Example of the larger type of Nantucket home at the end of the eighteenth century. PART I, HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1. Original and subsequent owners: Land was part of the Gardner Crooked Record conveyed in to Edward Cary. House was built by him about Owners were: -- Edward Cary & Estate of. -- Reuben Baxter & Estate of. -- William Baxter & Estate of. -- Melville B. Melendy, -- Eleanor D. Melendy, -- Marguerite G. Freeman. -- to date -- Norman L. & Edith E. Olsen. (Abstract,Records in Registry of Deeds, Nan- tucket, Mass.) 2. Date of erection: According to the period when such houses were common in New Bedford and vicinity, it would be expected that this house was built about or possibly a few years earlier. (Abstract, Nantucket Lands and Land Owners by Worth) 3.
Ar chi te c t: Unknown. 4. Original plans, construction, etc.: This hip roof house is an illustration of the more prosperous type of architecture that was built as business revived after the Revolutionary War. The house has five bays and the door, which is placed in the central and largest bay, has a much more pretentious aspect to it than those popular at an earlier date. The rooms are wide and well proportioned. There are large fireplaces. The height of the ceilings was increased and a central EDWARD GARY HOUSE HABS No. MASS-855(Page 2) hallway runs through the building. 5. Alterations and additions: No record of any significant changes. B.
Historical Events Connected with the Structure: Edward Gary, who built the house, was the first Cary to live on Nantucket, coming to the Island from Charlestown, Massachusetts, at the time of the Revolution as he was English (a Tory) but wanted to live in America. He did not want to fight against either England or the Colonies so migrated to Nantucket which was supposed to be neutral. His son, Robert, was the progenitor of one of Nan- tucket's most illustrious sailor families. The Carys were among the first of the Nantucket captains to sail directly to China. They were sealers who traded the valued fur-seal skins at Canton for nankeen (yellow cotton cloth), tea, spices and other commodities. Capt.
James Cary was at Canton in the ship Rose as early as The Carys sold this house to Reuben Baxter, whose son, Captain William Baxter, lived in it and in later years, when retired from the sea, ran the stage-coach to Siasconset. (Abstract, clippings in Scrapbook owned by Miss Grace Brown Gardner.) C. Sources of Information: 1. Old views: Two illustrations, one of doorway and one of house, in Early Dwellings Of Nantucket , The White Pine Series of Architectural Monographs, Vol. Ill, No. 6; photograph of exterior in Ninety-Five Percent Perfect by Everett U. Crosby, Nantucket: Tetaukimmo Press, old photograph in Nantucket Lands and Land Owners by Henry Barnard Worth, Nantucket: Nantucket Historical Association Bulletin , Vol 2, No. 2.