BlockBefore

Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars, Roe Street, North Island, San Diego

Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars, Roe Street, North Island, San Diego, San Diego County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A-, with a 8,906-word written history.

From the record

“The buildings are considered significant for their association with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of United States history.”

Written record, HABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A- · the record runs 8906 words · one of 194 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

8784 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The buildings are considered significant for their association with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of United States history. Naval aviation programs combined with the construction of naval air stations played an important role in the ( national defense program during the years before World War I and up through World War II. The Naval Air Station, North Island played a key role in the development of naval aviation and seaplanes were considered to be a valuable addition to the aviation program in the early years. Hangar space for the seaplanes was essential to the functioning of the base. One of San Diego's prime assets was its location on the West Coast and its ability to provide both land and sea activities.

The hangars constructed during the Buildings 29 and 68, and the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 aided the base in the fulfillment of its stated mission. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History - Buildings 29 and 68, Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 1. Date of erection: Building No. 29 was constructed in as a seaplane hangar. Building 68 was constructed in as a seaplane hangar. Original plans for the buildings and structures were located in the U.S. Navy Plan Files Departments at Naval Air Station, North Island; Naval Station, San Diego; and the Construction Battalion Center, Port Hueneme, California were reviewed.

In addition, the Inventory of Structures, the official United States Navy inventory of all base structures and buildings was reviewed for additional information. 2. Architect: Buildings 29 and 68 were designed by U.S. Navy architects at the Bureau of Yards and Docks. No specific individual is credited with the design but construction manuals from the Bureau indicate that standardized drawings were produced for the more utilitarian structures over the years. Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 were constructed as part of the original development of Naval Air Station, North Island and were designed by Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue and are included within the Naval Air Station, San Diego Historic District boundaries.

The Naval Air Station, North Island contains within its boundaries the Naval Air Station, San Diego Historic District (NAS San Diego). Historically, the district represents the principal administrative and residential core of one of the earliest naval air stations in the United States and the first air station on the West Coast. Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 are located within the boundaries of the historic district and are part of the original core buildings of the air station. Buildings 29 and 68 are located immediately adjacent to the historic district but are not considered to be part of the historic district.

NAS San Diego was nationally and locally important for the fundamental role it played in the development and maintenance of the United States naval aviation program in the years The base also helped to establish the foundation of the military presence in San Diego county and Southern California (National Register of Historic Places Registration Form 1). Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 3) The NAS San Diego Historic District is significant for its architectural characteristics and association with noted architect Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue. In addition, the association of the district with the broad national and regional themes in the development of military aviation adds increased importance.

The district serves as a "representation of a significant application of the district characteristics of the Spanish Colonial Revival style in military architecture; and in this contex, they represent an important example of the work of one of America's acknowledged master architects - Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue." (National Register of Historic Places Registration Form 1). The beginning of the Spanish Colonial Revival phase is attributed to Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue and his design of the Panama-California Exposition in San Diego.

Instead of looking exclusively at the early mission period of California, Goodhue took his design inspiration for the Exposition buildings from the Renaissance and Baroque architecture of Spain, Italy, Mexico and Guatemala, and from Islamic sources in the Mediterranean region. Over the course of his prominent career, he borrowed forms from historic work, interpreted them freely and trusted his own visual judgement on issues of scale and proportion. The air station commission in was the latest in a long string of successful interpretations and international acclaim. The Cathedral of St. Matthew in Dallas, the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, the St.

Thomas Church in New York and other important designs in Byzantine, Gothic, Classic, and American styles had earned Goodhue a well-deserved position in architecture and he was recognized as a significant master architect. The air station was designed as a unified composition of various Hispanic forms, with careful planning, massing, and coordination of building elements and roof lines. The core of Goodhue's plan remains largely intact, a cohesive group of buildings despite the dense development which has occurred in the perimeter areas (National Register of Historic Places Registration Form The siting of the seaplane hangars and Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, and 4 were defined by Goodhue as part of his original site plan for the air station.

The seaplane hangars were placed along the edge of the bay on the perimeter of the historic district's main core buildings. Originally a total number of eight seaplane hangars were planned, but a scaling back of funds and priorities resulted in the construction of only Buildings 1 and 2, now part of the historic district. Later additions to the air station followed the Goodhue site plan's practical guidance, at least in relation to the location of seaplane hangars. However, subsequent hangar construction was much simpler in scale and cost of materials than with Buildings 1 and 2. Building 29 was constructed in within four years after the development of the air station.

Building 68 was constructed in ten years after the construction of the historic district's core buildings, and reflects continuing changes in aviation technology, national defense needs, availability of construction funds and Department of Defense priorities. Buildings 29 and 68 were constructed as a more limited scale and lower cost alternative to Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 4) Goodhue's steel-and-masonry Spanish Colonial hangars. In this, however, they continue the original site plan's philosophy for the location of hangars with immediate water access.

The original drawings reveal that the design plans were created by the Department of the Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks, Public Works Department and probably constitute a set of standardized drawings applicable to a variety of air bases. The plans drawn up by Public Works were to be used at two air stations, Naval Air Station, San Diego and at Coco Solo in the Panama Canal Zone, further indication that these were standardized plans with no unique features. 3. Original and subsequent owners: The United States Navy has owned and controlled the buildings and seaplane ramps from initial concept and construction until the present time.

The design and construction of the Naval Air Station was developed during World War I and expresses both the wartime needs of the Navy and the inception of a military aviation program. Design and construction of the air station developed during World War I as an expression of the Navy's wartime needs and use has continued to the present in concert with the evolution of military aviation. In the years between the World Wars, Buildings 29 and 68 served an important role as two of four seaplane hangars and their use as an integral part of air station operations. Seaplane Ramps 2, 3 and 4 also continued their function as access for seaplanes to Buildings 1 and 2.

As aviation technology changed and strategies for maritime aerial warfare evolved, the use of seaplanes faded and these buildings and structures shifted use for a variety of shops and storage purposes. For Buildings 29 and 68, their functional construction meant such changes in use were easily accomplished. Conversion to another use for these facilities was not as easy on the integrity of Seaplane Ramps 2, 3 and 4. They fell into disuse, were not maintained and have deteriorated. Because they are located in the intertidal zone, this deterioration has been accelerated and much of their original integrity is lost. 4. Builder, contractor, suppliers: Building 29 was constructed by the Public Works Department with U.S. Navy supplies and materials. Building 68 was constructed by the Robert E.

McKee Company of Los Angeles. The contractor and/or builder of the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 is unknown. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 5) 5. Original plans and construction: Original plans for the structures were consulted for information related to the original construction techniques. The original contract could not be located for Building 29. The original contract for Building 68 called for construction of a "steel frame hangar, two bay design, x with 2 lean-to's 20' wide and long, sheathed with asbestos protected metal. This hangar provides space for housing a newly organized patrol squadron, Aircraft Squadrons, Battle Fleet, comprised of PD seaplanes." Building 68 was constructed by the Robert E. McKee Company of Los Angeles under Contract No.

NOy No.298 for a cost of and was completed by January 30, Buildings 29 and 68 were constructed according to design standards established by the Bureau of Yards and Docks. According to the Navy Department, Bureau of Yards and Docks Design Data in 193 8, very specific specifications were delineated for seaplane hangars. Presumably this design data was carried over from previous usage and reflected a continuance of design philosophy. The siting, setting, and construction of the buildings reflects the following information and it is assumed that the directions given below were a continuing pattern of seaplane hangar construction techniques. The hangars were to be: 160 by 240 feet with 32 feet clear height under trusses.

Seaplane hangars are being constructed in two units having the foregoing spans with doors at both ends. 'Lean-tos,' 20 feet wide, are constructed on sides of hangars to provide space for officers, shops, lockers, washrooms, and toilets. In some cases, these lean-tos are made 40 feet wide to give room for torpedo overhaul and storage. Seaplane hangars should be located adjacent to the runways with sufficient space between the hangars and bulkhead for conveniently parking, handling, and moving the planes. The standard type of hangar is of steel-frame construction with steel sash and concrete floor. In the past, wood roof sheathing and built-up roofing or steel roof decks covered with insulating material and built-up roofing, has been standard construction.

These comprise the cheaper types of roofing and have generally been found necessary because of limitation of funds. When funds permit, the bureau proposes to use a more permanent and fireproof type of construction such as light-weight precast concrete slabs with built-up roofing. Brick, concrete or corrugated asbestos should be used for siding material, depending on the locality and funds available. In addition to wind, snow, and dead loads, roof trusses on spans not exceeding 100 feet have generally been designed for a concentrated load of Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 6) pounds at any panel point on the bottom chord. This loading provides for lifting a plane for inspection, replacing pontoons, or other purposes.

For spans greater than 100 feet the roof trusses should be designed for carrying nonrail hoists of 1 ton capacity at the quarter points in lieu of concentrated loads at panel points. Reference drawings and show general features of typical seaplane hangars of 120-foot span, the former with sliding doors and the latter with bascule doors. Drawings and show a 160-foot span seaplane hangar at Seattle. Drawings and show a 110-foot span landplane hangar at Pensacola under specification The hangar doors are to be a sliding type. This type of door consists of a number of leaves with wheels on the bottom and guide rollers at the top. For a 110-foot opening six leaves, 18 feet 6 inches wide by the height to the underside of the trusses, are used.

This size of leaf approaches the maximum that can be readily operated by one person by hand. The leaves open from the center toward the sides and project beyond the hangar the width of a leaf, or into the next bay of multiple bay hangars when fully opened. Pavement around the hangars should be of concrete of a type which will withstand abrasion and heavy truck loads. Trees, posts, hydrants, etc. on the sides of roadways should be located so as not to interfere with the movement of planes from hangars and shops to either the beach or the landing field. To permit the moving of assembled planes from the flying field or land hangars to seaplane hangars and dock, a roadway clearance of approximately 150 feet should be provided.

The Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 were constructed according to specifications designed by Bertram Goodhue. 6. Alterations and additions: Alterations to Buildings 29 and 68 took place at several intervals over the last seven decades. As the base grew, and the use of seaplanes diminished, the need for seaplane hangars changed. Alterations took place in both structures that created a series of shops and maintenance related uses for the structures. As aviation technology developed, the U.S. Navy shifted to a reliance on different types of planes and seaplanes were gradually phased out. The original plans for the alterations are located in the Plan Files Department at the Naval Air Station, North Island.

Building 29 Building 29 was altered by the addition of "lean-to" structures on the north and south facades of the building in The lean-tos were three sided, rectangular additions with steel frames that were added to the existing Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 7) structure and utilized the outer wall of the main building as the fourth wall of the lean-to. The lean-tos had reinforced concrete base walls and were planned to rest on the existing concrete pavement. The additions had shed roofs with asphalt covering and the walls were brick with stucco covering. The placement of windows varies between the north and the south and reflects the range of uses of the interior space.

Later alterations also changed window patterns to conform to the changing uses of the interior sections. In plans were drawn for different usages of the lean-to sections and included space for oil and paint storage; engineering, flight, and captain's offices; metal, carpenter, radio, outrigger shops; storage for the beach crew, men's lockers, parachutes and navigator equipment, ordnance and towing gear and the pilot's ready room. The mezzanine provided more storage space. In an observation tower was approved for addition to the northwest comer of the structure. The observation tower is approximately 20 feet square and has large glass windows that cantilever outward to provide maximum observation capacity.

The tower has a deck surrounding it on four sides and is reached by a steel ladder built in sections up the side of the structure so access is available from the exterior of the building. In the interior of Building 29 has been divided into nine sections with a range of shop uses. Building 68 Alterations to the building include the alterations to the "lean-tos" in according to Public Works Drawing Number NAS/N5-74 under Contract No. These plans were used both at San Diego and at Coco Solo in the Panama Canal Zone. The lean-tos were placed on the north and south facades and divided into various work areas. At the time of the current study, the lean-tos were divided into eight sections. The lean-tos are twenty feet wide, with a slope floor and shed roof with asphalt covering.

The lean-tos have steel frames and corrugated metal siding. Traffic doors are placed at irregular intervals and windows repeat the same steel frame, multipaned approach found elsewhere on the building. A sawdust collector system was added in and additional traffic doors were also added in The doors were to be placed on the east and west facades within the main sliding doors and were to be self-closing, double acting, pairs of 6' x 12' Torador, Model No. O.S. Goodale doors. Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 The seaplane ramps have not undergone specific alterations, but they have deteriorated considerably due to their location within the intertidal zone and lack of maintenance. The lack of maintenance was a result of the shifting of priorities away from seaplane use.

Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 8) B. Historical Context for Buildings 29 and 68 and Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 A more complete account of the history of the North Island area and the Naval Air Station, North Island can be found in the National Register nomination form for the Naval Air Station, San Diego Historic District prepared by Andrew Yatsko, Archaeologist in The district was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in and gives a context for the buildings and ramps and how they relate to the other elements of the base. The written history of the Coronado/North Island area dates back to when Juan Rodriguez Cabrillo sailed into San Diego Bay on a voyage of exploration and claimed the lands and bay for the Spanish crown.

Coronado consisted of two separate pieces of land totaling acres - a two square mile peninsula and an island connected to the peninsula by a low tide sand bar. The water in between these two land masses would become known as the Spanish Bight (Master Plan Initial settlement and development of the San Diego region was undertaken by Spanish colonists and consisted of the creation of a system of missionaries, presidios, and pueblos. The land fell under the control of Mexico after their successful movement for independence in the and soon Americans began to filter into the region and became part of the economic and settlement pattern. California was transferred to the United States after the Mexican War with the conclusion of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo.

The discovery of gold and resulting onslaught of newcomers, speculators, conmen, artists and entreprenuers changed the face of California permanently (Rolle By the beginning of the twentieth century, California had acquired a reputation as a golden land filled with promise of health, wealth and prosperity. In the Panama-California Exposition in Balboa Park brought additional fame to San Diego, as well as more residents. During World War I, San Diego began its role as a major military and naval area with establishment of a destroyer base on the bay. One of the areas to play a prominent role in the development of the U.S.

Navy and its aviation program was the Coronado/North Island area (Rolle The Coronado/North Island area was originally part of Spanish territory, then Mexican land, and ultimately the area came under American control and in the process changed hands many times over the course of the century. Two men, Hampton L. Storey and Elisha Babcock, purchased the property in for construction of a major hotel complex, the Hotel Del Coronado. The first government land on North Island was acquired when 18 acres of land were condemned for construction of a jetty to keep the channel open into San Diego harbor. In an additional parcel of 38 Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No.

CA-2652-A (Page 9) acres was acquired to construct Fort Pio Pico, a coastal defense fort and the first military reservation on North Island (Engstrand The founding of Naval Air Station North Island (NASNI), originally known as Naval Air Station, San Diego, was a result of the development of naval aviation, first with the experimentation of Glenn Curtiss in and the subsequent establishment of the first Naval Aviation Unit in An agreement between the Army and the Navy was signed in to resolve differences over control of the island. This agreement gave control of the northern portion of the island to the Navy, however, the dispute continued until when Franklin D. Roosevelt issued an Executive Order.

The installation was designated Naval Air Station (NAS) North Island on October 26, (Master Plan Naval Air Station, San Diego was one of the earliest naval air stations in the United States and the first air station on the West Coast. Buildings 29 and 68 are located immediately adjacent to the historic district of core buildings designed by Bertram Goodhue. NAS San Diego was nationally and locally important for the fundamental role it played in the development and maintenance of the United States naval aviation program in the years The base also helped to establish the foundation of the military presence in San Diego county and Southern California (National Register of Historic Places Registration Form 1).

The NAS San Diego Historic District is significant for its architectural characteristics and association with noted architect Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue. In addition, the association of the district with the broad national and regional themes in the development of military aviation adds increased importance. The district serves as a "representation of a significant application of the district characteristics of the Spanish Colonial Revival style in military architecture; and in this context, they represent an important example of the work of one of America's acknowledged master architects - Bertram Grosvernor Goodhue." (National Register of Historic Places Registration Form 1). The original concept planned by Goodhue is still evident and the integrity of the district has survived.

The siting of Buildings 29 and 68 was determined by Goodhue as part of his master plan for the base but were never executed as part of his contract with the U.S. Navy. Later additions to the base followed the master plan in part, at least in relation to the location of the seaplane hangars, and the seaplane hangars were sited at the edge of the bay on the perimeter of the main core buildings which now comprise the historic district. Buildings 29 and 68 are functional in form and construction techniques and are an architectural departure from the original design concept for the base. The buildings were constructed after the initial base development period and reflects a change in national defense needs, availability of construction funds and a reassessment of priorities.

The design and construction of the Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 10) Naval Air Station, San Diego was developed during World War I and expresses both the wartime needs of the Navy and the inception of a military aviation program. By when Building 29 was on the drawing board, the war was over and the urgency surrounding the initial development of the base had receded. Even though the war was over, the building served an important role as one of the three hangars for seaplanes and its use for that purpose was an integral part of base operations. Building 68 was constructed in immediately north of Building 29 on the edge of the bay.

The buildings are sited on the location proposed by Goodhue and Navy architects in the original planning of the base as an appropriate place for seaplane hangars. However, the buildings actually constructed are much simpler in scale and cost of materials than Buildings 1 and 2, which are the original seaplane hangars located in the Naval Air Station, San Diego Historic District. The buildings do continue the base philosophy on location and siting of facilities and water access but on a more limited scale. During the a major dredging operation in San Diego Bay deposited 16 million cubic yards of material on the Island, increasing its size by 620 acres.

Dredging activity on North Island included the bayfront of the Naval Air Station (NAS) North Island extending from the City of Coronado city limits to the mouth of the Bay. This area is all built on fill. The fill on the northern and western bayfronts of North Island was placed in Fill along the southern (seaward side) of North Island was placed in The estuary that once existed between Coronado and North Island was filled in when the aircraft carrier turning basin was dredged and the carrier berthing quay was built.

Small fills were placed along the west side of the Bay entrance by various Navy and Coast Guard projects in and Small dredging projects occurred at some of these same locations in (bay entrance channel), and (Southwest Division World War II brought increased activity to the base including complete renovation of the airfields and the filling of the Spanish Bight for construction of storage buildings, medical facilities, administration, and recreation facilities. The increase in aviation technology, jet aircraft, Korean War, supersonic aircraft and guided missiles called for NASNI to play an increasingly important role in the Naval defense system. In the ship channel and turning basin were dredged to a depth of 42 feet and the quay wall was lengthened to accomodate supercarriers.

The base continues to maintain an active presence today and is currently the largest naval aviation complex on the west coast and the third largest civilian employer in San Diego County (Master Plan Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 11) PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural character: Buildings 29 and 68 are examples of a functional, utilitarian type of structure designed and constructed with post-war priorities and exigencies in mind. The buildings are metal structures located on the edge of San Diego Bay to provide easy access from the bay for seaplane storage. The hangars reflect the trends in utilitarian design philosophy of the and the concepts inherent in the beginning years of aviation technology.

The buildings were designed for storage and repair of seaplanes at a time when the use of seaplanes, particularly in the San Diego area, was seen as a potentially important part of the development of U.S. Navy aviation plans. Seaplane ramps 2, 3, and 4 were constructed as part of the first wave of development of Naval Air Station, San Diego on North Island during World War I. The ramps are associated with Buildings 1 and 2, Seaplane Hangars constructed in in the early years of naval aviation. The ramps provided access to the buildings and were a part of the development of the use of seaplanes and experimentation with this type of aircraft to test its long-term viability. 2.

Condition of fabric: Buildings 29 and 68 have undergone some alterations, but essentially the historic fabric of the structures remains intact. The buildings are large, utilitarian structures that have remained the same, with the exception of lean- to additions on the sides. The Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 are in poor condition and have deteriorated due to lack of use, their location within the intertidal zone and lack of maintenance. B. Description of Exterior 1. Overall dimensions: Building 29 is 151 feet in width, and 136 feet in length. The rectangular building is technically one story in height but the one story is 46 feet tall to the lower edge of the roof line. A tower projection rises an additional 20 feet above the roof line.

A one story lean-to addition is present on the south side of the structure. Building 68 is 223 feet in width, and 122 feet in length. The rectangular building is technically one story in height but the one story is 34 feet tall to the lower edge of the roof line. A one story lean-to addition is present on the each side of the structure. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 12) Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 are connected to each other in one long running strip measuring 168 feet in width and extending 62 feet. 2. Foundations: Buildings 29 and 68 have reinforced concrete slab foundations. The Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 are hewn-stone-paved concrete. 3. Walls: Buildings 29 and 68 have corrugated steel siding for walls. The buildings have been painted a beige color.

The walls have virtually no ornamentation. The buildings take their design elements from the simplicity of the form. The Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 do not have walls or other vertical elements. 4. Structural system, framing: Building 29 is constructed of steel frame construction with full-span steel roof trusses and measures 45' 6" from the ground to the edge of the eave line. The steel columns supporting the structure are 20' O" o.c. and the interior height from the reinforced concrete slab floor to the bottom of the steel truss section is The building originally measured 181 x 154 feet and at an undetermined time, the building was expanded by 40 feet to the west. The building has asphalt roofing with 2x wood decking and 6 x 10 wood purlins at the roof line.

Building 68 has a functional, utilitarian building style with a steel frame. The building has steel trusses which are o.c. and steel columns which are also o.c. The distance from the steel columns to the truss framework is The roof is trussed as a divided span across the long axis. The roof has asphalt covering over steel purlins and a metal fascia. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, bulkheads: Buildings 29 and 68 and the Seaplane Ramps do not have additional elements. 6. Chimneys: Not applicable to these structures. 7. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: On the east and west facades of Building 29, there are full-width, steel- sashed, glazed, rolling doors with outriggers. The doors are placed in 38 Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No.

CA-2652-A (Page 13) foot sections and contain small single entrance doors for easy access. The doors are composed entirely of steel frame windows. Single, metal doors with small windows are placed at irregular intervals around the south sides to provide access into the interior of the structure along the lean-to section. Building 68 contains full-width hangar doors with outriggers. The doors are located on the east and west facades of the structure. The doors are a series of sections and are composed of pairs of tripartite doors. Each door section has a pair of rectangular multilight windows with steel frames placed sided by side in the upper half of the door.

These windows in the doors comprise a continual horizontal band that adds a design element across the east and west facades, repeating window patterns elsewhere on the building. This information is not applicable to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 b. Windows and shutters: Windows are a dominant design element of the Building 29 and are placed in long double horizontal bands that extend the full length of the building on the north and south facades. The rectangular windows are steel sashed and provide a vast amount of light into the interior of the building. A long horizontal band of steel sashed windows has been placed above the doors in the area below the roof on Building 68. Each half of the building has a row of rectangular windows in this area that are centered under peak of the roof line.

The north and south sides of the building have the same window pattern which repeats the same motif as used on the doors and in the area above the doors. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. 8. Roof: a. Shape, covering: Building 29 has asphalt roofing with 2x wood decking and 6 x 10 wood purlins at the roof line. The roof is a high, vaulted roof and is front gabled. Building 68 has a roof that is trussed as a divided span across the long axis and is front gabled. The roof has asphalt covering over steel purlins and a metal fascia. The building has a shed roof over the the door track. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. b. Cornice, eaves: Building 29 has no eave overhang or gutters. Building 68 has a shallow eave overhang.

Metal gutters are present along the edges. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 14) This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: Building 29 has an observation tower addition. The addition projects from the roofline at the northeast corner of the structure and has windows on all sides. A large metal staircase provides access to the structure. The addition is 26 feet by 21 feet and has a hipped roof. Building 68 and the Seaplane Ramps do not have additional elements. C. Description of Interior 1. Floor Plans: a. Basement: Not applicable to the structures. b. First floor: Buildings 29 and 68 have rectangular floor plans. See Figures 1-5 for a complete view of the structures.

Basically the interiors are big, open rooms that were used for storage and repair of seaplanes. The main rooms have no internal divisions and the lean-to sections are divided up into small rooms for office and workshop space. Building 68 has an interior mezzanine area which is constructed of steel beams with a steel plate deck and steel railings. The plate deck is in height. Not applicable to the Seaplane Hangars 2, 3, 4. c. Second floor: Not applicable to the structures. 2. Stairways: Building 29 has an exterior staircase to the tower portion. Building 68 has interior metal staircase to the mezzanine deck area. Not applicable to the Seaplane Hangars 2, 3, 4. 3. Flooring: The flooring in Buildings 29 and 68 is concrete. The flooring in the lean-to portions is asphalt tile.

Not applicable to the Seaplane Hangars 2, 3, 4. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 15) 4. Wall and ceiling finish: The walls and ceilings within Buildings 29 and 68 are corrugated steel left untreated. The walls and ceilings of the lean-to portions have wall board and ceiling tiles which have been painted. Not applicable to the Seaplane Hangars 2, 3, 4. 5. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: On the east and west facades of Building 29, there are full-width, steel- sashed, glazed, rolling doors with outriggers. The doors are placed in 38 foot sections and contain small single entrance doors for easy access. The doors are composed entirely of steel frame windows.

Single, metal doors with small windows are placed at irregular intervals around the south sides to provide access into the interior of the structure along the lean-to section. Interior doors lead from the main room into the lean-to area and consist of single, metal doors of a simple design. Building 68 contains full-width hangar doors with outriggers. The doors are located on the east and west facades of the structure. The doors are a series of sections and are composed of pairs of tripartite doors. Each door section has a pair of rectangular multilight windows with steel frames placed sided by side in the upper half of the door.

These windows in the doors comprise a continual horizontal band that adds a design element across the east and west facades, repeating window patterns elsewhere on the building. Interior doors lead from the main room into the lean-to area and consist of single, metal doors of a simple design. This information is not applicable to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 b. Windows: Windows are a dominant design element of the Building 29 and are placed in long double horizontal bands that extend the full length of the building on the north and south facades. The rectangular windows are steel sashed and provide a vast amount of light into the interior of the building. A long horizontal band of steel sashed windows has been placed above the doors in the area below the roof on Building 68.

Each half of the building has a row of rectangular windows in this area that are centered under peak of the roof line. The north and south sides of the building have the same window pattern which repeats the same motif as used on the doors and in the area above the doors. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 16) 6. Decorative features and trim: These structures were meant to be functional, utilitarian buildings and do not display decorative elements. They are devoid of ornamentation and reflect a strictly functional approach. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. 7.

Hardware: These structures were meant to be functional, utilitarian buildings and do not display decorative elements or hardware. They are devoid of ornamentation and reflect a strictly functional approach. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. 8. Mechanical equipment: a. Heating, air-conditioning, ventilation: The buildings use the large doors at either end for ventilation and cooling of the interiors. Only the small lean-to areas have heat or air conditioning systems. The large open central portions were not heated or cooled, but simply depended on local weather conditions for their temperature regulation. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. b.

Lighting: The lighting systems consist of large banks of lights across the ceiling portion and individual lights in each of the office and shop areas of the lean- to structures. The interior portions were heavily dependent on the natural light that would come through the windows and the large open doors. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. c. Plumbing: Plumbing is minimal within the structures due to the limited nature of the repair activities within the buildings. The lean-to portions contain bathrooms and associated activities and during the and the plumbing was installed in these areas. This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. 9. Original Furnishings: There are no original furnishings within the buildings.

Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 17) This information does not apply to the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4. D. Site: 1. General setting and orientation: Buildings 29 and 68 and Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4 are located at the edge of the bay in an area designed for industrial use and is currently surrounded by paved parking lots, utility buildings, storage areas and no vegetation softens the functional nature of the site. 2. Historic landscape design: Due to the strictly utilitarian and functional nature of this portion of the air station, landscaping was not a priority and would have interfered with the necessary activities of the areas.

Storage and repair areas were needed and flexibility of the area to move equipment, planes and associated activities was essential. No landscaping was part of the area. 3. Outbuildings: This does not apply to these structures. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings Original architectural drawings are on file at the Department of Public Works, Plan Files Department, Naval Station, San Diego located at Street in San Diego; the National Archives in Washington, and Laguna Niguel; and the Command Historian's Office and Plan Files Department at the Construction Battalion Center, Port Hueneme, California. No original plans were found for the Seaplane Ramps 2, 3, 4.

The original plans for Building 29 were drawn in and the plans for Building 68 were drawn in Alteration plans for the two buildings are also present at these locations and include alterations done at various periods during the and Plans of the buildings were drawn in by John Dickinson, a local San Diego architect and are included as Figures B. Early Views The following photographs were obtained from the Plan Files Department at Naval Air Station, North Island (NASNI). Figure 6 - Map of Naval Air Station North Island Figure 7 - NAS North Island, CA. Building 29 in left foreground, obtained from NASNI Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 18) C.

Interviews An oral telephone interview was conducted with Anne Yoklavich, an architectural historian, of Spencer Mason Architects, an architectural firm in Hawaii specializing in military bases and historic preservation. The interview was conducted on February 12, An oral telephone interview was conducted with David Gebhard, an architectural historian and professor at the University of California, Santa Barbara. The interview was conducted on February 12, An oral telephone interview was conducted with Hill Goodspeed, architectural historian and librarian at the National Museum of Naval Aviation in Pensacola, Florida. The interview was conducted on April 5, Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 19) D.

Bibliography American Public Works Association History of Public Works in the United States. Washington, U.S. Government Printing Office. On file at U.S. Navy, Washington Naval Yard Library, Washington, Blumenson, Identifying American Architecture: A Pictorial Guide to Styles and Terms, Nashville: American Association for State and Local History. Brown, Jerold E. Where Eagles Land: Planning and Development of U.S. Army Ai,fields, Greenwood Press: New York. Chambers Consultants and Planners The Cultural Resources of North Island Naval Air Station, North Island and Outlying Landing Field, Imperial Beach, San Diego County, California. San Diego: Naval Air Station, North Island. Christman, F. The Romance of Balboa Park. San Diego: San Diego Historical Society.

Goodhue, The Buildings and Gardens of the San Diego Exposition. San Francisco: Paul Elder and Company. Goodhue, Personal Correspondence to Kirby Smith, Bureau of Yards and Docks, Navy Department, Washington, On file at National Archives, Washington Kennett, L. The First Airwar, New York: Macmillan Inc. Kettner, W. Why It Was Done and How. San Diego: Frye and Smith. Maddex, D. ed. Master Builders. Building Watchers Series, National Trust for Historic Preservation. Washington, The Preservation Press. McAlester, V. and L. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 20) San Diego Aerospace Museum Photo #27 Official U.S. Navy Photograph, North Island. Photo Official U.S. Navy Photograph, North Island.

Photo Official U.S. Navy Photograph, North Island. Photo Official U.S. Navy Photograph, North Island. No Photo Number, Official U.S. Navy Photograph, North Island. Misc. dates Miscellaneous photographs of North Island between Misc. dates Miscellaneous files related to aircraft and technology of aviation. San Diego Historical Society Research Archives (SDHSRA) Misc. Dates North Island Vertical Files. On file at SDHSRA, Balboa Park. Misc. Dates Biographical files - Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue. On file at SDHSRA, Balboa Park. Misc. Dates Architectural files, miscellaneous files. On file at SDHSRA, Balboa Park. Historic photographs of NASNI from TICOR Collection. On file at SDHSRA, Balboa Park. Sitz, A History of U.S. Naval Aviation, Technical Note No. 18, Series of U.S.

Navy Department, Bureau of Aeronautics, Washington, United States Government Printing Office. Sudsburry, E. Jackrabbits to Jets: The History of North Island, San Diego, California. San Diego: Neyenesch Printers. Swanborough, G. and Bowers U.S. Navy Aircraft Since New York: Funk and Wagnalls. Trimble, Wings for the Navy -A History of Naval Aircraft Factory Annapolis: Naval Institute Press. On file at Washington Naval Yard Library, Washington, U.S. Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks Activities of the Bureau of Yards and Docks, Navy Department, World War, Washington, D. C.: Government Printing Office. On file at National Archives, Washington, U.S.

Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks "Drawings Referenced in Design Data, Volume 2." Volume 1 of 2, PI-10, E.75, on file at National Archives, Washington, U.S. Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks. Public Works of the Navy Data Book. Washington, Government Printing Office. On file at Command Historian's Office, Construction Battalion Center, Port Hueneme, CA. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 21) U.S. Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks. Public Works of the Navy Data Book. Washington, Government Printing Office. On file at Command Historian's Office, Construction Battalion Center, Port Hueneme, CA. U.S. Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks. Public Works of the Navy Data Book. Washington, Government Printing Office.

On file at Command Historian's Office, Construction Battalion Center, Port Hueneme, CA. U.S. Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks General Correspondence, Shore Establishment. Record Group 71. On file at National Archives, Washington, U.S. Navy, Naval Air Systems Command U.S. Naval Aviation, Prepared at direction of Deputy Chief of Naval Operations (Air Warfare) and Command. Washington, U.S. Government Printing Office. U.S. Navy, Eleventh Naval Distric Naval Shore Establishments, General Correspondence of the Commandant, San Diego. Record Group On file at National Archives, Washington, U.S. Navy, Naval Air Station, North Island Misc. Dates Building Files, including original building plans, historic photographs, annual condition maps and miscellaneous documentation.

On file in Plan Files Department and Natural Resources Office, Staff Civil Engineer's Office, Naval Air Station North Island. U.S. Navy, NA VFACENGCOM Annual reports of Expenditures and Operations under Appropriations for the Bureau of Yards and Docks. Records on file at Command Historian's Office, Construction Battalion Center, Port Hueneme, CA. U.S. Navy, Naval Station, San Diego Misc. Dates Original Building Plans on file at Plan Files Department, Naval Station, San Diego, Street. U.S. Navy, WESTDIV Base Exterior Architecture Plan Naval Air Station North Island San Diego, California, Western Division, Naval Facilities Engineering Command, San Bruno, California. U.S. Navy,

Westdiv U.s

Navo[ Hospital Complex. Balboa Park, through Historic American Buildings Survey. Compiled by William Rutlidge. San Bruno, CA: WESTDIV. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 22) Williamson and Watts The Architectural Historical Significance of Buildings at Naval Air Station North Island San Diego California. Prepared for Naval Air Station North Island. On file at Naval Air Station North Island. Yatsko, A. 1990a National Register forms for Naval Air Station, San Diego Historic District. On file at Naval Air Station North Island, Natural Resources Office. Yatsko, A. National Register forms for U.S. Army Rockwell Field Historic District. On file at Naval Air Station North Island, Natural Resources Office. E.

Likely Sources Not Yet Investigated All likely sources were investigated over the course of the preparation of the Environmental Impact Statement and the HABS study. Other potential sources would be U.S. Naval personnel or other military personnel who had been involved in the early years of military aviation or personnel who had served on the various aviation oriented military bases. PART IV. PROJECT INFORMATION The Department of the Navy has prepared a Final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) to analyze homeport facilities for a NIMITZ class aircraft carrier in the San Diego area in southern California.

NIMITZ class carriers are part of the new, more modem fleet of deep-draft ships powered by nuclear energy and are referred to as This action was undertaken to comply with the Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) directive from Congress to close Naval Air Station (NAS) Alameda, and to relocate ships currently homeported there to fleet concentrations in San Diego and the Pacific Northwest. The proposed action is scheduled to start in and the EIS evaluated the potential effects of the proposed dredging, infrastructure, and facilities associated with the homeporting of one As part of the proposed homeporting project, Buildings 29 and 68 and Seaplane Ramps 2, 3 and 4 will be demolished to allow for the construction of new porting facilities.

During the process of evaluation completed as part of the EIS, the buildings were determined by the California State Historic Preservation Office to be eligible for nomination to the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion A. A Memorandum of Agreement was signed in July between the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the U.S. Navy, and the California State Historic Preservation Officer for mitigation of impacts to the structures to be demolished. The HABS research and documentation were prepared in August-October by Kathleen A. Crawford, Senior Historian, Ogden Environmental and Energy Services, Inc.

Ogden is located at Morehouse Drive, San Diego, California The exterior and interior photographs, and all ground/bay-level photographs were taken and processed by Christopher Wray, Evans Place, Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 23) La Mesa, California in August-September Mr. Wray is a photographic consultant to Ogden. The historic era photographs were obtained from the San Diego Aerospace Museum Archives, Balboa Park, San Diego, California and the historic records of the Natural Resources Office of the Staff Civil Engineer's Office and the Plan Files Department, Naval Air Station, North Island.

Aerial photographs and an aerial video were taken in August by Petty Officer David Weideman with the assistance of Chief Petty Officer Joseph and the Fleet Imaging Department at Naval Air Station, North Island. Christopher Wray processed the photographs taken by Petty Officer Weideman and the Fleet Imaging Department. Direction and coordination of the HABS study was provided by Andrew Yatsko, Staff Archaeologist, Natural Resources Office, Staff Civil Engineer (18NI) NAS North Island and Robert Hexom, Environmental Planner, Code Southwest Division, Naval Facilities Engineering Command, San Diego, California. Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No.

CA-2652-A (Page 24) SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIAL FIGURES 1-7 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 25) i ~ z ,-f .. <( _J CL ~ 0:: LLI I- ~ w ~ 0 w LL t- z ~ 0 ~ <( > 0 a: LLI Cf) CD 0 C ca . a: 0 0) .2 C\I LI. 0) .. C Cl) - 0) ,:, C :::cca m Cl) C .! C. ca Q) u, l ,J; ( -',,;i ~-- ,'i: ,o-,z.z; --- ,j. ~ WEST ELEVATIOt-1 .. +- r' li!:~-; ,, ' ~ Ji 'j 'i I ~ ~ Cl) e. z~ ? Cl) ns >i:z. O PARTIAL EAST _f:l,J;VATION NORTH 1::LEVATION ~-- -~. ~ ~ ~z NO >& ~ _p. Cl) (I) . w ,_:I: Im ffil lffi ~ e; SOUTH ..

ELEVA_TION PARTIAL EAST ELEVATION N en ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - FIG UR~ Building 29 Seaplane Hanger Building Elevation 2 , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 27) r-1 i ~ i ! ;:) I i 0, .I t:i 0 w u. ~ ~ C 0 ;: as ~ jjj Cl C a, - (\I ::2 CI- - "C ...ID = Cl) Cl ID C as Cl) C as C. as Cl) en z 0 1- () w Cl) ,SI + - - - - ~ pool( 71&'(:JIC: $1/l'PMTFKMl#i ~...fo-{JI,;- - LAPDl1t i I ~ C0/1.ltUt.lfTD,) Ir I I :::::'::::::::q:_::_A fi' 1 1 t SL/Dll'ti> DOOR, ! EAST ELEVAl!QN WEST SIMILAR I A-SPHIILT Ill 1"' ' ,,. ' u ,,::j.-1,I :1 m mmJ m1r -- -P)()II. TRIK!K 1 __, S<JPl'OAT,,._ f.looR. Tlft,e.K.

.': S_OUTH fk_I VATION z ~ ea Clle:_ ~~ nm1 ioo oottttttttttftfflfflft (i~ ea. I 0 N ::S fct0a 8:z NO NQB_l~E VA TION ~ _p. Cll '!f 0 ~rJ.t;ltU~T61>4't"TAt.. . ~- .; 6/o,N/i, /'RAl'llNr,;, ~ ;: -:;rem...FM1t1t!~& ;- . I ~ et~~~~ [ ~ ~ JT= -~ ca,u..t1NS eo .i, ci,c. ~~~ -~ 1~ ~ 0 JJ (IQ ,. Ill 111 l c - -- 111 "' 0 ~ SECTION ~ N r,, 00 FEET '-" FIGURE Building 68 Seaplane Hanger Building Elevation and Section 4 Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 29) 10 - ,io-:;,..__ - - ___ ,,_ _______to'.o ~ . -~- -~ ,,:5.:,c'.o _ _Ee,'-c!'.o~ ----+--t.O':!''' 2 !i "' - J ., I~ I ) J C ca ii: co .2 CO LL IC> ... t C _IC> G) "0 C .. ..

=:l :cca \ m G> C ca aca G) en 474 473 J e,aco~.~?~-~1~241---- BUILDINGS Q_ --o 1 400 0 400 800 I "- I t ~~ ~~ SKETCH MAP (i~ NAVAL AIR STATION, SAN DIEGO, HISTORIC DISTRICT ~~ Ng Naval Air Station, North Island San Diego, California I ~z NO District Boundary >e- ~ Contributing Buildings/Structures .., - ~ Non-contributing Buildings/Structures p.. Cl) ~ G San Diego Bay Shoreline . f 446 ' ._. I ~f (Jq (Jq G f:; ~ Cll -- s FIGURE Naval Air Station, San Diego Historic District 6 Naval Air Station North Island, Seaplane Hangars . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - HABS No. CA-2652-A (Page 31) - "C C: ... 0 C') ~ 0 u. ~ (I) C: 0) C\I C') C: =s co C\I~ C\I ,.. 0) <i. (.) "C C: ('0 en .t: t:: 0 z Cl) z

In context

San Diego, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Diego County, California 602 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Diego

24 of 114 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Diego building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
U.S. Naval HospitalHABS CAL,37-SANDI,27-28,449 words
Chollas Heights Naval Radio Transmitting FacilityHAER CAL,37-SANDI,31-17,945 words
Torrey Pines LodgeHABS CA-286811,722 words
Hotel San DiegoHABS CA-27817,976 words
Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental PropertyHABS CA-29637,639 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34A-7,163 words
Balboa ParkHABS CAL,37-SANDI,16D-6,909 words
The George White and Anna Gunn Marston HouseHALS CA-1316,416 words
Fort RosecransHABS CAL,37-SANDI,29-A-5,753 words
United States Custom House & Inspection StationHABS CA-28974,992 words
Savage Tire FactoryHAER CAL,37-SANDI,28-4,560 words
Mount Carmel RanchHABS CA-28944,165 words
Whaley HouseHABS CAL,37-OLTO,5-4,093 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34C-3,905 words
Point Loma Lighthouse No. 355HABS CAL,37-POLO,1-3,778 words
CALTRANS District 11 Maintenance StationHABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-3,389 words
George W. Marston HouseHABS CAL,37-SANDI,10-3,343 words
Melville Klauber HouseHABS CAL,37-SANDI,12-3,246 words
Santa Fe Railroad StationHABS CAL,37-SANDI,22-3,171 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34B-3,080 words
Stingaree BordelloHABS CAL,37-SANDI,25-2,999 words
U.S. Naval HospitalHABS CAL,37-SANDI,27-A-2,979 words
I. O. O. F. BuildingHABS CAL,37-SANDI,5-2,769 words
Mission San Diego de AlcalaHALS CA-812,750 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.