BlockBefore

Fort Rosecrans, Point Loma, San Diego

Fort Rosecrans, Point Loma, San Diego, San Diego County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CAL,37-SANDI,29-, with a 1,892-word written history.

From the record

“Fort Rosecrans, Point Loma, San Diego, San Diego County, CA”

Survey record header. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CAL,37-SANDI,29- · the record runs 1892 words · one of 194 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Present Use

1808 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,29-. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Naval Submarine Base FORT ROSECRANS (Naval Submarine Base) HABS No CA PROJECT INFORMATION ' " (^ 2> The Department of the Navy proposes to construct a permanent Single Enlisted Quarters (BEQ) facility at the U.S. Naval Submarine Base In San Diego, California. Under requirements of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of (as amended), Executive Order and Regulations 36 CFR 60 and 36 CFR the Navy was required to address the impacts of this project on the known historic and prehistoric resources within and adjacent to the project area. A finding (Schilz et al.

that the construction of the BEQ would have a direct adverse effect (36 CFR 800 on the mining Casemate (Building and on archaeological site SDi-48 resulted in the completion of the documentation of the Mining Casemate through an Historic American Buildings Survey (Hathaway et al. and the completion of an archaeological data recovery program at SDi-48 (Gailegos and Kyle Both of these programs were designed and carried out as a means of mitigating the adverse effects of the construction of the BEQ on these cultural resource sites. Findings of indirect adverse effects resulting from the construction of the BEQ and associated parking garage, on these four historic buildings, were also made by Schilz et al.

The BEQ as designed will not destroy or alter these historical buildings but construction will alter the visual character in the project vicinity (36 CFR Criterion 2). The view from Rosecrans Street towards the area of the proposed BEQ construction site offers an unobstructed view of an undeveloped hillside and four historic structures (Buildings and Following construction these structures will not be visible to pedestrian or vehicular travelers on Rosecrans Street. Views of these buildings will be limited to viewers situated on Sylvester Road, the road immediately west of Rosecrans Street. After construction of the BEQ Rosecrans Street will be framed by tall, modern structures which will change the historical period character of the current landscape.

Also, the view from Sylvester Road looking east, currently a rather expansive view of San Diego Bay and the area of South Bay, will be blocked by the BEQ building and p0*'1:ing structure. Finally, the placement of architecturally modern structures within 100 feet of the historic Fort Rosecrans Post Buildings will be visually incompatible with these historic structures. The architectural style, scale, and detailing of the proposed buildings are not conducive to the prevailing visual context and as such the visual context of the existing structures will be adversely affected by the construction of the BEQ building and associated parking structure (36 CFR 800 3B, Criterion 3) (Schilz et al. FORT ROSECRANS (Naval Submarine Base) HABS No.

CA-2255 (page 3) As a means of mitigating these indirect adverse impacts, a program of photographic documentation for historic buildings and 167 in their current setting prior to project implementation were completed.

Historical Overview

Five historic buildings, and 167 are adjacent to or within the proposed BEQ project. Buildings and 139 are immediately west of the proposed BEQ project site. Building 158 is roughly southwest of the project and Building 167 is within the project area (Figures 1 and 2). These buildings were constructed between and as part of the Fort Rosecrans Post Buildings (Schilz et al. Buildings 137 and 139 served historically as barracks and currently house the administrative functions of the Commander of Submarine Squadron Three and the Commander of Submarine Development Group One, respectively. The three story structures are virtually identical with peaked roofs, attics, brick chimneys, and covered first story verandas and second- story balconies (Schilz et al.

The facades consist of horizontally-laid wood siding and are painted a cream color. The buildings are trimmed at the base by a two to four-foot wide band of rectangular stone blocks. All of the window and door fenestrations are trimmed in wood which is painted dark brown. The cornices, cornerboards, columns, and pilasters are also trimmed in dark brown, painted wood. Finishing details include square paneled wood columns on the verandas and turned wood railings on the second story balconies. The street facing facades for both buildings includes a cross axial gable (Schilz etal. Building 138 was built sometime prior to and historically housed a YMCA Service Club. The building is currently known as Argonaut Hall and houses the Base facilities of National University.

This is a two-story building that includes a cross axial gabled entryway on the east or street facing side as well as an attic, covered verandas, and balconies on this same side. The building has a gabled roof and architectural details include: multi-paned windows with vertirn".y divided sashes; turned wood stairway railings; balcony railings with a diamond-and-square motif; exposed beams on the veranda and balcony ceilings; brackets under the eaves of the dormer; and square pillars on the verandas (Schilz et al. FORT ROSECRANS (Naval Submarine Base) HABS No. CA-2255 (page 4) Building 158 currently houses the administrative offices of the Commander of Submarine Group Five. Historically the building was the post exchange.

The building is an imposing brick structure of one and one-half stories. The building is roughly T-shaped with a hipped roof; white cornices, and chimneys. The brick is lai4 in a common bond pattern with an arched radiating brick pattern above all of the main windows, and raised brick patterns on the pilasters at the main entrance and along the lower story-line in the front of the structure. The multi-paned windows have concrete lugsils and there is a concrete keystone which caps the radiating brick pattern above the main doorway. This arched, brick doorway houses twin doors which are topped by a multi-paned fawlight and a transom (Schilz et al.

The mining Casemate, building which is within the project parcel, was an integral part of the first modern defense system built to protect San Diego Harbor (Schilz et al. The Casemate was built in early and as originally planned was to be a single 212 by 18 foot room of steel reinforced concrete construction. The poured concrete walls were 10 feet high and 4 feet thick. In order to withstand a direct hit from battleship artillery, the structure was built 15 feet below the ground surface (Schilz et al. Further protection was offered by the placement of 60 feet of soil on the north, south, and east sides. The building was accessed by means of a concrete stairway that led to the surface on the west side of the building (Schilz et al.

Three additional rooms were added to the Casemate beginning with an engine room in followed by the construction of sleeping and battery rooms in In a 60 foot tunnel was constructed to connect the basement of the post exchange (Building with the Casemate (Schilz et al. As a result of a national policy of disarmament which began in Fort Rosecrans was reduced to caretaker status until the middle In to revitalize coastal defenses, the new armament plan for the Fort did not include submarine mining and as a result the Mining Casemate became an obsolete component of the coastal military defense system (Schilz etaL1987;10).

Photographic Documentation

Mr. Ray Shipps, a professional photographer, was contracted through WESTEC Services, Inc. to provide the photographic services necessary for the satisfactory completion of this ' documentation. Documentation of these historic structures in the visual setting, which would be lost through construction of the BEQ, followed the photographic documentation standards and specifications of the Historic American Buildings Survey/Historic American FORT ROSECRANS (Naval Submarine Base) HABS No. CA-2255 (page 5) Engineering Record. Mr. Shipps used a 4 by 5 inch Cambo view camera and three lenses, including a 90 mm wide angle, and standard 150 and 210 mm lenses, for all of the photographs. All of these lenses are made by Rodenstock. No filters were used on any of these lenses.

The film used was Kodak Tri-X, a fine grain cut film, which has a minimum resolving power of not less than 80 lines/mm for the high contrast range and 32 lines/mm for the low contrast range. All contact prints were made on fiber-base paper and the processing of these prints followed all of the manufacturer's specifications and included the use of fresh chemicals.

All of the photographs were composed to give primary consideration to the architectural features of the historic structures as well as consideration of the visual setting looking from Rosecrans Street to the west As this documentation was intended as a means of mitigating the adverse affect of the proposed BEQ on viewing these structures from Rosecrans Street, the composition of the photographs was intended to duplicate the views of travelers on Rosecrans Street. Only natural sunlight was used as the photographs were taken on a clear day. The choices of the most effective and aesthetically pleasing views of the structures were made and every effort was made to eliminate extraneous objects from the composition, such as cars and pedestrians.

References for the photos provided in this document are keyed to a location map shown as Figure 1 This figure shows the location, shot number, and orientation of the photographer at the time each selected photograph was taken. A brief description for each selected photograph is provided below with all information required by the Historic American Buildings Survey permanently transcribed on labels which will accompany each photograph. Selection of the eight photographs provided was based on a number of subjective criteria. First and foremost, consideration was given to those photographs that present the historic buildings from the viewers perspective on Rosecrans Street, as this is the view that will be lost by the construction of the BEQ.

Secondarily, documentation of the architectural features and the overall setting of the historic structures were considered, as the buildings (except for Building 167 which has been separately documented) (Hathaway are not to be demolished. Finally, selection considerations were made as to lighting, sharpness of focus, the presence of extraneous vehicles and people, and general composition. FORT ROSECRANS (Naval Submarine Base) HABS No. CA-2255 (page 6) !UJ ID 0 CO o c CO CO in 01 oo en c '5 CO Q. n o o Q. D) c 3 o x: c/j a. S FORT ROSECRANS (Naval Submarine Base) HABS No. CA-2255 (page 7)

Bibliography

Schilz, Allan, Richard Carrico, Dennis Gallegos and Stephen Van Wormer Documentation for Determination of Adverse Effects (36 CFR Bachelor Enlisted Quarters (BEQ) Naval Submarine Base, San Diego, California. Gallegos, Dennis and Carolyn Kyle Five Thousand Years of Maritime Subsistence at Ballast Point Prehistoric Site SDi-48, San Diego, California. Report prepared for the Department of the Navy, Western Division Naval Facilities Engineering Command, San Bruno, California (on file at WESTEC Services). Hathaway, Roger, Steven Van Wormer, Allan Schilz Historic American Buildings Survey Mining Casemate (Building HABS No. CA-2255. Report prepared for the Department of the Navy, Western Division Naval Facilities Engineering Command, San Bruno, California.

In context

San Diego, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Diego County, California 602 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in San Diego

24 of 114 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through San Diego building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
U.S. Naval HospitalHABS CAL,37-SANDI,27-28,449 words
Chollas Heights Naval Radio Transmitting FacilityHAER CAL,37-SANDI,31-17,945 words
Torrey Pines LodgeHABS CA-286811,722 words
Naval Air Station North IslandHABS CAL,37-SANDI,33A-8,906 words
Hotel San DiegoHABS CA-27817,976 words
Perry D. and Olive B. Griswold Rental PropertyHABS CA-29637,639 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34A-7,163 words
Balboa ParkHABS CAL,37-SANDI,16D-6,909 words
The George White and Anna Gunn Marston HouseHALS CA-1316,416 words
Fort RosecransHABS CAL,37-SANDI,29-A-5,753 words
United States Custom House & Inspection StationHABS CA-28974,992 words
Savage Tire FactoryHAER CAL,37-SANDI,28-4,560 words
Mount Carmel RanchHABS CA-28944,165 words
Whaley HouseHABS CAL,37-OLTO,5-4,093 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34C-3,905 words
Point Loma Lighthouse No. 355HABS CAL,37-POLO,1-3,778 words
CALTRANS District 11 Maintenance StationHABS CAL,37-SANDI,32-3,389 words
George W. Marston HouseHABS CAL,37-SANDI,10-3,343 words
Melville Klauber HouseHABS CAL,37-SANDI,12-3,246 words
Santa Fe Railroad StationHABS CAL,37-SANDI,22-3,171 words
Naval Supply CenterHABS CAL,37-SANDI,34B-3,080 words
Stingaree BordelloHABS CAL,37-SANDI,25-2,999 words
U.S. Naval HospitalHABS CAL,37-SANDI,27-A-2,979 words
I. O. O. F. BuildingHABS CAL,37-SANDI,5-2,769 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CAL,37-SANDI,29-. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.