crans U.S. Army Coastal Defense Facility represents an extremely early use of reinforced concrete as applied to military installations and is the only example of its period and type in southern California. Originally intended as an electronic control facility for the detonation of mines, the underground building was designed to withstand the direct impact of heavy battleship artillery shells, thereby allowing for the continued protection of the harbor against possible invasion. As a result, the design and construction of the facility were directed solely toward the uninterrupted operation of the unit with little, if any, regard for user comfort. The building is, therefore, a remarkably pure expression of utilitarian construction and design where form is dictated entirely by function.
Built in the structure was remodeled in and in efforts to upgrade it in accordance with progres- sive developments in warfare planning and technology. Fort Rosecrans , Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS No. CA-2255-A (page^2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of Erection: Planning for the development of a nationwide coastal defense system began in 1885'with the establishment of the Endicott Board appointed by President Grover Cleveland. The board recom- mended fortification of 29 locations including San Diego, which ranked in importance (Lewis Callaghan The board advocated several classes of harbor defense including underwater mines planted in harbor channels.
Construction of the Mining Casemate (Building at Fort Rosecrans began early in Excavation was completed by the spring of and the building was finished in April of the following year (Chief of Engineers Appendix Appendix Outbreak of the Spanish American War In the spring of accel- erated the completion of the entire facility and the mining of the harbor. In April orders were received to mine San Diego Harbor. Supplies were obtained from San Francisco's harbor defense facilities. In addition, a volunteer crew of 80 citizens that included carpenters, electricians, civil engineers, surveyors, telegraphers, boiler makers, steam engineers, boatmen, and mechanics assembled to rapidly com- plete needed facilities and plant mines.
Work began in May of (Chief of Engineers Appendix It immediately became apparent that the casemate was not large enough to hold the necessary equipment. As a result, the generator, a four horsepower internal combusion unit which supplied power to the control unit, was housed in a hastily built wooden shed located in a nearby clump of trees. Telephone communication was installed between the casemate and a nearby warehouse that served as a loading room where the mines were armed. By May 24, 15 mines had been planted in the harbor in five groups and the facility subsequently became fully operational (Correspondence Chief of Engineers Appendix These mines were removed from the harbor in August (Chief of Engineers 2.
Architect: The architect of the Mining Casemate at old Fort Rosecrans was the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. As planned by the Endicott Board and designed by corps engineers, the basic or conceptual design of buildings and support facilities was stand- ardized. In a document entitled Report Upon Experiments and Investigations to Develop a System of Submarine Mines for Defending the Harbors of the United States: Professional Papers of the Corps of Engineers, No. 23 was prepared by Henry L. Abbott, This docu- ment outlined the components of harbor defense and made suggestions for the design of an adequate system. The Endicott Board, with Corps assistance, later implemented the system nationwide with minor varia- tions in the design of individual facilities.
Fort Rosecrans, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS No. CA-2255-A (page 3) 3. Original and Subsequent Owners: Chain of Title The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo gives the United States government ownership of the land as a military reservation of the former Mexican territories. The Point Loma Military Reservation is established by execu- tive order on February 26. On February 28, the U.S. Army takes possession of Ballast Point. Fort Rosecrans is officially transferred to the U.S. Navy. The Navy takes possession on June 29. NOTE: Since the government took possession of the base as part of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo In there are no deeds or records of sale for this property. 4.
Builder, Contractor, Suppliers: The actual builder/contractor and suppliers who contributed to the construction of the Mining Casemate are unknown. However, it is known that a volunteer group of citizens worked to complete the facility following the outbreak of the Spanish American War (Chief of Engineers Appendix 5. Original Plans and Construction: The Mining Casemate at old Fort Rosecrans was originally built as a 12-foot x 18-foot room of poured and reinforced concrete, 10 feet in height. In order to withstand a direct hit from heavy battleship artillery, the structure was built 15 feet below ground surface in a bluff at the north base of Ballast Point. The walls were '4 feet thick and 15 feet of concrete covered the roof.
Sixty feet of soil covered the structure on the north, south, and east sides. The facility was entered by a downward-leading concrete stairway from the surface of the west side (Correspondence U.S. Engineer Office A concrete tunnel built into the casemate floor, known as a cable gallery, provided a conduit for electrical cables that led from the facility to mines in the harbor. The gallery was 2 feet wide, 3 feet high, 60 feet long, and it extended eastward to just beyond the original shoreline at which point its opening was 1 foot below the mean high water line.
From that point, a concrete trough extended another 60 feet into the bay where it terminated 2 feet below the mean low water line (Corre- spondence Construction of the original unit called for the excavation of cubic yards of earth, the pouring of 550 cubic yards of concrete, the place- ment of steel beams weighing pounds, and the installation of wooden flooring, tables, shelves, and doors. Total cost of the project was estimated at (Correspondence Fort RosecranS, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS No.
CA-2255-A (page 4) A list including locations of plans relating to original construction is as follows: The following plans and drawings of the Fort Rosecrans Mining Case- mate are located at the National Archives, Washington Record Group 77-Office of the Chief of Engineers, U.S. Army Collection, Cartographic Section. Copies are available at the Cabrillo National Monument, Point Loma, San Diego, CA. Date Drawer Sheet Title Jan. 102 Typical section showing cable gallery and trough from casemate to the . water. Dec, 6, 102 Engine and battery room for the Min- ing Casemate at San Diego, Harbor, CA. Oct. 30, 102 Part of Fort Rosecrans, CA showing proposed location for new torpedo structures. 102 Endicott Period fortification loca- tions. Nov.
9, 102 Survey in the Vicinity of the Mining Casemate, Fort Rosecrans, CA. Jan.20, 102 Torpedo Structures, Fort Rosecrans, CA. 6, Alterations and Additions: The Mining Casemate became operational in the spring of but it was clearly evident that there was a deficiency in the size of the original unit as the generator had to be placed above ground in a simple wooden shed. Plans were, therefore, immediately made to construct an engine room adjacent to the original unit. Construction of the new engine room began in March and involved the excavation of 450 cubic yards of earth, the pouring of 140 cubic yards of concrete, and the installation of steel beams weighing pounds. Excavation was completed in April, and the cutting away of concrete from the original casemate was completed by May.
The structure, including the pouring of concrete, installation of equipment, and backfilling of dirt was completed by the end of June (Chief of Engineers Appendix A year later a storage battery was installed and a picket fence was placed around the new stairway and light well (Chief of Engineers The engine room was 10 feet x 18 feet x 9 feet in height, and was built adjacent to the north end of the original unit. The floor of the new unit was level with the ceiling of the original unit. A stairway along the west wall of the structure provided access to the surface on the north side, and to the Fort RosecranS, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS-No. CA-2255-A (page ,5) original below ground unit through a new passageway and door.
A light well and small window provided ventilation and light. Four feet of concrete and 6 feet of earth covered the new facility which housed the generator, transformer, and electrical storage batteries (Correspon- dence U.S. Engineer Office During this same period, construction also proceeded on a mine store- house and cable tank. These facilities were completed by June (Correspondence June 9, Regardless of these improvements, the mining facilities were soon found inadequate. An inspection report for February states that the Mining Casemate was of the "...old style, badly ventilated and inconvenient..." and that a new one should be built.
The same report also noted that both the cable tank and mine storehouse were inade- quate and inconveniently located (Correspondence As a result of these deficiencies, a board of officers recommended on October 7, that sleeping and battery rooms be added to the casemate, and that additional facilities including a mine planting wharf, storehouse, cable tank, searchlights, loading room, and fire control station be constructed. Plans for the proposed additional facilities were approved in January and all work was completed by January (Correspondence The battery and sleeping rooms were con- structed of reinforced and poured concrete on the north side of the existing light well. The sleeping room measured 9 feet x 16 feet and the battery room 10 feet x 16 feet. Both were 11 feet in height.
The walls were 2 feet thick and the structure was covered by approximately 4 feet of earth (Chief of Engineer In plans were again made to update the Mining Casemate to protect it from improved battleship artillery (Correspondence A frame roof was built over the light well and a 60-foot tunnel was constructed to connect the basement of Building 158 with the western entrance. The additions completed the final construction phase of the Mining Casemate unit. B. Historical Context The Mining Casemate at Fort Rosecrans is significant as an integral part of the first modern defense system built to protect San Diego Harbor.
It represents an early use of steel-reinforced and poured concrete construction as applied to military installations, and is the only example of its period and type in southern California. It also represents the use of century state-of-the-art elec- tronic warfare, and while relatively primitive in design, set the standard for increasingly more sophisticated systems which were subsequently developed. Armament for San Diego's defense was planned in by the Endicott Board, which was appointed by President Grover Cleveland to develop a national pro- gram of coastal fortifications. The board recommended fortification of 29 locations including San Diego, which was ranked in importance (Lewis Callaghan Fort Rosecrans, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No.
HAB'S'No, CA-2255-A (page 6) The Endicott Board advocated development of the most sophisticated and technologically advanced weapons system created up until that time, including the use of "electronic" warfare. Existing Endicott period fortifications, including the Fort Rosecrans Mining Casemate, represent late and early century state-of-the-art technology in the uses of steel for armament manufacture and poured concrete in ttie construction of defense emplacements (Lewis The board planned four classes of harbor defense. Each class of armament could be applied and combined with other classes as needed at each fortified location to form components of a total defense system (Lewis 1979i79).
The Endicott plan called for first, third, and fourth class armaments at San Diego to be constructed at the harbor's mouth on Ballast Point and North Island, Fortifications on North Island, known as Battery Mead, consisted of two 3-Inch rapid fire guns. Fortifications built at'Ballast Point Included Battery Wllken- son, an emplacement of two 3-inch rapid fire guns; Battery Fetterman, an emplacement of two 5-ineh rapid fire guns; and a mining casemate, storage facilities, and a planting wharf for electronically controlled mines (Both et al. Van Wormer and Roth Chief of Engineers Controlled submarine mines, known until the early as "torpedoes," were connected to a position onshore and remained inert until exploded.
The Mining Casemate was an underground structure of poured concrete that housed the control and electronic generating facilities for the mine fields. Mines were not permanently placed in harbors, but stored onshore along with miles of electronic cable and detonation devices. Additional facilities onshore for storage and planting of mines included a torpedo storehouse, cable tank used to keep the cable wet during storage, loading room, and wharves. A special mine laying vessel and fire control station completed the components of the underwater mine defense system (Lewis All Endicott period facilities were completed at San Diego by the end of providing San Diego Harbor with its first modern coastal defense system (Roth et al.
Van Wormer and Roth Callaghan Ruhlen May From to Fort Rosecrans was reduced to caretaker status as part of a national policy of disarmament. With the increased threat of world war during the middle action was taken to revitalize coastal defenses including Fort Rosecrans. New armament planned for the fort, however, did not include submarine mines or use of the Mining Casemate as part of the defense system. Quite simply, updated technology made submarine mines obsolete as a useful component of the defense system for San Diego Harbor (Roth et al. Van Wormer and Roth Fort RosecranS, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Rase, Building No. HABS No. CA-2255-A (page 7) PART n. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Architectural Character: The Mining Casemate at the old Fort Rosecrans U.S.
Army Coastal befense Facility represents an early use of reinforced and poured concrete as applied to military installations and is the only example of its period and type in southern California. The building is architecturally unique in that as an underground structure it is, with the exception of the northern or main entry elevation, void of architectural detail. Originally intended as an electronic control facility for the detonation of mines, the building was designed to withstand the direct impact of heavy battleship artillery shells, thereby allowing for the continued protection of the harbor against possible invasion.
As a result, the design and construction of the facility were directed solely toward the uninterrupted operation of the unit with little, if any, regard for user comfort. The building is, therefore, a remarkably pure expression of utilitarian construction and design, where form is dictated entirely by function. 2. Condition of Fabric: The setting of the building has been altered by the removal of the original earth fill surrounding the structure on the eastern and southern elevations and with the partial removal of the fill on the western elevation. This condition does afford the opportunity for a detailed study of the original underground construction, massing, and design of the building. The exterior of the structure, following its final construction phase, is virtually unaltered.
The interior still retains its design integrity, although the majority of the original electrical equipment has been removed. B. Description of Exterior 1. Overall Dimensions: The casemate is a shallow L-shaped structure oriented north to south on its long axis, with the junction of the long and short axes on the northwest corner of the structure. It consists of four rooms, two in each axis, and is built on two major levels. The structure measures 27 feet along the northern elevation of the short axis, which also serves as the main entrance, and 55 feet along the long axis. Each segment is 22 feet in width. The structure is approximately 36 feet high. 2. Foundation: The foundation of the structure is of reinforced concrete.
The precise thickness of the foundation cannot be determined as it is still partially underground, although drawings indicate that it is approx- imately 1 foot thick. The structure was originally built into a bluff approximately 35 feet above the former shoreline. The foundation of the structure rests, therefore, on or directly above the actual water table. 3. Walls: The walls of the structure are constructed of reinforced concrete. The horizontal mold lines are clearly outlined on all portions of the structure which were originally underground, and the surface has been covered with a black waterproofing compound. The original Fort Rosecrans. Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS No.
CA-2255-A (page 8) exposed portions of the structure, primarily the north elevation, have been surfaced in finished concrete and have been painted green. 4. Structural System and Framing: The structure Is universally construc- ted of reinforced and poured concrete with both steel beams and rods. The concrete is comprised of tmusally large rock aggregate. All walls are load bearing and they vary in thickness from 2 to 4 feet. The actual placement of the steel and rod reinforcing is unknown and is not shown on any drawings. 5. Porches, Stoops, Balconies, and Bulkheads: The structure does not have any porches, stoops, or balconies. The northwest corner of the structure has been roofed by a wooden observation deck which has recently been partially demolished.
This deck had pipe railings and asphalt and wood flooring. The pipe railings and the flooring are in ruin. Two bulkhead walls extend eastward from the upper level of the structure slanting downwards toward the roof of the lower level of the north elevation along the east to west axis. These walls are without detail, serving primarily as a means of containing the original earth fill and as a partial foundation for the wooden observation deck. 6. Chimneys: The structure has no chimneys but it does have four concrete pipe vent shafts which lead, two each, into the engine and casemate control rooms. The pipe is circular in cross-section, and was laid vertically as the roofing was poured. The original vent cap has been removed.
A second and entirely separate vent structure is located to the west of the main unit and directly atop a tunnel which leads to the basement of the Commander's Headquarters building. It consists of a rectangular concrete feature with screen siding. 7. Openings a. Doorways and Doors: The structure was designed with three entrances. The main entrance is set into the northern elevation at the upper level. A concrete stairway leads upwards from the lower level to the entry level and downwards from the street located atop the bluff and to the west of the structure. From the entry level, a concrete stairway leads downwards along the western wall of the structure to the main doorway. The door consists of a heavy wood unit with metal straps.
A large lockplate with a single oversize keyhole and handle is original. A second entrance is set into the northern elevation at the lower level. It consists of a simple sheet-metal door with a hasp lock which replaced the original doorway. The third entrance is located at the end of a tunnel which leads from the casemate control room via a stairway and tunnel to the basement of the Commanders Headquarters building. This entrance has been sealed with concrete block. b. Windows and Shutters: The structure currently has no window fenestration. The structure did have two rectangular window openings located directly to the west of the lower level entrance of the northern elevation, but these openings have been filled with concrete.
Fort ROSecranS, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Rase, Building No. HABS No. CA-2255-A (page\9) 8. Roof Shape and Covering: The roof Is irregular in shape. The actual roof surfaces are flat. However, parapet and buttress walls form a central pyramidal mass on the eastern elevation. These building features originally served as a means of containing the earth fill which covered the structure. They also served as a base for the wooden observation deck which covered the light well and a portion of the main entry stairwell. The concrete roofs are steel reinforced and they vary in thickness from 4 to 15 feet. C. Description of Interior 1. Floor Plans: The structure consists of four rooms and a light well. Two rooms are located in each axis, and the building is constructed on two interior levels.
The lowest level, the casemate control room, is placed below the remaining three rooms so that its ceiling is at the same level as the floor of the other rooms. The control room measures 12 feet x 18 feet, by 10 feet high. Above and to the north of the control room is the engine room measuring 10 feet x 18 feet, by 9 feet high. The two rooms, located in the east/west axis, are at the same level as the engine room and the light well. They are 11 feet high and measure 9 feet x 16 feet, and 10 feet x 16 feet, respectively. 2. Stairways: The interior of the structure has two stairway systems. The first is an extension of the entryway which leads downward from the north elevation entry level to the light well and engine room.
This stairway leads from the engine room to the casemate control room. A second stairway leads from the west side of the control room upwards to a concrete landing located directly below a rectangular concrete and screen-sided vent unit. An extension of this stairway leads upwards to a tunnel which angles south to the basement of the Commander's Headquarters building. The stairways are of poured concrete and are in good condition. 3. Flooring: The floors are universally of poured and reinforced concrete. The floor of the casemate control room is covered in narrow, unpainted hardwood planking. 4. Wall and Ceiling Finish: With the exception of the casemate control room, all wall and ceiling surfaces are of unfinished concrete.
The walls and ceilings of the control room are, however, finshed with a thin plaster covering. The original color coat appears to have been green with subsequent layers of white paint. Apart from paint, the wall and ceiling surfaces are without detail. 5. Openings a. Doorways and Doors: The structure has four period doorways. They are all of similar design consisting of diagonal wood planking with 2-inch metal strapping. The first doorway is located at the base of the entry stairway and it is set into the north wall of the light well leading into the generator room. A second, slightly narrower doorway is located at the base of the stairs leading from the engine room to the control room.
While it is more narrow than the other doorways, it is identical in Fort Rosecrans, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS No. CA-2255-A (page 10) design. A third doorway is set into the west wall of the control room and opens onto the stairs which lead upward to the vent unit landing. The fourth doorway is located at the top of the stairs leading to the vent unit landing. All of the doors have grey painted wood and black metal banding. A fifth doorway originally led from the light well to the 9-foot x 16-foot room located in the east/west axis. This doorway has been sealed with concrete block. b. Windows: A single bottom-hinged, rectangular, wood-framed and multi- pane glass window is set into the wall that separates the light well from the engine room.
This is the only interior window opening. 6. Decorative Features and Trim: The structure has no Interior detail apart from the doors. Very simple wood and metal cabinets are located in the two rooms located in the east/west axis. These are not, however, original interior features. 7. Hardware: The only hardware consists of a single pipe railing located in the engine room on the east side of the stairway leading downward to the casemate control room, and the utilitarian handle and lockplates which are a part of the four original doorways. 8. Mechanical Equipment a.
Heating, Air Conditioning, and Ventilation: The structure has no equipment of this type apart from the natural air vents located in the control and engine rooms and the separate rectangular and screen-sided concrete vent located above the stairway leading to the basement. Ventilation was also pro- vided by the light well. b. Lighting: No original lighting fixtures remain. However, several early metal cage utilitarian lamps are found in the stairway and.tunnel leading to the basement of the Comman- der's Headquarters building. In addition, a set of early push- button light switches are found in the control room. These switches and the cloth wrapped wire connected to them may be original. If not, they most certainly date from an early period of occupancy. c.
Mining Control Equipment: A single fuse box with wood insulators Is located in the casemate control room. This appears to have been part of the original control system. In addition, the cable gallery set Into the floor of the control room carried the cable 60 feet underground to a point just beyond the original shoreline. Remnants of original cable project from the walls of the cableway, although there Is no indication of their specific function. 9. Original Furnishings: Apart from a wooden hatch set into the floor of the control room to cover the access of the cableway, no original furnishings are associated with the structure. Fort RosecraitS. Mining Casemate i (Naval Submarine Base, Building No. HABS No. CA-2255-A (page 11) D.
Site General Setting: The structure is set into a 35-foot bluff overlooking the original shoreline. The bluff faces eastward and presently has an asphalt paved roadway (Sylvester Road) running along its crest and to the west of the casemate building. To the east of the roadway and slightly south of the casement, there is a one-story brick structure which currently serves as the Commander's Headquarters building Located to the west of the roadway are three 2-story wood frame structures (Building #'s These four structures are historic features and they add significantly to the overall sense of integrity that is part of old Fort Rosecrans.
To the north of the casemate building, there is a narrow asphalt paved path which curves downward from Sylvester Road to a parking area located to the north and east of the building. Several eucalyptus trees flank the path, which follows the original roadway leading from Sylvester Road to the shoreline. Guijarros Road splits off Sylvester Road, curving to the east, just south of the casemate building. Fort Rosecrans, Mining Casemate (Naval Submarine Rase, Building No- HABS No. CA-2255-A (page 12)