Built in with a southern addition built in the Hotel San Diego is listed as the San Diego Historical Site No. The building receives its significance in helping to establish the urban fabric of a growing city as well as its association with developer John D. Spreckels and architect Harrison Albright. The Hotel San Diego was the third building erected by John D. Spreckels on the south side of Broadway. This hotel was designed by architect Harrison Albright to match the height and stately simplicity of his Union Building (now demolished) and the Spreckels Office Building and Theatre, which was built shortly after completion of the hotel. The Hotel San Diego was designed in the same "contemporary" Chicago style as the Union Building and the Spreckels Office Building and Theatre.
The Hotel is also significant for its association with the burst of development in conjunction with the Panama California International Exposition in This building, with its style and size, was part of an uniform skyline south of Broadway and is thus important for its part in establishing downtown San Diego's urban fabric. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of erection: with a addition. 2. Architect: Harrison Albright. 3. Original and subsequent owners: References to the Chain of Title to the land upon which the structure stands are in the Office of the Recorder County Clerk, County of San Diego, San Diego, California. Numerous ownerships. Deed, January 8, recorded in Book p. John W. Heckert to John D. Spreckels, Jr.
Deed, March 7, recorded in Book p. John D. and Lillie C. Spreckels to Spreckels-Hannam Building Company. Deed, May, 25, recorded in Book p. Spreckels-Hannam Building Company to J.D and A.B Spreckels Securities Company. Deed, June 24, File No. of Original Records, and A.B. Spreckels Company to San Diego Hotel Co. Inc. Deed, February 18, File No. Hotel San Diego Inc. to Herman and Blance Miller, M. Bert and Mae Fisher, Morris and Freida Steinbaum, and Albert Steinbaum. Deed, December 31, File No. San Diego composed of Albert W. Seeberger, Johnson, E Tyson, and A.L. to San Diego Hotel, a partnership composed of Albert W. Seeberger and Hobart Hotel Corporation. Deed, September 6, File No. Hotel San Diego to Jack R. Young and Associates, Inc. Deed, April 15, File No.
California General Mortgage to San Diego Federal Savings and Loan Association. Deed, April 30, File No. San Diego Federal Savings and Loan Association to George Tate. Deed, May 2, File No. George Tate to Title Insurance and Trust Company under Holding Agreement No. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 3) Deed, October 1, File No. Title Insurance and Trust Company under Holding Agreement No. 330 to George Tate and Vincent Miranda. 4. Builder, contractor, supplier: Not known. 5. Original plans and construction: Original architectural or structural plans have not been located. 6. Alterations and additions: Annex addition. The Annex closely matches the original building's height, detailing, and methods of construction. B.
Historical Context The Hotel San Diego was originally completed in in anticipation of the Panama California International Exposition in Balboa Park as well as part of John D. Spreckels' plans in developing Broadway as a major urban thoroughfare. 1 The 275 room hotel was designed by Los Angeles architect Harrison Albright and commissioned by John D. Spreckels. Typical of other metropolitan cities, San Diego's downtown area was changing from primarily residential to commercial. The city's growth in population and industry required the expansion of business and commercial districts in downtown. In addition, transportation amenities, such as streetcars and automobiles, enabled residents to move to the suburbs where inexpensive homes could be purchased. John D.
Spreckels wanted to capitalize on the city's change. Spreckels had purchased all of the lots on the south side of "D" Street --- at the foot of which he had built his great wharf. He was determined to turn "D" Street into the model thoroughfare of a major city and he successfully enticed the City fathers into renaming his street "Broadway" in Spreckels built the Union Building, Spreckels Theater, the Hotel San Diego, and the Street Railway. 2 Spreckels hired architect Harrison Albright to build the first reinforced concrete structure, the Union Building, which occupied an entire block on Broadway. The building hosted several offices of many of his local companies. It also housed rentable office space.
The erection of the Union Building inspired other modern "sky-scrapers" to be built including the Hotel San Diego. The Hotel was located further west on Broadway and was considered a "splendid first-class building of the same height and stately simplicity of architecture as the Union Building.';i Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks Gloria Swanson, Cecil B. DeMill, the Keystone Cops, Dorothy Lamour, Mable Norman, and Don Knotts have been among the famous guests of the 1 The Hotel San Diego is one of four buildings on Broadway that was commissioned by Spreckels. 2 San Diego Historical Society. "Rufus Choate: A Taped Interview of Reminiscences." The Journal of San Diego History.
Volume 11, Number 3 (June Spreckels was doing so much work in San Diego that he decided to make his home in nearby Coronado across from the Hotel del Coronado. 3 City of San Diego. City of San Diego Historical Site Board Register. April 27, HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 4) Hotel San Diego. 4 Over the years the Hotel San Diego has been home to many San Diego Civic Groups as a meeting place. Tenants have included Oldsmobile and San Diego's first television station, (Channel 8). began broadcasting from studios in the basement of the Hotel San Diego on May 16, The ceremonial "switch" was thrown by Mayor Harley Knox in the Hotel's Ballroom and San Diego television viewers watched as city dignitaries and businessmen celebrated the beginning of television broadcasting in San Diego.
Several well known personalities were early broadcasters for Channel 8 including Harold Keen and weathergirl Racquel Welch. 5 The Hotel San Diego was also a second home to many Navy personnel who often dined in the coffee shops and used the meeting rooms and locker clubs.6 By the mid the county needed additional courtroom and office space and the San Diego County Board of Supervisors leased the second and third floors of the Hotel San Diego and remodeled it into ten courtrooms with offices for the Judges. Heggland, the county's Chief Administrative Officer, recommended purchase of the Hotel for The reason for the needed courtrooms and offices was that the Courthouse, then under construction, was already too small.
On October 17, the Board of Supervisors decided not to buy the Hotel, but failed to produce an alternate solution to the Court space problem. In December, the Board of Supervisors toured the leased spaces in the Hotel and again studied suggestions to buy the Hotel. 7 In February the Board authorized Heggland to negotiate the purchase of the Hotel with owner Bert Fisher.
The following week a committee of lawyers headed by Attorney Thomas Whelan sent a telegram to the Board of Supervisors suggesting that they "withhold approval of purchase of Hotel San Diego until after Grand Jury investigation." The argument by Whelan was the that the Hotel was worth less than the new asking price of and that it would cost the County more than to purchase the building and remodel it for use as courtrooms and offices. In March Attorney Whelan won a temporary restraining order to prevent the purchase.
The County Chief Administrative Officer and the Board of Supervisors vacillated on various options for a period of time and on March 5, they voted to lease additional space in the Hotel to meet their needs until when both the new Courthouse, still under construction, and the planned Courthouse Annex would be finished. In the building was purchased by Jack R. Young, who started a half-million dollar remodel, but before the work could be completed the owner was forced into bankruptcy. The building was 4 Ibid. 5 Ibid. 6 Interview with Vonn Marie May, local preservationist. 7 City of San Diego. City of San Diego Historical Site Registration. April 27, HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No.
CA-2781 (Page 5) again sold in 8 Portions of the movie "Traffic" were filmed in the hotel, mostly in the fifth floor "Peninsula" room. The movie was nominated for Best Picture and went on to receive four (4) Academy Awards including best director and best supporting actor. Development of Urban San Diego and John D. Spreckels Alonzo Horton laid out a compact city near the waterfront in the Horton insured the development of San Diego along the axis of Fifth and H (Market Street) by building a wharf at the foot of Fifth Street, and creating Market as the widest thoroughfare in the city plan. John D. Spreckels, more than any other single individual, changed all that. His visionary leadership helped put San Diego on the map of national and international commerce.
According to the City of San Diego's local register nomination, Mr. Spreckels ' influence, backed by his heavy investments at a time when the future of the city was none too bright, kept the city on the path ofprogress in early days of dashed hopes, and when the tide of prosperity began to rise, made that path many degrees smoother and easier. There are not many other communities in the United States which have that good fortune, and as the years have gone on --- more than thirty have passed since he came to San Diego --- San Diego has come to real appreciation ofwhat he has done. 9 In addition, John D. Spreckels dominated the political and financial life of the city.
He owned and operated the Hotel del Coronado, North Island, San Diego-Coronado Ferry System, San Diego & Arizona Railway, San Diego Electric Railway, Union-Tribune Publishing Company, Belmont Park in Mission Beach, Hotel San Diego, the Spreckels Building and Theater, and the John D. Spreckels Building. John D. Spreckels first came to San Diego on a visit in The wealthy son of "Sugar King" Claus Spreckels, he obtained a franchise from City officials in to build a wharf at the foot of D Street. 10 This provided space for the Spreckels Brothers Steamship line and also the much needed coal bunkers for the Santa Fe Railroad.
During the bust that followed the boom of Spreckels became the savior of San Diego's economy by extending credit to the Santa Fe Railroad so that it could continue to operate, and to the real estate developers, Babcock and Story, so that the Hotel del Coronado could be completed in In the Spreckels became the sole owner of the Hotel del Coronado, most of Coronado, and all of North Island." Spreckels bought the San Diego Union, and later the Evening Tribune, and acquired the transit system, the water system, and various oil, rubber, and lumber companies. 8 Ibid. 9 City of San Diego. City of San Diego Historical Site Registration. April 27, 10 D Street was renamed Broadway in 11 North Island was sold to the Federal government for during World War I. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No.
CA-2781 (Page 6) Spreckels managed his San Diego holdings from San Francisco until when he and his family left there after the earthquake and settled permanently in Coronado. 12 Spreckels began to develop his San Diego investments in earnest. He intended that Broadway should become the main thoroughfare of the city, and he bought all of the lots on the south side of "D" Street between the Santa Fe tracks and the Plaza. Between and Spreckels commissioned a series of buildings along "D" Street: Union Building (to house his newspaper and other projects), Spreckels Theatre Building, and the Hotel San Diego. The Hotel San Diego resembles the Spreckels Theatre building two blocks away, but it is more modest in its scale and ornamentation.
In the Golden West Hotel was built on Fourth and G Street. At the time of his death in Spreckels' largest project, the highrise Bank of America Building at Sixth and Broadway, was under construction. For the Exposition, Spreckels commissioned Harrison Albright to design the Spreckels Organ Pavilion, the largest outdoor organ in the world. His critics said that he had made San Diego in to a "one-man town," and that he controlled its political and economic life. Indeed, at one time it was estimated that Spreckels' various interests were responsible for more than 10% of the property tax revenues in San Diego.
Important as all these business projects were to the development of San Diego, Spreckels' most significant influence on the urban growth of the city lay in his control of transportation facilities. To spur transcontinental traffic to San Diego, and to provide more business for Spreckels' overseas steamship line, he revived the idea of a direct rail connection to the Mississippi Valley via Arizona. Spreckels purchased the San Diego, Arizona and Eastern Railroad, and acting as agent for the Southern Pacific Railroad, pushed through the line from San Diego to El Centro. The construction, begun in and was not completed until because of the mammoth engineering problems encountered in blasting tunnels and building trestles in the spectacular Carrizo Gorge.
Meantime, within the city of San Diego, Spreckels developed the local transit system, which he had acquired in He was granted a 50-year franchise from the City, against considerable opposition, and proceeded to electrify, extend, and reroute the streetcar lines. When one recalls that it was not until after that automobiles were widely used, it became clear how much influence street car routes had on patterns of residential and commercial development. Logan Heights, Sherman Heights, Golden Hills, Middletown, and Florence Heights, which had been the earliest "suburbs" of New San Diego, declined in popularity as the extension of streetcar lines provided easier access to Mission Hills, Kensington, Loma Portal, Mission Beach, and La Jolla.
Spreckels lured residents and visitors to these outlying suburban areas by building amusement parks in Mission Beach and Mission Hills, and developing "Ramona's Marriage Place" in Old Town.13 12 Cynthia B. Malinick. "Classiciscm and Concrete: Harrison Albright's Architectural Contributions to Coronado." The Journal of San Diego History. 43 (Spring 79. Harrison Albright designed Spreckels' Coronado home across from the Hotel del Coronado as well as a smaller beach house at the oceanfront located a short distance from the Hotel on Ocean Boulevard. The main house was constructed of reinforced concrete and according to the Union, was "one of the finest homes in Southern California." 13 "Ramona's Marriage Place" is also known as Casa Estudillo. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No.
CA-2781 (Page 7) Spreckels often remarked that "transportation determines the flow of population." His influence on the construction of buildings on Broadway and the extension and rerouting of streetcar lines did much to change the direction of San Diego's urban and suburban development. Fifth Avenue, south of Broadway to Horton's wharf, the previous main street of San Diego along which businesses were located, declined in importance as Spreckels' buildings along Broadway shifted commercial, office, and hotel space to Broadway, and residential development towards the new suburbs north and east of San Diego.
The extension of San Diego into its suburban outreaches, a process which began at the tum of the century, was sharply accelerated after World War II and has continued unabated until the present time. John D. Spreckels died in San Diego on June 7, His biographer, Austin Adams, called him "one of America's few great Empire Builders who invested millions to tum a struggling, bankrupt village into the beautiful and cosmopolitan city San Diego is today." 14 Harrison Albright Harrison Albright was born on May 17, to Joseph and Louise Albright in Shoemakertown, Pennsylvania.
He began his career, following his formal schooling, working as a fledgling architect apprentice for several years prior to establishing his own Philadelphia office in 15 In he moved to West Virginia and eventually earned the appointment of State Architect. While serving as State Architect, he designed one of his most important West Virginia structures, the Capitol Annex as well as the West Baden Springs Hotel in Indiana in 16 In the architect and his family moved to Los Angeles, California. There Albright established himself while designing the first reinforced concrete building erected in Southern California, the Laughlin Annex. 17 "With no apparent training in structural engineering, 14 San Diego Historical Society, "John D. Spreckels San Diego Biographies. 15 Malinick, 77.
16 The West Baden Springs Hotel featured a six-story domed atrium (the largest clear-span dome in the world until the Astrodome was built in 700 rooms, and natural mineral springs used for bathing and drinking. Lee Wiley Sinclair, owner, resolved to build the fireproof hotel within a year. Five hundred workers labored for 270 days to complete the hotel. Albright had agreed to forfeit a day for every day construction continued over 200 days. The building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and a National Historic Landmark 17 Jack Welch, "The Homer Laughlin China Company History." http://www.hlchina.com/ historybyJackWelch.htm. Homer Laughlin was the co-founder of Homer Laughlin China Company in ca. in Ohio. The company was one of the first whiteware plants in America.
By Homer Laughlin was ready to remove himself from the business which made him wealthy. The company was bought out by William Wells and Louis Arron in and is still in operation today. Laughlin had invested in real estate in Los Angeles and wanted to spend his last days developing the city. He is known for the Laughlin building and the Laughlin Theater in Los Angeles. The Laughlin Annex building contains storage space for the downtown Los Angeles Public Library. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 8) remarkably, Harrison Albright soon became popular for his commercial design utilizing reinforced concrete." 18 Albright's work eventually caught the eye of sugar magnate John D.
Spreckels.19 Albright designed three of Spreckels' Broadway buildings, including Hotel San Diego, as well as the Spreckels' residential home and beach home in Coronado, the Coronado Bank Building, and Public Library. 20 Albright also designed the U.S. Grant Hotel, the Organ Pavilion in Balboa Park, as well as several residential homes. John Lloyd Wright, second son of architect Frank Lloyd Wright and an employee of Albright's firm, designed the Golden West Hotel, a hotel for working people in downtown San Diego, which is another link in the long chain of Spreckels enterprises. 21 A relationship of mutual respect between Spreckels and Albright lasted nearly twenty years.
Albright recalled Spreckels as a "'sagacious business [man]' who was fully convinced of the merits of concrete construction."22 Albright's innovative use ofreinforced concrete early in the region's development helped to established Albright as one of the premier Southern California architects of his time. 23 Albright retired in and died in leaving behind a legacy in the built environment. Buildings designed by Harrison Albright include: 24 Abend-Rich House, Ogontz, Philadelphia, PA Charleston Capitol Annex, ca. Charleston, WV Power Plant, Columbus, IN West Baden Springs Hotel, French Lick, IN 18Malinick, 79. Reinforced concrete is defined as concreted embedded with steel bars of the proper form and size and in the proper position for the purpose ofresisting tensile stresses.
19Spreckels favored reinforced concrete construction because of his experience as a resident during the San Francisco earthquake. 20Spreckels' home on Orange Avenue has been rehabilitated into the Glorietta Bay Inn. The Coronado Bank Building is currently the home for the Coronado Historical Association and Coronado Visitor's Center. 21 Richard Amero. "The Spreckels Organ Pavilion in Balboa Park." Balboa Park, Spreckels Organ Pavilion. San Diego: San Diego Historical Society, and Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA. "Balboa Park Organ Pavilion Electrical System Upgrade." July "Originally built for the Panama California Exposition, the Organ Pavilion is a contributing building to the Balboa Park National Historic Landmark District.
The Spreckels organ is believed to be the largest outdoor organ in the world with pipes ranging in size from 6 inches to over 32 feet high. The Organ Pavilion still hosts free public concerts on a regular basis." 22 Malinick, 79. Four of Albright's buildings are listed on the National Register of Historic Places. These are: Adams 23 School, Maricopa County, AZ; U.S. Grant, San Diego, CA; Spreckels Office and Theatre Building, San Diego, CA; and the West Baden Springs Hotel, French Lick, IN. 24Malinick, And "On the History of the Santa Fe Freight Depot, Los Angeles." HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 9) Waldo Hotel, Clarksburg, WV U.S.
Grant Hotel, San Diego, CA25 Passenger Station, Los Angeles, CA (demolished) Los Angeles Freight Depot, Los Angeles, CA (demolished) 26 Laughlin Annex, Los Angeles, CA (first reinforced concrete building in Southern California) Consolidated Realty Building, Los Angeles, CA Spreckels Residence, Coronado, CA Coronado Public Library, Coronado, CA Spreckels Beach House, Coronado, CA Titus Residence, Coronado (demolished The Union Office Building, San Diego, CA (demolished) Spreckels Theatre Building, San Diego, CA Timken Building, ca.1912, San Diego, CA Hotel San Diego, San Diego, CA Golden West Hotel, John Lloyd Wright and Harrison Albright, San Diego, CA Organ Pavilion, Balboa Park, San Diego, CA Coronado Bank Building, Coronado, CA 25The U.S.
Grant Hotel was built in and is located across from the Horton Plaza Park on Broadway in downtown San Diego. 26 "On the History of the Santa Fe Freight Depot, Los Angeles." http://www.sairc.edu/about/ freightyard.htrnl. The former reinforced concrete Freight Depot was located south of the La Grande passenger depot in Los Angeles. The Freight Depot was a replacement for the previous freight depot that had been destroyed by fire. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 10) PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement: 1. Architectural character: The building was designed in the style of Architect Louis Sullivan's "Chicago School of Architecture." 2. Condition of fabric: Exterior: Fair to good; Interior: Poor. B. Description of Exterior: 1.
Overall Dimensions: The structure extends the entire two hundred foot length of Broadway between Union Street and State Street. The original Hotel was eighty feet deep on the State Street side and one hundred feet deep on the Union Street side. The Annex on the west side extended the State Street facade an additional one hundred feet. The Hotel San Diego is six stories high with full basement that extends below the sidewalks. The ground floor is nearly two stories high with a partial mezzanine. The Broadway elevation is divided into two wings at the east and west corners of the block with a deep forty foot wide light well recess at the center. The recess provided light and ventilation into guest rooms as well as space for skylights over the lobby and reception area.
The west facade is approximately square. The upper floors are flanked with wide flat vertical columns supporting a classical projecting cornice at the roof decorated with a regular series of large and small <lentils. The Annex at the southwest corner of the hotel was added in This Annex provided seventy additional rooms and a large banquet facility in the basement. A large rooftop neon sign at the northeast corner was added in ca.1935 and remains in The vertical blade sign on the northwest corner was added in ca.1960. 27 Several surface- mounted downspouts have been added as well as several flagpoles above the main entry. The Hotel San Diego has been refurbished and renovated several times. The west-facing facade of the Annex is in good condition.
The upper facade is unchanged and the street level windows and detailing are damaged, but close to their original appearance. The lower facade varies from the design with its use of faux cut-stone walls and arch-topped, divided-lite casement windows. There are small concrete medallions and keystones that are original and add formality to the Annex facade. An original postcard from the shows a rendered one-story rooftop extension to the Annex that was never built. The Hotel San Diego's blade sign helped to continue the urban feel along with the signs on the Armed 27 Forces YMCA Building, the Pickwick Hotel, and the Spreckels Theatre Office Building along Broadway. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 11) 2. Foundations: The Hotel San Diego has a concrete foundation. 3.
Walls: The Hotel San Diego was one of the first hotels in San Diego containing modern amenities. 28 At the time of its construction, the hotel was one of the largest reinforced concrete buildings in California. Unfortunately, the original architectural or structural plans have not been found. The structure is essentially concrete post and beam construction with concrete floor slabs and hollow clay tile exterior in-fill walls. The building remains essentially intact with the exception of various remodels of first floor commercial spaces over the years. 4. Structural system, framing: The structural system of the Hotel San Diego consists of a reinforced, non-ductile concrete frame in-filled with non-bearing hollow clay tile The building is finished in stucco.
Exterior ornamentation, such as the cornice and entry parapet, is constructed out of cast-in-place concrete. The interior is divided by wood stud and plaster partitions with structural concrete columns spaced in a grid pattern. The building has six stories plus a basement and partial mezzanine. There are several setbacks for light wells above the mezzanine level that allow for natural light and ventilation into the guest rooms. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, bulkheads: None. 6. Chimneys: None. 7. Openings: a. Doorways and doors The only historic street level features remaining on Broadway appear to be the main entry double door and side lites that open into the hotel lobby. The cast-iron glass doors with bronze details can be seen in a ca.1935 photograph.
The primary missing feature at the main, north entry of the Hotel San Diego is the metal and glass entry canopy/marquee. The canopy included signage for the hotel, was lighted internally and supported by two diagonal chains. Historic photographs indicate that a matching canopy occurred above the west entry for the Annex. The two original entry canopies have been replaced with simple, undecorated overhangs. The west canopy may contain the frame and diagonal supports of the original canopy. 28 Hotel San Diego Advertising Postcard, HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 12) The concrete ornamentation above the main (north) entry includes a shield flanked by two decorative brackets and a pair of oversized tassels. The ornamentation helped to highlight the main entrance of the Hotel San Diego.
The ornamentation is extant behind the metal facade panels and appears to be in good condition. There is a raised, recessed entry with gray marble stairs and walls in the center of the Annex, facing State Street. The doors are wood with a fanlight transom window above and the ceiling is a pendentive dome. An entry canopy that originally extended over the sidewalk has been replaced and is described in further detail below. The two southern fanlights above the street level windows have been covered with stucco. b. Windows The three main street-facing facades are penetrated by large, double-hung wood windows. The windows consist of large, uninterrupted panes and they are usually grouped in sets of three.
The majority of the windows are still operable and many have air conditioning units mounted on the sill below the lower sash. In contrast, the majority of the storefront windows and doors at the street and mezzanine levels are missing. Severe alterations to the street level storefronts have eliminated the historic windows and doors below the second floor. Historic photographs show very large display windows along the sidewalk and large, three-part transom windows at the mezzanine level. The corners of the building at either end of the north elevation were originally cut back at a 45-degree angle at the street level. These locations have also been modified, with the east recess being in-filled by a storefront.
In the storefronts and first floor windows were covered over with plywood panels to prevent vandalism and access by vagrants. The south elevation and the east elevation of the Annex are simple, flat facades with no ornamentation and unadorned window openings. The corner windows are clean punctuations and the windows between the corners are grouped between the columns in three sets of three windows to give the hotel a simple modern appearance. The east (Union Street) elevation has four sets of window groupings between the corner windows. At the top floor there is an incised rectangular panel between each set of windows and at the corners. Below the window groups on the third, fourth, and fifth floors each spandrel panel has three simple rectangular relief designs.
New tenants and changes in architectural fashion resulted in the original wood-framed storefront windows being replaced by aluminum storefronts and larger signage. In addition, painted lava rock (ca. and stone tiles clad the columns at the facade and cover the bulkheads below the display windows. Some of the mezzanine windows are in place behind the grid of facade panels and were simply walled-over and concealed. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 13) The sidewalks along State, Union, and Broadway extend over portions of the basement and have prismatic glass lites imbedded into the concrete sidewalk slabs to provide natural light into the basement. The condition of the glass block paving is poor and temporary shoring has been installed for safety reasons. 8. Roof: a.
The roof shape is flat with shallow slopes and crickets to perimeter roof drains. The roofing is typical built-up roofing with a cap sheet. The decorative upper cornice has an integral gutter that diverts water back to the main roof via scuppers. The roofing has been replaced several times over the years and the roof is in fair to poor condition. Several large pieces of mechanical equipment are located on the roof of the hotel, including grease vents for ground floor restaurants and two large water tanks. The roofs at the bottom of the light wells also are used for mechanical equipment. b. Cornice, eaves Above the mezzanine level, the exterior of the Hotel San Diego looks much as it did in the historic period.
Just below the sixth floor parapet at the roof line, a decorative concrete cornice is located along the east, north, and west main facades of the building. The deep cornice consists of simple, geometric bracket and <lentil motifs. Visual surveys of the cornice indicate that it is in fair condition, with some spalling and cracking. Small portions of the upper cornice have been cut away or otherwise altered, but the cornice is significantly intact. There are secondary cornices at the fifth and mezzanine levels that are simple, extruded moldings.
The fifth floor cornice is extant and visible, but the lower mezzanine cornice has been concealed behind a metal panel facade that is part of a more recent storefront facade, dating back to the The condition of the lower cornice along the north and east sides is unknown. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers None. C. Description of Interior: 1. Floor Plans The general layout of the hotel is as follows: The ground level consists of a main entrance on Broadway which leads into a public lobby. A central stair and bank of two elevators are at the back wall of the lobby.
The large, double-height lobby has undergone many significant changes since its original completion in Historic photographs obtained from the San Diego Historical Society's Photograph Collection indicate that there were two different designs for the lobby in ca.1915 and ca.193 5. The oldest known design of the lobby had a streamlined, classical appearance using sturdy materials such as marble and tile. The front desk was the same pale gray marble that is found on the HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 14) main stairs and as the wall bases in the ground floor rooms. The remainder of the original building has ground floor spaces for various commercial and retail uses that have been altered and display almost no original, historic fabric.
Most of the storefronts facing Broadway and Union Street have undergone dozens of remodels and are vacant in The northwest comer was the home of a Burger King fast food franchise. Two small retail spaces were added on either side of the main entry, reducing the size of the lobby. When the Annex was added in the southwest comer of the lobby was modified to provide a connection between the two wings. The ground floor of the Annex portion once housed assembly and banquet spaces and has been heavily remodeled. The east side of the Annex was used for hotel rooms. The entire first floor is vacant and in disrepair. The Hotel San Diego has a partial mezzanine level above the center portion of the main building.
Originally, the mezzanine ringed three sides of the lobby where it was open to the space below. The mezzanine was later enclosed on the east and west sides for management offices and storage areas. There is also a small non-historic dining mezzanine in the former Burger King restaurant at the northwest comer. Floors two through six are typical hotel floors with double-loaded corridors serving rooms in the L-shaped building. The modest guest rooms are accessed via long, narrow corridors that are periodically interrupted by original light wells. The light wells provide light and ventilation into the rooms. These floors have undergone major remodeling. The individual guest rooms are in a variety of configurations and sizes.
Many of the rooms have been combined to provide for larger suites or other uses. The roof of the Hotel San Diego has typical penthouse equipment such as elevator hoistways, water tanks, and mechanical equipment. A small meeting room was added in ca.1940 and is located on the west side with two porthole windows and a wood floor. The basement of the Hotel San Diego originally contained public banquet spaces and building services. In the basement is vacant and the finishes are seriously damaged from water leaks and mold. The banquet rooms are gutted and there is no indication of original historic fabric. 2.
Stairways: The main central stair is behind a bank of two elevators at the back wall of the lobby and the treads, risers, walls, and wall caps are all gray marble at the first floor and basement levels. The main stair is carpeted from the mezzanine level up. Four additional convenience stairs are distributed around the hotel for guest and worker use. Two non- historic stairs were added to the north end of the lobby to provide additional access to the mezzanine. The date of these stairs in not known. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 15) 3. Flooring: The lobby originally had a mosaic ceramic tile floor, arranged in a pattern of connected rings and consisting of three colors. The lobby tiles are extant beneath the existing burgundy carpet and pad.
Some of the original tiles are visible in small closets below the lobby stairs. The tiles are round and the colors are white with hunter green and dark red patterns. Some areas in the basement have mosaic tile floors made up of white and hunter green hexagonal and square tiles. These floors date from the original period. The Geometric commercial grade carpeting throughout the building in burgundy, yellow, and blue hues is not original. On floors two through six, the corridors and guest rooms have non-historic wall-to-wall carpeting. Vinyl flooring in the guest room bathrooms is typical and is not original. The stairs typically are covered in contemporary carpeting. 4. Walls and ceiling finish: The original interior walls are gypsum plaster over lath attached to wood stud walls.
Recent partitions are drywall over wood or steel studs. Gray marble wainscoting is extant in portions of the basement corridors. The original ceilings and ornamental crowns and capitals in the lobby are gypsum plaster over the concrete structure. The original ceilings in the guest rooms are gypsum plaster. On floors two through six, the corridors have suspended, T-bar ceilings used to conceal later utilities. The plaster and drywall corridor walls, doors, casework, hinges, knobs, bases, and ceiling have been spray "texture-coated" with an ivory-colored paint with turquoise and pink specs. The interior of the rooms is much like the corridors with all surfaces except for the windows, floors, and fixtures texture-coated with the same paint.
Remnants of wood picture moldings and baseboards can be seen in many of the rooms. According to historical records, there were at least three painted wall murals in the mezzanine depicting natural country landscapes. The murals have either been removed or painted over. The artist (or artists) of these murals is not known. 5. Openings: a. Doorways and doors Most of the doors throughout the hotel have been replaced with simple slab doors and their hardware is also new. In the basement there are remnants of the original marble toilet partitions, wood partition doors, and wood panel doors. On floors two through six, the original wood panel doors, casework, and hardware can be found inside the guest rooms.
The doors and casework have been texture-coated, concealing the original dark stain finish. b. Windows Large, double-hung wood windows are typical in the guest rooms. The windows consist of large, undivided panes and they are usually grouped in sets of three. The majority of the windows are still operable and some have air conditioning units mounted on the sill below the lower sash. Some of the corridor and stairwell windows have been retrofitted with plastic faux stained glass panels on HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 16) the interior side, ca. A large, semicircular art glass window has been installed above the main entrance in the lobby. Because of its contemporary- looking design and ill-fitting installation the art glass window appears to be a recent addition, ca.1980. 6.
Decorative features and trim: Some doors and casework in the lobby area date from the period. A tall, gray marble wall base can be found in much of the first floor of the Annex. In ca.1915 gray marble was used in the lobby to clad the lower part of the columns and as a wainscoting treatment. Other missing historical features seen in old photographs include the repeating classical motifs stenciled on the facade of the mezzanine and on the column capitals and coffered ceiling beams. Remaining lobby features from the historic period are the columns, column capitals, plaster ceiling moldings, and gray marble stairs. Missing features, in addition to those previously listed include doors, wall ornament near the west stairs into the Annex, and wood-capped metal mezzanine railings. 7.
Hardware: The original door hardware consisted of ball-tip hinges, thumb tum deadbolt locks, and simple knobs with rectangular escutcheon plates. The original hardware finish appears to be oil-rubbed bronze with nickel-plated finishes used in the restrooms. Most of the remaining doors have a combination of new and old hardware. The majority of the window hardware appears to be extant. Remaining elevator call button cover plates and floor indicators are extant adjacent to an abandoned elevator. 8. Mechanical equipment: a. Heating, air conditioning, ventilation The public spaces, such as the lobby and meeting rooms, were supplied with retrofitted heating, air conditioning, and ventilation distributed via ductwork and wall and ceiling grilles.
Many of the guest rooms had window mounted air conditioning units. Operable windows provided natural ventilation. The ground floor retail tenants provided their own HVAC systems. b. Lighting Chain-hung glass chandeliers within metal frames and original wall sconces are seen in historic photographs, but have been replaced. Remaining original light fixtures, consisting of ceiling mounted globes, are still located in isolated storage rooms and in some guest bathrooms. Most of the lighting in the basement and floors two through six is provided by flourescent box fixtures, ceiling mounted. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 17) c. Plumbing Most of the hotel rooms have bathrooms with a toilet, wall-mounted sink, and tub or shower. The plumbing fixtures are not original.
Several plumbing fixtures in the basement restrooms are original, including the toilet partitions. d. Elevators A bank of two passenger elevators are located at the back wall of the lobby, and appear to have replacement cabs, although they were not available for inspection. A freight elevator is located in the south end of the east wing. Two additional elevators are located in the north end of the Annex wing. The Annex passenger elevator nearest the light well is the only elevator that accessed the roof. 9. Original furnishings: In the lobby, several portions of the historic marble bases are extant, but the marble desk that can be seen is historic photographs is missing. The front check-in desk was originally located in the southwest portion of the lobby.
The ca.193 5 lobby photographs show many alterations including a new location for the front desk, which became dark-stained wood, the addition of carpet for the lobby floor, new chandeliers, stenciling, and column bases. A large, brass "letter drop" box at the west end of the lobby is a feature that dates from the original period. Non-original features and relocated components found in the lobby include doors, shutters, office windows, railings, "Hotel San Diego" coats of arms, upholstered column seating, and partitions that close-off the east and west mezzanines and the north end of the lobby adjacent to the entry doors. Older, non-original features in the hotel include the front desk, the east and west mezzanine stairs, the telephone booth, and several art glass windows. D. Site: 1.
General setting and orientation: The building faces north on Broadway on what has historically been part of the downtown commercial district area. The Hotel San Diego was one of three important public building constructed by John D. Spreckels on Broadway. 2. Historic landscape design The Hotel San Diego was built right up to the property lines, so there was no opportunity for site work or landscaping. Historic photographs from the show small potted trees flanking the main Broadway entrance. 3. Outbuildings None. HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 18) PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Architectural Drawings: Original architectural or structural plans have not been located. B. Historic Views: Historical photographs are courtesy of the San Diego Historical Society Photograph Collection.
Historic Photo 1: The newly completed Hotel San Diego, looking southwest, Historic Photo 2: Southwest "Annex" under construction, ca.1923. Historic Photo 3: Hotel San Diego Annex under construction, ca.1923. Historic Photo 4: Hotel San Diego looking southeast, ca.1930. Historic Photo 5: The Hotel San Diego looking southeast, Historic Photo 6: Original entry to the Hotel San Diego, with the canopy and shield, ca.1935. Historic Photo 7: Original lobby of the Hotel San Diego, with tile floor and marble desk, ca.1915. Historic Photo 8: Hotel San Diego, interior, ca. Historic Photo 9: Hotel San Diego, interior, ca. Historic Photo 10: Hotel San Diego, stairs to the Annex, ca. Historic Photo 11: Hotel San Diego, Annex banquet room, ca. 193 5.
Historic Photo 12: Hotel San Diego, ground floor cafe, ca. Postcards and pamphlets: Figure 1: Historic postcard of the newly completed Hotel San Diego, looking southwest, Courtesy of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA, private collection. Figure 2: Historic postcard of the Hotel San Diego, looking southwest, ca. Courtesy of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA, private collection. Figure 3: Historic postcard of the Hotel San Diego, ca. showing the Leavitt & Company and Oldsmobile signs as occupants of the building. Note that the Annex has not been built yet. Courtesy of David Marshall, private collection. Figure 4: Historic postcard of the Hotel San Diego with the Annex, looking southeast, ca. Courtesy of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA, private collection.
HOTEL SAN DIEGO HABS No. CA-2781 (Page 19) Figure 5: Historic postcard rendering of the Hotel San Diego showing the Annex addition. Note this rendering included a rooftop structure (upper right) that was never constructed. Courtesy of David Marshall, private collection. Figure 6: Historic postcard of the Hotel San Diego advertising the Continental Room, ca. Courtesy of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA, private collection. Figure 7: Historic postcard of the Hotel San Diego, ca. Note the rooftop and blade signs. Courtesy of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA, private collection. Figure 8: Postcard of the Hotel San Diego, front entrance, ca. Courtesy of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, FAIA, private collection.
Figure 9: Historic postcard of the Hotel San Diego, looking southeast, ca.1955. Courtesy of David Marshall, private collection. Figure 10: Advertising pamphlet for the Hotel San Diego in conjunction with the Panama California Exposition. Courtesy of David Marshall, private collection. Figure 11: Hotel San Diego advertising postcard for the Panama California Exposition. Courtesy of David Marshall, private collection. C. Interviews: None. D.