BlockBefore

CALTRANS District 11 Maintenance Station, Intersection of Taylor & Juan Streets, San Diego

CALTRANS District 11 Maintenance Station, Intersection of Taylor & Juan Streets, San Diego, San Diego County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-, with a 3,389-word written history.

From the record

“The maintenance shop originally housed vehicles for repair, and the motor pool originally housed vehicles for road maintenance.”

Written record, HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32- survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32- · the record runs 3389 words · one of 194 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

53 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The property is bounded by Taylor Street to the southeast, Juan Street to the northwest, Gaines Street to the northeast, and the AT&sF Railroad/Trolley Line to the southwest. USGS La Jolla Quadrangle Universal Transverse Mercator Coordinates: l Taylor Street) Taylor Street) Present Owner/ California Department of Transportation (Calfrans) Occupant: N Street Sacramento, California

Significance

2699 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The maintenance shop originally housed vehicles for repair, and the motor pool originally housed vehicles for road maintenance. Both of these Spanish Colonial Revival style buildings are characteristic of Caltrans maintenance station design. In response to local climate and architectural styles, four other maintenance stations in the state were built in the Spanish Colonial Revival style. CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 2) PART I. PHYSICAL

Setting of the Maintenance Station

The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) District 11 Maintenance Station sits adjacent to the Old Town San Diego State Historic Park. Old Town is the site of the first settlement in California, and the state historic park documents the time of early development, from Although Caltrans owns the area immediately surrounding the maintenance station, the neighborhood is primarily a tourist destination. The buildings in Old Town are generally one- or two-stories tall, and are simple structures with stucco walls and red clay tile roofs, reflecting the period of Mexican and early American settlement. The maintenance station sits one block from the trolley and bus transfer station, and the rail tracks used by the trolley and the AT&SF Railroad run along the west edge of the property.

Until the the area surrounding the buildings was primarily residential, with small cottages or trailers. In the Caltrans began building office spaces and industrial buildings in the area. The three buildings of the maintenance station sit on a triangular block of land. Interstate 8 runs to the north of the site, at a higher elevation. The buildings sit on the southeast section of the property and include the Caltrans District 11 Vehicle Maintenance Building Taylor Street.), the Motor Pool Building Taylor Street) and the Maintenance Station Office Taylor Street). Access to the site is by a vehicle entrance on Juan Street, or by a pedestrian access on Taylor Street. The two main buildings, and Taylor Street, lie parallel to each other, facing Taylor Street.

The length of these two buildings run from the northwest to the southeast. A third building, Taylor Street, sits to the west. Caltrans has cleared the area surrounding the buildings, and uses the site for storage of equipment and vehicles. Originally, vehicles entered the maintenance shop, at Taylor Street, from the west side of the building for repair. Vehicles were garaged in the motor pool, at Taylor Street, entering from the east or the west side. Caltrans built the District 11 headquarters office building across Taylor Street from the maintenance station in An additional 13 Caltrans structures, mostly offices or storage spaces, exist within two blocks of the site. Temporary trailers have been added and removed from the property over time.

Caltrans has scheduled all of the buildings, except for Taylor Street, for demolition or removal in A larger office complex will be built on the site. The building at Taylor Street will be retained under the present plan. A major remodeling altered the maintenance station after The bay doors along the west side of Taylor Street were removed and blocked in, eliminating vehicle access to the building. Caltrans removed one driveway, removing the access from Juan Street. CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 3) A fence runs along the north and south ends of the property, enclosing the area between and Taylor Street. The area surrounding the buildings is currently used as a parking lot.

Trees, shrubs, flowers, and lawn landscape the portion of the site facing Juan and Taylor Streets. PART II. HISTORICAL CONTEXT -

Development of the Maintenance Station

Spanish settlers first occupied San Diego in nearly 227 years after the discovery of the city by western explorers. Gaspar de Portola, the commander of the colonization effort and the first Governor of the state, and Father Junfpero Serra, the Father President of the future chain of missions, were among the first settlers to the area. Under the leadership of de Portola and Serra, the settlers built a walled settlement on Presidio Hill, near the site of Old Town. The presidio was approximately the size of a city block, and all of the initial settlers lived within its walls. Serra built the first mission inside the presidio shortly after the town was established. The site of the presidio is just a quarter of a mile to the east of the maintenance station.

Mexico gained its independence from Spain in although San Diego did not recognize the new government until Houses were not built outside the Presidio until this time, when building began on the flat area below the hill to the west. The heart of Old Town was built here between the mid-1820s to the early By the threats from foreign enemies and the native population had disappeared, and the Presidio was abandoned. Over the next decade, rebellions against the government were common, but it wasn't until that the end of the Mexican-American War signaled a turning point for Old Town.

The City of San Diego was incorporated in the same year that California became a state (Engstrand At this time, prominent citizens of San Diego decided that the best site for a seaport town would be closer to the bay. New Town, located at the current downtown district, was purchased and promoted as a new business center, although little development occurred. For the next two decades, the tiny community of New Town was overshadowed by Old Town. This all changed when Alonzo Horton arrived and purchased New Town in enticing businesses and county offices to relocate. After a fire that burned most of Old Town's business district in New Town became the new focus of the city. Old Town grew very little after this time, and the Mexican and early American era of Old Town is very well preserved.

Old Town became a state historic park in focusing on this era. A small amount of development did occur in Old Town during the and when soldiers and working class families moved into the area. The neighborhood was primarily residential, although industrial development also occurred around the site of the CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 4) maintenance station. A packing plant was built at the current site of the District 11 headquarters office in the late In the three buildings of the maintenance station were built to house vehicles for the Division of Highways, a branch of the future Department of Transportation. California was one of the first states to appoint a department to oversee transportation.

This occurred in when the State of California created the Bureau of Highways, consisting of Irvine, Maude, and Marston Manson. The first tasks for the Bureau were to survey the roadways of the state, and create a plan for development of a transportation system. The Bureau of Highways later became the Division of Highways, under the Department of Public Works. This organization later became the California Department of Transportation, and finally, Caltrans. Initially divided into 7 districts, the district covering San Diego also covered Imperial, Riverside, Los Angeles, San Bernardino, and Orange counties. Ultimately, the boundaries of the district were changed because the travel distance between the headquarters office and the rest of the district was too great.

District 11 (initially District XI), the office that covers San Diego county, was created in It covers San Diego and Imperial Counties (Reading The activities of Caltrans and District 11 have changed over the years. From to the streetcar and railroad were the main forms of transportation in San Diego. It was not until the era of the highway, from that the automobile began to play a factor in the development of the city. This was partially due to the accessibility of automobile ownership as well as the increase in the population for San Diego. The county population increased by 40% during the mostly due to the influx of the military, especially the Navy, and immigrants from the Dust Bowl region of the country.

In Camp Pendleton was established as a Marine Corps Base in San Diego county, introducing more families to the area. After World War II, soldiers and their families settled in San Diego, increasing the population even further. The county population exploded from to going from people to over Old Town was one section of the city that benefitted from the presence of the military, aviation, and recreation industries (Pryde The population boom throughout the state stimulated a push for better transportation systems, and in the late the freeway and freeway system was developed. The freeway is a multi-lane roadway with on- and off-ramps and no cross-streets or stop lights. The freeway system allowed greater numbers of people to travel at greater speeds than under the earlier highway system.

The first freeway in San Diego, the "Cabrillo", was built in marking the change from highway design to freeway design in District 11. In the District 11 was responsible for the widening of I-5 from 6 to 8 lanes, the construction of the Coronado Bridge, the extension of I-15 to the border, and the development of I-8 and I-805 (Reading CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 5) The old District 11 headquarters office building, built in was located at Harbor Street, at the corner of Harbor and Ash Streets in downtown San Diego. The building was a one-story Spanish Colonial Revival structure with a two-story tower at the corner. It was built in this style to resemble the County offices nearby.

The current headquarters building was built in directly across Taylor Street from the maintenance station. Caltrans has expanded its ownership in Old Town from the original maintenance station to the surrounding area. There are a total of 13 additional buildings owned by Caltrans within two blocks of the site. The buildings at the maintenance station are the only buildings that are currently more than 50 years old. The Division of Highways created maintenance stations in areas that needed highway repair or upkeep. The maintenance sites usually consisted of one to two acres covered with various buildings. Usually, the first buildings to be built were the foreman's cottage, an optional bunkhouse for the crew, a truck shed, an oil house, and a loading platform.

If the site served as a headquarters station, the site also included a warehouse and office (Dept. of Public Works Maintenance stations located in heavily populated areas are larger than other maintenance stations. They house material for equipment and automobile repair as well as providing space for supply of materials, storage, distribution of equipment, and the preparation of asphalt road coverings. The creation of maintenance stations began in the A patrolman was appointed to survey and repair the roads, initially using his own motorcycle. A sidecar transported the cement and materials for concrete. Eventually, it became necessary to use a Ford touring car or light truck to travel the roads.

Each patrolman was assigned to a section of the roadway that measured approximately 30 miles in length. The amount of equipment, including a five-ton truck, a grader, a concrete mixer, an asphalt kettle and various tools, created a need for a more permanent maintenance station. To set up a maintenance station, the Division of Highways appointed a foreman to maintain a section of roadway. The foreman had the authority to purchase property and employ labor for the job. Unfortunately for the foreman, most of the stations were located in towns with little affordable housing. The foreman with his family would be forced to camp out on the land used to store the maintenance equipment. Very few foremen stayed at their post for longer than six months under this system.

It became apparent to the Division of Highways that a more permanent solution was needed (Woodson After World War I, gasoline taxes provided funds for highway construction and maintenance, and for the creation of permanent maintenance stations. The Division of Highways initially leased most of the properties used for maintenance stations in the state. Once it became apparent that more permanent buildings were needed, the department began to purchase properties. By the division owned 208 maintenance CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAJNTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 6) stations, with 123 under lease. Most of these stations were used for equipment storage, and partnered with individual portions of highways (Dept. of Public Works Once land was purchased, a more permanent structure could be built.

A generic 'colonial' style building was usually used for maintenance stations so the buildings would blend with the surrounding community. Occasionally, the Spanish Colonial Revival style was used to satisfy building regulations, and reflect the local builrung traditions. The Spanish Colonial Revival style of architecture existed during the turn of the century, but the Panama-California Exposition held in San Diego was the first time that the style was used on a grand scale. The exposition drew massive attention to Balboa Park and the city. John C. and Frederick Law Olmstead designed the exposition, and Bertram Goodhue designed the buildings with assistance from Irving Gill.

Goodhue was familiar with Spanish Colonial architecture through his visits to Mexico, and his knowledge of Spanish-Churrigueresque designs influenced the look of the buildings at the exposition. Before the exposition, Mission Revival was the foremost "Spanish" style of architecture. The Mission Revival style was modeled after the Franciscan missions found in California and the American Southwest, and the style was used for resort hotels, railroad depots, apartment buildings, and homes. By Goodhue and other critics considered the style to be a mixture of crude and temporary frontier building traditions, and found the Mission Revival style inappropriate for modem buildings.

The buildings of the Exposition were designed as if the Spanish had never left California, and the Spanish Colonial Revival style is based on the architecture of Spain, Italy, North Africa, Italy, and other Mediterranean countries. The Spanish Colonial Revival style became popular in the and for residential and commercial buildings. The buildings usually have carved detailing around windows, entrances, and cornices. Curvilinear shaped-gables, parapets, arcaded entrances and porches, wrought iron detailing around openings, and round-arched or straight headed windows are also characteristics. The buildings are generally covered with light-colored stucco and have heavy tile roofs.

There are additional Spanish Colonial Revival style buildings built by Caltrans from The other maintenance stations built in this style were the facilities at Big Sycamore in Ventura County, Las Flores and Arroyo Seco in Los Angeles, and Serra in Orange County. In addition to the original District 11 office building, the other district offices built in the Spanish Colonial Revival style included the District 8 office in San Bernardino, the District 5 office in San Luis Obispo, the District 10 office in Stockton, and the District 3 office in Marysville. CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 7) The Division of Architecture of the California Department of Public Works designed the maintenance station.

The Division of Highways built the building in five years after the establishment of Caltrans District 11. George B. McDougall was the State Architect at the Division of Architecture during the design of the maintenance station. The District 11 Engineer, E.E. Wallace, assigned three men to oversee the maintenance station after its construction in Earl E. Sorenson, Luckenbach, and Walter Beuthel were in charge of maintenance operations at the station in San Diego. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Early Views: 1. Photograph of old Caltrans District 11 headquarters building, taken at the dedication of the building in Like the maintenance station, the building is in the Spanish Colonial Revival style, and predates the station by three years. No. the Caltrans Headquarters Library. 2.

Aerial photograph of Old Town from Presidio Hill, taken 15 October The thirteen original sliding bay doors of Taylor Street are visible, as are the original windows at Taylor Street. No. the San Diego Historical Society. 3. Aerial photograph of Old Town, taken in The front and west side of the buildings are visible, showing the original sliding bay doors before the remodeling. No. the San Diego Historical Society. 4. Aerial photograph of Old Town, taken in The rear and roof of the building are visible, showing the original windows along the rear of the building. N. the San Diego Historical Society. B.

Bibliography

560 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

California Division of Highways Creation of a New Highway District Compels Transfers and Promotions. California Highways and Public Works. September New Highway Office Building in San Diego. California Highways and Public Works. June Department of Public Works, Division of Highways Twelfth Biennial Report to the Governor of California. Sacramento: California State Printing Office. CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 8) Seventh Biennial Report to the Governor of California, Sacramento: California State Printing Office. Engstrand, Iris W. and Ray Brandes Old Town San Diego, San Diego: Alcala Press. Gibson, Lester Maintenance Yards are Established by California to Facilitate Work.

Public Roads, July Hanel, Mary Guide to the Caltrans Transportation Library History Center. Sacramento: California Department of Transportation. Main,Ron 53 Years & Miles. District 11, August San Diego. Parks, Bonnie Caltrans Facility Inventory, Taylor Street, San Diego. Submitted to District 11, California Department of Transportation, San Diego. Pryde, Philip R. San Diego: An Introduction to the Region. Dubuque: Hunt Publishing Company. Reading, James E. History of San Diego Highway Development. San Diego: San Diego Highway Development Association. Smythe, William Ellsworth History of San Diego, San Diego: History Company. Woodson, State Owned Maintenance Stations Bring Results. California Highways. May C. Supplemental Material: Location map, vicinity map, and site plan. PART IV.

PROJECTION INFORMATION The project was undertaken by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) and the Department of General Services, Real Estate Services Division during the years The CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 9) project will demolish the two maintenance station buildings Taylor Street and Taylor Street) in and build a new facility on the site by The report was prepared as a mitigation under CEQA guidelines. Angie Gustafson and Christy Dolan of EDAW, Inc. (EDAW) prepared the report during the summer and fall of Initial investigations for this project began with archival research at the San Diego Historical Society, the San Diego Public Library (California Room), and the San Diego State University Library.

The initial site visit was conducted on June 14, In an effort to gain more information on the property, historic maps, historic photographs, Sanborn fire insurance maps, newspaper articles, city directories, land patents, and aerial photographs were reviewed. The library at Caltrans Headquarters in Sacramento proved to be helpful in locating historic photographs and information on similar maintenance structures. HABS photographs were taken in June by Chris Wray. James H. Cleland, R.P.A., of EDAW, supervised the preparation of the document. CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 10) ORANGE COUNTY RIVERSIDE COUNTY ) ./ ,-= \ __ - , ' \ Fallbrook Camp Pendleton Palomar Mountain Valley Center c;:::>Lake Wohlford Sutherland Reservoir -() ~Capitan Alpine ?

Loveland Reservoir San Diego 0 No Scale Regional Map CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 11) CONTOURINTERVAL40FEET SOURCE: U.S.G.S. QUADRANGLE - LA JOLLA, CALIF. 0 ~' ~

Quadrangle Location

Location Map CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 MAINTENANCE STATION HABS No. CA-2730 (Page 12) GAINES ST D I- C/) z ST <( ~~ DD D TAYLOR ST A TAYLOR STREET I- CJ) J ARCHAEOLOGY OFFICE z :) E 8 TAYLOR STREET TEMPORARY BUILDING 0 I ..J <( - C TAYLOR STREET MOTOR POOL D (.) D TAYLOR STREET D VEHICLE MAINTENANCE BUILDING E CALTRANS DISTRICT 11 HEADQUARTERS D OFFICE BUILDING OLD TOWN SAN DIEGO STATE HISTORIC PARK 0 No Scale ~ PIIOJECiLOCATION Site Plan

In context

San Diego, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Diego County, California 602 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Diego

24 of 114 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Diego building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
U.S. Naval HospitalHABS CAL,37-SANDI,27-28,449 words
Chollas Heights Naval Radio Transmitting FacilityHAER CAL,37-SANDI,31-17,945 words
Torrey Pines LodgeHABS CA-286811,722 words
Naval Air Station North IslandHABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A-8,906 words
Hotel San DiegoHABS CA-27817,976 words
Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental PropertyHABS CA-29637,639 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34A-7,163 words
Balboa ParkHABS CAL,37-SANDI,16D-6,909 words
The George White and Anna Gunn Marston HouseHALS CA-1316,416 words
Fort RosecransHABS CAL,37-SANDI,29-A-5,753 words
United States Custom House & Inspection StationHABS CA-28974,992 words
Savage Tire FactoryHAER CAL,37-SANDI,28-4,560 words
Mount Carmel RanchHABS CA-28944,165 words
Whaley HouseHABS CAL,37-OLTO,5-4,093 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34C-3,905 words
Point Loma Lighthouse No. 355HABS CAL,37-POLO,1-3,778 words
George W. Marston HouseHABS CAL,37-SANDI,10-3,343 words
Melville Klauber HouseHABS CAL,37-SANDI,12-3,246 words
Santa Fe Railroad StationHABS CAL,37-SANDI,22-3,171 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34B-3,080 words
Stingaree BordelloHABS CAL,37-SANDI,25-2,999 words
U.S. Naval HospitalHABS CAL,37-SANDI,27-A-2,979 words
I. O. O. F. BuildingHABS CAL,37-SANDI,5-2,769 words
Mission San Diego de AlcalaHALS CA-812,750 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.