Addition of Uptown until roughly 1930.The bungalow defines the architectural aesthetic of residential neighborhoods developed in the San Diego region during the first two decades of the Twentieth Century. Nationally popular from to many Craftsman style dwellings in the San Diego region date from the forward.
The style was influenced by the English Arts and Crafts movement and emphasized handcrafted products over machine made details in reaction to the profusion of the mass manufactured ornamentation of the Victorian styles. The movement embodied every aspect of residential design from furniture to the bucolic setting of one's own yard, to the art pottery and the wallpaper that decorated house interiors. Popular literature, examples of which include, The Craftsman, Ladies Home Journal, Bungalow Magazine, and House Beautiful, distributed the movement s ideals to the middle class. The Craftsman style had broad boundaries that were further defined by regional tastes and interests.
Craftsman style design was popular nationwide, but flourished in California, because the mild climate allowed for an integration of interior and exterior spaces, as exemplified by large porches and balconies. In California, the Craftsman style often incorporated varying influences, including California's Mission tradition, Shingle style, as well as Middle Eastern and Asian influences.25 The Craftsman style is often associated with and applied to bungalows low one story houses with large front porches. Ornamentation in other styles, such as Queen Anne and Classical Revival, has also often been applied to the bungalow house form.
The California version of a bungalow was usually a one story detached house, however, variations on this norm included bungalow courts (several houses around a courtyard) and houses with an 24 Ibid., A36 A39. 25 Virginia McAlester, A Field Guide to American Houses, The Definitive Guide to Identifying and Understanding America s Domestic Architecture (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 10) inhabitable attic. Consistent plan features include the entrance directly into the living room with no parlor and a large kitchen. Many had sleeping porches, breakfast nooks, and inglenooks (or fireplace seats). Bungalows were usually constructed on small to medium sized lots.
Many two story houses were designed with Craftsman features, such as the large front porch, natural materials, and interior plan. Nationwide, the style often employed materials such as fieldstone, regular and clinker brick.
The basic character defining features typical to the Craftsman style are: Low pitched gabled roof, Wide unenclosed eave overhang, Decorative beams or braces under the gables, Columns or column bases that continue to the ground level without interruption at porch floor, Exposed roof rafters, and Full or partial width porches.26 In addition to the above listed typical or common design features, high style examples Craftsman bungalows sometimes include: Irregular or non symmetrical composition and irregular plan (not solely rectilinear) Multiple roof planes, Airplane design with cockpit feature comprised of an attic room projecting above the wings of its roof, Half columns at the front porch (secondary, non structural) for decorative urns or potted plants, Sloping or battered foundations and porch supports, Stone or ornate brick exterior chimneys, Trellised porch or Porte Cochere roof extending beyond the exterior wall plane, Large gabled or shed roof dormers, Window boxes, Stained glass window designs, Mix of exterior building materials including a combination of all or some of the following materials: o Wood boards, o Wood shingles, o Stone, o Brick or Clinker brick, o Concrete block, and o Stucco, and Secondary design features attributed to the Tudor, Oriental/Japonesque, Swiss, Prairie or Mission styles including: 26 Ibid, PERRY D.
AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 11) o False half timbering, o Oriental roof forms upswept, peaked or flared roofline articulations reminiscent of a Pagoda structure, o Japonesque turned up porch columns, o Arts & Crafts mortise and tenon paired porch columns, and o Swiss balustrades.27 With ready made drawings and materials for sale from local and regional design build companies and the popularity of mail order house catalogues, the proliferation of Craftsman bungalow construction formed the suburban landscape that typifies regional neighborhoods developed in the first two decades of the Century. Most of the vernacular Craftsman style residences constructed in the San Diego region are wood frame with either wood siding or an applied stucco exterior finish.
They do not regularly feature the more distinctive character defining characteristics or materials of high style examples. Craftsman Bungalow Duplexes While Craftsman Bungalows were largely constructed as single family homes, the same popular literature that popularized the movement also distributed floorplans for duplexes. The Modern Homes catalog, produced by the Standard Homes Company, distributed a floorplan for duplexes that featured a front gabled building split lengthwise down the center with mirrored doorways and windows on either slope of the gable.
Most Craftsman Bungalow duplex designs seem to have followed similar styles where both front entrances shared a singular central porch on the primary elevation of the building.28 The City of Orange s Old Towne National Register Historic District contains at least seven Craftsman Bungalow duplex homes that follow the similar front gabled split design.29 Other intact Craftsman neighborhoods, including Bungalow Heaven in Pasadena, CA, feature duplex homes amongst single family residential neighborhoods. In addition to catalog floorplan duplex designs, standard U shaped bungalow courts and L or I shaped half courts also occasionally included duplex structures among single family units.
Bungalow courts first emerged in Pasadena in as an alternative to apartment buildings that provided separated individual units with shared courtyards to offer a balance of privacy and community.30 Duplexes, larger apartment structures, or multi story single family residences were sometimes constructed in the center of standard U shaped bungalow courts in California. In linear or half courts, shaped in L or I configurations, duplex units could be constructed on one end of the bungalow court with separate street 27 Ibid, 28 The California, Antique Home Style, last modified california.htm 29 Steven G. McHarris, Old Towne Orange Historic District National Register of Historic Places Registration Form, Old Towne Preservation Association (January 9, 30 City of San Diego.
San Diego Bungalow Court and Apartment Court Historic Context Statement Workshop 2. PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 12) entrances and back patios that opened on to the shared courtyard space.31 However, for the most part, bungalow courts featured separated units and duplex bungalows were not a common feature. Bungalow courts largely stuck to configurations that only included single family units. In San Diego, there are no single story Craftsman Bungalow duplexes currently designated by the Historical Resource Board as being locally significant. There are six two story Craftsman style duplex homes designated, five of which are contributing buildings in the South Park Historic District.
Only one residence, the Carrie and Horatio Farmham Duplex at 4th Avenue is individually significant under Criterion C as a building that embodies the distinctive characteristics of the Craftsman style. The only designated one story bungalow duplexes in San Diego are 205 Street and & J Street which are California Bungalow style buildings that contribute to the Sherman Heights Historic District.32 While one story Craftsman Bungalow duplexes appear to have been a conventional building type with standardized duplex floorplans, duplexes in the Craftsman style were not as ubiquitous as Craftsman style single family bungalows in Southern California. As a result, buildings such the Perry D. and Olive B.
Griswold Rental Property are currently underrepresented in the City of San Diego s list of historical resources. In San Diego, it is unclear how many duplexes were completed in this style, but they appear to be a rare property type that is not well documented locally. San Diego only recently documented bungalow courts in a historic context statement. Only a few of the documented bungalow courts within the context statement contained duplex units within the larger court. Stand alone Craftsman Bungalow duplexes have not been researched thoroughly or widely documented in recent surveys because of their rarity compared to Craftsman style single family homes. While there may be other undocumented intact Craftsman Bungalow duplexes within San Diego, the Perry D. and Olive B.
Griswold Rental Property appears to be a rare property type with a uniquely high degree of integrity. Arnold & Choate s Subdivision Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property The Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property was built in forty years after the Arnold & Choate s Addition was platted in Developed by Cyrus Arnold, an attorney and real estate developer, and Daniel Choate, a dry goods merchant, the tract is bound by University Avenue to the south, Randolph Street on the west, Curlew Street to the east, and Arbor Drive to the north. Although subdivided early in the city s history, initial development was stymied by economic downturn and lack of access.
The tract featured a rectilinear layout amidst the canyons, gulches, and mesas that characterize Uptown and the surrounding city. Rectilinear lots represented unregulated maximization of land, pre dating the and Nolen Plans for San Diego which later emphasized the need to 31 Ibid., 31 32. 32 California Historical Resources Inventory Database, City of San Diego, accessed August 26, PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 13) develop and link central meeting places, street systems and traffic, and open spaces within new communities. The Nolen Plans together with the City Beautiful Movement, also espoused curvilinear streets to conform to existing natural topography.
The rectilinear gridiron adopted in the Arnold & Choate s Addition was a logical extension of the grid pattern established in Horton s Addition and Middletown. By horticulturalist Kate Sessions was a major landowner in the young subdivision. Sessions purchased a large portion of North Florence Heights as well as adjacent blocks in the Arnold and Choate s subdivision for a nursery site and attendant growing grounds. Development in Arnold and Choate s was spurred by the extension of the streetcar system in The line ran east west along Washington Street, then north south on Hawk Street and east west on Lewis Street. This connection made it possible for residents to reach downtown destinations and made the area appealing for middle and upper class families.
Interest in the area was additionally spurred by the scenic beauty and topography of the neighborhood, bound to the north and east by deep ravines and canyons. Residential blocks lining the north south streets in the area are punctuated by low density commercial buildings sited along two east west thoroughfares, Washington Street and Fort Stockton Drive, which offer neighborhood serving restaurant, retail, medical, religious and educational uses. Architectural styles observed include California Bungalows with Craftsman and Abstract Prairie influences, as well as Folk Victorian and Minimal Traditional styles.
By when the area was initially mapped by the Sanborn Fire Insurance Company, Arnold & Choate s Block 47 had been fully developed to include six dwellings fronting the east side of Goldfinch Street and two fronting the north side of Fort Stockton Drive and and three fronting the west side of Falcon Street and All dwellings were single story, likely bungalows, and all featured an ancillary structure either an auto garage or miscellaneous structure at the rear of the dwelling. No substantive changes are delineated on the subsequent Sanborn Map publications update and According to aerial imagery, the gulch lots adjacent to the Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property were improved with a two story apartment building with a central courtyard by (present day Falcon Street).
Between and original dwellings on Goldfinch Street through and Falcon Street were replaced with larger apartment buildings (present day Goldfinch Street and 800 808 Falcon Street). The original dwellings at 820 Fort Stockton Drive / Goldfinch Street, Goldfinch Street, and Falcon Street remained in place. In Falcon Street was replaced by a larger multi family building Falcon Street). Today the Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property building remains largely unaltered in its original location. The building at Goldfinch Street has been heavily 33 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, San Diego Volume 3, Sheet Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, San Diego Volume 3, Sheet PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No.
CA (Page 14) modified and the 818 Fort Stockton Drive building is in poor condition. The Goldfinch Street property, originally a single family dwelling, is now utilized for commercial purposes, and the front elevation has been extensively altered via construction of an addition that brings the front elevation to the sidewalk. The bungalows at 820 Fort Stockton Drive and the adjacent 818 Fort Stockton Drive are the few remaining unaltered buildings original to the block. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A.
Architectural Character: Craftsman Bungalow Duplex. Condition of Fabric: The wood frame building is extant with exterior building materials is in good condition with visible signs of aging and expected areas for repair. B.
Overall Dimensions: The Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property is a single story building with a rectangular floorplan situated in a north south orientation. One entrance and porch face Fort Stockton Drive and the other front entrance with a porch opens out onto Goldfinch Street. The roof of cross gabled building is clad in composite asphalt shingles with white trim and broad eaves. The roof is pierced by two exterior brick chimneys along the western elevation. The exterior is clad in horizontal board siding painted red. The overall dimensions are approximately 46 x 60 at its furthest reaches including porch extensions. The south elevation on Fort Stockton Drive has an asymmetrical fa ade which consists of a front facing gable end above a gabled porch on the west half.
The porch extends 5 out from the gable end and measures approximately 17 wide. The entire gable end measures 35 wide. The west elevation of the building along Goldfinch Street has an asymmetric fa ade with a front facing gable end along the northern half of the elevation that encompasses a porch roof gable extending out westward. The southern half of the elevation is composed of the south facing gable mass which terminates along Fort Stockton Drive. There are two exterior brick chimneys that pierce the gable end along Goldfinch Street and a gabled porch on the northern end of the fa ade. The porch gable extends approximately 4 from the gable end and measures 17 wide. The northern gable end along Goldfinch encompasses the northern 29 of the 60 long elevation.
The east elevation has an asymmetrical fa ade with a gable end on the north, an enclosed porch in the center, and a side gabled mass with windows extending southward towards PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 15) Fort Stockton Drive. This front facing gable on the north has false beams on the gable end, broad eaves, exposed false rafter tails, and lattice work within the upper third of the gable, in the same style as the Fort Stockton Drive gable end. The gable end measures 19 across, the enclosed porch measures 12 wide, and the side gabled mass is 16 long, extending 6 outward and eastward from the Fort Stockton Drive gable end, creating a small L shaped extension that is located 6 north of the south elevation in the southeast corner of the building.
In total, the north elevation measures approximately 55 . The north elevation is asymmetrical but runs along a flat plane beneath a wide eave overhang. False white painted exposed rafter tails run the length of the eave overhang. The eave is part of the gable end that extends out to Goldfinch Street on the west and the northern part of backyard on the east. The entire northern elevation measures 46 across. Foundations: The building has a raised foundation with a crawlspace supported by concrete pillars and wood posts. Walls: Exterior walls are clad with horizontal wood clapboard siding. Structural System, framing: The walls, flooring, and roof are wood framed with wood and brick decorative elements.
Porches, Stoops, Balconies, Porticoes, Bulkheads: The principal gable end and the porch gable roof on the south elevation both have white fascia boards with exposed false beams on the gable ends. Enclosed within the principal gable end, there is a white painted wood lattice. Beneath the wood lattice, the porch gable has white post and lintel framing with half columns that are painted white wood beams with pedestals clad in red painted horizonal board siding. The porch floor is poured concrete painted red with two steps. The porch entrance features a white painted wood framed glass door with a full length sidelight located west of the entrance.
The principal gable end on Goldfinch Street encompasses the porch gable roof which both feature white fascia boards with exposed false exposed beam ends. The porch has white post and lintel framing above battered porch piers with a half height wall enclosure that are is clad in horizontal board siding. The porch floor is clad in wood flooring that sits atop the concrete foundation with three concrete steps painted red with boards on top. The southern facing opening between the porch pier and the house is filled with a four light wood fixed pane window. In the center of the east elevation, the gable wing that extends southward to Fort Stockton Drive covers the formerly open central back patio that is now enclosed with white vertical wood bars and a wood framed asphalt shingle roof. PERRY D.
AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 16) Chimneys: To the south of the porch along the west elevation in the center of the wall plane, a Flemish Bond brick chimney with clinker headers pierces the center and northern half of the principal gable end. At the southern end of the front facing gable on Goldfinch Street, where the cross gable masses meet, there is another brick chimney with a Flemish Bond pattern and clinker headers. Openings: Along the south elevation on Fort Stockton Drive, there is one door with a sidelight and three windows within the gable end. On the western elevation bordering Goldfinch Street, there is one door and six windows. Along the north elevation, there are three windows. The east elevation features two doors and eight windows.
Doorway and Doors: On the south fa ade, there is a wood framed glass front door in the porch that faces Fort Stockton Drive. On the west fa ade, there is another door within the porch that faces Goldfinch Street. The west fa ade door has two panels, and the upper panel covers the top two thirds of the door. Within the upper panel, there are four long vertical lights separated by thin wood strips with a horizontal wood bar at the base of the lights supported by three equally spaced square wood blocks. On the east elevation beneath the northern gable end, there is a white painted wood door with a single light within the upper half of the door frame that is covered with white security bars that appears to be inoperable.
Within the center of the east elevation, in an enclosed patio space, there is another white painted wood door with a single light in the upper half of the door frame that opens south. Windows: The windows consist of one over one wood framed double hung sash windows, square hopper windows, fixed pane windows, and one modern casement window. All windows are of wood frame construction. To the east of the door within the porch on the south elevation, there is one original one over one double hung wood sash window painted white. Outside the porch, in the center and on eastern end of the elevation, there are two more white painted wood framed one over one double hung sash windows.
Within the porch on the western elevation there is a one over one white painted double hung wood sash window with white painted security bars. Immediately to the south of the northernmost exterior chimney, there is a two white painted one over one double hung wood sash windows between the two chimneys. South of the chimneys and outside the gable end that encompasses the western porch, there is a wide eave with exposed rafter tails above one white painted one over one double hung wood sash window, a small square white painted wood framed hopper window, and a tripartite white painted fixed pane wood windows at the southern corner. The northern elevation has three white painted windows and white painted security bars.
The westernmost window closest to the western porch is a small frosted single pane PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 17) hopper window painted white. Adjacent to the hopper window are two white painted one over one double hung wood sash windows. At the northern corner of the east elevation, the gable end from Goldfinch Street faces east into the backyard. Beneath the gable end, there is a double hung one over one wood sash window and a wood paneled back door with a casement window sitting immediately adjacent and south of the doorframe. The wood deck patio in the center has two one over one double hung wood frame sash windows that face east and one smaller one over one double hung wood frame sash window that faces north.
At the southern end of the east elevation, south of the enclosed and covered patio, there are two wood fixed pane rectangular windows that are oriented horizontally. In the southeast corner, the bay drops back, and one one over one double hung wood frame sash window is located on the southern end of the elevation. Roof: The roof is clad with asphalt composite shingles over a wood frame. Shape, Covering: The roof is cross gabled in form and configured in a T shape with a northern gable extending east to west and a southern gable extending north to south. Cornice, Eaves: The roof features latticed vent openings on the south and east gable ends; broad eaves; exposed false beams on the gable ends; and false rafter tails.
Dormers, Cupolas, Towers: There are no dormers, cupolas, or towers on the building. PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 18) PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION Bibliography Antique Home Style The California: From 101 Modern Homes by Standard Homes Company, Standard Homes Company. Last modified california.htm City of San Diego California Historical Resources Inventory Database. Accessed August 26, City of San Diego City Directories. Digital Archives.
Accessed August 25, directories City of San Diego Planning Department Burlingame Historic District: The Tract of Character (San Diego, California, City of San Diego Planning Department DRAFT Bungalow Courts and Apartment Courts Historic Context Statement (San Diego, California, July 12, City of San Diego Planning Department Uptown Community Plan Area Historic Resources Survey Report (San Diego, California, Hill, Robert G. Wheeler, William Henry. Biographical Dictionary of Architects in Canada Nationwide Environmental Title Research Historic Aerials. McHarris, Steven G. Old Towne Orange Historic District National Register of Historic Places Registration Form, Old Towne Preservation Association (January 9, NewsBank Inc. McFadden & Buxton Results. GenealogyBank. Accessed August 25, PERRY D.
AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 19) Day s Permits Total GenealogyBank, The San Diego Union, June 14, Advertisement McFadden & Buxton The San Diego Union, October 30, Firm Builds 72 Houses in Year The San Diego Union, December 31, Many Buildings Will Be Erected Evening Tribune, May 29, Deaths Griswold The San Diego Union, May 25, Rites Friday For Woman Pioneer Evening Tribune, April 30, Obituaries Ayres The San Diego Union, January 16, Sanborn Fire Insurance Company Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, Volume 3, Sheet 382 (San Diego, California, San Diego County Assessor, Recorder, Clerk Notice of Completion, Miscellaneous Book 39, (San Diego, California, October 2, 417 PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 20) PART IV.
SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIAL Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property, USGS: PERRY D. AND OLIVE B. GRISWOLD RENTAL PROPERTY HABS No. CA (Page 21) Portion of La Jolla Topographical Map Scale Map, Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental Property